The ZIMBABWE Situation
An extensive and up-to-date website containing news, views and links related to ZIMBABWE - a country in crisis
Please note: You need to have 'Active content' enabled in your IE browser in order to see the index of articles on this webpage
Zimbabwe police fire tear gas at protesters
By ANGUS SHAW, Associated
Press – 6 hours ago
HARARE, Zimbabwe (AP) — Police fired tear gas to
disperse supporters of the
Zimbabwe prime minister's party outside a
courthouse on Monday, witnesses
said.
About 200 demonstrators
gathered outside the High Court in downtown Harare
to protest charges being
brought against 29 activists of the former
opposition appearing there for a
bail hearing. The activists are seeking
bail on charges of murdering a
police officer a year ago.
Protesters also scuffled with police,
witnesses said. There were no
immediate reports of injuries or
arrests.
The detained suspects are accused of killing a policeman outside
a bar in
western Harare in May 2011. Repeated demands for bail have been
refused.
The activists have denied the murder charges and Prime Minister
Morgan
Tsvangirai's party insists police inspector Petros Mutedza, 45, died
in a
turf war between street vendors in Harare's Glen View
township.
In March, seven policemen were granted $50 bail each just one
month after
their arrest over the murder of a mine worker north of
Harare.
The former opposition Movement for Democratic Change accused the
court that
freed the policeman of bias.
Several people were injured
when the police raided a settlement at a mine
near Shamva, 80 kilometers (50
miles) from Harare, during an investigation
into the alleged theft of $1 and
a cell phone from the wife of one officer.
Theresa Makone, Tsvangirai's
co-police minister, has vowed to "weed out
murderous elements" in the
force.
Tsvangirai's party routinely accuses police commanders of acting
as
loyalists of President Robert Mugabe party in a troubled coalition
government formed in 2009.
Also on Monday, a group monitoring
violence and disputes affecting the
coalition described the May 27 killing
of a senior Tsvangirai party official
at Mudzi in eastern Zimbabwe as a
"dark deed" of political violence.
Witnesses to that incident said the
official who had been addressing a rally
of his supporters was stoned to
death by a mob of Mugabe loyalists holding a
rival party meeting
nearby.
The Joint Monitoring and Implementation Committee called on
political
parties to expel violent members and brand them as
criminals.
"Zimbabwe cannot afford to have its image continually soiled
through the
acts of misguided elements who believe they have the right to
kill in order
for their views to prevail," the group
said.
Independent human rights groups have reported a surge in political
violence
and intimidation amid calls for elections within the next few
months.
Police
teargas protestors calling for release of MDC-T activists
http://www.swradioafrica.com
By Lance
Guma
04 June 2012
All hell broke loose at the High Court in Harare on
Monday when police fired
teargas at MDC-T youths who had gathered to protest
the continued detention
of 29 activists, some of whom have been locked up
for over a year without
trial.
MDC-T Youth Assembly Chairman Solomon
Madzore and 28 fellow activists are
facing what his party believe are
‘trumped up’ charges of killing a
policeman. The group has had countless
applications for bail turned down and
Monday marked the first time the case
went to trial since the arrests in May
last year.
The Secretary
General of the MDC-T Youth Assembly Promise Mkwananzi told SW
Radio Africa
that the youths gathered at the court “to show solidarity with
the accused
and show frustration with the inefficiency of the justice
delivery system in
this country.
“Once our youths gathered, the police descended upon them,”
he said.
Asked what prompted the scuffles, Mkwananzi said: “It was
because the police
are intolerant and do not conduct themselves in a
professional manner. They
just came from the police station armed and just
descended on defenceless
youths.” He said there were a ‘couple’ of injuries
and some people were
‘ferried to hospital’.
The case has drawn
comparisons to a recent one in Shamva, where seven
policemen accused of
murdering a mine worker were granted $50 bail after one
month detention. The
MDC-T has also accused the police of arresting victims
of ZANU PF violence
who report the incidents to the police.
Senior officials in the army and
the police have publicly declared their
loyalty to ZANU PF and Robert Mugabe
and the Glen View case to many
highlights what commentators have referred to
as ‘persecution by prosecution’.
In addition to demobilising MDC-T
structures the party also has to use money
to fight the case.
US allows Zimbabwe officials in for diamond
meet
Jun 3, 5:52 PM EDT
By MATTHEW LEE
Associated Press
WASHINGTON (AP) -- The
Obama administration has granted visas to two senior
officials from Zimbabwe
to attend a meeting of an international body charged
with monitoring and
preventing the sale of blood diamonds, despite human
rights concerns and
financial sanctions against the pair.
The State Department said Sunday
that Zimbabwe's Attorney General Johannes
Tomana and Minister of Mines Obert
Mpofu would be part of the country's
delegation to the U.S.-hosted meeting
of the Kimberley Process that begins
on Monday.
The department would
not confirm that the two men had been given visas,
citing privacy concerns,
but officials acknowledged that they would not be
able to participate if
they did not have proper travel documents.
Both men are subject to U.S.
financial sanctions under an executive order
because of their positions in
Zimbabwe President Robert Mugabe's government,
which is accused of numerous
human rights abuses. They are not covered by a
travel ban.
.In
addition, the department noted that as the current chair of the
Kimberley
Process, the United States is "obligated to facilitate the entry"
of
participants.
Hillary Renner Fuller, a spokeswoman for the State
Department's Bureau of
African Affairs, said the participation of the
officials "is in no way
indicative of an easing of U.S. concerns about the
human rights situation in
Zimbabwe, nor a change in our sanctions
policy."
However, other officials said the decision to allow Tomana and
Mpofu to
attend was the subject of debate within the administration with
some arguing
against because of the human rights concerns. Those officials
spoke on
condition of anonymity to discuss internal
deliberations.
The U.S took the helm of the Kimberley Process earlier
this year amid
controversy after a major human rights watchdog quit,
accusing the body of
refusing to address links between gems, violence and
tyranny, notably in
Zimbabwe.
Rights group Global Witness left the
body in December, alleging it had
failed in Ivory Coast, Venezuela and
Zimbabwe, after the Kimberley Process a
month earlier agreed to let Zimbabwe
trade some $2 billion in diamonds from
fields where critics say miners have
been tortured. Zimbabwe denies
allegations of human rights abuses in the
fields.
The departure of Global Witness raised questions about the
credibility of
the process. At the time, the Obama administration said it
understood and
appreciated the group's concerns but that the U.S. would stay
in the body to
address the challenges and press it to reform to restore its
credibility.
Human Rights Watch has accused Zimbabwean troops of killing
more than 200
people, raping women and forcing children to search for the
gems in Marange
fields.
In February, Global Witness cited fears that
Mugabe loyalists were using
diamond revenue as an "off-budget cash cow"
instead of rebuilding the
shattered economy. It also said unspecified
amounts of Zimbabwe's diamond
earnings were being stashed away in tax-free
havens and could be used to
finance violence and intimidation in upcoming
elections.
Mugabe's party has denied hoarding any diamond
revenue.
The Kimberley Process, founded in 2003, groups the diamond
industry, rights
groups and 75 countries to certify rough diamonds as
"conflict-free" to
assure purchasers they are not funding violence. It was
born after wars in
Sierra Leone and Liberia that were fueled by "blood
diamonds."
KP
urged to pressure Zim over ongoing diamond abuses
http://www.swradioafrica.com/
By Alex
Bell
04 June 2012
The international diamond trade watchdog, the
Kimberley Process (KP) is this
week being urged to put pressure on Zimbabwe
to address ongoing human rights
abuses at the Chiadzwa diamond
fields.
The call from a leading human rights organisation comes as the
KP’s annual
meeting got underway in the US, which now holds the group’s
rotating
chairmanship position. That meeting is set to discuss mining and
trading of
conflict diamonds across the globe, and it is hoped KP members
will push for
critical reform of the monitoring body.
The KP has
faced serious criticism in recent years for appearing to let
Zimbabwe off
the hook over human rights abuses at Chiadzwa, where forced
labour,
assaults, murder and smuggling led to the country being suspended
from trade
in 2009. The KP was, back then, urged to ban Zimbabwe completely
over these
concerns.
Zimbabwe was instead allowed time to try and fall in line with
international
trade standards, in what was slammed as too ‘lenient’ a move
to force any
real change at Chiadzwa. The KP then faced more condemnation
after last year
giving the ZANU PF run Mines Ministry the green light to
resume diamond
sales, with no sign of significant changes at the alluvial
fields.
According to Human Rights Watch, which has conducted ongoing
research into
the situation there, abuses still persist, perpetrated mainly
by the ZANU PF
loyal security services. The group found evidence late last
year of serious
abuses by police and private security guards patrolling the
area, including
setting dogs on local miners and using excessive force to
clear the diamond
fields of ‘illegal’ miners. Human Rights Watch said that,
to date, no steps
have been taken to address these problems.
“Human
Rights Watch also remains concerned by the continued presence of the
Zimbabwean army, which was responsible for the killing of 200 local miners
in 2008, in
parts of the (Chiadzwa) fields. One of the agreements
between the Kimberley
Process and the government of Zimbabwe was that the
fields would be
demilitarised,” the group said in a statement
Monday.
It said that there are “significant concerns about the conduct of
police and
private security forces employed by companies operating in the
area, and the
failure of the authorit
ies to hold to account members of
the military, police and private security
companies responsible for serious
abuses.”
“In addition, more transparency is needed on diamond production,
revenue and
the allocation of mining rights,” Human Rights Watch
said.
It added that these abuses “have exposed the KP’s inability
effectively to
address human rights violations by government security forces
related to
diamond mining.”
“The Kimberly Process needs to address
the ongoing human rights abuses in
Zimbabwe’s (Chiadzwza) fields, and the
lack of transparency by mining
companies operating there,” said Daniel
Bekele, Africa director at Human
Rights Watch. “The KP meeting should demand
more tangible progress from
Zimbabwe and focus on reforming its
certification scheme so that it can
tackle the human rights problems that
taint diamond production.”
The group called on the Mines Ministry, other
relevant Zimbabwe authorities,
and the mining industry in Marange to take
immediate measures “to stop these
abuses and ensure accountability for
abuses by the police and private
security guards.”
“Zimbabwe’s
government has failed to meet its obligations to stop abuses in
Marange and
ensure that crimes committed there are prosecuted,” Bekele said.
“The mining
companies also need to be part of the solution, not part of the
problem.”
Human Rights Watch also called on KP members to commit to
essential reforms
to the Kimberley Process so that it “explicitly
incorporates human rights to
prevent ‘blood diamonds’ and other stones
tainted by human rights abuse from
reaching consumers.” The group said that
the current ‘narrow definition’ of
a conflict diamond has left a “major
loophole” since it does not prevent a
government like Zimbabwe’s from
committing abuses when it mines or sells
diamonds.
“This loophole
needs to be closed to protect the viability of the Kimberley
Process,” Human
Rights Watch said.
The call for the KP to redefine the ‘blood diamonds’
term has also been
voiced by other civil society groups, observers and
analysts. Zimbabwe
analyst Clifford Mashiri told SW Radio Africa on Monday
that the KP’s
credibility is at stake.
“We need to give the KP the
opportunity and chance to redeem itself, and
reforming in this way is an
important step,” Mashiri said.
SADC
commends coalition despite lack of progress and continued violence
http://www.swradioafrica.com/
By
Tererai Karimakwenda
04 May 2011
Despite the lack of progress in fully
implementing the Global Political
Agreement (GPA) facilitated by SADC, and
the recent increase in political
violence by ZANU PF, the regional leaders
meeting in Angola have commended
Zimbabwe’s coalition leaders for “their
commitment, cooperation and efforts”.
In a communiqué issued on Friday,
the regional leaders at the Extraordinary
Summit of SADC Heads of State in
Luanda, urged the three main parties to
finalise the constitution-making
process and hold a referendum before
conducting free and fair
elections.
The chief facilitator on Zimbabwe, President Jacob Zuma of
South Africa, was
also praised by the regional leaders for “his efforts
towards the
realisation of full implementation of GPA”.
The GPA was
signed nearly four years ago and contentious issues still
remain, with ZANU
PF continuing a campaign of arrests and violence against
the MDC formations.
In addition, a SADC team that was supposed to be sent to
Zimbabwe to assist
JOMIC make progress on the GPA has still not been
appointed.
Okay
Machisa from the Crisis Coalition said those two paragraphs in the
communiqué said a lot about the regional leaders’ commitment to a free and
fair election in Zimbabwe, because they insisted on reforms ahead of
elections. This is the same position they expressed at other summits in
Livingstone, Sandton and Windhoek.
“They are sending a clear message
to Robert Mugabe, to Tsvangirai and to
Ncube that they want free and fair
elections in Zimbabwe and for them to be
held under the standards that the
African Union and SADC expect,” Machisa
explained.
Machisa told SW
Radio Africa that the lack of a time frame for
implementation of the reforms
is the key factor that has been missing in
Zimbabwe so far.
“Civil
society has been saying there is need for a time frame that should
adhered
to. Otherwise we are getting nowhere,” Machisa said.
SADC’s call for full
implementation of the GPA effectively makes Robert
Mugabe’s wish for
elections this year, with or without key reforms, a
non-starter. Mugabe and
senior officials within his party had been pushing
for early elections,
amidst reports of Mugabe’s failing health and serious
infighting within the
party.
Tsvangirai
says SADC shocked by Mudzi death
http://www.swradioafrica.com/
By Tererai Karimakwenda
04 June
2012
The death of an official from the MDC-T last week at the
hands of known ZANU
PF thugs has shocked regional leaders gathered in
Angola, according to Prime
Minister Morgan Tsvangirai.
The MDC-T
leader addressed thousands of supporters who attended the burial
of Sekuru
Cephas Magura, who died after being assaulted by a ZANU PF mob
that
disrupted a rally at Chimukoko Business Centre in Mudzi North,
Mashonaland
East. Magura was the MDC-T Ward 1 chairperson for Mudzi North.
“The issue
of Magura’s death came up for discussion (at last week’s SADC
summit) and
most SADC leaders were shocked that this was still happening in
Zimbabwe at
a time when some political leaders are screaming for elections,”
Tsvangirai
told mourners at Botso Village.
He said the issue of continuing violence
was discussed by the Troika on
Politics, Defense and Security that met in
Luanda last week, who also
compelled the leaders of Zimbabwe’s coalition
government to urgently
implement all the outstanding issues in the GPA
before holding free and fair
elections.
The MDC-T leader announced
that he would initiate the formation of a fund
that would look after the
relatives of party members who have died, in what
he called “the struggle
for a new Zimbabwe”.
“The fund will enable Magura’s children to continue
going to school. If I
ignore them, I will be irresponsible ,” he
added.
The United States embassy last week condemned the ZANU PF thugs
who
assaulted MDC-T activists with logs, sticks and stones at the Chimukoko
Business Centre. In a statement last Thursday, the United States also
condemned the police, who reportedly ignored pleas to call for
re-enforcements.
Tabitha Khumalo, the MDC-T Deputy National
Spokesperson and MP for Bulawayo
East, also joined many Zimbabweans in
expressing anger at Magura’s death.
Khumalo challenged Robert Mugabe to
order the arrest of all the perpetrators
who joined in the attack, including
those who provided transport to the ZANU
PF gang.
Six ZANU PF
activists have been arrested so far by the police, but there is
concern that
the arrests were just a strategic move to save face, ahead of
the SADC
summit in Angola. The move appears to have back-fired.
Seven Year
Old Boy Narrated Horror Of MDC Activist Murder: Denga
http://www.radiovop.com
Harare, June
04, 2012 - A seven year old boy braved to narrate the death of
Movement of
Democratic Change (MDC) activist Cephas Magura in Mudzi after
older people
could not provide details of how the activist was murdered
fearing for their
lives, the Joint Monitioring and Implementaion Committee
(Jomic)
heard.
Jomic had visited Mudzi to investigate the murder of
Nyagura.
Piniel Denga, an MDC MP and member of the Jomic proivincial
committee in
Mashonaland East, said:"They (people) could not be open to tell
us what
really happened because of the fear of the unknown. We went to the
place
where the body was dumped because we were told that he was hit by
stones and
he fell down and more people came with more stones hitting him in
the head,
so he passed on closer to someone's homestead and they lifted the
body and
dumped him on the road."
"It was being narrated by a young
boy who is 7 years that we saw him
(Nyagura) being ferried and they put him
in the road and the police officers
came with some branches to safeguard the
body from other passersby’s."
"We went there as Jomic with my other
colleagues the other two
co-chairpersons and people at the venue couldn't
...narrate the stories
maybe because of fear of the unknown. You can go into
the shop and ask them
did you see what happened and they would say no, I
wasn’t here or I had
closed my shop I was inside," he added.
Denga
said Nyagura was murdered "just like what happens in these other
Muslim
countries where if someone has committed a serious crime against
their
religion could be stoned to death, so that's how it happened".
He said
the situation in Mudzi was tense and that police had given the green
light
for the MDC to hold its rally as well as Zanu (PF) to carry on with
their
small meeting in a hall at Chimukoko shopping centre, the place where
violence broke out.
"The Zanu (PF) youths started throwing stones,
taking away the flags from
the MDC, burning posters and fliers that the
structures had come to
distribute. People were beaten, that’s when Mr
Nyagura's life was claimed.
As it was said by the post mortem he was stoned
to death," he said.
But a Zanu (PF) Jomic official, gave a different
version of what transpired,
saying their findings had shown that Nyagura had
fell from a moving truck
after he tried to flee from violence at the
shopping centre.
"I have a report which doesn't quite go along with what
the MDC-T people are
saying. We wouldn't want to go much into that because
it is still under
investigation but according to the information given to us
we are told that
Cephas Magura actually fell from the truck when he was
trying to get on to a
truck which was fleeing and the truck was full and
that's when he fell to
the ground. This is story that we have," a Zanu (PF)
official said.
"From what he (Denga) had said you can actually see that
there is world of
difference, miles apart. So what is important now is to
let investigations
be carried out and the truth be
established."
Jomic co-chair, Thabitha Khumalo, said her organisation
condemned the murder
of Nyagura and said perpetrators should be brought to
book.
"Jomic would like to convey its deepest condolences to the Magura
family
following the death of Mr Cephas Magura, an MDC-T party official, in
a case
of suspected political violence in Mudzi, Mashonaland East last week.
May
his soul rest in peace," Khumalo said.
"The killing was a most
deplorable act, especially as the nation prepares
for next elections. As
Jomic we have made it clear that political violence
is a serious crime and
those involved should be punished accordingly."
"The blood of any
Zimbabwean that is spilt in this country is not worth the
elections that
will take place. Everybody in terms of the Global Political
Agreement has
the right to affiliate to a political party of their choice
and death should
not be the way of deterring any Zimbabwean to participate
in the political
arena,” she said.
Nyagura was buried in Mudzi on Sunday.
Prime
Minister Morgan Tsvangirai's MDC party has said over 300 of their
supporters
and officials were murdered in the last violent presidential
run-off
elections in June 2008.
PM
blasts police as activist buried
http://www.newzimbabwe.com
03/06/2012 00:00:00
by Staff
Reporter
PRIME Minister and MDC-T leader, Morgan Tsvangirai, has
accused police of
standing by and failing to take action as a party activist
was stoned to
death after political violence broke out in Mudzi district
last week.
Speaking at the burial Sunday of Cephas Magura, 60, Tsvangirai
said police
should have acted to prevent the clashes when it became clear
that trouble
was imminent.
"There are some people who masquerade as
army and police officers. Real
people want to develop this country. You see
someone being stoned while you
are in uniform and you run away. Remove that
uniform and we will deal with
you. That is the legitimate way,” Tsvangirai
charged.
“Magura is a hero who died a heinous death at the hands of Zanu
PF thugs. We
demand that all those fingered in his death must face the full
wrath of the
law. It is very painful for us as a party to accept that we
have lost many
such party carders since the formation of the MDC in
1999."
The clashes took place at a Mudzi business centre where MDC-T and
Zanu PF
supporters held rival gatherings.
Magura died as a result of
severe head injuries and seven Zanu-PF supporters
have since appeared in
court in connection with his murder.
The MDC-T claims the clashes took
place in full view of police officers.
“It is not good for people to kill
each other no matter their political
differences. As political leaders, we
are preaching the gospel of peace and
unity in Zimbabwe for political
violence is a national curse,” Tsvangirai
said.
“As leaders, we have
the powers to bring peace to our land and to confine
violence to the
dustbins — we should teach our supporters to shun violence,
to pursue peace
and to engage in civilised political campaigns.
“The issue of political
violence was topical at the recent Sadc Troika
meeting and we should clear
violence before elections because Sadc said it
is part of the road map
before the next elections.
“The MDC-T will work hard to make sure free and
fair elections are held in
Zimbabwe.”
MDC-T’s Women’s Assembly
chairwoman, Theresa Makone, accused Zanu PF MPs
Milton Kachepa (Mudzi North)
and Acquilina Katsande (Mudzi West) of fanning
the violence.
She said the
pair should have been arrested as accomplices.
The MDC-T says Magura was
stoned to death by suspected Zanu PF supporters
who disrupted a
police-sanctioned rally at Chimukoko business centre.
But police
spokesman Senior Assistant Commissioner Wayne Bvudzijena denied
officers had
been negligent.
“If indeed the police were negligent, that will come up
in our
investigations. We sent our team and arrests have been made and we
will
continue investigating the matter,” he said.
The MDC Today
- Issue 368
http://www.mdc.co.zw
Monday, 04 June 2012
Costa Machingauta, the MDC
Deputy National Youth Assembly chairperson was
this morning arrested at the
High Court and is currently detained at Harare
Central police
station.
He was arrested after he was denied access into Court A at the
High Court
where the trial of 29 MDC members who are facing fabricated
charges of
murdering started today.
It could not be established what
charges are being preffered on him.
Earlier in the morning, riot police
fired teargas outside the High Court in
a bid to bar hundreds of MDC
supporters and relatives of the accused who
wanted to enter the
court.
The trial continues at the High Court tomorrow
morning.
The people’s struggle for real change – Let’s
finish!!!
Watchdog
onto Zim 'rendition'
http://www.timeslive.co.za
GRAEME HOSKEN | 04 June, 2012 00:01
An
investigation into the alleged rendition, torture and murder of Zimbabwe
dissidents has been launched by South Africa's police watchdog.
The
Independent Police Investigative Directorate is investigating the
CIA-style
operations at the same time as the Civilian Police Secretariat,
which is
also probing the matter, said it had received more information
about the
allegations.
The secretariat is to wrap up its probe soon.
At
least six Zimbabwe nationals were allegedly smuggled out of the country
in
October by members of the Gauteng Hawks assisted by their Zimbabwean
counterparts.
Eight members of the Hawks tactical operational
management services in
Pretoria and Johannesburg are believed to be behind
the renditions [sending
suspected criminals from one country to another to
be interrogated or
detained].
The renditions are alleged to have been
carried out under the pretext that
the Zimbabwean authorities were looking
for criminals involved in armed
robberies and the shooting of police
officers.
Gift Nhadzi, a former Movement for Democratic Change organiser,
is one of
the alleged victims.
Not only dissidents but also their
families have allegedly been taken back
to Zimbabwe and
tortured.
Nhadzi's wife was allegedly tortured by Zimbabwe police seeking
information
about her husband.
Also sent back to Zimbabwe against his
will was Witness Ndeya, who was
alleged to have killed police officers in
Zimbabwe. He was returned to
Zimbabwe along with two others and
killed.
Sources have told The Times that the directorate's investigation
is being
pursued amid concerns about the secretariat's investigation.
Although the
Police Ministry ordered the secretariat to investigate, the
secretariat, as
a civilian oversight body, has no investigative
capacity.
It can only make recommendations to the ministry.
The
secretariat is responsible for monitoring police performance, assessing
police policies, recommending corrective measures and monitoring the
police's ability to deal with complaints against its officers.
The
police watchdog's investigation comes as National Prosecuting Authority
spokesman Mthunzi Mhaga said on Friday they would be challenging a recent
order by Pretoria High Court judge Hans Fabricius.
The order requires
Zimbabwean officials accused of torture in their country
to be arrested and
prosecuted if they come to South Africa.
Directorate spokesman Moses
Dlamini confirmed it was investigating the
allegations.
He said the
investigation would be separate from the secretariat's one.
Despite the
new investigation, sources say the renditions are continuing.
Secretariat
head Jenny Irish-Qhobosheane said because they had received
additional
information their investigation had not been completed.
She declined to
elaborate on the additional information.
Political
violence rocks Epworth
http://www.dailynews.co.zw
Written by Bridget Mananavire and Lloyd
Mbiba
Monday, 04 June 2012 12:22
HARARE - Ugly scenes of political
violence in the poor peri-urban settlement
of Epworth reflect how Zimbabwe
is precariously on the edge, as President
Robert Mugabe pushes hard for
elections this year.
Reports of violence flaring in some parts of the
country have increased in
recent weeks. But mass displacements in Epworth,
which is on the outskirts
of Harare, are a clear sign of how deep levels of
political intolerance are
affecting communities.
Zanu PF youths this
week wreaked havoc in the volatile settlement, forcibly
displacing residents
suspected of being MDC supporters.
Menacing youths were taking over
residential stands and properties belonging
to the suspected MDC supporters
when the Daily News crew visited the area
last week.
Women and
children could be seen sitting out in the cold as the youths took
over their
shelter and farm land.
More than 100 residents affected by the evictions
had grouped at an open
ground fearing for their lives.
A tense atmosphere
pervaded the area as a number of menacing youths milled
around.
According to residents who spoke to the Daily News, the
“rowdy” youths
intensified the evictions before the intervention of Epworth
police after a
local joint MDC- Zanu PF peace committee reported the
matter.
One of the victims, who alleged that her husband was killed by
Zanu PF
activists in 2001, said residents abandoned their homes last week in
fear of
being killed by the youths.
“We are not in our homes because
we are afraid. They are coming into our
homes and taking our land,” said
Hlengiwe Ngubane.
The land in question belongs to the Methodist Church,
according to
residents, who said the Zanu PF youths were claiming that
“Methodists did
not come with land from Britain”.
“We have been
paying rates to the church. The church said we could
temporarily stay while
they negotiate with the local board for us to be
given proper stands. But
Zanu PF people are taking our stands and selling
them to outsiders. They are
criminals,” said a resident.
“These guys are from Zanu PF and we know
them. Everyone in this area knows
that they are Zanu PF members,” the
resident said, speaking on condition of
anonymity for fear of
reprisals.
Police spokesperson James Sabau said he was not aware of the
incident.
Zanu PF spokesperson Rugare Gumbo refused to comment on the
issue.
Harare has been a political hotbed with the resurgence of
politically-motivated violence and intimidation in recent months
orchestrated by shadowy Zanu PF group Chipangano.
Violence has been
recorded in Budiriro, Chitungwiza and Mbare amongst other
suburbs, while
rural areas such as Mudzi have also been affected.
An MDC official Cephas
Magura died after clashes between Zanu PF and MDC
supporters in Mudzi last
week. Magura was buried yesterday.
Six Zanu PF supporters have so far
been arrested in connection with the
murder.
The violence comes hard
on heels of a visit by United Nations High
Commissioner for Human Rights
Navi Pillay at the end of last month.
At the end of her week-long
fact-finding mission to Harare, Pillay called on
leaders to take steps to
prevent a repeat of 2008 political violence in the
next
elections.
Regional Sadc leaders also discussed the situation in Zimbabwe
at a meeting
in Angola last week and called on political parties to ensure a
peaceful
environment for elections.
CIO
man arrested over ivory possession
http://www.newzimbabwe.com
03/06/2012 00:00:00
by Staff
Reporter
A CENTRAL Intelligence Organisation operative was last week
arrested in
Harare’s Eastlea suburb for illegal possession of two elephant
tasks.
Detectives said the CIO man had been arrested together with three
accomplices adding the suspects are all in custody as investigations
continue.
“On May 24, detectives who were on Women Network Operation
received
information that some people were looking for a buyer for their two
elephant
tusks,” said police Border Control and Minerals Unit spokesperson,
Detective
Inspector Shelter Rufu.
Rufu said, acting on the tip off,
detectives disguised as potential buyers
went to the house along Daventry
Road.
“Once the tusks were produced, the detectives identified themselves and
arrested the illegal ivory dealers,” she said.
The Zimbabwe National
Parks and Wildlife Management Authority recently
recovered 50 elephant tusks
worth more than US$1 million after shooting dead
a poacher and injuring
another in Binga and Victoria Falls.
The gazetted replacement value for each
slain elephant is US$50 000 while
ivory sells for US$250 per kg.
Kasukuwere
targets Barclays
http://www.newzimbabwe.com
04/06/2012 00:00:00
by Business
Reporter
EMPOWERMENT Minister Saviour Kasukuwere has summoned
Barclays Bank officials
to explain the ownership structure of the bank as
the government empowerment
drive targets the financial services
sector.
Kasukuwere said he would meet Barclays’ managing director George
Guvamatanga
Monday to discuss the bank’s compliance with Zimbabwe’s
empowerment
legislation.
“I will be meeting Guvamatanga on Monday to
discuss the status at Barclays,”
Kasukuwere told The
Herald.
“(Guvamatanga) has often said that Barclays is already
indigenised (and) I
will be very keen to understand what he means by
that.
“There is also the issue about the other foreign-owned banks, and
as the BAZ
president, I am sure he can give us some insight into the status
of his
colleagues.”
Barclays, Standard Chartered and the South
Africa-controlled Stanbic
dominate the country’s banking sector and
Kusukuwere said he was now
focusing on ensuring they comply with the
country’s empowerment legislation.
“My ministry is now focusing on the
financial services sector and we are
going to be closely evaluating the
proposals that they have tabled in
compliance with the indigenisation
regulations,” he said.
“Our expectations are that this should be done in line
with the aspirations
of the workers and other indigenous
investors.”
Under the country’s economic empowerment programme, foreign
companies are
now required by law to transfer control of at least 51 percent
of their
Zimbabwe operations to locals.
But central bank chief,
Gideon Gono has warned against applying the
legislation to the country’s
banking sector. Gono repeated the warning at an
empowerment conference in
Harare last Friday.
"The money that is in the banks does not belong to
Gono, or (George)
Guvamatanga (Managing Director) of Barclays Bank here," he
said.
"It belongs to depositors. It would be a great act of irresponsibility
not
to respect depositors' money."
14-year-old Zim
girl to start university
http://www.iol.co.za/
June 4 2012 at 12:31pm
By
SAPA
Johannesburg - A 14-year-old Zimbabwean girl will start
university in
August, according to a report.
Maud Chifamba will
attend the University of Zimbabwe in Harare and study
accounting, The Times
reported.
“I have always wanted to be one of those professionals and this
is a chance
I will grasp with both hands and cherish,” Chifamba was quoted
as saying.
“It's not everyone who is fortunate enough to have this
opportunity.”
According to the report, in 2003 Chifamba enrolled at a
primary school which
had only three teachers.
Her teachers, who had
noticed her aptitude, moved her from Grade 3 to Grade
6.
In 2006 she
was not able to write her Grade 7 exams because her school was
not
registered.
However, Chifamba wrote her Grade 7 exams in 2007 at the age
of nine. She
passed her O levels in two years.
In 2010, Platinum
mining company Zimplats agreed to pay her fees at
Sandringham High School in
Mhondoro for her A-level studies.
Last year, Chifamba attained 12 points,
which was enough to enrol in
university.
The Revenue Authority would
pay Chifamba's fees until she graduates four
years from now. - Sapa
Govt
to restructure energy sector
http://www.dailynews.co.zw
Written by Taurai Mangudhla, Business
Writer
Monday, 04 June 2012 14:40
HARARE - Zimbabwe plans to
restructure its energy sector and make way for
independent power
distribution firms, Zesa Holdings (Zesa) chief executive
Josh Chifamba
said.
He told a Thursday Confederation of Zimbabwe Industries Annual
General
Meeting, the move was in line with government’s plans to improve
utility
services while establishing an independent power
regulator.
“There is a lot of progress on that and I wouldn’t want to
pre-empt it (but)
there is a whole white paper on that and the minister is
supposed to present
it to cabinet,” Chifamba said without giving specifics
of the proposed new
plan.
The energy sector is currently regulated by
Zimbabwe Energy Regulatory
Authority.
The Zesa chief’s remarks came
after Francis Masawi, an engineer and regional
independent energy
consultant, argued there was an imminent need to
restructure the country’s
power sector.
He said the current single buyer model-only by Zimbabwe
Electricity
Transmission and Distribution Company (ZETDC)-was an impediment
to
investment in the energy sector.
“Imagine you have a private
production company and you want to sell to a
sole buyer that is owed $500
million by their consumers, how
are they likely to pay,”
Masawi said.
“That thing (the single buyer model) must be done away with;
it doesn’t
exist in the Act. It was only transitional.”
Masawi said
Zesa should assume a role of shareholder only.
He said competition should
be introduced in the supply side of electricity
just as it is required in
the petroleum sector.
“Whatever the reason, the current structure has
failed to resuscitate the
energy sector.”
Zimbabwe currently
has capacity to generate about 1 200 MW of
electricity, mainly from
Kariba Hydro Power Station and Hwange Power Station
(HPS) compared to a
rising national demand of around 2 200MW.
The country’s generation
capacity is now half of what it used to be in 1980
when the economy and
population was smaller.
New projects that are meant to improve the
current deficit position could
take longer to commence after potential
takers for the country’s HPS
rehabilitation project asked for a one month
extension on the June 5,
tendering deadline.
Chifamba said this would
delay adjudication of tender to restore HPS unit
seven and eight to end of
July.
“If we get to a financial close by the end of the year then by
early 2016
there should be something coming out of the two projects,” he
said, adding
his organisation was aware of the anxiety among Zimbabweans for
an immediate
power solution. Zesa, Chifamba said, was not spared by the
country’s
decade-long economic stagnation and needs a lot of
investment.
“The state of the equipment at all levels is appalling and
dangerous.
That explains the number of accidents we are having
now.”
In February government announced plans to unbundle the Zimbabwe
Electricity
Transmission and Distribution Company (ZETDC) into two separate
entities to
improve operating efficiency.
ZETDC is responsible
generating, transmitting and distributing power and was
formed in 2002 after
government unbundled ZETDC into different companies
under Zesa.
The
Electricity Act ushered in the formation of five successor companies,
the
Zimbabwe Power Company (ZPC), Zimbabwe Electricity Transmission Company
(Zetco), Zimbabwe Electricity Distribution Company (ZEDC), Zesa Enterprises
and Powertel Communications.
ZEDC’s business is the distribution and
retail of electricity to the final
end user.
In line with the
approved structure, all power generation assets and
operations are under
ZPC.
Zesa Enterprises, another subsidiary of Zesa Holdings comprises of
four
business units namely Zesa Technology Centre, Production and Services,
Transport Logistics and Projects.
It is a flexible investment arm for
Zesa Holdings that has a diversified
business portfolio.
Zim-torture
website goes live
http://www.izimbabwe.co.zw/news/local/item/14071-zim-torture-website-goes-live.html
Wednesday, 14 March 2012
HARARE, Zimbabwe – A
website detailing the horrors of political violence
which rocked Zimbabwe in
the 2008 general elections has gone live.
The webisite, www.zanupfcrime.com is showing graphic
pictures of injuries
sustained by people suspected to have been supporters
of the then opposition
party Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) led by
Prime Minister Morgan
Tsvangirai.
The victims were tortured by
alleged ZANU PF functionaries who had set up
torture camps in various parts
of the country to cow opposition supporters
in the run up to the June 2008
election run off.
A welcome statement on the homepage of the website
reads, “This website is
dedicated to the victims of Zanu PF crime committed
in the name of Zanu PF
on the people of Zimbabwe. To date, the perpetrators
of genocide,
mutilation, sexual abuse and murder continue to live amongst
the surviving
victims.
They continue their abuses with impunity.
Whilst there has been a temporary
reprieve since the formation of the so
called Government of national unity
was put in place, all the mechanisms of
state terror remain in place. What
you are currently viewing on this web
site is just small beginnings. There
are massive amounts of data in the form
of victims' testimony, video and
pictures to come forth.
For those
who care about Zimbabwe, we would be grateful if you would pass
the message
on.”
The website also lists alleged perpetrators and violators as well as
multiple farm owners.
The 2008 elections which resulted in the
formation of a coalition government
between President Robert Mugabe, Prime
Minister Tsvangirai and the smaller
formation of the MDC claimed hundreds of
lives and thousands sustained
permanent injuries.
Full text of communiqué from SADC
Summit in Angola
June 4, 2012 1:25 pm
Extraordinary Summit of SADC Heads of State and
Government
Luanda, Angola,
June 01, 2012
1. An
Extraordinary Session of the Summit of Heads of State and Government of the
Southern African Development Community (SADC) was held in Luanda, Republic of
Angola on 1st June 2012.
2. The Summit was
officially opened by H.E. Eng. José Eduardo dos Santos, President of the
Republic of Angola and the Chairperson of SADC.
3. Summit observed
a minute of silence in memory of the late President of Malawi, H.E. Bingu wa
Mutharika and extended condolences to the family, people and Government of
Malawi.
4. The Summit was
attended by the following Heads of State and Government and their
representatives:
Angola
H.E. President José Eduardo dos Santos
Botswana
H.E. President Lt. Gen. Seretse Khama Ian Khama
Namibia
H.E. President Hifikepunye Pohamba
South
Africa H.E. President Jacob Gedleyihlekisa Zuma
Swaziland
His Majesty King Mswati III
Zambia
H.E. President Michael Chilufya Sata
Zimbabwe
H.E. President Robert Gabriel Mugabe
United
Republic Rt. Hon. Mizengo Kayanza Peter Pinda, Prime
Minister
of
Tanzania
DRC Hon.
Raymond Tshibanda N’Tungamulongo, Minister of Foreign Affairs, International
Cooperation and Franchophonie
Malawi
Hon. Ephraim Mganda Chiume, Minister of Foreign Affairs and International
Cooperation
Mauritius
Dr the Hon. Arvin Boolell, Minister of Foreign Affairs, Regional Integration and
International Trade
Mozambique
Hon. Aldemiro Baloi, Minister of Foreign Affairs and International
Cooperation
Seychelles
Hon. Jean Paul Adam, Minister of Foreign Affairs
Lesotho
H.E. ´Matlotilso Ntoane, High Commissioner to South
Africa
5. H.E. President
dos Santos welcomed the Heads of State and Government and other delegates to the
Republic of Angola. In his speech, the Chairperson of SADC underscored the
importance of regional infrastructure development as one of the key pillars for
the SADC integration and development agenda and for poverty
eradication.
6. Summit
considered and adopted the Report of the Troika of the Organ Summit that met on
1st June 2012 in Luanda, Angola, which reviewed the political and security
situation in the Region. In particular:
6.1 Summit noted
that the Region continues to consolidate democracy and the rule of law as
reflected in the holding of successful elections in a number of Member States.
In this regard, Summit congratulated:
(i) H.E. President
James Alix Michel for winning Presidential Elections in the Seychelles in
September 2011.
(ii) H.E.
President Michael Chilufya Sata for winning the Presidential Elections in
Zambia, in September 2011, and
(iii) H.E.
President Joseph Kabila Kabange for winning the Presidential Elections held in
the DRC in November 2011.
6.2 Summit
commended the people of Lesotho for holding peaceful, free and fair National
Assembly Elections on May 26, 2012.
6.3 Summit
received an update on the positive political and security situation in DRC and
encouraged the Government of DRC to continue consolidating peace and
democracy.
6.4 On Madagascar,
Summit noted that efforts by the SADC Mediation team, led by former President of
Mozambique, H.E. Joaquim Alberto Chissano and the SADC Organ Troika resulted in
the signing, in September 2011 by ten of the eleven Malagasy stakeholders, of
the Roadmap that seeks to return the country to constitutional normalcy. Summit
reiterated the importance of the full implementation of the Roadmap for ending
the crisis in the country.
6.5 Summit
mandated the SADC Mediator and the Troika of the Organ to facilitate dialogue
and convene a meeting between H.E. Andry Rajoelina, President of the High
Transition Authority and H.E Marc Ravalomanana, former President as a matter of
urgency in order to ensure full implementation of the Roadmap and create an
enabling environment for holding credible, free and fair
elections.
6.6 Summit also
noted that the SADC Liaison Office that was established in November 2011 to
support the implementation process is fully operational with officers from the
Troika of the Organ Member States and office of the Chairperson of SADC on the
ground since January 2012.
6.7 On Malawi,
Summit commended the people of this country for adhering to the country’s
constitutional provisions regarding succession following the demise of H.E
President Bingu wa Mutharika on the 5th April 2012.
6.8 Summit
congratulated Her Excellency President Mrs. Joyce Mtila-Banda for ascending to
the position of President of Malawi on the 7th of April 2012.
6.9 On
Zimbabwe, Summit commended stakeholders for their commitment, cooperation and
efforts towards the implementation of the Global Political Agreement (GPA) and
urged the parties to the GPA to finalise the constitution-making process and
subject it to a referendum thereafter.
6.10
Summit also urged the parties to the GPA, assisted by His Excellency Jacob G
Zuma, President of the Republic of South Africa and SADC Facilitator of the
Zimbabwe Political Dialogue, to develop an implementation mechanism and to set
out time frames for the full implementation of the Roadmap to
Elections.
6.11
Summit further commended the Facilitator for his efforts towards the realisation
of full implementation of GPA.
7. Summit noted a
proposal from the Chairperson of SADC, based on a Concept Paper on the need to
develop a SADC Vision 2050 and referred the matter to Member States for further
consultations and contributions. Inputs from this process will be consolidated
and submitted to Council and Summit at the next meeting in August
2012.
8. Summit
reiterated its support for the candidature of Honourable Dr. Nkosazana Dlamini-
Zuma, Minister of Home Affairs of the Republic of South Africa for the position
of the Chairperson of African Union Commission.
9. Summit noted
that the Government of Malawi reaffirmed its commitment to host the AU Summit in
July 2012. In reaffirming its support for Malawi as a host for the next AU
Summit in July 2012, Summit underscored the need to finalise the election of
Members of the AU Commission during the session.
10. Summit noted
that the Regional Infrastructure Development Master Plan (RIDMP) is being
finalised to form the basis for implementing infrastructure networks in the key
sectors such as energy, transport, including maritime corridors Information and
Communications Technology, tourism and water, taking into account the
specificities of island Member States.
11. Summit
directed the Council of Ministers and in particular, the SADC Ministers
responsible for Finance and Investment to expedite the process for the
establishment of the SADC Development Fund in order to, among other things,
ensure the availability of adequate levels of resources to fund regional
infrastructure programmes.
12. Summit
expressed its unequivocal support to the candidature of Namibia to host the
Green Climate Fund Secretariat under the United Nations Framework Convention for
Climate Change (UNFCC) and also requested that the candidature be submitted to
the AU Summit in Lilongwe for endorsement.
13. Summit
commended the Government and people of the Republic of Angola for the successful
hosting of the Extraordinary Summit and expressed gratitude for the generous
hospitality.
LUANDA,
ANGOLA
1ST JUNE
2012
Zimbabwe
is poised for a great future
http://www.politicsweb.co.za/
Vince Musewe
04 June 2012
Vince Musewe
says once the political situation is sorted out, the country
will rebound in
a big way
ZANU (PF) has made some significant mistakes in the past but I
must say its
policies during the first decade of independence have created
some positive
factors that can hardly be reversed
You are probably
wondering which planet I am from or what I have been
smoking lately but let
me share with you some of my contrarian thoughts.
After reading Roy Bennett
speech made in Oxford recently, I can't help but
agree with much he has to
say with regard to the political culture in
Zimbabwe (see
here).
However as analysts, sometimes we fall in the trap of analyzing
macro issues
rather too much and reaching conclusions that minimize our
perception of
future opportunity while enlarging current and seemingly
insurmountable
problems. I am of the opinion that despite the current
problems my country
faces, the future holds significant opportunity that we
are likely to miss
unless we begin to change our attitudes.
My recent
visit to Zimbabwe confirms that there is some disconnect between
what we
read and what is actually happening on the ground. There is no doubt
in my
mind that Zimbabwe deserves a better leadership and that to large
extent the
quality of life could be better but that should not blind us to
the
opportunities that exist. I am also a firm believer that I thoughts
become
things and by changing our thoughts about circumstances ,we can
change them
for the better.
My interpretations have exposed that through hardship,
Zimbabweans in
general have become more entrepreneurial in their approach.
They no longer
look to government as the sole provider of economic
opportunity as in the
case in countries such as South Africa. Zimbabweans
have become more
resilient and somehow empowered particularly in their
attitude and demeanor
and one can sense a quiet self-confidence despite the
present macroeconomic
tribulations.
Significant opportunities exist
in rebuilding the country and reviving the
economy and all Zimbabwe needs is
money. I have no doubt that the country is
likely t rebound within a very
short space of time once the politics have
been resolved. Infrastructure,
telecoms, agriculture, media, manufacturing
and mining present some very
stimulating opportunities for the future and I
would advise those
Zimbabweans in the Diaspora to seriously consider
investing at home before
the opportunity space moderates.
It is disturbing however to note that
the media sector is still rather
constrained and there does not seem to be
the free flow of information and
robust public debate on pressing socio
economic and political issues. It is
also evident that selfish ambition by
most, particularly those in public
office, is reducing or arresting the
country's intrinsic potential.
On the economic front I would argue that
the macro economics we are so
competent at analyzing are not reflected in
the micro economics. True there
is a dire shortage of cash and the economy
is being constrained by lack a
capital. The existence of sanctions, although
targeted at individuals, has
however, created a rather unfair negative
perceived country risk that
ultimately has a negative impact on ordinary and
innocent Zimbabweans.
Because of sanctions, ordinary Zimbabweans cannot get
employment as most
companies have closed or are operating at minimal
capacity because of lack
of access to credit. The removal of sanctions is
therefore critical to
increase the opportunity space for Zimbabweans in
general and their
continued existence cannot be supported.
An
attractive development or unintended consequence is that, a large number
of
middle class Zimbabweans no longer look to be employed and you now have a
vibrant and hungry sector of middle class entrepreneurs who are producing or
supplying goods to the economy. This in my view is an irreversible positive
development that can only stand the economy in good stead in the
future.
Added to this is the indigenization philosophy which is
inadvertently
shifting economic aspirations in general and creating new
hope. Although its
implementation is under question, I however think that
there is nothing
inherently evil or disadvantageous in this policy and those
who are prepared
to embrace it, be they black or white can only benefit in
the future.
Zimbabwe's natural resources base, its skilled labor force,
peaceful
communities and excellent climate present advantageous
opportunities for the
future. The new entrepreneurial spirit evident within
the black middle class
adds a positive spin. These factors, in my view, have
tended to be immune to
the politics of the country and for me create
misunderstood opportunities
that must be taken advantage of.
ZANU(PF)
has made some significant mistakes in the past but I must say its
policies
during the first decade of independence have created something that
can
hardly be reversed- an educated middle class that has a strong work
ethic.
The ownership of land and the drive to localize ownership of other
assets
are creating a strong platform for future growth. My anticipation is
that
this process must be depoliticized so that it becomes a non partisan
wholesale empowerment drive geared to reposition the economy as a
whole.
If you add a participative democracy, respect for human rights, an
open
media and access to capital to all this, you are likely to get a
formidable
Zimbabwe that can once more become a significant economy within
the region.
It is my view therefore that, despite its current political
problems,
Zimbabwe is poised for an incredible recovery and an awesome
future.
Vince Musewe is an independent economist currently in Harare and
you may
contact him on vtmusewe@gmail.com
Not 'Satasfied' - Zimbabweans in UK protest at Zambian President's visit
Media Notice from the Zimbabwe Vigil – 4th
June 2012
Not ‘Satasfied’ – Zimbabweans in UK protest at Zambian
President’s visit
The
Zimbabwe Vigil is to stage a protest on Wednesday 6th June against
the visit to London by President Michael Sata of Zambia who is a guest at
Jubilee celebrations for the Queen.
Vigil Co-ordinator Dumi Tutani said ‘Sata is an
unashamed apologist for Mugabe. His parroting “Pamberi ne Zanu PF (Forward with
Zanu PF)” at last week’s SADC meeting even embarrassed Zanu PF (see:
https://www.zimbabwesituation.com/old/jun3a_2012.html
- Fireworks at Angola summit).
He
was referring to a meeting of the Southern
African Development Community in the Angolan capital Luanda which rejected
Mugabe’s demand for early elections before reforms were made in accordance with
the political agreement with the former opposition MDC in 2008.
The
Zimbabwe Vigil has asked permission from the police hold a protest from 1 – 2 pm
outside the Commonwealth Secretariat, Marlborough House, Pall Mall, London SW1Y
5HX, where President Sata is to attend a lunch hosted by the Commonwealth Secretary-General.
The
lunch is to be attended by the Queen so if the demonstration is not allowed for
security reasons there will be a protest at the Zambian High Commission, 2
Palace Gate, London W8 5NG (same time).
Southern Africans will deliver a new broom as a gift to
Mr Sata. He was previously a platform sweeper at Victoria Station but we now
think he needs to clean up his own act.
He
is in London for the Queen’s Diamond Jubilee. We thought any word of diamonds
would set his heart pounding so we will give him a bag of gems to wean him from
Mugabe’s largesse.
Protest details
Time and Date:
1 – 2pm on Wednesday 6th June 2012
Venue: outside
Commonwealth Secretariat, Marlborough House, Pall Mall, London SW1Y
5HX
If not allowed
Venue: outside
Zambian High Commission, 2 Palace Gate,
London W8 5NG at 1 pm
Contacts: Rose Benton 07970 996 003, 07932 193
467
Dumi Tutani 07960 039
775
Zimbabwe Vigil
Co-ordinators
The Vigil, outside the Zimbabwe
Embassy, 429 Strand, London, takes place every Saturday from 14.00 to 18.00 to
protest against gross violations of human rights in Zimbabwe. The Vigil which
started in October 2002 will continue until internationally-monitored, free and
fair elections are held in Zimbabwe. http://www.zimvigil.co.uk
Constitution Watch of 1st June 2012 [Select Committee Preparing for Second Draft]
CONSTITUTION WATCH 2012
[1st June 2012]
Select Committee Preparing for Second Draft
● Compliance “Audit” of the
first draft completed ● Lead drafters vindicated ● Consideration of political party comments
underway
● SADC urges completion of Constitution
Late on Thursday 31st May, the full 25-member Select Committee plus
technical advisors completed what they called an “audit” of the first draft of the new
constitution. The audit showed that the
lead drafters had followed their instructions and not imported their own or
other “alien” views. But, the other task
the Select Committee were working on – namely, to see what could be included
from the feedback from the GPA political parties – was not finished, because
they could not reach agreement on what to include, and the buck has once again
has been passed to the Management Committee.
Political Parties Feedback Under Consideration
When the revised first draft came back from the three GPA political
parties to whom it had been sent for comment the two MDC parties basically
endorsed it with a few suggestions and reservations that the remaining unsolved
issues must be resolved and put in the draft before they could finally endorse
it. [See Constitution Watch 19th
May] ZANU-PF however came up with a
29-page commentary which the other parties claimed contained newly introduced
demands or reopened demands on which some compromise had already been
agreed. Their significant demands
largely centred round taking away powers given to Parliament in the draft,
increasing the powers of the President, the accountability of security forces
and objections to any form of devolution.
MDC-T co-chair Mwonzora said that “We completely
rejected that 29-page document and said that we should work on the draft the way
we’ve always done” – that anything done
by way of revision would be confined to documents all parties had agreed to and
signed. He insisted it had not been
agreed that ZANU-PF was free to bring up
new issues that would drastically change previously agreed positions. But ZANU-PF are still manoeuvring to get
their demands met.
Recent Sequence of Events
On Monday 14th May the decision was made by
the Select Committee to delegate to the Co-chairs’ Forum the work of going through the first draft in detail, correcting errors and
considering what feedback from the political parties to accommodate and then
formulating instructions to the lead drafters for the preparation of a second
draft.
On Wednesday 16th May the Co-chairs Forum, consisting of the Select
Committee co-chairs plus six experts advisors, two nominated by each of the
three parties, started meeting to do this work.
On 17th May an impasse was reached in the Co-chairs Forum. Hardliners within ZANU-PF had already raised
objections to the Select Committee’s 14th May decision to leave to the
Co-chairs’ Forum the decision on whether or not to include their demands. When agreement could not be reached a work
stoppage was called. The matter was
referred to the Management Committee and the full Select
Committee.
On 21st May the Management Committee met to discuss the impasse
On 23rd May at a Select Committee meeting, a way forward was arrived
at to end the deadlock – that instead of the Co-chairs Forum going through the revised draft and
the party comments, the whole Select Committee plus technical advisers would go
through the revised draft following a two-tier methodology, before fresh
instructions were drawn up for the lead drafters.
On Monday 28th May the Select Committee started their work. [The impasse over ZANU-PF’s new demands
resulted in nearly two wasted weeks even before work resumed.]
Way Forward - Two-Tier Methodology
1. There would be an audit of the revised first draft, going through it clause by
clause through each of the 18 chapters of the draft, to assess the lead
drafters’ compliance with the instructions given to them before they began work
on that draft in late March. This was
considered important in view of much publicised accusations that the lead
drafters had included their own ideas in the revised first draft in defiance of
the instructions they had been given by COPAC.
This audit would be carried out by the full Select Committee, starting on
Monday 28th May.
While doing the audit, but keeping the two tasks separate, the full
Select Committee would also undertake a:
2. Consideration of the comments submitted by the three GPA political
parties Editorial and other minor
changes agreed on would be adopted. If
there was disagreement on changes asked for by a particular party – for
instance, on substantial changes which would involve reversing positions
previously agreed between the parties – those disagreement/s would have to be
referred to the Management Committee for resolution.
Outcome
The audit This part of the process appears to have gone relatively smoothly
and has overwhelmingly established that the lead drafters did comply with their
instructions – thus debunking the accusations that these three highly respected
professionals had imported their own un-Zimbabwean ideas into the draft and
departed from the instructions given them by COPAC.
Consideration of political party comments Minor editorial changes and
corrections of mistakes suggested were agreed on. But ZANU-PF’s demands for substantial changes to be made to the draft were not accepted. The Select Committee decided they had done as
much as they could and the disagreements have been referred to the Management
Committee.
Management Committee Meetings Schedule
The Management Committee has planned to meet on Tuesday 5th,
Wednesday 6th and Thursday 7th May. It
is to be hoped they can resolve matters promptly – but there will be competing
claims on the time of members who are Ministers – Cabinet on Tuesday, Parliament
[with important Bills] on Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday.
Note: In Constitution Watch of 26th April 2012 we incorrectly said
that the Minister of Constitutional and Parliamentary Affairs chairs the COPAC
Management Committee. In fact it is
usually chaired by the party negotiators in rotation, although occasionally the
Minister has chaired.
When will Lead Drafters Start the Second
Draft?
The three lead drafters were summoned on Wednesday 30th May to start
a second draft. It was a puzzling
summons, as reports indicated that there were still difficulties reaching
agreement between the three parties. In
fact the drafters, having reached the drafting venue, were sent home again and
told to come back possibly on Monday 4th June or soon thereafter. As the Select Committee has referred
disagreements to the Management Committee, they will probably not be called this
week nor for some time. There would seem
to be little point in merely producing an interim second draft pending decisions
on the areas of disagreement. There
remains the obvious ever-present risk that the Management Committee will not be
able to solve the issue of ZANU-PF demands which are totally unacceptable to the
other parties and that there may be another deadlock. If the issue is referred to party principals
and their advisors it may result in a whole new raft of
demands.
SADC Summit Calls for Finalisation of
Constitution
The final SADC Summit Communiqué on 1st June urged the parties to the GPA to finalise the constitution and confirmed that
together with agreed reforms it was part of the Election Roadmap to
be fulfilled before elections.
Hopefully, with SADC endorsement the constitution will not be abandoned
in favour of elections this year.
Last Words from COPAC Spokesperson
“This constitutional process
is nothing but politics” COPAC member Hon Jesse Majome said at a civil society
meeting organised by the Action for Conflict Transformation. “The politics of the constitutional process
is acrimonious, there is deep polarisation in Zimbabwe.”
Veritas makes every effort to ensure reliable information, but cannot
take legal responsibility for information supplied