The Times
July 7, 2007
Jan
Raath in Harare
President Mugabe has ordered petrol stations to slash the
price of fuel by
70 per cent in a desperate bid to bring down the world's
highest rate of
inflation. Mr Mugabe ordered the price of fuel to be cut to
18p per litre,
as his politburo announced plans to "tighten and intensify"
price controls.
Shops have already been ordered to reduce prices as the
President seeks to
beat hyper-inflation that he fears may spark civil unrest
and drive him from
power.
State radio called on the movement of war
veterans - a reserve unit of the
armed forces made up of former guerillas
who fought to end white rule more
than 25 years ago - the youth militia and
the women's league of Mr Mugabe's
ZANU(PF) party, to report to party
headquarters. Observers believe that the
groups have been summoned to
support trade inspectors, police and state
secret agents in enforcing the
price cuts.
Supermarkets, shops and warehouses are being forced to sell
produce at
prices far below the cost of replacing stock. The operation has
been
accompanied by state-approved looting as hungry Zimbabweans,
impoverished by
Mr Mugabe's ruinous economic policies, loaded cheap goods -
which were often
resold on the black market the same day at far higher
prices.
Lawyers have denounced the forced price cuts as illegal, while
many
businessmen have been arrested for failing to comply. "It's all by
edict in
the state press," said one lawyer who asked not to be named. "And
even if
they did make it official, it would be in violation of the
Constitution, for
depriving people unlawfully of their property. It is
legalised looting and
legalised theft."
Mr Mugabe's onslaught is seen
as a response to repeated forecasts that
Zimbabwe's wild inflation will
bring the economy to a halt within six months
and cause civil upheaval that
will drive him from power.
"Mugabe is taking these forecasts very
seriously," John Makumbe, a political
commentator, said. "But he thinks he
can bring down inflation by
manipulating it manually. He doesn't realise it
will rocket even higher. It's
unbelievable." Yesterday, traders in the
capital's predominantly Indian
business area had placed detachable
steel-grilled gates outside their shop
doors, ready to be shut at short
notice.
Shortly after dawn, hundreds of cars began queuing at service
stations in
the city, after state radio announced that fuel would have to be
sold at
$Zim 55,000 (about 18p) per litre. It had been selling for $Zim
180,000 per
litre. "This is going to be a very short honeymoon," John
Robertson, an
economist, said. "There will be no fuel to be had anywhere in
the country by
the middle of next week. That will bring an end to all
business activity. A
shutdown of the entire country is coming. In a week's
time, people are going
to be struggling to find food."
Mr Mugabe told
supporters that any businesses that halted production because
of the price
cuts would be forcibly nationalised. "We are saying to all
factory owners
'you must produce'," Mr Mugabe said. "If you don't produce,
we certainly
will seize the factories."
Losing control
- Inflation for May was
announced to be 4,500 per cent, although economists
say that the real figure
is closer to 10,000 per cent
- The movement of war veterans, the youth
militia and the women's league of
Zanu (PF) have been used repeatedly to
crush dissent, and to drive 5,000
white farmers from their farms
International Herald Tribune
The Associated PressPublished: July 6,
2007
HARARE, Zimbabwe: Hundreds of war veterans and ruling party
militiamen and
loyalists summoned by President Robert Mugabe arrived by the
busload at his
party headquarters for a meeting Friday as government-ordered
price cuts
spurred mounting chaos in the economy.
The unusual call on
state radio to veterans of the guerrilla war that swept
Mugabe to power and
ended colonial rule in 1980 came amid fears they would
be called on to
enforce the price cuts. Veterans and youth militias, known
as Green Bombers
for their green denim uniforms, were the main participants
in the chaotic
and bloody seizures of thousands of white-owned commercial
farms that began
in 2000.
The radio said the loyalists were required Friday for
discussions on
economic policies at a meeting of the party's central
committee headed by
Mugabe.
The radio also said the ruling party was
to discuss ways to "tighten and
intensify" price controls, saying the
government made available toll free
telephone hot lines for callers to
report shopkeepers and businesses in
breach of its prices edict.
Last
week, the government ordered sweeping price cuts of around 50 percent
to
curb inflation and stop profiteering and overcharging by businesses.
Price
inspectors and police have raided stories, warehouses and gas stations
to
enforce the order, as the falling prices caused stampedes, panic buying
and
near-riots by impoverished Zimbabweans. At least two store managers have
been hospitalized, one with a broken jaw, when they tried to restrain crowds
grabbing reduced items from the shelves.
Long lines of cars waited at
gas stations still selling scarce fuel Friday
after Industry Minister Obert
Mpofu warned fuel company staff they faced
arrest and seizure of their fuel
stocks if the price of gasoline was not
slashed by more than half from
immediate effect.
At least two gas stations in Harare sold out and shut down
by mid afternoon,
uncertain when they would reopen.
Mpofu ordered
them to sell gasoline at 60,000 Zimbabwe dollars to the liter,
state radio
reported. Oil industry executives said in meetings with the
government they
argued that minimum "cost recovery" on buying gas and
distributing it in the
landlocked nation now stood at about 130,000 Zimbabwe
dollars a
liter.
The new government price translates to US$4 (?2.94) a liter (about
US$8, ?6
a gallon) at the official exchange rate or 46 U.S. cents (33 euro
cents) a
liter (about US$180 or ?1.30 a gallon) at the dominant black market
exchange
rate. The fuel industry price for providing a liter to the pumps is
US$8.66
(?6.36) at the official rate and US$1 (73 euro cents) at the more
realistic
unofficial rate.
"It looks like the country will run dry in
the next few days and everything
could come to a standstill. It doesn't make
sense," said one fuel industry
executive. He asked not to be identified for
fear of retaliation from ruling
party militants.
In the week since
the government ordered sweeping price cuts most shops have
run out of the
cornmeal staple, bread, meat, salt, sugar and other basic
foodstuffs. Some
smaller shops have closed. Shelves were bare of basic foods
across the
capital.
Official inflation is running at 4,500 percent, the highest in
the world,
though independent financial institutions estimate real inflation
is closer
to 9,000 percent.
Mpofu, the industry minister, said the
excessive price of gasoline raised
the prices of all goods and services and
said fuel found being sold at above
the new price would be forfeited to the
state and suppliers faced
prosecution, the state radio reported
Friday.
The government on Thursday banned bulk storage of foodstuffs and
extended
price cuts to consumer goods, mobile phone charges, fares on the
state
airline and car spares.
Bustling shoppers swarmed into a
downtown shoe store Friday and congestion
on the mobile phone networks made
local call connections almost impossible.
State radio said the ruling
party's politburo, its highest policy making
body, met Thursday and
commended the new government task force on prices for
bringing down the cost
of living.
Reuters
Fri 6 Jul 2007,
11:37 GMT
By MacDonald Dzirutwe
HARARE (Reuters) - Zimbabwe
President Robert Mugabe on Friday told
manufacturers to carry on with normal
production despite an official price
freeze, warning that his government
would seize firms that stopped producing
basic goods.
Mugabe was
addressing thousands of ruling ZANU-PF party supporters in
Harare, some who
had earlier marched through Zimbabwe's capital in support
of the freeze
introduced to curb the world's highest inflation rate of over
4,500
percent.
The march came ahead of a ZANU-PF party meeting to adopt
tougher measures
against firms defying the freeze, which was introduced last
week when the
government ordered businesses to put prices back to June 18
levels.
The move, which sparked frenzied buying from shoppers, came after
prices of
some goods tripled within a week.
"This is no joke ...
there are some people who think this (freeze) will not
succeed because they
say there are empty shelves," Mugabe told supporters at
the ZANU-PF national
headquarters in Harare.
"We are saying to all factory owners you must
produce. If you don't produce
we certainly will seize the factories," Mugabe
said to loud cheers from
supporters.
Spiralling prices and soaring
inflation are part of an eight-year economic
crisis that has caused foreign
currency, fuel and food shortages. Economists
say the price freeze would
decimate what remains of Zimbabwe's struggling
industry as manufacturers
will not be able to produce goods at a loss.
The veteran Zimbabwe leader
said his government was still not satisfied with
current price levels,
adding that he wanted even lower prices to cushion
people from
inflation.
"PRICE FREEZE LEGAL"
Mugabe again accused businesses of
raising prices as part of a wider plot by
former colonial power Britain to
remove him from power and rejected
suggestions that the price freeze was
illegal.
He said Zimbabweans should alert a special unit of police, army
and
intelligence operatives formed to enforce price controls of businesses
hoarding or unfairly increasing prices.
More than 200 business
people, including a ZANU-PF senator, have been
arrested for ignoring the ban
on price hikes.
Mugabe supporters had earlier marched from ZANU-PF's
Harare provincial
office to its national headquarters where the 83-year-old
leader was to
preside over a meeting of the party's powerful central
committee.
Carrying placards and clad in party regalia, the marchers
chanted songs
extolling Mugabe and denouncing firms for profiteering,
temporarily bringing
downtown business to a halt.
"Mugabe is right,
down with economic saboteurs" read one placard while
another said "No to
profiteering".
The central committee meeting on Friday is expected to
adopt tougher
measures to crack down on defiant businesses and extend
products covered by
the freeze.
The price controls cover basic goods
such as maize meal, sugar, salt, bread,
beef, rentals and were on Friday
extended to fuel.
Reuters
Fri 6 Jul
2007, 9:44 GMT
By MacDonald Dzirutwe
HARARE (Reuters) - Hundreds
of President Robert Mugabe's supporters marched
through Zimbabwe's capital
on Friday in support of an official price freeze
introduced to curb the
world's highest inflation rate of over 4,500 percent.
The march was
planned ahead of a ruling ZANU-PF party meeting to adopt
tougher measures
against firms defying the freeze, which was introduced last
week when the
government ordered businesses to put prices back to June 18
levels.
The move, which sparked frenzied buying from shoppers, came
after prices of
some goods tripled within a week.
Mugabe has accused
businesses of raising prices as part of a wider plot by
former colonial
power Britain to remove him from power. He has warned his
government could
seize and nationalise companies that do not adhere to the
freeze.
Spiralling prices and soaring inflation are part of an
eight-year economic
crisis that has caused foreign currency, fuel and food
shortages. Economists
say the price freeze would decimate what remains of
Zimbabwe's struggling
industry as manufacturers will not be able to continue
to produce goods at a
loss.
The government has formed a special unit
of police and intelligence
operatives to enforce the price freeze, saying
this would protect suffering
consumers, and has also arrested more than 200
business people, including a
ZANU-PF senator, accused of ignoring the ban on
price hikes.
On Friday hundreds of Mugabe supporters marched from
ZANU-PF's Harare
provincial office to its national headquarters where the
veteran leader was
to preside over a meeting of the party's powerful central
committee.
Carrying placards and clad in party regalia, the marchers
chanted songs
extolling Mugabe and denouncing firms for profiteering,
temporarily bringing
downtown business to a halt.
"Mugabe is right,
down with economic saboteurs" read one placard while
another said "No to
profiteering". The supporters were expected to be
addressed by Mugabe later
in the day.
On Friday the central committee was expected to adopt tougher
measures to
crack down on defiant businesses and extend products covered by
the freeze.
The price freeze has been effected on basic goods such as
maize meal, sugar,
salt, bread, beef, rentals and was on Friday extended to
fuel.
On Thursday, the ZANU-PF politiburo discussed measures to further
tighten
price controls but this would need to be endorsed by the central
committee.
The government has set up hotlines encouraging consumers to
report cases of
overpricing or hoarding but some basic goods have already
disappeared from
shop shelves.
Yahoo News
HARARE (AFP) - At least 20 Zimbabwean children have died
over the past two
weeks after an outbreak of diarrhoea hit the southern town
of Kadoma,
reports said Friday.
"The town has been hit by an outbreak
of diarrhoea over the past two weeks,
but we worked hard to isolate ecoli
(bacteria) and we can now safely say the
situation is under control," the
state-run Herald newspaper quoted
provincial medical director for
Mashonaland West Wenseslaus Nyamayaro as
saying.
The report said the
outbreak, which has also affected some adults, was
caused by a shortage of
potable water in the town which is faced with
perennial water problems due
to limited pumping capacities.
Kadoma, which is located 140 kilometres
(88 miles) south of the capital, has
a population of about 800,000
people.
Gear Hanyani, the public relations manager for Kadoma said they
had made
some progress in improving the situation.
"We have tried to
increase access to water by putting water bowsers in
residential areas with
the support of UNICEF and other non-governmental
organisations," he
said.
Hanyani said council was making sure every household gets at least
20 litres
of water on a daily basis.
The daily quoted some residents
from the farming and gold mining town as
saying the water problem has not
been given due attention for a long time.
There was no immediate comment
from the provincial health authority or the
health ministry in Harare.
He first joined the CIO after being approached at one of the
country's notorious National Youth Service Training Camps. One day, four guys came, driving a black Mercedes-Benz. They put us in
a classroom and said they were from the Central Intelligence. I was afraid, because if you're me, and you don't know about the
secret service, all you know is that it protects the sovereignty of your country
- it's not a difficult job to do. I wanted a little bit of income. I said: 'Yes'. During training, we were told we were going to learn what they
called 'torture techniques.' Everyone was given a cup of gin. We were put into a room with no
doors and windows and had to start smoking marijuana. All of a sudden, a man was put in the room for 'random beating'
- where you beat someone haphazardly, no-one really takes charge. You just beat
him. At first the guy was blocking. But we kept on kicking and
assaulting him. After he started bleeding, we stopped. They said: 'Why are you stopping?' So we had to keep on beating
him. Then they gave us some pills - I'm not sure what they were, but after I
took them I had this rage. Pliers or screwdrivers Then another guy was brought in. They said he was a cattle
rustler who had been sentenced to 35 years in prison.
His feet turned black. When we removed him, he couldn't walk. He
just fell down and collapsed. Then a third guy came in. They said this guy had raped and
killed a 13-year-old girl. We were told to apply electronic shocking.
We poured some water on him, and then each one of us applied the
shock. That was it. By the time we left, he smelled of burnt meat. He just fell
down on his face. The fourth guy, we weren't told why he was brought in. A first
aid box was opened - and inside were pliers and screwdrivers. We asked the man
to choose between the two. Our captain attacked his ears with the pliers, pinching a piece
out of it. He started bleeding heavily. He then reached into the box, took the
sellotape, and put it over the man's mouth so that he couldn't make any noise.
You could only see tears. The captain then took the pliers and called us near. He got near
his genitals, then got one of his balls, pressed it with the pliers, and popped
it. There was a lot of blood. Later, we were told to do an operation called 'construction.'
We were told to go to Kariba with a parcel in the trunk of the
car. We were not told what was in the parcel, and we were not to open it. We
were given some money and drove out. Then we heard movement in the trunk. There was some kind of a
man's voice. We all panicked and tried to look for the keys to open the trunk.
But then we discovered that there was no key. We checked the
instructions we had been given, and they said we had to drive to the river -
where we would find a speedboat tied to a tree, a bag of cement, and the key to
the trunk. When we got there, we found the speedboat - and there was also a
new set of instructions and the key. We opened the trunk before reading the new
instructions, and saw there was a man inside. Haunted His hands were cut and he was bleeding heavily. His head was
soaked with blood. He couldn't say anything, because his tongue had been cut
out.
I said: 'I'm not doing it.' But Alexander said: 'Look behind
you.' I looked, and there was somebody in the tree wearing camouflage.
So we took the bag of cement and mixed it. Then we started
putting it in the trunk. We tried to shut the trunk, but we could not because the man's
head was partially outside. We put the trunk in the boat. We drove 50 metres into the river.
We came back in the boat, without the trunk. I have a guilty conscience. The things I have done haunt me
every day. Every night I cry myself to sleep. "John" now lives outside Zimbabwe. Parts of his story cannot
be verified because of the difficulty of reporting from Zimbabwe.
International Crisis Group Zim Online The Herald VOA VOA Sokwanele Article: 6
July 2007 The Robert Mugabe regime continues to turn logic on its
head in its desperate efforts to stay in power. In trying to avert street
protests over its management of the economy, the regime has decreed a slash in
prices of up to fifty percent for all businesses. Officially, the regime says
business must revert to prices that were current on 18 June 2007. Businesses in
Zimbabwe operate on a replacement costing basis; which means they factor in
inflation and estimate what it will cost them to replace stock, and price their
goods on at basis. The logic is simple enough: if they do not do this, they will
be the cheapest in town for a week or a month, but their businesses will go bust
shortly thereafter. Businesses
have been forced into replacement costing because of the hyperinflationary
conditions brought about by a regime that prints money on a daily basis in
defiance of "bookish economics." All businesses are affected because all of them
have two major components in their expense budgets: salaries and fuel.
Fuel is
imported and anyone who wants it has to pay the price that the seller is
offering. This means that a baker, for instance, who faces daily power cuts in
his bakery or supermarket, is forced to use large quantities of diesel to power
his ovens. So that pushes his cost of production up. In the meantime, his
employees have to contend with rising costs of transport to get to work because
the transport operators logically pass on the high cost of...fuel! Spending up to
$400 000 a week to get to work is far beyond the salary of a bakery employee
when he has to feed his family, pay rent, let alone school fees on top of his
transport costs. So the employee either stays at home and ekes out a living
selling vegetables, or asks his bakery employer to pay him a higher wage. When
the baker has added up all of these expenses, he has to sell his bread at a
price that allows him to replace the flour, pay the employee, and replace the
diesel at a 'guesstimate'. The Robert
Mugabe regime calls this 'economic sabotage' drawn up in London and Washington.
The baker simply wants to run his business, the employee simply wants a job so
he can look after his family, and the customers simply want their daily bread.
The Robert Mugabe regime wants them to eat dust. The result of their umpteenth
ill-conceived intervention in the economy is exactly that: dusty shelves in the
supermarkets with little or no product. That is not
all, however, because that would not be much fun. As stated earlier, the
official instruction is for businesses to revert to June 18 prices and posses of
men from the President's Office are arriving at supermarket doors and factory
gates to ensure compliance with this directive. At the same time, there is a
parallel group made up of militias that arrives at the same premises hours later
- usually just before close of business - and orders the business people to sell
everything at 50% of the prices. By strange
coincidence, a mob is always at hand to empty the shelves within minutes, taking
advantage of the bargain basement 18 June prices. When store managers resist,
they are threatened with violence. The results? A bourgeoning black market, and
empty fridges and shelves in supermarkets right across the country. In the
meantime, public transporters who cannot be effectively monitored are still
charging current prices. Workers are demanding more money in order to be able to
get to work and employers have no choice but to comply thereby increasing their
expenses in the process. Manufacturing
is operating at a third of its capacity, the lowest since Independence, mining
has lost 40 000 skilled employees in the last ten years, nurses cannot make it
to work, and the education and health infrastructure has all but crumbled. In
the midst of all this, the minister of mis-information, the comical Sikhanyiso
Ndlovu, tells Zimbabweans that the economy has never been better because nobody
could have managed this economy better than Robert Mugabe. Robert Mugabe
has a habit of issuing decrees before jetting off to an admittedly increasingly
smaller number of exotic destinations available to him. It was hoped the acting
Vice President would see reason and mitigate the effects of a heroes
acre-induced decree. Alas, it was not to be. The Vice President simply declared:
comply or close shop. We do not give a damn. That is
Zanu-PF logic for you. Even more baffling, is the international logic that
Robert Mugabe should be invited to summits where he can pontificate about
capital. Visit our website at
www.sokwanele.com We have a fundamental right to freedom of expression!
Sokwanele does not endorse the editorial policy of any source or website
except its own. It retains full copyright on its own articles, which may be
reproduced or distributed but may not be materially altered in any way.
Reproduced articles must clearly show the source and owner of copyright,
together with any other notices originally contained therein, as well as the
original date of publication. Sokwanele does not accept responsibility for any
loss or damage arising in any way from receipt of this email or use thereof.
This document, or any part thereof, may not be distributed for
profit. S.O.A.P. (Supporting Old Age
Pensioners) New Zimbabwe Afrol News
6 July 2007 Business Day Please send any material for publication in the Open Letter Forum to
Friday, 6 July
2007, 12:39 GMT 13:39 UK
"John" - not
his real name - is a former agent of Zimbabwe's Central Intelligence
Organisation, who claims he fled the country after being forced to kill a man in
by drowning him in a cement-filled trunk.
He was put on a
desk, and we were given rubber and sticks to beat his feet.
We knew what the
envelope would say before we opened it.
Zimbabwe: Is There Any Way Out?, Gareth
Evans
Notes for Panel Presentation by Gareth Evans, President, International
Crisis Group, to Royal Commonwealth Society Conference, Zimbabwe: Preparing
for Change, London, 2 July
2007
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The
Bad News
Zimbabwe is not fertile ground for optimists:
a.. The
internal situation is catastrophic, with the country's economy in
freefall
and its people suffering grievously. Economists are putting current
inflation rates at 9,000 per cent or worse. Over 80 per cent of the
population of some 12 million is living below the poverty line, and 80 per
cent is unemployed. The economy as a whole has shrunk dramatically in recent
years and has a current growth rate of negative 4.4 per cent. Health
indicators are equally depressing. Life expectancy has dropped below 40
years for both men and women, and the prevalence rate of HIV/AIDS in adults
hovers around one in five. And the last four months have seen the
government embark on another brutal campaign of state-sponsored violence
against opposition groups and their supporters.
b.. The internal
opposition is fragmented. The opposition MDC is trying
to coordinate a
common front but remains split between two wings and both
strategically and
tactically less effective as a result. The ZANU-PF is
internally divided
with a numerically strong anti-Mugabe faction led by the
Majurus, but the
debacle in the Central Committee immediately after the
SADC meeting in
late March, when Mugabe rammed through a resolution
supporting his running
again as President in 2008, showed the limits of its
strength, or
commitment, or both. There are divisions in the security
services,
reflecting the stress felt by families in every walk of life as a
result of
the economic meltdown, but these have not been enough to give
anyone
confidence that anything resembling a velvet revolution could
succeed. And
civil society organizations continue to struggle to exercise
any influence
at all on the course of events.
c.. External pressure remains ineffective.
International sanctions are
shrugged off, with general economic sanctions
hardly likely to make any
difference - except to further immiserise the
poor; targeted sanctions too
narrowly focused to make an impact (and with
travel bans regularly ignored,
most recently by the Portuguese presidency of
the EU with the forthcoming
EU-Africa Summit). General condemnations from
the North - especially the
UK - seem to be if anything counterproductive,
fuelling Mugabe's claims of
neo-imperialism: SADC leaders remain
hypersensitive to any suggestion they
are carrying out an external agenda,
in particular one imposed by Zimbabwe's
former colonial rulers. South
Africa continues to decline to use such
leverage as it has, and the regional
countries have - until very recently -
contributed nothing but support for
Mugabe's leadership.
All this means that there is little or no prospect of
Mugabe being
bludgeoned out of office in the foreseeable future - from
below, within the
country; from above, by the international community; or
from the side - by
any really coercive pressure from his regional
neighbours.
The Better News
Causes of Conflict Not Deep
Rooted
The first piece of more heartening news is that none of the causes
of
Zimbabwe's current discontents seem to have roots so deep that the
situation
cannot be quickly turned round once some decent leadership is
restored:
a.. Ethnic conflict has occurred between Ndbele and Shona in
the past, and
fears are periodically expressed that the present woes will
reignite it, but
so far remarkably little tension of this kind has
surfaced.
b.. Democracy is not something which Zimbabweans have had much
chance to
enjoy under successive regimes, but on available evidence they
appear to
have a taste for it and would hugely welcome free and fair
elections.
c.. Economic destruction has been great, but the resource base
of the
country remains strong, and with good planning and international
support,
the situation can be reasonably rapidly reversed.
d.. Land
distribution remains an emotive and divisive issue, but - even
with all the
additional problems created by Mugabe's expropriations and
reallocations -
it is not incapable of resolution, especially if generous
resources are
forthcoming from the UK and other international donors.
SADC has Engaged -
and Given Political Cover for South Africa for the First
Time
In its
March 2007 Dar es Salaam Extraordinary Summit meeting, the Southern
African
Development Community did not directly confront Mugabe, but did
finally
decide to take concrete action, mandating South African President
Thabo
Mbeki to mediate between the parties.
The first round of mediated talks
between ZANU-PF and the MDC - and the
first substantive dialogue between
them for four years - took place on 18
June, with an agenda agreed (covering
Constitution, Electoral Laws,
Repressive Legislation, and 'Political
Climate'), and a further meeting
planned for later in July. Mbeki is making
an initial progress report to the
AU Summit in Accra this week.
This
process faces significant hurdles and limitations, especially:
a.. Time
is running out to create the minimum conditions necessary for
reasonably
legitimate elections in March 2008, even with full cooperation
between the
parties - of which there is as yet no sign, with ZANU-PF bent on
proceeding
simultaneously with legislative and constitutional changes
reinforcing its
advantage
b.. The balance of power between ZANU-PF and MDC is very unequal,
making
it difficult for any mediator to obtain significant concessions
(although,
as noted below, this could be overstated: SADC has real leverage
if it
chooses to exercise it). The internal divisions within ZANU-PF
relating to
the succession have not yet translated into any fragmentation of
the
government's position vis a vis the MDC.
All that said, the SADC
development has introduced a new dynamic into a very
stalemated
process, and remains about the only game in town in terms
of moving forward.
There are essentially two levels of activity in play, or
potential play, so
far as the SADC leaders are concerned.
First, there is the overt agenda
of ensuring free and fair elections next
March, which will require:
a.. An immediate end to the repression and intimidation of the opposition,
civil society, media and legal professions, including by the repeal of the
repressive POSA and AIPPA laws;
b.. A hold on constitutional changes
aimed at strengthening ZANU-PF's
position;
c.. A fully independent
electoral commission, to replace the present
military-run body (this being
part of a larger need to demilitarise state
institutions), to prepare a new
voters roll and carry out everything
necessary to ensure a free and fair
election.
The hope is that a free and fair election would be followed,
notwithstanding
which party had the majority of seats, by a government of
national unity to
carry through all the necessary political, legal,
constitutional and
economic changes needed to stabilise the country and set
it back on the path
to recovery.
SADC's leverage in all of this is
great, if it chooses to exercise it. If
the South African mediation is
unable to achieve the outcomes necessary for
free and fair elections,
SADC
a.. can publicly state, before the elections, that the conditions
are
simply not in place for any possible outcome to be free and fair;
or
b.. after the election, refuse to certify it as free and fair.
SADC's
willingness to go down either of these paths would, if clearly
flagged in
the mediation, maximise the chances of the necessary reforms
being accepted.
The point is that Mugabe is politically very dependent on
support for his
positions from his Southern African peers: any condemnation
by them of the
electoral process would be likely to have a devastating
effect on his
credibility, and create the conditions for an effective
political move
against him. This may all be unduly optimistic, but I for one
have been
struck by the number of South African senior figures who attach
real weight
to the SADC role in this respect.
The second track in play is a behind
the scenes exercise, involving senior
SADC and other figures, to try to
negotiate a 'soft landing' for Mugabe, ie
a reasonably graceful exit
combined with assurances that he would not face
prosecution in any domestic
or international court. Present indications are
that this course has been
made very much more difficult by the removal of
Liberia's Charles Taylor to
face charges in the Sierra Leone Special Court,
notwithstanding safe refuge
assurances he had earlier been given by Nigeria's
President Obasajano in
2003 to secure an early end to threatened further
major warfare in
Monrovia. But efforts should certainly in my view - and I
believe most
Zimbabweans - continue to negotiate such a soft outcome:
sometimes the urge
for justice just has to yield to a more urgent need to
stop large scale
human suffering.
The Commonwealth's Role
a.. Political Support
for SADC. The Commonwealth's strong African and
general South membership
makes it an important source of political support,
with the November Heads
of Government meeting in Kampala a timely
opportunity for making that
clear - provided its North members are not seen
to be pushing the issue too
hard. Although there should be no question of
readmitting Zimbabwe to
Commonwealth membership until some normality in the
country is restored,
continued overt external pressure, here as elsewhere,
runs the risk of being
counterproductive.
b.. Support for Civil Society. By itself this may be
unlikely to change
the political balance in Zimbabwe, but is worth every
possible effort
nonetheless to avoid the disintegration of Zimbabwean
society under the
present stresses and to hasten the eventual return to
normality.
c.. Support in Planning and Coordinating Zimbabwe's recovery.
The
Commonwealth as an institution has particular technical expertise in
certain
areas, which should be harnessed and coordinated with the resources
of major
donors.
d.. Take a Leadership Role on the Land Issue.
-
A commitment on the part of the Commonwealth to engage on land reform
could
act as a powerful hook for Harare, which desperately needs a way out
of the
quagmire of its current land policy. To this end, the Commonwealth
Secretariat might consider establishing a working committee or a group of
Eminent Persons, tasked with exploring options for land reform in Zimbabwe,
mediating between Harare and the international community, and finding a
settlement on the land question that will allow international donors to
reengage on the issue and is acceptable to key stakeholders.
- The
grouping's African members could include both SADC and non-SADC
countries:
South Africa, Tanzania and Botswana (SADC countries and regional
stakeholders), Kenya (as a useful case study of a viable post-colonial land
settlement), and perhaps Ghana. It could be composed of former high-level
decision-makers, as well as officials with technical expertise. The
recommendations generated by such a body, composed predominantly but not
exclusively of African countries, might well carry weight with Zimbabwe,
allow the British to remain quietly engaged and overcome some of the
constraints that prevent SADC member states from addressing land
reform.
- Ultimately, the land issue must be resolved by Zimbabweans
themselves.
As Crisis Group has argued in a book-length report on the
subject, the
logical first step in moving the land process forward during a
transition
period would be to establish a Land Commission, with a clear
mandate, a
strong technocratic base and representing a large cross-section
of
Zimbabwean stakeholders. The responsibilities of the Land Commission
would
include conducting a comprehensive inventory of land, mediating claims
on
the ground, developing a compensation formula and so on. But a
Commonwealth
committee of the kind suggested would provide important
political and
technical support to Zimbabwe's own land reform
efforts.
Watching Zimbabwe's decline and fall has been one of the most
dispiriting
experiences of modern times. There are no easy ways out of the
abyss in
which the country now finds itself. But hopefully sustained,
carefully
modulated commitment by the international community - with the
Commonwealth
and its member countries playing a particularly important role
in this
respect - can and will make a difference.
SADC secretary in Harare for crisis talks over
economy
Saturday 07 July 2007
By
Tsungai Murandu
HARARE - Southern African Development Community (SADC)
executive secretary
Tomaz Salomao jetted into Harare on Thursday for
economic crisis talks with
Zimbabwean authorities as business conditions
worsened in the country.
Authoritative government sources said the SADC
chief yesterday briefed
officials from the ministries of finance and
international trade on a
proposed regional initiative to bail out Zimbabwe
and was expected to meet
Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe (RBZ) governor Gideon Gono
later on Friday.
"The visit is a follow-up to a similar mission in April
and this time around
the executive secretary sounded out Zimbabwean
officials on the rescue
package being proposed by SADC," said a senior
Ministry of Finance official,
who spoke on condition he was not
named.
Although finer details of the proposed package were not available,
it is
believed that the bail-out plan included support to build Zimbabwe's
foreign
exchange reserves.
SADC leaders mandated Salomao in March to
study Zimbabwe's economic crisis
and propose a rescue package for the
country.
During his visit in April, the SADC chief also met members of
the diplomatic
community stationed in Harare.
Zimbabwe's economic
problems have worsened since Salomao's last visit,
characterised by
world-record inflation now pegged at more than 4 500
percent but believed by
independent experts to be much higher.
Salamao's latest visit coincided
with a blitz on prices by the Harare
authorities that has spawned critical
shortages of basic commodities and
other goods.
The government last
week froze prices of all commodities following a spate
of price hikes that
had seen prices of basic goods rising by more than 500
percent in the space
of just three weeks.
Soldiers and police have since last week raided
several shops in Harare to
force owners to lower prices. At least 194
retailers have been arrested for
defying the order to lower prices while
President Robert Mugabe, who charges
business is conniving with his Western
enemies to hike prices and incite
popular revolt, has threatened to seize
factories and shops that fail to
lower prices.
Several companies are
reported to have closed down shop, warning that the
government order on
business to roll back prices to June 18 levels was
hitting hardest the same
workers who were supposed to benefit from lowered
prices. - ZimOnline
Thousands Laid Off As Shops Close Due to Price Freeze Anarchy
SW
Radio Africa (London)
6 July 2007
Posted to the web 6 July
2007
Tererai Karimakwenda
The ongoing government campaign to
monitor prices and arrest those who do
not comply has resulted in thousands
of workers being laid off as businesses
shut down around the country. After
being forced by the authorities to
reduce their prices by 50% last week,
many businesses ran out of stock
within days. They have not reordered
fearing further losses and this has
meant nothing to do for the workers.
Bulawayo businessman Eddie Cross said
the large manufacturer National Foods
has laid off all its casual workers.
Unfortunately the situation there is
being duplicated around the country.
All butchers in Bulawayo have closed
their doors and workers were sent home.
Our contacts on the ground say it
is difficult to tell who is in charge of
this Operation that has been dubbed
"Operation Dzikamai" (Operation be
calm). Some shops say they were raided by
armed police and others by plain
clothes intelligence or Prison Officers. On
Friday Eddie Cross's shop was
monitored by a team from the local police.
Cross described the situation as
anarchy. He said one owner of a petrol
station who dared to challenge the
authority of the team that raided him was
shown a loaded pistol and told:
"This is my authority."
Cross
said the police are also helping themselves to some of the goods in
the
shops. At one location they removed the shoppers then shut the doors and
picked out items that they wanted. They then paid for the goods in cash at
50% of the price. Cross said the informal sector and small businesses are
suffering the most. The police are confiscating goods from street vendors
selling vegetables and tomatoes and storing all of it in a warehouse at the
Bulawayo police station. According to Cross there will be an auction at the
warehouse on Saturday.
NCA Says 12 Activists Arrested During Marondera Workshop
SW Radio
Africa (London)
6 July 2007
Posted to the web 6 July 2007
Lance
Guma
The National Constitutional Assembly has issued a statement
saying 12 of its
activists were arrested in Marondera on Thursday during a
grassroots gender
workshop. All were said to be detained at Marondera Police
station. NCA
field officer Dasly Kagwambo and 11 others were at the centre
of the latest
police crackdown. At the time of broadcast Newsreel had been
unable to
verify if the activists had been released or not.
In
another incident Alois Dzvairo who is the NCA National Youth Chairperson
was
arrested in Gweru, again on Thursday before being released Friday. The
NCA
says no charges were placed on him but that he was severely assaulted.
On
Friday the pressure group says Elisha Makuyana, the NCA Regional
Chairperson
for Manicaland, was allegedly abducted by unknown people,
suspected to be
state security agents.
Load-shedding set to
increase
Friday, July 06, 2007
Herald Reporter
Zesa holdings has announced an increase
in load-shedding due to reduced
power generation at Hwange Power
Station.
In a statement, Zesa Holdings said this has been sparked by
limited coal
deliveries from Hwange Colliery Company following a series of
breakdowns on
their coal conveyer plant.
The power utility, however,
said coal deliveries had since resumed but added
that increased
load-shedding, which started on July 2 this year, would
continue.
"As
soon as there is enough coal stocks, Zimbabwe Power Company will
increase
generation at Hwange Power Station," read part of the statement.
Zesa
Holdings also apologised to Harare residents in Highlands, Lewisam,
Greendale and Mandara who had gone for up to two days without power owing to
underground cable faults.
Zesa technicians were working flat out to
restore supplies in the areas, the
statement added.
The breakdown of
the coal crusher and conveyer belt at the colliery last
month almost
paralysed operations at the power station, resulting in many
parts of
Zimbabwe being plunged into darkness.
Power cuts have been a cause of
concern for many urbanites who are being
ripped off by firewood traders who
overcharge, taking advantage of the
situation.
Zimbabwe Crisis Talks Resume But Some Civic Groups Question
Use
By Patience Rusere and Carole Gombakomba
Washington
06 July 2007
Mediated crisis resolution talks
between Zimbabwe's ruling party and the two
factions of its political
opposition were scheduled to resume Saturday in
Pretoria, following a review
of progress by regional leaders during the
recent African Union
summit.
Participants were tight-lipped, but sources in the Movement for
Democratic
Change faction of Morgan Tsvangirai said the sides will continue
to refine
their agenda.
There were rumblings of discontentment,
meanwhile, among Zimbabwean civil
society groups, some of which want a seat
at the table while others say that
the negotiations are a waste of time and
only serve the purposes of
President Robert Mugabe.
Those in the
latter camp include National Constitutional Assembly Chairman
Lovemore
Madhuku, who told reporter Patience Rusere of VOA's Studio 7 for
Zimbabwe
that his organization has decided to wash its hands of the South
African-mediated talks.
Spokesman Gabriel Chaibva of the MDC faction
of Arthur Mutambara said the
talks are in an early stage, and that his
formation is urging civil society
to involve itself.
Elsewhere, some
church leaders say they intend to keep pushing for dialogue
with the
government in hopes of finding a resolution to the long-running
political
and, increasingly, national economic crisis in that way.
Reverend
Kupakwashe Mutata, who addressed a meeting on church-state
relations in
Harare on Thursday, said that as Zimbabwe is a largely
Christian nation it
is important for the clergy to maintain a dialogue with
politicians to ease
the people's suffering.
Mutata is a member of the Zimbabwe Council of
Churches.
Minister of State for Public and Interactive Affairs Chen
Chumitengwende was
invited to Thursday evening's meeting, but failed to show
up or send a
representative.The symposium had been called by the Mass Public
Opinion
Institute.
Mutata told reporter Carole Gombakomba that he was
disappointed
Chimutengwende did not appear, but said churches will continue
to try to
engage the government.
Zimbabwe Opposition Charges Favoritism In Voter Registration
Drive
By Jonga Kandemiiri & Thomas Chiripasi
Washington, Harare
06 July 2007
The Zimbabwean
opposition has accused the country's registrar general of
tilting the
electoral playing field nine months ahead of national elections
by sending
the lion's share of mobile registration units to provinces
dominated by the
ruling party.
The Movement for Democratic Change faction led by MDC
founder Morgan
Tsvangirai cited imbalances in the distribution of voter
registration units
and charged that this was by design to register more
voters in areas
controlled by the ruling ZANU-PF party and leave voters
unregistered in
parts of the country where the MDC is strong.
MDC
sources said Mashonaland East with 11 constituencies has been allocated
470
mobile registration centers. Mashonaland West with 10 constituencies was
allocated 379 while Mashonaland Central with 10 constituencies was given 335
centers.
All three Mashonaland Provinces are dominated by Zanu
PF.
By comparison, Harare-Chitungwiza Province, with 18 constituencies,
has been
allocated 79 just registration centers, while Masvingo with 14
constituencies has 259 and Manicaland with 16 constituencies has been
allocated 264 centers.
The government launched a nationwide mobile
registration exercise last
month, dispatching units around the country to
register new voters or
re-register those who had moved, and to provide
identity cards to those
lacking them.
The opposition says many
would-be voters have been unable to register
because they lack national
identification cards, but that registration teams
in certain areas said they
could not issue the documents because they did
not have film for ID
photos.
Elections Secretary Ian Makone of the Tsvangirai opposition
faction told
reporter Jonga Kandemiiri of VOA's Studio 7 for Zimbabwe that
his party is
seeking a meeting with Zimbabwean Registrar General Tobaiwa
Mudede to
express its concerns.
Elsewhere, the opposition ZANU Ndonga
party said it won't field a candidate
in next year's presidential election
but will throw its support behind
Tsvangirai.
Correspondent Thomas
Chiripasi reported from Harare.
Zanu PF 'price wars'
creates shortages and more hardship in Zimbabwe
PROMOTING NON-VIOLENT PRINCIPLES TO ACHIEVE
DEMOCRACY
Visit our blog: This is Zimbabwe
(Sokwanele blog)
Send an e-card!
www.sokwanele.com/sendcard/
Support of Old Age Pensioners - inflation update July 07
Tel: 242455 Louise
Campbell/242486 Dave
Gill
P. O.
Box AC 646 ASCOT
BULAWAYO,
ZIMBABWE
E-MAILS:
soap@netconnect.co.zw
scallywags@netconnect.co.zw
Dear
Friends,
I can only say chaos rules. Last week there was a
government
directive that many goods should be reduced by at least 50%
irrespective of
what the retailer paid for them. This included Mazoe orange,
fuel, soap,
beef and bread amongst other things. Fuel was given a new price
of $50,000
petrol and $60,000 diesel per litre, this was selling at around
$130,000 per
litre. Beef which was around $400,000 per kilo had to be reduced
to 90,000
whether it was stew beef or fillet. Teams went round the shops
ordering
instant price reductions and the retailer had to sell all stock at
that
price, including whatever was held in the storerooms.A relative who has
two
butcheries paid $350,00 a kg for beef last week he now has to sell it
for
$90,000, chickens cost him $240,000 they have to be sold for $120,000
each.
The result? Bread, fuel, beef and many other items have now
disappeared.
Before this, last week I travelled to Botswana to buy tinned
vegetables to
include in our packs as these had not been available for some
time, one of
our benefactors supplied the fuel for the trip so no overheads
were
incurred.
Electricity supply has become very erratic, to give an
idea, here is a
typical week of load shedding for us. No power; Tuesday
1430-2000, Wednesday
0630-1330, Friday 1400-1930, Saturday 0545-1350, Sunday
0830-1300, Monday
1500-1900. If you can afford dinner you cook a one pot dish
in the morning
and then hopefully you have the means to warm it up at night,
if not, then
perhaps a sandwich, if you have bread of course. Unfortunately
you never
know how long the cut is, maybe it could last several days if it is
a fault.
For us, reasonably bearable as there is an inverter to power the
computer or
TV, a generator if the power is off for a long time (One street
was recently
off for over 5 days), also emergency lights which come on
automatically. But
look at those less fortunate. No means of cooking, heating
and a lone candle
if you can afford it for lighting. (We have started
supplying these but can
only afford to put in a couple each month) During
last months delivery I
spoke to one lady, at lunchtime her power had been off
since 6am. She had
not had anything hot to drink since the previous night.
She can't afford to
buy a flask or a paraffin stove to heat water, remember,
we are in the
middle of winter now.
One widowed railway pensioner last
month received her pension plus two
months back pay as there had been a wage
rise, the total amount received was
$155,000! This person is a diabetic, in
one month the price of insulin rose
from $1,145,000 to $6,750,000. Her
railway medical does not supply this type
of insulin so it has to be bought
separately, also, they had no heart
tablets in stock so they also had to be
bought. This is by no means an
unusual case. Luckily, this person has family
to support her, many do not.
One of our recipients age 83 was given one
months notice to quit her
cottage, luckily with the help of others she is now
safely in residence at
Coronation Cottages.
As she has no family other
than an unemployed son in Australia, Dave
volunteered to move her. Her
possessions consisted of a one plate 'stove', a
bed with no mattress, a
Formica table and two wooden chairs, one easy chair
and a wardrobe. Note, no
electric kettle, stove or refrigerator, she has no
income, previously selling
her possessions just to stay alive she is now
supported by SOAP and others
who pay her electricity, rent and rates. Is
this dignity in old age?
Just
compare the difference between now and last July remember there were
three
000's removed from the currency last August so the same basket of
goods today
is actually a staggering $2,961,746:00 more in one year, also
electricity
doesn't figure here as I removed it from the list as we haven't
had an
account since September last year. When looking at the figures below,
those
in blue are items that are now unavailable due to price
controls.
April 2006 July
2006
October2006 January 2007 April
2007
July 2007
Bread $85,000
$150,000 $295
$825
$4,000 $45,000
Milk 1Lt $70,000
$95,000 $680
$889
$6,079 $57,400
Electricity mon +/- $840,000 $1,500,000
(estimate)$5,000
(Estimate) $10,000
2ltrs Mazoe Oran
$240,000 $750,000 $1,300
$6,350
$49,000 $600,000
1 litre coke $150,000
$290,000 $1,050
$1,800
$14,000 $27,000
local stamp
$30,000 $60,000
$100
$100 $200
$3,000
500g butter
$946,000 $1,633,000 $2,640
$6,500
$49,000 $600,000
tin tuna $460,000
$580,000
$1,000 $4,150
$28,200
$235,000
100 Tea bags $140,000
$495,000 $475
$3,645
$30,125 $325,000
'phone call per unit $8,018
$18,800
$31.30 $31.30
$45
$3,022.80
kg steak mince $880,000
$1,445,000 $3,960
$15,150
$38,800 $375,000
kg stew beef $500,000
$850,000 $2,850
$11,200
$41,000 $375,000
4 toilet rolls $340,000
$810,000
$1,400 $8,560
$55,000
$325,000
$4,689,018.
$8,676,800
$20,781(000).30 $69,200.30
$315,449
$2,970,422.80
It only remains to say thank you to each
and everyone of you who continue
support and help 'our' pensioners.. Today
is interview day of more likely
recipients, this can be a harrowing
experience, meeting once proud people
who now have to rely on charity just to
stay alive.
Huge thanks and God bless you all for caring enough to read
this.
Dave and Louise.
Statement regarding MDC unity
negotiations
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ZIMBABWE'S
opposition MDC split in October 2005 over policy differences.
Negotiations
were established since late 2006 to bridge the differences.
Those
negotiations have collapsed, as the faction led by Arthur Mutambara
says in
a statement released
Friday:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Last
updated: 07/07/2007 05:58:33
WE HAVE noted the comments attributed to Morgan
Tsvangirai this past
weekend, in particular the following statement:
"On
our part, there have been calls across the board for unity within the
MDC. I
have argued against elite pacts. I have argued against attempts to
pick-up
individuals for specific party positions. That process cannot be
regarded as
uniting the party. Such a process is insincere and leads to
fresh political
setbacks. Whatever we seek to do must be comprehensive and
honest."
We believe that it is now important to put the record
straight regarding the
state of the negotiations between the two formations
of the MDC.
In the aftermath of the assault of Trudy Stevenson last year,
it was agreed
that there should be negotiations between the two formations
of the MDC to
formulate a functional working relationship between the two
political
entities.
Accordingly, in August, each formation of the MDC
appointed a four-person
negotiation team; the Tsvangirai formation's team
was led by Tendai Biti and
the Arthur Mutambara formation's team was led by
Welshman Ncube.
In the first meeting held in August, the two negotiating
teams drafted a
code of conduct which amongst other things we stated both
formations'
commitment to non-violence and which set up the mechanism to
reduce tensions
between the two formations.
In the meeting, it was
agreed between the two negotiating teams that for the
code of conduct to be
successful, there needed to be buy-in from the
leadership of both formations
and widespread publicity given to any final
agreement.
In the same
meeting, there was a detailed discussion regarding how the
assets of the
former United MDC could be split so the two separate political
parties with
distinct identities could emerge. A draft proposal was agreed
upon by the
negotiating teams and the meeting concluded with the undertaking
that both
negotiating teams would go back to their respective national
executives to
get both draft agreements endorsed.
The second meeting of the two
negotiating teams was held in September. At
that meeting both negotiating
teams advised that their respective national
executives had endorsed the
code of conduct with a few minor amendments.
Accordingly a final code of
conduct was agreed to. Both negotiating teams
agreed that the code of
conduct would be signed by the Presidents and the
Secretary Generals of each
formation and that a joint press conference would
be held as soon as
possible, attended by both presidents, at which the code
of conduct would be
released to the public and clear statements in support
of the code of
conduct would be made by both presidents.
At the same meeting in
September, the Tsvangirai formation's team reported
back that the national
executive wanted to pursue the prospects of unity
rather than agree to a
formula that would see the emergence of two separate
and distinct political
parties. As there was no objection to this from the
Mutambara formation's
perspective, it was agreed that a further meeting
would be held to pursue
Unity talks and that in the interim; the code of
conduct would be
implemented as a confidence building measure between the
two
formations.
Immediately after the September meeting, the code of conduct
document was
immediately signed by Arthur Mutambara, Welshman Ncube and
Tendai Biti. The
Mutambara formation was advised that Morgan Tsvangirai was
reluctant to sign
the code of conduct for reasons that remain unclear. After
being put under
pressure to do so, Morgan Tsvangirai eventually signed the
document but
insisted that he would not attend a joint press conference to
launch the
code of conduct, a position he has taken up until the
present.
The failure to publicly launch the code of conduct then
threatened to
undermine the negotiation process between the two formations
and indeed
delayed the holding of the third meeting which was to discuss the
prospects
of unifying the two formations. During the first weekend of
November, both
formations held national executive meetings.
At the
meeting of the Tsvangirai formation, a decision was taken to change
the
composition of the negotiating team and several people known to be
against
unity were included in the team. At a meeting of the Mutambara
formation, a
decision was taken to pursue the unity negotiations
notwithstanding the fact
that Morgan Tsvangirai had refused to attend a
joint press conference to
launch the code of conduct.
The third meeting of the two negotiating
teams was held over the last
weekend of November. The Tsvangirai team was
still led by Tendai Biti and
included the new members of the Tsvangirai
negotiating team mentioned above.
The meeting was advised that in view of
this, the participants representing
the Tsvangirai formation were there in
an informal capacity to explore what
prospects there were to unify the two
formations. In the meeting both teams
agreed that before serious unification
talks could begin, confidence
building measures would have to be
implemented.
In particular, it was agreed that the code of conduct should
be made public
and that there should be clear buy-in by both leaders. It was
also agreed
certain measures should be implemented to address the reasons
for the split,
especially the intra party violence. A proposal was put
forward that a
neutral panel of "grey-heads" be convened to investigate the
causes of the
split and to make representations to both formations as to how
the issues
could be redressed.
The negotiation process then got
bogged down. In early February 2007 the
mediator met with Morgan Tsvangirai
and was advised that he saw no point in
pursuing the negotiation process any
further. As a direct result of the
statement, the Mutambara negotiation team
was effectively stood down.
In the aftermath of the events of March 11
and Zanu PF's statement at the
end of March that they intended holding joint
presidential and parliamentary
elections by March 2008, the fourth meeting
of the two negotiating teams was
held in the first week of April.
At
this meeting it was agreed that there was now insufficient time, even if
there was political will, to resolve the issues which gave rise to the split
in the first place prior to the elections scheduled for March 2008. It was
also agreed that it was absolutely essential that the Zimbabwean electorate
be presented by a single opposition candidate in every Parliamentary
constituency and in the presidential election itself to confront Zanu
PF.
Accordingly it was agreed by the two negotiating teams that:
-
the two formations would fight the elections as one political organisation
to be known as the MDC Coalition
- a nominee of the Tsvangirai formation
would be the sole Presidential
candidate
- if the election was won, a
nominee of the Mutambara formation would be
appointed Vice President
- if
the election was won the winning President would appoint a small
cabinet
equally divided between the 2 formations but he or she would have
discretion
regarding the selection of a 3 person majority in cabinet
- a formula would
be agreed to ensure that the two formations shared
nominations for
candidates in all constituencies throughout the country
subject to
compliance with primary election procedures of the respective
formations
with a view to presenting the electorate with a single candidate
in every
constituency
-there was to be an irrevocable commitment to implementing a new
democratic
Constitution within the shortest possible time after taking power
and having
gone through a process acceptable to the Zimbabwean people to
ensure their
buy in
- because of the urgency of the matter the respective
formations would
publicly announce the agreement before the end of
April.
At the end of the meeting, all described it as "historic". A
photograph was
taken of all those who were in attendance as it was felt that
a major
breakthrough in the national interest of Zimbabweans had been
achieved. The
leaders of both formations were regularly consulted through
the two days of
negotiations and it was assumed that they were aware of what
was being
discussed and bought into the process and the agreement - that was
certainly
the case within the Mutambara formation. Crucially it was also
assumed that
each negotiation team had a mandate to agree on the broad
principles of the
agreement.
A seven page written agreement was
drafted by an independent lawyer who
attended the meeting. That draft
agreement was adopted by the leadership of
the Mutambara formation. It then
became apparent that the agreement had not
been adopted by the Tsvangirai
formation and as a result the undertaking to
announce the establishment of
the MDC coalition by the end of April could
not be fulfilled.
The
fifth meeting of the two negotiating teams was held in May. At that
meeting
the Tsvangirai negotiating team advised that there were elements
within the
Tsvangirai formation who were not prepared to endorse the April
agreement.
It emerged that they were two sticking points, namely:
1. The Tsvangirai
formation wanted the ability to appoint more than one
National Vice
President so that its own Vice President Thoko Khupe could be
appointed vice
president in addition to the nominee of the Mutambara
formation.
2. The
Tsvangirai formation wanted another method of nominating
Parliamentary
candidates which would involve both formations holding primary
elections in
every constituency and an electoral college consisting of 30
people from
each formation would then choose a Parliamentary candidate from
the two
candidates emerging from each faction from the primary election
process.
Objections were raised regarding the suggestion that there
be more than one
Vice President on the grounds that firstly the formulation
agreed to April
was a fair balance of power between the two formations and
that secondly it
was completely inappropriate for the opposition to mirror
the bloated
governmental structures created by Zanu PF.
Objections
were also raised regarding the proposed method of nominating
Parliamentary
candidates. It was pointed out that without addressing the
underlying
tensions between the two formations, a competitive process as the
one
suggested which would inevitably exacerbate tensions between the two
formations. The process suggested would create a highly charged and partisan
election in which 30 members from each formation will be expected to
vote.
That would be a gift to the CIO - in the run up to the elections
they would
be able to fuel tensions between the two formations. Within the
Electoral
College itself, the CIO could effectively decide who they wanted
elected by
bribing just one person from either of the formations. It was
pointed out
that one would have to assume that the 30 on each side would
invariably vote
for their own side and so someone bought could swing the
dead heat resulting
in a 31 - 29 victory for the CIO's preferred
candidate.
Secondly, it was pointed out that the process suggested was
not
"democratic" - giving 60 people the right to decide a candidate in a
constituency of 54000 voters is not democratic. It was pointed out that all
the suggested process would do would be to create a supercharged atmosphere
which would highlight divisions rather than emphasise what binds the two
formations.
It was reiterated by the Mutambara negotiating team at
the May meeting that
candidates should be identified countrywide through an
equitable system that
would ensure that there is equity between the two
formations, gender equity,
and that the person most likely to win is
nominated. It was emphasised that
all candidates should go through some form
of primary election but that it
was simply disingenuous to think that in
this environment there can be
democracy.
The meeting ended without
agreement and with a plea being made by the
mediator that responsible
leadership be demonstrated in the national
interest. It should be stressed
that the Mutambara formation is prepared to
honour the agreement reached in
April.
Regrettably it appears as if it the Tsvangirai formation is not
prepared to
honour that agreement, which is further borne out by the
comments made by
Morgan Tsvangirai this past weekend in
Marondera.
The agreement reached in April was not an "elite pact" nor did
it envisage
an attempt "to pick-up individuals for specific party
positions". On the
contrary the agreement was a carefully crafted document
designed to
accommodate the legitimate expectations of the Zimbabwean
electorate to
ensure that every single vote cast for the opposition is
effective.
Major concessions were made by the Mutambara formation to
agree to a single
Presidential candidate - it is obvious that any candidate
winning an
election will then have the vast executive powers at his disposal
now
enjoyed by Robert Mugabe. That is where the power resides at present and
where power will remain until there is a new democratic constitution enacted
which reduces executive power. It is obvious that our present Parliament has
very little power and to that extent, the Parliamentary election is of far
less importance than the Presidential election.
Ironically the only
specification of individuals in the entire process
concerned the implied
agreement that Morgan Tsvangirai would be the
presidential candidate and the
May suggestion that an additional vice
presidential post be created to
accommodate Thoko Khupe. There is no desire
within the Mutambara formation
for any of its members to be "picked up for
specific party positions" - that
was never part of the discussions as it was
clear in both the April and May
meetings that there would be two separate
political formations that would
however fight the election as a coalition.
The agreement reached in April
is not necessarily a dead letter but for it
to be given life, it is clear
that national interest is going to have to be
placed before petty personal
and partisan interest."
MDC Mutambara formation
4th July 2007
Zimbabwe collapse near complete
Robert Mugabe's mad version of economics has
comprehensively destroyed a
once-flourishing society.
The Gazette,
Montreal
Published: 13 hours ago
Zimbabwe's agony continues to worsen,
week by week, while the rest of the
world does nothing.
President
Robert Mugabe's mad version of economics has, over the last eight
years or
more, comprehensively destroyed a once-flourishing society. When
chaotic
land-ownership "reforms" chased out productive commercial farmers
and
exports collapsed, Zimbabwe began to pay its bills by printing more
money.
The obvious result of that was inflation, which has now spiralled out
of
control, to an estimated 4,500 per cent per year - or perhaps twice
that.
Mugabe's response to that problem, in turn, was to demand that
retail
merchants cut their prices in half. As any first-year economics
student
could tell you, the next step was empty store shelves, which is
where
Zimbabwe is now.
Email to a friendPrinter
friendly
Font:
a.. *
b.. *
c.. *
d.. *
The next step
is rioting in the streets. To prevent that, Mugabe has
threatened to seize
businesses, hardly a move that will help economic
recovery, and promised to
release government stocks of flour and gasoline at
the prices that were in
effect before inflation went into overdrive.
But the government has
stockpiled very few commodities, and as soon as
stocks run out, the riots
will start.
Nor are these Zimbabwe's only problems. Everyone with any
marketable skills
and a place to go has already left the country and will
not be wooed back
easily. Education and medical services are crumbling as
civil servants'
wages become worthless.
Why is this man still in
power, as his people sink further into impoverished
misery? The regional
power, South Africa, could send simple signals that
would force Mugabe out
in days. What is it waiting for?
© The Gazette (Montreal)
2007
Zimbabwe confronts food crisis
afrol News, 6 July - The
government of Zimbabwe has accepted a looming
severe food shortage in the
country. The ZANU-PF government said it would
accept food aid from the
international community but only on humanitarian
grounds.
Over the
years, Zimbabwe had been at the daggers' end of rights activists
for
trampling on the rights of citizens, especially the opposition, civil
society and the media.
Knowing fully that the donor community would
press for political and human
rights corrections to prevail as a condition
attached to their food aid, the
government was quick to sound the bell that
they would not welcome such
donors. No aid with political strings attached
are welcome even Zimbabweans
will die of hunger.
After declaring the
2007 as the year of drought, the Zimbabwean government
had invited experts
from WFP and FAO to assess the country's food situation.
"I have received
a preliminary report from (WFP/FAO) which confirms our
earlier fears of food
shortages," Zimbabwe's Minister of Agriculture, Rugare
Gumbo,
said.
"In their report they are saying the country will this year harvest
between
600 000 and 800 000 tonnes of grain, which falls far short of the
national
requirement of about 2 million tonnes. In my view, I think this is
a fair
assessment."
Over the past seven years, Zimbabwe has gone
through acute shortages of food
mainly because of recurrent droughts. But
the government's radical land
reforms which led to the transfer of lands
from white own farmers to blacks
has also led to the food
crisis.
Zimbabwe used to be the food basket of the Southern Africa
region.
The head of the European Commissioner's Humanitarian Aid Office
for Africa,
Cees Wittebrood, who visited the Southern African country,
blamed the food
crisis on the failure of the overall government policy on
agriculture.
"Zimbabwe has faced droughts before but was very much
capable of dealing
with a drought thanks to effective governance. They had
the systems, water
reservoirs, irrigation, inputs, knowledge and technology
to survive a period
without rain. But they don't have that any longer -
because the agricultural
policy and their policy in general is failing - the
drought can give them
(farmers) that last push over the edge."
It is
reported that Zimbabwean police have forced food sellers to reduce the
price
of the country's staple food, maize, the price of which plummeted.
By
staff writer
Zanu-Pf Politburo Resolves to Tighten Blitz - Shamuyarira
The
Herald (Harare) Published by the government of Zimbabwe
5 July
2007
Posted to the web 6 July 2007
Harare
THE Zanu-PF Politburo
met in Harare yesterday and discussed, among other
issues, measures to
tighten the current blitz to reduce prices of all goods
and
services.
The measures will be tabled today for consideration by the
Central Committee
before they are implemented by the relevant arms of
Government.
Zanu-PF Secretary for Information and Publicity, Cde
Nathan Shamuyarira,
said the Politburo was impressed by the results of the
current operation and
wanted the price reductions to be extended to other
items.
"The Politburo held its regular meeting chaired by President
Mugabe and had
a long agenda on important issues, one of which was the
pricing of products.
"We got a full report from the Ministerial Taskforce
and the Politburo was
very impressed that prices were coming down," said Cde
Shamuyarira.
The Politburo, he said, felt that there was need to
intensify and tighten
the process so that all goods are reduced and
stabilised to enable people to
afford them.
"The Politburo came up
with a number of measures to tighten and intensify
the process and these
will be tabled before the Central Committee tomorrow
(today). But we were
quite impressed with the process."
Cde Shamuyarira said it was the
Politburo's wish to see the cost of living
coming down so that goods become
affordable to ordinary people and the
Government would ensure this was
achieved by stabilising the prices of all
goods and services.
The
rampant increases in prices of goods and services will no longer be used
as
a tool for regime change as some businesspersons were anticipating, said
Cde
Shamuyarira.
He said the Politburo noted with concern that some traders
were creating
artificial shortages by hiding some goods, adding the
Government would look
into that.
Cde Shamuyarira, however, conceded
the need to draw the line between hiding
commodities and the need for
traders to keep stocks of various goods in
their warehouses.
"If
someone is running a big business he must have a warehouse to stock the
goods. We should be careful not to arrest such businesspersons," he
said.
Government has in the past week embarked on a blitz on retailers
and
manufacturers to comply with a directive to slash prices to their June
18,
2007 levels.
The blitz has seen several retailers and
manufacturers being arrested.
In a related matter, the Ministry of
Information and Publicity yesterday
said it had activated toll-free phone
lines which members of the public can
phone to communicate with Government
on matters of concern.
CHRA - The Resident
e-newsletter
RESIDENTS FORCED TO ATTEND BURIAL OF
HEROES
OVERZEALOUS Zanu PF youths have maintained their tradition of
terrorizing
and violating the rights of ordinary residents and vendors at
Mbare Musika
and Mupedzanhamo markets by forcing them to close shop and
attend burials of
national heroes. Those who refuse are accused of being MDC
activists, a
crime under the ruling regime.
Vendors have attended the
burials for fear of losing market space at the
lucrative Mbare Musika and
Mupedzanhamo markets. They complained that they
have lost millions of
dollars due to the long hours that they spend at the
National Heroes Acre
listening to the President's long and boring rhetoric.
In the last few
weeks, vendors and ordinary residents were force-marched to
attend the
burial of military commanders, Retired Major General Gideon
Taurayi Lifa and
Brigadier-General Paul Gunda at the National Heroes Acre.
President
Mugabe uses that opportunity to propagate the ZANU PF propaganda
Zanu PF's
profile of violence against residents has reached alarming levels.
CHRA
demands that residents should be allowed to live without fear of being
victimized for their political beliefs. It should be their choice whether to
attend burials of national heroes or not. All residents have the right to
make independent choices and it becomes a problem when those rights are
violated.
HEALTH DISASTER LOOMS IN HARARE
RESIDENTS of Harare
have had nightmares whenever they visit municipal
clinics and government
hospitals for medical attention.
The majority of the clinics in Harare
are temporarily closed and only
helpful to those coming for maternity and
chronic illnesses. Municipal
health staff is on strike and there are no
drugs.
Despite the fact that municipal clinics are under-staffed and
under-equipped
in terms of medicinal drugs and machinery, health charges
have increased by
more than 400% and most residents in Harare cannot afford
to pay the new
charges.
The current water and power shortages have
crippled the delivery of health
services in most hospitals and clinics.
These cannot operate without power
and water.
Affected hospitals in
the past month include Harare Hospital, Edith Opperman
Clinic and most of
the clinics in various suburbs.
The health sector has been hit by massive
resignations of qualified and
experienced health personnel due to poverty
remuneration and inhumane
working conditions, leaving most of the health
centres being manned by
inexperienced and demoralized staff.
CHRA is
concerned by the inaction of the government on this crisis facing
residents
and health staff on a daily basis. Their excuse that they do not
have
foreign currency to remunerate nurses and doctors, to purchase drugs
and
equipment must be rejected by all progressive forces. The same regime
has
managed to massage the egos of corrupt politicians and businessmen,
disguised as farmers by purchasing hundreds of tractors for them.
The
current crisis in the health sector and elsewhere is symptomatic of the
general collapse of the country's economy at the hands of a despotic regime.
They believe that resources that have been diverted to fund political
corruption must be channelled to the health and education
sectors.
There are companies that are offering special services to all
senior
citizens.
Most commercial banks and Building Societies are
offering free accounts to
senior citizens where they do not pay service
charges.
Some of these banks are: ZB Bank, The Jewel Bank (CBZ),
Beverley Building
Society, Stanbic Bank and CABS Building
Society.
Senior citizens who bank with CABS Building Society will pay
only $500 for a
Gold Class account instead of the usual $50 000. Produce a
positive National
Identity Card and open an account as a senior
citizen.
ZUPCO allows senior citizens to board their buses for free
during off-peak
hours- between 9am and 4pm.
OK Zimbabwe set aside a
day every month for senior citizens to come and shop
at OK Supermarkets and
they will be given 10% discount on the total cost of
the
groceries.
Senior citizens are given OK identity cards with their
pictures to benefit
from this service.
The City of Harare has come up
with a form, titled "Application for
pensioners rates, supplementary and
refuse charges exemption" which is
available at all 25 district offices for
a cost of $10 000 to pensioners.
NB The minimum cut off point for senior
citizens in Zimbabwe is 65 years.
GLEN VIEW RESIDENTS PETITION CITY OVER
COLLAPSED SERVICE DELIVERY
GLEN View residents on Thursday 5 July 2007
petitioned the City of Harare
over the collapse in service provision,
threatening to unleash a series of
actions against the municipality
including intensifying a rates boycott
campaign.
The major concerns
that are cited in the petition include the illegality of
Harare Commission,
refuse collection and the persistent water cuts that
residents are
experiencing.
Residents are unhappy with the proposed supplementary
budget and yet
residents had rejected Harare 2007 City Budget. The petition
was also copied
to the Ministry of Local Government.
In another
development, Budiriro residents invaded the local District
Offices
protesting against the prolonged water cuts they are experiencing.
Scores of
residents holding empty buckets marched around the offices singing
protest
songs on the 30th of June 2007.
The demonstration lasted two hours and no one
was arrested.
WATERFALLS and Highfield residents on 30 June 2007 had an
opportunity to
participate as witnesses in a play resembling the real court
process when
they hauled 'Minister Chombo and his surrogate Sekesai
Makwavarara' to
answer to charges of corruption, mismanagement of City
affairs, contempt of
court, embezzlement of public funds and the unlawful
handover of water
utilities and infrastructure to ZINWA.
THE PEOPLES'
COURT FOR WATERFALLS AND HIGHFIELD RESIDENTS
Residents from Waterfalls
accused Chombo and Makwavarara of negligence.
Grass is overgrown, there are
no street lights, increasing the incidence of
robberies at night and piles
of garbage are everywhere.
Refuse heaps provides mosquitoes and rats a
fertile breeding ground.
Highfield residents said they had no water supplies
for four consecutive
days forcing residents to bath in Mukuvisi River while
others used the same
water for domestic purposes. There is also massive
deterioration in social
services like use of public halls.
Both sets
of witnesses castigated the State for launching Operation
Murambatsvina,
saying it destroyed their livelihoods. The impact of the evil
exercise is
still being felt.
The 'court ' ruled that the commission was illegal, a
verdict that was also
reached by High Court Judges Lawrence Kamocha, Rita
Makarau, Moses
Chinhengo, Charles Hungwe, Tendai Uchena and Supreme Court
Judge Justice
Wilson Sandura Kamocha.
The People's Court ordered the
immediate holding of Council and Mayoral
elections in Harare and the
Commission should be dissolved today, the ZINWA
takeover was unlawful and
must be reversed because residents were not
consulted.
The judge also
declared illegal Operation Murambatsvina and ordered the
residents to
proceed to sue for compensation. Residents ululated and
resolved to boycott
payment of rates to the City of Harare until Mayoral and
Council elections
are held.
They also resolved to go and register as voters ahead of the
crucial 2008
Presidential, Parliamentary and Local Government
Elections.
VILLAGERS IN HARARE
CITY suburbs have been turned into
villages due to continued power and water
cuts that have been imposed by the
two State-controlled parastatals, ZESA
and ZINWA.
Areas like Mandara
have gone for more than six months without water. Most of
the residents
there now rely on their boreholes. But ZINWA continues to send
water bills
and yet they do not get the water at all.
ZESA has also made life
difficult for residents by turning the City of
Harare into an African
Village by imposing the prolonged power cuts.
Residents have now resorted to
using firewood which is mostly unaffordable.
Mabvuku residents have dug
wells in the swampy areas on the outskirts of
Tafara while those in
Waterfalls and Glen View Ward 1 drink contaminated
waters of Mukuvisi
River.
Ironically, the two parastatals still send monthly bills to
residents asking
them to pay for apparently non-existent services, a clear
case of daylight
robbery.
ZINWA is ignoring burst sewer and water
pipes that are scattered all over
Harare suburbs, and, on the other hand,
ZESA always excuses itself from
replacing stolen cables and
transformers.
NEWS FLASH!
The deadline for submitting objection
letters on the proposed supplementary
Budget ended on Sunday 8 July.
Ironically, the City of Harare started
implementing the proposed ridiculous
budget a fortnight before the expiry of
the date for submitting objections.
CHRA has instructed its lawyers to
prepare papers for court action against
the City on the budget.
NB: Any member of the public is welcome to write
stories to The
Resident
______________________________________________
Contact
Numbers:
Landline: 04- 705114 Mobiles: 0912 924 151, 011 862 012, 011 443
578, 011
612 860, 011 612 811, 0912 869 291, 0912 638 401, Write to us on
info@chra.co.zw or visit our website www.chra.co.zw or call the above
numbers.
Regards
Precious Shumba
Information
Officer
Combined Harare Residents' Association
Mobile: 011 612 860 or 0912
869 294
Tel: 04-705114
Website: www.chra.co.zw
"Stand Firm. Be of Good
Courage"
Official monthly newsletter of the Students Solidarity Trust
June
Newsletter:
Official monthly newsletter of the Students Solidarity Trust,
Zimbabwe July
2007 Vol 2 Issue 2
CIO on the sprawl
Once again,
the state in its increasingly regular and usual paranoid
behaviour has
descended upon two prominent student activists with its
unjustified heavy
handedness.
Beloved Chiweshe, Secretary General of ZINASU after a
grueling time at the
hands of his captors.He was made to swim in sewerage
water
Students at the University of Zimbabwe fought running battles with
the riot
police after a spate of disturbances rocked the campus last
night.
The disturbances were sparked by a feud between a University female
student
who was beaten by her boyfriend, allegedly for infedility. The
boyfriend is
a non-student, popularly known as Non Academic Bachelors
Association (NABA).
His car was burnt to ashes by as yet unidentified
assailants, believed to
have been implants who had intended to pre-empty the
demonstration which the
students had planned.
The case is a typical
example of the precarious situation female students at
tertiary institutions
face, as they attempt to outwit poverty by engaging in
abusive relationships
that are premised on material gain.
However, the students managed to stage
peaceful demonstrations around campus
after being addressed by student
leaders. The student leaders, who include
Lovemore Chinoputsa, the newly
elected SRC President and Tinei Mukwewa,
former President, are currently on
the run.
The students demanded that the administration reverse its
decision to
uniliterally ask students to pay top-up fees of 1million
Zimbabwe dollars
(9USD) on the parallel market. With inflation hovering over
the 4500 mark,
students, like many Zimbabweans are finding it difficult to
sustain decent
livelihoods as inflation erodes savings and incomes. Students
also contend
that the quality of food at the University has deterioated to
an extent
where they have to eat beans on a daily basis and cabbage with no
cooking
oil.
Beloved Chiweshe, the Secretary General of the Zimbabwe
National Students
Union and Munjodzi Mutandiri, were arrested by a plain
clothed member of the
dreaded spy agency, CIO in a commuter omnibus and
surrendered at Southerton
Police Station.
According to Beloved
Chiweshe the Secretary General of ZINASU who was among
the two students, the
incident occurred late last night. The Southerton
Police handed them over to
the Law and Order members at Harare Central.
The two who were on their
way home had just boarded a commuter omnibus when
two unidentified men,
presumably members of the infamous Central
Intelligence Organisation are
reported to have unceremoniously disembarked
them .The two were then force
marched to a waiting vehicle into which they
were bundled before being
driven away to a secluded place near Irvines farm.
It was at this point
that their captors subjected them to all forms of
torture, beating them up
regardless. And in a bizarre incident, the two were
forced to swim in a
sewerage pond. According to Chiweshe, the men would
order them to stay under
the sewage water for sometime. They only stopped
after Munjodzi had
collapsed.
Munjodzi Mutandiri...the assaults only stoppped after he had
collapsed (pic
shows his back).
This abduction comes in the wake of
some brutal attacks perpetrated against
student leaders at Masvingo State
University. The Students Solidarity Trust
as an Organisation strongly
condemns these systematic acts of torture and
inflicting terror against
vulnerable and defenseless students.
This is a sad and deplorable state
of affairs which goes against the grain
and spirit of a truly democratic
society. According to articles on the
Convention against Torture, torture is
outlawed and cannot be sanctioned or
sustained in any democratic space. An
exhibition of such arbitrary and
despotic tendencies is unjustified and
unacceptable. This kind of human
rights abuse should not be allowed to go
unchecked.
STOP THE TORTURE
The use of torture as an instrument of
coercion by the government of
Zimbabwe has become so pervasive and
institutionalized - it qualifies as a
way of doing things.
As
Zimbabweans join the rest of the world in commemorating the International
Day against torture, Zimbabweans are faced with the stark reality of torture
as a means of crushing dissent.
As it were, the legacy of Ian Smith
is still abound in "independent"
Zimbabwe today. As the nationalist leaders
fought a tenacious war with the
oppressive Smith regime for the attainment
of independence, they faced
relentless torture in a bid to cow them into
submission. Many of our leaders
today have harrowing experiences of torture
and how dehumanizing and
degrading it is to the human spirit.
Yet
Zimbabweans who dare to speak out against the oppressive policies of the
government face torture!
Article 2 of the Convention against Torture
places an obligation on State
members to prevent torture because it
represents the most basic denial of
human dignity which lies at the very
heart of the concept of human rights.
Acts of torture can also infringe on
the rights to security of person, the
right to equality and the right to
life itself.
Students and many other perceived 'enemies' of the state
have suffered
torture at the hands of state security apparatus. In many
cases, innocent
people have been tortured before proven guilty. In Zimbabwe,
perpetrators of
torture have been generally known as the police, secret
police, army and
vampire-like paramilitary forces (youth militias and war
veterans - with the
aid and protection of the state.
Munjodzi
Mutandiri...the assaults only stoppped after he had collapsed
(front
pic).
Even more worrying within the students' community is that acts of
torture
are now being perpetrated by campus security. Recently, they have
been on
the forefront of assaulting and torturing legitimate student
activists and
have assumed throle of pseudo-military juntas, spreading
terror at
institutions of higher learning
The Students Solidarity
Trust calls on the government to desist and impress
on the security
apparatus to desist from using torture as means of
investigating suspects
and stifling legitimate citizen's participation in
the political affairs of
their country. There is an inherent need to train
law enforcement agents
from instigating acts of torture. The code of conduct
of such officials
shall serve and protect the community at all times.
Disturbances rock
UZ...as students resist top-up fees proposal
Students at the University
of Zimbabwe fought running battles with the riot
police after a spate of
disturbances rocked the campus last night.
The disturbances were sparked by a
feud between a University female student
who was beaten by her boyfriend,
allegedly for infedility. The boyfriend is
a non-student, popularly known as
Non Academic Bachelors Association (NABA).
His car was burnt to ashes by as
yet unidentified assailants, believed to
have been implants who had intended
to pre-empty the demonstration which the
students had planned.
The case
is a typical example of the precarious situation female students at
tertiary
institutions face, as they attempt to outwit poverty by engaging in
abusive
relationships that are premised on material gain.
However, the students
managed to stage peaceful demonstrations around campus
after being addressed
by student leaders. The student leaders, who include
Lovemore Chinoputsa,
the newly elected SRC President and Tinei Mukwewa,
former President, are
currently on the run.
The students demanded that the administration reverse
its decision to
uniliterally ask students to pay top-up fees of 1million
Zimbabwe dollars
(9USD) on the parallel market. With inflation hovering over
the 4500 mark,
students, like many Zimbabweans are finding it difficult to
sustain decent
livelihoods as inflation erodes savings and incomes. Students
also contend
that the quality of food at the University has deterioated to
an extent
where they have to eat beans on a daily basis and cabbage with no
cooking
oil.
My Experience
By Witlaw Mugwigi
SRC
President
Masvingo State University
It was on a Monday, the 18th of
June 2007, when I and my Secretary General,
Edson Hlatswayo were forcibly
removed from an exam room. Just 15 minutes
into the Banking and Research
Methods (Ban 205) exam, two security guards
approached Edson and forced him
out of the exam, pushing and shoving him in
the process.
Witlaw
Mugwigi, after he survived a viscious attack by campus security
They
then ordered me to vacate the exam room for which I flatly refused to
obey
such an erroneous order and I continued to write my examination.
It was a
this point that they started dragging and pushing me out of the
exam room
causing chaos and commotion for about 10 minutes. I was finally
subdued and
dragged out of the exam room where more reinforcements came. I
was pinned to
the ground and the security guards started assaulting me with
clenched fists
and kicks.
After the brutal and savage attack I sustained a swollen eye,
a bruised and
swollen cheek, a fractured tooth and a sprained neck. I was
eventually
escorted out of campus and later reported the matter to the
police (Masvingo
Police Central) where a docket number was opened (RBB
335948)
On visiting Masvingo General Hospital I was admitted until
Wednesday 20 June
2007. On the very evening I was taken to Harare for better
medical
supervision by the Students Solidarity Trust.
It later turned
out that the security guards were acting under the direct
command of the
Vice-Chancellor, O. Maravanyika and Deputy Registrar
(Maposhere) who had
hoped to use this incident to intimidate would be
student leaders against
being vocal. However, this incident has strengthened
our resolve to continue
fighting against oppression and corruption. Struggle
is our
birthright!
State of the Higher and Tertiary Education sector in Zimbabwe
(Summary,
January-June 2007)
In January the SST recorded 15 cases of
human rights violations, all of
which had to do with unlawful arrests, most
notably in Bulawayo where 10
students were arrested and dumped in Matopos,
some 35km outside Bulawayo.
The month of February witnessed an upsurge in
repression, with 186 cases of
human rights violations recorded, in the form
of unlawful arrests and
restriction of the right to assemble. The upsurge in
human rights violations
in the month of February is attributed to the fact
that when students open
school, they are more often than not confronted with
the sad reality of
exorbitant new fees structures that would have been
imposed on the students
by the administration The month of March was a
bloody month for
pro-democracy activists in general. There were 36 cases of
unlawful arrests.
Notably, 2 student leaders were abducted in Gweru and
dumped in Shurugwi, in
a game park. 2 Students were suspended at Bulawayo
Polytechnic and there was
a case of systematic de-registration of one
student leader.
Abductions continued in the month of April, SST recorded
cases of 4
abductions of student leaders. There were 26 cases of unlawful
arrests and
two student leaders were suspended at Masvingo State University.
Clifford
Hltshawayo, a student leader at the University of Zimbabwe, was
acquitted on
charges of Malicious Injury to Property.
The month of May
saw an upsurge in the number of students being hauled
before bogus and
kangaroo courts disguised as disciplinary committee
hearings. One student
leader was arraigned before the disciplinary committee
hearing at the
University of Zimbabwe, and the National University of
Science and
Technology (NUST) hauled 8 student leaders. 61 students were
unlawfully
arrested nationwide. In Bulawayo, 5 student activists appeared in
court for
routine remand.
The month of June saw 14 student leaders being arraigned
before the
disciplinary court hearings, 12 cases at the University of
Zimbabwe in which
cases all of the students were acquitted or made to pay
fines. There were 2
cases of unlawful arrests, and 2 student leaders were
abducted and made to
swim in a sewerage pond after enduring hours of
torture. 20 students made
routine court appearing, notably in Masvingo. 6
student activists were
suspended, 5 at NUST and 1 from the University of
Zimbabwe.
In total, a total of 636 cases of human rights violations
against students
have occurred since January
Category of right
violatedNumber of times the rights were
violated
(January-June)
Unlawful arrests151
Unlawful detention
87
Torture/Abductions 8
Expulsion/Suspension 9
Assault 37
Political
discrimination/victimization 151 Freedom of expression/ass/mvt 101
Death
Threats-
Total636
Some students had their rights violated more than
once a month and some had
more than one right violated more than once a
month and some had more that
one right violated at a time.
Upcoming
Events
Have a story idea for a future issue? Share it with us. Know
someone who
would appreciate our newsletter? Pass it along. Did you recieve
this message
from a friend? After sending it along to someone else, signup
for the
newsletter yourself. Remove yourself from all our lists (or reply
with
"remove" in the subject line ©Student Solidarity Trust, 4th Floor
Construction House, Harare Email:- info@studentsolidarity.org
It is Africa's call on Mugabe, says
Pahad
06 July 2007
John Kaninda and Dumisani Muleya
SA AND other African
nations would insist that Zimbabwean President Robert
Mugabe be allowed to
attend a long-delayed summit between the European Union
(EU) and Africa this
year, Deputy Foreign Minister Aziz Pahad said
yesterday.
Mugabe and
more than 100 other Zimbabwean officials are banned from
travelling to EU
countries under sanctions imposed in 2002, a restriction
that threatens to
derail an EU-Africa summit scheduled for December in
Portugal.
The
conference was very important and had been held up since the first
Africa-EU
summit in Cairo, Egypt, seven years ago.
The issue of the 83-year-old
Zimbabwean leader, who has vowed to run for
another term as president next
year, is the main reason the EU and Africa
have not held a summit since
their first effort in Cairo. Pahad said the
summit had not yet taken place
"because of the insistence of the Europeans
to determine Africa's
delegation".
The African Union has said its 53 members should decide who
to send to the
meeting.
"I think Africa will not move on its position
that you cannot determine what
constitutes the African delegation," Pahad
said.
"Because there's a lot of fear. Today Zimbabwe (under pressure),
tomorrow it
can be us and the next day it can be somebody else.
"And
if we allow that to happen, it will not allow us to have a unity of
approach
on how we have to deal with the Europeans on many, many fundamental
issues."
Portugal, currently holding the EU rotating presidency
and host of the
summit in Lisbon, is reportedly under pressure from some
African countries
to include Zimbabwe, while some EU countries want Mugabe
excluded.
The Independent and Guardian newspapers in the UK reported
that Portugal had
decided to defy an EU travel ban and would allow Mugabe to
attend the summit
to prevent other African leaders from boycotting
it.
Portugal , which has made boosting ties with Africa a priority denied
the
reports, saying invitations would be sent out only in
September.
Pahad said he was encouraged by comments from senior
Portuguese officials,
including its foreign affairs minister, suggesting the
political crisis in
Zimbabwe and Mugabe's presence should not block a
summit.
Widely accused of abusing human rights, suppressing political
opposition and
driving Zimbabwe's economy into the ground, Mugabe became
persona non grata
in much of Europe in 2002 after winning an election
described as rigged by
international observers.
President Thabo Mbeki
is brokering talks between Mugabe's government and
representatives of
Zimbabwe's main opposition party under a mandate granted
to him this year by
the Southern African Development Community (SADC). Pahad
said he believed
Mbeki had briefed other SADC nations on the talks, but gave
no
details.
Ruling Zanu (PF) and opposition Movement for Democratic Change (
MDC)
negotiators meet tomorrow in Pretoria to start critical dialogue in
talks
facilitated by Mbeki.
After agreeing to a final agenda more
than two weeks ago, Zanu (PF) and MDC
negotiating teams would discuss the
first and most important item on the
agenda - the constitution, sources
said.
Mbeki, who looks set to be engaged on Zimbabwe for almost his
entire 10-year
tenure, is determined to ensure the talks succeed for his
legacy.
The summit in Portugal would likely focus on areas requiring
closer
co-operation between Europe and Africa. With Reuters, Bloomberg and
Sapa
Asylum seeking journalist prefers Botswana prison to Zimbabwe
By Lance
Guma
06 July 2007
A Zimbabwean journalist who formerly worked for the
state media says he
prefers to remain in a Botswana prison rather than go
back home, following
the refusal of his asylum application. Ever since his
application was turned
down in 2002 David Mpofu has been in detention for 5
years at Jerald Estate
Prison, 20 kilometres outside Francistown. The
Association of Zimbabwe
Journalists in the UK report on their website that
Mpofu fears for his life
in Zimbabwe, following death threats after he
published an article exposing
electoral rigging by Mugabe's regime. He
worked for the government
controlled Herald newspaper before becoming an
editor with the now defunct
Plumtree Post.
James Mushandu, a relative
of Mpofu who escaped from the same prison, told
the website that despite
poor living conditions the journalist has opted to
stay there rather than
face certain death in Zimbabwe. Mpofu says after
covering a story on vote
rigging in 2002 he received numerous death threats
from Zanu PF supporters
and state security agents. This prompted him to
escape into Botswana and
attempt to seek political asylum there. Mashandu
also told of how Mpofu's
health was fast deteriorating because of the poor
conditions in the
cells.
Illegal immigrants due to be deported from any country are
normally kept in
detention facilities, but Mashandu insists the facility
where Mpofu is being
held also houses common criminals. He says the place is
notorious for the
abuse of prisoners by prison guards and officials. Shaban
Ramadan, a
Burundian who tried to escape the detention centre and claim
asylum
elsewhere, was allegedly gunned down by guards. Officials in Botswana
have
up to now refused to discuss Mpofu's case. Forward Maisokwadzo, one of
the
coordinators of the Association of Zimbabwe Journalists in the UK, says
they
are now investigating the matter to see if they can intervene and help
Mpofu.
According to figures released on World Refugee Day last month,
out of 243
journalists who fled their countries, half of them came from just
five
countries: Zimbabwe, Ethiopia, Eritrea, Colombia and Uzbekistan. The
Committee to Protect Journalists estimates that 3 journalists a month flee
their home countries fearing threats of violence, prison or harassment. Only
one in seven ever return.
SW Radio Africa
Zimbabwe news
JAG Open Letter Forum No 493
jag@mango.zw with “For Open Letter
Forum” in the subject
line.
JAG Hotlines:
+263
(011) 610 073 If you are in trouble or need advice,
please don't hesitate to
contact us - we're here to help!
+263 (04) 799 410 Office
Lines
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Letter
1 – Egcross
Predatory
Kleptocracy
During the past 27 years of Zanu PF government in
Zimbabwe under Robert
Gabriel Mugabe, the State has slipped from being a
reasonably stable,
open democracy with a good civil service and real
potential for growth
and development, to an autocratic, corrupt predatory
regime that pays
scant regard to the law or the interests of its people. The
numbers are
astounding. GDP has fallen by over half, exports by two-thirds,
food
production by 80 per cent, industrial output by 50 per cent. In
the
social sphere, life expectancy has declined to the lowest in the
world,
falling by a year for every year Mugabe has been in power, all
social
indicators are negative and the real incomes of formal sector workers
has
declined by 90 per cent.
In the sphere of macro economic
management – by no means rocket
science today, the regime has run a
budget deficit of over 60 per cent of
GDP, raised taxes equal to another 50
per cent of GDP, stolen at least a
third of real economic output with most of
the resulting wealth being
spread amongst an elite of perhaps 2000
individuals and the security
establishment.
As a result, in
the midst of a steep decline in economic activity, a
massive expansion in
absolute poverty and the collapse of all State
managed services, we have the
spectre of a small political and military
elite who drive expensive cars, go
on shopping trips to Dubai and are
building mansions that would grace the
cities of the richest countries in
the world.
It is obscene.
While this is going on, we have seen our democracy
subverted and our human
rights taken from us in a similar fashion to the
nightmare regimes of the
Soviet Union or Germany circa 1930 –
1945. It is no exaggeration
to say we have seen thousands of political
killings (Gukurahundi), hundreds
of thousands tortured, beaten and raped
and millions displaced, both
internally and externally.
We know we are not alone in this sort
of situation – there are
several such regimes in Africa and even a
few elsewhere. The scary thing
is that the Zanu regime would be getting away
with all of this if it were
not for a small, brave and dedicated cadre of
activists who have worked
tirelessly to record what is going on, publicise
the outcome and fight
for matters to be corrected.
It was
this group who wrote the report “Breaking the
Silence”
that first revealed the horrors of Gukurahundi. It was the
UN that
disclosed the extent and seriousness of the Murambatsvina exercise,
it
was a lone cameraman working for the State controlled media
who
photographed the rioting and subsequent beatings of MDC leaders in
March
this year and was beaten to death for his courage.
Even
the much maligned IMF has played a small role by continuing to
prepare and
put out on its website, detailed technical reports that have
spelt out the
truth about the economy in the face of State propaganda.
The great failure
has been in Africa itself. There is no point in Britain
or the United States
coming out with a harsh critique of Mugabe and his
regime, this is simply
brushed aside by Mugabe and his cronies as another
example of
“neo-colonialism”. Other African leaders and the
regime
here deliberately misinterpret even the targeted sanctions aimed
at the
perpetrators of these crimes against humanity as economic
sanctions directed
at the people of Zimbabwe rather than the actual
targets
themselves.
Gradually the crimes of Mr. Mugabe and his entourage
has dawned on
African leaders. When they attend events such as the World
Economic Forum
in Cape Town recently they are confronted by the need to
resemble some
sort of a profitable and secure place for investment flows from
the rest
of the world.
It is very difficult to do so while you have
errant and truant regimes
like that which exists in Zimbabwe still being
treated as a
“respected” member of the African Club of
Nations.
Just take the current madness. Mugabe announces that
the run away
inflation in Zimbabwe is part of an international
“regime
change” agenda. He declares that Britain and the
USA are behind the
inflation (do not laugh – in many quarters he is
taken seriously
when he makes such ridiculous claims). He then sends out his
armed thugs
in small groups to force industrialists and retailers to roll
back their
prices. No rational basis – just reduce your prices
by
“X” or we will do “Y”. So for the
past 4 days we
have seen hundreds of businesses raided, managers and owners
beaten in
some cases, nearly 200 taken into Police custody and billions of
dollars
written off stocks of products already paid for.
I am
struggling right now to work out what we have lost in our small
business.
Customers fighting to get into the supermarket have smashed the
glass front
of the store and we have long queues – people anxious
to buy what
is available at the low prices and before stocks run out. I
have frozen all
buying and by the end of today we will start to close
down – 42
staff out of work. Many others are doing the same thing.
Wholesalers have
marked down their stocks and are now billing suppliers
for
rebates.
I am contemplating what to do at our level but cannot
see anyone being
willing or able to give me a cheque for many hundreds of
millions of
dollars in compensation for the measures forced on us. When
finally the
whole futile exercise collapses in a heap and we go back to
normal
trading, we will not have the cash to pay for new stocks. Of course
there
may not be any manufacturers still operating at that
point.
Just to give one example of nutty economics, Mugabe
style. An empty bag
for 10 kilograms of maize meal costs Z$79 000, the maize
at subsidized
prices from the GMB costs Z$26 000 and the new controlled price
is Z$85
000 – about half of total costs before any profit accrues
to the
miller. Fuel is the same – the landed cost is about US85
cents per
litre and this is equal to Z$170 000. The controlled price is Z$60
000.
By the end of today the only place you will be able to buy fuel will
be
behind closed doors in some back ally after dark – at Z$250 000
a
litre or more.
On Saturday the two teams from the MDC and
Zanu PF resume talks in
Pretoria. They are discussing the conditions for the
March 2008
elections. I do not think we will get there. Perhaps that is the
real
game being played behind the scenes by the predatory, kleptocratic
regime
that some call our government.
Eddie
Cross
Bulawayo, 4th July
2007
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Letter
2 – Pat Mangwende
Dear Jag,
It seems
that the last batch of letters has dried up conversation. I
thought this
might be the case as democratic space in Zimbabwe seems to
be closing down
rapidly. Would the convenor of this little bit of free
democratic space be
kind enough to confirm that this is, in fact, the
case. I have read the
letters below, particularly the one from Colin
Cloete, and am surprised at
the lack of comment. This is not a good sign.
Regards
Pat
Mangwende
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Letter
3 – Graeme Bell
Dear JAG
I would be
most grateful to hear from anyone who may know of the
whereabouts of Andries
and Yvonne Albertyn formerly of Beitbridge.
Graeme
Bell
2049 Ngunguru Road
Whangarei R D 3
New
Zealand
Email … g.m.bell@xtra.co.nz
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Letter
4 – Stu
Dear JAG,
Please could
somebody reply to this letter. I have lost the address etc
of the trust fund
that helps provide food parcels to the elderly there in
Zim. There is an
account in Bots and UK etc and I would like the UK
information please. So if
anyone can help I would appreciate it.
As times get harder
perhaps JAG can remind people of this trust fund
especially those of us
abroad in despora. It is important to help these
people.
As
ever all of you in Zim are in my thoughts and prayers and it is
sickening
that the world is prepared to sit on the side and watch a
preventable
disaster unfold there because of one
man!!!
Stu
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
All
letters published on the open Letter Forum are the views and opinions
of the
submitters, and do not represent the official viewpoint of Justice
for
Agriculture.