The ZIMBABWE Situation | Our
thoughts and prayers are with Zimbabwe - may peace, truth and justice prevail. |
HARARE, Zimbabwe
(AFX) - The government has formally rejected a report
by the Commonwealth
that said the election which returned President Robert
Mugabe to power
earlier this year was not free and fair.
In
March, Zimbabwe was suspended from the councils of the 54 nation
body on the
basis of the report by the Commonwealth Observer Group that
witnessed the
election.
Willard Chiwewe, senior
secretary for foreign affairs, said the
government has "come to the
conclusion that the composition of the
(observer) group, its intentions,
procedures, methodology and conclusions
were flawed in the
extreme,".
The report could therefore not
"be a legitimate guide for Zimbabwe's
relations and status in the
Commonwealth," he told a news
conference.
The ICC's international development board (IDI) took the decision after receiving a 12-page report from a delegation which recently visited Zimbabwe to assess safety issues.
Although South Africa is the main host of the competition, six first round games will be played in Zimbawe and two in Kenya.
Controversy continues, however, with opposition leaders in Zimbabwe and a number of English MPs calling for a boycott because of the policies being pursued by president Robert Mugabe's government.
The ICC is a cricket organisation - not a political
institution ICC chief Malcolm
Speed |
Shadow Foreign Secretary Michael Ancram recently claimed that Mr. Mugabe would see the tournament as an opportunity for "strutting on the world stage".
But ICC chief executive Malcolm Speed said they were only concerned with cricket-related issues.
"Some countries have issued limited sanctions on Zimbabwe, but no country has imposed sporting sanctions on Zimbabwe.
"Sporting sanctions are not a new weapon. The point here is they have not been used in relation to Zimbabwe and there have been many opportunities to adopt that course.
"Zimbabwe is one of the 10 full members of the ICC and has earned the right to host matches.
"There is common ground that Zimbabwe is a troubled country, but our aim is to try and bring a positive element to people in Zimbabwe, those who are interested in cricket and want to watch cricket."
Little impact
UK Sports Minister Richard Caborn has indicated that the government will abide by the decisions of the ICC and England and Wales Cricket Board.
And former England captain Mike Gatting said he doubted whether refusing to play in Zimbabwe would have a significant impact on the Mugabe government in any event.
World Cup games in Zimbabwe |
10 Feb Zimbabwe v Namibia, Harare
13 Feb Zimbabwe v England, Harare
19 Feb Zimbabwe v India, Harare
24 Feb Zimbabwe v Australia,
Bulawayo
28 Feb Zimbabwe v Netherlands,
Bulawayo
4 Mar Zimbabwe v Pakistan,
Bulawayo |
"I don't think anybody likes what's going out there, sportsmen included. I think again the politicians have handed sports people a lovely hot potato to carry, when we can't do much about it.
"Even if the tour is cancelled, would that make any difference at all to Mr. Mugabe?
"In South Africa it might have done because they are much more sport-oriented, but I'm not sure it will do in Zimbabwe," Gatting commented.
The Australian Cricket Board pulled their team out of a tour to Zimbabwe earlier this year because of security concerns.
But a recent series against Pakistan passed off without incident, a series which coincided with the visit of the ICC delegation.
Should the situation in Zimbabwe deteriorate, however, the ICC has put contingency arrangements in place to switch games to South Africa.
Speed also said the Zimbabwe government has given assurances that all officially accredited journalists would be allowed into the country to report on the cricket.
- HARARE
(Reuters) - Zimbabwe has ordered fuel worth more than $15
million from Kuwait
and South Africa to ease a shortage that has brought the
country to a virtual
standstill, a cabinet minister was quoted as
saying
Thursday.
A two-week shortage
has nearly paralyzed Zimbabwe's public transport
system, plunging the
southern African country deeper into its worst economic
crisis in decades and
provoking anger at the government of President
Robert
Mugabe.
Energy and Power
Development Minister Amos Midzi told the official
Herald newspaper the
state-owned National Oil Company of Zimbabwe (NOCZIM)
had bought fuel worth
more than $15 million from Kuwait's International
Petroleum Group and Engen
Petroleum of South Africa to ease the
crisis.
Supplies were expected in the
coming days, he said. It was not
immediately clear how the embattled
government would pay.
Midzi, who has been
silent while fuel pumps run dry, said the state
oil procurement agency was
not to blame for the crisis -- his first response
to charges of sabotage and
corruption leveled at NOCZIM by the Herald
newspaper last
week.
He said foreign currency shortages,
expenditure on food imports and
Zimbabwe's inability to meet all demands for
beef, sugar and tobacco to pay
for Libyan oil imports were to
blame.
"We are going through a difficult
time in terms of the availability of
foreign currency to enable the country
to procure adequate stocks of fuel,"
he
said.
Midzi added that a deal with Libya
to supply 70 percent of Zimbabwe's
oil needs in exchange for investment
opportunities and agricultural
commodities had not collapsed -- as reported
in the local media -- but had
run into problems because Harare could not
provide all the goods required.
"We did
not have enough sugar, tobacco and we have not been able to
meet Libya's meat
requirements," he said, adding that Zimbabwe had started
to export beef to
Libya and tea would be next.
Midzi said
the government would not raise fuel prices because it
wanted to protect
consumers hit by hardships as Zimbabwe struggles with
record high
unemployment and inflation.
Nearly half of
the 14 million people in Zimbabwe, once Africa's bread
basket, now face
severe food shortages caused by drought and Mugabe's
controversial land
reform policies.
Mugabe blames his
problems on domestic and foreign opponents who he
says are trying to
overthrow him for seizing white-owned farms for
redistribution to landless
blacks.
Sunday
Times (SA)
Mugabe scorns coalition
claims
Zimbabwean President Robert Mugabe today scorned claims
by opposition leader
Morgan Tsvangirai that the government was seeking a
meeting with the
opposition Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) to form a
coalition after
three years of political crisis.
Mugabe spokesman
George Charamba accused Tsvangirai of "a silly attempt to
reposition the MDC"
following a string of by-election defeats, which
indicated waning grassroots
support.
A spokesman for the MDC today confirmed the authenticity of a
leaked
statement, claiming that Mugabe was seeking a meeting with
Tsvangirai.
"The cutting edge of the diabolical onslaught is supposed to
come in the
form of a summit between Robert Mugabe and myself," said the
statement. "I
am reliably informed that Mugabe is prepared to meet with me
somewhere
outside the country to discuss his problems."
The statement
was released at a hastily summoned meeting yesterday between
Tsvangirai, his
54 MPs, and MDC local councillors.
Tsvangirai's party rejects the result
of March presidential elections, and
subsequent local polls, claiming
widespread rigging, intimidation, and use
of famine relief as a political
weapon.
Tsvangirai rejected any compromise with Mugabe until food
supplies to eight
million famine victims is "de-politicised", free political
activity is
allowed and Mugabe commits himself to fresh democratic
elections.
Foreign minister Nkosana Dlamini-Zuma said on Tuesday she was
preparing to
visit Zimbabwe in the hope of breaking political
deadlock.
Previous South African sponsored talks between the MDC and
Mugabe's ruling
Zanu(PF) broke down over the MDC's refusal to recognise the
presidential
election result.
Zimbabwe's economy has been brought to
the point of collapse by three years
of political turmoil. Alleging
opposition was being orchestrated by whites
and Britain, Mugabe launched
"fast track" redistribution of 5,000
white-owned farms to 350,000 black
recipients.
The government today announced a new US$15-million Libyan
import scheme, to
end petrol shortages that have paralysed road travel over
the past week.
There are also shortages of maize meal, bread, cooking oil,
salt, milk,
meat, and paraffin.
Sapa-DPA
Kenya Broadcasting Corporation
Opposition leader
rejects meeting with Mugabe
Web posted on:Thursday, December
19, 2002
By BBC
Zimbabwe's opposition leader has refused to meet
President Robert Mugabe to
discuss the political and economic
crisis.
Morgan Tsvangirai says that an "unholy alliance" of Britain,
South Africa
and Mr Mugabe's Zanu-PF party is trying to set up such a
meeting.
But Mr Tsvangirai insists that Mr Mugabe must resign as the
first part of
any solution to Zimbabwe's problems.
This must be
followed by the establishment of a transitional government to
organise free
and fair elections, he said.
He also demanded that the authorities stop
using food aid as a political
weapon.
Up to six million people,
half of the population, face starvation and
western countries, human rights
groups and the opposition Movement for
Democratic Change (MDC) say that MDC
activists are being barred from
receiving food aid.
Former
colonial power Britain and regional strongman South Africa are key
players in
the Zimbabwe crisis.
Mr Mugabe accuses Britain of plotting to oust
him, while the MDC wants South
Africa to take stronger action against the
Zimbabwe authorities.
"I am reliably informed that Mugabe is prepared
to meet with me somewhere
outside the country to discuss his problems," Mr
Tsvangirai told a meeting
of MDC MPs in Harare.
"The Anglo-South
African plan will fail to take off if it remains predicated
on the desire to
legitimise the illegitimate Mugabe regime. We will never be
used to prop up
this dying regime," he said.
A spokesman for the British Foreign
Office neither confirmed nor denied the
claims that it was trying to organise
a meeting between the bitter political
rivals.
But he did tell BBC
News Online that "dialogue is the only way of getting a
lasting solution" and
that this was what the Commonwealth was currently
attempting to
pursue.
From Mr Tsvangirai's speech, it appears that the plan would
involve Mr
Mugabe resigning and being replaced by Emmerson Mnangagwa, the
Speaker of
Parliament.
On Tuesday, Mr Mnangagwa was warmly
received at the congress of South
Africa's ruling African National
Congress.
"If Mugabe is to step down today, nothing will change as
long as the
fundamentals that brought this country to where it is remain
unresolved.
"We are ready to confront the Mugabe stooge at home and
show him the way,"
Mr Tsvangirai said.
Government spokesman George
Charamba told the French news agency, AFP, that
the comments were a "silly
attempt to reposition the MDC".
Mr Mugabe accuses the MDC of being a
front for Britain and white farmers.
A spokesman for the South African
High Commission told AFP that he was not
aware of any plan to organise a
meeting.
The MDC leader says that Mr Mugabe rigged the March election
and that
opposition activists continue to be attacked and tortured for
their
political beliefs.
Mr Mugabe has previously said that he
will not leave power until he has
finished his "land revolution" of
redistributing farms from whites to
blacks. Just a few hundred white farmers
now remain on their land.
But the disruption to agriculture has
worsened the food shortages and
contributed to the economic
meltdown.
Inflation is currently running at 175 per cent, while
unemployment is also
at a record high.
Zim Independent
US$20m Mirror
publishing deal flops
Mthulisi Mathuthu
Libyan investors have dropped a US$20 million
publishing deal with Mirror
proprietor Ibbo Mandaza after he failed to
produce what the investors called
a "credible feasibility
study".
Mandaza lost the much-needed injection into his struggling
company at the
last minute after he was unable to produce the feasibility
study which he
claimed had been done by a Swedish company, Graphium Consult
AB, Stockholm.
The Libyan Arab African Investment Company, who pulled
the plug in October,
are said to have been galled by administrative
complexities in Mandaza's
empire.
The Mirror boss failed to draw a
clear distinction between the Southern
African Printing and Publishing House,
Sapes, Sapem magazine, and the Mirror
raising fears of financial
opacity.
A Tripoli source said the Libyans also cited legal barriers
to media
investment in Zimbabwe which they were unaware of until the
Zimbabwe
Independent broke the story of Libyan interest in the Mirror in
July.
On that occasion, Mandaza denied any links with the Libyan Arab
African
Investment Company, but chairman Mustafa Tayeb-Khattabi confirmed
this week
that they had tried to enter into a partnership with him only for
them to
withdraw due to "feasibility problems".
"We needed to know
everything about the newspaper business in Zimbabwe,"
Tayeb-Khattabi said in
an interview from Tripoli.
"We must know the chances of making
profit, how many companies are in that
business and so on. We couldn't invest
because we were not satisfied. We
didn't see the feasibility studies and we
have to be satisfied as an
investment company," he said.
Mandaza
said he had "no comment" to make on the issue when contacted
on
Wednesday.
Tayeb-Khattabi first met Mandaza together with
Gideon Gono earlier this year
in Tripoli when they signed the Rainbow Tourism
Group and Jewel Bank deals.
It emerged that the Libyans also pulled
out of the related Juliasdale-based
Mvura-Amanzi water bottling project which
they had "in principle" agreed to
fund, at least according to correspondence
between Tayeb-Khattabi
and Mandaza in July.
Tayeb-Khattabi
said they couldn't fund the water bottling project because
the board of
directors was not satisfied with "some issues" and added that
they would
consider it at a later stage.
Mandaza wants to set up a regional
media project publishing his two
newspapers, the Daily Mirror and Sunday
Mirror as well as other regional
publications. It is understood he had also
hoped to purchase a printing
press with the money from the
Libyans.
Mandaza had also promised that the Swedish company would
help instal the
printing press and train staff at the Mirror. Mandaza has
previously failed
to secure loans from Zimbank and Barbican
Holdings.
The Independent also heard this week that four Libyan
companies would arrive
in the country in January to build a hotel in Kariba
and invest in shoe and
plastic manufacturing as well as in cold
storage.
Zim Independent
$2b set aside for
militia centres
Loughty Dube
THE week ahead is generally known as "the festive season" but in
the
Zimbabwe of today, there is little for most to be festive about. Rarely,
if
ever before, has there been such widespread despondency and depression,
and
hardly any believe that the year ahead can yield anything
positive.
It is difficult to convince anyone that matters are not as bad
as they seem,
and even more difficult to persuade the distressed that they
can look
forward to better times.
It is undeniable that 2002 has been
one of the most horrific years of
suffering experienced by Zimbabwe in many
years. The tragedy is that most of
the year's negative occurrences need never
have been.
Admittedly, there have been some most adverse, and not easily
combatable,
factors which impacted severely upon Zimbabwe's wellbeing. These
include the
effects of the blows to the global economy by an upsurge in
terrorism,
heralded by the contempt for innocent human beings demonstrated by
the
hijacking of United States aircraft and the crashing of those aircraft
into
the World Trade Centre Twin Towers and into the
Pentagon.
Zimbabwe was not immune to the sudden economic constraints for
the
international economic decline, compounded by the most adverse
international
perceptions of Zimbabwe, brought to a virtual standstill any
foreign direct
investment in Zimbabwe, and contributed significantly to the
immense
decrease in tourism from September 2001, and only now showing some
slight
recovery.
Similarly, the deleterious consequences of the
2001/2002 drought that
affected almost all of sub-Saharan Africa cannot be
denied. Inevitably it
undermined the viability of the agricultural industry,
which is the
foundation upon which the Zimbabwean economy is built.
In
particular, the drought resulted in only minimal production of maize and
of
other crops in the communal lands, where own-consumption needs have
been
produced for many decades by the millions who live in those lands.
That
commercial agricultural production which had not been destroyed by
the
strong-arm approach to land acquisition also suffered.
But,
however greatly the world economic circumstance and the drought
affected the
Zimbabwean economy, they were of limited effect compared with
the Zimbabwean
generated assaults upon an economy which had shown that it
had much potential
for growth.
It did so very markedly from 1994 to 1997, in which period
inflation fell by
almost 75%, numbers in employment increased, foreign and
domestic investment
grew rapidly, currency exchange rates stabilised,
shortages were eliminated,
taxation became much less, and all economic fronts
advanced significantly.
Oblivious to the magnitude of economic growth
achieved over a relatively
short period of time, government embarked upon
ill-considered,
politically-driven policies which not only caused a total
cessation of that
spectacular economic growth, but wholly reversed all that
had been achieved
and reduced the economy to levels lower than had existed at
any time during
the preceding one hundred years.
Government rejected
all private sector advice from both domestic and
international sources, as to
the detrimental consequences of its
resurrected, damaging economic policies
which had debilitated the economy
from 1982 to 1993.
It took a stance,
which it still has, that any that disagreed with it are
its enemies, and that
their disagreements with government were deliberately
ill-intentioned and
driven by self-centred motives and vested interests.
Whensoever such
contrary policies were promoted by any of the international
community or by
any in Zimbabwe's private sector, government would attack
those commending
such policies and, more often that not, would intensify
implementation of its
unsuccessful and counterproductive policies or would
embark upon policies and
measures diametrically opposite to those
recommended to it in order to assert
itself and its independence.
The results have been catastrophic. Yields
from agriculture fell sharply,
for not only did drought limit production, but
of far greater consequence,
the dogmatic pursuit of unjust land policies,
founded upon racism, bigotry,
disregard for economic need, nepotism,
self-enrichment and abuse of human
rights and of law resulted in sharply
decreased agricultural production.
Farms in areas not affected by
drought, and farms with substantial water
resources, were prevented from
producing critically required crops and, in
many instances, even those who
had been able to plant and grow crops were
prevented from harvesting or had
to stand by helplessly whilst others
vandalised and destroyed the crops or
misappropriated them.
Agriculture was not the only sector to suffer, and
to do so greatly. Since
the last devaluation of Zimbabwe's currency in August
2000, government in
general, and President Mugabe in particular, have
steadfastly resisted any
devaluation, notwithstanding that during the two
years following upon that
last devaluation, inflation amounted to
approximately 300%.
Production and operating costs for the mining
industry, manufacturers,
horticultural enterprises and tourism operations,
amongst others, increased
threefold over a two-year period, but no relief
against those cost increases
was available to them through adjustment of
currency exchange rates.
To increase selling prices was an unacceptable
alternative, for to do so
would destroy all price competitiveness in export
markets, resulting in
forfeiture of those markets and the bankruptcy of the
exporter businesses.
The failure to devalue, caused by rigid adherence to
ill-conceived economic
concepts and by an unfounded perception that
devaluation would reflect
adversely upon the sovereignty of Zimbabwe, was the
principal reason for a
parallel market in foreign exchange developing,
reinforced by an
insufficiency of foreign currencies to service Zimbabwe's
needs for import
funding, debt servicing, dividends to foreign investors, and
other essential
foreign exchange commitments.
In turn, the exchange
rates of the parallel market, and of a virile black
market, moved steadily
upwards as demand consistently exceeded supply, and
that escalation of rates
was catalytic of a continuing rise in inflation.
In the past year, a
major factor of surging inflation and economic decline
has been the foolhardy
and inequitable imposition of price controls and,
more recently, of a price
freeze on many goods and services.
Those prices were established by the
Ministry of Industry and International
Trade without considering the
realities of costs, and of ongoing rises in
those costs.
Numerous
products subjected to the controls could not be produced and sold
viably at
the controlled prices. Continuing production could only cause huge
losses for
the producer, culminating in eventual bankruptcy. As a result,
many ceased
production, or diversified into products not subject to
the
controls.
Shortages became intense, and that motivated black
marketeers to source
whatsoever limited quantities of greatly needed
commodities were available,
unlawfully selling them at massively increased
prices to those desperately
seeking the commodities (inclusive of maize meal,
flour, sugar, cooking oil,
salt, bread and much else). Thereby, real
inflation, as distinct from
officially determined rates of inflation, soared
upwards.
So great is the widespread economic distress, the poverty, the
starvation
and the misery, unnecessarily due almost entirely to the state's
adherence
to policies which should never have been embarked upon and, having
been
pursued nevertheless, should be consigned to the nearest waste-bin,
that
there will be very few imbued with any festive emotions next
week.
Instead, there will be millions that will be viewing the future
with great
fear and trepidation, unless government would belatedly
demonstrate the
maturity necessary to acknowledge error, reverse all its
harmful acts,
achieve national and international reconciliation, and thereby
give all
something to celebrate and a hope for the future.
Its track
record to date does not augur well for such a metamorphosis, but
very
occasionally miracles do happen. This year the need for such a miracle
is
desperate, failing which the festive season will sadly be one of
tears.
Zim Independent
Food shortages could
trigger unrest, EIU warns
Godfrey Marawanyika
THE Economist Intelligence Unit (EIU) has said that
the country's political
repression is set to continue as President Robert
Mugabe consolidates his
hold on power against a background of worsening food
shortages.
In its "Political Outlook" report, the EIU said that President
Mugabe and
his party are set to remain in power for the next two years and
possibly for
several years after that.
The report said that,
supported by the country's military and party
militias, Mugabe would maintain
the high level of political repression
against any form of opposition to his
government.
"A central element of the overall pattern of political
repression will be to
slowly, but steadily undermine the main opposition
party, the Movement for
Democratic Change," the just-released report
said.
The repression was likely to be three-pronged, it
said.
Firstly, the ruling party would try to reduce the number of
parliamentary
and local council seats held by the MDC.
It would
also persevere in its attempts to undermine the MDC leadership
through
arbitrary arrests on a range of often spurious charges.
"Finally, the
government will also limit the MDC's ability to organise any
anti-government
protests through the use of some of its recently-passed
legislation, such as
the Public Order and Security Act," the report said.
The report said
in addition to attempts to undermine the MDC, Mugabe's
government would
intensify its repression of the independent and foreign
press,
non-governmental organisations, labour unions and ethnic
minorities.
Already the government has used the draconian Access to
Information and
Protection of Privacy Act to bar foreign journalists from
coming to Zimbabwe
or refusing to renew the work permits of those already
working in the
country.
The EIU said it did not expect any
substantial increase in food supplies
next year, adding Zanu PF supporters
would continue to be rewarded with food
while those suspected to be from the
opposition would be denied it.
"This will be particularly evident in
southern Matabeleland which is
populated by Ndebele people.
"The
government will also try to restrict food aid from being distributed in
urban
areas which have broadly voted in favour of the MDC in recent
elections," the
report said.
"The Mugabe government is taking a calculated gamble
that food shortages,
coupled with the accelerating economic decline, will
weaken the opposition,"
it added.
The EIU report noted that
despite the politicisation of food aid, there
seemed to be very little sign
of widespread anger against the government
that could lead to mass protest,
but it did not rule out the possibility of
protest in the
cities.
"However, there is a possibility that an enraged population,
particularly in
the cities, will revolt," the report
said.
"Worsening food and fuel shortages, triple digit inflation and
rising
unemployment could all provide the spark that leads to mass protest
against
government in 2003," it said. "Of the potential triggers, worsening
food
shortages are the most likely to result in
protest."
Zim Independent
Govt mulls re-opening bureaux de
change
Barnabas Thondhlana
GOVERNMENT is reportedly considering
reversing its decision to close bureaux
de change as the flow of hard
currency to the central bank has now been
reduced to a trickle, analysts have
said.
Whereas in the past the Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe (RBZ) had access
to foreign
currency traded on the bureaux market, the closure has seen even
the little
inflows disappear, worsening an already serious
situation.
"The foreign currency parallel market has gone underground,"
one money
market dealer said.
"Exporters with foreign currency will
henceforth be banking their receipts
offshore to avoid remitting 100% to the
RBZ," he said. "Even Zimbabweans in
the diaspora have now resorted to
converting their foreign currency through
enterprising Zimbabweans in their
adopted countries, with the local currency
being banked here."
An
informal foreign currency market has sprouted which can neither be
monitored
nor controlled.
"It is agreed there were leakages in the bureaux market,
but the economy was
able to access the foreign currency for use in imports
and production," said
a bank executive.
"Noczim, Zesa, even the
central bank dipped into the parallel market to keep
the economy afloat and
make vital payments, but this is no longer the case,"
the executive
said.
It is an open secret in the financial services sector that leading
banks
were commissioned by the RBZ to source foreign currency for it from
the
parallel market.
The closure of bureaux was announced in tandem
with a new ruling that
exporters remit 50% of their receipts to the RBZ and
50% to a pool from
which beneficiaries would be allocated currency on a needs
basis. This led
to the closure of corporate Foreign Currency
Accounts.
While government was of the view that the closure of FCAs would
result in a
bonanza as about US$40 million was deposited in FCAs, all it
managed to
access was a paltry US$4/5 million.
Most of the deposited
funds had been sold or donated to other exporters to
avoid depositing them
with the RBZ and reaping a pegged exchange rate.
The exchange rate, which
at the end of November dipped against the
greenback, has crept back to its
lofty heights of between $1 500/$1 800 to
the United States unit.
The
central bank has reportedly issued a directive to banks to limit
large
withdrawals of money in a bid to nip the foreign currency black market
in
the bud.
Banking sources confirmed that any withdrawals of $5
million and above now
required central bank approval and one had to explain
what one required the
currency for.
"Government was hoping closing
bureaux would see inflows strengthen to about
US$3 million a day, but this
has not materialised," said the money market
dealer.
"Despite hard
lobbying for bureaux not to close, government still went ahead
and shot
itself in the foot. The only option left now is for the re-opening
of the
bureaux and this is expected to occur sometime early next
year."
Association of Bureaux de Change Zimbabwe chairman Nesbert Tinarwo
said they
were still holding talks with government over the
closure.
"We have not heard anything on re-opening but I can confirm we
are holding
talks with a view to finding the best way forward," Tinarwo
said.
Zim Independent
MPs urge South Africa to get tough with
Mugabe
Mthulisi Mathuthu
Members of the British House of Commons
have urged South Africa to join the
rest of the world in tightening screws on
President Mugabe's regime.
Andrew Mackay, MP for Bracknell, set the ball
rolling on Tuesday at the
Westminster Hall when he accused African nations of
damaging perceptions of
the continent and weakening the New Partnership for
Africa's Development
(Nepad) and the African Union by letting Mugabe's regime
off the hook.
"I hope that leaders elsewhere in sub-Saharan Africa,
perhaps particularly
in South Africa, will reflect on this debate and the
fact that the
continuing deterioration of the situation in Zimbabwe and the
lack of
regional action are harming not only the people there but the whole
of
southern Africa," he said.
Mackay said Zimbabwe could in the past
withstand drought. But now "no proper
farming is going on. Grain has been
sold on the black market to the obvious
benefit of government officials,
although a large part of the country is
starving..."
He said it was
tragic that 75% of Zimbabwe's population now lives in
poverty.
"That
would be an extraordinarily high level anywhere in the world, but for
a
country that was once prosperous, successful and a food exporter, it
is
shocking and disgraceful."
Mackay said: "Our prime objective must
be to isolate Zanu PF in every
possible way and make life so uncomfortable
for that party so it will be
unable to function again in future.
"The
whole Zanu PF apparatus is corrupt," Mackay said. "The senior civil
service
is corrupt. Much of the commercial world that remains in Zimbabwe is
corrupt.
Above all, the army is not only brutal but extremely corrupt as we
saw in the
recent rape of the Congo which was hugely to the financial
benefit of senior
army officers who pillaged diamonds and other reserves."
Mackay called
for an expansion of the sanctions regime to net all Zanu PF
cronies,
"commercial supporters", bankers and "safari operators". He singled
out Chris
Pasipamire who he described as "an evil thug". He said anyone
responsible for
human rights abuses should be held and tried.
Conservative spokesman
on Foreign Affairs, Michael Ancram, said he had seen
displaced farm workers
in Zimbabwe and food queues during his brief visit in
July. He said the
country was facing a catastrophe. Ancram described
Pasipamire as "a brutal
activist in farm evictions" and described as
"outrageous" the decision to
allow him to study in Britain.
He accused Mugabe of manipulating food
aid.
"The control of food in Mugabe's hands is in a sense a weapon of
mass
destruction. He has created the shortages. His illegal farm seizure
policy
has destroyed Zimbabwe's self-sufficiency."
Ancram referred
toZanu PF's "gerrymandering" to give it a two-thirds
majority. He referred to
the deaths of MDC MPs or their defeat in
by-elections.
"To put it
simply (Mugabe) is terrorising and bribing, if not murdering his
way to the
destruction of democracy," he said.
"Then there are the attacks on
justice and press freedom. There is now no
justice to speak of and no
protection to which people can turn."
The Parliamentary Undersecretary of
State for Foreign and Commonwealth
Affairs, Mike O'Brien, also drew a
connection between misrule and economic
collapse.
"The tragedy is all
the greater because, although southern Africa is
affected by drought, the
policies of Zanu PF have turned a situation that
could have been managed into
a humanitarian crisis," he said.
Several MPs urged England to withdraw
from the Cricket World Cup matches in
Zimbabwe next year.
However, the
International Cricket Council said yesterday that World Cup
matches should
take place in Zimbabwe as planned. A 10-man ICC delegation
visited Zimbabwe
last month to monitor the security situation in the light
of the crisis in
the country.
Zim Independent
Census riddled with anomalies -
experts
Augustine Mukaro
THE recent Census 2002 exercise was
fraught with anomalies which will result
in a gaping underestimation of the
country's population, enumerators and
population experts have
said.
The Zimbabwe Independent last week revealed that the exercise -
which put
the population at 11,6 million - had missed over three million
people but
new evidence suggests the figure could be much
higher.
Bulawayo City Council rejected the preliminary findings which put
the city's
population at 676 000 saying this was way below the figures shown
by
municipal records.
"The preliminary results do not tally with our
records," Bulawayo executive
mayor Japhet Ndabeni-Ncube said, adding: "There
are more than a million
inhabitants in this city. Based on the preliminary
report, planning would
now be difficult as too few resources would be
channelled to the city whose
population is far above the said
figures."
The report effectively means Bulawayo's population has grown by
only 56 000
in the past 10 years.
Enumerators who participated in the
census exercise said there was no way
the findings could reflect the
situation on the ground because it was flawed
from the beginning. Estimates
of the number of Zimbabweans living abroad
could not be regarded as anything
more than "guestimates" given the lack of
official figures from neighbouring
countries.
Census officials have been quoted in the official press as
saying the total
population figure should be around 14 million based on
estimates that some
three million people currently live outside the
country.
Enumerators who called the Independent said they snubbed the
reconnaissance
period where they were supposed to visit their enumeration
areas to
familiarise themselves with the local leadership and the people at
large.
"The crucial reconnaissance period was ignored by enumerators
because it was
not paid for," one enumerator from Mashonaland East
said.
Enumerators in Gokwe said maps used were based on Tsetse control
fences as
boundaries and were hopelessly out of date. The fences have long
since
disappeared.
"Tsetse control fences which were erected in the
1970s were shown on the
maps as boundaries but have since been removed and
masses of people have
since occupied the then tsetse-infested area," one
enumerator said.
"The boundaries could not be found, leaving vast
stretches uncovered by
enumerators who did not want to encroach into each
other's counting areas,"
he said.
Enumerators said field-mappers were
unable to correct the anomalies because
there were too few of them and they
had no transport to cover the whole
area.
Enumerators in Gokwe said
places such as Mangorowe gold panning area were
avoided by enumerators
because of health risks.
"Mangorowe was overcrowded with gold-panners but
no enumerator would go
there because there was no drinking water and there
was a cholera outbreak,
one enumerator said.
Zim Independent
EU/ACP still to decide on
probe
Mthulisi Mathuthu
THE European Union (EU) and the African,
Caribbean and Pacific (ACP) states
have yet to agree on the parameters of a
fact-finding mission to Zimbabwe,
raising fears it was unlikely to
materialise any time soon.
Sources this week said the two parties, who
have agreed to move forward
after the abandonment of the fifth joint
parliamentary assembly last month,
would finalise the issue early next
year.
They are also yet to agree on what course of action to take in
the event of
evidence of human rights violations by President Mugabe's
regime.
Mugabe, however, is expected to object to the demand that he
admit the
delegation on the assembly's terms. But if he resists the mission
it could
force the EU to tighten its sanctions regime.
A fortnight
ago the Party of European Socialists (PES) set conditions for
Mugabe after
they said he should admit MEPs banned from Zimbabwe who include
Glenys
Kinnock as part of the mission. Zimbabwe has come up with its own
list of
banned visitors in retaliation for similar sanctions imposed by
the
EU.
The PES warned that any "prohibitions or restrictions"
would not be
acceptable.
The ACP countries are said to be hoping
for an end to the impasse between
the EU and Zimbabwe ahead of the EU/ACP
joint plenary session to be held in
Congo-Brazzaville in
April.
The PES is reportedly pushing for the dispatch of the mission
in early
January before the EU sits to revise the sanctions
list.
"The PES is keen on this because they want the findings to be
the basis for
whatever action is taken in February," a source
said.
"If Mugabe refuses to admit the mission, that will also
determine the course
of action to be taken."
Zim Independent
Zimbabwe/Malaysia deal
collapses
Godfrey Marawanyika
A MUCH-TOUTED bilateral trade
agreement with Malaysia has been cancelled
following Zimbabwe's failure to
service a US$13,8 million debt due to the
Far East country.
The
project was launched amid great fanfare in 2000 as part of government's
drive
to promote South-South co-operation.
The cancellation comes as the
country struggles to repay its ballooning
foreign debt.
Zimbabwe's
domestic debt stands at $319 billion whilst foreign debt has shot
up to
US$491,1 million.
Malaysia threw Harare a lifeline as traditional trading
nations and donors
shunned Zimbabwe after the adoption of damaging economic
policies.
Ministry of Finance sources said the non-settlement of the
US$13,8 million
debt led to the collapse, forcing the Malaysians to suspend
the whole deal.
However, Malaysian sources privately suggest it was not a
"signed and
sealed" deal in the first place.
Failure of local
exporters to utilise the facility due to concerns over the
applicable
exchange rate compounded the problem.
The country has continued to
accumulate arrears to various multilateral
institutions.
By June 14
this year, Zimbabwe's debt to the International Monetary Fund
stood at
US$131,3 million, and shot up to US$173, 6 million by December 6
due to
interest accumulation.
Conservative figures from the Ministry of Finance
show that for the first
six months of the year government owed the World Bank
US$130,9 million, up
from US$92 million in December last
year.
Zim Independent
ANC seeks to revive Zanu PF/MDC
talks
Dumisani Muleya
WHILE South Africa spent the first six
months after the disputed March
presidential election trying to persuade the
Movement for Democratic Change
(MDC) - and the rest of the world - to
recognise President Robert Mugabe as
Zimbabwe's legitimate leader, it has
changed tack and is now trying to get
Zanu PF to accept the MDC as the
legitimate opposition.
Diplomatic sources said yesterday South Africa's
ruling African National
Congress (ANC) is battling to get Mugabe and his
party to end their
hostility towards the MDC as part of Pretoria's initiative
to resolve
Zimbabwe's political crisis.
"The heat is now being turned
on Zanu PF to stop treating the MDC like an
illegitimate party," a source
said. "They want both parties to accept each
other and resume the inter-party
dialogue."
South African Foreign Affairs minister Nkosazana Dlamini-Zuma
said this week
during the ANC conference which ends today in Stellenbosch she
would soon
visit Zimbabwe to engage government on the local
situation.
Dlamini-Zuma seems to have been making a strenuous effort to
secure Zanu
PF's cooperation ahead of her visit. Yesterday, she said the ANC
saw Zanu PF
as a "progressive" party. She said the land reform programme was
necessary
but expressed reservations on lawlessness and human rights
abuses.
The minister, however, dismissed claims by MDC leader Morgan
Tsvangirai that
an "unholy alliance" involving South Africa, Britain and Zanu
PF was
planning to arrange talks between Mugabe and the opposition
leader.
President Thabo Mbeki on Wednesday said Zimbabwe was faced with
multiple
challenges compounded by drought and food shortages and needed
help.
"We are interested that these problems are addressed because they
are having
a bad impact on the quality of life of the people of Zimbabwe,"
Mbeki said.
"What solutions do we find, what can be done?"
Mbeki said
the ANC has been in contact with the ruling Zanu PF and the
opposition
MDC.
"The ANC has been talking to Zanu PF and MDC and naturally the ANC
would
also be in contact with all other political forces around the world
that are
interested in Zimbabwe," he said.
Despite protestations from
both Zanu PF and the MDC about getting into bed
with each other, diplomats
said this week that South Africa was under
considerable pressure from the
European Union and others to resolve the
Zimbabwe crisis and that this could
only be effected through dialogue.
The South Africans recently applied
their "Codesa model" to the Congo and
Burundi and will now seek to do so in
Zimbabwe, one diplomat said.
Meanwhile, there were roars of approval from
conference delegates on
Wednesday when a Zanu PF observer announced that
11-million hectares had
been "acquired" in the land-grab by
government.
The exercise has however reduced the farming districts to
zones of
desolation, a reality that is already costing South Africa
dearly.
Zim Independent
Muckraker
Who is hoarding food and
fuel for elections?THE Zanu PF National People's Conference hosted
in Chinhoyi last weekend
confirmed Muckraker's worst fears that it is the
ruining party and not the
retail outlets that are hoarding
food.
Reports from Chinhoyi said that all basic commodities were
available in the
town. We are wondering who provided these foodstuffs? Where
did they come
from?
The same thing happened in Insiza and is now
happening in Kuwadzana and
Highfield. Zanu PF, it seems, is hoarding food in
anticipation of
by-elections. This is surely disturbing because close to 6,5
million
Zimbabweans are starving and the party is keeping food for
speculative
purposes. At the same time it is preventing the MDC from
importing grain.
Still in Chinhoyi, Chenhamo Chakezha Chimutengwende was
at it again last
weekend. The rumba-crazy Chen's contribution to the
conference we gather was
a performance that sent delegates into a
frenzy.
While Elliot Manyika once entranced the president with his choral
exploits,
Chen might have caught the president's attention with his
gyrations. Who
knows what the next reshuffle will hold in store for
him!
Dancing ndombolo in front of delegates from all over the country and
even
beyond is no mean achievement. Chen is indeed indoda sibili - at least
in
the Zanu PF lexicon.
What on earth was President Mugabe doing
poring over pictures of the body of
the late Rutendo
Jongwe-Muusha?
"If I were to show you pictures of the post-mortem of
Jongwe's wife you will
never want to hear about the MDC again," he told
conference delegates in
Chinhoyi last weekend.
How did these pictures
fall into the president's hands and is this the sort
of thing he should be
discussing at a public forum? Should he be using
police post-mortem pictures
for party-political gain?
Why did he not refer to the body of David
Stevens who was murdered after
being abducted from a police station in the
presence of policemen? Why did
he not disclose the appalling way Stevens'
body was treated after it was
thrown into the back of a truck by armed Zanu
PF supporters?
It took the police two years to bring that case to court
and still they don'
t have a conviction. Learnmore Jongwe handed himself in
and was incarcerated
for the rest of his life.
Mugabe didn't mention
that. Nor did he mention the case of a CIO officer who
has been named in
court as responsible for the deaths of Tichaona Chiminya
and Talent Mabika.
That officer continues to preside over a regime of terror
in Chimanimani with
impunity. Why weren't delegates in Chinhoyi invited to
reflect on the fate of
his victims after they had been doused with petrol
and set on
fire?
Mugabe should stop being an old hypocrite. His party is responsible
for the
murder and mayhem of the last two years and no amount of dissembling
or
unethical disclosures will persuade the nation otherwise.
But we
were interested to hear from the president that he had told his wife
that
when it came to serving his family and the people, "the people
come
first".
When did he tell her that? Was it on one of their many
visits to London and
Paris in happier times? And exactly how much is it in
foreign exchange they
consume on each trip abroad? We have never managed to
nail that figure down
and invite patriotic officials at the Reserve Bank to
pick up the phone and
tell us.
Nobody believes that Grace and the
Mugabe tribe have gone without bread or
mealie meal or fuel even once. Nor do
we ever imagine that she spares a
thought for the hundreds of fellow women
who have been brutalised by Zanu PF
militia during elections.
Anyway,
which "people" is Mugabe talking about when half the nation is
facing
starvation because of his ill-thought-out land policies?
Readers will
recall Didymus Mutasa's asinine remarks made in 1996 that
Mugabe was
Zimbabwe's king. He told the BBC that "you have your Queen. Why
shouldn't we
elect our king?"
Meeting the new Dutch ambassador recently, Mugabe noted
that the Netherlands
had a monarchy while Zimbabwe had "its own system". He
wondered why the
Dutch wanted to change Zimbabwe's system.
In fact the
Dutch monarchy is almost entirely ceremonial. Mugabe as an
ostensibly
republican head of state has far more powers than any crowned
head of state
in Europe. Indeed, it would be easier to compare him to Louis
XIV of France
who famously said: "L'etat? C'est moi (The state? It is I)".
The Dutch,
we are sure, like everybody else, have only one wish: that
Zimbabwe's
monarchy would resemble more the constitutional monarchies in
place around
the world than those ensconced in Swaziland and North Korea.
We were
interested to see that President Mugabe has been urging African
airlines to
promote African countries as tourist destinations. He said while
Africa was
endowed with numerous tourist attractions, it receives the least
share of
tourists in the world. He challenged airlines to consider how best
to improve
Africa's tourism industry.
African airlines should challenge him to
provide a political and economic
environment conducive to tourism growth.
That means one in which tourists
from Europe and the United States - the two
largest catchment areas - feel
they are not targets of a venomous racist
campaign led by the president
himself. That if they are in any danger the
police will react swiftly and
impartially. And that necessities like fuel are
available to them.
The fact is President Mugabe is the biggest
disincentive to tourism in this
region, even frightening visitors away from
Botswana's resorts, according to
President Festus Mogae. And when Mugabe
speaks about the viability of
airlines, he should reflect on the damage
caused by arbitrary diversion of
flights to collect him and his retinue. We
do concede however that with
invitations drying up, his travel plans are less
likely to impact on Air
Zimbabwe's service!
Muckraker was shocked to
see a report that Harare mayor Elias Mudzuri has
given a long-service award
to Joseph Chinotimba. The self-styled leader of
farm invasions was among 677
workers who have served the council for periods
ranging from 15 to 35 years.
They were given certificates and cash.
Chinotimba has served 20 years. In
2000 and 2001 he was on leave for long
periods heading a violent campaign of
land seizures on the environs of the
city which have added immensely to the
cost and complexity of the council's
work. We never heard who had authorised
that leave, whether Chinotimba was
paid while he was absent from work, and
who gave him a Cherokee and other
perks, including promotion at a time when
he was threatening the then Chief
Justice.
It defies belief that
ratepayers' money has now been used to reward him for
his "service" to the
city.
The mayor did at least make one telling point when handing out the
awards.
He warned workers against engaging in private business or
political
activities during business hours. And he said the council would not
be held
to ransom by incompetent and indolent employees. Did he have
anybody
particular in mind, we wonder?
The Herald this week carried a
long interview with Information minister
Jonathan Moyo that looked like an
elaborate attempt to justify spending $65
million on Miss Malaika - arguably
the biggest non-event of the year
organised by Moyo's pal
Adjovi.
There was no hint of who the interview was conducted with and,
given the
number of "I'm glad you asked me that" questions, speculation will
naturally
arise as to whether this was not another
self-interview.
Moyo complained about the "negativity and cynicism that
have taken hold of
some of our few but vocal compatriots". Even if they were
told Jesus was
coming they would protest and claim Zimbabwe did not deserve
the honour,
Moyo suggested without elaborating on Miss Malaika's Marian
virtues.
These were the same people seeking the cutting of fuel supplies,
Moyo
opportunistically claimed. The money was well spent to counteract
the
negative publicity being spread about Zimbabwe, he added.
In other
words, Zimbabwe loses millions of dollars in tourism because of
Zanu PF's
record of violence and lawlessness and then needs to spend $65
million in
persuading people that it's not as bad as it seems!
There was value for
money in African beauty, Moyo insisted, "because beauty
is by definition
invaluable". If you had difficulty with that logic the next
sentence was even
better.
"Even the most partisan and reckless among our detractors would
concede that
point save for those who have gone bananas and are no longer
capable of any
rationality and there are some like that
around."
Indeed there are minister, indeed there are.
Zimbabwe's
long-drawn-out fuel crisis doesn't seem to have an end in sight.
Not even
President Mugabe seems to have a clue what to do. Instead what we
have from
Mugabe are the usual, hard-to-believe accusations against
Noczim
officials.
Noczim has become Mugabe's own Frankenstein monster.
Allegations of
corruption at the oil procurement parastatal have gone on for
a long time
but nothing has been done to the officials, which makes Muckraker
believe
these guys are not entirely on their own. There are big fish
protecting
them.
But Mugabe was particularly furious that these Noczim
officials had
alienated the Libyans who were ready to give us their fuel in
exchange for a
stake in the petroleum sector such as pipelines, storage
depots and, above
all, retail outlets such as service stations. That was the
deal they were
negotiating last week, as this newspaper reported.
"Why
offend the Libyans? What for?" fumed Mugabe in Chinhoyi at the
weekend.
But he must know the Libyans have us over an oil barrel because
we have no
foreign currency and have foolishly made it our national duty to
alienate as
many erstwhile well-wishers as possible, thanks to Mugabe's
private war
against the world.
In the end all we had was a promise: "I
am going to look into this matter in
a serious way."
If that look will
yield fuel that's fine but no more counter-productive
ranting against the
petrol companies please. We need a few friends right
now!
As for
Mugabe's threat to take over the assets of the Big Five multinational
oil
companies operating in Zimbabwe, apart from being unconstitutional this
would
almost certainly put an end to even the small trickle of fuel we
are
currently getting. As the London Times reported this week, total
state
control over fuel distribution would condemn the industry to the
same
failure affecting much of the country's agriculture, transport,
mining,
telecommunications, railways and power industries.
When the
Russians occupied Berlin in 1945, Soviet soldiers who had never
lived in
towns unscrewed lightbulbs because they thought they produced light
and taps
because they thought they made water. Western diplomats in Harare
covering
the Chinhoyi conference think Mugabe's approach is much the
same.
"Mugabe's thinking is that taps make water," a Western diplomat
told the
Times. "If he goes ahead (with the takeover of multinational
service
stations), the country will dry up far quicker than it is doing
already."
Sounds like the president's idea of a Christmas present to his
people!
News24
'Europe must save Africa
summit'
Stellenbosch - The ball was now in Europe's court to
save next year's key
European Union/Africa summit, under threat because
Zimbabwean President
Robert Mugabe might be barred, according to Foreign
Affairs Minister
Nkosazana Dlamini-Zuma.
Portugal, who will host the
European Union/African summit in April, has
indicated it may not allow
Zimbabwe to attend the April summit because of
the travel sanctions imposed
by EU countries on Zimbabwean government
officials.
"It's up to them
(Europe) to see how they overcome the problem. It is in
their court. We as
Africans are ready to go. The question is are they ready
to receive us,"
Dlamini-Zuma told reporters in Stellenbosch where she is
attending the ANC's
51st national congress.
"There is no Africa that can exist without
Zimbabwe. Africa is indivisible."
Earlier this month, an EU-African,
Caribbean and Pacific meeting of
parliamentarians in Brussels was cancelled,
after European MPs barred two
Zimbabwean ministers from entering the
Strasbourg parliament. The summit was
not about individual
countries.
Dlamini-Zuma said she planned to visit Zimbabwe early next
year to continue
talks with political leaders there in a bid to help resolve
the crisis in
that country.
This was in line with President Thabo
Mbeki's statement to conference on
Monday that Pretoria was "convinced that
it is necessary to bring to a close
the controversial issues relating to our
important neighbour, Zimbabwe".
Asked whether she believed the opposition
Movement for Democratic Change
should drop its legal challenge of the
presidential election results, so
that talks with Zanu-PF could resume,
Dlamini-Zuma said it was not up to
South Africa to prescribe what the party
should do.
"The MDC has a legitimate right to take things to court if
they so wish. I
don't think any of us should interfere. It's their
judgement."
Dlamini-Zuma said she was not aware of a plan reportedly by
South Africa and
Britain to get Mugabe and MDC leader Morgan Tsvangirai to
the negotiating
table outside Zimbabwe.
Earlier, speaking in her
capacity as chair of the ANC's commission on
international relations,
Dlamini-Zuma said among the issues delegates
discussed was the need for the
party to work closely with other progressive
parties on the
continent.
Asked whether she believed Zanu-PF was a progressive party,
Dlamini-Zuma
said: "For us (the ANC), yes, for very obvious
reasons."
The ANC and Zanu-PF were sister organisations, who had fought
colonialism
and oppression, and liberated both countries from the yoke of
colonialism,
she said.
Zanu-PF was among the foreign guests invited to
attend the ANC's summit.
Zimbabwe's Speaker of Parliament, Emmerson
Mnangagwa thanked the ANC for its
principled support.
"Indeed, on
numerous occasions, you have sought to clarify the position in
Zimbabwe in
response to our detractors.
"We treasure your advice and counsel, and
assure you that in us you have
consistent and reliable allies who are fully
aware that our destinies are
inextricably intertwined," he told conference
delegates.
Dlamini-Zuma told reporters that Britain had abdicated its
responsibilities
to purchase land in terms of the Lancaster House agreement
which ushered in
Zimbabwe's independence in 1980.
The ANC supported
Zanu-PF's policy of distributing land to Africans who had
been dispossed, but
acknowledged there were problems with implementation
with Zimbabwe's land
reform programme.