The ZIMBABWE Situation
An extensive and up-to-date website containing news, views and links related to ZIMBABWE - a country in crisis
Please note: You need to have 'Active content' enabled in your IE browser in order to see the index of articles on this webpage
Zimbabwe president under pressure to share
power
Washington Times
CELEAN JACOBSON and CONSTANT BRAND ASSOCIATED PRESS
Originally
published 02:56 p.m., July 22, 2008, updated 02:48 p.m., July 22,
2008
JOHANNESBURG, SOUTH AFRICA (AP) - Europe turned up pressure on
Zimbabwe's
president to share power with the opposition, toughening
sanctions Tuesday
against Robert Mugabe just as his ruling party was to
begin talks with its
chief rival mediated by South Africa.
Mugabe and
opposition leader Morgan Tsvangirai met face-to-face Monday for
the first
time in 10 years and agreed to formal talks about power sharing
after three
months of state-sponsored electoral violence. The negotiations
were expected
to start either late Tuesday or Wednesday at an undisclosed
location around
the South African capital Johannesburg.
Analysts said growing
international pressure coupled with Zimbabwe's
economic meltdown left Mugabe
little choice but to sign the agreement with
the opposition. The central
bank issued a 100 billion-dollar note this week
in the face of the world's
worst inflation _ which officials estimate at 2.2
million percent annually
but independent finance houses say is closer to
12.5 million
percent.
"When you start to hit these kinds of figures, you know the
wheels have come
off in a big way," said Richard Cornwell, researcher at the
Pretoria-based
Institute for Security Studies in South
Africa.
Zimbabwe's latest political crisis began in March with a
presidential
election where Tsvangirai garnered the most votes _ but not
enough to win
outright.
Tsvangirai pulled out of the June 27 runoff
against Mugabe, citing
escalating state-sponsored violence against his
supporters. His party says
more than 120 of its activists have been killed
by Mugabe's police, soldiers
and party militants since the March vote.
Thousands have been injured and
tens of thousands have had their homes
torched or been forced to leave areas
where opposition legislators were
elected.
African election monitors said the June runoff was not free and
fair and
several African leaders broke ranks to declare they did not
recognize him as
president of Zimbabwe.
"It is impossible to accept
the second round of elections in Zimbabwe, with
children being tortured,
with barbarous acts being committed, with violation
of basic democratic
rules," French Foreign Minister Bernard Kouchner told
reporters Tuesday
after the EU decided to expand sanctions against Mugabe.
The EU agreed to
expand their sanctions blacklist of people linked to
Mugabe's government to
172 people, adding 37 individuals and four companies
believed to financially
support Mugabe and his ZANU-PF party. The list
already had 131 people,
including Mugabe and members of his Cabinet, under
measures passed in
2002.
British Foreign Secretary David Miliband said EU nations were
expecting more
proof that Mugabe was willing to sign on to a transitional
government with
the opposition.
Zimbabwe talks delayed
Yahoo News
by Jean-Jacques Cornish Tue Jul 22,
12:34 PM ET
PRETORIA (AFP) - Zimbabwean crisis talks due to start in
South Africa
struggled to get off the ground on Tuesday as chief negotiators
had yet to
leave Harare, sources from the opposition and ruling party
said.
Representatives of the ruling ZANU-PF party and the opposition
Movement for
Democratic Change (MDC) were meant to begin negotiations
towards resolving
the country's political crisis after the signing of a
historic pact on
Monday.
As representatives from both parties
remained tied up in Zimbabwe, the
European Union sought to tighten the screw
on veteran President Robert
Mugabe's regime by stepping up sanctions on
Tuesday.
The long-awaited Pretoria talks, given a tight two week
timeline, were now
expected to begin "in earnest" on Thursday, said Mbeki's
spokesman Mukoni
Ratshitanga.
Zimbabwean government sources said that
Justice Minister Patrick Chinamasa
and Labour Minister Nicholas Goche -- the
chief negotiators for the ruling
ZANU-PF party -- had been locked in a
cabinet meeting all afternoon and were
not now expected to fly until
Wednesday morning.
"Ministers Chinamasa and Goche are still attending the
cabinet meeting. We
are not sure what time it will finish," one official
told AFP on condition
of anonymity.
"We were initially expecting them
to leave in the afternoon but they should
now leave tomorrow
morning."
Meanwhile a source in the larger faction of the opposition
Movement for
Democratic Change (MDC) said its top negotiators, party
chairman Lovemore
Moyo and secretary-general Tendai Biti, had also yet to
leave.
"Chairman Lovemore Moyo is expected to leave tomorrow. He will
connect his
flight direct from Bulawayo," the source told AFP on condition
of anonymity.
However a source in the smaller faction of the MDC, which
is also taking
part in the talks in Pretoria, said its representative had
already arrived
in South Africa.
Both sides agreed in their
memorandum of understanding inked in Harare to
observe a media blackout
during the course of negotiations that are expected
to conclude within a
fortnight.
While commentators have warned significant obstacles remain in
the path
towards forming "an inclusive government", both Tsvangirai and
Mugabe tried
on Monday to draw a line under a crisis sparked by disputed
elections in
March.
At a ceremony in Harare overseen by chief
mediator and South African
President Thabo Mbeki, Mugabe and Tsvangirai
shook hands in their first
meeting since the opposition leader formed the
MDC in 1999 -- albeit with
few signs of warmth.
Long-standing
bitterness between the two hit new heights during the course
of the election
run-off when Tsvangirai was detained on five separate
occasions while
campaigning and Biti arrested for treason.
The MDC leader subsequently
pulled out of the contest after dozens of his
party's supporters were killed
in attacks that he blamed on pro-Mugabe
thugs.
Ignoring widespread
calls to shelve the ballot, Mugabe went ahead and staged
the poll, winning
by a predictable landslide.
The vote was widely condemned in the West as
a sham, with the European Union
warning that it would not deal with a
government unless headed by
Tsvangirai.
Despite the Harare agreement,
EU foreign ministers still pushed ahead with
plans to widen sanctions
against Zimbabwe on Tuesday, adding 37 more people
to a list of individuals
under a visa ban and asset freeze, officials
confirmed.
The EU's
French presidency and an EU official said that four "entities" --
probably
major companies -- would also be added to the list of more than 130
individuals under a visa ban and whose assets are frozen.
It is the
first time that business people and companies in Zimbabwe have
been targeted
by EU measures.
Once seen as a post-colonial success story, the former
British colony's
economy has been in meltdown since Mugabe began a land
reform programme at
the turn of the decade and annual inflation now stands
at some 2.2 million
percent.
Doubts linger over Zimbabwe deal
BBC
The ink that marks a possible resolution to the crisis that has dogged
Zimbabwe for the last eight years may be dry, but the tears of grieving
relatives are not.
Leslie Madamombe of Mashonaland Central province lost three brothers a week
before the country's 27 June presidential run-off.
One was shot point-blank and the others forced to drink a lethal Chinese
paraquat herbicide by militias from the ruling Zanu-PF party.
"[The agreement] should have happened long back," he says. "Nothing will ever
bring my three dead brothers back."
Leslie's mother and elder brother Hilton still fear for their lives, guarded
by armed police at a Harare hospital.
"I'm bitter, but I however look forward with hope," he says.
No embrace
National angst remains after President Robert Mugabe and his main political
rivals, Morgan Tsvangirai and Arthur Mutambara of the two Movement for
Democratic Change (MDC) factions, signed a Memorandum of Understanding that
could pave the way for a lasting political settlement.
|
This is not the time to outdo one another, but to think about the
suffering of the ordinary people
Mudiwa, Highfields township resident
|
There was a handshake and a smile, but no embrace. It appears the rivals did
not want to physically commit themselves that far.
The body language failed to provide a clue as to whether the ice had really
been broken in the hotel where they held a brief meeting.
Mr Mutambara seemed at ease, Mr Tsvangirai disinterested, and Mr Mugabe was,
as usual, self-confident.
The handshake was a temporary triumph for South African President Thabo Mbeki
and his much-criticised "quiet diplomacy" policy on Zimbabwe.
At last, the rivals had come face to face.
They signed a commitment to "end polarisation, divisions, conflict and
intolerance that have characterised our country's politics".
The talks are due to be completed in two weeks.
Economic collapse
With inflation at more than 2.2m%, unemployment at 80%, and basic food
commodities vanishing from shelves, locals have been finding things tough, with
millions forced into neighbouring countries.
It is a situation President Mugabe was finding difficult to wriggle out of.
Amid rampant inflation, Zimbabwe has printed a Z$100bn
note |
After winning the controversial run-off with an official tally of 85%, the
economy became his newest challenger.
This time, he was never going to win, hence the huge climb-down for
negotiations with Mr Tsvangirai - who he had previously characterised as a
"puppet," "dumb" and a "frog".
For now, both rivals' loose tongues are tied by a clause in the new deal that
states: "The parties shall refrain from using abusive language that may incite
hostility, political intolerance and ethnic hatred or undermine each other."
In the townships, there is some confusion.
"We wait and see, it's difficult to trust Mr Mugabe," says Caleb, 34, from
Chitungwiza, a dormitory town just south of Harare.
But Mudiwa, of Highfields said: "We trust all our leaders, we hope whatever
they will debate, is good for us all.
"This is not the time to outdo one another, but to think about the suffering
of the ordinary people."
Around the streets of Harare, the news came as a shock to many.
It drew laughter from those who thought it was a hoax, but excitement from
others.
A security officer at a local hotel said people were looking forward to
making sure "people are having enough food and they are having enough medication
from the hospitals".
Taxi driver Johannes Phiri said: "I am quite happy, what has been happening
was very bad.
"With the agreement, everything will be all right so that we can survive and
lead our normal lives again."
'Ball rolling'
A 40-year-old petrol attendant who refused to be identified said the country
could return to the relative prosperity of the past.
"The ball is rolling on now. I'm sure the country is going to prosper, it is
going to be a Zimbabwe like that one of the yesteryears."
Under Monday's deal, the objectives and priorities of new government are to
"restore economic stability and growth", and to address the issue of sanctions
and the land question.
The parties agreed to address the thorny issues of a new constitution,
national healing, free political activity, the rule of law and guaranteeing
security.
In past weeks, Zanu-PF terror squads have torched countless rural homes,
forcing villagers to flee into mountains where temperatures dropped to 6C.
The terror squads or militias are now expected to disband their bases, and
preach peace.
"Will they ever do that, let's wait and see, I am very sceptical," says
Leslie.
"Are people now able to walk freely with their party T-shirts without risking
their limbs?" he asked.
|
How the Army, Police are Defying the Courts on
Farms
The Zimbabwean
Tuesday, 22 July 2008 12:27
BY CHARLES
LOCK.
I am a Zimbabwean citizen trained in Zimbabwe as an
agriculturalist. I
have worked most of my life in Zimbabwe barring seven
years when I worked as
an agriculture consultant for a tobacco company
traveling all over the
world.
I have represented my country at
international level as a cricketer. I
inherited a farm of 1250 ha from my
father in 1999 in the district of
Murewa.
. In 2002 I
voluntarily gave up my farm to the state as part of their
land reform
Programme and moved onto my father-in-laws farm in Headlands. It
was 1200 ha
and in 2003 I acquired the majority shareholding. The farm
produced tobacco,
roses, cut flowers, cattle and maize turning over US$1, 5
million
per annum. We built a school on the farm holding 400 pupils and a
clinic
which we funded.
. In 2003 the state officials demanded we give up
some of our
remaining farm. We agreed to let go of 250 ha. A month later we
were asked
by the District Administrator to give more. We agreed again to
another 250
hectares but confirmed with the D.A. and the Governor that we
were free to
remain with the rest and the matter was finalized.
. At the end of 2003 Minister Made moved into the area and allocated
our
remaining portion to his relatives and we were put under pressure on the
land by him and his agents. We were served prosecution notices and taken to
court over the remaining portion despite all our prior agreements. In the
prosecution we were granted 376ha of land.
. The minister
refused to accept this and his relative continued the
harassment on the
ground until we had him evicted through a high court
order.
.
We then had about 2 years of trouble free farming until Brigadier
General
Mujaji arrived on the farm and claimed all was his including my
crops and
equipment. He produced an Offer letter signed by Minister Mutasa
and put 4
to 8 armed soldiers at my gate. My labour were harassed as was I,
and
some
of my equipment was looted. We were forced to grow crops for him
at
gun point. I then went to see the Acting President Msika who is chairman
of
the National Lands Board. He told me to stay on the farm as I had been
allocated it by the state under the Land Programme. He ordered the Governor
to put this in writing for me.
. Mujaji said that he did not
listen to Msika and carried on with his
extortion at gunpoint. I then went
to the high court and got an order
against him requiring him to leave and
replace what he had taken. He
appealed against this to the Supreme
Court and failed.
. He refused to acknowledge the ruling of both
the courts and evicted
me at gunpoint from my house whilst the police looked
on. He took whatever
equipment remained on the farm. I then sought a
contempt order on him and he
was found guilty and sentenced to 30 days in
prison with hard labour. See
appendix 5. He was never arrested despite
the order being served.
. I returned to my farm in November 2007
and built things up again. We
grew a large crop of maize 500 tons, and
managed to get about 20% of our
workers back. My flowers had been destroyed
as had the tobacco crop
amounting to a loss of 85% of income. As soon as we
had finished reaping
Mujaji pitched up
to the farm with Militia and
army staff and attacked us on the farm.
My labour was beaten up and I was
barricaded in my house. I managed to
escape at night and walked 15
kilometers to the main road where I got a
lift. My key workers were chucked
off the farm and Mujaji removed some of my
irrigation pipes and a trailer
and stole maize. He told me he was taking my
crops including my wheat crop
in the ground, my tobacco seed beds and all my
equipment. Even my house was
looted. The police reacted after two weeks and
only after I took the issue
to Head Quarters Police. They arrested no
one.Mujaji still commandeers the
farm with his soldiers and youth. He has
prevented me from delivering any
maize and all my workers have been severely
threatened should they
communicate with or assist me.
. In the meantime I have again been
charged by the state for being on
the land unlawfully; this was a criminal
case and holds a sentence of 2
years imprisonment. I pleaded not guilty and
was acquitted.
Mujaji ignored this and the local police have
refused to deal with
him.
I have got authority to be on the
land from
1. The Acting President Msika and the Governor of
Manicaland.
2. Two High Court Orders backed up by a Supreme Court
Order.
3. A Civil Prosecution where I was allocated the Land
4. A criminal prosecution where I was acquitted thereby confirming my
allocation.
In spite of all this and including the fact that I
donated my own farm
to the State and 70% of my last remaining farm which
really belonged to my
father in law; built a school and a clinic, I have
been evicted at gun point
and my crops and equipment looted and taken by
Brigadier General Mujaji.
I have never once taken the state to
court believing that they would
honour their own laws and agreements. I am
currently trying to get the
Police,through their highest office, to act, to
ensure the law is upheld.
Mujaji is a senior member of the Zimbabwe National
Army who is openly using
Military
Personnel to defy the Courts,
Police and laws to steal a farm that he
wants.
Zimbabwe rolls out $100-billion bill as inflation hits
2,000,000%
National Post, Canada
And to think we here at Posted were impressed by all those zeroes when Zimbabwe
began circulating a $50,000,000 bank note back in April as inflation rates
topped 164,900%. Ha! Turns out they were just getting the zero machine warmed
up.
Yesterday, the country's central bank introduced a new, higher-value
$100,000,000,000 bill in an attempt to curb inflation rates that have spiralled
into the stratosphere, clocked at
2,000,000% and climbing late last week.
So what does $100,000,000,000 bill get you in Zimbabwe these days? The
answer, predictably, is not much — according to Reuters, a single egg in
Harare now costs $35-billion. Haggle the vendor down $5-billion, and you've
got yourself three eggs in exchange for the world's largest bank note in
circulation.
As bad as things are, however, Zimbabwe's economic crisis is still miles away
from taking a place alongside history's worst cases of hyperinflation. As we
pointed out in our April
post on the economic phenomenon, that crown still belongs to post-WWII
Hungary, where at its peak the rate of inflation was 4.19 quintillion percent.
At that point, you might as well start paying for things with hugs.
— Chris Boutet, National Post
Photo: A vendor arranges eggs on a new 100 billion Zimbabwean dollar note
in Harare July 22, 2008. (Philimon
Bulawayo/Reuters)
Madhuku: approach taken by political parties illegitimate
By Violet
Gonda
22 July 2008
Outspoken civil leader Dr Lovemore Madhuku regards
the signing of the
Memorandum of Understanding by the main political parties
in the country as
"illegitimate," saying it does not take an all
stakeholders approach. The
leaders of ZANU PF and the two MDC formations on
Monday signed an agreement
on a framework for negotiations leading towards a
political settlement.
Madhuku said: "I think as civil society our
reaction is very clear. We
believe that the approach taken by the political
parties is illegitimate. It
is illegitimate because they believe that as
political parties on their own
they have the responsibility to resolve the
crisis and they are excluding
the rest of society generally, and not just
civil society."
"It is simply based on an understanding that once the
political parties
agree then that is all that is required," Madhuku
added.
The political parties have said this is an agreement to finding
solutions to
the country's political logjam, which intensified after the
disputed
presidential election. One of the stumbling blocks is the fact that
Robert
Mugabe is insisting on being recognised as the head of state after he
'won'
the one-man run off poll last month. However Madhuku, who is the
chairman of
the National Constitutional Assembly, says the crisis in
Zimbabwe is more
than what happened with the recent controversial
elections.
Madhuku said life has been very difficult for Zimbabweans for
the last few
years, with severe shortages of basic commodities. He said: "So
it can't
just be seen as an electoral dispute. We are not here to talk about
the
sharing of power. We are here to talk about how to address the enormous
problem that Zimbabwe is in. You have millions of Zimbabweans living outside
the country. Many of them left the country some four, five years ago and so
forth. Those are the kind of issues that we need to get out at the
moment."
He said it is very "naïve" to say it is about an election or
about who is
the head of government. He believes that because Zimbabweans
have suffered
for a long time it is time to devise a long term solution that
is done
properly and is inclusive.
Speaking on the agenda items in
the MOU, Madhuku said; "That whole
memorandum of agreement is simply a power
sharing arrangement. So if you
just pick out the so-called agenda items you
can be misled into believing
that there is going to be a serious discussion
of the issues there. There is
no serious discussion."
"You cannot say
that you have a new government, which is what the subject
matter is, and
that new government must look at the land question. And then
you have a new
government and that new government must look at the issues of
sanctions. All
those things are completely unrelated to the centre of our
problem - which
is a governance crisis that must be resolved by Zimbabweans
agreeing to
reform our political system, followed by free and fair elections
and a
legitimate government that has a clear mandate to govern."
There are
mixed reactions on the latest developments in Zimbabwe. While some
analysts
say the call for other stakeholders is correct, as even South
Africa had
strong input from civil society during the transition from
apartheid rule,
there are others who believe the signing of the agreement is
a major step as
it brings a dictatorship to the negotiating table. They say
Tsvangirai had
been left with no choice but to enter into negotiations after
a brutal
campaign decimated his party structures, resulting in the deaths of
hundreds
of people and the displacement of tens of thousands. A journalist
in
Zimbabwe said: "It is a beginning. It had to start, because there was
nowhere else to go. But let's hope the change will benefit the guy on the
street."
However Madhuku strongly disagrees with the notion that the
MDC was left
with no other options. He said: "There were so many options.
The options
that were available to Morgan Tsvangirai were to disengage and
to continue
to lead a broader base than his political party. He had been
given the
leadership of that broader grouping by the March 29th election.
The purpose
of that election result was to give him a broader leadership.
His weakness
is to continue to lead a smaller group of his political
party."
"And that is why he would have fewer options. He would have more
options if
he takes up the mandate to lead beyond the MDC and say - here I
am leading a
pro- democracy movement that would want reform and this is what
we want to
do, and Mugabe would be weaker that way. But Tsvangirai will
always be
weaker if he is simply leading an MDC with less than an absolute
majority in
parliament," Madhuku said.
Meanwhile world leaders have
welcomed the agreement on the framework for
talks. Commonwealth Secretary
General Kamalesh Sharma said this was a
significant step in the right
direction, which would initiate a dialogue
towards promoting peace,
stability, democracy, prosperity and the
reconciliation of the Zimbabwean
people.
The US government said it will be watching the talks closely and
voiced
support for a negotiation process "that leads to a result that
expresses the
will of the Zimbabwean people." A statement by the State
department said the
Bush administration is waiting to observe "the evolution
of this process"
While supporting the mediation process, the United Nations
Secretary-General
Ban Ki-Moon encouraged all sides to engage in good faith
and urged Zanu PF
to allow humanitarian organizations to begin their aid
operations again, as
they still remain banned.
SW Radio Africa
Zimbabwe news
1500 MDC officials still in jail
By Tererai Karimakwenda
July 22,
2008
State-sponsored violence is to be monitored by the Tsvangirai MDC in
the
next two weeks, in order to test ZANU-PF's sincerity while talks to
resolve
the country's political crisis are in progress. This is according to
Luke
Tamborinyoka from the MDC information department. He said the party had
signed the Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) on Monday, to show their
commitment to peaceful negotiations and the ball was now with the ruling
party.
As the MOU was being signed by the leaders of all three rival
parties, about
1500 MDC officials were still in prison on trumped up
charges. Tamborinyoka
said ZANU-PF released a batch of 10 prisoners last
week, but that is a small
number and the charges against them have not been
dropped. Among those still
facing charges are 18 MDC MPs. The charges
against them range from inciting
political violence to treason.
Many
Zimbabweans who were displaced during the elections this year are still
unable to return to their home areas because of the threat of violence.
Although the incidents of violence have decreased, 27 people have been still
been killed in the past three weeks and some youth militia bases remain
operational in parts of the country.
A BBC report broadcast on Monday
showed 170 opposition activists and
officials hiding in a makeshift camp in
the woods just outside Harare. They
have been there for more than two weeks.
The report also showed a young MDC
activist in a clinic with deep flesh
wounds on his buttocks. He told the BBC
that he had been beaten with sticks
a fortnight ago by dozens of ZANU-PF
militia, after he refused to join in
celebrations of Robert Mugabe's runoff
election victory.
Tamborinyoka
confirmed that many others are still in hiding, not trusting
that they will
be safe if they return to their constituencies. He explained
that they are
evaluating the situation in their individual areas, because it
is different
all around the country.
There are bases still operating in Murehwa
district, where Health Minister
David Parirenyatwa was implicated in
organizing violence. The Gokwe area is
also still very volatile because of a
parliamentary by-election that is due
there. Tamborinyoka said there is a
heavy military presence in the area.
According to our correspondent Lionel
Saungweme there is also a new ZANU-PF
thug named Shadreck Sayi, who is
described as extremely callous and brutal
by his victims. Saungweme said
Sayi beat up his own younger brother Themba
for supporting the MDC. Themba
was admitted to the Avenues Clinic for
treatment.
The MDC has
insisted that talks cannot take place while their officials and
supporters
are in prison and violence continues. With the talks reported to
have
started on Tuesday, Tamborinyoka said the pressure is on ZANU-PF to
show
their commitment, beyond just words. The MDC must now also show that
they
are willing to stick to their demands, should the ruling party fail to
do
so.
SW Radio Africa Zimbabwe news
Seeking Justice for Zimbabwe: A Case for Accountability Against
Robert Mugabe and Others, 1981-2008
http://www.sokwanele.com/thisiszimbabwe/archives/1261
Report Cover
This report was released jointly by !Enough and Impunity Watch. It came out yesterday - the same day Robert
Mugabe and Morgan Tsvangirai and Arthur Mutambara were signing their Memorandum of
Understanding. It explores the “Legal options available in holding
accountable President Robert Mugabe for possible international crimes”:
“This discussion paper will highlight the parameters of the legal options
available to hold President Robert Mugabe accountable for various international
crimes. It must be stressed that political and diplomatic options impact on the
legal options. To a large degree it will be a political decision as to whether
Mugabe should be held accountable, though the development of an
accountability/justice model to be used, should the decision be taken to
investigate Mugabe, is appropriate now.
[...]
The mandate should be prosecuting either Mugabe himself alone or those who
bear the greatest responsibility for the crimes committed in Zimbabwe, to
include Mugabe and selected henchmen. The facts will bear out who those possible
indictees are.
The crimes committed are both international and domestic in scope. It appears
the international crimes are largely crimes against humanity. Using the Rome
Statute as a guide, Article 7, crimes against humanity, some charges would
include persecution, imprisonment and other severe deprivation of personal
liberty, as well as other inhumane acts that intentionally cause great
suffering, all pursuant to a state policy.”
It can be downloaded from the !Enough website, or from the Impunity Watch site. We have also archived it on our site so it
appears alongside our violence map.
This entry was written by
Sokwanele on Tuesday, July 22nd, 2008 at 1:27
pm.
Tsvangirai should watch his back
Robert Mugabe and MDC leader Morgan Tsvangirai have shook hands in a public ceremony and vowed to work
together to end the nation’s political crisis that has resulted in riots and
violence after a disputed election. Mugabe really had no choice, after the MDC
took a convincing victory in the polls, and ZANU-PF had to work overtime
stuffing the ballots to come up with a victory that still had that infamous
piscesian odor.
This may look, to many observers, to be a convincing semi-victory for the MDC
- when was the last time Mugabe compromised with anyone on
anything? He usually just sends a fleet of ragged Toyotas filled with
AK-47-toting thugs to settle his compromises. This must surely be a sign of
progress.
Maybe - but don’t count on it. With his pillaging ways and habit of holding
onto power with an iron fist, Mugabe very literally rules a gangster state. And
what happens when a gangster like Mugabe buries the hatchet? His next move is
to knock off his opponent when he least suspects it. Tsvangirai shouldn’t get
into any cars with shifty-looking, garrote-toting guys in the back.
Below: this is what Tsvangirai
looked like after he got out of jail. Sure doesn’t look like a foreshadowing of
bipartisan cooperation to me. When will Mugabe apologize for all the
destruction he’s caused?
gangster
state, MDC,
Morgan Tsvangirai, Robert
Mugabe, ZANU-PF
Zanu PF Chefs Transferring Millions Outside the Country
SW Radio
Africa (London)
22 July 2008
Posted to the web 22 July
2008
Lance Guma
Senior figures in Mugabe's regime are
transferring millions of US dollars
out of the country, amid growing fears
of financial scrutiny by a possible
new government or expanded targeted
sanctions if the crisis remains
unresolved.
According to the latest
report by Africa Confidential most of the
transactions are being approved by
the Reserve Bank Governor Gideon Gono,
despite his pretensions of enforcing
strict monetary rules. The report says
Zanu PF aligned politicians and
businesses are using established western
banks and insurance companies to
make the transfers. 'They take advantage of
the fact that several big
financial institutions quote their shares on the
stock exchange in Harare,
as well as those in Johannesburg and London,' the
report
says.
This makes it easier for the money to be siphoned out of
Zimbabwe with
little or no scrutiny. The money is then transferred to safer
offshore
jurisdictions or financial centres in East Asia. Other safe
destinations
include Namibia and South Africa where the ruling elite have
property,
usually registered in the names of their spouses or children. But
the
one-man sham election of June 27 has led to many African countries
reviewing
their position on the legitimacy of Mugabe's regime. This has
forced some in
Zanu PF to move their money to financial institutions in
Malaysia and China,
using large trading companies or multinational banks.
The report blames this
capital flight for contributing to the
hyper-inflation which has destroyed
the country's economy.
Africa
Confidential cited the example of exiled Zanu PF businessman James
Makamba
holding accounts in Egypt, and former Guruve North MP David Butau,
who fled
to the UK after transferring his money into an HSBC bank account in
the
Channel Islands. Other companies are said to be exploiting government US
dollar lines of credit which are used to pay for external debts and other
current government expenditure. 'In return, they are given shares for
dual-listed companies that they can sell abroad for foreign exchange,' the
report says. Companies cited include Cargill Zimbabwe, African Banking
Corporation, Mettalon Gold, owned by South Africa's Mzi Khumalo and Vulya
Investments. All these companies were given Old Mutual shares as security
and these were eventually sold outside Zimbabwe.
Some of the key
figures implicated in the 'cash flight' include former army
general Solomon
Mujuru and former Metropolitan Bank CEO Enock Kamushinda,
who is now thought
to be running Mugabe's business portfolio from Malaysia.
Controversial
British property tycoon Nicholas van Hoogstraten was also
named. Meanwhile
the Central Bank is said to have availed US$2 million to
AMG Global
Nominees, a brief case company that is being used by Mugabe to
try and take
control of London-listed Africa Resources Limited. Businessman
Mutumwa
Mawere who owns ARL told Newsreel the report by Africa Confidential
served
to highlight the dirty deals being done by people in government and
yet the
same individuals were at the forefront of victimizing other
businessmen
accused of lesser crimes.
EU hits Zimbabwe with enhanced sanctions
package
Times Online
July 22, 2008
Rory Watson in Brussels
The European Union stepped up sanctions
against Zimbabwe today in an effort
to increase pressure on Robert Mugabe
following his pact to enter
power-sharing talks with the
opposition.
The new embargo identified 37 supporters of the regime whose
assets will be
frozen and who will be subject to a visa ban, preventing them
from entering
EU territory.
For the first time, the sanctions will
also affect four Zimbabwean companies
and aim to close loopholes which have
enabled Mr Mugabe to come to Europe
almost at will despite already being
subject to a ban.
Announcing the measures, in protest at June's widely
condemned presidential
election run-off, Bernard Kouchner, French Foreign
Minister, said: "It is
impossible to accept the result of the second
elections when children are
being tortured and basic democratic rules are
being violated. Sanctions have
an effect. They are not for
fun."
The decision to add new names to the 130 which are already the
target of EU
sanctions was taken despite the signing on Monday of a deal
between Mr
Mugabe and Morgan Tsvangirai, leader of the opposition Movement
for
Democratic Change, on a framework for talks.
The discussions,
which were due to start in South Africa today, got off to a
far from
auspicious start after the chief representatives for both parties
failed to
leave Harare. They are now unlikely to begin serious negotiations
in
Pretoria before Thursday.
David Miliband, British Foreign Secretary,
said: "The sanctions are designed
very much to reinforce the drive for the
transition government to reflect
the democratic will of the Zimbabwean
people."
The decision, which was implemented immediately, has extended
the sanctions
to four Harare-based companies. They included Zidco Holdings
and Jongwe
Printing and Publishing Company (PVT) Ltd, which carries out
printing and
publishing for Zanu-PF.
Also on the list is Cold Comfort
Farm Trust Cooperative, which is considered
a front for investments outside
Zimbabwe, and Zimbabwe Defence Industries.
The individuals added to the
visa ban come largely from the business sector
and the military. They
include Gideon Gono, the governor of the central
bank, Joyce Kazembe, the
vice-president of the Zimbabwe Electoral Commission
and Peter Chingoka, the
head of the country's cricket federation who is
accused of publicly
supporting the terror campaign before and during the
elections. For the
first time, two journalists have also been included:
Munyaradzi Huni and
Caesar Zvayi, both of whom work for the state-run
Herald.
Foreign
Ministers made clear tonight that the sanctions could be extended to
further
individuals and organisations. In the coming weeks, the EU will
"examine the
measures which might be taken against others responsible for
violence, and
other bodies linked to them," they said.
Aware that sanctions did not
prevent Mugabe from attending an EU-Africa
meeting in Lisbon last year, or a
more recent UN Food and Agricultural
Organisation (FAO) gathering in Rome,
the ministers tightened existing
arrangements.
In future, it will be
possible for just one country to oppose and prevent
the visit to Europe by
anyone on the banned list, unless the entry visa is
for "absolutely
necessary on urgent humanitarian grounds".
While it has less influence
over meetings in Europe involving UN agencies,
the EU has also imposed
further restrictions.
In future, it will only give visas for the persons
directly concerned by the
event. "So, if there is the funeral of a Pope or
an FAO meeting, nothing
will prevent Mugabe from attending. What will change
is that he will not be
allowed to have a delegation or be accompanied by his
wife so she can go
shopping," explained one official.
US still weighing Zimbabwe sanctions: White House
Yahoo News
Tue Jul
22, 11:16 AM ET
WASHINGTON (AFP) - The United States is closely watching
political
developments in Zimbabwe but still may impose fresh sanctions on
Zimbabwe's
Robert Mugabe and his top aides, the White House said
Tuesday.
"We're still looking into it, as we monitor the situation on
the ground," US
National Security Council spokesman Gordon Johndroe said
after the European
Union widened its sanctions against
Zimbabwe.
Brussels took action despite a deal between Mugabe and
opposition leader
Morgan Tsvangirai aimed at ending the political
crisis.
EU foreign ministers, at a meeting in Brussels, added 37 more
people to a
list of individuals under a visa ban and whose assets have been
frozen, as
well as four "legal entities," or companies.
The list --
which had already included Mugabe, his wife and other senior
officials --
now totals 168 people and four companies, and sees the EU for
the first time
target business people and companies in Zimbabwe.
The new names were not
immediately released so as not to alert those
concerned and allow them to
transfer their assets to safety.
The move came despite the signing Monday
of a deal between the veteran
president and Movement for Democratic Change
(MDC) leader Tsvangirai on a
framework for talks on a future
government.
Mugabe was re-elected in a run-off last month after
Tsvangirai pulled out,
citing a campaign of intimidation and violence
against his supporters that
had killed dozens and injured thousands.
SADC tribunal rules Zimbabwe government has violated its orders
Earth Times
Posted : Tue, 22 Jul 2008 18:23:07 GMT
Author :
DPA
Windhoek - The Zimbabwean government will have to answer to an
upcoming SADC summit for violating an injunction granted by the tribunal of
the Southern Afican Development Community to stop harassing Zimbabwean
farmers until their case was decided by the regional court. "The applicants
have adduced abundant material to show that the existence of the failure on
the part of the respondent and its agents to comply with the decisions of
the Tribunal has been established," the five-judge bench said in its ruling
released Tuesday.
"Consequently, pursuant to Article 32(5) of
the Protocol on Tribunal,
the Tribunal will report its finding to the summit
for the latter to take
appropriate action," it ruled.
The SADC
tribunal, which is based in Namibia, had ordered the Zimbabwe
government not
to interfere with Mike Campbell or 77 other white farmers
pending the
outcome of their case, in which they are challenging their
eviction under
President Robert Mugabe's controversial land reform
programme.
In recent weeks, however, militia allied to Mugabe's Zanu-PF party
have
invaded several of the farms. Campbell, the first of the farmers to
turn to
the SADC tribunal last year, in a last-ditch bid to remain on the
land, was
badly beaten along with his wife and son-in-law during an attack
on his
farm.
Last week the court also heard submissions from the farmers
and the
Zimbabwean government on one part of the farmers' case dealing with
a
Zimbabwean law that bars them from contesting their evictions through the
courts.
The farmers say the law violates the SADC treaty, to
which Zimbabwe
and 13 other countries in the region are signatories.
Judgement on that
appeal has not yet been passed.
Mugabe must be given safe exit - Kenya's Odinga
Reuters
Tue 22 Jul
2008, 15:15 GMT
LONDON (Reuters) - Negotiations between the Zimbabwean
opposition and ruling
party should work towards ensuring a safe exit from
office for President
Robert Mugabe, Kenyan Prime Minister Raila Odinga said
on Tuesday.
Odinga, one of Mugabe's most outspoken critics among African
leaders, said
the deal signed between Mugabe and opposition leader Morgan
Tsvangirai on
Monday opened "a window of hope".
Speaking in London,
he said Tsvangirai's Movement for Democratic Change
(MDC) should enter
negotiations knowing it has the upper hand, given it had
won a first round
of elections, which he said was the only poll accepted
internationally.
"Therefore Mr Mugabe is not president, therefore
they should not negotiate
with Mr Mugabe from a position of weakness,"
Odinga said at an event at the
Houses of Parliament, hosted by the
London-based think-tank, the Royal
Institute of International
Affairs.
"Then be flexible enough to reach a compromise which will give
Mr Mugabe a
place to exit... For the sake of the people in Zimbabwe, we must
give Mr
Mugabe a safe exit," he added.
Both Mugabe and Tsvangirai
have demanded to be recognised as Zimbabwe's
rightful president. Tsvangirai
refused to take part in the run-off election,
citing attacks on his
supporters. Mugabe was declared the victor.
Despite the recent crisis in
Kenya, Odinga stressed the differences between
Zimbabwe and his country --
in political, economic and military terms.
Kenya's own presidential
election, in December 2007, was disputed and led to
two months of violence
in which about 1,500 people were killed and more than
300,000 made homeless.
Peace was restored with the formation of a coalition
government between
President Mwai Kibaki and Odinga's former opposition
party.
Odinga
said Kenya did not provide a blueprint for the way forward in
Zimbabwe
"except on the need to open dialogue."
Odinga, who is also attending an
investment conference in London, said his
country was back on its feet after
the period of violence and urged
investors and tourists to
return.
"We have been to hell and back and never again in our history
will we return
to those times," he said. "Our nation is back on its feet.
Kenya is up and
kicking."
Zimbabwe's rhinos terrorised by poachers
The Australian
Jon Swain
in Harare | July 21, 2008
THE game scouts looking for a black rhinoceros
wounded by poachers in
Zimbabwe's Save Valley Conservancy could hear her
snoring but could not see
her through the long grass.
Eventually, by
making a lot of noise, they forced the rhino to stand up and
were greeted by
a sight so appalling that it took them a few moments to
realise what they
were looking at.
The whole face of the 16-month-old calf had been
removed, including her
eyes, in an attempt by the poachers to take off her
small horns.
The "snoring" was coming through a hole in the nasal bone.
She was very weak
and lay down again. One of the scouts crept forward and
darted her with M99
tranquillising agent, but the dart bounced off her hide
and she did not get
a full dose.
She was so dehydrated that the wound
on her face was not even bleeding. The
decision was taken to give her
another dose of M99 in the hope she would
succumb. After a short while, she
died.
A closer inspection showed that there was a snare wound on her left
lower
leg and a deep infected cut above it. There were also cut marks from a
panga
on her back.
The nature of the wounds to her face suggested
that the poachers had thought
the young rhino was dead and proceeded to
remove the horns when she suddenly
revived. Perhaps that was when they
slashed her with the pangas. In any
case, another of Zimbabwe's black rhinos
had fallen victim to poaching.
At independence in 1980, Zimbabwe had
2000, one of the largest groups in
Africa. But a wave of poaching driven by
demand for their horns in Asia and
the Arab world has drastically reduced
the population. In Asia, the horns
are desired as a traditional Chinese
medicine for fevers and as a sexual
stimulant. In fact, they are composed of
tightly pressed hair fibres and
have no medicinal properties. In Yemen, they
are fashioned into highly
prized ornamental dagger handles.
By 1993,
poaching had left only 370 black rhinos in Zimbabwe and it was a
critically
endangered species. To save the few remaining animals, a national
conservation strategy was launched in which some members of the surviving
population were captured and taken to national game parks and
conservancies.
The Save Valley Conservancy became a primary breeding
area, and today the
Zimbabwean population is believed to be about 530,
mostly in conservancies
in the Lowveld, in the south of the
country.
Raoul du Toit, manager of the World Wide Fund for Nature's rhino
conservation project in the Lowveld, emphasised that this was a "very, very
precarious success" that could easily be reversed by poaching, which has
been rife since so-called war veterans and ZANU-PF sympathisers invaded
white-owned farms eight years ago, supported by Robert Mugabe's government.
The chaotic land invasions precipitated the economic decline and lawlessness
that culminated in the widespread violence that swept the country before and
after the June 27 presidential election run-off.
Fourteen black
rhinos have been killed by poachers in just a few months.
Last October,
three were shot dead by members of the army, armed with AK-47
rifles and
dressed in camouflage, on Imire, one of the country's last
remaining game
ranches, which lies east of Harare. Each rhino had a guard
with it but they
were beaten and tied up.
The shootings were senseless: all the rhinos had
been dehorned so that they
did not have any value to poachers.
The
killing of the calf at the beginning of this month was another grim
setback,
although du Toit insisted that conserving the black rhino in
Zimbabwe was
not a lost cause.
Most rhino poaching, he said, was being "sporadically
and opportunistically"
carried out by locals, who knew where they were and
killed them from
economic necessity. But some were linked to corrupt
officials.
Johnny Rodrigues, the head of the Zimbabwe Conservation Task
Force, a
wildlife advocacy group, said a new law being considered to
nationalise the
country's remaining private game ranches could be the final
blow. However,
in a notable reversal of fortune, the authorities stopped war
veterans
seizing the Imire game ranch and expelling its white
owners.
Rhino poaching is only one part of a grim picture of the
destruction of
Zimbabwe's wildlife. The country had one of the largest
elephant populations
in the world. That, too, is plummeting as thousands are
snared by poachers
or shot illegally.
To help protect Africa's
elephant herds from poaching, a worldwide ban on
the ivory trade remains in
force. However, the ban does not extend to
killing elephants for meat, and
this has allowed the Zimbabwean authorities
to increase elephant hunting
without attracting international censure.
Some Mugabe loyalists have
profited from the land seizures to allocate
themselves hunting concessions
around national parks. They have allowed
professional hunters to bring in
clients to shoot game without applying
proper conservation rules. Even lion
hunting for meat was being offered by a
prominent professional hunter in a
recent advertisement, although it is
illegal to shoot lions for
meat.
Happyton Bonyongwe, Zimbabwe's spy chief, is one high-ranking
official
allegedly involved in the illegal game-hunting business. Informed
sources
said he received $2000 from a professional hunter for every elephant
shot on
a concession bordering a national park. Hundreds were being
shot.
Bonyongwe is blacklisted by the US and Britain. He is on the
sanctions list
barring him and other Zimbabwean officials from travelling to
the EU and the
US and freezing their assets.
Last week, posing as a
middleman seeking to buy a rhino horn for an Arab
sheik, I was able in just
a day of telephone calls in Harare to have a
specimen delivered. Hidden in a
black plastic bag in a blue holdall, the
horn was brought to my room for
inspection.
A rhino horn is worth as much as $120,000 in the Middle East
and China. I
was told I could buy it for between $20,000 and $40,000. I was
also told how
easy it would be to smuggle it out of Zimbabwe disguised in a
consignment of
car parts.
Further investigation revealed that the
horn had come from the rhino horn
store of the Department of National Parks
and Wildlife Management, which
holds thousands of horns, none of which is
allowed to be sold. The seller
had tried to erase the store's identifying
stamp to disguise its origins,
but I could still faintly make it out on one
side.
Two days later, after more phone calls and surreptitious meetings
in a
private house in a residential area of Harare, I was offered two pairs
of
tusks, each weighing 20kg, from two illegally shot elephants. The seller
said that, for a fee, he could easily arrange the paperwork to export
them.
I said I would get back to both sellers. It seemed strangely easy
to buy
horns and ivory, but behind their sale is a sickening tale of
wildlife
abuse, as the appalling killing of the rhino calf in Save Valley
Conservancy
exemplified.
The Sunday Times
Robert Mugabe wins, democracy loses in any Zimbabwe
power-sharing deal
The Telegraph
Scores of his supporters have been murdered and thousands
tortured in the
cause of ridding Zimbabwe of President Robert Mugabe, yet
Morgan Tsvangirai,
once the opposition leader, shook the old dictator's
hand.
Analysis by David Blair, Diplomatic Editor
Last Updated: 9:43AM
BST 22 Jul 2008
If a power-sharing deal emerges from the talks that
will now open, Mr
Tsvangirai will join the president in a "government of
national unity".
At a stroke, Mr Mugabe will neutralise his leading
opponent, cripple what
remains of the opposition, win international
recognition - at least in
Africa - and break the wall of isolation that
presently surrounds him.
This would be no mean achievement. Less than two
weeks ago, Mr Mugabe was
threatened with a United Nations resolution that
would have subjected him to
a global travel ban and asset freeze.
If
he reaches a deal with his opponents, Mr Mugabe will vault from pariah to
elder statesman, certainly among his African neighbours. In short, he will
have succeeded in guaranteeing his grip on power until, in his own good
time, he chooses dignified retirement.
African autocrats follow one
iron rule - either kill your opponents or buy
them off. Mr Mugabe's great
innovation was to do both. First he murdered Mr
Tsvangirai's followers, now
he will do his utmost to buy off his leading
opponent. There is still a
chance that Mr Tsvangirai will resist the
pressure and refuse to join a
coalition government under Mr Mugabe. But the
former opposition leader is
not very good at resisting pressure.
If so, Mr Tsvangirai and his
followers will be compensated with cabinet
jobs, official residences and
smart cars. Mr Mugabe will ensure, however,
that real power rests with
him.
President Thabo Mbeki of South Africa will claim vindication for his
long
years of much derided diplomacy.
The creation of a "government
of national unity" will be described as the
classic African solution to
political impasse.
But the result of the only contested round of
Zimbabwe's presidential
election - which Mr Tsvangirai won - will be
forgotten. Everyone will be in
the government, whether they won or lost the
election.
The people's verdict will be ignored. For as long as that
outcome is
tolerated, democracy in Africa is lost.
Bishop
expresses fear and a 'little bit of hope' on Mugabe / Tsvangirai
talks
http://www.lichfield.anglican.org
Date 22/07/08
The Bishop of Harare has expressed fears
and a 'little bit of hope'
following the announcement that Robert Mugabe and
Morgan Tsvangirai are to
hold talks which could lead to the formation of a
power-sharing government
in Zimbabwe.
The Rt Revd Sebastian
Bakare told reporters at the Lambeth Conference in
Canterbury that the
Church in Zimbabwe continues to endure persecution and
is denied the right
to worship in their own buildings. He told reporters
that Zimbabwe was 'at a
crossroad' following the run-off election, 'not
knowing where to go or which
direction to take.'
But he added: 'Having received some news this
morning that the two fighting
parties have agreed to go into some discussion
has sort of given us a little
bit of hope on what is likely to
happen.
'It is too early to say what the chances of a sustainable
solution are. For
the ordinary person on the street the most urgent issues
that need to be
addressed are to live in a peaceful environment with a deep
sense of
security and without fear for one's life; to make basic necessities
of life
available and affordable, especially food and medicine; to live in a
country
where the rule of law is observed and human dignity
respected.'
He added: 'With the memorandum of understanding we are
very fearful. The
other memorandum of understanding which was entered into
by Robert Mugabe
and Joshua Nkomo ended up swallowing another party; and
Mugabe emerged to
this day.
'I want to believe that those on the
opposition side are aware of the fact
that Mugabe is not there just to hand
in power.'
He spoke movingly and passionately about operating as a
church under Mugabe's
regime; where Christians are routinely intimidated and
prevented from
worshipping.
He said: 'We have been living under a
system that has been so oppressive and
denied people their human rights,
including religious freedom. As I speak
now, my diocese, the Anglican
Diocese of Harare, continues to suffer
persecution and is denied freedom to
worship as enshrined in our
constitution.
'We have not been
allowed to worship in our church buildings every Sunday
since November last
year. Police surround our churches every morning to
refuse us to enter into
our buildings. Our buildings are locked up and we
have to look for
alternative places to have our services every Sunday.
'This is the
context in which the church has to bear witness to the Gospel:
Where people
are denied to worship freely, preaching the Good News becomes a
challenge
because of the instruments of intimidation.
'I don't want to tell you
how long I have been ordained. I never, never was
so conscious about the
importance of peace and justice as proclaimed in the
Gospels. But today in
Zimbabwe I can not stand up in front of a congregation
without referring my
sermon to peace and justice.'
But the Bishop, who received warm and
prolonged applause from the assembled
journalists as he left the press
conference, said the experience had only
served to strengthen the church in
Zimbabwe. He said: 'It is in this context
I feel that many people are
beginning to see the centrality of the Gospel.
'Having been
forbidden, or disallowed, to worship in our churches, the
preaching of the
Gospel of Good News has now become the responsibility of
every Christian in
my diocese because they are not allowed to meet.
'Wherever they meet
they express their anger. Wherever they meet they pray.
Wherever they meet
they share some hope that one day our churches will be
opened once
more.
'That has also given our lay people a sense of ownership of
their church. It
is their church they are fighting for. Our people have
stood in front of
riot police with their guns. That is the courage our
people have developed
since last November.
'It is not very easy
for some people to pray when the other eye is looking
for the police to come
in. They have done it on many occasions: to barge in
to our congregations;
even pulling out people from the communion rail,
driving them out. So our
people are now used to pray and look out for the
police to come in and
interfere with their services.
'But this has not intimidated our
people. They seem to have been encouraged
to meet and meet as people who are
prepared to carry the cross.
'What then is Good News to the nation of
Zimbabwe? How does the church
promise a sense of hope where people are
hungry, no food on the shelves,
where people are dying with no medication,
where people's homes have been
destroyed, where 80 per cent of our people
are unemployed, where there is no
money anymore. What is the Good
News?
'The Good News we preach, or I preach, is that earthly powers
come and go
but people remain.
'And this is what we are saying to
our people: pray that God may intervene,
may take charge of his own creation
and redeem, liberate the people of
Zimbabwe.'
Zimbabweans hail 'historic' deal
BBC
Zimbabweans have warmly welcomed a deal
setting a framework for talks on the country's political crisis.
Residents in Harare and Bulawayo told the BBC they
were excited at news of the agreement, saying they hoped it would allow a return
to normal life.
The deal says power-sharing talks between President
Robert Mugabe's Zanu-PF and the opposition MDC should be completed within two
weeks.
South African officials say the talks would
begin immediately.
The signing ceremony, which MDC leader Morgan
Tsvangirai described as "historic", was the first time he had met Mr Mugabe in a
decade.
The talks, to be held in South Africa, are expected
to focus on a possible power-sharing agreement, how to revive Zimbabwe's
devastated economy and ending the political violence.
But the BBC's Jonah Fisher in Johannesburg says the
deal has not settled any of key issues, such as how two parties work together
and - crucially - what happens to Mr Mugabe.
New sanctions
Mr Mugabe and Mr Tsvangirai have been locked in a
bitter dispute over this year's presidential election.
Mr Tsvangirai, who leads the opposition Movement for
Democratic Change (MDC), won the first round of presidential elections at the
end of March, but official results gave him less than the 50% needed for
outright victory.
|
We should make sure people have enough food and enough medicines in
hospital
|
Mr Mugabe won the second round after Mr Tsvangirai
withdrew, complaining of a campaign of violence against his supporters.
The poll was widely criticised by Western powers and
by a small group of African countries.
On Tuesday, EU officials said they were extending
sanctions against Zimbabwe, adding 37 names to the list of people subject to a
travel ban and assets freeze.
Zimbabweans expressed hope that Monday's deal would
bring an end to the political unrest.
One resident in the capital, Harare, said Zimbabweans
were "looking forward to peace and development".
"We should make sure people have enough food and
enough medicines in hospital," said another.
In Bulawayo, Zimbabwe's second city, journalist
Themba Nkosi said both government and opposition supporters were desperate for a
return to normal life, wanting schools that had closed during the post-election
violence to reopen.
Zimbabwean exiles in South Africa were more
sceptical.
Solomon "Sox" Chikohwero, Vice-Chairperson of the
Zimbabwe Diaspora Forum, told the BBC there would only be cause to celebrate
once a power-sharing deal was signed.
South African presidential spokesman Mukoni
Ratshitanga said the talks would begin at an undisclosed location in Pretoria on
Tuesday afternoon.
However, MDC spokesman Nelson Chamisa said the
party's lead negotiator, Secretary-General Tendai Biti, remained in Harare.
The MDC says at least 120 of its supporters have been
killed, about 5,000 abducted and 200,000 forced from their homes since the first
round of the elections, in a campaign of violence by pro-Mugabe militias and the
army.
Cabinet ministers and military officials have denied
the charges. |
'Sign now and negotiate later'
IOL
By Fiona Forde
Zimbabwe's Movement for
Democratic Change lost bargaining power at a critical moment when they failed to
rush through three amendments to the Memo of Understanding (MOU) at the eleventh
hour.
As Morgan Tsvangirai, President Robert Mugabe and Arthur Mutambara
sat with President Thabo Mbeki on the 17th floor of the Rainbow Towers in Harare
on Monday, waiting to put their names to the five-page document, the parties'
negotiators sat a few floors down, arguing over the fine
details.
Tsvangirai leads the main opposition Movement for Democratic
Change and Mutambara heads a breakaway MDC faction.
The third clause asked that each party's two-man team of
negotiators be expanded to five | It is understood that the MDC attempted to rush through three
clauses just minutes before it was due to be signed.
The first called
for recognition of the right of the people of Zimbabwe to elect a government of
their choice.
The second appealed for each
party's negotiators to have the right to liaise with the recently appointed
Reference Group and report all progress on the dialogue, or lack thereof.
The third clause asked that each party's two-man team of negotiators be
expanded to five.
However, they failed to secure agreement on any one of
the three, their counterparts saying that Monday afternoon was not the time to
stall dialogue, particularly with Mugabe and Tsvangirai waiting for more than an
hour upstairs to sign the historic agreement in which they finally recognised
each other as political opponents.
'Mugabe has finally acknowledged Tsvangirai as a player,
and a significant player at that' | The MDC was advised to sign on Monday and negotiate later.
However, an MDC sympathiser close to the talks argued that yesterday's
setback should be not be viewed as a defeat.
"Mugabe has finally
acknowledged Tsvangirai as a player, and a significant player at that, in the
opposition. He has publicly recognised that Morgan is needed to have a political
settlement in the country.
"And he is indirectly telling the world that
without Morgan, you can't move the country forward. You must also view it as an
acknowledgment by Mbeki, by the SADC and by the local political leadership, that
Morgan must be counted."
The source referred to Friday's appointment of
the Reference Group, when Mbeki appointed diplomats from the Southern African
Development Community, African Union and UN as a support mechanism for all
future negotiations.
"That was a key development," he says, "having
oversight in the negotiations, especially from such an open-minded group as the
Reference Group."
The main points of the MOU signed by Mugabe,
Tsvangirai and Mutambara are:
Parties agree to commit themselves to dialogue towards creating a permanent
and sustainable solution to the crisis.
Parties acknowledge the ultimate goal of forming an inclusive
government.
The agenda is to include the objectives of a new government, economic
stability and growth, sanctions and land reforms.
The agenda is to include discussions on a new constitution, promotion of
national unity, external interference, free political activity and the rule of
law.
Parties agree to condemn violence, to ensure the law is applied fairly to
everyone irrespective of political affiliation.
Parties will refrain from hate speech that may incite political intolerance
and ethnic hatred.
Parties to discuss the time framework of a new government.
The dialogue should be accomplished over two weeks.
During dialogue, the parties shall not take any decisions that will affect
the talks, such as convening parliament or forming a new government.
The implementation of the global political agreements that the parties will
conclude, shall be underwritten and guaranteed by the facilitator, SADC, and the
AU.
Parties will not communicate the substance of talks directly or indirectly
to the media.
For a copy of the MOU see www.iol.co.za
This article was originally published on page 9 of Cape Argus
on July 22, 2008
|
Zimbabwe's Makoni 'saddened' by
talks exclusion
africasia
JOHANNESBURG, July 22 (AFP)
Simba Makoni, the third-placed candidate in Zimbabwe's first
round
presidential vote in March, hit out on Tuesday at his exclusion from
talks
aimed at ending the country's crisis.
Makoni, who was
previously seen as a possible bridge between President
Robert Mugabe and
opposition leader Morgan Tsvangirai, was notably absent
from a ceremony on
Monday to sign a deal to begin two weeks of intensive
talks.
"I
cannot explain my absence from that signing ceremony," the former finance
minister told South African public radio, saying "many Zimbabweans" believed
his movement should have a role in both the current talks and the future of
the country.
"I feel it is sad that we are not involved at this
stage. But this is only
the beginning, there is more to come and we believe
that we will make our
contribution in that more to come."
Despite his
exclusion, Makoni described the memorandum of understanding
signed in Harare
as "a promising start."
"I think the key factor here is how serious,
honest and genuine are people
at solving the country's problems together. We
hope that they genuinely mean
they wish to work together," he
said.
Makoni infuriated Mugabe when he decided to run as an independent
in the
first round of voting on March 29.
He trailed in third with
around eight percent of votes and was not a
candidate in a second round last
month which saw Mugabe re-elected after
Tsvangirai withdrew in protest at
attacks on his supporters.
Makoni not offended by exclusion in peace pact
SABC
July 22, 2008,
09:45
Zimbabwe's independent candidate, Simba Makoni, who came third in
the first
round of the presidential elections, says he does not feel
offended at his
exclusion from the agreement signed
yesterday.
President Robert Mugabe and opposition Movement Democratic
Change (MDC)
leader Morgan Tsvangirai have committed themselves to negotiate
an end to
the country's political crisis in the next two weeks. South
African
President Thabo Mbeki facilitated the signing of the deal in Harare
yesterday.
Makoni declined to be drawn on the possibility of an
alliance with either
the ruling Zanu-PF or the MDC.
Meanwhile, South
Africa's foreign affairs spokesperson Ronnie Mamoepa says
his country
remains committed to assisting Zimbabwe on the road to political
and
economic recovery.
African Union (AU) commission Chief Jean Ping says it
marks a significant
step in overcoming the crisis facing Zimbabwe.
Britain must continue to support change in Zimbabwe
- Davey
Liberal Democrats, UK
22 July 2008
Commenting on Robert Mugabe's and
Morgan Tsvangarai's signing of a deal
outlining a framework for talks on
Zimbabwe's political situation, Liberal
Democrat Shadow Foreign Secretary,
Edward Davey said:
"Given that the MDC won the elections fairly, nobody
wants to see Mugabe and
his thugs rewarded with part of a government of
national unity.
"A clear test for these talks must therefore be the level
of authority and
influence accorded to Morgan Tsvangirai and his
team.
"Britain must continue to support those voices in South Africa that
are
supportive of change in Zimbabwe."
Serious talk?
Jul 22nd 2008 | JOHANNESBURG
From Economist.com
How
seriously, or not, to take talks between Zimbabwe's rival claimants to
the
presidency
NEARLY four months after the first round of a presidential
election in
Zimbabwe, in March, which precipitated a frenzy of violence by
pro-government militias and general political turmoil, President Robert
Mugabe and the opposition leader, Morgan Tsvangirai, are about to start
talking. On Monday July 21st, reportedly for the first time in a decade or
so, the two men met face-to-face and even shook hands. Along with the leader
of a smaller opposition party, Arthur Mutambara, they signed an agreement
paving the way for negotiations over the country's political
future.
The ruling party lost its majority in parliament for the first
time since
independence and the opposition Movement for Democratic Change
(MDC) came
first in the presidential poll on March 29th, but following
months of
orchestrated state-sponsored violence Mr Tsvangirai withdrew from
the runoff
in June.
Since then a variety of outsiders, including
South Africa's president, Thabo
Mbeki, the African Union, the United Nations
and the Southern African
Development Community (SADC), have attempted to
encourage some sort of
compromise. Mr Mbeki is still the chief mediator
under a SADC mandate, but
the appointment a few days ago of a "reference
group" of senior
representatives from the three organisations was a
breakthrough. The MDC
said that Mr Mbeki is biased in favour of Mr Mugabe
and demanded other
mediators. The opposition still insists that there will
be no progress
without an end to political violence, the release of
political prisoners and
a resumption of humanitarian aid.
The initial
agreement calls on all sides to condemn and stop political
violence and make
it possible for thousands of families displaced by the
violence to return
home. It also proposes a two-week timeframe for talks to
happen. It is
unlikely that any power-sharing agreement could be reached
within that tight
schedule, but it could be extended if progress is made.
Negotiations are
expected to kick off this week in South Africa. While these
are under way no
new government is to be appointed and parliament may not be
convened.
Compromise may yet prove to be impossible-previous attempts
to negotiate all
failed when Mr Mugabe simply turned his back on them. Mr
Mugabe insists that
he won the election in June and must be recognised as
president. Security
chiefs who, de facto, run the country, would also not
tolerate any change of
political power that would leave them vulnerable, for
example to
prosecution. Mr Tsvangirai says that the only legitimate poll was
the first
round, in March, which the MDC won.
One possible outcome
would mimic the government of national unity created
earlier this year in
Kenya after disputed elections there. In that case the
defeated president
kept his job and the winner got the (not particularly
important) post of
prime minister. Mr Tsvangirai, for obvious reasons, says
that such a
solution is unacceptable. He wants to see a transitional
authority based on
the results of the March election that would pave the way
for fresh
elections.
Nor will talks be easy given the ongoing repression in
Zimbabwe. In the past
few months alone over 120 opposition activists have
been killed and
thousands arrested. The opposition says that 200,000 people
have fled the
violence. The lead negotiator for Mr Tsvangirai's side, Tendai
Biti, is
facing treason charges and is out on bail. Mr Tsvangirai has been
denied a
new passport, so cannot travel. Mr Mutambara is also on
bail-arrested and
charged for daring to write an editorial that was critical
of Mr Mugabe.
Previous attempts to negotiate ended in failure as Mr
Mugabe's ruling
ZANU-PF reneged on its commitments. Negotiations meant to
ensure a free and
fair election began last year and went on for months, but
collapsed in
February this year when Mr Mugabe set a date for the poll
before a new
constitution was in place. The opposition must also worry about
the last
time a unity government was formed in Zimbabwe. In the 1980s a
rival
liberation movement ZAPU was absorbed into a unity government and
eventually
into ZANU-PF itself, following a ruthless campaign of violence
that left
many thousands dead in Matabeleland. Mr Mugabe, of course, stayed
securely
in office.
Who will be president of Zim?
IOL
July 22 2008 at
09:35AM
By Susan Njanji
Deep mistrust between Robert
Mugabe and arch-rival Morgan Tsvangirai
will remain a major obstacle to
rapid progress in ending Zimbabwe's crisis,
despite an agreement to sit down
and talk.
While there is a common sense of urgency for the two
sides to bury
their differences as Zimbabwe's economy lurches from bad to
worse, observers
say neither Mugabe nor opposition leader Tsvangirai is
about to give up his
claim to be the country's rightful leader.
And while South African President Thabo Mbeki may have pulled off
something
of a coup on Monday by persuading the pair to sign a memorandum of
understanding on full-scale talks, Tsvangirai's pointed refusal to refer to
Mugabe as president of anything more than his Zanu-PF party hardly boded
well.
According to Joseph Kurebga, a
political scientist at the University
of Zimbabwe, the talks could proceed
"very fast and to the satisfaction of
all parties" - but only if and when
the main sticking point is resolved.
"President Mugabe will want to
be recognised legitimately, while
Tsvangirai would also want to be
recognised as the leader or winner of the
elections."
Mugabe
was predictably re-elected late in June in a one-man poll that
was boycotted
by Tsvangirai.
Tsvangirai, who pushed Mugabe into second place in
the first round of
voting on March 29, has refused to acknowledge Mugabe's
victory and insists
he has the right to the biggest slice of cake in any
power-sharing
agreement.
In a speech a week after the June 27
second-round vote, Mugabe warned
that for any talks to even begin, all sides
had to recognise him as head of
state.
While Mugabe may have
given some ground then in agreeing to at least
speak to Tsvangirai, Lovemore
Madhuku, a pro-opposition analyst, says that
should not be interpreted as a
sign of the 84-year-old's weakening resolve.
"Mugabe still wants to
be an executive leader of this country and he
will remain the executive
leader - there's no illusion on that," said
Madhuku.
"The major
issue is where to place Tsvangirai, and whether Tsvangirai
will accept the
position he will be offered or not."
If Mugabe has slightly
softened his line, Tsvangirai has also had to
temper some of his demands
such as on the make-up of the mediation team.
He has called for
Mbeki to be sacked from the position that was handed
to him by the Southern
African Development Community in March 2007.
Although Mbeki has now
set up a new body which would allow input from
the AU and UN, he remains the
chief mediator - a point reinforced by his
presence at Monday's
signing.
Mbeki has come in for heavy flak over his refusal to
publicly
criticise Mugabe. Eldred Masunungure, a Harare-based commentator,
said
Mugabe was indebted to Mbeki - especially as he was instrumental in
ensuring
that an attempt to introduce a new package of sanctions failed at
the UN
Security Council earlier in July.
This article
was originally published on page 7 of The Mercury on July
22, 2008
MISA calls for media freedom & inclusion in unity talks
By Alex
Bell
22 July 2008
Media freedom organisation, MISA Zimbabwe, said on
Tuesday that the two week
negotiation period following Monday's signing of
the Memorandum of
Understanding should have been preceded by an "unequivocal
and explicit
guarantee to the right of freedom of expression, access to
information and
freedom of the media", and called for the immediate
inclusion of civil
society in the unity talks.
The MOU between ZanuPF
and the two MDC formations excludes involving the
media during the two week
negotiating period, stating that "none of the
parties shall, during the
dialogue period, directly or indirectly
communicate the substance of the
discussion with the media".
MISA Zimbabwe's chairman Loughty Dube, told
Newsreel on Tuesday that he was
"cautiously optimistic" about the MOU as a
potential way forward but
emphasised that the issue of the media is "a
critical one". He said that if
the parties involved are "sincere in solving
the crisis" they need to
"remain true to the need for a transitional process
that carries the people's
confidence". Dube added that this can only be
achieved "in an environment
that allows Zimbabweans to enjoy their
fundamental right to freedom of
expression, access to information and media
freedom".
Dube said this environment can be achieved if the ongoing
arrests,
harassment and torture of journalists are stopped, and if all media
houses,
both foreign and Zimbabwean, are given permission to cover the
political
situation as it unfolds. He added that the Zimbabwe Broadcasting
Corporation
needs to be immediately transformed into a "truly independent
public
broadcaster" to serve the will of the people.
Dube said the
influence of the Minister of Information needs to be "urgently
reduced" to
transform the ZBC from a state run broadcaster into "the people's
voice". He
said the Minister's influence is the only reason why the ZBC has
become "a
party megaphone" and that a board "excluding political
roleplayers" needs
to be appointed by parliament to ensure the
transformation has the will of
the people in mind.
Dube added that the negotiations between the MDC
formations and ZanuPF
should not be the "exclusive realm and prerogative of
political parties
alone", despite the parties going ahead with talks on
Tuesday.
Dube said the process needs to be one that "embraces the
inclusion of civil
society, as opposed to the exclusionary nature of the
MOU", and called for
the immediate involvement of civil society
organisations and the media in
the unity talks.
SW Radio Africa
Zimbabwe news
Villagers Wary of Police Presence
http://www.radiovop.com
CHIMANIMANI, July 22 2008 - While
police here say they have started
investigating cases of political violence
perpetrated against members of the
opposition Movement for Democratic Change
(MDC) by Zanu (PF) militias almost
a month after the June 27 one-man
presidential election, villagers still
remain wary of their
presence.
The Zimbabwe Republic Police (ZRP) says it has
deployed police in
violence-torn areas such as Biriiri, Mhakwe, Honde Valley
in Manicaland to
investigate cases of violence during the period leading to
(and after) the
controversial run-off. Ironical, though, the villagers say
the police
officers are stationed at torture bases that were used by
militias to maim
and torture members of the opposition.
"We
are suspicious about the purposes of these investigations. Why
didn't the
police come to our rescue when we were being beaten and when our
shops and
homesteads were being looted in broad day light," said Zvenhamo
Mapaike,
whose shop was looted by militia a few days before the run off.
Mapaike vowed not to co-operate with the police investigations
because, he
said, he believed the operation to root out the perpetrators of
violence was
just another cover up by the ZRP
"Considering that most of the
youths who were committing these crimes
were bused from outside the
district, it is not fair for the police to
expect me to identify the youths
who took away my two goats on the 21st of
June," he said.
Added another villager in Biriiri, Zondai Mushanguri: "The Manicaland
Development Association (MDA) offices where the police are based is to us a
haunted place because it is where a lot of people were killed and maimed by
the youths."
Police in Chimanimani on Monday defended their
late action saying the
operation to arrest the perpetrators of violence was
delayed because of lack
of manpower.
Tsvangirai's open letter on the memorandum of
understanding
Politicsweb
Morgan Tsvangirai
22 July 2008
As issued by the
Movement for Democratic Change President July 22 2008
Open Letter
from the President of the Movement for Democratic Change,Mr.
Morgan
Tsvangirai, on the Signing of the Memorandum of Understanding, July22
2008
My fellow Zimbabweans,
Yesterday I signed a Memorandum of
Understanding with Mr.Robert Mugabe and
Prof. Arthur Mutambara. This
document commits our threeparties to a
framework of negotiations that will
take place over the next twoweeks.
I know that in signing this Memorandum
of Understanding, Irepresent the
hopes and aspirations of millions of
Zimbabweans to end thiscrisis as soon
as possible. Honest, hardworking
Zimbabweans who want nothingmore than a
life that offers peace, security,
economic opportunity, democracyand social
and personal development. This is
a responsibility that the Movementfor
Democratic Change and I take with the
utmost seriousness.
This Memorandum offers the most tangible opportunity
in thepast ten years to
improve the lives of our fellow citizens. But, our
signaturesalone do not
guarantee that we will be able to make the most of
thisopportunity. Our
signatures on this document must be accompanied
byacknowledging some very
basic truths:
We are Zimbabweans who want
only what is best for our countryand our
citizens. Our shared goal isbest
achieved in a climate of tolerance and
stability, not divisiveness andanger.
We believe that wanting a more
democratic future or expressing analternate
political opinion should be
viewed as a right and not as adeclaration of
war. No one has a monopoly on
patriotism.
We believe that the will of
the people is the fundamentalbasis on which to
ground our
negotiations.
We acknowledge that these negotiations can only proceed
andsucceed if the
rule of law is restored, if people are able to go about
theirbusiness in
safety, if the public media refrain from using hate speech
topolarize the
community, if the persecution of MDC MPs, members and
supportersceases, and
if humanitarian organizations are allowed once again
to provide aidto the
millions of Zimbabweans in need of
assistance.
For my part, I call on all Zimbabweans who believe in
theideals of democracy
as espoused by the MDC, to continue to abide by the
rule oflaw, to live in a
spirit of tolerance and inclusiveness in the
knowledge thatif we work
together in this spirit, a better future lies ahead
and justice willprevail.
Yesterday, we committed ourselves to a process
that presentsthe framework in
which we can strive to find a solution to the
Zimbabwecrisis. This is just
the first step on a journey whose duration and
success isdependent on the
sincerity and good faith of all parties
involved.
In the spirit of a shared vision to heal our nation, I callupon
my fellow
signatories to join me in putting aside our differences
andacknowledging
that we have a responsibility to the people of Zimbabwe to
showtrue
leadership and to find agreement that will bring an end to the
violence,polarisation, poverty and fear in which we have all been living for
too long.Our fellow countrymen and women look to us to find common ground
that willallow us, as a nation, to chart a democratic path
forward.
We must acknowledge that the outcome of these negotiationswill
not be
acceptable until it has been endorsed by Zimbabwean civil society,the
trade
unions and the people themselves. We are not here to form an
elitistpact,
but rather to represent the hopes and aspirations of each
citizen andevery
stakeholder. This is my commitment to our partners who have
struggledwith us
for a more democratic form of government.
To the
people of Zimbabwe I say, have courage, bestrong, better days lie
ahead.
The heart of the entire world is broken by what has happenedin
our country,
and your bravery is praised among all peoples everywhere. The
world stands
ready to join us inrebuilding our nation and restoring what has
been lost,
once our peace andfreedom are re-established.
May God
bless Zimbabwe.
Morgan Tsvangirai
President MDC
Statement
issued by theMovement for Democratic Change July 22 2008
Karadzic arrest puts spotlight on new tribunals
Associated Press
By
ARTHUR MAX - 33 minutes ago
AMSTERDAM, Netherlands (AP) - The former
president of Liberia is on trial. A
vice president of Congo is in custody.
The former leaders of Cambodia are in
the dock. And a key figure in the
Bosnia war is now in custody.
It all seemed impossible 15 years ago, when
the creation of the first war
crimes tribunal since World War II was being
discussed.
The arrest Monday of Radovan Karadzic, the alleged architect
of Bosnia's
bloody 1992-95 war and of Europe's first genocide since the
Holocaust,
highlights the long path to create a system of international
justice, with
its successes and its many teething problems.
Karadzic,
the leader of Bosnian Serbs during the war, evaded arrest for 13
years after
he was indicted for the massacre of 8,000 Muslims in the
U.N.-declared safe
zone of Srebrenica in 1995 and other alleged atrocities.
Since the
creation in 1993 of the International Criminal Tribunal for the
former
Yugoslavia, an array of war crimes courts have sprung up, all with
the
declared purpose of punishing the leaders, instigators and planners of
mass
crime in times of conflict.
Dozens of people, mainly ethnic Serbs from
the former Yugoslavia and Hutus
from Rwanda, have been convicted.
In
the process, the courts have refined international law.
Heads of state
are no longer immune. General amnesties are no longer
accepted unquestioned.
Using children in war is outlawed. Rape has been
defined as a weapon of war,
and abusing women or forcing them into marriage
are punishable crimes.
Looting and plunder - the age-old prize for
warriors - adds prison
time.
"The cornerstone has been laid for another 100 years worth of
jurisprudence,
which has faced down this beast of impunity that has nibbled
on the edges of
civilization for a century," said David Crane, a law
professor at Syracuse
University and the then-U.N. prosecutor who indicted
former Liberian
President Charles Taylor for his role in West Africa's
upheavals.
The threat of prosecution also is meant to deter others. That
goal has been
met, with measured success.
Michael Scharf was working
for the State Department during the debate over
creation of the Yugoslav
tribunal by the U.N. Security Council. He says most
of his colleagues
believed it would be a symbolic court that pursued only
low-ranking
officials and soldiers.
"People are really beginning to think of these
tribunals as an effective
deterrent. That is just now happening," said
Scharf, director of the
Frederick K. Cox International Law Center at Case
Western Reserve
University.
Ethnic slaughter still rages in Sudan's
Darfur region and Congo, and
conflicts continue in a dozen other places -
from Iraq to Sri Lanka to
Colombia to the Middle East.
But both
Scharf and Crane believe the risk of prosecution was a factor that
prompted
a settlement in Kenya's election crisis this year and in the
promise by
Zimbabwean President Robert Mugabe to end a campaign of violence
against his
political opponents.
"Mugabe is hearing the footsteps behind him," said
Crane.
The tribunals are still in development.
Judges presiding at
the trial of former Yugoslav President Slobodan
Milosevic allowed him to
manipulate and delay the proceedings - until he
dropped dead in his jail
cell of a heart attack in his trial's fifth year in
2006.
The case
against former Congolese warlord Thomas Lubanga, the first to go
before the
new International Criminal Court, was on the verge of collapse
because of
contradicting rules that let the prosecutor keep some evidence
confidential
while also requiring that he turn over all material that could
help the
defense. The judges are working on a compromise that will allow the
trial to
begin.
But the most serious flaw in the tribunals is outside the
courtroom: They
may be instruments of justice, but they are creatures of
politics.
The long delay in arresting Karadzic and his top military
commander, Gen.
Ratko Mladic, who is still a fugitive, is largely seen as a
deliberate
political act by the Serbian government.
"There is a
change of political will" in Belgrade, said Florence Hartmann,
the longtime
aide of former Yugoslav tribunal prosecutor Carla Del Ponte.
Karadzic's
arrest came only after the previous government was ousted in
elections.
"Europe has changed its mind and convinced Belgrade that it was
the best way
to go, and I think together they have made a big step,"
Hartmann
said.
Africa provides more illustrations. Leaders on the continent barely
criticized the killings and beatings during Zimbabwe's disputed elections
and refused to call Mugabe to account. Sudanese President Omar Al-Bashir was
defended by his peers after the chief prosecutor of the International
Criminal Court linked him to genocide in Darfur and asked for his
arrest.
"It always boils down to politics," Crane said. "The legal
aspects may be
relatively clear, but turning over senior government
officials or a head of
state is purely a political
decision."
Associated Press writer Gaelle Faure in Paris contributed to
this report.
July 22nd, 2008 at 7:38 am
I live just across the border in neighboring South Africa, and our feeling here is that the ‘agreement’ signed yesterday is yet another sham by the Vampire of Harare to stay in power for as long as possible.
Mugabe knows, as do we, that if he should hand power over to the legitimate leader of Zimbabwe, Morgan Tsvangirai, then its as good as a one way ticket for him to a nice jail cell - where his thugs tortured and murdered thousands during his 28 years of evil and corrupt rule. At least, for now, he can still live in the lap of luxury while his people still starve or are beaten up by his security forces.
I don’t trust that terrorist, and I never will. Poor decent Tsvangirai is the latest victim to be sucked into his trap. And Thabo Mbeki is yet another one to fall prey to the vampire…
Remember, a leopard never changes its spots. Only the spot it sits on.