By Alex Bell
07 June 2010
SW Radio Africa
The South African government has been ordered to release a hidden report on the 2002 elections in Zimbabwe, after a successful court bid by a local newspaper.
Since 2008 the Mail & Guardian has been trying to have the report released, amid widespread speculation that it contained evidence showing that Zimbabwe’s 2002 disputed election was not free or fair. Judge Sisi Khampepe and Deputy Chief Justice Dikgang Moseneke were at the time commissioned by then president Thabo Mbeki to visit Zimbabwe and report back on the state of the election. The report was handed over to Mbeki but never made public, although the former President insisted the electoral process in Zimbabwe was completely democratic.
The newspaper’s efforts to access the details of the report were repeatedly denied, leaving it little choice but to seek the intervention of the High Court. The government, now under President Jacob Zuma’s leadership, has seven days to release the report to the Mail & Guardian, after the High Court ruled in the newspaper’s favour last Friday. The government can appeal in that time, but their plan of action is not yet known.
Mail & Guardian Editor Nic Dawes told SW Radio Africa on Monday that he is “extremely pleased” with the outcome of the court challenge, calling it a victory for “freedom of information in South Africa.” He explained that there is a “sense” that the report “will say something very different to what Mbeki was saying about the elections in Zimbabwe.”
The government has argued that the report was ‘confidential’ and a “record of the cabinet and its committee.” They said it contained information “supplied in confidence by or on behalf of another state, for the purpose of assessing or formulating a policy,” and that the content of the report was not in the public interest. The government has also argued that the report would lead to a deterioration of relations between the two countries, as South Africa is the facilitator in Zimbabwe’s ongoing political crisis.
The newspaper has in turn argued that the report is of enormous public interest, as the 2002 elections were marred by vote-rigging, intimidation, violence and fraud by Robert Mugabe’s government, despite South Africa’s contention that the election was free and fair. Dawes also explained that the report was never handed to cabinet despite being described as a “document of cabinet,” and instead remained within the office of the President, rousing more suspicions of its content.
Dawes described the court’s decision as an important one for South Africans who he said were left “injured” by the government’s abysmal handling of the Zimbabwe crisis. Former President Thabo Mbeki faced international criticism for his policy of ‘quiet diplomacy’ towards Zimbabwe; a policy that many say has crippled South Africa’s own reputation. Dawes said that it was a “painful and difficult period” for South Africa, because “it seemed to jar with our own democratic values.”
“The truth of the report might be a way to address some of the hurt and frustration by reasserting our democratic values,” Dawes said, expressing hope that the Zuma administration won’t fight the court’s ruling “too hard.”
“The Zuma administration has taken a more robust and assertive approach than Mbeki, and appealing this ruling and hiding this report will be very damaging,” Dawes said.
By Lance Guma
07 June 2010
SW Radio Africa
Several community leaders in Hwange have expressed concern that the constitutional outreach exercise, scheduled to begin on the 15th June, will clash with the football World Cup being hosted in South Africa. Pressure group Bulawayo Agenda this week raised the concern, arguing ‘the process might not be undertaken with thoroughness as some people will choose to watch soccer matches and might shift their attention from Zimbabwe to South Africa.’
Newsreel spoke to Constitutional Affairs Minister Eric Matinenga who insisted the issue could be resolved by those administering the outreach. ‘People want to enjoy watching their soccer. But I think let’s put this thing in its proper context. I don’t have the timetable for the soccer matches but I do not believe there is going to be a soccer match everyday from the 11th June to the 11th of July.’ He said most matches were played ‘fairly late in the day or early evening’ and they could sort themselves out ‘administratively’ to avoid any clashes.
The Minister meanwhile told us the launch of the outreach exercise has been moved by a day, from 15th to the 16th of June. He said when they initially selected the 15th of June they had not realized it was a Tuesday and this meant it was the day Cabinet meets. Matinenga said they expected all three leaders, Morgan Tsvangirai, Robert Mugabe and Arthur Mutambara, to be present for the launch on Wednesday next week.
The constitutional exercise has been plagued by endless delays caused by squabbling over donor funding, allowances for participants, talking points for the outreach and the composition of rapporteurs to assist in the collection of data, among many other things. The first all-stakeholders conference in Harare last year was disrupted by ZANU PF youths and war vets who invaded the venue, chanting slogans and threatening a repeat of the bloody violence that marred the June 2008 election.
Human rights groups are worried that ZANU PF sponsored violence in the rural areas will also discourage participation by people.
By Tichaona Sibanda
7 June 2010
SW Radio Africa
The political logjam between Robert Mugabe’s ZANU PF party and Morgan Tsvangirai’s MDC, over the remaining issues in the GPA, is unlikely to be resolved anytime soon, according to analysts.
Robert Mugabe, Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai and his deputy Arthur Mutambara have failed to resolve the sticky issues. A document compiled by their negotiators, detailing the state of the GPA talks and providing suggestions on how to resolve the issues, was handed over to the party principals in April. But there have been endless excuses and delays as to why all three principals have been unable to meet for the past two months to discuss it.
On Monday Tsvangirai’ spokesman James Maridadi confirmed that the Prime Minister had a meeting with Mugabe, but would not be drawn into saying what they had discussed.
When we contacted deputy Prime Minister Arthur Mutambara to enquire if he attended the meeting he told us he had no time to discuss the matter.
‘I have no time to talk about that, phone me tomorrow (Tuesday),’ then he switched off his phone.
Analyst Clifford Mashiri said Mugabe and his ZANU PF party were the spoilers in the inclusive government and were against the full implementation of the GPA. He added that Mugabe has dragged his feet on virtually every aspect of the agreement, even where his negotiators have agreed.
‘I don’t think there will ever be a solution to this crisis because the
so-called remaining issues are so fundamental to ZANU PF’s survival that if Mugabe was to give in, that would signal the fall of his party,’ Mashiri said.
Political commentator Munjonzi Mutandiri told us there will be no movement on issues that are likely to have a significant impact on the transfer of power.
‘People in the MDC know very well that Mugabe will not fully implement the GPA. It is clear this is a marriage that is very unstable and will remain rocky until outstanding issues are resolved,’ Mutandiri said.
The latest edition of the Financial Gazette reported that the South African mediation team has hinted at a special SADC meeting as being the only way forward. This is also something that Tsvangirai has requested – with little result.
The weekly paper said the team assembled by South African President Jacob Zuma has been sitting on the fence in the hope that Mugabe, Tsvangirai and Mutambara would soon discuss the points of departure among their parties, and reach an understanding to avoid the regional instability the crisis is creating.
‘The facilitation team has made its own proposals on how Zimbabwe can manoeuvre out of its political quagmire, but said it would keep a tight lid on them until all else has failed,’ the paper said.
As the negotiations go on endlessly, Zimbabweans and the international community are disappointed at the lack of progress in implementing what was agreed to in the power-sharing document, more than a year ago.
By Violet Gonda
7 June 2010
SW Radio Africa
Farai Maguwu, the Marange diamonds watchdog who was arrested last Thursday was formally charged by police in Harare on Monday. One of his lawyers, Trust Maanda, said the activist is yet to appear in court. He is being charged under the Criminal Law Codification and Reform Act for allegedly communicating information, via email, that is prejudicial to the State.
A source said it’s believed the police are accusing the activist of sending information via email to exiled human rights lawyer Gabriel Shumba and an Anton Dekker, from the Netherlands. This would mean that his emails have been monitored and intercepted.
Maguwu is the Director of the Centre for Research and Development and has been monitoring rights abuses at the Chiadzwa diamond fields in Manicaland. He was forced into hiding after his house was raided by the police and his relatives arrested and assaulted.
His lawyer said the police have not made reference to the recent meeting Maguwu had with the Kimberley Process monitor, Abbey Chikane. In an interview with SW Radio Africa last week Maguwu said he suspected he was set up by the KP monitor, shortly after their confidential meeting.
Lawyers had hoped their client would have been granted bail by now since he handed himself to the police voluntarily. But the activist was moved from Mutare to Harare on Sunday and is being held at Rhodesville Police Station, where MDC-T MP Ian Kay is also being held.
Kay, who is the MDC-T MP for Marondera, was arrested last week for allegedly ‘distributing expired and unregistered medicines to three clinics in his constituency’. He was picked up at his house in Harare during a raid by the police who said they were looking for drugs and unlicensed firearms.
MDC-T legislator, Eliah Jembere from the Epworth constituency, was also arrested on Saturday for allegedly ‘insulting the Office of the President’. Jembere was arrested at an MDC rally in Shamva, together with Gilbert Kagodora, the party’s provincial treasurer for Mashonaland Central.
MDC-T spokesperson Nelson Chamisa said his party is ‘witnessing a very disturbing and destabilising trend of MDC members and leaders being victimised using very flimsy and unwarranted excuses by colleagues in ZANU PF’.
Chamisa also confirmed that the police ransacked Kay’s home, claiming they were looking for ‘pornographic materials and expired drugs, and that the other two were arrested shortly after Jembere addressed a rally on the constitution making process in Shamva.
He said that recently several MDC MPs, including Makoni South MP Pishai Muchauraya and Glen View MP Paul Madzore, have been summoned to court on similar charges of insulting Robert Mugabe. Senator Morgan Komichi has been taken to the courts for allegedly singing a song at a rally in January that insulted Mugabe.
Chamisa said: “It’s not just MPs but also ordinary MDC members who are being threatened. There is new wave of violence that is almost at par with what happened in June of 2008.”
The spokesperson said there is an increase in violence and cases of harassment because of the forthcoming constitution outreach programme, which starts across the country this month.
Daniel Makina
University of South Africa. [email: makind@unisa.ac.zam]
The paper presents a chronological unravelling of the political economy of Zimbabwe. It commences by giving an analysis of economic performance within a framework of four periods, namely, (i) the pre-independence period, (ii) the post-independence period of controls, (iii) the economic liberalization period and (iv) the economic crisis period. It proceeds to discuss the deterioration in economic performance emanating from inappropriate macroeconomic policies followed post-independence. The role of the monetary policy regime in exacerbating macroeconomic instability is also highlighted. Furthermore, the system of governance is noted to be another significant contributory factor to economic decline. One important insight from the analysis is that the economy had been operating sub-optimally throughout the post-independence period, a factor which is often ignored in research on Zimbabwe. Furthermore, if we take into account the lacklustre performance during the pre-independence period when it was under international sanctions, Zimbabwe could be said to have had ‘five lost decades’ –the 1960s, the 1970s, the 1980s, the 1990s and the decade commencing in the year 2000.
Full paper can be viewed here http://jds.sagepub.com/cgi/reprint/26/1/99
Veritas apologises for late distribution of this
bulletin, owing to ISP technical problems
[31st May 2010]
Media – An
Instrument for Peace or Violence?
With the principals
of both major political parties talking about the possibility of elections
being held next year, the use of hate speech and falsehoods by a partisan
public media becomes a burning issue. In the lead up to the March and
June 2008 elections the public media used hate speech extensively. [See Media Monitoring
Project of Zimbabwe [MMPZ] publication “The Propaganda War on Electoral
Democracy”: “(there was) a resurgence in the
use of ‘hate speech’ in the government controlled media aimed at publicly
discrediting ZANU-PF’s legitimate political opposition in a concerted campaign
to portray these groups as ‘traitors’, ‘sell-outs’ and ‘puppets’ intent on
undermining the country's sovereignty”.].
After the
Presidential run-off election in June the Pan-African Parliament Observer
Mission reported that “the State-controlled media was used as a vehicle to
discredit the opposition candidate in all forms” and summed up the effect
of hate speech during the campaign: “Hate speech, incitement of violence and
war rhetoric instilled fear and trepidation amongst voters.” The SADC
Observer Mission noted the “one sided
coverage in content and extent of one candidate on the part of the state media,
print and electronic.” [Both missions found the run-off election had not been free
and fair. It was not only unfair media coverage that did not permit fair
elections, but also that the period before the elections was marked by violence
– political murders, rapes, assault, destruction of dwellings, etc.] The
role of the media in whipping up violence before the 2008 elections has also
been documented by MMPZ in “The Language of Hate” [available on their website www.mmpz.org.zw].
The Zimbabwe Electoral
Commission [ZEC], obliged by law to monitor the media during the election
period to ensure “fair, balanced and equal or equitable coverage of
contestants”, reported that it had not been able to establish a “well
thought-out mechanism to effectively manage this function, let alone to develop
a good working relationship with media houses”, but cautiously admitted
that “the media found it challenging to comply with the regulations
and, in the main, their editorial policies influenced the content of their
publications on electoral issues”. ZEC said all newspapers had failed
to maintain fairness, and the period before the Presidential run-off election
had seen all of them “engaging in name-calling and the use of unrestrained
language”.
What is Hate Speech?
In MMPZ’s
“The Language Of Hate” hate speech is defined thus : “Hate speech is
bigoted language that attacks or disparages a social group or member of such a
group. The intention is to systematically undermine and subjugate the
identified victim using insulting and offensive language in order to destroy
the public reputation of the individual or group.” MMPZ adds: “By
its very nature hate language is specifically intended to excite hostility and
public contempt for those individuals or groups who are its targets to an
extent that the general perception is that they no longer deserve to have their
basic human rights protected.”
Hate Speech Can Be
Deadly
The
Rwanda Experience: The
use of hate language as “code words” to convey unspoken but unmistakable
meanings was demonstrated during the Rwanda genocide of 1994 during which Human
Rights Watch estimates 800 000 Tutsis were massacred and about two million were
displaced. With enough political will, Zimbabwe could draw some lessons
from the Rwanda experience. It is generally accepted that during this
tragedy the media, particularly Radio Television Libre des Mille Collines
[RTLM] and the state owned newspaper Kangura, played a crucial role in
fanning hostilities through the use of hate language against Tutsis. It
was noted that anti-Tutsi hate speech “became so systematic as to seem the
norm”. For example, RTLM began to routinely use the term Inyezi
[cockroach] to refer to Tutsis. Once people are de-humanized it becomes
easier to brutally kill them.
Hate
Speech in Zimbabwe: The
same resort to hate speech to dehumanize targeted groups of people
by referring to them as things has also been seen in Zimbabwe. At the
height of the Gukurahundi massacres, veteran nationalist leader Joshua
Nkomo was referred to as a “snake” whose head needed to be chopped off.
The Shona word Gukurahundi itself means “sweeping or washing away
chaff” and in this case the chaff represented people in Matabeleland, from
Nkomo’s ethnic group. In 2005, another form of purging or cleansing “rubbish”
was undertaken in the form of Operation Murambatsvina, the government
clean-up exercise which rendered about a million people homeless and robbed a
further two million of livelihoods.
The
gender-based angle to the Rwanda media campaign, featuring cartoons depicting
Tutsi women as sex objects, has been replicated in Zimbabwe. Slogans such
as “Let us see what a Tutsi woman tastes like” used by Hutu extremists
to justify rape and other sexual crimes have been echoed in this country.
Women victims of rape and other forms of violence whose ordeals are
recounted in Cries from Goromonzi, published by the Crisis in
Zimbabwe Coalition, have described being referred to as “Tsvangirai’s
prostitutes”.
The MDC
and its leader, Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai are routinely referred to in
the official media as “Western puppets” responsible for the imposition
of targeted sanctions on President Robert Mugabe and his inner circle.
Non-governmental organizations, trade unions, the Law Society of Zimbabwe,
human rights groups and many other organizations are routinely labelled “regime-change
agents” and accused of being in the employ of foreign governments.
The peddlers of propaganda, falsehoods and hate speech behave as though
repeating allegations often enough makes them true and valid.
The
assassination of character through the publication of false allegations about
groups or individuals is catastrophic for the victims. It often results
in assaults, abductions, torture, rape and arbitrary arrests when the
aspersions cast are seized upon by youth militias and other similarly
politically aligned entities as cues to pounce on those maligned in this
manner.
GPA Recognised the
Dangers of Hate Speech
Preamble: In the preamble to the Global Political Agreement
[GPA] the parties proclaimed their determination to “build a society free of
violence, fear, intimidation hatred, patronage, corruption and founded on
justice, fairness, openness, transparency, dignity and equality” and to act
in a manner that “demonstrates respect for the democratic values of justice,
fairness, openness, tolerance, equality, respect of all persons and human
rights”.
Article
19.1(e) of the GPA states that all three parties
agree: “…that the public and private media shall refrain from using abusive
language that may incite hostility, political intolerance and ethnic hatred or
that unfairly undermines political parties and other organizations. To
this end, the inclusive government shall ensure that appropriate measures are
taken to achieve this objective.”
GPA Prohibition of
Hate Speech Not Implemented
More
than a year after the formation of the Inclusive Government, commentators point
out there has been no let-up in party political propaganda in the state
controlled media – The Herald, The Chronicle, The Sunday Mail
and the Zimbabwe Broadcasting Corporation [radio and television]. The
People’s Voice, ZANU PF’s recently revived official organ, complements the
tone of state newspapers. The public media still adopts a hostile and
defamatory tone of reporting towards other political parties and organizations
or groups deemed to be opposed to President Mugabe’s policies. Reports
released recently by organizations such as the Civil Society Monitoring
Mechanism [CISOMM] and the Media Monitoring Project Zimbabwe [MMPZ] lament the
fact that the public media continues to function as a ZANU- PF mouthpiece [reports available at www.cisomm.org and www.mmpz.org.zw]. Based
on past experience, Zimbabweans have reason to be apprehensive about a biased
public media and its seeming impunity to prosecution for inaccuracies, in the
build-up to an election and its aftermath.
JOMIC [the Joint Monitoring and Implementation Committee set
up under the GPA] is supposed to monitor measures taken by the government to
restrain media use of abusive language that may incite hostility, political
intolerance and ethnic hatred. At an early meeting soon after the
formation of the inclusive government JOMIC received complaints from MDC-T
about abusive language in the public media – and from ZANU-PF about external
radio stations – and formed a Media Committee. JOMIC’s response, if any,
to these complaints has had no obvious effect on public media products. [Veritas has tried without success
to obtain JOMIC reports which should be publicly available.]
Organ
on National Healing and Reconciliation: The media can play such a critical role in the
incitement to violence that the Organ should also be looking into this.
The Organ has had a meeting with the Minister of Media Information and
Publicity and his Permanent Secretary and editors of State-controlled
newspapers. [Again Veritas has tried without success to get
feedback from the Organ.]
Parliamentary
Investigation: The House of
Assembly Portfolio Committee on Media, Information and Communication Technology
is due to finalise its report on the state of the public media this week.
Organisations and individuals giving evidence at well-attended public hearings
held by the committee expressed dissatisfaction with the public media’s
lopsided and partial approach. The committee’s report will not be
available to the public until it is presented to the House after it resumes on
30th June. [Veritas will
circulate the report as soon as it becomes available.]
ZMC a Ray of Hope?
Could
there be a light at the end of the tunnel? After a long delay in setting
up the Zimbabwe Media Commission [ZMC], Zimbabweans have welcomed the
registration by ZMC of five privately-owned newspapers, including the Daily
News. The nation now waits to see whether, when these publications hit the
streets, they help to counteract the propaganda in the State media. But
the ZBC’s continued monopoly of the airwaves, with no sign of new broadcasters
being permitted, is cause for continued concern.
Encouraged
by ZMC’s relatively prompt registration of the new newspapers and remembering
that the Constitution requires ZMC to “promote and enforce good practice and
ethics in the press, print and electronic media, and broadcasting”, the
nation also waits to see what impact the ZMC will have on the behaviour of the
public media.
Refusal of Renewal of
Newspaper’s Registration for Abuse of Freedom of Expression
Significantly, AIPPA authorises the ZMC to
refuse renewal of registration to a newspaper that has been convicted of abuse
of freedom of expression under AIPPA, section 64 [see below] or that has
published untruthful information and failed to publish a correction when
required to do so.
Abuse of freedom of
expression
Freedom of expression does not come without
responsibilities. There are stiff penalties for a newspaper or
broadcaster convicted of the offence of “abuse of freedom of expression”: a
fine of up to $5000 or up to three years’ imprisonment and the possibility
that when the time comes its registration will not be renewed by ZMC [AIPPA,
sections 64 and 66A]. Abuse of freedom of expression includes:
·
the
publication of information that has been intentionally or recklessly falsified
by the newspaper or broadcaster so as to injure the reputation, rights and
freedoms of other persons
·
the
publication of information that the newspaper or broadcaster has maliciously or
fraudulently fabricated
·
the
publication of statements that injure the reputation, rights and freedoms of
other persons when the newspaper knows the statements to be false or does not
have reasonable grounds for believing them to be true and nevertheless
recklessly, or with malicious or fraudulent intent, represents the statements
as true.
There is a similarly-worded offence entitled “abuse of
journalistic privilege” which is applicable to individual journalists; the
penalties on conviction are a fine of up to $400 or up to two years’
imprisonment [AIPPA, section 80].
Veritas makes every
effort to ensure reliable information, but cannot take legal responsibility for
information supplied.
BILL WATCH SPECIAL
[6th June 2010]
House of Assembly Portfolio Committees and Senate Thematic Committees:
Open Meetings 7th to 11th June
The
meetings listed below are open to members of the public, as observers only,
not as participants. [See note at the end of this bulletin on public
attendance and participation at different types of committee meetings.] Note:
This bulletin is based on the latest information provided by Parliament late on
4th June. Last-minute changes are, however, possible. So,
if you wish to attend any of the following meetings, Veritas recommends that
you avoid possible disappointment by first checking with the relevant committee
clerk that the meeting is still on and open to the public. Parliament’s
telephone numbers are Harare 700181 or 252936-55.
Meetings of Special
Interest
Monday morning: Public Service Commission acting chairperson giving
evidence on ghost workers in the civil service
Monday
afternoon: Reserve Bank
Governor giving evidence on Reserve Bank debts
Monday 7th June at 10
am
Public Accounts Committee
Oral evidence from Acting Chairperson of Public Service Commission on
ghost workers in the civil service
Committee Room No. 4
Chairperson:
Hon
Mashakada
Clerk: Mrs Nyawo
Portfolio Committee: Mines and Energy
Oral evidence from management of Shabanie and Mashaba Mines on their
operational challenges
Senate Chamber
Chairperson:
Hon Chindori-Chininga Clerk: Mr Manhivi
Monday 7th June at 2
pm
Portfolio Committee: Budget, Finance, Economic Planning and Investment
Promotion
Oral evidence from Reserve Bank Governor on Reserve Bank debts
Committee Room No. 4
Chairperson:
Hon Zhanda
Clerk: Mr Ratsakatika
Portfolio Committee: Justice, Legal Affairs,
Constitutional and Parliamentary Affairs
Oral evidence from University of Zimbabwe Vice-Chancellor on quality of
law students UZ is currently producing
Committee Room No. 413
Chairperson:
Hon T.
Matutu
Miss Zenda
Tuesday 8th June at 10
am
Portfolio
Committee: Health and Child Welfare
1.
Report back on measles outbreak outreach
2.
Oral evidence from Dr Vera on road accident emergency front
Committee
Room No. 1
Chairperson: Hon
Parirenyatwa
Clerk: Mr Ndlovu
Portfolio
Committee: Agriculture, Water, Lands and Resettlement
Oral evidence from the Attorney-General
on negotiations re unpaid balance from 1998
maize deal between Zimbabwe and Zambia
Committee Room No. 4
Chairperson:
Hon
Jiri
Clerk: Miss Mudavanhu
Portfolio Committee: Foreign Affairs, Regional
Integration and International Trade
Oral evidence from ZIMRA on operational improvements at Chirundu and
Beitbridge Border Posts
Committee Room No. 3
Chairperson:
Hon
Mukanduri
Clerk: Ms Macheza
No Meetings on Wednesday 9th June
Thursday 10th June at
10 am
Portfolio Committee: Women, Youth, Gender and Community Development
Oral evidence from Minister of Youth Development, Indigenisation and
Empowerment on the Indigenisation Regulations
Committee Room No. 3
Chairperson:
Hon
Matienga
Clerk: Mrs Khumalo
Thursday 10th June at
11 am
Thematic Committee: Indigenisation and Empowerment
Oral evidence from National Indigenisation and Economic Empowerment
Board on its programmes and activities
Government Caucus Room
Chairperson:
Hon Mutsvangwa Clerk: Mr Ratsakatika
Public Attendance
at and Participation in Committee Meetings
·
Not
open to the public:
Portfolio and thematic committee meetings in which the committees are doing private
business – e.g. setting workplans, deliberating on reports and findings, or
drafting reports for Parliament, or when the committees make field visits. [Veritas
does not list these in these bulletins.]
·
Open to
the public to attend as observers only: Portfolio and thematic committee meetings where oral
evidence is being heard. [As listed above.] If
attending, please use the Kwame Nkrumah Ave entrance to Parliament. IDs
must be produced.
·
Stakeholders
by invitation: At some committee
meetings stakeholders [and those who notify Parliament that they consider
themselves stakeholders and are accepted as such] are invited to make oral or
written representations and ask questions. [These meetings will be highlighted
in these bulletins.]
·
Public
Hearings: When committees call for public
hearings, members of the public are free to submit oral or written
representations, ask questions and generally participate. [Veritas
sends out separate notices of these public hearings.]
Note:
Zimbabweans in the Diaspora can send in written submissions to stakeholders’
meetings if they consider themselves stakeholders, and to public hearings, by
emailing their submissions to clerk@parlzim.gov.zw
Veritas makes every effort to ensure reliable
information, but cannot take legal responsibility for information supplied.
By Violet Gonda
8 June 2010
SW Radio Africa
Farai Maguwu finally appeared in court on Tuesday, six days after his initial arrest in Mutare, which was in violation of his constitutional rights. The Director of the Centre for Research Development (CRD) , an organisation that has been investigating rights abuses at the Chiadzwa diamond fields in Marange, is being accused of violating the Criminal Codification Act by allegedly publishing false information.
The State claims he did this ‘knowing that there would be a risk to Zimbabwe’s economic interest’ and that he allegedly ‘earned his living by damaging the government of Zimbabwe’.
Maguwu’s lawyers said they were surprised to see that while their client was initially arrested for recent communications about the controversial Chiadzwa diamonds to the Kimberly Process Monitor Abbey Chikane, these details were not placed before the court.
Lawyer Tinoziva Bere said: “He was definitely arrested on the grounds that he had said something or testified to Chikane and only the police can now answer why they are running away from the Chikane business. I don’t know the politics behind the charge but when he was arrested, his arrest record referred to Chikane.”
It is not yet clear how the State came upon the information with which they are charging the activist.
The Marange diamonds researcher had said that problems started for him when he held a confidential meeting with the South African KP monitor almost a fortnight ago in Mutare. Shortly after the meeting the police ransacked his home and office and confiscated documents and other properties, including his car. CRD staff members were forced to go into hiding and some of Maguwu’s family members were beaten up and arrested.
His lawyers said police have yet to return the confiscated assets and documents. Maguwu was supposed to travel to Israel this month as part of the Kimberley Process Civil Society Coalition, to present his organisation’s findings on the crisis in Chiadzwa, especially matters of human rights abuses.
Speaking to SW Radio Africa before his arrest Maguwu accused the KP monitor of setting him up and he is concerned that Chikane revealed some of the confidential issues they discussed to Zimbabwean authorities. Maguwu said: “And this setting up and all these nefarious allegations being levelled against me are simply meant to start a long legal battle that will keep me in the country and that will also paralyse the operations of our organisation. I think that was the intention of Chikane.”
Meanwhile the Crisis in Zimbabwe Coalition said: “Maguwu’s arrest is unwarranted interference with his liberty and with the work of CRD, calculated to cow civil society activists into ignoring abuses by government, particularly the military in the Marange diamond fields.”
The Kimberley Process Civil Society Coalition - including Global Witness, Human Rights Watch and Partnership Africa Canada - have said the KP approach on Zimbabwe is ‘very faulty’ and are calling for the suspension of the ‘monitoring arrangement in Zimbabwe, pending further investigations’.
However, in his official report on his findings at the Chiadzwa diamond fields, Abbey Chikane has reportedly said that Zimbabwe ‘complies with its minimum requirements and should be allowed to export its diamonds’.
By Violet Gonda
08 June 2010
SW Radio Africa
Ian Kay, the MDC-T MP for Marondera, was released on $500 bail on Monday. The police had ransacked his home last Friday, claiming they were looking for illegal firearms, pornographic materials and expired medical drugs. Kay is expected back in court towards the end of the month.
His wife Kerry Kay, who is also an MDC official, told SW Radio Africa on Tuesday that her husband committed no offence and the medicines he allegedly distributed in his constituency were part of a consignment that was donated by the Church of Latter-day Saints. The MDC official said the church has over the years been donating non-prescription drugs, such as vitamin tablets, whose life often exceeds the expiry date.
Also released on bail were Eliah Jembere, the MDC-T MP for Epworth, plus a senior MDC Mashonaland Central official, Gilbert Kagodora. They were arrested at the weekend for allegedly undermining the president, shortly after attending and addressing an MDC rally in Shamva. Their remand hearing is on 24thJune.
The MDC said in a statement that another Mash Central official, Isaac Mupinyuri, who was arrested in Guruve on similar charges after addressing another rally in Guruve South, was also released on free bail on Tuesday and is expected to appear in court on 22nd June.
In Manicaland province Teddy Chipere, the MDC-T Makoni Central chairperson, is expected to appear in court at the Mutare magistrates’ courts on Wednesday. He is facing similar charges of insulting Robert Mugabe. The MDC official is currently in police custody in Mutare and police failed to bring him to court on Tuesday claiming they were still investigating.
By Alex Bell
08 June 2010
SW Radio Africa
The three principals in Zimbabwe’s fragile unity government finally met on Tuesday for what is hoped was the long awaited discussion on the critical negotiators report, aimed at resolving the political deadlock.
Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai, Deputy Prime Minister Arthur Mutambara and Robert Mugabe, met after the Cabinet meeting ended on Tuesday afternoon. By Tuesday evening there were still no details about what was discussed, although it was believed that the report would be on the agenda. The three have not met since the report was compiled by party negotiators in April. Conflicting ‘travel schedules’ had been blamed for the delay that has effectively left Zimbabwe in limbo.
Mediation by the South African facilitation team under President Jacob Zuma’s leadership is dependent on the principals discussing their negotiators’ report. Zuma is then expected to present the report to President Armando Guebuza of Mozambique, the chairperson of the security arm of the Southern African Development Community (SADC), the Troika. All of this is part of regional plans to solve Zimbabwe’s political crisis, but there has been no urgency in dealing with the matter.
Previous scheduled meetings were all postponed, and Tuesday’s meeting is the first where all three leaders were available. Last week, Deputy Prime Minister Mutambara was not in the country to join Tsvangirai and Mugabe for talks, while the week before that, Tsvangirai called off a meeting saying he was ‘tired’ from his recent travels.
The usual issues that have stalled any progress by the already fragile unity government have been added to by Mugabe’s recent, unilateral appointment of new judges, that the MDC says was done behind its back. One of those appointed by Mugabe was the controversial former Zimbabwe Electoral Commission (ZEC) chairman, George Chiweshe, who is now Judge President of the High Court. Tsvangirai, who only read about the appointments in the state controlled Herald newspaper, has been expected to challenge Mugabe over the appointments, but that has not yet happened.
Meanwhile, there is a general sense of fatigue and growing cynicism over the handling of the political stalemate, with many analysts arguing that the outstanding issues will not be resolved any time soon. Other observers have commented that Zimbabweans are more concerned about the constitutional reform process and preparing for possible elections, rather than the ‘talks’. At the same time there is a growing concern from many by what they see as the MDC becoming complacent within the unity government
Veteran journalists and author Geoff Hill told SW Radio Africa on Tuesday that there is a sense among Zimbabweans that the MDC is becoming “comfortable” in government. He said this was a “dangerous” perception for the party, with rumours swirling that elections will be called soon. Hill said it was likely nothing significant will happen until the football World Cup in South Africa comes to an end in a month’s time, because President Zuma has called for calm from all African states while the spotlight shines on the continent. But Hill warned that after the tournaments ends, Mugabe could call an election.
“Mugabe and ZANU PF will have no gain, no advantage, by having these outstanding issues resolved,” Hill said. “It is more likely that they will prepare for elections and snatch-back power, and relegate the MDC back to being just an opposition party.”
By Lance Guma
08 June 2010
SW Radio Africa
The country’s first independent daily newspaper in seven years was this week being sold on the streets. Last Friday NewsDay, owned by Alpha Media Holdings, distributed free promotional copies of the paper. But on Monday morning it was time for the real business to begin as they began selling an estimated 20 000 copies of the paper to excited but slightly nervous readers.
Seven years ago the popular Daily News, owned by Associated Newspapers of Zimbabwe (ANZ), was shut down using a combination of repressive registration laws and a vicious campaign of intimidation and harassment that included bombing its printing press. Even as NewsDay was launched last Friday four members in its marketing staff were arrested and later fined for allegedly ‘obstructing traffic’. This was after information starved Zimbabweans jostled for the free copies of the paper.
The paper costs 50 US cents, but because of the problems with small change in the scarce foreign currency, people who pay US$1 are being given a plastic token that entitles them to buy the next issue of the paper.
The newspaper was sold in most cities like Harare, Bulawayo and Mutare but more remote areas like Kariba didn’t get the paper on the day of the launch.
NewsDay is one of four newspapers recently granted licences by the Zimbabwe Media Commission. The others include the Daily News, Daily Gazette and The Mail owned by Footlink Ventures, a ZANU PF youth organization. The Worker, a monthly publication from the Zimbabwe Congress of Trade Unions, received a licence to publish weekly. Despite the granting of these licences and this small opening up of the media space, Mugabe refuses to loosen his tight grip on broadcasting.
By Lance Guma
08 June 2010
SW Radio Africa
A former Zimbabwe student leader, turned successful businessman in Namibia, is being blocked from building a much needed clinic in his home area of Chegutu East by Information Minister Webster Shamu. Building plans for a clinic at the Chanakira Business Centre have been rotting in government offices for over 29 years, with a lack of resources blamed for the failure of the project to get off the ground.
Villagers are walking more than 15 km to the nearest clinic, despite government having earmarked the building of a clinic as a priority.
That was until former Harare Polytechnic student leader Charlton Hwende offered to fund the construction of the clinic. But he didn’t anticipate the fierce resistance from Shamu, the local ZANU PF MP for Chegutu East. The Minister ordered the District Administrator (DA) not to release the building plan paperwork, which was required before any work could begin.
Innocent Nhira, a Ward Secretary in the area, told Newsreel he had travelled to the DA’s offices to get the building plans but was told the ZANU PF MP had made it clear all development efforts had to come through his office.
Shamu remains determined to politicize the issue because Hwende is a member of the MDC. Hwende told us, ‘I was born in this area. My own grandmother lives here and also has to walk 15 km to the nearest clinic. I was approached by residents including my grandmother to help.’ He said there was no law that development projects had to go through the local MP and instead it was the local councilors he is dealing with that had a mandate to oversee development.
Another example of the tight grip the ZANU PF MP is exerting in the area came when Hwende bought chemicals for dipping cattle at the local dip tank. ‘Cattle in the area had not been dipped for nearly one and half years. I bought cement to fix parts of the dipping enclosure and also bought chemicals for the dip itself. But Shamu sent his people to tell me that if I wanted to help I had to write a letter to the Ministry of Agriculture asking for permission,’ Hwende said.
A community leader in the area told us Shamu’s behaviour was typical of how ZANU PF controls rural areas and monopolises all areas of people’s lives. ‘It’s a carefully layered patronage system where development is always promised in return for political support. In the case of Chegutu East, Shamu’s people are already mobilizing youths to spread the word that the MP has raised money to build the clinic, even though he was quiet about it all along.’
By Tichaona Sibanda
8 June 2010
SW Radio Africa
A coalition of churches in Zimbabwe has urged SADC to use their summit in August to put pressure on the political leadership to pave the way for free and fair elections next year.
A communiqué issued by the churches said free elections were the only route out of the country’s misery, which is being deepened by continued squabbling amongst the three coalition government partners.
The Legal Monitor, a weekly newsletter published by Zimbabwe Lawyers for Human Rights, quotes the churches saying unfair elections have been the source of conflict in the country.
‘The GPA is a transitional mechanism for the democratization of Zimbabwe which we will not allow to be permanent. We therefore demand that the SADC summit in August 2010 ensure that the elections are held in 2011,’ the communiqué said.
The churches’ communiqué was signed by the Zimbabwe Council of Churches and the Zimbabwe Christian Alliance.
Civil society partners - the Zimbabwe Peace Project, the Zimbabwe Election Support Network, the Crisis in Zimbabwe Coalition, the National Association of Non-Governmental Organizations and the Lutheran development Services - were all party to the communiqué.
Exiled Anglican Reverend Lameck Mutete told SW Radio Africa on Tuesday that it was the churches’ fundamental right to speak the truth in a non-partisan way.
Rev Mutete noted that the unity government has stabilised the country’s economy to improve the lives of ordinary Zimbabweans.
‘But you cannot say the same about political reforms and the never ending human rights abuses. The church has become the voice of the voiceless. They’ve realised the unity government is not working and their main challenge is to make sure that the next elections are conducted in a peaceful and free atmosphere,’ the Reverend said.
Dewa Mavhinga, the newly appointed regional coordinator for Crisis in Zimbabwe Coalition in South Africa, said the key to holding free and fair election is to have wholesale electoral reforms.
He said reforms would create a culture of transparency, fairness and openness to ensure that the outcome of the election was legitimate and acceptable to Zimbabweans and the rest of the world.
‘The current situation in the country does not provide a conducive environment for the holding of credible elections. We in the civil society will push for the political leadership to have substantive and meaningful reforms. We want an election whose outcome is uncontestable, legitimate and acceptable,’ Mavhinga said.
Already there is clear evidence that there is a surge in intimidation, harassment and violence waged by ZANU PF supporters against the MDC in rural areas.
Analysts say it is vital that the appropriate conditions be created now to ensure that by the time the country gets to an election, it would be peaceful and conducive enough to allow people to choose a party and a leader of their choice.
But reports from the countryside suggest ZANU PF has unleashed its violence machinery ahead of the constitutional making programme that begins next week Tuesday.
The MDC-T said in a statement on Tuesday that ZANU PF has set the stage for another wave of violence and intimidation to cow the people of Zimbabwe from participating in the outreach programme.
ZIMBABWE CONSERVATION TASK FORCE
8th June 2010
TRAGEDY AT CHIPANGALI
On the 1st of June 2010, Robyn Lotz, a 26 year old volunteer at Chipangali Wildlife Orphanage near Bulawayo, was attacked and killed by a fully grown male lion.
The lion had been moved into a security cage while Robyn and several other workers were loading bales of fresh grass into the main cage. Tragically, one of the workers had neglected to close the gate of the security cage properly and the lion attacked and pulled Robyn to the ground, seizing the back of her head in his mouth. Kevin Wilson, the proprietor of Chipangali shot the lion in an effort to save Robyn's life but sadly, she died upon arrival at the hospital.
We would like to extend our deepest sympathy to Robyn's family and to all those at Chipangali who were involved in this horrific incident.
THE DEATH OF THE MUSANGO BULL ELEPHANT
The Musango Bull Elephant was a magnificent animal, considered by some to be part of Zimbabwe's national heritage. He lived on the shores of Lake Kariba near the Bumi Hills area. On the 23rd of May 2010, he was shot in the Omay North area by a professional hunting organization despite the fact that he was wearing a clearly visible satellite tracking collar. For more details, see the pamphlet attached. If anybody would like to sign the petition, please email me.
SHARON PINCOTT - ELEPHANT AMBASSADOR
In the midst of
this latest elephant-related controversy, I looked back at a recent Getaway
magazine (April 2010) to a short article about the capture of wild elephants in
ANIMALS DYING ON STARVATION ISLAND
Starvation Island which previously had an area of 5 square kilometres has now shrunk to a third of its size due to rising water in Lake Kariba. Approximately 200 animals are in immediate danger of starving to death and some have already died or drowned in a desperate attempt to swim to the mainland, 3 kilometres away.
Elephants have managed to escape by swimming to the mainland but the smaller species such as kudu, buck, warthogs and monkeys are too weak to survive the marathon swim. Rescuers have managed to save some of the buck by holding their heads out of the water by their horns for the last stretch of their escape.
The animals are too weak to be darted and moved to the mainland so conservationists are trying to raise funds to feed the animals with hay bales and food blocks.
SILENT AUCTION
In an effort to raise funds, we would like to auction this painting by Cheryl Rodrigues.
LONE RANGER
MEDIUM: Oil on canvas
DIMENSIONS: 80cm x 60cm
RESERVE PRICE: USD2 000
CLOSING DATE: 30th June 2010
Shipping costs will be for the account of the buyer.
Musango Bull Elephant Info.pdf
Johnny Rodrigues
LINK: http://www.swradioafrica.com/pages/hotseat070610.htm
SW Radio Africa Transcript HOT SEAT : Arrested Zimbabwean diamond researcher ‘set up’ by KP Monitor On Hot Seat Violet Gonda has an exclusive interview with Farai Maguwu, the Director of the Centre for Research and Development ( CRD), who has been investigating human rights abuses at the Chiadzwa diamond fields. Maguwu was forced into hiding after police raided his office, his house and arrested and assaulted some of his relatives last week. On Thursday he handed himself in to Mutare police and was immediately arrested. The CRD has been forced to shut down and all staff are in hiding. Speaking the night before his arrest Maguwu accuses the Kimberley Process (KP) monitor to Zimbabwe, Abbey Chikane, of setting him up, as a result of a confidential meeting the two had about the ongoing militarisation of the diamond fields. Maguwu says his troubles started when Chikane (from South Africa) betrayed his confidence and shopped him to the police. BROADCAST: 04 JUNE 2010 |
|
FARAI MAGUWU: It all started on Tuesday last week, in fact prior to Tuesday, I received an email from Abbey Chikane requesting to meet me on his second visit to Zimbabwe and I duly agreed to meet him on Tuesday 25 th of May at 6pm and that particular day, 26 th of May, he called me early in the morning and it was around ten minutes to eight in the morning and he said he was no longer able to meet me in the evening, I should come in the morning. |
|
I told him it was a public holiday and I was not prepared to go to work early so I need some time to prepare and he kept on phoning, telling me that I have to come now because he wanted to proceed to Chiadzwa. Then I went to meet him at Holiday Inn and to my surprise, there were a lot of suspicious people sitting in the lobby and others were standing outside, so I discussed with him what we were observing in Marange especially with the issues of human rights abuses which are continuing, the issues of illegal panning activities and the smuggling of diamonds without the KP certification. Then the following day, that’s when we saw on television, the government alleging that Chikane’s emails had been intercepted and his itinerary had been ‘drafted by the Americans’. Then I immediately felt insecure and the following morning I did not go to work early suspecting that something was going to happen and then at around half past nine in the morning, a truckload full of men in suits pitched up at my home and they were armed to the teeth and when they were advancing to my door, I slipped through the window and then they went on to start beating my relatives at home and they took one of them into custody and they kept him in the police cells, beating him for the four days. He was arrested on Thursday and he was only released on Monday. So when I saw these events unfolding, I felt very insecure and I felt like they wanted to do a Ken Saro-Wiwa on me so I went into hiding. GONDA: Right and is there any understanding as to why exactly they were after you or they are after you? MAGUWU: They are charging me that I gave Chikane a State Security document which was drafted by the army and they are saying that was prejudicial to the State and that’s why they are looking for me. GONDA: And did you do this?
GONDA: So are you accusing the Kimberley Process monitor of setting you up and if so, why would he do this? MAGUWU: The reasons are to me, he is now part of the gravy train, there must be something that is going on behind the scenes between Abbey Chikane and ZANU PF officials who are plundering the Marange diamonds. And he obviously, him now being an interested party, if this case goes to court he is going to be a witness against me and him now being an interested party, it means he’s now working to advance the interests of one party against the other, that is the interests of the government against me. And the Centre for Research and Development is a member of the Kimberley Process Civil Society Coalition, and this month we were due to travel to Israel to present our findings of the goings on in Chiadzwa especially matters of human rights abuses which are continuing, panning and smuggling and this setting up and all these nefarious allegations being levelled against me are simply meant to start a long legal battle that will keep me in the country and that will also paralyse the operations of our organisation. I think that was the intentions of Chikane. GONDA: So has he made any statements or said anything about your harassment and I understand that not only was your brother in Mutare arrested but that your elder brother who’s at the University of Zimbabwe was also quizzed by the police?
GONDA: And were you given assurances by Chikane that whatever you discussed with him during that meeting would remain confidential? MAGUWU: In the beginning, before we started talking, I told Chikane we are living in a very difficult situation where human rights are not respected, where there is a rule by law and not rule of law and my life is not secure discussing these issues with you and I need your promise of confidentiality in everything that I’m going to discuss with you and he promised me and he gave me assurance that nothing that we were going to discuss was going to be revealed to anyone except only for his own mission to help him on his tour of Marange. GONDA: So what implications do you think what you are saying and what you are accusing the KP monitor of doing, what implications does this have on the KP itself and also with its relationship with civic groups in Zimbabwe? MAGUWU: I think it’s really going to affect the smooth running of the KP, especially given that Zimbabwe is taking centre stage in KP issues since 2008 and now that this monitor, he had been appointed to try to resolve these issues and also to work with all the stakeholders in trying to help Zimbabwe to get this certification. Now the civil society coalition in the KP obviously is very angered by this unfortunate and unprofessional behaviour by Chikane. He may be forced to withdraw, to halt his monitoring activities, possibly another monitor may have to be found who is agreeable to both the Zimbabwe and the KP membership but this behaviour is putting a dent on the KP operations and its credibility as an institution because Chikane was coming here holding the portfolio of the KP and representing the values of the KP and given this corrupt nature of his behaviour, he’s really a very terrible agent of such a very respectable organisation. GONDA: I understand from well placed sources that Chikane has defended his decision, he claims that you gave him the document, this document by the security forces, and he was saying that he handed it over to the security agencies to find out if it was ‘authentic’ because he didn’t want to be in possession of an ‘illegal document’. What do you think this is about then because it doesn’t add up? MAGUWU: Yah it’s true, I agree with you that it does not add up. I’ll give you an example, some few years ago, after Operation Murambatsvina the United Nations sent a special envoy to Zimbabwe and she met a lot of stakeholders and at the end of her fact-finding mission, she thanked everyone, she went out of the country, she did her work professionally which was well received by all Zimbabweans and she did not leave any Zimbabwean in danger because of confiding in her what really happened to the people and this is unlike Abbey Chikane, he is actually talking like a ZANU PF activist. He has no sympathy, he has got no empathy, he has no feeling for what is happening to me, to my family and to all the people I work with. Right now the organisation, everyone is into hiding. We expected him to protest to the Zimbabwe government that these people spoke to me in confidentiality and they were actually helping to make my mission possible but to our surprise it appears like he came as wolf in sheep’s clothing. So it’s quite very unfortunate that he is even having the audacity to say he went to the government to try to authenticate. In any case, if he receives any documentation, that’s why he was on a fact finding mission, he was supposed to go to Marange on his own and try to see whether whatever information he got from all quarters was correct, not for him to go to the government to say I received this document from so-and-so and is it true? That is very childish and primitive. GONDA: For the benefit of those people who would not know what your organisation actually does, can you tell us about your organisation and what were your finding?
GONDA: What about this ‘leaked document’ that was allegedly compiled by an assistant commissioner Mawere? What was he able to tell you about this document because I hear it also highlights the fact that there’s been no security sector reform under the Global Political Agreement and that JOC is still very much in control in the Chiadzwa area?
GONDA: Earlier on you talked about Chikane’s stolen emails. Now media reports actually quote him blaming the theft of his emails on ‘naughty intelligence’. In your view, was this an appropriate response from him? MAGUWU: He was actually showering praise on the person for his ingenuity in getting into his emails and the like. We were expecting Chikane to burst out of anger and say – how can this be, that the government has disrespected my person, they’ve disrespected my mission, how can a government agent break into my privacy? He was supposed to protest even to the KP chair and possibly he was supposed to walk out of the country and say I cannot continue with my mission because my security is not guaranteed. But to our surprise he went on even to promise that certification is within sight, within two weeks it should be done, which means he voluntarily gave this information to the government of Zimbabwe and he was trying to expose anybody - be these people be Zimbabwean or be American or British or South African - anyone who was trying to show him some elements of non-compliance, he exposed them to the government of Zimbabwe so that his relationship with the government is solidified for whatever benefits he is getting which we do not know. GONDA: Have you complained to the mother body, the actual KP to tell them about what has been happening or even the civil society in Zimbabwe, have they issued a statement to KP to complain?
GONDA: You are still in hiding but for how long? The police are still looking for you, what is your next move?
GONDA: And you feel that this is the best way to respond, bearing in mind what you were telling us about your family members being assaulted and arrested?
GONDA: Now I was actually going to ask you about those who are benefiting from the diamonds in Chiadzwa. Have you been able to actually gather the names of some of the people who are behind this plunder? And also do you know how much Zimbabwe is actually losing every month from diamond sales, from illegal diamond sales? MAGUWU: For now it is difficult for me to mention names but all I can say is that the two companies that were formed which are mining in Chiadzwa were illegally licensed to mine there, in that the Minister did not follow the government tender regulations in awarding these licences. But coming to the issue of the losses which the government is incurring, we do not have a round figure of the total sums of the loss which the government is incurring - but the calculations we did on Canadile Mining alone, we noted that about two thousand carats are being lost daily through smuggling and theft by workers who we think have actually overtaken the syndicates and the army in supplying diamonds to buyers. GONDA: And two thousand carats is roughly how much? Would you know?
GONDA: What about the issue of the human rights abuses?
And go all over the world there is nowhere where the military is involved in mining. The role of the military is to defend the country from external enemies. There are companies, there are a lot of Zimbabweans who are jobless. Unemployment rate is standing at about 85 per cent at the moment. We can’t say the government has failed to find people who can work in Marange and produce diamonds for the country. So the military has to be replaced by trained security guards. And also the other problem Violet I must bring to your attention is that Marange diamond field stretches for about 70 000 hectares. Of that 70 000 hectares only about less than ten per cent is under production and as long as all these vast fields are lying idle, the problem of panning will never stop and therefore we will always get this lame excuse that we need the military because we need to protect the diamond field. Why is the area lying idle when the country is keeping on singing this song that we don’t have money, we need help from outside? GONDA: So what about the inclusive government itself, especially the MDC? You’ve complained about the Mines Minister Obert Mpofu as being one of those people benefiting from what is happening in Chiadzwa. What is the MDC doing about it? Are you happy with the way the MDC is handling, if at all, this issue in Chiadzwa?
GONDA: I understand that recently a parliamentary committee was actually blocked from going or entering the Chiadzwa area, now I wonder have government ministers been able to go there?
GONDA: Right and of course I’m speaking to you on the night before you actually go and hand yourself in to the police. What’s going through your mind with all that has been happening to you?
I thank everyone who is standing with us at the CRD. There is a lot of support from civil society within Zimbabwe and beyond and I encourage everyone to know, to stand up for our resources. This is a rich country but the moment we remain silent about things that matter, this is when evil will thrive so we need to unite and stand up for what is right and denounce what is wrong. GONDA: Thank you Farai Maguwu for speaking to us on the programme Hot Seat. MAGUWU: Thank you very much Violet. GONDA: The director of the Centre for Research and Development was speaking to us the night before his arrest. Maguwu, who surrendered to the police on Thursday morning in the company of his lawyer, was immediately charged under the Criminal Law Codification and Reform Act for allegedly communicating falsehoods on the Chiadzwa diamond field activities to the Kimberly Process monitor. He is still being held in police cells in Mutare. Feedback can be sent to violet@swradioafrica.com |
MDC-USA. www.mdc-usa.org. Chinja Maitiro. Guqula Izenzo
Movement for Democratic Change United States of America
(MDC-USA)
Information and Publicity
Press Release June 2010
Most people agree that elections are the one and only way civilized nations decide who should
and who should not form the government of the country. In Zimbabwe developments in the
most recent past point to a disturbing trend where this tried and tested democratic tradition has
been turned upside down. Not only has the process of electing public officials itself been marred
with violence and death but even more disturbing with the refusal of those so resoundingly
rejected at the polls refuse to accept the verdict as handed down by the people. It is, sadly not
only a Zimbabwean first but also Kenyan phenomena, which one fears may turn out to be
Africa’s contribution to the democracy and elections debate in the halls of academia in world
universities and colleges. Sadly this is no longer theory but a very sad chapter in the ever
catastrophic African record of dictatorship, life presidency and kleptocracy.
MDC-USA notes with increased trepidation the ever increasing call for elections in Zimbabwe in
2011. Most recently, the MDC President and Zimbabwe Prime Minister, Morgan Tsvangirai, as
reported by Reuters said “Zimbabwe elections will go ahead next year, despite infighting that
continues to hamper the government power sharing agreement.” Prime Minister Tsvangirai
added a caveat we all agree with when he said, “When we emerge from the constitutional reform
program an agreed time frame for elections will be outlined.”
He also said something the people of Zimbabwe have been crying for that the ideal arrangement
is to “respect, (the) conduct of an election with a clear winner.” Deputy Prime Minister Arthur
Mutambara has been all over the map so much so that it is really difficult to ascribe him a
position on this issue. Suffice to say his recent statement while on a visit to Ghana didn’t
illuminate but muddled the waters even further.
Mr. Mutambara is also quoted by a New Zimbabwe.com reporter as having said that “We are
working on electoral reforms, economic, political reforms and constitutional reforms that will
make our elections free and fair.” In Zimbabwe, he added, “the question should not be about
how soon elections should be held, it should be about how to hold quality elections. There will be
no elections until such time when we are ready.” He however, revealed in the same piece that “it
will not go beyond 2013. We want to make sure that everything is set before elections are held,”
he pontificated in his usual professorial gibe.
President Robert Mugabe on the other hand, like Prime Minister Tsvangirai has indicated on
several occasions that elections would be held in 2011 whether the ongoing constitutional reform
process is concluded or not. Mugabe has already hinted and more recently during his birthday
interview that “he is ready to represent his ZANU PF party in the election which would go ahead
next year whether or not there was a new constitution.” If precedent is anything to go by,
Mugabe’s statement should not be taken lightly. Arbitrary decisions by ZANU PF in the
supposedly inclusive government should tell us who is to be believed. Like it or not whether
elections will be held in 2011 or 2013, the only difference between Prime Minister Tsvangirai and
President Mugabe is the completion or otherwise of the new constitution, its endorsement and
referendum.
Herein lays the problem we in the diasporas and particularly the MDC-USA finds disturbing. It is
the total absence and total disregard of fair, just and peaceful elections whose results will be
respected by all parties that the three principals should be falling over each other to address first.
It is also the lack of consensus within the GPA as to what should occur first, the constitution and
referendum, the MDC –T position or political opportunism as is exemplified by ZANU PF and
MDC-M. To ZANU PF it is always the political environment first and elections conduct second.
Any signs of negative voter perception is a trigger for more violence and elections soon after.
Their mantra is cow the electorate, beat the population to pulp and then conduct a sham election.
If that result does not confirm them as the eternal rulers of the country, delay announcing results,
manipulate the numbers and invite only those observers of a like mind who will declare the
violent charade as free and fair even if it is patently clear that the process was flawed.
Zimbabwe has had a tradition of holding some form of elections beginning with the historical
1980 elections that ushered in the government of Robert Mugabe after the protracted armed
struggle. Imagine Ian Smith et al had at that time behaved the way Mugabe and his coterie are
behaving now. The war would have continued. And rightly so the international community
would have condemned let alone intensified the sanctions against the country. Fast forward to
the year 2000 when ZANU PF for the first time had a credible opposition at its hands. We knew
all along that ZANU PF had unparallel degrees in political violence. What we didn’t know was
the extent to which those degrees could be unleashed against fellow citizens for the sake of
ZANU PF continued stranglehold on power.
There is no denying that the country needs a new government and soon. But to pretend that we
can hold the next elections on the basis of the current constitution and under the same conditions
and supervision by a handpicked group of observers is the height of naïveté. ZANU PF is a
violent party. ZANU PF is not about to become some civilized political contestant pledging to
abide by the same rules that govern elections elsewhere in the civilized world. It is also naïve to
assume that the new constitution will fundamentally change ZANU PF from a violent to an
accommodating political party willing and able to accept the electoral results.
Quite the contrary. We in MDC –USA strongly feel that a lot has been achieved by the Unity
government in terms of the quality of the people’s lives, but this does not in any way mean
ZANU PF has been transformed. Until and unless ZANU PF disavows itself of the notion that the
country owes them eternal gratitude for the liberation of the country, we can forget that a paper
constitution can achieve what the collective conscience of ZANU PF has failed to do regardless of
all their Christian protestations.
The constitution making process is a good thing for our country. The threat by civil society to
pull out of the constitution making process is enough evidence that politicians want to have their
cake and eat it. There are not only financial hurdles to this process, but also increased violence
ahead of the public consultation period. Evidence abounds of ZANU PF thugs targeting several
communities and “reeducating” them on what to say and not to say during the outreach
programs. This is hardly the recipe of a people driven constitution let alone one that will usher in
a new political dispensation we can all live with and be proud of. It is not the enshrinement of a
life presidency in the constitution either. We may have that clause. What matters is whether
people will be able to freely and without intimidation vote for the political party and or
candidates of their choice. This is the crux of the matter. Political violence and intolerance
currently define us as a people. We do not need a new constitution in our opinion to change these
atavistic tendencies. They are bad for business plain and simple. ZANU PF needs to understand
that violence is the source of our international estrangement, of the mass exodus of its best men
and women, of the collapse of its infrastructure and also sadly of turning this once bread basket
of the region to a basket case.
Local, regional and international observers cannot prevent our people from being killed by
political thugs. Observers cannot expedite the process of announcing results and observers
cannot compel the losing candidate to concede defeat if they refuse to do so. It is our belief as a
nation in the sanctity of elections that the process of choosing who shall run the affairs of our
country should be entrusted. None of that will be achieved as a result of a new constitution,
desirable though it may be. It is a whole change of national psyche, a desire by all political
leaders regardless of party affiliation to respect the will of the people. Until and unless that
national moral turnaround is achieved we can have all the paper constitutions we need and the
dictatorial tendencies among us will always rear their ugly heads. Unfortunately, people will die,
needlessly and the country we all love so much will continue to bleed and provide,
unfortunately, the unenviable moniker of how not to run the affairs of the state. Elections yes, but
not over the citizens dead bodies.
Vigil supporters
were encouraged by a call from Zimbabwean Christian leaders for new elections
under international supervision. The Zimbabwe Council of Churches, Zimbabwe
Christian Alliance and
The
statement (The Zimbabwean: http://bit.ly/9C3OEO)
is the latest of a series of calls for new elections as impatience grows at the
inertia of the ZANU-MDC coalition.
The three
principals seem to be engaged in a game of GPA talks avoidance. As we noted in
last week’s diary a scheduled meeting of the principals was postponed because
Tsvangirai was tired after his latest international posturing. The meeting was
rescheduled and Vigil supporters were not surprised when this meeting also
didn’t happen – this time because Mutambara was in
Mutambara, of course,
will stop at nothing to sabotage any change whatsoever. He said “when you start
talking about elections, you make people confrontational. It is distractive and
unhelpful to the process of reforms.” (http://www.swradioafrica.com/news020610/threeprinc020610.htm).
Well the Vigil
rejects Dimwit Mutambara’s self-serving argument and also the demands that
various conditions must be met before new elections are called. We believe that
the only demand should be that Zanu PF is prevented from terrorizing the
electorate. Any other conditions will be manipulated by the three principals to
provide reasons to postpone elections.
The Vigil gathers
that the other Deputy Prime Minister, Thokozani Khupe, is planning a visit to
the
The Vigil took as a sign of the future the
takeover of a block of flats in
We
were impressed by the initiative of the officer in charge of Harare Remand
Prison, Chief Superintendent Chibaya, who closed the prison’s juvenile section
and used the cells to house his chickens (leaving the juveniles at the risk of
abuse by adult prisoners) – check: http://www.zimeye.org/?p=180300. At
a meeting with his bosses who ordered him to move the chickens out, he in
characteristic Zanu PF fashion said they should instead be hunting down the
person who gave the information to the press.
Other points
· After a long spell of
ill-health, it was good to have Geraldine Takwanda back with us looking well.
· We were joined by a
lady who was silver from top to toe – make-up, hair dye and clothes – just part
of the kaleidoscope of
· Supporters have been
following with pride the progress of the act ‘A3’ comprising three Zimbabwean
brothers who came third in their semi-final of the TV show ‘
For latest Vigil pictures check: http://www.flickr.com/photos/zimbabwevigil/.
For the latest ZimVigil TV programme check the link at the top of the home page
of our website. For earlier ZimVigil TV programmes check: http://www.zbnnews.com/home/firingline.
FOR THE RECORD: 146 signed the
register.
EVENTS AND NOTICES:
· Two opportunities to meet Philip
Barclay, a diplomat stationed at the British Embassy in
· OTIENO by Trevor
Michael Georges.
A contemporary reworking of Shakespeare's Othello, set against the continuing
deprivation of present-day
· ROHR
South
·
ROHR
· ROHR
· Church Service in Support
of Zimbabwean Victims of Torture. Saturday
26th June from 12 -1.30 pm. Venue:
· ROHR
· Campaign on behalf of
Zimbabweans with disputed nationality. There is a possibility that the group known
as London Citizens may launch a campaign on behalf of Zimbabweans with disputed
nationality (such as arriving in the
·
· Zimbabwe
Association’s Women’s Weekly Drop-in Centre. Fridays 10.30 am – 4 pm. Venue: The
Fire Station Community and ICT Centre,
· Strategic Internship
for Zimbabweans organised by Citizens for Sanctuary which is trying to
secure work placements for qualified Zimbabweans with refugee status or asylum
seekers. For information: http://www.citizensforsanctuary.org.uk/pages/Strategic.html
or contact: zimbabweinternship@cof.org.uk.
· For Motherland ENT’s
videos
of the Vigil on
Vigil
Co-ordinators
The Vigil, outside the Zimbabwe Embassy, 429
FYI, WHO colleagues there confirmed
that today is expected to be the last day of the campaign and
they provided an updated number of children vaccinated
against measles so far to 4.7m, with 1.5m receiving Vit A. The
campaign, which was expected to conclude on 2 June, has been extended
slightly in some areas to ensure the target population was reached by
vaccinators.
Also find these updates at http://www.who.int/hac/crises/zwe/sitreps/measles_immunization/en/index.html
ZIMBABWE Measles Immunization and Child Health
Days campaign 2010
(24 May to 2 June)
Campaign diary day 10: 2 June 2010
The campaign came to its scheduled end on
2 June. By the end of Day 10 (2 June), 4496 408 children had been vaccinated against
measles and 1 465 974
had received vitamin A
supplements.[1] Approximately 79% of the targeted children for measles and 76%
for vitamin A supplementation were reached. In terms of population vaccine
coverage in different provinces, Chitungwiza, Harare [2] and Manicaland have
either reached or surpassed the 95% benchmark. Mashonaland East, Masvingo,
Midlands, Bulawayo and Mashonaland West range between 80-86% coverage while
Mashonaland Central, Matabeleland North and South range from 75-76%. So far, the national
coverage stands at 79%. See graph.
Following discussions
held between the national coordinating committee and provincial medical
directors, it was decided that Beitbridge (Matabeleland South Province), Gokwe
South (Midlands) and Bulawayo would extend their campaign dates by one day,
during which they would conduct “mop up” activities. It was agreed that all
immunization activities would be concluded by the end of 4 June. The mop up
activities consist of visiting areas that failed to achieve their targets as
well as newly discovered areas for example recently registered schools in
Bulawayo and Beitbridge, religious gatherings and others.
[1] The
reports received were incomplete and these figures are expected to change
[2] The administrative (but not functional)
boundary of Harare city includes Epworth, Seke district-the current population
is being verified with the Central Statistics Office.
Photo
captions:
Picture 1: Dr Kampo, UNICEF supporting immunization of
school children in Mberengwa, Midlands; Picture 2: Mothers queuing for
vaccination, Bulawayo (credit: Abou Kampo/UNICEF)
For more information, please contact:
Wendy Julias
World Health Organization
+263 (4) 253 724
+263 (91) 243 1408
JuliasW@zw.afro.who.int
Dear Family and Friends,
When Finance Minister Tendai Biti suspended use of the Zimbabwe dollar in February 2009, the country breathed a huge sigh of relief.
Within a fortnight hyper inflation, which was then in the billions of percentage points, dropped to almost zero. A couple of weeks later the black market, which had turned bums and thugs into multi billionaires, also disappeared. Currency dealers who had brazenly parked their fancy cars outside empty banks and conducted massive deals from the trunks of their vehicles, also disappeared. Suddenly Zimbabwe had joined the real world and Minister Biti announced that we were now a multi-currency economy and trade would be allowed in US Dollars, British Pounds, Botswana Pula and South African Rand.
Dealing in real money for the past 15 months has given us all a sense of security again and although the cost of living is still far above people's wages, we've felt a permanence having Dollars, Pounds, Pula and Rand in our pockets.
Permanence disappeared in an instant this week when by chance someone mentioned the withdrawal from circulation of the 200 South African Rand note at the end of May. I thought it was a joke at first, a rumour or scare mongering and the obvious way to find out for sure was to phone the bank.
Having been a customer of this international bank for 35 years and of my local branch for 20 years I was sure they'd be able to help. This wasn't those silly Zim dollars with masses of zeroes we were talking about after all, this was "real money."
"No," the man at the bank said, "the 200 Rand notes are no longer acceptable."
When I said I hadn't heard that the notes were being withdrawn he said that the Reserve Bank had made the announcement in February.
"Our Reserve Bank?" I asked.
"No, the South African Reserve Bank?" he replied.
"But we're not in South Africa! And you haven't let your customers know!" I exclaimed but this conversation was going nowhere fast.
Then the stuttering began and the excuses followed in rapid
succession:
"We, we, we, flighted a notice in the press for 2 weeks," bank man said.
When I asked which newspaper he said: "The Herald of course."
"Why of course?" I asked. "Who reads the Herald? What about in the Independent Press?"
He said no, they'd only advertised in the Herald.
There was no answer to my query as to why the bank couldn't have written, phoned or emailed their customers to warn them that their "real money" was about to become worthless. Needless to say the bank refused to take my 200 Rand notes and their only advice was that I should travel to South Africa and try and change them there myself.
Is that what I'll I have to do when a British pound denomination note is withdrawn, or a US dollar one, travel to those countries? And what about all the people deep in Zimbabwe's remote rural areas with a few 200 Rand notes tucked away in a safe place for an emergency? Its obscene to think that their precious money, sent home by loved ones slaving away in South Africa, has become good for starting the fire.
This, along with daily power cuts lasting from 5 am till 10 pm and no water for 4 days - even for the schools and hospitals, has made for a very trying week in Zimbabwe. Relief didn't even come with the warm up football match between Zim and Brazil because there was no electricity to watch it.
This might all sound very funny to the outsider, but its real life in Zimbabwe!
Until next week, thanks for reading, love Cathy Copyright cathy buckle 5 June 2010. www.cathybuckle.com <http://www.cathybuckle.com/>
For information or orders of my new book about Meryl Harrison's animal rescues: "INNOCENT VICTIMS" or previous books "African Tears"
and "Beyond Tears," or to subscribe/unsubscribe to this newsletter, please write to: cbuckle@mango.zw <mailto:cbuckle@mango.zw>