Zim Independent
Dumisani Muleya
PRESIDENT Robert
Mugabe yesterday tried to wriggle off the hook
of international diplomacy on
the eve of a critical meeting tomorrow with
United Nations secretary-general
Kofi Annan and South African President
Thabo Mbeki in Banjul, the Gambia,
claiming Zimbabwe did not need to be
rescued from the current
crisis.
Mugabe's meeting with Annan, which Harare has been
trying to
evade, is widely seen as an escalation of UN involvement in
Zimbabwe which
could end up with the country being placed on the agenda of
the Security
Council of the world body. Government is now anxious to avoid
Security
Council measures.
Annan, who has confirmed he
would like to meet Mugabe on the
sidelines of the African Union summit
tomorrow, and Mbeki are pushing for a
resolution of Zimbabwe's protracted
political and economic crisis.
South African deputy foreign
minister Aziz Pahad this week said
Mbeki wanted to be part of the meeting.
Annan has said it was necessary to
take action to save Zimbabwe from "total
collapse". Mbeki has said he was
awaiting the outcome of the Annan
initiative on Zimbabwe.
The Annan plan is part of wider
diplomatic efforts - which
include initiatives by Mbeki, Benjamin Mkapa,
churches, and opposition MDC
leader Morgan Tsvangirai - designed to rescue
Zimbabwe.
However, Mugabe tried yesterday to get out of the
tight
diplomatic spot by firing warning shots at Annan, saying such efforts
were
unacceptable.
"Lately, we have heard about so many
so-called 'initiatives' to
rescue Zimbabwe. You would think we are about to
perish. We tell the world
from this sacred (Heroes) Acre that Zimbabwe is
not about to die, in fact
will not die ever," Mugabe told mourners in Harare
gathered at the burial of
former Information minister Tichoana Jokonya who
died on Saturday.
Mugabe claimed that countries which
depended on Zimbabwe were
now trying to rescue it.
"Zimbabwe has no saviours outside of its own people. Is it not
ironic that
nations that are sustained by and depend on resources from our
country dare
talk about 'saving us'? Who is saving who, we ask?"
He said
Zimbabwe had helped Mozambique and South Africa in times
of
difficulty.
Mugabe said while Zimbabwe did not need foreign
nations'
intervention to sort out the current political impasse and economic
problems, it needed their money. Sources said Mugabe would try to hide the
issue of sanctions - which even if he said before were not working -
yesterday admitted they were biting.
His remarks were
widely seen as an attempt to duck pressure
exerted on him to resolve the
current situation. Annan has said he would
want to engage Mugabe on the
situation in Zimbabwe. Harare has been trying
to invite the UN boss on an
Operation Garikai/Hlalani Kuhle whitewash
mission. Annan has refused,
however, insisting UN agencies must address the
consequences of Operation
Murambatsvina.
Efforts by Mugabe's isolationist spokesmen to
say Annan's
invitation to Harare had expired and was therefore now stale had
not been
taken seriously in New York.
Zim Independent
Clemence Manyukwe
JUSTICE minister Patrick Chinamasa will
still be abroad on the
day he is due to stand trial next week on charges of
trying to defeat the
course of justice, throwing doubts over the prosecution
of the case in
court.
As reported in this paper on May
26, the Attorney-General's
Office set July 3 as Chinamasa's trial date. The
case is widely seen as part
of the Zanu PF power struggle to succeed
President Robert Mugabe. Ruling
party insiders have claimed that Chinamasa
was being punished by rivals from
the faction led by former army commander
retired General Solomon Mujuru for
perceived loyalty to the camp headed by
party heavyweight Emmerson
Mnangagwa.
Chinamasa is also
reportedly battling with Attorney-General
Sobusa Gula-Ndebele over control
of the AG's office. The two apparently
clashed after a Bill was proposed
last year to make Gula-Ndebele's office
independent of the
ministry.
Chinamasa will be away on Monday when he is
expected to appear
in court. He left the country a fortnight ago for the
inaugural session of
the United Nations Human Rights Council held from June
19-22 in Geneva,
Switzerland, and will not be back on Monday although his
mission is over.
Chinamasa's secretary said this week the
minister would not be
back in the country until Friday next week. On
Wednesday, Paul Mangwana, the
Anti- Corruption and Anti-Monopolies minister,
who is also currently acting
as both Information and Justice minister, said
he would be in charge of the
Justice ministry until July 4, a day after
Chinamasa was supposed to appear
in court.
He said
Chinamasa was attending the UN meeting, but when told it
was now over, he
said: "He is just on government business."
Mangwana then
referred further questions to the Attorney-General
Sobusa Gula-Ndebele, who
in turn directed the Independent to the chief law
officer, Florence
Ziyambi.
Ziyambi refused to comment but Gula-Ndebele later
said: "l have
not been briefed on that case. If there is anything you go to
court and you
will find it. It will be there on the court
roll."
If he is not present, this would be the second time
that
Chinamasa would have failed to appear in court after an incident in
July
2002 when he was outside Zimbabwe on the day he was supposed to answer
contempt of court charges that had arisen from his excessive criticism of a
six month jail-term imposed on three Americans accused of illegal possession
of arms.
At the time former High Court judge Fergus
Blackie imposed a
three month jail term and a $50 000 fine. Blackie said:
"It is clear that
Chinamasa has no intention of appearing before this
court."
Blackie rejected the government's assertion that the
sentence
was his "hostile parting shot against the
executive".
In the current case, Chinamasa and five others
including the
head of the Central Intelligence Organisation (CIO) in
Manicaland, Innocent
Chibaya, face allegations of attempting to influence
state witnesses to drop
charges against State Security minister Didymus
Mutasa's supporters who were
charged with political
violence.
The supporters, who included Albert Nyakuedzwa,
have since been
jailed for up to three years for assaulting war veteran
James Kaunye who
wanted to challenge Mutasa in Zanu PF's Makoni North
primary elections ahead
of the 2005 parliamentary poll.
Previously Chinamasa said he would comment at the appropriate
time while
Mutasa has said the case "would not go anywhere". A docket for
Mutasa has
since been prepared on allegations he was an accomplice in the
case.
Zim Independent
Dumisani Ndlela
ZIMBABWE'S
domestic public debt appeared set for a major
explosion due to exorbitant
financing costs, central bank statistics
revealed this
week.
Government debt doubled in a space of 15 days to $43
trillion by
mid-June after reaching $21 trillion on June
2.
Bank sources indicated that unpublished estimates place
the debt
level at $48,2 trillion.
The sharp hike in debt
had been spurred largely by high interest
rates on government debt, most of
which is held through short tenor treasury
bill (TB)
instruments.
Government debt held through TB stock amounted
to $17 trillion
by June 16, with interest on the TB stock amounting to $22
trillion, more
than double the principal TB debt on June 2 of $8
trillion.
"We're in a bind," said analyst Washington
Mehlomakhulu of
Highveld Financial Services. "The method of funding debt is
a major
concern."
Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe (RBZ) governor
Gideon Gono last year
adopted measures making government securities,
especially TBs, more
attractive to private sector investors in order to
attract funds to finance
the large government deficits.
Investors had been directing their funds mainly to the equities
market,
shunning the money market because of weak returns. Gono had
shortened the
tenor of the TBs and increased returns on the money market
instruments.
This had the effect of attracting funds back
to the money
market. However, this came at a huge cost to government as the
cost of
financing the short term paper had the effect of blowing up the
domestic
debt.
The yield on 91-day TBs is currently at
510%. Assuming the
government continues to issue 91-day paper at this rate,
the effective rate
compounded quarterly is 2 569% annualised. "The cost of
running that debt is
worrying," said Mehlomakhulu.
Zim Independent
Reagan Mashavave
GOVERNMENT
has endorsed the suspension of Harare Town Clerk
Nomutsa Chideya, raising
fears that city commission chairperson Sekesai
Makwavarara's obdurate
behaviour at Town House could have been sanctioned by
the central
government.
Making an official announcement of the suspension
yesterday
Local government minister Ignatious Chombo said Chideya had been
suspended
due to poor management of the city.
Chideya
would soon be placed under an enquiry chaired by Harare
provincial
magistrate Mishrod Guvamombe.
"In consonance with the
practice of natural justice and in
compliance with the provisions of the
law, the commission shall proceed with
reasonable urgency to cause an
enquiry to be conducted into the suspension,"
Chombo
said.
"The enquiry shall be chaired by magistrate Guvamombe
and shall
include legal advisor to the ministry Ms T Nyakujara and two
others.
City director of Health Services Dr Stanley Mungofa
was
appointed acting Town Clerk.
Chombo revealed that
Chideya had been offered a job at the Urban
Development Corporation (Udcorp)
with benefits similar to what he is
enjoying as Town Clerk, but Chideya
turned down the offer.
Chombo however failed to explain why
government would offer
Chideya a job at Udcorp when he was facing suspension
for mismanagement. Nor
could he explain what powers Makwavarara had in
offering Chideya a job at
Udcorp.
"I would also want to
let you know that Cde Chideya was offered
a job to be the head of capacity
building at Udcorp which he refused to
take," Chombo told journalists
yesterday. "The job had same benefits that he
was enjoying as Town
Clerk."
Earlier in the week Chideya had defied Makwavarara's
orders that
he must not conduct any council meetings without her approval.
He had
questioned Makwavarara's powers and threatened to take legal action
if she
continued interfering with his work.
Makwavarara
becomes the fourth Harare council leader to suspend
Chideya on alleged
incompetence and mismanagement.
It is understood that Chideya
is considering challenging his
suspension in the courts. It was not possible
to contact him for comment
after his mobile phone was surrendered to
council.
Zim Independent
Itai Mushekwe
FOREIGN
investment in Zimbabwe for the year will remain subdued
owing to President
Robert Mugabe's threats of forced indigenisation of the
economy and
government's record, a recent US Department of State report on
Zimbabwe's
investment climate notes.
The report titled Zimbabwe 2006
Investment Climate Statement
says that government's mismanagement has
crippled the economy, while the
prevailing economic and political terrain
spells dismal prospects for sound
foreign investment.
"The government of Zimbabwe's misgovernance has severely
crippled the local
economy, making it unlikely to attract or absorb
significant foreign direct
investment in 2006," the report says.
"Investment prospects
in Zimbabwe are bound to remain dismal due
to the country's unstable
economic and political environment. Government
policies and recent
constitutional amendments have eroded the rule of law
and put private
property rights at grave risk."
The report also cites
government's increased intervention in
many economic sectors as "generally
unwelcoming to foreign investment",
particularly from Western countries
which have since slapped Mugabe and his
lieutenants with travel
sanctions.
The Zimbabwe 2006 Investment Climate Statement,
which can be
used as a barometer by potential US investors, dismisses
government's "Look
East" policy described as "commensurate with its
anti-West stance", as
reaping limited investment from
Asia.
It adds that government's continued disregard of the
constitution by expropriating private property without compensation and
barring recourse to the courts in the case of those aggrieved "has raised
serious questions about respect for property rights and rule of law. Any
potential foreign investors should take into account the risk of
uncompensated expropriation," the report notes.
The
damning report also raps the state's politicisation of the
judiciary as
another contributing factor to foreign investor apathy.
"Government efforts to influence and intimidate the judiciary
since the late
1990s have raised serious concerns in that area. The
government and ruling
elite have ignored numerous adverse judgments, and
senior officials have
reiterated publicly that court orders that are not
politically acceptable to
the ruling party will not be honoured," the report
says." However, it says
"administration of justice in commercial cases that
lack political overtones
are generally impartial".
Zim Independent
Augustine Mukaro
GOVERNMENT has withdrawn its intention
to acquire Gletwyn
Estate, a move that exposes the state's policy
inconsistencies and
shortcomings of laws hastily promulgated to facilitate
land seizures.
Administrative Court documents in the hands of
the Independent
show that government was forced to withdraw its intention to
acquire Gletwyn
farm after the dispossessed landowner, Alexander Stuart
Ross, went to court
seeking an order to compel President Mugabe to reverse
the acquisition of
his property, arguing that the farm falls under Harare
urban.
The government's Land Acquisition Act and
Constitutional
Amendment Act No 17 passed last year exempt municipal land
from seizure by
the state under the land reform
programme.
In its notice of withdrawal, dated May 24, the
attorney general's
Civil Division said: "Take notice that the Applicant
(Minister of Lands,
Land Reform and Resettlement) withdraws the above matter
and tenders
reasonable costs."
In the papers filed on May
18, seeking the reversal of the
acquisition, Ross said Gletwyn, which is
registered in his name, was
incorporated into the Harare municipal area by
Statutory Instrument 41 of
1996 exempting it from acquisition for
resettlement purposes. The land was
"urban land within Harare's municipal
area, not rural land, nor agricultural
land required for resettlement
purposes in accordance with the land reform
programme," the court documents
say.
Mugabe was cited as the first respondent and Didymus
Mutasa,
Lands, Land Reform and Resettlement minister, the second
respondent.
Ross said acquisition of his property was
reviewed on the basis
of "gross irregularities in the proceedings and
decisions by generally
failing to comply with the requirements of the
legislature regarding urban
land".
Gletwyn has been
targeted for acquisition since 2002 with a
flurry of Zanu PF-inspired
invading groups moving in to grab the prime
property.
First it was the Sally Mugabe Housing Cooperative, before
government seized
the property in November 2004 and gave it to Divine Homes
to subdivide into
low-density residential stands.
Police Heights Housing
Cooperative earlier this year occupied
the farm, forcibly evicting more than
200 people on the pretext of
developing residential stands for senior law
enforcement officers.
Divine Homes, a private land developer
chaired by Deputy Finance
minister David Chapfika, has already started work,
subdividing Gletwyn into
600 residential stands.
Ross
argues in the court papers that it was illegal for the
government to acquire
Gletwyn because the Land Acquisition Act upon which it
based its actions
does not permit the state to acquire municipal land for
purposes of
redistribution.
"A piece of land under municipal area cannot
be acquired under
the provisions of the Land Acquisition Act applicable to
agricultural land,
as all land within any municipal area is expressly
excluded from such
provisions," Ross states in his
papers.
Section 2, Chapter 20:10 of the Act stipulates that
"agricultural land required for resettlement purposes" means any rural land
the acquisition of which is
reasonably required for
resettlement purposes and which is
identified in a preliminary notice as
being required for those purposes.
Rural land means any land other than land
which is in a municipal area or
local government area.
Last August's constitutional amendment bans citizens from
contesting in
court seizure of their land by the state but it also makes it
clear that
government can only take farmland for purposes of
resettlement.
"If the state were to start seizing urban land
by 'selective
nationalisation', it is possible the property market, upon
which the state
depends for many revenues and many people depend for their
livelihoods,
would collapse," Ross said in his court
application.
Zim Independent
Tendai Mukandi
THE Zimbabwe Congress of Trade Unions
(ZCTU), a labour umbrella
body, has reiterated calls for mass protests to
press for realistic wages
aligned with the current inflation
figures.
Wellington Chibebe, the secretary-general of ZCTU,
in an
interview this week said workers had opted to protest after
negotiations
involving the government and business for new wages linked to
Zimbabwe's
galloping inflation failed.
"This decision is
a follow-up to a congress resolution and will
only come to pass if the
employers do not budge. The poverty datum line is
increasing by the day,"
Chibhebhe said.
"We are busy making consultations and no date
or model of the
strike has been made but the workforce is raring to go if
their plight is
not addressed."
The work boycott threat
comes as the Zimbabwean economy continue
its downslide with inflation now at
1193,5% and the breadbasket for an
average family standing at $55 million
dollars a month.
The main opposition Movement for Democratic
Change (MDC) has
already threatened mass protests to force President Robert
Mugabe to accept
dialogue for a new constitution.
Asked
whether the ZCTU was going to join forces with the
opposition, Chibhebhe
said the labour body was only trying to implement the
goals reached at the
congress.
"The MDC called for protests in their own capacity
as a party
and we are organising protests as workers," he
said.
Eric Bloch, an economist, said that protests can have
significant impact on the economy but was doubtful if the protests would
take place.
"Although their plight can be understood, the
demands of labour
cannot be met by placing businesses into liquidation,"
Bloch said.
ZCTU has not given a date for the planned
protest.
Zim Independent
FORMER
Zanu PF provincial chairman Daniel Shumba, who launched
his own opposition
political party, the United People's Party (UPP), in
Harare on Saturday,
will announce the party executive on July 31.
Shumba, the
interim president of the UPP, said the party
executive would be announced
after consultations with provinces had been
completed.
He
also said the UPP would soon after that embark on national
road-shows to
drum up support. The UPP programme shows there are a lot of
activities lined
up in the next few months, including preparations for the
party's first
congress.
While Shumba has said he expected 100 000 people at
the launch
of his party at Zimbabwe Grounds, there were only a couple of
thousand
people present.
The party has however printed at
least two million membership
cards and has claimed it was getting "an
overwhelming response from the
people on the ground".
Although the UPP did not announce members of its interim
executive at the
launch, Shumba said they included prominent opposition and
civil society
activists.
He said his party was pulling out all the stops to
recruit
people with solid political credentials to take leadership positions
and
build strong party structures.
Shumba, also a former
senior Zanu PF central committee member
and businessman, formally resigned
from the ruling party in January after he
was suspended for five years over
a power struggle that rocked Zanu PF in
November 2004 in the run-up to the
party's congress that year.
He was suspended together with
five other provincial chairmen
following the episode which claimed a number
of high-profile political
casualties, including former Information minister
Jonathan Moyo, who were
accused of backing Zanu PF luminary Emmerson
Mnangagwa's bid for power.
Mnangagwa and his faction -
sometimes referred to as the
Tsholotsho camp - have been linked to the
United People's Movement (UPM)
whose primary mover has been Moyo and ex-Zanu
PF central committee member
and MP Pearson Mbalekwa who resigned from the
ruling party last year over
Operation Murambatsvina.
Shumba was expected to be a member of the UPM but decided to
form his own
party.
The UPP said it has already drafted a party
constitution,
printed membership cards and set up nationwide structures. The
party's
position paper, which outlines its policies, deals with
constitutional
issues, electoral law, legislative affairs and a wide range
of democratic
reforms that the party says are needed.
It
also addresses human rights issues such as the Gukurahundi
massacres and
Operation Murambatsvina, land redistribution, macro-economics,
food
security, health, education and foreign policy. It says the UPP
believes in
a free market economy.
"UPP pronounces the people's will and
a mandate for saving the
nation from further demise. Recent episodes have
turned and subjected the
generality of Zimbabweans to poverty, hopelessness
and victims of misrule,
greed, brutality, terror, corruption and
dictatorship," the document says.
"Zanu PF is using fear and
terror to subdue and disenfranchise
the whole country, thus guaranteeing its
grip on power. It is now an offence
to speak the truth, criticise and have a
different opinion." - Staff Writer.
Zim Independent
Clemence Manyukwe
ZANU PF Makoni
North chairman Albert Nyakuedzwa and eight other
Zanu PF supporters from
Rusape are expected to stand trial next month for
the August 2005 murder of
war veteran Tina Wilson Mukono.
The trial is expected to kick
off on July 17 at the High Court.
Nyakuedzwa, largely viewed
as administration secretary Didymus
Mutasa's right hand man in his Makoni
North constituency, is currently
serving a three-jail year term for assaults
on another war veteran, James
Kaunye.
Fifteen other
ruling party supporters from the same area are
serving similar
sentences.
Kaunye was assaulted for intending to challenge
Mutasa, who is
National Security, Lands, Land Reform and Resettlement
minister during Zanu
PF primary elections for Makoni North constituency in
2004.
The minister, who was not charged, was said to have led
the
attacks together with Nyakuedzwa.
Nyakuedzwa was a
Grain Marketing Board regional manager and part
of Agriculture minister
Joseph Made's campaign team in the 2005 general
election. Made won the polls
amid allegations of violence and vote-buying
using grain.
According to the state case the deceased was assaulted after
buying electric
cables stolen from one of the accused persons' farms.
In his
testimony, George Mukono who actually stole and sold the
electric cables but
turned a state witness said: "The accused were driving a
white vehicle
belonging to Zanu PF Makoni province when they found the
deceased. The
accused started assaulting Mukono all over the body using hose
pipes and a
tyre strip".
They later handed him over to the police and
Mukono died while
being taken to the hospital.
The cause
of Mukono's death, who was declared a provincial hero,
was established as a
ruptured spleen and multiple inquiries.
The other accused
Zanu PF members include Tonderai Makoni, Delta
Mandibaya and Maruva
Kurima.
Nyakuedzwa and the ruling party's supporters face the
death
penalty if convicted of the murder that the state says was carried out
with
intent.
Zim Independent
Augustine Mukaro
ZIMBABWE Human
Rights NGO Forum, a coalition of human rights
groups and legal
organisations, has identified state agencies, the Central
Intelligence
Organisation (CIO), police and the army as the main
perpetrators of violence
and torture over the past eight years.
In its latest report
titled "An Analysis of the Zimbabwe Human
Rights NGO Forum Legal Cases,
1998-2006", the NGO Forum says there is
"abundant evidence that state agents
have carried out torture "on a massive
scale" particularly during
elections.
The NGO Forum reported over 15 500 violations of
human rights
cases in the past eight years, but said only 300 cases have
entered the
initial phases of litigation.
"The Human
Rights Forum has published 60 monthly political
violence reports since July
2001 in which there are monthly statistics for
the organised violence and
torture that has taken place," the report says.
"A total of 15 523
violations cases have been reported."
Only 51 of these cases
went to their conclusion, with the state
being held accountable in 89% of
cases, it said.
"The Zimbabwe government itself is conceding
liability for the
perpetration of gross human rights violations," the report
says. The Forum
said it would send its report to the United Nations to press
for further
action against government.
Police were cited
as the most common perpetrators.
"People in detention are
generally at a much greater risk of
abuse unless there are extremely strong
safeguards in place governing the
process of detaining people," reads the
report. "People in custody are
likely to be beaten irrespective of their
alleged crime, political or
criminal, and are commonly subjected to falanga
- the excruciatingly painful
practice of beating the soles of the feet,
which leaves little obvious
bruising."
Police had
"adopted torture as a means to eliciting confessions
on a widespread basis",
the report says.
Harare Central police station has been cited
as the worst
station where people have suffered severe torture.
Zim Independent
Augustine Mukaro
AS the
tragicomedy of unforeseen consequences of the land reform
programme continue
to unfold in rural Zimbabwe, viewed as the bastion of
Zanu PF's political
support, infrastructure has begun coming apart at the
seams.
A drive to Mutoko, one of Zimbabwe's expansive
rural areas,
reveals that virtually all infrastructure is falling apart,
characterised by
almost inaccessible roads because of eroded verges and
potholes, and
derelict clinics and schools resembling abandoned buildings
due to neglect
and lack of funds.
No form of transport is
available along the 60-kilometre
stretch, from the Harare-Nyamapanda highway
to Musiiwa Township and even
beyond.
Bus operators,
including the Mashonaland East governor Ray
Kaukonde who owns RPK buses,
have long ago withdrawn their fleet to save the
buses from wear and
tear.
Ramshackle, old and battered pick-up trucks often ply
such
routes, otherwise people have to endure the long journey on foot after
disembarking from buses along the highway.
As if the bad
roads were not bad enough for the poverty-stricken
people, clinics have
absolutely no drugs for the sick except in some cases,
painkillers.
Schools looked deserted, with almost all
classroom blocks
showing broken windows. Even administration blocks were not
spared. A
glimpse into classrooms showed broken
furniture.
The state of dereliction resembled a war
zone.
People blamed government and their MPs for failure to
provide
grants or even visit the constituency to see the plight of the
electorate.
"Government has forgotten us," one villager
identified as
Chisese said. "There is no one to take our problems to higher
offices. MPs
only come down here when they want to be voted for again. We
last saw our
MP, Olivia Muchena, during the campaign period in 2005. She is
not aware of
what is happening in this community."
Samson
Sete, another villager had no kind words for the
government either, saying
it had worsened their situation when it banned
non-governmental
organisations from distributing food and initiating food
for work programmes
which usually helped in the repairing of roads and
moulding of bricks for
other developmental projects.
"Most schools and clinics
around this area were built by donors
with villagers providing labour
through food-for-work programmes but that
has since stopped," Sete
said.
"Government has failed to come up with alternative
programmes to
maintain these structures, resulting in the dilapidation you
are seeing."
Rural District Councils (RDCs) attributed the
dereliction to the
land reform programme saying it starved them of a
constant income as new
farmers were not paying levies.
When Zanu PF encouraged people to invade farms in the year 2000,
it was
expediently silent about payment of levies, which most people resent
paying.
Funds generated from levies were used for the
repair and
upgrading of district infrastructure such as roads, clinics and
schools.
Apparently, the drying up of financial largesse for the District
Development
Fund has accentuated the problems.
An
Association of Rural District Councils (ARDC) official told
the Independent
that reluctance by farmers to pay levies has crippled local
councils'
operations and their capacity to provide basic services.
He
said some RDCs have engaged debt collectors and are
contemplating taking
legal action to force new landowners to pay the levies.
"Most
RDCs have already engaged debt collectors," the official
said. "It is within
the RDCs' powers to engage debt collectors or even
lawyers to ensure that
farmers pay the levies."
The official said summons have been
dispatched to more than 2
000 A2 farmers, the majority of them political
bigwigs and war veterans who
have evaded levy payments over the past five
years when they forcibly
occupied commercial farmlands.
Sources said RDCs which have already forwarded names to debt
collectors
include Mazowe, Shamva and Mvurwi in Mashonaland Central
province.
"Topping the list of non-paying people are A2
farmers," the
sources said. "The majority have not paid anything from the
time when they
moved on to the properties." War veterans, Zanu PF members
and their
hangers-on form the bulk of the new commercial
farmers.
Government however should ensure that the new
farmers pay the
levies when they sign leases. Currently, A2 farmers have
resisted paying
rentals to councils, which have no mechanisms of
enforcement.
Zim Independent
Shakeman Mugari
THE two-year-old
Time Bank saga has taken a new twist amid
revelations that the Reserve Bank
of Zimbabwe (RBZ) will next week hand over
the bank to its founding
shareholders.
The handover comes despite the decision by the
RBZ to cancel
Time's operating licence last month. The RBZ claimed the bank
could no
longer maintain enough assets to safeguard its creditors and
maintain
prescribed minimum capital requirements.
Time
has however appealed to the High Court against the
cancellation.
Sources told businessdigest that the bank
would be handed back
to shareholders early in July.
The
handover follows the expiry of Time's curatorship today.
Time has been under
curatorship since its disputed closure by the RBZ in
October
2004.
Sources said communication regarding the expected
handover has
been going on for the past three weeks between the curator,
Tinashe Rwodzi
of PricewaterhouseCoopers, Time shareholders and central bank
officials.
Despite claims by the curator that the bank is
insolvent, Time's
directors and major shareholders said in a statement this
week that the bank
was prepared to open its doors to the
public.
In a statement, Time Bank Investment Company (Pvt),
the major
shareholders in Time, said they would be able to repay their
creditors once
the bank was handed back to shareholders. The statement said
the bank was
still solvent, contrary to findings by the curator that it was
unable to pay
its creditors.
"Time Bank will be in a
position to pay all the depositors and
creditors who wish to withdraw or to
be paid their money, after the
institution has been formerly handed back to
its shareholders and
directors," said the statement seen by
businessdigest.
The shareholders said the payments would be
made after the
verification of the accounts that would have been submitted
by the curator.
"To avoid certain risks, the payments will be
subject to the
account balances being genuine and
verifiable."
The return of Time to shareholders is understood
to have little
potential of holding back an ongoing legal battle between the
major
shareholders of the bank and the central bank which shareholders have
taken
to court over the initial decision to close the bank in October
2004.
Zim Independent
Eric
Chiriga
BUSINESS is booming on the parallel market
despite numerous
government efforts to kill the market through a spirited
crackdown by the
law enforcement agencies.
The parallel
market now actually has well-established trading
points, which include
Roadport in the capital, Lobengula Street in Bulawayo,
popularly known as
"World Bank", and the country's border points.
The existence
of uniformed police officers at these places poses
no threat to the illegal
foreign currency dealers.
The dealers now openly advertise
their highly prized and sought
after commodities.
"There
is no need for us to hide. Even the law enforcers trade
their foreign
currency here," said one of the traders at Roadport.
While
the official interbank market has struggled to raise
volumes of US$5 million
per trading day since January this year, hefty
amounts of major currencies
like the US dollar, the British pound and the
South African rand change
hands on a daily basis on the parallel market.
Zimbabwe
Republic Police (ZRP) spokesperson Assistant
Commissioner Wayne Bvudzijena
said the police had not lost the battle
against informal foreign currency
dealers. Instead, he blamed the law for
having too many loopholes to let
culprits off the hook.
"The laws have loopholes and have to
be tightened," said
Bvudzijena.
He said it is difficult
to arrest a person who is illegally
trading in foreign currency unless they
were caught executing the
transaction.
"We can only
arrest (dealers) if we catch them actually
trading," he
said.
When questioned on why there had been arrests of
illegal foreign
currency dealers before and none now, Bvudzijena said the
arrests were on
the basis of well-documented illegal trading or tip offs
from duped
individuals.
Last year, a number of company
executives from Econet and
Telecel among other top companies were arrested
for violation of the
exchange control regulations. Econet executives were
exonerated of any
violation of exchange controls by the
courts.
Bvudzijena refused to give recommendations on how the
law could
be improved and tightened.
"The law should be
tightened but we cannot give suggestions," he
said.
Local
analysts said the parallel foreign currency market was
being fuelled by
demand and supply.
They said officials could only destroy the
parallel market by
liberalising the official exchange
rate.
In other words the exchange rate should be determined
by market
forces.
The parallel market is thriving because
it trades at rates that
are way above those on the interbank
market.
Whilst the US dollar and British pound are trading at
around
US$1:$450 000 and GBP1:$750 000 respectively on the parallel market,
on the
interbank system the same currencies are trading at US$1:$101 195,41
and
GBP1:$184 307,44.
Zim Independent
Eric Chiriga
INTEREST rates on
savings remain subdued, militating against
government efforts to boost
savings and turn around Zimbabwe's ailing
economy.
The
government launched an economic blueprint, the National
Economic Development
Priority Programme, nearly three months ago. The
blueprint, aimed at
tackling a six-year economic crisis, is expected to
enhance savings and
trigger investments inflows in the country.
Savings are
estimated to be at around 10% of gross domestic
product (GDP). Ideally,
savings should be at 60% of GDP.
Low savings have resulted in
increased money printing by the
government, which cannot raise enough money
from domestic borrowings.
Interest rates on savings are
pegged at between 3% and 10% per
annum, while rates on borrowings are as
high as 800% per annum.
Some commercial banks are paying
interest on savings of as much
as 9% only on amounts exceeding $500
million.
However, fixed deposits are attracting better
interests of
between 100% and 500% depending on the tenor of
investments.
The low interest rates have resulted in people
moving their
money quickly from cash into assets due to the high inflation
rate.
Moreover, a cash crunch evidently troubling the
financial sector
has also worked as a disincentive to
saving.
Sources said while deposits in current and savings
accounts
constituted the largest chunk of deposits made with local banks,
banks were
finding it unprofitable to pay high interests on these forms of
deposits
because of the high statutory reserve requirements on
them.
"Interest on savings is not significant," a bank
official told
businessdigest.
"Savings accounts are now
used to keep money that is used like
current accounts and not as a way of
saving (investing)," the official said.
Some banks have
announced that they shift focus from retail
banking, which includes savings
and current accounts, to wholesale banking
due to poor business in the
area.
Because of the country's galloping inflation, most
individuals
have developed a tendency of maintaining minimum balances in
their savings
accounts.
According to statistics from the
Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe, the
difference between maximum interest rates
offered on savings and three-month
deposits have continued to grow,
especially in the second half of 2005.
In January 2005,
maximum interest on savings was 25% per annum
compared to 105% on 90-day
deposits.
Zim Independent
Pindai Dube
LOBELS Holdings has
acquired a state-of-the-art automatic
bread-making machine in a bid to
expand the Bulawayo plant.
The equipment, which was imported
from South Africa at a cost of
R5 million ($75 billion), is meant to produce
close to 120 000 loaves per
day.
At present, only 60 000
loaves are being produced per day.
During a tour of the plant
on Monday, Ngoni Mazango the managing
director of Lobels Bulawayo branch
told businessdigest that the new
bread-making machine is expected to be
operational by December.
Mazango said presently the
bread-making machine is producing 4
000 loaves per hour and 60 000 loaves
per day.
"Our aim is to produce a capacity of almost 200 000
loaves per
day
after the completion of this second plant
which we brought from
South Africa at a cost of R5 million," said
Mazango.
"At present, only the oven machine that started
operating some
weeks ago is operational. The mixers, prover and the dividers
for the whole
second plant would be in full operation by
December."
The investment, according to Mazango, is expected
to create 300
new jobs, bringing to 600 the staff complement at the
plant.
The first plant, which was officially opened by the
Reserve Bank
governor Gideon Gono last year, created 300 jobs for Bulawayo
residents.
Lobels Holdings operations manager, John Chikomo
said his
company is currently facing many viability problems spawned by the
economic
challenges the country is facing.
Zim Independent
Ray Matikinye
THE Movement
for Democratic Change (MDC) is retracing a familiar
path that has led into a
cul-de-sac in the past and is most likely to meet
the same fate with its new
"road map", analysts say.
Proponents of the seven-stage plan
crafted by the Morgan
Tsvangirai-led MDC that would culminate in a
transitional government
recognise the heavy odds militating against
wholesale acceptance by
stakeholders.
For all its
enthusiasm and hope to garner support and
acceptance, the road map
recognises President Mugabe as a major factor and
likely impediment in
efforts "to persuade Zanu PF to agree".
The document
benchmarks its pessimism on the fact that
"government and its machinery are
major shareholders and major beneficiary
to the current status
quo".
Analysts say the road map to unlock the political
impasse could
be yet another hard-sell given the dramatic failures earlier
local and
regional initiatives encountered owing to the refusal by leading
politicians
to engage in constructive resolution to the internal conflict,
they say.
Political analyst and chairman of the department of
politics and
administration at the University of Zimbabwe (UZ), Dr Eldred
Masunungure,
says the MDC is just testing the waters and casting a symbolic
gesture that
it is serious in solving the present crisis.
He says by proposing a road map the MDC is also putting Zanu PF
in a corner
and wanting to see politicians in that party viewed by the
electorate as
devoid of policy options.
Masunungure says he did not see
Zanu PF taking the road map
seriously.
"They are involved
in a nebulous road map between themselves and
the churches. Zanu PF is
vigorously pursuing its own initiative to steal the
thunder from the
opposition," Masunungure says.
Roping in the church to a
parallel initiative, he adds,
represents open rebuff of the MDC
proposal.
"They have completely abandoned inter-party talks,"
Masunungure
says.
"The MDC are engaged in an illusion if
they think Zanu PF will
accept it. You can judge by the manoeuvring that
Zanu PF is trying to
counter the road map initiative by the
opposition."
Masunungure says resolving the current political
stalemate needs
a comprehensive stakeholders' conference but Zanu PF prefers
engaging in
politics of inclusion by exclusion.
"Government is excluding key stakeholders such as civic society
by extending
its hand to selected clergymen. But this will lead it nowhere,"
Masunungure
said.
Spokesperson of Crisis Coalition Primrose Matambanadzo
agrees.
She says dialogue was essential to get the country
out of the
morass but points out that it cannot exclude faith-based
institutions.
"A stand-off is not the solution and the talks
should not only
involve the two parties but all stakeholders to craft a new
constitution
which is essential to restore legitimacy," Matambanadzo
said.
She said although it will be difficult to convince Zanu
PF that
talks are essential, the question of legitimacy could not be
resolved
without a new people-driven constitution.
"When
you exclude other parties, you cannot come up with a
broad-based
constitution acceptable to all.
Another political
commentator, Professor Heneri Dzinotyiwei,
also of the UZ, said Zanu PF
itself feared the prospects of successful
constitutional talks that they
view as meant to ladle out political
advantages to the
opposition.
"The ruling party is part of the problem. There
is a
misconception that a new constitution will give the opposition enormous
political advantage," Dzinotyiwei says.
And there are
clear signs too that Zanu PF might be playing
politics to divert public
attention from the current political impasse.
The party's
body language seems to have adopted a more
favourable posture towards the
church after an avowed "going it alone"
policy lost all its steam, forcing
the party to compromise its stance and
attempt to "build bridges" with the
international community.
Dzinotyiwei says Mugabe knows the
problems bedevilling Zimbabwe,
but instead of facing the problem head on, he
would rather digress.
"Zanu PF knows the problem but one
wonders why they have to
bring in the church," he says.
"The party itself faces difficulties in coming up with solutions
to the
current political impasse and the economic crisis but it continues to
go
astray," Dzinotyiwei says.
"The biggest problem with Zanu PF
is that it is a one-man band.
Deep inside his heart he (Mugabe) knows the
country has been run down but
perhaps fear of retribution has clouded his
judgements."
He says proposals by the MDC recognise the
dilemma government is
in and try to assist it out of it.
Admissions by President Mugabe while addressing church leaders
might also
mean a fresh look at the current impasse.
"We must accept our
failures. We should have to acknowledge that
as trustees in our part of the
world we have not succeeded as we had
wished," Mugabe
said.
Masunungure says Zanu PF is looking for legitimacy
because the
local, regional and international community is contesting the
space it is
occupying.
"It will not get that by engaging
church leaders. Zanu PF is
engrossed in politics of self-deception, not
wanting to accept the brutal
realities that you need to engage your
enemies," he says.
While the road map recognises Mugabe as a
major impediment to
acceptance, Masunungure says the divisions in Zanu PF
over the succession
issue could pose serious hindrance to engagement between
Mugabe, the
opposition and civic society.
He says the
ruling party has lost the initiative to come up with
solutions to the
national crisis due to these divisions.
"It is difficult to
come up with an agreement acceptable to both
the 'hawks' and the 'doves' in
the party depending on who has the upper hand
between them," he
says
"The hardliners will shoot down any proposals that
threaten
their interest while the doves could accept
anything."
The MDC says its modest proposals are a
demonstration of its
sincerity, good intentions and commitment to a peaceful
resolution of the
crisis through dialogue and
negotiations.
It says the proposals represent the MDC's
determination to chart
a course and a soft landing out of the crisis with
minimum costs in terms of
human suffering.
What remains
to be seen is whether the MDC road map has much
road to run and the
directions it will have to take.
Zim Independent
By Brilliant
Mhlanga
THE recent National Constitutional Assembly (NCA)
saga got a lot
of independent thinkers talking about the future of civil
society in
Zimbabwe.
Interestingly, they were all singing
the chorus that Lovemore
Madhuku had erred, therefore he should resign. At
least this was the final
call by some notable colleagues in the
opposition.
However, the discord is on the genesis of the
disease in the
civil society movement as a whole in Zimbabwe. In my view,
the problem stems
from the founder syndrome in civil society. This also
explains why there was
a deafening silence from other civil society leaders
about the NCA
predicament.
A closer analysis would
further show that the deafening silence
about the Madhuku issue by the
mainstream civil society in Zimbabwe was a
result of their celebrated double
standards when issues of relinquishing
positions are
concerned.
It would appear that someone somewhere in Zimbabwe
ejected
political principles and morals through the window and locked the
door never
to have them back. I am not sure whether we really need to blame
Mugabe for
everything, even loose political morals displayed by the civil
society
leaders.
This article is a direct challenge to
civil society, especially
those organisations that used to meet at Meikles
Hotel in 2003/4 to discuss
the creation of a long-lasting strategic
alliance. These included a lot of
people from various organisations and
regions of the country.
The major thrust at these meetings
was to forge alliances rooted
in democratic principles and to challenge Zanu
PF from a democratic
grounding. It never was on the cards to challenge Zanu
PF as its offshoots
seeking to polish its undemocratic ideals or to parallel
its violent
activities.
The focus was to shun by any
means necessary all undemocratic
tendencies. Everyone in civil society
agreed and undertook to abide by those
principles. Now, where are the
voices?
Everyone has chosen to be quiet, even when Madhuku
openly agrees
in his interview with SW Radio Africa that there was violence
at the NCA's
delayed annual general meeting. No one from civil society had
the temerity
to stand up and remind Madhuku that violence is violence,
whether meted out
to one individual or even the threat of it is considered
undemocratic in
this era.
No one could remind Madhuku
about the spirit of "love" and
"principles" for a revolutionary, and also
that a civil society is
considered "civil" due to the fact that members are
drawn from various
private groupings and the generality of the
citizenship.
This advice was supposed to be followed by the
view that any
attempts to arm or militarily radicalise a section of the
civil society
movement, be they male or female, young or old, is considered
uncivil and
will never be within the ambit of being civil, law-abiding and
upright.
I have witnessed the radical militarisation of the
youths in
civil society under the guise of mass demonstrations meant to push
the
democratic envelope. I have experienced the pain of being lowered to a
potential stone thrower when the leaders embark on what they call "capacity
building drives".
This move is not going to help Zimbabwe
progress into the
future. It is also inimical to the creation of a positive
society founded on
values of tolerance and acceptance of divergent views. If
anything, civil
society is showing double standards.
The
concept of "civil society" in Zimbabwe has been diluted by
capitalist ends
with most leaders seeking to view the whole democracy and
human rights idea
as an industry for making money and improving their CVs.
This unfortunate
development has been aggravated by the founder syndrome
together with the
"executive directorship" crusade which was spruced up by
the
Non-Governmental Organisations Bill (NGO Bill 2004) - a Zanu PF move
aimed
at crushing the civil society movement.
With the advent of
this Bill, which is still pending, a lot of
clumsy individuals turned
people-driven organisations that were established
through trusts into
individual organisations run by an executive director.
These overnight
developments that were a subversion of respective
organisational
constitutions, with the NGO Bill as the excuse, meant that
terms of office
were extended for as long as the executive director's
contract with God runs
on earth.
Interestingly, today it is Madhuku who has caused a
serious
chorus by twisting the NCA constitution inside out - a thing he has
always
done together with other leaders in various organisations, which is
why they
cannot criticise him. Strange bedfellows!
I will
not elaborate on this issue, as this topic requires a
separate focus
someday. I have knowledge about the goings-on in a lot of
organisations that
were said to be people-driven during their inception
stages, but later
personalised. I also have names of these organisations.
In
short, I would describe these characters as downright wicked
because they
must know in their hearts that their cause is wrong, and yet
refuse to
acknowledge it. They suffer from the lie in the soul.
They
are engaged in pursuing their own interests or interests of
their class, in
gratifying a lust for power through discreditable forms of
conduct. They
form a class which in Freiran description would be seen as
wallowing in the
shadow of the oppressor which lingers in their minds and
hearts, yet at the
same time struggling to point fingers at the evils of the
Mugabe
regime.
In reality they are worse off than the ruling party,
as they are
beneficiaries of a system that swindles the ordinary people of
their lives,
rights and property by claiming victimhood at the expense of
the masses.
They have resigned to the role of being official and perennial
civil society
leaders, a role they have embraced for as long as it helps
them to cause
serious retardation to any meaningful democratisation process
in Zimbabwe.
The civil society in Zimbabwe has internalised
the image of the
ruling party, its tactics and general guidelines, and is
therefore fearful
of freedom and any meaningful change. This explains the
reasons for their
quick move to scoff at any suggestion aimed at influencing
change in
Zimbabwe. Their fear of change is based on the fact that freedom
would
require them to discard the Zanu PF culture and replace it with
autonomy and
responsibility.
Most of them have
even
forgotten that freedom is acquired by conquest and not by
gift
because they are like a short man who gets himself elevated to a higher
position to aid his retarded view but have now decided to block the rise of
the same people who elevated them lest they take away their
limelight.
This forms the crisis faced by the civil society
movement in
Zimbabwe. It becomes imperative therefore for all civil society
leaders,
including Madhuku, to understand that the nefarious claims that
power
resides only in those who are in the ruling elite (Zanu PF) is a
monumental
scandal.
Zimbabwe's crisis has its genesis
from such warped lines of
thinking perpetrated by an irresponsible
leadership who fail to realise that
power resides in the people who thrust
them up in those offices.
Otherwise they seem to be
confirming the view that elites give
way to elites and that history is a
graveyard of aristocracies. Following
this view we may see them as emulating
the activities of a ruler who sees
himself as a shepherd who fattens the
sheep for the good of the shepherd.
What a shame to
democracy!
* Brilliant Mhlanga is a human rights
activist.
Zim Independent
By Magari
Mandebvu
AT our local post office one Saturday morning
you would not have
believed that we were in the country with the highest
average IQ in the
world - IQ for sugar, IQ for soap, IQ for matches, IQ for
upfu, IQ for
bread, IQ for milk, IQ for cash and IQ because this queue is
probably for
something I will need.
There was no queue.
In fact, there were so few customers that I
was able to discuss this
phenomenon with the cashier for some time before
another customer came
along. My main point in the discussion was that we
were seeing a
demonstration that whoever planned this did not have a very
high IQ in the
sense that we used to use that term.
It is not very
intelligent to raise your prices when they are
already so high that you are
losing customers. The average post office
salesperson could have told the
bosses when we reached that level, and
remind them that you will not get
more customers by a move like that.
On a newsstand, I saw a
headline saying that "tough new traffic
laws" were being introduced.
Apparently, the motive for this is to reduce
the number of road
accidents.
Now, I am as appalled as anyone by the
extraordinarily large
number of road accidents we see in this country, and
by the large number of
deaths from these accidents. But is it intelligent to
counter lawless
attitudes by making more laws?
I don't
see how you will persuade people who do not keep the
rules of the road that
we have already to drive more carefully by making
more and tougher rules for
road users.
So may we remind ourselves of a few simple
truths?
* You don't increase sales by raising prices when
customers are
already drifting away because your prices are
high.
* You don't persuade people to obey the law by making
more laws.
* You don't move forward by looking
backward.
If you want to move forward, you need to look
forward, not
sideways or to the back. Ask any child learning to ride a
bicycle. If you
look where you don't want to fall, you most certainly will
fall there. If
you concentrate on where you want to go, you will get
there.
If you want to create an independent nation, you need
to keep
your gaze fixed on the ideals of independence and on what will give
real
power to the people. If you prefer to keep looking back at the evils of
racism and colonialism you will re-create the evils of racism and
colonialism.
However, we should not forget entirely where
we came from. "Just
look forward" can sound like the false "reconciliation"
we had in the 1980s.
The government announced a policy of reconciliation and
the white farmers
embraced it enthusiastically. Both were enthusiastic about
it because they
did not understand that real reconciliation makes heavy
demands on both
sides.
Our trouble in 1980 was that the
white farmers were allowed to
carry on their business and their social life
as they always had, while the
government were content to allow this and even
to help them keep their
workers in line, as long as they made sufficient
donations to "Zany PF" and
didn't support any other
party.
Neither seemed to realise that such an approach just
sweeps the
real problems under the carpet, where they will fester and
eventually break
out as they did in 2000. Such outbreaks are often as
disastrous as we saw
then.
Real reconciliation requires
each side to examine and admit
their own crimes and to make what reparations
they can. You can't bring the
dead back to life. You can't undo torture. You
can't give victims back lost
limbs or destroyed manhood.
But there are things you can restore, and, when you can't, there
are ways of
finding an agreement with the victim and making amends that can
be
accepted.
If you ignore these requirements, some will
continue giving the
old offence, as they did, and others will nurse their
memory of grievances,
increasing their hatred of the old system until, as so
often happens, they
hate it so intensely that they become like
it.
So now we have our ruling party telling us daily of the
evils we
suffered in 1965, until it really looks as if we are still living
in 1965,
with state control and censorship of the media, arbitrary arrest
and torture
of political opponents, eviction of the poor from their pathetic
shelters,
destruction of their livelihood and legislation such as the Law
and Order
(Maintenance) Act, alias Posa.
We can see that
is not the way to freedom, democracy and
dignity, but somehow up there none
of the chefs see it.
And more simple
truth:
* You don't house people by destroying their
shelter.
Giving them better housing would be a noble aim, but
the better
houses should be built before destroying the old. People should
be moved
respectfully to something better than they had. Otherwise you seem
to be
condemning them because they can't build mansions for
themselves.
We all know they were just thrown out in the cold
and rain. As
for the houses built, apparently as an afterthought to the
so-called
"clean-up" - have you seen any of these Garikai
dwellings?
What I have seen are not as good as the lean-tos
and extensions
that many people I know were living in before May last year.
In some cases,
they may be more solid, but in their old places the evicted
people usually
had better access to water and sanitation. These seem to have
been
completely ignored by the builders of the Garikai houses I have
seen.
No wonder those houses are ignored by the people who
squat
around them. Often their shelters are less solid, but more spacious,
which
means they have room to dig themselves latrines and they don't have to
light
a cooking fire in their bedroom.
* You don't
liberate people by undermining their dignity.
Why call poor
oppressed people "people without totems" or
rubbish
(tsvina)?
Have you seen the film Hotel Rwanda? There, people
were called
"cockroaches" on state radio and by the police and soldiers so
that they
could be more easily killed. They were not considered
human.
Here, there is less violence, but people are dying of
hunger,
cold and disease and they don't count because they "don't have
totems" or
are "rubbish".
I could add to the list of
attacks on the dignity of the povo.
The police use forms of torture that do
more to debase people than to hurt
them physically.
Poor
people are denied the most basic sanitary needs. I really
can't see how
national security is threatened if poor women are allowed to
feel
clean.
That leaves me with a big question: if they go the
wrong way
about freeing people, creating democracy and even housing people,
do they
really want to free the people, to create democracy or to house the
people?
* Magari Mandebvu is a Harare-based
writer.
Zim Independent
By BDA Moultrie
I WOULD like
to congratulate our esteemed power provider on the
unique achievement of
effecting the 100th power cut in my part of Greendale
since January 24, when
I returned from a break in the UK.
These cuts have totalled
just under 300 hours which admittedly
includes a major 40-hour fault in
April, which was immediately followed by a
further three load shedding cuts
totalling another 10 hours within the
ensuing 24 hours!
Just to make this deplorable state of affairs even worse, my
monthly
electricity account has increased four-fold.
And, as if this
was not enough, the constant and unscheduled
outages have cost me two
compressors on fridges and a new deep freeze.
This ignores
the uncountable number of blown globes which, at
the current $150 000 each,
adds up to even more expenses with absolutely no
possibility of
compensation.
While I appreciate the excuses (these are even
more frequent
than the power cuts, and certainly more predictable!), what I
do find
completely untenable is the total lack of consistency/planning in
load
shedding. This, despite numerous phone calls requesting some form of
schedule around which we could plan our lives.
They are
quick enough to forward their bills. Would it not be
just as simple to
include regular load shedding schedules and keep to them,
or is this far too
complicated a proposal for them to action?
Although it is
extremely unlikely that any answers will be
forthcoming from Zesa I will,
nonetheless, pose the following questions,
answers to which will make for
absorbing reading:
* Why are several areas virtually immune
from shedding? (I know
of two addresses in the Greendale area that endured
only one or two cuts in
the five months to which I
refer);
* Although Zesa asserts that they do publish shedding
schedules
in the press, why do they not adhere to them?
*
The only consistent element of the shedding "programme" is its
total
inconsistency. Why?
* Why does "Faults" invariably place one
on hold, sometimes for
up to 10 minutes, that is when one is fortunate
enough to get through to
them?
* BDA Moultrie is a
resident of Greendale.
Zim Independent
Editor's Memo
By Vincent Kahiya
IN
the book Profiles in Courage, the late US President JF
Kennedy spoke about
political leaders who sacrificed their own continuation
in office in pursuit
of a noble cause. These were individuals who produced
public goods even when
doing so meant losing their job. Few leaders have
this profile in
courage.
If citizens were to choose leaders to belong to a
leadership
Hall of Fame they might select individuals who consistently, over
a long
career in office, produce peace and prosperity for their
country.
Peace and prosperity, after all, are the
cornerstones of a
flourishing, successful government that does its utmost to
promote the
well-being of its citizens.
Kennedy said if
national leaders themselves were to select
candidates for a leadership Hall
of Fame, their criteria might be different.
They might forego measures of
peace and prosperity and just emphasise
longevity in office. Long tenure is
not necessarily the hallmark of a
government that promotes social welfare,
but it is the hallmark of a
politically successful leader, he
argued.
For more cynical analysts, leaders stay in office for
personal
aggrandisement and to create opportunities to steal from the state.
These
leaders would fit in the "Haul of Fame". Closer to home, poor Harare
Town
Clerk Nomutsa Chideya who is fighting for political survival again at
Town
House in Harare is not a candidate for the Hall of Fame despite his 10
years
service as Town Clerk.
The current attempt to elbow
him out from his post as the most
senior bureaucrat in Harare has evoked
some sympathy because the aggressor
is the super-inefficient Sekesai
Makwavarara who is surprisingly conscious
that useless officials should be
fired.
Her record of delivery in Harare is as dubious as the
acclaim
bestowed on her by Local Government minister Ignatious Chombo who
recently
told us of the good work the political turncoat was doing in
Harare.
There is no better way of being inducted into the
"Haul of Fame"
than being foisted on a city that regards you as a nuisance.
To government,
she is a convenient mess as long as her presence ensures that
the opposition
MDC is kept out of Town House. This should give Chideya hope
and a sense of
security but this should not be his lifebuoy. He should
demonstrate to city
dwellers that he deserves the position of Town Clerk
because of his record
of delivery which I do not see.
Chideya could enter record books for long service in fighting
for survival
to keep his job.
When he came to Town House for the first
time in 1998, the late
Harare Executive Mayor Solomon Tawengwa immediately
launched an onslaught to
drive him out on the premise that he could not
perform.
He survived this wave of attack and should have
rejoiced the
firing of Tawengwa and the subsequent appointment of a
commission chaired by
Elijah Chanakira to run the affairs of the
city.
But Chideya was soon out of favour with the Chanakira
Commission
which also sought to have him removed from the position on the
pretext that
he was failing to deliver.
He again survived
this turbulent era in which the commissioners
presided over a period of a
steep decline in service delivery in the city.
Municipal
elections in Harare in 2002 brought in Elias Mudzuri
as executive mayor.
City centre roads were resurfaced and the Africa Unity
Square fountains
started to work after a long period of inactivity.
Chideya
was quick to associate himself with this success until
October 2002 when
Mudzuri suspended him on allegations of inefficiency.
Chideya was
subsequently restored to his position by government and
immediately assumed
executive powers at Town House.
He warned officials against
drawing undue interference from
politicians in council
affairs.
His opportunism was manifest when Chombo appointed
the Kurasha
Commission to investigate the conduct of the suspended Mudzuri.
Like his
current nemesis Makwavarara, he told the commission that Mudzuri
should not
come back to Town House.
"I actually wanted
him (Mudzuri) trapped and unfortunately the
wheel of justice takes its
time," Chideya said. "I mean I am aware that the
mayor was not comfortable
in our own family situation. I am actually married
to a CIO operative, my
wife works for the President's Office."
His wish was granted
and Mudzuri was fired.
This is the same Chideya whom
Makwavarara has said should be
removed from Town House on medical grounds.
Apparently a job has been
organised for Chideya at the Urban Development
Corporation which I believe
is not an infirmary.
I feel
pity for Chideya; especially his quest to stay at Town
House at all costs.
My advice to him is to leave the "Haul of Fame" to those
who are schooled in
the art of "hauling".
Zim Independent
Muckraker
WE were interested to note the
lavish praise bestowed upon
Bishop Trevor Manhanga by Nathaniel Manheru in
his column last weekend.
Manhanga's warning about "fly by night messiahs"
who "line their pockets
with donor money" was taken by Manheru to be a
reference to Archbishop Pius
Ncube. Manhanga has not denied the
suggestion.
Indeed, Manhanga's role in defending the current
dialogue
between church and state is fascinating. Here was a once robust
critic of
government who clearly understood the issues which divided a
conscientious
church from an abusive regime. But Manhanga appears to have
changed his tune
and is now not only in the forefront of promoting support
for the
government, but also leading attacks on churchmen who cannot in all
conscience defend supping with politicians who have presided over the most
appalling human rights abuses, not least the Murambatsvina urban
holocaust.
Even today the impact on informal business
activity in the
townships of that "clean-up" is everywhere visible as is the
social cost.
Yet Manhanga and his fellow-church collaborators think they can
deliver
dialogue with a government that has never listened to anybody and
shows no
prospect of doing so.
How then do we explain
turnabouts by people such as Manhanga who
appear happy to be used by state
propagandists? And how can churchmen with a
mission to build a better nation
consort with those who are determined to
continue with the policies of hate
and repression that have got us where we
are today?
The
most we got from President Mugabe was an intriguing prayer
for God to pardon
Zimbabwe for "sins committed that had brought reproach to
the
nation".
We weren't told who committed those
sins!
Manhanga spoilt his credibility by repeating the Zanu
PF mantra.
"We refuse to join our detractors and short-sighted fellow
citizens who
cannot see any good in our nation," he told fellow suborned
clergymen.
Such cognitive dissonance is dangerous for a man
of the cloth.
By the way, we see that the Zimbabwe
Catholic Bishops Conference
was listed as among those sponsoring this
questionable day of prayer. Is
that true? While we know the Zimbabwe Council
of Churches lost its way years
ago, we don't expect the Catholic Bishops,
with their fine reputation for
resistance to oppression under two regimes,
to collaborate with the
incorrigible author of the nation's
pain.
Neither of their two archbishops were present so
perhaps the
Herald misled us. And the 5 000 people who attended the event
can hardly be
counted as a sizable crowd. More people attended a soccer
match on the same
day.
But all the same, we welcome
President Mugabe's virgin admission
of his government's plethora of failures
at the event. And, it must be said,
he pulled off a clever religious coup by
persuading the men of the cloth
present to organise the
proceedings.
The clergy surrendered their initiative and
allowed Mugabe to
dictate the pace of events.
We suspect
he learned the trick of pacifying critics from Bingu
waMutharika on his
recent visit to Malawi where a road was named after him.
Bingu made sure
critics singing the wrong hymn by opposing Mugabe's visit
turned over a new
leaf by inviting them to State House for lunch.
Mugabe used
the same therapy effectively on the clergy. Having a
chit-chat at State
House works wonders in massaging egos!
Unless the Herald
misquoted him, Mugabe said: "We must accept
our failures. We should have to
acknowledge that as trustees in our part of
the world (read Zimbabwe), we
have not succeeded as we had wished."
Well said Mr President.
Now we know that all along we have been
wishing we could succeed but have
failed dismally in spite of all advice.
But please Mr President, don't use
the inclusive "we" as the povo were not
part of your skewed schemes that
brought about such ubiquitous failure.
"We" (the ruling
elite) are so mentally challenged that "we"
(the Zanu PF chefs) could not
distinguish that wishing and succeeding are
completely different
things.
So for the past 26 years leaders have been wishing
"we" would
succeed, but "failed" and still continue to wish "we" could
succeed. Now
that "we" know, what are "we" going to do about it? For how
long can "we"
remain in wishful mode without succeeding and still wish
something different
will happen?
Those worrying about
growing corruption in Zimbabwe need fret no
longer. Everything is under
control, Anti-Corruption minister Paul Mangwana
assures us. The
Anti-Corruption Commission is at work, he says, but
operating "outside the
public glare".
Responding in parliament to concerns about its
performance,
Mangwana said its members were only sworn in last October. It
had been
putting in operating "structures" since then. It would soon be
launching a
website, he said.
Let's hope it takes less
than eight months to get that up and
running!
Every
Zimbabwean has a responsibility to build a positive image
about this country
and to communicate the message to the outside world to
change the
misconceptions held by many out there," government spokesman
George Charamba
has said.
"The burden of building a positive image about
Zimbabwe should
be carried by every member of society," he said. And in a
revealing
admission he added: "Zimbabwe has a bad image out there because it
has a bad
image here at home."
Indeed it has. And which
Zimbabweans are responsible for that:
those that campaign for good
governance, freedom of expression, the rule of
law and human rights, or
those that use hate speech against their critics,
devise oppressive laws,
use the police as a tool of repression, and loot
farms for their own
benefit?
Building a positive image for Zimbabwe should start
at the top.
Tourists will not visit a country where there is no rule of law,
where human
rights are subverted, and where political leaders use racist
language to
justify their brutal grip on power.
Zimbabwe
Tourism Authority chief executive Karikoga Kaseke said
his organisation was
working on a "perception management programme".
He really
doesn't get it, does he? You can't improve Zimbabwe's
international image so
long as its leaders are delinquent in what they say
and do. While some
visitors paid for by government may be impressed by our
facilities, it is
only a matter of time before the country's leaders say
something outrageous
which directly impacts on source markets.
Charamba described
Zimbabwe as "a country subjected to illegal
sanctions by countries of
ill-will", but, he said, "we have managed to
implement empowerment
programmes to eradicate poverty".
Has anybody heard of any of
these programmes? And are those
"countries of ill-will" the same ones that
are keeping Zimbabweans fed?
Then there is the issue of the
rule of law. Where is Joseph
Mwale? Where are the bombers of the Daily News
and Voice of the People? What
sort of society is it that shelters such
miscreants? Tuesday's edition of
the London Times provided instructive
reading on the extent of torture in
Zimbabwe, quoting a report by the
Zimbabwe Human Rights NGO Forum.
Zimbabwe's international
reputation can be directly ascribed to
the behaviour of its rulers. So long
as the ZTA fails to understand that it
will fail in its
mission.
Still with building a "positive image" for the
country, the
Times cited a recent episode at Reps bar where patrons were
watching the
World Cup. Deputy Finance minister David Chapfika who was also
present, the
newspaper reported, switched the channel to the local station
so he could
watch the government news bulletin.
One of
the drinkers switched it back to football. "We don't
watch that garbage
here," he said. Twenty minutes later two policemen
entered the bar and took
the man away, the Times said. They accused him of
saying: "We don't watch
that Mugabe here," confusing the word "garbage" with
"Mugabe". He was kept
in the ordurous cells of Avondale police station for
two freezing nights
before being let go without charge.
On the subject of
getting things mixed up, we were amused to
hear Simba Mumbengegwi's
reference, during his harangue to diplomats last
week, about aborigines
being held in a Tasmanian zoo where the last of the
species died out in the
1930s.
Could he have been thinking of the Tasmanian Tiger,
the last of
which died out in a Tasmanian zoo in the 1930s? Whatever the
case,
Mumbengegwi's outburst against Australia convinced many diplomats
present
that Zimbabwe's rulers have lost the plot. Didymus Mutasa
contributed to the
debacle with his customary words of
wisdom.
Bridge-builders will have difficulty proceeding,
several of
those present say, after that episode where Zimbabwe put its
worst foot
forward. But can you imagine the government thinking it could
make a good
impression on experienced diplomats by putting up the trio of
Mumbengegwi
(thinking he could do another Hardtalk), Mutasa and Joseph
Made!
Bulawayo commemorates the death of veteran
nationalist and
founder politician, Joshua Nkomo, who died seven years ago.
The gala
celebrated with an orgy of saturnalia, accompanied by song and
dance serves
to remind Zimbabweans of the political icon. As usual the state
television
station has been running cherry-picked rave reviews of Joshua
Nkomo and his
works and speeches.
In order to give the
younger generation an accurate history,
would it be asking too much for ZTV
to get someone to recite excerpts of the
great man's letters written during
his short exile in Britain, written to
the then Prime Minister, Robert
Gabriel Mugabe?
Karigamombe Building, built from Railway
Pension funds, was so
named in fawning praise of Mugabe to mark how his Zanu
PF had slaughtered
the Zapu bull.
The then Transport
minister, the late Herbert Ushewokunze, came
up with the name to spite Nkomo
and his party symbol.
Is it impossible to rename Karigamombe
Building more
appropriately to reflect the unity we are so keen to crow
about? What about
cloning a bull and a rooster, then pitch the result on the
party
headquarters where the cockerel still reminds us who rules the
roost?
Muckraker notices some parts of the neon sign on the
building
have gone on the blink at night. Instead of ZANU PF the neon sign
reads ZA U
F, probably signifying that there is no longer "nationalism" and
"patriotism" in whatever we do.
It is amazing how
revealing reports by the parliamentary
committees on various portfolios can
be . The reports are second only to the
indicting details contained in
maiden speeches by newly elected MPs. These
can easily pass for a barometer
to measure how government has fared or
failed depending on the sycophancy of
the orator.
The maiden speeches invariably make short shrift
of the mythical
claims that Zanu PF has been developing the rural areas
since ZIMCORD all
these years it has been in power.
Unwittingly new legislators' speeches contradict the
pre-election party
manifesto that always paints a glowing picture of Zanu PF's
achievements.
Almost all MPs gripe and groan about lack
of infrastructure such
as roads, bridges, clinics and all that stuff in
their constituencies. The
huff and puff contradict rather bashfully
government's self-glorification.
Maiden speeches are
instructive too on the probabilities that
the legislator would have employed
the lack of infrastructure as a campaign
strategy in convincing biddable
peasants to vote for him or her.
Muckraker cannot remember
which legislator debunked the
misplaced notions that an MP can bring about
development. For one thing the
MP has little resources to do so. For another
the legislator will have to
convince everyone else in parliament that his
constituency is worse off than
the rest and merits first
preference.
What might be a priority in his constituency
might not
necessarily be so in the eyes of the cabinet.
But going back to committee reports, Muckraker was deeply
unsettled by a
report that government's failure to provide basic sanitary
items in prisons
has forced inmates into committing sacrilege.
Inmates
obviously don't expect God to forgive these ungodly acts
even when they have
atoned themselves of their crimes by serving their
sentences.
Prisoners are tearing the prison-issue Bibles
apart and using
the pages as toilet paper out of necessity and
desperation.
Why not collect pages of "The Other Side" or
"African Focus" as
well as heaps of returns from a certain publication and
deliver it to
prisoners?
Remember the Tswanas buying
copies of the Chronicle saying it
was cheaper than a toilet
roll?
Zim Independent
By Eric Bloch
AS
Zimbabwean inflation surges upwards, creating new record
highs each month,
the hardships upon the
overwhelming majority of the population,
the calls upon
government to impose price controls where they do not exist,
and to enforce
those that do, become increasingly
strident.
The letter pages of the national press are flooded
with letters
scathingly attacking commerce and industry for alleged "
profiteering" and
exploitation of the poor. The Consumer Council of Zimbabwe
vigorously urges
governmental price control actions. MPs and Senators
(having arrived at the
legislature in their luxurious, state-funded motor
vehicles, and wearing
top-of-the-range outfits), weep crocodile tears of
sympathy for the
beleaguered consumers, and demand that the Minister of
Industry and
International Trade should curb the perceived avarice of
private sector
marketeers.
That these reactions are so
prevalent, and intensifying, is not
surprising. Ever greater numbers are
reduced to the lowest levels of
poverty. They cannot adequately feed
themselves and their families. When
ill, they cannot afford to seek medical
attention or purchase medications.
Many cannot pay their children's school
fees. Those fortunate to have
employment can still not make ends meet, to
such extent that tens of
thousands cannot afford public transport to and
from their places of
employment. Instead, they leave their homes before the
break of dawn,
walking many kilometres to work, and then walk like great
distances homeward
at the end of day, at best having one meal in the entire
day, and knowing
that upon arrival home they will be confronted by crying,
unhappy,
under-nourished children, and embittered, poverty-traumatised
spouses.
Those same distressed masses see owners of
businesses still
driving executive style motor vehicles, usually coming to
their places of
business from upmarket residences, and therefore assume that
they are
earning vast profits, and are the cause of the misery of the
majority. They
are oblivious to the magnitude of debt accumulated by most
businesses in
their struggles to survive within the collapsing Zimbabwean
economy; debt
attracting interest rates of up to 700%.
They are blind to the progressive erosion of the capital of the
enterprises,
caused by ever-rising costs, concurrently with declining sales
revenues.
They disregard the fact that manufacturers, importers,
wholesalers,
retailers and all other suppliers are as subject to inflation
as are the
populace at large and that, therefore, the survival of their
businesses is
dependent upon increasing prices. The reality is that very few
Zimbabwean
businesses engaged in meeting consumer needs are achieving
increases in
profits, in real terms.
With official inflation having
reached almost 1 200% in the year
to May, profits will have had to increase
12-fold just to have retained
constancy of value. Not many enterprises have
attained such profits. In
fact, a great many have incurred losses, forcing
numerous to cease
operations.
Moreover, to make a profit
is not a crime. Why should any place
their capital at risk, devote their
time, energy and expertise to business
operations, and be confronted by the
array of economic hazards that exist in
any economy, but especially in a
distressed one, if not in order to make a
profit, and that profit should be
commensurate to the risks that are faced,
and to the capital and other
resources employed. If there is not a prospect
of such a profit, whether due
to economic environmental circumstances or to
governmental actions and
constraints, then the businesses will not be
established or, if existent,
will not continue. In that event, price becomes
irrelevant, for the goods
and services are simply not available to the
consumer, irrespective of
affordability or otherwise.
But, most of all, those who
demand enforcement of price controls
fail to recognise that price controls
do not work. All that results from
controls are scarcities in official
markets and, in consequence, growth in
black market activity, invariably at
prices markedly greater than would have
pertained in normal markets, had
there been no controls. Thus, price
controls are actually inflationary, and
worsen the lot of the consumers. A
marked example of this was when the
Zimbabwe Republic Police recently tried
to enforce the prescribed fare of
$50 000 for commuter omnibus services in
urban areas, as against the fares
being imposed by operators of $80 000
(which they required in consequence of
massive escalations in costs of motor
spares, tyres, petrol and diesel). The
police set-up road blocks to catch
the "errant" operators. To counter this,
the operators would end their
journey before reaching the road blocks,
charging $80 000 for the trip to
that point, whereafter the passengers would
walk to the other side of the
road blocks, and board other commuter
omnibuses, paying yet a further $80
000 to complete their journey. Thus, in
seeking to limit costs to $50 000,
instead of $80 000, the commuter was
actually faced with a cost of $160 000!
In like manner, the
authorities descended heavily upon bakeries
and other purveyors of bread,
arresting nearly 300 for selling standard
loaves at prices ranging from $120
000 to $135 000, when the "controlled"
price was $85 000. In consequence,
standard loaves of bread are no longer
available and, if the consumer is to
have bread, he must buy non-standard
loaves (such as super loaf), at prices
ranging as high as $200 000. Once
again, the consumer was not protected by
the controls, but afflicted by
them, with yet further intensification of
hardships.
Petroleum prices have rocketed upwards in the last
few weeks,
partially driven by growing scarcity, which does motivate some to
make
excessive profits by exploiting the desperate need of the customers,
but
mainly driven by massive increases in procurement costs. Those increases
are
partially attributable to surging world crude oil prices, but more so to
the
vast movement in exchange rates within the parallel market. On radio,
last
Thursday, the Consumer Council of Zimbabwe vehemently demanded
governmental
action to reinstate controls upon petroleum prices. That it did
so was
undoubtedly driven by very real, genuine concern for consumers. That
concern
is fully justified, but the proposed remedy of intensified controls
is not,
for such controls will be counterproductive in the
extreme.
Instead of regimented prices, which will destroy
supply-lines,
and therefore further decimate the economy, and intensify the
affliction of
consumers, government, and the rest of society, needs to bring
inflation
under control. A social contract must halt inflation driving
inflation,
exchange rates must move to restore export viability and,
thereby, increase
productivity, government must cut its spending, money
supply growth must be
curbed, and parastatals must be made effective (why is
no-one demanding a
control upon Zimpost's recurrent increases in charges, or
querying why Zupco
is realising a profit of more than $180 billion in three
months, whilst
increasing fares?).
If inflation would be
driven down by effective measures, instead
of fruitless attempts to do so
with price controls, and if at the same time
competition would be encouraged
and productivity assured, then prices would
be very much more constant, and
the pressure upon consumers would
progressively decline. The hard fact is
that price controls have never been
an effective economic measure - they
don't work, and Zimbabwe must resort to
measures that do work!
Zim Independent
Comment
ZIMBABWE'S parallel foreign currency market,
which the
government has unsuccessfully battled to terminate despite its
inflationary
effects, is once more a dominant feature of an economic crisis
that has
ravaged the country for the last six years.
There has always been significant official attention on parallel
foreign
currency activities by the government and its monetary agency in the
last
six years, but events over the last few days should draw not only
attention
but shame on a government that has failed to deal decisively with
the
country's economic problems despite its claims to the
contrary.
Our defenceless currency has lost ground
significantly over the
past month on the parallel market, while the exchange
rate on the official
interbank market has remained stagnant, despite
increased inflationary
pressures in the economy.
Prices
of basic and non-basic commodities have soared
considerably during the same
period, reflecting the fact that industry and
commerce are factoring the
parallel market rates in their pricing systems.
Indeed
parallel exchange rates have had an enormous impact on
the
economy.
Continued increases in the premium on the parallel
exchange
market have encouraged the diversion of exports from official to
unofficial
channels.
Importers have been forced to source
foreign currency from the
parallel market because the official market is
literally dry.
This has pushed up the domestic prices of
imported goods as
prices are determined by the parallel
rate.
But clearly the emergence and persistence of the
parallel market
can only be attributed to skewed economic policies by
government.
The traditional government approach to the crisis
has always
been to blame economic saboteurs for spawning the parallel market
and
fuelling the economic crisis.
This narrow-minded
attitude has evidently ignored the heart and
soul of parallel foreign
currency market activities, resulting in futile
efforts by the government to
destroy the market through police raids on
individuals and companies
suspected of dealing in foreign currency and
prosecution of firms failing to
remit foreign currency on time.
Zimbabwe, which adopted an
open market economy when it undertook
International Monetary Fund
(IMF)-backed economic reforms in 1991, still
possesses rigid exchange
restrictions prompted principally by its external
indebtedness and
increasing non-creditworthiness made worse by the depletion
of international
reserves.
The country's reserves have suffered significantly
due to
dwindling export receipts. Once the country embarked on controversial
land
reforms in 2000, agriculture, the bedrock of the country's export
sector and
the economy, suffered historic losses.
The
country's agriculture-dependent manufacturing sector was
affected, again
resulting in a reduction of exports.
The fixing of the exchange
rate, despite high inflation levels
evidently eroding the value of the
domestic currency, has had the effect of
making Zimbabwe's exports
uncompetitive in foreign markets.
Moreover, the high costs
associated with production in a
hyperinflationary environment mean that
exporters have to cash their foreign
currency on the official market at
rates that do not make exports
profitable.
This has
restricted access to official markets by exporters
leading to the emergence
of an illegal parallel market.
The parallel market has
consequently grown in significance as
the authorities respond to a
deteriorating balance-of-payments situation by
tightening and extending
controls rather than devaluing the official
exchange
rate.
As a result, Zimbabwe's currency has become
persistently
overvalued on the official market and this has discouraged
exports.
The parallel market, which has responded rapidly to
macroeconomic developments, has therefore become the preferred channel for
disposing of foreign currency by both exporters and
individuals.
It is important to note that officials from both
the government
and the central bank, who have vigorously defended the skewed
exchange
policy and condemned the parallel market, have themselves been key
traders
of hard currency on the parallel market.
This is
an acknowledgement that the official market rate is
unrealistic and that a
decisive resolution to deal with the current crisis
should be
undertaken.
Zim Independent
Candid Comment
By Dumisani Muleya
THE recent dramatic increase in Zimbabwe's domestic debt from
$15 trillion
to about $48 trillion has painted a grim picture of the
economic situation
and cast a pall over prospects of recovery of the
economy.
Latest central bank statistics show the public
debt was $42,9
trillion as at June 16. The debt was $21 trillion on June 2
and $27 trillion
on June 9. It is now $48,2 trillion. The debt shot up from
$1,7 trillion in
December 2004 to $15,9 trillion in December last
year.
This means on average every Zimbabwean - including all
those who
are outside the country and newly-born babies - have a debt of
$3,2 million
if we assume the population is 15 million.
Officially the population is around 12 million people but
estimates suggest
if locals in foreign countries are to be included, the
figure is actually
much higher.
Zimbabwe's running national budget is $124
trillion. The budget
deficit is expected to be 4,6% because government
anticipates collecting
$110 trillion in revenue and spending $123,9
trillion.
The debt has been skyrocketing against a background
of
deteriorating macro-economic fundamentals and the socio-economic
situation.
The central bank's overnight accommodation rate
yesterday stood
at 850%, the inter-bank rate at 722,86% while treasury bills
yielded 510%.
Inflation is 1 193%, while the exchange rate has crashed to
land at
US$1:$400 000.
Internal debt is the part of
government debt owed to creditors
who are citizens of that country. It is a
form of fiat creation of money in
which the government obtains cash not by
printing it, but by borrowing it.
The money created is in the
form of treasury securities or
securities borrowed from the central bank.
The domestic debt forms a part of
the national debt which includes the
external debt.
Zimbabwe's foreign debt is US$3,9 billion.
Zimbabwe recently
printed $21 trillion to pay the International Monetary
Fund (IMF) arrears
although the global fund refused to lift the sanctions it
imposed on the
country for non-payment.
Zimbabwe's
external arrears are not limited to the IMF, World
Bank and African
Development Bank. It owes a number of suppliers money for
fuel and
electricity, among other critical imports. Printing money can't be
the
solution but improved economic and export performance is.
Currently the balance of payments position is extremely bad
because the
country had a negative trade balance of US$363 million last year
after it
registered total exports worth US$1,6 billion - a 6,4% decline -
vis-à-vis
imports of US$1,9 billion although the imports had fallen by
2,6%.
This means the country is now caught up in a debt trap
which is
detrimental to the already battered economy. The situation is
worsened by
the fact that Zimbabwe is isolated internationally and cannot
get foreign
direct investment, donor funds, or debt cancellation, which are
all critical
to economic growth.
The domestic debt has
become a problem not only because of its
massive size but also the rate at
which it is mounting.
The other problem is that a large
portion of the debt is held in
short-term bonds that attract high real
interest rates and this inevitably
creates a debt vicious
circle.
The strucure of the domestic debt reflects the
dominance of
short-term paper - more than 90% - with medium to long term
debt taking up
less than 10%. The structure of the debt is very expensive
and certainly not
sustainable.
The government amassed the
debt mostly through its uncontrolled
expenditure patterns. President
Mugabe's regime is notorious for dishing out
money like confetti every time
there is an election coming in a bid to
purchase votes.
It also spends recklessly for other political reasons, for
instance paying
the ex-combatants to placate them when they show signs of
unrest.
The government recently printed large amounts of
money to pay an
army of restless soldiers and civil servants, as well as pay
its own debts.
This came against a background of a public service wage bill
which is above
40% of the budget, something clearly
unsustainable.
The fiscal and monetary consequences of the
debt are enormous.
The debt situation leaves the government facing
bankruptcy, even though this
regime thinks a government can never get broke
because it can always print
money.
While this is true in
simplistic terms, it betrays economic
ignorance writ large. A government can
get broke in real financial terms.
Printing large sums of paper money - not
backed by wealth - is a sign of
bankruptcy, a hallmark of economic
failure.
Given the current situation, it would be difficult,
if not
impossible, in the short to medium-term to improve the fiscal
position from
a chronic deficit situation to a surplus to reduce the growing
debt threat
to the economy.
While there are a number of
options which can be exercised to
deal with the debt situation, there are no
easy answers.
The government can divest from some
non-performing national
assets and use the proceeds to reduce the
debt.
Privatisation and commercialisation are the main
options
although they always carry a political cost.
The
domestic debt has grown rapidly over the past six years with
the increasing
deficit that has become structural.
Since Independence in
1980, Zimbabwe has always had a debt
problem but the situation was worsened
by government's unsustainable
populist spending policies.
Government has never been able to marshal enough revenue to
finance its
expenditures. This has resultantly created deficits that have to
be financed
either by borrowing from the domestic market or externally.
Since government has been over-borrowing locally and cannot
borrow from
outside, it has now resorted to printing money to finance its
expenditure
and pay interest on the debt.
This has become
hyper-inflationary. Unless the government deals
with the debt problem, it
may soon find itself locked in a terminal fiscal
crisis which can easily
aggravate mounting political problems.
Shumba doesn't deserve
coverage
I HAVE seen that many times Zanu PF "rejects" seek
independent
media attention after they are ditched by the
party.
Daniel Shumba, the UPP president, should not be
allowed any
media coverage by independent papers.
Why
can't he approach the Herald to make known his stupid move.
I'm sure only
foolish people will vote for this creature which sadly has the
guts to say:
"I was once a part of Zanu PF and tried to sort out things from
within. I
know how they rig elections and I know how we can achieve our
goal."
Maybe he should be tortured by CIOs himself for
speaking bad
about the president's party. He's a confused sell-out who
helped Zanu PF rig
elections but now wants to give the world the impression
that he's clean.
Why didn't he tell us about how Zanu PF rigs
elections before he
was fired?
What things was he trying
to sort out apart from masterminding
the rigging of elections and other ills
that have destroyed Zimbabwe?
He will not fool me by
pretending to be perfect himself. He was
part of this crooked and evil
regime and rigging scheme.
I would rather vote for a
cockroach than vote for a conman like
Shumba.
He just
didn't want Joice Mujuru to become vice-president, hence
his attendance at
the Tsholotsho meeting.
If Shumba had attended that meeting
to scheme ways of getting
Mugabe out of power then I would have respect for
him and take him
seriously.
What goal does Shumba want to
achieve? What madness does he want
to stop? He had better fool someone else.
Anything with traces of Zanu PF is
dirty and evil to me.
It's high time independent papers refused to be abused by such
kind of
selfish ex-Zanu PF members who treated us like door mats at the time
they
licked Mugabe's boots. Let them have their stories published by
Nathaniel
Manheru.
As an independent paper, the Zimbabwe Independent
should not
allow these Zanu PF "convicts" to grace its pages unless they are
convicted
of rape, theft and other kind of
things.
Black out Shumba and all the creatures of the same
calibre. That
will make you a truly independent paper. Allowing them
coverage is as good
as allowing evil to prevail.
They
have nothing constructive to offer to Zimbabwean society.
They destroyed our
country, stole our riches and raped us. They should be
forgotten once and
for all.
No Zanu PF convict for
president.
Viomak Mugabechienda,
Harare.
-------------
Where's
the povo's ire?
POOR Zimbabwe, once a sovereign
state (as we were
constantly told) but now with all our efforts to give away
failing
parastatals and unmined minerals to the East, is fast becoming a
zhing zhong
Chinese colony.
Even
Vice-President Joice Majuru recently "returned
empty-handed from
China".
Inscrutable Chinese learn very
quickly.
And now the United Nations are asking us
to accept
that Zimbabwe is a failed state - the lowest of the low. Poor
Zimbabwe, once
the breadbasket of southern
Africa.
Last Friday's issue also told us that
Simbarashe
Mumbengegwi, our Foreign Affairs minister, had blown away
President Robert
Mugabe's bridge-building efforts sky-high by a stinging
20-minute "rant and
rave outburst" at a meeting with diplomats also
attended, I gather, by
Didymus Mutasa.
And so
our worthy president goes to Banjul to attend
the African Union meeting and
meet SA president Thabo Mbeki and UN
secretary-general Kofi Annan,
unsupported by any possible areas of agreement
in seeking peace and
understanding from the West and the United
Nations.
It looks as though we're going to have
to continue
to battle on against the odds set by our own
government.
How long will it be before the povo
finally gets so
desperate and angry that they rise up, as the late ex-Chief
Justice Enoch
Dumbutshena, I seem to recall, foresaw would be the case some
few years ago
and throw the government out on its
neck?
PNR,
Harare.
--------------
Mutambara's political maturity,
sensitivity
impressive
PRESIDENT of the
pro-senate MDC faction,
Professor Arthur Mutambara is a very sensitive man.
From the tone of his
message of condolence to the Tsvangirai family on the
death of Sekuru
Dzingirai Chibwe Tsvangirai, father of Morgan, leader of the
anti-senate MDC
faction, he sounded very touched by the death of Mr
Tsvangirai senior.
He praised the deceased
for having nurtured
Morgan to become the national symbol of hope in our
struggle for democracy
and freedom against Robert
Mugabe.
This was a very mature statement to
say the
least. I also noticed that Mutambara and his faction are the only
group that
issued a positive press statement on the death of Mr Tsvangirai
senior. Even
Tsvangirai's faction did not issue a statement and we do not
know why?
Tsvangirai must appreciate that
he is now a
national figure and a national
asset.
Whatever happens in his personal
life or in
his family is of national significance and the nation has the
right to be
informed about it.
Mutambara must be congratulated for displaying
a mature approach to national
issues.
May the soul of Sekuru Chibwe rest
in eternal
peace.
Zivai
Vusimbe,
Harare.
-------------
From which planet are
they?
YOUR article from AFP, "Zim cannot
happen in
SA", (Zimbabwe Independent, June 16), sounded rather comical
.
From which planet or solar system are
these
people? Are they for real, or on the latest illegal substance call
"Tik".
Lourie Bosman and his fellow
Afrikaners must
remove the blinkers from their eyes. What happened on
Zimbabwe's farms will
be described by future historians as an English tea
party.
Bosman must be an ostrich farmer
and, like his
birds, has his head deeply buried in the
sand.
He must only look at the South
African navy to
realise that the only white thing left is the sailors'
uniform.
Leslie
Vollenhoven,
Gweru.
----------
Chikomba's curse
WHILE in Zanu PF circles
Chikomba constituency
is touted as the hub of the party's politics, there is
one thing that
remains a mystery to many, especially in the wake of
incumbent MP Tichaona
Jokonya's death.
l From 1980 Chikomba has had six other Zanu PF
MPs - Ernest Kadungure,
Tedius Kudzedzereka, Solomon Mujuru, Chenjerai
Hunzvi and Bernard
Makokove;
l Out of the six, only
Kudzedzereka was
resident in Chikomba while the rest were "visiting MPs"
only seen at
election times;
l Three of
them - Kadungure, Hunzvi and
Jokonya died in office;
and
l Mujuru and Makokove were rejected by
the
people.
Today, the district still
resembles the tribal
trust lands established by Ian Smith; backward,
neglected and
underdeveloped.
Frank
Matandirotya,
Chikomba.
----------
God won't intervene at the behest of
Zanu PF
I AM a firm believer in the
power of prayer,
but when this is convened at the behest of Zanu PF and its
renegades within
the Christian church, I don't believe God will intervene to
pacify their
evil agenda.
I am also
certain that such endeavours now or
in the future will have no positive
consequence for our long-suffering
people.
Based on recent press reports,
it seems
Zimbabweans forced to attend this fiasco have no clue on the sort
of favours
Zanu PF is seeking from God.
In their plethora of lies and deception, Zanu
PF is resorting to the
religious card to dupe our people.
It is
sad that certain elements in the
Christian church are complicitly upholding
the current status quo created by
Zanu PF's bad human rights
record.
Perhaps Zanu PF is attempting to
emulate our
previous colonial masters. When they descended on us a century
ago, they
brought with them their bibles, told our people to turn their
cheek and in
the process forcefully took our land and raped us of our
culture.
Isn't this history repeating
itself 100 years
later, but this time being waged by our so-called
liberators - Zanu PF.
God bless our people
who deserve better
leaders than those found in Zanu
PF.
Nazir
Lunat,
California,
USA.
----------
Andy Pycroft lost
it
I WOULD like to express my concern
over the
story "Zim A coach not worried about results", (Zimbabwe
Independent, June
23).
The remarks,
attributed to Andy Pycroft, coach
of the "second" string Zimbabwe cricket
side, are not only alarming but also
shocking, considering his background in
the sport.
I'm of the view that they were
meant to
embarass and humiliate the Bangladesh Cricket Board that has been
pestering
Zimbabwe for matches yet the country is at its weakest
ever.
Such an attitude only confirms that
Zimbabwe's
continued participation in international cricket, especially at
Test level,
is a farce as it is pointless to take on an opposition that
doesn't mind
losing the contest.
Unless
Zimbabwe cricket rids itself of the
current administrators led by Peter
Chingoka, who are ironically virtually
clueless about the sport, but were
only lured to it by its deep pockets, it
is most certainly headed for
oblivion!
Kakembo
Philip,
Kampala, Uganda.
Please send any job opportunities for publication in this newsletter to:
JAG
Job Opportunities; jag@mango.zw or justiceforagriculture@zol.co.zw
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ad
inserted 1 June 2006
Data capturer/Administrator
If you are
seeking a job in the above field, please contact Sarah at OXFORD
I.T. on
309274/309371-2 or alternatively email Sarah on
sarah@oxfordit.co.zw.
The above
position is working for Oxford I.T. and involves about 75% data
basing, 15%
filing, 10% assistant duties to Sarah.
The position is available
immediately and interviews are being conducted
with Sarah at the Oxford I.T.
offices.
Ideal candidates would be school leavers due to the nature of
the position,
but other candidates will be considered.
Don't hesITiate
- IniTiate!
Call Oxford I.T.
today.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ad
inserted 8 June 2006
Concession Manager. Mozambique - based
TCT
successfully recruited a manager from Zimbabwe in February 2006 and are
now
looking for an additional manager to join the team.
Forestry and sawmill
operation in northern Sofala Province seeks bush
manager as part of a team
managing 2 forest concessions, 2 sawmills and a
factory.
Should be
self-motivated, industrious, able to work alone and live in remote
areas.
Owing to nature of work the candidate should have good technical
sense. Suit
an ex-Farmer experienced in running low-skilled teams,
overseeing maintenance
of machinery and equipment and "doing whatever is
necessary to get the job
done"!
The candidate should be prepared to reside in Mozambique full
time, with the
majority of time spent in bush. Fully legal residence and work
permits will
be provided.
Package in US$ with vehicle &
accommodation in bush.
Portuguese not essential at the start but the
successful candidate would
have to learn to communicate in the
language.
Basic computer literacy an advantage.
CV's will be
accepted until the 26th of June 2006, short listed candidates
will be advised
by the 5 July and a candidate will be selected by the 20th
of July, candidate
expected to start as soon as possible, preferably August
2006.
Package
to be negotiated
Please send your CV to email tctdalmann@tdm.co.mz or fax +258 23 30 21
61.
Included in your CV or on the covering letter please advise what package
you
will be expecting.
Those candidates who submitted their CV's for
the first position that has
been filled and would like to apply for the
second position, please resubmit
your CV's.
For additional company
information see www.dalmann.com
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ad
inserted 8 June 2006
Tobacco Farm Manager Required
Irrigated and
Dry land Crop. Good Package for Experienced Person.
Contact northerntobacco@zol.co.zw
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------
Ad
inserted 15 June 2006
Secretary Wanted
.
A keen and enthusiastic
person wanted to fill a secretarial position at
Garden Genius Pvt ltd. Hours
would be 8 - 5 from Monday to Friday.
Please phone 746538 if you are
interested.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ad
inserted 15 June 2006
Manager Wanted - Namibia
Zimbabwean farmers,
who may be interested in exploring the possibility of
moving to other African
countries to start projects or equity in business.
Farm of 4433 hectares
situated 7 km from the mining town of Tsumeb, Namibia.
The farm has 7
boreholes but only two of them are currently used. It has a
transformer with
continuous electricity power supplied by NAMPOWER. In the
past, 30 hectares
have already been cleared for crop production and
currently we have 21
cattle, which we would like to increase to make it
economically viable. Also,
wild animals such as kudu, eland, wild boar and
many small buck animals roam
freely through the farm. The farm also has
ample supply of trees for
firewood.
We require somebody to manage, develop and run the farm
profitably because
at the moment we have our jobs in the city, Windhoek,
which is 440 km from
the farm. We will be interested in entertaining business
proposals for
profit sharing ventures or applications from individuals who
will be
interested in developing, managing and running the farm as a
business
enterprise.
For further information they might like to
contact us at our email address,
erniebar@mweb.com.na or contact Estefania
at +26461223088 (After 18h00
Namibian time) or Stephen at mobile phone
+264812988991.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ad
inserted 15 June 2006
General Manager Wanted
General Manager
required for locally based international seed company.
Applicants should have
a good background in administration with particular
emphasis on the ability
to operate in an economy affected by hyperinflation.
Experience in
horticulture is essential.
Position would suit a mature ex-farmer who is
computer literate.
Motor vehicle and other benefits included in
package.
Please apply to indchem@indchem.co.zw
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ad
inserted 15 June 2006
TRANSPORT MANAGER / FUEL MANAGER
We need a
Transport Manager as soon as possible that can handle the basic
transport
management side as well as fuel procurement.
Competitive salary offered
to the right person.
Please apply to 609841@ecoweb.co.zw with CV and
references.
Phone no. (067) 28603/4 (067) 29299
011609841
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ad
inserted 15 June 2006
OPERATIONS MAN / CONTROLER REQUIRED
1) Small
scale tobacco project in D.R.C.
2) Tough conditions (but safe!)
3) Project
in developing stages.
4) This post is for a "Jack of all trades" person with
sound knowledge of
tobacco and admin skills.
5) Applicants to reply to
advertiser, at Box 4601, Harare. Please advise
contact phone number.
6)
Salary to be
negotiated.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ad
inserted 22 June 2006
Wanted
SUPERVISOR- NORTHFIELD FLATS FITH ST
/JOSHIAH TONGARA
CONTACT HENK BOTHA
091-324-976
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ad
inserted 22 June 2006
Manager Wanted
Position Offered: Manager
required to oversee factory in Harare and to
travel to Chalala, Kariba for
one week per month for stock takes etc. In
Harare the job will entail the
overseeing of factory, machinery and vehicles
maintenance and managing
labour, stocks and security. Position available
immediately. Interested
applicants please email headoffice@matmark.co.zw
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------
Ad
inserted 29 June 2006
VACANCY:
C.E.O required to Head the Kapenta
Industry in Kariba. Good package
depending on applicants qualifications. To
start, 1st August 2006. Applicant
required to be good & meticulous
administrator & very active (35 years &
above). Please apply to email
address: conquest@mweb.co.zw
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ad
inserted 29 June 2006
SITUATION VACANT
BUSY ESTATE AGENT IN
AVONDALE NEEDS A GIRL FRIDAY/ADMINISTRATOR AS SOON
AS POSSIBLE - COMPUTER
SKILLS NOT NECESSARY. IDEAL FOR MATURE LADY WITH
ENTHUSIASM, INTELLIGENCE
AND A SENSE OF HUMOUR. PLEASANT WORKING
ENVIRONMENT
AND VARIED
DUTIES.
PLEASE TELEPHONE 091 305 313, OR EMAIL dundawidaho@mango.co.zw
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Employment
Sought
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ad
inserted 1 June 2006
Employment Sought
Situations wanted
Tourism/Hospitality for a management couple or assistant
Management couple
with experience for a Lodge, bush camp or fishing camp in
Zambia, Botswana,
South Africa or Kenya.
Situations wanted Motor industry. Workshop
Manager, warranty officer/Parts
manager. With extensive experience in the
motor trade totalling 30 years on
Mazda, Nissan and Peugeot vehicles. We
would prefer expatriate conditions of
employment if possible. Prepared to
relocate to Zambia, Botswana or Southern
Africa.
Please contact N A
Spreeth on 091369872, 091951340 or email
zimginger@yahoo.co.uk
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ad
inserted 22 June 2006
Position Required in Safari/Outdoor
Organization;
Single male with previous experience in Zimbabwe and
Mozambique seeks
position. Has experience in camp management, catering,
lodge/camp
construction, and administration. Please contact Ned via Duncan on
011 405
387, 309971 (work hours) or email at ddollar@genham.co.zw
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ad
inserted 22 June 2006
"HEAVY DUTY DRIVER
We are shortly leaving
Zimbabwe and wish to find employment for our driver
Munyaradzi Maliki. He is
a non-drinker, very reliable, hard working and
honest. Munyaradzi has driven
our T35 extensively on long distances over
extremely poor dirt roads to our
Kapenta Fishing Camp (Harare to Kariba -
via Gokwe). He is meticulous in
conducting regular full vehicle checks and
has proved to be a valued employee
and a good team player, who willingly
undertakes other duties if he is not
driving. His availability would be on
an immediate basis. Please contact
Shaw: 091 945686 or 091 270 245
(landline not
working)."
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ad
inserted 22 June 2006
Farm Manager
Looking for a farm job as a
manager, Qualified at Blackfordby Agricultural,
Institute.
Three years
farming experience in tobacco, maize and wheat.
Please contact George Heyns
home: 064 8388
Cell:091272216
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ad
inserted 22 June 2006
Ex Farmer
Ex Farmer/Consultant and
Agronomist for Alliance One Tobacco aged 50 years
living in Zimbabwe with 23
years experience in growing tobacco, maize, seed
maize, horticulture, beef
cattle, pigs, chickens. Excellent management,
administration and
communication skills, computer literate, full clean
drivers licence. Was
runner up'Tobacco Grower of the Year' in 1985. Spent
last 2 years consulting
for Imperial Tobacco Group in Madagascar on the
production of flue-cured
tobacco.
AVAILABLE IMMEDIATELY. CONTACT: 091 439 911/011 602 583 or
heather@karina.co.zw
Can send CV
if
necessary.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
For
the latest listings of accommodation available for farmers, contact
justiceforagriculture@zol.co.zw
(updated 29 June 2006)