The ZIMBABWE Situation | Our
thoughts and prayers are with Zimbabwe - may peace, truth and justice prevail. |
"Our plan was to leave in the
morning by bus for Bulawayo. I have been
waiting here for the past four hours
and my friends are nowhere to be seen,"
said a worried Sarah
Ndlovu.
The last time Sarah and her friends crossed the
Ramokgwebana border at
the gazetted point of entry was about six months ago.
The three women have
regularly illegally crossed the border into Botswana
from Zimbabwe to find
menial jobs.
Mostly they go unnoticed. The
police, who "trouble illegal Zimbabwean"
have never managed to round up
Ndlovu and her friends.
"I suspect that my friends could have been
nabbed by police when they
left the houses where they had been temporarily
employed as housemaids,"
contemplated Ndlovu. She added that the three of
them have been hired by
some teachers at a local secondary school to cook,
wash clothes and
sometimes to baby-sit.
They have been renting a
one-roomed house in town and shared it to be
able to afford the rent. Their
employers have told them to leave because the
schools have
closed.
Wednesday morning was another chance to escape unnoticed.
As tough
luck would have had it, Ndlovu fears that the police nabbed her
mates and
took them to the centre for illegal immigrants where border jumpers
are kept
while awaiting deportation.
She finds herself in a
serious dilemma. She cannot go back to the
house they rented because she
could fall in the trap of the police. "I have
seen a number of Zimbabwean
illegals bundled into police vans before.
"We have been very lucky
ourselves - until today's incident," she
said.
When brought to
her attention that she had broken the law, she had no
qualms. "My brother,
have you ever been to Zimbabwe, or read about Zim.
"Millions of
people in our country are literally starving", she
explained. She claims to
have been a teacher at a primary school in Zimbabwe
before, but was driven by
hunger to Botswana in the hope that things would
work out here.
"Prices are soaring everyday while the value of the Zim dollar plunges
almost
daily. This is a sad reality isn't it?" she asked.
She said that
she breaks the law to survive. She finds herself in a
fix because her
passport shows that she has an entry stamp from the
Immigration Department
but that she has overstayed.
"I cannot risk going into the bush
with people I don't know and trust.
I would rather hand myself to the police
so that I join my mates at the
centre until we are driven back
home."
Ndlovu is one of the many Zimbabwean illegals that are
arrested daily.
She finally stated that she would rather hand herself over
than risk her
life.
Zimbabwean illegal immigrants fleeing
economic realities back home,
flock to the city in the hope of getting menial
jobs. Daily they traipse the
streets and residences in search of
jobs.
Most of them are women. Male illegal immigrants mainly flock
the
industrial sites in search of "piece jobs".
Most of them are
qualified, but because they cannot be absorbed into
the labour force back
home, they find themselves moving from yard to yard in
search of
opportunities. They are mostly cheap to hire and are employed at
cattle posts
and jobs shunned by Batswana.
The Francistown Commanding Police
District Officer, Boikhutso Dintwa,
has seen the many faces of illegal
immigrants. His officers have even set up
special operations to nab
Zimbabwean illegals.
"The situation is just like before. We still
have them living amongst
us and we still arrest them almost on a daily
basis," explained Dintwa.
The police are worried that their budget
for feeding awaiting-trial
prisoners while they are locked up, has been under
strain because they feed
many illegals before handing them over to the Centre
for Illegal Immigrants.
Government vehicles also transport them,
which further puts strain on
the budgets.
Irrigating nothing
Saturday 13th December 2003
Dear Family and
Friends,
It has been a diabolical week for Zimbabwe. The Abuja decision to
renew our
suspension from the Commonwealth caused a tidal wave of
recriminatory
statements, propaganda and threats. First President Mugabe
pulled Zimbabwe
out of the Commonwealth altogether and then he, his wife and
two dozen
officials went to a UN Information Summit in Geneva. President
Mugabe used
this world forum to publicly slate his critics saying that the
email and
internet were being used to destroy Zimbabwe and recolonise the
Third World.
Meanwhile back at home Zanu PF turned up the temperature. First
they pushed
through Parliament a ratification of the decision to leave the
Commonwealth.
Then a Zanu PF caucus meeting resolved to expel the foreign
diplomats of
Britain, Canada, Australia and New Zealand from Zimbabwe.
Finally, having
used the fear factor to the limits, Foreign Minister Stan
Mudenge announced
that the diplomats would not be expelled "at this
time."
Sitting on the edges of our seats and praying for sanity, wisdom
or just
plain common sense, these are extremely worrying days for Zimbabwe.
The
consequences of statements and decisions made in anger and to try and
soothe
hurt pride, are almost too awful to contemplate and describe. And,
through
it all, the lives of ordinary Zimbabweans, just plummet ever
downwards.
One night this week the usually pitch black view from my
window was
disturbed by a brilliant but un-natural spotlight. The light came
from the
direction of a nearby cemetery and I didn't stay to inspect it,
rapidly
closing the curtains and praying that the light was in fact coming
from
further away. Goose bumps covered my arms as I thought about the
latest
horror story in Zimbabwe. At night grave robbers are descending
on
cemeteries and digging up newly filled graves. They are removing the
corpses
and taking the empty coffins for resale. I don't know if this
appalling
practice is being conducted by money making entrepreneurs or just
by
desperate people trying to get enough money to stay alive.
With
unemployment now at well over 70% in Zimbabwe, people are resorting
to
desperate means in order to feed themselves and their families and
stay
alive. Zimbabwe has now entered the fourth growing season in a row
without
any sort of decent agriculture being practiced. Every half hour, 72
times a
day, our state radio churns out the latest propaganda jingle telling
us that
"Our Land is our prosperity". The government have seized 11 million
hectares
of prime agricultural land and yet, for the fourth year in a row,
half of
our population needs world food aid and people are starving and
digging up
coffins for re-sale. The majority of the seized farms have not
been
ploughed, the resettled people have no seed, no chemicals, no fertilizer
and
no money with which to buy the inputs they need to grow food.
A
recent overseas visitor to my home walked around my small garden and said
it
felt like looking at something from World War Two. In every flower
bed,
between daisies and lilies, there are vegetables: onions, carrots,
cabbages,
beetrots and spinach. Along one wall, standing tall and about to
blossom are
sunflowers which I am growing in order to supplement the feed I
give to my
half a dozen chickens. In flower pots are chillies, strawberries
and
climbing beans. Up and down my driveway my six laying hens patrol
and
scratch, crop the lawn, dig out worms and beetles, feast on flying ants
and
eat weeds. From my kitchen pelmets hang great heavy strings of home
grown
onions cropped from one small bed in the corner of the garden. In my
pantry
cupboard are two dozen jars of home-made marmalade, jelly, jam and
chutney
made from the jealously guarded single naartjie and paw paw trees in
my back
garden. In the fridge is home-made butter and in the deep freeze home
grown
chickens. You have to be extremely hard working in order to survive
in
Zimbabwe these days but mostly, you have to have access to a small piece
of
land and learn to become very inventive. This is the ironical tragedy
of
Zimbabwe's so called agricultural revolution.
With so much land
having apparently been given to the people, why the hell
are we all starving?
Why are people digging coffins out of newly filled
graves? Why are young boys
sitting in filthy rags on pavements, starving and
begging? Why are people
living in cardboard boxes in shop doorways? Why are
families of four or six
living in one room with neither toilet or kitchen
and without even a window
in which to put a flower pot and grow one
strawberry or tomato plant ? The
biggest tragedy of all is that we are
wasting the fourth growing season in a
row. In Marondera we have already had
8 inches of rain this season and yet it
is irrigating nothing. It is
tragically clear for anyone who cares to see,
that this supposed
agricultural revolution has turned Zimbabwe into a nation
of beggars,
thieves, racketeers and grave robbers. These are the realities of
our daily
lives here and as we struggle to cope with them it is hard to look
at the
bigger picture and to concentrate on caucus meetings, diplomatic
decisions
and UN Summits.
Until next week, with love, cathy.
The Herald
Illegal to demand rent in forex
Herald
Reporter
UNSCRUPULOUS landlords billing their tenants rent and people quoting
prices
of certain goods in foreign currency are heading for a serious clash
with
the Government, a lawmaker said yesterday.
The chairman of the
Parliament portfolio committee on budget finance and
parastatals, Cde David
Chapfika, said the Government will not sit and watch
the practice destroy the
economy.
Some homeowners are getting away with crime by charging rentals
in foreign
currency, which is in contravention of the country’s foreign
currency
regulations.
Last week a family renting a two bed-roomed flat
in the Avenues area was
evicted from the flat after failing to raise $US200
demanded by the owner.
The family that had been paying $500 000 was
ordered to pay $1.2million if
they had no foreign currency and they had no
option but to vacate from the
flat.
Some estate agencies yesterday
confirmed most of their clients demanded to
be paid in foreign
currency.
"Our clients have cited high inflation rates as the main cause
of quoting
their rentals in foreign currency," one estate agent
said.
He said because the majority of people are paid in the local
currency
foreigners mainly from Nigeria and the DRC are renting most flats in
the
Avenues area.
The practice had seen Zimbabweans pushed out from
the heart of their capital
city and relegated to second class
areas.
Although the police and other stakeholders indicated the practice
was
illegal, some owners of houses from most low density suburbs and others
from
the Avenues area have not been discreet about their demand for
foreign
currency rentals.
This has been evidenced by some adverts that
have been published in local
newspapers since January this
year.
According to the Exchange Control Act, only safari operators and
those in
the Hotel and Tourism business are allowed to quote their fees or
prices in
foreign currency only to foreigners.
Cde Chapfika said the
Zimbabwe dollar remains a legal tender in the country
and no person had the
right to charge house rentals in foreign currency.
"It is our obligation
to protect tenants from unscrupulous homeowners before
we see people without
foreign currency unable to secure accommodation in
Harare, " Cde Chapfika
said.
He said the anomaly needs to be corrected to save helpless and
desperate
tenants who sometimes have no choice but to pay a black market
equivalence
of the money required.
The undue profiteering, he said,
was fuelling the black market the
Government has been fighting to eradicate
since last year.
Police spokesperson Assistant Commissioner Wayne
Bvudzijena yesterday said
the police have made several arrests of homeowners
involved in illegal
charging of rentals.
"It is an offence for any
person in Zimbabwe to quote goods or ask for
rentals in foreign currency," he
said.
The Herald
ZRP won’t tolerate rotten eggs: Chihuri
Herald
Reporter
THE top management of the Zimbabwe Republic Police will not tolerate
rotten
eggs among its ranks, Police Commissioner Cde Augustine Chihuri has
said.
He said he was very aware of some police officers that are behaving
badly
within the force.
Cde Chihuri said the involvement of police
officers in illegal activities is
worrisome.
"Some of these corrupt
officers have unashamedly abandoned their smart
police attire in favour of
the dusty and muddy gold panners’ clothing.
"I cannot honestly imagine a
situation where I am told that one of my
officers has been killed when a
mineshaft collapsed on him whilst gold
panning," he said.
He said
police officers must appreciate that the present depressed economic
climate
creates temptations for officers to engage in illegal and
corrupt
activities.
"The top management of the ZRP will not tolerate
rotten eggs among its
ranks," said Comm Chihuri.
Some police officers
are often accused of soliciting and accepting bribes
from members of the
public.
"Indeed some have been arrested and appeared before the courts,"
he said.
Comm Chihuri said the recently completed board of inquiry into
corruption,
indiscipline, underperformance and training underscores the
seriousness with
which the police force views corruption.
"I am
convinced that with renewed determination as spelt out by the
President
during the State of the Nation address on December 2, we will
succeed in
eliminating corruption in the ZRP in particular and the country
in general,"
said Comm Chihuri.
In his state of nation address, President Mugabe said
the ZRP, with the
assistance of related agencies, would be urged to enforce
the law without
fear, favour and regard to stature or status of persons for
organisations.
The Commissioner urged members of the public to assist
them with any
information on police officers who solicit for bribes.
The Herald
Private doctors to demand cash upfront
Herald
Reporter
ALL private doctors will soon be charging patients cash upfront, a
move that
will further push healthcare costs beyond the reach of
many.
Medical aid schemes have been making it easier for Zimbabweans to
cope with
medical expenses as they have been getting treatment without having
to fork
out cash except for co-payments.
Medical aid societies pay the
bills on behalf of their members, while the
member pay monthly
contributions.
Sources in medical circles said doctors were fed up with
the problems they
faced in receiving payments from medical aid societies and
the time taken to
pay.
It takes anything up to 60 days for doctors to
receive their payments from
medical aid societies.
In an interview
with The Chronicle, the president of the Zimbabwe Medical
Association, Dr
Billy Rigava and the Secretary General, Dr Paul Chimedza
confirmed that they
were now going to deal directly with patients.
"Medical aid societies
have been squeezing our patients and the doctors.
They have made us suffer by
not paying on time while at the same time
charging their members in monthly
subscriptions," said Dr Chimedza.
Monthly contributions range from $5 000
to $100 000 depending on the medical
aid society as well as the
package.
Dr Chimedza said the new system, under which doctors would
demand cash
upfront, patients would pay and later demand to be reimbursed by
their
medical aid societies.
Under the old system, doctors used to
negotiate tariff and fee increases
with the National Association of Medical
Aid Societies but that has now been
declared irrelevant and the doctors have
come up with their own new fee
structure.
With effect from January
2004, consultation fees will go up from $20 000 to
$46 000 per
visit.
Currently, most doctors are charging between $15 000 and $23
000.
Namas executive secretary, Mr Job Chiviru said it was unfortunate
that the
doctors were accusing medical aid societies of squeezing them and
the
patients.
He said while his association noted the doctors’
concerns, he did not think
that all the doctors’ costs could be met by
medical aid.
Wages and salaries determine medical aid.
"As a
result what we pay has to be determined by the wages people are
getting,
which is not much. As a result, doctors might not be happy with
what we offer
but they have always been free to do what they want.
"No doctor is forced
to work with Namas and if it is true that all doctors
now want cash upfront,
then people will just get reimbursed by medical aid
societies as has always
been the case," he said.
To make life easier for the doctors, he said,
Namas had agreed that medical
aid societies should honour their accounts in
30 days.
"We understand the issue of inflation and know that if we take
long to pay
then the value of the money would just be eroded."
Members
of the public however, said the new system would see many of them
failing to
access health services.
They said using medical aid had been a blessing
in disguise as one could get
treated without having to think about
money.
"This means only the rich will be able to access
treatment.
"It will further worsen the lives of ordinary Zimbabweans,"
said Ms Tsitsi
Munhumumwe of Harare.
Surveys in the past week showed
that some specialist doctors are already
operating on a cash basis only while
some private hospitals were refusing to
accept certain medical aid societies
and demanding cash.
However, Dr Rigava, who is also a committee member of
the Private Hospitals’
Association said private health institutions were busy
negotiating with
Namas as they regarded it still relevant in their
operation.
Some medical aid societies also said they were in the process
of reviewing
monthly contributions and would increase them with effect from
January 1.
UN Integrated Regional Information
Networks
December 15, 2003
Posted to the web December 15,
2003
Bulawayo
With an iron grip on a medium-sized travelling bag,
Zodwa strolls leisurely
along Fifth Avenue, one of the busiest streets in the
southern Zimbabwean
town of Bulawayo, keeping an eye out for cars bearing
foreign plates, and
the police.
Zodwa is a foreign currency dealer,
one of the hundreds working on the
parallel market in Zimbabwe's second city.
Her business is made possible by
an official exchange rate that bears no
relation to the street value of the
local currency, which has been steadily
eroded by the country's economic
crisis.
The government, however,
blames people like Zodwa for the shortages of
foreign currency in the formal
economy. It is determined to hit back,
especially with Christmas approaching,
when people working abroad return
with plenty of hard currency.
In a
statement last week, the police said 24-hour roadblocks, manned jointly
by
the police and the Zimbabwe Revenue Authority (ZIMRA), would be set up
along
the main highways from the South African and Botswana borders in a
crackdown
on currency smuggling.
The response revives the stop-and-search
operations carried out by the
police and ZIMRA in early November, which were
halted after a public outcry
over their intrusiveness.
"The police
will intensify their crackdown to monitor the movement of
foreign currency
into the country during the festive season. We expect many
Zimbabweans who
work in South Africa, Botswana and Namibia to enter the
country. These are
the people who smuggle in the foreign currency that feeds
the black market in
Bulawayo and Harare," said a police spokesman.
The crackdown is the work
of a nine-member cabinet taskforce led by Water
Development and Rural
Resources Minister Joyce Mujuru. Apart from using the
police and ZIMRA to
clamp down on the dealers and smugglers, the taskforce
is also monitoring the
conduct of banks that run foreign currency accounts.
Under the new law on
foreign currency transactions, the Reserve bank of
Zimbabwe takes as much as
50 percent of foreign earnings in taxes, while the
remaining amount must be
exchanged at the official rate of US $1 to Zim
$824. On the parallel market
the rate varies between Zim $5,600 to Zim
$8,000 to the
greenback.
Several hundred foreign currency dealers have been arrested in
Bulawayo over
the past month, with about Zim $40 million (US $49,000) seized,
according to
police spokesman Inspector Smile Dube. The police have also
recovered over
Zim $32 million through searches at Beitbridge, on the border
with South
Africa.
VOA
Zimbabwe Food Crisis Continues
Tendai Maphosa
Harare
15 Dec
2003, 15:55 UTC
For more than two years, Zimbabwe has had to rely on
food supplied by
outside agencies such as the World Food Program to feed
millions of its
citizens. That situation might not change anytime soon
because most of the
new farmers do not have the seed and fertilizer that they
need, and getting
these necessary supplies can be expensive.
The problem
is a shortage of locally produced seed and fertilizers, and the
high cost
when they are available. The government is not supplying those who
cannot
afford these farming necessities.
This is raising more questions about
whether the Zimbabwe government's much
vaunted agrarian revolution will
succeed.
Even when the rains finally come - and they are already late
this year -
most farmers still have no seed to plant.
Traditionally
Zimbabwe has produced its own seed maize, but President Robert
Mugabe's
land-reform program has disrupted most of the country's commercial
farming
activity, resulting in less than enough to meet local requirements
being
grown.
Villagers at a World Food Program food distribution point told VOA
that they
and most other farmers simply do not have any seed maize "Some of
us have
nothing," said one villager. "Only a very few people have any
seed."
"We do not have any seed, we are going to use the maize we receive
for food
as seed," said another. There is nothing we can do. Maybe we can
harvest
something."
A spokesperson for the Commercial Farmers Union
who spoke to VOA on
condition of anonymity blamed the seed shortage on bad
planning on the part
of the government.
One official of a
seed-marketing company who also requested anonymity says
that while seed
production was lower than normal last season, the issue now
is the prices of
seed from commercial outlets.
As if this were not enough, he said, seed
is finding its way onto the black
market where prices go up substantially.
That means the seed is priced out
of the reach of the country's mostly black
new farmers, who have no access
to either government or bank
loans.
And what this means, in turn, is that when it comes harvest time,
there will
be little or nothing to harvest.
New Farmers Try to Stop Flower Exports
Zimbabwe Standard
(Harare)
December 15, 2003
Posted to the web December 15,
2003
Liberty Chirove
A GROUP of resettled farmers recently
attempted to stop a shipment of
horticultural exports to Europe, citing foul
play by established exporters,
it has been established.
The standoff,
which reportedly affected freight-forwarding agencies'
business, only ended
when police and authorities in the horticulture
industry intervened to secure
unease peace.
"The new farmers blamed the established exporters - mainly
whites - because
the new farmers' exports are currently not being accepted
internationally,"
said an official source.
"The new farmers tried to
stop shipments by two jumbo jets that were to
export flowers and vegetables
and business came to a halt at the entire
Europort area at the Harare
International Airport," he said.
Industry officials say the new farmers,
who have occupied horticulture
farms, are struggling to gain a foothold in
the highly lucrative export
business.
"Many of the newly resettled
farmers who took over farms are failing to meet
the specified requirements
and acquire licensees as required by the Royalty
Administration International
(RAI) and therefore they cannot export because
their exports will not be sold
as they will be labeled as 'stolen flowers',"
said Basilio Sandamu, the
president of the Horticulture Promotion Council.
RAI is a worldwide
organisation representing growers of ornamental plants in
the field of plant
variety rights and plant patent administration.
The organisation issues
conduct regulations in consultation with the breeder
and also issues
worldwide licences.
RAI also takes care of the application, the
administration, the filing and
the maintaining of plant variety rights and
plant patents in the name of the
breeder.
Industry officials said that
some of the exports from the new farmers such
as ornamental plants and
vegetables were deemed "unauthorised" and not sold
in Europe and South Africa
because the farmers failed to produce the
required licenses.
"Unlike
the new farmers, growers from all over the world pay royalties on
all the
protected products they propagate and as a result breeders are able
to bring
new and improved varieties to the markets," said Sandamu.
"The newly
resettled growers are also finding it difficult to start the
breeding which
needs about US$120 000 or to raise working capital which
requires about Z$40
million," he said.
"Horticulture exports have been steady from 1999,
which was the peak period
but exports are set to decrease by 10% this year
due to a lot of
disturbances and chaos on the farms and also the loss of
skill from
established farmers who left the country," he added.
Mary
Dunphy, the Exporters' and Flower Growers' Association of Zimbabwe
Chief
Executive, said a meeting had been held to discuss matter and a
Press
statement concerning the incident at the airport would be issued out
soon.
Dollarisation: Can It Work for Zimbabwe
Zimbabwe Standard
(Harare)
ANALYSIS
December 15, 2003
Posted to the web December 15,
2003
Mehluli Mpofu, Investments Analyst Intermarket Asset Managers (pvt)
Ltd
Introduction There has been much debate in various circles on the
issue of
dollarisation with several Latin American countries having gone this
route
with different levels of success. Maybe the starting point should be to
ask
ourselves, what is dollarisation?
Dollarisation in its simplest
form is the process in which a local currency
loses its function as a medium
of exchange and is instead replaced by a
foreign currency usually the United
States Dollar, hence dollarisation
(though it can be used to refer to use of
any other currency).
Types of dollarisation
There are basically
three types of dollarisation namely; unofficial,
semi-official and official.
Under unofficial dollarisation, individuals and
corporates alike strive to
acquire and store assets that have a foreign
component. Such assets include
machinery, computer equipment, motor
vehicles, offshore deposits and in some
cases currency itself.
Under semi official dollarisation, foreign
currency can be used as legal
tender. Local currency however remains in use
for daily expenditures.
Under official dollarisation the foreign currency
becomes the principal
legal tender for the country. In this article we will
dwell more on
unofficial dollarisation.
Dollarisation
process
What leads to a scenario, where citizens of a country decide to
discard
their own currency in favour of a foreign one? Going back to
economics,
monetary theory tells us that the function of money is one; a
store of
value, and two: money is a means of payment and exchange. As a store
of
value, money brings out a very important aspect, inflation, where
inflation
put simply, is the rise in the price of goods and
services.
To act as a good storage of value, the goods that you can buy
today with X
amount of dollars should be roughly equal to the amount of goods
that you
can buy with that same amount at a later date, say a period of one
year.
This works well in a zero inflation environment. In practice
however, this
ideal environment is not normally achievable such that there is
always some
degree of inflation. Under such a scenario, if you decide to
defer spending
your X amount of dollars today, you are compensated by earning
interest on
your money.
All things being fair and equal, at the end of
the year your X amount of
dollars plus the interest earned, will afford you
the same quantity of
goods.
In a hyperinflationary environment it
becomes a challenge to maintain a
balance in the equation stated above by
increasing interest rates without
pushing the country's productive sectors
and other borrowers closer to the
edge of the precipice.
When this
balance between interest rates and inflation is lost, money loses
its
function as a store of value. If you decide to defer payment for goods
and
services to a later date and instead deposit your money into the bank,
you
will definitely buy less when you get around to doing so.
Unfortunately
it does not end there; under such an environment the local
currency's
interplay with other currencies is also affected. The value of a
currency is
determined by lots of factors but the relation between interest
rates and
inflation plays a key role.
If the margin between interest rates and
inflation is negative, investors
from outside the country will shun the
country as an investment destination.
As a result, where a country is not a
strong exporter, supply of foreign
currency will be outweighed by
demand.
The local currency will thus tend to lose its value relative to
other
currencies, as more and more local currency units will be needed to
buy
scarce foreign currency units. By nature, no one wants to lose money
so
people begin to quote goods and services in a more stable
currency.
Deals are then effected in the hard currency itself or paid off
in the local
currency at the ruling exchange rate on that day. This process,
as defined
earlier, is what is largely referred to as unofficial
dollarisation.
The Zimbabwean case
Year on year inflation as at
October 2003 stood at 526%. In his budget
speech, the Minister of Finance put
forward an inflation projection of 700%
by the end of the first quarter next
year.
Though we have seen a rise in interest rates in the last couple of
weeks on
the back of market shortages, interest rates have largely lagged
behind
inflation by margins of about 300% thus upsetting the balance
mentioned
earlier.
In addition, the local currency has continued to
lose its value when
measured against the currencies of its trading partners.
The official
exchange rate has been maintained at 1US$: ZW$824 since the
first quarter.
To runaway from this stagnation of the exchange rate on
the official system,
a lot of players are operating on the unofficial market
where rates as high
as 1US$: ZW$6500 are being quoted, a significant premium
over the official
market.
This sets the background for what we are
currently seeing on the ground.
Flipping through the classifieds section of
our local newspapers it has
become common to see prices for houses, cars,
fuel etc quoted in United
States dollars.
Any news of a collapse of
the ZW$ on the unofficial market, inevitably
brings with it a wave of price
increases. This in itself is a manifestation
of unofficial
dollarisation.
The most pronounced benefit that results from this, is
that, while the local
currency collapses, people are better able to maintain
and realise the true
value of their assets. To some extent, investor
confidence is also boosted,
and this could see investors from abroad pouring
more money into the country
given the relative stability of the adopted
currency.
From this, it does seem as if unofficial dollarisation is a
good thing to
have. But, what is the flip side to the coin, do we all stand
to benefit?
For most of us, our main income stream is our pay cheque
which comes every
month, or in some cases on a fortnightly basis.
With
unofficial dollarisation, quoting services in a foreign currency is
largely
and understandably so, against the law. As a result, incomes remain
quoted in
local currency.
While salaries and wages are at best only reviewed on a
quarterly basis,
prices of goods and services on the other hand, track on a
daily/weekly
basis the movement of the local currency versus the foreign
currency.
A mismatch therefore results with incomes continuously
shrinking in foreign
currency terms and failing to cope with rising price
levels.
This is further compounded by the existence of two markets as
noted above,
with incomes largely being drawn assuming the official exchange
rate while
goods and services are linked to the unofficial market. This
article is not
exhaustive in terms of the full pros & cons of unofficial
dollarisation, it
is however apparent that in the absence of indexation of
salaries and wages
with respect to the foreign currency the general populace
stands to lose.
End of Era for Kwekwe's 'Makorokoza'
Zimbabwe Standard
(Harare)
COLUMN
December 15, 2003
Posted to the web December 15,
2003
Rangarirai Mberi
LEANING heavily over the bar and hurling
relentless abuse at the hapless
barman, 23-year-old Peter Arubi is as bitter
and cold as the brandy he's
drinking.
Life has taken a nasty turn for
this Kwekwe resident, as it has for hundreds
of his former gold panner
colleagues.
Five months ago, he would have strutted into this pub and
bought everyone
within sight a beer. Now, as on this Saturday morning, he
spends all his
days draining away what remains of his gold "fortune" in
endless glasses of
brandy.
"We were lied to", he says, the bitterness
in his drink and in his heart
warping his face. "They told us
lies".
Before joining Kwekwe's gold panner ranks, Peter was an assistant
to his
uncle, a motor mechanic. Then a friend introduced him to the hazards
and
fortunes of digging for gold. He made a quick bundle and, the day after
his
first pay-off, went back to work and threw a spanner across the workshop
at
his stunned boss.
After a year living a life that swung between
burrowing through cavernous
mineshafts and going on wild drinking orgies,
Peter finds himself with empty
hours he finds impossible to
kill.
Peter is a typical victim of the "Zanu PF way", or rather modus
operandi Ñ
use and reject.
Five months ago, gold panners in this town
were the untouchables, the city's
top dogs, and Stanford Bonyongwa's foot
soldiers in his fight for Kwekwe's
mayoral robes.
Kwekwe's natural
wealth became its curse, as the "makorokoza" ruthlessly
went about their
business without interference from the law. Residents of
this neat Midlands
town watched helplessly as their once picturesque
environs were allowed to
deteriorate into a wasteland of open pits and
abandoned piles of
sand.
Sleep became uneasy for residents, as huge dynamite explosions tore
through
endless nights, shaking homes at the foundations and rattling
windows. As
all this continued, residents could find no protection for life
and property
alike.
"My neighbour had part of his security wall
destroyed by those people. They
came early one morning and dug right through
under the wall. We made
repeated reports to both council and police but no
one would help," a Kwekwe
resident who only identified himself as Govere
said.
The fortune hunters even brazenly dug under a section of the
Harare-Bulawayo
railway line.
The city council would not intervene;
even when the "makorokoza" casually
slashed water pipes and even punched
holes in sewer pipes for free water
with which to sift their ore. Even when
Globe and Phoenix school lost an
entire football pitch and a classroom to an
army of pick and shovel wielding
panners, ratepayers still had no
recourse.
It was a police problem, concerned residents were told at
townhouse. At the
police stations, it became a political
problem.
Among the gold panners, the Midlands ruling party bigwigs had
found an easy
and willing army to recruit.
The thriving gold digging
enterprise was clearly illegal, but also evidently
addictive. The gold
panners had come to know no other life, and blackmailing
them onto the party
campaign wagon was no huge task. They would be barred
from the mines or
arrested Ñ the tacit warning said Ñ unless they agreed to
beat, harass and
intimidate those opposed to the party.
At meetings with the party
leadership, they were repeatedly assured their
future was secure.
"The
leaders of our association were always talking to Zanu PF and they
were
assured we could continue our operations. They only warned us against
going
into abandoned mines. Otherwise, we could mine anywhere", said
Peter.
Then Zanu PF's Bonyongwa won the election, and today, many of the
faithful
"makorokoza" wallow in police cells. Only those working for senior
party
officials are allowed to continue their illegal operations. The rest
spend
time evading the law and attacking the same Zanu PF councillors
who
recruited them, as they allege, to vote more than once in the
council
election.
Before the election, the spendthrift gold panners
were accused of bidding up
prices in the local stores. But fortune has turned
against them. Recently
they ordered shop owners to sell bread at $1 500. And
now that they can no
longer afford to wheel about in expensive taxis, the
gold panners have
ordered commuter bus operators to slash their fares by
half.
The impact of the po-lice crackdown is however not restricted to
the gold
panners and the dealers.
Shop owners say sales slumped more
than 50% after the raids began. Peter's
barman says he used to push over 30
crates of premium lager on a good night.
Now, he moans, he would be lucky "if
one of them orders a single Pilsener".
If there was one trait about the
"makorokoza" that set up them apart from
mere mortals, it was their penchant
for pricey bicycles. At one time, a
leading bike dealer in the town had his
order book bulging at the seams.
Now, after the election, bicycle prices
in this town have hit the rocks
because just about every other former gold
panner is desperate to sell his.
"I sold mine last week," says Peter,
initially refusing to say how much he
sold it for, but then giving it away:
"I needed money to pay rent."
Asked to whom he sold his gold, Peter
frowns again. A well-connected local
businessman bought his gold, he says,
but then "everybody knows who really
controls things around
here".
Despite Mines Minister Edward Chindori Chininga's tough line
against the
illegal trade in gold, select groups close to senior ruling party
officials
still ravage Kwekwe's mines with flagrant impunity, undisturbed by
the
fearsome Police Gold Squad.
Government says 70%of the country's
gold output is not making it to central
bank, costing the economy US$350
million this year.
Peter says he spent two nights on the cold concrete
floors of police cells
after his sister-in-law tipped off the
police.
He remembers watching the earth cave in on one of his
colleagues at an
abandoned mine.
He tries hard to be nonchalant about
the tragedy, but he pauses for a while
gazing into his glass reflecting on
the tragedy. Clearly, he is haunted by
how helpless he had felt then
scratching away frantically with his bare
hands into the debris and knows how
helpless he is now wasting away at the
bar.
Waiting for Godot: Firms Await Policy
Zimbabwe Standard
(Harare)
December 15, 2003
Posted to the web December 15,
2003
LOCAL markets and the private sector say they still face too
many
impediments in and now wait for the unveiling of the Reserve Bank
of
Zimbabwe's long awaited monetary policy statement, expected to be
released
this week.
"The skewed macro-economic environment, negative
impact on the productive
sectors and instability characterised by a high
budget deficit, high levels
of debts, low levels of domestic savings and
productive investment is
halting business operations," said economist and
consultant, James Jowa.
"Unless issues pertaining to the exchange rate
and the monetary policy are
addressed, we are heading for a big crunch as the
much-awaited 2004 Budget
did not address these issues," he
added.
Zimbabwe's year-on-year inflation is currently pegged at 525,8%
and economic
analysts have predicted a further 13,4% decline in economic
performance this
year from the negative growth of 12,1% last year and a
further 8,5%
deceleration in 2004.
In the last four years, Zimbabwe's
economy has shrunk by 50% with the
unemployment rate down by 20% between 2001
and 2003 as the country gained
the dubious distinction of being ranked the
fastest shrinking economy in the
world.
The harsh economic climate has
resulted in a blooming parallel market for
hard currency, which has also
pushed up the prices of imported goods,
thereby further fuelling consumer
inflation.
Zimbabwe's exports have, during the same time, drastically
been reduced in
volume, going down by 70% between 2000 and 2003, while
capacity utilisation
now averages 45% and manufacturing investment is down by
more than 50% from
its 2000 figures.
Hundreds of companies have closed
down or relocated outside Zimbabwe as the
situation continues to
deteriorate.
Analysts last week said only market-driven policies would
stop the decline.
Irish Examiner
Tutu slams South African silence over
Zimbabwe
15/12/2003 - 4:18:49 pm
Nobel Peace Prize winner Archbishop
Desmond Tutu today slammed South Africa’
s failure to speak out against human
rights violations in Zimbabwe.
“The credibility of our democracy demands
this,” he said. “If we are
seemingly indifferent to human rights violations
happening in a neighbouring
country, what is to stop us one day being
indifferent to that in our own?”
Tutu’s comments came after South African
President Thabo Mbeki shrugged off
human rights concerns in Zimbabwe in a
blistering attack on the Commonwealth
for extending the country’s suspension
from the bloc of Britain and its
former colonies.
Tutu, former
Anglican Archbishop of Cape Town, also criticised South Africa’
s acceptance
as ”legitimate” of disputed 2002 elections that returned
Zimbabwean President
Robert Mugabe to power for a fifth consecutive term.
The polls were widely
regarded to have been rigged.
Tutu, who won the 1984 Nobel Peace Prize
for his efforts against apartheid,
said abuses in Zimbabwe were “totally
unacceptable and reprehensible.”
He added that he did not understand why
the country’s African neighbours had
resisted the decision to continue
Zimbabwe’s 18 month suspension at a recent
Commonwealth summit in
Nigeria.
Within hours of the decision, Zimbabwe announced it was quitting
the body
for good over what it considered to be a challenge to its
sovereignty.
Recalling that international sanctions helped end apartheid
in South Africa,
Tutu said: “We appealed for the world to intervene and
interfere in South
Africa’s internal affairs. We could not have defeated
apartheid on our own.”
Mbeki’s government advocates a policy of “quiet
diplomacy” in Zimbabwe,
saying it has been working to bring the opposition
and Mugabe’s ruling party
together for talks.
Zimbabwe is suffering
its worst political and economic crisis since
independence in
1980.
The often-violent seizure of thousands of white-owned farms
for
redistribution to blacks has crippled the agriculture-based
economy.
The government has also stepped up a crackdown on political
dissent,
arresting opposition leaders and shutting down the country’s
only
independent daily newspaper.
The Australian
Mugabe praises China
From correspondents in Addis
Ababa
December 16, 2003
A DEFIANT Zimbabwean President Robert Mugabe today
heaped praise on China
during a Sino-African cooperation conference in the
Ethiopian capital, and
lashed out at the "predatory, warrior states" of the
west.
China, Mugabe told the conference attended by heads of state
and
representatives from across Africa, has been "among the few genuine
global
makers of democracy, among the authors of comprehensive human rights,
rule
of law and legality."
The Zimbabwean president said this lay in
stark contrast to "the predatory
warrior states and kingdoms of the west who
now pose as global defenders of
good governance, democracy and human
rights".
"We small states who cherish our sovereignty and independence
are the most
targeted," he said.
"Our struggles for sovereignty are
demonised and criminalised, our search
for social justice through correcting
the historic ills of western
colonialism and racism invites reprisals,
through illegal sanctions and
undemocratic suspensions," Mugabe
charged.
Zimbabwe pulled out of the
Commonwealth on December 8, a day after delegates
at a Commonwealth summit in
Abuja, the Nigerian capital, indefinitely
prolonged its suspension from the
grouping's ruling councils.
The southern African country was originally
suspended from the Commonwealth
in March last year, after Mugabe was
re-elected in polls which observers
have said were marred by violence and
vote-rigging.
"Zimbabwe will not collapse, our struggle will not fail and
we will never be
colonised again," he declared.
"We will not relent
until we fully recover our land and use it to
economically empower its
rightful owners to restore social justice and
secure our national
sovereignty," he said.
Zimbabwe faces massive food shortages both because
of drought and the
government's controversial land reform program, under
which white-owned
farmland has been seized and re-distributed to
blacks.
Centre for Torture Victims Established
Zimbabwe Standard
(Harare)
December 15, 2003
Posted to the web December 15,
2003
"POLICE set electric wires on my feet, my teeth and on my
genital parts. I
urinated and the next thing I was unconscious," said one
victim.
Such were the moving testimonies recounted by victims of torture
at the
official launch of the Centre for the Rehabilitation of Torture
Victims
(Ceretov) in the capital on Friday, graced by
diplomats.
Ceretov is the brainchild of a group of torture victims who
came together
after having realised the effect of torture on their lives and
other silent
victims in general.
Initially formed as a group in
Chitungwiza, the victims who met almost every
Saturday to counsel each other,
decided to form an association, which would
attempt to engage many victims
and find strategies for rehabilitation.
The organisation's objectives are
to counsel survivors of torture, providing
legal aid to survivors and to
advocate against torture nationally and
internationally among
others.
Officially launching Ceretov, board chairman and a survivor of
torture, St
Mary's legislator Job Sikhala said the emergence of the
organisation was a
challenge to those who have been using stress and duress
tactics to
interrogate and harass opponents.
Ceretov intends to file
test cases with the United Nations in The Hague
against prominent individuals
who have been sanctioning torture.
"Those responsible shall be exposed to
the entire world. We shall challenge
torturers locally and internationally,"
said Sikhala.
Anthrax Claims 8 in Masvingo
Zimbabwe Standard
(Harare)
December 15, 2003
Posted to the web December 15,
2003
Savious Kwinika
Masvingo
Eight people in Masvingo province
are reported to have died of anthrax in
the past few months and many more are
under threat from a host of other
diseases that include rabies because of the
ill planned land reforms and the
shortage of drugs.
Officials at the
Ministry of Health confirmed the deaths but refused to give
details referring
The Standard to Provincial Medical Director, Dr Tapiwa
Magure, said to be the
only person allowed to speak to the Press. Magure was
reportedly out of town
since Monday.
A senior veterinary officer however said his department,
which had run out
of vaccines owing to foreign currency shortages and the
strained relations
with donors, was on high alert after reports that three
people from Gutu,
four people in Bikita and one in Masvingo district had died
of anthrax.
Besides the deadly anthrax disease that has claimed eight
lives to date,
officials disclosed that many rural people were contracting
rabies.
"We are in a serious crisis, my brother. Anthrax, rabies and foot
and mouth
disease have become major problems threatening both human beings
and
livestock in Masvingo province. And we don't any have any vaccines
for
that," said the official.
He attributed serious problems of foot
and mouth in areas such Chiredzi,
Mwenezi, Zaka and Gutu to the chaotic land
reform programme.
"The land reform programme brought a lot of chaos
resulting in the outbreak
of rabies, anthrax and foot and mouth diseases,"
said the veterinary
officer.
"For rabies, if you are bitten by an
affected dog, there are no two ways
besides dying because we don't have
vaccines or treatment drugs," he added.
He said the only vaccines they
received recently were the 150 000 doses for
foot and mouth disease but his
department had no fuel for the past month to
visit the hardest hit areas,
especially Chiredzi and Mwenezi.
Police Beat Up Security Guards
Zimbabwe Standard
(Harare)
December 15, 2003
Posted to the web December 15,
2003
Tafara Tandi
BUlawayo
More than 30 people were injured, 12
of them seriously, when riot police
descended on the premises of a local
security company owned by newly elected
Zanu PF district chairman for
Embakwe-Silonda, Reginald Mavangire, and
indiscriminately started beating up
everyone in sight.
The heavily-arm-ed riot policemen num-bering about 20
arrived at Mavangire's
fifth floor Treger House offices on Wednesday last
week and accused him and
his security guards of planning an illegal march
before beating them up.
A fuming Mavangire, who owns Guaranteed Security
company, told The Standard
that he was shocked by the
incident.
According to Mavangire the police are said to have been further
incensed by
the uniform worn by his security guards, which they claim
resembles that of
the riot police.
Earlier this year, Bulawayo police
applied to the High Court to bar his
organisation from using the uniform but
the police lost the case.
Mavangire said after the assaults he and his
employees were bundled into
police vehicles and taken to Drill Hall police
station where they were later
released without being charged.
Some of
the seriously injured had been taken for treatment at the time The
Standard
visited the troubled Guaranteed Security premises, while others
were waiting
for transport to hospital.
Another company director, who refused to be
named, said the security company
planned to sue the police for the
assault.
Smile Dube, the police spokesman, however dismissed Mavangire's
claims that
the police had beaten the security guards. The Standard however,
has in its
possession documents showing that the assaults were reported to
the police
and a docket to that effect was opened.
Mt Darwin Villagers Blast Zanu PF
Zimbabwe Standard
(Harare)
December 15, 2003
Posted to the web December 15,
2003
Nyasha Bhosha
DURING the March 2002 Presidential
elections, top Zanu PF officials were
frequent visitors to this remote area
drumming up support for President
Robert Mugabe but now, the people of
Katarira, over 100 km north of Mt
Darwin town, say they feel abandoned and
neglected.
"We are now depending on donors. If it was not for them, many
of us could
have died of starvation months ago," said a villager who declined
to be
named fearing reprisals from marauding Zanu PF youths who are
almost
everywhere in the area.
After winning the controversial
presidential election, with a considerable
number of votes coming from Mt
Darwin, traditionally a stronghold of the
ruling Zanu PF party the government
has allegedly ditched the area leaving
donors to help villagers ward off the
effects of starvation.
Katarira villagers say their area is a perfect
example of how the ruling
party can use and dump people after getting
votes.
"We used to see them everyday, now we are on our own, waging a
difficult
battle to survive," said another villager.
At the moment,
more than 7 000 people from this community are benefiting
from food aid,
provided by donors.
And these days, it's common to see barefooted hungry
young women carrying
babies on their backs, scruffy teenagers in ragged
clothing and the elderly
standing in the scorching sun, waiting for food at
the Final Delivery Points
(FDPs) where they receive the food from
donors.
It was the same story on Thursday at Katarira Primary School,
where
villagers were receiving mealie meal, cooking oil, beans and cereals
for
children from World Vision Zimbabwe.
"It's good that we got this
food but we are still waiting for the government
to give us farming inputs
because we will still need to eat next year. We
can't even afford to buy a
packet of seed," said an old woman clutching to
her breast a 5-kg bag of
mealie meal.
"A 25 kg bag of maize seed is going for $100 000 while a 50
kg bag of
fertiliser is almost twice the price of maize seed Ñ who can can
afford
that? Ñ and what of the bus fare to go and buy the inputs," asked the
woman.
As if poverty was not enough for the suffering villagers, the
constituency
has been hit by a cholera out-break which has been attributed to
lack of
protected water sources and toilets.
The only few blair
toilets in the area were constructed through the
assistance of World Vision,
otherwise the bush provides relief to the
majority of villagers when
answering the call of nature.
"There has been a cholera out-break in Mt
Darwin because a lot of people are
using bush toilets and some still fetch
water from unprotected sources such
as rivers," said Ambuya
Chirise.
"They (Zanu PF) don't even realise that we need decent blair
toilets," she
added.
High levels of unemployment have hit the area and
the Border Gezi training
centres have failed to accommodate the
ever-increasing number of unemployed
youths who are searching for
opportunities to better their impoverished
lives.
"We have been told
many times to come up with a list of people who want to
join the centres but
all in vain. They have never given us a reason why we
can't secure places at
the centres.
"At least that's the only way we can secure employment
because we have tried
to find jobs in government but were told to first go
and join the youth
training centres," said Mafara, one of the unemployed
youth.
The Great Exodus Continues
Zimbabwe Standard
(Harare)
December 15, 2003
Posted to the web December 15,
2003
Henry Makiwa
AN armed police officer confidently struts
on the broken-down pavement while
he gazes at the reflection of his AK 47 on
the long glass doors at the
entrance of Harare's Corner House the offices of
the British High Commission
to Zimbabwe. Three other equally armed police
officers menacingly stand a
distance away, their eyes hovering on hundreds of
people who form a snaking
queue waiting for the hard-to-get visas at the
mission.
Among the scores of people is Nomore Gore, an unemployed but
qualified
telecommunications technician.
"I have been there before, we
(Zimbabweans) have taken over London like our
own country," Gore
says.
"You have university graduates like myself who have failed to get
employment
at home relocating there because we have no choice," he
says.
"The bad politics and economic meltdown here is the reason why many
of us
are going these far-flung places even though we love our Zimbabwe," he
says
while jostling for a vantage position in the winding queue.
Gore
says despite the stringent British visa requirements and a steep rise
in
airfares, the UK remains one of the most favoured destinations
for
Zimbabweans seeking relief from economic hardships at home
This is
evident by the increasing number of people visiting the British
High
Commission in search of visas in the past fortnight.
At some
point, the mission reportedly asked the riot police to contain the
situation
after an increasing flood of Zimbabweans seeking visas besieged
its offices,
some sleeping on the pavement outside.
Though an official comment from
the British High Commission could not be
obtained, it was clear the recent
wave of visa seekers was unprecedented,
taking into consideration the high
visa fees required.
Scores of people mill around the offices each working
day these days. A few
days ago, before security was stepped up, many would
even sleep at the
office's entrance.
Such is the desperation of many
Zimbabweans who want to flee from the
country, once the envy of the
region.
Across town, at the South African High Commission offices,
chaotic scenes of
Zimbabweans desperate to get visas, are now a thing of the
past, thanks to
the introduction of restrictive visa requirements.
The
SA government last month imposed a new visa regime which requires
Zimbabweans
to show proof of 1 000 rands in the form of traveller's cheques,
in response
to the growing numbers of people entering their country.
"Since the new
visa regime was introduced not too many people come here
anymore," said a
security officer manning the premises.
"One can simply come and apply for
his visa in no time as long as he is
armed with proof of the thousand rands,"
he added.
The new arrangement has however, adversely affected the
business of
middlemen, who were charging to facilitate the quick issuance of
visas.
One of them, a middle-aged man donning a well-worn shirt and faded
jeans and
standing a few hundred metres away from the South African High
Commission's
offices, says before the new visa regime, his business was
good.
"It's true that there are not too many people coming here anymore.
But I
reckon if you go to Limpopo River you will see them," he says,
punctuating
his remarks with a shrill call to advertise his
business.
But crossing the border into the "Promised Land" down south is
risky
business.
The illegal Zimbabwean emigrants have to crawl through
the wilderness that
lies between the two neighbouring countries before they
are halted by the
rushing waters of the Limpopo, one of the largest rivers in
Southern Africa.
In the river are hippos and crocodiles that lie in
ambush, waiting to topple
rickety boats to get at their human
cargo.
If one is lucky to cross the river, there are still miles and
miles of
twisting barbed wire to trascend and worse, there is also the danger
of
being caught by patrolling South African National Defence Force soldiers
who
are ready to shoot any fleeing aliens.
Jeremiah Ndou, the South
African High Commissioner in Harare, says his
country has however eased the
rules governing Zimbabweans living on the
border with South
Africa.
"We have devised special permits for Zimbabweans living in
Beitbridge to be
allowed to do shopping across the border in the northern
border town of
Musina and return home without having to travel to Harare for
visas," said
Ndou.
"We have also set up other functions for
informal traders to be allowed into
South Africa, without showing the 1 000
rand requirement, if they can
convince the immigration officers that they
will be able to raise such an
amount for their upkeep
"It is
understood and felt by all that the foreign currency situation is
severe that
is why we have to map out strategies to halt the recession,"
Ndou told The
Standard in an interview recently.
Standard Comment: Zim and the Commonwealth
Zimbabwe Standard
(Harare)
EDITORIAL
December 15, 2003
Posted to the web December 15,
2003
THE last kicks of a dying horse? Yes. A craze for attention and
reverence?
Perhaps. An unharnessed ego of a small child? Indeed. Wild man of
Africa on
a senseless warpath? Definitely.
How else can one explain
the crazy decision on the part of the government of
Zimbabwe to pull the
country out of the Commonwealth. What conceivable
benefit is there in such a
course of action?
As New Zealand Prime Minister Helen Clark rightly
pointed out: "The Zimbabwe
government's decision to withdraw is not a
disaster for the Commonwealth. It
is an indictment of Zimbabwe's government
that it has chosen this path."
In today's rapidly globalising and
inter-dependent world, countries are
seizing opportunities to maximise
friends and minimise adversaries. It is
most unfortunate that Zimbabwe is
moving backwards when most of the world is
moving forward.
Elsewhere
in this issue, we provide a fraction of the benefits Ñ
quantifiable and
unquantifiable Ñ that have accrued to Zimbabwe before and
after independence.
The gains are enormous and space limitations prevent us
from doing justice to
them.
No amount of posturing, showmanship and grandstanding by the likes
of Stan
Mudenge and the gormless and brainwashed battalions in the ruling
Zanu PF
party can wash away the importance of the Commonwealth to the people
of
Zimbabwe.
Contrary to what is in the market place, much of what
happened in Abuja did
not reflect a white-black divide on the fundamental
principles and values of
democracy and human rights. The clear consensus of
the Abuja Chogm was that
democracy was the road map of the future.
Differences of opinion and
emphasis emerged on whether reform in Zimbabwe can
best be achieved by the
country remaining suspended or from
within.
Zimbabwe's supporters led by South African President Thabo Mbeki
opposed
continuing suspension arguing that President Mugabe should be
encouraged to
reform by being reinstated.
But the so-called "white"
Commonwealth of Britain, Australia, Canada and New
Zealand favoured a tougher
line arguing that there was no possible
justification for lifting Zimbabwe's
suspension. In this they won the
unanimous support of a largely silent
majority of Caribbean, Asia and
Pacific states along with a number of African
countries notably Botswana,
Kenya, Ghana, Gambia and Sierra
Leone.
Clearly therefore, Africa is not united on the Zimbabwe crisis.
Neither is
there one Sadc view on the country. The vote over the renewal of
Don
Mckinnon's term by 40 votes to 11 showed that there was no African
consensus
on how to deal with the Zimbabwe issue.
South Africa opposed
the re-election of Mckinnon in favour of little known
Sri Lankan candidate
simply because of Mckinnon's determination to continue
with the suspension of
Zimbabwe until the country complied with the Harare
Declaration
principles.
It behoves ill of South Africa that they could go for a man
whose name most
of the world knew nothing about. Lashman Kadirgamer of Sri
Lanka was an
unknown quantity. This was amply demonstrated by the former
Canadian Prime
Minister Jean Chretien in a press briefing: "There was a
candidate who stood
against Mckinnon. I don't know him. I have never met him
and if I did, I
don't remember."
Even the Group of Six countries
comprising Jamaica, Australia, Canada,
India, South Africa and Mozambique
appointed by the Commonwealth leaders to
try to dispose of the Zimbabwe issue
produced a consensus document
recommending continued suspension of Zimbabwe
although South Africa and
Mozambique later voiced "strong disagreement" with
the decision.
The dissociation of South Africa and Mozambique from the
Group of Six
consensus report did not go down well with the host chairman
President
Obasanjo. Describing the behaviour of these countries as unethical,
Obasanjo
went further to say: "In a situation like this, consensus means that
you may
not have your way. Consensus really means that you can smile with one
side
of your face and frown with the other side at the same
time."
Smiling or frowning, the point must be forcefully made that the
Zimbabwe
government is clearly in breach of the Harare Declaration whose
essential
ingredients include genuine democracy, human rights, good
governance, the
rule of law, freedom of expression and the independence of
the judiciary.
In today's Commonwealth, you do not arrest opposition
members and close down
newspapers and hope to get away with it.
The
report by the Commonwealth observer team on the Presidential election
last
year which was the basis for Zimbabwe's suspension was not flawed as
Foreign
Affairs Minister Stan Mudenge would have us believe. The crisis of
governance
including political violence, widespread hunger and unemployment
and the
collapse of the economy are all staring us in the face right
now.
Zimbabwe was a thriving democracy which sadly has gone down the
hill. And
President Obasanjo, Prime Ministers Tony Blair and John Howard far
from what
Mugabe wants the world to believe, mean well for
Zimbabwe.
So does President Mbeki and the other Sadc leaders Ð only that
there are
differences of approach and tactics. Playing the race card as
President
Mugabe is doing will not help to find solutions to our political
problems.
The Harare Declaration principles, ironically drawn up in
Harare in 1991,
are still on the Zanu PF table. Meet and comply with them and
you are back,
is the clarion call. Commonwealth leaders' desire is to
re-engage Zimbabwe
and assist it to return to the Commonwealth family of
nations. As President
Obasanjo pledged:
"We are determined to do
everything possible within the Commonwealth
principles and values to see that
Zimbabwe is returned to the fold. I will
leave no stone unturned to carry out
my mandate to the best of my ability."
Mr President, it is not the right
thing to do to thumb one's nose at those
who are merely trying to help.
State Leading Human Rights Abuse: Lawyers
Zimbabwe Standard
(Harare)
December 15, 2003
Posted to the web December 15,
2003
THE State security apparatus, mandated with protecting human
rights, are the
most guilty of violating people's rights in Zimbabwe as the
country recedes
into total political and economic chaos, the Zimbabwe Lawyers
for Human
Rights (ZLHR) has said.
Speaking on the International Human
Rights' Day last week ZLHR chairperson,
Nokuthula Moyo, lamented the current
state of affairs where the supposed
custodians of law have become the
abusers.
She said Zimbabwe's human rights climate had deteriorated year
by year since
the country started commemorating the global Human Rights Day a
few years
ago.
"We have regressed to the extent that those organs of
State, which should be
protecting and upholding human rights, such as the
police, are the ones who
are the most guilty of violating people's rights,"
said Moyo.
Some of the attacks have been targeted at the most vocal human
rights
defenders, including lawyers, throwing Zimbabwe into the
international
limelight for the wrong reasons.
Moyo said the attack of
human rights defenders by President Robert Mugabe's
security agents mirrors
the government's lack commitment to upholding and
the promotion of basic
rights.
She noted: "It is a pathetic human rights record for our police
force that
lawyers have suffered abuse at the hands of the police. It is a
reflection
of a lack of commitment by our government to the protection and
promotion of
human rights."
Prominent lawyers that have been subjected
to verbal abuse or beatings by
the police and other extra judicial forces
include Beatrice Mtetwa, Arnold
Tsunga, Gugulethu Moyo, Alec Chadehama,
Kossam Ncube and Gabriel Shumba.
There has been a number of mass protests
sponsored by organisations such as
the National Constitutional Assembly
(NCA), Women of Zimbabwe Arise (Woza),
the Zimbabwe Congress of Trade Unions
(ZCTU) and the opposition Movement for
Democratic Change (MDC) against
Mugabe's rule.
Each time there were demonstrations, a great number of
people were arrested
and lawyers had a difficult time trying to have access
to their clients. In
some cases, they were assaulted, verbally abused and
denied access to their
clients.
Several people were allegedly beaten,
tortured and murdered by security
forces during both the 2000 parliamentary
election and the controversial
presidential poll last year.
Some of
the accused agents continue to hold positions of influence and are
moving
freely, committing more heinous crimes. The majority of those killed
were
opposition MDC supporters.
The actions of the police, together with other
state security agents such as
the army and the Central Intelligence
Organisation (CIO), reflects badly on
the country's international human
rights record.
According to the Southern Africa Trade Unions Coordinating
Council (Satucc),
an umbrella body of trade unions in the region, Mugabe's
government tops the
list of brutal and oppressive regimes in southern Africa
followed by
Swaziland.
The organisation has since Southern African
Development Community (SADC)
chairman, Benjamin Mkapa, to rein in Mugabe's
repressive regime.
New Zimbabwe
Botswana disowns SADC statement on Zim
By
newzimbabwe.com staff
15/12/03
THE Botswana government has sensationally
disowned a statement by some
southern African countries condemning Zimbabwe's
suspension from the
Commonwealth.
Jeff Ramsay, spokesman to President
Festus Mogae said contrary to a recent
news reports, Botswana was not and is
not a party to the statement issued by
a number of SADC member states, dated
December 9, "On the Continuation of
the Suspension of Zimbabwe from the
Councils of the Commonwealth".
It should be further noted that Botswana
was not in fact present at the
meeting at which certain SADC countries agreed
to issue the said Statement
distancing themselves from the position taken by
the Commonwealth as a
whole, he said.
Observers say this indicates a
split within the SADC community which
manifested itself when some countries,
including Botswana and Malawi, voted
for Don McKinnon to continue as
Commonwealth secretary general while other
countries led by South Africa and
Zambia tried to lead a rebellion.
It is likely, they say, that the
statement could have been drafted by one of
the SADC countries, most probably
South Africa, then circulated for
endorsement by other
countries.
Ramsay said it was also Botswana's consistent position that
the suspension
imposed on Zimbabwe by the Commonwealth should be lifted so as
to allow
Zimbabwe to remain fully engaged as a member of the Councils of
the
Commonwealth.
"In the spirit of compromise, Botswana accepted the
Commonwealth Heads of
Government of member state's (CHOGM) decision to
endorse the recommendations
of the special Committee as was reflected in the
final CHOGM Statement on
Zimbabwe. This is in accordance with our known
democratic traditions".
The SADC statement condemned Zimbabwe's
suspension from the Commonwealth,
blaming it on the "dismissive, intolerant
and rigid attitude" of some member
countries.
"The present situation
in Zimbabwe calls for engagement by the Commonwealth
and not isolation and
further punishment," said a statement by those members
of the 14-nation
Southern African Development Community (SADC) which are
also members of the
Commonwealth.
"This decision will do nothing to assist the people of
Zimbabwe overcome
their present difficulties. As we warned, it has resulted
in Zimbabwe
withdrawing from the Commonwealth," it said.
New Zimbabwe
The Zimbabwe we live in
By Chido
Makunike
15/12/03
ONE of the things I endeavor to do in this column is to
give Zimbabweans
living outside the country a flavour of life at home beyond
the news stories
they read, watch or listen to where ever they
are.
The mere facts of some event or another are not sufficient to give
a
consumer of news a full picture of it. While I cannot completely fill in
the
gaps, I will strive to provide nuance and flesh beyond the bare
bones.
Hate propaganda
Hate speech has become entrenched in Zimbabwean
politics to an extent that
is surprising for a society that has always prided
itself for at least a
surface politeness. In the last few years since
Jonathan Moyo took over the
government propaganda portfolio, political
discourse has almost completely
lost any good-naturedness it might have had
before. His deep personal hates
and complexes are fully mirrored in the venom
of the propaganda that is
spewed forth against opponents of the Mugabe regime
in the state newspapers
and electronic media.
There is little
intelligent debate about anything anymore. It has been
almost entirely
replaced by name calling, the most common tactics being to
label dissenters
from the government line stooges of the west or the whites,
sell-outs and so
forth. It matters little that some of those who orchestrate
the demonisation
of government opponents could not withstand scrutiny on
some of the charges
they so freely hurl themselves.
Professionals in the media have been
replaced by a hungry group of young
"journalists" with little sense of
professionalism and even less of personal
esteem and probity. Young chaps
with rudimentary writing and grammatical
skills, but who are enthusiastically
amenable to instruction from their
political masters spin astonishingly crude
tales of conjecture, innuendo and
insults dressed up as news.
Even if
one concedes that the state media will back the government of the
day, it's
lack of proportion is mind-numbing. One looking for a well
reasoned, well
researched and written defense of government positions is
sorely disappointed
to read or tune in to any of the state media. The
"dumbing down" of the state
media in these waning days of the Mugabe
government will be one of the
legacies for which Jonathan Moyo will long be
remembered.
Experience,
tight thinking, good writing and a sense of integrity have
completely given
way to the ability to perform fascinating mental and verbal
gymnastics in the
defense of the government. I have often thought that the
propaganda is often
so overdone that it must often embarrass those it is
designed to defend, but
this could be a naive misreading of the sense of
proportion of the ruling
authorities on my part! Still, there are many times
that I have thought the
outlandishness of some pro-Mugabe story or opinion
piece must surely turn off
the least bit discerning reader.
Implicit in the puerile propaganda we
are bombarded with is the idea that
most of the readers/listeners/watchers
will not know any better than what
they are being told. That their
intelligence levels and powers of
discernment will not allow them to see that
what they are being regaled with
is so patently at odds with what they
experience! Yet certainly for the
newspaper and TV information that is mainly
consumed by the urban
populations, we now have electoral evidence to suggest
that the vast
majority simply do not believe what they are fed by the state
media.
We are bombarded with speeches, songs,discussion programs that
are
pro-establishment , with not a second allowed to opposing views, yet
the
urban electorate has consistently rejected ruling party candidates in
most
recent elections. They may read, listen and watch, but they by and large
do
not believe!
Nothing for free
As things get tighter and more
desperate economically, things that one could
take for granted before have
now assumed economic value. Leave your car
lights on and need a push to get
your car started? Before,in any crowded
area one could count on the good
natured help of several volunteers. Now one
is likely to have to undergo a
several minutes haggling session first.
It is an opportunity for one who
is lower on the socio-economic ladder to
wring some concessions from one more
privileged than he, at least for those
few minutes. The calculations and
underlying tensions involved in even this
kind of seemingly simple, harmless
bargaining are relatively new to this
society. Have a flat tyre or battery in
the "wrong place" at night, and
those who might help you for a fee by day are
more likely in today's
Zimbabwe to rob and manhandle you. They might not be
"professionals," but
crimes of opportunity have skyrocketed as everybody's
economic fortunes have
plummeted.
Service
The quality of all kinds
of services have deteriorated across the board for
all kinds of reasons,
including the difficulties with fuel, which have
recently began to ease as
private importers secure their supply lines and
motorists become accustomed
to prices up to ten times those of earlier in
the year. In many stores
customers who complain about anything are looked at
askance by both floor
personnel and management.
The attitude that you must simply accept what
you can get is becoming
entrenched. Till operators who hold private
conversations amongst themselves
while customers wait to pay for goods are
not unusual sights any more. A few
months ago I watched with disgust as one
ate and drank noisily at the once
upscale suburban branch of a leading
supermarket chain in between punching
entries into his machine. I know the
manager and could have complained to
him but the standards at this and many
other stores have deteriorated so
steadily over the years I didn't think it
would make any difference.
Besides, one now tends to keep one's energy for
the many bigger battles one
must fight to get through a Zimbabwean
day!
Tension levels
Zimbabweans are still an amazingly good natured
people given the stunning
fall in their standard of living in the last few
years, but it is not hard
to find signs of how the stresses of daily life are
taking a toll on various
kinds of relationships.
For instance, it is
difficult to keep track of all the economic sectors that
are on strike for
better wages as inflation fast moves towards 600%.
There is deep
suspicion between government and civil servants, with doctors
at government
hospitals having been on strike for months now, with no sign
of any serious
effort to deal with the cause of their grievances. In the
private sector
where there may be presumed to be a better appreciation by
all of the link
between the state of the economy, company productivity and
employee
remuneration, workers and management in a lot of companies are
at
loggerheads, each trying to get more out of the other than working
together
to try to find ways of weathering the economic storm.
When
relations get bad enough, it almost always leads to the downsizing or
closure
of the company after the details of the labour dispute have faded
from the
news. Productivity and morale in many places of employment is very
low as the
country's mood of depression touches all but the most
resilient.
Politics
At the moment the country might as well be a one
party state, with the
ruling party having completely failed to deal with any
of the issues
pre-occupying Zimbabweans, but nevertheless totally dominating
the political
space. This has been made a lot easier by the closure of the
Daily News as
well as the rash of repressive laws meant to keep a very tight
lid over
demonstrations and any displays of dissent.
Despite all the
odds stacked against the opposition MDC, it is still
surprising that a party
whose main cry is "change!" has so failed to
innovate ways around designs to
keep it down. A few weeks ago a lackluster
end of year message from party
president Morgan Tsvangirai made the rounds
but otherwise the party is for
the moment disappeared from the public
consciousness. Parliament has recently
been in session but that body has
never been as removed from the day to day
concerns of the people as it is
now, with both ZANU-PF and MDC members
seemingly very remote from and
irrelevant to their constituents.
On
the land
Considering that Zimbabwe and Mugabe's notoriety is mainly over "the
land
issue," it is shocking how little activity is in evidence on the
farms
expropriated from white landholders. At the end of the last rain season
I
had occasion to drive from Harare to Kariba in the north, Bulawayo in
the
south and Mutare in the east. Like many others, I was stunned by the lack
of
activity along the main highways that had previously given one a
passing
glimpse of Zimbabwe's agricultural power. Even allowing for the
many
problems with the land exercise, it was a frightening picture of
desolation.
In the last few weeks, at the beginning of this year's
worryingly late and
so far spotty rain season, the picture on all three major
highways is little
changed. Perhaps all the new farmers have chosen to work
the land away from
the highways out of modesty! Cynical, far-flung supporters
of Mugabe to whom
taking the land is completely divorced from what is done
with it for the
benefit of the "previously marginalised" do not give a damn
that Mugabe's
chaos has made it all but impossible for the vast majority of
those who
genuinely hoped for a better deal from land reform to use it to
any
significant economic degree. The rains are late again this year, but even
if
they should be good for the rest of the season, much as I would want to
hope
otherwise, there is little evidence on the ground to give reasons
for
optimism about a bumper harvest. We are likely to depend on food
handouts
for years to come.
Except for a very few, life in Zimbabwe
has declined in quality
precipitously again this year. One can be cushioned
by money or power from
the deprivations that most Zimbabweans are suffering,
but there are many
levels at which the decline affects you regardless of what
your vantage
point is.
chidomakunike@yahoo.com
This Day, Nigeria
My Meeting with Mugabe after CHOGM, by
Obasanjo
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
----
President
Olusegun Obasanjo yesterday disclosed that he met "a little bit
angry"
President Robert Mugabe of Zimbabwe in Geneva a day after the end of
the
Commonwealth Heads of Government Meeting (CHOGM) in Abuja.
The
disclosures which was made during the president's media chat on NTA is
ahead
of the visit of a delegation to the Southern African country to pave
way for
the return of Zimbabwe to the Commonwealth before Christmas as
announced by
Obasanjo in his capacity as the chairperson-in-sitting of
the
Commonwealth.
Obasanjo, however, expressed optimism that Zimbabwe
will soon return to the
Commonwealth, giving an accord of his Geneva meeting
with Mugabe, he said
"of course rightly, he (Mugabe) was a little bit angry.
He said if he will
receive me, he will receive me as president of Nigeria and
not an envoy of
the Commonwealth which is understandable."
"We chatted
as two brothers and president Mugabe is a very honourable and
reasonable
person. I have always said that I understand how he is feeling
and all I want
to do is to help him and help Zimbabwe alone who has to do
something. The
other side too will have to do something. And all of us in
the Commonwealth
will also have to help both sides because both sides need
help," he stated.
Obasanjo regretted that "it was really unfortunate from
all that I know. I
wish Zimbabwe had gone a little bit faster or that GHOGM
had come a little
bit later. Maybe the situation that happened (suspension
of Zimbabwe from the
Commonwealth), would not ahve happened."
ZWNews
Ministers behind illegal gold
trade
Zimbabwe Standard
published:Sun
14-Dec-2003
Four Cabinet ministers, two deputy
ministers and an army general have
been identified as kingpins in the illegal
trade in gold
By Kumbirai Mafunda
Four Cabinet
ministers, two deputy ministers and an army general
(names supplied), have
been identified as kingpins in the illegal trade in
gold that is draining the
country of one of its most valuable resources, The
Standard has established.
The ministers, who include an influential former
Zapu leader from
Matabeleland South, are said to have cornered the illegal
gold market by
employing agents who sale the precious metal to dealers on
their behalf. The
dealers market the bullion mostly in South Africa. Others
accused of illegal
gold deals include a retired army general, two Cabinet
ministers from
Mashonaland Central, another from Mashonaland West, a
recently retired
provincial governor and two deputy ministers, one from
Mashonaland Central
and the other from the Midlands Province, among others.
Senior
government officials involved in mining told The Standard that
it was clear
that the illegal mining and sale of gold outside Zimbabwe would
continue
unless President Robert Mugabe acted and punished some of his
closest
advisers involved in the scam. “These culprits are very influential.
So how
then do you make decisions to eliminate the trade when you are
involved in
it,” a top mining official said. “Nyaya haisi yemakorokoza. It
is about those
organising the makorokozas,” he said. “Makorokoza” is slang
for illegal gold
panners whom the government is publicly accusing of gold
smuggling. The
ministers and army and police officers, it is alleged, own
milling
concessions and work with most of the prominent illegal gold dealers
in
Kwekwe, Kadoma, Filabusi and Shamva. The Midlands town of Kwekwe, which
is
214 kms from Harare and lies along the gold rich Great Dyke belt, is
under
siege from gold panners who have been locked in running battles with
the
police gold squad, after the government recently banned trading in
the
metal.
“The issue of gold smuggling cannot be resolved as
long as those in
government or positions of authority are working in cahoots
with white-owned
and black-owned milling centres,” said a highly-placed
government official.
“Unless the kingpins who are smuggling gold are dealt
with, we can forget
about clamping down the trade,” he added. Apart from the
ministers, other
officials alleged that gold smuggling was still very rampant
- even after
the recent government crackdown - and most of the culprits were
senior
serving members of the army and police as well as leading politicians.
The
government abruptly cancelled 14 gold concessions last month alleging
that
licenced gold buyers were involved in the illegal trade of the
precious
mineral. Fidelity Printers and Refineries, a unit of the Reserve
Bank, was
instructed to carry out door-to-door buying of gold from milling
centres.
Official sources said the government had begun to reshuffle officers
in its
mining commissioners’ pool as part of cleansing the department.
The
department issues licences for claims and some of its officers have
been
accused of taking bribes as well as owning claims themselves. Efforts to
get
comment from Mines Minister Edward Chindori-Chininga were
unsuccessful.
ZWNews
The open sore of Zimbabwe
Tablet
(UK)
published:Sun 14-Dec-2003
Reversing its
earlier request to keep a low profile for fear of
inflaming Mugabe, the
opposition MDC is calling for Britain to introduce a
motion at the UN in New
York demanding human rights inspections in Zimbabwe.
That would be a
start
Comment
The summit of the Commonwealth nations
in Abuja could have achieved
great things: a new global consensus on trade or
debt, for example, or a new
impetus to the battle against Aids. It achieved
none of these things, and
broke up in acrimony over how to deal with the
dictatorship of Robert
Mugabe. On the one side President Thabo Mbeki of South
Africa wanted
Zimbabwe readmitted to the Commonwealth after its 18-month
suspension. Mr.
Mbeki, supported by seven or eight of his neighbours, argues
that Zimbabwe
is going through a transition similar to that of South Africa a
decade ago
and that while terrible things are happening, progress is being
made. He
also believes in an African solution to an African problem and
resents any
interference by outsiders, especially Britain and other "white"
Commonwealth
members. Indeed, he fears being seen as the West’s policeman in
Africa. On
the other side Britain and others insisted that membership of
the
Commonwealth presumes certain standards of civil and human rights, and
that
Mugabe’s regime clearly fails this test.
Despite the best
efforts of the chairman, President Olusegun Obasanjo,
the summit ended in
bitterness. Britain and others won and Zimbabwe remained
suspended. Mr.
Mugabe promptly tore up Zimbabwe’s membership card and the
South Africans
said "I told you so." The relationship between Mr. Mbeki and
Tony Blair, who
has tried to garner more international help for Africa, has
been seriously
damaged. But the real victims of the failure in Abuja are the
people of
Zimbabwe. As Archbishop Pius Ncube of Bulawayo describes in these
pages [in a
BBC interview reproduced], people are quietly dying in their
thousands as the
economy spins downwards and the repression grows ever more
brutal and
indiscriminate. Unlike most of the other bishops in Zimbabwe,
both Anglican
and Catholic, Archbishop Ncube has had the courage to put his
head above the
parapet and name what is happening to his country. It is an
evil regime, he
says, which is willing to sacrifice the lives of thousands
of ordinary
Zimbabweans for the sake of remaining in power. Archbishop Ncube
’s powerful
moral witness deserves to be listened to, and acted upon.
But what
action? Zimbabweans cannot take the matter into their own
hands. Mugabe rigs
elections, beats and tortures demonstrators, and exerts a
reign of terror
which makes an internal political answer impossible. The
answer must come
from the outside. Zimbabwe’s tragedy is that South Africa,
the country which
could most easily remove Mugabe simply by turning off the
supplies of
electricity and oil on which he depends, refuses to do so out of
a misplaced
loyalty to a fellow anti-colonial freedom fighter. The task
therefore falls
to Europe and the United States. Reversing its earlier
request to keep a low
profile for fear of inflaming Mugabe, the opposition
MDC is calling for
Britain to introduce a motion at the UN in New York
demanding human rights
inspections in Zimbabwe. That would be a start.