The ZIMBABWE Situation
An extensive and up-to-date website containing news, views and links related to ZIMBABWE - a country in crisis
Please note: You need to have 'Active content' enabled in your IE browser in order to see the index of articles on this webpage
Brains behind abductions exposed
Abducted human rights activist, Jestina
Mukoko
By Our Correspondents
A SENIOR police officer in Harare has now been
identified as the leader of a group of state operatives who have orchestrated
the recent wave of abductions.
The Zimbabwe Times can
reveal that Chief Superintendent Chrispen Makedenge, who has been associated
over the years with the arrest of opposition politicians, journalists and human
rights activists, is the alleged mastermind behind the wave of the series of
abductions.
Makedenge is the officer commanding the Law and Order
section of the police, The operatives drawn from police, the Zimbabwe National
Army and Central Intelligence Organisation have targeted members of the
mainstream Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) party as well as civic and human
rights activists and journalists.
The operation has strangely been code-named
“Chimumumu”, Shona for a dump person.
Sources within the police force also allege that
Makedenge is also in charge of the
torture chamber at Harare Central Police
Station.
“Chief Superintendent Makedenge is the man in charge
of the operation to abduct MDC members and anyone else believed to be a threat
to the government,” said a source within the police force, who spoke on
condition he was not identified, for fear of victimisation.
“He even accuses fellow members of the police for
supporting MDC.”
The source said a large budget had been allocated to
Operation Chimumumu.
Among the benefits enjoyed by Makedenge’s team were
access to a variety of new vehicles that had been placed at their disposal, an
unlimited fuel supply and permanent bookings in various hotels throughout the
country.
The source said Makedenge had been allocated a
commercial farm in the rich Banket farming area and had benefited immensely from
the Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe’s farm mechanisation programme.
The team is said to report directly to President
Mugabe’s office.
Makedenge’s deputy is a police officer identified by
sources only as Muwuya. He is also based at Harare Central Police Station in the
Law and Order Section.
“Other members of the team include several army
intelligence officers, police officers as well as a CIO hit squad whose task is
to gather information on targeted people,” said another source.
“The CIO gather information which they pass onto to
the abductors who are the officers from the Law and Order Section and the army
who will then effect the abductions. The team is under strict instructions to
take the abducted people alive.”
Among some of the prominent people to be abducted so
far are Jestina Mukoko, a leading human rights activist, former news anchor at
the Zimbabwe Broadcasting Corporation (ZBC). She is now the director of the
Zimbabwe Peace Project (ZPP). The organisation has been outspoken about the
political violence and intimidation accompanying this year’s
elections.
Mukoko, whose organisation has publicised human
rights violations in Zimbabwe, was taken hostage on December 3 by a group of
about a dozen armed men in a pre-dawn raid on her home in Norton, 40 kilometres
west of Harare.
Lawyers said Tuesday that she and various other
abducted activists had been located at various police stations in
Harare.
Ghandi Mudzingwa, a former Tsvangirai personal aide
and a member of the MDC security department was abducted in Msasa, Harare. Close
to 40 people have been abducted in recent months.
The Managing Editor of The Zimbabwe Times, Geoffrey
Nyarota, was arrested by the Law and Order section on six occasions between 2001
and 2002. He said Tuesday that Makedenge had either personally arrested him or
assigned subordinates to arrest him.
“On one occasion Chief Superintendent Boysen Mathema
and Chief Inspector Henry Dowa came for me just after midnight and on another
they came at dawn,” Nyarota said. “In the dawn raid they arrested me as well as
Wilf Mbanga, former general manager of Associated Newspapers of Zimbabwe,
publishers of The Daily News.”
Mbanga now publishes The Zimbabwean in the United
Kingdom.
“In fact,” Nyarota says, “Makedenge was the immediate
reason why I fled from Zimbabwe in January 2002.
“After I was mysteriously fired from The Daily News
Makedenge made several telephone calls to my house to demand that I report to
his office. I was forced to go into hiding. When I returned home a week later
Makedenge had left a pile of messages requesting that I report to his office. He
had called day and night.
“Without the protection of The Daily News I had
become vulnerable. I caught the next plane to Johannesburg. Once safely
ensconced in Sandton I returned Makedenge’s many telephone calls. He said I
should report to his office immediately but refused to disclose the reason for
this request, saying I would be informed on arrival. Without disclosing that I
was calling from Johannesburg, I told him I would call again to say when I was
coming to his office.”
Nyarota says has never been back to Zimbabwe since
then. He publishes The Zimbabwe Times from Massachusetts in the United
States.
In September 2003, the United Nations asked the
Zimbabwe government to withdraw Henry Dowa, described in official reports as “a
notorious Zimbabwean police torturer”, from Kosovo where he was stationed as
part of the United Nations Interim Administration Mission in Kosovo (UNMIK)
civilian police force (CIVPOL). CIVPOL is made up of several thousand police
officers drawn from UN Member States, including Zimbabwe.
Zimbabwe obliged and Dowa returned to
Harare.
Redress, a British-based organisation, which
campaigns against torture, had submitted a comprehensive dossier to the head of
UNMIK in June 2003. The dossier comprised affidavits from Zimbabwe torture
victims detailing what they had suffered allegedly at Dowa’s hands, including
electric shock, torture and beatings on the bare soles of the feet. The
affidavits were supported by medical evidence.
The dossier also contained an analysis of human
rights violations in Zimbabwe then, especially torture. It was demonstrated in
the dossier even back then that it was virtually impossible to bring violators
to justice under Zimbabwean law under the then prevailing conditions.
The situation has only worsened now.
Over the past few months a new wave of human rights
violations, including abductions, torture and killings, have been perpetrated
with impunity by state agents against political and civil society
activists.
Jestina Mukoko to appear in
court
http://www.herald.co.zw
Published by
the Government of Zimbabwe
Herald Reporter
FORMER ZBC newscaster Jestina Mukoko and
nine MDC-T activists are expected
to appear in a Harare court today on
charges of recruiting or attempting to
recruit people for purposes of
undergoing military training to overthrow the
Government.
Mukoko, an
MDC-T activist and director of an NGO - the Zimbabwe Peace
Project - was
picked up at her Norton home on December 5.
The other eight are the
husband and wife team of Manuel and Concilia
Chinanzvavana of Zvimba, Pieter
Kaseke of Banket, Audrey Zimbudzana of
Chinhoyi, Broderick Takawira, the
provincial co-ordinator of the ZPP for
Mashonaland East; Fidelis Mujabuki
Chiramba, the MDC-T Zvimba South
chairman; Violet Mapfuranhewe and Collen
Mutemagau, MDC-T Zvimba South youth
district chairman.
A statement
from the Zimbabwe Republic Police yesterday said some time in
April this
year, Manuel allegedly recruited Ricardo Hwasheni, a police
constable based
at Waterfalls in Harare, to undergo military training in
Botswana with a
view to forcibly deposing the Government and replace it with
one led by
Morgan Tsvangirai.
Manuel allegedly tasked Hwasheni to recruit four other
policemen, promising
them US$2 000 each.
Later, the statement said,
Manuel and Kaseke, who is Hwasheni's cousin, went
to MDC-T's headquarters at
Harvest House, where a man identified only as
Josen interviewed
Hwasheni.
After the interview, Josen allegedly told Hwasheni that he
would hear from
him within two weeks or that Mukoko would contact
him.
In June, the statement says, Hwasheni met Mukoko at her offices in
Milton
Park in Harare where she further interviewed him before handing him
over to
Takawira, who told him that he would be contacted within two
weeks.
The statement further alleged that a man
who had been sent
by Mukoko met Hwasheni at Girls' High School in Harare and
gave him 200 pula
and some Zimbabwean dollars for transport to Botswana
where he was to meet a
man known as Special.
Hwasheni crossed into Botswana in July through the
Plumtree border post and
met Special at Ramokgwebana Border
Post.
Special took Hwasheni to a military camp in Botswana where he
underwent
training in the use of FN and AK rifles, military tactics as well
as
political lessons together with five other MDC-T recruits.
There
were, according to the statement, 50 other recruits undergoing
military
training in the same camp.
Hwasheni returned to Zimbabwe with specific
instructions to study the mood
of junior police officers inasfar as loyalty
was concerned and the mood of
the public towards Government.
When he
was arrested Hwasheni implicated Mukoko, Takawira, Manuel, Kaseke
and
Zimbudzana.
The other four - Concilia, Chiramba, Violet and Mutemagau -
are being
accused of recruiting people for training under the National Youth
Symposium
Training Programme in Botswana in July.
Concilia is alleged
to have recruited Tapera Mapfuranhewe, who is Violet's
brother, for the
programme warning him not to tell anyone about it.
Tapera was given two
letters which he took to Harvest House by Concilia and
Ellen Musoni
recommending him as a suitable candidate for the training.
Morleen Ncube
and "Professor" Malvern interviewed Tapera together with 50
others at
Harvest House and 48 who passed the interview attended a workshop
held in
Kadoma where they were told about the trip to Botswana for military
training.
Between the end of August and September 9, the group
allegedly travelled to
Botswana in three batches with Tapera in the last
batch that had 17 recruits
with instructions from Edson Chamisa to meet a
man known only as Zola.
The group was taken to Okavango Training Camp
where they joined 120 other
recruits, but on October 16 Tapera escaped and
returned to Zimbabwe where he
reported the military training to the State
prompting an investigation.
Concilia and Chiramba are also being accused
of holding meetings in Banket
where they encouraged MDC-T youths to undergo
military training in Botswana.
Zimbabwe run by a criminal mafia: COSATU
http://www.zimonline.co.za/
by Own Correspondent
Wednesday 24 December 2008
JOHANNESBURG - Zimbabwe's ruling
elite operates like a "criminal mafia,"
abducting and murdering political
opponents while their subjects face a
daily struggle against disease and
worsening economic hardships,
neighbouring South Africa's trade union
movement has said.
In a New Year message the Congress of South African
Trade Unions (COSATU)
criticized southern Africa leaders for kowtowing to
President Robert Mugabe
while ignoring he lost elections last March and was
unwilling to implement a
power-sharing deal with the
opposition.
"While millions of ordinary Zimbabweans struggle to survive
and avoid
falling prey to cholera, the ruling elite are now ruling as a
criminal
mafia, arresting, abducting and murdering anyone standing in their
way,"
said COSATU in the statement released Monday.
The union has led
criticism against Mugabe's government and in one of
several actions against
the Zimbabwean leader, last April blocked a Chinese
ship carrying weapons
for Zimbabwe from offloading its cargo at a South
African port saying Mugabe
could use the arms against opponents.
COSATU, which is part of South
Africa's ruling tripartite that is led by the
ANC and includes the South
African Communist Party, criticized Southern
African Development Community
(SADC) for its kid gloves approach towards
Mugabe.
It said: "The SADC
leaders have shamelessly ignored the daily, widespread
abuse of human rights
by a 'government' that lost the elections on 29 March
2008, while trying to
patch up a 'power-sharing' agreement that would leave
the party that won
that election with a token role in a government still
dominated by Mugabe's
police state and paramilitary thugs."
The SADC, which analysts say has
the most influence over the Harare
administration, has resisted calls by
Western governments for Mugabe to step
down, insisting the only way to
resolve Zimbabwe's crisis was through a
power-sharing agreement signed three
months ago.
Mugabe, opposition leaders Morgan Tsvangirai and Arthur
Mutambara signed an
agreement on September 15 to form a government of
national unity, raising
hopes that Zimbabwe could finally emerge from its
crisis.
But the agreement brokered by former South African President
Thabo Mbeki has
failed to take off as Mugabe and his main rival Tsvangirai
wrangle over who
should control key ministries and other top government
posts.
A spate of abductions of opposition supporters and government
critics in
recent weeks has added to doubts over the power-sharing pact,
with
Tsvangirai threatening to quit talks unless the kidnappings are brought
to
an end and all abductees are released.
Once a regional
breadbasket, Zimbabwe, is in the grip of an unprecedented
economic and
humanitarian crisis marked by acute shortages of food and basic
commodities,
amid a cholera epidemic that the United Nations says has killed
more than 1
000 people since August.
Critics blame the crisis on misrule by Mugabe
who has presided over the
southern African nation since its 1980
independence from Britain.
Mugabe denies ruining Zimbabwe and instead
blames his country's problems on
economic sabotage and sanctions by Westerns
governments opposed to his
rule. - ZimOnline.
Two
Billion Zimbabwe Dollars For a Loaf of Bread As Hyperinflation
Surges
http://www.voanews.com
By Jonga Kandemiiri
Washington
23
December 2008
Zimbabwe's beleaguered consumers have witnessed massive
increases in the
prices of basic foodstuffs and other commodities following
the Reserve Bank
of Zimbabwe's introduction late last week of new notes in
denominations of
Z$1 billion, Z$5 billion and Z$10 billion.
The
central bank also increased the monthly bank cash withdrawal limit for
individuals to $10 billion in response to pressure from trade unions that it
allow workers to access all of their funds, and rampages by disgruntled
soldiers turned away from bank cash windows.
Sources in Harare said a
loaf of bread was going for between $2 billion and
2.5 billion dollars. A
kilogram of meat on fetched five U.S. dollars - the
equivalent of Z$45-55
billion dollars at the prevailing street exchange rate
of Z$9-11 billion
dollars per greenback.
Commuter omnibus operators were demanding Z$2
billion or much-sought-after
gasoline coupons for a ride from the Harare
city center to Highfield and
other inner suburbs.
Soaring prices for
food have increased reliance on imports and remittances
in cash and kind
from relatives living in the so-called diaspora in South
Africa in
particular.
Makomborero Chikwezeze, a Zimbabwean in Johannesburg, told
reporter Jonga
Kandemiiri he has resorted to sending groceries back home to
make sure his
family survives.
Zimbabwe's cholera
epidemic still not under control, UN reports
http://www.un.org
23 December 2008 - The worst
cholera epidemic ever recorded in Zimbabwe is
still not under control after
infecting nearly 24,000 people, with the death
toll approaching 1,200, the
United Nations Children's Fund (UNICEF) reported
today.
The disease now
affects all provinces in the impoverished southern African
country and there
continues to be staffing issues at cholera treatment
centres as many medics
are going without salaries and cannot show up to
work, UNICEF Country
Representative Roeland Monasch told reporters in a
telephone briefing from
Harare, the capital.
Half the cases are in Harare, and only a handful of
professionals are
staffing clinics where several dozen are
needed.
UNICEF is providing 700,000 litres of clean water a day, even
digging
boreholes in urban areas. It is also procuring 4,000 tons of water
treatment
chemicals for urban areas to fight the disease, which is caused by
contaminated food or water, and can lead quickly to severe dehydration and
death if treatment is not promptly given.
The first ever UNICEF
airlift of critical emergency supplies to Zimbabwe has
brought in
intravenous fluids, drip equipment, essential drugs, midwifery
and obstetric
kits to boost the agency's cholera response and help the
Government to
deliver some essential health services to expecting mothers.
Yesterday
four independent UN human rights experts called on the Government
of
Zimbabwe and the international community to do more to rebuild the
country's
health system, end the cholera epidemic and ensure adequate food
for all
people.
Low-tech pump helps to keep villages
cholera-free
Click to find out more about The Times Charity Appeal
The big nurse strode up to the car and greeted the
driver by banging her fist against his. I was surprised. Instead of the long,
intimate meeting of two sweaty, microbe-rich palms in an ordinary handshake, it
was a fleeting contact between two dry, bony surfaces.
Even Watsomba district, far away in the rolling hills
of eastern Zimbabwe, knows the anti-cholera handshake they use in Harare,
Zimbabwe’s capital and the epicentre of a devastating cholera epidemic.
But the danger is potentially close by, said Sister
Mercy Maodzwa – only 20 kilometres (13 miles) away at a squatters’ camp on the
Mutare river, fouled by sewage and the detritus of gold panners.
But where we are now is Govingo, a small village with
a constant traffic of women with buckets balanced on their heads to collect
water from one of several Elephant pumps in the area, sealed from the outside,
so that little or no dirt blows in. The pumps are raised well above ground – so
no mud or pathogens brought in by the feet of people and animals seep in – and
pumped from the outside by a large metal handle, so no dirty hands touch the
rope that passes through the water in the well.
“The first thing I ask people who come to the clinic
with diarrhoea is whether they use an open well. We don’t have diarrhoea in this
area because the pumps’ water is protected. Those who don’t have the pumps, they
get diarrhoea.”
At Govingo well, Mavis Chimteng-ise shouted at her
son for playing with the water as it came out the pump. “We can feel sure about
our water,” she said. “We know our water is safe.”
About 100 metres away was another pump, a large
robust-looking machine with a long, heavy diagonal handle sticking out from its
head. It is a Bush pump, designed by Harare’s Blair Research Laboratory,
renowned for its innovations of simplicity and strength in water and sanitation
technology. Thousands of Bush pumps were bought by the Government to bring clean
water to rural settlements all over the country, and they have been used and
copied all over Africa.
It was installed in 1990, but like many others around
the county, stopped working after ten years.
“It’s a great design and it’s very strong, but it
costs ten times more to build and install than the Elephant pump,” said Amos
Chitungo, Zimbabwe director of Pump Aid, one of the charities chosen by The
Times for its Christmas appeal.
“Spare parts are difficult to find and are expensive.
They need specialised technicians to repair them, and specialised tools. There
are supposed to be official ‘pump minders’ in every district, but they move on.”
Govingo got its Elephant pump in 2005, and when the
rope and washers in the mechanism wore out last year, said Douglas Makomva, the
community’s pump mechanic, it took 30 minutes to change, and it has been fine
since.
Poverty-stricken rural communities like those in
Watsomba can function on inexpensive technology without a lot of help, which
Zimbabwe’s Government is incapable of providing. Pump Aid’s aim is to find the
cheapest, functional and adaptable materials for the Elephant pump.
In a blistering hot corrugated iron workshop in the
city of Mutare 80 kilometres south of here, David Katiyo, the Pump Aid
technician, is trying out cheap locally manufactured sisal rope to replace the
nylon rope that raises the water from the bottom of the well.
Soon after he joined three years ago, Mr Katiyo built
from scrap metal a simple plastic injection mould device to make the washers
that hold the water on its way up to the outlet pipe. For material, he melts
down “scuds”, plastic bottles for traditional beer, or empty cement bags of
woven plastic.
He has also devised a new rope guide, the mechanism
at the bottom of the well that feeds the rope and washers into the upward pipe
of the Elephant pump to replace the expensive stainless steel version in use
now. Mr Katiyo’s looks like an elaborate wire toy they sell to tourists in
township markets, but it has only two moving parts, of short lengths of scrap
plastic pipe that can be replaced for next to nothing when they wear out.
Steven Makunike, 55, was one of Pump Aid’s first
beneficiaries, in 1996, after trials were conducted on his 22-hectare (54 acres)
smallholding in Watsomba. Fourteen metres deep, the well has been watering neat
rows of 125 apple trees, several kinds of vegetables and maize that he sells
locally. His huts’ thatch is trimmed, there is a lawn in the courtyard and
shrubs and flowers.
Before the Elephant pump, he and his family of eight
children had to hoist water out of the open well and carry buckets to water the
crops. “It was very laborious,” he said. Turning the pump handle was much easier
and more efficient but still they had to carry buckets. Then he built a
reservoir from which he ran a hose. His next project is to put in underground
pipes to water the fruit trees.
“Since 1996 I haven’t changed the rope and the
washers once, and I use the pump all the time,” he said. He smiled the smile of
a satisfied perfectionist.
Zimbabwe must change now
Op-ed in The Australian
Wednesday December
24, 2008
By Senator David Coltart
ZIMBABWE is in the vortex of a
perfect humanitarian storm; an unprecedented
convergence of AIDS, poverty,
hyperinflation, malnutrition, a regime that
does not care and, now, cholera.
The humanitarian crisis has its roots in
the political crisis.
The
political agreement signed in September by ZANU-PF and both factions of
the
Movement for Democratic Change has not been implemented. Both the
agreement
and the process leading to the agreement have been widely
criticised.
There is no doubt that the agreement is seriously flawed.
The powers of the
Prime Minister are weak and the prospects of securing
consensus in a cabinet
in which the combined MDC factions have a narrow
majority are limited.
Scepticism in the West may also result in limited
support for the
transitional government.
ZANU-PF has demonstrated
extreme bad faith since the signing of the
agreement and is unlikely to
change even once the transitional government
has been established. There has
been a surge in abductions of human rights
and political activists in recent
weeks and Morgan Tsvangirai still has not
been given a passport. ZANU-PF
also retains all the coercive ministries,
including defence, the secret
police and the police.
However, as bad as the agreement is, there is no
other viable, nonviolent
option open to Zimbabweans. An appeal to the
African Union or the UN against
what the Southern African Development
Community has arranged and endorsed,
namely the September agreement, will be
fruitless.That was demonstrated
graphically this week through the
frustration of the US and Britain's
attempts to raise Zimbabwe's
humanitarian crisis in the Security Council.
While strong statements made by
Gordon Brown, George W. Bush, Angela Merkel
and Desmond Tutu have called for
the removal of Robert Mugabe, there is
little prospect that their rhetoric
will translate into action. There is no
stomach in the West for military
intervention and many of us opposed to
Mugabe would not support such a
policy.
A spontaneous uprising is unlikely. Zimbabwe does not have a
pressure-cooker
environment such as existed in East Germany where young
people, usually the
vanguard of any uprising, are forced to remain in the
country. Zimbabwe has
two safety valves - Botswana and South Africa - to
which most of the young
opponents have escaped. Most people left in the
country are physically
weakened by the collapse of the economy and the
humanitarian crisis.
Some argue that if the MDC waits a while the Mugabe
regime will collapse.
This is a possibility but a huge gamble. There is
every chance that in the
event of Mugabe losing power some of the more
radical elements within the
military may seize power, which in turn could
see Zimbabwe degenerate into
even worse forms of anarchy than exist at
present.
Furthermore, a wait-and-see policy will not address the extreme
humanitarian
crisis that needs to be resolved immediately if the lives of
potentially
hundreds of thousands are to be saved.
In short, there is
no alternative but to press for the September agreement
to be implemented,
warts and all. The combined MDC should join the
transitional government
under protest and reserve its right to withdraw from
the government if needs
be.
It should also be stressed that the agreement is not all
bad.
Indeed, Zimbabweans suffer from such a victim mentality that there
is a
danger that in focusing so much on the negative aspects of the
agreement we
will ignore the real opportunities that the agreement provides
to transform
Zimbabwe from an autocracy to a democracy.
First, the
office of prime minister will have huge de facto power. The
success of the
transitional government will depend on the amount of
international
assistance that can be raised. There is such disdain for
Mugabe that there
is no prospect of any assistance coming through his door.
The International
Monetary Fund, World Bank, European Union and other
governments and
institutions will want to channel all their aid through the
office of prime
minister. MDC also will hold the finance ministry, giving
Tsvangirai
enormous power and an effective veto. If he decides to withdraw
from the
transitional government, aid will dry up at the same time.
Second,
ZANU-PF's fixation with controlling the coercive ministries has
resulted in
it ceding control to the combined MDC of nearly all the service
ministries,
such as health and education, likely to have the biggest impact
on the lives
of Zimbabweans. If the MDC improves services, which should not
be too
difficult given that most government departments have all but
collapsed, it
will increase its support.
Third, the agreement obliges the transitional
government to liberalise the
political environment and to start,
immediately, a process of constitutional
reform that must culminate in a new
democratic constitution being enacted
within 18 months. Both SADC and the AU
have guaranteed the agreement
including these provisions.
In addition,
for all the criticisms levelled against SADC governments in the
past few
months, they have demonstrated a commitment to enforce all the
terms of the
agreement and it will be in regional governments' self-interest
to ensure
reform continues.
Fourth, ZANU-PF is a shadow of its former self. Mugabe
turns 85 in February
and is increasingly out of touch with reality. He has
retained some of his
patronage system, ironically, because the transitional
government has not
been set up, but once it is he will be even
weaker.
So, although the agreement is fraught with potential problems,
the sooner it
is implemented the better. Constitutional amendment 19, which
gives legal
teeth to the September agreement, has just been gazetted. By
mid-January
2009 it should be passed into law, making the process of
transition almost
irreversible.
Thereafter the success of the
transitional period will depend on the
statesmanship of Zimbabwean
politicians and the role played by the
international community. SADC must
honour its pledge to guarantee the
agreement. It must deploy a senior envoy
to enforce the agreement and to be
permanently based in Harare at least for
the 18 months leading to the
enactment of a new constitution.
The
wider international community including the IMF, World Bank, UN, EU and
the
US, is going to have to give the agreement a chance by helping to
stabilise
Zimbabwe's economy and address the humanitarian crisis. While
there is
understandable scepticism about the agreement, it is important that
these
concerns do not become a self-fulfilling prophecy.
One thing is certain.
If the MDC is unable to improve the lives of
Zimbabweans, the agreement will
fail and the region will be further
destabilised.
Tutu accuses S Africa over Mugabe
Archbishop Desmond Tutu has accused South Africa of losing the
moral high ground by failing to stand up to Zimbabwe's president, Robert Mugabe.
The Noble peace-prize winner told the BBC that using force should be an
option to get rid of Mr Mugabe.
Archbishop Tutu also said he was saddened that his own country appeared not
to be on the side of Zimbabweans.
He said: "How much more suffering is going to make us say 'No we have given
Mr Mugabe enough time?'"
Archbishop Desmond Tutu also said South Africa had a leadership role as its
president chairs the Southern African Development Community.
But he told BBC Radio 4's Today programme that South Africa had instead
betrayed its legacy by blocking firmer action from the United Nations.
|
I have to say that I am deeply, deeply distressed that we should be
found not on the side of the ones who are suffering
|
He added: "I want to say first of all that I have been very deeply
disappointed, saddened by the position that South Africa has taken at the United
Nations Security Council in being an obstacle to the security council dealing
with that matter.
"And I have to say that I am deeply, deeply distressed that we should be
found not on the side of the ones who are suffering.
"I certainly am ashamed of what they've done in the United Nations.
"For the world to say no, we are waiting for South Africa's membership of the
Security Council to lapse and then we can take action."
That, the Archbishop, said, was an "awful indictment" to a country that had a
"proud record of a struggle against a vicious system".
He said: "We should have been the ones who for a very long time occupied the
moral high ground.
"I'm afraid we have betrayed our legacy."
The Archbishop's comments come as Foreign Secretary David Miliband has
written to the Times newspaper, describing Mr Mugabe as a "stain" on Zimbabwe
and reaffirming Britain's view that he has to go.
|
Tsvangirai
must pull out of agreement
http://www.thezimbabwetimes.com/?p=9109
December 23, 2008
By Tendai
Dumbutshena
ZIMBABWEANS face the worst festive season in living memory as
the
consequences of a failed state hit home hard. With the state unable to
provide basic services it is now left to international aid agencies to
provide health care and feed half the population. Thousands of families have
lost loved ones to a cholera epidemic caused by the inability of the state
to provide clean potable water.
As the year 2009 approaches the
situation cries out for leadership. Robert
Mugabe will certainly not provide
such leadership. He cannot see beyond his
obsession to remain in State
House. All around him is collapsing but he sees
no urgency to act. All he
could tell delegates at his party's conference was
that Zimbabwe was his to
rule forever. He is blind to the misery and squalor
that blights the lives
of millions. He simply refuses to accept any
responsibility for the
destruction his rule has caused.
It is impossible to imagine any relief
for Zimbabweans with Mugabe at the
helm.
The year 2009 will determine
the political future of MDC leader Morgan
Tsvangirai. He simply has to raise
his game. He has to rise to the occasion
and demonstrate that the faith many
Zimbabweans have in him is not
misplaced. He blundered by signing the
power-sharing agreement which handed
over the presidency to Mugabe on a
silver platter. He got nothing in return
except an empty shell called the
Council of Ministers which Patrick
Chinamasa said disdainfully would only
meet about four times in a year.
What is important is that since the
agreement was signed Mugabe has
demonstrated beyond any doubt that he cannot
stomach having the MDC in
government with him even as junior partners.
Examples of his bad faith have
been too widely reported to repeat
here.
The abduction of MDC officials and civil society activists is a
sinister and
deadly development which requires an appropriate response from
all
pro-democracy forces.
Tsvangirai has threatened to suspend
negotiations with Zanu-PF if all people
abducted by state agents are not
released or brought to a court of law by 1
January 2009. His threat was
quite unambiguous: "If these abductions do not
cease immediately and if all
the abductees are not released or charged in a
court of law by 1 January
2009 I will be asking the MDC National Council to
pass a resolution to
suspend all negotiations and contacts with Zanu-PF."
His deadline is
only a week away. Since the state through the police has
denied knowledge of
the whereabouts of these unfortunate people it is
unlikely they will be
freed by January 1. This is to assume that all of them
are still alive.
Given the history of state violence under the Mugabe regime
some may be
dead. Will Tsvangirai carry out his threat? These are crucial
times for the
MDC leader. All the hard work done by the MDC over the past
nine years will
come to nought if he makes strategic blunders.
For too long his
leadership has been reactive. It is time for him to seize
the initiative and
shape events. A resolution of the MDC National Council
clearly spelt out
conditions under which the party will join a so-called
unity government. In
the circumstances these are reasonable demands they
must stick to. If they
are not met they should pull a plug on this charade.
The MDC should go back
to basics and fully re-engage with civil society to
rediscover its soul and
purpose. It was formed to democratically transform
Zimbabwean society and
not to cut deals that circumvent the will of the
people.
Mugabe's
intention is to destroy the MDC. This he will attempt to do whether
they
join his government or not. He wants to have elections when he believes
the
party has been fatally wounded. The abductions are only the beginning of
this process. At some stage he will charge MDC leaders with treason. This is
where the Botswana story about training MDC insurgents is leading to.
Confessions by MDC captives obtained through torture will be used as
evidence of a plot supported by Botswana to overthrow Mugabe's
government.
The agreement is a gigantic fraud that the MDC must walk away
from.
The Brussels-based International Crisis Group (ICG) recently
published a
report on the way forward for Zimbabwe. This is compulsory
reading for
anyone with an interest in the future of Zimbabwe. Crucially the
report is
premised on the recognition that the power-sharing agreement is a
con job
that must be discarded as unworkable. Its call for a neutral
transitional
authority is not a new one. Botswana has proposed this as the
only viable
solution. The report goes into some detail on how the
transitional authority
would work.
This is the path the MDC must
pursue instead of squabbling over crumbs from
Mugabe's table. Tsvangirai,
with the support of civil society, must mobilise
people inside Zimbabwe to
clamour for a transitional authority whose work
culminates in an
internationally-run election. All manner of pressures both
internally and
externally must be applied on the regime to accept this. It
is, however,
imperative that agitation for this solution be driven by
Zimbabweans
themselves with foreigners playing a supportive role.
The principle that
those who govern Zimbabwe must do so with the consent of
the people must
prevail. It cannot be right for Mugabe to get a new full
five year term as
president on the basis of the guns he controls.
Tsvangirai is under
immense pressure from SADC leaders to capitulate to
Mugabe. They hope this
will make the Zimbabwe problem go away. They neither
have the courage nor
inclination to hold Mugabe to account. They want
Tsvangirai to make life
easier for them at the expense of Zimbabweans. He
must not buckle under
pressure from people who abdicated their
responsibility to uphold the
founding principles and values of SADC.
Surrender is never a good way of
solving a problem.
On January 1, 2009 it is unlikely that any of the
people abducted by state
agents will be freed or brought before a court of
law. They will be in
dungeons or torture bases being subjected to savage
violence. Tsvangirai
must be true to his word. If the regime does not heed
his call for the
release of these people and the cessation of violence and
abductions he must
pull out of the agreement. He will have the support of
the majority of
Zimbabweans and the international community.
We
might as well think of Plan B
http://www.zimdiaspora.com
With much regret we should accept that the
unity government cannot work. It
is sad to all Zimbabweans but the sooner we
move into reality the better for
all of us. This unity government has made
us look like beggars yet we are
the winners for months now. There is no
passion at all for us to be seen
playing small in settling for a political
share smaller than that we fought
for and democratically deserve.
We have
displayed enough patience and leniency far enough and we deserve the
most
prestigious peace prize. Our fate remains doldrumed by the African
britherwood.African brothers have not let us down solely but we helped them
let us down. We gave them too much charge of our affairs and locked
ourselves out of the negotiating room where the negotiation is on us. We
display too much literacy on show-offs than the one we tend to apply on
issues affecting us nationally, which need real political intellect. We have
an immature belief that degrees are the only measure of wisdom. Let us
remember that wisdom is not a product of schooling but the product of a
lifelong journey in trying to acquire it.
There has to be times when we
need to give in on one thing and try another
.I personally do acknowledge
that everyone has tried this one and it has not
worked. We thank all
Zimbabweans for trying to be modest for modesty is for
those who are
patient. Because you fought with an enemy that is conniving
and
manipulative, it does not mean you did not do your best. Do not turn
against
each other and embark on the blame game. If you switch games, the
enemy
would have accomplished his goals. We all know it is time to think of
plan
B, if we don't think of the next plan we might be caught unawares by
the
outer forces who will utilize their manipulative tricks tactfully.
You all
agree that Zanu pf has pulled us long enough to hate them but do not
give in
on the fight now because heroes are made at an hour of defeat. When
you
start realising that you cannot do it anymore, it is the time you have
neared achievement because success is described as a series of glorious
defeats. You do not have to give in but engage different plan because every
exit has to be an entry somewhere.
Remember how much time has been wasted
to announce the results of the
elections, time wasted talking about the
re-run of the presidential, time
wasted trying to legitimise the
illegitimate Mugabe, time wasted going to
Zambia for SADC summit on
Zimbabwe, time wasted by Thabo Mbeki telling the
world that there was no
crisis in Zimbabwe, time wasted in Egypt, time
wasted by the SADC troika on
defence and security, time wasted negotiating
with losers and the time
Mugabe wastes everyday foul mouthing the British.
Don't we ever get enough
of this circus! All this was calculated to make you
lose hope on Zimbabwe.
We must never!!
Mugabe has to know that Zimbabweans are like tall mountains,
they retain
their stability even during the most severe storm. Zimbabweans
have survived
the worst and they deserve the best and that is going to be
the greatest use
of their lives, spending it for something that outlasts
it;peace,freedom,good governance and transparency.
Zimbabweans are like
drowning men, they are not troubled by rain, even if
they fear they will
still be oppressed so they need not display any fear,
they need to intensify
their demand for democracy using all means available.
Instead of marching to
the UK Home Office to demand only the right to work,
let's also demand that
the international organisations overseeing world
order do something more
practical on Zimbabwe, like helping us remove all
the Zanu pf trash from
power, even those we think are innocent, because a
man is not honest only
because he did not have the chance to steal, their
support of the junta
alone will take us back into the rot. We need a clean
image for a new
Zimbabwe.LOVEMORE MAZIVISA.
The land of
pedestrian millionaires
http://www.mg.co.za
RAY MWAREYA - Dec 24 2008 06:00
As I was about
to step into a public taxi in Harare's Unity Square, a shout
drew my
attention. "Ladies and gentleman, the fare is cheap today -- one
million Zim
dollars only," boasted the scruffy young taxi-rank marshall. "If
you don't
have change don't board."
I had just withdrawn my new maximum amount of
Z$100-million from the bank
after six hours in the queue. That made me rich
enough by Harare's
standards: I could afford 100 trips in and out of
town.
But a new sense of funny reality began to unravel inside me as I
took a
closer look at the new red Z$100-million dollar note. A queue started
to
form behind me in the taxi rank. The anxious crowd was keen to go home
and
escape Harare's evening thunderstorms.
Each of the commuters held
a red Z$100-million note, but complained that
despite their newfound riches
they could not afford the Z$1-million taxi
ride home! I thought they were
being illogical until a young retail
assistant uttered to me the words:
"Change, buddy."
Forget cholera and hunger. The new kid on the block of
crises in Zimbabwe is
change.
I decided to take a laidback walk to
the nearby Nandos and buy two loaves of
bread and tea. After a short wait in
the queue the bill came to
Z$30-million. When I produced my red
Z$100-million, the cashier frowned and
looked aside.
"We don't have
change, mukoma [brother]. Your money is too big. Next!" she
said, stuffing
small notes from the till into her handbag. I dropped the
goods back on the
shop's empty shelves.
But I reasoned that a pint of my favourite Windhoek
Lager would do the
trick. As I beat the pavement to my favourite bar at
Ximex Mall, I couldn't
help cursing Gono, the country's all-powerful central
bank chief. A day
earlier I'd been praising his name for having raised the
cash withdrawal
limit to Z$100-million per week.
The dimly lit bar
was full but only two patrons were drinking -- even though
a pint was a mere
Z$20-million. "Ray, I can serve you," said the barman,
smiling. "But if you
buy one beer, I won't have the Z$80-million change
you'll need."
To
my disbelief he proposed that I use the whole Z$100-million to buy five
lagers, informing me that the patrons killing time in the bar had the red
notes but couldn't afford a lager costing Z$20-million -- all for lack of
change.
As my frightening new situation dawned on me, I saw young men
just outside
the bar holding bundles of old notes. At first I thought they
were the now
familiar forex dealers. But then I was astonished to see a new
form of
lucrative trade --exchanging your Z$100-million note for
Z$20-million
denominations.
For this you paid: the streetboys were
pocketing Z$20-million a time. "It is
up to you to take up our deal,
shamwari [friend]," bellowed the leader of
the street dealers, "or you can
walk home with your red Z$100-million note
in your pocket."
At first
I thought it was daylight robbery, needing the attention of the
Anti-Corruption Commission. But as the night and the rain descended I was
left with no option but to trade the red note.
Never mind about
forex: the new gold in Zimbabwe is change. Those with
access to lower
denominations are selling them with interest and raking in
super-profits
overnight.
As the squeaky taxi roared towards Avondale surburb every soul
inside was
nodding their head and muttering the word "change". And hordes of
people
with single Z$100-million notes were walking home just because they
didn't
have Z$1-million notes for a taxi. What a land of pedestrian
millionaires!
Shame Cycle
http://www.tnr.com
by
Alvaro Vargas Llosa
Wishing that Robert Mugabe might one day cede power,
and that South Africa
might one day stop propping him up.
Post Date
December 24, 2008
WASHINGTON--Zimbabwe's Robert Mugabe has been blaming
the cholera epidemic
that has already killed 1,100 people and may have
infected 20,000 others,
along with a famine that threatens another 5
million, on--who else?--Western
colonialism. But both are of his own making
and should shame most of the 14
governments, led by South Africa, that make
up the Southern African
Development Community. They have abetted the world's
most evil ruler.
Zimbabwe was once one of Africa's promising economies.
Although Mugabe did
not mess with it too much in the first part of his
28-year rule, in the last
decade he has systematically destroyed it through
corruption, the assault on
private property and the maniacal printing of
money. Inflation, according to
Zimbabwean economist John Robertson, now
reaches a figure so high--an eight
followed by 18 zeros--that it is
inconceivable. Public services, including
the water and sewer systems that
Mugabe wrested from city councils
controlled by the opposition's Movement
for Democratic Change, have
collapsed. The cholera epidemic is a direct
result of that descent into
economic hell.
The dearth of food is another
byproduct of Mugabe's delirium. It can be
traced back to the new wave of
land reform that started in 2000, when under
the pretext of undoing the
legacy of colonialism, the government terrorized
white farm owners by
sending the War Veterans Association, supposedly a
group of Zimbabweans who
had fought for the country's liberation, to seize
the farms by force. Even
though Mugabe lost a constitutional referendum that
would have legally
empowered him to confiscate farms, more than 100,000
square kilometers were
taken over in a matter of weeks. As had been the case
with a more civilized
land "reform" of the 1980s, most of the property ended
up in the hands of
cronies or peasants unable to engage in economies of
scale in the plots that
were distributed to them. Agricultural output was
decimated in what was once
known as the breadbasket of southern Africa.
This exercise in economic
self-flagellation has taken place under a tyranny
that has murdered
thousands of citizens. Even after the power-sharing
agreement signed by
Mugabe last September in the wake of his defeat in the
first round of the
presidential elections and the subsequent,
government-sponsored violence,
people close to opposition leader Morgan
Tsvangirai have been kidnapped or
killed.
With the exception of Botswana, Tanzania and Zambia, the member
states of
the Southern African Development Community, South Africa in
particular, have
provided the regime in Harare with political cover on every
important
occasion. They whitewashed the rigged presidential election in
2002, called
for Tsvangirai to recognize the legitimacy of Mugabe's
dictatorship, blamed
the opposition for most of the violence and did not
protest when Mugabe
refused to publish the results of the first round of the
presidential
election this year.
There are several reasons why Thabo
Mbeki was a shameful president of South
Africa until he was legally kicked
out of power a few months ago--including
his contention that the human
immunodeficiency virus (HIV), which according
to the United Nations affects
one in five people in his country, is not the
cause of AIDS. Part of his
foreign policy legacy is the protection of Mugabe
all these years. In a
recent conversation, former South African opposition
leader Tony Leon told
me that "Mbeki's liberation movement mindset led him
to see Mugabe as a
fellow comrade in arms and exculpate him from the evils
of his
government."
Britain accused of deserting Rhodesia pensioners
Hundreds of pensioners who served the Crown in
pre-independence Zimbabwe have been rendered destitute because no country –
including Britain – recognises any obligation towards them.
By David Blair, Diplomatic Editor
Last Updated:
9:09PM GMT 23 Dec 2008
Many retired officials who spent decades in the
government of Rhodesia, which became independent Zimbabwe in 1980, have been
left without pensions and at the mercy of charity despite having paid
contributions throughout their working lives.
President Robert Mugabe's regime, which is legally
obliged to pay their pensions, stopped giving anything to former civil servants
living overseas in 2003. Those in Zimbabwe still get their pensions - but
hyperinflation has destroyed their value.
In all, some 2,000 elderly people, many of them
Britons, have been left with very little. Campaigners believe that Britain has a
moral obligation to help people who served the Crown before Zimbabwe's
independence. Most are now believed to live in South Africa, with a few hundred
in Britain and Zimbabwe.
"We have over 1,700 names of Zimbabwe pensioners on
our database, many of whom are too proud to ask for help," said John Redfern,
the chairman of the Flame Lily Foundation, which helps the former
officials.
"They have been treated as if they don't exist by the
country they came from and once loyally served. It is scandalous that a wealthy
country like Britain has just abandoned them to their fate."
When Zimbabwe won independence, Mr Mugabe's new
government assumed formal responsibility for the pensions of civil servants who
had worked for the old Rhodesian administration. At Britain's urging, this
commitment was written into Zimbabwe's new constitution.
The Foreign Office argues that all legal obligations
towards retired civil servants accordingly transferred to Zimbabwe. It also
points out that these former officials were never employed by the British
Government through the Colonial Service. They worked for Rhodesia - which had
self-government from 1923 onwards and unilaterally declared independence from
Britain in 1965.
But Lord Malloch-Brown, the Foreign Office minister
responsible for Africa, conceded during a House of Lords debate last year that
Britain still had a "moral" obligation.
After hearing a plea from Lord Waddington, the former
Conservative Home Secretary who chairs the Overseas Service Pensioners'
Association, Lord Malloch-Brown said: "I shall go back to officials and examine
this extremely carefully as I think that he has a case."
The minister added: "There is a moral and pragmatic
case here, and a responsibility to public servants who have served the Crown so
honourably."
In later correspondence, however, Lord Malloch-Brown
retreated from this position. "Although we recognise the moral arguments for
providing assistance, we have concluded that, unfortunately, we are not able to
provide direct financial support to this group of pensioners at this time," he
wrote.
The annual cost of paying a full pension to the 2,000
people concerned would be about £25 million. The Government's bill for the
pensions of former colonial officials falls by £2 million every year because of
deaths.
"These people were civil servants, working for the
Crown," said David Le Breton, the secretary of the Overseas Service Pensioners'
Association.
"They paid for their occupational pensions for over
40 years. Some were in very senior positions and all of them had expectations of
an appropriate pension income when they retired. Now in the twilight years of
their lives, they find themselves destitute and
abandoned."
Case
study: Rhodesia pensioners relying on charity
http://www.telegraph.co.uk
Her husband served Rhodesia as
a doctor for decades, but now Joan Wright
must rely on charity.
By
Sebastien Berger in Simonstown
Last Updated: 8:57PM GMT 23 Dec
2008
Mrs Wright, 90, lives in a cottage overlooking the old British
naval base of
Simonstown in South Africa's Cape Peninsula. Born in London,
she moved first
to Northern Rhodesia, now Zambia, and then to Southern
Rhodesia, now
Zimbabwe, with her husband Gavin.
Dr Wright rose to be
provincial medical officer for the whole of
Matabeleland. "I can't tell you
how dedicated all these people were and how
they loved the country and loved
their work and really strived to make
things better," she said. "They really
managed to keep malaria at bay, it
truly was a very well run little country.
It's very sad for me that all the
tremendously wonderful work they did has
just vanished into nothing."
Despite her age, her faculties are intact,
but her finances are another
story.
The couple moved to South Africa
when Dr Wright retired in 1973. He died a
decade later after 44 years of
marriage. "I still miss him," said Mrs
Wright.
In 2003, Zimbabwe's
regime stopped paying her widow's pension. Her plight
can be gauged by the
fact that she describes herself as "extremely lucky" to
receive £70 a month
from the Crown Agents because of her husband's service
in Zambia, not
Zimbabwe. "I'm lucky enough to have that, so many people have
nothing," she
said. "My Rhodesian pension was much bigger because my husband
had many
years of service but I haven't seen that since the beginning of
2003."
A dual British-South African citizen, she receives a hardship
grant from the
South African government, and when her cottage needed
repainting, the Flame
Lily Foundation stepped in. "At certain times it's
very difficult," she
said. "I find it so hard. I have never been overseas or
anything like that,
which I miss because my sisters and nieces have died in
the meantime."
She is far from alone.
For more than four decades,
John Speares worked in Rhodesia's mining
department, starting as a clerk and
rising to become under-secretary for
mines.
After 41 years with the
same employer - except for service in the Second
World War - he retired in
1974 and moved to South Africa five years later.
Now 94, he lives with
his daughter, Pat Dean, at her home in Durban. "Mugabe
just quit paying it
and the pension didn't come," he said. "I'm finished
with that, I'm 94 now,
I haven't got much longer to go."
Mrs Dean, 60, who runs a charity,
explained: "He blames Mugabe personally
for stopping the pension, he thinks
it was a personal move of spite against
people who were being paid by his
government, and Mugabe didn't have any
appreciation of what they did to
build the country. When it stopped it was a
psychological blow, he was one
of those people who grew up thinking you did
a job, you put your best into
it, you put into your pension and it paid out
when you retired. It was the
natural view of things.
It was a tremendous blow for him because he felt
abandoned. It's the only
work he's ever done."
When the payments
stopped in 2003 Mr Speares was receiving £300 a month. "It
was perfectly
adequate, he bought a mobile home on a caravan park and lived
there quite
happily," said Mrs Dean. "He could clothe himself, he had a
reasonable old
person's lifestyle."
Mr Speares took South African citizenship some years
ago, and now receives a
pension of around £65 a month from the authorities.
But Mrs Dean relies on
charitable help for his care.
She believes
Britain has a moral responsibility to pay the lost pensions.
"These are
people of British stock who have been abandoned, and the there
are many
Zimbabwean pensioners who are in desperate straits," she said.
Commentary:
Remember Zimbabwe's pensioners
http://www.telegraph.co.uk
It is heart-rending to know that any group of
elderly, respectable people
should be reduced to spending Christmas in
penury.
By Clive Aslet
Last Updated: 8:37PM GMT 23 Dec
2008
But when they are former Crown servants for whom the governments
admits a
moral responsibility, the blood boils. Zimbabwe's forgotten
pensioners are
such a case.
These are individuals who were recruited
to run the civil service of
Southern Rhodesia, as it then was, before
independence. When Ian Smith's
regime declared UDI in 1965, Harold Wilson
urged them to stay at their
posts.
During the Lancaster House talks
of 1979, which negotiated the transition to
majority rule, they were assured
that their pensions would be secure. Since
2003, the ex-civil servants who
now live in South Africa or the UK have
received no pension at all. Those
who have remained inside Zimbabwe find
that their pensions won't buy so much
as a postage stamp. All are eking out
their final years in conditions of
direst poverty and distress.
In a House of Lords debate last October,
Lord Crickhowell, who was a member
of the Thatcher cabinet during the period
of the Lancaster House talks,
spoke of his "sense of deep shame and
embarrassment that we are now in this
position" and expressed his "hope and
expectation that this Government will
do something to honour the pledges
given". To which the whole nation,
surely, would cry hear,
hear.
Since 1973, Britain has been committed (under the Overseas Pension
Act) to
paying the pensions of the civil servants who ran other
colonies.
Arrangements in Southern Rhodesia had always been slightly
different. Being
exceptionally well administered, it enjoyed a great degree
of autonomy,
recruiting its civil servants directly, often through Rhodesia
House in
London. Today, the Foreign Office is hiding behind this
technicality in its
refusal to honour the Lancaster House commitment. That
commitment was partly
enshrined in the constitution of Zimbabwe, paragraphs
112 and 113, which
protected the pension rights of "public officers". While
this placed the
onus of paying the pensions on the new state, British
ministers clearly
believed that they had ensured, in the words of one of
them, "full
safeguards for public service pensions and their
remittability".
Nobody foresaw the tragedy that Robert Mugabe's tyranny
and mismanagement
would inflict on a wonderful country. Now that Zimbabwe
has become a failed
state, the British government must surely honour the
clearly stated
intention to protect the pensions of Crown servants, to which
some of them
have contributed for 40 years.
Lord Waddington,
championing the pensioners in the House of Lords, put it
succinctly. "The
fact remains that it was not the archangel Gabriel who
granted independence
to Zimbabwe - it was the British Government ... How on
earth in those
circumstances can the Government say that what has happened
to the pensions
is nothing to do with them? That is completely ridiculous."
Waddington
focused his argument on the civil servants who were recruited to
Britain,
and returned to Britain after they retired. There are 350 of them,
mostly
now in their 80s and 90s. Often they are living on minimum state
benefits
and charity. Because the Department for International Development
already
has a fund to pay the pensions of Crown servants in other colonies,
the
additional money that the government would have to find is a paltry £2
million.
At a time when we have been used to assessing fresh
Government commitments
in billions, if not trillions, this is the equivalent
of small change. It
amounts to 0.0002% of the £500 billion bank bailout
announced in October.
The government could help 1,700 times the number of
Zimbabwe pensioners in
Britain for the £3.4 billion it produced for Northern
Rock. The comparison
with the gold-plated, inflation proofed pensions
available to UK civil
servants working comfortably in their home country
need hardly be made.
There is a group of over 1,700 now in South Africa
and Zimbabwe itself,
sometimes having been trapped by regulations that have
prevented them taking
any of their savings out of Zimbabwe. Their plight is
even more pitiful and
desperate. Many are effectively homeless and live on
minimum South African
state support of £16 a week. According to the Flame
Lily Foundation, a
charity in South Africa, they are often too proud to seek
help. "They have
been treated as if they don't exist by the country they
came from and once
loyally serves," claims the Chairman, John Redfern. "It
is scandalous that a
wealthy country like the UK has just abandoned them to
their fate."
Incredibly, Lord Malloch-Brown, Minister of State in the
Foreign Office,
acknowledges the "moral and pragmatic arguments" for
supporting the
pensioners, yet will not offer financial help. Instead, he
falls back on the
laughable assurance that the FO "will continue to remind
the Zimbabwe
pension authorities of their legal commitment to former
employees of the
Southern Rhodesia Government" - even though the Zimbabwe
dollar is now
valueless and the government reneged on its pension
responsibilities to
these former civil servants five years ago.
Day
by day, the unfolding horror in Zimbabwe, now smitten with cholera,
seems to
take a new turn. For the most part Britain, whom Mugabe tries to
blame for
the appalling suffering that he has brought on his people, can
only sit by
and watch. But while we may be powerless to rectify most of the
wrongs that
have been inflicted on what is now a wretched country, the
misery of former
Crown servants is easily within our power to redeem - it is
indeed our clear
duty to do so.
This case has echoes of the wretchedly mean treatment
meted out to the
Ghurkas. It took the High Court to give these former
soldiers the right to
remain in the UK, regardless of when they retired or
were stationed. The
Zimbabwe pensioners can only hope that the Ghurkas
victory will show the
government the way of compassion.
May Gordon
Brown can find the charity in his heart to rescue them from
destitution this
Christmas.
- Clive Aslet is Editor at Large of Country Life