| The ZIMBABWE Situation | Our
thoughts and prayers are with Zimbabwe - may peace, truth and justice prevail. |
![]() |
James Coomarasamy BBC Paris correspondent |
Le Monde described Mr Mugabe's welcome as an insult to his
victims |
In the run-up to the one-and-a-half day Franco-African summit, French officials were confidently predicting that - whatever the British press and politicians might say - the presence of Robert Mugabe in Paris would not spoil the party.
Zimbabwe, after all, is largely seen in France as a post-colonial, British problem.
The suffering of the expelled white farmers is viewed with pity, but not anger.
But when he opened Friday's edition of Le Monde, the French leader would have read an editorial that could have easily come from one of the more moderate sections of the British press.
Dangerous ground
"Mugabe's presence in Paris for this summit is an insult to all the victims of his regime," the paper wrote.
"Did Jacques Chirac really think that ticking him off - in a corridor - about democracy and human rights, would really change the mind of this ageing autocrat?"
|
President Chirac |
And if the rest of the French media has been less explicit in its criticism of the president, it has been noticeable that most newspapers - including the pro-Chirac Le Figaro - have filed reports this week about human rights abuses in Zimbabwe.
President Chirac may have broad public support in France at the moment, but - on this issue - he is on more dangerous ground.
His shoo-ing away of the Zimbabwean leader at Thursday's photo call seemed to say it all.
"All right, you've got what you want, you're here - the gesture implied, "now don't embarrass me any further."
Temporary irritation
The Sun outraged French
readers |
And, with Mr Mugabe's wife, Grace, indulging her shopping habit and the president and his 20-strong entourage staying in a luxury hotel, the French have failed to convince the rest of the world that they have administered a diplomatic rap over the knuckles.
At the closing press conference of the summit, Mr Chirac was asked what he made of the criticism he had received for hosting several leaders, with dubious democratic credentials.
He shrugged it off with the bland phrase: "France is committed to the fight for mutual respect, law and morality."
But will the Mugabe row cause anything more than temporary irritation for the French president?
After all, the French television news - and indeed many of the papers here - have given more coverage to the special French edition of the British tabloid, the Sun, with its photomontage of "Chirac the worm", than to Robert Mugabe's presence in Paris.
So the answer is, probably not - but it may make Mr Chirac think twice before inviting the Zimbabwean leader again.
Land reform was supposed to help landless
farmers |
The audit was carried out following complaints by those who thought they would benefit from Mr Mugabe's controversial land reform programme, according to a London-based newsletter, Africa Confidential.
Prominent figures mentioned include air force commander Perence Shiri, Information Minister Jonathan Moyo, President Mugabe's sister, Sabina, and Defence Minister Sydney Sekeremayi.
Some of those named have reportedly seized more than one farm, including farms larger than the newly stipulated maximum size.
In the worst case, Air Marshal Shiri is accused of having three farms - one three times the maximum size.
He is reportedly trying to evict 96 families, who were allocated the farm under the land redistribution programme.
Just 600 white farmers remain on their land, out of some 4,000 two years ago, according to farmers' organisation.
'Factionalism'
Mr Mugabe says that he is addressing an inequitable pattern of land ownership due to racist colonial-era laws.
His critics accuse him of bribing voters with land after a strong opposition party emerged.
|
MUGABE'S LAND REFORM
2000: 4,000 whites owned 11m ha of prime land
2000: 1m blacks owned 16m ha, often in drought-prone areas
2000: Land invasions began
2003: 600 white farmers remain |
The audit was carried out by Vice-President Joseph Msika's office.
Mr Mugabe has promised to act on its findings but correspondents say it will be difficult for him to take on political heavyweights at a time when he needs all the allies he can get.
But not acting might mean alienating those very voters, whose support he was hoping to win by giving them land.
Following previous allegations of corruption in the land redistribution exercise, the government has responded that it has two programmes: one for landless blacks and another to encourage blacks with money to enter commercial farming.
Up to half of Zimbabwe's population, some six million people are currently in need of food aid.
Mr Mugabe blames poor rains but donors say that the agricultural disruption caused by the land reform programme has worsened the situation.
|
By Carolyn
Dempster BBC, Southern Africa |
The ruling party is accused of
intimidating the opposition |
In the cities people are scared of openly criticising President Robert Mugabe, because it might mean instant arrest.
In the rural areas they stay silent and do whatever it takes to access the food they need to keep their families alive.
Three years of overt violence, suppression of dissent, and the arrest and torture of opposition political supporters under draconian security legislation has left the president's Zanu-PF party in a stronger position, claims political analyst and chairman of the Crisis in Zimbabwe Committee, Brian Raftopolous.
He believes that Zimbabwe's worsening economic crisis is not sufficient to spur a popular uprising.
"I think people are angry. But they're also despondent, they're scared. For an action to come, there'd have to be a lot more organisation on the part of civic groups.
"Given the increased impoverishment, there's been a disempowerment of most people," he said.
Onslaught
The opposition Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) calculates that between January and November last year, 1,060 MDC activists were tortured, 227 abducted and beaten, 58 murdered, 111 unlawfully detained, and 170 picked up, tortured and released without being charged.
And those figures exclude the women who are linked to the MDC in some way who have been raped for their political beliefs.
|
OPPOSITION INTIMIDATION
1,060 activists tortured last year
227 abducted and beaten
58 murdered
111 unlawfully detained
170 tortured and released without
charge Source: MDC
|
This, claim many Zimbabweans, is far worse than the security laws imposed by Ian Smith's minority white regime before it fell in 1980.
Job Sikhala, an MDC member of parliament, was recently arrested for the 17th time, held without being charged, interrogated and then driven to an unknown destination where he was beaten and tortured for eight hours, and then given poison to drink.
"I screamed for help, and no help came and I was told to shut up. At the third stage of torture, when they applied electric shocks to my mouth, and in my left ear, I lost consciousness.
"I heard a voice from a distance saying: 'We have killed a person here. What should we do? Let's go and throw him into a dam'. That is the time when I lost control of my bladder."
'Joke investigations'
Mr Sikhala was eventually released, and examined by a government doctor who confirmed he had been tortured.
People are scared to openly
criticise President Mugabe |
The government has since admitted he was tortured and has promised to bring the police officers to book.
Mr Sikhala laughs at this: "The police themselves are the torturers. For them to investigate themselves is really a joke."
During the weeks I spent in Zimbabwe, I heard similar stories of arbitrary arrest, a night spent in the crowded police cells and "bail" of 50,000 Zimbabwe dollars being extorted - whereupon the person was released without being charged.
There is a growing sense of despair among Zimbabwe's citizens that they cannot rely on the police to protect them or their property because the security forces are partisan and have become the foot soldiers of Zanu-PF.
'Under siege'
Sternford Moyo is president of the Law Society of Zimbabwe, but that did not protect him from arrest and harassment at the hands of the authorities.
"We haven't reached a stage where the legal system is not functioning," he says, but admits that judicial rulings are sometimes blithely ignored by the police.
|
Elias Mudzuri, Harare Mayor
|
"And whenever members of the public feel that they cannot enforce their rights through the normal court system, the temptation to resort to self-help becomes irresistible."
Recently the courts ruled that the arrest and detention of the Mayor of Harare, Elias Mudzuri, for addressing a public meeting about the city's water shortages, was "unlawful" and should never have happened.
High Court judge Justice Benjamin Paradza issued the order to free the mayor twice before Mr Mudzuri was finally released by the police.
The mayor had been beaten, kept for two nights in a police cell and prevented from calling his lawyer.
"We are under siege," he said.
"I was threatened with death by some police officers. I was not allowed to talk to my lawyer, my wife. How do I cry out to the external world?"
'Green bombers'
Worse than that - says Mr Mudzuri, who was elected on an MDC ticket in a landslide victory - the security forces now act with impunity.
"The democratic space for anyone who is perceived to be opposition is closed. And people are being maimed and killed. The country has become a police state."
The police are seen as
partisan |
In the streets the police now have the support of some 9,000 young men who have been trained as Zanu-PF youth militias and are known as the "Green Bombers" after the green uniforms they sport.
They are being used to instil fear among ordinary citizens who dare speak out against food shortages.
In the town of Marondera, former farmer and author Cathy Buckle recounts how she watched 30 Green Bombers intimidate 3,000 people standing in a bread queue.
"Thirty youths bossing people, pushing them out of the way with rubber truncheons, going to the front of the queue, grabbing a dozen loaves of bread, going away, hiding them, then coming back. Thirty youths controlling 3,000 people."
Ms Buckle sighs when she says: "That is the whole nature of everybody in Zimbabwe now, this huge fear, all the time."
The BBC's Carolyn Dempster has now returned to South Africa after a three-week tour around Zimbabwe.