Zim Online
Thu 10
August 2006
BULAWAYO - Another 26 people died in Zimbabwe's second
largest city of
Bulawayo in the month of April because of
malnutrition-related illnesses.
The latest deaths bring to 136
people the total number of people who
have died since the beginning of the
year because of malnutrition-related
diseases in the city of more than one
million people that is tucked at the
heart of the arid and hunger-prone
Matabeleland region.
The Bulawayo city health officials told a
council meeting last week
that of those who had succumbed to hunger-related
illnesses, most were
children below the age of five.
But
council was divided on the death statistics with councilors
belonging to
President Robert Mugabe's ruling ZANU PF party disputing the
figures, saying
malnutrition was not that prevalent in Bulawayo and could
not have caused so
many deaths.
"The figures mentioned are highly
unlikely particularly in the light
of a bountiful season and good harvests
throughout the country, there are no
cases of malnutrition in my ward and
probably in other wards," said Stars
Mathe, a ZANU PF member.
Bulawayo, the only city that publishes figures of malnutrition-related
deaths, is controlled by the main opposition Movement for Democratic Change
(MDC) party.
Mugabe's government, which has threatened to use
powers granted it by
the Urban Councils Act to fire the opposition-led
council over
hunger-related deaths statistics, accuses Bulawayo Executive
Mayor Japhet
Ndabeni-Ncube of inflating the figures in order to embarrass
the government.
Ndabeni-Ncube denies misrepresenting the
hunger-induced mortality
statistics, saying all the figures published by his
council were obtained
from the government's Births and Deaths Registry
Department.
"Most people can hardly afford a balanced diet and as a
result
malnutrition is inevitable under the present harsh conditions," MDC
councilor Charles Mpofu told last week's council meeting.
Zimbabwe's food crisis has been compounded by a severe economic
recession
gripping the southern African country for the past six years.
The
recession has seen annual inflation shooting to 993.6 percent, the
highest
in the world outside a war zone and also spawned shortages of fuel,
electricity, essential medicines, hard cash and just about every basic
survival commodity.
The MDC and Western governments blame
Zimbabwe's crisis on repression
and wrong policies by Mugabe such as his
seizure of productive farms from
whites for redistribution to landless
blacks.
The farm seizures destabilised the mainstay agricultural
sector and
caused severe food shortages after the government failed to give
black
villagers resettled on former white farms skills training and inputs
support
to maintain production.
But Mugabe, who has ruled
Zimbabwe since the country's 1980
independence from Britain, denies
mismanaging the country and says its
problems are because of economic
sabotage by Western governments opposed to
his seizure of white land. -
ZimOnline
Zim Online
Thu 10
August 2006
HARARE - Analysts have warned against premature
celebrations in
Zimbabwe's war against inflation, citing "technical factors"
as the reason
behind the dramatic fall in the July rate.
Zimbabwe's annualised rate of inflation, still the highest in the
world,
dipped a massive 191 percentage points in July to 993.6 percent in
figures
released by the Central Statistical Office (CSO) yesterday. The rate
was 1
184.6 percent in June.
But economic analysts immediately poured
cold water on the excitement,
arguing that the decline was not indicative of
an improvement in the
macroeconomic environment but was instead a purely
statistical issue.
"It is nothing to celebrate about in terms of
the effectiveness of the
government's economic management but the decline is
because there was a
bigger increase in the consumer index during the same
period last year
compared to this year," said consultant economist John
Robertson.
The annualised rate of inflation is calculated by
calculating the
percentage change between the consumer price index (CPI) for
one month
against the CPI for the corresponding month the year
before.
In this case, the CPI for July 2005 grew by a larger margin
compared
to the one for this year, hence the decline in the July
rate.
"The more meaningful figure is the month-on-month inflation,
which
again was high at 25 percent," added Robertson.
The CSO
also conceded that the decline was due to the higher rate of
change in July
2005 and not July 2006. The inflation figure climbed to 254.8
percent in
July last year from 164 percent the previous month.
In tandem with
the "technical factors", Zimbabwe's inflation had until
June this year been
on an upward trend, plateauing at 1 193.5 percent in
May.
"A
closer examination of macroeconomic fundamentals will show that
nothing much
has changed and the battle against inflation is far from being
won," said an
economist with a leading Harare commercial bank, who declined
to be named
for professional reasons.
The chief culprit responsible for
inflation has been unbridled money
supply growth caused by the printing of
money by the government to finance
its burgeoning bureaucracy.
The bank economist said taming the inflation beast would always remain
an
impossible task for Zimbabwe unless the government "learns to live within
its means".
Hyperinflation is one of many severe symptoms of
Zimbabwe's six-year
old economic crisis that has also spawned shortages of
fuel, electricity,
essential medicines, hard cash and just about every basic
survival
commodity.
The main opposition Movement for Democratic
Change party and Western
governments blame the crisis on repression and
wrong policies by Mugabe such
as his seizure of productive farms from whites
for redistribution to
landless blacks.
The farm seizures
destabilised the mainstay agricultural sector and
caused severe food
shortages after the government failed to give black
villagers resettled on
former white farms skills training and inputs support
to maintain
production.
But Mugabe, who has ruled Zimbabwe since the country's
1980
independence from Britain, denies mismanaging the country and says its
problems are because of economic sabotage by Western governments opposed to
his seizure of white land. - ZimOnline
Zim Online
Thu 10 August 2006
HARARE - Police in Harare were on
Wednesday forcing mourners to open
coffins as they searched for illegally
stashed cash as the law enforcement
agents stepped up a country-wide
crackdown against foreign currency dealers
that began two weeks
ago.
Respect for the dead is a deeply held social norm in
Zimbabwean
culture.
A frustrated Artwell Simango, who was
transporting the body of his
mother for burial to his rural home in Murehwa,
yesterday told ZimOnline
that he was forced by the police in Harare to open
his mother's coffin as
they searched for cash.
"This is very
bad. The police have gone too far in trying to look for
cash from the
public. After showing them my mother's burial order, they
still insisted
that we open the coffin as acceptable proof that we were
indeed carrying a
dead person.
"Even after they had seen what was inside, they did
not offer any
apology saying that they were doing their job," said
Simango.
Similar reports of the police forcing mourners to open
coffins were
also reported in the capital Harare.
Another man
from Glen Norah suburb in Harare, who hires his pick-up
truck to bereaved
families, said he had been stopped twice by the police who
wanted him to
prove that he was indeed ferrying the dead to the cemetery.
Police
spokesman Wayne Bvudzijena yesterday denied that the police
were forcing
mourners to open coffins saying police officers were also
sensitive to the
feelings of the bereaved.
"Police officers are human beings who
come from society and for as
long as there is nothing to suggest some people
are using coffins for
illegal deals, there is no reason for us to force them
to open coffins," he
said.
Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe governor
Gideon Gono, last week ordered state
security agents to seize cash from
individuals holding any amounts above
Z$100 million as part of fresh
measures to fight rampant trade in foreign
currency.
Under the
new monetary changes, individuals and companies handing over
to the banks
money in excess of $100 million and $5 billion respectively,
must explain
the source of the funds or have the cash forfeited to the
state. -
ZimOnline
Zim Online
Thu 10 August
2006
HARARE - Zimbabwe's President Robert Mugabe on Wednesday
rejected
claims he had left the country to seek medical treatment in Asia,
declaring
he was well and fit enough "to box".
Speculation had
been rife in some newspapers and internet news sites
that Mugabe, who had
last Friday quietly left Harare aboard a China-bound
Air Zimbabwe plane, had
gone on an emergency trip to either Singapore or
Beijing for medical
treatment.
Uncharacteristic quietness about the trip by the state
media, which
normally announces Mugabe's travels, appeared to have fed much
of the
speculation. But a buoyant Mugabe told journalists on arrival at
Harare
International airport mid-morning that he had "just taken a few days
off".
Asked about speculation that he was either dead or had gone
on an
urgent trip to Asia to seek treatment, Mugabe responded: "Tell them I
am
dead so I am now a ghost that has come back.
"Now, if the
President has three days off and takes kids away, what's
wrong with that?
My wife had gone to Thailand with students who are going
to university there
and the arrangement was that I bring the kids and we
meet again in Malaysia,
which we have done. And then I come back to arrange
with others on next
week's (Heroes Day) celebrations."
Mugabe, 82, looks physically fit
and those closest to him testify that
his intellect and grip on facts
remains sharp.
But doubts about his health have remained since he
collapsed in
November 2000 at a public function in Malaysia. -
ZimOnline
Zim Online
Thu 10 August 2006
HARARE - The Law Society of Zimbabwe
(LSZ) has criticised a campaign
by Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe (RBZ) officials
and other state agents to search
and seize money from citizens as degrading
and potentially a violation of
human rights.
RBZ officials,
police and government youth militia have used powers
granted them under a
presidential decree promulgated last week to confiscate
money from
individuals and corporates found holding cash in excess of the
prescribed
amounts of Z$100 million for individuals and $5 billion for
corporates.
At least 3 199 individuals and corporate executives
have been arrested
and more than $10 trillion has been seized since the
decree was promulgated.
But in a stinging response to the blitz,
the LSZ said that it condemns
very strongly the arbitrary, invasive and
degrading actions of the police
and other state agents at roadblocks set up
on most motorways to search
travellers for excess cash.
The
society expressed grave concern at the practice of stopping and
searching
members of the public on roads and other public places.
It said
that the ongoing practice by the police was not only grossly
invasive, a
violation of the individual's right to privacy, dignity and
integrity of the
person but was also unlawful and unsanctioned by the decree
under which the
state agents purported to act.
The LSZ said the wide-sweeping
regulations established by the decree
also raised pertinent issues of human
rights.
Under Section 4 of the regulations, the state is given
power in
certain circumstances, to confiscate money and to issue the owner
of the
seized cash a one-year bond. However upon maturity of the bond the
person
will be refunded their cash without interest even where the person is
absolved of any crime.
"This amounts to compulsory and punitive
acquisition of property
without compensation, contrary to the provisions of
section 16 of the
Constitution of Zimbabwe in that the benefit of any income
on investment of
such confiscated money is lost to the person affected," LSZ
said.
LSZ deplored the immunity from prosecution granted state
agents or
institutions that may breach the law while implementing the new
monetary
measures on behalf of the state.
It said such blanket
immunity had the effect of promoting and
cultivating "state agent impunity,
(and) also amounts to an ouster of the
jurisdiction of the courts to decide
whether the private individual's rights
have not been infringed or violated
by any person acting under the
regulations." - ZimOnline
Zim Online
Wed 9 August
2006
HARARE - Zimbabwe's annual inflation tumbled to three digits
in July,
the second time in about 15 months that the key rate has
declined.
Government Central Statistical Office acting director
Moffat Nyoni
announced on Wednesday that annual inflation was 993.6 percent
in the month
of July, a significant 191 percentage points less than the June
figure of 1
184.6 percent.
Inflation, labelled Zimbabwe's enemy
number one by President Robert
Mugabe, first shot beyond the 1 000 percent
barrier in April but has since
June showed signs of receding. The 1 184.6
percent recorded in June was 8.9
percentage points less than the 1 193 .5
May figure.
Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe governor Gideon Gono had at
the beginning of
the year vowed to bring down inflation to two-digit figures
by year-end but
appears to have accepted the impossibility of that self-set
task.
Gono now says he wants inflation to end the year
at around 400
percent, a figure most economic experts say is still too
ambitious given
over expenditure by the government which ultimately fuels
inflation.
High money supply growth and the existence of an
unregulated and
turbulent parallel economy that has become the most reliable
source of jobs,
goods and services for many Zimbabweans are yet some more
factors fuelling
inflation in the country.
Hyperinflation is
one of many severe symptoms of Zimbabwe's seven-year
old economic crisis
that has also spawned shortages of fuel, electricity,
essential medicines,
hard cash and just about every basic survival
commodity.
The
main opposition Movement for Democratic Change party and Western
governments
blame the crisis on repression and wrong policies by Mugabe such
as his
seizure of productive farms from whites for redistribution to
landless
blacks.
The farm seizures destabilised the mainstay agricultural
sector and
caused severe food shortages after the government failed to give
black
villagers resettled on former white farms skills training and inputs
support
to maintain production.
But Mugabe, who has ruled
Zimbabwe since the country's 1980
independence from Britain, denies
mismanaging the country and says its
problems are because of economic
sabotage by Western governments opposed to
his seizure of white land. -
ZimOnline
Zim Online
Wed 9 August
2006
HARARE - Police yesterday temporarily detained Zimbabwe
Congress of
Trade Unions (ZCTU) secretary general Wellington Chibebe over
alleged
financial irregularities at the union but ZCTU officials dismissed
the
police action as a ploy to derail worker protests planned for later this
month.
The ZCTU, the largest umbrella union body for workers in
Zimbabwe, has
threatened to call nationwide street protests by workers later
this month to
pressure employers to pay wages and salaries linked to the
poverty datum
line (the breadline), pegged at Z$75 million per month and way
above the
average monthly wage for workers of between $15 million and $25
million.
Chibebe was summoned to the police's serious fraud squad
offices in
Harare at about 9 o'clock in the morning. For the better part of
the day,
the police quizzed the ZCTU official over what they allege are
irregularities in the labour body's foreign currency account and only
released him at around 3 o'clock in the afternoon.
ZimOnline
was unable to reach police spokesman Wayne Bvudzijena to
establish whether
the law enforcement agency planned to arrest or charge
Chibebe at a later
stage.
ZCTU legal adviser Tsitsi Mariwa, who
accompanied Chibebe to the
police, however said his interrogators had
indicated that they would charge
the union leader.
"We told the
police that there was no violation of any section of the
Foreign Currency
Exchange Controls but police still insist they want him
arraigned before the
courts," said Mariwa, who is a lawyer.
But ZCTU spokesman Mlamuleli
Sibanda said the police move was part of
attempts by the government to
scuttle plans by the ZCTU to mobilise workers
to protest for better
wages.
Sibanda said: "We believe this is calculated as a
pre-emptive strategy
to frustrate our plans to mobilise workers on issues
affecting the
generality of the workforce in Zimbabwe."
The
ZCTU spokesman said the union would not be daunted by "harassment"
of its
leaders and would this coming weekend hold workshops with workers
across the
country to finalise plans for the protests later this month.
The
government fears protests for more pay by workers could easily
turn into
mass protests against President Robert Mugabe, who most
Zimbabweans hold
directly responsible for the country's worst ever economic
crisis. -
ZimOnline
Zim Online
Wed 9 August
2006
HARARE- Zimbabwe Finance Minister Herbert Murerwa has
condemned two
troubled financial institutions, Barbican Bank and Time Bank,
to liquidation
after dismissing their appeals against cancellation of their
registration
licences.
The Registrar of Banking Institutions
cancelled the registration of
the two financial institutions on 19 May 2006
on grounds that they were
technically insolvent.
Murerwa
rejected Barbican Bank's appeal against cancellation of its
registration
licence on July 10 while the appeal by Time Bank was turned
down about a
week later on July 26.
In notices published earlier this week, the
Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe
(RBZ) said that because the appeals had been
rejected the two black-owned
banks were no longer banking institutions and
were now awaiting liquidation.
The RBZ said the banks' licences
were cancelled after it had been
established that they were insolvent and
could not maintain net assets
sufficient enough to safeguard creditors. The
banks were also unable to
maintain minimum amounts of capital and reserves
required in terms of the
Banking Act.
Barbican Bank and Time
Bank were placed under curatorship by the RBZ
at the height of Zimbabwe's
banking crisis in 2004. More than 10 banks and
other financial services
collapsed as a result of the crisis. - ZimOnline
Zim Online
Wed 9 August 2006
HARARE - Zimbabweans will be forced
to dig deeper into their pockets
after the price of fuel shot up last
weekend by more than 36 percent
triggering a fresh wave of price increases
across the board.
A litre of diesel or petrol is now selling for
Z$750 000 up from the
$550 000 it used to cost last week.
Commuter omnibus operators in Harare immediately hiked their fares in
response to the fuel price increase.
Commuters now pay $200 000
per trip to nearby suburbs such as Msasa
Park, Hatfield and Cranborne, up
from the from $150 000 while those from
Chitungwiza and Ruwa are now paying
between $250 000 and $350 000 per single
trip.
Fuel companies
blamed the latest hike in the price of the commodity to
last week's
crackdown by the Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe governor Gideon Gono
on foreign
currency traders who were financing some of the fuel imports.
"Each
oil company and individuals are importing fuel depending on how
they are
able to hard currency (on the black market), so the cost components
do
determine the selling price," said one oil merchant who refused to be
named.
Economic analysts who spoke to ZimOnline yesterday said
the sharp rise
in the price of fuel will stoke up inflation which at 1 184.6
percent
remains the highest in the world outside a war zone.
"It adds to inflationary pressures right across the economy," said
Tony
Hawkins, an economics professor at the University of Zimbabwe's
Graduate
School of Management.
Harare economist, James Jowa said the
parallel foreign currency market
was the one keeping the wheels of industry
in Zimbabwe turning after the
official foreign currency market dried
up.
"They (fuel dealers) had no other access to other sources of
foreign
currency. So they had to transfer part of that cost to consumers,"
said
Jowa.
Zimbabwe is in the grip of a severe six-year old
fuel crisis because
of a critical shortage of foreign currency sparked by
the withdrawal of
balance-of-payments support to Harare by the International
Monetary Fund
following serious differences with President Robert Mugabe's
government. -
ZimOnline
Reuters
Wed Aug 9,
2006 10:37 AM BST
HARARE (Reuters) - Zimbabwe security agents have seized
more than 10
trillion Zimbabwe dollars (21 million pounds) in old banknotes
at the
country's main airport in a drive against money laundering, state
media
reported on Wednesday.
The official Herald newspaper said the
agents intercepted the money at
Harare International Airport on Tuesday as
it was being smuggled back into
the country to beat an August 21
deadline.
Police say money laundering investigations have been launched
against more
than 3,000 firms and individuals since the beginning of last
week.
Zimbabweans have until August 21 to dispose of old banknotes for
redenominated Zimbabwe dollars after a 60 percent devaluation last
week.
Central bank Governor Gideon Gono knocked three zeros off all
banknotes to
help consumers cope with hyperinflation of nearly 1,200 percent
and
announced that the old currency would be phased out in three
weeks.
"The Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe (RBZ) ... seized more than $10
trillion ...
belonging to three local financial institutions at the Harare
International
Airport as the ongoing clampdown on money launderers
intensifies," the
Herald said, adding the central bank had confirmed the
seizure.
"The money was stashed in huge boxes when it was intercepted ...
by security
agents," an unnamed source told the paper.
Central bank
officials could not be reached for comment on Tuesday but this
would be the
biggest seizure since the clampdown started last week.
SUSPECTED
ARSON
State media reported at the weekend that huge fires had damaged the
central
bank governor's farm in a suspected case of arson after an
unidentified
armed gang "caused commotion".
"The incidents follow
reports that there are people in positions of
authority who were trying to
intimidate the (central bank) boss into
abandoning the turnaround
programme," the state Sunday Mail newspaper
reported.
During the
transition to new notes, individuals are barred from depositing
old notes in
banks in excess of 100 million Zimbabwe dollars unless they can
show that
they have acquired the funds legitimately.
This requirement has left many
holding large sums of cash, which they are
rushing to convert into
assets.
Gono says trillions of Zimbabwe dollars were stashed in homes
and outside
the country to facilitate black market deals. Border patrols
have
intercepted billions worth of old banknotes from black market traders
trying
to enter the country before the deadline.
Analysts have hailed
the anti-money laundering drive but warn that
corruption by top business and
government officials could undo Gono's
efforts as seen by large amounts of
new banknotes already trading in
neighbouring Zambia and
Mozambique.
President Robert Mugabe's government has branded inflation as
the country's
number one enemy but says rampant graft threatens to derail
efforts to
reverse an 8-year recession widely blamed on state
mismanagement.
The veteran leader, who has ruled the country since
independence from
Britain in 1980, denies responsibility for the economic
rot and in turn
accuses Western opponents of sabotaging the country as
punishment for his
seizures of white-owned farms for
blacks.
$1=250,000 (250 redenominated) Zimbabwe dollars
People lining up outside a bank to change their old currency |
HARARE, 9 Aug 2006 (IRIN) - Zimbabwe
business has shrugged off a directive by the government to freeze prices and has
done the reverse, increasing commodity prices after the Zimbabwean dollar was
devalued by 1,000 percent.
The price freeze ordered by industry and
international trade minister Obert Mpofu coincided with a reserve bank
initiative to rein in the country's hyperinflation, which has been officially
pegged at 1,183 percent.
Reserve Bank Governor Gideon Gono knocked three
zeroes off the currency to implement a new exchange rate regime of Z$250 to
US$1, from the previous official rate of Z$250,000 to the US dollar.
Gono has given Zimbabweans three weeks to exchange old denominations for
the new currency, but individuals were only permitted to exchange a maximum of
Z$100 million (US$1,000 at the official rate) at the bank each day.
The
monetary reform has caused a run on the banks, as many people kept huge sums of
money outside of the banking system.
Mpofu said at the weekend that the
price freeze was temporary, but businesses have ignored the directive.
Supermarkets, small traders and petrol stations, citing the devaluation of the
Zimbabwe dollar against the US dollar, have hiked their prices.
Supermarket owner Wilbert Shoko, whose business is situated in the
upmarket residential area of Harare's Mabelreign, said the devaluation, coupled
with a spending spree by people desperate to offload the old currency, had
resulted in a natural increase in prices.
"The manufacturing sector in
this country has virtually collapsed, and that means we have to import basics
like cooking oil, soap, toothpaste and many other toiletries, especially women's
sanitary-wear. It does not make business sense to continue trading at old prices
when the local currency has been devalued," Shoko commented.
Petrol and
diesel prices spiked from Z$500,000 per litre to Z$650,000. On the parallel
market the price for a litre of fuel has reached Z$800,000. The fuel increase
pushed taxi fares from Z$150,000 to Z$200,000 and in some cases to Z$300,000.
By Monday, however, the country had "gone dry", after the fuel industry
announced they would stop selling petrol and diesel until the price-freeze
deadline had passed.
According to Mpofu's price-freeze statement, "no
trader, manufacturer, wholesaler, dealer, or retailer of any commodity shall, as
a result of the conversion of any price of that commodity, increase the price of
that commodity by any amount. This direction shall have effect from August 1 to
August 26, 2006."
Soldiers have been deployed on the streets of the
capital, Harare, and at Beitbridge, the main border crossing with South Africa.
As a reaction to the beating of taxi-drivers in the past week by
soldiers who accused the transport operators of sabotaging the economy,
residents attacked a uniformed soldier. In response, more than 100 soldiers
attacked commuters during rush hour. Army spokesperson Lt-Col Simon said the
army command had not ordered the attacks on the civilians.
In an apparent
public relations drive to mend fences, Simon announced that 66 soldiers had been
deployed around the capital to offer health services, counselling, electric
repairs and general cleaning.
Broadcast on the 8th August 2006
Violet Gonda: Welcome to Part Five of
the Teleconference debate with Dr
Lovemore Madhuku, the Chairperson of the
National Constitutional Assembly
and the two Secretary General's of the MDC
factions; Professor Welshman
Ncube from the Mutambara MDC and Tendai Biti
from the Tsvangirai MDC. This
week we discuss the issue of the roadmap to
democracy and mass action. I
start by asking Tendai Biti why, in light of
the current crisis situation in
Zimbabwe the opposition has not been able to
capitalise on so many
government failures?
Tendai Biti: Well, I think
that firstly, you know, you must understand what
you are dealing with. And I
think what you are dealing with is a very
privatised state and a very
militarised state. In fact, I would argue that
the current Zimbabwean state
is what I would call a national security state,
in other words, a state
where, bar name only, it's really the military
running this country, and
that the existence of ZANU PF, the existence of
regular elections is just a
veneer and make up; mascara, to cover what is
really a securitocracy, what
is really a silent military coup de tat in
respect of which the military has
taken over the Zimbabwean state. And, our
problems I think have been that as
civic society and as political parties,
we have been slow to really
understand the fascist military junta that is in
fact ruling or misruling
us. Also, I think that, yes, people might want to
see opportunities haven't
been taken off but I think that it's easy to adopt
an armchair approach
without understanding the true nature of the crisis in
Zimbabwe and the true
nature of the militarised and privatised kleptocratic
state presided over by
Robert Mugabe. And, I think that we are growing and
the language we are
speaking is the language that understands certain values
that we want to see
in the new Zimbabwean society. Which is why, to me, for
instance, it is key,
it is key that we focus our struggle around a new
constitution. Two, it is
key that we continue pursuing a non violent
democratic peaceful
confrontation with this regime. There is a temptation,
and you hear this
being said by many sectors, by our youth in particular,
that 'oh, people
should get guns and so forth'. The minute we do that, we
are finished. So,
the biggest challenge on us as political leaders or the
civic society is to
remain relevant but in a peaceful, constitutional
democratic manner. I would
rather have change that comes slowly that is
permanent than change that
comes in a fast track manner but that is
inconsistent, that is ambiguous and
that takes you twenty years back. And,
we have seen the results of botched
up settlements across Africa. Look at
the history of countries like Sierra
Leone, Liberia, look at the crisis in
Ethiopia and Eritrea, and as the
Professor has already referred to, the
situation in Zambia which happened
because, Kenya for instance, is an
excellent example, and is one of the
things that in the road map we have
crafted, we have made it very clear,
that, as far as we are concerned, there
must be a new constitution first by
Zimbabweans before you have any general
election so that people are clear
and we are all operating on the same side
of the fence; we are opposition
and therefore in the constitution that we
see we are distrusting anyone. In
the constitution that we want to see, none
of us has got a superior
advantage to the other. Those are fundamental
values, and fundamental
principles that ensure that never again should
anyone bastardise us in the
manner that Robert Mugabe and ZANU PF has done
and to be fair, in the manner
that Ian Smith, and his grandfather Cecil John
Rhodes did, and to me, that
is critical.
Violet: We will come to the issue of the constitution later,
but I still
want to talk about the road map to democracy and the issue of
mass action. I
want to ask Professor Ncube the same question that I asked
Tendai Biti. Or
rather, Professor Ncube, how did the opposition party miss
such important
opportunities to mobilise people during or immediately after
Operation
Murambatsvina and when the elections were stolen or
rigged.
Professor Ncube: Well, that's of course a very important but also
difficult
question. Some of us hold the view that while you are bleeding and
you are
sick as an opposition, you are not in a position to take part in a
race; you
cannot participate in a race, you cannot participate in a match
when in fact
you are hospitalised and you are sick. And, this is what was
happening, in
my view, to the MDC during the time of Operation
Murambatsvina. This is a
time when you had young people abducting Provincial
leaders in Harare, the
Secretary for Harare, the Chairman for Mashonaland
East, and beating them
up. And, the party then turned inwards and focused on
those things and at
the end of the day, lost the opportunity to be united in
confronting the
regime. So, those opportunities have been lost. There are
also other
external objective facts. It is a mistake to view the struggling
Zimbabwe as
a short term struggle and the sooner we realise that this is a
long term
struggle and we should be prepared for the long haul and therefore
plan in
that context, the better for everybody. And, I therefore, do not
find it
useful to speak of missed opportunities. I think we should talk
about
strengthening the pro democracy movement; strengthening civil society,
finding common ground on the things which unite us and agreeing on those
things which unite us and work together and agree to disagree on those
things on which we do not agree, and then move forward in that area. I agree
with Tendai, that the obvious starting point is a new constitution. Whatever
else happens, whether you build bridges with Britain, whether you have Mkapa
whatever else you have, unless and until you find a formula, a roadmap, to
use that popularised term, to make peace with the people of Zimbabwe, so
that each of us is at peace with each other so that the government of
Zimbabwe is not at war with its people, so that ZANU PF is not at war with
the people of Zimbabwe. Unless we do that, we are not going to move forward.
And, the starting point, in my view, is the question of the new
constitution, because the constitution is fundamental. It sets out the
fundamental framework, the fundamental rules under which we are going to
structure the State, under which we are going to compete for political
office. That is where the crux of the matter is. And, in my view, it is
important for the NCA, it is important for all the components of the MDC and
other components of civil society to begin to realise that taking
fundamentalist views on the process of achieving that new constitution is
not going to take us anywhere. You can only impose your procedure, your
process, if you have won a war. If you have not, and you have all the
contending people in the ring, you need to arrive at some compromise so that
ZANU PF is in the ring, the two MDC's are in the ring, the NCA and its
constituent elements are in the ring. We say: ok, that is the ZANU way; that
is the MDC Tsvangirai road map; that is the MDC Mutambara roadmap; that is
the NCA roadmap, can we find a mean somewhere in respect of which we can
agree. After all the most important thing at the end of the day, is the
content of the constitution and how it is operated in practice, and then, of
course, the buy-in of the people through the process is also important in
this respect. But, we cannot then be slaves to the process, that unless
someone is able to impose their process we can't move on. And, that is the
view that I hold, that we need to be able to find some compromise which will
be acceptable to the pro democracy forces in the country acceptable to the
ruling party, because ZANU PF still has the supporters, whether they are
30%, 20%, they are still part of Zimbabwe, and you need a national consensus
of everybody in Zimbabwe, including those who support ZANU PF of a new
constitution because these are the ground rules under which we will then
compete for political office. They must be acceptable to everyone. Just as
much as if you were going into a soccer match, a football match; the rules
are accepted by the referee, they are accepted by FIFA, they are accepted by
the teams who are playing under that, and then you can play a game of
soccer. Politics is the same. And, the constitution constitutes those rules,
and I think there is general consensus that is the starting point. The
disagreement as I understand it, is over where do you begin, how do you
begin, who are to be the players. And, my own understanding in various
discourse over the last six years with people in ZANU PF, is that ZANU PF
has an obsession with controlling the process and controlling the outcome.
And, they need, somehow, to be persuaded that it is not in their interest to
seek to control the outcome and to control the process; but to seek to
guarantee that the outcome is one which is reflective of the generality of
opinion in Zimbabwe as a whole.
Violet: Now, Professor Ncube, you
said some of these not useful to discuss
now but I disagree with this
because many people say that it's important to
discuss issues of how and why
the opposition missed such important
opportunities to mobilise the people,
you know, during and after Operation
Murambatsvina and when the elections
were rigged because the same things are
happening again. Mugabe is at his
weakest right now with a collapsed economy
but the MDC is busy fighting each
other. Now, my question to you is, it has
been reported that while others in
the MDC wanted to mobilise the masses for
street action, there was
resistance from some people, and mainly from
yourself . Is this
true?
Professor Ncube: That is part of the garbage which is propagated in
the
course of the dispute within the MDC. As Tendai will no doubt confirm to
you, at every meeting of the National Executive of the MDC before October
12th, at every meeting of the National Council, there was always unanimous
endorsement of the need for democratic resistance; not one dissenting voice.
What some of us later had problems with had nothing with the principle of
commitment to mass action and to democratic resistance. What we had problem
with goes back again to the thing that Tendai says he doesn't want to talk
about and disempower himself; that when the Party then decides on a course
of mass action, of democratic resistance, the responsibility then for
running with that is then reposed in a kitchen cabinet which then runs away
with that process; is not accountable to the political processes and indeed
does things in its own way, and when the ZANU PF reacts to mass action, the
targets are not these shadowy kitchen cabinet people who were never
accountable to anyone. The targets became the structures of the Party in
Mabvuku, in Bulawayo, in Harare, everywhere else. The people were then
arrested, who were tortured and who became the victims of the state
aggression around mass action were in the formal structures of the party.
Whereas, in fact, the people who were then running the show were some
shadowy people outside those formal structures. This is what some of us took
issue with. And of course, members of the kitchen cabinet will go around
saying those of us who opposed them being given a free rein to run some of
the processes of the party where then opposed to mass action, maligning our
name. But, that was never the case. We all, in all instances, were unanimous
on the need for democratic resistance, and we disagreed when this was then
reposed in the hands of unaccountable, unelected individuals. Then, those
who suffered the pain, after that, were the elected individuals in the
political structures of the MDC.
Violet: Tendai, can you comment on
this?
Tendai Biti: Well, I mean I can't comment on organisational issues
with
regards to what happened in the past. I can speak authoritatively with
what
happened in the last action that we did which was the so-called 'Final
Push'
between the 2nd and the 5th of June 2003. In my respectful opinion, I
think
that the only mistake we made there was to describe that action as a
'Final
Push' which then denoted an attempt to dispose of Mugabe through
street
action, which I think in my view, was never the intention. I think
the
intention was to stretch the dictatorship and to increase the -
(inaudible)
of the dictatorship and in that respect I think we achieved our
goal. As far
as 2005 was concerned, I think that it was a lost year; I think
the Party
missed a lot of opportunities and I think that we set so much
momentum with
regard to the 31st March General Election. I think we
campaigned so much.
Remember, we took the decision to participate as late as
the 28th January
2005, but two months down the line we had run, possibly,
our best campaign
ever, we were in all places; you know, Mutoko, Gokwe ,
Nkayi, Tsholotsho.
Places where we had never been active even in the
fantastic 2002 Elections,
even in the fantastic June 2000 Elections. Having
raised the people's
momentum and people's expectations so much, I think we
abused it by failing
to respond to what the people wanted on the 1st April
2005. And, again, come
Murambatsvina, there was so much anger and we did not
respond and provide
leadership to that anger. So, I think that in 2005 we
failed to provide to
the leadership to the huge fear or frustration that was
there and I think
that, to me, that leadership was critical. And, because we
failed to provide
that leadership we begin to eat into ourselves and th12th
October was the
inevitable result of that. But, yes; we are entitled to
learn from the past,
but I think what is critical is to re-focus on the
vision, to re-focus on
the agenda again for democratic change in Zimbabwe.
And, I think some of us
are re-energised, nothing has changed on the ground;
as I keep on saying,
inflation is high, there are no jobs, there is no food
and that is the
language that Zimbabweans want to hear being talked about.
And, that is the
language that we, in the democratic trenches have to keep
on talking about.
Violet: Now, Dr Madhuku, on the issue of street
protests. The NCA has, in
the past, been one of the few organisations that
has taken to the street,
but, it has been said that the demonstrations would
have had more impact if
you work with other stakeholders in the
pro-democracy movement. Now, what is
stopping you from doing that?
Dr
Madhuku: Ya, we have been talking about that. First, we agree that the
demonstrations have more effect if we have more people, we work with others
but those who would want us to explain why we have not been doing that, may
not be understanding the nature of the NCA demonstrations. Demonstrations by
the NCA over the past few years; two, three years, have been designed simply
as a way of putting across our message. They have not been demonstrations
necessarily to either overthrow the government or to do spectacular things.
They have been demonstrations to put across a message and we believe those
demonstrations have succeeded to the extent that they have always kept the
message of a new constitution. As for the demonstration succeeding in
effecting pressure on this government to change and to accept what we are
demanding, I think, that what I would agree, and in fact everyone in the NCA
would agree with those who criticise our demonstrations for not being big
enough to put the kind of pressure that the people have in mind; a pressure,
which, when exerted, would make Mugabe agree and give in and say ' yes, I
see your point, I now do this' and so on. We don't even know how much
pressure that is. So, our demonstrations have succeeded on the first rung of
trying to make a message. Keep putting across our view like as an advocacy
point, and then, we obviously need to work with others. We obviously need to
ensure that these demonstrations are bigger to achieve the second rung;
which is to put the pressure, or to achieve the relevant
pressure.
Violet: Tendai, are you there? Now what about this winter of
discontent. You
know it was said recently we are discontented and winter is
nearly over. Now
people ask, when is the MDC going to deliver on its
promises that people
would rise up and show Mugabe the red
card?
Tendai Biti: Well, I think that people should not have illusions as
the
Prof. has said, about the process of this struggle. I think we shouldn't
have any illusions that this is not a short 100 metre sprint which you do if
you are as fast as Ben Johnson in 9.7 seconds. You know, that is not going
to happen. But, in so doing, clearly, I think there is a duty of care on the
democratic forces to confront this regime democratically and peacefully and
I think we have made a commitment to that. But, having made a commitment to
that democratic resistance, we are not going to be rushed into doing things
when we are not ready. I think, at the present moment, we are busy trying to
institutionally rehabilitate the Party, institutionally rehabilitate
relations that were dented and assaulted following the 12th October 2005
happenings, and it's very important to refocus and bring back the morale
back in the democratic movement. So, we will not allow anyone, ZANU PF or
otherwise, to set the pace for us. I think the democratic movement, and the
people of Zimbabwe must set the pace of all the processes that they are
going to engage in and all the processes to which they are
shareholders.
Violet: And, still on the MDC roadmap. Is non-violence a
principle or a
tactic?
Tendai Biti: Well, I think if you have read
the roadmap, if you are talking
about the document per se, it's quite clear.
There's a section there which
is labelled 'How do we get there', and we make
the point that, should this
regime not accept the roadmap, we are entitled
to engage in peaceful,
constitutional, non-violent, democratic discourse or
confrontation with the
regime in order to persuade it to adopt a paradigm
shift that accepts the
reality that Zimbabweans want change, that there has
to be a dialogue on the
process of arriving at a new constitution, and, that
there has to be a
constitution written by Zimbabweans and for Zimbabweans
and eventually, that
there has to be free and fair elections in terms of
that constitution. And,
what we offer in that roadmap imposition of our
views, we don't have a right
to do that. But, what we simply say there; and
to us there are two or three
principles that to us are inviolable... The
first is the need to agree on
the process of writing the constitution. The
second thing, which we think is
not negotiable, is the need and obligation
for Zimbabweans to write a
constitution for themselves and by themselves;
which constitution has to be
subjected to a referendum. The third thing,
which to us is not negotiable,
is the obligation to resolve the issue of
legitimacy once and for all by
having free and fair elections in terms of
that particular constitution that
would have been written by Zimbabweans and
accepted by Zimbabweans at a road
map. In our roadmap we suggest the issue
of a constitutional conference.
That's just a suggestion. Some might say
'no, look, let's go the South
African CODESA route and have elections to
elect people into the
constitutional assembly'. I am not against that.
That's for Zimbabweans to
define. Some might say 'let's go the Kenyan
route', some might say 'let's go
the Ugandan route'. To us, those are
matters of detail. What is not
negotiable is the need to have a new
constitution and a new constitution
before elections so that you avoid the
chaos that for instance, Kenya finds
itself in. And, we are quite clear in
what we are trying to achieve in that
particular roadmap.
Violet:
And, Dr Madhuku, so much has happened and has been destroyed in
Zimbabwe. In
the event of a new Zimbabwe, you know, the post-crisis period,
what
specifically can be done to rebuild the social fabric and the economy?
Dr
Madhuku: Well, I think that first and foremost, you really need a
legitimate
government. Once you have a legitimate government in place it
must engage
all Zimbabweans or stakeholders in defining our priorities
there,
re-building our economy; which is primary so you can get jobs, you
can get
the clinics working again and so forth. So, what is required in my
view, I
mean I haven't focused on the nitty-gritty's; if you get a
legitimate
government that has the interest of Zimbabweans at heart, that
will be able
to then engage all of us in building a new society.
Violet: That was Part
Five of a series of discussions with the principle
architects of the
opposition. Join us next Tuesday for the final discussion
officials give us
their thoughts on the reported appointment of former
Tanzanian President,
Benjamin Mkapa.
SW Radio Africa Zimbabwe news
BBC
Zimbabweans are facing
chaos and confusion as they try to deposit and
spend their cash before it
becomes worthless on 21 August.
The central bank decided to lop
three zeros off Zimbabwean banknotes
in an attempt to help people deal with
spiralling inflation which stands at
more than 1,000%.
But last
week's surprise devaluation has led to a bureaucratic
nightmare for
businesses and consumers.
"There's not enough cash. You deposit
your old money in the bank and
then you go to an ATM (cash-machine) and it
gives you old notes too. I've
only seen two bills of new currency," an
accountant in Harare told the BBC
News website.
Supermarkets
are labelling prices with the new values, but are
accepting and mainly
dealing with the old currency.
"This is causing a great deal of
confusion about the new values. The
first day they knocked the three noughts
off people went into the
supermarket near where I work and were going crazy
buying everything," she
said.
"Then of course they got to the
till and they didn't have enough
money."
Confiscated
The move is an attempt by central bank governor Gideon
Gono to crack
down on those believed to be profiteering on the black
market.
Only Z$100m ($400) in old money can be deposited in
a bank each week
without any questions being asked.
Anyone
attempting a larger transaction is subject to an investigation
and is liable
to have the money confiscated if it is found to be have been
acquired
illegally.
There are also road blocks across the country as police
try to catch
those with large amounts of old notes.
"I was
stopped at a road block just outside Harare near Norton over
the weekend," a
business manager told the BBC.
"I was carrying Z$60m ($240) of the
old currency for wages; I had to
show the wage slips before the police would
let me pass."
Another Harare resident said her car was searched
thoroughly by the
same policeman when she passed through a roadblock twice
on one day.
"I even had to open the bonnet and he stuck his gloved
hand through
all the gaps in the engine to make sure there wasn't cash
there," she said.
Spending spree
A 27-year-old artist
admitted that the move has forced her to open her
first bank account this
week.
"I couldn't see the point of it [a bank account]
before. I kept my
money under my pillow because by the time you bank it you
can't use it
because it loses so much value."
Although, unlike
some, she said she is not worried about losing her
savings.
"I
keep an excess in US dollars so that if anything happens I know at
least
I'll have some money," she said.
But other Zimbabweans with larger
wallets have gone on massive
spending sprees to dispose of their old
banknotes.
"There's a kitchen shop which has sold all its washing
machines - all
gone, all sold and I saw a woman going in to buy all the
double-door
fridges," said an office worker, who had just been shopping in a
wealthy
northern suburb of the capital.
Cheque
errors
The cash shortage is also leading to a fuel shortage - as
petrol can
only be purchased in cash, she said. But like most people she
believes these
are just teething problems.
"It's going
to be better carrying less notes - you see people carrying
money in boxes.
So the idea is good, but there has not been enough time to
plan the
transfer," she said.
At her office, statements are checked daily
for mistakes as banks have
different rules and regulations.
Cheques accepted after 1 August are supposed to be made out in the new
currency with "revalued" written on them; but bank staff often make errors
as computer systems have yet to be transferred to the new
values.
But many Zimbabweans do not have the luxury of earning
Z$69m ($275) a
month - the amount of old currency needed to keep above the
poverty line.
"People don't have much to spend any more not
because of the new
currency - just generally. It's terrible," a bottle store
manager about 25km
north of Harare told the BBC.
The business
manager, meanwhile, said many of his workers, although
confused about the
exact value of the new notes - there is even a one cent
bill - have welcomed
the devaluation as they feel it will tackle corruption.
But he said
as he drove past Mr Gono's farm near Norton (40km east of
Harare) on
Saturday, it was on fire.
"The whole place was burning. Lots of the
big chefs are angry, really
angry, because they're having their little apple
carts turned upside down."
The government has now been given the go-ahead to forcibly
send Zimbabwean
asylum seekers back home. One refugee, who fled when militia
threatened to
kill him, tells Alison Benjamin of his fight to stay in the
UK
Wednesday August 9, 2006
The Guardian
At the beginning
of the summer, Thomas, 24, looks happy and relaxed - very
different from the
gaunt, angst-ridden young man who had responded to my
request in spring last
year to write an article about living underground in
this country after his
asylum application failed. He feared for his life if
he was sent back to
Zimbabwe, where he claimed that Robert Mugabe's youth
militia, the Green
Bombers, had threatened to kill him.
By Thomas's side now is a young woman,
and round his neck he wears a gold
chain - a present from his adoring
companion. They met six months earlier
and he is living with Tanya and her
four small children in a village in East
Anglia. But it has been a long,
hard journey surviving as a persona non
grata in Britain. And it is not over
yet.
After his final appeal for asylum was turned down back in November
2004,
Thomas lived from pillar to post in Manchester; on friends' floors and
in a
disused factory with other failed asylum seekers. Last summer he spent
a few
months sleeping on a camp bed in a friend's shared flat.
Every
morning he folded away his bed and walked to a local cafe, where he
volunteered his services in return for lunch. One night, on his way home,
five white youths set on him. They kicked him to the ground, stole the
mobile phone a friend had given him, and left him with bruised ribs and a
swollen eye. But he wouldn't go to the police. "I was terrified that they
would send me back to Zimbabwe," he explains.
Shaken by the attack,
he accepted an invitation to stay with friends in
Glasgow. They sent him a
train ticket. During his two-month visit, a
recurring health problem flared
up and he was rushed to hospital. "One night
I started coughing up blood
from my nose and mouth," he recalls. "It was
lots of blood and my fellow
Zimbabweans didn't know what to do. We were all
frightened about going to
hospital because of our status. They knocked on
the door of a British
neighbour. She took me to hospital. I was on a drip
for five days. I was too
scared to tell the doctors about my kidney stones
in case they wanted to
know who was my GP. I don't have one, so I gave a
false name. After I was
discharged, they asked me to come in for a check-up,
but I
didn't."
Racist jokes
Back in Manchester in October, with nowhere
to stay, Thomas spent the night
huddled under his jacket in the National
Express bus station. The following
day he turned to Refugee Action - the
charity which had helped him with his
asylum case. Since no hostels in
Manchester take people who, like Thomas,
are not eligible for state funding,
they had no choice but to send him to a
homeless hostel in Liverpool. "It
was full of drug addicts," says Thomas.
"There was a massive room with lots
of beds. Five o'clock, they gave me
dinner, and six o'clock you had to be in
bed. I was scared of the other
residents. They made racist jokes. I couldn't
sleep all night. The next
morning I took the first bus straight back to
Manchester."
He spent his second night in the bus station before another
friend agreed to
put him up.
At this time, the Asylum and Immigration
Tribunal judged that it was unsafe
for the government to deport failed
asylum seekers to Zimbabwe and that
refugee status should be given to anyone
from the country. "If I'd had any
money, I would have made a big party,"
says Thomas.
As a result of the ruling, Thomas was able to reapply for
asylum. While
waiting for his new case to be heard - which could take
months, or even
years - he was also entitled to claim Section 4 (a limited
form of
government support for asylum seekers in Thomas's position) for food
vouchers and accommodation. But this claim was turned down. His case worker
at Refugee Action appealed against the decision, and Thomas was invited to
attend an appeal hearing in London.
"At the hearing, a National
Asylum Support Service (Nass) solicitor argued
that I couldn't be destitute
because I had been living here for a year,"
Thomas recalls. "I showed the
adjudicator letters from charities that had
fed me because I was homeless,
and the article that I had written for the
Guardian. I could see tears in
her eyes."
He won the appeal and returned to Manchester ready to move
into a Section 4
funded hostel and to receive food vouchers, instead of
having to rely on
handouts from friends and charity, but it was another two
months before
anything arrived.
Three days before Christmas, he was
finally given a room in a Nass hostel.
But his problems didn't end there.
"It was a proper shit hole," he
remembers, his language now peppered with
the Mancunian vernacular. "My
bedroom floor was covered in water, the
kitchen ceiling leaked, there was
mould growing everywhere, and I didn't
have a lock on my door. One day I
came back and the few clothes I had were
gone; another day cornflakes had
been poured on to my
bed."
Conditions were so bad that he ended up house sitting for a friend
over the
Christmas holidays. "His flat was freezing but at least it was
dry," says
Thomas.
As for the £35 food vouchers, he received the
first ones on Christmas Eve,
when the only supermarkets that accepted them
were closed. "I spent
Christmas Day ill with hunger," he says. "I even went
to the police station
in desperation to see if they had any food, but they
said they didn't have
any." He wasn't able to eat until the shops reopened
two days later. The new
year, however, started more promisingly. With his
case worker's help, Thomas
was transferred to a better maintained Nass
hostel. He then heard some
amazing news: his sister was living in the
Midlands. He had last seen her
three years ago, before fleeing Zimbabwe. "I
couldn't believe it," he says.
"She had left the same night as myself after
the Green Bombers had beaten me
up in front of my family for deserting them.
None of the family had heard
from her. We thought she was somewhere in South
Africa."
A refugee charity organised a reunion. He remembered Sonia as a
big woman.
Now aged 43, she was tiny. She, too, was a failed asylum seeker.
She was
living with her boyfriend. "We hated each other when I was growing
up,"
Thomas laughs. "I was an impulsive, noisy teenager and she was a very
religious woman who didn't drink and went to church. But now I just wanted
to be with her. She is the only family I have here."
He has another
two sisters and one brother in South Africa, another brother
still in
Zimbabwe, and one brother who died last year. His mother, whose
house was
destroyed by Mugabe's so-called slum clearance programme, is also
now living
in South Africa with Sonia's two children.
Thomas stayed with Sonia for a
month. During his visit, Tanya, 26, became a
regular visitor to his sister's
house. She had met Thomas through a mutual
friend and they clicked
immediately, sharing a similar sense of humour and
sunny disposition. As his
new hostel did not allow overnight guests, she
invited Thomas to move in
with her and her four young children.
With Tanya at work all day, Thomas
quickly became a house husband. It was a
role he clearly enjoyed. "It's the
happiest I have ever been," he beams,
clutching Tanya's hand.
The
young couple are openly affectionate. They are engaged and plan to
marry,
but say they don't want to tie the knot until Thomas has his refugee
status.
"I don't want anyone to think we are getting married so I can stay
here," he
insists. "She's been there for me, more than anyone else in my
life. She
took me in when I had fuck all."
A few weeks after our meeting, Tanya
went to South Africa with her eldest
daughter to meet Thomas's family. They
took her over the border to show her
where Thomas grew up and from what he
has fled. She says the trip has helped
her to understand what he has been
through.
Prohibited from working
Back in England, Tanya lost her
job. Thomas is desperate to find employment
so he can financially support
his new family, but asylum seekers are
prohibited from working. Despite
Tanya hiring the services of a
Birmingham-based solicitor in March - at a
cost of £585 - five months on
there is still no word from the Home Office
about his new asylum case.
The uncertainty is making him nervous and edgy
again. "It's the not knowing
what is going on that is stressful," he says
over the phone. As a result,
they are aware that their fragile happiness
could be shattered at any
moment.
In April, the government
successfully challenged the ruling that prevented
it sending failed asylum
seekers back to Zimbabwe. Last week, the challenge
was upheld, giving the
government the green light to forcibly remove up to
7,000 people. This is
despite warnings from refugee organisations that a lot
of asylum seekers are
still at real risk if sent back.
"The British government has itself
repeatedly condemned the human rights
abuses of the Mugabe administration,"
says Sandy Buchan, chief executive of
Refugee Action. "The lack of
monitoring of asylum seekers on return means
their safety cannot be
assured."
Asked what happens if the Home Office refuses to reopen his
case and does
resume its policy of returning failed asylum seekers to
Zimbabwe, Thomas
says: "It's harder now. I have a family here, but I'll have
to go
underground again. No way am I going back." And Tanya? Without
hesitation,
she replies: "I'll go wherever he is."
· Thomas, Tanya,
and Sonia's names have been changed. Thomas's original
article, and more on
asylum seekers, at SocietyGuardian.co.uk/asylumseekers
The Herald (Harare)
August 9,
2006
Posted to the web August 9, 2006
Harare
EIGHT more
transmission towers belonging to Snel, the Democratic Republic of
Congo
(DRC) electricity generating company, have been vandalised, dashing
Zimbabwe's hopes of a quick resumption of electricity imports from the vast
central African country.
Zesa Holdings imports 100 megawatts from DRC
on contract basis, which it
uses during peak periods to minimise load
shedding.
Zimbabwe also imports electricity from neighbouring South
Africa, Zambia and
Mozambique, bringing total imports to 35
percent.
Power supplies from Snel were interrupted two weeks ago
following the
vandalisation of three transmission towers. Engineer Edward
Rugoyi, managing
director of the Zimbabwe Electricity Transmission Company
(Zetco), a
subsidiary of Zesa Holdings, confirmed that the local power
utility would be
cut from the DRC until the transmission towers were
fixed.
"Things are not looking good yet," he said during an interview on
Monday.
"Snel informed us last week that eight more transmission towers had
been
vandalised while they were in the process of repairing the other three
that
had been vandalised before."
He said the impact was being felt
during peak periods when electricity from
DRC was used to augment power
supplies from local and external sources.
Eng Rugoyi was not in a
position to say when the supplies would be restored.
The Zetco boss
dismissed speculation that DRC was no longer interested in
supplying
Zimbabwe with electricity, saying discussions were currently
underway to
extend the the prepaid contract.
Famine Early Warning System Network (FEWS NET)
Date: 24 Jul 2006
- Wide disparities in local cereal
availability
Summary and implications
The national availability
outlook for staple cereals (maize, millets and
sorghum) for the 2006/07
marketing year indicates greatly improved
availability compared to last
year. The key determinants of household food
security will be sub-national
grain availability, market grain flows, and
the ability of urban households
and those cereal producing households with
deficits to purchase sufficient
food on local markets. The wheat production
forecast for 2006 is 13 percent
higher than last year's production, but will
only cover about 34 percent of
national requirements. The Zimbabwe
Vulnerability Assessment Committee
(ZimVac) 2006 rural food security and
vulnerability assessment, whose
results are likely to be released in early
August 2006, will give some
indications of the size and geographic spread of
the food insecurity problem
for Zimbabwe's rural population in the 2006/07
marketing year. ZimVac has
plans to conduct at least two food security
monitoring assessments, before
the onset (around October 2006) and at the
peak (February 2007) of the
hunger period.
Current hazard summary
- High annual inflation -
measured in June 2006 at 1,184.6 percent - further
eroding purchasing
power.
- Projected cereal deficit of about 22% for the 2006/07 marketing
year,
which is concentrated in the southern districts as well as the western
and
eastern margins of the country.
Angola Press
Harare, Zimbabwe, 08/09 - A Zimbabwean firm and a Chinese
company said
Monday they had teamed up to invest more than US$40 million in
a chrome
mining venture in Zimbabwe`s central mineral-rich
region.
Dande Capital Holdings (DCH) said it had secured financial
support from the
China National Construction and Agricultural Machinery
Import and Export
group for the chrome venture, that could net about US$65
million in annual
exports.
DCH chief executive, Evison Masanjeya said
about three billion Zimbabwean
dollars had been injected into the project,
and the Chinese partners would
provide US$18 million in fresh capital,
mainly in the form of equipment.
(250 Zim dollars=1USD).
"We expect
to earn US$65 million per annum from this venture if everything
goes
according to plan. This deal has so many advantages in that it is
highly
negotiable and we are assured of selling our chrome at international
market
prices," Masanjeya said.
According to him, the venture will produce
25,000 tonnes of chrome, up from
6,000 tonnes it is producing at the
moment.
Zimbabwe, which is reported to have the largest reserves of
chrome in the
world, is currently a major supplier of the
mineral.
Masanjera said the Chinese partners were also looking into
building a
smelter near Zimbabwe`s central city of KweKwe.
VOA
By
Tendai Maphosa
Harare
09 August 2006
The trial
of Zimbabwe's justice minister for attempting to obstruct the
course of
justice finally got under way after a retired magistrate was
appointed to
preside over the case. Serving magistrates in the province the
offense is
alleged to have occurred had refused to try the minister citing
intimidation.
Justice minister Patrick Chinamasa appeared before
retired magistrate
Phineas Chipopoteke in Rusape in the Manicaland province.
Chinamasa faces
charges of trying to persuade the victim of intra party
violence to withdraw
charges of assault against a fellow ruling Zanu - PF
party member.
The trial failed to start last week when the chief
magistrate of the
province said no magistrate in the province was prepared
to hear the case.
They cited intimidation by the state security minister
Didymus Mutasa. The
magistrates said Mutasa had accused court officials of
being members of the
opposition Movement for Democratic Change.
The
charges against Chinamasa stem from violence in a constituency in the
province when the complainant, James Kaunye, challenged Mutasa to be the
party's candidate for member of parliament in 2004. A gang of fellow party
members assaulted Kaunye allegedly on Mutasa's orders. Mutasa was cleared of
wrongdoing but some of the assailants were convicted.
According to
the state controlled daily The Herald, Kaunye told the court
that Chinamasa
had tried to bribe him into withdrawing the charges against
the alleged
leader of the assailants, as it would tarnish Mutasa's image.
Chinamasa
allegedly offered to facilitate the complainant's acquisition of a
farm and
to assist him in an attempted murder case he was facing. Chinamsa
denies all
charges saying he approached the complainant to hear his side of
the
story.
The Law Society of Zimbabwe called the refusal of the magistrates
to try the
minister disturbing. The society's president Joseph James says
the incident
further underscores the need for the judiciary to be completely
independent
of the executive. He said the magistrates were being asked to
try Chinamasa
who happens to be their boss, adding that the matter brings
the
administration of justice in Zimbabwe into question.
New Zimbabwe
By Staff Reporter
Last updated: 08/10/2006 03:22:07
THE
trial of Zimbabwe's Justice Minister Patrick Chinamasa was abruptly
halted
Wednesday after a massive power outage swept through the small town
of
Rusape where the trial is being held.
Chinamasa is facing charges of
attempting to obstruct the course.
The power cut came as Chinamasa's
accuser James Kaunye was grilled by
defence lawyers during cross
examination.
Kaunye accuses Chinamasa of trying to bribe him so that he
could drop his
complaint against Albert Nyakuedzwa, the campaign manager of
State Security
Minister Didymus Mutasa, now serving three years in jail for
brutally
assaulting him.
Retired magistrate, Phenias Chipopoteke,
adjourned proceedings at noon to
2.15 pm but the power had not been
restored, forcing him to further postpone
the trial to next
Thursday.
Chipopoteke took over the case after magistrates in Rusape
refused to
preside over the trial, accusing Mutasa of intimidating
them.
The demand for electricity in Zimbabwe often outstrips supply due
to a host
of problems, including foreign currency shortages. The Zimbabwe
Electricity
Supply Authority (Zesa) has resorted to load shedding for long
periods
across the country.
On Tuesday, Chinamasa denied offering
Kaunye bribes, describing the
allegations as "false, baseless and
malicious".
Kaunye told the court that the minister called on him at his
Yorkshire Farm
in Headlands and offered him bribes so that he could drop his
complaint
against 23 of Mutasa's supporters who had earlier attacked and
left him for
dead.
Kaunye, who was challenging Mutasa for the Makoni
North constituency in Zanu
PF primary elections, was due to testify in
Nyakuedzwa's trial when
Chinamasa allegedly approached him and
offered:
. to help him start a cattle ranching project.
. to
ensure that his path was cleared for him to run for a senate post.
. to
influence the DDF to build a dam at his Yorkshire Farm.
. to facilitate
the withdrawal of attempted murder charges he was facing.
. to assist him
get an offer letter for Precinct Farm which he wanted.
Chinamasa, Kaunye
told the court, stressed that if he went on and testified
against Nyakuedzwa
and the Zanu PF supporters, that would "tarnish" the
image of the party,
Mutasa and that of President Robert Mugabe.
Kaunye said: "He further
explained that United Nations Secretary General
Kofi Annan was expected to
visit the country and when he comes, the
publicity would be focused on
Minister Mutasa and this meant that the party
and the President would be
blamed for appointing people like that."
In his defence, Chinamasa
rejected having made any of the offers cited by
Kaunye, insisting that he
only went to his farm on December 18 last year to
express his concerns about
violence in Makoni District and "establish the
cause of the
disturbances."
Chinamasa said he held a lengthy meeting with Kaunye,
during which he
offered to set up a meeting between him and Mutasa to sort
out the dispute
over the party candidate. During the discussion, Chinamasa
said, Kaunye
described Mutasa as a "very bad man".
Chinamasa said:
"To James Kaunye, therefore, Minister Mutasa was bent on
making him suffer
and so Kaunye had to fight back. Kaunye seems to harbour
hatred against all
people whom he perceives as Minister Mutasa's allies or
associates and he
will try to destroy them.
"In me, Kaunye sees an extension of Minister
Mutasa and it is not difficult
to see his motive for lying against
me."
Freedom House
Extract from
Countries at the Crossroads
2006
by Sanja Tatic and Christopher Walker
The increase
in the number of electoral democracies, the spread of
democratic ideals, and
the proliferation of human rights values over the
last three decades have
generated domestic and international pressure for
reform on autocratic
states, one-party dictatorships, and monarchies.
Emerging democracies are
similarly scrutinized as to whether their newly
formed democratic
institutions are sustainable. While a wide range of states
now face growing
pressure to make crucial choices about liberalization and
reform, world
leaders, foreign assistance providers, and the international
business
community are eager to have at their disposal effective tools for
monitoring
and measuring political development among countries standing at
the
crossroads of democratic governance.
Countries at the Crossroads provides
detailed written analysis and
comparative statistics on two sets of 30
states at this very
juncturetypically middle-performing countries that
qualify neither as
failed states nor as clear beacons of democracy. The
countries evaluated
represent a range of governments: traditional or
constitutional monarchies;
one-party states or outright dictatorships;
states where reforms have
stalled or lagged behind; and states that suffer
from insurgencies. Every
other year each edition evaluates 30 countries;
over a two-year time period
a report is issued on each of the 60 countries
identified for analysis.
In this way, Crossroads covers an extensive set
of countries while offering
readers useful time series data as well as
comprehensive narrative
evaluation of the progress and backsliding underway
in the countries
covered. The survey examines four main aspects of
governance: public voice
and accountability, civil rights, the rule of law,
and anticorruption and
transparency. The 2006 edition marks the third year
of the survey and thus
allows for drawing clear conclusions regarding some
of the evaluated
countries' progress toward democratic norms and others'
growing
authoritarian tendencies since 2004.
As illustrated in so
many of the narratives in this edition, entrenched
corruption stands out as
a major obstacle to reform in transitional
countries. In 2006, as was the
case in 2004, Anticorruption and Transparency
saw the weakest performance of
the four main areas evaluated, averaging a
score of 2.71 (on a scale of 0-7,
with 7 being strongest), more than a full
point lower than the strongest
overall category, Civil Liberties. Across
country types and geographical
regions, none of the 30 evaluated countries
has ever scored above a 4.0 on
the anticorruption measure.
The crumbling of authoritarian regimes in the
midst of popular protests in
Georgia, Kyrgyzstan, and Ukraine was in no
small part spurred by public
frustration with corrupt governance. Although
these countries still confront
profound challenges, particularly in the
spheres of anticorruption reform
and the rule of law--common to many
post-transition countries--the political
changes represent a significant
development in the two-year period since
this set of countries was last
examined.
Not all countries covered in the survey have demonstrated an
improvement.
Most countries have maintained the status quo while others,
such as
Zimbabwe, Nepal, and Nigeria, showed a decline as a result of the
growing
authoritarian tendencies of their leaders. Arguably, the case of
Nepal has
been the most extreme: "King Gyanendra has suspended Nepal's
entire
democracy, dismissed parliament, and appointed a hand-picked prime
minister
and cabinet. The rule of law has been subverted through the
creation of a
number of extrajudicial bodies, and human rights have been
profoundly
compromised."
The survey presented a number of other
significant findings:
a.. Respect for the rule of law has dramatically
declined across the
survey since 2004, with decreased scores in nearly half
of the countries
examined.
b.. Torture in police custody remains the
most pressing human rights
problem in more than half of the countries
examined.
c.. Countries that have achieved particular improvement in the
past two
years include Kyrgyzstan, Georgia, Morocco and Ukraine. Those that
have
declined the most are Nepal, Zimbabwe and Nigeria.
d.. In nearly
two-thirds of the reports, experts' recommendations
emphasize a need to
balance the political playing field, especially in the
context of election
campaigns, where incumbents often dominate and prevent
the press from
providing useful information to the public.
Entrenched Corruption Poses
Enormous Challenge to Reform
Crossroads' Anticorruption and Transparency
section analyzes a government's
performance in fighting corruption by
evaluating the existence of laws and
standards to prevent and combat corrupt
practices, the enforcement of such
measures, and overall governmental
transparency. Scores in this category are
remarkably low across regions and
country typologies. Even in those
countries with relatively sound
performance in accountability and public
voice, such as South Africa and
Kenya, the scores for corruption remain low.
Crossroads analysts and
regional specialists found Zimbabwe, Azerbaijan,
Yemen, Kazakhstan, and
Bahrain to be the five weakest performers in this
category among the 30
countries evaluated in this year's edition. In these
countries, powerholders
effectively maintain an institutional chokehold on
the state, maximizing
private benefits while assigning a secondary role to
the public interest.
Zimbabwe was the worst performer in this category. The
report observes that
"the primary interest of the Mugabe government is to
retain power through a
system of patronage that includes access to both
state and private assets.
The ruling ZANU-PF party owns a wide range of
businesses, allowing party
elites to profit personally."
In another example, in Kazakhstan, where
President Nursultan Nazarbayev has
ruled for a decade and a half, the report
finds that "the government of
Kazakhstan is unlikely to take decisive steps
to eliminate corruption as
long as Nursultan Nazarbayev remains president of
the country& It is hard to
imagine that he will support a complete
overhaul of the existing system,
which has brought significant wealth to his
family."
Even in the states that have recently experienced transition,
where a new
generation of leaders took power amid tremendous public
enthusiasm, with
strong mandates to stamp out corruption, meaningful
anticorruption reform
remains elusive. The Ukraine report, for example,
finds that the
breakthrough in the exposure of corruption on a grand scale
following the
Orange Revolution "was not accompanied by a change in the
structural
incentives for politicians and civil servants to blur the line
between
private and public interests."
The issue of corruption is
particularly pernicious in countries where
citizens are dependent on the
government for their most fundamental needs.
In such settings, entrenched
corrupt networks feed on weak and insular state
institutions that were
designed to deliver political goods to the public.
Absent sufficiently
strong countervailing institutions, even new governments
principally
dedicated to reform are often unable to unshackle themselves
from the
narrow, private interests that subsume the public interest. In
Yemen, for
example, "a culture of bribery permeates the state apparatus
including
hospitals, schools, and universities." Bribes are necessary for
such basic
activities as obtaining hospital treatment, and those who raise
objections
publicly often face criticism or even worse.
In any democracy, the news
media is a vital institution with the
responsibility to report on government
activities, increase transparency,
help ensure government integrity, and
serve the public interest. However,
Crossroads' Accountability and Public
Voice measures suggest that media
itself is often subject to influence by
powerful political and economic
interests that leads to self-censorship and
a muzzling of the sort of
reporting that would ameliorate corrupt
practices.
Journalists and editors are frequently co-opted by officials
and business
interests. Moreover, reporters who expose government corruption
or are
particularly critical of regime practices are often subject to
arbitrary
arrest or threats or acts of violence. In Armenia, for example, at
least
four journalists were severely beaten by special police while covering
the
brutal break-up of an antigovernment demonstration in Yerevan in 2004.
The
fear of such retribution leads to poor government transparency, allows
corruption to remain ingrained, and serves to prevent any meaningful
discussion of issues that could lead to policy reform.
The
governments, for their partwhether long-standing procedural
democracies,
countries newly in transition, or autocratic statesoften list
rooting out
corruption as their top priority. Many have waged aggressive
anticorruption
campaigns throughout the two years under study, including
passing important
anticorruption legislation and some high-profile arrests,
often cited as
evidence of their progress. Yet none of the 30 countries have
reduced
corruption to levels where it no longer presents a serious obstacle
to
sustained economic growth and further political development. In fact,
between 2004 and 2006, anticorruption and transparency scores have declined
in nearly one-third of all countries surveyed.
Sub-Saharan
Africa
The countries of sub-Saharan Africa were the second-best
performing regional
group. South Africa was the strongest overall within
this region. As a
region, Africa underwent the greatest decline on issues
under the indicator
measuring "Protection Against State Terror,
Imprisonment, and Torture."
Zimbabwe, the worst-performing country in the
region, has suffered a
considerable decline in performance since the last
review, dropping nearly
four full points in the aggregate. President Robert
Mugabe has dragged
Zimbabwe into a political, social, and economic morass.
ZANU-PF economic
policies have transformed one of Africa's most diversified
economic sectors
into a pre-industrial, peasant-based economy. Mugabe's
manipulation of food
shortages has generated untold misery in his country.
Some 75 percent of
Zimbabweans now live in poverty; the country is facing a
crisis of major
proportions, one created by Zimbabwe's leadership. Violence
and intimidation
have been used to control what remains of a free press and
to convert the
country's once highly respected and independent judiciary
into a reliable
instrument for implementation of the president's policies.
As a result of
its increasingly brutal and anti-democratic rule, Robert
Mugabe's regime's
precipitous descent into the ranks of the world's most
repressive systems
was reflected in the survey findings: Of all 30 countries
examined, Zimbabwe
received the poorest scores in three of the four main
categories.
Expert Recommendations
Countries at the
Crossroads includes recommendations that highlight
priorities for government
action in the four thematic categories in each
country. Analysts are
encouraged to focus on issues that need to be
addressed most urgently in
devising their recommendations. Therefore,
variation from one set of
recommendations to the next is considerable.
However, several
recommendations stand out. In nearly two-thirds of the
reports, experts
emphasize the need for balancing the media playing field,
especially in the
context of election campaigns, when incumbents often
dominate and prevent
the press from playing a meaningful role in providing
information to the
public. Moreover, the authors of these reports recommend
that media freedom
should be increased, whether through less restrictive
laws or practices,
less government interference, or better protections for
journalists who
cover controversial issues.
The second most frequently recurring
recommendation is for efforts to combat
torture. In particular, experts
cited the need for improving police training
and professionalism. Of the 30
reports, 13 call for measures to improve
police reform and encourage better
training. The countries for which this
recommendation was highlighted were
Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Armenia,
Azerbaijan, Georgia, Morocco, Bahrain,
Jordan, Uganda, Venezuela, Guatemala,
Cambodia, and
Indonesia.
Moreover, along with the most recurrent recommendations are
also calls for
more effective enforcement of financial disclosure laws that
prevent
conflicts of interest among public officials. Most countries have
these laws
on the books; however, in many cases the agencies in charge of
enforcing the
regulations are either too weak or lack independence to
prosecute
individuals who breach them.
The 2006 edition of Countries
at the Crossroads also revisits the
recommendations first made in 2004 for
these countries (these
recommendations and their updates can be found in the
Appendix). In far too
many cases, little or no action has been taken on
these critical reform
priorities, suggesting that governments have not
devoted sufficient
attention and political will to these
issues.
Conclusion: Democracy's Fragility and Resilience
The
global trends toward democratization paint a promising picture of the
world.
However, sound institutions and democratic governance do not develop
overnight. With good governance increasingly being acknowledged as one of
the key factors in encouraging growth, a reality that has been recognized by
the Millennium Challenge Account among others, it is important that policy
makers remain focused on the basic elements that constitute accountable and
responsive governance. The evaluation of the states examined in Countries at
the Crossroads is designed to enhance understanding of the progress that
states should make if they are to achieve transparent and accountable
governance. By focusing on state performance, Crossroads puts primary
responsibility for the protection of basic rights and good governance on
governments.
These countries at the crossroads are by definition
neither optimal nor
irredeemably poor performers. They are countries whose
leadership can make
policy choices to ensure basic human rights and to
enable these states to
join the community of stable, free, and democratic
nations. And they should
be encouraged to do so.
Sanja Tatic and
Christopher Walker are co-editors of Countries at the
Crossroads.
New Zimbabwe
By
Staff Reporter
Last updated: 08/09/2006 21:41:59
ZIMBABWEAN police were
holding two opposition legislators late Tuesday
following protests over high
water tariffs in Chitungwiza.
St Mary's MP Job Sikhala and Goodrich
Chimbaira, MP for Zengeza, were
arrested in St Mary's after voluntarily
attending a police station with
their lawyer, Edmore Jori.
Police had
been looking for the two MPs following riots against increased
water charges
in Chitungwiza on Monday which saw 22 people arrested.
Public
demonstrations are not allowed in Zimbabwe without police approval.
In a
statement released Wednesday, the Movement for Democratic Change (MDC)
said
its national secretary for security and defence in the youth assembly,
Costa
Chipadze, had also been arrested with the two MPs.
The men are likely to
face charges under the Public Order and Security Act
(Posa) for organising
"illegal" demonstrations.
The MDC said: "The party is disappointed that
the police force is being used
by the government to muzzle the democratic
voices of the people against
corrupt tendencies some of which are rampant
and evident everywhere in the
country.
"Why the police feel it
incumbent upon themselves to deny the residents the
right to express their
disquiet over phenomenal charges that are not
commensurate with an efficient
service delivery system from the council,
boggles the mind.
"It is
surprising that while the police continue to make arrests, denying
residents
their right to express themselves against a corrupt Chitungwiza
council,
today's Herald newspaper has reported that the council has lost $24
billion
through corruption.
"This clearly vindicates the position taken by the
residents. We condemn the
wanton and arbitrary arrests by the police
especially under circumstance
where it is evident that the residents have
genuine grievances."
By
Tererai Karimakwenda
09 August 2006
South Africans on
Wednesday celebrated the contribution made by women
to the building of their
nation. The event had a particular focus on the
thousands of women who
descended on the Union Buildings in Pretoria in 1956
to demonstrate
peacefully against the law which restricted where non-white
people could
live, work and travel. By all accounts the celebrations were
inspirational,
but Zimbabwean women who attended a ceremony in Johannesburg
say the joyous
occasion was ruined for them when Zimbabwe's Vice President
Joyce Mujuru was
announced as a special guest.
Elinor Sisulu of the Crisis in
Zimbabwe Coalition South Africa told us
she was so shocked Mujuru was
honoured this way that it spoiled the spirit
of the day and she left. The
Reverend Dr. Martine Stemerick
attended the ceremony as well and she
too was angered by Mujuru's
attendance. She said: "Mujuru should have been
the guest of dishonour."
Sisulu explained that Mujuru is a woman
who represents the Zimbabwean
government which destroyed the homes and
businesses of thousands of people
and sent them to the rural areas with
nothing. She said this was exactly
what the South African women were being
honoured for fighting against in
1956 and Mujuru should not have been
invited. Sisulu was referring to the
government's Operation Murambatsvina
which displaced nearly a million people
last year. Most were dumped in rural
areas without food or shelter. Mujuru
did not make a speech but Sisulu said
she would have booed the vice
president if she had spoken and many South
African women would have joined
her.
Sisulu said it was
inspiring to see young fathers at the ceremony in
South Africa pushing baby
strollers while the women marched. She felt the
occasion represented the
ambitions and hopes of those women who marched
fifty years ago. She then
paid a special tribute to the members of Women Of
Zimbabwe Arise (WOZA)
saying their spirit is the same as the South African
women. Sisulu added
that she is amazed at the courage of the WOZA women and
has a deep respect
for the peaceful ways in which they protest injustice in
Zimbabwe.
Dr. Stemerick told us as they marched in South Africa
Wednesday
morning they remembered the late Sheba Dube who co-founded WOZA
along with
Jenni Williams. She said Sheba once brought a number of very poor
women to
meet Elinor (Sisulu) and to speak to the Crisis Coalition about the
conditions of women without a voice, particularly women in the rural areas.
She said the WOZA women should have been the special guests, not Joyce
Mujuru. The WOZA slogan "Strike a woman, you strike a rock" was adopted from
the slogan of the South African women who were celebrated
Wednesday.
SW Radio Africa Zimbabwe news
The Herald
(Harare)
August 9, 2006
Posted to the web August 9,
2006
Tsungirirayi Shoriwa
Harare
SOME 248 intern doctors who
last month boycotted duties in protest against a
Government decision to
deploy them to rural district hospitals for a year,
will not get their
certificates of good standing, the Zimbabwe Medical and
Dental
Practitioners' Council has said.
The council said all junior doctors who
took part in the industrial action
acted in breach of the Hippocratic oaths
they took, which was the basis of
the medical ethics.
The council was
responding to Hospital Doctors' Association (HDA) lawyer Mr
Derek Sigauke of
Mavhunga and Associates, who wanted to know the legal basis
upon which the
council was withholding the doctors' certificates.
Certificates of good
standing are issued to doctors who have completed
internship at Government
hospitals and the documents act as their reference
letters.
They also
empower the doctors to apply for employment outside Zimbabwe.
However,
the council's position has set the stage for a protracted legal
wrangle with
the doctors since the interns were of the view that the council
lacked legal
grounds to withhold the certificates.
For as long as the interns have no
certificates of good standing, they
cannot operate private surgeries or go
into private practice.
But they can only work in Government health
institutions.
Junior doctors went on strike last month protesting against
the Government's
decision to deploy them to rural district hospitals
countrywide.
Through its lawyer, Mr Godfrey Mamvura of Scanlen and
Holderness, the
council said section 132 of the Health Professions Act
empowered it to
withhold the certificates.
"As we have previously
indicated, in terms of section 132 of the Health
Professions Act,
certificates of competence are issued on an individual
basis to persons who
have undergone such training and course of instruction
as council may
prescribe and passed an examination or examinations to the
satisfaction of
the council," Mr Mamvura wrote to Mr Sigauke.
The letter, dated August 1
2006, also said the certificates would only be
issued to those doctors "who
have done the mandatory one-year community
service at a designated health
institution".
Mr Mamvura further stated that the industrial action by the
intern doctors
was ---- in the view of the council --- contrary to the oaths
the doctors
took.
"We are further instructed that some of the intern
doctors are reported to
have been on strike. This is viewed by our client as
being contrary to the
Hippocratic oath which is the basis of medical
ethics.
"Any intern doctor who went on strike will not be issued with a
certificate
of good standing because he or she is not in good standing," Mr
Mamvura
further said.
Last month, Mr Sigauke, on the instructions of
the HDA, challenged the
council to produce the legal basis upon which it
relied in withholding the
certificates.
"In that event (of failing to
produce the legal basis), we shall proceed to
institute legal action to seek
an order compelling you to issue the
certificates to the medical doctors to
whom they are due and you shall be
liable for legal costs," Mr Sigauke
wrote.
Mr Sigauke yesterday said section 132 of the Health Professions
Act did not
deal with the issuance of the certificates, adding that they
might go to
court over the issue.
Meanwhile, Mr Sigauke has written
to the Parirenyatwa Group of Hospitals
demanding that the hospital provide
HDA president Dr Kudakwashe Nyamutukwa
and Dr Takaruda Chinyoka with copies
of the Memorandum of Agreement they
signed with the Ministry of Health and
Child Welfare upon admission to
internship.
"Our clients were,
however, not furnished with copies of the agreement for
their retention. We,
therefore, write to demand as we hereby do, that you
provide our clients
with copies of the said agreement forthwith," Mr Sigauke
said in the letter
addressed to the hospital chief executive officer Mr
Thomas
Zigora.
Government has already indicated that the doctors, who also
protested
against their deployment, would only receive the certificates
after serving
at the district hospitals.
The doctors returned to work
last month after Government increased their
vehicle loan facility from $50
000 ($50 million old currency) to $2 million
($2 billion).
Their
salaries were also raised to between $81 000 ($81 million) and $88 000
($88
million) up from $57 000 ($57 million).
They would also get 20 percent of
their salary as medical allowance and 15
percent as rural allowance. The
doctors also stand to get 124,5 percent of
their gross income as on-call
allowance.
The Herald (Harare)
August 9,
2006
Posted to the web August 9, 2006
Harare
ACTING Chitungwiza
executive mayor Mr Darlington Nota allegedly consumed
almost 1 500 litres of
fuel within 20 days.
The consumption translates to 68 litres a
day.
Mr Nota consumed 1 435 litres of fuel between August 2 and 30 last
year,
prompting the now suspended town treasurer Mr Goodway Mvududu to write
to
the late town clerk, Mr Simbarashe Mudunge, questioning the rationale
behind
the acting mayor's expenditure.
Mr Nota was acting mayor when
the then mayor, Mr Misheck Shoko, was on
leave.
According to
statistics, Mr Nota used an average of 47,5 litres of fuel a
day between
August 2 and 11 and his consumption rate rose to 65, 3 litres a
day between
August 12 and 20 the same year.
Between August 22 and 30 2005, Mr Nota's
fuel consumption rate declined to
64,2 litres per day, which Mr Mvududu
described as unreasonable.
Mr Nota's average daily consumption translated
to 68,2 litres.
For the 21 days recorded, Mr Nota is alleged to have
managed to account for
only 355 litres for his trips to Kadoma, Mutoko,
Nyamapanda and Mberengwa.
The remainder was unaccounted for.
In a
confidential memorandum to the town clerk, Mr Mvududu said the rate at
which
Mr Nota was consuming fuel was "rather apparently too high if the
principle
of exemplary conduct was anything to go by".
Mr Mvududu said he only
learnt of the abuse of the fuel facility by the
acting mayor after receiving
an anonymous call.
"Arising from an anonymous call to my office, it was
alleged that the
official mayoral car was refueling at an alarming rate. I
was left with no
choice but to submit a report on the subject matter. The
objective was to
establish whether or not the fuel consumption was, indeed,
a cause for
concern.
"I was disconcerted to discover that the fuel
consumption rate was rather
apparently too high if the principle of
exemplary conduct was anything to go
by," wrote Mr Mvududu.
Mr
Mvududu went on to say that in terms of the Urban Councils Act, an acting
mayor was not entitled to the benefits, salary and allowances of a mayor,
but enjoys an allowance fixed by council.
He said the official
vehicle would only be made available to the acting
mayor when conducting
official functions only.
"It follows, therefore, that the use of an
official vehicle for personal
business is prohibited to the extent that it
would be seemingly tantamount
to an abuse or a misuse of public
property.
"Surely the fuel consumption was a cause for concern, let alone
the
depreciation of the official vehicle arising from an apparent abuse or
misuse of the mayoral vehicle. Your guidance is necessary in terms of
section 136 (c) of the Act that requires the town clerk to recommend to the
executive committee the measures necessary to safeguard the finances and
assets of the council," Mr Mvududu further wrote.
He pointed that
there was need to reinforce public accountability at the
local
authority.
However, the acting mayor last week dismissed Mr Mvududu's
memo as
mischievous.
Mr Nota said as the acting mayor, he was
entitled to benefits, which
included council fuel and vehicles.
He
said he was not even responsible for the refueling of the vehicles, but
it
was the duty of his drivers, who report to the town clerk, to do
so.
"That was a mischievous memo. Mvududu is not aware of council
operations.
"If he were, then he should have known that the mayor does
not go to refuel
cars.
"He was just mischievous for reasons which I
do not want to know," said Mr
Nota, speaking from Victoria Falls where he
was attending the just-ended
local government conference.
He added
that Mr Mvududu was sacked from council for incompetence.
Mr Nota said if
fuel was drawn from council coffers at the said rate, then
Mr Mvududu was
also to blame since he had a duty to see that fuel was
economically
used.