http://www.swradioafrica.com/
By Alex Bell
16 November 2009
The
court case against MDC Treasurer General Roy Bennett hit yet another
snag on
Monday, when Judge Chinembiri Bhunu refused to recuse himself from
the case.
Bennett's legal team last week requested that Justice Bhunu hand
the trial
over to another judge, saying his handling of the related Peter
Hitschmann
trial in 2006 showed he might be 'prejudicial' to Bennett. But
Bhunu refused
to hand the case over when proceedings got underway on Monday,
saying the
cases of Hitschmann and Bennett were separate.
State prosecutors have
indicated that Hitschmann, who was jailed for two
years for possessing
dangerous weapons but was acquitted on the more serious
terrorism charge
that Bennett is facing, will give evidence that will
implicate Bennett. But
Bennett's defence has said that Hitschmann's
testimony will contradict a
sworn affidavit and statements he made to the
High Court in 2006. Hitschmann
himself has also made clear that he is not
prepared to be a state
witness.
Monday's court proceedings saw Bennett plead not guilty to the
charges laid
against him, and also saw the first state witness in the case
take the
stand. SW Radio Africa correspondent Simon Muchemwa reported that
the
witness, police superintendent James Makoni, kept alluding to statements
made by Hitschmann during the arms dealer's case in 2006. The defence argued
that the evidence was 'inadmissible' because Hitschmann himself has not yet
been called to testify. The trial will continue on Tuesday.
ZLHR Press Release – 16 Nov : Deputy Agriculture Minister-Designate, Roy Bennett on Monday 16 November 2009 pleaded not guilty to charges of insurgency, banditry, sabotage and terrorism after they were read to him for the first time in court by Attorney General (AG), Johannes Tomana.
Earlier on Justice Bhunu refused to recuse himself from presiding over the trial as requested by Bennett’s lawyers last week. He delivered his ruling in Chambers before Bennett’s lawyers Beatrice Mtetwa and Trust Maanda together with State lawyers, Tomana, Chris Mutangadura and Florence Ziyambi.
As the trial commenced in earnest, Tomana told the court that Bennett [who is facing several charges ranging from possessing weaponry for insurgency, banditry, sabotage and terrorism to incitement to commit insurgency, banditry or terrorism] plotted, together with Peter Michael Hitschmann, to depose a lawful government through the use of violence, insurgence, banditry, sabotage and terrorism.
Tomana alleged that Bennett was the financier to the acquisition of firearms and also planned the demolition of a Microwave link, which is a communication system that uses a beam of radio waves in the microwave frequency range to transmit information between two fixed locations.
After Bennett pleaded not guilty to the charges Tomana led evidence from the State’s first witness, Chief Superintendent Sipho James Makone of Criminal Investigations Department (CID) Mutare, who arrested Hitschmann on 6 March 2006 and is the investigating officer in the case.
However Mtetwa objected after Tomana started leading evidence she claimed was based on hearsay.
Justice Bhunu, who adjourned court before lunchtime to consider Mtetwa’s objection, ruled when proceedings resumed after lunch that Makone should restrict himself only to what he did and found out or discovered, and not hearsay.
Justice Bhunu then deferred the matter to Tuesday 17 November 2009 after Tomana asked for a postponement to consider Bhunu’s ruling which he said “he wasn’t anticipating”.
http://www.mg.co.za
HARARE, ZIMBABWE Nov 16 2009
15:38
A senior official in Zimbabwe Prime Minister Morgan
Tsvangirai's party
pleaded not guilty on Monday to terrorism charges in a
trial that has raised
tensions in the unity government formed early this
year.
Roy Bennett, treasurer general in the Movement for Democratic
Change (MDC),
was arrested in February on charges of illegal possession of
arms for
purposes of committing terrorism, insurgency and
banditry.
Bennett's lawyer said he viewed the case as "political
persecution".
Bennett is the MDC's nominee for the post of deputy
agriculture minister,
but President Robert Mugabe has refused to swear him,
saying that he should
be acquitted first.
Asked on Monday by High
Court Judge Chinembiri Bhunu how he pleaded to the
charges, Bennett said:
"Not guilty, my Lord."
Attorney General Johannes Tomana told the court
that Bennett, together with
accomplice Peter Hitschmann, was involved in an
anti-government plot to
destabilise the country between 2002 and May
2006.
Tomana said Bennett was the chief financier, at one time depositing
$5 000
in Hitschmann's account to purchase arms, including rifles, eight
machine
guns, ammunition and grenades.
"The grand plan included
assassinating certain individuals in government,"
Tomana said.
The
plot was supposed to be carried out in March 2006 when Mugabe was
attending
a birthday function in the eastern city of Mutare.
Beatrice Mtetwa,
Bennett's lawyer, said Bennett denied all the charges.
"The accused will
contend that the state summary discloses no offence and
that this is
continued political persecution from his rivals who continue to
stop his
participation in the unity government," she said.
Judge Bhunu refused a
request by defence lawyers for him to step aside from
the trial. The defence
says he previously made certain comments that could
be prejudicial to
Bennett's case.
State prosecutors have indicated that Hitschmann -- who
was jailed for two
years for possessing dangerous weapons but was acquitted
on the more serious
terrorism charge -- will give evidence that will
implicate Bennett.
Defence lawyers say Hitschmann's testimony will
contradict a sworn affidavit
and statements he made to the high court in
2006 and that he has also made
clear that he is not prepared to be a state
witness. -- Reuters
Colin Cloete of Gramara farm in Chegutu, Zimbabwe was harassed this weekend by a group of alleged “war vets”. The following sms was received from him during the incident:
“Am being harassed in my house at the moment. They want me to leave now. Go back to Britain. Making fire on my lawn jambanja* style. Police not responding.”
Soon after the message was sent two police officers did in fact arrive and they left with the “invaders”.
Apparently Colonel Kapanga’s wife is the main instigator behind the operation to hound Cloete.
Yesterday the police charged the invaders and it remains to be seen whether or not the charges will be acted upon. Cloete was upbeat and felt that the police had done their job for the moment; however, the past experience of other farmers inspires caution and the justice system stands to be tested today.
Although the invaders were in possession of a stamped and signed letter from the War Vets Association, the authenticity of the letter could not be checked.
The situation in Zimbabwe is such that individuals believe they are above the law as President Mugabe has given blanket authority to “take back” the land and the rule of law has time and again not been adhered to.
In 2008 Cloete was one of several white commercial farmers prosecuted for allegedly staying on their land, which had been forcibly acquired by the government under the violent land reform exercise. Cloete is part of the group of 78 farmers who fall under the SADC ruling that argued that the seizure of their farms constituted discriminated on the grounds of race, and did not afford them a hearing in court and above all violated the SADC treaty on property and human rights.
The SADC tribunal ruled that the farmers could go back on their farms and ordered the Zimbabwe government not interfere with their operations, however the Zimbabwe Attorney General and Minister of Justice has since denied the authority of the SADC appointed body.
Cloete has come under fire in the past for the stance he took as President of the CFU, but states that in his personal capacity he has never believed in or supported land invasions and he is determined to fight against injustice in Zimbabwe. He said,“As president of the CFU I was representing other people’s opinions, not my own opinion and executing the wishes of the organisation’s members.”
This latest farm incident coincides with Mugabe’s visit to Rome to attend the United Nations World Food Summit , taking with him a sixty strong delegation.
*Jambanja is Zimbabwean urban lingua franca or slang for ‘violence’ or ‘chaos’. Popularised after 2000, officials and the public used the word to describe the violent and chaotic farm occupations.
http://www.swradioafrica.com/
By Alex Bell
16
November 2009
The MDC transport manager who was severely tortured after
he was abducted by
state security agents last month, is still being denied
private medical
care, in what his lawyers say is a 'calculated' and
'deliberate' act by the
state.
Pascal Gwezere has remained behind
bars at Chikurubi maximum security prison
after he was finally brought to
court, a week after he was abducted from his
home. His lawyers have been
fighting ever since for Gwezere to have access
to private medical care as a
result of the serious injuries he sustained
after being tortured by his
abductors.
But despite a court order issued more than two weeks ago,
directing prison
officials to allow doctors to examine and treat Gwezere,
this has still not
happened. According to the Zimbabwe Lawyers for Human
Rights, Gwezere's
doctors said last week that a prison doctor, identified as
Dr Makanza, who
had agreed to accompany them to see Gwezere on Friday, did
not show up.
Gwezere's lawyer, Alec Muchadehama, has criticised prison
authorities for
denying his client access to doctors of his own
choice.
"It (denial of medical examination) is calculated and
deliberate," said
Muchadehama.
http://www.swradioafrica.com/
By Tichaona Sibanda
16
November 2009
Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai met in Harare with
negotiators from ZANU PF
and the MDC-T on Monday, to set the agenda for the
make-or-break
negotiations between the rival parties. James Maridadi,
Tsvangirai's
spokesman, confirmed the meeting.
The talks between the
negotiators were due to begin in earnest this week,
but have been postponed
to next week due to the unavailability of
negotiators from the MDC-M. Both
their negotiators missed the Monday meeting
with Tsvangirai.
The
crucial talks will have to wait until the return of Welshman Ncube and
Priscilla Misihairambwi-Mushonga, who are both outside the country. Ncube is
expected back in the country on the 23rd November while Mushonga will be
back on Wednesday. It has been impossible to find out why two key
negotiators are unavailable for meetings, which have direct and vital
impacts on the lives and futures of all Zimbabweans.
MDC-T national
spokesman Nelson Chamisa said their negotiators were ready
but were only
informed of Ncube and Mushonga's absence on Monday. The MDC-T
is represented
by Tendai Biti and Elton Mangoma, while Patrick Chinamasa and
Nicholas Goche
represent ZANU PF.
Ten months into the inclusive government, Robert
Mugabe is still refusing to
share power and now negotiations will have to be
guided by the SADC Troika
communiqué which urged full compliance with the
letter and spirit, not just
of the GPA, but also with the decisions of the
SADC Summit of January 27,
2009.
That communiqué refers specifically
to the issues of provincial governors,
the Attorney-General and the Governor
of the Reserve Bank and issues around
the National Security Council, which
has met only once, four months ago,
since the formation of the new
government in February.
These issues, including the appointment of
provincial governors and the
swearing in of deputy minister of
agriculture-designate Roy Bennett, are
threatening the existence of the
unity government.
Weekend reports said a SADC ministerial team, that
assessed
the implementation of the power-sharing arrangement, recommended
that RBZ
Governor Gideon Gono should be 'reassigned' to save the coalition
government
from collapse.
On Sunday Chamisa told The Star newspaper
of South Africa that the parties
had no option but to fully implement what
they agreed to when the GPA was
signed.
'This is a straightforward
case which does not need days to complete because
everything was agreed by
the parties. We therefore expect full
implementation of the GPA. All the
chapters, commas, full stops, clauses,
punctuation marks, signatures and
paragraphs must be respected and must be
complied with. The political
parties must agree on implementation so that we
do not embarrass SADC, who
are guarantors to the deal,' Chamisa told the
paper.
Last week,
Mugabe, Tsvangirai and Mutambara met in Harare and reportedly
agreed to
reforms pertaining to the media, electoral and human rights.
Media
reports in South Africa over the weekend said Mugabe will soon
announce the
various commissioners for the Zimbabwe Media Commission,
Zimbabwe Electoral
Commission and the Zimbabwe Human Rights Commission.
But observers remain
highly skeptical of such reports, as Mugabe is a master
at delaying tactics
and has shown that he has absolutely no intention of
allowing a free media,
a free electoral commission or a genuine respect for
human
rights.
http://www.swradioafrica.com/
By Alex Bell
16 November
2009
Scores of lawyers gathered in Harare on Monday to protest the
increasing
intimidation tactics being used by the state against them, as
they try to
defend various human rights activists in the country.
The
group of about 60 lawyers, dressed in their black gowns, braved the
pouring
rain in the capital to march to the office of Justice Minister
Patrick
Chinamasa. The group had first attended Monday's High Court
proceedings, in
support of their colleague Mordecai Mahlangu who was
arrested two weeks ago
on charges of interfering with the course of justice.
Mahlangu was arrested
after writing a letter to Attorney General Johannes
Tomana, saying his
client Peter Hitschmann had no evidence to offer in the
treason trial
against MDC Treasurer General Roy Bennett.
From the High Court the
lawyers marched to Chinamasa's offices to hand over
a petition, calling for
an end to the ongoing harassment of lawyers and
rights defenders alike.
Lawyers have been routinely harassed by police,
often finding themselves
facing trumped up charges. Magistrates too have
expressed concern about the
state's overwhelming interference in the
supposedly independent legal
system.
For example, Harare magistrate Chioniso Mutongi, has reportedly
resigned on
the basis of state interference and harassment. The magistrate,
who has been
presiding over the state's case against top civil rights
lawyer, Alec
Muchadehama, said she had been 'undermined' after the state
refused to carry
out sentencing of the state prosecutor that Mutongi had
ruled was in
contempt of court. The prosecutor, Andrew Kumire, was facing a
jail term as
a result of the contempt charges, after he was disrespectful to
Mutongi
during court proceedings.
But Mutongi reportedly said she had
endured a "torrid time during which I
was entirely abused and harassed at
the hands of the State prosecution
(authorities)." She added that she felt
she "did not get professional
protection from this office, as I reasonably
anticipated."
Political analyst and lawyer, Alex Magaisa, said the
situation "raises
questions yet again about the independence of the judiciary
and more
significantly, about the plight of the officers in the lower
echelons of the
judiciary."
"The independence of the judiciary must be
protected and this goes
beyond concerns for judges in the superior courts but
to all the men and
women who are the foot soldiers of the judicial system,"
Magaisa said.
http://www.zimonline.co.za
by Own
Correspondent Monday 16 November 2009
HARARE -
Deputy Power Development Minister Hubert Nyanhongo will not
be elected ZANU
PF chairman for Harare province because of his links to a
party faction led
by Defence Minister Emmerson Mnangagwa, sources told
ZimOnline at the
weekend.
Nyanhongo, who is the only Member of Parliament from
President Robert
Mugabe's ZANU PF party in Harare province, is appealing the
results of last
week's provincial election in which he polled 807 votes but
lost to Amos
Midzi who got 1 052 votes.
A senior ZANU PF
official speaking on condition of anonymity said
although Nyanhongo is
contesting the results his links to Mnangagwa has cost
him the coverted
prize.
"Even if Nyanhongo has appealed last week's results he will
not be
able to topple Midzi from the post," the source said.
"He has serious links with Mnangagwa and everyone in the party knows
that.
He is a Mnangagwa front, he spends his time at his farm in Kwekwe."
ZANU PF, whose power is on the wane after it was defeated by the MDC
in
elections last year, is riven by factionalism much of it linked to the
unresolved issue of Mugabe's succession.
Two camps, one led by
former army commander Solomon Mujuru and the
other by Mnangagwa, are
fighting for control of the party when and if Mugabe
retires.
"If Nyanhongo had won that post that would have somewhat tilted the
power
balance between general Solomon's Mujuru's camp and Mnangagwa's camp
and
that cannot be allowed to happen," the source said.
Under the ZANU
PF structures, Mnangagwa is the party's secretary for
legal affairs making
him number five in the organisation behind Mugabe,
vice-president Joice
Mujuru, national chairman John Nkomo and Didymus Mutasa
who is the party's
secretary for administration.
Although Nyanhongo was not reachable
for comment at the weekend, last
week he said he was awaiting response from
the party hierarchy on his
appeal.
The source said Mugabe was
"well aware of the Nyanhongo's links to
Mnangagwa and Ngwena cannot be
trusted, but mudhara (the old man) wants him
to continue his ambitions of
being elected to the presidium, but he is fully
aware that he is not popular
in the party so he will not be elected anywhere
near the presidum." -
ZimOnline
http://www.capetimes.co.za
November 16, 2009 Edition 1
Peta
Thornycroft
Mining of "conflict" diamonds in eastern Zimbabwe by a web of
companies in
which South African giant Old Mutual has a share, has begun, in
defiance of
a Harare High Court order.
And the companies are setting
up a diamond-cutting operation at Harare
airport which would allow them to
export the diamonds without proper
certification that they are not blood
diamonds.
Justice Charles Hungwe ruled in the Harare High Court on
September 24 that a
British company, African Consolidated Resources plc
(ACR) is legally the
lessor of some of the land now being exploited by two
Zimbabwean companies,
Canadile Miners and Mbada Mining (Pvt) Ltd, working in
joint ventures with
the parastatal, Zimbabwe Mining Development
Corporation.
Canadile and Mbada have a complex list of shareholders,
which include trusts
and South African- and Mauritian-based companies and
individuals, among them
the Johannesburg company New Reclamation Group. Old
Mutual has a nearly 6
percent share in New Reclamation Group.
High
resolution satellite pictures taken last month showed that a plant
which can
process 150 tons of concentrate was already on one of ACR's
Chiadzwa's
sites, ACR says.
It was manufactured by a Johannesburg engineering
company, Consulmet.
Consulmet confirmed on Friday that the plant was in
Zimbabwe and that the
contract for the plant was ultimately paid for by New
Reclamation Group.
ACR also says that the companies which have taken over
its claims, are
planning to cut gem diamonds in Harare.
This would
would allow them to be smuggled out of Zimbabwe - bypassing the
Kimberley
Process set up to identify conflict or blood diamonds - as the
origins of
cut diamonds cannot be identified.
Whereas the rough diamonds on
ACR's claims, on its Chiadzwa diamond leases,
in the Marange district of the
Manicaland Province in eastern Zimbabwe, are
easy to recognise as they are
covered in a dense skin. On Wednesday Zimbabwe's
mines minister Obert Mpofu
said
he had awarded licences to mine parts of the Chiadzwa diamond fields
to
Canadile Miners and Mbada Mining (Pvt) Ltd, to operate joint ventures
with
the parastatal,
Zimbabwe Mining Development
Corporation.
ACR says both the claims which have been awarded
to
Canadile and Mbada Mining overlap its own claims. The Zimbabwe Mining
Development Corporation is one of the
Zanu-PF-aligned businesses
which is on the sanctions lists of many Western
countries and so their
nationals may not buy the Chiadzwa diamonds.
Under Zimbabwean law,
according to several legal opinions from Harare, any
diamonds extracted from
ACR's claims by these companies, and then sold
either through local front
companies, or smuggled to any international
market, would also be "stolen"
goods.
Apart from the legal issue of ownership of the diamonds, is the
ethical
issue. Human rights groups such as Global Witness say that
Chiadzwa's stones
reflect the real meaning of "blood diamonds" which led to
establishment
of the Kimberley Process. None of the companies involved,
including Old
Mutual, has responded to questions about their involvement in
the
exploitation of the Chiadzwa diamonds.
http://news.scotsman.com
Published Date: 16
November 2009
By Jane Fields in Vila De Manica, Mozambique
THE young
dealer in a cap fiddles with his BlackBerry. As he reaches for a
beer, I see
the stone he's holding.
His companion, a Malian, turns to me on this terrace
in central Mozambique.
"You want?" he whispers.
Driven out of
Zimbabwe's eastern diamond fields by police, illegal diamond
dealers now
operate in this town ten minutes from Machipanda frontier post.
You know
you are in diamond country when you reach the border. "You want
diamonds?"
asks the official checking the serial numbers on our car engine.
"I can get
you one: 16 carats," he promises.
Vila de Manica is not rich.
Tea-bag-size sachets of washing powder are on
sale in a dusty
market.
However, diamond money has changed the landscape here -
literally. Dotted
among the drab concrete buildings are houses freshly
painted in yellow and
purple. Coils of razor wire top the walls. There are
satellite dishes, armed
security guards.
Outside the Flamingo
Restaurant four dealers order rounds of Manica beer.
They speak bitterly of
the brutality of Zimbabwean police.
The Marange fields were the scene of
a frenzied diamond rush from 2006 to
last year. Schoolchildren threw their
books into the bush and dug alongside
their teachers. Dealers booked into
the Holiday Inn in the nearby city of
Mutare.
President Robert
Mugabe's security forces ended the free-for-all last
November, moving into
the fields with dogs and guns. Rights groups say 200
people were killed. The
brutality nearly got Zimbabwe suspended from the
Kimberley Process
Certification Scheme (KPCS), the global diamond trade
body.
Earlier
this month, the KPCS gave Zimbabwe until June 2010 to implement a
plan to
bring it up to international standards.
But military abuses reportedly
continue.
"Zimbabwe is very bad," says a Somali dealer. He has a front
tooth missing
after a beating in Marange last year, he says. Police stole
£4,800 he was
carrying. "Our friend had both his legs broken two weeks ago.
He lost
£21,000," claims a dealer from Mali.
The dealers say it's
easier operating in Mozambique. The police leave them
alone if their
passports and visas are in order. They travel to and from
northern Nampula
province. The Zimbabwean diamonds they deal in go to Dubai
and then Asia.
They say the stones are mostly industrial grade, used for
machines.
In a clothes store, a Lebanese man in an Emporio Armani
T-shirt says he's
from Essex, where his three children go to school. His
brother has bought
property in Vila de Manica. "Now I sell stones," he
says.
He looks at my cheap flip-flops and moves away. I am obviously not
a serious
buyer.
It's getting harder to smuggle Zimbabwe's diamonds.
The authorities have
awarded contracts for Marange to two companies: Mbada
Mining, a little-known
local firm, and Canadile Miners, which has South
African investors. They are
investing heavily.
There's just one
problem: according to a court ruling, the claim belongs to
African
Consolidated Resources, a company listed on the London stock
exchange.
Desperate for money - mines minister Obert Mpofu believes diamonds
can bring
Zimbabwe £360,000 a day - the government has gone ahead with
mining, pending
an appeal.
A pharmacy in Mutare is sparsely stocked but can sell you an
electric
diamond scale for £20.
http://www.zimeye.org/?p=10502
By
John-Chimunhu
Published: November 15, 2009
Harare
Non-governmental organizations in Zimbabwe have vowed to continue a
boycott
of government functions in protest over continuing arrests of aid
workers,
an official has said.
National Association of Non Governmental
Organizations (NANGO) board
secretary Godwin Phiri told ZimEye that a
boycott of a conference convened
by justice minister Patrick Chinamasa on
October 28-30 was just a 'test case'
and more boycotts would
follow.
"We cannot participate in meetings with the government when our
leadership
is being arrested," Phiri said."We'll not create the impression
that
everything is okay when they are arresting our leaders. Where
government
invites us, we're not attending until the situation
improves."
The measure was taken following the arrest of Nango
chairperson Dadirai
Chikwengo and the organization's chief executive Cephas
Zinhumwe in Victoria
Falls. The two were accused of holding a political
meeting without police
clearance, a serious offence under the
much-criticized Public Order and
Security Act. The pair said they spent two
nights in 'filthy' cells. They
deny the charges, pointing out that the
meeting in question was the NGO
directors' summer school, an annual
event
Two officials from the Zimbabwe Election Support Network were
arrested two
days later in Dete under the same law, while a day later United
Nations
rapporteur on torture Manfred Nowak was detained overnight at Harare
airport
before being deported.
Commenting on the failure by NGOs to
meet with Chinamasa, Phiri said "in an
environment where the law is
arbitrarily applied against NGOs it would be
improper to endorse the
validity of such meetings through attendance".
Phiri said NGOs had a
right to comment on policy issues and decisions and to
participate in
'political discourse'. The government has repeatedly
threatened to shut down
NGOs that are critical of the Robert Mugabe's
policies.
http://www.radiovop.com/
Harare, November 16, 2009 - The
Solidarity Peace Trust has released
four videos to the media showing the
victims and testimonies of the horrific
political violence last year towards
June after President Robert Mugabe lost
to Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai
in the first round of the presidential
elections in March.
The videos which were shot last year as the country's political and
economic
crisis worsened, shows victims, mainly opposition supporters
narrating their
ordeals.
On two of the videos titled Democracy: Missing Presumed
Dead and After
the elections: A crisis in Zimbabwe, supporters of the
Movement for
Democratic Change (MDC) narrate the ordeals they went through,
how they were
abducted, beaten using various weapons that included
chains,iron bars, whips
while others were burnt under their feet with
burning grass for supporting a
'British' funded party.
The
other two videos are titled Death of a nation and A marriage of
in-convenience narrate the effects of the cholera epidemic and while the
other video chronicles stages to the formation of the inclusive
government.
The videos on violence shows property and houses that
were burnt down
and destroyed which were for MDC supporters in various parts
of the country
as Zanu PF supporters and state security agents reigned on
anyone perceived
to be an MDC supporter.
The role of the
dreaded government spy agency the CIO, the police and
the army is told in
the videos , how they were using state institutions to
suppress ordinary
people and how they used cars without registration plates
to abduct and kill
opposition supporters.
Names of Zanu PF Members of Parliament,
Newturn Kachepa, Edward
Raradza , Saviour Kasukuwere are mentioned
frequently in the testimonies by
the victims of the political violence on
their role in the violence against
MDC supporters.
Mugabe's
presidential run-off election campaign last year was
spearheaded and led by
the military at the highest level leaving dozens
dead, thousands displaced
and resulted in Tsvangirai pulling out of the
presidential race days before
the polling day citing 'unprecedented'
violence against his supporters by
Mugabe's Zanu PF supporters and state
security agents.
The MDC
has said over 200 of its supporters and officials were killed
in the
violence towards the presidential run-off election after the March
general
elections.
Although the government formed an organ on national
healing and
reconciliation led by the three political parties, victims of
the violence
have called for justice to be done and for the police to arrest
perpetrators
of violence.
The Solidarity Peace Trust is a Non
government organisation based in
South Africa and led by church leaders in
Southern Africa who are committed
to human rights , freedom and democracy.
The trust has already documented
rights abuses in Zimbabwe in the past
years.
--------
Comments
"Public knowledge" by samaita of the
N-pole at Monday, 16 November
2009 11:13
What you say is on the
tapes is largely public knowledge for people
who witnessed the elections
referred to in the story.What makes the tapes
important is that we have a
record of the ugly side of our country and its
leaders.The tapes can be very
useful in future efforts to ensure that these
sad events do not revisit us.I
know worse things about Kasukuwere and a lot
of people are not surprised to
know he is frequently mentioned.What is
missing is the real force behind the
violence, JOC and Bob.Hopefully those
messengers of the JOC can lead us to
its doorstep and describe the
instructions given and who gave them and what
they got in return.Most
important they can disclose where some people
unaccounted for up to this day
have been dumped and how they were
eliminated.Then and only then can the
nation be healed , what Nkomo and
Holland and Sibanda are doing will not
give a sustainable measure of
healing.We will get there
someday!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Comment by
Zvaigwadzavaisara at Monday, 16 November 2009 15:00
Zvichakupfukirai
vanaKasukuwere. Rinamanyanga hariputirwi, hayo mavideo
ongobuda. Manje kana
musingazivi kuti ngozi yerombe iganda nzara,
muchapfidza matadzo katatu
samaRoma. Everything is well document, yo hands
are dripping from innocent
blood yu massacred yu vampires. Manje let me tell
yu something mucharipa
mhosva dzenyu iyodzo pasi nekudenga.
http://www.swradioafrica.com/
By Lance Guma
16 November
2009
Robert Mugabe arrived in the Italian capital Rome on Saturday, for a
United
Nations food summit. Despite European Union targeted sanctions that
restrict
his travel Mugabe is allowed to travel to meetings that are under
the
auspices of the UN. The travel restrictions were put in place in 2002 in
response to widespread human rights abuses, but many observers are critical
of the fact that despite this, Mugabe and his ruling elite still get to go
on plenty of shopping trips.
The ZANU PF leader, blamed for
destroying Zimbabwe's economy through
corruption, mismanagement and bad
policies, showed his penchant for
extravagance by arriving at Italy's
Fiuminicino airport with over 60
officials. Exactly what this large
entourage is meant to be doing is not
clear. What is clear is that once
again the tax payer will foot the bill for
the hefty allowances given to
this entourage. Mugabe has brought hunger and
starvation to millions during
his brutal reign, and the irony of him
attending a 'food summit' was not
lost on anyone.
The UN's Food and Agriculture Organization is having a
three-day World
Summit on Food Security which began Monday. More than 60
other heads of
state, (the same number of people in Mugabe's entourage) are
expected to
attend the summit.
Mugabe remains determined to actively
stop farmers growing food and back
home his loyalists continue to disrupt
commercial farming operations by
using soldiers from the Zimbabwe National
Army to harass the remaining white
farmers in the country. The Commercial
Farmers Union predicts Zimbabwe will
have the worst harvest ever, with less
than 500 tonnes of maize being grown,
against national requirements of 1.8
million tones.
In October pressure group Zimbabwe Democracy Now called on
the UN to ban
Mugabe from attending UN meetings. They argued that in October
a UN special
rapporteur on torture, Manfred Nowak, was detained at Harare
International
Airport and told to get on the next plane out. Nowak was on an
8-day mission
that had previously been organized, and agreed to, by the
government, before
Mugabe made a u-turn.
'The United Nations allows
Mugabe (and his wife, and his ministers and
security people and various
relatives and other hangers-on) to visit the
United Nations offices wherever
they may be - in New York, Geneva or Rome.
The Mugabe's love this, because
it's the only way they can get round the
targeted sanctions and Grace, the
First Shopper, spends her 'crochet money'
on designer shoes and jewels,' the
group said.'
http://www.radiovop.com/
Johannesburg, November 16, 2009 -
Occupancy rates at hotels in
Zimbabwe, especially those for businessmen,
have trebled since last year,
pointing to signs of life in the battered
African economy, the country's
industry chief said on
Monday.
The improvement supports the claims of Zimbabwe's
troubled
power-sharing government that business and investment activity has
mushroomed since the worthless Zimbabwe dollar was scrapped nine months
ago.
"Rates were below 30 percent but already in the last
months -- most
notably in city-centre hotels -- they're up to 90 percent,"
Zimbabwe Council
of Tourism president Emmanuel Fundira told
Reuters.
"Much of this is business travellers coming in to look
at investments
and things like that," he said on the sidelines of an
investment conference
in South Africa. "That level of interest in Zimbabwe
is extremely
encouraging."
President Robert Mugabe and his
arch rival, Morgan Tsvangirai, agreed
to the unity government in September
2008 after disputed elections, but the
deal has yet to be implemented in
full and disputes over economic policy
continue to unnerve potential outside
investors.
Despite this, the government this month projected
economic growth for
this year of 3.7 percent, jumping to 12.5 percent next
year and 15 percent
on average for the period 2010-2015.
Occupancy rates at tourist-focused hotels, such as those near the
Victoria
Falls in the northwest border with Zambia, had not fared so well,
currently
enjoying only 40 percent occupancy, Fundira said.
However, he said
the government was still projecting tourism revenues
of $100 million for
2009, compared to just $40 million last year when the
country was riven by
political violence.
Shingi Munyeza, chief executive of
Zimbabwe-based hotel firm African
Sun Limited, backed Fundira's view, saying
some of his hotels in the country
were 70 percent full.
Despite its problems, all the signs pointed to the Mugabe-Tsvangirai
power-sharing deal muddling through, Munyeza said, providing a modicum of
stability that has helped stop the economic rot of the last
decade.
"We don't gloss over the issues. But we also are very
clear what is
the worst-case scenario from here. Will the guys pick up guns
and start
fighting? We think that if that was possible, it would have
happened a year
ago," Munyeza said.
"The very fact that the
parties that fought viciously with each other
are able to sit in parliament
for nine months and come up with productive
policies, is a miracle."
Reuters
http://www.thestar.co.za
MDC says parties have no option but to honour
deal
November 16, 2009 Edition 1
Stanley Gama
Zimbabwe's
partners in the coalition government, the Movement for Democratic
Change and
Zanu-PF, were due to meet in Harare today for make-or-break
negotiations.
Regional leaders have given the leaders until December
5 to resolve the
crisis.
Nine months into the inclusive government,
President Robert Mugabe and Prime
Minister Morgan Tsvangirai are still
haggling over outstanding issues from
the fragile Global Political Agreement
(GPA) that brought about the
coalition government.
The impasse
between Mugabe and Tsvangirai exploded last month when the MDC
temporarily
pulled out of the government, leaving the government paralysed
and in a
constitutional crisis.
This forced the guarantor to the unity deal, the
Southern African
Development Community (SADC), to intervene, and on November
5 it gave
Tsvangirai and Mugabe between 15 and 30 days to make sure they
implement the
outstanding issues.
President Jacob Zuma is expected to
visit Zimbabwe on December 6 to assess
whether they have resolved the
problem. He was assigned by SADC to
facilitate the implementation of the
deal.
MDC spokesman Nelson Chamisa said the parties had no option but to
fully
implement what they agreed to when the GPA was signed.
"This is
a straightforward case which does not need days to complete because
everything was agreed by the parties. We therefore expect full
implementation of the GPA, and expect the negotiators to embrace the letter
and spirit of the GPA.
"All the chapters, commas, full stops,
clauses, punctuation marks,
signatures and paragraphs must be respected and
must be complied with. The
political parties must agree on implementation so
that we do not embarrass
SADC, who are guarantors to the deal.
"We
are, however, conscious of the stubbornness and insincerity in Zanu-PF.
They
are dragging their feet and are reluctant to implement reforms, and we
hope
that this time around they come to the meetings more serious so that we
can
move the country forward," said Chamisa.
Efforts to obtain comment from
Zanu-PF spokespersons and negotiators were in
vain. But it has been reliably
learnt that Mugabe is already showing signs
of giving in on a number of
issues, suggesting that today's meeting could
make a
breakthrough.
Mugabe and Tsvangirai met last week in what insiders say
was a fruitful
meeting, where the two political heavyweights agreed on a
number of reforms
pertaining to the media.
"Mugabe and Tsvangirai
agreed on the media reforms when they met last week,
and all what's left is
for the president to announce the various media
commissions which will pave
the way for the coming in of new players in the
media," said a top
government official.
Among the outstanding issues the MDC wants
implemented are the appointment
of provincial governors; the appointment of
the attorney-general and the
Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe governor; the swearing
in of deputy minister of
agriculture-designate Roy Bennett; and other
complaints, such as the slow
progress in the constitution-making process and
the continued harassment of
MDC supporters and officials.
Mugabe, on
the other hand, wants the MDC to help remove targeted sanctions
and to stop
foreign radio stations like the Voice of America broadcasting in
Zimbabwe. -
Independent Foreign Service
(AFP) - 3 hours
ago
HARARE - An international crime syndicate is behind an escalation in
poaching in Zimbabwe which has slaughtered 65 elephants and 30 rhinos this
year, a wildlife official said Monday.
"From January to October this
year we have lost 65 elephants through
poaching," Vitalis Chadenga,
operations director of the Zimbabwe National
Parks and Wildlife Authority
told journalists.
"In the same period we have lost 24 black and six white
rhinos. It is true
that we have witnessed an escalation of poaching
nationwide, particularly on
private farms."
The black rhino is listed
as critically endangered by the International
Union for Conservation of
Nature and the white rhino is categorised as "near
threatened."
"We
do have a group of international gangsters, who are funding poachers
around
this part of the world and taking away many horns and it is a major
problem," Chadenga said.
He could not provide numbers from last year,
but said poaching was on the
rise.
"We have arrested 2,500 poachers
in the same period, ten poachers have been
shot dead since the beginning of
this year," Chadenga said.
Zimbabwe has a population of nearly 100,000
elephants, which Chadenga said
has been growing over recent years, and is
banned from international ivory
trade.
The southern African nation
has 26 tonnes of ivory in its stocks and four
tonnes of rhino
horns.
Last year, Zimbabwe auctioned four tonnes of ivory to buyers from
Japan and
China getting 487,162 dollars (380,268 euros). During the same
period,
Namibia, Botswana and South Africa sold a total of 102 tonnes of
tusks.
The four countries are home to 312,000 elephants, and their
government
stocks of tusks came from natural deaths or the culling of herds
to keep the
population under control.
November 16, 2009 By Takarinda Gomo HOW refreshing it is to hear that the Sadc ministerial review team that
recently visited Zimbabwe to review implementation of the Global Political
Agreement (GPA) recommended that the Reserve Bank Governor should be relieved of
his post. Here is an excerpt of what the troika ministers recommended, among other
things: “The Governor of the Reserve Bank should be assigned to another position
as a way of conversion.” Before you say chickens have come home to roost, listen to what Ephraim
Masawi deputy to Nathan Shamuyarira in the Zanu-PF politburo told the Standard,
in his capacity as party spokesman: “Gono is just a Governor to the RBZ (Reserve
Bank of Zimbabwe). Whether he goes or stays, it does not affect Zanu-PF.” In Shona language, the reflex reaction among many people would be, “Ho Nhai?”
(Really?) So Zanu-PF is preparing to spit Gono out at long last? Lest people forget, Gono became the centre of attraction in Zimbabwe in 2008
because everybody in Zimbabwe was affected, albeit in very tormenting ways. That
is why ordinary people, except those who benefited from the loot, are baying for
Gono’s blood. In dispensing largesse to the Zanu-PF leadership, and to senior officers in
the army, police, intelligence and prison services, Gono was paying insurance
premium for future protection when the chips are down. That is why many people
believe the change of tone displayed by Masawi is either mere bluff to divert
attention, or perhaps it can be true that the chickens have indeed finally come
home to roost. Is it possible for Zanu-PF to dump Gono who keeps records of who was given
what? Can all those recipients of tractors, combined harvesters, scotch carts,
harrows and ploughs come forward and tell the nation that they received loans
from the central bank to purchase that equipment, and that they are actually
servicing the loans? Can somebody ask Oppah Muchinguri and Olivia Muchena, who were last year
reported as having gone on a tour of RBZ vaults and come out driving new sleek
KB Isuzu vehicles, now registered in their names, explain what really
happened? When push comes to shove, it is possible to just blow Gono out of the Reserve
Bank, like someone blowing their nose. The problem is that time is ticking away
and December 6, 2009, the deadline agreed in Maputo is just around the corner.
The Umtshini Wami warrior, Jacob Zuma is coming to Harare to ensure that all GPA
outstanding issues have been implemented. That is a tall order and some people
just have to be sacrificed. Gono is dispensable, without causing much political
turbulence among and between delegates who will attend the forthcoming “Congress
of the People”, penciled in for December 8, 2009, just two days after Zuma’s
visit! The bone of contention is, should Gono go alone like a lamb led to the
slaughter, or should he be allowed to name names of all those who benefited from
his illicit largesse? If this inclusive government in general and the two MDC formations in
particular, want to be taken seriously, they should not just ask Gono to leave
the central bank. He should also be held accountable for what he did during his
tenure at RBZ. That is the essence of justice. A Commission of Inquiry should be immediately be set up with sweeping terms
of reference that allows it to hold public hearings. Among other things the
Commission should: It is a fact that Gono did not loot as a lone ranger. He should be given an
opportunity, during the open hearing, to expose those who have taken possession
of State assets illegally, and if they are convicted, then Justice will not only
have been done; but will also be seen to have been done. Punishing evil doers has this cathartic effect that confirms the universal
belief in the ultimate triumph of good over evil.
Email: jag@mango.zw; justiceforagriculture@zol.co.zw
Please
send any material for publication in the Open Letter Forum to
jag@mango JAG OPEN LETTER FORUM - No..zw with "For
Open Letter
Forum" in the subject
line.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1.
Will I be back? - Cathy Buckle
2. What will Santa bring Zimbabwe? - Ed
Cross
3. Old Mutual issue - Kevin Grant
4. LIFE IN MUGABE'S
ZIMBABWE - Robb WJ Ellis
5. Old Mutual issue - Dave Wood
6. Time
for Action and Prayer.-
Namatai
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1.
Will I be back? - Cathy Buckle
Dear Jag
If you think things are
back to normal in Zimbabwe, just walk into a
bank. It's something I haven't
done for many months and flipping
through my last cheque book reminded me of
the mayhem of our banks less
than a year ago. My cheque stubs look like
something from a crazy
kindergarten. There's a payment for a telephone bill
of four hundred
million dollars, another to a dentist for forty one billion
dollars.
There's a deposit of four trillion, six hundred billion dollars
and
another page showing a balance on hand of fourteen trillion dollars.
One
page is slashed through in red ink with the words: "NB: Aug 08: 10
zeroes
removed by Gono." And then, in October 2008, also in red ink on a
cheque
stub are the words: "Can't get in bank, queues of
thousands."
It seems like a lifetime ago but in fact it's just a year ago
that
this was happening and now of course Zimbabwe doesn't even have its
own
currency - thanks to Zanu PF and Reserve Bank Governor Mr
Gono.
Zimbabwe's much talked about sovereignty is long gone when it comes
to
the economy and now we buy and sell in US dollars and South African
Rand.
Having been taught since childhood to save, save save, I decided it
was
time to get back into the banking habit.
I was the only customer
in the newly refurbished international bank in my
home town last week. Yes I
still have an account, they told me after
tapping in my numbers, but it's no
longer valid. The balance left there
in January 2009 of trillions, or was it
quadrillions, is gone -
apparently eaten up by devaluation and ledger fees,
not converted to
'real' US dollar money. A new account number has been
allocated to me,
the bank said but it's dormant and requires a deposit of 20
US dollars to
bring it to life. No, the bank say, the money left in my
account doesn't
qualify to activate the new account, you must deposit REAL
money they
insist. Once this has been done I enquire about a cheque book - oh
no, we
haven't got any yet I'm told. And an ATM card - oh please, what planet
am
I on to be asking such an insane question!
A week later with the
account open and activated I take a deep breath and
embark on the first
withdrawal. I am the only customer in the bank and my
shoes click loudly as I
cross the polished floor. The lady at the
enquiries desk is applying her
makeup and doesn't stop as I stand in
front of her. She won't tell me if my
expected transfer has arrived. She
says I have to fill in a slip before she
can tap the number into the
computer. She doesn't have any slips, I've got to
get them from a man
sitting at a desk back at the entry door. I walk back
across the banking
hall, the man is busy chatting and laughing to someone on
the phone. He
ignores me until he is finished. I fill in the slip back at the
enquiries
desk while the lady carries on with her face decorating, mirror in
hand,
lips pouted.
Finally with a completed cash withdrawal slip in
hand I approach the only
teller on duty. I am still the only customer but
have to wait because the
teller is busy - chatting to a friend. At last I'm
noticed, the friend
steps aside and I am served. My greeting to the teller is
ignored. My
slip is checked, ticked and stamped and then all the information
is
copied, written by hand into a ledger. This fools me completely
because
the electricity is on and the computer screen at the teller's
side
is working. The teller takes my ID, withdrawal slip and ledger book
and
disappears. When he reappears he says: 'What about my commission?'
What
commission I ask, saying I wasn't informed there would be a
commission
and saying that I know the depositor paid bank transfer fees
and
commissions at the other end. "No," he says, you have to pay
a
commission." I am then told to deduct the amount and change and
counter
sign all the amounts written in words and numbers on the now stamped
and
signed withdrawal slips to allow the bank its commission.
Finally
after 17 minutes and now with one other customer in the bank, the
money looks
like it may be forthcoming. The teller shouts out through the
bullet proof
glass to someone in the back to bring him bank notes. They
only have small
denominations it turns out and finally these appear in a
locked steel box.
Checked and rechecked below the counter, the teller
finally pushes a pile of
notes across to me. No, I say, I wish you to
count the notes to me. "What?"
he says. I repeat my request and he rolls
his eyes and with an audible sigh,
the bank notes are counted to me. 26
minutes later and again the only person
in this very well known
international bank, I leave.
Will I be back
soon - I don't think so. This is the face of Zimbabwe for
investors and
tourists, what a shocking disgrace both for a country and
an international
bank.
Until next week, thanks for still reading, love
Cathy
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2.
What will Santa bring Zimbabwe? - Ed Cross
The sense of insecurity and
uncertainty has never been more foreboding.
Talk of the Reserve Bank printing
a new currency behind closed doors and
in great secrecy and the President
saying last week that the local
currency would be back by the end of the
year. The sudden withdrawal of
the MDC from the transitional government and
the subsequent negotiations,
have all thrown the Zimbabwean population into
the slough of despond.
Whatever the truth, the community fears a return
to the situation that
prevailed in 2008. Businessmen fear that they will wake
up one morning
and find their hard currency accounts converted to a new local
currency
that is basically worthless at a rate set by the Reserve Bank. They
fear
the imposition of restrictions on prices and a return to the harsh
regime
of the recent past.
The slow recovery in the banking system has
evaporated, a run on the
banks has put severe strain on cash flows and this
is not helped by
information that the Reserve Bank has been misappropriating
the reserves
of the commercial Banks. People are suddenly reverting to a
strictly cash
system.
The revelation that the Ministry of Youth and
Empowerment has
clandestinely drafted new regulations that would expropriate,
without
compensation, 51 per cent of the shareholding of all foreign firms
with a
capital value of more than $500 000 has simply halted all FDI
activity.
Firms that are already invested in Zimbabwe have frozen their
operations
here and those thinking about new investments have stopped
all
preparations and plans.
Without FDI there will be no significant
recovery in the economy and no
growth in the mining and tourism sectors - the
only sectors that
are likely to lead the recovery in the economy. Billions of
dollars of
new investment in both these sectors are now frozen and will not
be
invested unless the government moves to remove this uncertainty and
to
clarify what our intentions really are. The damage is so severe that
it
will take more than a few statements to remedy the problems.
The El
Nino factor has suddenly intensified with the news that
temperatures in the
Pacific have risen by 1,5 C. and this suggests that
we must anticipate a
below average wet season. The early signs are not
encouraging and after a
series of good seasons including a near perfect
season last year, we must
expect a rough season. Even without the
problems of a dry season, this year
is going to be another disaster.
Commercial farm production will be down even
on last year. We are
distributing small quantities of seed and fertilizer to
600 000 families
in rural areas but this is scratching the surface of their
needs.
Worse, I sense that the international community is weary of the
ongoing
Zimbabwe crisis that seems to have no end. A needs survey is underway
and
I am sure the outcome is going to shock the authorities - people
have
no food stocks and the hunger season is about to start and resources
have
declined and the global situation no longer makes it easy to raise
the funds
needed to prevent starvation.
So what can we, as Zimbabweans expect for
Christmas? Not much, I am
afraid. Talks to end the crisis in government
started on Friday, the
deadline for their resolution looms and what then? Our
experience tells
us not to expect too much. But so much is required to
alleviate our
difficulties.
So long as we are forced to tread water by
the grip that Zanu PF holds
over the reform process, we run the threat of
being drowned by the waves
generated by the storm that rages above our heads.
It is at times like
these that faith counts.
When Christ began his
long walk to the Cross He knew the odds and the
likely outcome. His followers
refused to accept the reality of that and
at the end they tried to use force
to defend the man when His freedom and
life were threatened. Christ made no
moves to defend Himself and went to
the Cross without complaint or
struggle.
What followed was in fact more than His disciples could have
asked or
imagined. His death was followed by a demonstration of
God's
control over life and death and the final stamp of authenticity
for
Christ's life and ministry. In weeks the ultimate defeat was
turned
into victory and in 300 years the World worshipped the one they
had
killed and who had then demonstrated absolute control.
Christ's
teaching that "in the world you will have
tribulation" are more than true for
the average Zimbabwean, but
somehow the truth of the next sentence "but be of
good cheer, I
have overcome the world" suddenly changes everything. The man
who
died at the hands of a corrupt Judge and on the whim of a cruel
dictator,
actually was in charge and has made it possible for us to do
the
impossible, including fighting on when all else seems to fail
us.
So we turn to Christ at this season and suddenly find that He
turns
lemons into oranges and failure into victory, death into life. All
that
He asks is that "we walk by faith and not by sight", He knew
that if
we kept our eyes on the storm, we would never see his hand
inviting us into
the safety and security of the boat.
The sceptics say this is just mumbo
jumbo and pie in the sky, however
those of us in the water, in the storm,
know the reality is something
else. It is real and tangible and can be relied
upon and all who
"call on the name of the Lord, will be saved" and if you
read
the bible carefully it is not talking about pie in the sky.
For
those of you who are of the faith, remember Roy Bennett this week.
Roy told
me on Friday that he feared that no matter what the evidence
was, the
authorities were determined to find him guilty and to sentence
him. The
charges are serious but without foundation - the Judge is
clearly under
instruction and from confidential documents we have seen,
the old regime is
determined to press this case to a conclusion even if
they have to fabricate
the evidence.
It is a statement of great faith and courage as well as
commitment to his
country and our people that he remains here and goes to
Court knowing
that the authorities are trying to find him guilty. This is
tough on Roy
but also think of Heather, his wife, for whom the whole ordeal
is so much
worse.
Eddie Cross
Bulawayo, 14th November
2009
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
3.
Old Mutual issue - Kevin Grant
Dear Jag,
I am rather surprised not
to see more comments on the Old Mutual issue,
because so many people must
have lost their investments since the demise
of the Zim economy??However it
is pleasing to note that Mr P. Mangwende
is keeping the issue alive and more
recently, COSATU IN RSA, seems to
want to take on the OM about their
shareholding in the Herald propaganda
machine!
Roger Freshman also
raises another smelly issue, the Farm Workers Pension
Scheme?? What remains
of that today? But my main contention remains, and
that is to get the OM to
be answerable to where all our investments in
pension schemes over the past
20yrs have gone. They cannot be worthless!!
The OM led us to believe that
their employees are financial experts, so
they must have hedged the wealth of
OM, WHICH IS WHY OM IS STILL WEALTHY
IN ZIM-with shares worth something after
all this time???Why then if they
hedged their own company wealth, did they
not do the same with our
pension premiums?
As we paid in money, it was
good, strong currency, but weakened over time
as the govt. became rotten. The
clever fellows at Head Office must have
placed profits in floating assets
that would hold value, in order to
retain the company value. But they didn't
do the same for the policy
holders???
Between the Zim govt and Old
MUTUAL THERE MUST BE A FAIR SOLUTION TO THIS
ISSUE. Pension schemes must
surely be honoured at a reasonable value,
especially since the Old Mutual is
still up and running and financially
strong.
A strong case now
perhaps, for us to be allowed to move our shares
offshore, since many of us
have left Zim and reaching pensionable age??
The Old MUTUAL ARE IN
DEFAULT AND HAVE AN OBLIGATION TO FULFIL.
Probably a pie in the sky, but
on principle, why should the OM be allowed
to continue with
impunity.
The OM IS FULL OF MONEY IN THE REGION AND INTERNATIONALLY,
money made
from folks like us who trusted them. I would be surprised if they
were
actually hurt by the Zim developments at all.
Old Mutual should,
just like Nestle, should be exposed and be made
accountable for their
irregularities.
Kevin
Grant.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
4.
LIFE IN MUGABE'S ZIMBABWE - Robb WJ Ellis
In the free world, we manage to
live quite easily from one day to the
next. We also have a little bit of
money that allows us to enjoy life a
little more, whilst we live in houses
that have all the amenities that we
would expect.
We have electricity
and water.
We can walk into a shop and chose what we want to purchase,
pay for it
and take it away with us.
If we are ill or sick, we can
visit a general practitioner and get help
and medication to treat the
problem. If we need surgery or specialist
treatment, we can get that
relatively easily - and I should know as I
have been the recipient of
specialist treatment and caring in the last
nine years since my
accident.
Children are educated here, and if our motor cars need fuel, we
go to the
petrol garage.
Even though the country is coming out of a
worldwide recession, jobs are
pretty easy to get - although quite a bit
harder to secure for the
handicapped and disabled.
Law and order seems
to function well, and daily we read and hear of the
criminal element in
society being punished for their crimes.
In other words, much of our
lives here in the United Kingdom is normal,
affordable and quite
comfortable.
Remember that Robert Mugabe rejects anything remotely
English or colonial
- but bleats loudly because he and his wife (and many of
his senior
followers) cannot visit here because of the targeted travel
sanctions in
place against them.
My family left Zimbabwe eleven years
ago - before the rapid deterioration
in the country began in earnest - and so
my experience of a country on
its knees is limited to the experiences shared
by writers and film makers
on the internet.
And you can't argue with
basic video evidence that shows the
degradation of what used to be a
beautiful country.
Don't get me wrong - much of the natural beauty is
still apparent,
but it is the infrastructure that was built up to lend to the
aesthetic
quality that now works against that beauty to offer it as a grim
reminder
of what once was.
The roads in Zimbabwe are littered with
potholes - potholes big enough to
rip an exhaust system off, tear a wheel
off, or cause other damage that
few can afford.
The normal services
such as garbage collection have virtually been
forgotten, with waste being
piled high in the streets, the neighbourhood
dogs allowed free rein, fighting
with the street people who dig anxiously
for something to eat, to wear, to
sell.
Electricity - produced at Kariba Dam - is severely rationed, with
some
coming from the Cabora Bassa in Mozambique. But it still isn't
enough
with the country spending much of the day in darkness and without
power -
without warning or excuse.
Water is a problem, insofar as there is never
enough of it, and what does
get through is not treated and could carry all
manner of water borne
illnesses.
Shop shelves are full once again, but
unless you have the South African
rand, the British pound, or the American
greenback, commodities are out
of reach - and if you have the currency, you
are probably paying over the
odds anyway.
The problems in Zimbabwe
continue to mount up, and, by way of comparison,
here in the United Kingdom,
we may spend our days in the comfort of our
homes, warm, clean, fed and
watered, whilst many, many people in Zimbabwe
spend their days wondering how
they can get through today - just so that
they can do it all over again
tomorrow
That's not a life!
Robb WJ
Ellis
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
5.
Old Mutual issue - Dave Wood
Dear JAG
In response to Roger
Freshmans letter.
Roger, Roger, Roger, Roger!! Have you all finally woken
up to the Old
Mutual saga this very minute? No one at the time, complained
when they
were moving all our funds - amounting to hundreds of millions of
Dollars,
to off shore accounts. Yes, it was all conducted with Gono's
approval,
through the money market in Harare. We refer to it as "money
laundering"
in the West. OM were working with the RBZ. We bought local shares
and
redeemed them a few days later and were paid out in the UK. Everyone
did
it!!! How do you think we managed to import our agric inputs during
our
final farming days? What? Walk into Barclays and ask them for
US$250
000-00 to pay my fert bill. No! We went to Mr. X, who did it all for
us.
Anyway, OM are the tip of the iceberg! If you really want to
talk
"skulduggery", then take a very close look at Anglo and Impala
Platinum.
Our Organisation has had a direct inroad into both those
organisations
for a very long time - not via office clerks, but through
senior
management. All I am prepared to say for now, is that if one
applies
pressure to these 2 then Mugabe and his lot are out pretty smartly!
Don't
worry about Bob bringing in the Chinese to take over - it is easier
said
than done. Yes, that is how bad it is. Between the two of them
they
are entirely responsible for propping up Mugabe and his regime.
By
pressure, I am not referring to the JAG forum, I am referring
to
international pressure. So let's see what the JAG readers can come
up
with. Then we can continue with Barclays, Billy Rautenbach etc. etc.
to
name a few others.
To those of you who harp on about the plight of
the farm workers- come
on, get real! We employed close on 250 people. The
majority of them
during the early days were pro us all being kicked off our
farms. You
must all remember, none of them had travelled to Zambia,
Mozambique,
Angola, Tanzania, Uganda, Sudan, Somalia.... (In fact every
square inch
of Africa) to see what it was like living under a black
government and
having a black boss. So they had no idea it all would not
work. But!
Today they know that the Western European will not let them
starve. They
couldn't care less if they made a mistake - so what! So out
comes the
begging bowl. They honestly couldn't give two hoots if
commercial
agriculture does not exist. This is the reality of Africa folks!
This is
how it works, this is how the senior men in African Governments want
it
to be. It then becomes easier to loot, pillage and plunder. And do
not
think for one minute South Africa is excluded. Out of 3200 farms
bought
or expropriated by the SA Government 2800 have become non producers.
Look
at what is happening with the CEO's of Escom and Armscor, look at the
ex
chief of police - Selebi. The list is endless .. but the breakdown
is
happening faster than you and I can blink. Don't get me wrong - I am
not
a racist - I am a realist, I ask questions, before giving answers. If
you
remember what Mobuto stole in the DRC and what Dos Santos is steeling
in
Angola, and Chiluba, Banda, Museveni etc etc. then you must all
realise
that Mugabe is no different.
As for Ben Freeths trip to the
USA - Ben you are wasting your time and
effort. The West is not at all
interested in our problems - we have
nothing to offer, we have no oil!! But,
at the same time we are a
reliable dumping ground for their surplus food
products - so why change
it all? If Tsvangarai can't even restore law and
order on the farms how
do you expect Hilary to do it - she has enough
problems on her hands with
that "old rogue dagga boy" Bill !
John, if
JAG can get 100 farmers back on their farms I will personally
see to it that
you are resettled on a nice farm in the heart of "Harley
Street" in London,
care of the Queen! Do yourselves all a favour and buy
the book - " A
Capitalistic Nigger". It is written by a black Kenyan
chap. It is well worth
the read - he has hit the nail on the head in
every sentence, every paragraph
and every chapter, in his book. How wrong
we all were when we thought the rot
would stop at the Zambezi all those
years ago - it will only stop at Cape
Aghulus, when they have destroyed
every inch of Africa - sad, very, very
sad!
To the folk at JAG - I can only say "That it takes men on white
horses
and not cockroaches on sticks" to try and achieve the unachievable!
You
are the folk on the white horses, but unfortunately it is
virtually
impossible to eradicate the cockroaches on the sticks- the
rot
has unfortunately set in, and is here to stay. Reality, Reality,
Reality,
Reality!!!!
May the Zambezi Valley remain the memory it once
was - "Gods
Valley".
Dave
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
6.
Time for Action and Prayer.- Namatai
As a Black Zimbabwean citizen, I am
deeply grieved by the stories of
continued farm occupation. For the 10 years
that these occupations have
been going on, there is nothing to show for it in
economic terms except
disaster. Yet with these compelling facts, the
inclusive government
whose main priority is supposed to be Economic
Development is doing
things that compromise this development.
The
Socialist Agricultural system that we have adopted is seemingly not
working.
People are given "offer letters" and the land is supposed to
belong to the
state for at least 99 years. Whereas Ian Smith said "not
in a thousand
years", it seems our government is saying "not in 99 years"
will we have
private property rights again. It's a cursed system I
believe. As a
Christian, I believe the system of property rights is
biblical. The book of
Joel speaks of God entering into judgement against
a nation that "divides the
land of Israel." What does it mean to divide
the land of Israel? Israel
represents land (property) and that property
has ownership just like God gave
the various tribes of Israel ownership
of land. When you disregard property
rights, I believe you qualify into
that state of dividing God's land and
eventually provoking his wrath.
The government must immediately honour
property rights and abide by the
law if we are to redeem our
economy.
So, one may want to know, where do we go from here. The
people
in control are seemingly not wanting to reform to these biblical
values.
But SADC has come out with a communiqué dated 5 November that
calls
the parties to honour the GPA in its entirety and the SADC communiqué
of
27 Jan. The one of 27 Jan called for discussions on the offices of
the
Attorney General and the Reserve Bank governor. This was an
effective
win for the forces of reform in government. It's up to
SADC
particularly South Africa to ensure the timeline is respected.
The
ruling of the SADC Tribunal must also be respected I believe.
Most
importantly "PRAY AND SEEK GOD'S FACE." He will definitely hear
us.
Winds of change are upon us and Victory in Jesus' name is
close.
Regards
Namatai
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
All
letters published on the open Letter Forum are the views and opinions
of the
submitters, and do not represent the official viewpoint of Justice
for
Agriculture.
If anyone were to use one word to describe the judicial system
in Zimbabwe,
we might hope for words like 'fair' and 'just' - perhaps even a
word like
'equal' may make the listing - but alas, such a list would be a
lie.
I worked within the judicial system in Zimbabwe in the early to
mid-1980s
and watched the legal wheels turn, and perhaps then my only
criticism would
be that they turned ponderously slow.
But fast
forward to the same system in the courts in Zimbabwe today and we
witness an
entirely different story.
One of the cases which has sprung to prominence
is the banditry, terrorism
and weapons charges which have been preferred
against Roy Bennett, the white
commercial farmer who has become a regular
target for the Mugabe
'treatment'.
Roy "Pachedu" Bennett has already
spent time in Mugabe's disgusting jails,
having been imprisoned by
Parliament for pushing Patrick Chinamasa to the
ground reacting to being the
subject of a Chinamasa haranguing in which
Bennett's forefathers were
labelled as 'thieves' and 'murderers'. But that
was only the last straw in
the wholesale abuse of Roy Bennett, his family,
his farm and his farm
workers. Prior to that, Mugabe sent the army in to
steal his farm. The army
killed one his workers, brutalised and raped others
and the stress of this
whole sorry saga caused his pregnant wife to lose
their child.
Mugabe
makes no secret of his dislike of the whites in general and Bennett
in
particular.
The evidence that Mugabe's prosecuting council - none other
than his
unilaterally appointed Attorney-General - will use is fabricated,
elicited
under duress and torture, manufactured and presented displaying the
utmost
prejudice.
The State's key witness, one Michael Hitschmann, a
former firearms dealer
from the Eastern Highlands town of Mutare, is alleged
to have implicated
Bennett in his 'confession' obtained under torture.
Hitschmann supposedly
heard and discussed with Bennett an intended
conspiracy to assassinate
Mugabe.
Hitschmann spent 2 ½ years in
Mugabe's prisons for his 'crimes'.
Mugabe's state council have worked
tirelessly to present the Bennett case in
the worst possible light, and even
went so far as to issue the indictment at
the courthouse and have his bail
revoked. Bennett spent a few days
languishing once again in Mugabe prisons -
possibly amongst the worst in the
world.
Mugabe has refused to swear
Bennett into cabinet, stating that he is facing
serious charges - which
carry the death penalty if a conviction is secured -
and prefers to wait for
the court to 'exhaust their authority' before he can
consider any
move.
Mugabe talked himself in full circle by bringing up the subject of
pardons,
stating that any pardon can only be applied once the court has
completed
their remit. How is it then that Mugabe was able to issue a
blanket pardon
for all persons involved in the Gukurahundi in the early to
mid-1980s in
Matabeleland and the Midlands?
Was he not obliged to
wait due court process before issuing such an order?
Bennett has lost his
Chimanimani farm, his wife lost a baby, and then he
sought refuge in South
Africa - a safe haven - until it was deemed 'safe' to
return by none other
than the South African government.
His very livelihood was plucked from
his hand, illegally and with undue and
specific force. He and his family
have had to realign themselves to being
displaced persons, dispossessed
commercial farmers, and yet Mugabe is not
happy with that.
He wants
Bennett to suffer. And so Bennett does. Under Mugabe's evil eye and
deathlike grip on Zimbabwe and the law courts, he has little option but to
rely heavily upon his legal representative to ensure that justice is
preserved.
Bennett is innocent. If there is anyone out there who
believes in justice
and fair play and can put a stop to this farcical
charade, justice will be
well and truly served.
The Attorney-General
does not just do Zimbabwe an injustice by being where
he is - but the whole
of Africa.
The man is ignorant of court procedure, and although the
defence council,
Beatrice Mtetwa, is making mincemeat of him, the judge, who
has already
sidestepped a defence request to recuse himself, will obviously
do what he
is told rather than the right thing.
The Attorney-General
has no respect for courts or legal system - what little
remains of
it.
And since when does the Zimbabwean Attorney-General prosecute a case
in
court? That has to be a first!
But it is Mugabe who should facing
treason charges because he is the one
with the blood of thousands of
innocent Zimbabweans on his hands.
There is a long list of people who
have faced the very same charges that
Bennett currently faces. In every
single case, the charges have been
dismissed. Mugabe has corrupted the
judiciary to such an extent that he now
uses 'the law' and his judiciary as
tools of oppression, as a method to tie
his victims up financially and to
divert their attention.
What is different in Bennett's case is the extent
to which the
Attorney-General's office have gone to create
'evidence'.
Mugabe desperately wants Bennett convicted.
Not the
Mugabe justice that would see people die at the hands of his
minions, but
the justice that every sane person in the world seeks. Justice
is the right
to a fair hearing, reasonable punishment if found guilty - and
entire
vindication if cleared in a court of law.
Justice should be blind - blind
to colour creed and religion - but in
Zimbabwe it is prolonged, pro-Mugabe
and pro-ZANU PF.
In Zimbabwe, the law has become an ass.
Robb WJ
Ellis
The Bearded Man
http://mandebvhu.instablogs.com/entry/justice-honesty-integrity-the-three-missing-elements-in-roy-bennetts-trial/
http://www.zimonline.co.za
by Mutumwa Mawere Monday
16 November 2009
OPINION: Africa's future is our business.
Its legacy is and should be shaped
by our own experiences, actions and
choices. We have the power to change
Africa and yet many of us feel
powerless.
We all know that the identity of any society is inextricably
linked to the
actions of people who choose to be part of the social contract
that
underpins the society's foundation.
This is the first part of 30
conversations whose themes are drawn from
selected comments and questions
that have been directed at me by readers and
followers of my own personal
business and professional journey.
On November 15 2009, I received the
following message from a facebook
contact:
"I know sometimes people
will ask from you as I am now, some things can
never be duplicated but if
you can pass some of your legacy onto our
generation it would be most
welcome. As a young Zimbabwean I fail to escape
the business mentality that
has been prevailing. So I would like to learn
from you in any way possible
to establish businesses that transcend
generations and that will inevitably
set a higher standard in our country."
The question posed is no
different from the many questions that I receive
everyday. Unfortunately,
being only human there are limits to what I can
personally digest and more
importantly respond to.
God has not made it easy on
humanity.
Irrespective of one's station in life, there is little one can
do to
increase the number of hours in a day.
Accordingly, rich or
poor we all have the same access to God's time and,
therefore, it is
important to organise ourselves. I have learnt that the
only enduring power
that people who have no power is the power to organise.
If for instance,
we decide to convert an idea like AHS to a bank or
insurance company, there
is nothing that can stop us. However, if we bank
with people we purport to
despise then there is no one to blame that the
people who make the wrong
choices.
There is no conspiracy out there preventing us to conspire about
Africa's
future let alone Zimbabwe's. No political leader will do for
citizens what
they cannot do for themselves. After all citizens only get
leaders they
deserve.
In the quietness of my time, I also have been
reflecting on what is required
to establish institutions that transcend
generations and that will have a
legacy impact.
I have come to accept
that faith is the most powerful instrument to make
human beings do what
ordinarily would be impossible to imagine. Each of us
is ordinary but
together we can produce extraordinary outcomes.
If, for example, Jesus
Christ were to come back to earth, he will no doubt
be pleasantly surprised
that his legacy still lives on.
Equally, Prophet Mohammed's legacy is
still intact. The number of
institutions that have been built on the back of
faith are staggering.
It was Christ who said that if two or three people
meet in my name then he
would be there.
If people choose not to meet
in the name of Christ, then it would be
difficult to imagine how
Christianity like other religions has managed to
prevail.
When the
first Christian church was built, Christ was not there for people
to consult
and yet many institutions have been built because of him.
People often
want to blame leaders for their lack of progress.
What is even more
remarkable is that they expect, for instance, that merely
because I have
chosen to share my insights in the public domain that I have
superior
answers to issues that confront many of us in life. This is simply
not the
case.
Often we want to look for solutions from outside our circle of
influence.
Each individual is sovereign and there is nothing one cannot
do if they set
their mind to it.
Success is linked to attitude. A
right attitude can make altitude elastic
and scalable.
When we are in
the valley we are challenged by the steepness of the climb
but what makes
the heights scalable is the idea that someone else has walked
the
path.
It is never easy to scale the heights but what is satisfying is
that the
experience inspires many in the valley to invest in
hope.
People who understand and appreciate the true meaning or
meaningless of life
are better builders of enduring institutions than people
who live for the
present.
Human beings value immortality and yet
generation after generation who have
come to learn that what we leave on
earth are memories of our experiences.
To the extent that human life is
perishable, all one can do in life is to
play one's part. There is nothing
that man has done in life that is meant
for the dead.
For those of us
who have chosen business as a vocation, we all know that
shareholders do not
own businesses and more importantly that human beings
are incapable of
owning anything.
Through the instrumentality of companies, human beings
can do more together
without suffering the burden of constantly dealing with
the ownership issue.
Even the rich are not guaranteed a better life than
the poor. In the final
analysis the poor may very well lead a stress-free
life than the few who may
be privileged to have access to
resources.
If in the construction of life as we know it human beings are
incapable of
owning anything then the challenge is to bridge the knowledge
divide on some
of the critical and fundamental principles that allow nations
to progress.
One has to start appreciating the very idea of what it means
to be African,
what heritage means and finally what obligations are imposed
in terms of
nation building.
At the nation state level, we have to
interrogate the notion of what it
means to be, for example, Zimbabwean. To
be or not to be is a choice. Being
born in Zimbabwe does not entitle one to
citizenship. One could be born in
Zimbabwe and yet choose to be a citizen of
another country.
If Zimbabwe belongs to all who choose to be Zimbabwean
then Africa ought to
belong to only those who choose to be
African.
One has to accept that in as much as many black Africans may
choose to be
citizens of foreign states, many who may be African need not be
black.
I have to come to accept that shareholders like parents have to be
selfless
for their children to succeed.
Shareholders do not own
companies in as much as it is impossible for
children to be not owned by
their parents.
The sole purpose of a company is to serve. If a company
produces what
customers are not willing to purchase, it loses its reason to
exist.
The real owner of a business, therefore, is the customer and yet
many look
to shareholders as the true owners. If a company earns, for
instance, US$1
million profit the profit does not belong to the shareholders
but to the
company.
Shareholders are only entitled to income that the
company does not need to
grow. A dividend is not a claim on a company rather
it is a discretionary
allocation of income that is not required by the
company.
In many cases a company may be liquid while its shareholders may
be
challenged financially.
What is required for sustainability is
that shareholders like directors need
to understand their rights and
obligations to the company.
A company belongs to its stakeholders and
what is required for durability is
that the company must be close to its
customers.
One needs to enlarge the circle of influence to include
customers,
suppliers, employees and many other stakeholders to
succeed.
In many cases the company may benefit from the services of
people who may
not hold shares in it and yet many owner operators are
reluctant to
relinquish control to others.
It is not unsurprising
that people who are outgoing and goal-getters are
more likely to succeed
than people who spend their time looking at the
rear-view mirror in search
of answers to current challenges from the past.
If we invest in
knowledge, it will be easier to appreciate, for example,
that Jesus did not
need to be alive for the first Church to be built.
What he left was an
idea that was more powerful than his present. Jesus did
not leave cash with
his disciples and yet faith pulled them together and
generation after
generation has followed the tradition.
Religion transcends national
borders and yet the same people who belong to a
global Christian family, for
instance, are the very people whose minds never
transcend the race, gender,
and ethnic barriers.
What is obvious is that in business we tend to be
more selfish to the extent
that we invest in a misplaced notion that we will
live forever and in so
doing condemn the institutions associated with us in
life to failure after
we die.
We established AHS www.africaheritage.com as a response to
our own personal
loneliness in business.
As first generation role
players in business, we lack the support system
required for success. People
who purport to know us rarely invest in
understanding what we go through to
create the perception of success.
People who look up to us mistakenly
believe that we are in control and only
need us for their own selfish ends
rather than as partners in a pyramid of
opportunity and
challenges.
We need to share business experiences and I intend to use the
remaining 29
articles to do precisely this.
Through these kinds of
exchanges we may discover that there is more that
unites us than divide us.
- ZimOnline
BILL WATCH
39/2009
[15th November
2009]
The
House of Assembly will sit again on Tuesday 17th
November
The
Senate has adjourned until Tuesday 1st December
Update on
Inclusive Government
Cabinet
Meeting –
Cabinet met on Wednesday for the
first time since MDC-T re-engagement. The Prime Minister and other MDC-T
Cabinet members attended.
Council of
Ministers – the first post-re-engagement
meeting of the Council of Ministers will be next Thursday 19th November, chaired
by the Prime Minister.
Meeting of
Principals – the three party principals met on
Friday afternoon as a start to the Troika-mandated dialogue.
Meeting of
Negotiators –
the full
negotiating teams of the three GPA political parties will meet on Monday 16th
November. The have not met since the SADC Organ Troika meeting on 5th November,
although there was an informal meeting of some members on Wednesday. All team
members are Ministers, and they have apparently been too busy attending to their
Ministerial duties and other engagements to get together for the dialogue
demanded by the Troika.
Can the Troika
Timeframe be kept? – Already 10 of the 30 days allowed by the
Troika for resolving disagreements between the two major parties have been
lost. President Zuma had offered to come to
Forthcoming
Statement by Prime Minister – in the House of
Assembly on Wednesday the Prime Minister deflected a question about the
feasibility of talking about national healing in the present political
environment by saying “a more detailed response to the issues affecting the
political environment will be in my statement in the near future”. This
referred to a statement he will make in the House of Assembly in his capacity as
Leader of Government Business in Parliament during the week commencing 23rd
November.
Ministerial
Portfolios: Which Minister is in charge of
what?
The SADC Summit
communiqué of 27th January requires a review of the “allocation of ministerial
portfolios” six months after the formation of the Inclusive Government, and the
Troika Summit stipulated that this should be one of the issues the negotiators
deal with. This review is complicated by the current lack of clarity about the
responsibilities attached to the existing Ministries. Since the formation of
the inclusive government, the President’s Office has failed to gazette revised
lists of Acts of Parliament assigned to Ministries for purposes of
administration. The existing lists were gazetted in 2006; in some cases they
refer to Ministries that have ceased to exist, they do not mention several of
the current Ministries at all. This has practical implications, such as the
confusion about the responsibilities of the Ministries of Information
Communication Technology and Media, Information and Publicity. It is still
unclear which Ministry, Justice and Legal Affairs or Constitutional and
Parliamentary Affairs, is responsible for the Electoral Act and by-elections.
[See below for the growing number of
Parliamentary vacancies requiring by-elections.] Another example: when companies were
recently “specified” under the Prevention of Corruption Act by the co-Ministers
of Home Affairs, their lawyers pointed out that the Act had not been assigned to
the Ministry of Home Affairs
Parliamentary
Update
Proposed
Private Member’s Bill to Amend POSA
There was no progress
last week on Mr Gonese’s motion, and it has been carried forward to this week.
So far, no Ministers have contributed to the debate, not even the co-Ministers
of Home Affairs, who are responsible for the administration of POSA and could be
expected to explain the Inclusive Government’s attitude to Mr Gonese’s
proposals. Assuming that Mr Gonese is permitted to proceed with his Bill, its
eventual passage or otherwise by the House cannot be regarded as assured, given
the present delicate balance of voting strengths between the parties [Veritas will shortly be issuing a Bill Watch Special
giving the current figures in both House of Assembly and Senate].
This
Coming Week in Parliament
House
of Assembly
Bills: On Tuesday Minister
of Finance
Debate on the Reserve
Bank of Zimbabwe Amendment Bill will continue, but there may be problems ahead
for Mr Biti, because, although the Bill was sanctioned by Cabinet, ZANU-PF Chief
Whip Joram Gumbo has stated
that the ZANU-PF Parliamentary caucus has decided to oppose the Bill in its
present form, and has told Mr Biti he will have to agree to changes if he wants
the Bill to be supported. Mr Biti’s two other Bills, the Audit Office and
Financial Adjustments Bills, may also come up for Second Reading during the
week.
Motions: Debate will
continue on motions carried forward from last week [see below]. Also on the
agenda is a motion by Mr Matutu [MDC-T, Masvingo Urban] calling for an audit of
the voters roll to rid it of inaccuracies and irregularities.
Question Time
[Wednesday]: The
written questions from last week have been carried
over.
Senate:
The Senate will not be
sitting.
Parliamentary
Committee Meetings Open to Public:
Portfolio and Thematic
Committee Meetings open to stakeholders or the public have been listed
separately in Bill Watch Special of 14th November.
Last
Week in Parliament
House
of Assembly
Bills: On Tuesday Minister of
Finance
Motions: Debate commenced on
[1] the motion put forward by Kudakwashe Bhasikiti, ZANU-PF MP for Mwenezi East,
calling for increased action against corruption, including the adoption of codes
of conduct by executive, judiciary and legislature and the adoption by
legislators of the Zimbabwe Chapter of African Parliamentarians Network Against
Corruption, and [2] a condolence motion on the death of Senator R.C. Hove.
There was no further debate on the motion on the criteria used to declare
national heroes; it remains on the Order Paper for continuation this
week.
Questions: A number of
questions went unasked because the Ministers concerned were not present to
respond to them. The Prime Minister assured the House that this problem would
not recur – it had been discussed in Cabinet and Ministers would in future be
present to deal with questions. In answer to a question about external
[“pirate”] radio stations, Deputy Prime Minister Mutambara said that once the
Zimbabwe Media Commission is in place and has started issuing licences for
additional internal broadcasters, there would be no need for external
broadcasters.
Parliamentary Legal
Committee [PLC]: The PLC
presented a non-adverse report on the Minister of Finance’s Public Finance
Management Bill, clearing the way for its Second Reading. It is still
considering the Audit Office Bill and the Financial Adjustments Bill.
Senate
The Senate sat briefly
on Tuesday and Wednesday
afternoons [less than hour on each occasion] before adjourning to
Tuesday 1st December. The only business was continued debate on the President’s
Speech at the Opening of Parliament,
Senator
Roy Bennett: High Court Trial
Senator Bennett’s trial
did not start on Monday 9th November, as it was supposed to. Preliminary
procedural points raised by both State and defence were dismissed by the
presiding judge, Justice Bhunu, on Wednesday. On Thursday the defence applied
for Justice Bhunu to recuse himself, arguing that this was necessary because of
views expressed by him when dismissing a bail application made in 2006 by Peter
Hitschmann, who is listed as the principal State witness in the Bennett case.
The judge is due to give his decision on the recusal application on Monday 16th
November.
Blessing
Chebundo MP acquitted
On 10th November the
regional court in Gweru returned a not guilty verdict in the trial of Blessing
Chebundo, MDC-T MP for Kwekwe Central, on a charge of rape.
Constituency
Vacancies Awaiting By-elections
New vacancy in the
House of Assembly – with the
death of John Nyamande, MDC-T MP for Makoni Central, on 7th November in a road
accident, the number of House of Assembly vacancies requiring the holding of
by-elections has risen to 10. In the Senate there are 6 constituency seats
vacant. So the country now awaits 16 by-elections. Under the Electoral Act the
new vacancy must be notified to the President as soon as possible, and the
President must within the next 14 days gazette a proclamation fixing dates for
lodging of nominations and polling for a by-election to fill the vacancy. No
proclamations have ever been gazetted for any of the earlier vacancies. The
latest explanation offered for this breach of the Electoral Act was that the
inclusive government had decided that all by-elections should wait for the
setting-up of the new Zimbabwe Electoral Commission. The failure to call
by-elections is unconstitutional, being in breach of sections 34 and 38 of the
Constitution, which require Parliamentary vacancies to be filled in accordance
with the Electoral Act, and of the new section 23A [“political rights”], which
gives Zimbabwean citizens the right to free, fair and regular elections for
Parliament.
Update on
Independent Constitutional Commissions
There is still no news of any
appointments being to the Human Rights Commission, the Electoral Commission and
the Media Commission,
and the President has not initiated consultations with Parliament on
appointments to the Anti-Corruption Commission.
Legislation
Update
Acts – the Appropriation
(Additional)(2008) Act [No. 7 of 2009] was gazetted on 6th November. All Bills
passed by Parliament this year have now been gazetted. The Acts previously
gazetted are: Constitution Amendment (No. 19) Act; National Security Council
Act; Finance Act; Appropriation (2009) Act; Finance (No. 2) Act; Appropriation
(Supplementary)(2009) Act.
Bills
in Parliament – Reserve
Bank Amendment Bill [HB 7, 2009], Public Finance Management Bill [HB 9, 2009],
Audit Office Bill [HB 10, 2009] and Financial Adjustments Bill [HB 8, 2009]
[Electronic versions available on request.]
[See Update on Parliament
above.]
Statutory
Instruments
SI 179/2009 –
suspension of customs duty on civil aviation security equipment, effective 13th
November.
Veritas makes
every effort to ensure reliable information, but cannot take legal
responsibility for information supplied.