| The ZIMBABWE Situation | Our
thoughts and prayers are with Zimbabwe - may peace, truth and justice prevail. |
They say that Canada-based political consultant Ari Ben-Menashe video-taped a meeting with Mr Tsvangirai as part of a government plot to stifle the opposition.
Ari Ben-Menashe: A former Israeli intelligence officer
|
Mr Ben-Menashe, a former Israeli intelligence officer, says the three contracted him to assassinate President Robert Mugabe before last year's elections.
Mr Mugabe won but international observers said the poll was marred by violence and fraud and Mr Tsvangirai is contesting the result in court.
Coincidence
South African anti-apartheid lawyer George Bizos said prosecutors would not give him any information on Mr Ben-Menashe's work for the government, though the consultant testified that he had been paid about $1m for his lobbying work.
Prosecutors said Mr Ben Menashe's services to the government were unrelated to the treason charges, Mr Bizos told Judge Paddington Garwe.
|
MORGAN TSVANGIRAI |
![]() |
|
Previous treason charges dropped
Former union leader
Appealing against 2002 election
results |
"There is a similarity between the fraud we say was committed against the MDC and its office bearers and a number of other frauds that have been committed by the witness and his companies by interfering with high profile political matters, getting money and then turning the tables against the people to whom the fraudulent representations were made," Mr Bizos said.
The lawyer submitted documents of a London arbitration court ruling that one of Mr Ben-Menashe's companies had failed to deliver $7million-worth of promised corn to Zambia.
Mr Ben-Menashe said that deal was altered by former Zambian President Frederick Chiluba and was still being contested by lawyers.
'Not elimination'
The court has also been watching the grainy video, which Mr Ben-Menashe recorded as evidence against Mr Tsvangirai.
During one of the audible sections of the tape, Mr Tsvangirai said:
"The discussion was never about the elimination of Mugabe, it was about the election, and the post-election outcome."
|
MUGABE AND JUDGES |
![]() |
|
Mugabe has lost several important cases
White judges forced to resign
Replaced by government
sympathisers |
Mr Ben-Menashe said on Tuesday that the MDC had signed a $500,000 contract with his firm and promised $10m to the head of the air force, Air Marshal Perence Shiri, to stage a coup after Mr Mugabe's assassination.
Mr Tsvangirai had said sources in the British Government would provide the money, according to Mr Ben-Menashe.
"He also asked us to enlist the United States Government to assist the MDC in carrying out his plot," he said on Thursday.
If found guilty, Mr Tsvangirai, Welshman Ncube and Renson Gasela could face the death penalty.
Mr Tsvangirai was the main challenger to Mr Mugabe during last March's presidential elections.
Previous treason charges against Mr Tsvangirai were dropped when they were ruled unconstitutional.
The trial comes as the European Union is considering whether to renew sanctions on Zimbabwe's leader, which are due to run out on 18 February
|
Millions still depend on food aid |
JOHANNESBURG, 6 Feb 2003 (IRIN) -
Clarity is being sought over a discrepancy between Zimbabwe's official tally of
cereal food stocks - which indicated a national surplus - and the reality of
on-going shortages on the ground, humanitarian sources told IRIN.
In its
December report the Zimbabwe Vulnerability Assessment Committee (ZimVAC) - a
consortium of government, NGOs and UN agencies - noted inconsistencies between
tallies of food sourced by the state grain monopoly, the Grain Marketing Board
(GMB), and what had been distributed at community level.
The ZimVAC
report said: "Distribution of GMB imports at the community level is inconsistent
with reported imports at the national level. For the time period 1 April 2002 to
1 December 2002, total maize available - from domestic availability, GMB
imports, and food aid - was 1.3 million mt. The [national consumption]
requirement for this time period was 1.1 million mt, indicating a surplus of
200,000 mt at the national level."
A local newspaper, The Financial
Gazette, picked up on this note in the report and wrote that "at least 200,000
mt of maize earmarked for starving Zimbabweans is unaccounted for". However, the
newspaper did not clarify that the tallies related to the total national
consumption requirements - not just emergency food aid needs for people facing
hunger.
A ZimVAC member explained that "the discrepancy is that when
there should be a surplus there is actually a deficit ... the reality on the
ground and the figures don't tally".
A humanitarian worker told IRIN that
inconsistencies were unearthed when ZimVAC was "doing their field work, they
came up with the result that only 1.1 million mt had reached the people, which
lead them to conclude there was inconsistencies on the ground".
While
there have been reports of incidents of diversion of GMB food stocks by ranking
ruling party officials and so-called war veterans, this was unlikely to account
for 200,000 mt - a significant amount given that Zimbabwe's total emergency food
aid requirement through to March is estimated to be 345,000 mt.
Another
humanitarian source suggested that the official figures - of total food stocks
available through imports and in-country stock - could have been incorrect in
the first instance, resulting in the discrepancy when the December assessment
was undertaken. But this was dismissed as unlikely by the ZimVAC
member.
It was also unclear whether backlogs in distribution could be to
blame for the discrepancy.
Either way, ZimVAC is seeking clarity on the
issue. The committee stated that "this discrepancy between reported import
levels at the national level and community availability of cereals warrants
further investigation".
Aid agencies estimate that some 7.1 million
Zimbabweans require emergency food aid through March this year.