The Telegraph
By Peta
Thornycroft in Harare and Sebastien Berger
Last Updated: 6:54PM BST
07/07/2008
Zanu-PF militiamen have raided a refugee camp housing hundreds of
opposition
supporters supposedly under the protection of the Red Cross and
United
Nations agencies, in an indication of Robert Mugabe's disregard for
international opinion.
The 400-strong group at Ruwa rehabilitation centre
sought refuge at a car
park outside the South African embassy in Harare
three weeks ago, before
Zimbabwe's one-candidate presidential
run-off.
They moved to the site 15 miles south-east of the city after
assurances for
their safety were given by the South Africans and the
Zimbabwe Red Cross,
they said.
But around a dozen men in camouflage
uniforms, some wearing balaclavas,
walked past a lone policeman on duty at
the gate and attacked refugees
sleeping in a squash court.
"The
screaming and the noise of what they were doing was terrible, I don't
even
know how many were hurt, I couldn't see," said a 45-year-old man who
escaped
from the camp.
He believes scores of people were injured and many,
including women and
their infants, were kidnapped or fled into the bush to
escape.
Most of the group are from rural areas who first sought
protection at the
MDC's Harvest House headquarters in Harare, but after it
was raided by
police several times moved to the position outside the
embassy.
"We knew President (Thabo) Mbeki was mediating the situation and
we thought
they would help us," said the man.
"We moved to Ruwa
because the South Africans told us we would be safe, but
we are not
safe."
The International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent
Societies in
Johannesburg said it would issue a statement about the assault,
but so far
had failed to do so.
Violence against MDC officials and
supporters has risen in the last few days
and more than 1,500 officials and
members are presently in detention,
according to the opposition party
spokesman Nelson Chamisa.
Western condemnation of Mr Mugabe's
"re-election" has been vocal, with a
draft UN Security Council resolution
circulating calling for sanctions to be
imposed on the regime.
But
his fellow African leaders have been notable for the weakness of their
response, and in some cases outright support.
David Miliband, the
British Foreign Secretary, told an audience at the
University of South
Africa today that Mr Mugabe had unleashed "a campaign of
unchecked brutality
against his own people".
"He has turned the weapons of the state on his
own people," he said.
By Alex
Bell
07 July 2008
As the numbers of displaced Zimbabweans continues to
grow, the safety of
refugees has become a matter of serious concern after
armed militia raided
two camps of people fleeing post election
violence.
There have been reports that several people died after armed
men stormed a
camp in Gokwe, but we have been unable to confirm the
claims.
At the same time, another group of displaced victims also became
targets of
militia thugs in Ruwa late on Sunday night. The group of 354 men,
women and
children had been removed to the so-called place of safety after
seeking
shelter at the South African embassy, in the week leading up to the
sham
run-off poll.
The group of refugees had fled their homes in
Epworth after the extreme
violence there and sought shelter and safety at
the embassy in Harare. Their
removal to Ruwa was part of an agreement
facilitated by South Africa's
ambassador to Zimbabwe, Lungisi
Makalima.
Other organisations that supported the move include the Zimbabwean
National
and the International Red Cross. The Zimbabwean Red Cross however
is
unfortunately heavily compromised in its agreement to care for the
refugees,
because of suggestions of links with Zanu PF.
The group were
taking shelter at a state rehabilitation centre in Ruwa, and
despite
promises by both embassy officials and the Red Cross that security
would be
provided, the group were forced to set up their own security
patrols.
Eight people were hospitalised after masked men with
shotguns stormed the
shelter in Ruwa at around midnight and attacked the
refugees. Another 14
people, mostly young men from the security patrols set
up by the camp, are
missing.
Meanwhile, another group of refugees who
sought shelter at the US embassy
last week have all been moved to charity
safe houses and to a settlement
camp set up by embassy officials on private
land.
SW Radio Africa Zimbabwe news
http://www.hararetribune.com
By ZimbabweMetro | Harare
Tribune News
July 7, 2008 13:28
news@hararetribune.com
Despite the much publicized talks between the MDC and ZANU-PF,state
sponsored terror is raging on and according to a plan by JOC the MDC has to
be destroyed completely.Metro has obtained information from Credible Sources
with the Zimbabwean Security Services.
Soon after arriving back
from the AU Summit in Egypt, Mugabe met with
the ZOC , namely Chiwenga,
Chihuru, Shiri, Mnangagwa, Zimondi and others. He
briefed them on: AU
Position on Zim Botswana's position on Zim West Africa
(Nigeria) All
anti-Zimbabwe sentiments worldwide Looming sanctions UN
Position Africa's
position ZANU PF's increasing isolation from the rest of
the
world.
The JOC's response was as follows: To target and eliminate
the MDC
from the political map in Zimbabwe. This operation is to begin at
cell,
ward, District, province and national levels. To target and eliminate
selected MDC MP's so that the other MPs are forced into hiding and after 21
days of being absent from parliament by-elections will be held and rigged to
regain ZANU PF's majority in parliament. Killing of all critical journalists
from both the public and private media to silence all independent voices.
Police internal security intelligence (PISI) have all the names of all the
MDC activists in the country so targeting them will not be a
problem.
This is meant to cripple the MDC to eventually force it
into a
government of national unity where it will be swallowed by ZANU PF
and there
will be no MDC in the future. This operation is being coordinated
now and
all logistics are being mobilized. The operation will begin Monday
7th July
2008 by attacking and abducting MDC refugees. The Junta assured
Mugabe that
no country in the world can invade Zimbabwe as their state of
preparedness
was second to none in Africa. It is obvious from this
information that the
Mugabe regime is not sincere about negotiating a
peaceful resolution to the
Zimbabwe crisis and is determined to continue to
wage war against the people
of Zimbabwe.
Personnel Identified
as being integrally involved in the past and
forthcoming violent operations:
Supt Remegio Utsiwembanje - Officer
Commanding Police Protection Units (PPU)
Projects Supt Absalom Mudzamiri -
DISPOL Minor PPU Tomlinson Depot Ex-Supt
Nyawani - now with the Reserve Bank
of Zimbabwe Inspector Patric Maramba -
Officer In ChargeTomlinson Depot
Inspector Marufu - 2nd IC Parliament
Inspector Mbokochena - Officer
Commanding PPU Assistant Inspector Jongwe -
PPU Tomlinson Depot Assistant
Inspector Madziwana - PPU Police Internal
Security Intelligence (PISI)
Assistant Inspector Muranganwa - PPU PISI
Assistant Inspector Ndangana - PPU
State House Assistant Inspector Maguma -
PPU State House Sgt Nyamunaki - PPU
PISI Sgt Muridzo - PPU Transport Sgt
Madzinga - PPU Willovale Sgt
Chikazaza - PPU State House Sgt Deremete - PPU
State House Assistant
Inspector Mudonhi Assistant Commissioner Martin
Kwaimona Chief
Superintendent Musvita Superintendent Linda Superintendent
Chikerema Chief
Inspector Mukudu Chief Inspector Tigwere Superintendent
Mumba Inspector
Ngazi Inspector Bonyongwa Insepector Muzondiwa Sgt Mudzova
Sgt Jaji Sgt
Sharara Assistant Inspector Mutendamambo Constable Tarise -
Armourer
Constable Matara Assistant Inspector Matienga - Armourer Police
General
Headquarters--Harare Tribune News
| Harare Tribune
News July 7, 2008 11:48 news@hararetribune.com |
Zimbabwe, Harare-- Twenty opposition Movement for
Democratic Change supporters have been killed since Zimbabwe's Robert Mugabe
stood as the sole candidate in a run-off presidential election, the party said
on Monday.
These revelations indicate that though Robert Mugabe won the election, the political violence opposition supporters and activits continues unabated, with the full blessing of the ZANU-PF leadership. The latest casualties bring the overall number of party followers to have been killed since the first round of voting in March to 109, said a statement from the MDC, blaming the bloodshed on pro-Mugabe militias. It alleged the veteran president's supporters have "murdered 20 MDC activists, while thousands have been severely assaulted" since the June 27 election which Mugabe won by a landslide after MDC leader Morgan Tsvangirai pulled out of the contest. "A total of 109 MDC activists have been murdered by ZANU-PF supporters," the statement added. The MDC had previously said that 103 of its supporters had been killed in politically-related violence since the first round of voting in which Tsvangirai beat Mugabe into second but fell short of an absolute majority. In his pre-conditions for any government of national unity, Tsvangirai has said that "there must be peace, then negotiations" in allusion to the ongoing campaign of violence by ZANU-PF militia across the country. Meanwhile, in Japan, G8 leaders called the crisi in Zimbabwe to be resolved. US President George W. Bush said Monday he was "extremely disappointed" with Zimbabwe's "sham" election, as world leaders pushed for sanctions against the regime. "I care deeply about the people of Zimbabwe, I am extremely disappointed in the election, which I labelled a sham election," Bush said on the sidelines of a summit of rich nations at this mountain resort in northern Japan. France President Nicolas Sarkozy would back a UN Security Council resolution imposing sanctions on Mugabe's regime, which "tarnishes the image of all of Africa", a source close to the president said late Monday. "We are in favour of sanctions against Zimbabwe through a UN Security Council resolution," the source told reporters in the spa resort of Toyako. The United States last week proposed a resolution that would slap sanctions on Zimbabwe and 12 of its citizens, including Mugabe. The draft is expected to be published next week. Germany was also clear at the G8 it wanted to see sanctions. "We have made clear, I have made very clear, that the result of the election is not legitimate," German Chancellor Angela Merkel told reporters. Germany "does not exclude more sanctions" against Zimbabwe, she said. UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon urged Zimbabwe's parties to restore the "rule of law" and said he would take up the crisis with African leaders. Ban, speaking to AFP on the plane taking him to the Group of Eight (G8) summit, said last month's election giving Mugabe a sixth term lacked legitimacy. "Therefore I urged that political parties in Zimbabwe should work out an arrangement so that they can really bring back democratic rules, the rule of law and peace and stability in their country," Ban said in the interview. African leaders attending an expanded session of the G8 summit acknowledged the growing concerns about Zimbabwe but did not endorse Washington's call for new UN Security Council sanctions. "I want to assure you that the concerns that you have expressed are indeed the concerns of many of us in the African continent," said African Union chief and Tanzanian President Jakaya Kikwete. "The only area that we may differ is on the way forward," said Kikwete, standing at Bush's side. Kikwete noted that the African Union at a summit last week adopted a resolution calling for dialogue between Mugabe and Tsvangirai and for a government of national unity. "We are saying no party can govern alone in Zimbabwe and therefore the parties have to work together, come out to work together in a government and then look at the future of their country together," said Kikwete. The United States has introduced a UN Security Council resolution that would impose new diplomatic and economic sanctions on Mugabe and his regime, including an arms embargo, a travel ban and a freeze on financial transactions. Earlier, Japanese Prime Minister Yasuo Fukuda, chair of the three-day summit, discussed Zimbabwe with Merkel and British Prime Minister Gordon Brown. Brown, who has been outspoken over developments in the former British colony, told Fukuda it was "important to send a strong message to secure democracy in Zimbabwe," a Japanese government official said. Fukuda told Brown that he shared his concerns and replied: "It is necessary for the G8 to have firm discussions on the issue and consider measures." G8 leaders told their African counterparts that Zimbabwe was "a major negative factor for the whole of Africa," another Japanese official said. While there were no clear objections to the G8 warnings, one African leader noted that putting pressure on Zimbabwe may worsen a confrontation between the ruling and opposition camps in the country, the officials said.--Harare Tribune News |
Chris McGreal in
Harare
guardian.co.uk,
Monday July 7, 2008
The tortured and burned
body of an opposition party worker has been found on
a farm belonging to an
army colonel two weeks after the activist was
abducted while helping to
protect the widow of a murdered human rights
lawyer.
The Movement for
Democratic Change said the discovery of Joshua Bakacheza's
badly disfigured
corpse came amid a renewed intensification of violence
against its officials
and supporters, as the government attempts to break
resistance to President
Robert Mugabe's victory in the widely condemned June
28 election.
At
least 20 opposition activists have been murdered since the ballot. The
MDC
said the escalation in violence was particularly targeted at its members
of
parliament to try to overturn the party's newly won majority.
Costin
Muguti, an opposition MP, was abducted from his home in Gokwe and
severely
beaten by soldiers today before being handed to police who locked
him up on
charges of violence. At least 11 other MPs are facing criminal
charges and
scores have gone into hiding.
State security agents monitoring the home
of the MDC leader, Morgan
Tsvangirai, confronted guards at the house and
threatened them with guns but
eventually left.
Near Harare, masked
men attacked a centre housing about 350 people,
including children, who were
victims of earlier political violence by the
ruling Zanu-PF and who had
sought shelter at the South African embassy. The
South Africans had
persuaded them to move to the compound near Ruwa with
assurances of their
safety. The assault left at least eight people in
hospital and more than a
dozen missing. The rest are now being housed at a
church.
Bakacheza's
body was found 30km from Harare with signs of torture gunshot
wounds. The
MDC said he had been abducted by state security agents along
with another
activist, Tendai Chidziwo, while the pair were helping to move
the family
and furniture of Tonderai Ndirai, a prominent human rights lawyer
who was
murdered before the election.
The men were taken to an interrogation
centre, the MDC said. "Once there,
they tortured the two, asking questions
relating to their involvement in the
MDC and then shot them both. Joshua was
shot three times and died on the
spot, while Chidziwo is now recovering in
hospital after he was shot once on
right side of the head. Good Samaritans
assisted him after they found him in
a state of unconsciousness in the
Beatrice farming area."
An army colonel owns the farm where Joshua's body
was found.
Yahoo News
by Susan
Njanji Mon Jul 7, 11:47 AM ET
HARARE (AFP) - Zimbabwe's opposition
accused militias loyal to Robert Mugabe
of stepping up deadly attacks
against its followers Monday as the veteran
leader faced more foreign
criticism over his controversial re-election.
While US President
George W. Bush again labelled the June 27 poll a "sham",
the main opposition
Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) said another 20 of
its activists had
been killed since the run-off, bringing the total number
of dead since the
first round of voting in March to 109.
With Britain's top diplomat
accusing Mugabe of unleashing "a campaign of
unchecked brutality against his
own people," G8 leaders meeting in Japan
also heaped scorn on the Zimbabwean
president and discussed imposing new
sanctions.
However one of
Mugabe's top lieutenants in the ruling ZANU-PF party snapped
back that the
outside world had no role to play in the crisis and should
"stop meddling"
in Zimbabwe's affairs.
"ZANU-PF and state security agents have
intensified violence on MDC
supporters across the country since the holding
of the sham run-off," the
opposition party said in a statement.
As
well as the 20 activists known to have died since last month's one-man
poll,
thousands more had been severely assaulted, it added.
MDC leader Morgan
Tsvangirai, who beat Mugabe into second place in the first
round of voting,
boycotted the run-off after scores of his supporters were
killed. He said
last week that he would not take part in negotiations with
Mugabe's camp
until the violence was halted.
With Mugabe insisting last Friday that
there can be no dialogue until the
MDC acknowledges his re-election as
president, the prospects of a
breakthrough looked dim despite the claims of
ZANU-PF's chief negotiator
Patrick Chinamasa.
"We are confident that
if we are left to discuss this matter as Zimbabweans,
we will find a
solution sooner rather than later," he told state media.
But Chinamasa
also warned Mugabe's Western critics they were harming rather
helping the
prospects of progress towards a political solution.
"We appeal to
foreigners and external forces to leave the resolution of the
Zimbabwe
situation to Zimbabweans alone," Justice Minister Chinamasa told
the
state-run Herald newspaper.
"Britain, the US and the EU, in particular,
should stop meddling in our
affairs."
Bush however renewed his
criticism of 84-year-old Mugabe -- who has led the
former British colony
since independence in 1980 -- saying he was "extremely
disappointed" with
the "sham" election.
His comments came at a summit in Japan of the Group
of Eight industrial
powers, also attended by South African President Thabo
Mbeki, who is the
chief mediator on Zimbabwe, and UN Secretary General Ban
Ki-moon.
Ban, speaking to AFP on his plane as he arrived in Japan, said
Mugabe's
election lacked legitimacy.
"Therefore I urged that
political parties in Zimbabwe should work out an
arrangement so that they
can really bring back democractic rules, the rule
of law and peace and
stability in their country," Ban said.
German Chancellor Angela Merkel
meanwhile said new sanctions were to be
discussed at the three-day
gathering.
During a visit to South Africa, British Foreign Secretary
David Miliband
said Mugabe had "turned the weapons of the state on his own
people" and
called on the world to support fresh sanctions.
A limited
package of sanctions, including a travel ban and a freeze of bank
accounts,
was imposed on Mugabe and his inner circle by Western governments
after he
allegedly rigged his 2002 re-election.
Mugabe has regularly blamed the
sanctions for the economic collapse of the
region's breadbasket where
inflation is now well into eight figures and the
most basic foods, such as
bread and cooking oil, are scarce.
His critics say that Mugabe triggered
the country's economic woes by
expropriating thousands of white-owned farms
as part of a land reform
programme and say hyper-inflation is being fuelled
by the non-stop printing
of money.
Times Online
July 7, 2008
Philip Webster and Richard Lloyd Parry, Lake Toya,
Japan
President Mbeki of South Africa endured a rough ride at the G8 summit
as
major power leaders called him to task for failing to bring Zimbabwe's
Robert Mugabe to book.
Mr Mbeki was among seven African leaders who
joined a session at the Group
of Eight summit in Japan, where they were
warned clearly that trade and
investment on the continent could be hit
unless they acted to deal with the
"illegitimate" Zimbawean
president.
Several leaders, including President Bush, were said to have
directly
criticised Mr Mbeki, for his failure, as regional mediator, to rein
in Mr
Mugabe. Mr Bush calling last month's election a sham, while Chancellor
Angela Merkel said that she would back more sanctions.
"There's
growing support for sanctions against the Mugabe regime being
stepped up,"
Gordon Brown told reporters.
Tomorrow, the G8 leaders are expected to
threaten even tougher sanctions
against Zimbabwe unless African nations take
on a stronger role in
negotiations to remove him from power.
Mr Bush said
Zimbabwe was discussed extensively at the meeting on the
northern Japanese
island of Hokkaido but, according to the Tanzanian
President Jakaya Kikwete,
African leaders and the G8 differed over how to
respond to the
crisis.
"The only area that we may differ is on the way forward. You see
differently
but for us in Africa we see differently, but I think again there
is still
room for us for discussions," said Mr Kikwete, who is also head of
the
African Union.
"I want to assure you that the concerns that you
have expressed are indeed
the concerns of many of us in the African
continent," said Mr Kikwete, who
called again for a unity government in
Zimbabwe.
His words masked deep divisions in today's meeting, and growing
frustration
among European governments, including the British, at the role
played by Mr
Mbeki.
Mr Brown hopes that the G8 will call for tougher
UN and EU sanctions, and
will back his call for a UN envoy to go to
Zimbabwe.
Mr Mugabe was the only candidate in the June 27 run-off
election after the
opposition leader Morgan Tsvangirai pulled out because of
state-sponsored
violence against candidates and supporters of his the
Movement for
Democratic Change.
British officials came close to
saying that Mr Mugabe should go, insisting
that his election was not
legitimate and pointing to the first poll in which
the MDC leader finished
ahead.
Comments
As a South African, I am absolutely horrified by our
president's
misjudgement on Zimbabwe. The crisis has deepened to the point
where our
national security as risk. South Africa is now home to nearly 4
million
Zimbabwean immigrants, many of them illegal. The president seems not
to care
about us.
John Bostock, Johannesburg, South Africa
How
serious is the G8? If they cared enough pressure could be used to force
Mugabe out. I wonder if the G8 looked at the mutilated bodies, or saw
pictures of innocent people forced to drink liquids that burned out there
insides and blinded them. Oh, Zimbabwe has no oil, now I understand no
action.
M. Hulton, Carol Stream, USA
While I agree that Mugabe
is a dictator and a monster who has ruined his
country he is only one of
several in Africa. We seem to pay special
attention to Zimbawe but there are
many other equally nasty and illegitimate
regimes. Is it beacuse he claims
to be democratic when he clearly is not?
Kevin Miller,
Tonbridge,
Why do the G8 members want to impose their own solutions on
Zim? Why are
Zimbabweans being treated as bystanders in the solution to
their own
problems?Imposed solutions never work.
Davis,
Manchester,
Talk, Talk Talk Talk ... when is one of these people, I
cannot call them
leaders because none of the lead, going to stop talking and
do something?
Mugabe knows they are all weak and he will do whatever he
likes.
Lloyd, London,
The west loves justice, see Hollywood
for proof. We are disgusted by Zanu-PF
and it has nothing to do with race,
colonialism or white farmers. Murder is
a murder - no excuses. The west also
loves soccer. Will the west want to
play soccer in Africa in 2010 if
Zimbabwe is not free? No.
Eric de la Harpe, Reading, UK
Independent, Ireland
Monday July 07 2008
Robert Mugabe must not be allowed to wield
power from behind the scenes as
part of a new transitional government in
Zimbabwe, Britain warned today.
South African President Thabo Mbeki has
reportedly drawn up proposals that
would allow Mr Mugabe to remain as
titular president and head of state while
handing over power to opposition
leader Morgan Tsvangirai as prime minister.
However Foreign Secretary
David Miliband, in Johannesburg for talks with
South African leaders,
reacted coolly to the idea of any continuing role for
Mr Mugabe as part of
transitional settlement.
``We cannot be in a situation where in fact Mr
Mugabe is able to control
things from behind the scenes,'' he told BBC Radio
4's The World at One.
Britain, like other leading powers including the
United States and France,
has refused to recognise Mr Mugabe's victory in
last month's final run-off
for the presidential elections after Mr
Tsvangirai pulled out citing the
brutal campaign of violence and
intimidation against his supporters.
Mr Miliband said he believed that
the original elections in March - which
were won by Mr Tsvangirai and his
Movement for Democratic Change - still
offered the basis for a transitional
settlement.
``We do have the first round which showed us the democratic
will of the
people of Zimbabwe. They voted for change,'' he
said.
``The opposition has a majority in Parliament and Mr Tsvangirai won
the
presidential election, even though he didn't reach the 50% threshold
that
would have negated that need for a second round.
``So there is
the start of a democratic mandate. That is the basis for a
transitional
government and I think that that is the basis for progress in
Zimbabwe.''
Mr Miliband said that he hoped Mr Mbeki - as the regional
mediator - would
add an African Union delegate to his mediation team in
order to strengthen
the drive for a transitional settlement.
By Daily
Mail Reporter
Last updated at 6:18 PM on 07th July 2008
World leaders raised the prospect of more sanctions against Zimbabwe on
Monday unless quick progress is made to end a political crisis after a violent
election that extended President Robert Mugabe's 28-year rule.
At a Group of Eight nations summit in Japan, G8 heads of state told seven
African leaders at the gathering to deal with Mugabe or trade and investment
could be hit on the world's poorest continent, a Canadian official told
reporters.
G8 leaders slammed the poll on Monday, with President George W. Bush calling it a sham, while Chancellor Angela Merkel called it illegitimate and said she would back more sanctions.
Get in line: Italian Prime Minister Silvio Berusconi, left to right, Russian President Dmitriy Medvedev, German Chancellor Angela Merkel, Gordon Brown, Japanese Prime Minister Yasuo Fukuda, U.S. President George W. Bush, Canadian Prime Minister Stephen Harper, French President Nicolas Sarkozy and President of European Commission Jose Manuel Durao Barroso
'There's growing support for sanctions against the Mugabe regime being
stepped up,' British Prime Minister Gordon Brown told reporters.
Bush said Zimbabwe was discussed extensively at the meeting but Tanzanian President Jakaya Kikwete suggested African leaders and the G8 differed over how to respond to the crisis.
'The only area that we may differ is on the way forward. You see differently
but for us in Africa we see differently, but I think again there is still room
for us for discussions,' said Kikwete, who is also head of the African
Union.
'I want to assure you that the concerns that you have expressed are indeed the concerns of many of us in the African continent,' said Kikwete, who called again for a unity government in Zimbabwe.
International pressure: Gordon Brown chats with South African President Thabo Mbeki
International pressure: Zimbabwean President Robert Mugabe
Mugabe was the only candidate in the June 27 run-off election after
opposition leader Morgan Tsvangirai pulled out citing state-sponsored violence
against candidates and supporters of his the Movement for Democratic
Change.
The United States also pointed to divergent views.
'There were differences. Not all leaders are there yet,' said Dan Price,
assistant to the president for international economic affairs, said referring to
sanctions.
'It is fair to say that, you know, not all African leaders are in a position to support sanctions at this time.'
White House spokeswoman Dana Perino said there was discussion among some of
the African leaders about a power-sharing agreement for Zimbabwe and what it
would look like.
Asked how the White House would view a such a deal, Perino said: 'We're
waiting to see what it would look like.'
But G8 leaders suggested their patience was short.
'The Mugabe regime is an illegitimate regime and it should not be tolerated. Public opinion in G8 countries questions why the world would tolerate such a regime and questions why Africa would tolerate such a regime,' a senior Canadian official quoted G8 leaders as telling their African counterparts.
'A number of G8 leaders drew attention to the fact that if Africa were to
develop, more than just official development assistance was needed.
'It required trade, it required investment and the image of Africa was
suffering because of what was going on in Zimbabwe,' he told reporters.
An African Union summit issued a resolution last week calling for talks
leading to a national unity government in Zimbabwe.
But despite heightened African criticism, Mugabe, who attended the AU summit, seemed unchastened.
From left: Maria Margarida Sousa Uva Barroso, wife of European Commission President Jose Manuel Barroso, Laureen Harper, wife of Canadian Prime Minister Stephen Harper, Sarah Brown, wife of Britain's Prime Minister Gordon Brown, a model, Laura Bush, wife of U.S. President George W. Bush, Svetlana Medvedeva, wife of Russian President Dmitry Medvedev, and Kiyoko Fukuda, wife of Japanese Prime Minister Yasuo Fukuda
Merkel said she was willing to ramp up pressure on Mugabe.
'I have made very clear that I see the presidential election as
illegitimate,' Merkel said on Monday.
'I do not rule out further sanctions against Zimbabwe.'
European Commission President Jose Manuel Barroso urged a quick
solution.
'There was especially frank discussion underlining the damage that the current situation in Zimbabwe is making to the overall image of Africa and the need to find a quick solution for that very appalling and dramatic situation,' he said.
The G8's talks on Monday at a luxury hotel in northern Japan included leaders of Algeria, Ethiopia, Ghana, Nigeria, Senegal, South Africa and Tanzania.
SW
Radio Africa (London)
7 July 2008
Posted to the web 7 July
2008
Tichaona Sibanda
There is increasing concern for the
safety of the MDC MP for Buhera South,
who has not been seen or heard from
since he was abducted outside the High
court in Mutare last week
Tuesday.
The newly elected MP, Naison Nemadziwa was bundled into the back
of a
waiting car and driven away, after he became involved in an argument
with a
group of six men. The incident took place in full view of shocked
passersby
after the MP had gone to the court to hear an electoral petition
filed by
Joseph Chinotimba, the losing Zanu-PF candidate in the Buhera South
constituency.
Elton Mangoma, the MDC acting treasurer-general,
said having worked with
intensity in the last week to get information on his
whereabouts, most party
officials in Manicaland were now seriously concerned
about his safety.
'We are dealing with a rogue regime that can do
anything, so obviously we
are all worried about his well-being.' Mangoma
said.
Pishai Muchauraya, the MDC MP for Makoni South in the province,
said they
identified one of his abductors as Zimbabwe National Army Colonel
Morgan
Mzilikazi. The army officer, together with Chinotimba, has been
waging a war
of post election violence against MDC activists in Buhera.
IOL
July 07
2008 at 03:55PM
As G8 leaders began meeting in Japan on Monday for
talks on issues
including Zimbabwe, the country's opposition Movement for
Democratic Change
(MDC) repeated its demands for an end to political
violence as a condition
for entering talks with President Robert Mugabe on a
unity government.
Releasing gruesome photographs of the burnt body
of a man the MDC said
was its missing driver Joshua Bakacheza, the party
asked: "How does a self
respecting party enter into negotiations within the
context of such level of
violence?"
The MDC said Bakacheza was
abducted in the Zimbabwean capital Harare
by 16 armed men in three trucks
nearly two weeks ago.
He was abducted along
with another MDC activist, Tendai Chidziwo, who
was later found on a farm
and rushed to hospital with serious head injuries.
The photographs
circulated by the MDC on Monday shows the body of a
man whose trunk is so
badly burnt the flesh has melted off the bones,
revealing his rib
cage.
According to the MDC, more than ten of its supporters have
been killed
by pro-Mugabe youth militia since Zimbabwe's controversial June
27
presidential election, which the MDC, the West and a handful of African
countries have denounced as illegitimate.
Mugabe was
inaugurated as president for a sixth term after running
uncontested in the
election run-off that Tsvangirai boycotted.
The latest MDC
fatalities bring to about 100 the number of opposition
supporters killed by
Mugabe supporters since the first round of voting for
president on March 29
that Tsvangirai won.
As G8 leaders prepared to discuss the
Zimbabwean impasse, for which
the African Union has prescribed a Kenya-style
unity government, the MDC
repeated on Monday it would not recognise Mugabe
as president, a condition
Mugabe gave last week for talks on sharing
power.
"MDC does not recognise the 27th of June 'event' and
accordingly does
not recognise the outcome, thereof," the MDC said in a
statement, calling
again for the MDC's March 29 victory to be the basis for
the talks.
At the weekend Tsvangirai boycotted talks with Mugabe
brokered by
South African President Thabo Mbeki, southern Africa's mediator
in Zimbabwe.
The leader of a smaller MDC faction, Arthur Mutambara, was in
attendance.
Party spokesman Nelson Chamisa said Tsvangirai ducked
the meeting
because the MDC's conditions for talks had not been met. -
Sapa-dpa
IOL
July
07 2008 at 01:05PM
Pretoria - British Foreign Secretary David
Miliband on Monday said
Robert Mugabe had "turned the weapons of the state
on his own people" and
urged the world to support fresh sanctions against
his regime.
In a speech at a university during a three-day visit to
South Africa,
Miliband accused the 84-year-old Zimbabwean leader of
unleashing "a campaign
of unchecked brutality against his own
people."
"He has turned the weapons of the state on his own
people," Miliband
told an audience at the University of South
Africa.
He reiterated Britain's call for a "transitional government
based on
the 29 March election".
Opposition Movement for
Democratic Change (MDC) leader Morgan
Tsvangirai finished ahead of Mugabe in
the March 29 first round of the
election, but with an official vote total
just short of an outright
majority.
"For the British
government, the way out is clear," said Miliband.
"We will argue
this in the UN this week. There needs to be a
transitional government based
on the 29 March election in Zimbabwe."
He added: "The world
community needs to unite with the UN, not only to
condemn violence but to
initiate further sanctions on the regime ..."
Tsvangirai pulled out
of the June 27 run-off five days ahead of the
poll, citing rising violence
against his supporters that left dozens dead
and thousands
injured.
Defying international and regional calls to postpone the
election,
Mugabe pushed ahead with the vote, which predictably handed him a
landslide
victory.
Mugabe, who has ruled Zimbabwe since
independence from Britain in
1980, has said he is open to talks with the
opposition but only if they
accept him as president.
The MDC,
which also won a majority in parliament over Mugabe's Zanu-PF
party, insists
it has a mandate to head up any government.
Miliband visited
Zimbabwean refugees at a church after arriving in
South Africa on Sunday and
warned that the crisis in the neighbouring
country was "infecting the whole
of southern Africa".
Yahoo News
By David
Ljunggren Mon Jul 7, 7:37 AM ET
TOYAKO, Japan (Reuters) - World leaders
raised the prospect of more
sanctions against Zimbabwe on Monday unless
quick progress is made to end a
political crisis after a violent election
that extended President Robert
Mugabe's 28-year rule.
At a Group
of Eight nations summit in Japan, G8 heads of state told seven
African
leaders at the gathering to deal with Mugabe or trade and investment
could
be hit on the world's poorest continent, a Canadian official told
reporters.
G8 leaders slammed the poll on Monday, with President
George W. Bush calling
it a sham, while Chancellor Angela Merkel called it
illegitimate and said
she would back more sanctions.
"There's growing
support for sanctions against the Mugabe regime being
stepped up," British
Prime Minister Gordon Brown told reporters.
Bush said Zimbabwe was
discussed extensively at the meeting but Tanzanian
President Jakaya Kikwete
suggested African leaders and the G8 differed over
how to respond to the
crisis.
"The only area that we may differ is on the way forward. You see
differently
but for us in Africa we see differently, but I think again there
is still
room for us for discussions," said Kikwete, who is also head of the
African
Union.
"I want to assure you that the concerns that you have
expressed are indeed
the concerns of many of us in the African continent,"
said Kikwete, who
called again for a unity government in
Zimbabwe.
Mugabe was the only candidate in the June 27 run-off election
after
opposition leader Morgan Tsvangirai pulled out citing state-sponsored
violence against candidates and supporters of his the Movement for
Democratic Change.
POWER-SHARING
The United States also
pointed to divergent views.
"There were differences. Not all leaders are
there yet," Dan Price,
assistant to the president for international economic
affairs, said
referring to sanctions.
"It is fair to say that, you
know, not all African leaders are in a position
to support sanctions at this
time."
White House spokeswoman Dana Perino said there was discussion
among some of
the African leaders about a power-sharing agreement for
Zimbabwe and what it
would look like.
Asked how the White House would
view a such a deal, Perino said: "We're
waiting to see what it would look
like."
But G8 leaders suggested their patience was short.
"The
Mugabe regime is an illegitimate regime and it should not be tolerated.
Public opinion in G8 countries questions why the world would tolerate such a
regime and questions why Africa would tolerate such a regime," a senior
Canadian official quoted G8 leaders as telling their African
counterparts.
"A number of G8 leaders drew attention to the fact that if
Africa were to
develop, more than just official development assistance was
needed. It
required trade, it required investment and the image of Africa
was suffering
because of what was going on in Zimbabwe," he told
reporters.
An African Union summit issued a resolution last week calling
for talks
leading to a national unity government in Zimbabwe.
But
despite heightened African criticism, Mugabe, who attended the AU
summit,
seemed unchastened.
Merkel said she was willing to ramp up pressure on
Mugabe.
"I have made very clear that I see the presidential election as
illegitimate," Merkel said on Monday.
"I do not rule out further
sanctions against Zimbabwe."
European Commission President Jose Manuel
Barroso urged a quick solution.
"There was especially frank discussion
underlining the damage that the
current situation in Zimbabwe is making to
the overall image of Africa and
the need to find a quick solution for that
very appalling and dramatic
situation," he said.
The G8's talks on
Monday at a luxury hotel in northern Japan included
leaders of Algeria,
Ethiopia, Ghana, Nigeria, Senegal, South Africa and
Tanzania.
Reuters
Mon Jul 7, 2008 3:13pm
BST
By Nelson Banya
HARARE (Reuters) - Zimbabwe urged the
world on Monday to accept President
Robert Mugabe's re-election and said any
move to impose U.N. sanctions on
his government would hurt everyone
involved.
This week, the U.N. Security Council is due to discuss a U.S.
and
British-based proposal for financial and travel restrictions on Mugabe
and
his top officials as well as an arms embargo on Zimbabwe.
World
leaders at a Group of Eight nations summit in Japan also raised the
prospect
of more sanctions on Zimbabwe unless quick progress is made to end
a
political crisis after Mugabe's re-election in a poll that drew global
condemnation.
"It is the UK that is pushing for sanctions, but
isolating and demonising
Zimbabwe is not in the best interests of anyone.
They should treat Zimbabwe
as a partner rather than an enemy," Deputy
Information Minister Bright
Matonga said.
"The people of Zimbabwe
made a decision on June 27 and that decision has to
be
respected."
The sanctions are aimed at punishing Mugabe and his closest
aides for
holding a presidential run-off election last month that was
boycotted by
challenger Morgan Tsvangirai, who accused Mugabe of deadly
attacks on his
supporters.
Mugabe, 84, was sworn in for a new
five-year term after election authorities
declared he had won a landslide
victory. Britain, the United States and many
Western nations refuse to
recognise his victory and view his government as
illegitimate.
Foreign Secretary David Miliband called on Monday for
the world to unite on
the sanctions proposal.
Tsvangirai won a March
29 election but failed to win the absolute majority
needed to avoid a second
ballot. He withdrew from the campaign after
repeated attacks on supporters
of his Movement for Democratic Change by
pro-Mugabe militia.
The MDC
leader has refused to recognise Mugabe's victory and demanded that
violence
be stopped and that the result of the March 29 elections be
accepted as
pre-conditions for any talks with the veteran ruler's
government.
The
opposition accused Mugabe's ruling ZANU-PF of terrorising MDC activists
and
voters between the March and June polls. The MDC says more than 100 of
its
followers have been killed in a crackdown by Mugabe's supporters. The
party
said on Monday that one more body had been found.
Tsvangirai was arrested
five times and his lieutenant, Tendai Biti, was
detained on a treason charge
after returning to the country to participate
in the campaign. He could face
the death penalty if found guilty.
A Zimbabwean court on Monday postponed
proceedings against Biti until August
26. The MDC secretary general is
accused of prematurely leaking the results
of the March elections. He is
currently free on bail.
(Additional reporting by Muchena Zigomo in
Pretoria and David Ljunggren in
Tokyo; Writing by Paul Simao; Editing by
Matthew Tostevin)
It is Armed Struggle or
All-inclusive Dialogue
By Arthur G.O.
Mutambara
7th July 2008; Harare,
Zimbabwe
The Stark Choices
Zimbabwe is
facing a major political, humanitarian and economic crisis after
the illegal
and fraudulent Presidential election on the 27th of June 2008.
The output of
such an electoral process can only be an illegitimate
incumbent. There are
two options for us as Zimbabweans: Pick up arms of war
and drive out Robert
Mugabe or negotiate an all-inclusive national political
settlement. These
are the only choices. We need to be decisive in our
analysis and strategic
thinking. Given our circumstances and history it
seems the only sensible
and conceivable way forward is through national
dialogue among all the key
civic and political stakeholders, in pursuit of a
political agreement. The
immediate challenges include defining the
framework, format, timeline and
terms of reference for that dialogue.
Thereafter, and more importantly, the
question then becomes: What kind of
political settlement will lead to a
democratic, justiciable and sustainable
resolution of the
crisis?
The Political Settlement
In terms of the
potential outcomes of the dialogue, there are three key
possibilities; an
inclusive and stable government on the terms of
democratically elected
citizens, a government of national unity involving
all key political
players, and a transitional government tasked with the
mandate of
supervising fresh free and fair elections. These are the
scenarios, or their
variations or permutations, which could constitute a
political settlement in
our country. Beyond the political agreement there
must be a comprehensive,
drawn out and all-inclusive national healing and
rehabilitation program.
This is very essential, given the extent of the
political polarization,
physical devastation and psychological trauma that
our people have gone
through in the last 3 months. There is also need to
quickly address the
humanitarian aspects of the crisis, while putting in
place mechanisms to
salvage, recover and stabilize the economy.
It must be emphasized
that commitment to dialogue as a strategy of
resolution does not mean
agreement to a particular negotiation format, nor
does it mean endorsement
of a specific political outcome. All these matters
must be discussed and
resolved as part of the all-inclusive dialogue
process. What is imperative
for Zimbabweans is making up their minds on
whether they want an armed
revolution or they want to talk to each other. It
is that simple. Of course
if negotiations do not succeed there will be only
one option left to the
people of Zimbabwe. We will fight.
Towards a Sustainable
Resolution
Resolving the current national crisis through
mediation and external
intervention must be understood as a short-term
effort that must be
complimented by long-term and holistic processes driven
by Zimbabweans
themselves. We need to start defining a common
socio-economic-political
framework that we all defend as citizens
irrespective of political
affiliation. This should be a shared framework in
which we contest each
other for power and develop economic strategies to
drive our country. There
must be some things we agree on in spite of our
diverse political
associations. In addition to agreeing on the name of the
country and its
boundary, why can't we have a constitution that we all
defend and revere?
Why can't we have both a democratic culture and a
political system, rooted
in issues-based plural politics, which we all
celebrate and protect? Would
we all not cherish the day when Gideon Gono,
Emerson Munangagwa and Joice
Mujuru spend 15 months in public debates in a
party primary election to
determine the ZANU-PF national Presidential
candidate? Surely, a similar
internal, protracted and public contestation in
the opposition will enable
distillation of ideas leading to both high
quality candidates and platforms.
Change must have both form and substance.
This is the long term dream,
beyond the immediate crisis. Why can't we
collectively develop a 20-30 year
national economic vision shared by all
Zimbabwean political parties and
civic society? Why can't we just differ on
strategies and tactics of
achieving the vision but not question the nature
and existence of the
Promised Land?
There is need for
Zimbabweans to embrace generational thinking and analysis.
The generation of
Joshua Nkomo, Herbert Chitepo, Robert Mugabe, Jason Moyo
and Nbabaningi
Sithole have a result; the Independence of Zimbabwe in 1980.
What is the
legacy of Saviour Kasukuwere, Sylvester Nguni, Nelson Chamisa
and Priscilla
Misihairambwi? What is their generational result they can
point to when they
are 84 years old? We need to establish a multi-party,
all-encampsing
generational agenda which must define us as Zimbabweans. Yes,
we should
borrow and learn from other successful economies and cultures.
However,
there must be local ownership and buy-in of the formulation,
construction
and implementation of the socio-economic models. Making
Zimbabwe a peaceful,
democratic and prosperous nation should be the central
organizing mantra of
our thinking. More significantly and specifically, if
our generation can
make Zimbabwe a globally competitive economy in 20 years
time, in terms of
GDP, per capita income, entrepreneurship, business growth,
exports,
productivity, competitiveness, financial literacy, and quality of
life, that
will be our cross-party generational result.
Yes, we must
confront the Zimbabwean crisis and resolve it as a matter of
urgency.
However, there is need for broader and longer term processes to
ensure
sustainability of the resolution. Let us step up to the plate. We owe
it to
ourselves and to posterity.
This is our generational
mandate.
Arthur G.O. Mutambara
By Violet Gonda
7 July
2008
The Mutambara MDC has come under fire after it emerged that the
group met
with Robert Mugabe and South African President Thabo Mbeki in
Harare on
Saturday. A meeting boycotted by MDC leader Morgan
Tsvangirai.
The leader of the MDC breakaway faction, Professor Arthur
Mutambara, said:
"Our information was that Mr Tsvangirai was the one who
requested that
meeting and secondly Mr Tsvangirai had confirmed his
attendance at that
meeting, otherwise we would not have attended that
meeting if we knew that
Mr Tsvangirai was not going to
attend."
However, an official from the Tsvangirai MDC said a request had
been made
for a meeting, but that was before the 27 June sham election. The
Tsvangirai
MDC said Mugabe refused to have the meeting and went ahead with
the run off
poll.
The Tsvangirai MDC official who spoke on condition
of anonymity, said the
meeting was supposed to be between Mugabe and
Tsvangirai, but for this
Saturday meeting Mbeki had gone ahead and invited
the Mutambara MDC. "It was
very clear that Mugabe wanted a photo shoot
opportunity and Thabo Mbeki
wanted to hoodwink leaders at the G8 summit that
the parties were talking,"
the official said.
The Tsvangirai MDC
added that it boycotted Saturday's meeting because
conditions for
negotiations had not been met, which included an end to
violence and
clarification on the issue of Thabo Mbeki as the sole
negotiator. Tsvangirai
has in the past complained that Mbeki is not an
honest broker who favours
the Mugabe regime.
There was an outcry from many Zimbabweans when they
saw news photos of
Mutambara shaking hands with Mugabe at State House. The
photos were used in
the state media as a PR opportunity.
Asked if
going to State House was legitimising Mugabe, Mutambara responded
by saying:
"That is nonsense. What is important is meeting. We want to make
sure that
Zimbabweans get together. It doesn't matter where they meet. We
are not
caught up on the rubbish around form. We are concerned about
substance. if
Mr Tsvangirai is concerned about meeting in the State House we
can meet
under a tree and discuss the matters of our country."
Some Zimbabweans
had hoped the two MDC's would emerge as a united front
against the Mugabe
regime but the gap between the two formations seems to be
widening. Although
the two groups went to the negotiating table as one
before the elections,
they contested the parliamentary elections as separate
entities and continue
to differ on ideologies. While the Tsvangirai MDC says
it will only
participate in negotiations when the violence stops, the
Mutambara MDC says
you can't begin the discourse on violence if you don't
talk.
Mutambara says it is well documented that there is political
illegitimacy in
Zimbabwe because of the fraudulent election held on the 27th
June. He said
this leaves Zimbabweans with only two choices, either an armed
struggle to
drive Mugabe out of power, or an all inclusive dialogue leading
to a
political settlement.
He defended his party's decision to attend
the meeting saying given the
history of Zimbabwe and the current
circumstance the only option that is
viable is negotiations. "The issues
about the format, the terms of
reference, the timeline, the type of
mediation for that negotiation could be
resolved as part of the
dialogue."
SW Radio Africa Zimbabwe news
MASHAVA, 7 July 2008 (IRIN) - The ban on non-governmental organisation
(NGO) activities in the lead-up to the second round of voting in the
presidential ballot is beginning to bite, according to Zimbabwe's communal
farmers, who are weathering the worst food shortages in living memory.
Photo:
Obinna Anyadike/IRIN
Still banned
Alleging political bias, the government suspended all NGO activities,
but the opposition Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) claims the ban was
instituted to try and hide the political violence unleashed against its
supporters after the 29 March general elections, in which President Robert
Mugabe's ZANU-PF lost control of parliament for the first time since the country
gained independence from Britain in 1980.
Neither Mugabe nor MDC leader
Morgan Tsvangirai was able to win 50 percent plus one vote in the first round of
voting to elect Zimbabwe's president, necessitating a second round of voting on
27 June, from which Tsvangirai withdrew after more than 80 MDC supporters were
murdered and tens of thousands of people displaced by violence, allegedly by
ZANU-PF militia.
Hansen Chipembere, 60, a small-scale farmer in the
Zvinyaningwe area of Masvingo Province, about 60km from the provincial capital,
Masvingo, told IRIN: "We are an unlucky lot. This year has been the worst ever
for us, and that is when authorities decide our benefactors (NGOs) should stop
assisting. You can smell the hunger as you move around."
He inherited
the land from his father five years ago, but had worked the smallholding outside
the old asbestos mining town of Mashava for 40 years. During that time, he had
never witnessed such levels of crop failure as that experienced during the
2007/08 season.
This year has been the worst ever for us, and that is when authorities
decide our benefactors (NGOs) should stop assisting. You can smell the hunger
as you move around
The poor harvest is being blamed on a combination of
heavy rains at the beginning of the planting season, followed by a prolonged dry
spell, as well as the lack of agricultural inputs, such as fertilisers and seed,
leaving farmers without food to feed themselves or any surplus to produce an
income.
Chipembere told IRIN that government's agricultural planners
had consistently failed to heed the advice of smallholder farmers, which would
have made them less vulnerable to the vagaries of the weather.
His 50ha smallholding hugs Muzhwi dam, built at a cost of US$5.8 million
a decade ago primarily to augment water supplies to the sugar estates in the
Lowveld, 500km south of the capital, Harare, but also to irrigate communal
lands.
"We can only watch and admire the scenery while we scrounge for
food. That body of water could alleviate our plight," Chipembere commented. For
the past three years he and other communal farmers have travelled to Masvingo to
try and persuade agricultural planners to design an irrigation scheme suitable
for their area.
"We were frustrated by the bureaucracy and gave up after
spending a lot of money on bus fares, and investing a lot of time in trying to
get the officials to act," Benjamin Guruva, a smallholder farmer whose plot
borders Muzhwi dam, told IRIN. "We have the farming experience but have been
completely left out of the government scheme."
Food promised
British cabinet minister Douglas Alexander, the Secretary of State for
International Development, which promotes poverty alleviation and development in
poor countries, has promised US$18 million to the World Food Programme to
provide for the millions of people expected to require food assistance.
Alexander also called on Zimbabwe to lift the ban on NGOs, so that aid could
reach those in need and facing starvation.
The bulk of the funding will
be used to provide food, but a proportion will be used to strengthen WFP
monitoring systems to prevent political interference and ensure that the food is
received by all those who require it.
The Food and Agricultural
Organisation (FAO) and World Food Programme (WFP) crop assessment forecast,
released in June 2008, projected that about 5.1 million Zimbabweans will suffer
food insecurity.
"The Mission estimates that 2.04 million people in
rural and urban areas will be food insecure between July and September 2008,
rising to 3.8 million people between October and peaking to about 5.1 million at
the height of the hungry season between January and March 2009," the FAO/WFP
Crop and Food Supply Assessment Mission to Zimbabwe said.
Zimbabwe's
population is estimated at about 12 million people, but this does not take into
account the more than three million people thought to have left the country
since 2000 as a result of mounting economic and political instability.
Republic of Botswana - Office of the President
4/7/08
From: Dr.
Jeff Ramsay
Coordinator- Government Communication and Information
System
(BGCIS)
Contacts: Office Telephone: (267) 3975338 & Facsimile:
(267) 3957830.
Cell: (267)71318598. E-mail: jramsay@gov.bw
Please find below the
Statement by the Botswana Observer Team of the SADC
Election Observer Mission
that was read out at this morning's Press
Conference Gaborone, which was also
addressed by Hon. Minister of Foreign
affairs and International Cooperation
(Statement Previously
forwarded)
STATEMENT OF THE BOTSWANA OBSERVER
TEAM ON THE JUNE 27, 2008 ZIMBABWE
PRESIDENTIAL RUN-OFF ELECTIONS
On
behalf of the Botswana Team that took part in the observation of the
Zimbabwe
Presidential run off elections I would like to start off by
thanking the
Government of Botswana for having given us the opportunity to
be part of the
SADC Election Observer Mission otherwise known as SEOM.
Due to time
constraints what we are going to present here today is a brief
summary of our
report to the Botswana Government concerning our
observations, findings, and
conclusions as we saw the situation on the
ground.
The main objective
of our mission was to ensure that the Zimbabwe
Presidential run-off elections
were held in accordance with the SADC
Principles and Guidelines Governing
Democratic Elections. These principles
constitute on essential tool for
determining the validity, integrity and
credibility of elections. The
expectation was that at the end we should be
able to make a determination as
to whether or not the elections were free
and fair. Briefly stated and to
the extent material these principles are as
follows:
* Full
participation of the citizens and political process
* Freedom of
association
* Political tolerance
* Equal opportunity for all political
parties to access the state media
* Equal opportunity to exercise the right
to vote and be voted for
* Independence of the judiciary and the impartiality
of the electoral
institutional, just to mention but a few
The team
which represented Botswana was made up of 50 persons drawn from the
three
political parties represented in the National Assembly, Civic Bodies,
Civil
Servants and Academics.
I believe ladies and gentlemen as you can see the
team is well represented
in terms of gender balance, age and background. All
in all, the SADC
Observer Mission had 413 observers from 12 of the 14 SADC
member states.
You will note that the number was quite large compared to the
number sent in
the March 29 elections. The Government of Botswana also
availed 8 vehicles
to be used by the Mission. The increase in the number was
to allow for a
better coverage of the election process taking into account
the nature of
these elections. You will note with the benefit of hindsight
ladies and
gentlemen, that this approach by Government has benefited the
Mission and
SADC as well as all those concerned about the situation in
Zimbabwe.
Because of the numbers, we were able to cover all the 10 provinces
of
Zimbabwe and this gave us the opportunity to observe first hand
what
transpired during the run-up to the elections.
OBSERVATIONS
AND FINDINGS
Coming to the observations and findings I will start with
the campaign
process.
1. CAMPAIGN PROCESS
In terms of the SADC
principles, contesting parties are entitled to
equitable access to the state
controlled media. We however observed that
the state media prominently
featured ZANU-PF political advertisements and
messages to the exclusion of
MDC-T. In the few instances where reference
was made to the MDC - T in the
state media, the messages were ZANU -PF
sponsored and intended to disparage,
de-campaign and discredit the MDC-T. A
case in point was a TV advertisement
depicting Morgan Tsvangirai's head
alongside those of some three known heads
of state from the Western world
and is entitled the Loser's club. On inquiry
by the observers as to why
MDC-T was not covered, the Zimbabwe Electoral
Commission responded by saying
ZBH which controls the state media declined to
flight MDC advertisements on
the basis that they were uncomfortable with the
language used.
I will now move on to the observations we made under the
right to vote and
be voted for. Voting in Zimbabwe is in two ways, there is
postal voting
which is conducted some days prior to the actual voting day and
the voting
that takes place on polling day. Postal voting is intended for
members of
the disciplined forces, foreign missions and any other applicant
whose
nature of duty may take them away from their wards on polling day.
Under
postal voting ZEC informed the observers that in the March 29 elections
8000
people had applied for postal voting, but that in the Presidential
run-off
elections this number had increased to 64000. The Observer Teams
were
however, not able to observe the postal voting process because
information
about it was not forthcoming from ZEC. Even where the Observer
Teams got
information about postal voting taking place they were denied
access to the
polling stations by the Commanders at the Police Stations where
most of this
postal voting was taking place. When the Observer Teams enquired
about this
with ZEC we were informed that it was within the discretion of
the
Commanding officers to either grant or refuse such authority. Worth
noting
however, was that the Observer Teams received reports that postal
voting
took place in the presence, and under the directions of Commanding
Officers
who instructed their juniors to vote for the ZANU-PF candidate or
risk
losing their jobs.
2. HOLDING OF RALLIES
The Team observed
that the holding of rallies was a preserve of the ruling
ZANU - PF, whilst
the MDC-T political rallies were systematically disrupted
by the ZANU-PF
militia and youth. For instance, on Sunday 22nd June 2008,
the Team
witnessed first hand how a planned "star rally organized by Mr.
Morgan
Tsvangirai was prevented from taking place by a group of youth
wearing
ZANU-PF regalia armed with sticks, stones and sjamboks. They chased
and
indiscriminately beat all the people in the vicinity of the venue where
the
rally was taking place. All this was done in full view of SADC
observers
including some members present here. Riot police passively
witnessed these
attacks making no attempts whatsoever to intervene. After
completing their
task these youth retreated to the ZANU-PF headquarters
where they were
treated to food.
Other incidents of politically motivated violence by the
Team included the
following:
People believed to be associated with the
MDC-T party were subjected to
severe beatings, harassment, torture, killings
and general threats of
violence. The Police also appeared not to be
enforcing law and order, and
the ZANU-PF youth and militia mounted illegal
road blocks, forcing people to
attend ZANU-PF rallies and had bases where
they tortured perceived opponents
under the guise of re-educating them. In
contrast ZANU-PF supporters
received the full protection of the Police as
their rallies were never
disrupted nor did they report any incidents of
harassment to the Observer
Teams.
3. LACK OF RESPECT FOR THE ELCTORAL
PROCESS
During the campaigns, the observer mission noted with concern
the
uncompromising positions adopted by the contesting
political
parties/candidates to accept the outcome of the electoral process.
The
MDC-T Presidential candidate Mr. Tsvangirai, on the one hand made it
clear
that he will not accept a win by ZANU-PF Presidential candidate, Mr.
Mugabe,
citing politically motivated violence among other things. On the
other hand,
ZANU-PF President Mr. Mugabe made it clear at most political
rallies and
meetings he addressed that he would not accept the outcome of the
election
if MDC-T presidential candidate won. His reasons were also
supported by the
leadership of the party, the Military and Police
Commanders.
4. POLITICALLY MOTIVATED VIOLANCE
The team observed
high level of intimidation and politically motivated
violence that escalated
with the approach to the run-off elections leading
to injuries to persons,
internal and external displacements of people,
abductions, loss of property,
loss of lives, theft and looting. In short,
the may hem observed by the team,
had the effect of depriving the people of
Zimbabwe, the opportunity to fully
participate in the electoral process.
5. POLLING DAY
VOTING
Generally speaking there was an apparently calm atmosphere on
voting day.
But beneath this calmness was a noticeable voter intimidation
where voters
were required to record the Serial Number on their ballot papers
and later
submit that information to functionaries of the ruling ZANU-PF.
One
actually came and asked where the serial number is. This was intended
to
induce some voters into believing that the information pertaining to
how
they voted would be accessible and used against them.
In some
rural polling stations, Chiefs/Headmen were used to record the names
of their
subjects who were then required, against their will, to go and
queue behind
their chief / headmen on voting day and vote in a
pre-determined sequence.
In this way voters were made to believe that their
voting patterns were
capable of being verified as to whether they indeed
voted for ZANU-PF. We
noticed a high number of those who said they could not
read and write and in
such cases they were "assisted" by the Presiding
Officers in the presence of
two other Polling Officers and a Police officer.
6. WITHDRAWAL OF MR.
MORGAN TSVANGIRAI FROM THE RACE
It is now common knowledge that on 22
June 2008 Mr. Tsvangirai announced his
withdrawal from the Presidential race
citing among other things the
prevalence and escalating politically motivated
violence. It is also common
knowledge that ZEC did not accept his withdrawal
from the elections arguing
that it was not in accordance with the Zimbabwe
electoral laws and
regulations. The bottom line however, is that for all
intents and purposes
the election effectively became a one-horse race,
pitting Mr. Robert Mugabe
against a non-participating Mr. Morgan Tsvangirai.
It is worth noting
however, that even after Mr. Tsvangirai's withdrawal from
the race the level
of violence did not go down. Voter harassment and
intimidation, beatings
and displacements continued unabated.
7.
HARASSMENT OF OBSERVERS
The Team noted with that some Observers were
subjected to harassment. On
different occasions, some members of the Team
were chased away from rallies
addressed by ZANU-PF and prevented from
carrying out their observer duties.
In some instances, Observers were
threatened with violence and instructed to
leave such rallies. The Team was
in particular singled out for harassment
on account of perceptions that
Botswana was anti-ZANU-PF.
CONCLUSION
The level of intimidation
and political violence that escalated with the
approach of the June 27
Presidential run-off elections has been clearly
catalogued. There were many
victims of violence in the form of injuries,
displacements, abductions, loss
of property, and loss of lives. The
atrocities have been corroborated and
constitute the necessary evidence to
conclude that the credibility and
integrity of the election process was
compromised.
Notwithstanding the
apparent orderly conduct that prevailed on voting day,
the entire election
process was marred by a wave of violence. The Team
therefore concludes that
the Presidential run-off election was not free and
fair and does not
represent the will of the people of Zimbabwe.
Financial Times
By Krishna
Guha
Published: July 7 2008 19:14 | Last updated: July 7 2008
19:14
Leaders from the developed world and Africa failed on Monday to
agree on how
to deal with the crisis in Zimbabwe, which overshadowed a
meeting between
the Group of Eight and seven African heads of
state.
The African leaders resisted pressure from the US and Europe for
sanctions
against the Mugabe regime, telling the western nations that they
still saw
scope for African diplomacy to lead to a power-sharing
accord.
Appearing at a joint news conference with President George
W. Bush, Jakaya
Kikwete, president of Tanzania and chairman of the African
Union, said: “The
only area where we may differ is on the way
forward.”
Last week the African Union called on both sides in the Zimbabwe
crisis –
President Robert Mugabe and the opposition Movement for Democratic
Change –
to come together in a national unity government. The call came
after Mr
Mugabe declared himself the winner of a presidential election
run-off on
June 27 which the MDC candidate, Morgan Tsvangirai, boycotted,
citing
violence against his supporters.
Mr Kikwete said: “We are
saying no party can govern alone in Zimbabwe and
therefore the parties have
to work together.”
He assured Mr Bush that African leaders understood the
urgency of dealing
with the crisis, saying: “The concerns that you have
expressed are indeed
the concerns of many of us in the African continent.”
Dan Price, US deputy
national security adviser for international economic
affairs, told reporters
after the meeting: “There were differences. Not all
leaders are there yet,
in respect of sanctions.”
The US and its
European allies made it clear they would keep up the pressure
for a further
United Nations Security Council resolution on Zimbabwe.
US officials said
there was broad agreement with the African leaders on the
need to resolve
the crisis.
Dana Perino, the chief White House spokesperson, suggested
the US was still
open to an accord that respected the “will of the people of
Zimbabwe” while
also sharing power between the two main parties.
http://www.worldpoliticsreview.com
Michael Wilkerson | 07 Jul
2008
World Politics Review Exclusive
Nigerian author Wole
Soyinka -- the first African to win the Nobel
prize -- famously described
the Organization of African Unity (OAU) as a
"collaborative club of
perpetual self-preservation." Part of the reason the
continental body
re-branded itself as the African Union (AU) in 2001 was to
distance itself
from the days, when the most brutal of dictators took a
break from killing
the opposition and stealing state funds to mingle will
colleagues in fancy
hotels.
As the African Union summit in Egypt closed July 1, its
failure to
take any serious action on Mugabe's crumbling Zimbabwe was
reminiscent of
the old days when the OAU simply looked the other way. After
Zimbabwe's
blatantly unfair election, much was made of the opportunity for
the AU to
prove its recently democratized values were more than words alone.
The
organization's latest charter, adopted with the name change in 2001,
codified democratic principles like constitutionalism, separation of powers,
human rights, freedom of expression, and political pluralism. It even
strengthened the AU's power to intervene in member countries in "grave
circumstances."
Presented with undeniably grave circumstances
in Zimbabwe and the
support of almost every Western power, the AU did
nothing. Is anyone really
surprised?
Yes, there was an official
call by the AU for a government of national
unity in Zimbabwe, and a few
leaders like the presidents of Sierra Leone and
Liberia vocally protested at
the meeting. But these leaders, Ernest Bai
Koroma and Ellen Sirleaf Johnson,
respectively, are from a different mold
than much of the AU crowd. Both lead
new, improving democracies and came to
power not long after witnessing
devastating civil wars in their countries,
which were unleashed by the kind
of people the OAU used to condone.
Their courageous protests at the
summit were backed by other
condemnations of Mugabe from afar by people like
Kenyan Prime Minister Raila
Odinga and former South African leader Nelson
Mandela. The courage of these
few leaders should be applauded. The sad thing
is the AU was never really in
a position, morally or practically, to do
anything about Mugabe.
As Guardian columnist Simon Tisdall noted in
a June 30 column, Africa
retains an unfortunately high number of leaders who
have been there for
decades -- some longer than Mugabe. The ugly human
rights records of many of
these men would make it difficult for them to come
down too hard on Mugabe
for moral reasons, international pressure or not.
"Publicly defenestrating
Zimbabwe's self-declared president might create an
uncomfortable precedent
for them," Tisdall wrote.
Practically,
what could the AU do to coerce Mugabe? South Africa, the
only AU country
that could exert serious military or economic pressure on
Zimbabwe has
refused. Though the AU has sent peacekeepers to Darfur and
Somalia, those
forces have been small and underfunded -- hardly sufficient
to deal with
those disasters. Short of endorsing a force from the U.N. or
from a Western
country (and none were volunteering) the AU was left with
little choice but
to issue a grandiose statement. Still, this statement
could have condemned
the elections or refused to recognize Mugabe's
presidency. But rather than
confront Mugabe, the summit took the easy
choice. One step above
nothing.
It didn't help that Mugabe still commands an almost
unexplainable
respect from his days as liberation hero. Only last year at
the AU summit in
Ghana, huge crowds turned out to hear Mugabe and his North
African buddy
Moammar Gadhafi preach from the pan-African bible. Two of
Africa's
longest-standing dictators, the two were brothers in arms in the
fight for a
continental democratic ideal they've long before abandoned at
home.
Like last year, the AU summit in Egypt largely proceeded with
business
as usual. There were inspirational speeches and leaders were
protected from
a crowd of reporters. Once again, the AU has left the
question of what to do
about Zimbabwe open.
Finding a Way
Out
Most of the discussion within the international community about
that
question centers around three options: refusing to recognize Mugabe and
cranking up the sanctions; pushing for a unity government on the model of
Kenya; or intervening militarily. Obviously, much depends on Mugabe himself,
but if any negotiated settlement is to be reached two conditions are
requisite. First, any solution must guarantee an end to the violence and
persecution against the opposition MDC and its supporters. Second - and this
may surprise some -- Mugabe must be promised a way out.
In
their superb collection of case studies about changes of leadership
in
Africa, "Legacies of Power," editors Henning Melber and Roger Southall
explain the rules by which African leaders have historically operated: "If
they were not forcibly ejected from power, it was common for leaders to
remain in office, often citing their indispensability, cultivating an iconic
status, and even claiming that age could not wither them."
But
the main focus of the book is to examine the circumstances under
which a
growing collection of African leaders left power willingly. A key
lesson is
that repressive leaders fear retribution. As the book says, they
"may have
reasonable cause for expecting that their political opponents will
seek to
humiliate if not prosecute them" after they leave office.
Dissatisfying as it may be, if he is to be convinced to leave, Mugabe
must
be protected from punishment for his crimes by his own people or the
international community. If he is to ever actually leave, he will need a
guarantee of physical and material security. There is a precedent in
Zimbabwe. Despite the atrocities committed by Mugabe's predecessor,
apartheid leader Ian Smith, Mugabe never touched him. To free Zimbabwe again
28 years later, the country's current oppressor will need the same
promise.
Michael Wilkerson is currently working in Uganda for the
Independent
newspaper.
A News Release
from the Office of...
LESLEY GRIFFITHS AM
Welsh Assembly Member
for Wrexham
National Assembly for Wales
Cardiff Bay
Cardiff CF99
1NA
For immediate release: 7th July 2008
AM CALLS ON BARCLAYS TO
"MAKE A STAND" AGAINST MUGABE
A Labour Member of the Welsh Assembly has
written to senior executives of a
major high street bank, calling on them to
follow the example of Tesco and
take "make a stand" against the bloody
regime of Robert Mugabe in Zimbabwe,
and suspend its operations in the
country.
Wrexham AM, Lesley Griffiths - who has compaigned in the Welsh
Assembly
against the violation of trade union rights and the wrongful arrest
and
imprisonment of three prominent trade union leaders by the regime of
Rober
Mugabe - has written to Marcus Agius (Chairman) and John Varley (Group
Chief
Executive) of Barclays Bank plc, calling on the company to suspend its
operations forthwith in the African country, until the political crisis
there is resolved and democracy restored.
Commenting on her letter to
bank executives, Lesley Griffiths AM - who is an
account holder with
Barclays - said:
"Barclays plc has a controlling 67 per cent share in
Barclays Bank of
Zimbabwe. This bank provides loans and invests in
government bonds that
indirectly enable Mugabe to finance his regime of
terror and enable his
thugs to torture and imprison trade unionists in the
country.
"For a UK high street bank to be seen giving any kind of support
- indirect
or otherwise - to the heinous regime of Robert Mugabe's, is I
believe,
extremely damaging to company's reputation. As a Barlcays Bank
account
holder, I have asked them to suspend its operations immediately,
until the
current political situation is resolved and democracy is restored.
I await
their reply with great interest."
Roberts Mugabe's has made
it law that any commercial bank operating in the
country - such as Barclays
- must reinvest 40 per cent of its profits in
Zimbabwean Government bonds.
The result of Barclays' continued presence in
Zimbabwe, therefore enables
the Zimbabwean Government to have access to
vital foreign
exchange.
"I hope Barclays Bank take heed of the criticisms they are now
facing from
across the political divide in the UK. As the main opposition
party in
Zimbabwe - Morgan Tsvangirai's Movement for Democratic Change - has
said
recently, any company doing business in Zimbabwe is keeping that regime
alive. Barclays must now listen to those voices and do the honourable thing
by suspending its presence and help the ordinary people of Zimbabwe make a
stand against the tyrant Mugabe."
http://www.swradioafrica.com
George B.N. Ayittey, Ph.D.
In life, there
arise many situations where one falls victim to one's own
scheming, plot or
trap. Sometimes the intentions may not be malicious. For
example, your
cousin has stayed at your home for five years. He contributes
nothing to the
upkeep of the house. He eats for free and pays no rent.
Worse, he
threatens you when you try to evict him. So you enlist the help of
your
uncle, who helps evict the cousin. Later on, the uncle moves into your
home,
bringing along his wife, his seven children and even his dog. When you
tried
to complain, WHAAAAAACK! came a slap across your face and a threat to
evict
you from your own home! Chei. Someone watching this might say "poetic
justice" or a Shona would say, "Haudyii marutse," meaning "eating your own
vomit."
However, when the intentions are diabolical, a couple of
expressions capture
this situation. One is, "Being hoisted by one's own
petard," and another is,
"Riding a tiger that eventually devours you." There
have been many such
instances in Africa's post colonial political
history.
African tyrants spend an inordinate amount on an elab orate
security cum
military structure to protect themselves, wipe out the
opposition and
suppress their people. Since their hold on power is tenuous
(their
legitimacy is often questionable) or came to power through
illegitimate
means (via military coup), they are suspicious of everyone and
paranoid of
every little event, however innocuous. So they spend enormous
amounts of
resources creating layers upon layers of security -- just in case
one level
fails -- and shower security agents with perks and
amenities.
In Nigeria, former dictator, Gen. Ibrahim Babangida rewarded
"nearly 3,000
of his most loyal military chiefs by giving them new Peugeot
sedan s. Most
Nigerians will never be able to afford anything like a new
Peugeot 505,
which costs the equivalent of $21,000 in Lagos. A senior
university
professor, for example, earns about $4,000 a year, while a nurse
or mechanic
is lucky to bring home more than $1,000" (The New York Times,
Dec 2, 1993;
p. A3).
But they can't trust the military completely
because some soldier might get
the same idea of staging a coup. They ban
coups but that does not help. So
they create a Special Division Force (like
the 64th Battalion Rawlings
created in Ghana), and equip it with better
weapons than the ordinary
soldiers so that the Special Force can put down
any upris ing or coup
attempt from the military. Still, they don't sleep
well at night because
they can't trust the Special Division Force, so they
create an Elite Strike
Force (like the Commandos), which are directly
answerable to the president.
Even then, that is cold comfort. So they
create the Presidential Guard,
often drawn from members of their own tribe,
and equip it with the best
weapons. As Africa Report noted regarding
Mobutu's security::
" According to military sources in Kinshasa, the Zairian
army currently
numbers around 100,000 personnel. The largest sector is the
regula r army
known as the Zairian Armed Forces (FAZ), which numbers 81,000,
60,000 of
whom are under arms. Next in size is the 12,000 strong civil
guard, headed
by General Kpama Baramoto, brother-in-law of Mobutu. But it is
the Special
Presidential Division (DSP), numbering 15,000 under arms, which
represents
the strong arm of Mubutu's rule. Both the Civil Guard and the DSP
are
answerable to the president, while the FAZ is under the control of the
ministry of defense. Senior officers are largely from Mobutu's Equateur
region" (Jan-Feb 1992; p. 28).
Other military regimes in Africa
have similar elite presidential guard. As
The Washington Post (July 23,
1994) reported:
"The (presidential) guard is a typical feature of
undemocratic sub-Saharan
African regimes -- a coup deterring force recruited
for its personal loyalty
to the commander in chief. A 1,500-man brigade of
guards in Nigeria's inland
capital, Abuja, and a similar-sized force in
Lagos, the country's commercial
capital, are described by military sources
as the linchpin of Abacha's
internal security apparatus.
As in other
undemocratic African countries, Abacha's presidential guard is
drawn from
his own ethnic group in his home town. The guards often get the
best
equipment and the best training" (p. A16).
Courage, however, is not the
forte of Africa's presidential guards. In May
2007, hundreds of marauding
soldiers fired guns in the air in the streets of
Conakry, Guinea, and other
towns around the country, demanding th eir
salaries. They had not been paid
for months. "We want the leaders who stole
our wages and betrayed us to step
down," said one of the soldiers marching
in central Conakry close to the
presidential palace. President Lansana
Conte, immediately deployed his
presidential guards, distinguished by their
red berets, to the centre of the
city. They were shooting in the air in an
attempt to scare off the mutinous
soldiers. But when the presidential guards
saw that they were outnumbered,
they fled.
Ambushed by bunch of rag-tag cattle rustlers, Kenya's elite
presidential
guards quickly surrendered. Johann Wandetto, a reporter for the
People
Daily, a newspaper in Kitale, Rift Valley province, submitted a story
in the
March 6, 1999 edition with the title: "Militia men rout 8 crack
unit
officers: Shock as Moi's men surrender meekly." Wandetto was arrested
and
sentenced to 18 months in prison on what the court described as an
"alarmist
report" (Index on Censorship, 3/2000; p.99).
As Africa's
infrastructure and public services disintegrated, African
dictators found
the wherewithal -- $15 billion annually -- to spend more and
more to import
arms and maintain their military. But the security system,
quite apart from
the threat that can come from within the country,
frequently fails to
provide them with adequate protection. In fact, quite
often, it is the very
same security apparatus that overthrows them. The
Asante have this proverb:
If a bed bug bites you, it is from your own cloth.
The late Samuel
Doe of Liberi a, for example, spent so much to keep his
soldiers happy. In
addition, he had a crack Presidential troops, secretly
trained by the
Israelis. But they could not protect him from the Charles
Taylor's rag-tag
rebels of 1,000. Note that Charles Taylor was not even a
soldier but an
ex-civil servant. Similarly, Comrade Haile Mariam Mengistu
spend an enormous
amount to build Africa's largest army with 200,000 under
arms. But his army
could not protect him from a band of determined Eritrean
and Tigray rebels.
The same can be said for Siad Barre of Somalia.
In 1974, Colonel Haile
Mariam Mengistu overthrew Emperor Haile Selassie in a
1974 military coup.
The ailing emperor was suffocated with a wet pillow, and
his body buried in
an unmarked grave. Scores of his relatives were murdered
or chained to walls
in the cellars of the imperial palace.
Thousands of suspected
counterrevolutionaries were gunned down in the
streets. More than 30,000
people were jailed. When a member of his own junta
questioned the wisdom of
such terror tactics, Mengistu shot him in the head.
In 1991, after
routing by a rag-tag army of Eritrean rebels, Mengistu fled
to Zimbabwe. How
safe was he there?
"Former Ethiopian dictator, Mengistu Haile Mariam
panicked and ran yelling
for help when a would-be assassin fired a single
shot at one of his guards
last fall, a Zimbabwe court was told. The Eritrean
suspect, Solomon Haile
Ghebre Michael, 36, pleaded not guilty Monday in the
attack on the exiled
Col. Mengistu, given asylum by President Robert Mugabe
in 1991 after he fled
Ethiopia (The Washington Times, Thursday July 11,
1996; p.A10).
On July 29, 1975, General Gowon of Nigeria was overthrown
in a bloodless
coup, planned and executed by some of his most trusted
colleagues, including
the Commander of the Presidential Guard.
Interestingly, General Joe Garba,
who announced the overthrow, was Gowon's
closest personal staff in whom he
could confide in all matters of security.
Ironically, reasons for the coup
against Gowon were: inaccessibility,
insensitivity, indecision and lack of
political direction. Strange that his
own closest aide had no access to him.
On March 18, 1991, angry
Malians took to the streets to demand democratic
freedom from the despotic
rule of Moussa Traore. He unleashed his security
forces on them, killing
scores, including women and children. But
pro-democracy forces were not
deterred and kept up the pressure. Asked to
resign on March 25, he retorted:
"I will not resign, my government will not
resign, because I was elected not
by the opposition but by all the people of
Mali!!!! But two days lat er when
he tried to flee the country, he was
grabbed by his own security agents and
sent to jail. From there, he
lamented: "My fate is now in God's hands." The
same happened to Joseph Momoh
of Sierra Leone, Sani Abacha of Nigeria, and
many others.
Rather strangely, they always think they can count on 100
percent loyalty
from their troops. When Charles Taylor set out in Decemb er
1989 oust
General Doe from power, more than half of Doe's own soldiers
deserted him
and joined Taylor's forces. And in Zaire's 1996 civil war,
hundreds of
Mobutu's soldiers abandoned him. In Kalemie, Goma, Bukavu and
Uvira, they
barely put up a fight and defected in droves with their weapons
to the
rebels' side.
In Cameroon, Mbia Meka, the senior commissioner
of police and the commandant
of the paramilitary Special Operations Squad,
as well as Joseph Owona, and
Remy Ze Meka, secreta ry general at the prime
minister's office, were
arrested on Sept 9, 1994 and charged with plotting
to overthrow the Biya
regime. "The revelations stunned Cameroonians since
the alleged coup leaders
were all members of Biya's own Beti ethnic group
and, as part of the
powerful Essingan sect, were held in close confidence by
the 61-year old
president" (The African Observer, Nov 15-28, 1994;
p.14).
In Rwanda, the late president Juvenal Habryimana "fell victim to
the monster
he created" (The Washington Post, April 18, 1995; p.A17). His
plane crash
was plotted by his own allies in the military, who saw that he
was edging
closer to political reforms that woul d threaten their
power.
But the next military buffoon doesn't learn. Being a product of
that
structure, with intricate knowledge of its inner workings, he repairs
the
weaknesses and strengthens the structure. Eventually he too is
overthrown by
the same security apparatus.
Remember General
Mainassara of Niger who seized power in a coup in 1996? He
didn't trust his
own military, so he created a Special Presidential Guard
and fortified his
palace. It was impregnable but just in case somebody might
have an idea of
attacking from the air, he g ave his Presidential Guard some
heavy
artillery, including heavy-duty anti-helicopter machine guns.
Sometime in
1999, returning from a trip overseas, his Presidential Guard
went to the
airport to meet him. They opened fire with their anti-helicopter
machine
guns. Mainassara's body was shredded into pieces, littering the
tarmac. Upon
seeing the bits, his wife collapsed on to the tarmac.
In Ivory Coast,
ousted president Henri Bedie believed that the gendarmerie
was strong enough
to protect the state and his presidency against any thr
eat. Accordingly, he
gave hefty pay increases to the gendarmerie and the
police and ignored the
army. "But the coup came, the gendarmes' commander
refused to order his men
to fight fellow Ivorians" (The Economist, Jan 8,
2000; p.42).
The
next coconut-head, General Robert Guie, did not learn. After seizing
power
in a December 1999 coup, General Guie claimed he had only come to
"sweep the
house clean" and return to the barracks. After tasting power for
a few
months, he decided that "power isweet, haba." So he decided to run for
the
presidency. He asked the very political party he overthrew for
corruption to
choose him as their presidential candidate. Imagine. When none
of the
parties would have him, he decided to run anyway as the "people's
candidate"
in the October 27, 2000 elections.
When early returns showed that General
Guie was losing, he ordered his
soldiers to raid the Electoral Commission
and sack the commissioners. The
vote was then counted in secret and General
Guei declared the winner. But,
"Crowds of Abidjan residents--angry at the
general's attempt to steal
Sunday's presidential elections--fought for a
second day with troops loyal
to Guei. The battle turned when key army units
and the paramilitary gendarme
force defected to the opposition, recognizing
veteran opposition politician
Laurent Gbagbo as the elected president" (The
Washington Post, Oct 26, 2000;
p.A33). General Guie fled Ivory Coast in a
helicopter on October 29 but he
died from mysterious circumstances a year
later .
The law is this: The more an African head of state spends on
security, the
more likely he will be overthrown by someone from his security
forces. As
Decalo (1976) put it: "Military hierarchies often carry within
them the
seeds of their own destruction or instability. Most of them have
been rocked
by internal power struggles, factionalism, decay of cohesion and
discipline,
personal power gambits, and successful or attempted coups"
(p.36). Recall
that, each year, African governments spend about $15 billion
on the
importation of weapons and maintenance of the military--an amount
which is
nearly equal to what Africa receives in aid from all sources. The
futility
of such military expenditures was pointed out by Archbishop Desmond
Tutu.
Speaking at the Teachers Hall in Accra on November 25, 1990, he noted
cogently: "Freedom is cheaper than repression. When you are a leader chosen
by the people you don't need security. All the money spent on weapons
doesn't buy one iota of security," he said (Christian Messenger, Jan 1991;
p. 1).
"I bought jet fighters. I bought MiG-23s. I bought armed
helicopters. And I
lost the war. When there's social unrest, it' s difficult
to win. It's the
same feeling today," said Likulia Bolongo, the defense
minister of President
Mobutu Sese Seko during the 1996-1997 war (The
Washington Post, Nov 23,
1999; p.A24). His successor, President Laurent
Kabila, did not learn. He was
shot and killed in 2001 by Rachidi Kasereka, a
member of the presidential
bodyguard. Kasereka himself was killed
immediately thereafter. Kasereka, 26
years old, was from North
Kivu.
On August 2, 2005, army officers overthrew President Maaouiya Ould
Sid Ahmed
Taya in a bloodless revolt. Speaking after the coup, Mr Taya said
he had
been shocked to find out who was behind it. He was toppled by the
former
security chief and close colleague, Colonel Ely Ould Mohammed Vall,
who had
been the director of national security since 1987 and, after played
a key
role in the 1984 coup which brought Mr Taya to power.
"My situation
reminds me of the old adage: 'God, save me from my friends,
I'll take care
of my enemies'," President Taya told Radio France
Internationale from Niger.
"I was stunned by the coup d'etat [...] and even
more so when I heard who
were the authors," Mr Taya said
(http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/africa/4126296.stm).
After
the 2002 elections in Zimbabwe, an unpopular, insecure and paranoid
Mugabe
started to rely increasingly on the army generals to prop up his
regime
after he retires. He FEARED that he might suffer the same fate as
former
Chadian president, Hisene Habre, retired Zambian president, Frederick
Chiluba, and former Malawian president, Bakili Muluzi. Habre became "Africa'
s Pinochet" when he was indicted in a court in Senegal in 2006. Chiluba and
Muluzi were hounded by their hand-picked successors on charges of corruption
and mismanagement.
Mugabe believes a heavily militarized government
that would take over from
him would not try him for any rights violations
carried out under his
administration. And since the plunder of Congo's
mineral riches and
lucrative deals had kept Zimbabwe's army generals fat and
happy, they were
only too happy to oblige. Accordingly, the commander of the
defense forces
at that time, General Vitalis Zvinavashe, warned in February
2992 that the
country's military, police and intelligence chiefs would not
accept a
"Morgan Tsvangirai" as a national leader if he won the March 9
election
since he was not a veteran of Zimbabwe's independence
struggle.
Accordingly in 2006, Mugabe embarked on an accelerated plan to
militarize
all state institutions ahead of his retirement. Senio r military
officers
were appointed to ZANU-PF's top decision-making body, the
Politburo. The
military generals were invited into the State House and
started assuming a
significant roe in the running of the country, with
serving and retired
soldiers on boards of parastatals, even including
sports.
From then on, military and police officers took over the electoral
process,
orchestrating a campaign of intimidation, beatings against
opposition
supporters. Morgan Tsvangirai was badly beaten up in May 2007 and
three
assassination attempts have been made on his life. According to
Zimbabwe
Human Rights Forum, organised violence and intimidation of the
opposition
was rife in the run up to the March 29, 2008 elections. Groups of
thugs,
mainly belonging to the ZANU (PF) party, terrorized and harassed
residents,
supporters and purported supporters of their opponents. There was
a lot of
tension, intimidation and violence in perceived opposition
strongholds such
as Mbare and Epworth where members of the ZANU (PF) party
used coercion to
try and win the support of the electorate. Of grave concern
was the
degrading manner in which some of these attacks were carried out. Of
note
are the incidences in Epworth in which two women were stripped of their
MDC
party regalia leaving them half naked.
In spite of all these
brutalities, the astonishing incompetence of the
military officers and ut
ter failure of the militarization process became
apparent when the election
results started coming in. The opposition MDC had
won control of parliament
and Morgan Tsvangirai appeared to be winning the
presidential
elections.
FEAR and PANIC struck the hearts of Mugabe, the Politburo and the
cabal of
military generals. FEAR that they would be held accountable for
rampant
corruption, egregious mismanagement of the economy and flagitious
violations
of human rights, not to mention the vast sums of wealth they
would lose
should the MDC win power. What to do? Withhold the presidential
election
results!
At a hastily arranged meeting a day after the
elections, Mugabe told his
security officials that he had lost the election
and was going to step down.
But Zimbabwe's military chief, General
Constantine Chiwenga, told Mugabe
that stepping down from power was not a
decision he alone should make. The
military would take control of the
country and keep him in office or he
could contest the run-off election,
which would be directed in the field by
senior army officers supervising a
military-style campaign against the
opposition to ensure his re-election.
Mugabe agreed to the second option,
which was codenamed, CIBD: Coercion,
Intimidation, Beating, Displacement.
Remember you invited your uncle into
your home to help you evict your
cousin, now the uncle has taken control of
your home! Mugabe is no longer in
charge of the State House. And the ruling
ZANU-PF politburo has been
rendered impotent by the military generals. When
Vice President Joice
Mujuru, warned the ruling party's politburo in a May 14
meeting that the
violence might backfire, she was overruled repeatedly by
Chiwenga, the
military head, and by former security chief Emerson
Mnangagwa.
Of all the military coups that have taken place in
post-colonial Africa,
Zimbabwe's is the most bizarre. Nearly all Africa's
coups are motivated by a
grievance against ruling regime and, therefore,
seek change of government or
the removal of the incumbent. But for purely
selfish reasons and fear,
Zimbabwe's coup is an attempt to maintain or
defend the rotten status quo.
The ruling Politburo is powerless to do
anything; it has been devoured by
the very beast it unleashed against the
opposition. Talk about being hoisted
by one's own petard.
But that is not
the end of this torrid saga. Who killed Presidents Laurent
Kabila Ibrahim
Mainassara? Members of their own presidential guards.
There is this
adage: "The wise learn from the mistakes of others while fools
repeat them.
Idiots, on the other hand, repeat their own stupid mistakes."
Stay tuned.
http://www.echo-news.co.uk
POLICE guarded a Southend pub
as dozens of Zimbabweans gathered for a branch
meeting of the opposition
party, the Movement for Democratic Change.
Police - on hand for party
members' safety - have also started looking into
claims by a leading
Zimbabwean exile dictator Robert Mugabe has put agents
on the streets of
south Essex to spy on and harass MDC members here.
Stanford Biti, brother
of MDC general secretary Tendai Biti, make the
shocking claim in the Echo
last week. Police have offered their assistance,
if needed.
At
yesterday's meeting, Mr Biti spoke out against Mugabe's Zanu PF party,
which
held on to power amid widespread reports of voter intimidation. The
Southend
pub where the group met has asked not to be named for fear of
reprisals.
Mr Biti said: "This latest meeting was for me to tell
everybody how the MDC
leaders in Zimbabwe want us to go forward.
"I
did speak to them, in Harare, the capital, just before I came to the
meeting
and since the South African president has not helped, we want action
from
the Pan-African Agreement."
advertisement
The Pan-African
Agreement is a simpler form of the European Union treaty,
which governs
relations between nations.
MDC supporter Margaret Cuipandambira, 35, of
Lancaster Gardens, Southend,
was at the meeting.
Ms Cuipandambira,
who who works in a care home in the town, said: "I had
four shops, but Zanu
PF closed me down because I belonged to the MDC "Then I
was the only
breadwinner for the rest of my family.
"Today, most of them are in South
Africa, but I still go to bed fearing for
their safety."
Jameson
Mashakada, 30, is a Southend resident and vice chairman of the MDC
in
Britain.
He said: "Southend has many nationalities living
here.
"But when we speak to friends and people we meet here they are all
very
worried when they learn we are exiles from Zimbabwe."
http://www.sowetan.co.za/
07 July 2008
Mary
Papayya
'Politicians should not overstay their
welcome'
ANC president Jacob Zuma took a swipe at African leaders such as
Robert
Mugabe who "refuse to step down" and overstay their political
welcome.
Zuma was speaking at a celebratory ANC dinner in
KwaZulu-Natal to welcome
the new ANC leadership and pay tribute to outgoing
premier and ANC chairman
S'bu Ndebele.
Acknowledging Ndebele,
Zuma said: "You are a good political student . who
knows how to step down
with dignity . you have learnt from our great leaders
such as
Madiba.
"In Africa we have some political leaders who refuse
to bow out and try to
change the constitution to accommodate themselves . as
in neigbouring
Zimbabwe."
Zuma also publicly
acknowledged the challenge of leading the volatile
province of KwaZuluNatal,
especially when political tensions between the ANC
and Inkatha Freedom Party
were at an all-time high.
"Flanked by a highly capable deputy (Zweli
Mkhize) you provided dynamic
leadership and managed a precious and peaceful
co-existence with the IFP,"
Zuma said.
He also congratulated Ndebele
for his role in making sure that the recent
provincial election was "united
and peaceful", unlike in other provinces.
Welcoming Mkhize to
his new position Zuma said it was important for
transparency and open debate
within the ANC to continue saying that "open
discussion and debate" should
be encouraged.
He said "politics does not sleep" and it was important for
a leader not to
allow "the gossip" to swelter.
He said he wanted to
bid farewell to one of South Africa's "finest leaders"
and "welcome an even
finer leader".
In a show of public unity Ndebele and Mkhize
embraced. They fired the party's
first electioneering salvo for next year's
poll, urging everyone to vote for
the ANC.
Yahoo News
1 hour, 44
minutes ago
MALABO (AFP) - A Malabo court sentenced British mercenary
Simon Mann to 34
years and four months in prison on Monday for leading an
abortive coup in
Equatorial Guinea.
Mann was arrested in March
2004 along with 61 other suspected coup plotters
when their plane landed in
Zimbabwe. Mann also implicated Mark Thatcher, the
son of former prime
minister Margaret Thatcher, in the plot.
The court fined Mann 100 million
CFA francs (150,000 euros or 235,000
dollars) and ordered that he be barred
from entering Equatorial Guinea's
territory for a further 20 years after his
sentence is served.
His co-accused, Lebanese-born Mohamed Salaami, was
jailed for 18 years and
three months with the same fine and territorial bar
applied.