The ZIMBABWE Situation Our thoughts and prayers are with Zimbabwe
- may peace, truth and justice prevail.

Back to Index

Back to the Top
Back to Index

Daily News

Leader Page

      Zimbabweans must reset attitude template

      2/20/2003 12:34:15 AM (GMT +2)


      By K Harry Laubscher

      Without question, the overriding priority of Zimbabweans must be to
usher out the government of President Mugabe which, is generally agreed, is
now illegitimate.
      Most reasonable people acknowledge that after this struggle there
awaits another huge challenge that of ensuring not only a society founded on
democracy and human rights for all, but also a template for a sustainable
standard of living.



      At the heart of this lies an imperative that of changing the mindset
of Zimbabweans which has often made them their own worst enemies. Perhaps
the greatest attitude failure of all is that Zimbabweans, through their very
complacency, have allowed Mugabe to establish a virtual dictatorship. It is
thoroughly abnormal that the continent's best educated state with the full
array of commercial and administrative infrastructure should now be
literally governed by thugs of the Joseph Chinotimba calibre, for instance.
The fact that those Zimbabweans who celebrated independence 23 years ago
have ignored their responsibilities to maintain proper checks and balances
on Zanu PF has in itself directly led to the future of the supposedly
"born-free" generation being so woefully jeopardised. It is one unassailable
characteristic of the Mugabe era that Zimbabweans have been taught to
believe that the world needs them more than the other way round. Creating
what is viewed by most civilised nations as a pariah state and now cut off
from aid and financial assistance has been the outcome of this policy, with
the resulting suffering all too evident.

      Nothing short of starvation now faces half the country's population a
damning indictment of arrogant government attitudes if ever one was needed!
Anecdotes of the perennial arrogance of Mugabe and his palace guards can
fill many encyclopaedias, yet it is a sad reality that negative attitudes of
one sort or another pervade most corners of society. Even prior to the
current environment of conflict, attitudes clearly played a huge part in the
decline of the State. How frequently was a government official to be seen at
his desk during the afternoon? Sure, the jacket would be conveniently hung
on the back of the chair, but the owner of the garment would be long gone
for private business, pleasure or whatever and all at the taxpayers'
expense. In the private sector, too, those that did manage to work a full
day would invariably leave on the dot of finishing time, irrespective of the
pile of work on one's desk, hardly a productive approach, and almost unheard
of in the modern age of cut-throat competition. And therein lies the rub.
These are symptoms of a spoiled society, not one which is adequately
prepared to compete with any hope in the rough and tumble of world markets.
Zimbabweans have for far too long been protected, firstly by the carry-over
from UDI, where sanctions inevitably prompted home-grown industries which by
definition were detached from outside competition, and which left Zimbabwe
hugely vulnerable after independence when the country rejoined the
international host of nations.

      The new elite after 1980 was reluctant to change such a comfortable,
protected situation, until it was accepted by almost any fool that this
simply wasn't sustainable.
      By which time it was almost too late, and Zimbabweans had been led to
believe that this economic house of cards was indeed a model to keep them
going indefinitely. Only with a full acceptance by Zimbabweans that they
will have to seriously toil for success rather than viewing this simply as
their divine right will any meaningful work attitudes begin to produce the
desired affect. It has been a great shock to many that those of our
neighbours such as Zambia who have been lampooned for so long as the very
examples not to follow, are now in turn laughing at Zimbabweans. It is only
logical that Zimbabwe, unless fundamentally turned around, will continue to
spiral downward. What price the Zimdollar below the kwacha this year? A full
appreciation of the realities of the modern world is a basic prerequisite
for moving forward. Zimbabwe must know literally where its bread is
buttered, and to honestly and efficiently operate with the world's major
trading partners not to be hopelessly locked in perpetuity into the
post-independence African nationalist mentality. And where has one's civic
and national pride gone, or is everyone out for oneself? Some years back I
met a Zimbabwean undergoing extensive medical treatment in the United
Kingdom, whose costs had begun to seriously spiral. When I asked how he was
likely to meet these expenses, his astonished reply was that it would, of
course, be the British taxpayer!
      This is a popular default attitude by many Zimbabweans, and one which
fully chimes with Mugabe's habitual ranting against the UK and the United
States the very countries which have been the largest donors of aid to
Zimbabwe. The examples are legion of those looking out for themselves, and
themselves alone.
      Perhaps the most disgraceful episode in recent years was the unseemly
scramble to secure "war veterans" benefits.
      Many who grabbed these funds were not only those whose patriotism and
devotion to their country's freedom now takes the form of torturing and
raping suspected opposition supporters, but many of them were totally
unconnected with the 1970s war and were simply out for what they could get.
Yet, in fact, what was most sad here was not that many undeserving people
managed to rip off the taxpayer and send the economy into what could be
terminal decline, but that those who did fit the criteria no less than
demanded such payments. What it means in simple terms is that their
participation in the war was driven not by patriotism but by greed the
prospect of what they would demand when the war was won. Never should any
sector of society hold a whole country to ransom, whatever their supposed
contribution. At the end of the day, it's all an attitude thing and one that
requires a radical overhaul.

Back to the Top
Back to Index

Daily Telegraph
 

Gallows humour in a land hung out to dry
(Filed: 20/02/2003)

As Zimbabwe's president arrives in Paris for the African summit, his countrymen are left to scramble for maize, writes Stephen Robinson in Harare

Walk into a Harare restaurant these days, and the waiter will quickly run through "the specials" - by which he will mean, in keeping with the prevailing gallows humour that soothes the senses in Robert Mugabe's devastated country, what you cannot order because it's off the menu.

A quick lunch in the Harare suburb of Newlands was typical. "Sorry, no bread, no rice. And no Coke and no fizzy drinks - the plant has run out of gas to carbonate the drinks. Oh yes, and no de-caff coffee."

 

Strangely, there are always beer and cigarettes, but that is of little comfort to the African women waiting patiently in the streets outside for word of where to find the bread and maize.

The problems facing diners in the smarter Harare restaurants are utterly trivial compared to the horrors that are being visited on the vast majority of Zimbabweans, an estimated seven million of whom are experiencing life-threatening food shortages.

But a curious racial solidarity has taken hold in the capital, despite Mr Mugabe's best efforts to blame the dwindling band of whites for all the country's problems.

As you walk in Harare you come upon snakes of cars backing around the suburban streets, and motorists waiting patiently in line to fill up their cars. "Not too bad today," explained one white woman, anxious to get to her tennis four. "Just about two hours, which is a lot better than last week."

A black delivery driver one space behind nodded stoically. When calculating whether to drive somewhere, Zimbabwean motorists no longer speak in terms of distance or time, but in fractions of petrol tanks.

Motorists queue patiently together with exaggerated good humour, proving that in today's chaotically repressive Zimbabwe, there is some part of Harare that will always be British Southern Rhodesia.

And no one, black or white, has a good word to say about Mugabe. The country seems to be on hold, waiting for him to die or flee into exile.

Hardship and hunger are bad enough to witness when they are caused by natural disaster or a civil war, but when they are deliberately inflicted upon a people as government policy, it is much more painful to see.

Apart from the queues and a creeping shabbiness, Harare can seem quite normal until you speak to members of the opposition and learn that the farm invasions continue. The show trial of Morgan Tsvangirai, the opposition leader, on trumped up treason charges, continues in the centre of town.

Since the beginning of the year, a further 77 white farms have been "listed" prior to confiscation and handover to Mugabe's cronies, ensuring further torment for the owners and more food shortages in the months ahead.

Scarcely a day goes by without the arrest of MPs from Mr Tsvangirai's Movement for Democratic Change. They face routine intimidation, even torture. And now, having bullied the judiciary for many months with ill-concealed menace, Mugabe's men are actually arresting judges.

Zimbabwe has never been a rich country, but it was once well ordered and not without hope. After independence, most of the whites who could not face the thought of black rule left quickly for South Africa and beyond, and by the mid-1980s, the country appeared to be making slow if unspectacular progress towards racial reconciliation.

Throughout the 1990s, Mugabe enacted many reforms dictated by the IMF and the World Bank, and as the Zimbabwean dollar was allowed to float, the shops filled with Western goods, albeit at a very high price for the locals.

Whites generally thought they had reached a tacit understanding with Mugabe that would allow them to get on with running their businesses and farms unmolested by post-colonial retribution.

The problem came with Mugabe's humiliation in the 2000 constitutional referendum, and some whites are now critical of their friends who set up the MDC, which harnesses a lot of black opposition to the government but is essentially run by white farming interests.

"Mugabe would have left us alone, but he couldn't take us whites getting involved in his politics," said one white businessman, whose brother is active in the MDC and narrowly survived a recent assassination attempt.

The most troubling aspect of spending time in Harare these days is reading the comments of Olusegun Obasanjo, the Nigerian president, that land seizures have "substantially ended" and that law and order are returning to Zimbabwe.

He and Thabo Mbeki of South Africa are adamant that Zimbabwe's suspension from the Commonwealth should be lifted because conditions are improving - a baffling contention to anyone who spends even half an hour in Harare.

Zimbabweans cannot understand why those leaders should tolerate torture and repression of fellow Africans in the name of the spurious concept of "African unity".

Despite the obvious dangers, people will not be silenced. Henry Olonga, the cricketer dropped from yesterday's cricket international after wearing a black armband in protest at Mugabe's repression, knows full well that he is vulnerable.

"I am in God's hands," Olonga told me, when I asked him if he was scared about the retribution he faced for his stand against Mugabe. "To be honest, I'll be fine for now, but the problems will come when the fuss of the cricket dies down, and when you people forget about Zimbabwe."

Back to the Top
Back to Index

ABC Australia

Thursday, February 20, 2003. Posted: 07:05:34 (AEST)

Fans join Flower, Olonga in anti-Mugabe protest
Zimbabwe's star batsman Andy Flower defied cricket authorities on Wednesday
by protesting once more against President Robert Mugabe's government during
the World Cup match against India in Harare.

Flower, who wore a black armband in the first match against Namibia last
week and issued a strong statement condemning human rights abuses in his
country, took the field against India wearing a black wrist band.

Fast bowler Henry Olonga, who had joined Flower in the extraordinary protest
in the first match, was relegated to 12th man duties on Wednesday but still
wore a black wrist band similar to Flower's.

They were joined in their protest by a group of four men and two women in
the stands who were also wearing black armbands.

They held posters, one praising Flower and Olonga as "two brave men", for
their statement of protest against President Robert Mugabe's government.

Another poster applauded England's boycott of their scheduled World Cup
match in Harare as well as the stance of captain Nasser Hussain.

"There's more to the meaning of 'cricket' than cricket - well done England
and Nasser," it read.

Uniformed crowd control police sitting directly in front of the stands took
no action.

According to the SAPA news agency, among the group of spectators was farmer
Mike Carter, who was arrested for wearing a black armband at Zimbabwe's game
against Namibia.

He was forced to pay a fine of around 55 dollars for "conduct likely to
cause a breach of the peace."

Both Flower and Olonga were reported to the International Cricket Council
(ICC) by the Zimbabwe Cricket Union after the Namibia game, but the sport's
governing body declined to take action and only asked the players not to
wear the armbands.

There was no immediate response from the ICC on the latest action by the two
players.

Almost half of Zimbabwe's 14 million people reportedly face food shortages
and the leader of the main opposition party faces a death sentence after
being accused of plotting to kill Mugabe.
Back to the Top
Back to Index

Daily News

Leader Page

      Sacrificed on the altar of self-interest

      2/20/2003 12:31:32 AM (GMT +2)



      One of President Mugabe's greatest weaknesses is that he will not let
an opportunity to travel abroad pass him by, no matter how urgently certain
problems back home may need his attention. He will fly out of the country on
the flimsiest of pretexts, when an invitation has been extended to the
country, even when representation by a junior minister in his Cabinet would
have sufficed.



      It would be redundant to revisit his morally reprehensible decision to
go on a shopping jaunt with his family last December when the country was
and still is in the grip of its worst economic and political crises ever,
with half the population facing starvation. Suffice it to say it provoked
great ire nationwide, the government-controlled media's puerile attempt to
glibly justify that clearly ill-conceived trip as "a working holiday"
notwithstanding. More recently, on Sunday 2 February 2003 to be precise,
Mugabe flew out to Addis Ababa in Ethiopia to attend one of those useless
meetings of African heads of state just as shock waves triggered by the
death of at least 50 people in the country's worst ever rail disaster the
previous night were spreading to every corner of the country.

      For him to have gone ahead to make that trip in the face of such an
unprecedented national disaster was, even by the Zanu PF regime's lamentably
poor standards, a remarkable display of his incredible capacity for getting
his priorities wrong. Any other head of state would have cancelled that trip
and immediately flown to the scene of the train disaster to assess its
enormity first-hand and get a personal feel of the tragedy, as was done by
United States President George W Bush following the 11 September 2001 World
Trade Centre and Pentagon infamy. That same evening, Mugabe ought to then
have gone on television to address the nation, with feeling and showing
appropriate grief, and immediately declare the accident a national disaster.
But he did not do anything like that. True to form, he would not allow
anything, no matter how paramount in terms of national importance it may be,
to come between him and those things that give him that great feeling of
infinite importance and, consequently, immense personal joy.
      It is that same heedless self-interest which must have been behind his
eager acceptance of the invitation by the morally bankrupt French government
to him to attend the 22nd Franco-Africa conference which opened in Paris
yesterday. Strictly speaking, that conference is supposed to be the
Francophone world's equivalent of the Commonwealth Heads of Government
Meeting. The latter brings together, at regular intervals, leaders from all
former British colonies while the former brings together leaders from all
ex-French colonies. Mugabe's presence at Francophone meetings is, therefore,
puzzling, to say the least, since Zimbabwe is not a former French colony and
Mugabe is not particularly known either for his mastery of the French
language or his appreciation of French culture. For him to have seen fit to
turn his back, even if only temporarily, on his country's mounting crisis,
just to be at that meeting, where he is probably the odd man out, only goes
to further illustrate how totally consumed he is with his own
self-aggrandisement at the expense of the entire nation. His cannot be
classified as actions of a leader who, by any stretch of the imagination,
has the best interests of his people at heart as he would like the world to
believe. No doubt, Zimbabweans will be keeping their fingers crossed hoping
that Peter Tatchell's lone campaign to get him arrested which he has now
taken to the French capital will succeed this time around, even if that
success will only be in the form of pricking the conscience of the French
government into realising their mistake in giving succour to Mugabe.
Tatchell has said he is seeking Mugabe's arrest "on the grounds of torture"
of his own people. In their heart of hearts, the French know quite well not
only that Tatchell's charge is true, but also that it is only one of the
Mugabe regime's many other "crimes against humanity" committed against its
own people crimes for which he will certainly have to answer one day.
Back to the Top
Back to Index

Daily News

      Resettled war vets abandon farming for gold panning

      2/20/2003 1:14:11 AM (GMT +2)


      Staff Reporter

      THE Parliamentary Portfolio Committee on Public Service, Labour and
Social Welfare, last week heard that some resettled war veterans and Zanu PF
supporters, had abandoned farming and joined thousands of displaced
farmworkers in illegal gold panning.



      The committee was on a fact finding mission on farms in all the
Mashonaland provinces, to establish the nature of problems being faced by
resettled farmers and ex-farmworkers. Settlers and the former farmworkers
told the committee that gold panning by war veterans settled at Simoona Farm
in Bindura was rife. A former farmworker who refused to be named, said the
settlers always threatened them with eviction if they refused to work on
their plots. "But they are not working on their plots," she said. "Most of
the time, the settlers, particularly the war veterans, walk to the rivers
around the farm and engage in massive gold panning.
      "Whenever they decide to evict or harass us, they claim that we are
refusing to work for them. But we have no place to work because the war
veterans who were resettled here are not tilling the land. "This has forced
us to follow them to the river for gold panning," she said. "That's the only
way through which they make money, not farming. The few who are tilling the
land pay us very little and we refuse to be sidelined in gold panning."
Anthony Magombo, 41, a settler, at Simoona Farm admitted that gold panning
was sustaining them.
      He said they had no draught power to till the land and had not been
assisted with the essential farming inputs. The gold panning issue was
raised after some settlers had told the committee that their colleagues,
especially the war veterans, had turned to gold panning, neglecting their
farming responsibilities. Simoona Farm was designated under the A1
resettlement model and more than 150 people were resettled there. During the
fact finding tour, the committee implored the settlers and
      ex-farmworkers to disclose, without fear of victimisation, their
needs, problems and recommendations. Throughout the tour, gold panning was
said to be rife. Ex-farmworkers at Milverton Farm in the Golden Valley area
of Kadoma, were said to be inviting friends from Gokwe area to come and live
in the farm compound to pursue gold panning.
      This has led to increased prostitution, rampant child abuse, stock
thefts and a general rise in criminal activity.
Back to the Top
Back to Index

Daily News

      Mudzuri rejects cricket invitation

      2/20/2003 1:08:33 AM (GMT +2)


      Staff Reporter

      Engineer Elias Mudzuri, the Executive Mayor of Harare, will not attend
the Cricket World Cup matches being played in Harare because he says part of
the invitation letter treated him "like a criminal".



      Mudzuri turned down an invitation from the Zimbabwe Cricket Union
(ZCU) to attend the matches because of the following paragraph in the
invitation from Vince Hogg, the ZCUšs managing director: "Just inside Gate 1
will be a checkpoint where you must expect to be checked and searched for
the following: alcohol, chairs, umbrellas, anything that can be classed as a
weapon, anything that is going to make a noise, such as a firecracker."
Mudzuri received the letter on 29 January inviting him to Zimbabwešs three
International Cricket Council (ICC) Cricket World Cup matches against
Namibia, England and India on 10, 13 and 19 February, respectively.The match
against England was cancelled after the England team refused to come to
Zimbabwe, fearing for their safety. Mudzuri said that part of the letter was
degrading as it insinuated that he was irresponsible. He said: "I did not go
to the game with Namibia and I am not going to go to the game with India.
The ZCU are treating me like a criminal. How can they say they will search
the mayor for things like alcohol, weapons and even firecrackers?" Mudzuri
said he had asked the ZCU what they meant by writing that he would be
subjected to a search. He said: "They said it was a general letter sent to
other people but that letter was addressed to me personally. I asked them
why they would write such a general letter to the mayor, but I did not get a
satisfactory answer."

      The mayor said he had declined to meet the visiting teams at the
airport. He said: "First the ZCU write to me as if I am going to kill the
cricketers, and then they ask me to go and meet them. I said no."Hogg on
Tuesday said no offence was meant as similar letters had been sent to about
250 people invited to the VIP enclosure.
      He said: "We are just following ICC security regulations. The same
security measures are being taken at the other game venues in Kenya and
South Africa."
      Hogg said nothing had been communicated to him about the mayoršs
concerns. Mudzuri said that apart from the intended physical search, he was
not happy to attend the cricket matches while the police harassed and beat
up people in the name of the games.He said: "The police should just not pick
up people for nothing. Before the match with the Namibians they arrested
people who were trying to buy tickets. There is a lot of harassment of the
citizens of this city." Mudzuri himself was recently locked up by the police
on allegations of holding an illegal political rally in Mabvuku, a suburb of
Harare.
Back to the Top
Back to Index

Daily News

      Manzunzu faces more allegations

      2/20/2003 1:04:59 AM (GMT +2)


      By Brian Mangwende Chief Reporter

      FRESH allegations of corruption have been levelled against Jacob
Manzunzu, the Registrar of the High Court, after he bought property worth
about $3 million which his office was auctioning.



      Tichaona Samuriwo, the director of Dakarai Investments Private Ltd,
accused Manzunzu of awarding himself Lot 22 of Tynwald, Harare, despite the
fact that he had already paid a deposit of about $400 000 for three
properties, including the one in question. Manzunzu is at the centre of
another scam involving the cancellation of an agreement by Harare
businessman, Nhamo Chikweka Tutisani, worth about $500 million to develop
stands at a plot in Highlands, Harare. Asked in an interview with The Daily
News yesterday, whether it was proper for him to purchase property his
office was auctioning, Manzunzu said: "When I established interest in that
property, I handed the necessary files pertaining to it to another officer
to handle it."
Back to the Top
Back to Index

ABC Australia

Thursday, February  20, 2003. Posted: 07:07:12 (AEDT)

Players continue Zimbabwe protest
Zimbabwean cricketers Andy Flower and Henry Olonga have defied the
International Cricket Council (ICC) by continuing their protest against
President Robert Mugabe.

The players wore black wristbands during their World Cup match against India
in the Zimbabwean capital Harare overnight.

The pair had earlier escaped ICC action after wearing black armbands during
Zimbabwe's first match of the tournament.

On Wednesday the pair repeated their earlier statement that they were making
the protest in mourning at the death of democracy in Zimbabwe.

Dozens of spectators also wore armbands, with some leaving the ground
through the rear exit amid fears of retaliation from ruling party
supporters.

Zimbabwe security forces are now on alert for next week's encounter between
Zimbabwe and Australia as opposition activists threaten to disrupt the match
in the southern city of Bulawayo.

Back to the Top
Back to Index

Daily News

      Menashe pleads exhaustion

      2/20/2003 1:04:25 AM (GMT +2)


      By Lloyd Mudiwa

      ARI BEN-MENASHE, the key witness in MDC president Morgan Tsvangirai's
high treason trial, yesterday afternoon buckled under intense
cross-examination by defence lawyers and asked for time-off from the witness
stand as the trial entered its 13th day..

      Earlier, Ben-Menashe had been grilled by defence lawyers over his
alleged involvement in the traffic of blood diamonds in the Democratic
Republic of Congo (DRC). "May I ask to be excused today?" Ben-Menashe asked
High Court judge, Justice Paddington Garwe, when the trial was about to
resume after lunch. "I am not feeling very well. May I be excused this
afternoon?" Asked by Garwe what he was suffering from, Ben-Menashe, who has
been on the witness stand for 12 days now, said: "I am just feeling very
exhausted." The judge allowed the Canada-based political consultant to be
spared the barrage of questions until today. He left the court room guarded
by a State security agent and is expected back in court this morning. The
Israeli made the plea after Garwe indicated that he would give his ruling
tomorrow to a second bid by Bharat Patel, the Deputy Attorney-General, for
Ben-Menashe to be released to attend to "urgent family and business
interests" in Montreal, Canada.

      A similar request to be so excused failed last week. Ben-Menashe's
troubles were, however, far from over as Advocate George Bizos, leading the
defence team, immediately requested the court to imprison him in terms of
Section 233 of the Criminal Procedure and Evidence Act if he failed to
provide certain documents.

      The documents are bank statements pertaining to the US$976 000 (about
Z$54 million) received from the MDC for political lobbying services and
reports on work done for the Zimbabwe government in terms of a contract
lodged with the United States Department of the Attorney General. The
defence also wants names of the employees of Ben-Menashe's company, Dickens
& Madson, in 2001 and 2002, and the company's financial statements for the
same period. This is the second time that the defence has called for his
imprisonment after it earlier said he should be jailed for refusing to
testify on the contract he entered into with the Zimbabwe government on 10
January 2002, ostensibly to spruce up the country's bruised international
image. Garwe later ruled that the cross-examination be conducted in camera.

      Patel yesterday objected to the provision of three of the documents,
saying they were either irrelevant or protected by privilege. These included
the reports of the work done on behalf of the government, money paid by the
MDC to Ben-Menashe and reports by Dickens & Madson to the US
Attorney-General. Patel said should Garwe, however, rule that Ben-Menashe
provide the documents, the defence should foot his travel expenses so he
could return to Montreal to collect them.

      Bizos said this was unheard of. Garwe said he would hand down his
ruling on that application during the week. Earlier on, Bizos said
Ben-Menashe was involved in the "blood diamonds" trade in the Democratic
Republic Congo (DRC). The Israeli's now-abandoned company, Associated Metals
and Gems Ltd, was involved in conflict diamonds in the DRC, he said.

      Bizos said Ben-Menashe and Rupert Johnson, a director in Dickens &
Madson, had gone to the DRC for the diamonds. Large sums of money were
deposited in Canadian lawyer Marie Larin's trust account for his benefit
from deals that were going on, said Bizos. Ben-Menashe, however, flew into a
rage in his denial of any involvement in the diamond scam. He said: "His
(Bizos') wild accusations, that are totally false, were run in newspapers
all over the world and they were originating from the mouth of accused one
(Tsvangirai)." Ben-Menashe, despite Garwe's efforts to calm him, ranted and
raved: "The false accusations of blood diamonds and mines in the DRC, I
really wish this innuendo would stop . . . were published by newspapers,
including The Daily News." Tsvangirai, the MDC secretary-general Welshman
Ncube, and the party's shadow minister for agriculture Renson Gasela, are
being charged with scheming to assassinate President Mugabe and overthrow
his Zanu PF government in November 2001.

      Ben-Menashe has said Tsvangirai requested him to get the help of the
DRC in staging the coup d'etat. Yesterday he said Johnson went to the DRC to
facilitate that.
      Ben-Menashe's answers under cross-examination were punctuated with "I
don't remember" and "I have no idea" and occasional outbursts. Bizos at one
time asked Ben-Menashe how many times he had answered "I don't know", to
which the witness answered "I don't know", drawing laughter from the gallery
Back to the Top
Back to Index

Daily News

      Women's group condemns arrest of Valentine marchers

      2/20/2003 1:02:07 AM (GMT +2)


      Staff Reporter

      THE founding members of Women of Zimbabwe Arise, (Woza) have condemned
the arrest of 73 people on Valentine's Day who were demonstrating for love
and peace in Harare and Bulawayo.



      The demonstrators in Harare included two MPs of the MDC, Trudy
Stevenson (Harare North), Evelyn Masaiti (Mutasa) and Jenni Williams, one of
the founding members of Woza and former spokesperson for the farmers'
pressure group Justice for Agriculture. The 59 women, arrested in Harare
were released on Friday night without being charged, except for Williams.
She was charged under the notorious Public Order and Security Act for
allegedly organising an unlawful meeting.
      In Bulawayo a group of 15 women including Sheba Dube-Phiri, one of the
Woza founders, Zodwa, the wife of the MDC vice-president Gibson Sibanda, a
Catholic priest, Father Nigel Johnson and Ricardo Caprez, who was playing a
drum for the marchers, were arrested.

      Father Johnson was taking a video of the procession and police
allegedly manhandled him and confiscated his camera. However, they were all
released the following morning after spending a night in police detention.
In celebration of the release of the group, dozens of women who had gathered
in solidarity, placed red roses on the pavement in front of the Bulawayo
Central Police Station. In sharp contrast to the arrests elsewhere, eight
policewomen in Victoria Falls escorted a group of 11 women marchers who
successfully delivered the message of love to residents of the town in a
peaceful procession. A spokesperson for Woza said: "We thank the Almighty
that the unnecessary assault on Father Nigel by the police, was not serious.
The struggle for love and peace continues on undeterred."
      The peaceful marches were organised by Woza to say "no" to violence in
all its forms and "yes" to love.
Back to the Top
Back to Index

Daily News

      Chinotimba's guards assault NAGG official

      2/20/2003 1:00:54 AM (GMT +2)


      Staff Reporter

      MOSES Mutyasira, the secretary for information and publicity for the
National Alliance for Good Governance- Democratic Front (NAGG), was on
Friday allegedly assaulted by security guards from Edlan Security, a company
run by war veteran Joseph Chinotimba.



      He was beaten up after he protested against their harassing people at
a Zupco bus terminus in Harare. Chinotimba is the Zanu PF candidate for
Highfield in a by-election scheduled for 28-29 March. The security company
is contracted to guard Zupco's premises and its crew. Mutyasira said he was
assaulted at Rezende bus terminus where the guards were allegedly
threatening and harassing commuters. He said: "When I realised that they
were taking the law into their hands, I confronted them and demanded to know
why they were violating people's rights. "I demanded Chinotimba's cellphone
number from one of their supervisors who only identified herself as Molly.
They instead handcuffed me and started assaulting me with batons, open hands
and booted feet." Mutyasira said they bundled him into a truck and took him
to Masca House in Fourth Street before transferring him to the Zanu PF
offices on the same street.

      "After my release, I made a report at Harare Central Police Station.
The police took me to the scene of the incident and I managed to identify
three of my assailants." A medical report obtained from Parirenyatwa Group
of Hospitals dated 15 February confirmed Mutyasira sustained multiple
injuries from the assault. The three security guards were arrested and taken
to Harare Central Police Station where they were charged with common
assault.
Back to the Top
Back to Index

Daily News

      Zimdollar devalued for exporters

      2/20/2003 1:06:48 AM (GMT +2)


      Business Reporter

      THE Government has taken a giant step towards devaluation of the
Zimbabwe dollar following the amalgamation yesterday, of all existing
special exchange rates for different export sectors, into a unified export
support scheme of Z$800 for each US dollar

      This means that the exchange rate applicable for all exports would,
with immediate effect, stand at US$1 to Z$800, at least 14,5 times higher
than the official exchange rate of US$1 to Z$55 applicable to other sectors
of the economy. Speaking at a Press briefing yesterday after a Tripartite
Negotiating Forum meeting, Herbert Murerwa, the Minister of Finance and
Economic Development, said the government, business and labour, had adopted
a new policy thrust under which the dollar would be devalued in relation to
the export sector. The new policy would be known as the National Economic
Revival Programme. The Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe (RBZ) would administer and
review the new scheme on a quarterly basis, "to maintain competitiveness and
sustainability in the export sectors".
      Murerwa said the monetary policy announced last year by the RBZ would
continue to apply, together with the National Economic Revival Programme. He
said: "The 50-50 RBZ policy will continue to be implemented. Exporters,
however, now stand to benefit more out of the policy since they could
recover the 50 percent remitted to the Reserve Bank, at the new higher rate
of $800."

      Under the revival programme, exporters and the productive sector would
also receive about Z$100 billion through the RBZ, and the banking community.
      Murerwa also outlined other sector-specific measures set to be
implemented under the National Economic Recovery Programme. The targeted
areas include agricultural producer prices, food imports, dairy and
livestock development facilities, contract farming, industrial development
strategies, distressed companies, the national productivity centre, mine
closures, tourism, monitoring and surveillance, productive and export
facilities, prices and incomes, interest rates, fuel, public transport, and
anti-corruption measures.
Back to the Top
Back to Index

FinGaz

      Zim at crossroads as Mugabe turns 79

      By Luke Tamborinyoka News Editor
      2/20/03 3:36:53 AM (GMT +2)

      PRESIDENT Robert Mugabe turns 79 tomorrow amid unprecedented suffering
in Zimbabwe, but analysts this week said the nation should not expect the
sprightly leader to announce that he might soon be calling it quits or to
engage in public introspection about the economic crisis widely blamed on
his government.


      "He doesn't feel 79," said University of Zimbabwe political science
lecturer John Makumbe. "He is actually raring to go and he is not going to
use his birthday to review his past misdeeds.
      "He has stuck in his roots and it is simply unlikely that he will talk
of retirement soon after blowing out those candles," Makumbe added.
      Mugabe, who this week left for Paris to attend the Franco-African
summit despite a European Union (EU) travel ban, celebrates his 79th
birthday a few weeks after media reports sparked speculation that he might
be willing to step down before the expiry of his five-year term.
      The President, who retained power after his controversial re-election
in last year's presidential poll, has denied rumours that he might make way
for a transitional government, saying this would "subvert the people's will"
.
      But analysts this week said the people of Zimbabwe, who have been hard
hit by the country's worst economic crisis since independence from Britain
in 1980, were more than ready for changes that would alleviate their
suffering.
      United Nations' agencies say more than seven million Zimbabweans are
in need of emergency relief because of food shortages resulting from drought
and the government's land reform programme.
      The agrarian reforms combined with drought to slash food production by
more than 60 percent last year and have also reduced the output of several
crops, including tobacco, the country's single largest foreign currency
earner.
      Hard cash shortages have hampered food and fuel imports and also
worsened the plight of already struggling local companies, many of which are
expected to shut down this year if the economy does not improve.
      Analysts say the resulting unemployment will worsen the lot of
ordinary people in a country where joblessness is estimated at more than 70
percent and incomes have not kept pace with inflation, which has forced up
the cost of living.
      Shortages of basic commodities, partly the result of instability in
the agricultural sector - the backbone of Zimbabwe's economy - and price
controls imposed by the government, have spawned a thriving black market
where the cost of foodstuffs and other goods is unaffordable for most
Zimbabweans.
      Repressive laws have also eroded basic media and public freedoms,
while the erosion of the rule of law in the past three years has meant that
many people are uncertain about their personal security.
      But despite growing international and local pressure for change in
Zimbabwe, Mugabe, who is among the longest serving leaders in the world, has
been buoyed by the recent support of his African colleagues and divisions
within the EU over sanctions against his government.
      Nigeria and South Africa, part of a troika mandated by the
Commonwealth to review the situation in Zimbabwe, have indicated that they
support the lifting of a 12-month suspension imposed last year by the club
of former British colonies.
      The EU, which finally resolved last week to renew a travel ban and
financial sanctions against Mugabe and his top hierarchy, has meanwhile seen
France breaking ranks by inviting the Zimbabwean leader to this week's
Franco-African summit.
      "He (Mugabe) obviously feels encouraged and that is all the more
reason why he is unlikely to retire," Makumbe said.
      But political commentators said although the Zimbabwean president
might play up his recent victories against his Western critics, he was
likely to be confronted with massive local unrest and opposition to his
government because of the worsening economic crisis.
      They pointed out that the ruling ZANU PF seemed unable to halt
Zimbabwe's economic meltdown and the unsustainable policies it was using to
manage the crisis would continue to be unsuccessful.
      Analysts say the country, isolated from international investors and
donors because of Mugabe's disputed re-election and the government's human
rights record, among other concerns, needs a huge injection of foreign funds
to put it on the road to recovery.
      But Zimbabwe is unlikely to attract foreign investment or balance of
payments support until it restores the rule of law, property rights and
deals with political violence, among other problems that the government does
not recognise as deterrents to the resolution of the economic crisis.
      They said Mugabe's exit from active politics, since his government
seemed unable to initiate crucial reform, would continue to be the most
viable solution for most critics.
      "It's mind-boggling because he should have gone a long time ago since
he has no new ideas to remedy the country's problems," Welshman Ncube,
secretary-general of the opposition Movement for Democratic Change (MDC),
told the Financial Gazette.
      Ncube, whose party is ZANU PF's main political rival, added: "Mugabe
should be at home, sitting by a fireside and telling folk-tales to his
grandchildren. If you look at the two Vice Presidents, Joseph Msika and
Simon Muzenda, who are both 80, you come to the mind-boggling reality that
Zimbabwe is being ruled by geriatrics."
      UZ political science lecturer Masipula Sithole added: "I don't see
anything spectacular happening. But it's too much to ask such an old man to
come up with new ideas."
Back to the Top
Back to Index

FinGaz

      Govt to allow Byo to borrow $2.3 bln


      2/20/03 3:39:19 AM (GMT +2)

      BULAWAYO - Local Government Minister Ignatius Chombo has pledged that
the government will soon grant the Bulawayo City Council permission to
borrow $2.3 billion on the open market to bankroll crucial capital projects,
Bulawayo town clerk Moffat Ndlovu said this week.

      Ndlovu told the Financial Gazette that the minister made the promise
at a meeting held at the end of last month with Bulawayo municipality
officials, who had previously been denied borrowing powers by the
government.
      The meeting, held on January 31, also discussed a directive issued by
Chombo's ministry to city councils, instructing them to report to their
respective district administrators instead of communicating directly with
his office.
      Ndlovu said at the meeting, held on January 31, Bulawayo mayor Japhet
Ndabeni-Ncube and other high-ranking council officials had sought
clarification from Chombo about delays in granting city councils borrowing
powers.
      He said: "At the meeting, the minister, who was accompanied by his
permanent secretary, made an undertaking that he will speed up the process
and I understand that this week, our application was with the Ministry of
Finance."
      There was no immediate comment from Chombo, but city council officials
who attended the January meeting said they had raised the issue of a
circular issued by the Ministry of Local Government in November, directing
local authorities to forward their communication to the ministry through
district administrators.
      Under the new policy, city councils would have to request borrowing
powers from the government through the DAs, which however do not operate in
urban areas.
      "The Bulawayo City Council was told that the new circular would not
affect them now but in future," a senior local government ministry official
who attended the meeting told the Financial Gazette.
      The government has announced that it plans to appoint provincial
governors for Bulawayo and Harare, a move it says will bring them in line
with other Zimbabwean provinces, but which critics say is part of attempts
to control urban municipalities now being run by opposition Movement for
Democratic Change mayors.
      Municipality officials say they suspect that the November directive
would come into effect once the governors were in place.
      Ndlovu said: "We did not resolve the issue (of the DAs), but we told
him (Chombo) that it was a cause for concern as this would delay
decision-making processes within councils."
      The Bulawayo City Council wants to borrow $2.3 billion from the open
market to finance capital projects that were suspended several years ago
because of financial constraints.
      The suspension of the projects has hampered council operations in the
last few years. - Staff Reporter
Back to the Top
Back to Index

Zim Independent

GMB splashes $1,5 billion on vehicles as millions starve
Augustine Mukaro
THE Grain Marketing Board (GMB) has splashed over $1,5 billion on new
vehicles, some of which have been used for Zanu PF campaigning at a time
when millions of Zimbabweans are starving, the Zimbabwe Independent
established this week.

The parastatal, which has struggled to raise money for the government's
humanitarian operations, has bought at least 100 trucks for its managers,
raising questions about its priorities.


The food situation in the country is set to worsen as World Food Programme
humanitarian assistance is scheduled to end next month.


Highly-placed sources said the GMB had purchased three consignments of Mazda
B1800 trucks and twincab vehicles, many of which have been allocated to Zanu
PF taskforces. Other vehicles would be given to the middle-level management
staff throughout the country.


"The first consignment of over 30 vehicles was bought in February 2002,"
sources said.


"The main beneficiaries of this consignment were mainly national taskforce
members handpicked by government to co-ordinate food distribution which was
used as a campaign tool for the ruling party in the presidential election."


Government appointed a pool of army officers, Central Intelligence Officers
and police details into a national taskforce to co-ordinate the movement of
grain at the parastatal in 2001 when it was rocked by a spate of corruption
allegations.


"The second batch of vehicles were delivered in October 2002 and some of
them have since been dispatched to various depots dotted throughout the
country. The remaining vehicles would be dispatched to the various provinces
for provincial co-ordinators," the sources said.


The parastatal will soon appoint provincial co-ordinators who will be
directly responsible for the distribution of food at provincial level.


The vehicles are currently parked at Dura House, the GMB head office in
Harare. The GMB has over 50 depots throughout the country. The market value
of a B1800 truck is $19,8 million. The GMB also purchased four twincab
vehicles for its directors, which were delivered last month. The market
price for a twincab Mazda vehicle is $38 million for petrol and $42 million
for diesel.


The vehicles were bought from Willowvale Mazda Motor Industries

(WMMI). WMMI officials confirmed having supplied GMB with vehicles but could
not give details of the deal, citing client confidentiality.


Sources said the parastatal has been turned into the ruling party's main
weapon of campaigning to regain support, especially during the current
drought.


"Government is abusing GMB monopoly over grain and cereals to whip the
vulnerable people into their direction. All strategic positions in GMB are
being filled with either ex-military or military personnel to ensure that
Zanu PF ideology is followed without questioning," sources said.


Government recently appointed Lieutenant Colonel Samuel Muvuti as GMB acting
chief executive.


To date, the parastatal has managed to import a paltry 685 784 tonnes of
maize instead of 1,9 million tonnes needed to stave off the looming famine.
Back to the Top
Back to Index

Zim Independent

Zesa to introduce load-shedding
Augustine Mukaro
SERIOUS power cuts and load-shedding are looming for Zimbabwean consumers as
Eskom and Cahora Bassa, the country's major suppliers, have reduced their
power exports to Zimbabwe over the country's failure to pay its debts, the
Zimbabwe Independent established this week.

The Confederation of Zimbabwe Industries (CZI) warned government of the
looming shortages in December 2002, describing the electricity supply
situation in the country as a serious cause for concern.


The Zimbabwe Electricity Supply Authority (Zesa) has failed to service its
debts with regional power utilities due to foreign currency shortages, said
the CZI statement.


"Zesa's debts with regional power utilities are now in excess of US$143
million," the CZI said in its proposals to resuscitate the economy. "The
Mozambican power utility has already significantly reduced power supplies to
Zesa, therefore load-shedding is inevitable given the reduced imports and
the limited local generation capacity."


Sources in the industry said load-shedding was imminent because the Wankie
Colliery Company was not supplying enough coal to the adjacent Hwange
thermal power station. Wankie Colliery is operating at only 50% capacity
because it does not have foreign currency needed to buy essential equipment
and spares.


"Currently the company is supplying only half of the nation's requirements,
including supplying Hwange power station, thereby increasing the need to
import electricity," sources said.


Zesa management services officer, Daniel Maviva, would not confirm or deny
whether the parastatal would be introducing load-shedding. He said Zesa was
negotiating a new contract with Eskom, including a management contract to
administer the Hwange power station.


"The contract when Eskom was managing the Hwange power station expired last
year and we are currently negotiating for a new contract for Eskom to supply
us with power," Maviva said.


The Southern African Power Pool arrangement prohibits a country from
importing power from another member of the pool to compensate for supplies
lost through failure to pay debts.


Meanwhile, Zesa is negotiating to borrow US$350 million from an Indian
financial institution to offset its debt to regional power utilities and to
purchase spares. The shortage of foreign currency has reduced Zesa's
capacity at all power stations in the country.


The bank is understood to have agreed to lend the money on condition that
Zesa hikes its tariffs. The state-owned power utility has to apply to
government for approval to hike tariffs following the introduction of price
controls in October 2001.
Back to the Top
Back to Index

Zim Independent

      Wankie seeks $900m to boost production
      Loughty Dube

      THE country's only coal producer, the beleaguered Wankie Colliery, is
engaged in negotiations with local and international financiers to source
over $900 million needed to boost production as the company is failing to
meet local demand, the Zimbabwe Independent has established.

      Wankie Colliery is currently operating at half its capacity due to a
shortage of spares for equipment. The problem is compounded by the failure
of the National Railways of Zimbabwe (NRZ) to transport coal to customers
countrywide.


      Wankie needs an initial capital of $600 million to put its operations
back on track and a further $300 million to revamp machinery.


      Sources at the mine warned that if no foreign currency is raised soon,
operations at the giant mine could come to a halt.


      "If the $900 million is not raised urgently to purchase spare parts
and new machinery, Wankie Colliery will come to a standstill and this will
affect all industries that use coal for their operations," said a source.


      Industries that rely on coal include tobacco, cement, power utilities
and iron and steel manufacturing companies. The Minister of Mines and Mining
Development, Edward Chindori-Chininga, said the government was trying to
raise the money for Wankie Colliery.


      "I can confirm that government is involved in frantic negotiations to
raise $900 million for Wankie Colliery as a matter of urgency but I cannot
give you details at the moment as I am currently out of the country," said
Chindori-Chininga.


      Wankie is experiencing problems in getting foreign currency despite it
being granted special permission by the Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe to retain
all its export earnings.


      However, Wankie public relations manager, Simukai Chihanga, denied
that government was spearheading the search for funds for the company.

      "There is nothing like that," said Chihanga.


      "We are not a parastatal so the truth is that we are raising the funds
on our own and not with the help of government," Chihanga said.


      Wankie's attempts to raise the funds from international institutions
are likely to hit a brick wall as Zimbabwe's creditworthiness is far from
good.
Back to the Top
Back to Index

Zim Independent

Evicted Kamativi families stranded
Staff writers
MORE than 40 families evicted from their homes in Kamativi two weeks ago
remain stranded as police ignore criminal activities perpetrated by Zanu PF
militia at the disused tin mine, the Zimbabwe Independent has established.

Zanu PF militia, led by Johannes Moyo, the party's losing candidate in the
rural council elections, has for the past two weeks been forcibly evicting
suspected MDC supporters from their homes, according to residents.


Moyo has imposed himself as the unelected councillor for Kamativi since the
incumbent MDC councillor, Matthew Ngwenya, fled the area after he was
assaulted and left for dead by Zanu PF militia last year.


The MDC provincial chairman for Kamativi ward, Morgan Komitshi, said the
situation had become worse for MDC supporters in the last two weeks.

Komitshi charged that a letter signed by affected families and sent by MDC
lawyers to the police was handed over to the Zanu PF leadership in the area
who are now using it to further victimise the families.


"The police have done nothing to deal with this situation. Instead, through
their inaction, they have given the Zanu PF militia the green light to
proceed with renewed violence against MDC residents in the area," said
Komitshi.


Efforts to get a comment from police spokesman, Wayne Bvudzijena, proved
fruitless by the time of going to press.


Komitshi said Zanu PF youth brigade leaders from other provinces had been
sent to Kamativi where they are spearheading violent attacks on all
suspected MDC sympathisers, the majority of whom have had to flee their
homes.


"The Zanu PF youth militia leader from Masvingo known as 'Black Jesus' and
one from Binga known as 'Mudimba' are terrorising people here at will and
they know nothing will happen to them," Komitshi said.


The government has said it plans to open the country's largest national
youth training centre at the disused Kamativi tin mine.


Komitshi said residents who were thrown out of their homes have reported the
matter to the police, but nothing has been done as their property is still
strewn around and their homes have been taken over by the youth brigade.


"The militia invaded the homes of all suspected MDC supporters, forcing them
to leave their homes. Police in the area have done nothing to handle this
matter as they say it is political," Komitshi said.
Back to the Top
Back to Index

Zim Independent

Irrigation projects no solution to food security
Vincent Kahiya

THE announcement by government two weeks ago that it would open up 100 000
hectares of land in the Lowveld to grow maize raises fundamental concerns
about the state's ability to execute a project of that magnitude.

The mooted irrigation scheme, dubbed the Nuanetsi Irrigation Project, is
already being touted as the panacea to restore food security in a country
where large commercial irrigation projects have been decimated by the
disorderly resettlement programme.

A Chinese company has already been awarded the contract to clear the land
and subdivide it into smaller plots to produce three maize crops per annum
with expected yields of seven tonnes per hectare.

The failure by newly resettled farmers to produce enough winter wheat last
year and an early maize crop under irrigation this year on established farms
raises questions about the thinking behind the new project.

State-funded irrigation developments in Zimbabwe have generally failed to
live up to expectations. This poor performance derives mainly from
experience with large-scale developments. Where costs are very high,
production levels have generally remained poor and led to
lower-than-anticipated returns. The government has in the last 20 years
built dozens of dams but has failed to put in place infrastructure for
irrigation near the dams.

The biggest tragedy of Zimbabwe's water policy and irrigation development is
the failure to put into practice water management strategies whereby water
is treated as an economic good which is a key facet of agriculture.

Agriculture, which contributes about 20% to Zimbabwe's gross domestic
product and is closely inter-linked with other sectors of the economy, is
currently facing a major challenge following the land reform programme and
successive droughts.

Farmers' greatest challenge when the current farming season began was to
maintain the traditional role of agriculture of ensuring food security,
regular supply of foreign currency and raw materials to the manufacturing
sector.

Thus the responsibility of government, given the recent drought, was to
replenish the country's maize reserves in addition to maintaining export
quality and raise the country's stocks of beef and milk.

Last year the government announced it would open up at least 8 000ha of land
for irrigation. Projects announced then included 2 520ha under the Marange
Irrigation Scheme in Makoni and Nyamazura Irrigation Scheme in Mutare
drawing water from the Osborne Dam.

The government also said it would establish 1 200ha of irrigated land in
Makoni under the Chiduku Chiware Irrigation Scheme and an additional 20ha
under the Nyahangare Irrigation Scheme in Makoni.

An additional 1 000ha of irrigated land was mooted in Matabeleland South to
complement the already existing Zhove Irrigation Scheme in Beitbridge.

In Masvingo Province, the government said it would open Nyahombe with a
total of 178ha, Mbindangombe (150ha), Tokwane (250ha), Manyuchi (228ha),
Muchena (100ha), Mushaya/Bangala (54ha) and Matezwa (60ha) irrigation
schemes.

The Midlands province was expected to establish schemes set at Mutange with
a total of 105ha, Mundi Mataga (520ha), Muchembere (22ha) and Bannockburn
(23ha) for irrigation schemes.

In Mashonaland Central, irrigation projects planned included Mfurudzi
(35ha), Bruton (200ha), both in Bindura, Mwenje (69ha) and Banana (50ha) in
Shamva, Chipa (60ha) and Tsakare (45ha), both in Mount Darwin.

In Mashonaland East, smaller projects were planned to be implemented at
Dzvete in Goromonzi, Evergreen (30) in Marondera, Chitora in Mutoko,
Dangarendove in Seke and Mutawatawa in Uzumba-Maramba-Pfungwe.

In Mashonaland West, the Biri Dam project near Banket collapsed after
farmers were chased off their land. Envisaged wheat and citrus projects have
failed to get off the ground.

The long wish list has not assisted in mitigating the effects of the drought
as implementation has been slow or failed to take place at all due to lack
of funding.

The newest addition to the wish list, the Nuanetsi Irrigation Project in the
south-east Lowveld of the country, does not appear a viable proposition in
ensuring food security.

Critics of the project have pointed to the huge capital outlay and vast sums
required as recurrent expenditure to launch the project. They have said the
project would not be an immediate panacea to the country's food problems.

They believe the immediate concern of the government should be to
rehabilitate abandoned projects and ensure that those that are still running
are put to maximum use.

Sophisticated irrigation systems



designed for large-scale commercial agriculture have been rendered
ineffectual as land has been subdivided into small plots and equipment
pillaged.

Experts have also pointed to the inadequate training of new farmers who
still have to appreciate the complexities of running irrigation projects and
to develop a culture that should see them move away from rain-fed
agriculture.

The Commercial Farmers Union (CFU) Mashonaland regional director Ben
Kaschula said the government should first address the reasons why areas
which traditionally produced food for the nation could no longer do so.

"Before we resort to developing these 100 000ha we have to find out what
happened to the land where we used to grow enough food to feed the nation,
fill the strategic reserves and export," said Kaschula.

Critics have pointed out that Zimbabwe's immediate concern is ensuring food
security in the face of another drought forecast to hit the country in the
2003/2004 season.

Experts in land clearance and irrigation say the Nuanetsi project would not
come on-stream in the coming season considering the amount of work to be
done and the costs involved.

"It is not just a question of felling trees and destumping," said an estate
manager in the south-eastern Lowveld. "Soil tests have to be carried out,
the land has to be surveyed, levelled and basic infrastructure like roads,
canals and holding tanks should be installed.

"There is also the huge cost of purchasing irrigation infrastructure like
pumps, pipes, pivots, transformers, sub-stations and putting up powerlines,"
he said.

Then there is the problem of water. The success of the project hinges firmly
on the consistent supply of water to irrigate the 100 000ha three times a
years. The government's failure to secure adequate funding to complete the
Tokwe-Mukorsi Dam which started in 1998 is telling of its ability to execute
huge projects. Water experts say at least two billion cubic metres of water
are required to irrigate the project throughout the year.

They said the government also has to sort out issues regarding water rights
as sugar producers in the Lowveld would require water from Tokwe-Mukorsi.

Experts say the government will require at least US$200 million to put up
the project which was initially billed to expand sugar, citrus, cotton and
wheat production in the Lowveld and not necessarily maize production.

Irrigation experts in the Lowveld said yields from last year's Masvingo Food
Initiative - which entailed maize production in winter - engendered
reservations about the viability of the Nuanetsi project.

Last year the Masvingo Food Initiative achieved yields of 1,5 tonnes per
hectare which is a far cry from the feel-good figure of seven tonnes per
hectare which the government says Nuanetsi will achieve.

The CFU believes for the project to be viable, yields of at least six tonnes
per hectare have to be achieved.

"Unless a yield of six tonnes per hectare is achieved it is uneconomic to
grow maize at Nuanetsi," said Kaschula.

As bulldozers and other plant equipment move on to the site to start
clearing land, farmers hope this will not mark the beginning of an
ecological disaster on land traditionally reserved for cattle and game
ranching.
Back to the Top
Back to Index

Zim Independent

Eric Bloch Column

Govt cannot delay devaluation any longer
THE Minister of Fiction, Fable and Myth has decreed that not only is
"devaluation" a dirty word, but also that it is not going to happen as such
an action has not even been considered by the cabinet, or by the Tripartite
Negotiating Forum (TNF).

For many exporters his statement came as a breath of fresh air, for past
performance suggests that anything denied by him is fact, whilst anything
confirmed by him is fiction.

First of all, it would accord the minister's statements an unaccustomed
credibility if he would seek to synchronise them with those of others.
Whilst he says that the TNF has not deliberated on a devaluation of Zimbabwe
's currency, highly-reputable, non-governmental participants have made
statements diametrically opposite.

Not only do they claim extensive TNF consideration of the desirability or
otherwise of devaluation, but also considerable evaluation of any positive
or negative repercussions. Moreover, they claim that recommendations have
been put before the cabinet, concurrently with recurring, appropriate
proposals of the Ministry of Finance and Economic Development, and of the
Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe. So, who is to be believed? Those with a reputation
for adherence to fact, or he who spews forth vitriol against any whom he
perceives to be opposing his Lord and Master?

In addition, it was widely-reported by the media (inclusive of that
controlled or dominated and abused by the minister) that when a delegation
from the Confederation of Zimbabwe Industries met with then acting President
Simon Muzenda, they were assured that the cabinet was considering the pros
and cons of devaluation.

Was Muzenda deceiving the delegation? Surely not! Far more likely is that
the minister, be it intentional or otherwise, is oblivious to the facts, for
he could not conceivably have alleged misrepresentation by Muzenda.

The government has an unassailable record of doing too little, too late. Had
a formalised devaluation been implemented 18 months to two years ago,
concurrently with other very necessary economic measures, the economy today
would be a very different, and positive one.

Recognition of the real depreciation in value of Zimbabwe's currency, and
constructive reaction stemming from that recognition, would mean that many
businesses that have had to close down would still be operating. Others,
forced to downsize, would have maintained operations at prior levels, or
even increased them. If devaluation had occurred when required, Zimbabwe
would still be subject to constraints of insufficient foreign exchange, but
those constraints would have been of lesser extent.

As a result, shortages of essential commodities would not be as acute as is
presently the case. Petrol queues would be fewer and shorter. More spares
would be available to keep the wheels of the Zimbabwe Electricity Supply
Authority, those of the National Railways of Zimbabwe and of Wankie Colliery
Company, turning.

Zimbabwe's health delivery system would not be collapsing due to lack of
medications, health supplies, and spares for life-saving equipment.

Simba Makoni, theformer Minister of Finance and Economic Development,
recognised very early on his appointment, that there was a critical need for
exchange rates to be realistically determined. When in August 2000 he
implemented the only devaluation he was permitted by an ill-advised,
dogmatic cabinet, he foreshadowed regular devaluations targeted at achieving
purchasing power parity with Zimbabwe's trading partners.

Unfortunately that was not to be, and hence progressive inflation, soaring
into hyperinflation levels, destroyed all competitiveness in export markets,
resulting in an even lesser supply of desperately needed foreign currency,
with repercussions on all sectors of the economy and of society.

Speculation suggests that there can only be three reasons for government's
continuing obduracy over the issue of devaluation.

The first would be a perception that devaluation is an acknowledgement of
economic mismanagement, and government pride precludes any such
acknowledgement. However, sometimes the bullet must be bitten. Zimbabwe's
economy has been grossly mismanaged, and any mature government concerned
with the well-being of the populace would admit to it and try to revitalise
it. Regrettably, a government which suffers extreme paranoia and a
pronounced persecution complex does not. It believes itself to be
omnipotent, incapable of error, and the innocent victim of evil machinations
of others.

The second reason is associated with the first, for there are those in the
corridors of government who are wholly-convinced that anyone who calls for
devaluation is attacking Zimbabwe's sovereignty.

But that is just not so. The decision to devalue, if ever taken, is one at
the instance of those who rule the state. That is evidence that the state's
sovereignty is intact. It is sheer mania to believe that those who advocate
devaluation do so out of mischievous and destructive intent, to erode
national sovereignty, to denigrate government, or to accelerate economic
collapse.

They are not enemies of the state or saboteurs. They espouse their
recommendations in the firm belief that implementation of those
recommendations will either restore the economy to well-being, or will slow
down the economic decline.

The third, and most frequently promoted reason of opposition to devaluation
is that inflation is an inevitable result. And normally that is so, for
devaluation increases the landed cost of imports.

But Zimbabwe is in a near-unique situation where that is not so. Almost all
of Zimbabwe's imports are funded through the parallel market, where exchange
rates currently approximate $1 450:US$1 in sharp contrast to the official
rate of $55 : US$1. Thus, if devaluation is to be to any rate of less than
the present parallel rate, the inflationary effects have already been
sustained, and do not repeat themselves. In fact, if the importer is able to
source a greater proportion of foreign currency needs within the official
market at rates below the parallel rates, his import costs should diminish,
and that would enable a lowering of prices and a reduction in inflation.

Whilst it is pleasing that despite the assertions to the contrary of the
Minister of Fiction, Fable and Myth, non-government participants to the TNF
believe that devaluation is imminent, they suggest that in order that some
of the opponents of devaluation should "save face", the devaluation will be
a disguised one. Many of them anticipate that to conceal the fact of
devaluation, government will preserve the existing exchange rates, but will
pay exporters an incentive which would effectively raise the exchange rate
to $800:US$1. However, indications are that this would only apply to the 50%
of export-generated foreign exchange as must mandatorily be sold to the
Reserve Bank.

The consequence of that would be that, in practice, the exporter would
achieve an effective "blend" rate of exchange of $427 : US$1.

Having regard to the extent of inflation-driven increases in exporters'
production and operating costs, such a rate will not suffice to restore
export viability. At very best, and most improbably, it would be a
short-term panacea for some, but not for many.

It is time that government faced the facts, squarely and fairly, including
that:

Chronic foreign exchange shortages will continue until a realistic
devaluation is effected, followed by further devaluations at regular
intervals until inflation falls to trading partner levels;

Because of the unique consequences of parallel market trading to date, the
inflationary impacts of devaluation will be minimal, and especially so if
constructive other economic recovery measures are concurrently pursued with
vigour;

There is no shame in devaluing Zimbabwe's currency. There is great shame in
not doing so when it is critically-needed, and only not pursued out of
misguided ego considerations.

So, although devaluation has been declared to be dead, it should be accorded
the opportunity of reincarnation.
Back to the Top
Back to Index