http://africa.reuters.com/
Wed 3 Dec 2008, 7:53 GMT
HARARE,
Dec 3 (Reuters) - Zimbabwe riot police charged protesting union
members,
doctors and nurses with batons to disperse fresh demonstrations on
Wednesday
as the country sank further into crisis, a Reuters witness
said.
Zimbabwean trade unions have called a day of protest over a
deepening
banking and cash shortage crisis while at least a hundred doctors
and nurses
protested outside the health ministry in the capital Harare.
(Reporting by
Nelson Banya; Editing by Matthew Jones)
http://www.iol.co.za
December 03 2008 at 09:12AM
Harare- Zimbabwe's Reserve Bank will introduce new higher denomination
banknotes of up to 100 million Zimbabwe dollars, as it battles to contain
hyperinflation, state media reported on Wednesday.
The Herald
newspaper said the Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe had unveiled
new Z$10-million,
Z$50-million and Z$100-million notes that would go into
circulation on
Thursday.
The previously highest denomination was
Z$1-million.
Bank withdrawal limits would also be raised, just days
after soldiers,
reportedly angry they could not draw cash from banks, turned
on residents
and currency dealers.
"The release of the new
notes follows the recent review of cash
withdrawal limits to $100-million
and $50-million for individuals and
company account holders per week
respectively," the Herald said.
The army blamed
the violence on undisciplined soldiers.
The southern African
country is in the midst of an economic meltdown,
highlighted by the world's
highest inflation, officially estimated at 231
million percent, although
suspected to be much higher.
Unemployment is more than 80 percent
and food, water and fuel is
scarce.
The World Health
Organisation says the death toll from a cholera
outbreak has risen to nearly
500 due to broken water systems forcing people
to drink contaminated
water.
Critics blame the crisis on President Robert Mugabe's
policies, and
the situation has worsened amid a stalemate in power-sharing
talks with the
opposition over cabinet positions.
Zimbabwe's
Reserve Bank has repeatedly lopped zeros off the currency
in a failed
attempt to rein in inflation. - Reuters
http://www.latimes.com/
Crop failure and economic collapse have left the
nation without food.
Millions survive on nothing but wild fruit. 'Children
are dying out in the
bush,' one foreign doctor says.
By Robyn
Dixon
December 3, 2008
Reporting from Matabeleland South, Zimbabwe -- The
child's name is Godknows,
and his mother smiles softly when she explains the
choice: Only God knows
whether he will live or die.
"I'm leaving
everything in God's hands because the child is always ill," she
whispers.
Godknows is 2 but looks like a frail 6-month-old,
wrists and ankles like
twigs, dark hollows under his solemn eyes, sores on
his face. He flops in
his mother's arms like an exhausted old man, a victim
of Zimbabwe's silent
hunger crisis.
The twin miseries of crop failure
and economic collapse have left Zimbabwe's
villages without food. Millions
survive on nothing but wild fruit, and many
have died.
There are no
official statistics. But ask people here in Zimbabwe's
Matabeleland South
province whether they know anyone who died of hunger
recently, and the
answer is nearly always yes. Sometimes it's four or six
people in the last
couple of weeks. Sometimes they just say "plenty."
"Children are
dying out in the bush," one foreign doctor says, on condition
of anonymity.
"We are all guarded. We have to keep quiet or else we'll be
kicked out" by
the government.
The crisis has been exacerbated by President Robert
Mugabe's decision in
June to suspend humanitarian aid during the run-up to
his one-man
presidential runoff. The long-ruling Mugabe, stunned when he won
fewer votes
than opposition leader Morgan Tsvangirai in the first round in
March,
accused aid agencies of supporting the opposition and didn't lift the
ban
until August. Critics say the regime, which has a history of denying
food to
opposition areas, was using hunger as a political tool to force
people to
vote for Mugabe.
In past years, groups such as Human Rights
Watch, Amnesty International and
the Zimbabwean rights group Solidarity
Peace Trust have reported that the
Grain Marketing Board, the state monopoly
responsible for distribution of
maize, the nation's staple, has routinely
denied food to opposition
supporters. But this year, there is virtually no
grain from the board -- and
in many areas, no humanitarian aid
either.
"The food always ends up in the hands of ZANU-PF," says villager
Solomon
Nsinga, 66, referring to Mugabe's ruling party. "The guys in charge
of
distribution are ZANU-PF. This is where the problem is. ZANU-PF gets it
first."
(The locations of the Matabeleland South villages have not
been disclosed,
to protect the identities of villagers, who fear
repercussions for speaking
out.)
Nsinga says he's lost count of how
many people have died in his village.
"There are plenty of people who
have died this year. Plenty people," he
says. "They are dying a lot more
than usual. This is not normal.
"I feel angry, sad." He sighs and pauses.
"I don't know what to feel."
With the hunger crisis in the rural areas
and a cholera epidemic raging in
urban areas, former President Carter,
former United Nations
Secretary-General Kofi Annan and Graca Machel, wife of
former South African
President Nelson Mandela, tried to visit Zimbabwe a
week and a half ago to
report on the humanitarian situation. But they were
denied visas by Mugabe's
regime.
Nearly 5 million people desperately
need food aid, but the hunger is
expected to worsen. The World Food Program
said recently that there were no
funds for food distribution in the months
of most severe hunger, January and
February, because of a lack of donations.
With a funding shortfall of $140
million, the U.N. agency already has cut
rations in the food aid being
distributed now.
One agency, CARE,
reached only half its 500,000 intended aid recipients last
month, citing
bureaucratic hurdles and the paralysis of Zimbabwe's currency
and banking
system.
McDonald Lewanika of the Crisis in Zimbabwe Coalition says U.N.
reports
don't reflect the scale of the crisis.
"People have been
reduced to hunters and gatherers who have to look for wild
food to survive,"
he says.
He recently traveled to Wedza, a town only 60 miles from the
capital,
Harare. "You see people fighting with each other and even with wild
animals
like wart hogs just to take some food back to their children," he
says.
In the village where Godknows lives, six people died of hunger in
October.
"Three were children aged about 8 or 10. The others were aged
about 60. They
were just buried in the village. They were living on wild
berries. There was
no food, other than wild fruits," says Godknows' mother,
Phumuzile Moyo, 21.
Her village has had one food handout, from World Vision,
but only the most
vulnerable people were helped, about a third of the
population of 50.
Moyo got a food handout, but her son, who is
HIV-positive, was already so
frail that he continued to go downhill. She
took him to a clinic, where he
is getting treatment.
People
search for scraps in garbage dumps, working shoulder-to-shoulder with
baboons. Young men throng frantically at the entrances of dumps, dashing up
to trash-laden pickup trucks, tearing bags down from their loads and ripping
them open.
Everyone has a desperate story, even people seen as
"privileged," like
soldiers.
An army lance corporal, hitchhiking on
the road to Binga, in western
Zimbabwe, says his monthly pay, which is the
equivalent of less than 50
cents at the black-market rate, buys virtually
nothing. His parents have no
food, and he can't help them.
"I
went to see my parents, and they said their son doesn't love them
anymore.
When I got there, they were just sitting there with nothing. They
said,
'What have you brought us?' I said, 'Nothing.' It was very painful. I
feel
sad!" he says, but the words come out sounding angry.
In a Matabeleland
South clinic, a woman with a scarf on her head watches
over her malnourished
granddaughter. The child's limbs are swollen; she
wears a lacy blue and
white party dress meant for happier times.
The woman, Dorothy Mkwananzi,
66, stares blankly into the distance as she
murmurs in numb
despair.
"We don't know how things are going to end," she says. "We just
feel
helpless. We can't even help ourselves. I think this hunger will just
go on
and on. No matter how we feel, there's nothing we can do. We're only
human
beings."
When the food aid does not come, people get desperate.
Everyone watches the
wild fruit trees, so as to be there first when the
fruit is ripe enough to
eat.
People in Simo Mpofu's village waited
and waited, but no food trucks came.
"A lot of people have died in our
village due to hunger," she says. "A lot
of people are sick because of
hunger. It's worse than I've ever seen."
Mpofu relates the story of one
woman in her village, with three children to
feed, who faced a terrible
choice early in November.
Unable to find any food for days on end, the
woman went into the bush and
carefully selected the fruit she knew to be
poisonous. Then she took the
fruit home, cooked it and fed it to her
children and herself.
The four were buried together. Everyone in the
village went to the funeral.
Then they went out to watch the wild fruit
trees, waiting for the fruit to
ripen.
Dixon is a Times staff
writer.
robyn.dixon@latimes.com
http://www.nationalpost.com
Humanitarian Crisis
Peter Goodspeed,
National Post Published: Wednesday, December 03, 2008
Zimbabwe is
rapidly becoming a catastrophic humanitarian crisis, with
growing food
shortages, inadequate medical care and the complete collapse of
all
government services turning what was once one of the richest countries
in
Africa into a failed state.
"We are definitely getting to the stage where we
can say there is a collapse
in every single sector," said Irene Petras,
executive director of Zimbabwe
Lawyers for Human Rights.
"Unless
there can be urgent humanitarian assistance and an urgent political
will to
deal with the crisis, we are going to be in trouble," she said.
This
week, officials in Harare, Zimbabwe's capital, had to cut off all water
supplies in the city, in the middle of a national cholera epidemic, simply
because they don't have enough chemicals to treat the water.
Cholera
is raging through all but one of Zimbabwe's 10 provinces, infecting
nearly
12,000 people and killing nearly 500.
Yet the only advice Zimbabwe's
Health Minister, David Parirenyatwa, has
given people is to advise them to
stop shaking hands to avoid spreading the
disease.
"A lot of the
problems we are experiencing now are the result of a crisis in
governance,"
said Ms. Petras, a lawyer whose organization, which defends up
to 1,500
victims of human rights abuse each year, was just awarded Canada's
Rights
and Democracy's 2008 John Humphrey Freedom Award.
"The fact there is no
transparency, there is no accountability, that's why
you have a situation
where there is a health minister who is out of touch
with reality and who
has failed to mobilize international support to stop a
cholera
epidemic."
Zimbabwe's political crisis and its growing humanitarian
disaster are two
sides of the same coin, Ms. Petras said. But the
humanitarian dimension has
reached such dangerous proportions it demands
immediate international
intervention.
"There is a responsibility to
protect," she said, "and when you get a
humanitarian crisis of the
proportions that you have now, where there are
gross human rights violations
happening, then all countries have a
responsibility to go in and protect the
people of that country.
"I am talking about basic rights, the right to
food, to health. The right to
life basically. There are humanitarian
violations [in Zimbabwe] that need to
be addressed."
Once one of
Africa's most successful economies, Zimbabwe is plagued by
disaster, with
inflation running at 230 million per cent a year,
unemployment at 90% and
nearly half the country's population dependent on
international food aid to
survive.
Zimbabwe's problems are further aggravated by chronic
malnutrition, the
cholera epidemic, a malaria outbreak, HIV/AIDs, shortages
of food, fuel and
clean water and the collapse of all government services
including education
and health care.
Nearly 10% of the country's
population has already fled to neighbouring
states.
Political
deadlock between Robert Mugabe, the only president Zimbabwe has
known, and
opposition leader Morgan Tsvangirai, head of the Movement for
Democratic
Change (MDC), has left the country without a legitimate
government for nine
months.
Yet Zimbabwe human rights activists argue a power-sharing deal
that opens
the door to political and institutional reform may be the only
way Zimbabwe
can avoid complete collapse and civil war.
"Zimbabweans
are really very tolerant," Ms. Petras said. "We are a
peace-loving nation
with the highest literacy rate in Africa -- 90% . When
people went to vote
in March, they realized their lives weren't working and
they wanted change,
but they tried to do that peacefully. I think people are
very much invested
in a peaceful solution."
"For the first time, Mugabe is under pressure,"
said Andrew Makoni, a lawyer
and board member of Zimbabwe Lawyers for Human
Rights. "With the economy in
free fall, he no longer has the power he had in
the past and there is
pressure in the region saying, 'We want an inclusive
government in Zimbabwe
to resolve the crisis.' "
Only, a fresh string
of crises could easily overtake Zimbabwe's haggling
politicians and plunge
the country even deeper into chaos.
On Monday, off-duty soldiers went on
a rampage in downtown Harare, after
they were unable to get cash from the
banks. They attacked illegal foreign
currency dealers and looted
shops.
Police using tear gas managed to quell the riot, but it could have
been an
early sign Mr. Mugabe is losing control of the armed forces that
have kept
him in power.
pgoodspeed@nationalpost.com
http://africanpress.wordpress.com
Posted by africanpress on December 2,
2008
The spread of cholera in Zimbabwe has killed 473 people, the
World Health
Organisation (WHO) office in Harare has said.
"A large
cholera outbreak is affecting most regions of the country, with
more than
11,700 cases and 473 deaths recorded between August and November
30,"
Custodia Mandlhate, of the WHO's Zimbabwe office, wrote in a report
released
on Tuesday.
President Robert Mugabe's government cut off water supplies
to Harare, the
capital, on Monday in an attempt to stem the spread of the
disease.
The Zimbabwean National Water Authority (Zinwa) had failed to find
chemicals
to treat the water supply.
"Most parts of Harare -
including the city centre - did not get water
yesterday amid claims by Zinwa
staff that the authority had stopped pumping
after it ran out of one of the
essential chemicals," the Herald newspaper, a
government mouthpiece,
reported.
Residents in Chitungwiza, Zimbabwe's second city, were cited by
the Agence
France-Presse news agency as saying that they too were not
receiving water
supplies.
Locals were instead searching for water
with pans and optimistically digging
wells near their
properties.
Chitungwiza has been at the centre of the
epidemic.
Neighbours affected
Harare says that 425 people have
died of the disease nationally since the
outbreak in August.
A total
of 11,071 cases have been recorded in the impoverished south east
African
country.
The UN said on Friday that the disease is also spreading into
neighbouring
Botswana and South Africa.
The UN Office for the
Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA) warned of
an "alarming regional
dimension" and said the health ministries of South
Africa and Zimbabwe were
working on co-ordination efforts together with the
WHO.
"The rapid
deterioration of the health service delivery system in Zimbabwe,
the lack of
adequate water supply, and lack of capacity to dispose solid
waste and
repair sewage blockages in most areas will continue to contribute
to the
escalation and spread of the outbreak," Elisabeth Byrs, the OCHA
spokeswoman, said.
UN efforts
UN humanitarian agencies are
working on the ground to ensure the delivery of
medical supplies, clean
drinking water and water purification kits.
Byrs said that basic hygiene
kits comprising a bucket or jerry can, soap and
water treatment tablets have
been distributed to at least 4,000 households
in the capital
Harare.
Veronique Taveau, a Unicef spokeswoman, said that unlike previous
outbreaks
that mainly hit rural areas, the current epidemic is affecting
densely-populated urban centres, "which leads to its rapid expansion and
makes it harder to fight against the disease".
South Africa has
reported seven cholera deaths over the last two weeks, all
Zimbabweans or
people who recently came from the country.
Phuti Seloba, health
department spokesman in the South African border town
of Musina, said that
dozens of cholera patients from Zimbabwe enter the
country every
day.
Border river contaminated
South African health authorities
have set up five cholera treatment centres
along the border to handle the
influx, he added.
But the Limpopo River, the natural border between
Zimbabwe and South Africa
which many Zimbabweans cross to reach the
neighbouring country, was also
confirmed as contaminated with Cholera on
Monday.
Zimbabwe belatedly changed its tune on Thursday and asked for
international
help to fight the outbreak after long insisting that the
situation was under
control.
"With the coming of the rainy season,
the situation could get worse," Edwin
Muguti, deputy health minister,
said.
"Our problems are quite simple. We need to be
assisted."
Cholera is spread via water contaminated with feces and can
potentially kill
within
hours.
API/source.aljazeera.agencies
http://www.thezimbabwean.co.uk
Wednesday, 03 December 2008
JOHANNESBURG, (CAJ News)--ZIMBABWE may be facing an economic meltdown
and
lately a devastating cholera outbreak, but for cross-border traders, it
is
business as usual. Informal traders who buy items in South Africa for
resale
in Zimbabwe say the current developments in their country have not
deterred
them from continuing with their business which helps sustain their
families
in the face of a plethora of economic problems arising mainly from
political
turmoil.
"There are problems indeed in the country, a shortage of
everything
and a cholera outbreak. The shortage of food especially is of
great concern.
But anyway, it boosts my business as the commodities I bring
in remain in
demand," said Nomusa Tshuma from Entumbane suburb of Bulawayo,
Zimbabwe's
second-largest city.
Another informal trader, Tracey
Zinyowera, who was on his way back to
Zimbabwe, said she was stocking up
ahead of the festive season.
"There is demand for food such as rice
during Christmas, which is why
I bought more of the commodity than usual.
The little money Zimbabweans have
is spent on food and I am certain they
will buy it," she said at the teeming
Park Station in Johannesburg.
Zimbabwe is currently experiencing a myriad of problems which have
been
worsened by an outbreak of cholera, which has left about 500 dead and
millions exposed.
The country has scant supplies of basic
commodities such as food,
water and fuel.
Traders have cashed in on
the situation and cross to neighbouring
countries to buy such goods for
resale back home at a huge profit.
An economic analyst, Collin Ncube,
said: "It is sad people have to
travel such long distances for food, which
they resale at exorbitant prices
to their impoverished fellow citizens back
home. Nonetheless they are
providing a useful service as the nation is now
dependent on them,"--CAJ
News.
http://www.zimonline.co.za
by
Tendai Maronga Wednesday 03 December 2008
HARARE -
Zimbabwe's ruling ZANU PF party's end of year conference will
not discuss
the succession of President Robert Mugabe, ensuring the 84-year
old leader
stays at the helm despite a deepening economic and humanitarian
crisis
blamed on his rule.
Mugabe has presided over ZANU PF since the 70s
and Zimbabwe since
1980. In that period, Zimbabwe has slumped from being an
envied African
economy and the breadbasket of southern Africa to a nation
shunned by key
international donors and scrambling for aid and food imports
from countries
it used to feed.
The world's highest inflation
rate of 231 million percent plus an
outbreak of killer diseases such as
cholera - which the World Health
Organisation said on Tuesday has killed
nearly 500 people since August -
further dramatise Zimbabwe's decline under
Mugabe.
ZANU PF political commissar Elliot Manyika said
notwithstanding the
worsening economic crisis, the December 10 to 14
conference would not
discuss replacing Mugabe because only a full congress
could discuss issues
of leadership renewal under party rules.
"The issue to do with leadership change or leadership renewal are not
discussed by the conference but during congress which is usually held after
every five years according to the party constitution," Manyika
said.
ZANU PF, which held an extraordinary congress last year
reportedly at
the instigation of some senior party leaders who wanted to
replace Mugabe
but failed to do so, is due to hold another congress next
year.
Mugabe's succession is a hotly contested issue that ZANU PF
has
avoided discussing in open fora, fearing its potential to cause the
disintegration of the party.
But a vicious power struggle has
carried on behind the scenes between
two factions, one led by former
parliamentary speaker Emmerson Mnangagwa and
the other by retired army
general Solomon Mujuru, and both vying for control
of the party in the event
of Mugabe stepping down.
Mugabe has in the past spoken against
infighting in his party,
slamming senior officials for holding "late night"
meetings and "coup" plots
to position themselves to succeed him when he
retires.
Zimbabweans had hoped a power-sharing government between
Mugabe and
opposition leader Morgan Tsvangirai would eventually see the
ageing
President eased out of office.
Zimbabwe's power-sharing
agreement remains in limbo despite
negotiators from the country's rival
parties reaching agreement on Thursday
on details of a constitutional
amendment required to give legal force to the
unity agreement of September
15.
The UN's resident representative to Zimbabwe, Agostinho
Zacharias,
told a delegation led by former UN chief Kofi Annan that visited
southern
Africa last month that while Mugabe's departure from office was
desirable,
his exit would have to be managed carefully or it could create a
"power
vacuum" that could lead to violence in Zimbabwe. - ZimOnline
http://www.afriquenligne.fr
Dakar, Senegal - The
Bulawayo Magistrate's Court in Zimbabwe on Tuesday
relaxed bail conditions
for Jenni Williams and Magodonga Mahlangu, the
embattled leaders of Women of
Zimbabwe Arise (WOZA), before adjourning the
trial to 22 January, WOZA said
in a statement received in Dakar by PANA.
According to WOZA, a leading
pressure group in Zimbabwe, the case could not
go far as the state lawyer
was "not ready for the trial" and the presiding
magistrate Sithembile Ncube
had to adjourn.
The two women are accused of charges related to illegal
assembly and
disturbing the peace, security or public order.
Williams
and Mahlangu were arrested on 16 October after organising street
protests
which are deemed illegal by the Zimbabwean authorities
Dakar -
02/12/2008
Click here to read the MDC-T draft ("No 3")
Click here to read the ZANU(PF) draft ("No 1")
The Combined Harare Residents Association joins the rest of the world in
commemorating World Aids Day
02 December 2008
"Leadership makes or breaks the response
against AIDS"- Peter Piot, UNAIDS
Executive Director.
The Combined
Harare Residents Association (CHRA) joins the rest of the world
in
commemorating World Aids Day. This day comes at a time when the
Zimbabwean
public health delivery system has disastrously collapsed, owing
to the
prevailing political and economic crisis. With this year's theme
heavily
leaning on leadership as the pivot on which the response to HIV/AIDS
rests,
Zimbabwe suffers from a chronic leadership failure which has seen the
economic failure, exodus of skilled workers (including if not mostly,
health) to neighboring and other countries, endemic and absolute poverty and
a perpetual cloud of hopelessness which has made the situation unbearable
for the people infected with HIV/AIDS and the generality of the Zimbabwean
populace.
The Zimbabwean de facto government recently misappropriated
the Global AIDS
fund allocated to the country, the "government" allegedly
used the money to
fund some populist programmes to further political
expediency and had
nothing to do with combating the AIDS pandemic. The
Executive Director for
the Global Fund, Michael Kazatchkine, said that about
US$7, 3 million had
been misused by the government. Such actions are
reflective of the
leadership/government's lack of empathy for the HIV/AIDS
victims. In 2005,
UNICEF estimated that the average amount of international
HIV-related
funding available each year in the Southern African region was
$75 per
person. In Zimbabwe just $4 per person was available. Statistics
show
Zimbabwe has six times more HIV cases now than it did 20 years ago and
malnutrition; poor sanitation and overcrowding (compounded by Operation
Murambatsvina and the ZINWA's failure to effectively manage the water and
sewer reticulation services) have contributed to the spread of the
disease.
In Zimbabwe, it is said that 1 person in every 4 is HIV positive
amid a
collapsed public health delivery system that has dismally reduced
accessibility of medical attention by the HIV patients as a number of major
government hospitals have been forced to close (or are now operating at
around 25% their capacity) due to lack of resources, both human and
material. The economic and health sector collapse, among other factors, have
reduced accessibility of Anti-retroviral drugs to people living with
HIVAIDS. Most of them have had to wait (in the waiting list) for more than
four months before they can access the drugs. Moreover, the inaccessibility
of water and the ineffectively managed sewer systems which have resulted in
Cholera and other related diseases have further compounded the health blues.
People living with HIV/AIDS and the rest of Zimbabweans are facing abject
rural and urban poverty and most families can hardly put a meal let alone a
balanced diet together. This means that; the patients` immune system is
further compromised which means their lives are seriously shortened. It also
means an increase in prostitution and other risky behavior which is against
the fight against HIV/AIDS.
The hostility of the 'government' towards
humanitarian and non-governmental
organizations has also affected the
efforts that have been invested towards
the fight against HIV/AIDS. Some
humanitarian from operating by the
government, especially in the run-up to
the June 27 presidential run-off
elections. Organizations that were
providing aid (in the form of food, drugs
and other forms of aid) to HIV
infected and affected people were banned by
the government on flimsy
accusations of having ulterior motives and
political ambitions. The
country's internationally condemned human rights
(abuses) record and lack of
democracy has kept it a pariah and many
international donor agencies have
either reduced or frozen financial aid
destined for humanitarian programs:
"Leadership makes or breaks the response
against AIDS?"
CHRA demands a
responsible, accountable, transparent and democratic
leadership which will
afford the HIV/AIDS infected and affected and the rest
of the Zimbabwean
populace a chance of re-building the country `s economic
and socio-political
institutions and systems that will pave way for
effective programs to combat
the spread of HIV and enable the country to
take care of the infected and
affected citizens.
Farai Barnabas Mangodza (CEO)
Combined Harare Residents
Association (CHRA)
145 Robert Mugabe Way
Exploration House, Third
Floor
Harare
ceo@chra.co.zw
www.chra.co.zw
Landline: 00263- 4-
705114
Contacts: Mobile: 0912 653 074, 0913 042 981, 011862012 or email
info@chra.co.zw, and admin@chra.co.zw
December 3rd, 2008 From Lin, who is trying to survive in Zimbabwe. Along with others on that
patch of earth, with few resources, defending against men with rifles who lust
for money offered by those who sell, not cocaine, not opium, but another
addictive substance: the superstition of aphrodisiacs. Her story arrived in my mailbox this evening via a friend who has been to
Zimbabwe many times, and knows Lin and her husband, Clive… “That Lonely Thorn Tree” Ice, the five year old daughter of Natalia, was gunned down in broad daylight
yesterday. No, these are not family members of ours, although they are as important–
these are two of the many precious black and white rhinos we have lost in the
Save Valley Conservancy in Zimbabwe over the last few years. At nine thirty am on Monday the 10th, automatic rifle fire was heard by the
pump house attendant on Arda Ranch, neighbouring Senuko Ranch in the
Conservancy. George Hulme and his scouts mobilized a field search to discover what they
could, as did the Senuko scouts. Hours of tracking and backtracking led them
onto at least six different sets of recent spoor-all illegal poachers and
itinerants on Arda. They came across a freshly butchered impala in a snare and
picked up numerous wire snares in their ongoing search….. Clive, after having had no choice but to spend an infuriating morning in his
office trying to manage pressing money, staff and administrative issues, all the
while with his heart out there in the bush with the scouts and his distracted
mind running through all the possible terrible scenarios, eventually managed to
escape paperwork and meetings and traversed the Arda area in the afternoon. Before running out of light, he found himself standing over a young buffalo,
newly strangled in a snare. Probably one of the very large, tame herd of over
200 animals that we are privileged to have drinking at our water hole
nightly… Nothing conclusive was found regarding the rifle shots that day. A total of two zebra, two buffalo and three impala, all dead in wire snares,
were found by the search team. Frustrated and deeply pessimistic about what he would find, Clive went out
again early today, Tuesday, and began to systematically work out where the shots
were heard from and triangulate back to areas where he knew the habitat was
suitable for Black rhino… Knowing that Sarah, a mature female who was the first Black rhino born on the
Conservancy, had been seen in this area with a young calf, his dread was that he
would find her, the “flagship rhino” of the Conservancy, poached and her calf
dead, abandoned or mutilated…. Joined by his son Glenn and the Senuko scouts, shortly before midday they had
discovered spoor of a running rhino, overlaid with blood spots and yet again
overlaid by human tracks. Within 800 metres they came upon the grisly murder scene, (see drawing next
page)
the female rhino crumpled onto her chest near a lone thorn tree, legs buckled
under her and her face obliterated by the hacking cuts of the poachers who had
removed her horns after mowing her down with automatic fire. No sign of a calf……..and the poachers long gone on the next leg of their
journey to pass the horn on to couriers who would then spirit it across the
border. Was this Sarah? She looked to be a young animal and Clive took note of her
ear notches, of which Graham Connear, the Conservator, has records, enabling
identification of each individual rhino. Coming home saddened and distraught, Clive rested himself for half an hour
and then we drove to meet Mark Brightman and Graham Connear on the boundary road
between Senuko, Hammond and Arda, together with details of Support Unit and
Chiredzi police whom Mark had picked up. Graham confirmed that, from the ear notch data, this was not Sarah who was
killed but Ice, a young female, who had not yet been known to have a calf. Small consolation-this was not beloved Sarah, and I could see that register
in Clive’s eyes, but this was still an irreplaceable loss-a young female who
could have borne many babies in her lifetime. She was the daughter of Natalia,
who herself was killed by poachers last year. We drove into thorn scrub and when we reached the clearing with the one lone
tree, where her body lay, I subdued my emotions, clambering out of the vehicle
with heavy heart to take photographs, to sketch and to try to understand the
process of what had happened in this lonely space under a thorn tree; the last
breaths of a rare and special animal, the triumphant antics of the killers who
had chopped out the object of their greedy desire, her horn. Her open, staring eyes and intact ears were all that was left of her face,
the rest a gaping hole of tattered flesh and busy flies. Apart from the carnage
of her face, her body had been attacked… the horn poachers, or perhaps some
others who had followed, had flayed sheets of skin off her forequarters and rump
and buttocks to harvest meat in large quantities, leaving exposed, sun-darkened
flesh, and her pathetic tail hanging intact. She lay chest down, legs crumpled
beneath her, one eye hardened and sun scorched, the other eye unglazed, still
seeming almost aware, protected as it was in the shade of her head. With subdued and sad murmurings the team set to work to photograph her ear
notches, locate bullet wounds and check the two microchips implanted at
different times, once when she was dehorned*** last year and before that, when
she was ear notched as a very young rhino. All the while I squatted in front of her and drew her poor sad head, my mind
determinedly in numb mode and my fingers moving the pencil automatically to
record the tragic mess. Graham and Mark located and followed bullet tracks with the metal detector,
whilst the rest of the team cut, pushed and pulled the body as necessary to
enable them to retrieve the bullets-five in all they found-two in her fore
quarters and lung and three in her intestines. The team then decided to return
to where they had originally picked up her running tracks yesterday and to back
track from there until they found the place where the poachers had initially
confronted her. They all departed. I remained. As silence descended I climbed onto the bonnet of the cruiser, parked under
the same thorn tree that Ice lay under. As I lay there staring up through the
branches into a clouded and bird less sky, I listened to the buzzing of the
flies attending to the feast, smelt slow whiffs of her as yet untainted flesh,
and began to let myself mourn this tragic waste, this terrible tribute to
greed. After what seemed like hours of weeping slow tears through closed eyes,
drifting in and out of stressed sleep, listening to distantly approaching
thunder and the twittering of Little bee eaters arriving to hawk flies at the
carcass, letting my surroundings absorb me, I eventually opened my lids and
stared straight up into gathering grey cumulus clouds. Vultures had arrived. A wheeling vortex of more than forty circled, the
closest, a White backed vulture, soaring at tree height over me and the furthest
I could see being nearly invisible, pepper-grain specks against the massed
clouds high above. A strange and enlightening sensation– I felt as if I was the
object of their intent as the first bird whistled at speed in to perch on a
neighbouring thorn tree, and pretended to preen busily eyeing me all the while.
I pursued my depressed thoughts, while the vulture waited and watched…no
others came down, staying high aloft-were they awaiting a signal from the first?
The wind freshened to a stiff breeze, scattered raindrops fell and the Vulture,
buffeted about on a flimsy branch, gave up and flapped silently away. If I had
not been there would they have all descended to begin their task of clearing up
the remains of Ice? Perhaps the lateness of the afternoon and the threatening
lightening also put them off… European bee eaters arrived en masse, briefly dipping and chirruping above me
as they picked flies out of the air and then, as quickly as they had arrived,
they were gone again. I pondered so many things lying there under that lonely tree- Dusk began to fall under that lonely thorn tree, and voices betrayed the slow
steps of the returning trackers. They had found the place in thick scrub where
the poachers had discovered Ice dozing peacefully, had sneaked closer, disturbed
her so that she panicked and fled a short way, to stand and short-sightedly
search the air for the cause of her alarm as is the wont of Black rhinos. While
she stood there, undecided, confused and vulnerable, they opened murderous fire
on her. Ten cartridge shells were found on that killing ground. We have lost over 30% of our breeding female Rhinos to poaching in the Save
Valley Conservancy and the statistics of losses country wide are no more
encouraging……. _______ See below, from “Dehorning Black Rhinos,” by Brice Eningowuk Dehorning black rhinos helped save them from extinction in the early 1990s
from poachers because the armed guards patrolling the National Parks did not
prove to be effective. Another way to preserve the rhino is to find substitutes
for the horns. Black rhinos, also known as the hooked-lip rhino, were poached mainly for
their horns in the early 1990s, which led to the rhinos near extinction. The
black rhino once roamed the extent of Africa’s sub-continent. Now the rhinos are
primarily found in Kenya, Tanzania, South Africa, Nimibia and Zimbabwe because
of the demand for the horns. The rhino population has declined in those
countries from 65,000 in the 1960s to 25,000 today (Rhino, Internet). Rhino horns are used for pharmaceutical and ceremonial reasons in countries
such as China, Taiwan, South Korea, and Thailand (Rhino, Internet). Rhinos are also hunted for other reasons besides their valuable horns. The
skin is used for skin disease, the bones are used for bone disorders, the blood
is used for women with menstrual problems, and the penis is used as an
aphrodisiac (Tudge, 1991, 34). The main importing countries of rhino horn include South Korea, China,
Thailand, and Taiwan. In 1987 China paid about $16,000 per kilogram, in 1988
South Korea paid $4,410 per kilogram, in 1990 Taiwan paid $4,221 and Thailand
paid $10,284 per kilogram of horns (Rhino, Internet). The Chinese have been using rhino horns for medical purposes for about 2,000
years to make remedies for flu, fever and convulsions (Tudge, 1991, 34). Chinese
studies have shown that rhino horns reduce fevers in lab rats, but rhino horn
does not compare to aspirin (Tudge, 1991, 38). In Yemen the horns are carved into ceremonial dagger handles, also known as a
jambiya, that men acquire after reaching manhood (Johannesburg, 1997). The
country of Yemen imports 1,500 kilograms of horn each year, about half of which
is used to fashion the dagger handles. Dagger handles would not seem to be a
practical use because the horns are composed of hard protein and keratin
compounded by hair, but when the horns are polished, they look like grained,
dark, translucent, amber (Tudge, 1991, 34). Dehorning is one method to prevent poachers from shooting a rhino. Dehorning,
the process of removing the front and rear horns of a rhino (Wright, 1991, 36),
is a simple procedure, although only trained professionals are allowed to
practice it because of the safety for both the rhino and veterinarian. If the
safety of both the rhino and the veterinarian is low, it is pointless to dehorn
if the species is harmed (Atkinson, Internet). For maximum safety, veterinarians
tranquilize the rhino with a tranquilizer dart fired from a rifle with the
correct dosage for the size and weight of the rhino. Two veterinarians then use
a handsaw or a chainsaw to cut just above the rhino’s snout to remove the horns.
The veterinarians coat the remainder of the horn with tar to prevent infection.
After the dehorning process there is a regrowth of the horn, so the process has
to be repeated every 12-18 months (Atkinson, Internet). The rhino is not harmed during or afterwards and no side effects have been
reported (Atkinson, Internet).
By DR. CLARISSA PINKOLA ESTÉS,
Assistant Editor, TMV Columnist
by Lin Barrie
Tuesday 11th
November, 2008.
Sometimes the hardest stories to write are the very ones
that need desperately to be told,
no matter the difficulties of trying to
balance emotion and fact…
Her mother was shot to death last year….
Clive came home with a murderous look in his
eye…
–the
inability of our follow ups to secure convictions of known poachers,
–the
desperate need for information which could be served by being able to offer a
reward to informers and scouts,
–the dearth of effective scout bases and lack
of presence on the ground in vulnerable areas,
–the sheer inability of paying
and feeding the extra staff needed to mount more intensive patrols and follow
ups….
Then,
mortally wounded, she ran until she could run no more and, giving up, she
collapsed under that lonely tree……..
The African Hunting Dog population in the Conservancy has been
very badly impacted by snaring as has every other species of game such as
Impala, Kudu and Wildebeests-even Giraffes and Elephants have fallen foul of
indiscriminate snaring methods……Where to from here?
CODA
*** dehorned; this is a practice in the refuges of
Zimbabwe of removing the horn of the Rhino surgically, literally (i’ve the
startling photos) with a chainsaw, thereby saving the rhinos from poachers. The
horn grows back. One wonders why poachers dont develop their own herd of rhinos
and harvesst the horns every year.