The ZIMBABWE Situation | Our
thoughts and prayers are with Zimbabwe - may peace, truth and justice prevail. |
Under a deal reached at talks in Australia, the leaders agreed to set up a three-member committee to decide possible action, based on the findings of the group's election observers deployed in the country.
Without any feeling of 'Oh, I have lost out or I have won',
there's no winner, no loser |
Nigerian President Olusegun Obasanjo
|
The BBC's diplomatic correspondent Barnaby Mason says it was a painful compromise between countries like Britain and Australia - which had pushed for immediate suspension - and mainly African nations that had wanted the issue off the talks agenda altogether.
In its first reaction, Zimbabwe's opposition Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) said it was totally dissatisfied with the deal as there was no question the election could be free or fair.
'Credible outcome'
A statement from the summit in Coolum, Queensland, says possible measures against President Robert Mugabe's government range from "collective disapproval to suspension", if the poll is not free or fair.
Australian Prime Minister John Howard said it had not been easy to reach a deal which was a "quick, sure and fair mechanism".
"There is a range of views, strong feelings are held. But what the Commonwealth has decided upon is not something that pushes it [Zimbabwe] to the never-never if there is an adverse report but provides a mechanism [for action]."
|
Significantly, Zimbabwe had been party to the agreement, President Obasanjo told the BBC.
"Frankly, and without any feeling of 'oh, I have lost out or I have won', there's no winner, no loser. The consensus agreement we have reached, we are all the better for it," Mr Obasanjo said.
Although the three-member body will have the power to suspend Zimbabwe from the Commonwealth, our correspondent says there is no commitment to any particular action even if the poll on 9-10 March is not free and fair.
And despite the summit's condemnation of violence in the run-up to the election, the statement refrained from blaming Mr Mugabe or his Zanu-PF party for it.
MDC spokeswoman Sekai Holland told the BBC the opposition was disappointed - it had hoped for action not words as Mr Mugabe had flouted all previous agreements and instituted a regime of violence against opposition members and their leaders.
Racial divide
The dispute over what the Commonwealth should do about Zimbabwe has been extremely divisive - pitting many African countries against a group of predominantly white member states led by Britain and Australia.
They had been urging Zimbabwe's suspension from the body.
I think it's a credible outcome for the Commonwealth
|
Australian Prime Minister John Howard
|
Zimbabwe's Information Minister, Jonathan Moyo, described Britain's stance as "disgraceful" when he made an impromptu appearance at the summit.
President Mugabe himself has reportedly called on Mr Blair to keep his "pink nose" out of Zimbabwe's affairs.
Tendai Biti, MDC shadow minister for foreign affairs, said the Commonwealth should have carried out its earlier threat to suspend Zimbabwe, given that state-sponsored violence against the opposition had got worse.
The decision... is a bitter disappointment to the MDC
|
Tendai Biti, MDC |
But a spokesman for the ruling Zanu-PF party welcomed the Commonwealth's ruling, under which a three-member committee will be set up to decide future action based on the findings of the group's election observers.
BBC diplomatic correspondent Barnaby Mason says the Commonwealth decision was a painful compromise between member countries.
Britain and Australia had pushed for Zimbabwe's immediate suspension, while others such as Tanzania and Namibia opposed any discussion at all.
Violence
Hours after the deal had been announced, police in Zimbabwe broke up a meeting in a Harare hotel between Morgan Tsvangirai, leader of the MDC, and foreign diplomats.
They had been in the middle of discussing food shortages in the country when officers went in and declared the gathering illegal.
| |||||
More voices from Zimbabwe |
In other incidents, an MDC spokesman said three activists were being held at a ruling party base south-west of the capital.
A group of militants supporting the ruling party had also attacked shops owned by an opposition supporter, he said.
The three-member Commonwealth committee, or troika, is made up of Nigerian President Olusegun Obasanjo, his South African counterpart Thabo Mbeki and Australian Prime Minister John Howard.
Analysts say President Robert Mugabe is likely to be pleased with the deal as Nigeria and South Africa have in the past opposed sanctions on Harare.
A statement from the summit in Coolum, Queensland, said possible measures against Mr Mugabe's government range from "collective disapproval to suspension", if the poll is not free or fair.
Mr Howard said it had not been easy to reach a deal which was a "quick, sure and fair mechanism".
|
"I think it's a credible outcome for the Commonwealth," he added.
Significantly, Zimbabwe had been party to the agreement, President Obasanjo told the BBC.
"Frankly, and without any feeling of 'oh, I have lost out or I have won', there's no winner, no loser. The consensus agreement we have reached, we are all the better for it," Mr Obasanjo said.
But British Prime Minister Tony Blair said the summit ought to have gone all the way.
"The case for suspending Zimbabwe now, I think, is very plain," Mr Blair said.
Zimbabwe's Information Minister, Jonathan Moyo, described Britain's stance as "disgraceful", when he made an impromptu appearance at the summit.
President Mugabe himself has reportedly called on Mr Blair to keep his "pink nose" out of Zimbabwe's affairs.
Despite the summit's condemnation of violence in the run-up to the election, the statement refrained from blaming Mr Mugabe or his Zanu-PF party for it.
Under a deal reached at talks in Australia, the committee will be made up of Nigerian President Olusegun Obasanjo, his South African counterpart Thabo Mbeki, and Australian Prime Minister John Howard.
The leaders will decide on any possible action to take against Zimbabwe based on the findings of the group's election observers deployed in the country.
Although the three-member body will have the power to suspend Zimbabwe from the Commonwealth, there is no commitment to any particular action even if the poll on 9-10 March is not free and fair.
Do you think that the Commonwealth body will help to resolve the turmoil in Zimbabwe? Should sanctions still be imposed against the country?
I hope I am wrong, but I do not think this will help. What seems to be clear
from the last few months is that the African leaders think first about
protection for fellow African leaders and only secondly about protection of
African peoples. This includes their own peoples in Mbeki¿s case, as Zimbabwe
drags the SA economy and credibility downwards. The club rules will not be
broken, because each one of them knows that they might be the next one under
pressure.
Ally, Scotland
I can appreciate the African leaders in the commonwealth being sick of the
West trying to "rule the world" and this is why they are having trouble in
deciding what to do with Zimbabwe. The problem though, as we all now know, is
with Mugabe and his greedy henchmen who know what will happen to them when they
eventually come of power, and these are the people that need to be eradicated.
John Williams, UK
I pray that the people will go to the polls and vote for
Morgan. |
Muungwe Tom, Zimbabwe |
I find the attitude of the African leaders objecting to sanctions in Zimbabwe
somewhat predictable. What has caused the real lasting problems in Africa is
that power seems to always concentrate into the hands of a very small number of
determined men. Countries like Nigeria and South Africa seem to have formed a
somewhat distasteful bond of solidarity with a man they see as helping them
resist the meddling west. The Populations of their countries should wake up and
realise that it is their own leaders, not the Commonwealth, which makes their
countries a difficult place to live.
Russell Priest, UK
The commonwealth is a waste of time space and energy. I want my country out
of it now. I don't want to be a subject of a racist foreign power and part of a
body does has done absolutely nothing for the ex-colonies but banish them to
poverty and subject them to racial discrimination. Kenya should leave the
commonwealth [and the Useless Nations] now and we should forge our own destiny
in this hostile world based on a policy of self-reliance and self defence.
International co-operation to date simply means a raw deal for you if you're not
the right colour and hopelessly tedious lip service being paid to your concerns.
Amoroso, Kenya
There is no democracy in Zimbabwe and no law, therefore change will only come
about with the help of outside forces like the commonwealth. If they pass the
buck and do not use their present opportunity well - there will have to be
another civil war. Sanctions will only work if the right sanctions are done.
Rhodesia survived a very long time on sanctions and was made stronger for it.
Rather attack Mugabe's money reserves and army movements.
Thompson,
Zimbabwean in UK
Once again the Commonwealth has shown itself incapable of
facing up to real issues |
Steve Male, UK |
If, and hopefully when, Morgan Tsvangerai becomes president of Zimbabwe, I
would not blame him if he pulls out of the Commonwealth and the Southern Africa
Development Community, who both have exhibited weakness to the point of
complicity with Mugabe's mafia.
Andrew Cover, UK
Britain favours sanctions against Zimbabwe for the purpose of encouraging
free, fair and democratic elections. Well it seems quite hypocritical when you
consider that when moves to impose trade sanctions against South Africa were
made, they were steadfastly resisted by Margaret Thatcher prior to Mandela
becoming the first democratically elected President of South Africa.
Martin Doyle, Australia
The Commonwealth is not the national police force of Zimbabwe. If Mugabe
kills anyone, then surely that is a national matter for their justice
department. If the truth is that the West are worried he will win again and
treat the white minority badly, then the Commonwealth ought to wait and act
"after the fact". How can you imprison a person because you think he is going to
commit a crime? And I thought this was all about a democratic process.
Austin Amadasun, Nigeria
Austin from Nigeria has got it wrong. It's not just the white minority we are
concerned about but EVERYONE who lives in Zim, or who has been forced to leave
the country in fear of their lives from this oppressive and unjust regime. How
many MDC supporters are white compared with 'native' Africans? I think you'll
find the majority are not white. When Mugabe is prepared to look after ALL his
citizens, he'll be respected as a true democratic leader. I suspect that will
never happen. SO, vote for Morgan and end the dictator's rule.
Brian
Naylor, England
Mugabe is a hero for not bowing down to pressure from Europe
|
Melchior Julien, Boston, USA
|
The people in Zimbabwe whose families have been affected in the most brutal
and tragic way must be totally appalled at the lack of response to their pleas
for help. Are the leaders of the other African nations fully aware of the
atrocities being committed or are they merely turning a blind eye??
Mark Corton, Netherlands
Just imagine how the Commonwealth, and other nations would have responded to
attempts by the apartheid regime in South Africa to rig elections. It's time
African tyrants were treated with equal contempt and with far tougher sanctions
than have been agreed in Australia. It's time we stopped treating Mugabe as a
naughty child and started treating him as a mature, accountable dictator.
John, UK
Message from African 'leaders' to world: Keep out - unless you're carrying
money. The Commonwealth's action is too little, far too late, and sends a clear
message to other thugs on the Continent that they can do as they please. Plus ça
change.
Peter Tallon, Geneva
The MDC spokesperson at the CHOGM, Sekai Holland, rightly pointed out that
the need to redistribute land is undisputed. Believing that current opposition
to Mugabe and Zanu-PF is about land plays directly into their hands. This is
about an autocratic leader who stops at nothing to remain in power- against the
wishes of a majority of the population. Don't we have a responsibility to find a
way to help the people of Zimbabwe?
John Bird, UK
If the facts stated on the BBC2 Correspondent programme are correct, this
apology for a president has been torturing and murdering the people of Zimbabwe
for the last 20 years. The Commonwealth should ostracise such people at once
without waiting for the outcome of the forthcoming election.
Simon
Fenland, UK
Zimbabwe Movement for Democratic
Nigerian President |
Coolum, Australia (prenter News) Concerns of
widespread violence were expressed today following the action plan released by
the Heads of Government at CHOGM to monitor the election in Zimbabwe on 9-10
March. Ms Sekai Holland from the Zimbabwe Movement for Democratic Change said
that the statement issued today did not go far enough. "There will be a
bloodbath. This will give Mugabe the opportunity to dispose of his opponents and
those that will not vote for him", said Ms Holland. The critical time for the
people of our country will be when the Commonwealth observers are not there.
That is when he [President Robert Mugabe] will strike", she explained.
The statement released by Heads of government describes a 3-point action plan. Firstly, a Commonwealth Observer Group (COG) will be present whilst the election takes place. This group will be made up of similar people etat observed the last election in 1998. The report from this group will then be presented to a troika of leaders comprising the current Chairman of the Commonwealth, Australian Prime Minister John Howard, the immediate past Chairman, South African President Thabo Mbeki and the next Chairman, Nigerian President Olusegun Obasanjo. The three leaders in consultation with Commonwealth Secretary General Donald McKinnon will then jointly decide what sanctions, if any, will be imposed on Zimbabwe. These sanctions range from collective disapproval to suspension from the Commonwealth. Economic sanctions were not ruled out. It is expected that this process will take from 9 to 14 days. "If there is to be an Observer Group they must be in Zimbabwe for four weeks", pleaded Ms Holland. "This is not a good outcome for the people e of Zimbabwe", she stated. The CHOGM statement on Zimbabwe follows claims yesterday from Information Minister Professor Jonathan Moyo that others should stay out of his country and that British Prime Minister Tony Blair should; "Shut up" and "Grow up". The election to be held in 5 days is expected to be fought bitterly particularly following accusations of vote rigging and murder plots. Not all African leaders expect mass violence. Nigerian President Olusegun Obasanjo applauds the plan that Heads of Government have delivered and is encouraged for a peaceful outcome in Zimbabwe. "There should not be a bloodbath. Those that speak of violence are irresponsible", he said. "I am a fair man and this is a fair plan.", added President Obasanjo. He summarised the situation by stating; ""Zimbabwe is a poor country and the most important point is that they need our help. That is far more important then fuelling the flames of violence." By Peter Higgins |