Zimbabwe's land reform could destroy nation
Having survived the stiffest opposition challenge to his 20-year rule,
President Robert Mugabe is accelerating his wreckage of Zimbabwe's agricultural
economy.
It threatens famine and crises in banking and foreign exchange.
The violent farm seizures that preceded parliamentary elections in June, only
narrowly won by Mugabe's ZANU-PF party, have evolved into a government
confiscation program targeting 3,000 of Zimbabwe's 4,500 white-owned farms.
Farmers are being given 90 days to leave, without compensation, and their
land is being resettled by blacks with no farming experience at all.
Mugabe claims, with some justification, that he is correcting a historical
injustice, one that afflicts many former African colonies. Whites, who form 2
percent of the population, own a third of the arable land. It is up to Britain
to compensate the descendants of its former settlers, he says, since his
government doesn't have the money.
However, white-owned farms produce half of Zimbabwe's staple food, corn; most
other crops such as soy and wheat, and the biggest foreign exchange earner,
tobacco. They also provide jobs, schools and medical care for 700,000 black farm
workers and their families, who are being thrown off the land along with their
white bosses.
Thus Mugabe is adding to 60 percent unemployment.
So-called "war veterans" - many of them too young to have fought in the
Rhodesian War that preceded Zimbabwe's 1980 independence - have already caused
havoc by occupying 1,600 farms. The General Agricultural and Plantation Workers
Union says 5,000 black farm workers have been driven from their homes since
February and another 10,000 are "in immediate jeopardy."
Wheat and tobacco harvests are down 25 percent and farmers cannot prepare for
planting ahead of November rains because banks have cut off their loans.
The banks want guarantees that farmers will continue to own their land and
harvest crops unhindered. And the Commercial Farmers Union concedes that farmers
whose land is confiscated are unlikely to repay the loans they already owe,
threatening the entire banking sector.
With foreign exchange only worth one day of imports, Zimbabwe had to devalue
its dollar by 24 percent two weeks ago - from 38 to 50 per U.S. dollar. The
devaluation is designed to boost exports, but South African analysts say it is
too little too late to rescue an economy burdened with interest rates of around
70 percent.
A national strike Aug. 2 was observed by 80 percent of Zimbabwe's workers,
showing how unpopular Mugabe really is in urban as well as rural areas. But he
won the backing of his neighbors at a summit of the 14-nation Southern African
Development Community.
African leaders lauded Mugabe's efforts "to address land hunger" in his
country, condemned "biased reporting" of his land grab by the Western media and
a U.S. Senate bill that would suspend aid to Zimbabwe unless he halts the land
seizures.
They had good reason for doing so. For Mugabe's land seizures have touched a
sensitive nerve in other former colonies still struggling with land reform.
In South Africa, where whites are a 15 percent minority, 85 percent of the
land still is in white or government hands. President Thabo Mbeki acknowledged
the disparity in June, saying: "Our people have a responsibility to recognise
the fact that the land question constitutes an important part of the national
agenda. If we do not address it, we will experience an enormous and angry
explosion by those remaining disadvantaged."
In Namibia, independent since 1990, about 44 percent of large commercial
farms are owned by the descendants of German colonials. The government has vowed
not to copy Zimbabwe's land seizures, but wants Germany to contribute to a land
acquisition fund as compensation for land stolen during the Herero Wars of the
early 1900s.
In Kenya, veterans of the Mau Mau rebellion are demanding $90 billion in
damages from the British government for land "stolen" by settlers and
"atrocities" committed in the war that preceded independence.
Yet Kenya's colonial legacy is one of rich tea and coffee plantations and
game parks that draw tourists from around the world. If nearly half its people
live below the poverty line, whose fault is that?
18 August 2000
From Reuters, 17 August
Zimbabwe Opposition Says Illegal Land Reform Risky
HARARE - Zimbabwe's opposition warned on Thursday that President Robert Mugabe's government would plunge the country into further chaos if it took illegal steps in resettling black peasants on seized white farms. ``The government cannot lawfully acquire these farms within the time available, implying that it intends to use...extra-legal means, hence plunging this country into further anarchy,'' Tendai Biti, land secretary of the opposition MDC, told a news conference. Mugabe has announced plans to take over nearly half the 12 million hectares (30 million acres) owned by about 4,500 white farmers. Last week the government began settling black families on 200 farms whose acquisition the farmers have not contested. On Wednesday the government said that before the start of the rainy season in three months' time it would have resettled landless peasants on about 100 farms in each of the country's eight provinces.
Biti also warned that the ``fast track'' resettlement approach would not allow the cash-strapped government to equip peasants with the means to farm the land, further undermining the key agricultural sector which contributes 20 percent to gross domestic product. ``Our people will be dumped on unsurveyed pieces of land, in the middle of the bush, under circumstances where there are no access roads, no social infrastructure, no support services and no capital support,'' Biti said, adding that Mugabe's land program made no mention of title deeds for resettled people. ``What the government is doing is sentencing people to perpetual subsistence,'' Biti said. ``If people don't have titles to land, how are they going to borrow from banks?''
The program would also displace about 500,000 farm workers and their families and threaten the viability of financial institutions exposed to targeted farms, Biti said. ``We estimate that the 804 farms that have been targeted for acquisition were indebted to about Z$5 billion (US$100 million) to financial institutions. Surely it is foreseeable that domestic finance capital will collapse,'' he warned. CFU President Tim Henwood said last week that the group of mostly white farmers was dropping a court application challenging the constitutionality of government plans to forcibly acquire white-owned farms to resettle blacks. He said the union was committed to working with the government on land reforms.
From The Daily News, 17 August
More than 800 affected by renewed reign of terror
AMANI Trust, a human rights organisation, says 898 people have been affected by political violence, perpetrated mainly by Zanu PF youths and war veterans since 26 June. In its report covering the period 26 June to 3 August released on Tuesday, the human rights watchdog said five people died from beatings and 232 were assaulted with weapons, burnt, shot and strangled. Eight people were raped, 125 displaced, 155 threatened with assaults, 18 abducted while 37 were threatened with death. The report said: "Accounts of assaults, property damage, death and assault threats have all increased in the last week."
Amani Trust said the displaced people are mainly MDC supporters who fled their homes when war veterans and Zanu PF supporters unleashed a reign of terror in their areas. It said among the displaced are 800 farm workers who were forced to leave their jobs after being threatened by war veterans. The trust said two deaths have been confirmed, one in Harare and the other in Bulawayo. Both were MDC supporters. The report said there had been little change in the political affiliations of victims and perpetrators. Zanu PF is alleged to be responsible for 75 percent of the cases involving violence and the ruling party's victims are only 2,41 percent of the cases. MDC supporters and officials are said to be responsible for 0,8 percent of the human rights violations recorded. The percentage of victims from MDC has decreased from 26,26 percent to 24,19 percent. There has been an increase in victims whose political affiliations are not known, which now stands at 74,19 percent from 70,7 percent.
From The Zimbabwe Independent, 18 August
Spouse anxious about fate of kidnapped husband
THE wife of Patrick Nabanyana, a member of the MDC kidnapped by war veterans before the general election, is anxious about delays in unearthing the truth about the fate of her husband. "I am worried," Patricia Nabanyana, told the Zimbabwe Independent. "This issue has taken too long. Will they find him alive? My children are also worried," she said. Patrick Nabanyana (53), the polling agent for the MDC Bulawayo South MP, David Coltart, has been missing since the afternoon of June 19. War veterans allegedly abducted him from his Nketa home. He was taken away after a brief struggle as the war veterans, some of whom had threatened him with death, told family members that they wanted him to answer questions.
His wife, who is self-employed, has suspended the cross-border trading business she has been engaged in since the disappearance of her husband almost two months ago. The Nabanyana's have six children aged from 18 years to nine months. Three of them are still at school while two school-leavers are unemployed. Patricia Nabanyana said despite receiving moral and material support from relatives and well-wishers, the emotional anguish was mounting as little information was filtering through on the fate of Nabanyana, an employee at one of Ingwebu Brewery's Taverns. "I wish to know what exactly happened to him," she said. "It has taken too long."
Police, acting on a tip-off, have in the past two weeks nabbed six war veterans linked to Nabanyana's disappearance. As despair began to set in on the chances of ever finding Nabanyana alive, the war veterans who appeared at the Western Commonage magistrate's court in Bulawayo last month have not been asked to plead. Among them is the Bulawayo chairman of the war veterans association, Cain Nkala, who has denied knowing the whereabouts of Nabanyana. Four of his associates, Ngoni Dube, Fackson Ndhlovu, Aleck Moyo and a Simon, were arrested on July 22 while Nkala was picked up two days earlier. The war veterans are all out of custody on remand after a court appearance at the end of last month. "The information trail has dried up and we are relying on what the police say," said Coltart, the MDC's shadow minister for Justice who worked with Nabanyana during the run-up to the elections last month. Patricia commended the efforts made by the new group of police officers working on the case but was unhappy that the earlier group had not acted when Nabanyana's disappearance was first reported to them.
From The Star (SA), 17 August
Zimbabwe's fuel lies on Beira's docks
Harare - Millions of litres of fuel destined for Zimbabwe are stranded at Mozambique's port of Beira, oil industry sources said here, as a general upsurge in farm invasions continued with the abduction of another white farmer and his foreman. Officials from the National Oil Company of Zimbabwe (Noczim) confirmed on Wednesday that fuel had been offloaded from ships into storage tanks at Beira this week but could not be pumped into the pipeline to Zimbabwe because the government had no money to pay for it. The Noczim officials spoke as the parastatal's boss, Webster Murititirwa, told state radio that the country's fuel supplies had almost run dry.
Meanwhile, the CFU reported the abduction of white commercial farmer Koos Smit and his foreman, and a general upsurge in farm invasions and violence. Smit, owner of De Rust Farm in Nyazura, and his unnamed foreman were waylaid by 40 people on their way to another farm to start grading tobacco early on Wednesday. The CFU said police had managed to defuse the situation and the two had been released late on Wednesday. Zimbabwe's black rhino population and other endangered species could be at serious risk because of an increase in poaching in the wake of political unrest, the Worldwide Fund for Nature said in Switzerland, yesterday. It said poaching had increased in the six months since squatters began invading white-owned farms.
From News24 (SA), 17 August
World support for Zim 'unlikely'
Harare - International support for the beleagured Zimbabwe economy is unlikely without economic stability and recovery from a "perceived" negative international image, a top government official said Wednesday. "International support is unlikely to come back until certain fundamental issues are addressed," the Industry and International Trade Minister, Nkosana Moyo, said during the opening of a national export conference. Zimbabwe's economy and reputation have suffered in the wake of countrywide farm invasions by landless blacks pressing authorities to resettle them, he said.
Moyo urged government and the private sector to fill the "broad gaps" in society. Moyo said other issues included the southern African nation's status as a "net importer," which he said was responsible for the debilitating shortage of foreign currency here as imports continue to exceed exports. "We, all of us, are in this mess together," Moyo said during an upbeat address to business leaders and industrialists attending Wednesday's conference, which is expected to last two days. Government and the private sector have become increasingly polarised as economic conditions worsen in the country, and Moyo said the gaps were widening as each side tried to blame the other. He said his ministry has an "open door" policy, adding that a programme for economic recovery required input from the rest of Zimbabwe. "It's not a government programme, it's a national one," he said.
From The Zimbabwe Independent, 18 August
Mugabe loses control of Kabila
PRESIDENT Mugabe and his Sadc colleagues have lost control over the Congolese leader Laurent Kabila whom they now see as a stumbling block to peace in the war-ravaged country, the Zimbabwe Independent has learnt. Government sources said Kabila has managed to free himself from Mugabe's grip which has caused a political fallout between the two erstwhile allies. Frosty relations between Harare and Kinshasa have threatened Zimbabwe's business deals in the DRC, the Independent has been told. It is understood Kabila and his advisors are now opposed to the exploitation of the DRC's mineral resources by foreigners. While no immediate details are available on which companies stand to lose, it is understood several important deals involving leading Zimbabwean businessmen are now on hold.
Sources who attended the abortive Lusaka summit this week confirmed that Mugabe has lost control of Kabila. Sadc leaders - including Mugabe who in the past has been seen as holding the whip hand - failed to convince him to change his position on the deployment of UN peace-keepers and accept Sir Ketumile Masire as internal dialogue facilitator. Kabila left the summit in a huff claiming it was his colleagues who had failed to grasp the meaning of UN resolutions. But he has now reportedly agreed to accept UN peacekeepers in exchange for the dumping of Masire.
Last week Kabila failed to attend the Windhoek summit citing "security reasons". But the real reason was to avoid confronting the issues that had been tabled for discussion, sources said. "The failure by Sadc leaders, especially President Mugabe, to convince him to change his hard-line stance was a slap in the face. It shows that Kabila is no longer prepared to be controlled by anybody," one diplomat told the Independent. DRC ambassador to Zimbabwe Dr Kikaya Bin Karubi however said Kabila was not under anybody's control. He rejected suggestions that he had ever been under Harare's direction. "President Kabila has never been under anybody's control. He is only answerable to the Congolese people. I reject that idea completely," Karubi said. "Sadc leaders came to our rescue following principles governing the organisation," he said. Asked whether Kabila would not be ousted if Zimbabwe withdrew its troops before the war ended, Karubi said: "I don't know. But even without our allies, we will still fight our own war. The Congolese will prosecute the war."
. . .
Observers said Kabila's behaviour was causing deep anxiety for Mugabe and Zimbabwe's military high command who had thrown everything into their gamble to ward off the rebel onslaught. Mugabe could ill-afford staying there any longer because of the deep unpopularity of the war at home. His recent public pronouncements are very different from the fist-waving of only six months ago and betray a keenness to get out as soon as possible. East African diplomats said they were not surprised by Kabila's latest approach. "Once he is out of danger Kabila will desert Mugabe. He has done it in the past. He is currently strengthening his army with the help of military instructors from other countries to stand alone," said a source close to the Lusaka talks.
From The Daily news, 17 August
Nkomo to move war vets off farms
The Minister of Home Affairs, John Nkomo, yesterday indicated that government would now start moving war veterans off commercial farms they have invaded since February. Nkomo told the CFU at a meeting in Harare yesterday police would soon start evicting war veterans from the farms as government moved in to restore law and order in the agricultural sector. The minister would, however, not say when the evictions would start. Tim Henwood, the CFU president, speaking after a meeting between the CFU and Nkomo, said the minister did not make concrete assurances. Nkomo, however, made an undertaking that he would bring back law and order as the minister responsible for the upkeep of the rule of law, said Henwood.
Yesterday's meeting was the second between the CFU and Nkomo within a week. Last Friday Nkomo, at another meeting, assured the CFU that law and order would be restored on the commercial farms and there would be no new invasions. Despite these assurances, invasions have continued with 48 farms being invaded since last Friday. "Nkomo assured us that the war veterans will do whatever the police will tell them but he did not specify when the war veterans would be moved out," Henwood said yesterday. Nkomo could not be contacted for comment last night, but this would be the first time he has promised to remove war veterans from the more than 1 500 farms they have invaded since February. Police and war veterans' leaders were not available for comment.
The Minister of Industry and International Trade, Dr Nkosana Moyo, attended yesterday's meeting. Henwood said the CFU briefed Moyo about the problems the war veterans were causing to the commercial farmers and apprised him on the inability of the agricultural sector to earn foreign currency this season and the next because of the invasions. The agricultural sector is a major foreign currency earner for the country. Between March 1999 and March this year tobacco earned about $21,4 billion, cotton lint $4,1 billion, horticultural exports $2,2 billion, sugar exports $1,4 billion and beef $1,4 billion. In a recent address to Parliament outlining measures to resuscitate the economy, Minister of Finance and Economic Development, Dr Simba Makoni, said the success of any moves to restore macroeconomic stability hinged on the restoration of law and order, especially in the agricultural sector.
Before his meeting with the commercial farmers, Moyo told the delegates at the Confederation of Zimbabwe Industries exporters' conference that the controversy surrounding the land issue and lawlessness continued to plague Zimbabwe and was contributing immensely to the country's bad image internationally. "Moyo said: "The controversy which continues to plague the land resettlement exercise and the perception of lawlessness which, sadly, has become associated therewith, have not helped, and have contributed enormously to the undermining of Zimbabwe's good name and respected status within the international community. "We are all in this mess together. And that rather than concentrate on recriminations and finger-pointing about who is to blame for what, we must, all of us, concentrate on pulling together to pull ourselves out, and to place the economy and our country back on the path to recovery."
Moyo stunned the audience when he said international support was unlikely to come back to Zimbabwe until certain fundamentals had been addressed. War veterans and Zanu PF supporters intensified their invasion of farms soon after the parliamentary election in June, creating further uncertainty over the stability of agriculture at a time when farmers were preparing for the next season. "Government is fully aware of this and is working towards addressing those issues," Moyo said. "But things take time and, in the interim, we, Zimbabweans, have to do our utmost to keep going." Economic consultant Dr Peter Robinson, however, in his presentation said the minister was treating the lawlessness issue with kid gloves, saying he had heard the same sentiments expressed by other ministers before. Robinson said what was needed was concrete action.