The ZIMBABWE Situation Our thoughts and prayers are with Zimbabwe
- may peace, truth and justice prevail.

Back to Index

Back to the Top
Back to Index

IOL

Anglo gives Mugabe a fuel lifeline of R240m

      February 21 2003 at 05:11AM

      By Basildon Peta


The Anglo American Corporation has bailed out the Zimbabwe government with
$30-million (about R240-million) to import fuel which has remained in short
supply after Libyan leader Muammar Gadaffi halted supplies to Harare.

Supplies were stopped three months ago after the Zimbabwe government failed
to pay for fuel deliveries worth more than $100-million from Gadaffi's
company Tamoil.

Talks between the Zimbabwe government and Tamoil officials to have the
supplies resumed collapsed with Tamoil demanding cash upfront for any new
deliveries.

It was not clear what benefit Anglo would gain from helping the Zimbabwe
government, but authoritative oil industry officials said the multinational
company might be motivated by a genuine need to rescue the embattled
Zimbabwean economy.

Others speculated that Anglo wished to maintain good ties with the Zimbabwe
government after President Robert Mugabe confiscated land owned by its top
directors for his land resettlement exercise.

Last year, Mugabe threatened to seize Anglo companies, particularly National
Foods, accusing them of hoarding commodities so as to fuel public anger
against his regime.

Anglo's spokesperson in Harare, Ezra Kanganga, has repeatedly refused to
comment on the deal citing confidentiality clauses.

Under the terms of the latest deal, Anglo will release $30-million to buy
fuel for the state-run National Oil Company of Zimbabwe (Noczim).

Exor Petroleum Limited, a company owned by a group of indigenous businessmen
with strong links to the ruling Zanu-PF party, would be used as a middle-man
to buy the fuel for Noczim using the Anglo money.

The involvement of Exor has raised eyebrows in Zimbabwe, with the main
opposition dismissing it as a new opportunity to benefit influential people
accused of looting Noczim.

Chairman of the parliamentary committee on energy and power, Joel Gabuza,
said he had inquired from Energy Minister Amos Midzi why Exor Petroleum, a
recently registered fuel company, was being used as a middle-man ahead of
established fuel companies. Gabuza said he did not get satisfactory answers
from the minister.

He said the way in which Anglo and the Zimbabwe government had coined up the
deal would inevitably benefit some corrupt officials.

"Somewhere along the line, someone is getting a kickback," said Gabuza, who
is the opposition Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) MP for Binga.

Top Zimbabwe government officials have been linked to the ownership of Exor
Petroleum. In fact one of Mugabe's two vice-presidents is believed to be the
owner of Exor Petroleum, which operates from the offices of Noczim, under
unexplained circumstances.

The fuel crisis in Zimbabwe started with disclosures of massive corruption
at Noczim where billions of rand were lost to fraudulent fuel procurement
deals.

The crisis worsened as the macro economic environment deteriorated with the
collapse of the agricultural industry, the main foreign currency earner.

The Zimbabwe government will reportedly repay the $30-million from Anglo, in
Zimbabwe dollars at a black market exchange rate of one dollar to Zim$1,30.

The Anglo bailout will help the government improve deliveries for at least a
month while it tries to re-engage Gadaffi's Tamoil to resume supplies. -
Foreign Service
Back to the Top
Back to Index

ample

      (AFX-Focus) 2003-02-21 13:30 GMT:
 Anglo American denies media reports of loan given to Zimbabwe govt

      LONDON (AFX) - Anglo American PLC denied media reports it has given a
loan to the Zimbabwe government.
      The transaction that was reported was a purely commercial currency
transaction and in no way constituted a loan to the Zimbabwe government or
any other entity, it said.

      Anglo American Corporation Services Ltd, a subsidiary of Anglo
American, acting on behalf of a consortium of exporters - Mimosa Platinum
Mines, Makwiro Platinum Mines, ZIMASCO, Cotton Company of Zimbabwe, Ariston
Holdings, Bindura Nickel Corporation and Zimbabwe Alloys - entered into a 35
mln usd currency swap in which the consortium received Zimbabwe dollars in
exchange for US dollars generated by export activity.

      Exporters have been urgently seeking permission from the Zimbabwean
authorities to exchange export earnings at a more commercially viable rate
than the official exchange rate and as soon as permission had been received
effected the transaction in order to generate funds needed domestically to
maintain existing operations and the jobs supported by them, Anglo American
said.

      Currency swaps have been common business transactions in Zimbabwe for
the past two and a half years in which fair value is exchanged by the
parties involved, it added.
Back to the Top
Back to Index

BBC
 
Chirac slips up on Mugabe banana

James Coomarasamy
BBC Paris correspondent

Le Monde described Mr Mugabe's welcome as an insult to his victims
President Chirac must be wondering how it happened.

In the run-up to the one-and-a-half day Franco-African summit, French officials were confidently predicting that - whatever the British press and politicians might say - the presence of Robert Mugabe in Paris would not spoil the party.

Zimbabwe, after all, is largely seen in France as a post-colonial, British problem.

The suffering of the expelled white farmers is viewed with pity, but not anger.

But when he opened Friday's edition of Le Monde, the French leader would have read an editorial that could have easily come from one of the more moderate sections of the British press.

Dangerous ground

"Mugabe's presence in Paris for this summit is an insult to all the victims of his regime," the paper wrote.

"Did Jacques Chirac really think that ticking him off - in a corridor - about democracy and human rights, would really change the mind of this ageing autocrat?"

France is committed to the fight for mutual respect, law and morality
President Chirac

And if the rest of the French media has been less explicit in its criticism of the president, it has been noticeable that most newspapers - including the pro-Chirac Le Figaro - have filed reports this week about human rights abuses in Zimbabwe.

President Chirac may have broad public support in France at the moment, but - on this issue - he is on more dangerous ground.

His shoo-ing away of the Zimbabwean leader at Thursday's photo call seemed to say it all.

"All right, you've got what you want, you're here - the gesture implied, "now don't embarrass me any further."

Temporary irritation

The Sun newspaper
The Sun outraged French readers
We have been told that Mr Chirac expressed Europe's concerns to Mr Mugabe at the state dinner on Thursday night, but the Elysee has given no further details.

And, with Mr Mugabe's wife, Grace, indulging her shopping habit and the president and his 20-strong entourage staying in a luxury hotel, the French have failed to convince the rest of the world that they have administered a diplomatic rap over the knuckles.

At the closing press conference of the summit, Mr Chirac was asked what he made of the criticism he had received for hosting several leaders, with dubious democratic credentials.

He shrugged it off with the bland phrase: "France is committed to the fight for mutual respect, law and morality."

But will the Mugabe row cause anything more than temporary irritation for the French president?

After all, the French television news - and indeed many of the papers here - have given more coverage to the special French edition of the British tabloid, the Sun, with its photomontage of "Chirac the worm", than to Robert Mugabe's presence in Paris.

So the answer is, probably not - but it may make Mr Chirac think twice before inviting the Zimbabwean leader again.

Back to the Top
Back to Index

News24

Focus turns to 'CIA agent'
21/02/2003 18:00  - (SA)


Harare - Still pictures were taken of an alleged US intelligence agent who
attended a meeting in Canada where Zimbabwe's opposition leader is accused
of having plotted to kill President Robert Mugabe.

The photographs were taken from a grainy black-and-white video tape which
has been the main source of evidence against Morgan Tsvangirai, leader of
the main opposition Movement for Democratic Change (MDC).

The video tape was secretly recorded by the chief witness and political
consultant, Ari Ben Menashe, to collect evidence of the alleged MDC plot
against Mugabe.

The defence asked for permission from the court to take the pictures in an
effort to try and identify one Edward Simms who chaired the meeting.

Simms' true identity has so far not been established.

The key state witness in the trial Ari Ben Menashe said he only knew Simms
as a member of the Team America (slang for the Central Intelligence Agency).

Ben Menashe hinted at the start of the trial that the US government was
involved in an alleged plot to assassinate Mugabe.

Simms, according to Ben Menashe was the CIA deputy director for Africa.

The CIA in Washington has said it does not comment on "whether people work
for us or not".

It was not immediately clear what the defence intends to do with the
pictures of Simms.

Meantime the defence continued on Friday cross examining Menashe over the
specific requests and vocabulary used by Tsvangirai to ask Ben Menashe's
political consultancy firm to help with the assassination of Mugabe.

"I don't remember the words he used but the gist of what was asked would be
apparent when ...(the judge) looks at the wholeness of the tape especially
when Mr Simms was present in the room," Menashe told the court.

The court has so far listened to the tape in the trial of Tsvangirai and two
of his party's senior officials. If convicted the three face a maximum of
death sentence. - Sapa-AFP

Back to the Top
Back to Index

Low Key Celebrations for President's Birthday Planned

The Herald (Harare)

February 21, 2003
Posted to the web February 21, 2003

Harare

PRESIDENT Mugabe, who is attending the 22nd France-Africa Summit in Paris,
celebrates his 79th birthday today.

The ruling Zanu-PF party however, said there would be low key celebrations
of the President's birthday owing largely to the drought.

Zanu-PF secretary for information and publicity, Cde Nathan Shamuyarira,
said yesterday that the country would not be seen holding big celebrations
when there is a drought.

"This is a year of drought. We do not want to feast when there is a
drought."

"We are leaving it to civic bodies and individuals to show their joy and
happiness."

President Mugabe has led the country since 1980 when Zimbabwe gained its
independence from Britain.

Last year, he won a fresh mandate to lead the country after he beat his main
rival Mr Morgan Tsvangirai of the MDC in the March presidential polls.

Cde Mugabe has been fiercely criticised by Britain and other western
countries for carrying out a land reform programme, which sought to redress
colonial land imbalances.

"We are pleased the birthday is taking place when he is making a
breakthrough at the France-Africa summit and the Non-Aligned Meeting in
Kualar Lumpur," Cde Shamuyarira said.

Cde Mugabe has won international admiration for his principled stance on the
land issue and for taking up the cause of the poor in the face of opposition
from the dominant wealthy nations at various international gatherings like
the Earth Summit, which was held in South Africa last year. At the summit,
Cde Mugabe upstaged and fired a broadside at British Prime Minister Tony
Blair blasting him for interfering with Zimbabwe's sovereignty.

French President Jacques Chirac, shrugged off pressure from Britain and
invited President Mugabe to the France-Africa summit arguing that the
Zimbabwe-EU relations can only be improved through dialogue and not through
sanctions.

Cde Mugabe was born on February 21, 1924 at Kutama Mission, northwest of
Harare and was educated at various institutions.

He worked first as a teacher but continued to study, stacking up university
degrees - three of them while in prison - to bolster his intellectual image.

In 1995, after the death of his Ghanaian-born first wife Sally, he married
the First Lady, Grace.

The couple has three children.

Back to the Top
Back to Index

Financial Times

      Zimbabwe 'devalues' currency by 93%
      By Tony Hawkins in Harare
      Published: February 21 2003 18:24 | Last Updated: February 21 2003
18:24

      Zimbabwe has effectively devalued its currency by 93 per cent amid
signs of growing divisions in the upper ranks of President Robert Mugabe's
ruling party.

      The Zimbabwe dollar has been pegged for exporters at Z$800 to the US
dollar, compared with the previous official rate of Z$55.

      Significantly, the announcement was made while Mr Mugabe was in Paris
attending France's African summit.

      In deference to Mr Mugabe and Jonathan Moyo, his information minister,
both of whom had ruled out devaluation, Herbert Murerwa, the finance
minister, called the measure an "export support scheme".

      The measure coincided with fresh evidence of machinations among rival
factions in Zanu-PF, the ruling party, in preparation for the succession to
Mr Mugabe.

      The leaking of a report implicating senior party figures and Mr
Mugabe's sister in abuses committed under Zimbabwe's controversial land
reform programme is widely seen as an attempt from within the administration
to incriminate some key political players.

      Alleged violations of land reallocation limits were detailed in
interim conclusions of an audit Mr Mugabe ordered last year. The
wide-ranging list of names, published by the London-based newsletter Africa
Confidential, included some government and military figures close to the
president.

      The currency decision was welcomed by exporters, who had expected the
government to devalue by a much smaller margin and to retain the Z$55
official rate.

      Since October 2000, when the exchange rate was fixed at Z$55, Zimbabwe
has operated a multi-tiered exchange rate system, with incentive rates for
exporters of gold and tobacco and a parallel market rate that has hovered
around Z$1,600 to the US dollar in recent months.

      In a statement, Dr Murerwa said all existing export schemes had been
"collapsed" into a uniform export system of Z$800 to the US dollar.
Exporters must sell half their export proceeds to the Reserve Bank of
Zimbabwe at the new rate.

      Officials hope the move will stifle if not eradicate the parallel
market.

      Dr Murerwa warned of an imminent increase in fuel prices, last
adjusted in June 2001. Industry sources said they expected petrol prices to
rise to at least Z$300 a litre - more than four times the current price.

      The minister also promised savers an adjustment in interest rates, now
about 30 per cent.
Back to the Top
Back to Index

gomemphis

Editorial 02/21: Courting Mugabe
February 21, 2003

FOR UNWORTHY reasons, French President Jacques Chirac has conferred
momentary respectability on an odious dictator. It won't last.

When Robert Mugabe returns this weekend to Zimbabwe, the African nation he
brutally mismanages, more than half its 12.7 million people will still be
starving. Inflation, unemployment and corruption still will be rampant. The
press still will be muzzled. And his political opponents still will be in
jail.

The European Union and the British Commonwealth have imposed sanctions on
Zimbabwe, including a ban on its leadership traveling to their member
countries. But as the price of voting to continue the EU sanctions, Chirac
insisted that the ban be waived so Mugabe could attend a Franco-African
summit in Paris this week.

France envisions a much larger role for itself in Africa, and Chirac saw an
invitation to Mugabe as a way of extending its reach into the
English-speaking former British colonies. For that, he was willing to risk
the anger of Britain, the United States and other nations that would like to
see the ouster of Mugabe, who retained office in a flagrantly fraudulent
election.

Chirac argues that Mugabe, who has been in power for 22 years, is more
likely to be changed by engagement than isolation. There were suggestions
the French president would bring up his guest's miserable human rights
record. But the only evidence of disapproval was that Mugabe received a
stiff handshake rather than the kiss on each cheek accorded to other African
heads of state.

Agence France Presse says Mugabe's presence cast a "cloud of controversy"
over the summit, but it looks as if Chirac got a lot of what he wanted.
Forty-five African heads of state and government attended the summit,
"Africa and France, a New Partnership." They thanked their host by voting to
endorse the French position opposing the use of force against Iraq.

As a matter of simple expediency in courting mineral-rich Zimbabwe, Chirac
may be on the winning side, at least in the short term. In a gesture of
misbegotten African solidarity, Commonwealth members South Africa and
Nigeria will oppose renewing sanctions on Zimbabwe. South Africa argues
implausibly, even as more of the Mugabe regime's opponents are herded off to
jail, that Zimbabwe's human rights record is improving.

And what do the Zimbabwean people get out of Chirac letting their leader
back into respectable circles? More misery.

Back to the Top
Back to Index

BBC
 
Mugabe cronies 'get farms'
Poor farmers
Land reform was supposed to help landless farmers
Ministers, senior officials and President Robert Mugabe's sister have been accused of grabbing land meant for landless blacks, according to a leaked audit carried out for the Zimbabwe Government.

The audit was carried out following complaints by those who thought they would benefit from Mr Mugabe's controversial land reform programme, according to a London-based newsletter, Africa Confidential.

Prominent figures mentioned include air force commander Perence Shiri, Information Minister Jonathan Moyo, President Mugabe's sister, Sabina, and Defence Minister Sydney Sekeremayi.

Some of those named have reportedly seized more than one farm, including farms larger than the newly stipulated maximum size.

In the worst case, Air Marshal Shiri is accused of having three farms - one three times the maximum size.

He is reportedly trying to evict 96 families, who were allocated the farm under the land redistribution programme.

Just 600 white farmers remain on their land, out of some 4,000 two years ago, according to farmers' organisation.

'Factionalism'

Mr Mugabe says that he is addressing an inequitable pattern of land ownership due to racist colonial-era laws.

His critics accuse him of bribing voters with land after a strong opposition party emerged.

MUGABE'S LAND REFORM
President Robert Mugabe
2000: 4,000 whites owned 11m ha of prime land
2000: 1m blacks owned 16m ha, often in drought-prone areas
2000: Land invasions began
2003: 600 white farmers remain

Some of those accused of "land-grabbing" have denied the accusations and told Africa Confidential that their reputations were being deliberately tarnished by rival factions within the ruling Zanu-PF party.

The audit was carried out by Vice-President Joseph Msika's office.

Mr Mugabe has promised to act on its findings but correspondents say it will be difficult for him to take on political heavyweights at a time when he needs all the allies he can get.

But not acting might mean alienating those very voters, whose support he was hoping to win by giving them land.

Following previous allegations of corruption in the land redistribution exercise, the government has responded that it has two programmes: one for landless blacks and another to encourage blacks with money to enter commercial farming.

Up to half of Zimbabwe's population, some six million people are currently in need of food aid.

Mr Mugabe blames poor rains but donors say that the agricultural disruption caused by the land reform programme has worsened the situation.

Back to the Top
Back to Index

IOL

Mugabe's happy birthday in gay Paris

      February 21 2003 at 12:51PM

Paris - Zimbabwean President Robert Mugabe turns 79 on Friday, but the acute
misery among his countrymen will force his birthday to go largely unnoticed.

Mugabe's birthday is normally celebrated as a national event, with bulk
newspaper supplements eulogising him, children assembled at various centres
to get indoctrination about his liberation war credentials and a lavish
staff party at the State House.

An institution called the 21st February Movement, run by the youth wing of
his ruling Zanu-PF party has, over the years, co-ordinated events to mark
Mugabe's birthday.

But with Mugabe having become a subject of constant ridicule among many of
his people in urban areas, including children, and with his government
having introduced draconian legislation criminalising "disrespectful"
gestures at his motorcade, it is hardly surprising that the enthusiasm for
his birthday this year is almost zero.

Mugabe is in Paris attending the Franco-Africa summit. This marks the first
time he has been away on the occasion of his birthday.

Since last year, Mugabe has, as much as possible, avoided any interaction
with the people in the cities and towns who feel the pinch of the economic
hardships induced by his policies the hardest.

Many prophets of doom have over the last five years predicted that Mugabe
would use the occasion of his birthday to announce he was quitting.

With Mugabe and his wife reportedly gorging themselves on French food and
wine and expensive shopping sprees in Paris, only the most accomplished
fantasists would imagine a resignation announcement emerging from the Champs
Elysées. - Independent Foreign service
Back to the Top
Back to Index

      Ananova

      Zimbabwe treason trial witness loses memory

The main prosecution witness in Zimbabwe's treason trial admitted he was
unable to remember Morgan Tsvangirai using the words murder, assassinate and
coup d'etat.

The opposition leader faces the death penalty over claims he tried to
arrange the murder of resident Robert Mugabe.

Lawyers for Tsvangirai say he was framed by Ari Ben Menashe, a political
consultant, who was working for the Mugabe government.

A video tape of him meeting Tsvangirai in Montreal, which the defence says
was crudely doctored, is the prosecution's main piece of evidence.

Ben Menashe, who earlier testified that Tsvangirai asked him for help
killing Mugabe, admitted he could not remember the exact words the former
trade union leader had used.

"I don't remember what words he used," he said. "Maybe those words were not
used, but the context was definitely there. The main subject of our
discussions was his need for help in a transitional government after the
elimination of Mugabe."

But defence lawyer George Bizos said the treason charges rested on proof
that Tsvangirai had talked about Mugabe's murder and overthrow.

The trial was adjourned until March 4 after Ben Menashe asked to be excused
to deal with pressing family and business matters.

He was the first witness called, and the trial is expected to last at least
another two weeks after his return.

Tsvangirai was charged with treason two weeks before he ran against Mugabe
in last March's presidential election. Mugabe won the election, which
international observers said was far from free and fair.

© Associated Press


Story filed: 17:05 Friday 21st February 2003
Back to the Top
Back to Index

BBC

     Last Updated:  Friday, 21 February, 2003, 17:55 GMT

            SA defends Zimbabwe policy

            South Africa has denied that it is being soft in its dealings
with neighbouring Zimbabwe.
            Speaking to the BBC World Service's Talkabout Africa programme,
senior parliamentarian Pallo Jordaan said that the country was engaged in
dialogue with both sides of the political divide in the country, which is
currently in the midst of a chronic food crisis.

            "The issue of Zimbabwe is one that is going to have to be
addressed by the people of Zimbabwe themselves," said Mr Jordaan, who is
chairman of the Parliamentary Foreign Affairs Committee.

            "We as neighbours can assist in finding a solution - but it must
be a Zimbabwean solution."

            And he stressed that South Africa would not pursue an aggressive
policy which would risk destabilising the political climate of Southern
Africa.

            "South Africa is interested in stability, peace in the region.

            "We cannot afford war in this region anymore."

            'Humanitarian crisis'

            But the shadow foreign minister in Zimbabwe's opposition
Movement for Democratic Change, Moses Muzila Ndlovu, was highly critical of
South Africa's stance.

            "We believe South Africa should stand up and condemn what is
happening in Zimbabwe," he said.

            "It is a humanitarian crisis that is preying upon the ordinary
person."

            Many ordinary Zimbabweans have been equally critical of their
neighbours, with some attacking the policy of "quiet diplomacy" and accusing
South African President, Thabo Mbeki, of listening too much to his
Zimbabwean counterpart, Robert Mugabe.

            But Mr Jordaan defended the way South Africa's Government was
handling the Zimbabwean president.

            'Always tomorrow'

            "The hard part is always the second act," he said.

            "After you have said nasty things about a country's president,
or his minister of justice or whoever, there is still tomorrow.



            "If it is going to impair your ability to perform that second
act, it is not a very worthwhile exercise."

            But he added that there were responses to the crisis that South
Africa would like to see implemented - provided it was with the consent of
Zimbabweans.

            "It might be useful if there was a government of national unity
in Zimbabwe - but we cannot impose that," he said.

            "Zimbabweans have to do that themselves."
Back to the Top
Back to Index

BBC
 
Opposition despair in Zimbabwe
By Carolyn Dempster
BBC, Southern Africa

Zanu-PF supporters
The ruling party is accused of intimidating the opposition
Zimbabweans are today a people paralysed by fear of their own regime.

In the cities people are scared of openly criticising President Robert Mugabe, because it might mean instant arrest.

In the rural areas they stay silent and do whatever it takes to access the food they need to keep their families alive.

Three years of overt violence, suppression of dissent, and the arrest and torture of opposition political supporters under draconian security legislation has left the president's Zanu-PF party in a stronger position, claims political analyst and chairman of the Crisis in Zimbabwe Committee, Brian Raftopolous.

He believes that Zimbabwe's worsening economic crisis is not sufficient to spur a popular uprising.

"I think people are angry. But they're also despondent, they're scared. For an action to come, there'd have to be a lot more organisation on the part of civic groups.

"Given the increased impoverishment, there's been a disempowerment of most people," he said.

Onslaught

The opposition Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) calculates that between January and November last year, 1,060 MDC activists were tortured, 227 abducted and beaten, 58 murdered, 111 unlawfully detained, and 170 picked up, tortured and released without being charged.

And those figures exclude the women who are linked to the MDC in some way who have been raped for their political beliefs.

OPPOSITION INTIMIDATION
1,060 activists tortured last year
227 abducted and beaten
58 murdered
111 unlawfully detained
170 tortured and released without charge
Source: MDC
Independent human rights groups who have attempted to document the growing onslaught on public dissenters have been outlawed - like the Amani Trust - or silenced through harassment and intimidation under the draconian Public Order and Security Act (POSA).

This, claim many Zimbabweans, is far worse than the security laws imposed by Ian Smith's minority white regime before it fell in 1980.

Job Sikhala, an MDC member of parliament, was recently arrested for the 17th time, held without being charged, interrogated and then driven to an unknown destination where he was beaten and tortured for eight hours, and then given poison to drink.

"I screamed for help, and no help came and I was told to shut up. At the third stage of torture, when they applied electric shocks to my mouth, and in my left ear, I lost consciousness.

"I heard a voice from a distance saying: 'We have killed a person here. What should we do? Let's go and throw him into a dam'. That is the time when I lost control of my bladder."

'Joke investigations'

Mr Sikhala was eventually released, and examined by a government doctor who confirmed he had been tortured.

Riot police
People are scared to openly criticise President Mugabe

The government has since admitted he was tortured and has promised to bring the police officers to book.

Mr Sikhala laughs at this: "The police themselves are the torturers. For them to investigate themselves is really a joke."

During the weeks I spent in Zimbabwe, I heard similar stories of arbitrary arrest, a night spent in the crowded police cells and "bail" of 50,000 Zimbabwe dollars being extorted - whereupon the person was released without being charged.

There is a growing sense of despair among Zimbabwe's citizens that they cannot rely on the police to protect them or their property because the security forces are partisan and have become the foot soldiers of Zanu-PF.

'Under siege'

Sternford Moyo is president of the Law Society of Zimbabwe, but that did not protect him from arrest and harassment at the hands of the authorities.

"We haven't reached a stage where the legal system is not functioning," he says, but admits that judicial rulings are sometimes blithely ignored by the police.

The country has become a police state
Elias Mudzuri, Harare Mayor

"And whenever members of the public feel that they cannot enforce their rights through the normal court system, the temptation to resort to self-help becomes irresistible."

Recently the courts ruled that the arrest and detention of the Mayor of Harare, Elias Mudzuri, for addressing a public meeting about the city's water shortages, was "unlawful" and should never have happened.

High Court judge Justice Benjamin Paradza issued the order to free the mayor twice before Mr Mudzuri was finally released by the police.

The mayor had been beaten, kept for two nights in a police cell and prevented from calling his lawyer.

"We are under siege," he said.

"I was threatened with death by some police officers. I was not allowed to talk to my lawyer, my wife. How do I cry out to the external world?"

'Green bombers'

Worse than that - says Mr Mudzuri, who was elected on an MDC ticket in a landslide victory - the security forces now act with impunity.

"The democratic space for anyone who is perceived to be opposition is closed. And people are being maimed and killed. The country has become a police state."

Riot police
The police are seen as partisan

In the streets the police now have the support of some 9,000 young men who have been trained as Zanu-PF youth militias and are known as the "Green Bombers" after the green uniforms they sport.

They are being used to instil fear among ordinary citizens who dare speak out against food shortages.

In the town of Marondera, former farmer and author Cathy Buckle recounts how she watched 30 Green Bombers intimidate 3,000 people standing in a bread queue.

"Thirty youths bossing people, pushing them out of the way with rubber truncheons, going to the front of the queue, grabbing a dozen loaves of bread, going away, hiding them, then coming back. Thirty youths controlling 3,000 people."

Ms Buckle sighs when she says: "That is the whole nature of everybody in Zimbabwe now, this huge fear, all the time."

The BBC's Carolyn Dempster has now returned to South Africa after a three-week tour around Zimbabwe.

Back to the Top
Back to Index

SABC

            France to work with Africa on Zimbabwe crisis
            February 21, 2003, 19:45

            The France-Africa summit has ended in Paris. Jacques Chirac, the
French President, has agreed with the Presidents of Zimbabwe, Nigeria and
South Africa to work on solutions to the political and economic crisis in
Zimbabwe. France will be working to advance African issues at the next
meeting of leading economic powers.

            This meeting of 46 heads of state and government inevitably had
some pomp and circumstance - it had some agreement as well. France was
delighted that Africa took its position that weapons inspections should
continue and Iraq could be disarmed without war. President Chirac said law,
not force is needed in Iraq but also in Africa - the old ways of autocratic
rule are no longer acceptable.

            Thabo Mbeki, the South African President, said President Chirac
has agreed to work with South Africa and Nigeria in resolving democracy,
rule of law and land ownership issues in Zimbabwe. Mbeki said: "I think it
will be a positive thing because indeed he was insisting that if there is a
problem let's discuss it and let's find a solution..

            "And if there are things that need to be done what might require
resources in order to change the situation for the better let's see what we
can do. And so as I say practically he will be working with President
Obasanjo, myself and President Mugabe, working with President Chirac to see
how we can push forward these changes that are needed in Zimbabwe."

            The French president, determined to forge a new partnership with
Africa, has named a special representative to work on the New Partnership
for Africa's Development (Nepad) issues before the next G8 summit. The ties
with South Africa are visibly warming.

            For France, the immediate issue is Iraq and it may now have the
backing of the three African nations on the UN Security Council. France
considers this summit a success as does South Africa, but it is an ongoing
process and it continues back in France in June at the G8 summit.

Back to the Top
Back to Index

From The Daily Telegraph (UK), 21 February

Modigliani's death mask gives Grace some pause for thought

By Henry Samuel in Paris

As Robert Mugabe was engaged in a tète a tète with fellow African leaders at
the Franco-African summit in Paris yesterday, his wife Grace paused
spellbound in front of the death mask of Amedeo Modigliani, the Italian
artist, during a swift visit to a retrospective of the painter in the Musée
du Luxembourg. Dressed in a lavender suit encrusted with beads, Zimbabwe's
first lady appeared distant, pensive and far more Western than her
colleagues, who had almost all opted for bright traditional material and
headdress. Bernadette Chirac's blond bouffant hairstyle lit up the gallery.
As Mrs Mugabe gazed into Modigliani's withered features, moulded by his
friend Jacques Lipchitz, she appeared troubled. Above her, Modigliani's
words were projected: "As the serpent slithers free of its skin, so you will
be delivered from sin?" On the opposite wall was a second offering: "I am
the plaything of powerful forces that rise up and die." Whatever the reason,
Mrs Mugabe quickly regained her composure. And then they were gone, whisked
to the exit and cocktails in the adjoining Jardin du Luxembourg under the
bemused gaze of midday joggers and outdoor chess players. "They've been here
half an hour and hardly even looked at the pictures," complained one
outraged visitor. "They walk in with no warning and no apologies," she
added, before whispering, "Did you see Bernadette's hair?"
Back to the Top
Back to Index

From Africa Confidential, 21 February

This land is our land

A secret government report shows how officials are grabbing farms and
violently evicting landless farmers

A confidential government audit of Zimbabwe's land reform has found
widespread evidence of corrupt allocations and the use of violence by senior
politicians and military officers to evict landless small farmers - the very
people President Robert Mugabe claimed the land reform policy would help.
Reports of corruption and abuses uncovered by the auditors will embarrass
Mugabe, who has staked his domestic reputation on the speedy transfer of
land to Zimbabwe's more than two million landless poor farmers. Now, from
the government's own investigations, it appears that not only has the policy
precipitated a catastrophic fall in food crop production which, along with
the regional drought, is causing as many as seven million Zimbabweans to go
hungry but above all, the policy has financially benefitted the nomenklatura
of Mugabe's ruling Zanu PF. The audit, of which Africa Confidential has
obtained a copy, reveals that some of the worst violations of the land
reform policy were committed by Mugabe's closest political allies, such as
Air Marshal Perence Shiri and Information Minister Jonathan Moyo, as well as
Mugabe's sister, Sabina Mugabe. This is the President's dilemma: his
credibility with the Zanu PF grassroots supporters demands action against
violators named in the audit but many of these are major figures in his own
political network. It becomes harder still for Mugabe to take punitive
action against offenders in the Zanu PF hierarchy as party factions jockey
for the succession. Mugabe, who is yet to state when he will retire and call
a fresh presidential election, is unwilling to commit himself publicly to
one faction. Most of the transgressions reported in the audit were committed
by his closest political allies, Zezuru politicians from Mashonaland.

For example, the report of those violating the 'one man, one farm' rule
reads like a list of the Zanu PF elite and their allies: Information
Minister Moyo, presidential sister Sabina Mugabe; former Higher Education
Minister Ignatius Chombo; Defence Minister Sydney Sekeremayi; the Air Force
Commander, Air Marshal Perence Shiri; Provincial Governors Eliot Manyika,
Obert Mpofu, Peter Chanetsa, Josia Hungwe; newspaper publishers Ibbo Mandaza
and Mtumwa Mawere; and Barclays Bank Chief Executive Alex Jongwe. Both
Mandaza and Mawere fiercely deny that they have violated the land policy.
They accept they have investments in companies that own several farms but
say their inclusion in the audit is a result of 'mischief making' by their
political enemies. The audit accuses both Mawere, who has investments in
FSI, and Mandaza, who has a stake in Rainbow Hotels, of 'prejudicing the
rights' of poor landless farmers. Mawere said he'd heard no complaints from
landless farmers about FSI's operations and insisted that, although he was a
friend of leading succession contender Emmerson Mnangagwa, he had no
political agenda. The wealthy Mnangagwa's absence from the audit's list of
transgressors may do him some political good. Mandaza accused former
Interior Minister Dumiso Dabengwa and Matebeleland Governor Mpofu of running
a politically and ethnically motivated smear campaign against him. He said
that the individuals whom he was trying to evict from his farms were
'middle-class Zimbabweans' not the landless poor farmers that his opponents
claimed.

The worst case reported in the audit involves Mugabe's in-law and business
ally Air Marshal Shiri, who is identified as owning at least three farms,
with one of them - the 1,460 hectare Eirin Farm in Marondera - over three
times the maximum size allowed. According to the audit, Shiri is trying to
evict 96 landless families from Eirin who had been allocated the farm under
the government resettlement scheme. Shiri had approached Agriculture and
Land Resettlement Minister Joseph Made, who issued a certificate saying the
state had 'no interest' in Eirin, effectively countermanding the decision of
the local land committee. Shiri then brought in troops to remove families
who have effectively resisted the attempts to evict them. Shiri was not
available for comment. Back in 2000, Mugabe's advocacy of 'fast-track' land
reform was a political masterstroke: after two decades of foot-dragging,
some 70 per cent of the most productive land in Zimbabwe was still in the
hands of less than one per cent of the population. Its propaganda value
boosted Mugabe's standing when Zanu PF's popularity had sunk to new lows
with the launch of the Movement for Democratic Change.
Back to the Top
Back to Index

JAG OPEN LETTER FORUM
Email:
justice@telco.co.zw; justiceforagriculture@zol.co.zw
Internet: www.justiceforagriculture.com

Please send any material for publication in the Open Letter Forum to
justice@telco.co.zw with "For Open Letter Forum" in the subject line.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Letter 1: J.L. Robinson

The Director,
CFU,
Harare.

Dear Hendrick,

Some of my letters have been perceived as attempting to destroy the CFU,
and that Justice for Agriculture has a hidden agenda. Mr. Gavin Conolly,
Matabeleland Branch President, has been very direct to us in saying that
the sooner JAG and CFU can get together, the better, and JAG accepts his
suggestion. I am fully aware that you, as Director have attempted to
facilitate this meeting - a closed meeting and I thank you for your effort.
It is more than likely that I have been a bit over the top at times, and I
have to accept responsibility for that. However, I would like to take the
opportunity to point out to all farmers, whatever their situation, or
belief, the official CFU policy and line that was published in January,
1991. This was put together by the CFU team at the time, under the
leadership of A.D.P. Burl Esq., CFU President.

Please could you as director, furnish every Council Member with a copy of
the paper at your earliest convenience - if for some reason you do not have
access to it, I will ensure that you get some copies.

At the outset I must tell you, and the farmers, that this is CFU material
and that I am only quoting some of the pertinent points, but am asking you
to ensure that Your Council read the full paper.

The paper came about as a result of the Land Policy by way of the
Constitution of Zimbabwe Amendment (No. 11) Bill.

1.  "While it may not be the intention of Government to use these powers in
an unreasonable or disruptive way now, they remain enshrined in the
Constitution and may be used at some future date. Consequently, Government
is simply not in a position to give an assurance as to how these powers
will be used in the future, especially when the powers of acquisition are
so wide and vested in one Minister and outside the scrutiny of the Courts.
Rarely has constitutional protection from deprivation of property been
rendered of so little value."

 - shortly after the referendum, exactly three years ago, the farm
invasions "miraculously" started?

 - I personally had never heard of Dr. J. Made twelve years ago.

2.  "It is unfortunate that with few notable exceptions, the majority of
resettlement schemes to date have led to a serious loss of productivity,
denudation of resources, insufficient income and even food aid being
required by settlers."

3.  "500 000 Ha of the 2,8 million Ha purchased by Govt. has not yet been
settled."

4.  Commercial farms consisted of 11 270 Ha or 28,8% of Zimbabwe's land in
1989.(CFU figures)

At that stage (1991) the Govt. was wanting to take 6 million Ha or 53% of
the commercial land. The CFU team then projected a number quantified
effects.

i) Tobacco - 35,6% drop in production.
ii) Soyas 35,7% drop.
iii) Horticulture 47,9% drop.
iv)Wheat 36,7% drop.
v) Beef 32,1% drop.
vi) Dairy 42,0% drop.

The covering notes were:-
"Sugar and tea- assumed not affected."
"Poultry -two major producers assumed not affected."

5.  "THE MOST IMPORTANT SINGLE ISSUE FACING ZIMBABWEANS OF THE FUTURE WILL
DEPEND UPON HOW THE LAND QUESTION IS MANAGED TODAY." - seven million people
can now vouch for this, it seems.

6.  About overgrazing in the communal lands, by non resident stock owners
the CFU said "This lack of accountability is arguably the single most
important contributor to mismanagement of these areas." - take a look at
the southern half of Zimbabwe to substantiate this.

7.  "The CFU fears that those who look at Zimbabwe from the outside will be
less willing to be helpful in terms of contribution to both FINANCING and
INVESTMENT of this development as one of the conditions of their
participation is traditionally, that THE RULE OF LAW and that JUSTICE is
seen to be done.

Zimbabwe's impeccable record since Independence in this regard has now been
SEVERELY IMPAIRED by the substantial reduction in constitutional protection
afforded property owners." - did the Government read this part of the paper
- twelve years ago, or three years ago? How about going back to the 1998
donor's conference?

8.  "Zimbabwe's sound economic base must not be eroded or jeopardised for
short term expediency."
     - 200% inflation, massive unemployment, no fuel, mealie meal, sugar,
cooking oil, bread, etc...

9.  "Hybrid and certified seed for maize, soyas, cotton, wheat, sorghum,
and potatoes is produced extensively by large scale farmers." - is there a
seed shortage today?

10.  "The downstream effect of this (land grab) on industry, its
productivity and employment potential will be serious." - unemployment
figures?

Hendrick, every time I read this paper I marvel at how all encompassing it
is. I believe that Justice for Agriculture embraces the paper put out by
the CFU, in 1991, fully. Extrapolate the land taken, and the corresponding
loss of production will probably be proportionate - 75%?

Taking things to their logical conclusion, Justice for Agriculture is made
up of people who were very much CFU in 1991, obviously. CFU schooled an
Ostrich and a Dairy Chairman for JAG, a Regional Executive Enunciator, a
ZTA Council member, a Wildlife Vice Chairman, and then a few FA chairmen or
commodity representatives.

If I am the impediment to Justice for Agriculture and the CFU coming
together, I ask you one thing.

Please reply in writing and tell me. Perhaps, I must now say "I have fought
a good fight, I have finished my course, I have kept the faith?"
                           Yours faithfully,
                                 J.L. Robinson.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Letter 2: John and Judy Trav

Dear John,

  Firstly, Thank you and your team for keeping us all in touch on a daily
basis. Living in this desperate isolation it is good to hear real news,
however distressing and to keep closely in touch, we do appreciate it
enormously.

  We have a bush Camp snuggled into the base of Castle Kopje, which is in
actual fact in the Nyala Park. It is seriously basic and very rustic... But
it is bush, and there is a lovely dam' Squinks Dam' beside the camp. There
is the silence that we all need so much... and of course there is the game
... which has to be the greatest healer of all. If you know of anyone who
is needing time out ...we would love to share this peace with them... the
bush peace that is and the fishing peace. (Fishing is great, Norman
catching bream daily on his fly rod.)

 They would have to book as we feel just a family at a time during the
school term. Also we would need to get a watercart up there. And of course
bring all their own kit... there is nothing there, except loos, water,
rondavels, showers, stars, hippo , nightjars and of course feed the Rhinos
in the evenings..........if they want to do a Game Drive ... then they
would have to pay..... or a supper in the lodge at night would be an added.
But to Chill it comes with all our love!!!!!

 If there has been one very valuable lesson learnt in this whole 3-year
saga it is the lesson of community life. My gosh!, it is damn hard living
in a ghost district. But our destiny is obviously right now to look after
the game...which I have to say is becoming more and more of a nightmare as
the hunger strays.

  Any way John there you are. If you know of anyone farmer in need to chill
and they have a sleeping bag*give us a ring on 022354.

 Lots of love John and Judy Trav

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Letter 3: J.L. Robinson

The Chairman,
NADF
CFU Harare.

My dear Stoff,

Hot on the heels of your invitation to the Dairyperson Dinner, came the SA
Dairy Mail. In it is a most interesting article by yourself, under "Uit die
Possak." There are a number of questions that arise from the article, as
well as some areas of common ground.

Firstly, I fully support your ideas:

-"The most important message is to never stop thinking." -this is great and
you are obviously a disciple of Descartes, and I hope that you can engender
this into your fellow Council members, possibly starting with Colin and
Doug.

-"Those who fail to study history are doomed to repeat its mistakes." - I
tend to follow history too, and concur with your belief.

Secondly, I need to be fully enlightened, on the following statements in
your article that I cannot answer myself, and have caused me to think even
more and come up with some more questions for you. Thank you for making me
think.

1. "The Government of Zimbabwe is the single most important stakeholder in
the Zimbabwe dairy industry. As an industry we have tried to publicly
demonstrate our recognition of this fact, and our desire to work with our
government to meet its goals and policies."

- I am lead to believe that when you took over as Chairman in July 2000,
the daily collection figures were about 400 000 litres, and that at the
moment they are about 260 000 litres. A drop of 35% or 140 000 litres
daily.

- May I assume that this has been a planned goal by yourself and the
Government?

- Taking this to its logical conclusion, how much further do you and
government intend to reduce milk production by, by say July 2003? 50 000 or
100 000 litres?

- Historically, there must have been dairy farmers in Yugoslavia, Romania
and Germany when those countries experienced similar upheavals to this
country.

Did you get `our desire to work with government' from the historical
perspective of their respective NADF Chairpersons? For example, in say
1943, was the NADF (Germany) working with `the Government of the day' (your
words) when about six million Jewish people were systematically starved,
and then gassed?

- Are you comfortable with the figures put forward that in Zimbabwe, there
are about seven million people facing starvation - meaning that we are
likely to surpass the Nazi affair?- and that you "worked with government to
meet its goals and policies?"  May I assume that you are participatory in
the 200% inflation that Zimbabwe now boasts? - least of all by reducing
milk supply by 140 000 litres daily in less than three years, and that
there may well be further planned reductions in supply based on any other
bilateral agreements you may have entered into?

2. "We have consistently walked a road of dialogue with our government*this
has resulted in less disruptions on dairy farms in general, compared with
those experienced by other commodities. *The biggest challenges facing the
Zimbabwean dairy industry are economic not political."

- I find the above statement very difficult to comprehend, but I am a
simple fellow.

- Jan Smuts, followed by Savory have covered the science of Holism. Put
simply, a country needs a wide range of skills, goods and services and thus
agriculture needs to be broadly based, just as industry, commerce, mining
etc. do as well. I tend to think that your smugness is short-sighted, and
will be short lived as well. Most dairy farmers need by products from soya
beans, cotton, sugar cane, maize, wheat and tobacco (Rhodes grass hay). To
operate in isolation of these would require a lot of water, land, equipment
and expertise to achieve total self-sufficiency as a dairy production unit.
The eventual effect of the three years of this "government and CFU land
reform programme" has taken longer to show itself in the dairy industry,
but as I write there is no stock feed at one factory in Bulawayo. The
effects of your "personal master plan with government" will probably be
much more spectacular in the coming months. Using your own words, I hope
that you will also "be brave enough to adapt and manage for change."
Probably, much longer queues for fuel, mealie meal, bread, sugar,
margarine, cooking oil, biscuits, breakfast cereals, MILK and meat
products.

- Perhaps I am way out of touch - for you to say that we face economic
challenges, not political ones is beyond me. Does the economic problem not
spring from the political one - in line with the thinking of Smuts and
Holism?

- Your bravery is unsurpassed in my humble opinion. To put your name
forward in support of what has happened to Commercial Agriculture in
Zimbabwe over the last three years (page 72 and 73 of "Dairy Mail,"
February 2003) takes a huge amount of guts, and I commend you for sticking
to your convictions in supporting the government agrarian reform - in a
Voltaire like manner that is. ("I disagree with what you say but will
defend your right to say it.")

3. Lastly, your quote from Claude Moller. I thoroughly enjoyed his
presentation at Congress. "The learners will inherit the earth while the
learned will find themselves beautifully equipped for a world that no
longer exists."

- our friend Moller has got me foxed. At what stage will a learner become
learned?

- Are the seven million people facing starvation, learners or learned,
about the life experience they are having as a result of commercial
agriculture having been destroyed?

- Is it a catch 22 situation where the political leaders, communistically
schooled, have found themselves "beautifully equipped" and we commercial
farmers are also "beautifully equipped" - but in both cases, for a world
that no longer exists for either group?

- At what stage will commercial farmers, or politicians, change from
learners to learned?

- Personally, I find it impossible to adapt to a new world of drugs,
deceit, theft, arson, lawlessness, land abuse, poverty, street kids, theft,
rape, torture and murder. I have attempted to seek Justice - so I am not
sure if I am a Learner or Learned, or both.

Stoff, I would like to hear from you regarding the above questions, and
then you can share your views with the readers of the Open Letter
Forum.(
justice@telco.co.zw) and get them thinking, of course.
                Yours faithfully, J.L. Robinson.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------
All letters published on the open Letter Forum are the views and opinions
of the submitters, and do not represent the official viewpoint of Justice
for Agriculture.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Justice for Agriculture mailing list
To subscribe/unsubscribe: Please write to
jag-list-admin@mango.zw




















xaw
Back to the Top
Back to Index

GENOCIDE WATCH REPORT ON ZIMBABWE.

For those of you who did not receive the ZWNEWS full 12 page report from an
independent Human Rights Consultant, here is a short synopsis.

There are 8 stages in the development of Genocide or Politicide (the
killing of political opponents), and there is compelling evidence that many
of these stages have already taken place in Zimbabwe.  Genocide Watch
argued in Feb. 2002 that stage 6 (Preparation) had already been reached in
Zimbabwe.  This has been reaffirmed as of January, 2003.

In Article II of the Genocide Convention says: genocide means any of the
following acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a
national, ethnical, racial or religious group, as such:
· Killing members of the group
· Causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group
· Deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of like calculated to
bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part

One can see that a lot of the above three points have been carried out
systematically on farmers and their farm workers, members of the opposition
party and indeed anyone who has the courage to speak the truth!

Based on their analysis, Genocide Watch declared the following in Feb. 2002:

"Genocide Watch declares a Politicide Watch for Zimbabwe. We call on
governments to protest not only President Mugabe's new restrictions on
civil liberties, but also to demand in the strongest terms, that Zanu(PF)
dismantle and disarm its Youth Brigade militias.  President Mugabe must be
put on notice that if political or genocidal massacres are committed by
these militias or by elements of the Zim. Armed Forces, he will be held
personally responsible.  Zimbabwe's leaders should be notified that if such
massacres occur, the US and EU will support armed intervention by a UN
authorized regional force, and President Mugabe and those who might
perpetrate the crimes would be subject to prosecution."

That was a year ago and already the Youth Militia (dressed in Support Unit
uniforms) have been deployed in the Binga area (MDC MP area).  They are
armed with weapons recently purchased from China.

All Zimbabweans need to be made aware of the possibilities based on the
above information and in so doing can assist in preventing such activities
or atrocities taking place.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------
JAG is a part of Crisis Zimbabwe Coalition and signatories to the freedom
charter. We fully endorse the following press statement.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Crisis In Zimbabwe Coalition
Box 434 Causeway, Harare
Phone/Fax 747 817
Email:
crisis_zim@transparency.org.zw
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
CIVIC SOCIETY LEADERS DETAINED

The Crisis in Zimbabwe Coalition scheduled a public meeting last Thursday,
13 February 2003, at Northside community church, Borrowdale. The topic of
the meeting was, "The Church: Resolving or Worsening the Zimbabwe Crisis."
Police were notified about the meeting on 4 February 2003.

When Assistant Inspector Shoko arrived, the gathering was instructed to
disperse. Unprovoked, the police became aggressive and assaulted several
people. All the people on site complied with the order to disperse. Dr John
Makumbe, Chairperson of Transparency International (Zimbabwe) was assaulted
and later arrested.

Police also arrested Bishop Trevor Manhanga, President of the Evangelical
Fellowship of Zimbabwe (EFZ), Brian Kagoro, Coordinator of the Crisis in
Zimbabwe Coalition, and Ian Makore, a citizen who had come to attend the
meeting while they were having drinks at the Borrowdale food court,
approximately 100 metres from the church.

"The ink is not yet dry on (Nigerian President Olusagan) Obasanjo's letter
to (Australian Prime Minister) John Howard, claiming that all is normal in
Zimbabwe" said Kagoro. "And yet the clampdown on democratic voices is
worsening. Is this naked aggression against civil liberties and freedom
what Obasanjo and (South African President Thabo) Mbeki condone?"

Commenting on his arrest, Bishop Manhanga said: "The heavy handedness of ce
rtain police details was unnecessary and a clear case of harassment. This
was a meeting addressed by the church leaders and Christian commentators in
a Church Hall. This a serious affront on our freedom of worship and
assembly."

The four were taken to Helensvale Police Station, and held for four hours.
They were later charged under Section 20 of the Public Order ad Security
Act (POSA), and were released just before midnight. They were requested to
report at Harare Central law and Order at 8am on Friday 14 February 2002.
When they reported to the Law and Order section, the police advised their
lawyer, Mr Tendai Biti of Honey and Blanckenberg" to "tell them to go
home."

Dr Makumbe proceeded to Dandaro Medical Centre where his wounds were
treated. He said "This is blatant harassment and intimidation. Any one who
thinks torture is no longer practiced in Zimbabwe needs only to look at my
face."

The Crisis in Zimbabwe Coalition demands an end to the harassment of civil
society leaders. Events such as yesterday's mean that the Constitutional
guarantees of freedom of assembly are effectively non-existent. The heavy
handedness with which the police respond to legitimate expression of
democratic rights is provocative and mischievous. Thus the coalition calls
for an end to the misapplication of POSA and the unconstitutional and
repeated efforts by the Zimbabwe Republic Police to disperse meetings where
there is no possibility of a breach of peace.

Crisis in Zimbabwe Coalition is a coalition of more than 350 civil society
organisations whose vision is a democratic Zimbabwe. The Coalition's
mandate is to address the twin questions of governance and legitimacy.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Justice for Agriculture mailing list
To subscribe/unsubscribe: Please write to
jag-list-admin@mango.zw




















xaw
Back to the Top
Back to Index

JUSTICE FOR AGRICULTURE LEGAL COMMUNIQUÉ - February 21, 2003

Email:
justice@telco.co.zw; justiceforagriculture@zol.co.zw
Internet: www.justiceforagriculture.com

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

Farmers are aware of the frustration we have experienced in terms of the
registration of a Senior Counsel from South Africa to represent farmers in
the Quinnell case.  The Quinnell case challenges not only the procedural
irregularities but more importantly the constitutionality (on 8 separate
counts) of the amended Land Acquisition Act.  Application was made to the
Minister of Justice for Legal and Parliamentary Affairs in October/November
2002 and numerous requests for meetings with the secretary in the Ministry
to rectify the obvious "delaying tactics" being employed have been
rebuffed.  This culminated in submission of an application to the High
Court to rule on and rectify this matter.

On the 19th February 2003 this High Court application resulted in a
certificate being issued allowing for Advocate W Trendgrove SC to represent
farmers in the Quinnell case.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------
JAG Sitrep February 21, 2003
--------------------------------------------------------------------------

CHEGUTU
Jack Lowein, from Kasama Farm near Chegutu, was shot in the leg at about
1.30am on the 20th.  He had gone out to try to arrest poachers/cattle
rustlers who had cut the fence and were driving around close to his cattle
herd.  Jack has lost numerous cattle to poachers over the last 3 years.  He
was waiting for the poachers when they arrived and they started shooting at
him.  They fired approximately 15 shots but only one hit him.  They were in
a white Toyota pick-up and were wearing green jackets.  Three of them had
rifles.  They then drove off.  Jack Lowein is an elderly gentleman in his
70's.

NORTON
We refer to our Sitrep put out on 11th February in which it stated that Ben
Barry's centre pivot "was stolen from Norton with the help of Doré & Pitt".
The wording was unfortunate in that although the pivot remains stolen, Doré
& Pitt were only, as far as we can establish, involved with the
transportation of the said pivot.  We apologise to Doré & Pitt.  The matter
is under further investigation.  Any help in retrieving the pivot would be
most appreciated.

CHIREDZI
One elephant has been shot and another wounded on Mungwezi Ranch in the
Chiredzi River Conservancy. The elephants were purchased as calves as part
of a breeding herd, with the help of international organizations, on the
condition that these original calves were never hunted or shot.
The first elephant was shot and wounded on the night of the 13th/14th. It
was not followed and the wounding was not reported. Members of the
conservancy followed the spoor 4 days later. The national park's detail,
who have been given the appropriate authority and have been deployed in the
area by the DA without notifying the members of the conservancy, did no
follow up spoor.

On either Saturday or Sunday night a 12-year-old bull was shot. The meat
was taken by the invaders and the skin was left to rot. The matter was
reported to the police on the morning of 19th.

The ranch has not been acquired and has a high court order on it allowing
the owner to continue operations and remain as the appropriate owner.
However, people have moved into the conservancy. Despite Mungwezi Ranch
being a central and founding member of the Conservancy, it is not
acknowledged as such by the DA or the Land Committee for political reasons.
Members of the Conservancy are appalled at the insensitivity of the local
parks, and that such a happening was permitted to take place to satisfy the
needs of a small community. This same community has destroyed 90% of the
wild life in the area. The High Court order was disregarded and the matter
was not discussed with the Conservancy members.

------------------------------------------------------------------------

THE JAG TEAM

JAG Hotlines:
(011) 612 595 If you are in trouble or need advice,
    (011) 205 374
       (011) 863 354 please don't hesitate to contact us -
       (091) 317 264
    (011)207 860 we're here to help!
(011) 431 068

---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Justice for Agriculture mailing list
To subscribe/unsubscribe: Please write to
jag-list-admin@mango.zw




















xaw
Back to the Top
Back to Index

Independent (UK)

Desperate Zimbabweans risk arrest abroad rather than starvation at home
By Basildon Peta in Musina, South Africa
22 February 2003

Of all the extreme measures to which wretched Zimbabweans are resorting in
their daily struggle against hunger, Norman Sithole's is probably the most
extraordinary.

He has never owned a passport. Yet every other day he illegally jumps the
border from Beitbridge on the Zimbabwe side to Musina in South Africa,
taking an open route that guarantees he will be arrested either by troops
from the South African National Defence Force or by the South African
Police.

His sole aim is to stay a night at the police station in Musina, where he
gets a free supper.

Mr Sithole has been doing this for the past four months. He speaks highly of
the food in South African custody, where he gets meat, porridge and bread,
unknown in Zimbabwean custody and increasingly scarce anywhere in the
country. He says he has run out of options for survival in his homeland.

Yesterday, the President, Robert Mugabe, who has been blamed for the food
crisis, flew back from the Franco-African summit in Paris to a country where
most people have given up hope of a decent life.

Mr Sithole said: "I have no work. I can't afford anything. The truth is
that, since moving to Beitbridge, I have only managed to eat decently from
this police station."

The 60 or so Zimbabweans who sat with him awaiting deportation in the cells
of Musina police station wore faces of unremitting misery as they related
details of the plight that forced them to flee south.

The many who had children to feed said that despite being caught and facing
deportation, they would not give up trying to enter South Africa illegally
to find jobs. They do this despite the risks involved in crossing the
border, including crocodiles in the Limpopo river and three, huge razor-wire
fences - one electric - which run the 250km length of the border on the
South African side of the river.

The captured immigrants have nicknamed the police trucks outside their cells
waiting to deport them the "Air Zimbabwe fleet". Marco Sigauke, who has
already been arrested and deported 12 times, said: "They move so fast in
getting us back to Zimbabwe, but as soon as we are dropped there, we are
already planning on our next moves to come back."

Mr Sigauke, 29, an elevator technician, said he gave up his job at home
because hyperinflation (running at 208 per cent) had made his income
worthless. "After paying rent, I was left with no money to buy food. I could
not even afford underwear ... After I lost my wife last year to another guy
who could buy her food, I decided I had no future in Zimbabwe and have been
trying to get work here."

Robert Moyana, 38, had walked more than 750km (about 460 miles) from eastern
Zimbabwe to Beitbridge before crossing into South Africa to look for work.
As a labourer he could not earn enough to buy basic foodstuffs to feed his
wife and four children. He dreamt of finding a job in Johannesburg and
sending money home to feed his family, but was arrested after his first
attempt.

Tony Mude, 19, trained in President Mugabe's youth militia during the
violent campaign for re-election in March last year. But he ran away after
witnessing brutalities at a camp in a small mining town in Midlands
province. "We rounded up young girls whose parents supported the opposition,
and raped them at night. Some girls were kept as sex slaves for the youth
leaders. We were given dagga [cannabis] to master enough courage to beat up
opponents. I couldn't stand it."

Rosemary Mavese, from southern Zimbabwe, was with her two children in the
cell. She did not think the crisis in Zimbabwe was sustainable. "It will
explode soon and I did not want to be caught with my children in the
crossfire," she said.

People in Zimbabwe were trying to make money any way they could, she said.
Stories abound of women sending their daughters into prostitution to pay for
food.

In her village, Mrs Mavese said, hungry youths had robbed elderly people of
the food packs delivered by aid agencies, leaving many to die of hunger. She
said scores of women and children were succumbing to hunger and disease but
their deaths were going unnoticed because no government officials had
visited the remote area and journalists were being kept out. "People are
dying like flies," she said. "We might end up eating each other because of
lack of food." Indeed there have been unconfirmed reports of women in a
rural part of Manicaland Province seen feeding on a corpse. Aid agencies say
that eight million of Zimbabwe's 11.6 million population need immediate food
aid. The organisations admit they are only covering a fraction of the
affected worst areas because of lack of resources. "It is so bad that during
one incident, villagers just seized food upon our arrival. They were too
hungry to wait for an orderly distribution," one charity worker said.

Farming associations estimate that agricultural output will plunge by 60 per
cent this year, after President Mugabe's land seizures, and the country is
still suffering from drought.

Frustrated by the government's failure to provide seeds and tools to farm
the land that has been seized from white farmers, many people are turning to
gold panning on the rivers and in long-abandoned mine shafts to raise a bit
of money for survival.

Despite the huge numbers of Zimbabweans arrested every day in Musina, the
exodus continues. Asked how the police station was preparing for the next
influx, Superintendent Clifford Steyn said: "How can we gear up? This is
crisis management."


Back to the Top
Back to Index

ABC Australia

Australia urged to abandon Zimbabwe game

The mayor of the Zimbabwean city of Bulawayo, Japhet Ndabeni-Ncube, is
calling on the Australian cricket team to abandon its scheduled World Cup
match.

The mayor says the Australian players are ignoring the plight of millions of
suffering Zimbabweans.

Mr Ndabeni-Ncube is urging the players not to take part in their planned
match against Zimbabwe.

The mayor says it is insensitive to stage the World Cup at a time when so
many Zimbabweans are facing hunger and poverty.

"[It's] extremely unfortunate, it's very disappointing to find that
Australia is allowing its team to come here," he said.

Dozens of police have already been deployed at the Bulawayo cricket ground
amid fears of demonstrations by opposition activists.

The Australian team is scheduled to arrive tomorrow.
Back to the Top
Back to Index

The Times

            February 22, 2003

            Mugabe's praise discredits Chirac
            From Adam Sage in Paris

            ROBERT MUGABE fuelled controversy over his invitation to the
Franco-African summit in Paris yesterday when he heaped praise on President
Chirac for the "tremendous hospitality" he had received.
            His words appeared to discredit M Chirac's claims to have given
the Zimbabwean President a dressing-down over his human rights record at a
private meeting on Thursday night. They added to speculation that M Chirac's
real aim in issuing the invitation had been to woo Zimbabwe's President as
part of his attempt to extend French influence into Anglophone Africa. Mr
Mugabe, who was put up with his wife and entourage in a luxurious Paris
hotel at the French Government's expense, said: "We felt at home here."

            He told Radio France Internationale in an interview shortly
before flying back to Harare: "We have received tremendous hospitality, and
we are leaving with a very good impression of France." His remarks will be
an embarrassment to M Chirac, who said he had invited Mr Mugabe to Paris
despite a European Union travel ban so that he could tell the Zimbabwean
President "face to face" of his concerns.

            If France's head of state did criticise Mr Mugabe, the message
did not get through. In a long, rambling answer to the radio interviewer, Mr
Mugabe praised M Chirac for overriding objections to his invitation from
Britain and other EU countries. "It has been an excellent summit, truly
excellent," Mr Mugabe said.

            "President Chirac insisted that we should come because some
other members of the European Union did not want President Mugabe here. He
had to put his foot down on principle, and we regard him as a principled
person, absolutely principled. He is the kind of leader we regard as very
important, given the state of the international community."

            With the reporter unable to get in more than one question during
the entire interview, Mr Mugabe added: "We want M Chirac to continue playing
his role so that he can serve as a link between developing countries,
particularly in Africa, and developed countries."

            Mr Mugabe, who celebrated his 79th birthday yesterday,
concluded: "All I can say is that all the European Union should behave like
France."

            Earlier, M Chirac had defended his decision to invite some of
Africa's most brutal rulers to the summit. "We want to encourage, accompany
and reinforce the movement towards democracy in Africa, but we do not want
to dictate it," he said. "We go down this path hand in hand with African
countries."

            Questioned about an editorial in Britain's The Sun comparing him
to a worm and denouncing his policies over Zimbabwe and Iraq, M Chirac said:
"France's battle is a battle for law, for morality and for mutual respect."

            But it was another comment that probably came nearest to
explaining M Chirac's determination to bring Mr Mugabe to Paris, whatever
the price. "France wants to play the role of a catalyst in the service of a
multipolar world," he said. In other words, he will do all he can to prevent
the US from being a unique pole of attraction, influence and power.

            One upshot of this policy is the drive to extend French
influence in Africa, even if that means having to wine and dine the likes of
Mr Mugabe at the Elysée, as M Chirac did on Thursday night.

            The moves to gather support for France's resistance to war with
Iraq also reflect this policy. Yesterday M Chirac won backing from the 52
delegations in Paris for the summit when they signed a declaration that
"there is an alternative to war".

            Speaking at a press conference at the end of the summit, M
Chirac said: "Things being as they are today, everything argues for the fact
that the goal (of Iraqi disarmament) can be achieved by peaceful means, that
is to say through inspections, and not by military means."

            Apart from rallying African nations around France's position on
Iraq, the summit seemed to produce only one tangible result: the resumption
of negotiations between rebels and government forces in Ivory Coast. The
West African country has been in the grip of a civil war since September
despite French attempts to impose a peace settlement.



Back to the Top
Back to Index

News24

Furore over Mugabe kin at SABC
21/02/2003 23:43  - (SA)

Barnie Louw

Cape Town - "Yes, but," was the DA's reaction on Friday to the SABC's
explanation of the appointment of a relative by marriage to president
Mugabe, to its Zimbabwean news team.

Journalist Supa Mandiwanzira is described by foreign media organisations as
a "servile disciple of the Zimbabwe regime".

Mandiwanzira is said to be a direct relative of the president's wife, Grace
Mugabe, and appears to have been awarded a farm in Mashonaland under the
Zimbabwean land reform programme.

SABC spokesperson Victor Dlamini earlier said Mandiwanzira was merely an
employee of a Zimbabwean post-production company, Mighty Movies, the SABC
has been using in Zimbabwe to improve its news coverage.

DA communications spokesperson Dene Smuts said on Friday it was unclear how
the recipient of a farm under the land reform programme could be expected to
report objectively about the land reform issue.

Smuts claims Mandiwanzira has bought Mighty Movies, a move understood to
have been supported by the Zimbabwean information ministry.

"Is Supa Mr (Jonathan) Moyo's (Zimbabwe's information minister) man or not?"
Smuts exclaimed.

"These questions demand an answer if people are expected to trust the public
broadcaster's news reporting on Zimbabwe."


Back to the Top
Back to Index

The Times

            Zanu land grab claims deepen party divisions
            By Richard Beeston, Diplomatic Editor and Jan Raath in Harare


            ZIMBABWEAN Cabinet ministers, senior army officers and a member
of President Mugabe's family have been accused of illegally seizing
white-owned farms destined for landless black peasants.
            According to an internal audit prepared by Joseph Msika, the
Zimbabwean Vice-President and chairman of the land reform committee, key
figures in the leadership have been involved in a land seizure that breaks
the regime's limits on the size of farms and its "one man, one farm" rule.
The disclosure will add to growing dissent within the ranks of Mr Mugabe's
Zanu (PF) party.

            The document, obtained and published by Africa Confidential, a
London newsletter, accuses Mr Mugabe's closest advisers - such as Jonathan
Moyo, the Information Minister, Sabina Mugabe, the President's sister, and
Sydney Sekeremayi - of some of the worst excesses.

            Illegal land seizures by the regime's cronies have been well
documented, but Mr Msika's report suggests that it has become a potentially
explosive issue and is causing rifts within the ruling party.

            "It is very important to take urgent corrective measures,
particularly where the leadership is the perpetrator of anomalies, as the
general public is restive where such cases exist and a multitude of people
are still on the waiting list," the report said.

            The most serious violations were said to have been committed by
Air Marshal Perence Shiri, chief of the air force. He allegedly appropriated
three farms, one of them larger than the maximum size allowed by the
Government's regulations. He is also accused of trying to evict 96 landless
families who had been given land in the controversial redistribution
programme.

            Others named in the report are Ignatius Chombo, a former
Minister of Higher Education; the provincial governors Eliot Manyika, Obert
Mpofu, Peter Chanetsa and Josia Hungwe; Ibbo Mandaza and Mtumwa Mawere, two
newspaper publishers; and Alex Jongwe, the chief executive of Barclays Bank
in Zimbabwe.

            The report acknowledges that the land seizures have damaged the
country's food production at a time when millions are going hungry because
of drought. In particular it claimed that land disputes in Mashonaland, the
heartland of Mr Mugabe's support and "traditionally a highly productive
 area", has had its food production seriously disrupted.

            Over the past three years about 4,000 white-owned farms have
been taken by force, in theory for redistribution among two million landless
Zimbabweans. Today there are only about 500 white-owned farms left in the
country. The redistribution has caused turmoil in the agricultural sector
and exacerbated food shortages.

            The accusations will be an embarrassment to other African
leaders who have recently spoken out in defence of Mr Mugabe's land policy.
President Mbeki of South Africa and President Obasanjo of Nigeria are
pressing for Zimbabwe to be readmitted to the Commonwealth and for European
Union sanctions against the Mugabe regime to be lifted.
Back to the Top
Back to Index