http://www.radiovop.com
Harare, October
20, 2012- Police last Thursday charged Julius Magarangoma,
the Movement for
Democratic Change (MDC) party chairperson for Manicaland
Province for
allegedly threatening to commit murder, almost two years after
the offence
was allegedly committed.
Detectives from the Law and Order Section at
Mutare Central Police Station
on Thursday charged Magarangoma with
contravening Section 186 (1) (b) as
read with Section 47 of the Criminal Law
(Codification and Reform) Act.
The police alleged that the MDC provincial
chairperson, who reported to the
police station in the company of his lawyer
Blessing Nyamaropa of Zimbabwe
Lawyers for Human Rights threatened to kill
Mutizwa Mhondiwa for mobilizing
and sending some people to destroy his
homestead in Buhera.
The police said the incident took place on October 1,
2010 at Manyadza
homestead, in Mhondiwa village under Chief Chitsunge in
Buhera.
Magarangoma was released after the police recorded a warned and
cautioned
statement and advising that they will proceed by way of summons if
they
intend to pursue the matter.
Meanwhile, Beitbridge Magistrate
Gwineth Drawo on Thursday acquitted 12 MDC
officials, who had been on trial
for contravening the Public Order and
Security Act (POSA).
The MDC
officials were arrested in February and charged with contravening
Section 26
of POSA after they held an internal party meeting at some private
premises
in the border town of Beitbridge, which the police charged was
“unauthorized”.
Magistrate Drawo acquitted the MDC officials after their
lawyer, Lizwe
Jamela of ZLHR applied for discharge at the close of the State
case, which
had been opposed by State prosecutor Jabulani Mberesi.
ZIMBABWE'S football federation has given lifetime bans to 15 players, officials and journalists for match-fixing and corruption.
The Zimbabwe Football Association, or ZIFA, said its former chief executive Henrietta Rushwaya was among those banned after he was accused of masterminding match-fixing during Asian tours in 2009.
Others included former national team captain Method Mwanjale, and the country's most decorated coach Sunday Chidzambwa.
ZIFA said that 16 players and officials were cleared of any wrongdoing in matches rigged by an Asian betting syndicate linked to Singaporean Wilson Raj Perumal, who has been jailed in Finland.
During the Asian tours, Zimbabwe lost 6-0 to Syria, and 3-0 to Thailand.
http://www.newzimbabwe.com
20/10/2012 00:00:00
by Sports
Reporter
SPORTS Minister David Coltart has called on
Police Commissioner Augustine
Chihuri and Attorney General Johannes Tomana
to initiate criminal
proceedings against football players and administrators
involved in the
Asiagate scandal.
An official report said national
team matches were fixed by ex-ZIFA
officials along with convicted
match-fixer Wilson Perumal between 2007 and
2009.
ZIFA announced on
Friday that 15 players and officials – including the
decorated former
Zimbabwe coach Sunday Chidzambwa and ex-ZIFA CEO Henrietta
Rushwaya – had
been banned for life from all football activities.
Over 50 other players
and officials will, in the coming weeks, learn of
their punishments which
will range from suspensions of six months to 10
years, say
officials.
On Saturday, Sports Minister Coltart said prosecutions must
follow.
“I fully support ZIFA's decision to serve life bans on various
players and
administrators responsible for what is undoubtedly the most
shameful chapter
of Zimbabwe's sporting history,” Coltart.
“I trust
that the Police and the Attorney General will now act quickly to
investigate
and prosecute those identified. If they don’t, then their
offices will also
be tainted by this scandal.
“I have no doubt that the football loving
public expects that those
responsible for criminal activity should face the
full wrath of the law.”
An independent panel chaired by retired High
Court judge Ahmed Ebrahim
identified systematic corruption after Perumal
burrowed his way into the
heart of Zimbabwean football.
Justice
Ebrahim said in Rushwaya and other senior officials including ZIFA
programmes officer Jonathan Musavengana and football agent Kudzai Shabba,
Singapore national Perumal found willing participants in his
corruption.
Players – including the former captain Method Mwanjali now of
Sundowns in
South Africa, former CAPS United goalkeeper Edmore Sibanda,
Dynamos defender
Guthrie Zhokinyi, Kaizer Chiefs defender Thomas Sweswe and
Danisa Phiri –
dragged their teammates along as they assumed a central role
in the
corruption in which they were paid to lose matches. They will never
play
football again, ZIFA said.
Journalists were not spared by the
corruption. Robson Sharuko, editor of the
country’s biggest daily newspaper
– the Herald – and former Sunday Mail
reporter Hope Chizuzu, who was now
working for the Premier League side
Monomotapa, were also banned.
The
Herald had previously said it would stand by Sharuko until Justice
Ebrahim
delivered his final report. On Saturday, his weekly column was
missing from
the newspaper, fuelling speculation he may have been suspended
or
sacked.
ZIFA says it will, in the coming weeks, release the names of
players who
will be suspended over the scandal in batches.
The next
release will be for players and officials banned for 10 years,
followed by
those who face a five-year layoff, then three years, two years
and finally
those suspended for less than a year.
FIFA and the Confederation of
African Football say ZIFA’s sanctions will be
given global effect, ensuring
that the named individuals are blacklisted
worldwide.
LIFE BANS:
Henrietta Rushwaya, Jonathan Musavengana, Kudzai Shabba, Sunday
Chidzambwa,
Thompson Matenda, Godfrey Japajapa, Rodwell Dhlakama, Emmanuel
Nyahuma,
Robson Sharuko, Edmore Sibanda, Danisa Phiri, Thomas Sweswe,
Guthrie
Zhokinyi, Method Mwanjali, Hope Chizuzu
CLEARED: Gilbert Banda, Justice
Majabvi, Richard Mteki, Energy Murambadoro,
Costa Nhamoinesu, Kingston
Nkhatha, Washington Pakamisa, Edward Sadomba,
David Kutyauripo, Lincoln
Zvasiya, Cuthbert Malajila, Willard Manyatera,
Brighton Tuwaya, Edward
Chagonda, Cyril Mukweva, Solomon Makuvaro
http://www.newzimbabwe.com
20/10/2012 00:00:00
by Chengetai
Zvauya I Daily News
THE race for Parliament and council seats
ahead of the forthcoming general
elections has ripped Prime Minister Morgan
Tsvangirai’s MDC-T apart, with
factions fighting for
supremacy.
Factionalism in the party has resurfaced as jockeying
intensifies with
different camps, fighting for supremacy. There is a camp
which is fielding
young cadres and academics, which enjoys the support of
younger leaders like
Tendai Biti while Tsvangirai is using his former trade
union colleagues to
continue with his hold on the party, sources close to
the ground say.
Women and youth assembly members are being roped in the
factionalism.
According to sources, the factions have been fighting for
turf for months,
as evidenced by the splits and violent clashes that
characterised provinces
such as Bulawayo, Masvingo, Manicaland and
Mashonaland East.
The party is yet to firmly deal with the issue of
internal violence driven
by factionalism despite public promises to do
so.
Sources said the infighting had intensified across provinces in
recent weeks
due to the race to get the party ticket for next year’s
elections.
A new front in the war has been opened as well.
A
directive from the MDC-T’s national executive that incumbent councillors
and
MPs will not be contested in primary elections to choose party
candidates
ahead of the watershed polls that could be held in June 2013 has
raffled
feathers in the young party.
Aspiring candidates are uncomfortable with
the directive barring them from
contesting sitting MPs and councillors as
they feel it protects failed and
corrupt office bearers.
They feel
Tsvangirai’s band of top leaders is abusing high office to protect
themselves from internal democracy.
MDC-T deputy spokesperson Joel
Gabbuza confirmed that sitting MPs will walk
to the general elections
unopposed.
“In the constituencies where we have incumbent MPs and
councillors, we will
delay the process of primary elections because we
already have persons
elected by the electorate,” said Gabbuza.
“We do
not want to disrupt the work they have done. So we are going to be
starting
in the constituencies where we do not have representatives. In
those
constituencies people can start running around canvassing for
support,”
said Gabuzza.
The MDC-T’s decision not to hold primary elections has left
the party that
was formed in 1999 deeply divided with some people who have
been in the
trenches for the past 13 years feeling that this is a form of
candidate
imposition — a phenomenon copied from Zanu PF.
Zanu PF,
however, appears to be changing tact and has announced that apart
from
President Robert Mugabe, every other official will have to fight it
out.
The move by the MDC-T not to hold primary elections in more than
90
constituencies has been picked by the party rivals as undemocratic but
Gabbuza said the party will not deviate from its “democratic”
practices.
“We are not going to impose candidates on our supporters. What
is happening
at the moment is that our election directorate is working on
the procedure
to elect candidates. They are fine-tuning the resolution of
our congress on
elections,” said Gabbuza.
Aspiring candidates say the
majority of sitting MDC-T MPs and councillors
have failed to deliver and
have joined the gravy train and therefore should
make way for fresh
blood.
Even though Tsvangirai’s party has taken steps to bring sanity to
towns it
leads by expelling councillors deemed to be corrupt, many feel the
action is
incomplete and should net all councillors who are enjoying a
rags-to-riches
lifestyle and targeting the small fish.
Gabbuza, who
also has been an MP for more than a decade now, defended the
decision by his
colleagues not to step down and allow others to take over.
“There is no
provision in our party constitution which says a member should
have served a
certain number of years for him to step down from being a
councillor or MP,”
said Gabbuza.
http://www.voazimbabwe.com
Gibbs
Dube
19.10.2012
Observers have dismissed as suspicious remarks by
Mines Minister Obert Mpofu
that at least $20 million in diamond sales linked
to companies on targeted
sanctions has been impounded by the United States
and its allies.
They said there is no tangible evidence that diamond
sales generated by
Mbada Diamonds and Marange Resources have been targeted
by America, Britain
and other nations which imposed sanctions on President
Robert Mugabe and his
inner circle.
Project manager Melanie Chiponda
of Chiadzwa Community Development Trust
said it is difficult to prove
Mpofu’s allegations due to lack of
transparency in the mining of the gems in
Manicaland Province.
“There is a lot of activity in Marange and we
believe that those companies
are making a lot of money through diamond
sales,” said Chiponda.
Sharon Hudson-Dean, public affairs counselor of
the U.S. Embassy in Harare
said companies mining diamonds in Marange are
shortchanging Zimbabweans.
“We believe that Mr. Mpofu and the people that
he works with in terms of
keeping trace of diamond sales and revenues should
be transparent about the
process and should disclose exactly what the sales
are,” said Hudson-Dean.
The minister said Zimbabwe is now unlikely to
earn the projected $600
million in diamond revenues as a result of the
sanctions and depressed
international prices of the gems.
Oct 20, 9:52 AM EDT
HARARE, Zimbabwe (AP) -- The United Nations deputy
humanitarian chief says
food shortages are "a chronic problem" in southern
Africa and more than 5.5
million people in eight countries need aid this
year, a 40 percent increase
compared to 2011.
Catherine Bragg,
winding up a five-day southern Africa trip Saturday, said
worsening food
shortages are the result of drought or floods and rising
world food
prices.
In Zimbabwe, 1.6 million people are affected by food shortages
and many
rural families have begun selling village livestock, often kept as
a symbol
of status and wellbeing, to cope with the "dire situation," Bragg
said.
A decade of seizures of commercial farms has disrupted food
production in
Zimbabwe, a former regional breadbasket.
Food shortages
are also particularly acute in Lesotho, Malawi and Swaziland,
Bragg said.
http://sydneypeacefoundation.org.au/
2012 Senator Sekai
Holland
Senator Mrs. Sekai Holland Co Minister for Reconciliation Healing and
Integration in the Cabinet of President Robert Mugabe and Prime Minister
Morgan Tsvangirai was announced as the recipient of the 2012 Sydney Peace
Prize, in a ceremony hosted by the Australian Embassy in Harare , Zimbabwe ,
April 30.
The Sydney Peace Prize jury’s citation reads: ‘ Sekai
Holland: for a
lifetime of outstanding courage in campaigning for human
rights and
democracy, for challenging violence in all its forms and for
giving such
astute and brave leadership for the empowerment of
women.’
The announcement of the choice of Sekai Holland was made by Dr
Meredith
Burgmann at a reception hosted by Australian Embassy in Harare on
Monday 30
April. Professor Stuart Rees, Chair of the Sydney Peace Foundation
said, ‘In
addition to her work for the education of rural women and her
founding of
Australia’s anti Apartheid movement fifty years ago, Sekai
Holland has been
a significant leader of non violent, democracy campaigns,
and is a key
figure in her country’s national dialogue on how to heal the
deep wounds of
social conflict.’
In response Senator Holland
commented, ‘This award comes as a wonderful
surprise but one which is so
encouraging. I accept on behalf of the brave
women I have worked with for so
many years and for my colleagues in our
present Organ for National Healing
Reconciliation and Integration. I also
acknowledge the long term support and
friendship which I have received from
Australian Aboriginal campaigners for
human rights and for peace with
justice.’
Sekai Holland will travel
to Australia in November to give the City of
Sydney Peace Prize Lecture in
the Sydney Town Hall on Wednesday November 7th
and will receive the 2012
Peace Prize ($50,000 and a trophy crafted by the
artist in glass Brian Hirst
) at a Gala Dinner and Award Ceremony on
Thursday November
8th.
Senator Sekai Holland, Dr Meredith Burgmann and Professor Stuart
Rees are
available for comment.
For media enquires: please contact
Melissa McCullough –
melissa.mccullough@sydney.edu.au
| +61 432 861 653
Tickets for the lecture: available via Ticketek
http://premier.ticketek.com.au/shows/show.aspx?sh=SYDNEYPE12#.UFaVYK5qwbr
($25/$35)
Tickets to the Gala Dinner: please contact Juliet Bennett
at the Sydney
Peace Foundation – peace.foundation@sydney.edu.au
| 9351 4468
Dear Family and Friends,
There’s a constant
tapping on the windows at night, now that the
first rains have fallen in
Zimbabwe. The reappearance of millions of
insects after an absence of four
months is an attack on the senses.
From the persistent whining of mosquitoes
that turn sideways and
disappear when you look for them, to the silent
ascension from the
depths of the earth of a million flying ants, the insects
are back. A
vast array of airborne beetles, ranging from small shiny
brown
creatures to large glossy black monsters with fearsome body
armour,
horns and spiked legs, spend their nights pinging against lights
and
tapping on windows. The natural aerial assault has added to the
man
made surprises and uncertainty that has overtaken Zimbabwe this
week.
It started with a visit from South Africa’s ex ANC youth
leader
Julius Malema who had apparently come to Zimbabwe to
‘meet
progressive forces’ and also to attend the wedding of a Zanu
PF
youth leader. Met at the airport by Zimbabwe’s minister of youth
and
indigenisation, Malema was said to have been ‘whisked away,’
first
through the airport’s VIP section and then in a convoy of
fast
moving vehicles. Later, when Daily News reporters tried to
interview
Malema, his body guards whom the paper described as ‘heavily
built
goons,’ manhandled the press photographer, forced him to
delete
photographs of Malema and then confiscated the camera’s memory
card.
Speaking at the wedding he’d come to attend, Malema had
obviously
been taking lessons from us. He said that white South Africans
must
give back land and minerals. Malema said that they would not pay
for
the land in South Africa when it was surrendered and the only
thing
they were scared of was defeat. ‘Seeing blood is not what we
are
scared of as long as that blood delivers what belongs to us we
are
prepared to go to that extent.’ It wasn’t clear who the ‘we’
was that
Julius Malema referred to but they were frighteningly
familiar sentiments in
a country that has witnessed at first hand just
how easily radical rhetoric
becomes terrifying reality.
The next frighteningly familiar thing came in
the form of newspaper
photographs and TV video footage of houses being
knocked down by
bulldozers in Epworth outside Harare. Disturbing images were
shown of
men, women and children standing amidst the rubble and ruins of
their
homes with all their worldly goods jumbled in heaps around
them:
furniture, bedding, clothing, kitchen equipment and food. Hundreds
of
families were affected by the demolitions and said they’d
been
allocated stands on the land a year ago by a couple of men they
called
Zanu PF party leaders. Asked to comment on the allocation of stands
on
privately owned land, Zanu PF’s Harare province chairman, Amos
Midzi,
said: “we have no policy whatsoever to take over private
property anywhere in
Harare.' It was the most ironic statement after
twelve years of private
property seizures.
Then came the warning made by Zanu PF spokesman Rugare
Gumbo who was
being interviewed by a South African TV channel. Gumbo said
that if
Zanu PF lost the next election it would be ‘messy.’ Gumbo
said
that events such as had taken place in Libya and were still
taking
place in Syria, could happen in Zimbabwe. ‘There will be
deaths.
People could be killed and maimed,’ he said. It wasn’t clear if
Mr
Gumbo was representing his own position or that of Zanu PF but it
all
adds to the fear factor that increases as we draw ever closer to
a
constitutional referendum and election. Until next time, thanks
for
reading, love cathy 20th October 2012. Copyright � Cathy
Buckle.
www.cathybuckle.com
http://www.cathybuckle.com
October 19, 2012, 1:23
pm
Robert Mugabe resorted to his old socialist rhetoric when addressing
his
supporters last week. Predicting a ‘blatantly God-given victory’, he
went on
to condemn the opposition as ‘corrupt from top to bottom’ but then
he would
say that, wouldn’t he – anything to deflect attention from his own
party’s
misdeeds. Looking in from the outside, it seems that the country is
in a
state of moral decline and that applies not only to political parties.
Uncertainty about the country’s future may be the explanation for this state
of affairs. Whichever way you look at it, no one is quite sure what the
future holds; elections, whenever they happen, always create uncertainty and
at 88 years of age, Mugabe’s future is limited. Love him or loathe him, the
man has been in power for so long that a whole generation has grown up
knowing nothing else but Mugabe and Zanu PF. The prospect of change and an
unclear future creates an atmosphere of nervousness and that, combined with
the political patronage that Mugabe has actively promoted, makes for an
attitude of ‘every man for himself’ that is fertile ground for corruption in
one form or another. As Simba Makoni declared recently, “Corruption should
be declared a national disaster.”
The victory of his old friend,
Hugo Chavez, in the recently held
elections, Mugabe told his supporters, was
‘a win for the people of
Venezuela’. That sounds like an endorsement of the
democratic process from
the president, so it was oddly contradictory to hear
one of his ministers,
Patrick Chinamasa, in a BBC interview saying that Zanu
PF would not accept
an MDC win. “There will be trouble” Chinamasa prophesied
and when asked what
exactly he meant by that, he eventually replied, “We
will not accept it”. So
much for tolerance and acceptance of different
political views that Mugabe
has recently been advocating; it seems that
Mugabe’s Justice Minister is not
following the same agenda as his master.
Like his master, however, Chinamasa
was careful to put the blame for any
possible MDC victory on the
‘imperialists’ who are always blamed for any
independent thinking on the
part of the ‘masses’. Clearly Zanu PF and its
higher echelons have a pretty
low opinion of the ordinary Zimbabwean
people’s ability to think for
themselves. In another interview, this time
with a South African tv station,
the president’s spokesperson, Rugare Gumbo
threatened a ‘bloodbath’ if Zanu
PF loses the election. These repeated
threats of violence if they lose the
election show very clearly that Zanu
PF’s belief in democracy is paper-thin:
violence is their preferred method
of persuasion.
Right on cue, in comes another hothead, South African
Julius Malema who
is given a red-carpet welcome by Zanu PF. (Incidentally
the rumours of
personal corruption have not left Malema untouched either) He
says he only
went to Zimbabwe to attend a wedding but that didn’t prevent
him from making
a most un-wedding like speech! Zimbabwe under Zanu PF has
been “an
inspiration to Africa” he said and went on to castigate whites who
should
surrender their minerals and land without compensation. As for
Tsvangirai,
declared Malema, he is an ally of imperialists. Once again we
see that
anyone who disagrees with the party line is automatically condemned
as a
lackey of the imperialists, not capable of thinking for themselves. In
true
‘celebrity’ fashion, Malema brought his own body-guards with him and
they
proceeded to beat up journalists who tried to photograph their boss.
This
cult of celebrity is prevalent in Zimbabwe too, as the increasing
number of
cases of people charged with ‘insulting the president’ reveals.
Now, as if
to place him even higher in the ‘hero’ class, we hear that
Mugabe’s original
house in Highfield is to become a National Monument where
visitors will
presumably be treated to a lecture on Mugabe’s ‘heroic’ life;
his burial
plot having already been reserved at Heroes Acre.
It
was Malema’s attitude to white people that most closely chimed with
the
Zimbabwean president’s own views. Mugabe’s latest comment about whites
may
have been intended for a partisan audience at home but they reveal the
duplicity of a man who willingly takes funding from European based NGOs but
never fails to insult the owners of the white hands that feed his people. “A
lion eats flesh,” he said, “and you can never trust it with your sheep no
matter how passive that lion is. Trust white people at your own peril.”
Coming as it does from the head of state, this thoroughly racist remark
reveals the depths to which Mugabe will sink to win popularity, as he
believes, with ‘the masses’.
CONSTITUTION WATCH
2012
[20th October
2012]
Second
All Stakeholders’ Conference Programme
Sunday
21st – Tuesday 23rd October
Conference
Programme
Day 1: Sunday 21st
October: Arrival of Delegates
There will be no
Conference meetings on Sunday 21st October.
Out-of-town delegates will arrive and settle in at their various hotels
so that all everyone will be ready for a punctual early start of the Conference
proper at the Harare International Conference Centre [Rainbow Towers] the
following morning. Delegates can get
details of accommodation from COPAC Head Office, 31 Lawson Avenue, Milton
Park, Harare, phone Harare 703268 and 702529 or on the cellphone number of the
COPAC officer assigned to their province: Manicaland 0775 605 312; Mashonaland
East 0772 252 272; Mashonaland West 0772 926 962; Mashonaland Central 0773 369
622; Harare Province 0773 098 047; Matabeleland North 0772 854 110; Matabeleland
South 0772 423 428; Midlands 0775 359 332; Masvingo 0712 782 225; Bulawayo 0774 032 657.
Day 2: Monday 22nd
October: Conference Begins
8 am Delegates to be seated
8.30 – 9 am Arrival of invited
guests
9 am Proceedings commence with
National Anthem followed by introduction by Minister of Constitutional and
Parliamentary Affairs
9.30 am GPA principals address
Conference
10.30 am GPA principals and invited guests
depart
11 am Co-chairs give overview of
constitution-making process and explain methodology of
Conference
1 pm Lunch
break
2.30 pm Delegates break up into
groups
3,30 pm Tea break
4 pm Plenary – groups report
back
Day 3: Tuesday 23rd
October: Departure
The
morning is available if there is unfinished business carried over from
Monday.
Conference
Documents
·
A
copy of the COPAC draft constitution. Delegates and observers were given this on
accreditation. They
will receive the other promised documents before the start of the Conference on
Monday:
·
National
Statistical Report [see
details below]
·
And
documents agreed among the 3 GPA parties provided to the
drafters:
o
Constitutional
principles
o
List
of agreed constitutional Issues and points to be covered.
o
Gap-filling
document –
identifying
gaps in information collected during the outreach and indicating
how they should be dealt with.
Security
at the Conference
The
COPAC co-chairs assured Friday morning’s press briefing that arrangements had
been made to ensure strict maintenance of security at the conference. Security personnel would be present both in
uniform and in plain clothes.
Delegates
Code of Conduct
Every
accredited delegate has been required to sign an undertaking to abide by a Code
of Conduct framed by COPAC in an effort to prevent the sort of rowdy behaviour
that had marred the First All Stakeholders’ Conference in 2009. The Code
prohibits
disorderly, riotous and unbecoming behaviour, abusive language and gestures,
heckling and interjecting, and other disruptive conduct. Breaches of the Code may result in expulsion
from the Conference and forfeiture of any allowances payable for
attendance.
International
and National Observers and Press
COPAC
has also kept to their assurance that international – mostly from embassies –
and some national observers will be able to monitor the conference and these
have been accredited. Limited
accreditation of media also took place – marred by complaints about the limited
numbers and method of allocation for media representatives, with free-lance
journalists being turned away initially and some media houses being told they
were too small to warrant registration.
Despite one of the COPAC co-chairs being called in to try and sort things
out, journalists are complaining that they should not be restricted in covering
what is a national event of great general interest. Nevertheless, the presence of observers and
even limited media will assist in deterring potential disruptions.
Accreditation
Process
Accreditation
of Conference delegates and observers largely proceeded smoothly, starting on
16th October. The accreditation process
itself was well organised, comfortable, and courteous. There were only short queues and the actual
process took only two or three minutes, after which one walked away with a
Conference ID complete with photograph and a copy of the COPAC draft
constitution.
Unfortunately
on the last day there were hitches and delays caused by the restricted number of
media places
[see
above]
and
the continuing disagreement between COPAC and some civil society networks and
organisations. Trouble was largely as a
result of political parties having already nominated “their” NGOs to attend the
Conference. There were also accusations
that names had been substituted or dropped from NGO lists. This caused delays and confusion at the COPAC
offices on 19th October, resulting in some would-be delegates still not being
accredited.
NGOs meeting in Harare to prepare for the
Conference wrote to President Zuma complaining that NGO participation would be
limited and not inclusive. Apart from
this highly unsatisfactory aspect, still not resolved at the time of writing, on
the whole, in comparison with the First All Stakeholders’ Conference, COPAC
deserves credit for a better-organised process.
Last
Minute Court Case on Conference - High Court Says Conference Must Go
Ahead
On
Thursday 18th October Justice Hlatshwayo gave the go-ahead for the Stakeholders
Conference. In a last-minute application
businessman Danny Musukuma had asked the court to prevent the Conference going
ahead until COPAC had published its National Statistical Report in the
press. COPAC explained to the judge that
it had in fact published the report on its website some time ago – well before
the application was lodged, and that it
had already arranged to supply the report to all Conference delegates before the
start of the Conference. Mr Musukuma and
COPAC then agreed to the judge issuing an order as
follows:
·
the
Conference would go ahead
·
COPAC
must ensure the distribution of hard copies of the report to the 10
provincial administrators’ offices countrywide by midday Saturday 20th October
for people to photocopy it. [Note: the COPAC co-chairs gave an assurance at a press briefing on
Friday morning that this would be done - [Note:
The Short version of the National Statistical Report has almost 2000 pages.]
·
COPAC
must by 10 am on 19th October release a Press statement informing the public through the national
and other media that the National Statistical Report is accessible on its
website www.copac.org.zw [Note: this was done. See
below about accessing documents on the website.]
·
Mr
Musukuma must be given a copy of the report [Note:
this has been done].
The
COPAC Website
The
Conference documents: The
Conference documents may be downloaded from the COPAC website www.copac.org.zw Most of these documents are on the website’s
“Conference” page, so click on the link to that page, where you will
find:
·
two
versions of the National Statistical Report, both of them very large pdf
documents – version 1 over 11 MB, and version 2 over 30 MB [see
below for a note on these two versions]
·
the
COPAC draft constitution as handed to delegates – i.e. with each page signed by
all three co-chairs – 2 MB pdf
document
·
the
drafting instruments – i.e., what COPAC provided to the three lead drafters – a
7 MB pdf document.
A
chance to comment on the COPAC draft via the COPAC website: It
is not too late for those not attending the Stakeholders’ Conference to submit
comments on the COPAC draft constitution for consideration by COPAC. This can be done through the website – www.copac.org.zw – by clicking on the “Draft
Constitution” tab and then clicking on whichever of the 18 chapters of the
Constitution you are interested in. The
text of the chapter will then open on your screen and you will see that
immediately under the text of each section there is an invitation to “Add a new
comment”.
Note
on Version 1 and Version 2 of the National Statistical
Report
Why
are there two versions of the National Statistical Report? The foreword to the National Statistical
Report explains this in some detail and demonstrates how the two versions are
linked to the debate over quantitative and qualitative methodologies that caused
delays in the preparation of district and provincial reports on the
outreach. “The Select Committee resolved that both the statistics (quantitative)
and the qualitative aspects of the outcomes (for example meeting atmosphere and
others) must be taken into account in deciding what would eventually go into the
constitution. The interpretation of these statistics therefore has to take into
account these limitations in the methodology used. Whilst a high frequency was a general guide,
that in itself was not the sole determinant of the importance of an issue enough
to find its way into the Draft Constitution that has been produced. It is for this reason that the Select
Committee adopted two versions of interpreting the final data:
Version 1 the National Statistical Report, which aggregates
the outcomes in each ward and expresses that as a percentage of all the wards in
the country, and Version 2 the Provincial
Statistical Reports, which basically indicate how an issue fared per each
province without subjecting it to the outcomes of other
provinces.”
Veritas makes every effort to ensure
reliable information, but cannot take legal responsibility for information
supplied