The ZIMBABWE Situation
An extensive and up-to-date website containing news, views and links related to ZIMBABWE - a country in crisis
Please note: You need to have 'Active content' enabled in your IE browser in order to see the index of articles on this webpage
Zimbabwe court delays ruling on vote
count as opposition leader visits South Africa
International Herald Tribune
Riot police keeping watch outside a court
building in Harare on Monday. (Howard Burditt /Reuters)
JOHANNESBURG:
Zimbabwe's high court on Monday delayed by at least 24 hours a decision on
whether to force the government to issue the results of the disputed
presidential election, as the opposition leader who requested the ruling
traveled to South Africa for talks.
The developments came on the ninth day of waiting by Zimbabweans to find out
who had won the election. The race pitted President Robert Mugabe against the
main opposition leader, Morgan Tsvangirai, who has insisted he won the March 30
election by a slim majority.
Mugabe, facing the biggest political crisis of his career since he led
Zimbabwe to independence from Britain 28 years ago, has requested a recount of
the results, even before they have been made public. Tsvangirai's party, the
Movement for Democratic Change, asked the Supreme Court to force the election
commission to release the results.
The court had planned to issue a ruling on Monday. But Tendai Biti, secretary
general of the Movement for Democratic Change, said in a telephone interview
from Harare, the Zimbabwean capital, that the court had decided to delay
deliberations on a decision until Tuesday.
Biti also said that Zimbabwe's judiciary has benefited from government
patronage, particularly having been given farms that were confiscated from white
farmers, suggesting that the court was in no hurry to act. "We're skeptical," he
said.
The UN secretary general, Ban Ki Moon, urged the electoral commission on
Monday "to discharge its responsibility and release the results expeditiously
and with transparency."
In a statement issued in New York, Ban said he was "concerned that
presidential results have not been released in spite of the constitutional
deadline" and said that the people of Zimbabwe had cast their ballots "in a
responsible and peaceful manner."
He called on all sides to exercise "restraint and calm and to address all
issues regarding the elections through recourse to legal means and dialogue as
necessary for the good of all Zimbabweans."
His spokeswoman, Michèle Montas, said Ban had had no contact with Mugabe or
the Zimbabwean government and that no requests for UN intervention had been
received despite news reports that opposition figures in Zimbabwe were seeking
it. For the United Nations to act on such a request, she said, it would have to
come from the government.
Tsvangirai's visit to South Africa, the regional powerhouse and a mediator in
the longstanding conflict between the government and the opposition, was his
first trip outside Zimbabwe since the election. There was no word on who he was
meeting or how long he intended to stay.
In the state-run Herald newspaper on Monday, Mugabe urged Zimbabweans to
defend their land from former white "colonizers," adding to fears that he may be
preparing to stir unrest and mount a campaign of violent intimidation of the
kind he has used to win past elections. The newspaper said there were
"widespread reports of white former farmers flocking back into the country" to
take over the land in the event of an opposition victory.
Supporters of the ruling party invaded eight of the few remaining white-owned
commercial farms on Sunday, driving at least four cattle ranchers off their land
and seizing equipment and livestock, the farmers reported, according to an
Associated Press report.
Mugabe, 84, is considered a hero of Zimbabwe's anti-colonial struggle but he
has led his country into a calamitous economic collapse in recent years. Four of
five Zimbabweans are unemployed. Inflation has reached more than 100,000
percent.
Opposition leaders ridiculed the delaying tactics of the governing party, the
Zimbabwe African National Union-Patriotic Front, as the desperate attempt of a
loser clinging to power fraudulently. They asked how Mugabe's party could ask
for the recount of a vote that had never been made public, and said the party
must have inside information.
"You can't ask for the remarking of an exam whose result is not known by the
student," Nelson Chamisa, a spokesman for the Movement for Democratic Change,
said in a telephone interview Sunday. "It shows their mischief and shenanigans
in trying to manipulate the poll."
The state-run Sunday Mail newspaper reported that Mugabe's party had asked
the electoral commission to recount and audit the presidential vote "following
revelations of errors and miscalculations in the compilation of the poll
result." The BBC reported that the Zimbabwean deputy information minister,
Bright Matonga, had said there were discrepancies between the voting results
posted outside polling stations and the tallies sent to the commission.
The governing party announced Friday that it backed Mugabe in a runoff
election if neither he nor Tsvangirai won a majority.
Tsvangirai predicted Saturday that a runoff would be a traumatizing event for
the country and charged that the governing party was "preparing a war on the
people."
His party has called for intervention by the United Nations and other
countries to assure a fair outcome.
"African leaders surely must now say no to Mugabe the same way the Zimbabwean
people have said no to him," Tsvangirai said.
But so far, there has been little public pressure on Mugabe from leaders of
other southern African countries. The South African president, Thabo Mbeki, has
said the world should wait as the electoral process plays out.
A senior Western diplomat who has spoken with leaders in many of the region's
countries said in an interview Sunday that many of them were worried that a
runoff in Zimbabwe could lead to violence and damage tourism and their
economies.
"Everyone has an interest in trying to head off this grisly showdown," he
said, speaking on the condition of anonymity under normal diplomatic rules.
But their phone calls to Mugabe have mostly gone unanswered, the diplomat
said. And they are reluctant to speak out publicly against the hero of
Zimbabwe's liberation from white rule for fear of being seen as puppets of the
United States or Britain, who have made their disapproval of Mugabe plain.
Graham Bowley contributed reporting from New York.
Zimbabwe election officials arrested
The Telegraph
By
David Blair in Johannesburg
Last Updated: 8:01pm BST
07/04/2008
Zimbabwean police have arrested seven election
officials for
undercounting votes cast for Robert Mugabe in the Presidential
election.
"We're still investigating, but we have established that
there was
deflation of figures in respect of one candidate ... the ZANU-PF
presidential candidate (Mr Mugabe)," said Wayne Bvudzijena, a police
spokesman.
Those arrested,who were working for the Zimbabwe
Electoral Commission
in four provinces, will be charged with
fraud.
As the results of the election remain unannounced,
speculation is
mounting that Mr Mugabe is planning a strategy to overcome a
majority won by
the opposition Movement for Democratic Change
(MDC).
Mr Mugabe this morning demanded a recount, with his
opponents fearing
he will secure and then rig a runoff
election.
His Zanu-PF party has also reverted to familiar tactics
by unleashing
its militias on some of the last remaining white-owned
farms.
Veterans of the war against white rule, who will play a
central role
in Mr Mugabe's strategy to win a fifth term, invaded eight
farms yesterday.
Their actions followed a silent but
menacing march through the
capital, Harare, on Friday. It suggests they have
been mobilised to help
Zanu-PF cling to power.
With a
presidential result still unannounced a week after the
election, the MDC
asked the High Court in Harare to rule on a petition
demanding the immediate
release of the results.
Zanu-PF countered by attempting to stymie
the legal action with its
own demands.
The party said it wanted
the Electoral Commission to "recount and
audit all its electoral material
relating to last week's presidential
election following revelations of
errors and miscalculations in the
compilation of the poll
result".
It added that the commission should "defer the
announcement of the
presidential election result".
The MDC
spokesman, Tendai Biti, said the request was "madness". He
said: "Legally
they have no right to ask for a recount, they have absolutely
no footing to
ask for a recount, so what they are trying to do is illegal."
Under
the Electoral Act, a second round must take place by April 19.
But if the
announcement of the result continues to be delayed, Mr Mugabe may
have an
excuse to delay the run-off.
The MDC, which secured a majority in
parliament's lower house, has
been officially announced the winner in half
of the Senate's elected seats.
Because Mr Mugabe appoints six
senators, Zanu-PF will still have a
narrow majority in the upper
house.
Electoral Officials Under 24 Hour Surveillance
SW Radio Africa
(London)
7 April 2008
Posted to the web 7 April 2008
Tichaona
Sibanda
There are reports that senior Zimbabwe Electoral Commission
officials are
under 24-hour surveillance by government, who fear they might
leak
information regarding the presidential poll which the MDC claims to
have won
outright.
The MDC are accusing Robert Mugabe, now in
opposition in parliament, of
stalling to provide time to alter the results
to show that Tsvangirai got
less than 50 percent and that a run-off is now
required.
Liberty Mupakati, a former intelligence operative with the
CIO, claims that
members of the top echelons of ZEC are more or less under
house arrest as
they are not allowed to leave the confines of their hotel,
which also
doubles as the poll collation centre, and that they are literally
under CIO
guard 24/7.
'I find it inconceivable that the newly
constituted Zimbabwe Electoral
Commission is coming up with flimsy excuses
to justify their utter failure
to announce the victor in the presidential
elections. The real reason why
the results have not been released is to
enable Mugabe and his party to
explore alternatives, specifically to
increase the number of votes that he
received in the just ended elections,'
wrote Mupakati.
He told Newsreel his sources were impeccable that even
die-hard Zanu-PF
people talk openly about Mugabe having comprehensively lost
to Tsvangirai.
'I can testify that late on Sunday (March 30) I was
informed by one of these
officials that Mugabe had been beaten by Tsvangirai
by 57,8 percent of the
poll to 39,9 percent. Armed with these results
Chiwenga, Chihuri, Bonyongwe,
Shiri and Paradzai Zimondi of prisons, then
approached Mugabe at State
House. Mugabe, in a state of shock, sent them
back to Chiweshe to ask him to
reverse the result. Chiweshe told them he was
bound by his professional
ethics as a lawyer and could not reverse the
election result. They pleaded
with him to try his best to save the
situation. Chiweshe tried his best -
the results of the presidential
election have not been announced since
then - for a week,' Mupakati
said.
The MDC have embarked on a diplomatic offensive to try and pressure
the
international community to intervene and force Mugabe to either release
the
results or accept defeat and step down.
Tsvangirai in South Africa Seeking Pressure for Election
Results
SW Radio Africa (London)
7 April 2008
Posted to
the web 7 April 2008
Tererai Karimakwenda
MDC leader Morgan
Tsvangirai was in South Africa Monday, as the electoral
crisis in Zimbabwe
continued without the release of the presidential poll
results. MDC
secretary-general Tendai Biti told reporters that Tsvangirai
was meeting
with "important people in South Africa" but he gave no other
details.
South Africa has not been much help in resolving the
situation in Zimbabwe.
President Thabo Mbeki and his policy of "quiet
diplomacy" deprived
Zimbabweans of information during the SADC initiated
talks that he mediated.
Comments made by Mbeki and officials from his
government have also been
criticized for their suggestion that all was well
in Zimbabwe.
Most recently deputy Foreign Minister Aziz Pahad said he
had ruled out any
possibility that Robert Mugabe would doctor the election
results, because
"they have already been displayed to the public." Pahad
blasted the media
saying there was an orchestrated campaign, by sections of
the international
and South African media, to claim that the delay is a plot
by the government
to "doctor" and "steal" the elections.
South Africa
based writer and reporter Geoff Hill, who also chairs the
Foreign Press
Association, dismissed Pahad's suggestion that the press has
orchestrated a
canmpaign. He said; "The media are very competitive. We do
not sit together
like a group of witches making up a spell. We are on each
other's tails
trying to steal stories in the best spirits, trying to be the
first to print
something."
Hill said what Pahad should be addressing is the absence of
an explanation
by the Zimbabwe Electoral Commission. He added: "If there is
no effort to
change the results, then why has the ZEC not published those
results."
Regarding Tsvangirai's visit to South Africa, Hill said the MDC
leader is
believed to have been meeting with President Mbeki himself. He
sees this as
a positive sign because Mbeki usually meets with Mugabe first
when there are
serious issues in Zimbabwe.
Despite calls by the
opposition for SADC, AU and UN intervention, on
Saturday Mbeki said the
situation in Zimbabwe was "manageable" and the
international community
should wait for full election results and refrain
from intervention.
Speaking at a conference of "progressive governance"
leaders hosted by Prime
Minister Gordon Brown in the UK, Mbeki said: "If
there is a rerun of the
presidential election let's see what comes out of
that."
Hill
believes that tension within Mbeki's ANC party will soon prove to be
helpful
to the MDC. This is due to the fact that the newly elected ANC
President
Jacob Zuma has a "much tougher line on Zimbabwe".
Mugabe Militants Target Whites Farmers
Associated Press
By ANGUS SHAW – 32
minutes ago
HARARE, Zimbabwe (AP) — Militant supporters of President
Robert Mugabe
targeted whites Monday, forcing about a dozen ranchers and
farmers off their
land as Zimbabwe's longtime ruler fanned racial tensions
amid fears he will
turn to violence to hold on to power.
Mugabe's
opponents pressed a lawsuit seeking to compel the publication of
results of
the March 29 presidential election that they say Morgan
Tsvangirai
won.
The opposition leader urged the international community to persuade
Mugabe
to step down.
"Major powers here, such as South Africa, the
U.S. and Britain, must act to
remove the white-knuckle grip of Mugabe's
suicidal reign and oblige him and
his minions to retire," Tsvangirai wrote
in Monday's edition of Britain's
Guardian newspaper.
"How can global
leaders espouse the values of democracy, yet when they are
being challenged
fail to open their mouths?" he asked.
Tsvangirai was in South Africa
meeting with "important people" on Monday,
said Tendai Biti,
secretary-general of the opposition Movement for
Democratic Change. Biti
declined to give details. South African President
Thabo Mbeki, who mediated
failed pre-election talks between Tsvangirai's and
Mugabe's parties, was out
of the country.
A Zimbabwe court postponed until Tuesday an expected
ruling on an opposition
petition demanding the release of the presidential
election results.
Mugabe's ruling party has called for a recount and a
further delay in the
release of results.
After an increasingly
authoritarian rule during 28 years in power, Mugabe
has virtually conceded
he did not win, and is already campaigning for an
expected runoff against
Tsvangirai on a platform of intimidation of his foes
and exploitation of
racial tensions.
During a talk at a funeral Sunday, the president urged
Zimbabweans to defend
land seized from white farmers in recent years, the
state-controlled Herald
newspaper said.
"This is our soil and the
soil must never go back to the whites," Mugabe
said, referring to whites by
the pejorative Shona term "mabhunu," the Herald
reported.
He spoke as
militants began invading more white farms and demanding the
owners leave.
Such land seizures started in 2000 as Mugabe's response to his
first defeat
at the polls — a loss in a referendum on measures designed to
entrench his
presidential powers.
Commercial Farmers Union spokesman Mike Clark said
at least 23 farms were
invaded and the owners of about half of them were
driven off their land. He
said the farms were in at least seven areas across
the country, saying land
grabs had "become a national exercise
now."
Police in some areas persuaded the invaders to leave, but elsewhere
officers
did not intervene, saying it was a political matter, Clark
said.
Farmer Graham Richards said about 20 local veterans of the 1970s
bush war
against a white-minority government moved onto his Pa Nyanda game
lodge in
southern Masvingo late Saturday. "We were terrified," he said, but
added
that the invaders were not armed.
On Sunday, police arrived
with a bus and took the intruders away, he said.
Two leaders of the veterans
came to the farm to apologize, saying what had
happened was wrong, he
said.
"I think they (police) put a stop to it for the time being, but I
don't know
what will happen tonight or tomorrow," Richards
said.
Mugabe's land reform program was supposed to redistribute among
poor blacks
large commercial farms owned by about 4,500 whites that covered
80 percent
of Zimbabwe's best land. Instead, he used the farms to extend his
patronage
system, giving them to ruling party leaders, security chiefs,
relatives and
friends.
Zimbabwe had been a major food exporter until
then, but its agricultural
sector collapsed and the economy started
unraveling. Today a third of
Zimbabweans depend on international food
handouts, and another third have
fled abroad looking for work or political
asylum.
Eighty percent of Zimbabwe's workers don't have jobs, and the
country
suffers chronic shortages of medicine, food, fuel, water and
electricity as
inflation blazes at 100,000 percent a year.
The elite
that still lives in luxury has a vested interest in keeping Mugabe
in power.
He makes them rich with gifts of land, government contracts and
business
licenses.
Some also fear an opposition government could bring
prosecutions of some
Mugabe loyalists, such as security chiefs involved in
the 1980s subjugation
of the minority Ndebele tribe in which tens of
thousands of civilians were
killed.
Tsvangirai has expressed concerns
Mugabe's regime will mobilize the armed
forces, youth brigades and war
veterans to terrorize voters into supporting
the president in a
runoff.
While government officials have sought to play down the worries
about
violence, Mugabe has been accused of winning previous elections
through
violence and intimidation, with dozens of his opponents killed
during the
2002 and 2005 campaigns.
Mugabe has seen his popularity
battered by the economic crisis.
Official results for parliamentary
elections also held March 29 said
Mugabe's ZANU-PF lost its majority in the
210-seat parliament for the first
time since independence in 1980. Final
results for the 60 elected seats in
the Senate gave the ruling party and the
opposition 30 each.
Unofficial tallies by independent monitors of
presidential results posted at
local polling stations indicate Tsvangirai
won more votes than Mugabe — but
fewer than the 50 percent plus one vote
needed to avoid a runoff.
The law requires a runoff within 21 days of the
election, but diplomats in
Harare and at the United Nations have said Mugabe
might order a 90-day delay
to give security forces time to clamp
down.
The government banned most foreign journalists from covering the
election
and barred Western observers.
A lawyer said Monday that an
American reporter and one from Briton who were
detained last week on charges
of reporting illegally on the election had
been released on bail of 300
million Zimbabwean dollars — about $6 at the
black market rate or $10,000 at
the official rate.
Lawyer Harrison Nkomo said the two journalists were
not allowed to leave the
country and were expected to appear in court
Thursday, when he planned to
argue they should not be tried because they did
not commit a crime. The
American, New York Times correspondent Barry Bearak,
was moved to a clinic
after injuring his back in a fall in his cell, Nkomo
said.
Two South African journalists similarly charged were also granted
bail
Monday, but were not released because the ruling came too late for bail
payments to be made, Nkomo said.
JAG - urgent cautionary statement communique: to
all farmers, Dated 7 April 2008
Email: jag@mango.zw : justiceforagriculture@zol.co.zw
JAG
Hotlines: +263 (011) 610 073, +263 (04) 799 410. If you are in trouble
or
need advice, please don't hesitate to contact us - we're here to
help!
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
FRESH
FARM INVASIONS
The deadlock in the country's political process following
last weeks general
election and the slow announcement of results has left the
government
looking once again for scapegoats to blame for the
outcome.
It is little surprise that further farm invasions have been
orchestrated
in response to falsified reports that white farmers are to blame
for
threatening those currently occupying land with eviction in the event
of
an opposition victory.
At this time it is essential that nothing is
done to aggravate this
situation which might result in any incident that can
lend credence to
government's claims or which may heighten tensions
unnecessarily on the
ground in commercial farming areas. Traditionally,
commercial farmers and
farm workers have always been at the forefront of
these retributive attacks.
JAG is anxious to see a comprehensive and
inclusive solution to Zimbabwe's
land crisis. Whilst we acknowledge
historical injustice, that can no
longer be used as an excuse to defend the
excesses and abuses perpetrated
against farmers and farm workers or as a
reason for a crackdown.
It is high time that all of Zimbabwe's citizens
and stakeholders are treated
with respect so that a sound future for all can
be worked for. This will
involve the re-engagement of farmers through the due
process of the law
in a return to the rule of law and not by any maverick or
individual action.
A call for unity and
a message to the Zimbabwean people
Sokwanele - Enough is Enough -
Zimbabwe PROMOTING NON-VIOLENT PRINCIPLES TO ACHIEVE
DEMOCRACY
|
Sokwanele : 7 April
2008
Zimbabweans protest in
London: this image sent to us by a subscriber
A call for
unity
We at Sokwanele issue a call for all democratic forces in the country to
publically stand strong together, to send a clear message to the people of
Zimbabwe that we are all united in our fight for democracy.
A message
to the Zimbabwean people
We have won Zimbabwe. We have won.
No matter what happens in the days that follow, we need to remember that we
have won.
The Zimbabwe Electoral Commission (ZEC) is taking a long time to release the
Presidential results and this is creating a sense of despondency around many in
the country. We are getting worried messages from Zimbabweans and we are seeing
and hearing people beginning to feel filled with despair.
We have won, so why has this not been announced?
Zimbabwe... this is Robert Mugabe we are dealing with, and his party is Zanu
PF.
What did we expect?
Did we really expect that after our victory that Robert Mugabe would step
forward like a gentleman and congratulate Morgan Tsvangirai before handing over
power?
This is not what Robert Mugabe will do: he will struggle to the end; that is
in his nature.
We need to set aside unrealistic expectations, and we must expect that we
will witness all sorts of efforts from Robert Mugabe and Zanu PF to silence the
will of the people.
None of this changes the fact that the majority of people in our country
voted for change and nor does it change the fact that we have won.
Say no to despair!
In this uncertain period we must remember that dictators thrive on
despair.
Mugabe and Zanu PF know that the longer ZEC delays with announcing the
winner, the more likely it will be that people in our country will start to feel
despondent. They know that people who are depressed and struggling with despair
also find it hard to stand strong and to confront challenges.
The road to democracy is not a 100m sprint: it's a marathon.
We are at that stage of the race where our limbs are tired and our muscles
are aching and our body is telling us to slow down and maybe even give up. But
this is the stage where our minds and our hearts have to take over and we need
to keep focussed and we need to stay strong and committed to seeing our will,
loudly expressed through our votes on March 29th, come to fruit.
The next stage of the struggle we are all involved with now begins within
ourselves. We have to stay strong. We must not be weakened by despair. We must
not sink into doom and gloom. We must resist these impulses and remember a few
truths.
Truth 1
For the first time in many many years, it is us, the forces of democracy and
freedom and of peace and justice, who have established the rules of the game. As
a nation, with one clear voice, we voted for change. Those scores were placed on
the doors for all of us to see with our own eyes. We know the results because we
saw them.
Truth 2
For the first time in their 28 years of history, Zanu PF is obviously and
publically on the backfoot. They are struggling to find a way to change the
incontrovertible reality that they are finished. We are watching them respond to
the simple truth that the people said 'no more'. What we are witnessing now are
the reactions of a dying regime dancing to tune we started to sing on March
29th.
Truth 3
If Mugabe had been victorious, the results would have been released a long
time ago. We would have seen the inauguration ceremony already, and we would
have seen the Heads of State of certain nations flying in to Zimbabwe to eat,
drink and be merry at Mugabe's party.
This has not happened; it has not happened, because Mugabe is not victorious
and he knows it.
Truth 4
Yesterday an article appeared in the Sunday Mail (Zanu PF's mouthpiece)
telling us that Zanu PF is demanding that ZEC should defer announcing the
results of the Presidential vote. The article said
"ZANU-PF has requested the Zimbabwe Electoral Commission (ZEC) to
recount and audit all its electoral material relating to last week's
presidential election following revelations of errors and miscalculations in the
compilation of the poll result. Consequent to the anomalies, the party has also
requested that the commission defer the announcement of the presidential
election result."
Zimbabweans must note that a request for a recount of Presidential ballots
before results are announced is unprocedural and premature. Zimbabwe Lawyers for
Human Rights (ZLHR) have already issued a statement pointing out that this is
wrong.
ZLHR say: "In relation to a presidential election, the Electoral Act, as
amended, does not have any provision for a recount of the votes at all,
and especially during the verification process."
They go on to point out: "such a recount can only be requested once the
declaration of due election has been made by the constituency elections
officer or the senatorial constituency elections officer respectively" and that
this request for a "recount must be done within 48 hours of the declaration
of a candidate to be duly elected."
This means that Robert Mugabe can only demand a recount of the votes after
Morgan Tsvangirai has been declared the winner.
Robert Mugabe's effort to subvert the electoral process muts be seen for what
it is: an attempt for him to avoid the humiliation of being publically
declared the loser.
(The ZLHR full statement is posted on our blog at this
link)
Truth 5
The Sunday Mail article has also revealed Mugabe's weakness and frailty.
Places Zanu PF cites as having votes miscounted includes Mberengwa East and
South, "Where Cde Mugabe was deprived of 468 votes, one of his co-contestants,
Mr Morgan Tsvangirai of the MDC, had the benefit of 100."
Zimbabweans must note that the figures under dispute are pathetically small -
so small that in normal circumstances they would almost be considered
irrelevant. To Robert Mugabe, however, they are very relevant because he is
desperate and he is struggling to claw back the smallest number of votes.
Mugabe is not fighting for victory here; he is fighting for a run-off.
He is fighting for a run-off because he has lost the Presidential vote.
His fight now is for one last chance to try and steal a victory in a run-off.
He knows he has been defeated, and so do we.
Truth 6
Last week The Herald reported that Zanu PF would be contesting results in 16
seats in the House of Assembly. Isn't it very ironic, laughable even, that Zanu
PF is trying to contest results?
We must remember that Zanu PF themselves have set a precedent when it comes
to what happens when results are contested.
In 2000 the MDC contested 39 seats, but before the court could rule on these,
Zanu PF insisted that those Zanu PF MPs who had been 'elected' (or had stolen)
those seats, should be sworn in to the House of Assembly anyway.
So despite their claim that they will be contesting 16 seats, Zimbabweans can
still expect to soon see a House of Assembly where Zanu PF is in the minority in
accordance with the results announced by ZEC for the House of Assembly.
This means that the democratic opposition parties who have fought for justice
for the people will be in the majority. This is a massive victory that marks a
very big turning point in the history and future of Zimbabwe.
Truth 7
What many Zimbabweans don't realise because they are cut off from
communication with the rest of the world, is that the world is watching. We at
Sokwanele know this because we are getting emails from the press, emails from
people all over the world, and we have seen the traffic to our website and
subscriptions to our newsletter increase exponentially.
This time the feedback we are getting is different.
In previous elections the world has watched Mugabe steal and cheat his way to
victory. It has witnessed regional countries endorse victories in the face of
overwhelming evidence that they were stolen.
The world's reaction to those previous elections has been impotence; they
have been left with a sense that there is nothing they can do in the face of
what looks like yet another African cliche of misery and corruption - a tragedy
that the region has allowed to take place.
For Zimbabweans, the world's impotence has felt like a slap in the face, as
if we have been abandoned to a life without justice, stripped of our basic human
rights.
The difference on March 29th 2008 is that the world witnessed an old monster
of a regime, one that appears to be a monolithic undefeatable force, be quietly
overwhelmed at the ballot box.
We - ordinary Zimbabweans - did this despite every effort of the Mugabe
regime to bias the election playing field in its favour; we did this despite
years of abuse and violence; we did it despite the fact that we are poorer and
hungrier and weaker than we have ever been.
The messages we are getting from outsiders around the world is that the
dignity of the Zimbabwean people has impressed and moved those who are following
our story.
Ours is no longer a typical African story of misery and failure.
It's an incredible achievement, and almost a fairytale story of how the
dignity and spirit of peace and justice can dominate the forces of evil. We did
that, and the world is watching with barely suppressed excitement.
With all its heart, the international community wants to see us victorious;
they are cheering for us from the sidelines and praying for us everywhere.
It may not feel like it, but we are not alone.
Truth 8
Zimbabweans have done this by themselves. No country anywhere in the world
can claim that they created our victory.
We did it by ourselves.
Truth 9
We are on the brink of momentous change in our country. As individuals our
lives will change for the better. Now is the time to defeat despair by daring to
dream about what that change will be like.
Imagine what it will be like to have food on our shop shelves again, fuel at
the petrol stations, power throughout the day, water that has been properly
purified and comes out a tap when you switch it on.
Imagine education, jobs, and healthcare.
Imagine that when we go to visit South Africa it will be because we want to
go on holiday rather than shopping trips to buy bread and soap and toilet paper.
Imagine our family and friends all coming home.
Above all, imagine a life without fear.
Truth 10
Zimbabwe is standing on the brink of being a beacon of hope for Africa.
With our dignity and adherence to democratic processes and values, and our
rejection of violence as a route to change, we have shown the world and other
African nations that the Zimbabwean people challenge the cliche that Africa is a
continent plagued only by war and cruelty.
We have managed to resist all the violence that Mugabe has thrown at us, and
time and time again we have turned to the ballot box.
When people turn to us and say 'This is Africa'; we can respond, 'No it's
not, this is Zimbabwe'.
We did it. Rather than feeling filled with despair, we should be feeling
strong, and very, very proud.
What if there's a run-off?
We do not want a run-off because we are the winners.
But it might happen, and if it does happen we must be prepared for it. We go
into a run-off knowing that in a two-horse race there will be even more votes
going towards Morgan Tsvangirai than in the House of Assembly results, where
some of the votes went to Simba Makoni. Zimbabweans, excited by how far people
at home have brought them will come home to add their votes to ours.
We all know, because we know Robert Mugabe and Zanu PF, that if we go to a
run-off then it is likely to be a bumpy ride.
But we also know that Mugabe's fight for power is just one fight on his
hands. The bigger challenge he faces is the economy and poverty in our country.
Robert Mugabe has no solutions to the problem of the economy.
He has passed laws which suppress the free press and control information in
our country, making it hard for us to know the truth amidst all the rumours that
circulate. But the one truth that Mugabe cannot hide from us is the reality that
we are hungry, we have no jobs, we cannot school our children anymore, and we
can barely survive from one day to the next.
To stand any chance of a victory, Robert Mugabe has to be able to tell us
that he can make our lives better. Mugabe cannot offer us, the people, a
solution to our problems unless he can secure support from the international
community. All he can offer us is anti-western rhetoric and propaganda. This
will not feed us, and it will not help us school our children. He cannot prevent
us from knowing this as a fact.
To get the support of the international community, Robert Mugabe needs to be
able to them that his victory is legitimate. Mugabe has relied on extreme
violence in the past to secure his victories, but since the 2005 elections his
propensity for violence has begun to try the patience of even the regional
supporters.
Operation Murambatsvina, for example, brought condemnation from the UN onto
the Zimbabwean government. This happened just after the 2005 elections. The
images of our beaten and tortured civic and opposition leaders in March last
year disgusted the world and shamed regional leaders. Those images showed the
world what we in Zimbabwe already know; that the Mugabe regime can behave like
violent thugs. Violence will not earn him the legitimacy he craves.
Nor will rigging and fraud: many in our country have worked hard to expose
all of Mugabe's tactics, and those people in the world who have the ability to
help Zimbabwe recover now know his tricks.
If we go into a run-off, we will be prepared to continue exposing the rigging
and the fraud and the violence.
We have the advantage this time that by delaying the results in the way he
has, the world is already very suspicious of Mugabe's motives and believe he is
stalling and rigging. Their minds and ears are open and they are ready to listen
to the truth from us.
What can we do as individuals?
-
Begin to break down the barriers between us
Mugabe has done his best to divide our nation, to turn us against each other
and build suspicion and hatred. Now is the time to challenge those lies and
begin to heal and build unity. Smile at those who you previously feared: the
police and security forces. Show them in your behaviour and attitude that the
future is positive and that we all stand to benefit.
-
Keep all of our spirits up
Do your best to remind those around you that just because Zanu PF and Robert
Mugabe are thrashing about like a fish on a hook, it doesn't mean that we have
lost.
Support each other when we begin to let go of hope.
Never forget: we have won.
Subscribe to
this list results by sending an email to elections2008@sokwanele.com.
Please, it
would be very helpful to us if you could subscribe yourselves automatically via
our website at the following address: www.sokwanele.com/join.html. If
you can't, we will still do our best to ensure your addresses are added to the
list for successive mailings.
Visit our website at
www.sokwanele.com Visit our blog: This is Zimbabwe
(Sokwanele blog) Send an e-card!
www.sokwanele.com/sendcard/
We have a fundamental right to freedom of expression!
Sokwanele does not endorse the editorial policy of any source or website
except its own. It retains full copyright on its own articles, which may be
reproduced or distributed but may not be materially altered in any way.
Reproduced articles must clearly show the source and owner of copyright,
together with any other notices originally contained therein, as well as the
original date of publication. Sokwanele does not accept responsibility for any
loss or damage arising in any way from receipt of this email or use thereof.
This document, or any part thereof, may not be distributed for
profit. |
Mugabe under fire over Zimbabwe poll results
Yahoo News
by Godfrey
Marawanyika 56 minutes ago
HARARE (AFP) - Zimbabwe's Robert Mugabe came
under enormous international
pressure on Monday to release presidential
election results as rival Morgan
Tsvangirai made his first foreign trip
since the March 29 polls.
As the heat on Mugabe intensified with
near-simultaneous calls from the
United States, United Nations chief Ban
Ki-moon and the European Union,
Tsvangirai held meetings described as
"private" in Johannesburg.
"He was just discussing normal party
activity... There's nothing to write
home about, it was just an ordinary
visit to the office," the opposition's
spokesman there, Nqobizitha Mlilo,
told the SAPA news agency.
A judge in Harare dismissed a claim by the
electoral commission that the
courts could not hear an opposition legal bid
to force the immediate
declaration of the results and said he would rule
Tuesday on the matter.
"The judge dismissed the Zimbabwe Electoral
Commission's application that
the court had no jurisdiction to hear the
matter," MDC lawyer Alec
Muchadehama told reporters outside the high court
in the capital.
UN chief Ban urged the commission, whose leaders are
appointed by Mugabe, to
release results of the polls "expeditiously and with
transparency," while
the European Union called for them "without further
delay."
The US also questioned the logic behind Mugabe's ruling party's
calling for
a vote recount before it knew the results.
"It's overdue
that the election results be announced," State Department
spokesman Sean
McCormack told reporters.
"It's interesting that they haven't had the
official election results
announced, yet there is a call for a recount. I'm
not sure of the logic
train there," McCormack said.
Tsvangirai, 56,
claims outright victory in the March 29 poll but the ruling
Zimbabwe African
National Union - Patriotic Front (ZANU-PF) says there was
no clear winner
and has endorsed Mugabe for a second-round vote.
The MDC wrested control
of parliament from Mugabe's party for the first time
in the simultaneous
legislative elections, but the ZANU-PF is contesting
enough seats to
potentially overturn that result.
As impatience in the country grew,
hardline Mugabe supporters known as war
veterans, who led often violent farm
invasions at the start of the decade,
tried to move onto several of the few
remaining white-owned farms.
The Commercial Farmers Union, which
represents white farmers in Zimbabwe,
said Mugabe supporters had moved onto
at least 30 white-owned properties and
accused the ruling party of an
"apartheid" campaign.
"People are being paid to basically carry out the
wishes of the highest
office. This is purely racial. We should be living in
a country of harmony
but the state media is pushing racial hatred which is
not good for the
country," the union's president Trevor Gifford told
AFP.
The farm invasions serve as a reminder of the violence which
followed
Mugabe's last electoral reverse when he lost a referendum on
presidential
powers in 2000.
The then occupation of some 4,000 farms
came after he was defeated in a
constitutional referendum aimed at
broadening his powers and facilitating
land seizures.
Gifford warned
similar sentiments were on the boil again and urged the
Southern African
Development Community (SADC) regional bloc to intervene.
"It's another
apartheid. It's going to get out of hand if SADC does not have
a grip on
it," he said.
Mugabe, who has ruled Zimbabwe ever since independence from
Britain in 1980,
has sought to stoke racial tensions and discredit the
opposition as Western
puppets who would reverse his land
reforms.
"Land must remain in our hands. The land is ours, it must not be
allowed to
slip back into the hands of whites," Mugabe was quoted as saying
by the
state daily Herald on Monday.
Critics blame Mugabe's land
reform programme, which was intensified after he
lost the referendum in
2000, for Zimbabwe's meltdown from regional
breadbasket to economic basket
case.
Faced with 80 percent unemployment and six-digit inflation, almost
one third
of Zimbabwe's 13 million population have left the country, both to
find work
and food as even basics such as bread and cooking oil are now hard
to come
by.
Meanwhile, a Harare court released on bail New York Times
correspondent
Barry Bearak, a British national and two South African media
workers after
charging them with covering the last week's polls without
accreditation.
UN Chief Asks Zimbabwe's Electoral Commission To Declare
Election Results
nasdaq
(RTTNews) - UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon
urged Zimbabwe's electoral
commission to announce the results of the
election held nine days ago, after
a court on Monday deferred judgment in an
urgent application by the
opposition seeking their release.
In a
statement issued on Monday, Ban Ki Moon urged the electoral commission
to
"discharge its responsibility and release the results expeditiously and
with
transparency."
He also asked the political leaders to act responsibly and
settle all issues
through legal means "for the good of all
Zimbabweans."
Earlier in the day, the Harare High Court rejected an
argument by the
Zimbabwe Electoral Commission that it did not have the
authority to hear the
opposition's application for a court order forcing ZEC
to release the
results of the election held on March 29.
But it
deferred until Tuesday a ruling on whether the application was urgent
or
not.
Also on Monday, war veterans chased several white farmers off their
land in
Mashonaland Central province, as "ordered from the top".
For
comments and feedback: contact editorial@rttnews.com
UK wants "proper monitoring" of any Zimbabwe run-off
Reuters
Mon 7 Apr
2008, 12:19 GMT
LONDON (Reuters) - British Prime Minister Gordon Brown
called on Monday for
"proper international monitoring" if there is a runoff
of Zimbabwe's
presidential election.
Zimbabwean ruling party and
independent projections point to a runoff
between veteran President Robert
Mugabe and old rival Morgan Tsvangirai
after the March 29 vote in the former
British colony. The opposition said it
won outright.
But no results
have yet been released from the presidential election,
fuelling opposition
suspicions that Mugabe is playing for time to find a way
to keep his 28-year
hold on power.
If a second round of elections is held, "it's very
important that there is
proper international monitoring," Brown told a news
conference.
"I believe there is a united will of the international
community that
elections have got to be seen to be fair, election results
have got to be
published, elections have got to be properly monitored," he
said.
During the first round, Zimbabwe banned monitors from Western
countries,
such as Britain, that are critical of Mugabe.
Brown held
two hours of talks with South African President Thabo Mbeki on
Sunday and
said he was also in touch with other African leaders on Zimbabwe.
British
officials declined to give details of the talks with Mbeki, who has
previously mediated in Zimbabwe's political crisis and has been accused by
critics of being soft on Mugabe.
Tsvangirai flew to South Africa on
Monday for talks, aides said.
US questions ruling party's call for vote recount in
Zimbabwe
Yahoo News
Mon Apr 7, 11:46 AM ET
WASHINGTON (AFP) - The United States
on Monday questioned the logic behind
the Zimbabwean ruling party's call for
a vote recount before the results of
the March 29 presidential election are
announced.
"It's overdue that the election results be announced,"
State Department
spokesman Sean McCormack told reporters.
"It's
interesting that they haven't had the official election results
announced,
yet there is a call for a recount. I'm not sure of the logic
train there,"
McCormack said, eliciting a laugh.
"Let's have the... official election
results announced and from there, as
we've been saying for some time, let's
see how this process unfolds," the
spokesman said.
"It needs to be a
process in which the Zimbabwean people need to have
confidence. So the first
step in that process is to have the election
results announced officially,"
McCormack said.
State media said Sunday that President Robert Mugabe's
ZANU-PF was now
demanding a complete recount after detecting
irregularities.
The demand was swiftly branded "illegal" by the
opposition, which claimed
the ruling party had been stuffing ballot boxes
with false voting slips
since election day.
Mugabe, in power since
independence from Britain 28 years ago, suffered the
heaviest blow of his
rule in the March 29 joint presidential and
parliamentary
elections.
ZANU-PF lost control of parliament to the main opposition
group, the
Movement for Democratic Change, while the ruling party has
conceded Mugabe
failed to surpass the 50 percent threshold needed to avoid a
run-off.
At a meeting of its politburo Friday, the party endorsed Mugabe
to stand in
a run-off, which should take place on April 19.
MDC press statement - Zanu PF dusts up an old lie to deceive
Zimbabweans
Zanu PF dusts up an old lie to deceive
Zimbabweans
Zanu PF is once again desperate to find an issue that it
will bring to the
centre-stage to reverse the heavy and structural losses it
has suffered in
this election.
That issue, sadly, is the issue of
land. Indeed, sadly for Zanu PF, it is a
message that sounds like a broken
record. In the past few days, Zanu PF has
upped the tempo and unleashed war
and terror on farmers perceived to be
sympathetic to the MDC.
In
Masvingo, Mutoko, Chiredzi and Mhangura our people are being brutalised
by a
regime that is smarting from a heavy electoral defeat. The regime has
also
created the myth that white people are revisiting their erstwhile farms
with
a view to reoccupying them following the MDC's victory in last week's
election.
We restate the principle that the land reform programme, as
done by Zanu PF
in 2000, is irreversible but there has to be an audit of the
land and a
transparent agrarian reform programme that emphasises food
security and
productivity.
In our RESTART programme, we said that
land allocation will reconcile the
MDC's policy principles with
on-the-ground realities of farm occupation by
applying the principles of
justice, accountability, need and ability.
There is no possibility that
the rationalisation will result in the
pre-February
2000 status quo
being restored on the land, but equally the current status
quo arising from
the fast-track land grab will not be maintained. In other
words, the MDC
will neither return to the pre-2000 land-ownership patterns
nor endorse or
condone the inequitable and inappropriate land distribution
arising from the
fast-track process.
Where people are found to have been settled
legitimately, according to the
Land Commission's criteria, or are
subsequently legitimately settled, they
will be fully supported, with the
state ensuring that they have the inputs,
working capital and other
assistance needed to make their farming ventures
succeed. Under the MDC
government, agrarian reform will also embrace the
communal areas, where the
bulk of the rural population will continue to
live.
Similarly, in our
manifesto, we made it clear that we recognise the
country's brutal colonial
past, the need to deal with historical injustices
and the obligation to
create a modern industrial state in which land is the
engine of equitable
development and not a dead asset.
The MDC will rationalise the situation
by ensuring that there is no return
to the pre2000 status nor will the
present regime of wastage, corruption,
under-utilisation and multi-ownership
be preserved.
Thus, the land issue cannot be used to divert attention
from the real issue
at hand. The issue at hand is that Zanu PF has dismally
lost this election.
Robert Mugabe has lost the election hands down and is
refusing to let go.
The issue at hand is that Mugabe's term expired on 11
March 2008 and he no
longer has the mandate to govern. The real issue is
that Zanu PF, by
refusing to grant President Tsvangirai the mandate to form
a government, is
committing a coup de t'at against the people's sovereign
will.
No amount of energy in trying to reinvent what s essentially a dead
issue
can change the reality that this regime of dinosaurs is history. The
decision to refuse to announce the result is unacceptable as it is
unconstitutional.
We thus reiterate the call made by President
Tsvangirai in asking the United
Nations, the African Union, SADC and in
particular President Thabo Mbeki to
demand that Mugabe resigns immediately
to allow the country to move forward.
Hon Tendai Biti, MP
MDC
Secretary-General
DA: Mbeki out of touch with reality in Zim
IOL
April 07 2008 at 04:25PM
Opposition parties on Monday criticised
President Thabo Mbeki's
assessment of Zimbabwe's elections.
Mbeki's remarks made in Britain on Sunday indicated he was either
woefully
out of touch with reality in Zimbabwe, or he was attempting to
"deliberately
mislead the world's media about the extent of the crisis in
that country,"
the Democratic Alliance's Dianne Kohler-Barnard said.
Independent
Democrats leader Patricia de Lille lambasted Mbeki's
"flawed
logic".
"To suggest that Africans are claiming their space and that
African
leaders are taking full responsibility for their problems at home
and in the
same breath to refer to Zimbabwe as an example of this is not
only
misleading, it borders on the delusional," De Lille
said.
The argument that Zimbabwe's election
process had been "more
satisfactory" this time around was just not good
enough for the people of
Zimbabwe.
"The fact is that the people
of Zimbabwe may indeed be claiming their
space and voting responsibly to
deal with their problems, but [President
Robert] Mugabe is doing everything
he can to deny them their rights."
The delay in releasing the
presidential vote outcome was just more
evidence that Mugabe was a tyrant,
and as long as Mbeki continued to remain
silent and failed to act on his
Southern African Development Community
(SADC) mandate, he would remain a
silent partner of Mugabe's tyranny.
Mbeki should be at home in
Africa lobbying African leaders in the
African Union and the SADC to speak
with Mugabe as a matter of urgency and
insist he allow democracy to take its
course, De Lille said.
Kohler-Barnard said to ensure Mbeki did not
remain misinformed about
how flawed the elections were, the DA would provide
him with a copy of its
minority report on the elections.
Kohler-Barnard was one of two DA MPs in the SA delegation in the SADC
observer mission.
The report detailed the material flaws in the
way the election was
conducted, and showed there was "no way that the poll
can be judged as
having been free and fair", Kohler-Barnard
said.
"The reality is that the elections were held in conditions
where the
odds were heavily stacked in favour of the governing party,
Zanu-PF.
"The net result of this fundamentally undemocratic
environment was
that any opposition victory could occur only in spite of
overwhelming odds
designed to mitigate the possibility of such an
eventuality," she said.
Mbeki had also suggested to the world
community that it should wait
for the results of a Presidential run-off
before judging the situation in
Zimbabwe.
"This position is
nonsensical for a number of reasons including, most
obviously, the question
of how a run-off can be mooted before the results of
the presidential poll
have even been released.
"Secondly, and perhaps even more
importantly such a run-off is likely
to be held in an even less democratic
environment, and one in which there is
a real chance that all available
measures (including violence and torture)
will be used to stifle the
democratic will of the people."
It was high time that Mbeki be
honest and open about the true extent
of the crisis in Zimbabwe,
Kohler-Barnard said. - Sapa
War veterans lay siege again to Zimbabwe white
farmers
Monsters and Critics
Apr 7, 2008, 16:45 GMT
Harare/Johannesburg - They
arrived in the dead of Monday night - around 100
of them - outside a
white-owned tobacco farm near the Zimbabwean capital
Harare, kicking at the
gate and singing Chimurenga (liberation war) songs.
The farmer, who
cannot be identified for security reasons, knew four of
their leaders. They
were local men, he told Deutsche Presse- Agentur dpa by
telephone.
'They said they didn't have a problem with me but that it
had been directed
from the top. They said all the white farmers will be
asked to go.'
The farmer was given until morning to evacuate his wife and
four kids. 'I
asked them if we could continue grading the tobacco crop that
is in the
barn. They said they thought so but that they'd have to
ask.'
Zimbabwe's few remaining white farmers - estimated at around 300,
down from
around 4,500 eight years ago - are under attack.
In scenes
harkening back to 2000 when President Robert Mugabe encouraged war
veterans
(mostly ruling party youth militia) to seize white-owned commercial
farms
his henchmen are on the march again.
The trigger then as now was an
electoral defeat. White farmers - mostly
supporters of Mugabe's rival
opposition leader Morgan Tsvangirai - were
scapegoated for Mugabe's defeat
in a referendum on a draft constitution that
would have significantly
boosted his powers. Dozens of white farmers and
black farm workers were
killed in the ensuing land grabs.
Now they are being hung out to dry for
his Zanu-PF party's defeat in March
29 parliamentary elections and his
apparent second-place finish behind
Tsvangirai in concomitant presidential
elections.
The results of the presidential vote have yet to be announced
but an
independent estimate by an election NGO showed Mugabe taking under 42
per
cent of votes to Tsvangirai's 49 per cent.
The election was 'a
way to reopen the invasion of Zimbabwe by the whites,'
the head of the
Mugabe-loyal War Veterans Association said Friday, accusing
white farmers of
conspiring with the opposition to retake their farms from
blacks.
'The MDC (Tsvangirai's Movement for Democratic Change) has
made a monumental
blunder provoking a vicious dog it had better left
sleeping,' Mugabe's
information secretary George Charamba warned.
The
invasions started on Saturday, in the same area as in February 2000, in
the
dusty farming town of Masvingo, where they took over three farms and a
lodge.
By Monday the action had moved to Centenary in Mashonaland
Central. By
Monday afternoon sources there said the area had been emptied of
white
farmers and the total number of expropriated farmers nationwide were
estimated at over 10.
'They are still here,' a farm clerk said by
telephone from a tobacco farm in
Centenary. 'They (the war veterans) are
plenty. More than 30. They are
beating drums and asking for
food.'
The farm owners and the farm manager had fled, but 'we (workers)
are also in
trouble,' he said.
'I'm making money under Mugabe but if
they throw me off again I think I will
leave,' said another farmer who lost
three farms since 2000 to Mugabe's
brand of land reform and now breeds
cattle and grows tobacco and seed maize
on a leased farm of around 2,000
hectares.
Analysts say Mugabe's scaremongering about the 'white menace'
is all part of
a ploy to claw back support for a runoff in rural areas once
loyal to him
where Tsvangirai took votes from him for this
election.
'Sometimes the party creates enemies where real ones don't
exist to keep
itself going,' South Africa's Business Day newspaper noted.
'Now the
perceived enemies are the farmers, whereas in the 1980s
'dissidents' had to
be crushed in Matabeleland.'
Among Mugabe's loyal
supporters are some of the black subsistence farmers
that benefited from
land reform, which decimated commercial agriculture,
wrecking the economy
and causing widespread food shortages.
The MDC has denied plans to turn
back the clock on land reform, saying it
will only take back farms where the
owner has more than one and accusing
Mugabe of a planning a war against his
own people.
So far the violence that characterized the 2000 land grabs
has been absent.
'They didn't treat us badly,' the expropriated farmer in
Harare said. 'But
I'm out of a job for now.'
Zimbabwe court slaps charges on foreign media workers
Yahoo News
1
hour, 30 minutes ago
HARARE (AFP) - A court in Zimbabwe charged on Monday
two South Africans, a
British national and a US journalist with breaking
media accreditation rules
and released them on bail, their lawyers
said.
New York Times correspondent Barry Bearak, 58, and a
45-year-old British
national have been told to reappear in court on
Thursday, a week after they
were picked up by the authorities at a guest
house in Harare.
They spent four nights behind bars.
"They have
both been released on 300 million (Zimbabwean) dollars bail,"
lawyer
Harrison Nkomo told journalists outside the court. The bail amount is
equivalent to 10,000 US dollars according to the official exchange
rate.
Bearak, who won a Pulitzer prize in 2002 for his reporting from
Afghanistan,
has been ordered to reside at a medical clinic after he slipped
and injured
his back in jail, while the Briton must stay at the British
embassy, Nkomo
said.
The South Africans, technicians for satellite TV
servicing company
Globecast, were slapped with two sets of charges, their
employer said.
They will appear in court on Tuesday over the first charge
of breaching
accreditation rules and again on Friday on a second charge
related to their
initial release last week, Globecast CEO Alan Hird told
AFP.
After Monday's hearing one of the South Africans, who suffers from
diabetes,
was expected to return to a Harare hospital where his blood sugar
level was
being monitored.
The pair were ordered to pay bail of 200
million Zimbabwean dollars each
before they would be freed pending their
next court appearance.
Zimbabwean authorities barred most foreign media
from covering last
Saturday's presidential, parliamentary and municipal
elections and had
warned they would deal severely with journalists who
sneaked into the
country.
However a number of news organisations,
including the BBC, have been filing
reports from correspondents operating
under cover.
President Robert Mugabe's government passed a media law on
the eve of the
last presidential elections in 2002 which has been invoked to
expel foreign
correspondents and shut down at least four independent
newspapers.
Why Zimbabwe Matters
OhMyNews
[Opinion] A defining moment
for Africa, South Africa and the world
Nicolas van der
Leek
Published 2008-04-08 03:47 (KST)
Can rhetoric hold an
entire country captive? Will the leaders (both inside
Africa and beyond)
stand by while evil men do something?
In many ways, no news now from
Zimbabwe is bad news for Zimbabweans. What
happens now though will enlighten
outsiders more about the realities and
motivations of South Africa's,
Africa's and the rest of the world's leaders
than about anything new we can
learn about the poor beleaguered country
itself.
The story of
Zimbabwe is the story that anyone outside of Africa,
contemplating investing
in Africa, worries about most. An incisive article
in Time ("A Lion Meets
His Winter," by Alex Perry and Ian Evans) summarizes
Zimbabwe's history as
being essentially a history of Africa: "They wrested
their continent back
from colonial rule only to plunder it afresh."
Heidi Holland on
Mugabe
While those who know and understand Mugabe -- such as author Heidi
Holland -- are not surprised by Mugabe digging in his heels, what is
surprising is the South African and international press trumpeting hopefully
that "Mugabe must go." Despite virtually no evidence and with Mugabe making
no appearances himself subsequent to the polls, the press repeatedly (and
hopefully) dismissed Mugabe, describing him as "teetering." Holland says
Mugabe is at his most dangerous once he perceives himself to have been
"humiliated." Holland also predicted (speaking to SkyNews) that 'we haven't
seen the worst from Mugabe."
Did journalists (local and foreign)
suddenly forget about the last decade of
history in Zimbabwe?
Despite
20 years of dictatorship, and obviously Mugabe's old guard remaining
comfortably entrenched and safely ensconced in their corridors of power, the
media after the election seemed to run away on a series of hubris filled
tangents -- in a citizen-journalism-Hollywood-reporter-style of third-hand
rumor-based reporting. After the US and international media's complicity in
promoting (even if by echoing other media) the invasion of Iraq, this looks
similarly shaky.
Lame Duck Leadership From South Africa
The
most powerful figure outside of Zimbabwe able to wield influence in
Zimbabwe
is South Africa's President Thabo Mbeki. True to the "lame duck"
label,
Mbeki described the crisis in Zimbabwe as "manageable." African
National
Congress president Jacob Zuma went further, but not by much. These
wishy-washy hands-off approaches by the so-called leaders of Zimbabwe's
powerful neighbor say an awful lot about the new ruling psychology in South
Africa.
Meanwhile the Movement for Democratic Change (a rival party
in Zimbabwe)
could do nothing but announce their "victory," and do so again
and again,
each subsequent announcement appearing increasingly ineffectual.
All the
while Mugabe was biding his time, waiting for the hubbub to die
down.
Playing Poker
During this period the Zimbabwe Electoral
Commission (tasked by and
answerable to the governing ZANU-PF) found itself
in a quandary, having in
its hands a vote count that "didn't look good for
ZANU-PF." The ZEC and
ZANU-PF's hesitation upon discovering the election
results itself also
demonstrates to what extent they have been surprised by
the popular
sentiment of Zimbabweans, and to what extent the government has
become
disconnected and indoctrinated by their dear leader.
The ZEC
has since simply kept the voting results close to their chests,
while Mugabe
ordered a mopping up of those elements that he perceived to be
rocking his
boat. Journalists that were arrested included New York Times
reporter Barry
Bearak and, writing for The Sunday Telegraph, Stephen Bevan.
CNN
Speaks
Meanwhile, Fiona Forde, writing for South Africa's The Star
newspaper,
exposed some of the troubling ironies going on, to some extent,
behind the
scenes. While George Charamba, minister of information, banned
CNN from
reporting on Zimbabwe's election, a few exceptions were made to
allow
foreign media "accreditation." The fee for accreditation? $1,700.
Presumably, the handful of licenses was given to only those whom Charamba
considered "friends of the state."
But when news around the world
took the sort of slant Charamba didn't
support, on whom did he call? CNN.
Ford writes, "You couldn't make it up if
you tried: the president's man
reporting live on a banned TV station that
was being carried live in his own
country." And what was Charamba saying? He
was dismissing reports that
Mugabe was about to step down.
Hesitation
Most of the news the
outside world received in the end, Ford contends, was
provided by these
"unaccredited" reporters roaming around Zimbabwe. The most
recent reports
describe ZANU-PF's take on the election as filled with
"inaccuracies."
Meanwhile, even Zimbabwe's High Court, expected to rule on
Monday, appears
hesitant to appear to be in a position to provide
jurisdiction on any of the
election issues.
Outside of Zimbabwe, Britain has committed to spending
$2 billion a year for
a Mugabe-free Zimbabwe. South African businesses and
leaders, taking their
cue from Mbeki, are adopting a wait-and-see attitude.
One South African
expert has described the Zimbabwe economy as being "about
the size of
Soweto," a large township on the outskirts of
Johannesburg.
While businesses outside Zimbabwe insist that property
rights be restored,
the war veterans are running amuck in Zimbabwe,
spreading rumors and fear
amounting to "whites are coming to take back their
farms."
While one company -- IMPLATS (the world's second largest producer
of
platinum) -- wants to build a power plant in Zimbabwe, South Africa and
rest
of the world seem to remain of the opinion that the country is too
insignificant to warrant any form of real intervention.
With 80
percent unemployment, an inflation approaching 200,000 percent,
Zimbabweans
say "Zuakwana" (enough). Apparently, for Zimbabweans at least,
it may take a
while longer to reach absolute rock bottom.
Botswana opposition urge SADC and AU to intervene in Zimbabwe
By Lance
Guma
07 April 2008
The head of the Botswana Peoples Party, Bernard
Balikani has called on the
Southern African Development Community and
African Union leaders to
intervene in Zimbabwe before the situation gets
worse. Speaking to the
Botswana Press Agency Balikani said SADC and the AU
must exert pressure on
Mugabe’s government to release the results of the
March 29 presidential
elections. He expressed concern that the delay in the
release of results was
a ploy by Zanu PF to manipulate the outcome even
though they had been
defeated.
Balikani described the policy of
‘quite diplomacy’ exercised by many African
leaders as a failure and said
they use the policy as a pretext to avoid
criticising Mugabe. He also said
the withholding of results by the ZEC was a
clear demonstration that most
bodies running elections in Africa were not
independent. The Botswana
opposition leader urged African leaders to
intervene and avert the
possibility of bloodshed in Zimbabwe. He stressed
the need for an urgent
political solution to be found.
.
SW Radio Africa
Zimbabwe news
Alert Over Zim Crisis?
Mmegi, Botswana
Monday, 7 April 2008
BY
TUMELO SETSHOGO
CORRESPONDENT
The Botswana Defence Force (BDF) is
reportedly on high alert following the
delayed announcement of results of
presidential elections in neighbouring
Zimbabwe. Reliable sources within the
BDF told Monitor on Saturday that the
military has been on standby should
events in Zimbabwe threaten the peace
and tranquility of
Botswana.
The sources said over the weekend that BDF has been on
the alert since
Thursday and they are not aware when this will end. "We have
been on a
standby since last week Thursday should anything happen in
Zimbabwe," said a
BDF soldier.
Word on the streets of Gaborone is
that the BDF has been on the alert
because of the events in Zimbabwe. Some
people in the city said their
friends and relatives who are members of the
army told them about the
matter.
"Yes I know that these guys are on
standby to prepare for whatever happens
in Zimbabwe which could cause
disruptions in our country," said a young man
in Maruapula whose uncle is a
soldier.
Meanwhile, BDF's director of protocol Lieutenant Colonel
Mogorosi Baatweng
denied that the military is on the alert. "That is not
true.
The BDF is not on a standby," he said. But he stated that the
National
Disaster Preparedness Committee is on standby to assist if anything
happens
in Zimbabwe. Baatweng said though they are not part of the
committee, they
help whenever there is need. "That is where we come in to
assist. It is
business as usual at BDF," he said.
Government
spokesperman Jeff Ramsay said he is not aware of any orders
concerning the
BDF to be on a standby.
"I am not aware of anything like that," said
Ramsay. However, he said
government is closely watching the situation in
Zimbabwe. "But I don't want
to speculate on what could happen
there."
Efforts to get comments over the weekend from Vice President
Mompati
Merafhe, Minister of Justice, Defence and Security Brigadier
Ramadeluka
Seretse were futile.
Zim election commission comes under
fire
From AFP, 7 April
Zimbabwe’s electoral commission (ZEC) has been accused of
pro-government
bias by the opposition and of rank incompetence by the ruling
party as it
sits on results of last weekend’s presidential polls. The
theoretically
independent body has come under fire not only from both sides
of Zimbabwe’s
political divide but also from abroad, with the US querying
its impartiality
because President Robert Mugabe appointed its leadership.
In its pre-emptive
announcement last Tuesday that it had won both the
parliamentary and
presidential election, the opposition Movement for
Democratic Change (MDC)
made clear its lack of faith in the commission. "We
don’t trust the ZEC,
which is not independent," said party secretary general
Tendai Biti before
either the presidential or parliamentary results had been
announced. Even
though the ZEC has since declared the MDC beat Mugabe’s Zanu
PF in the
parliamentary elections, the opposition is still not convinced.
"Instead of
verifying, they are modifying the results in the presidential
elections,"
chief MDC spokesperson Nelson Chamisa said yesterday. The MDC,
convinced the
delay in the presidential election results is a tactic to buy
Mugabe time,
has launched a legal bid to force the commission to declare the
outcome.
However, as its lawyers spent the weekend in the high court, the
ZEC has
also had to fend off flak from Zanu PF. The ruling party now wants a
complete recount, both of the presidential election and 16 key parliamentary
constituencies. "This the worst-run election I have ever experienced," Zanu
PF secretary for administration Didymus Mutasa said in announcing plans to
contest some of the parliamentary results.
In revealing Zanu PF’s
demand for a complete recount of the presidential
election, the state-run
Herald said the party was particularly concerned
about the outcome in four
particular constituencies. In a letter to the
commission, Zanu PF’s lawyers
wrote: "The constituency elections officer and
his team committed errors of
miscounting that are so glaring as to prejudice
not just our clients’
candidate but also (in some instances) his
co-contestants." Amid the
accusations, one provincial elections officer has
been arrested. The ZEC
replaced the Electoral Supervisory Commission in 2006
after complaints from
the opposition that it had helped Mugabe rig previous
elections. According
to the law, the ZEC’s chairperson is appointed by the
president after
consultation with the judicial service commission. It
consists of four other
commissioners appointed by the president from a list
of seven nominees
submitted by a parliamentary committee. But Lovemore
Madhuku, a
constitutional lawyer and long-time government critic, said it
would be a
"fallacy" to describe the ZEC as independent. "There is no
difference
between the Zimbabwe Electoral Commission and its predecessor,
the Electoral
Supervisory Commission. What we had was just a name change and
no
fundamental change," he said. US State Department spokesperson Tom Casey
suggested last week that delays could be down to the "somewhat politicised
composition" of the ZEC. But with the parliamentary results having
confounded predictions that the ZEC would hand victory to the ruling party
on a plate, some commentators say such criticism is unfair.
Zimbabwe's civil groups
speak on delayed election results
zimbabwejournalists.com
7th Apr 2008 14:47 GMT
By Civil Society
Organisations
ZIMBABWEAN civil society expresses its gravest concern
at the unacceptable
delay in the release of poll results for local
government, House of
Assembly, Senate and Presidential elections. We find
the reasons given by
the Zimbabwe Electoral Commission (ZEC) for this delay
to be inadequate as
all of the results were displayed outside all polling
stations at the close
of counting and verification on 29 March 2008 and were
therefore in the
public domain. We therefore call upon ZEC to release these
results urgently
to restore some measure of public confidence in the
electoral process.
We also call upon the establishment to desist from
unlawfully arresting or
threatening with arrest, foreign or local
journalists, opposition political
party leaders/activists and civil society
leaders/activists at such a
sensitive national political moment in
Zimbabwe.
We have been informed that as of last night (3 April 2008)
armed Zimbabwe
Republic Police (ZRP) personnel had raided local hotels and
arrested and
detained at least 3 journalists and a number of people
celebrating House of
Assembly victories in some parts of the country for
reasons best known to
themselves. Such actions, on the part of the ZRP and
those in charge of
them can only but add to the serious suspicions by the
electorate that their
vote is not being respected.
We also have it on
good and reliable record that the Zanu Pf party has
already embarked on a
retributive and violent campaign before the final
results for the Senate and
Presidential elections have been announced. It
is our view that such
actions show lack of respect for the will of the
people.
Further to
this, and in the event that there is no clear winner in the
Presidential
election result, a circumstance that will necessitate an
electoral run off
in terms of Section 110 of the Electoral Act, we urge the
ZEC to ensure that
said run-off is undertaken within 21 days as is outlined
by the Electoral
Act.
This is said because, we have it on reliable knowledge that the
government
has the undemocratic intention of extending the period for the
holding of a
run-off Presidential election from 21 to 90 days using disputed
and
autocractic Presidential powers on the pretext that the ZEC is
ill-prepared
to hold it in the stipulated period. We hold that this is
unacceptable given
the anxiety that is gripping the nation and given that in
essence, such a
move is patently undemocratic and has all the vestiges of
creating a serious
constitutional and political crisis of tremendous
proportions.
We therefore insist and call upon ZEC to follow the
Electoral Act and ensure
that the processes of a run-off, should there be
one, are democratic and
instil confidence in the electorate that the ballot
will not be subject to
arbitrary and undemocratic procedures.
Camp Restore Democracy in Zimbabwe
On the 6th of April 2008, Phil Matibe set up "Camp Restore Democracy"outside
President George Bush's Crawford Texas Ranch. Its a one man tent draped with the
Zimbabwe flag with banners appealing to President Bush to assist us in our time
of need.It is my intention to present a petition to President Bush, asking for
the US to support a UN Security Council Resolution for Intervention in
Zimbabwe.
This is a visible 48hr one man demonstration by Phil Matibe supported by Tom
Nyandoro coordinating the web technology and media side. Phil Matibe braving
inclement Texas weather and the harsh elements this fight for democracy will
prevail. Join us in petitioning The UN and President George Bush at http://www.ipetitions.com/petition/mdczimbabwe/index.html
This action will be complemented by a demo and petition to the UN SG by MDC
Zimbabwe North America Province(NAP) on Friday April 11 at 9:30AM commencing
from The Zimbabwe UN Mission and proceeding to the UN Plaza in New York.
For more information please contact Phil Matibe at Phone 512-788-6355 pmatibe@gmail.com and Tom Nyandoro at
267-421-2304 nyandorot@gmail.com and
the petition is located at our website http://www.zimbabweindistress.org/?cat=3
Regards
Tom Nyandoro
Zimbabwe In Distress Press Contact
Fearful Zimbabweans begin exodus to new life
africasia
BEIT BRIDGE, South Africa-Zimbabwe border, April 7
(AFP)
With his wife and two
children in tow Aaron Mashebu crosses from Zimbabawe
into South Africa,
fearful his homeland might descend into post-election
chaos.
Zimbabwe
could "snowball into anarchy and at that time it might be difficult
to run
away, the borders may be closed," the 42-year-old former teacher
tells
AFP.
He was just one of 1,500 Zimbabweans to cross the border post at
Beit Bridge
on Sunday and while many were simply nipping across to stock up
on
much-needed basics like sugar, rice and cooking oil, others say enough is
enough.
"My family and I have passed through the furnace of hell in
the past two
years. I can bear it no more. For me it is final farewell to
Zimbabwe until
further notice," says Celine Majola, who is without her two
children.
"I do not know where I am going in particular in South Africa.
But anywhere
there is just fine," says Majola, who shunned her husband's
advice to stay
put and crossed the Limpopo into South Africa in the hope of
finding work.
"I hope to start a new life, look for something to do and
send money back
home to feed my children. Zimbabwe no longer holds any
promising future for
me," she says as she adjusts the load on her
head.
Eunice Lindiwe, 27, carrying a baby, has just arrived in South
Africa from
Zimbabwe and hopes to find any menial job to tide her
over.
"It is frightening what is happening in Zimbabwe. Now I do not feel
safe
staying in this country any longer."
Majola, 32, tells how her
grocery shop was destroyed in a state-sponsored
demolition blitz and how she
later got a job as a factory hand only for the
company to close down late
last year as Zimbabwe's economy imploded.
She said she had decided not to
heed her jobless husband's pleas because she
did not want to be in Zimbabwe
if fighting broke out after the elections.
Others have decided to stay,
keeping a careful eye on developments to see if
Robert Mugabe's attempts to
cling to power following presidential elections
claimed by opposition leader
Morgan Tsvangirai turn nasty.
"We are really suffering in Zimbabwe. But
there are some of us who have
decided to stay and watch the political
situation unfold for now," Tracy
Tumba, a 29-year-old trader tells AFP at
the Zimbabwean end of the border
crossing.
Tumba wants Mugabe to go.
"We need fresh brains, hands and ideas, but he is
stubborn," she
says.
She crosses the border posts twice a week to buy scarce basic goods
in South
Africa which she resells in Zimbabwe. "That is what I do to keep us
alive,"
she adds.
Agricultural production in Mugabe's country has
been halved by his
controversial land reform programme and Zimbabwe is now
forced to import its
own staple crop maize from neighbouring
countries.
This has helped Zimbabwe chalk up world-record inflation above
100,000
percent and an unemployment rate of a staggering 80
percent.
The economic conditions in Zimbabwe were even too much for 60
Somalis, who
said they had fled their war-torn country and crossed five
countries and
arrived in Zimbabwe two months ago.
"Life is unbearable
in Zimbabwe," says Mustapha Umar, who is leading the
group, as he shares
three loaves of bread with his compatriots. "We escaped
bullets in Somalia
only to face starvation in Zimbabwe."
Many Zimbabweans at the border post
were wearing yellow t-shirts emblazoned
with the picture of presidential
candidate and former finance minister Simba
Makoni, but appearances were
deceiving.
"I am not wearing a Makoni shirt because I am his supporter. I
am for Morgan
(Tsvangirai). But the Makoni t-shirts, produced in South
Africa, were not
allowed to cross the border into Zimbabwe. So they were
given to us in large
quantities," explains an ice-cream seller who
identified himself only as
James.
How Zimbabwe's refugees help Robert Mugabe
The Telegraph
By David
Blair in Johannesburg
Last Updated: 7:37pm BST
07/04/2008
As he lays out a selection of giraffes and
elephants made of wire and
beads, Obert Gomba seems indistinguishable from
any other street vendor in
South Africa.
Yet Mr Gomba and
millions of others like him provide the single most
important explanation
for how President Robert Mugabe has managed to hold
power despite the
catastrophe overwhelming Zimbabwe's economy.
Mr Gomba is a
Zimbabwean migrant who fled his collapsing homeland for
neighbouring South
Africa five years ago. Of Zimbabwe's 12 million people,
at least three
million now live abroad, according to an official estimate
from Mr Mugabe's
regime.
At a stroke, this mass exodus on a scale usually created
only by civil
war has deprived Morgan Tsvangirai, the opposition leader, of
hundreds of
thousands of votes. Without this outflow of people, Mr
Tsvangirai would
almost certainly have won a clear outright victory in the
first round of the
presidential election, instead of the 49.1 per cent of
the vote his party
estimates he received.
"It's obvious who I would
have voted for," said Mr Gomba. "I would
have backed Tsvangirai. If Mugabe
goes then we can get back home. Life is
better back home."
Mr
Gomba now earns a meagre living as a street vendor in Johannesburg.
Perhaps
two million Zimbabweans are thought to have settled in South Africa,
stirring great resentment among the host population.
"Some
South Africans are OK, but others say 'you Zimbabweans, we don't
want you
here, you are taking our jobs'," said Mr Gomba. "There are some
places where
it's not safe for us to stay."
After South Africa, Britain is the
most popular refuge for Zimbabwean
migrants fleeing their worthless currency
and inflation exceeding 100,000
per cent. At least 500,000 now live in
Britain, according to a recent
estimate from Paul Boateng, the British High
Commissioner in South Africa.
By sending money and food to their
relatives, this immense diaspora
keeps Zimbabwe's economy
alive.
Every month, Mr Gomba sends about £50 and a few bags of
groceries to
his wife, Charity, and their two sons in the Zimbabwean town of
Chitungwiza.
Bus drivers plying the route between Johannesburg and
Harare have now
become trusted couriers. In return for 20 per cent
commission, they take
envelopes full of cash and bags stuffed with food from
Mr Gomba and his
fellow migrants and hand them to their families in
Zimbabwe.
"Without this, my wife would not survive," said Mr Gomba.
"Things are
very tough for her."
Migrants living in Britain pay
for groceries, generators and furniture
over the internet using websites
like Zimbuyer.com. Their relatives then
collect these items in
Zimbabwe.
Despite the destruction wrought by his regime, Mr Mugabe
can rest
assured that Zimbabwe's economy will be saved from total collapse
by this
support from the diaspora.
Hostile voters have left the
country, while money and goods pour back
in. Mr Gomba acknowledged that all
this helped Mr Mugabe. "It's true," he
said. "But what can we do?"
ZADHR Statement on World Health Day
World Health Day Statement 2008
Zimbabwe Association of Doctors for Human
Rights
7 April
2008
The Zimbabwe Association of Doctors for Human Rights calls to
attention the
state of the public health system. Zimbabwe?s healthcare
system, in a known
state of crisis, is in need of urgent attention. It is
crippled by
dilapidated infrastructure, drug shortages, equipment
breakdowns, brain
drain and costs of healthcare skyrocketing beyond the
reach of the majority
of Zimbabweans.
Average life expectancy,
according to the WHO, has declined from 60 years to
37 years for men and 34
for women during the past decade. Maternal mortality
is rising to a level
which meets that of the world poorest countries.
ZADHR commends health
professionals and health workers in Zimbabwe who have
continued to deliver
health services in very difficult circumstances and
remain committed to the
recovery and improvement of the public health
system.
ZADHR notes the
need for a comprehensive national health plan to replace
some of the
uncoordinated ad hoc measures that have been put in place to
address the
crisis in the short term. Such a plan must guarantee that
Zimbabwean?s are
able to enjoy their right to health. The responsibility for
this lies with
government in consultation with other stakeholders.
Marking World Health
Day, ZADHR calls upon the newly elected Parliament of
Zimbabwe, amidst a
myriad of challenges ahead of it during its term in
office, to prioritise
policy interventions to address the public health
crisis in Zimbabwe. In
doing so ZADHR urges the new Parliament to attend to
the following key
areas:
Formulating legislation that protects, respects and fulfils the
right to
health for all Zimbabweans.
Providing adequate infrastructure
needed for effective and equitable
healthcare such as safe running water,
adequate sanitation, electricity and
transport.
Taking measures to
address shortages of drugs and medical equipment in the
short, medium and
long term.
Creating conditions under which good training quality for health
professionals is guaranteed and ensure that conditions in which these skills
can be retained exist.
Hot Seat interview: Dr John Makumbe & Professor Brian
Raftopoulos
SW
Radio Africa Transcript
HOT SEAT INTERVIEW : Journalist Violet Gonda
interviews political
commentators Dr John Makumbe and Professor Brian
Raftopoulos on the
elections in Zimbabwe . Who will benefit more in a
Presidential run-off and
who stands to lose?
Broadcast 4 April
2008
Violet Gonda: We welcome political commentators Dr. John Makumbe in
Zimbabwe
and Professor Brian Raftopoulos in South Africa . Hello there and
thank you
for joining us on the program Hot
Seat.
Makumbe/Raftopoulos: Hello Violet.
Violet: Now controversy
has marred the elections in Zimbabwe as the main
political parties are
jostling for power. The opposition Movement for
Democratic Change says its
leader Morgan Tsvangirai won the Presidential
election while ZANU PF has
rejected these claims. Let me go first to Dr.
Makumbe, what is your
assessment of the situation right now?
John Makumbe: It's a bit confused
Violet. It's confused in the sense that
for the first time in the history of
Zimbabwe - 28 years - we have ZANU PF
really in a tight spot as it were and
really worried about loosing power and
we also have a situation where the
Zimbabwe Electoral Commission (ZEC) is
releasing results in dribs and drabs,
and almost like it is afraid to
announce the Presidential results - almost
like they are anxious to give
Robert Mugabe as much time in office as
possible even though it sounds like
the result will actually require that
there be a run off. But the MDC has
published results which show that Morgan
Tsvangirai has won the contest.
Violet: Will come back to that issue of
the run off. What about you
Professor Raftopoulos , how do you see things
right now in Zimbabwe ?
Brian Raftopoulos : Yeah I think that we are in a
kind of a stalemate with a
ruling party which has clearly lost the
parliamentary elections and lost
legitimacy of the electorate but is
unwilling to really give up power at
this stage; and an opposition party
which has momentum behind it, the
momentum of a free and fair election but
is now facing a Security
Establishment which is unwilling to let go of that
power. So we are now
waiting to see exactly how this Security Establishment
wants to deal with
this very dangerous situation and it certainly looks like
there will be a
run off. But I think if it's a run off we are going to have
a very different
kind of environment, a much more repressive one, a much
more violent one and
if we think about the loss around the referendum in
2000 what happened in
the aftermath of that, it might give us some idea of
what the options for
the ruling party are.
Violet: What are the
options for the ruling party, what options exist for
Robert Mugabe right
now?
Raftopoulos : Look I think the options are clearly for him, first of
all for
them to release the results of the Presidential elections as soon as
possible so that we can know what the official position is. And if he indeed
he has lost -although even if the MDC figures are contradictory on this
score - but if he has lost, to give up power peacefully and to facilitate a
transition. The other of course is for him to massage those figures or and
declare victory or to go into a run off and to carry out a much more violent
campaign and to hang on to power. The latter option, the last option I think
will be a disaster. Any option which keeps Mugabe in power will be a
disaster for the country and in the long run even for his ruling
party.
Violet: Dr. Makumbe what options do you think exists for the
MDC?
Makumbe: I think the MDC has only one option and that is to
re-emphasis that
Morgan Tsvangirai won this election and he should be
recognised and Robert
Mugabe should either agree to a run off if he thinks
Morgan Tsvangirai
failed to win 50 + 1. But I think it is necessary for ZEC
to release that
final result and MDC will then be at liberty to say that's
not what we found
but they are already saying that whatever results will be
released by ZEC
they will go with it and they are ready for a run
off.
Violet: But who will benefit more in a run off and who stands to
lose?
Raftopoulos : With the way the figures are playing right now, Simba
Makoni's
people and Mutambara's people are said to be anxious to support
Morgan
Tsvangirai in a run off and Robert Mugabe at the moment doesn't have
anyone
or ZANU PF doesn't have anyone wanting to work with ZANU PF. In fact
just
two days ago civil society issued a statement saying; "We urge all
political
formations other than ZANU PF to commit themselves to a situation
where they
will not work with or cooperate with anyone who violates the
peoples' rights
or who use violence as a means of attaining political power
and forcing
people to do what they would rather not do." Essentially they
were saying
that anyone who cooperates with ZANU PF will really be held in
bad light.
Violet: Now Professor Raftopoulos do you agree with this
because there are
others who say that if there is a run off this is the last
thing that Morgan
Tsvangirai needs because Mugabe can use the state
machinery to suppress the
vote. What are you're thoughts on
that?
Raftopoulos : Ya I think that as things stand and just listening to
ZANU PF
Deputy Minister of Information Bright Matonga that if there is a run
off the
environment will be very different. I think the danger is that they
will do
anything now to retain power. So I think that one would have hoped
this
thing could have been settled and I think one of the ironies of this
election is that as a result of the division in the MDC and the lack of
cooperation on an election pact, there were 9 seats that were lost as a
result of that division and this thing may well have been settled at this
point already. But that being as it is I think we are in a situation where
we are left to watch whether ZANU PF is going to adopt its usual violent
strategy at a time like this.
Violet: On the issue of the split
between the two MDC factions what do you
think Morgan Tsvangirai should do
in the event this goes to a run off?
Raftopoulos : Well I think clearly
he needs to develop and I am sure he is
already talking to the other
formation of the MDC as well as to Simba
Makoni. I think they need an
agreement on how this pact will operate and I
think that there is certainly
a basis for this cooperation. I just think
it's now up to Morgan's
Statesmanship to take the lead and to lead this
alliance into what could be
another bruising battle.
Violet: Now Dr. Makumbe there is this other
issue that is doing the rounds
in Zimbabwe and it's pretty difficult to
actually get information because as
you said earlier if only ZEC would
release the results and then we could
find out what the way forward is. But
I understand that Mugabe is planning
to use Presidential Powers to change
the re-run from 21 days to 90 days,
what have you heard about
this?
Makumbe: Yes there is a lot of speculation about that. One of the
things
with Zimbabwe at the moment is that there are a lot of rumours, there
is a
lot of gossip going around so it becomes very difficult to know what
the
difference is between a true or authentic report and what a rumour or a
baseless rumour or gossip is. For example it was rumoured on the first day
the counting began that Sabina Mugabe (Mugabe's sister) had died and people
were laughing it off and saying she died of shock because ZANU PF was losing
power (laugh). But to answer your question, it is rumoured and very strongly
so, that Robert Mugabe is playing around with the possibility of using the
Presidential Powers Temporary Measures Act to change the law - The Electoral
Act - where it says a run off within 21 days it would then read a second run
off of voting within 90 days.
90 days will give Robert Mugabe a lot
of time to plan and manipulate the
electoral process; it will also give him
time to deploy the war veterans,
the ZANU PF militia, the soldiers, and the
CIO back into the field to whip
up support. Above all it will give him time
to rest. We understand he is
really very tired after campaigning for the
past 3-4 weeks; he is very
tired. The man is 84 years old, here sometimes we
say 84,000 years because
here we talk mainly in thousands, but he's 84 years
old and he gets tired so
he needed 3 months to do it again and that will be
a real violation of the
law. And I suspect very strongly that if that goes
through the MDC will have
a very difficult time, as Brian is saying, winning
that second round.
Violet: But is it not realistic though to extend the
days because is there
enough time to have a re run in 21 days. Has the ZEC
for example got the
resources to hold another election in 21 days and get
things like ballot
boxes and inks?
Makumbe: It is realistic, it is
realistic. 21 days is really a lot of time
to print ballots which have only
two names and the ballot boxes which exist
now can be emptied and the
ballots package in a reasonable way for storage
and the same boxes can be
used for the run off.
Violet: Do you agree Professor Raftopoulos that 21
days is enough time to
hold the second round of Presidential
elections?
Raftopoulos : Yes I think I do agree and I think it's
absolutely necessary
that this is done as quickly as possible for the kind
of psychic state of
the nation. I think people are extremely desperate,
extremely anxious to
know what is going on and I think that the world is
waiting to see what is
going to happen. My sense is that it will take place
towards the end of this
month and at this stage I think it's most likely to
be that.
Violet: It also appears from the figures that we have seen, you
know the
parliamentary figures that Mugabe has support and that the MDC can
claim
victory but not landslide victory as we have seen with the results.
Now is
it possible that if Mugabe were to win in the run off can he be
considered
as having been legitimately elected? In other words doesn't a run
off have
the risk of legitimising Mugabe in the eyes of the world, Professor
Raftopoulos?
Raftopoulos : Look I think from the beginning the
opposition and the civics
have been saying this election process no matter
what happens cannot have
been free and fair. There have been huge problems
with this result. It's
also clear that Mugabe and ZANU PF continue to have
support. There is no
doubt that they have a social base and that has to be
contended. And indeed
a run off which is done in a reasonably free and fair
way could provide that
legitimacy for Mugabe and indeed raise problems. But
it is the issue that
what Zimbabweans are demanding is an election which is
not only seemed to be
free and fair but is actually so in practice. I think
if that were done it
will indeed open up spaces in the political sphere
which would take us
forward.
Violet: Dr. Makumbe on a different
issue, some have said that people were
voting for change and not necessarily
the quality of the Members of
Parliament - that their main concern was to
remove Robert Mugabe and his
ZANU PF. What can you say about the caliber of
the new parliamentarians? Do
you think they really know the functions of the
parliament - some of them?
Makumbe: Ooh no, there are a lot of new
Members of Parliament but not really
only on the ZANU PF side but even on
the MDC side there are a number of MPs
from MDC who lost their seats
particularly those from the Mutambara
formation. That formation was almost
wiped out, but what is interesting
about that assertion is that even within
ZANU PF there were voters who voted
for a ZANU PF MP but they voted for
Morgan Tsvangirai as President and that
is one thing which has absolutely
shocked ZANU PF to say; 'Why were people
voting for Morgan Tsvangirai at the
Presidential level and voting a ZANU PF
MP?' In several constituencies where
ZANU PF MPs won, in the same
constituencies Morgan Tsvangirai beat Robert
Mugabe at the Presidential
level. And so there was really a desire for
change and change was viewed as
getting rigged not so much of ZANU PF but of
Robert Mugabe. But if you look
at it again in another way, why didn't people
vote for Simba Makoni who was
actually saying you want ZANU PF you get it
only it is roped in by another
name and people again wouldn't even bother to
vote for Simba Makoni and his
grouping they couldn't even get one seat in
parliament.
Violet: What about the quality itself of the Members of
Parliament do you
think that they really know the functions of the
parliament because some are
saying people were not voting for quality but
just for change?
Makumbe: Well you can't really say that because you
don't really know the
quality of these people until you look at their CV.
The truth of the matter
is that this is going to be a much younger
parliament. This is going to be a
much better educated parliament than what
we have had in fact for the past
28 years. Educated not so much in the
number of people with PhDs but
educated in the number of people with more
than just O'levels. And then if
you look at the senate which we had, there
were literally grandparents who
were literally just dragged to some room at
Parliament and asked to say nice
things about Robert Mugabe. It's very
different now from at least the few
results that have come through. It's
going to be a real debating Chamber and
that's a much higher level. Again
not too many PhDs, not too many highly
educated people but nobody who will
say I don't understand what you are
saying because you are saying it in
English?
Violet: Professor Raftopoulos do you think it is going to be a
difficult
parliament in terms of none of the political parties have the 2/3
majority
and therefore it will be difficult for any party to actually
railroad
through bills or legislation. What are your thoughts on
that?
Raftopoulos : Yes I think obviously there is going to be a need for
a lot of
compromise but in the political structure that we have got the
Presidency is
the real centre of power and of course that is the danger of
any President
coming at this time - that very quickly after, if there is a
change of
Presidency the Constitutional reform process needs to come into
play.
Because obviously if Mugabe won a re-run in some way legitimate way
then the
real power will rest with the Presidency and not with the
parliament and
that will be the real danger of the gains of this period
being eroded with
very quickly.
Violet: What are your thoughts of the
future of the Mutambara MDC as critics
say they made such a massive
miscalculation and misjudged the situation in
Zimbabwe ?
Raftopoulos
: Let me put it this way; I think obviously the losses in
Matabeleland were
a big blow for the formation and they have to look very
carefully at the
strategy and what has happened. At the same time I think it
was a huge
blunder not to go into this election with an election pact
because as I said
it cost at least 9 seats which were lost because of that
division and it may
well have been that Morgan could have had this 50 +1
percent already had
that pact been done. So in some ways the victory of the
Morgan Tsvangirai
formation in terms of numbers is a pyrrhic one because we
still have Mugabe
there, and this Presidency now talking about a re-run. So
one has to look at
all aspects of this current situation and assess in due
course what were the
pros and cons of such a strategy.
Violet: And Dr. Makumbe what are your
views on the future of the Mutambara
MDC?
Makumbe: I think the fact
that Arthur (Mutambara) didn't run for the
Presidency could work to their
advantage in the sense that they could now
really restart negotiations and
restart talks to reunite the MDC. It will
not benefit Morgan in the sense of
this particular 50% + 1 which is needed
but it will do a lot of good to the
country and to the MDC as a party for
all of them to belong to one party
instead of two formations. But as Brian
has said I think it was a
miscalculation on their part. But those are the
dynamics of politics also, I
don't really blame them, it is really the
dynamics of politics. I think
where a mistake may have been made was to
commit themselves to supporting
Simba Makoni in the pre-election period, in
the campaigning period because
they essentially were giving an impression
'they are so alienated to Morgan
Tsvangirai and his group they would rather
support someone coming directly
from ZANU PF', and people are right now
saying are they going to go with
ZANU PF in which case ZANU PF will never be
an opposition political party
even if Morgan Tsvangirai wins the
Presidential vote.
Violet: What
about on the issue of Simba Makoni, what are your views on the
issue that
there are some who say he galvanised this election and took votes
away from
Robert Mugabe, do you agree with this?
Makumbe: Yes I think Simba Makoni
was the best thing that ever happened to
MDC because he literally took - he
split ZANU PF. Even if Robert Mugabe and
ZANU PF refuse to accept the
statement that ZANU PF is split, it is split
and the catchment area for
Simba Makoni's support was really previously ZANU
PF supporters. Morgan
Tsvangirai may have actually suffered some loss in
support but if that loss
actually simply went to the Mutambara formation
rather than to the Simba
Makoni formation, there may be give and take areas
here. But Simba Makoni's
galvanising of or splitting basically of ZANU PF
gave Morgan Tsvangirai a
wonderful opportunity to grab the largest slice of
the cake and run with
it.
Violet: And also still on you Dr. Makumbe people seem to be waiting
for
Mugabe to make up his mind and there seems to be no collective action
like a
strike or industrial action from the trade unions or the civic
society. What
are you doing as civic society on this particular
issue?
John Makumbe: We are working very hard; we have been issuing press
statements over and over - first of all urging the people to remain calm and
to wait for ZEC to release the results. Morgan Tsvangirai in fact when he
made his first appearance after the ballot after the voting, he actually
appealed to the whole nation to wait until ZEC publishes the results and
confirms them - even though his party was going to publish the results the
following day - he urged the civil society, he urged the public to wait
until ZEC publishes the results. That's what we are doing. We are very much
aware and mindful of the last few weeks in Kenya and we know that Zimbabwe
cannot afford that situation. With violence we all lose and the regime is -
as Mugabe said - has degrees in violence. And if people should go on strike
or street demonstrations the regime will love to just come whipping or
breaking bones, cracking skulls and say the President has declared a State
of Emergency and therefore the elections - as the results which have been
published have been nullified and the law actually allows Mugabe to nullify
an election process. I think its Section 151 but I would have to check that.
But it allows the President to nullify an election or to validate anything
done in an election even if it might be in violation of that Electoral Act.
And so we can't take that risk we will wait until ZEC announces the results
and we will either celebrate the victory for progressive forces or we will
make decisions with regards to what other options we will
have.
Violet: Professor Raftopoulos we all know that the economy is in
big trouble
in Zimbabwe and many have said it cannot be revived with Mugabe
in power.
Now t here is International consensus that the will of the
Zimbabwean people
must be properly revealed and respected, what happens if
it is not respected
what help can Zimbabwe hope to get from the
International Community
Brian Raftopoulos: It is clear that any kind of
Mugabe victory however
illegitimate or legitimate is going to continue the
crisis in Zimbabwe .
Mugabe and the regime have lost so much International
legitimacy that it is
very difficult for Mugabe and his party on his own to
regain that. So I
think the real danger of this run off is that Mugabe would
do anything to
win and then the economic and the political crisis will
continue to deepen.
And as bad as things are in Zimbabwe they can get worse,
they can get a lot
worse and that I think is the tragedy.
So one
hopes that also the leaders in the region who have been really not
very
useful to the Zimbabweans over the last few years are able to take some
positions which will intimate to Mugabe that in the best interest of the
nation and Zimbabwe it's really time that this thing was resolved in a way
which can really be a prelude for national reconstruction both politically
and economically.
Violet Gonda: Thank you very much Professor Brian
Raftopoulos and Dr John
Makumbe.
Comments and feedback can be emailed
to violet@swradioafrica.com
Democracy is soap for the stain of tyranny
New Zealand Herald
5:00AM
Tuesday April 08, 2008
By Gwynne Dyer
It has been a vivid
demonstration of how power really works. A week ago,
Robert Mugabe was still
the undisputed ruler of Zimbabwe.
He was 84, and he had reduced the
country to ruin: four out of five adults
are unemployed, inflation is
running (officially) at over 100,000 per cent,
and one-third of the
population has fled abroad in search of work, mostly to
South Africa. Yet
nobody in his own party, Zanu-PF, dared to question his
rule, the police and
the Army remained loyal, and ordinary people lived in
quiet
desperation.
The silent submission of the population owed a good deal to
the brutality of
the police, but what can explain the loyalty of his own
colleagues in the
party and the Army? After all, Zimbabwe is theirs, too,
and nobody likes to
see their homeland dragged in the dirt.
Moreover,
it was all Mugabe's fault, brought about by policies that he
freely chose to
pursue. He is not 10 feet tall and he has no magical powers.
Why did they
obey him?
They obeyed him because he has been in power for 28 years,
longer than the
great majority of Zimbabweans have been alive. (The average
Zimbabwean woman
is dead at 34, the lowest life expectancy in the world. Men
make it to 37.)
They obeyed him because he was the hero of the independence
struggle and an
icon of African liberation.
Most of all, they
obeyed him because his rule was apparently the only thing
that kept them out
of the desperate poverty in which most Zimbabweans live.
Powerful people who
defied him were rarely killed, but they were cut off
from the flow of wealth
and had a very hard time of it.
So the regime cruised on almost unaffected by
the ruin of the country, and
Mugabe even felt secure enough to allow more or
less free elections on March
29.
He had been under heavy pressure by
the African Union to clean up his act.
The farther away potential investors
are, the harder they find it to tell
the difference between one African
country and another, and Zimbabwe's bad
reputation was hurting the whole
region.
So Mugabe made what seemed to be a harmless concession.
Typically, in
Zimbabwean elections, the cities vote against Mugabe, but the
countryside,
where 75 per cent of the people live, votes for him. At least,
it seems to.
Rural people are more easily intimidated, opposition observers
can easily be
chased away from isolated rural polling stations, and things
can happen to
the ballot boxes on the way to Harare to be
counted.
Mugabe was so confident, he didn't even send out Zanu-PF's
storm-troopers,
the so-called "war veterans" (most of whom were not born
during the
liberation war), to frighten people into voting the right
way.
But he had made one crucial miscalculation: in response to
pressure from the
African Union, he agreed to let the vote be counted
locally, with the
results posted up outside each polling station.
So
the main opposition party, the Movement for Democratic Change (MDC), sent
members to photograph the results at more than 8000 polling stations, and it
suddenly got very hard to manipulate the returns at a central location. And
it turned out - maybe it had been true at every previous election, too -
that around half the population had not voted for Zanu-PF.
Suddenly,
in a huge shift, the "old man" is not the object of fear and
adulation any
more.
In the eyes of some senior party people and their military and
police
colleagues, Mugabe has become a bargaining counter.
If the jig
is really up, maybe they could trade Mugabe and power for a
peaceful
retirement with no awkward questions about where their wealth came
from. Of
course, Mugabe would also have to be allowed an honourable
retirement
himself - but as one of the last heroes of Africa's independence
generation,
he was guaranteed that anyway.
Or maybe they should declare martial law,
annul the election and push Mugabe
aside - or leave him out front as a
figurehead and flak-catcher. He must be
very disconcerted, after 28 years of
absolute power, to discover that it was
just a confidence trick all
along.
But the game is not over yet. While both those options remain
open, the
party elders and the security forces have opted for the moment to
play more
or less by the rules: a run-off election in two weeks between
Mugabe and MDC
leader Morgan Tsvangirai.
That gives them time to
deploy the bully-boys, re-intimidate the rural
population, and pull off a
second-round victory for Mugabe. Or, if that
strategy doesn't look like it's
going to work (for once people have lost
their fear, it's much harder to
re-instil it), then they still have time to
exercise Option A or Option
B.
So what does this tell us about power? That the more absolute and
illegitimate it is, the easier it is for it to dissolve overnight. And that
democracy is a good solvent.
* Gwynne Dyer is a London-based
independent journalist whose articles are
published in 45 countries.
Pisa in
Bikisa
www.swradioafrica.com
Monday 07 April, 2008
by Phillip Barclay
The light
from the candle on the trestle table catches Tobias’ face, casting
Rembrandtesque upward shadows from his features. A big-eared bug lights on
his shoulder, but Tobias is concentrating so deeply on the Zimbabwe
Electoral Commission manual that he doesn’t notice the creature, which
appears to be peering down to study the impenetrably bureaucratic guidance
too.
Tobias inhales.
“Now we can open the seals on the ballot
boxes. But first I must warn our
foreign observer from the British Embassy
that once I break these seals you
cannot leave until the counting is fully
complete.”
I nod. Some fiddling with keys and sealing wax; and suddenly a
pile of
ballot papers pours onto the table. Slumbering polling officers
spring to
life and grab ballots chaotically, shouting out and flinging
papers at each
other:
“ZANU-PF!”
“Makoni!”
“Tsvangirai!”
Tobias
tries to referee the frenzy and finally persuades his colleagues to
collaborate in producing three piles, one for each of Zimbabwe’s
presidential candidates. I am so captivated I find I’m holding my breath.
The piles take shape. One is just a few papers; the second is a decent pile,
about as tall as a doughnut. The third is a tottering, towering Pisa of
papers.
I am in a tiny place called Bikisa, deep in rural Masvingo,
where Robert
Mugabe’s ZANU-PF party has won every election that has ever
been held. (Ian
Smith did not believe in elections for black folk). So my
assumption is that
the big pile is Mugabe’s.
But I am wrong. The
presiding officer asks for the votes to be counted. The
smallest pile is
Simba Makoni’s – 11 votes. The middling pile is Mugabe’s –
44 votes.
Amazingly, incredibly, the Pisa-pile belongs to Morgan Tsvangirai.
The
polling officer gets tongue-tied at ‘one hundred and twenty-seven’ and
loses
count. She sighs desperately and starts again. 167. Tsvangirai has won
with
about three-quarters of the vote.
I force myself to keep breathing
steadily; fainting at this point would not
become an officer of Her
Majesty’s Government. Though I suppose I could
plead hunger. Anticipating
that I would be locked into the count for hours,
my bag is full of chocolate
and other essential rations, but I feel too
self-conscious to stuff my face
while this little piece of history is
happening right in front of
me.
Bikisa, of course, is only one of 9,400 polling stations. So my
result is
just one small head of mealie in a very big field. But it’s
suggestive, and
as I travel round other polling stations and speak to
British Embassy and
DFID colleagues in remote parts of every province, it’s
the same story.
Tsvangirai has done well and his Movement for Democratic
Change has made
gains in areas where its activists used to be beaten for
wearing a party
t-shirt.
Tobias, like a million other Zimbabweans is
a decent and principled
professional, who has done his job scrupulously and
well. This election may
be fiddled, but not by him. By the time he releases
me it’s the early hours
of Sunday morning. The Milky Way stretches over me.
Weakened by lack of
chocolate I am overcome by whimsy – I see a starry
pathway to infinity paved
with hope and new possibility. Definitely time to
take a breath and eat some
chocolate. Not, sadly, a Milky Way.
A
policeman sidles up and whispers in my ear:
“Mr Philip, we are so pleased
you are here, but do you really think there is
hope?”
Tonight the
answer is yes. Tomorrow, who knows? Will they ever dare to
release these
results? How does a country that has only ever transitioned by
violence
accept peaceful change? Next week’s questions. Now to bed.
JAG open letter forum - No. 527 - Dated 4 April 2008
Email: jag@mango.zw; justiceforagriculture@zol.co.zw
Please
send any material for publication in the Open Letter Forum to
jag@mango.zw with "For Open Letter Forum" in the
subject
line.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1.
John and Joy from Chidza
Dear JAG
Looks like the terror and farm
invasions are back ...............
"Well, never thought I would have to
do this email do not know if it may
be my last from Chidza. At 3.30pm today a
lorry load of war vets arrived
at our gate to take over our land, equipment
and cattle. It is now 6pm
and they have been singing their war songs at our
gate and more and more
of them have arrived.
We managed to get Alison
and the Little John to town and for now it is
just John and myself and dogs
in the house now on the farm.
They have said that our labour will not
work tomorrow and that they want
us to kill them a sheep which John refuses
to do so no doubt they will
kill one for themselves. They have said that no
labour will come to work
tomorrow either!
Graham Richards was under
siege at the same time as us so it has to be
orchestrated. Goddards and
Deidricks are in the same boat.
They have already taken over PaNyanda
Lodge, Graham and Callie are in
town. Alison is at Lorna in town and Carl is
expected back from Bulawayo
tonight and will go to Lorna.
Lorna's no.
is 039-******; Ali is on 011-******. Our phone landline is
039-******. Cell
Phone Nos. 011-******; 023-******;
Please pass this email on to as many
folk as you would like to. If you
know of anyone in the Media all the better.
We have to let the world know
what is happening.
Well done to ZESA
(Zimbabwe Electricity Supply Authority). As they load
shedded us and I phoned
my friend in the ZESA Faults and he phoned Harare
and they have switched us
back on.
So for now please keep all of us in your prayers and we will
send a follow
up tomorrow if we are able.
Our love to you
all.
John and Joy from
Chidza."
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2.
James Anderson
Dear JAG
Well done to Mike Mason for letting us all
know that the white collaborators
are still hard at it.
These
collaborators hate it when stories about their support for the evil
gangsters
are exposed.
This is not survival, it's just horrible greed.
One day,
bright lights will be shone into dark places.
James
Anderson.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
3.
Stu Taylor
Dear JAG
I think my sentiments lie with Mike Mason on
the question of pandering to
those that try and intimidate us. In the last
near-decade a lot of us have
shown our true colours; some are still on the
land, others not, for one
reason or another, but they who aided and abetted,
even "under duress",
know who they are. I hope they sleep at night, but care
not if they don't.
Should Mugabe force a re-run of the election, the guy
is going to be so
humiliated in defeat that he'll wish he never got into
politics, let alone
became the leader of a country!! Those who failed to vote
must take a
look at the result, realise that their vote could have made a
difference,
and flock to the polling stations in hoardes to witness the final
exit
of a man whose only legacy to Zimbabwe is one of misery. 30-odd% is
not
a true reflection of how the people feel; I was disenfranchised in
2002,
after having voted in every election since 1980, but care not, as
when
the new order takes the reins I will get my vote back. Pasi ne
ZANU(PF).
Stu
Taylor.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
4.
Mike Mason
Dear JAG,
Amy- Lee's reply is not bad but needs a
little correction. Yes there are a
few farmers left out there who have not
collaborated and I admire them. I
did not include them in my criticism, only
those who supplied vehicles
to rallies etc. NO we did not all send our
vehicles in 2000. I said NO
from the beginning. I did not last long after
that but at least I have a
clear conscience.
Mike
Mason
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
5.
Cathy Buckle
Dear JAG
As we stand exhausted and betrayed at this
critical moment in Zimbabwe's
crisis, it seems pertinent to look back over
the last few days and record
who said what.
On the 29th March shortly
after casting his ballot Mr Mugabe said: "We are
not in the habit of
rigging... We don't rig elections. I cannot sleep with
my conscience if I
have rigged,"
On the 29th March, sure that Zanu PF would win the
elections, Mr Mugabe
said: "We will succeed. We will conquer. Why should I
cheat? The people
are there supporting us. The moment the people stop
supporting you, then
that's the moment you should quit politics."
On
the 29th March asked if he would participate in a run off
Presidential
election should the result not be decisive, Mr Mugabe dismissed
the
suggestion and said: "We are not in the habit of boxing matches here.
We
knock each other out in the first round."
In an evening press
conference on the 1st April MDC President Morgan
Tsvangirai said: "Zimbabwe
will never be the same again; the people have
spoken with one voice. I would
like to thank the millions who came to
reclaim their dignity and invest in
the change they can trust."
In the evening of the 1st April the world
media went into a frenzy and
reported that a deal had been done and Mr Mugabe
was about to step down.
The news didn't last long and a CNN reporter said:
"What's clear is that
nothing is clear."
On the 2nd April at a press
conference MDC Secretary General Tendai Biti
announced election results based
on figures displayed as public notices
outside polling stations. Biti said:
"Zanu PF have lost this election.
Morgan Richard Tsvangirai is the next
president of Zimbabwe."
On the 3rd April, long before the results of the
Presidential election had
been announced, Deputy Minister of Information
Bright Matonga said: "Zanu
PF is ready for a run-off, we are ready for a
resulting victory. ... we
only applied 25 per cent of our energy into this
campaign... we are going
to unleash the other 75 per cent that we did not
apply in the first case."
On the 3rd April the former Malaysian Prime
Minister Mahathir Mohamad said:
"If he (Mr Mugabe) wants to come here, the
(Malaysian) government should
welcome him. If he has lost, he has to accept
the decision of the people,
that is the best thing he can do."
On the
4th of April, before the results of the Presidential election had
been
announced, Zanu PF Secretary Didymus Mutasa confirmed that Mr Mugabe
would
contest in a re-run. He said: "We are down but not out. Absolutely
the
candidate will be Robert Gabriel Mugabe - who else would it be other
than our
dear old man?"
On the 4th April, hinting at what will inevitably be the
slogan if there
is re-run of the election, war veteran leader Jabulani
Sibanda said:
"It now looks like these elections were a way to open for the
reinvasion
of this country [by the British]."
And so now we wait. We
thought our poor broken country had suffered enough
and that at last our
prayers had been answered - it seems not - not yet.
Until next time,
thanks for reading, love cathy.Copyright cathy buckle
5th April
2008.
www.cathybuckle.com
My
books: "African Tears" and "Beyond Tears" are available in South Africa
from:
books@clarkesbooks.co.za and in
the UK from:
orders@africabookcentre.com To
subscribe/unsubscribe to this newsletter,
please write to: cbuckle@mango.zw
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
6.
Cathy Buckle
Dear JAG
A letter from the diaspora
5th April
2008
'What is it that makes a man want to stay in power forever?' asks
Hugh
Masikela the wonderful South African jazz trumpeter in a song
recorded
some years ago. In the song, Masikela lists the African dictators of
the
time, Robert Mugabe's name was there then - and still is there now.
Did
any of us really believe that the old man would just pack his things
and
quietly fade away into the sunset? I for one admit that I thought
that
HE was intelligent enough to recognise when it was time to go. I
thought
this week's official ZEC announcement that the MDC has won a majority
in
the House of Assembly would be the time for the old man finally to
admit
to himself that now is the time. There were stories on Wednesday
night
that he was going to broadcast to the nation and like everyone else
here
and at home I sat up till the small hours waiting for news that never
came.
It has been like that all week; waiting for news that never came,
an endless
week of hope alternating with despair. Desperate phone calls
between the
UK and Zimbabwe but none of us here or there really knowing
anything. I
understand ZTV has been its usual moribund self; When it happens
we'll be
there - as long as it's not real news of course. Everywhere else in
the
world and specially in the UK there's been wall-to-wall coverage on
all
channels and endless column inches in the papers but the truth is that
none
of these so-called analysts and intrepid (!) foreign journalists know
any
more than we do. We are in the dark, quite literally. One of the
funniest
sights of the week was the BBC's John Simpson doing his piece to
camera by
the light of torches held by his colleagues. Where were the dreaded
CIO
spooks, I wondered? There was this large white man 'somewhere in
Harare'
he told us very mysteriously, doing his thing in full view and yet
he
hadn't even been threatened let alone!
picked up by the men in dark
glasses!
Another BBC man was shown talking, so he said, to former war
veterans on
a once thriving commercial farm telling him how they no longer
supported
Mugabe.
But for me, it was the interview with the
indefatigable Dr John Mukumbe that
rang the first warning bell of trouble
ahead. In the event of a runoff,
Mukumbe warned, Mugabe's men will have three
weeks to terrorise the rural
population. HE will once again unleash his war
veterans and Youth Militia
on the thousands of rural people who so bravely
voted against the dictator
and voted instead for Change. Mugabe could use his
Presidential powers to
extend the three weeks even to three months, Mukumbe
told the BBC and that
would give Mugabe and his black boots and Green Bombers
plenty of time to
silence the hungry and angry masses.
Six days after
the elections ZEC has still not announced the Presidential
results and Mugabe
is still there in State House. 'He's not going
anywhere' declared a gloating
Bright Matonga, Zimbabwe's Deputy Minister
of Information, to the BBC who
faithfully reported his words and showed
his toothy grin on just about every
news bulletin. Why, I wondered has the
Deputy Minister been chosen to do all
the talking, where's the Minister
himself? Then I remembered when I had first
become aware of the Bright one.
Zimbabweans will remember Matonga hit the
headlines at home when he
violently
invaded a farm aided by the usual mob
of youth militia. His wife was with
the Bright one; it so happens she's a
white woman from Essex. As the mob
struck up their usual chorus of hate and
anti-white rhetoric, she was
heard yelling, Give us back our land. You stole
it from us. 'It struck us
as odd,' commented the farmer's wife, an
understatement if ever there was
one but typical of the sort of madness that
has prevailed over the last
ten years under Mugabe's leadership. Unlike
Morgan Tsvangirai who talks
of love and reconciliation, in his old age Mugabe
speaks of nothing but
hatred and vengeance against his perceived
enemies.
Last night viewers at home had their first glimpse of Mugabe
since the
elections. We in the diaspora saw him too, saying Farewell to the
team of
African observers. The sound quality was poor but we heard Mugabe
telling
the team 'We don't cheat, we don't do that but the other side. Ooh,
aah'!
Along with all his other 'skills' - those degrees in violence -
what a
consummate performer he is. Today he meets with the Polit Bureau, I
wonder
if Simba Makoni will be there? Will they be thinking at all about what
is
right for the country, do they even care about the welfare of
Zimbabwe's
people or are they thinking only of themselves? These Big Men have
so much
to lose and Robert Mugabe has more to lose than any of them. I
remember
Bishop Lamont, that brave fighter for justice who was tried for
treason by
the Smith regime and kicked out of Rhodesia because he chose to
stand with
the suffering black people. 'rearranging the deck chairs on the
Titanic'was
how he described the dying days of the Smith regime. History
repeats itself
it seems. The question now is whether Mugabe's men will choose
to go down
with his sinking ship or whether they will find the courage to
tell the
old man that it's time to go. And that brings us right back to the
question:
What is it that makes a man want to stay in power
forever?
Yours in the (continuing) struggle.
PH
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
7.
Eddie Cross
Dear JAG
A Wounded Buffalo
Zanu PF is behaving
just like a wounded buffalo. The African buffalo is
one of the most dangerous
adversaries in the world of wildlife. It has
an enormous capacity to take
punishment, is extremely difficult to kill
outright and when wounded - even
fatally, it has the ability to do great
damage. It is also a highly
intelligent adversary.
I have never hunted buffalo but have friends who
have and had a senior in
my department when I was a young man actually
ambushed by a wounded buffalo
in the Zambezi Valley. He was very lucky to
survive and was never quite
the same again. A frequent target of the trophy
hunter are the lone bulls
who move about in small groups or on their own and
have a magnificent set
of horns with that huge mass of bone across the
head.
If the hunter gets a clean heart shot, the buffalo has the capacity
to run
for some considerable distance before collapsing. If the shot is not
clean,
then the buffalo is known to run and then circle back and lie in
ambush for
his hunter. That is what happened to my senior in the valley.
Although a
large animal, the buffalo knows exactly how to stand in the shade
and to
blend in with his background. Often the only thing that might alert
you
to his presence is a flick of the ears or a tail. Fail to spot him
and
you could be on the receiving end of a short and furious rush and
fall
victim to the horns or just his mass.
Zanu PF lost this election
massively - if you take the combined vote of
Makoni and Tsvangirai, 73 per
cent of the people who voted (2,4 million)
voted against him - he only got 27
per cent of the vote. The poll was
41 per cent if you use the voter's roll
but by my calculation (2,8 to 3
million actual voters) it was nearer 80 per
cent. Even when the National
Command Centre had spent a day massaging the
results they only got them
down to 50 per cent for Tsvangirai and nearly 10
per cent for Makoni -
still a huge defeat for a sitting President.
In
addition they have lost control, even with the rigging, of the House
of
Assembly. In the Senate it looks as if we will have a stand off -
but this
does not make that much of a difference. But any measure, Zanu
PF has taken a
shot that has fatally wounded the old bull. However, like
the buffalo I
described above, he is still dangerous.
As things stand right now, the
Zanu PF Politburo has decided that a full
audit of the Presidential results
can go ahead. We demanded this when we saw
the results for Mashonaland
Central four days ago. When this is completed
(perhaps today) then we will
hear if the final tally gives Morgan 49 or
50 per cent of the final count. If
its 49, they want a rerun, if he gets
50 per cent plus one vote, he will be
sworn in as President and we will
get a new government.
I will not
bore you with all the gory details of what has gone on this
week, but just to
say that Zanu PF and Robert Gabriel Mugabe have had a
tough time accepting
the reality of the loss of power and privilege. I
understand that Grace
Mugabe has left the country and has taken a very
considerable sum of money
(real money) with her. There is also a strong
rumour that the man who led 5th
Brigade during the genocide in the 80's
has committed suicide. But that may
or may not be true. Nevertheless it
shows how much of a total shock this has
been for the Zanu machine.
If there is a run off, I can only anticipate
an electoral massacre. Ex
President Mugabe will not even get the numbers he
currently has in the poll.
It will be, in effect, a coup de grace.
So
we are thinking through what a re-run might mean for us - how we might
handle
it. It is already clear that despite the fact that so far the people
have
committed no acts of violence in any way, that Zanu PF is going to
use
violence to try and get its way in the re-run. Already yesterday we
have
seen new violence in several areas, Masvingo especially. Morgan
Tsvangirai
said in his press conference yesterday that Mugabe is preparing to
go to
war against the people. It will not help him.
I just pray that
there will not be a re-run. The country simply cannot
take any more of this.
Work is impossible - our factories are shut down as
the staff cannot work,
suppliers cannot fix prices and buyers are frozen
in their tracks. The
economy is virtually at a stand still and inflation
is racing ahead. There is
no food in the country and hunger is becoming
a real problem, the Reserve
Bank has been looted and I understand that
enough foreign exchange has been
taken out to supply the countries needs
for all basic foods for 12 months. It
is an absolute disgrace and to think
they still want to hang onto
power!
What has become clear over the past week is that Zanu PF can no
longer
command what happens in the administration, power is slipping away
and
they are already yesterday's men. It is also clear that the army and
the
police are both divided in their loyalties and now support change.
This
was the last pillar of support for the Zanu PF regime and with this
gone
it is just a matter of time.
The region is playing a key role and
is trying to persuade Mr. Mugabe
to step down and allow a peaceful
transition. Mugabe is not co-operating
and it is time regional leaders
stepped up the pressure. As for the UN,
this august body has yet to comment
and do anything effective - must we
slide into complete chaos and anarchy
before they become engaged? Thabo
Mbeki is in the UK for a summit of leaders
- I am sure he is getting it
with both barrels. Last night Aziz Pahad was
jousting with Kate Hoey -
wish I could have seen that contest.
But for
the rest, thank you to all who stood with us - through the criticism
of our
stand and strategy, through the long nights of despair and finally
doing the
hard work that will make democracy the tool we used to bring
down a corrupt
and cruel tyrant. We showed it could be done - not with guns
and bullets, not
with fire and machete's, just with the quiet strength of
ordinary men and
women going out and voting when they got the opportunity.
Eddie
Cross
Bulawayo, 6th April
2008
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
All
letters published on the open Letter Forum are the views and opinions
of the
submitters, and do not represent the official viewpoint of Justice
for
Agriculture.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------