The ZIMBABWE Situation
An extensive and up-to-date website containing news, views and links related to ZIMBABWE - a country in crisis
Please note: You need to have 'Active content' enabled in your IE browser in order to see the index of articles on this webpage
Zimbabwe arrests Tsvangirai aide for reporting dumped ballots
By Reagan
Mashavave (AFP) – 8 minutes ago
HARARE — Zimbabwean police on Sunday
arrested an aide to Morgan Tsvangirai,
President Robert Mugabe's main rival
in upcoming polls, after he reported an
irregularity in early voting.
The
Movement for Democratic Change said Morgan Komichi was arrested after
informing the electoral commission that ballot papers marked for Tsvangirai
had been found in a dustbin after security forces voted at the Harare
International Conference Centre two weeks ahead of nationwide polling on
July 31.
"Around 6:00 am (0400 GMT) our deputy national chairman,
Honourable Morgan
Komichi, who is a deputy minister of transport, was picked
up at his home by
the police," the MDC's Nelson Chamisa told
reporters.
Police spokeswoman Charity Charamba confirmed the arrest just
three days
before general elections that will end an uneasy unity government
between
Mugabe, 89, and his archrival Prime Minister Morgan
Tsvangirai.
"Yes, he has been arrested," she told AFP.
Komichi,
Tsvangirai's delegate at the Zimbabwe Electoral Commission (ZEC),
this week
handed the polling panel an envelope with ballot papers in favour
of
Tsvangirai.
The MDC said several such ballots had been dumped in a dustbin at
the
conference centre where security forces, who will be on duty in
Wednesday's
polls, voted early on July 14 and 15.
Now police threaten to
charge Komichi for contravening electoral laws if he
refuses to reveal his
source.
"As long as he refuses to disclose the identity of this person the
police
will hold him accountable, therefore he becomes the prime suspect,"
said
Charamba.
"This is a very urgent and serious matter that will have
bearing on the
election process and therefore cannot be left for any other
time except
now."
The discovery of the papers added to fears of
vote-tampering that Tsvangirai
has raised in recent days.
But Mugabe
branded Tsvangirai a "cry-baby," pledging the polls will be
legitimate.
"It's going to be free and fair. We are not forcing anyone to
vote this way
or that way," Mugabe told reporters after addressing his final
campaign
rally in Harare.
Zimbabweans vote for a new president and
parliament on Wednesday, four years
after Mugabe, who has ruled the country
since independence in 1980, and
Tsvangirai were forced to share
power.
"Vote, vote, vote in peace, peace peace, peace. We want peace," Mugabe
told
around 40,000 supporters at his rally at the National Sports
Stadium.
But as campaigning wrapped up, the MDC's Chamisa accused the ZEC of
launching a witch hunt instead of dealing with the dumped ballot
issue.
"There is no denial of the fact that indeed it's an authentic ballot
paper
and indeed the ballot paper was found in the dustbin, but of course
they
want to know the whistle-blower," Chamisa said.
"We believe that ZEC
and not Komichi have a lot of questions to answer," he
added.
"If there
is any investigation, the theatre of investigations is supposed to
be
ZEC."
"The development we have witnessed seriously demonstrates a dent on the
credibility of this election," he said, questioning the electoral
commission's neutrality.
Chamisa complained that the MDC, which won more
votes than Mugabe's Zanu-PF
in the 2008 parliamentary polls, has been denied
important election-related
information.
"The voters' roll has not been
availed to us, we don't know who is printing
the ballot papers," he
said.
Violence erupted after the first round of the 2008 polls didn't deliver
a
conclusive winner. Mugabe said he was pleased that the election campaign
has
been devoid of violence so far.
Zec
printing duplicate ballot papers: Biti
http://www.dailynews.co.zw/
BRIDGET MANANAVIRE • 28 JULY 2013
1:03PM
HARARE - Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai’s MDC has accused the
Zimbabwe
Electoral Commission (Zec) of attempting to steal the July 31 vote
in favour
of President Robert Mugabe’s Zanu PF.
MDC secretary-general
Tendai Biti said the Rita Makarau-led Zec was
“deliberately engaging in
errors of commission and omission” including the
duplication of ballot
papers, putting Mugabe’s party in a favourable
position in the make-or-break
poll.
Biti said MDC had been informed by inside sources of on-going
cheating in
the commission’s system.
“For the special vote, the
serial numbers were from one to 100 000 and the
next books now contain
serials from 100 001,” Biti said.
“These are the sequences of the ballot
papers; this is what they have done.
What worries us now is that the ballot
papers for the presidential and
parliamentary have been printed at Fidelity
Printers, the ballot papers for
the local authorities are being printed at
Printflow.
But yesterday, now, according to our information, they printed
additional
papers on the 26th of July. What is of concern to us now is that
they are
now busy printing ballot papers with duplicate serial numbers
particularly
on the special vote.
“We have written to Zec and
challenge them to provide the accurate thing so
that what I have given you
here can be discounted and can be proved to be
illegitimate.”
Zec has
rejected claims that it was cheating, registering concerns with the
MDC
complaints.
Biti said his party was going to furnish Southern Africa
Development
Community (Sadc), African Union (AU) and other observers with
this new
“rigging” evidence.
The AU on Friday said their long-term
observer team had noted anomalies in
the conducting of voter registration
and special voting but said they were
confident Zec was capable of running a
credible election on July 31.
Tsvangirai, accused AU chairperson
Nkosozana Dlamini-Zuma of cushioning the
truth as concerns rise that Zec
will again spoil the general election as
they did the special
vote.
“What we do know from our sources; (illustrating) the first page
shows the
number of ballot books that were printed which means every book
has got 100
ballot papers which will give you 8 328 100 that on its own is
problematic
given the fact that there are six million people registered,”
Biti said.
Biti said the duplicated ballot papers are meant to replace
those cast on 14
and 15 July as several wards had not yet received
them.
The Harare East Constituency candidate said Zec was refusing to
release the
final voters’ roll for meticulous voter inspection and
withholding crucial
information from contesting parties.
“With four
days to go to the election, we don’t have a copy of the voters’
roll they
are refusing to give us a copy of the voters’ roll, which was the
final
voters’ roll,” Biti said.
“I have dispatched our lawyers to file an
application for us to get a copy
of the voters’ roll. Even if we get it, how
many days do we have to do the
voter inspection?”
He added: “We are
going to elections, the final list of polling stations has
not been given
out, this will be a challenge and prejudice to political
parties because
right now we are working on 9 000 (polling stations)
published
provisionally. Suppose they increase them to 20 000, we then have
to find 40
000 election agents to train and deploy in two days. These things
are being
done deliberately to ensure this election is stolen.”
With four days left
to the harmonised elections, the Zimbabwe Election
Support Network (Zesn)
has appealed to Zec to publish the final list of
polling stations ahead of
the polls to enable party agents and observer
groups to deploy.
At a
briefing for international, regional and local observers on Wednesday,
Zec
announced that the final list of polling stations would be published on
the
actual polling day.
Zesn said the last minute publishing of polling
stations would make it
problematic for stakeholders to engage with Zec to
address any problems
related to the distribution of the final list of
polling stations.
“We urge Zec to release the final list in advance in
the spirit of promoting
transparency, credibility and the smooth running of
the elections as this is
also in line with good international practices,”
said Zesn chairperson,
Solomon Zwana.
Zesn encouraged Zec to ensure
that polling stations are adequate to avoid
long queues that may discourage
potential voters from voting.
Tsvangirai
to address “Red Monday” rally
http://www.dailynews.co.zw/
GIFT PHIRI AND KUMBIRAI MAFUNDA • 28 JULY
2013 1:18PM
HARARE - Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai makes his last
throw of the dice
tomorrow at a star rally in Harare dubbed the “Red Power
Monday” that police
had earlier attempted to ban citing shortage of
manpower.
Tsvangirai will make his final poll pitch before an expected
100 000-strong
crowd, according to an MDC spokesperson, in what could be the
most important
speech of his political life.
Three days before
presidential and parliamentary elections, police had
earlier blocked
Tsvangirai from staging the rally in Harare ostensibly
because they have no
manpower while approving President Robert Mugabe’s star
rally scheduled for
Harare today.
Tsvangirai’s “Cross Over” rally is scheduled for the open
space next to the
Rainbow Towers Hotel (formerly Sheraton) which the party
has rechristened
“Freedom Square.”
“All the MDC supporters in Harare
are expected to converge in their big
numbers there,”said MDC organising
secretary Nelson Chamisa, calling on
everyone to wear red.
The furore
over the attempted cancellation of the MDC star rally, which
forced police
into a climb down after the MDC filed an urgent High Court
chamber
application challenging the ban, was the latest sign of tension in
the
run-up to Zimbabwe’s eighth presidential election since independence in
1980.
The poll has been marked by opposition and civil society
allegations of
irregularities and concerns about inadequate
preparations.
In a stand-off that began earlier yesterday, police chief
superintendent
Alex Chagwedera, the officer commanding Harare, wrote to the
MDC advising
that they were not sanctioning the rally.
“Be advised
that we have already deployed all our personnel to polling
stations where
they are securing election and government materials,”
Chagwedera said in the
letter to the MDC.
“We have no extra personnel to spare so that they
cover your intended rally.
Some of our personnel have been deployed to some
other provinces to augment
the strength of such provinces.
“In view
of the foregoing, holding of the intended star rally has not been
sanctioned
and should not be allowed to take place as the absence of police
officers
from the rally may culminate in political violence.”
Tendai Biti, the MDC
secretary general, approached the High Court after
issuing a damning press
statement at Harvest House, the MDC headquarters,
police backtracked and
cleared the rally, but with stringent conditions.
Chagwedera said the
police will keep an eye on the conduct of the MDC
supporters during the
rally. He had earlier indicated that the ZRP had no
manpower to do
so.
“By copy of this minute, all sections of the security forces have
been
advised of your intended star rally and will be monitoring the
situation,”
reads part of Chagwedera’s letter seen by the Daily News late
last night.
The Harare police chief expressed fears that the MDC rally
could “culminate
in political violence.”
But Chamisa said: “All the
tactics will not work, they are tactics of
desperation. They want to cause
problems. But we are urging our MDC
supporters and Zimbabweans at large to
press for the last moment. The
darkest hour is before dawn. It’s dawn in
Zimbabwe, dawn is coming. It might
be the darkest hour, but dawn is coming.
Sure, no matter how painful this
period is, it is dawn tomorrow. We are
beginning a new day.”
Biti said: “This is the kind of thing we are
dealing with and as we have
said, we get shocked when some people are saying
the country is having a
free and fair election, what rubbish! This election
is illegitimate, is
illegal, is not free, is immoral and
unfair.”
Mugabe has acknowledged that his Zanu PF party faces a real
battle to stay
in power in next Wednesday’s make-or-break elections, given
the groundswell
of support for Tsvangirai, who understands that Wednesday’s
election is
about the ownership of Zimbabwe’s national
institutions.
Obert Gutu, the Harare MDC spokesman, said they expected a
turnout of no
less than 100 000 at the ‘Cross Over’ rally, and said several
hundreds of
thousands dressed in red were expected to turn out to hear
Tsvangirai speak.
Meanwhile, Mugabe has been repeating the familiar
history themes on the
campaign trail that land belongs to the black people
of Zimbabwe who waged a
liberation war to gain freedom from colonialism,
accuses his main opponents
the MDC of being a puppet of foreign forces
opposed to Zimbabwe,
particularly Britain.
Scores of those attending
are leaving his rallies while he is still speaking
soon after getting
T-shirts and caps.
Tsvangirai has been staging a colourful campaign show,
including a “show
boat”— a convoy of open trucks driving around the township
streets and
shopping centres like a carnival.
The banner and
red-festooned convoy has been moving from shopping centre to
shopping centre
to wild cheers from people in streets and buses.
Tsvangirai faces a stark
choice: run in the July 31 vote many believe is
being stolen amid a frenzy
of sympathy from many Zimbabweans after his
demand that the government
extend the campaign period faced resistance from
Mugabe and the overwhelming
grassroots support that could boost his chances
during the vote.
Police
impose stringent conditions for final MDC-T rally
http://www.thezimbabwean.co/
28.07.13
by
Farai Mabeza
MDC-T’s final rally is set to go ahead at the Glamis grounds
in Harare
tomorrow under stringent conditions after the police rescinded its
decision
to block the campaign.
An election alert from the
Zimbabwe Lawyers for Human Rights announced the
latest decision by the
police.
“The Zimbabwe Republic Police has reversed its ban of an MDC-T
final
election campaign rally set for Monday July 29 2013 and imposed a
stringent
code of conduct and conditions to be adhered to by the conveners
and party
supporters,” the statement said.
ZLHR said the decision to
ban the rally was set to become the latest in a
long line of spats between
the partners in the outgoing Government of
National Unity.
“In an
incident which stoked up tensions between President Robert Mugabe and
his
long-time rival turned coalition government partner Prime Minister
Morgan
Tsvangirai, ahead of Wednesday’s harmonised elections, the ZRP
through Chief
Superintendent Titus Chagwedera, the Officer Commanding Harare
Central
District on Friday 26 July 2013 turned down the MDC-T’s notification
to hold
its final election campaign rally near Rainbow Towers in Harare on
the
grounds that the law enforcement agency did not have enough police
personnel
to cover the rally after deploying them to polling stations around
the
country to secure some election material,” the statement said.
According
to ZLHR, the ZRP claimed it feared that the MDC-T rally could
“culminate in
political violence.”
Chagwedera reversed the ban on Saturday under
unclear circumstances and
sanctioned the MDC-T to proceed under severe
conditions.
The police said no party supporters from outside Harare would
be allowed to
attend the rally and no toyi-toying should be done before,
during and after
the rally.
Even though Chagwedera had said the
police did not have manpower he said
they would keep an eye on the conduct
of the MDC-T supporters during the
rally. He warned that all sections of the
security forces would “monitor the
situation”.
Meanwhile, the MDC-T
candidate for Mutare West, Shuwa Mudiwa, was on
Saturday released on $30
bail by magistrate Noah Gwatidzo for allegedly
holding an unsanctioned
rally.
He was charged with contravening Section 25 (1) (b) of the Public
Order and
Security Act after he allegedly convened the meeting at
Mashukashuka
Business Centre, Marange, in Manicaland.
The meeting was
held on Friday July 26. He was represented by Chris Ndlovu
of Gonese Ndlovu
Legal Practitioners and Blessing Nyamaropa of ZLHR.
Mugabe
fails to fill National Sports Stadium
http://www.newzimbabwe.com/
28/07/2013 00:00:00
by Brian Paradza
PRESIDENT Robert Mugabe’s last star rally ahead
of watershed elections this
week failed to live up to its billing as the
veteran leader failed to fill
Harare's 60,000-seater National Sports Stadium
on Sunday.
Several sitting bays at the giant stadium were unoccupied and
scores of
supporters could also be seen walking towards the exit points
barely 15
minutes into the veteran leader’s long speech.
Proceedings
also started rather ominously for Mugabe as a mini football
match organised
to demonstrate the concept of bhora mugedhi/bhola eghedini
ended up sending
the wrong signals with the keeper, dressed in red (MDC-T
colour), who was
supposed to have let the ball in ending up making a save.
And as if that
were not bad enough, when President Mugabe took to the podium
having been
introduced by his deputy, Joice Mujuru, some of his supporters
started
walking out of the stadium.
The police had to form a human shield to
block them from leaving the stadium
but, determined, some fashioned all
kinds of excuses to get past the
barricade.
“Ndoda kuenda kunotora
chipepa changu mwanangu (I want to pick-up my paper
bag my son),” said one
elderly lady as she tried to find her way past the
barricade.
“We are
hungry we need to buy some food outside,” shouted supporters at one
of the
exits.
Unfazed, Mugabe warned voters in the capital against repeating the
2008
“mistake” when his Zanu PF party lost all but one of the local
parliamentary
seats.
“If you repeat what you did in 2008 of voting
again for the MDC-T I will be
surprised, that day I can even have a heart
attack,” he said.
The Zanu PF leader also warned bitter rival Morgan
Tsvangirai he would be
arrested if he follows through with a threat to
announce the election result
should the Zimbabwe Electoral Commission fail
to conduct the poll in a
transparent manner.
“I was terrified to hear
that the Tsvangirai wants to announce the election
result even daring the
police to arrest him. The electoral commission is
tasked under the law to
announce and no one else, now if he does that he
will be arrested,” said
Mugabe.
He also accused the MDC-T leader of being a cry baby after he
attacked both
the Zimbabwe Electoral Commission and the African Union
Commission
chairperson Nkosana Dlamini Zuma.
Zanu
(PF) busses in villagers for Mugabe Byo rally
http://www.thezimbabwean.co/
28.07.13
by
Gladys Ncube
Hundreds of villagers were bussed from as far as Tsholotsho,
Insiza and
Nyamandlovu districts to attend President Robert Mugabe’s rally
at White
City Stadium in Bulawayo on Saturday.
For the first
time in decades, Mugabe addressed a fully packed stadium in
Bulawayo, which
has been a strong hold of MDC since 2000.
Zupco and CMED buses started
dropping Zanu (PF) supporters from different
parts of Matabeleland region at
White City early Saturday morning.
Most attendants were carrying bags and
blankets as they came a night before
the rally.“We came from Insiza last
night,” said one of them.
“We were promised to be given food but we have
not eaten anything as yet,”
another party supporter from Bubi
said.
It was evident the crowd did not follow Mugabe’s speech with
enthusiasm as
people kept chatting as the party leader spoke, with some
complaining of
hunger.
“We greet our farmers that travelled from
rural areas to attend this
meeting. I thank you all for coming to this
resounding, thunderous meeting,”
he said.
When contacted yesterday
Zanu (PF) Bulawayo Deputy Provincial Chairman,
Killian Sibanda, said : “We
never bussed anybody. If there are people who
came from outside Bulawayo ,
they did that on their because they love their
President.”
Mugabe
yesterday pleaded for votes and said Bulawayo in the 2008 elections
made a
mistake and voted for “thieves”. “You chose thieves, corrupt
characters
completely without conscience,” he said.
Zimbabwe's
Mugabe warns rival against early poll win claim
http://www.timeslive.co.za/
Reuters | 28 July, 2013
18:45
In his final campaign rally ahead of a
presidential and parliamentary vote
on Wednesday, Mugabe said his ZANU-PF
party was confident of victory, which
would extend his three decades in
power.
But he expressed concern that Tsvangirai, who is making a third
run at the
presidency, had threatened not to wait for official results from
the
electoral authorities.
Tsvangirai told his own Movement for
Democratic Change (MDC)supporters at
the weekend that although ZANU-PF was
trying to rig the elections, he
expected an overwhelming victory and did not
have to wait for the Zimbabwe
Electoral Commission (ZEC).
On Sunday,
Mugabe dismissed Tsvangirai's charges of ZANU-PF vote rigging as
unfounded
complaints of a "political cry baby" staring at inevitable defeat,
warning
him to respect laws giving only the ZEC the power to announce
results.
"I can tell you in advance that if you breach the law and
become a law
breaker, the police will arrest you," he said to cheers from
thousands of
supporters at a stadium in Harare.
In 2008, the election
commission announced presidential election results
after five weeks, which
showed Tsvangirai had beaten Mugabe but not by
enough votes to avoid a
run-off.
His MDC said ZEC had cooked the figures to keep Mugabe in
office, and
Tsvangirai went on to occupy the prime minister's post in a
power-sharing
government.
Tsvangirai will address his last major
rally on Monday.
TIGHT RACE SEEN
Mugabe, 89, is seeking to extend
his 33-year hold on power after leading the
former Rhodesia to independence
from Britain in 1980 and surviving his
party's loss to the
MDC.
Although both Mugabe and Tsvangirai have been predicting that they
would win
the July 31 contest by huge margins, political analysts say it
could be a
tight race in which Mugabe's control of the electoral machinery
might prove
the decisive element.
On Sunday, the veteran Zimbabwean
leader - who denies he has been receiving
treatment for prostate cancer in
Singapore over the last few years - said he
deserved re-election to continue
a black economic empowerment drive opposed
by the MDC.
"Tsvangirai
and his MDC are shameless Western puppets, created by the West,
funded and
controlled by the West, and I urge you to reject them once and
for all in
these elections," he said, repeating charges he makes often about
his rivals
but which the MDC strongly denies.
Mugabe jokingly said he would suffer
heart failure if the capital Harare, an
MDC stronghold in which ZANU-PF won
just one of the 29 parliamentary seats
in the 2008 elections, backed
Tsvangirai again at the polls.
This year's short election campaign period
has been largely free of the
violence that has marred previous
polls.
But the MDC accuses ZANU-PF of rigging the July 31 polls in its
favour
through a shambolic voters' register and a refusal to open up the
media to
all sides or to restrain security forces from active
politics.
Mugabe was driven around Harare's main stadium on Sunday,
waving at
supporters from the back of a truck surrounded by heavily armed
security
men, some with automatic rifles.
Despite his age and fears
that his health is failing, Mugabe has said
ZANU-PF would fight like a
"wounded beast" to retain power after being
forced into a compromise unity
government after the contested 2008 election
outcome.
That vote took
place amid a severe economic crisis, with hyperinflation of
more than 500
billion percent and food shortages, many of which were blamed
on Mugabe's
policies.
The crisis has eased under the power-sharing government, but
the recovery is
fragile and the MDC says Zimbabwe will not realise its full
potential if
ZANU-PF retains power.
The security establishment has
emerged as Mugabe's power base, with security
chiefs publicly backing Mugabe
in elections while suggesting they would not
allow Tsvangirai to take power.
Tsvangirai
warns Mugabe not to 'steal' Zimbabwe vote
http://www.timeslive.co.za/
Sapa-AFP | 28 July, 2013
08:39
Zimbabwean Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai has warned
President Robert
Mugabe not to "steal" a crunch vote this week, so that his
veteran rival
could exit office with dignity.
"Mugabe stole
an election in 2002, he stole the election in 2008. This time
we want to
tell him that he will not steal again," Tsvangirai said to
thousands of
supporters.
"As a party we don't have intentions of retribution. What we
only want and
what we are saying is: 'Mr Mugabe run this election freely and
fairly so
that we can give you a dignified exit.'"
After two previous
polls condemned by observers as unfair, Tsvangirai is
vying to end Mugabe's
33-year rule and a four-year shaky coalition forced
after chaotic elections
in 2008.
Speaking in the farming town of Chinhoyi, 100 kilometers (62
miles)
northwest of the capital Harare, he hit out at the electoral
authority after
a disorganised special early vote and the absence of an
electoral roll.
"I have not been given the voters roll, three days before
the elections,"
Tsvangirai said, saying this was a loop-hole for
rigging.
He again accused the Zimbabwe Electoral Commission (ZEC) of
printing eight
million ballots – instead of 6.2 million, the number of
registered voters.
"I am saying this in full view of observers," he
said.
"We know you have printed eight million ballots for (the)
presidential
election, eight million for (the) parliamentary election. You
don't explain
why you need two extra million ballots."
The lead-up to
the July 31 election has been marred by flawed voter
registration, chaotic
early polling for security forces, and lopsided
campaign coverage in state
media.
A special early vote held on July 14 and 15 for police officers
and soldiers
saw polling stations open without ballot papers, leaving
thousands unable to
cast their vote.
The country's Constitutional
Court on Friday ruled that the thousands of
officers who were unable to vote
due to the disorganisation, will get a
second chance to cast ballots during
the Wednesday general elections.
Tsvangirai claims his Movement for
Democratic Change (MDC) party had also
discovered that some of the ballot
papers that were cast were later thrown
away.
"You (ZEC) messed up
the special vote of 70 000 people. In two days you
could not handle those
people," he said.
"How are you going to handle the 6.2 million voters who
are going to line up
for one day."
Mugabe
a Puppet of The Military, Says Tsvangirai, as Political Temperatures
Rise
http://www.voazimbabwe.com/
Thomas Chiripasi
28.07.2013
HARARE — MDC founding
president Morgan Tsvangirai launched a scathing attack
on his main rival in
Wednseday’s election, President Robert Mugabe, calling
him a puppet of the
military that he says is in control of the country.
President Mugabe
regularly calls Tsvangirai a puppet of the West saying his
MDC party was
sponsored by western nations, chief among them Britain and the
United
States, seeking to topple him following his controversial land
reforms.
Addressing thousands of supporters at Chibuku Stadium in
Harare's satellite
town of Chitungwiza Sunday, Tsvangirai said his partner
in the coalition
government for the past four years was not in charge of the
country.
“Mugabe himself knows that he’s not his man. He’s a beholden.
He’s a puppet
of the military,” said Tsvangirai. “Now we have a challenge of
the military
that says it does not want Mai Mujuru to take over because
she’s a woman and
they do not want Tsvangirai to rule either. But we want to
tell them that
the will of the people will prevail.”
Tsvangirai also
told a rally in Chegutu Saturday that the military had
stopped President
Mugabe from relinquishing power in 2008 when he lost to
the premier in the
first round of voting.
Mugabe now wants to retire, Tsvangirai said,
adding the veteran Zanu PF
leader is now an appendage of the
military.
“We are two days left before achieving real change” said
Tsvangirai
thousands of ululating supporters.
Meanwhile, Tsvangirai
said he’s aware the Zimbabwe Electoral Commission is
planning to move ballot
papers to a central place after voting before
counting is done in violation
of the Electoral Act.
He also criticized Sunday’s arrest of his party's
deputy national chairman
Morgan Komichi. The deputy transport minister was
arrested over a ballot
paper used in the early or special vote for members
of the uniformed forces.
Tsvangirai warned that all those who looted the
country's resources,
especially diamonds, will face the full wrath of the
law if he is elected
into office in Wednesday's watershed
elections.
"Zanu PF has all along condoned corruption within its rank and
file, but we
in the MDC have a Zero tolerance on corruption. We fired all
corrupt
councillors of Chitungwiza but who retained them? It was Chombo of
Zanu PF,”
he said.
Tsvangirai met election observers to brief them on
what he said were
problems affecting Wednesday's election, chief among them,
his failure to
access the voters roll ahead of the polls, the independence
of the electoral
commission and cases of violence being reported in some
parts of the
country.
The prime minister addresses his final campaign
rally dubbed "The cross
over" at open grounds near the Harare International
Conference Center
Monday. The MDC-T has named the grounds the Freedom
Square.
Zimbabwe Campaigns Enter Final Frenetic Stages
Jul 28, 12:14 PM EDT
BY
ANGUS SHAW
ASSOCIATED PRESS
HARARE, Zimbabwe (AP) -- Frenetic
campaigning entered its last stages Sunday
for make-or-break elections in
Zimbabwe on July 31 with both main contenders
calling for their supporters
to turn out in large numbers to cast votes.
President Robert Mugabe, 89,
spoke for two hours Sunday at the main
50,000-seat sports stadium in Harare
that was not filled to capacity. He
said his ZANU-PF party will rescue the
troubled economy with a renewed black
empowerment program. His campaign
organizers said 1,138 foreign-owned
companies still operating in the
southern African nation will be targeted to
yield 51 percent control to
blacks.
Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai told enthusiastic crowds of his
supporters
at another sports arena that he wants to create jobs and rebuild
the economy
with new investments. He said Mugabe ruined the once prosperous
nation
through reckless policies.
"We want to build, not destroy. We
will remove dictatorship using democratic
means," Tsvangirai
said.
Amid concerns of voting rigging, lawyers for Tsvangirai's party
said Morgan
Komichi, a top party official and the deputy transport minister
in the
coalition government, was arrested for questioning by police earlier
Sunday.
Komichi reported being handed voting papers from a special ballot
that was
held July 14-15 for uniformed services on duty on election day. He
said the
papers, which carried votes for Tsvangirai's party, were found in a
garbage
can outside a convention facility where the state election
commission has
its command center. He said they had evidently been thrown
away.
Police said he should have reported the find first to the
commission before
releasing the information.
Mugabe used his campaign
to voice his criticism of same sex partners,
telling a rally in the second
city of Bulawayo on Saturday he believed in
"castration" for homosexuals.
Earlier, he described Tsvangirai as a "frog"
and a "python" that nearly
swallowed voters in the last disputed elections
in 2008 that led regional
leaders to intervene and form Zimbabwe's shaky
coalition.
"We should
make him vomit this time," Mugabe said. "Tsvangirai is a coward,
more like
my late Uncle Shoniwa's dog which used to run away from game when
we went
hunting. It died without killing a single prey and the same will
happen to
Tsvangirai."
Tsvangirai is to hold his last campaign rally in downtown
Harare on Monday.
He questioned Sunday why Mugabe wanted another five years
in presidential
office.
"What can he change which he didn't change in
33 years?" since independence
from colonial rule in 1980.
Campaigning
is disallowed on Tuesday, the eve of polling.
Violence
flares up in Mberengwa
http://www.dailynews.co.zw/
PINDAI DUBE • 28 JULY 2013 12:53PM
MBERENGWA
- A wave of political violence has hit Mberengwa District in the
Midlands
Province with the resurfacing of Zanu PF campaign bases and the
re-emergence
of notorious war veterans’ leader Biggie Chitoro.
According to Prime
Minister Morgan Tsvangirai’s MDC, eight Zanu PF campaign
bases have
resurfaced at Chomubhobho, Vanguard Mine, Gwamasaka, Neta,
Sarauro,York,
Gwengwena and Langeni areas.
Takavafira Zhou, the MDC Mberengwa North
parliamentary candidate, was
attacked by a group of Zanu PF youths at
Gwengwena Business Centre on
Thursday and had his vehicle stoned.
“As
I am speaking to you, we are at Mberengwa Hospital where we are
receiving
treatment after an attack by a group of Zanu PF supporters led by
war
veterans leader Geza Zimi,” Zhou said.
“Chitoro is leading another group
which is causing terror here and he
operates from a Zanu PF campaign base at
Vanguard Mine,” said Zhou, who is
also the Progressive Teachers Union of
Zimbabwe (PTUZ) president.
The attack was reported at Mberengwa Police
Station under RRB number
1831748.
Zhou, who is contesting against
Zanu PF’s Tafanana Zhou for the Mberengwa
North seat, said he sustained head
injuries after being pelted with stones
by Zimi’s group during the Thursday
attack while another party member
Stanford Maturure sustained a deep cut
above the right eye.
“My car had its windscreen smashed; they attacked us
with stones at
Gwengwena Business Centre after holding a rally at Langeni
Business Centre.
I think they were angry over the large crowd which we
addressed,” he said.
In Mberengwa East Constituency on Friday night, the
home of MDC ward five
organising secretary Godfrey Dzivakwi was burnt down
by an alleged group of
Zanu PF supporters reportedly led by councillor
Bankie.
“They are on a terror campaign here harassing, intimidating
people and last
night we had a kitchen hut belonging to Dzivakwi burnt down.
The matter has
been reported at Buchwa Police Station,” Tirivangani-Gadu
Matavire, the MDC
Mberengwa East District secretary for elections, told the
Daily News.
MDC’s Cumming Hove is contesting against Zanu PF’s Makhosini
Hlongwane for
Mberengwa East parliamentary seat.
In Mberengwa South
on Monday, police at Mataga Growth Point nabbed a Zanu PF
youth leader
Sebastian Shumba for threatening to burn down the homestead of
MDC branch
chairperson Blessed Mashango in Mushandu village in Garinyama.
“Shumba
was going around threatening MDC supporters here and, last week he
threatened to burn down my homestead and I immediately reported to Mataga
Police Station. We are happy that police responded quickly as they picked
him up just a day after we reported the matter,” said Mashango.
Zanu
PF spokesperson Rugare Gumbo confirmed the incidents accusing MDC
supporters
of provoking Zanu PF supporters.
“What I understand is that in some of
these incidents MDC supporters are the
ones provoking Zanu PF supporters and
when they retaliate violence breaks
out. And as for the Gwengwena incident
what I am told is that Takavafira
Zhou and his group provoked the situation
after they accused our
parliamentary candidate Tafanana Zhou who is also
from the Lemba tribe like
Takavafira for not being a really Lemba,”said
Gumbo.
Midlands police spokesperson Emmanuel Mahoko said: “I will have
to check
what’s happening that side.”
Mberengwa District has been a
Zanu PF stronghold since independence and
every election, war veterans and
Zanu PF supporters have been turning it
into no go area for MDC
supporters.
During his visit to the district last week, Tsvangirai, who
addressed large
crowds in the district for the first time, called for
peaceful campaigns.
Obasanjo
jets in, no Zim officials at airport
http://www.newzimbabwe.com/
27/07/2013 00:00:00
by Nkosana Dlamini
FORMER Nigerian President and head of the African
Union Observer Mission
Olusegun Obasanjo finally arrived in Harare late
Saturday night and
immediately declared that his job was not to prescribe
solutions to Zimbabwe’s
conflicted electoral process.
Obasanjo,
arrived at 11.30 pm aboard a Nigerian Air Force plane and was
accompanied by
an entourage that hardly exceeded seven people. Not a single
Zimbabwe
government official was on hand to receive him.
“I just want to remind
you that we are here not to conduct elections. We are
here to observe the
conduct of elections,” Obasanjo told a group of waiting
journalists on
arrival at the Harare International Airport.
“That is what AU has done
wherever it has sent people to observe elections
anywhere in Africa and that
is part of the mandate of our continental
organisations. That is the first
point that l want to emphasise.
“The second point l want to emphasise is
that l think the entire world
should commend the effort that has taken place
and l take it as a rebirth
for Zimbabwe after some 33 years of
independence.
“You have a new constitution and that new constitution
would be put to test
at this election. And we wish the country every success
not only in this
election but in its future endeavour.”
The AU
diplomat shrugged off questions from journalists insisting he would
not go
beyond what he had already said.
“Just keep to what l have said now. “What we
did in the 70s, what we did in
the 80s, what we did in the 60s, we will talk
about that. Let us leave
things to what l have said now and we move on
because l have just come in.
“Don’t put your hand into my mouth because l
will bite your fingers,” he
said before being whisked away by a team of
Nigerian embassy staff and a
handful members of the AU observer
mission.
Obasanjo’s coming to Zimbabwe to head the 60 member AU observer
team
remained uncertain until the latter stages of this past week amid
speculation his coming was being blocked by President Robert Mugabe’s
government.
The former Nigerian military boss, who pioneered
Zimbabwe's delicate
mediation process when he was still President back in
2000, is viewed
suspicion by some in President Robert Mugabe’s Zanu PF who
feel he has a
spot for Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai.
Zimbabwe
election: Ageing Mugabe still hungry for power
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/
Robert Mugabe is fighting to
prove that, at the age of 89, he is still fit
to be Zimbabwe's president.
And, remarkably, it is a battle for the vote
that he seems to be winning,
write Peta Thornycroft and Colin Freeman.
By Peta Thornycroft, Harare and
Colin Freeman7:30AM BST 28 Jul 2013
Dancing alongside his wife and two
children, the elderly figure in the
baseball cap beams cheerfully for the
camera as he struts his stuff.
His steps are slow and awkward, yet the
image conveyed is of a man still
very much in his prime – despite his 89
years and the persistent rumours of
cancer.
Like a cross between a
hip-hop act and the Von Trapp Family Players, this is
the virile picture
that President Robert Mugabe is seeking to project ahead
of this week's
elections – a proud and vigorous father not just to his
children, but to the
wider nation of Zimbabwe.
Already the world's oldest serving leader,
victory on Wednesday could see
him remain in office into his mid 90s, giving
him nearly four decades at the
helm of power.
Yet as "Comrade Bob"
has hit the campaign trail in the past week, critics
have wondered just how
much stomach – and indeed brains – he has left for
the fight.
Like
the recent television interview in which he appeared with his family,
his
rallies these days are carefully choreographed events, timed for those
hours
in the day when he is less likely to fall asleep mid-sentence, or
become
rambling and forgetful. Aides are keen to avoid a repeat of his
performance
at a summit in neighbouring South Africa two years ago, where he
slurred his
speech and addressed his host, President Jacob Zuma, as "Mr
Mandela".
Last week, his electoral rival, Morgan Tsvangirai, even
claimed that the
only reason Mr Mugabe was still seeking office was because
of pressure from
his formidable wife Grace, 40 years his junior, who has
been campaigning
energetically on his behalf.
"I asked him once why
he was not retiring, when he is falling asleep as he
talks," Mr Tsvangirai
told a campaign rally last week in Chikomba, on the
sweeping plains of
central Zimbabwe's High Veldt area.
"He said he wanted to rest, but the
problem was if he left, Zanu-PF would be
doomed. The problem is that if you
take a young wife, she will be pushing
you and you cannot resist that. The
important thing is that this time, he
lets us give him a pension."
As
things stand, though, it is far from certain that the polls will put Mr
Mugabe into retirement. On the contrary, all the signs are that the
octogenarian Zanu PF leader will either cheat his way to victory again, as
he did in 2008, or indeed win almost fair and square.
Five years
after Mr Mugabe bowed to international pressure and entered a
power-sharing
arrangement with Mr Tsvangirai's Movement for Democratic
Change party (MDC),
the country that he all but destroyed is slowly on the
mend. Food is back on
shelves, schools and hospitals are functioning once
more, and the 25,000 per
cent annual inflation rate is just a distant,
shuddering memory.
But
with three days to go until the election, a familiar sense of chaos
surrounds the arrangements for the polls, which could allow Mr Mugabe to
snatch victory without even resorting to the thuggery he deployed in 2008.
The electoral register of 6.4 million people has not been updated, with up
to two million of the younger voters who make up Mr Tsvangirai's core
support base left off the list.
Instead, it contains more than
100,000 names of voters aged over 100 –
unlikely in a country where life
expectancy has declined to roughly half
that, and a potential opportunity
for long-dead voters' ballots to be
fraudulently cast.
Disturbing,
though unconfirmed, reports have also emerged of a Zanu-PF plot
to rig polls
in MDC strongholds and unleash squads of armed thugs in the
event that the
result still does not go his way.
Moreover, for a ruthless opportunist
like Mr Mugabe, power-sharing has
proved to have its advantages after all,
by blurring the lines of
responsibility in his own constituents'
eyes.
What successes it has had he has shamelessly claimed the credit
for, while
what failings there have been he has blamed on his coalition
partners, with
the result that Wednesday's contest is difficult to call.
Hence the
Zimbabwean president's bullish comments during a rally last week,
when he
said that Zanu-PF had never rigged elections in the past, and had no
need to
start now.
"The MDC is saying we rig elections, but they know
for a fact that they play
second fiddle to us in elections," he told a
cheering crowd in Mutare,
Zimbabwe's third largest city. "We have had good
elections in the past and
we will have them again this year."
Despite
his mounting infirmity – he is widely reported to be receiving
secret
prostate cancer treatment – the speech was vintage Mugabe, and proof
that
even very old age has not mellowed him whatsoever.
Mr Tsvangirai, he
compared to a cowardly hunting dog that his uncle had once
owned, which
lacked any killer instinct. Gays, he said, were "worse than
wild animals".
And in perhaps the ultimate fit of chutzpah, he accused the
huge numbers of
Zimbabweans who had fled abroad for a better life of
deserting the country
in its time of need.
"How can a man who caused almost a quarter of the
population of his country
to leave and look for better opportunities
elsewhere ask why they left?"
responded Kumbirai Muchemwa, an MDC official.
"What cheek is that?"
Audacious though it may be, some Zimbabweans seem
to buy Mr Mugabe's line.
Reliable opinion polls are not available in
Zimbabwe, but a survey last year
by Freedom House, a US-based democracy
watchdog, said that 31 per cent said
they would support Zanu-PF, against
only 20 per cent for the MDC. It was a
dramatic turnaround from a previous
Freedom House survey in 2010, which had
put the MDC ahead on 38 per cent
against just 17 per cent for Zanu-PF.
Some of the loss of MDC support is
blamed on Mr Tsvangirai, who has been
accused of failing to trumpet the
party's successes and being too timid to
confront Mr Mugabe. Others claim
the party has simply lost its appetite for
reform now that its leaders have
ministerial cars and generous expense
accounts. Depressingly for the
country's surviving white farmers, Zanu-PF
has also retained some support
for its disastrous land redistribution
policy, painting the MDC as the
stooges of white colonialists.
"Elections are about expectations," said
one Harare businessman who was a
heavy investor in agriculture before the
start of the land-grab policy in
2000. "Zanu PF has played the land-grab
message brilliantly and promised
that the people will share in the
resources. So Mugabe will win."
Nonetheless, the pre-election rallies
organised by the MDC have been far
bigger, and unlike Mr Mugabe's
get-togethers, there are no reports of them
being bussed in specially for
the occasion.
Use of social media via smart phones is likely now also
much more widespread
in Zimbabwe than it was in 2008, meaning that fraud or
intimidation at
polling station is harder to get away with.
About 600
foreign election observers, mainly from bodies like the African
Union, have
been accredited to observe the polls, although Western observers
were not
invited because of the sanctions still imposed on Mr Mugabe.
Few, though,
are confident that Mr Mugabe will accept an outright verdict in
Mr
Tsvangirai's favour, despite his promises to go quietly.
Goodsen Nguni, a
long-time Zanu-PF supporter, warned The Sunday Telegraph
that there would be
"civil war" if Mr Tsvangirai gained a clear victory, as
only Zanu-PF was
capable of "delivering for black Zimbabweans".
Then again, if Mr Mugabe
were to win outright – ushering in a retrenching of
land-grab policies and
other "indigenisation" measures to gain control over
foreign investment –
the Zimbabwean diaspora that Mr Mugabe so disparaged
last week is likely to
get even bigger.
"There won't be any cash left in any of the banks 24
hours later if Zanu PF
wins the elections," said one businessman. "Zimbabwe
won't survive another
stint of Robert Mugabe."
Zimbabwe
election: Tsvangirai has paid dearly for compromising, but has never shirked
his duty
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/
That Morgan Tsvangirai chose to get his hands dirty perhaps says
more about
him than whatever verdict is passed on him on Wednesday, writes
Colin
Freeman.
By Colin Freeman
7:30AM BST 28 Jul 2013
As I
sat in a leather armchair opposite Morgan Tsvangirai in his Harare
villa two
years ago, I was confident I was interviewing the man who would
one day
become President of Zimbabwe.
It was June 2011 and, once again, the winds
of change were sweeping across
Africa. Four months earlier, a revolution had
ousted Hosni Mubarak in Egypt,
while in neighbouring Libya, the war that
would ultimately topple Colonel
Muammar Gaddafi was already half-way
won.
The continent finally seemed to be losing patience with its
remaining Cold
War tyrants, and it seemed unlikely that Robert Mugabe,
Gaddafi's fellow
liberation hero, would be tolerated for much longer
either.
That, too, seemed to have been Mr Tsvangirai's calculation,
having entered a
power-sharing government with Mr Mugabe despite strenuous
objections from
some of his own supporters. Many feared it would simply
taint their own
party with the failings of Zanu-PF, a reasonable concern
given the dire
state of Zimbabwe's economy when the coalition started back
in 2008.
Having accepted the poisoned chalice on the grounds that it was
the only way
to save his country from anarchy, Mr Tsvangirai had quaffed
long and hard,
taking on the thankless task of getting Zimbabwe's finances
back into shape,
and even managing to be polite about his new working
partner.
When I asked him how coalition government was going, he sounded
more upbeat
than David Cameron and Nick Clegg are
normally.
"Coalitions are not the best arrangement in the world, but they
are
undertaken by a politician in order to pass through a certain phase," he
told me. "I think to a large extent we have delivered."
Mr Mugabe, he
added, was at least "polite and respectful" during cabinet
meetings, even if
he did then go off and issue entirely different
instructions to his own camp
afterwards.
Yet Mr Tsvangirai's generosity towards the Zanu-PF leader was
borne,
perhaps, of an expectation that history was on his side, and that it
was
only a question of waiting until the next elections before Zimbabwe
would
finally dump Mr Mugabe.
The rationale was that Mr Mugabe's
appalling record over the three previous
decades was now all but certain to
catch up with him.
And while he might have got away with election fixing
in 2008, it would
surely be harder to repeat it in 2013, with the outside
world watching more
closely than ever. There was also a good chance, anyway,
that Mr Mugabe's
ailing health would finish him off well before any
ballot.
With election day now just three days away, though, neither of
those
scenarios look likely.
Not only is Mr Mugabe still alive and
kicking, he is actually doing better
in the polls than Mr Tsvangirai. Part
of that is down to the MDC's own poor
PR efforts, which have failed to take
sufficient credit for steering the
country away from economic collapse, and
essentially letting Mr Mugabe off
the hook.
But Mr Tsvangirai's
Movement for Democratic Change party has also had
problems of its own. A
number of MDC politicians have become mired in the
kind of corruption
scandals that so often engulf their Zanu-PF counterparts.
Meanwhile, Mr
Tsvangirai's liaisons with various different women have been a
gift to
Zanu-PF, allowing them to paint him as an indecisive philanderer who
cannot
even decide which lady he wishes to wed, never mind what policies the
country should follow.
That, as much than anything else, may cost him
at the polls, making him the
Zimbabwean answer to Bill Clinton.
For
many of Mr Tsvangirai's supporters, electoral defeat on Wednesday will
be
confirmation that it was a bad idea to enter coalition politics all
along.
But those who might wish to rewrite history now should bear in
mind what the
alternative might have been. Were Mr Tsvangirai to have
aloofly stayed out
of government, his reputation today might be more intact,
but Zimbabwe would
have remained entirely in Zanu-PF's inept stewardship,
with potentially
disastrous consequences.
That he chose to get his
hands dirty perhaps says more about him than
whatever verdict is passed on
him on Wednesday.
Mugabe
hell-bent on reviving Zim dollar
http://www.dailynews.co.zw/
STAFF WRITER • 28 JULY 2013
12:50PM
HARARE - President Robert Mugabe has vowed to revive the Zimbabwe
dollar and
urged local to keep the shelved notes for possible compensation
if wins
re-election.
In an address to tens of thousands of people in
Gweru on Friday, said the
Zimbabwean Zim dollar, once on par with the
British pound and reduced to
almost nothing, was due to bounce back if the
89-year-old Zanu PF leader
secures a fresh mandate.
In 2009, in
response to unprecedented hyperinflation, Zimbabwe shelved the
local unit
and legalised the use of foreign currencies including the
Botswana pula, the
South African rand, the United States dollar, the Euro
and the British
pound.
The highest note previously in circulation, a 10 trillion Zimbabwe
dollar
note, was not even enough to buy a loaf of bread.
Mugabe said
Reserve bank of Zimbabwe governor Gideon Gono had conferred with
him that
many were still holding on to the Zimdollar notes.
“VaGono vakauya
vachindipa zevezeve rekuti vanhu nemadollar aye
aingovakwirira achive
billions, billions dollars, millions, millions, vamwe
vakazoaruza vachiti
vamwe vachinawo (Dr Gono told me that many people have
kept the Zimbabwean
currency in their homes). We will look into the issue
and if you still have
them don’t destroy them,” Mugabe said.
“Chikwereti chatinacho kwamuri (We
owe you compensation). We will work out
on how best to compensate
you.
“It might not be much but we will see how much you will be given to
compensate you. We will be looking at this matter as government together
with you.
“This is among many of the things that we want to do to
improve things in
our country, to have quality leadership and progress as a
nation. This is to
make sure that our party and the Government led by our
party are following
the people’s wishes.”
The central bank governor
has clarified that the re-introduction of the
Zimbabwe dollar will not be
done immediately but in the medium to long term.
Gono, a close ally of
Mugabe, said indeed discussions around this have been
made with the veteran
Zimbabwean leader, but said the re-introduction of a
local currency whose
name may or may not be the “Zimbabwe dollar” would be
done much
later.
Zimbabwe will not reinstate the local currency while it tries to
repair an
economy which critics say was destroyed by Mugabe.
“As
monetary authorities, we advise that as per the announcement by His
Excellency President R.G. Mugabe, the re-introduction of a local currency is
rather a medium to long term aspiration than an immediate, near-term agenda
item on our radar as the Central Bank,” Gono said.
“Essentially, it
is every country’s desire to have its own currency in order
to avail potent
policy options to policy makers, and Zimbabwe is no
exception in this
case.”
Gono outlined five key conditions, including attainment of
sustained
macroeconomic stability and re-orienting the economy on a firm
recovery
trajectory, before the local currency bounces back.
ZANU
hijacks government programme
http://www.thezimbabwean.co/
28.07.13
by Eddie Cross
In
the past three weeks President Mugabe has said a great deal about the
“donation” of 40 motorized graders that have recently been supplied to Rural
District Councils. Last week it was announced that a further 40 units were
expected shortly and would be distributed to the
Councils.
The truth behind this “donation” is that the State
controlled Zimbabwe
National Road Authority (ZINARA) which is funded by
levies on fuel supplies
and tolls on the main roads as well as vehicle
license fees, went out to
tender some months ago for the supply of graders
for the Rural District
Councils.
The tender documents were published
by the State controlled National Tender
Board and nearly 50 firms responded.
Many commented at the peculiar
specifications used in the documents at the
time. When the tender was
awarded it was to a company Univern Enterprises
(Pvt) Limited whose name had
not appeared on the list of companies tendering
for the contract.
Despite objections from several of the unsuccessful
companies the Board
reffered them to ZINARA from whom no replies were
received. When the
equipment arrived in Zimbabwe it was from a Chinese
Company whose products
are not well known here and for which there is no
maintenance or spares back
up. It is further estimated that the equipment,
which will cost over $16
million dollars when delivered, is overpriced by as
much as 100 per cent,
clearly indicating the payment of significant
inducements to those making
the decisions on supply.
ZINARA is
controlled by the Minister of Transport, Nicolas Goche who is well
known as
a corrupt Minister. The misuse of State funds in this way is common
on the
Zanu PF side of the GNU fence but they should at least have the
decency to
attribute the supply of this equipment to a State controlled and
funded
institution that has nothing whatsoever to do with the Zanu PF Party
or the
State President. It is simply dishonest politicking and the diversion
of
funds away from the critical needs of the Councils for cash allocations
to
repair existing road infrastructure.
A further shocking revelation is
that the graders come equipped with snow
plows suggesting that they confirm
that the Chinese had no idea whatsoever
of just what conditions their
equipment would have to deal with in Zimbabwe.
‘Credible’ elections? – Zimbabwe Vigil Diary: 27th July 2013
With only
four days to go before the elections, the Vigil ‘commends’ President Mugabe on
his ‘credible’ re-election for another 5 year term as he approaches his
90th birthday.
Despite
overwhelming evidence that the elections on 31st July are being
rigged, the SADC ‘Summit’ on 20th July had four ‘commendations’ and a
‘credible’ in its brief four-point communique released after meeting to consider
complaints by the MDC about the election arrangements. For connoisseurs of
bullshit, here is the communique in full:
‘8. On the Republic
of Zimbabwe
8.1 The Summit was
pleased to note that all the political parties have committed themselves to
ensuring that the forthcoming elections are held in a peaceful environment.
Summit encouraged the Government, all political parties and leaders to continue
with these commendable efforts which will help realize credible
elections.
8.2 The Summit
commended the Government of Zimbabwe for extending an invitation to SADC Member
States to deploy election observers and the manner in which these (sic) Observer
Mission has been received in Zimbabwe.
8.3 The Summit
commended H.E. Jacob Zuma, President of the Republic of South Africa and SADC
Facilitator for his tireless efforts in ensuring that the Zimbabwe political
stakeholders hold successful elections.
8.4 The Summit noted
the problems that arose during the special vote on 14-15 July 2013 and would
like to commend ZEC for taking these up as challenges to be overcome on the 31st
of July, and called upon all political parties to cooperate as fully as possible
with ZEC in order to ensure that it is able to meet these
challenges.’
The Vigil ‘commends’
the observers who went to such pains to see that the elections were ‘credible’,
including President Zuma’s former wife, the AU Commission Chairperson,
Nkosazana
Dlamini-Zuma, who astonished Morgan Tsvangirai by saying he had told her he was
‘happy’ with the election environment (see: AU speaks on Zim elections –
https://www.zimbabwesituation.com/old/jul27a_2013.html#Z3).
Tribute must
also be paid to President Zuma himself and SADC’s ‘commendable’ support for the
elections without which the people of Zimbabwe would not be able to look forward
to such a ‘credible’ disaster.
The Vigil
further ‘commends’ the security forces who ensured that President Mugabe was
‘credibly’ returned to power.
Lastly, to
the UK, the EU and the US: the Vigil was impressed by the weasel words by which
they abandoned the standards of ‘free and fair’ for the slippery slopes of
‘credible’. We look to them to support President Mugabe’s ‘credible’ and
‘commendable’ nomination for the Nobel Economics, Peace and Literature
Prizes.
The Vigil’s dyspeptic
view is supported by the comprehensive account of Zanu PF’s rigging which
appeared in the UK’s Daily Mail (see: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2371951/Proof-Mugabe-buys-elections-Astonishing-documents-evidence-neutralising-voters-millions-paid-systematic-rigging-smuggling-blood-diamonds--ensure-tyrant-89-clings-power.html).
We were further
persuaded by the analysis of SADC’s dilemma by Herbert Moyo in the Zimbabwean
Independent (see: Sadc fails to keep up reforms
momentum – https://www.zimbabwesituation.com/old/jul27a_2013.html#Z4)
and by Simon Allison’s piece in the Daily Maverick (see: Analysis: Maybe we
expect too much from SADC on Zimbabwe – http://www.dailymaverick.co.za/article/2013-07-24-analysis-maybe-we-expect-too-much-from-sadc-on-zimbabwe/).
Other
points
·
President Mugabe, in
the form of Fungayi Mabhunu in our Mugabe mask, was again at the Vigil to stuff
ballot boxes. He had with him two large black bags marked ‘Nikuv’, the Israeli
company being paid millions to help the Zanu PF vote riggers. We were visited by
a news team from the BBC for a report for Radio 4’s ‘The World this Weekend’ on
Sunday at 1.30 pm (http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/b037gnxm/The_World_This_Weekend_28_07_2013/
– available about 16 minutes into the broadcast on BBC iPlayer until
4th August).
·
On Election Day –
Wednesday 31st July – the Vigil is being joined by Action
for Southern Africa (the successor to the Anti-apartheid Movement) and the
Trades Union Congress to protest outside the Embassy at the rigging of the
elections. We will launching a petition to President Zuma calling on him to
arrange new elections in keeping with the roadmap and SADC principles. See
Events and Notices for more details.
·
Thanks to Helen
Rukambiro, Nkosikona Tshabangu, Francesca Toft and Kelvin Kamupira for being at
the Vigil early to help set up.
For latest Vigil
pictures check: http://www.flickr.com/photos/zimbabwevigil/.
Please note: Vigil photos can only be downloaded from our Flickr website – they
cannot be downloaded from the slideshow on the front page of the Zimvigil
website.
FOR THE RECORD: 34
signed the register.
EVENTS AND NOTICES:
·
Demonstration
for Democracy. Wednesday
31st July. The Vigil is to be joined by Action for Southern
Africa (ACTSA) and the TUC in a protest outside the Zimbabwe Embassy on election
day. Meet at 12 noon. Visit the South African High Commission at 2 pm. The
protest ends at 6 pm.
·
‘Will
2013 see the end of Mugabe’s 33-year rule?’ Wednesday
31st July at 7 pm. Venue: the Frontline Club, 13 Norfolk Place,
London W2 1QJ. Panel includes Wilf Mbanga publisher and editor of the Zimbabwean
newspaper. To buy tickets, check: http://www.frontlineclub.com/will-2013-see-the-end-of-mugabes-33-year-rule/.
·
ROHR
Executive meeting. Saturday
3rd August from 12 – 3 pm. Venue: Strand Continental Hotel (first
floor lounge), 143 Strand, London WC2R 1JA.
·
Zimbabwe Action Forum
(ZAF). Saturday
3rd August from 6.30 – 9.30 pm. Venue: Strand Continental Hotel
(first floor lounge), 143 Strand, London WC2R 1JA. The Strand is the same road
as the Vigil. From the Vigil it’s about a 10 minute walk, in the direction away
from Trafalgar Square. The Strand Continental is situated on the south side of
the Strand between Somerset House and the turn off onto Waterloo Bridge. The
entrance is marked by a big sign high above and a sign for its famous Indian
restaurant at street level. It's next to a newsagent. Nearest underground:
Temple (District and Circle lines) and Holborn.
·
Zimbabwe Yes We Can
meeting. Saturday
17th November from 12 – 3 pm. Venue: Strand Continental Hotel (first
floor lounge), 143 Strand, London WC2R 1JA.
·
Zimbabwe Vigil
Highlights 2012 can be viewed on
this link: http://www.zimvigil.co.uk/the-vigil-diary/467-vigil-highlights-2012.
Links to previous years’ highlights are listed on 2012 Highlights
page.
·
The Restoration of
Human Rights in Zimbabwe (ROHR) is the Vigil’s
partner organization based in Zimbabwe. ROHR grew out of the need for the Vigil
to have an organization on the ground in Zimbabwe which reflected the Vigil’s
mission statement in a practical way. ROHR in the UK actively fundraises through
membership subscriptions, events, sales etc to support the activities of ROHR in
Zimbabwe. Please note that the official website of ROHR Zimbabwe is
http://www.rohrzimbabwe.org/. Any other website claiming to be the official
website of ROHR in no way represents the views and opinions of
ROHR.
·
Facebook
pages:
-
Vigil: http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=8157345519&ref=ts
-
ZAF: https://www.facebook.com/pages/Zimbabwe-Action-Forum-ZAF/490257051027515
-
ROHR: https://www.facebook.com/pages/ROHR-Zimbabwe-Restoration-of-Human-Rights/301811392835
·
Vigil Myspace
page:
http://www.myspace.com/zimbabwevigil.
·
Useful
websites: www.zanupfcrime.com
which reports on Zanu PF abuses and www.ipaidabribe.org.zw where people can
report corruption in Zimbabwe
Vigil
co-ordinators
The Vigil, outside
the Zimbabwe Embassy, 429 Strand, London, takes place every Saturday from 14.00
to 18.00 to protest against gross violations of human rights in Zimbabwe. The
Vigil which started in October 2002 will continue until
internationally-monitored, free and fair elections are held in Zimbabwe. http://www.zimvigil.co.uk.
Statement Regarding The Failure By The Zec To Comply With Section 21 Of The Electoral Act
We
now have 4 days to go until the election. I have just this morning spoken to our
Elections Director in Harare and she advises that despite repeated requests we
still have not received the voters roll in any format.
I
repeat that the ZEC is obliged to supply us with the roll. I attach the relevant
section
of the Electoral Act.
"21 Inspection of voters rolls and provision of
copies
(1) Every voters roll shall be a public document and open to
inspection by the public, free of charge, during ordinary office hours at the
office of the Commission or the constituency registrar where it is kept.
(2)
A person inspecting the voters roll for a constituency may, without removing the
voters roll, make any written notes of anything contained therein during office
hours.
(3) The Commission shall within a reasonable period of time provide
any person who requests it, and who pays the prescribed fee, with a copy of any
ward or constituency voters roll, either in printed or in electronic form as the
person may request.
(4) Within a reasonable period of time after the calling
of an election, the Commission shall provide, on payment of the prescribed fee,
to every political party that intends to contest the election, and to any
observer who requests it, one copy of every voters roll to be used in the
election, either in printed or in electronic form as the party or observer may
request.
(5) Fees prescribed for the purposes of subsection (3) or (4) shall
not exceed the reasonable cost of providing the voters roll concerned.
(6)
Within a reasonable period of the time after nomination day in an election, the
Commission shall provide -
(a) free of charge, to every nominated candidate,
one copy in electronic form of the constituency voters roll to be used in the
election for which the candidate has been nominated; and
(b) at the request
of any nominated candidate, and on payment of the prescribed fee, one copy in
printed form of the constituency voters roll to be used in the election for
which the candidate has been nominated.
(7) Where a voters roll is provided
in electronic form in terms of subsection (3), (4) or (6), its format shall be
such as allows its contents to be searched and analysed."
The ZEC is in
serious breach of section 21(3) in that it has not supplied the MDC, despite our
repeated requests in writing and verablly, with a copy of the voters roll within
a reasonable period of time.
Furthermore it is breach of section 21(6) in
that it has not supplied me as a candidate, and I suspect every other candidate,
with a copy of my constituency voters roll within a reasonable period of time.
It is obvious that 4 days prior to the election is not a reasonable period of
time.
The provision of a voters roll goes to the very heart of a free and
fair election and its non supply undermines the credibility of this election. It
also raises very serious questions about what the Registrar Generals office is
up to regarding the roll.
This matter is brought to the attention of the
AU and SADC Observer teams and we look forward to receiving their comments
regarding this very serious breach of the law and the electoral
process.
Senator David Coltart.
Secretary for Legal
Affairs
MDC.
Bulawayo 27 July 2013
An analysis of Zanu PF's rally in Bulawayo on Saturday 27th July 2013
There have been some commentaries suggesting that the size of Robert Mugabe's
rally yesterday in Bulawayo is indicative of revitalisation of support for him
in Bulawayo. Had those journalists based their commentary on the rallies
Mugabe
has had in say Marondera or Chinhoyi then they might have had a point. But to
base them on the turn out in Bulawayo actually illustrates better than anything
else the fraud which is before us. Mugabe and Zanu PF have never won alone in
Bulawayo - in 1980 he and Zanu PF didn't get a look in; in 1985 even in the
midst of the massive threat towards the electorate posed by Gukurahundi they
didn't get a single seat. Post the unity accord in 1990 and 1995 they won but
only because of the ZAPU support which has since gone. Since 2000 they haven't
come close save for a few rural seats in Matabeleland.
So whilst one
cannot discount the size of the crowd yesterday - bigger from the photos I have
seen than the recent MDC T rally - it simply does not represent the actual
support Mugabe and Zanu PF have on the ground in Bulawayo. Zanu PF have hardly
been campaigning in my constituency and that is the picture nationwide - they
have focussed virtually all their efforts into 10 star rallies - 1 per province.
They have poured massive resources into these rallies - they have bused and
trucked people in from afar to attend them (on Friday for example there was an
accident involving Zanu PF supporters who had been trucked in from Gokwe to
attend the Zanu PF star rally in Gweru - seehttp://www.newsday.co.zw/2013/07/27/3096224743851935/ )
.
They have employed pop stars (a recent Zanu PF rally in Bulawayo featured Freddy
Gwala a leading South African singer well known to Zimbabweansb, Zimbabwean star
Sulumani Chimbetu has sung at other rallies), they promise T shirts, caps,
torches, even stainless steel pots etc and, critically for impoverished people,
food. And that has got people to attend in their droves.
They also employ
intimidatory tactics - yesterday I received several reports of people being told
that they had to go or else there would be dire consequences, enforced by the
police. Yesterday every single one of my posters on the road from the airport to
town was ripped down in broad day light, often in the view of police, with
absolute impunity. This sheer impunity has a chilling effect on people. I drove
through town yesterday afternoon and there was a palpable sense of fear -
whereas people all week have been freely waving the open hand salute of the MDC
at me, yesterday they were cowed and merely nodded their heads as I
passed.
So it has been through this carrot and stick cocktail that people
have been attending these rallies. Then in addition I think there is an element
of voyeurism - a bit similar to how crowds gather to watch the aftermath of a
traffic accident. Mugabe is an intriguing character to many people; as
devastating as his policies have been to Zimbabwe and especially Bulawayo and
Matabeleland many people are intrigued how this 89 year old continues and will
go to listen to him.
But all of this does not mean that people support
him. In fact I believe that Bulawayo more than any other centre will give the
lie to him and Zanu PF having support here.
The purpose behind all this
effort of course is far more sinister. It is designed to lay the foundation for
rigging on a massive scale. Zanu PF have in some respects managed to con the
international press and to that extent they have been very successful. They need
this to justify the ludicrous results that may come out on Wednesday if people
do not turn out en masse and vote. So I remain very concerned about their plans
to rig because that is the only way they can win this election. They certainly
will not win based on the genuine support of people on the ground. Few outside
of the obscenely rich ruling elite who have plundered Zimbabwe's diamonds want a
return to 2008 and the chaos of Zanu PF rule.
Whilst I cannot speak for
the rest of the country I can tell with absolute confidence that in my
constituency at least Mugabe and Zanu PF have minimal support and the attendance
at the rally yesterday bears no relation to the support Mugabe and Zanu PF have
on the ground in Bulawayo.
David
Coltart
MDC
candidate for Bulawayo East
Zimbabwe's Elections: Has Robert
Mugabe Changed?
The violent
political crisis surrounding the 2008 elections in Zimbabwe garnered a storm of coverage across the
globe.
President Robert
Mugabe's supporters were said to have led a reign of terror against supporters
of the opposition party, Morgan Tsvangirai's Movement for Democratic Change,
including rape, torture, and forced disappearance, ultimately leading Tsvangirai
to quit the race.
Amnesty International
reported 200 deaths, with 12,000 tortured and 28,000
driven from their homes during the clashes.
Outgoing Zimbabwean president Robert
Mugabe delivers a speech to launch his re-election
campaign
Even after his
success in the election, his Zanu-PF party continued the violence. But since the
successful establishment of the unity government with his rival Tsvangirai
installed as prime minister, the rhetoric has changed around
Zimbabwe.
This year, as the
July 31 election looms, there have been no such graphic reports of intimidation
and torture.
With the now
89-year-old Mugabe again challenging his old rival Tsvangarai in a tight race,
it is possible Western politicians will begin to adopt a more nuanced approach
to the once pariah leader, should he succeed.
But Zimbabwean human
rights groups argue that the violent language, threats and the intimidation
still pervade. In a video shown to the Huffington Post UK, Zanu-PF organisers
lead songs describing the beating and torturing of opponents.
In films of rallies
recorded by activists in Zimbabwe over the past year - activists The Huffington
Post UK has agreed not to name - supporters of Mugabe sing: "Zanu PF can torture
you anytime, the youths can beat you." Another chant goes: "This country is
ruled by Gushungo [Mugabe]. If you oppose it, we cut off your
head."
The film captures one
MP saying if you "provoke Zanu PF, it will destroy you."
One opposition
supporter at Mataga Growth Point, Mberengwa, said that earlier this year he was
beaten up by soldiers and threatened with a gun, breaking his neck and spinal
cord.
Another clip captures
a pastor at a church in Nyamapanda preaching that supporters of MDC would go to
hell.
Amnesty International said in a report this
month that "while the levels of violence over the
past year leading to these elections have remained low, Amnesty International
has documented systematic clampdown on the rights to freedom of expression,
association and peaceful assembly."
"Although President
Mugabe and Prime Minister Tsvangirai have made public statements urging their
supporters to be tolerant and desist from violent conduct, such statements have
not been followed by concrete steps to specifically take action against
perpetrators of human rights violations," the report
continued.
"As a result, people
on the ground perceive the statements to be nothing more than just public
relations rhetoric."
Posters for President Robert Mugabe are
covered with graffiti for the opposition Movement for Democratic Change in
Harare, Zimbabwe, in 2008
On Saturday, the man
who could be the seventh-time president of Zimbabwecastigated US President Barack Obama
and retired Archbishop Desmond Tutu over their support for gay
rights. "Man can marry man, woman can marry
woman. Never, never, never. When bishops cannot interpret the Bible properly
they should resign and leave it to those who can.
"You just know you're
a man through the physical talents that were given to you by the
Almighty.
“If you take men and
lock them in a house for five years and tell them to come up with two children
and they fail to do that, then we will chop off their heads.
"This thing
(homosexuality) seeks to destroy our lineage by saying John and John should wed,
Maria and Maria should wed... Obama says if you want aid, you should accept the
homosexuality practice... We will never do that.”
Tsvangirai on
Friday told the Associated
Press he is deeply disturbed by chaotic
preparations for the elections. He said the state election commission appeared
not to be ready for Wednesday's vote.
"The credibility of
this election is at risk. The chaos will lead to inconclusive and contested
results," he said.
Douglas Mwonzora,
Secretary for Information and Publicity at the MDC told
HuffPost that Mugabe's
supporters were still prepared to assassinate opponents. "Mugabe will stop at
nothing to suppress those that speak out against corruption," he
wrote.
"From the beginning,
I believe Mr Mugabe has cowardly attempted to veil state-sponsored murders as
car wrecks. Zimbabweans are not that naïve. May July 31 send an unmistakable
message to the regime that corruption and violence will no longer be allowed to
rule the land."
Nelson Mandela,
Robert Mugabe And The Countries They Shaped
Zimbabwe's
President Robert Mugabe, left, greets South African President Nelson Mandela in
Harare, Zimbabwe, in 1998. The two men have shaped their countries in
dramatically different ways.
Rob Cooper/AP
As the ailing
Nelson Mandela turned 95 this month, the international community celebrated his
legacy and rooted for his recovery.
Just to the north
in Zimbabwe, President Robert Mugabe, 89, is running for re-election this week.
He's looking to extend his 33 years in power, which have been marked by
authoritarian rule, economic collapse and international
isolation.
These two men have
shaped their neighboring countries in dramatically different ways. Mandela is a
global icon in a country often cited as a land of hope. Mugabe is a widely seen
as pariah in a country that has endured a precipitous decline.
Their global
reputations could hardly be more different. With both men in the news, we took a
look at their legacies, and two things stand out.
First, before
Mandela and Mugabe came to power, they had remarkably similar biographies.
Second, neither South Africa's successes under Mandela nor Zimbabwe's failings
under Mugabe were foregone conclusions.
Parallel
Lives
First, the
similarities between the two men. Martin Meredith, a British author
who has written biographies of both men, sums them up this
way:
"Both were born in
an era when white power prevailed throughout Africa, Mandela in 1918, Mugabe in
1924. Both were products of the Christian mission school system, Mandela of the
Methodist variety, Mugabe of the Catholic. Both attended the same university,
Fort Hare in South Africa. Both emerged as members of the small African
professional elite, Mandela a lawyer, Mugabe a teacher. Both were drawn into the
struggle against white minority rule, Mandela in South Africa, Mugabe in
neighboring Rhodesia. Both advocated violence to bring down white-run regimes.
Both endured long terms of imprisonment, Mandela, 27 years, Mugabe, 11
years."
Mugabe led a
successful guerrilla campaign that led to the demise of white-ruled Rhodesia and
he was inaugurated as the president of the newly independent nation of Zimbabwe
in 1980.
Despite a civil
war, the country was considered one of the most prosperous in Africa. It's
economy was still largely intact and its education system was considered one of
the best on the continent. Western aid flowed into the
country.
Peter Godwin, a
white Zimbabwean, was attending university in Britain in 1980, but decided to
return home, as did many of his friends living abroad.
"We thought
Zimbabwe had a great future, and I went home determined to play a part in it,"
says Godwin, who has written several books deeply critical of Mugabe's rule,
including The
Fear in 2010. "We thought we would
get past the war and the racial issues, and this would be a bold, new experiment
that would succeed."
In contrast, there
was no such optimism in South Africa at that time. The country's white leaders
remained firmly entrenched. Mandela had been in prison for close to two decades
and there was no sign his release was on the horizon.
His movement, the
African National Congress, was banned in South Africa and operated from the
sleepy city of Lusaka, Zambia, hundreds of miles from the South African
border.
Gazing into the
future from the vantage point of 1980, it would have been reasonable to predict
that Zimbabwe had better prospects than South Africa.
Different
Personalities
But Martin, the
British author, points to what he considers a crucial difference between Mandela
and Mugabe.
"Whereas Mandela
used his prison years to open a dialogue with South Africa's white rulers in
order to defeat apartheid, Mugabe emerged from prison bent on revolution,
determined to overthrow white society by force. Military victory, said Mugabe,
would be the 'ultimate joy,'" Martin notes.
Once in power,
Mugabe's military waged a brutal campaign against a rival black movement in the
early 1980s, leaving an estimated 20,000 dead and setting the tone for dealing
with any group seen as a potential rival, says Godwin.
When Mandela was
released from prison in 1990, he negotiated with the country's white leaders for
four years to end apartheid. As the country's first black president, he
consistently preached national unity, sometimes to the point of irritating the
country's blacks, who felt he was too conciliatory.
And on a continent
where many leaders rule until they are overthrown or die, Mandela served just
one five-year term and then retired in 1999.
Mandela was lauded
for this highly unusual move, for relinquishing power even though the South
African constitution allows for a second term.
John Mattison, a
former NPR correspondent in South Africa, later worked in Mandela's
administration. "I would meet with counterparts from other parts of Africa,"
Mattison says, "and they would say, very emotionally, he deserved a second Nobel
Prize for peace for stepping down because of the example it set in Africa,
because so many people in Africa, even in government, are so frustrated that
their leaders never step down. Once they get in, they stay. And he was very
clear about the constitutional state he wanted to set up and be a precedent
for."
Mandela's African
National Congress has dominated the country since 1994 and has not faced the
prospect of losing an election and handing over power. South Africa's current
leader, Jacob Zuma, is the country's fourth black president since apartheid
ended.
Concentrating
Power
In contrast, the
longer Mugabe has remained in power, the more authoritarian he has become,
Godwin says.
"Mugabe has been
absolutely consistent. From the very beginning, he realized he could get what he
wanted through violence," says Godwin, who now lives in New York and is
president of the PEN American Center, the writer's
association.
Mandela and other
South African leaders have rarely criticized Mugabe, arguing that quiet
diplomacy is a better option. However, Mugabe has rarely held his tongue, and
recently took a poke at Mandela.
"Mandela has
gone a bit too far in doing good to the non-black communities, really in some
cases at the expense of (blacks)," Mugabe was quoted as saying in South
Africa's Sunday Independent. "That's being too
saintly, too good, too much of a saint."
Mugabe also
defended his decision to run for another five-year term.
"My people still
need me," he said.
Zimbabwe votes on
Wednesday, and Mugabe is heavily favored.
After
Zimbabwe election, Mugabe needs a way out
http://www.csmonitor.com/
The Zimbabwe election on July
31 appears rigged and could lead to a repeat
crisis like that after a 2008
vote. The African nation needs a peaceful
transition through some form of
forgiveness.
By the Monitor's Editorial Board / July 28,
2013
Forgiveness can be a powerful tool to end a conflict, whether in
politics or
diplomacy. Yet measures such as amnesty or pardon are too rarely
used. They
often lose to a desire for justice. One place where forgiveness
might be an
effective tool right now is Zimbabwe, an African nation on the
brink of a
critical election – and a potential repeat of mass
violence.
Zimbabweans go to the polls July 31 to elect a president. The
last election
in 2008 saw the long-ruling president, Robert Mugabe, lose the
ballot count.
His security forces unleashed such postelection violence that
the ballot
winner, Morgan Tsvangirai, was forced to accept a submissive role
as prime
minister.
Now faced with possibly losing the vote again to
Mr. Tsvangirai, Mr. Mugabe,
as well as his top generals and the ruling
party, are doing what autocratic
regimes often do to stay in power: They are
rigging the voting process.
The timing of this election was rushed by
Mugabe on purpose, perhaps
illegally. An estimated 2 million young people
have not been registered. The
voting rolls have the names of more than
100,000 voters aged 100 or older.
These and other dubious tactics led Human
Rights Watch to declare: “The
chances of having free, fair and credible
elections are slim.”
Ending the long rule of leaders like Mugabe is
rarely easy. Even if they
want to leave, they and top supporters fear
retribution if they let go of
the state’s levers of power. They have gained
ill-gotten wealth or hurt
people in ways that demand justice.
It is a
delicate choice between offering a ruler a form of forgiveness as a
way to
get him to exit and seeking to punish him. Opting for justice can
create a
deterrent against future abusive leaders and satisfy a desire for
retribution by a ruler’s victims. Yet demanding justice might push a ruler
to stay in power at all costs – such as rigging an election.
An offer
of forgiveness and a guarantee of protection, meanwhile, could
persuade a
ruler to leave, ending his abuses and creating a just democracy.
Yet that
may not serve as an adequate deterrent to future rulers. And
victims are
left with little justice.
Mugabe, who has ruled Zimbabwe for 33 years,
has reasons to cling to power.
Many of Africa’s despots – most recently,
those in Egypt, Libya, and
Tunisia – have either been put on trial, killed,
or forced into exile. A few
have been either indicted or convicted by the
International Criminal Court.
In addition, if Mugabe does lean toward
handing over power, he might face a
coup by top security forces or a
rebellion within his party, the Zimbabwe
African National Union-Patriotic
Front.
Fortunately, the opponent in the presidential race, Tsvangirai,
says he
would honor Mugabe once he left office, allowing him an adequate
pension and
recognizing his legacy in leading the liberation of the country
from white
rule in the 1970s.
“One would say ‘let sleeping dogs
lie’,” Tsvangirai told the Financial
Times. “What is important is to ensure
that there is stability, because
stability is the basis for future
progress.”
Sadly, Tsvangirai’s efforts to talk to Mugabe’s top generals
about their
future if he wins have been rebuffed. They, like Mugabe, see
their
legitimacy to rule as more derived from their role in the liberation
struggle four decades ago and less from a constitutional process of
elections.
Still, Mugabe and Tsvangirai have enough of a personal
relationship that it
is possible to create the trust necessary to allow a
peaceful transition of
power, one that allows Mugabe and his allies to live
peacefully in their own
country.
The country already has one
important precedent: black Zimbabweans were
largely forgiving of their
former white rulers during the transition from
the old nation of
Rhodesia.
And it has a model in South Africa’s transition to democracy
two decades
ago. Nelson Mandela made a key decision to forgive white rulers
if they
admitted their mistakes. That process helped create the conditions
for peace
and growth. The idea sprung in part from the South African
philosophy of
ubuntu, as explained in its 1993 Constitution: “There is a
need for
understanding but not for vengeance, a need for reparation but not
for
retaliation, a need for ubuntu but not for victimization.”
Both
Mugabe and Tsvangirai have invoked the name of God in their political
fight.
Mugabe says “only God” can remove him from power. Tsvangirai says it
is
God’s wish that his opposition party, the Movement for Democratic Change,
win. Yet it may be the godly attribute of forgiveness that will help
Zimbabwe find the healing it deserves out of this election crisis.
Coming soon, ‘Robert Mugabe: A Tyrant’s Quest for Legitimacy’
By Dr Clifford Chitupa Mashiri, 28 July 2013.
Preface
The purpose
of this book is to interrogate the classic authoritarianism of
Robert
Gabriel Mugabe as Zimbabwe enters an uncertain future after the
expiry of
the Global Political Agreement amidst squabbling within the
coalition
government in Harare. The book is focusing on Robert Mugabe
because he has
been in charge since independence to the present day. It has
become de
rigueur for analysts to recognise that he was a promising leader
who became
corrupted by power. “The Black Robespierre,” as the Telegraph’s
Aislinn
Laing once described Mugabe, put white fears at rest through his
reconciliation rhetoric only to become a political demagogue two decades
later as he took revenge on white farmers supposedly for backing the
rejection of his draft constitution in the 2000 referendum. Since then,
Mugabe’s despotic rule has wreacked havoc as the good man went wrong to
arguably surpass the absolute ruler or tyrant depicted in the introduction
to Niccolo Machiavelli’s The Prince, a book which teaches effective tactics
for the absolute ruler. In Robert Mugabe: A Tyrant’s Quest for Legitimacy,
emphasis is on how the he fits or departs from the description of a prince
as being solitary, vicious and grindingly cruel to those who stand in his
way.
Chapter one seeks to correct widespread misrepresentations about
the country’s
cultural heritage while Chapter two is a critique of Mugabe’s
leadership or
lack of it using the theoretical framework of a tyrant
described by Girolamo
Savonarola in his Treatise on the Government of
Florence and aptly included
in Anthony Grafton’s introduction to The Prince.
Chapter three examines the
corruption pandemic under the stewardship of
Robert Mugabe, while chapter
four is a brief discussion on the economic
challenges facing Zimbabwe.
Chapter five examines Mugabe’s disregard for
human rights while chapter six
takes a look at how he has shaped Zimbabwe’s
isolation and reclusive
character in international relations. In chapter
seven, land reform is
subjected to a critique based on theoretical, research
and practical
anecdotal evidence. In the final chapter, discussion turns to
what is
perceived as Zimbabwe’s institutionalised electoral corruption and
was
written with the July 2013 elections in mind, therefore includes
commentary
on the voters roll which analysts say is in a shambles; the
disenfranchisement of the Diaspora; and the Special Vote debacle of 14 and
15 July 2013. Enjoy the book and send the author your comments – including
constructive criticisms and reviews.
Everything is now in the hand of
the editor. Clifford has washed his hands!
It’s coming soon. Watch this
space. Herewith a link to the cover preview or
email the author for
assistance.
About the author
Clifford is a London-based political
analyst and strategy consultant. He
will be interviewed about Zimbabwean
elections by CBC Radio tomorrow Monday
29 July at 11.15 a.m. and will give a
live commentary on the same elections
on Arise cable/Satellite Television
channel on Wednesday 31July between 2.00
p.m.- 3.00 p.m.
Zimanalysis2009@gmail.com
The Huffington Post UK | Posted: 28/07/2013 16:32 BST | Updated: 28/07/2013 16:32 BST