http://www.newzimbabwe.com/
15/08/2012 00:00:00
by Phyllis
Mbanje
SEVEN street vendors who attacked two police officers with
iron bars before
smashing window panes at a police post have been spared
jail – because they
were assaulted in custody.
Harare magistrate
Tendai Mahwe condemned police brutality as he fined Taurai
Nherera,
Simbarashe Makaha, Muchineripi Muzengeza, Murambiwa Dzwenge,
Kudakwashe
Usai, Mclean Barnabas Mwanaka and Simbarashe Chinodya US$500 each
on
Wednesday.
Charges were dropped against four others while a 12th man charged
over the
January 11 violence was acquitted.
Passing sentence on the
seven, Mahwe said: “Although your conduct was
dangerous and warranting a
custodial sentence, I will waive it in favour of
a fine because you were
assaulted by the police.
"I will therefore opt to hit your pockets hard with
a $500 fine payable by
August 31."
One of the vendors, Mwanaka, was
allegedly hit with a brick while in police
custody and broke his
leg.
Prosecutors said the seven were part of a group of street vendors
who
attacked Seargent Chitima and Constable Mutada on January 11 after the
two
officers tried to move them on from illegal vending bays along Nelson
Mandela.
The group attacked the two police officers with stones and
metal bars before
marching on the First Street police post where they
smashed 12 window panes.
The vendors, the court heard, then sought refuge at
the MDC-T’s HQ but they
were smoked out with tear gas.
Alec
Muchadehama, defending, told the court that the arrests were
politically-motivated and that the police had provoked the
vendors.
He said the damage was very minimal and in no way did the
group's actions
disturb public order since it was between the police and the
vendors.
But Mahwe convicted the seven on public violence charges.
http://www.thezimbabwean.co.uk
A police officer identified as Frank Katandika of
Dombotombo Police Station,
allegedly threatened to shut down businesses run
by MDC-T District vice
Organizing Secretary, Tonderai
Chitaguda.
15.08.1212:28pm
by Staff Reporter
Eyewitnesses
told The Zimbabwean that Katandika stormed into Chitaguda’s Eli’s
Takeaway
last Monday night and warned that MDC had no right to run
businesses in the
country. He proceeded to assault the manager, Elizabeth
Mandaza.
On
arrival at the station, the cop allegedly asked for a baton to further
discipline MDC members.
“The police refused to open a docket against
their violent colleague and
clearly told us that they had not witnessed any
violence in the charge
office. To date, no docket has been opened in this
regard,” said Chitaguda.
Continued visits to the police station failed to
yield any positive result.
He said he would not be cowed by anyone into
closing shop, as he believed
that it was every citizen’s right to run a
business as long as it was in
compliance with the law.
Police
officers at the station confirmed the incident, but said their hands
were
tied, since Katandika was a former Border Gezi Youth Trained Zanu (PF)
cadre.
http://www.swradioafrica.com
By Alex Bell
16
August 2012
The Zimbabwe Conservation Task Force (ZCTF) has issued a
public warning that
illegal hunting activities are taking place at a
wildlife ranch in the Save
Valley Conservancy, as the ‘indigenisation’ of
the hunting sector continues.
The Savuli Ranch has been taken over by
female war vet called Shuvai Mahofa
who was illegally granted a 25 year
lease for the property by National
Parks, who are not entitled to issue such
leases.
The High Court of Zimbabwe this year ruled on the illegality of
Mahofa’s
claim, stating that the legal owners of the Ranch, Forever African
Safaris,
should not be interfered with.
This has made no difference
and Mahofa has already evicted the owners and
their employees. A white
farmer who has previously been accused of working
with Mahofa, has now moved
on to the Savuli Ranch and is operating under
Impala Safaris.
The
farmer, Ken Drummond, was earlier this year implicated in a campaign to
intimidate the remaining white farmers in the Chiredzi and Hippo Valley
area. SW Radio Africa reported in January that Drummond had teamed up with a
war vet called Francis Zimuto, who calls himself Black Jesus, in the illegal
takeover of properties there. Zimuto in turn was understood to be working on
Mahofa’s orders.
Mahofa is also one of the recent beneficiaries of a
hunting licence that has
been granted to indigenous ‘farmers’, who include
other top ZANU PF
officials like Masvingo governor Titus Maluleke and
Education Minister Stan
Mudenge.
According to the ZCTF Mahofa has
issued Drummond a hunting quota as part of
her licence, and hunting is
already well under way. Drummond has been
posting pictures of the Savuli
Camp and of several hunting trophies on the
website of Impala Safaris, which
in turn is owned and run by a man called
Arnold Palmer.
“We would
like to inform any prospective clients that Arnold Palmer, Ken
Drummond, and
Impala Safaris are acting completely illegally. This is the
opinion of the
High Court of Zimbabwe set down in their recent judgement.
Sadly, their
judgement has been completely ignored and the wholesale
slaughter of animals
on Savuli continues,” the ZCTF warned.
ZCTF chairman Johnny Rodrigues
told SW Radio Africa on Thursday that the new
hunting licences are merely a
“show of appreciation” to ZANU PF officials
and have nothing to do with the
indiginisation of the hunting or wildlife
sectors.
“If they wanted to
indigenise, then they should give theses licenses to
local people who
already work on the conservancies and know what it is all
about. These
people (the new recipients) know nothing,” Rodrigues said.
He added:
“This is going to destroy tourism and destroy the hunting sector.
There will
be no animals left.”
http://www.tourismupdate.co.za
16 Thu, Aug 2012
Members of the
tourism industry have joined forces to protest the threat of
opencast mining
in Zimbabwe’s Mana Pools National Park with the launch of a
Facebook
Community Page, ‘Save Mana Pools’. In 2010, a similar campaign led
to Protea
Hotels having to abandon its plans to develop a hotel on the banks
of the
Zambezi across from Mana Pools.
Two major mining companies, Habbard
Investments and Geo Associates, have
recently expressed interest in mining
heavy minerals in Mana Pools. They
received a prospecting licence at the end
of last year. According to
industry players, the proposed sand mining could
have a severe impact on the
tourism appeal of Mana Pools as well as on the
riverine vegetation, as it
would involve excavating the river to least 100m
on each side of the bank.
Alan Dryden, spokesman for ‘Save Mana Pools’,
says: “Mana is not for mining.
We have drawn a line in the sand. This
opencast form of mining has been
notoriously destructive in other natural
areas worldwide and, if permitted,
would irreparably scar the World Heritage
Site and destroy the wildlife and
ecological resources that belong to all
indigenous Zimbabweans.” He says
Mana Pools will be worth much more as a
tourism employer and a pristine
wilderness in 20 years than it will be as “a
scarred and ecologically
deserted ruin”.
Besides the imminent mining
threat, there are two tourism developments that
are of concern in Mana
Pools. Construction has already begun on Mana Pools
Safari Camp, which is
allegedly not intended to be a tourism venture but a
private holiday home
consisting of six double chalets and staff quarters to
house no fewer than
24 staff members. The other lodge, Nyamepi Lodge, is
currently undergoing an
Environmental Impact Assessment.
UK Spokesperson for Advancing Tourism To
Africa, John Berry, says mining the
river as well as any further tourism
developments in the area could taint
the pristine image of the area. “Mining
within the World Heritage Site will
eclipse the threat of two over-zealous
tourism developments in Mana. The
international travel trade will receive an
immediate negative message about
Zimbabwe, just as we’re looking forward to
a recovery but, more so, the
developments will have a permanent effect on
Mana’s appeal as a
destination.”
Dorine Reinstein
Tourism Update
http://www.voanews.com/
Sebastian Mhofu
August 16,
2012
HARARE, Zimbabwe — South African President Jacob Zuma is in Mozambique,
where he is expected to brief regional leaders about his failure to make a
breakthrough in Zimbabwe. Power-sharing partners there are deadlocked over
contents of a draft constitution. Zuma, the Southern African Development
Community [SADC] mediator in Zimbabwe, left Harare saying there was some
progress, but sticking points remain.
Zuma held more than five hours
of meetings Wednesday with Zimbabwe President
Robert Mugabe, the leader of
the ruling ZANU-PF party and Prime Minister
Morgan Tsvangirai, the leader of
the Movement for Democratic Change party.
Zuma spoke to reporters
afterwards.
“I think there is progress which has been made. But there are
still some
hitches [obstacles] here and there. But there has been progress
that has
been made by the parties. I will be reporting to SADC as from
tomorrow,”
said Zuma.
Zuma was in neighboring Zimbabwe to monitor
progress on reforms that African
regional leaders expect from the Zimbabwean
leadership in preparation for a
referendum on a new constitution and then
elections.
The first of the reforms that SADC leaders want in Zimbabwe is
a new
constitution. Mugabe’s ZANU-PF party wants a draft constitution
amended.
However, Tsvangirai and Welshman Ncube, leader of a small MDC wing,
are
opposed to Mugabe's proposal to amend the constitution.
Leaving
the meeting, Mugabe dismissed Zuma’s assertions that there were
obstacles,
or what he called “hitches,” regarding the draft constitution.
“I do not
know what hitches there are. We’ve made amendments," said Mugabe.
"I
supposed that is what he [Zuma] is referring to. We are an enlightened
party
and do not just accept things as conclusive.”
Mugabe’s ZANU-PF party
wants a revision of the draft constitution since it
reduces the powers of
the presidency and increases the control of parliament
in Zimbabwean
politics.
If a referendum on a new constitution can be held in Zimbabwe
later this
year, elections are possible in 2013. It remains to be seen what
details of
Wednesday's meetings with Zuma will tell regional leaders meeting
in
Mozambique, and if a path forward is possible.
http://www.swradioafrica.com
By Tererai
Karimakwenda
16 August 2012
The mediator on Zimbabwe’s political
crisis, President Jacob Zuma of South
Africa, has described the current
stalemate over the draft constitution as a
minor hitch after meeting the
coalition leaders in Harare on Wednesday.
The South African President met
separately with Prime Minister Morgan
Tsvangirai, Robert Mugabe and Welshman
Ncube in Harare on Wednesday. He was
briefed on progress in the
Constitutional reform exercise and the GPA, in
preparation for the SADC
summit starting in Maputo, Mozambique on Friday.
Speaking to reporters
after the meetings Zuma said there has been “some
movement forward, although
there are some hitches here and there, but they
are not as major as they
used to be”.
Mugabe, who also addressed journalists, said: “We’ve
considered the draft
and we’ve made amendments to the draft. We’ll meet as
principals to exchange
our ideas.”
This drew strong criticism from
the Crisis Coalition and the MDC formations,
who have already adopted the
draft as the final version to be taken to a
referendum.
MDC-T leader
Morgan Tsvangirai told reporters that some of the disagreements
would be
discussed at the SADC summit on Friday.
MDC-N spokesman Nhlanhla Dube
told SW Radio Africa that their president
Welshman Ncube had briefed
President Zuma on the draft charter and the time
for political negotiations
is over. Dube said the party position is that
Zimbabweans must go to a
second All Stakeholders Conference to decide.
“All the issues were
negotiated with express instructions from the political
parties. The
negotiators consulted their top leadership so there is nothing
new. Enough
concessions have been made and time for negotiations is
finished,” Dube
said.
Regarding the “hitches” President Zuma spoke about, Dube said there
is a
deliberate effort to stall progress on the draft charter by some
factions
within ZANU PF.
Okay Machisa from the Crisis Coalition
agreed and insisted the document does
not belong to ZANU PF. He said
negotiations have been going on for a very
long time and the draft was
agreed on through consultations with all the
political parties.
“It
is shocking that one party would make a u-turn and demand further
amendments
after all the negotiations are done. It is time to let the people
of
Zimbabwe decide and move on,” Machisa told SW Radio Africa.
Regarding
Zuma’s comments that some “hitches” remained, Machisa said: “The
issue of
the constitution should not be described as minor. It is a major
issue for
Zimbabweans. Maybe President Zuma was trying to soften it because
he knows
that SADC will make it mandatory for this document to sail
through.”
The ZANU PF politburo was scheduled to meet for the fifth
time on Thursday
to discuss the constitution.
http://www.swradioafrica.com
By Tererai
Karimakwenda
16 August 2012
Robert Mugabe has insisted that changes
need to be made to the draft
Constitution that was agreed on by the
negotiators last month, drawing
strong criticism from civic society groups
and the MDC formations.
Mugabe made the comments after meeting with the
SADC mediator on the
Zimbabwe political crisis, President Jacob Zuma of
South Africa, who also
met separately with Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai
and MDC-N leader
Welshman Ncube.
Zuma was briefed on progress in the
Constitutional reform exercise and the
Global Political Agreement (GPA).
This is in preparation for the report he
is to present to regional leaders
at the SADC summit starting in Maputo,
Mozambique on Friday.
Speaking
to reporters after the meetings, Zuma said there has been “some
movement
forward, although there are some hitches here and there, but they
are not as
major as they used to be”.
Mugabe, who also addressed journalists, said:
“We’ve considered the draft
and we’ve made amendments to the draft. We’ll
meet as principals to exchange
our ideas.”
This drew strong criticism
from the Crisis Coalition and the MDC formations,
who have already adopted
the draft as the final version to be taken to a
referendum. MDC-T leader
Morgan Tsvangirai told reporters that some of the
disagreements would be
discussed at the SADC summit on Friday.
MDC-N spokesman Nhlanhla Dube
told SW Radio Africa that their president
Welshman Ncube had briefed
President Zuma on the draft charter and the time
for political negotiations
is over. Dube said the party position is that
Zimbabweans must go to a
second All Stakeholders Conference to decide.
“All the issues were
negotiated with express instructions from the political
parties. The
negotiators consulted their top leadership so there is nothing
new. Enough
concessions have been made and time for negotiations is
finished,” Dube
said.
Regarding the “hitches” President Zuma spoke about, Dube said there
is a
deliberate effort to stall progress on the draft charter by some
factions
within ZANU PF, so they can continue to sort out their internal
factional
disputes.
Okay Machisa from the Crisis Coalition agreed and
insisted the document does
not belong to ZANU PF. He said negotiations have
been going on for a very
long time and the draft was agreed on through
consultations with all the
political parties.
“It is shocking that
one party would make a u-turn and demand further
amendments after all the
negotiations are done. It is time to let the people
of Zimbabwe decide and
move on,” Machisa told SW Radio Africa.
Regarding Zuma’s comments that
some “hitches” remained, Machisa said: “The
issue of the constitution should
not be described as minor. It is a major
issue for Zimbabweans. Maybe
President Zuma was trying to soften it because
he knows that SADC will make
it mandatory for this document to sail
through.”
The ZANU PF
politburo is scheduled to meet for the fifth time on Thursday,
as the party
tries to adopt a final version of the Constitution to present
for further
negotiations.
http://www.swradioafrica.com
By Alex
Bell
16 August 2012
The MDC-T is facing criticism for appearing to try
and ‘mislead’ the public
over the controversial draft constitution, with the
party being urged to
explain its agenda.
Former commercial farmer Ben
Freeth said recent comments by the party’s
spokesman Douglas Mwonzora, about
the land clauses in the draft charter, are
a reason to
worry.
Mwonzora told SW Radio Africa’s Question Time programme on
Wednesday that
there was no reason to be concerned about the land clauses,
which appear to
legalise the state theft of land. He was responding to
questions sent in by
Freeth about section 4.29 of the draft, with Freeth
raising concern that the
section does not protect the rights of farmers and
farm workers and allows
theft to take place.
Mwonzora responded by
insisting that section 4.29 “provides for acquisition
of land, land that has
been acquired and it says in respect of land that has
been acquired, then
compensation shall be for improvement only if it is land
taken for redress
of colonial imbalances. This is land that has already been
acquired, not
land subject to being acquired. This is land already acquired.
So section
4.29 deals with acquisitions that have already happened.”
He also
insisted that the discrimination clause, controversially written
into the
draft, was only based on these previously acquired properties that
were
seized “to redress colonial imbalances.” He said that this does not
apply to
the present situation where the property rights of all Zimbabweans
are
‘secure’.
But, as Freeth pointed out, the actual text of the draft tells
a very
different story to what Mwonzora has been insisting. Section 4.29 of
the
draft document clearly enshrines the right of the state to seize land,
while
also guaranteeing land invaders the right to the properties they
seize.
The draft states that all agricultural land, including forestry
land,
conservation land and horticultural land, among others, “may be
acquired by
the State by notice published in the Gazette…whereupon the land
vests in the
State with full title.” The draft clearly says that these
future takeovers,
when done for “public purpose” will be done without
compensation and
compensation issues cannot be challenged in the courts. The
draft also
stipulates that legal challenges to the future state takeover of
land may
not be on the ground that it was “discriminatory.”
Freeth
told SW Radio Africa that 4.29 is clearly not limited to the past
acquisitions of land and clearly provides for the future and legal takeover
of land by the state.
“I am frankly very confused by Douglas’s
response. He is being very
misleading and you have to ask what the agenda is
here?” Ben said.
Mwonzora was not available for comment on Thursday but
he will be returning
as a guest on Question Time next week.
http://www.thezimbabwean.co.uk
President Robert Mugabe on Wednesday denied poll rigging,
as Prime Morgan
Tsvangirai hoped for a legitimate national
census.
16.08.1207:43am
by Edgar Gweshe
Launching the
fourth decennial census in Harare, Mugabe dismissed
accusations of vote
rigging by his party, Zanu (PF), in the past, saying
ballot theft happened
in ‘‘some African countries’’.
In his speech, Mugabe admitted that there
was a possibility that some unruly
elements would want to tamper with the
census figures as is done in election
time when ballot boxes disappear in
some African states but distanced
Zimbabwe from the practice.
Mugabe
has been accused of rigging elections since the early years of
independence,
using the national intelligence agency and a partisan
electoral
body.
In 2008, he withheld general election results for almost a month in
a move
that observers said was intended to doctor the outcome.
Even
though Tsvangirai beat him, the results showed that he did not obtain
enough
ballots to form a government on his own, prompting a bloody runoff
from
which the MDC-T leader withdrew in protest.
Mugabe blamed ethnic and
religious differences in other African countries
for irregularities and
violence during election and census times.
"There are countries even in
Africa where censuses are impossible to conduct
because of ethnic divisions
in them, religious divisions in them and midway
as the censuses are
conducted, boxes start missing just as they go missing
when they start
voting.
‘‘People actually carry them away. But what for? We don't want
that. We want
honest, objective facts, the data that will help us," he said,
referring to
the census.
Tsvangirai also spoke at the launch and
hoped that the census would be
carried out in a manner that promoted
legitimacy.
He alluded to recent interruptions of the training of census
enumerators by
the military, saying the population stocktaking process had
always been a
civilian preserve.
‘‘Conducting the national census has
always been a civilian exercise and it
is my sincere hope that we will have
a legitimate census that will give us
credible results to enable national
visioning and planning,’’ said
Tsvangirai.
Both Mugabe and Tsvangirai
called for transparency and accuracy during the
census.
http://www.voazimbabwe.com
Blessing Zulu
16.08.2012
The
southern african development community troika on peace, defence and
security
is scheduled to meet in maputo, mozambique today to dicuss the
political
situation in zimbabwe and other regional hot spots ahead of the
summit that
starts friday.
south african president jacob zuma, the outgoing chairman
of the troika, is
expected to table a report on zimbabwe.
The same
report will be tabled before the 15 regional leaders meeting in
summit
tomorrow.president robert mugabe, prime minister morgan tsvangirai
and
industry minister welshman ncube of the smaller formation of the mdc
backed
by their negotiators are expected to attend the troika meeting.
Sources
privy to the zuma report say he will note progress in the passing of
the
electoral and human rights bills, but will also highlight the latest
political logjam - the draft constitution.
Mr. Zuma who was in harare
yesterday spent the better part of his
consultation trying to find common
ground on the constitution.human rights
watch urged sadc to press zimbabwe
in addressing key human rights issues,
including security sector reform,
accountability for past abuses, and
deterring politically motivated violence
and other human rights abuses.
An aide to mr. Zuma, lindiwe zulu, says
they are already in maputo for the
key summit.
http://www.swradioafrica.com
By Alex
Bell
16 August 2012
A two day protest organised by residents in
Chiweshe turned violent on
Thursday, with protesters overturning a car and
forcing a group of officials
from the Salvation Army to flee.
The
Salvation Army officials had arrived at Howard Hospital to serve a fresh
eviction notice to the chief doctor there. Chiweshe residents have been left
raging by the attempts to evict Dr. Paul Thistle, who has been caught up in
a worsening situation with the Salvation Army administrators.
The
public protests on Thursday turned ugly when residents overturned the
car
the Salvation Army officials from Harare had arrived in. The group was
then
forced to flee the angry locals and seek refuge in the hospital.
Dr.
Thistle, who has been unable to go to the hospital, has been at home
while
the facility runs on a skeleton staff that does not include another
doctor.
SW Radio Africa’s correspondent Simon Muchemwa said the hospital was
temporarily closed on Thursday morning while all emergency cases are being
transferred to Harare.
Muchemwa explained that the local residents
have been left “very angry”
because Dr. Thistle is now their only doctor,
and he is also a very
respected and loved part of the community. Dr. Thistle
is a Canadian doctor
who has spent more than sixteen years helping
Zimbabweans, and has worked
tirelessly in sourcing and providing the best
care for the local people.
But according to Muchemwa, he has now run
afoul of the Salvation Army after
raising concerns that supplies and money
he had sourced for the hospital
never made it to the institution from the
Head Office. Muchemwa explained
that the officials are now intent on
evicting the doctor and transferring
him to ministerial duties somewhere
else.
SW Radio Africa meanwhile has been told that the orders have been
handed
down by Vice President Joice Mujuru, who is a senior member of the
Salvation
Army, and that Dr. Thistle is caught in the middle of the
worsening
infighting in ZANU PF.
Mujuru and her main rival Emmerson
Mnangagwa have intensified their war for
the potential leadership of ZANU
PF, a war that came to a head last month
when the grassroots District
Coordinating Committees (DCC) of the party were
disbanded. This followed a
highly contest DCC election that appeared to show
Mnangagwa as a
favourite.
It’s understood that Chiweshe is one of the areas where
Mnangagwa has
support and the local chief is said to be a Mnangagwa man.
Speculation is
now rife that Mujuru is attempting to control the area by
exerting her
authority on the Howard Hospital.
http://www.voazimbabwe.com
Marvellous
Mhlanga-Nyahuye
15.08.2012
A high powered eight-member delegation of
local Government officials from
Zimbabwe is in the United States on a
two-week fact-finding mission on
running local authorities.
The group
- comprising local authorities Association President Nimrod
Chiminya,
Bulawayo Mayor Thaba Patrick Moyo, Masvingo Mayor Femius
Chakabuda, the
Harare town clerk and high ranking officials from other
councils - are in
Washington at the invitation of the United States' State
Department.
The delegation met with State Department officials in
Washington DC Tuesday
and later held discussions on investment opportunities
in Zimbabwe with
members of the Zimbabwe diaspora in the US
capital.
The delegation is expected to visit Chicago, Missouri and
Baltimore.
Meanwhile, the group Wednesday visited the City of Baltimore.
Nancy Hafford
Executive Director of the Baltimore-based Towson Chamber of
Commerce said
she hopes the Zimbabwean delegation will learn a lot about how
her city
conducts its activities.
"We hope that they will learn about
how we have successfully run some
programs that have been financially
rewarding for our chamber," said
Hafford.
She told VOA Studio7 this
was the first African state that had visited her
city and she was excited to
host Zimbabwe.
http://www.thezimbabwean.co.uk
Several years ago Zimbabwe not only produced enough
maize to feed its people
but also had surpluses to export. More recently
Zimbabwe’s food security
position is governed by its inability to attain
self-sufficiency in maize
production and this position is now set to get
worse. Output in 2012 is less
than half of domestic consumption, and
substantial imports will be necessary
to meet the production
deficit.
16.08.1203:01pm
by Charles Taffs
These imports
will have to be undertaken when the world grain markets are
undersupplied.
The main commodities affected are maize, wheat, and
soyabeans. Droughts have
struck food producing regions in all the
continents. Of special significance
to Zimbabwe are world maize production
and trade developments because this
commodity is our staple food commodity.
In the United States maize crops
continue to wilt in the corn belt of the
mid-West because of dry conditions
and unusually high temperatures and this
position is forecast to extend into
the autumn. As a result U.S. maize
exports for the 2012/13 marketing season
are projected to fall by more than
8 million tonnes. This will seriously
impact on its main customers in the
Far East and elsewhere. Already
unsettled overseas financial markets and
shortages are driving up world
maize prices. Zimbabwe cannot secure all of
maize imports within southern
Africa and will be forced to compete for
scarce and expensive maize
elsewhere.
GMO maize is produced in South Africa so that market cannot be
tapped as GMO
maize is prohibited for human consumption in Zimbabwe. Two
other regional
countries, Zambia and Malawi, have surpluses of non-GMO maize
available for
export but the limited quantities available will not be enough
to satisfy
Zimbabwe’s requirements. In any event Zimbabwe will be in
competition with
other importing countries in the region. Thus Zimbabwe
needs to act
expeditiously to secure maize supplies from both regional and
world markets.
Looking into the future, prospects for Zimbabwe’s maize
production in the
coming season and beyond are not good. This situation
stems from funding
difficulties arising from illiquid money markets and
looming input supply
problems. Farmers are faced not only with scarce and
costly inputs but also
have a great difficulty in raising loans in a hostile
financial environment
where competition is stiff for limited funding
resources. Credit is scarce
and interest rates prohibitively
high.
Regarding inputs seed companies and fertilizer manufacturing
companies are
also owed tens of millions of dollars by debtors for purchases
of seed and
fertilizers.
Production of maize seed this year, at
27,170 tonnes, was below the national
requirement of around 36,000 tonnes.
Seed companies have not paid many
growers who were contracted to grow seed
for them because of the outstanding
debts owed to them. As a result many
small scale maize seed growers cut
their losses and on-sold or consumed the
seed as grain.
Carryover stocks this year will fortunately plug the
supply gap and negate
the need to import seed for the coming maize growing
season. On the down
side, however, the non-payment of seed growers is likely
to reduce plantings
in the coming season with farmers switching to other
crops where payments
for product are more certain. This will undoubtedly
increase Zimbabwe’s
dependency on imports of a major input which
traditionally domestic output
has always met demand with sizeable surpluses
being exported.
The local fertilizer industry is also in a precarious
position. Procuring
working capital and a substantial level of unpaid debts
have prevented
manufacturers from importing potash and other required
ingredients. Stocks
at the end of June were very low at 29,000 tonnes. The
production capacity
of the industry will not be able to meet the combined
national requirements
for growing maize of 370,000 tonnes for both Compound
“D” and Ammonium
Nitrate by December. Thus there will be a need to import
substantial
quantities of fertilizers to make up shortfalls. Farmers will
have to bear
the higher costs of imported fertilizers.
Unless the
Zimbabwe Government immediately puts in place policies that boost
maize
production the country may well face starvation. The Commercial
Farmers’
Union stands ready to assist in formulating such policies and
contributing
to food production.
http://www.voazimbabwe.com
15.08.2012
Zimbabwe’s first privately owned commercial
radio station, Zi-FM Stereo,
officially hit the airwaves Wednesday,
promising to fill a void in the
country’s media entertainment and news
arena.
Zi-FM Stereo owner, former ZBC broadcaster Supa Mandiwanzira of AB
Communications, said the station will be geared towards dishing out various
music genres and relevant news and will changeZimbabwe's media
landscape.
"Our radio is going to be driven by our audiences, it's going
to be highly
interactive we are going to make sure what the people want to
hear and
listen to is what we will play, in terms of music and in terms of
discussions we will focus on the issues that are topical and relevent to the
people of Zimbabwe," said Mandiwanzira.
Zi-FM will be
broadcasting in Harare, Bulawayo, Mutare, Nyanga, Beitbridge,
among
areas.
Another commercial station, Star FM Radio, owned by Zimbabwe
Newspapers
Group was launched last month after being awarded a broadcasting
license by
the Broadcasting Authority of Zimbabwe.
The licensing of
the two broadcasters last year, ahead of other applicants,
sparked demands
for the dissolution of the licensing authority which was
accused of favoring
those linked to the former ruling party, Zanu PF.
When pressed to comment
on the controversy surrounding the awarding of a
commercial licence to ZiFM
and its political links, Mandiwanzira said
content would be largely
determined by the market.
"No media institute is not politically aligned
... We are very glad that
Zi-FM is politically aligned to the government of
Zimbabwe which is the one
that has licensed us," he said.
http://www.swradioafrica.com
By Tererai
Karimakwenda
16 August 2012
Residents in thirteen villages in the
Mudzi North constituency are being
forced to pay money to support the
families of ZANU PF thugs accused of
murdering Cephas Magura, who was the
MDC-T Ward One chairman in the area.
SW Radio Africa correspondent Lionel
Saungweme spoke to villagers from
Chimukoko and Nyamhondoro districts of
Mudzi North, who said the campaign
is being coordinated by ZANU-PF MP Newton
Kachepa and Chief Otelia
Chimukoko.
“ZANU PF people are going around
13 villages and forcing people to pay 50
cents per family towards the upkeep
of Sekuru Magura’s murderers, who are
still incarcerated pending their
trial,” Saungweme explained.
He added that some villagers are paying the
money every week and others are
being visited fortnightly.
MDC-T
activist Cephas Magura died in May after a ZANU PF mob directed by MP
Kachepa attacked MDC-T activists who had gathered for a rally at Chimukoko
Business Centre. Several others were seriously injured.
This is not
the first time villagers in Mudzi North have been forced to
assist the
accused ZANU PF members. Last month Saungweme reported that Chief
Chimukoko
had collected funds to pay lawyers representing the accused,
during their
bail application.
Villagers have named some of the ZANU PF thugs who are
collecting the money
on behalf of the chief and MP. Our correspondent said
the list includes
Bhobho, Bhana (Barnabus), Chirova, Kangora and
Simenti.
Mudzi North is in Mashonaland East where Saungweme said several
army bases
were established back in 2008. He said residents there live in
fear and
experience heavy intimidation from ZANU PF officials, activists and
traditional leaders.
http://www.newzimbabwe.com/
15/08/2012 00:00:00
by Phyllis
Mbanje
ZIFA chief executive Jonathan Mashingaidze has told how he
suffered a
“harrowing experience” at the hands of an alleged CIO operative
who tried to
extort US$10,000 from him earlier this
year.
Mashingaidze was testifying in the trial of alleged CIO officer
Richard
Mubaiwa, 31, and Banket farmer John Chari, 32, which opened
Wednesday before
Harare magistrate Tendai Mahwe.
The ZIFA boss said
his nightmare started on the evening of February 21 when
the pair and
several others still to be identified lured him to a secluded
place in
Harare, threatened him with death and later hounded him with
numerous phone
calls.
The court heard that Mubaiwa called Mashingaidze and identified
himself as
'Ruhanga from the President’s Office'.
The CIO operative
requested that they meet at Chikwanha Shopping Centre,
claiming to be in
possession of a file that had serious implications for
Mashingaidze. The
caller said he was also looking into the ZIFA boss'
political background and
suspected connections with the MDC-T party.
Mashingaidze hired a taxi and
proceeded to the shopping centre where he met
by Chari and four other
accomplices.
Chari told him he was from the President’s Office and asked that
they go to
a secluded place behind the shopping centre. A second man was
with them.
"He (Chari) claimed that six of his principals had asked him
to convey
information pertaining to photographs showing FIFA president Sepp
Blatter,
ZIFA president Cuthbert Dube, Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai and
myself,”
Mashingaidze said, adding that the said photograph had been taken
during
FIFA president’s visit to Zimbabwe.
"He also said my life was
in danger due to my involvement in the Asiagate
investigations. Chari then
said their principals had ordered that I should
be eliminated but my life
could be spared if I paid them $10,000 for
protection.
"I then asked
when I was supposed to pay the money and Chari said by 8AM the
next morning.
He said a file had been opened on me and checks were being
made on my
political affiliations.
"When I told them it was not possible to raise
that amount of money between
9PM and 8AM, Chari said the choice was mine to
raise the money or lose my
life."
Chari allegedly asked if
Mashingadze had any money on him and the ZIFA CEO
handed over
$20.
After breaking the meeting, Mashingaidze later phoned the
ZIFA president and
treasurer, Rtd Brigadier General Eliot Kasu, and told
them about the
abduction and extortion bid.
The next day, Chari phoned
Mashingaidze and told him to bring the money to
Avondale but later changed
the venue to Kensington.
Mashingaidze was given $2,000 by the ZIFA
president and a trap was set up
with the help of the police.
The ZIFA
CEO then proceeded to Kensington where he met Chari in a Spar shop
and
handed him the money in a brown envelope.
As Chari left the shop, he was
confronted by plain clothes police officers
who searched him and recovered
the money. He later implicated Mubaiwa during
questioning.
The trial
continues and prosecutors have lined up eight witnesses to
testify.
http://af.reuters.com
Thu Aug 16, 2012 4:11pm
GMT
By Cris Chinaka
CHINHOYI, Zimbabwe Aug 16 (Reuters) -
According to the official figures,
Zimbabwe's economy is booming. The agony
etched on the faces of those in the
auction rooms in Chinhoyi, watching
helplessly as prized possessions go for
a song, tells a very different
story.
Zimbabweans from all walks of life are drowning in debt after the
implosion
of a three-year credit bubble. High-rollers are losing mansions
and
limousines; ordinary people chickens and pots and pans.
The only
ones doing well are the auctioneers holding the sales and the
newspapers
advertising them.
As well as hammering some of the southern African
country's biggest firms,
the crisis is threatening the stability of its
banks and piling more pain on
a population of 13 million traumatised by a
decade of drastic economic
decline up to 2008.
"It has been a real
nightmare," said Milton, a victim of the burst bubble
standing at the back
of an auction in Chinhoyi, a farming town 130 km (80
miles) northwest of
Harare.
Instead of fulfilling his ambitions of owning and running a car
workshop, he
is watching nervously as his bed, a six-piece lounge suite,
refrigerator and
stove go under the hammer to try to repay a $1,500 bank
loan.
"First, I lost my car over a loan that I used to start this
business, and
now this. I have to start afresh," he said, with a
sigh.
When President Robert Mugabe, one of Africa's longest serving
leaders,
formed a unity government with rival Morgan Tsvangirai after
disputed
elections in 2008, Milton and thousands of others hoped the former
British
colony and its once-vibrant economy had turned the
corner.
That belief took root when the new administration quickly
scrapped the
worthless Zimbabwe dollar in favour of the U.S. dollar and
South African
rand, ending multi-billion percent hyperinflation at a
stroke.
Three years later, the court-auction advertisements filling
newspapers
suggest the hopes were premature.
"It's painful but I have
to be here to see if the goods they have taken will
be able to cover the
debt," said Milton, who would only give his first name.
"Otherwise they come
for more stuff."
LENDING FRENZY
With the relative political
stability of a unity government and the monetary
stability of dollars and
rand, many banks went on a lending spree in 2009,
taking title deeds on
homes and ownership documents for cars as security.
Interest rates ranged
from 15 to 50 percent but businesses from second-hand
clothes stalls in
townships to village grocery stores lapped up loans to
restock after the
lean years.
"There was a frenzy," said Brains Muchemwa, a private
economic consultant.
"And it has been one huge disaster, both for the
borrowers and the lenders,
with big losses for individuals, families, banks
and businesses."
Over the past year, two banks have collapsed and two
others have slid into
administration under a mountain of bad
debts.
Worse could be in store, with the central bank saying that loans
to
individuals for consumption more than doubled from 8.6 percent of all
loans
in June last year to 18 percent by June 2012 - against the backdrop of
an
economy in trouble.
In his mid-year budget statement last month,
Finance Minister Tendai Biti
slashed his 2012 growth forecast to 5.6 percent
from 9.4 percent, a cut that
took few Zimbabweans by surprise given the
widespread belief the government
has been over-egging the figures to lure
outside investors.
GROWTH SLUMPS
The tough times can be seen in
the growing numbers of people eking out a
living as street vendors, and in
the boom of court-appointed auctions.
Even the central bank has been
clobbered, with outstanding debts of $1.4
billion to individuals, companies
and government institutions - the legacy
of a system in which a business and
political elite with close links to
Mugabe's ZANU-PF party borrowed money
cheaply from the bank and never paid
it back, even if they
could.
Overall, eight out of 10 adult Zimbabweans are jobless in an
economy that
shrank by almost half in a decade of recession blamed on the
disastrous
economic policies of Mugabe, who has been in charge since
independence in
1980.
Hampering the push from investment is a drive
by Mugabe to force foreign
mining companies and banks to surrender at least
51 percent shares to black
Zimbabweans.
Fears of violence during
elections due within the next year have also
unsettled investors given the
trouble that has marred polls since 2000, the
year after Tsvangirai's
Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) emerged to
challenge Mugabe.
The
court auctions have already sucked in the headquarters of Zimbabwe's
largest
pharmaceutical company to clear debts of $4 million, and two houses
belonging to the directors of Merspin, one of its oldest and biggest textile
firms.
Tourism Minister Walter Mzembi from ZANU-PF and his wife
Mercedes stand to
lose a house to the state-owned POSB Bank over an unpaid
$129,000 loan,
according to the state-controlled Herald newspaper.
In
the countryside, the auctions are often held in the grounds of police
stations and lots range from cows and black and white TV sets to crates of
empty beer and Coca-Cola bottles.
"At first, I tried hard and I was
paying half the monthly instalment but
after four months, I stopped
completely and that's how I ended up here,"
said John Moyo, who borrowed
$10,000 two years ago to start up a
furniture-making business.
Unable
to make the $1,000 monthly repayments, he had to forfeit his trusty
Mazda
truck, which sold for $2,000, a quarter of its value.
"I am sunk," he
told Reuters. "Many other people are sinking too."
"THIEVES IN DESIGNER
SUITS"
Most auctions have a funereal air, with sellers shuffling in
quietly, alone
or in pairs. Pictures of houses on sale are pinned on walls
around the hall.
However, sharp-suited businessmen and women will
typically occupy the front
two rows, knowing they are picking up houses or
cars for a fraction of their
market value.
Few are prepared to talk
to reporters, feeding the perception of a predatory
business and political
elite sucking the economy dry.
Biti, a senior figure in Tsvangirai's MDC,
has accused top officials from
Mugabe's ZANU-PF, which controls the mining
ministry, of stealing millions
of dollars in diamond revenues for themselves
or party election coffers.
"What we have now are people getting filthy
rich on resources that should be
going into national development while the
ordinary citizens of this country
are sinking deeper into poverty," he said
at a recent news conference.
"The facts are evident all around us. It is
obscene."
ZANU-PF dismisses Biti's charges as cheap politicking, but the
public
mistrust of those with cash to splash runs deep.
In an
editorial, the Zimbabwe Independent, a private weekly, urged the
government
to tackle what it called "theft by those in designer suits".
"Authorities
must stop this systematic economic sabotage and halt dead in
their tracks
these thieves in imported designer suits," it said.
http://www.thezimbabwean.co.uk/
Not every child in Zimbabwe
suffering from stress has had a family member
jailed or murdered, although
there are those instances right across the
social and racial spectrum. There
are also the everyday examples of living -
and growing up - in an
environment with an unusually high level of stress,
and with parents whose
exposure to, and efforts to deal with uncertainty,
rubs off on their
children.
14.08.1204:06pm
by Sokwanele
Tomorrow’s leaders:
What do they have to look forward to?. Tomorrow’s
leaders: What do they
have to look forward to?.
Thandiwe, a mother of two, remembers the era of
food shortages and how it
affected her children, at the time aged four and
seven.
“I still see this anxiety, related to food, in my children,” she
said.
“There’s definitely an element of gluttony - eating even when they
aren’t
hungry - just because they can. It’s two years on, and I’m certainly
seeing
early signs of weight problems in my nine-year old daughter,
something
no-one in the family has ever suffered from before.”
The
effects of stress on the young are, however, most pointedly felt at
school.
When the top stream of a local school started their high school
career in
2004, there were 32 students in the class. When they graduated six
years
later, in 2010, they had lost almost half that number.
The more subtle
results are even more widespread...and more alarming. Among
them are
increased disciplinary and learning problems, as well as an
increase in the
number of students who are not only living alone but, in
many cases, running
a household of younger siblings.
“The situation forced many people to
seek work outside the country, merely
to survive, leaving their children
here to continue their schooling,” said a
remedial teacher at another high
school.
“We’re seeing the result of this every day in the school:
children living
without reliable adult supervision, or any supervision at
all, responsible
for their own meals and transport and, in many cases, with
little or no
guidance in terms of responsibility, moral values and
discipline,” she said.
She remembers the instance of a 15-year-old boy
who kept falling asleep in
class. When she questioned him about his lack of
energy, she discovered that
he was living alone as both his parents were
working in South Africa.
He had to find his own transport home, a
distance of about 15km, at the end
of a long day of school and sports, and
then, when he reached home, would
often have to wait for the electricity to
come back after load shedding,
sometimes as late as 10pm, to start cooking
himself a meal.
“Sometimes, if his parents were late sending money, he
would have to walk
home. He was just perpetually exhausted, and not coping
at all,” she said.
The number of children being referred for remedial
lessons is increasing
every year, and in many of the instances, the students
are found to be
capable, but unable to apply themselves.
“They’re
showing more signs of violence and aggression than I’ve seen in my
six years
of teaching at the school. Some exhibit fear and insecurity which
can only
be put down to neglect and lack of adult guidance and supervision,”
said the
remedial teacher.
A local psychologist who specialises in child and
family counselling
confirms that stress is playing a large role in shaping
Zimbabwe’s young.
“What is of concern is that these effects will not be
short-term. We are in
for a long run, which is worrying because these are
the adults of tomorrow,
who will one day be running the country,” she
said.
One of the most notable stress factors facing youth is pessimism
about the
future, resulting in a generation lacking in direction and
ambition.
She said even if a child was fortunate enough to leave school
with good O
and A Levels, the opportunities for tertiary education and
career
development were still severely limited.
“What do they have to
look forward to? They ask themselves this question
and, when they realise
the answer is very little. So they give up, choosing
to fill their lives,
instead, with drugs, alcohol and vandalism,” she said.
The counsellor was
quick to caution against labelling the pressures on
Zimbabwean youth as Post
Traumatic Stress Disorder, saying this was
over-used and over-rated, saying:
“PTSD is a very real condition for people
who have experienced a particular
incident that has been life-changing
and/or life-threatening, the result of
which would be a number of
conditions, from flashbacks to sleep
disorders.”
The lack of parental supervision coupled with the easier
access to the
internet, was also leading to an increase in the viewing of
pornography, it
being the belief that in Zimbabwe today there is porn in
some form in many
households.
A resultant effect is an early onset of
sexual awareness, leading to
children as young as six or seven engaging in
activities of a sexual nature
and, in the worst case scenario, being raped
or sexually abused.
The high level of sexual abuse in the country has led
to units being
established at major hospitals solely to deal with the
victims and offer
counselling and support, while there is an increase in
children as young as
two years old who have been raped and
abused.
“You get a nicely-spoken 13-year-old boy referred to you for
counselling,
and you ask him why he raped the neighbour’s three year old
child and he
tells you, I saw people having sex on the computer and wanted
to see what it
was like,” said the counsellor.
Counselling centres
are also seeing an increase in the number of school
referrals, students who
have exhibited violent or aggressive tendencies,
shown lack of respect for
others and their property, and have been abusing
drugs and alcohol.
A
reaction to this has been an initiative in some schools to form clubs
which
encourage children and youth to speak out about the issues that
concern
them. One of the greatest concerns voiced among the youth who attend
these
clubs is how to reshape what looks like a dismal future, and they
believe
the only way to do this is to make money. Having experienced the era
of
hyper-inflation, where “wheeling and dealing” became, often out of
necessity, the norm in order to survive, they have grown up knowing little
else.
“No-one is interested in an education or a career anymore, the
lesson they
have learnt from watching society around them is that the only
way out is by
making a lot of money,” the counsellor said.
August 16th, 2012
Growing up in Chitungwiza was one of the best things that ever happened to me. This bustling town on the outskirts of Harare acts as a dormitory town for the city’s blue collar workers.
I liked going to school, playing plastic ball with friends and even those days when we went to watch wrestling next door because we did not have a television set in our two roomed house. A family of six, we squeezed in our warm home and it never bothered me that I slept on the floor while people would walk over my snoring body.
These are sweet memories of a home that we once had and shared, mother, father and children.
It was in the 90s, a time so long ago when the family unity was still intact, uncorrupted by the progress of time.
Age meant that we parted ways, my parents died and then my siblings, one by one got married, the family grew for better or worse.
Economic hardship came and cousins began the great trek down south to South Africa.
At first we used to communicate but that is now all gone.
It is the death of the family unity.
I do not know the number of relatives who have died from HIV infection but there are many, and their deaths are often shrouded in secrecy because the disease is still stigmatised here as in the rest of Africa and even beyond.
Family unity is disappearing from the social radar but still we remain Zimbabweans eager to forge ahead.
I sometimes wonder if my mother, who passed away in 1999, was to return now whether she would be able to live in today Zimbabwe. A country so called that fathers are raping their own children in order to be cured of HIV infection, a nation so polarised along political lines that it needs to be divided into two.
The spirit of community is long gone and there is no way a person can drop in and watch television in my room as of days of yore.
Indeed things change and certainly if my mother was to return she would fail to find the innocence that defined us long ago when corruption was a topic frowned upon, but today it is the order of the day. The police officers who we trusted are now the most corrupt.
My mother would not fit in today’s Zimbabwe where innocence, love and oneness has been overtaken greed, selfishness and political aggrandizement.
When I was a student at Gwebi Agricultural College
in the early 60’s we
often visited farms to see firsthand what they were
doing to improve
production or manage harsh resources. We soon learned that
you could tell
what sort of farmer we were going to meet by two yardsticks –
what was the
condition of the farm fences and what sort of dogs greeted us
at the
homestead.
The first measure told us about the farmers technical
and farming abilities
in that we never found an outstanding farmer in any
field who did not have
neat, well maintained fences. Farmers with good human
resource skills always
had friendly dogs. Overall this really summed up the
farmers abilities and
potential for success.
Today, there is no more
telling indicator of failure of agricultural
policies and practices than our
fences – there are none, and where they do
exist they are untidy,
ineffective and often in a state of collapse. They
reveal many things – the
absence of any real sense of ownership or pride,
the lack of security, the
absence of any idea of what fences mean in terms
of management and control.
Where those occupying the farms do erect fences
they are seldom tidy or
effective. That too says a great deal about the
farmer.
Just what
happens to the fences? Commercial farmers occupied about 10
million hectares
of land in Zimbabwe in 2000, they had carefully fenced
every farm – not just
boundaries but also internal paddocks and lands. In
many cases there were
fences designed for game as well as cattle and small
stock, fences two
metres high, straining posts set in concrete and steel,
gates and cattle
grids. They are all gone, they vanish over time and you
seldom see any sign
of what they do with the wire and poles.
Friends of ours who farmed 25
000 hectares of semi arid land in region 5 or
6 in the south of the country
are a useful example. He was once the top
breeder of Brahman cattle in the
country and ran the cattle in conjunction
with wild life. He had fenced the
property with two metre high game fence,
cattle grids at the main crossing
points and gates elsewhere, 8 boreholes
and many kilometers of pipelines to
feed water toughs. This is very dry
country and the soils poor in most case.
No surface water.
Sam had learned over the years that you had to rotate
your cattle and he
basically rotated the cattle so that at any one time he
was able to rest
half the farm in the wet season so that the grass could
make maximum use of
the rains when they fell. Over 100 years they maintained
rainfall records
and the average never varied significantly over 300 mls per
annum. However
in that period they had serious drought every 3 or 4 years –
in some years
no rain fell at all. In this hard, unforgiving climate, they
made a living
and when times were good were able to put in development. To
do this
eventually he had 3 800 kilometers of wire in his
fences.
Under this management system the grass cover on the farm
gradually improved,
different species became established and the overall
carrying capacity
improved until he had an estimated 2200 wild animals on
the property and
slightly more cattle. Sam was Afrikaans in background but
he and his wife
chose to leave South Africa because of its racial policies
and come to this
country. Here he learned the local language, Venda, which
he speaks
fluently; he always tried to maintain good relations with the
local
community and the local chiefs.
They were invaded 8 years ago,
the State moving people onto the property and
providing them with food and
other support. Today the property is semi
desert, I doubt if you could find
enough grass on the entire 25 000 hectares
to fill a bag. The majority of
the “settlers” have abandoned the property
because it cannot support their
livestock. The only borehole still working
is at the homestead where Sam
lives with his wife. There is not a metre of
fencing left on the entire
property. A handful of Zebra and Impala remain,
the Eland are all gone along
with the Giraffe and Wildebeest.
Last year he was forced to sell the last of
his beloved Brahmans and they
now have no cattle for the first time in their
lives. 50 years of breeding
and selection have been lost, genetics that will
take many years to recover
when and if production can be resumed.
But
that is only the final effect of this tragic story, the reality for us
as a
country is the loss of investment, genetic capital, employment and
income
generation on a sustainable basis and now just another extension to
what is
rapidly becoming desert.
Many would argue that the desertification of
these areas is due to “Global
Warming” but of this there is no evidence at
all. A careful study of the
meticulous records on this farm over 100 years
shows that there is no
discernable change in rainfall – either in
distribution or volume. The sole
change in the past decade is the removal of
ownership rights through a
destructive and illegal land grab and the
subsequent deliberate destruction
of the management infrastructure essential
to land management in this
marginal rainfall area.
In every area of
the world where land ownership is vested in community
structures and not in
individual title with long term security, land use and
production is
unsustainable and destructive. Communal agriculture is only
sustainable at
subsistence level in conditions where the availability of
virgin land is
open and unrestricted. As the land is exploited in these
conditions its
productive capacity declines and the people simply destroy
their homes and
move to new areas and start again. Over time the areas used
recover and can
eventually be reoccupied in 20 or 30 years time.
In semi arid areas,
especially in the sensitive savannah bushveld of Africa,
the most immediate
impact of growing populations has been to replace nomadic
land use patterns
with fixed abode and this is invariably associated with
land degradation and
in extreme cases, desertification. When deserts form
they are almost
impossible to rehabilitate. That is why the Kalahari desert
is growing at a
kilometer a year, that is why the Savannah of the Sahael has
disappeared and
been replaced with desert sand dunes.
Africa cannot ignore this reality
for much longer. As countries came to
independence in the period after 1950,
one by one they destroyed the systems
of tenure that the colonial powers had
brought to the continent. In their
place they created systems that always
left the ownership of land in State
hands and usage rights subject to
political patronage. The result is that
the continent with more potentially
productive land than any other is now
the largest net importer of food in
the world. The USA with its private farm
industry and only 3 per cent of its
population engaged in agriculture;
produces half the surplus food production
of the world. American farmers in
the mid west are so important that the
current drought there has doubled
global grain prices in a matter of
weeks.
The “land reform” process in Zimbabwe has been an unmitigated
disaster.
Despite the steady recovery in the wider economy since 2008,
agriculture
remains in steep decline. No greater symptom of failure exists
than the
disappearance of our fences. But behind that façade lies a deeper
malaise –
that of total insecurity. There can be no recovery in the farm
industry
until this is addressed – not just in commercial farming districts
but also
in communal areas where the absence of security for decades has
resulted in
conditions of absolute poverty, hunger and land
degradation.
Eddie Cross
Bulawayo, 12th August 2012
CONSTITUTION WATCH 2012
[15th August 2012]
ZANU-PF
Politburo Continues to Stall Constitution
ZANU-PF has still not come out with a final and definitive statement
of its position on the COPAC draft constitution. The Politburo has already held four meetings
to review the draft – on 25th,
27th July, 1st and 8th August – some lasting into the early hours of the next morning, which reportedly
indicated considerable internal disagreement.
What has, however, become clear from statements by their lead negotiator,
Patrick Chinamasa, and the ZANU-PF spokesperson, Rugare Gumbo, is that the
Politburo has decided the party wants substantial “improvements” to the draft.
Mr Gumbo has said the Politburo may make an official statement on the
party position after yet another Politburo meeting scheduled for after Heroes and Defence Forces Days. Although politburo meetings are usually on a
Wednesday, because of the long weekend, Cabinet will be meeting on the Wednesday
and there will probably be a Politburo meeting on Thursday 16th August.
Meanwhile the party’s legal team was tasked to prepare a new draft
for the Politburo incorporating the changes that have already been decided
on. This may be accepted at the next
meeting , or the Politburo may
continue to demand more changes and yet another new draft will have to be
prepared before final acceptance. Only
when the ZANU-PF new draft is made public will it be possible to know precisely
to what extent the Politburo’s new draft has departed from the COPAC draft
accepted and initialled by the party negotiators.
Impasse
Mr Gumbo said that ZANU-PF’s negotiators had been “insensitive” to the party’s position
and had compromised too much. Although
Mr Chinamasa declined to respond to that assessment, he is now adamant that the
“final” draft agreed by the Management Committee was still open to change. In other words ZANU-PF wants the other
parties to compromise further to meet its demands. Moreover, Mr Gumbo said ZANU-PF was not going
to budge on this position – “The
constitutional draft is not final and we will not go to a referendum without
amendments. If they want, they can go
alone. We want to hammer a draft that is
acceptable to all and not just to two parties.”
But the two MDCs insist that they have already compromised far more
than they wanted to on key issues, and are adamant that they cannot give away
more without grossly violating what their parties stand
for.
It remains to be seen whether President Zuma’s visit and the
forthcoming SADC Summit will influence this new impasse and if pressure is
applied who will succumb to it – ZANU-PF or the MDCs.
Both MDCs Committed to COPAC Draft as a Negotiated
Compromise
MDC-T “After
extensive deliberations, the National Council resolved to accept the [COPAC]
Constitutional draft. This is despite the fact that some aspects which the MDC
would have wanted included in the Draft could not be incorporated. It recommended Zimbabweans to vote ‘YES’ for
the constitution in the referendum.”
When it became known
that ZANU-PF was going to demand further changes, MDC-T spokesperson Douglas
Mwonzora said ZANU- PF will not have its way with the draft constitution this
time around. “The draft constitution that we have is not
a product of the MDC alone but a result of two key processes that ZANU-PF
participated in – the outreach process and the negotiation. In both instances, ZANU-PF was equally and
ably represented by people with a requisite mandate. We cannot possibly re-subject the draft to
further negotiation. As far as we are
concerned, it is decision time for Zimbabweans including those that support
ZANU-PF on whether what we have is a good or bad draft.”
MDC Party leader Welshman Ncube said that, while the
draft constitution was not perfect and did not contain many issues Zimbabweans
would have wanted included, it had been negotiated and his party had accepted it
as a “compromise”. He
cautioned that “It is not possible to renegotiate or alter
anything without collapsing the whole process.
We as a party will not accept any
attempt by anybody to renegotiate any aspect of this draft. We will
not accept any forum for some people to veto or alter the agreed
document.” Party spokesman Qubani Moyo said the draft was “a fair compromise” and should be put to
the people at the Referendum to allow them to decide.
When the Politburo demands became known Prof. Ncube said his party
will not play into the ZANU-PF political games.
He said his party was done with negotiating the draft constitution. “If
they (ZANU-PF) think their rejection will draw the MDC back to negotiation, then
they are misleading themselves, we will not go back there. If they are not happy, they can produce their
own draft that will be taken to the people together with the COPAC draft. The
people will choose, as they know what they said. They will vote for a draft that
is reflective of their views.”
Minister of Constitutional and Parliamentary
Affairs:
Minister Eric Matinenga [speaking in his capacity as Minister and not as a
party member] has commended the draft and advocated its adoption, saying “the draft will democratise our institutions,
thereby promoting good governance and accountability”.
What
Happens Next?
Will
there be further negotiations? ZANU-PF wants them but both MDC formations
have already said they will adamantly oppose any change to the COPAC draft. Even were the MDCs to back down and
negotiations reopen, would the negotiators in the
Management Committee reach consensus? It took weeks of hard bargaining to reach
consensus following the ZANU-PF demands after the first draft. How long would another round of negotiations
take?
Will
the impasse be referred straight to the principals? Would the principals be more likely to reach
agreement? And would such agreement be
acceptable to their parties? Would Prof
Mutambara, who still occupies the role of a principal, be acceptable to the MDC
negotiators?
Could
there be more than one draft put to a Referendum? There was a suggestion that ZANU-PF put their
draft to the Referendum as well as the COPAC draft. But if that route is followed, the two MDCs
may want to redraft the COPAC draft to put back what they gave away under
pressure from the ZANU-PF. Putting two
or more drafts to the referendum would be difficult and in any case only a
temporary solution unless there was a binding commitment from all parties to
respect the outcome of the referendum.
In the absence of such a binding agreement a showdown between opposing
parties might simply be postponed as the constitution would still have to go
through Parliament [see below]. Finally, having alternative drafts put to the
referendum would give rise to fear that what negotiations could not agree on
would inevitably increase the danger of inter-party conflict degenerating into
violence during the referendum campaign.
No
Party Can Go it Alone
After being approved in the Referendum the draft constitution must be
gazetted as a Bill which will need a two-thirds majority in both the House of
Assembly and the Senate to pass through Parliament. This is a legal requirement for a new
constitution or constitutional amendments.
The MDCs do not have this majority and it is unlikely they will garner
enough support from ZANU-PF backbenchers to go against their party
directives. Even were the MDCs to
somehow put together the required majorities and get the Bill passed by both
Houses, it would then need the President’s signature before being gazetted and
coming in to force. Which would mean
that even if outvoted in Parliament ZANU-PF could still, through the President’s
veto, block the new constitution at the last moment.
Comment: This was known right
from the start of the process. There was
lobbying for Constitution Amendment No. 19 to include the GPA provisions on the
constitution-making process and its time-frame, with an added provision that a
YES vote at the referendum would be automatically legally binding. In the absence of this, it was suggested that a Constitution
Act should be passed at the outset of the process guaranteeing that the outcome
of a YES vote would be adopted. COPAC’s
reply was that the goodwill of the parties, and a moral imperative for
Parliament and the President to accept the outcome of a referendum, were enough.
[Contrast the smooth passage of the Kenyan constitution – the Kenyans first
passed an Act providing for the whole process and they included a provision
stating that if there was a YES vote at the referendum, the constitution would
automatically come into force 14 days later.]
COPAC
Plan for Second All Stakeholder Conference on Ice
ZANU-PF’s
time-consuming audit of the final draft has effectively stopped COPAC’s progress
towards the Second All Stakeholders’ Conference,
which will in turn delay plans for the Referendum.
Translation
exercise not started
– COPAC promised translation of the draft into all vernacular languages. Translators already hired were expected to
start work on Monday 30th July, but this did not go ahead, and the translation
exercise is on hold.
Management
Committee meetings cancelled Several Management Committee
meetings scheduled to discuss arrangements for the Second All Stakeholders’ Conference had
to postponed and then cancelled.
Project
Board quarterly meeting indefinitely postponed The Project Board brings together COPAC, the
Ministry of Constitutional and Parliamentary Affairs and the development
partners [donors] who have so generously borne a substantial portion of the cost
of the constitution-making
process and from whom further financial assistance will be required. The Board’s regular quarterly meeting
scheduled for 2nd August was postponed for a week, to 9th August, and then
indefinitely postponed until the way forward becomes clearer.
Veritas makes every effort to ensure reliable information, but cannot
take legal responsibility for information
supplied
BILL WATCH 38/2012
[16th August 2012]
President
Zuma's Last-Minute Visit Before the SADC Summit
SADC
Facilitator President Zuma’s Visit
SA
President Zuma, the SADC appointed mediator/facilitator visited Harare on 15th
August, flying in late afternoon and leaving
again late that night. He met
party leaders President Mugabe, Prime Minister Tsvangirai and Professor Ncube
separately in Harare during the evening.
This was a hasty last-minute visit before the meeting of the SADC Summit
in Maputo. It was long awaited, as
President Zuma had been expected several times since the SADC Luanda Summit of
1st June tasked him to assist the GPA parties to develop an
implementation mechanism and set out time frames for the full implementation of
Zimbabwe’s Roadmap to Elections. His
proposed
visits were repeatedly put off by the Zimbabwean side, but this time President
Zuma insisted as he needed something to report to SADC.
President
Zuma did not issue an official statement.
He will report his findings to the SADC Organ on Politics, Defence and
Security Cooperation on 16th August. The
Organ does not usually issue statements but in turn reports to the Heads of
State Meeting so an official statement/communiqué is unlikely before next
Monday. He did, however, give a brief
briefing to journalists and was reported as acknowledging both some movement
forward and also “hitches”. [He
described the hitches as “not major”,
an assessment with which not everyone will agree.]
President Zuma’s report to the
Organ, and in turn the Organ’s report to the full Summit, will presumably be of
only qualified progress.
SADC
Summit, Maputo 17th and 18th August
The
full Summit meeting is preceded by a meeting of the SADC Organ on Politics,
Defence and Security Cooperation scheduled for 16th August in the
afternoon. On the agenda is a report
from President Zuma on the situation in Zimbabwe.
At this meeting Tanzanian
President Jakaya Kikwete will take over from President Zuma as chairperson of
the Organ.
At the ceremonial opening of the Heads of State Meeting on 17th
August, Mozambique President Armando Guebuza
will take over from President dos Santos of Angola as SADC chairperson before
business starts. President Zuma is
expected to continue as SADC Facilitator for Zimbabwe. The Organ will report to the Heads of State
meeting on the situation in Zimbabwe.
MDC
Concerns to be Raised at the Summit
The MDCs will raise
concerns at the SADC Summit, including:
·
ZANU-PF’s moves to
have the COPAC final draft of the new constitution re-negotiated to incorporate
substantial changes to provisions agreed by all party negotiators
·
ZANU-PF’s continued
stalling over media, electoral and security sector reforms. They will cite last week’s ill disciplined
disruptions by police and solders of the training for the 2012 Census as showing
that Zimbabwe is not ready for free and fair elections until there is
transformation in the security sector.
SADC
Tribunal
The
Summit has, as usual, been preceded by meetings of Ministers from the SADC
countries. The Ministers of Justice and
Attorneys-General met in Luanda in June to finalise their report on the task
assigned to them at the Luanda Summit of 19th May 2011 – to draw up legal
instruments for the replacement of the suspended SADC Tribunal by establishing a
new Tribunal with different jurisdiction and a new membership. They are due to report to the Summit in
Maputo. Their proposal is reported to
provide for a new Tribunal
which will not have the human rights jurisdiction wielded by the suspended
Tribunal. It is hoped that, in the face
of campaigns from legal associations throughout SADC, the Summit will not revive
an emasculated Tribunal.
It was one of the key
purposes, when the SADC Tribunal was set up as an independent legal body, to ensure
that every country within SADC respected and conformed to the principles and
objectives enshrined in the SADC Treaty of 1992, including human rights and the
rule of law. It was also to provide SADC
citizens with a platform to seek justice and hold their governments to account
when their human rights had been infringed and local legal remedies had been
exhausted. To do away with this would be
a retrogressive step and curtail trade and investment, and would be in adverse
contrast with ECOWAS and EAC, whose courts of appeal have a clear mandate to
adjudicate on human rights matters.
Veritas makes every effort to ensure reliable information, but cannot
take legal responsibility for information supplied