HARARE, March 4 (Reuters) - President Robert Mugabe has managed to get rid of white Chief Justice Anthony Gubbay, but he has not broken the independent spirit of Zimbabwe's judiciary, political analysts and legal experts say.
Gubbay's four Supreme Court colleagues and many of the 24 High Court judges have a record of fearless and independent action and are likely to continue to measure Mugabe against the constitution and protection of human rights.
As a result the former guerrilla leader, hoping to extend his 21-year rule in elections due within 14 months despite discontent over the collapsing economy and alleged corruption, is likely to pursue his unprecedented war against the judiciary, media and opposition.
"We should be able to continue enjoying an independent judiciary if the executive stops tampering with judges. Many of them are quite professional," said Lovemore Madhuku, a constitutional law lecturer at the University of Zimbabwe.
Mugabe made an uncharacteristic climbdown on Friday, avoiding a constitutional crisis by giving Gubbay room to leave office with some dignity through retirement.
The government backed down from a bid to kick Gubbay out in humiliating fashion, instead signing a compromise deal including the withdrawal of all allegations of bias against him.
GUBBAY ON IMMEDIATE LEAVE
Gubbay and Justice Minister Patrick Chinamasa said in a joint statement he would go on pre-retirement leave immediately and would retire 10 months early at the end of June.
For two days Gubbay, 69, had defied an order to take early retirement from March 1 while the government insisted he was retired and that it could appoint a successor.
"The government made some concessions in terms of both style and substance," said political analyst Emmanuel Magade, a law lecturer at the University of Zimbabwe.
"Instead of running him out of his chambers, they talked him out, and the substance is that by that route, they just managed to avoid a crisis of having two men, each claiming to be the chief justice," he told Reuters.
Political and legal experts say by defying the government and forcing it to negotiate, Gubbay dramatised the predicament of the judiciary, claimed the moral high ground and possibly slowed Mugabe's campaign to drive other judges off the bench.
The settlement acknowledged the independence of the courts and that "any action by any party to undermine or interfere with that independence is contrary to the interests of the people of Zimbabwe."
Analysts said the judiciary would be irreparably damaged only if Mugabe pursued plans to get rid of at least a quarter of the country's 24 High Court judges and the remaining four judges in the Supreme Court.
Both the supreme and high courts are racially mixed.
FIGHT'S NOT OVER YET
Magade said the government was unlikely to totally abandon its programme to intimidate the judiciary, the media and the opposition ahead of the elections.
"To the extent that this is a political programme ahead of elections, it might not all go away."
Mugabe's black war-veteran supporters, who are spearheading his election campaign against unprecedented opposition from the Movement for Democratic Change (MDC), are threatening to oust more judges despite the government's agreement with Gubbay.
"We will continue fighting them. If they want us to use violence, then we are going to do that," war veterans' leader Chenjerai Hunzvi told the Sunday Standard.
But Sternford Moyo, president of the Law Society of Zimbabwe, said the deal with Gubbay had given the nation an opportunity to defend the independence of the judiciary.
"What is important is what is going to happen from now. People must stand up to defend their institutions, and the legal process. I believe the government was persuaded to change its stance because it realised it had a weaker case."
The government had charged that it wanted Gubbay and the other Supreme Court judges out because they had a colonial "Rhodesian mentality" favouring Zimbabwe's minority white community and the opposition.
Gubbay, who has challenged Mugabe's use of decrees to bypass the constitution on several issues, raised the temperature in December when his court ruled against the president's controversial land-seizure programme.
The Supreme Court and some lower courts had also during 2000 ordered the government to evict militants from Mugabe's ruling ZANU-PF party who invaded hundreds of white-owned farms in support of his drive to appropriate land for blacks.
HARARE, Mar 5, 2001 (Xinhua via COMTEX) -- Zimbabwean Vice President Joseph Msika Sunday warned war veterans from taking the law into their own hands by purging government officials suspected of supporting the opposition Movement for Democratic Change (MDC), a party which he said is trying to take the country back to colonialism, The Daily News reported on Monday.
Msika's warning came less than a month after he made a blistering attack on the war veterans for closing and besieging almost all government offices of Matabeleland Province.
He described the war veterans' actions as unruly behavior, which is not befitting for former freedom fighters.
Addressing more than 2,000 former freedom fighters in Bulawayo, the country's second largest city, Msika said: "When we fought the war, we had discipline. Some of the things you are doing now, leave a lot of question marks. Do not destroy institutions of the government when you are part of the government."
Msika further pointed out that the MDC is a "dangerous movement " which should not be allowed to exist.
He added the government and his ruling party will not go back on the land reform program and will not cooperate with white commercial farmers for allegedly spurning the government's hand of reconciliation.
"Whites can not tell us about human rights and fairness when they are still clinging to our land. We will take back our land and then we will start talking about the rule of law," the vice president added.
HARARE, Zimbabwe (Reuters) - Zimbabwean police launched a manhunt Monday for gunmen who killed the mother of a farmer slain last year at the start of a government campaign to seize white-owned farms for redistribution to blacks.
Chief Superintendent Wayne Bvudzijena said police were searching for a gang of men who had shot dead 68-year-old Gloria Olds Sunday at her farm near Zimbabwe's second city, Bulawayo, and fled in her truck.
"There is a massive manhunt going on right now. We have also invited experts to analyze evidence at the scene," Bvudzijena told reporters.
He added: "It appeared to be a plain robbery in which the suspects were targeting motor vehicles at the Olds property."
Police have made no arrests so far in the cases of seven white farmers murdered last year.
Police officials in Bulawayo told Reuters they had recovered Olds's Toyota Hilux truck abandoned in Pumula, a sprawling township on the western outskirts of the city.
"We got the car, but we have not made any arrests yet," said a police officer.
Bvudzijena said the police investigation into Olds's murder had been delayed Sunday after her surviving son, David, drove from Bulawayo and locked himself in the house with a firearm and his mother's body.
He refused entry to anyone for several hours, including neighboring farmers and the police. The body was later moved to a city mortuary.
Gloria Olds was found dead Sunday on the farm in the Nyamandlovu district where she lived alone.
Farmers, who rushed to the murder scene, reported that she had been shot 15 times in a dawn ambush as she opened a gate to her farmhouse and that 30 empty cartridges had been recovered.
Olds's three dogs were also shot dead, they said.
Her other son, Martin, was the second of five white farmers killed last year in a land-grab sanctioned by President Robert Mugabe and spearheaded by veterans of the former Rhodesia's 1970s liberation war.
Martin Olds was killed when more than 100 war veterans surrounded his home and opened fire. His wife and two children later sought political asylum in Britain.
Two more white farmers were killed last year in apparent robberies.
UNEASY TRUCE ON FARMS
The Commercial Farmers' Union (CFU), grouping 4,500 mainly white farmers, condemned Olds's murder, saying the government must move fast to restore law and order in the country.
The Olds family was unavailable for comment Monday. Friends said they were busy organizing Gloria's funeral.
Sunday's shooting came two days after a war veteran threatened white Chief Justice Anthony Gubbay with "war" if he refused to obey a government order to take early retirement.
Gubbay agreed the following day to go on leave immediately and to retire 10 months early on July 1, clearing the way for Mugabe to appoint a new head of the judiciary.
Mugabe, ministers and war veterans had criticized Gubbay and other white judges for decisions favoring white farmers.
Self-styled war veterans, many too young to have served in the liberation war which led to Rhodesia's independence from Britain in 1980, have occupied hundreds of white-owned farms.
Some farmers have abandoned their lands near Harare and Bulawayo in the face of threats and violence from war veterans.
Others have continued to farm in an uneasy cooperation with war veterans who have kept at least a token presence on many farms earmarked for redistribution to landless black peasants.
BRUSSELS, March 5 (Reuters) - Zimbabwe's President Robert Mugabe confronted European critics of his human rights record on Monday during a one-day trip to Belgium which included a bid to "arrest" him by a gay rights campaigner.
Mugabe, rapped by the West over his drive to seize white-owned farms and his intimidation of Zimbabwe's independent media and judiciary, is a special hate figure for homosexuals, whom he has branded as "dogs."
The veteran African leader steered well clear of reporters during his visit but his bodyguards had to intervene when Peter Tatchell, a prominent British gay rights campaigner, tried to make a citizen's arrest of their president.
Tatchell yelled "Arrest Mugabe, arrest the torturer" as Mugabe left the Hilton Hotel in Brussels.
In the ensuing scuffle, Tatchell was pushed to the ground. He said he had been punched by a Zimbabwean bodyguard.
"I am OK, I fell down," he told reporters.
"I said the president should be arrested for the crime of torture under the 1984 United Nations' Convention on Torture of which Belgium is a signatory," Tatchell said.
Tatchell and two other members of their group OutRage also tried to effect a citizen's arrest last October during a private visit by Mugabe to Britain.
MUGABE SAYS JOURNALISTS SAFE
In his talks with Belgian Prime Minister Guy Verhofstadt and other officials, Mugabe defended his human rights record and also pledged to support the fragile peace process in the Democratic Republic of Congo, a former Belgian colony.
"President Mugabe denied rumours that he was planning to expel all foreign journalists from Zimbabwe," Verhofstadt's spokesman Alain Gerlache told Reuters.
He said Mugabe had also given assurances to Belgium about the freedom of Zimbabwe's judiciary, noting last week's decision to reinstate Chief Justice Anthony Gubbay until July 1 and the withdrawal of allegations of bias against him.
For two days, Gubbay, 69, had defied a government order to take early retirement from March 1 while the government insisted he had retired and that it would appoint a successor.
Mugabe's supporters have threatened to chase some white judges out of courtrooms and to invade the homes of those seen as opposed to the government.
Gerlache said Verhofstadt and Foreign Minister Louis Michel had urged Mugabe to protect the life and property of white farmers, who include a small number of Belgians, in Zimbabwe.
But he said Mugabe had reiterated the official line that some farmland should be redistributed to black Zimbabweans.
European Commissioner for Development Poul Nielson raised the EU's worries about human rights in Zimbabwe over a lunch meeting with Mugabe. The two sides agreed to launch a formal "political dialogue" over the concerns, EU officials said.
ZIMBABWE COULD PULL OUT TROOPS
Belgium invited Mugabe mainly to discuss the latest efforts to cement peace in Democratic Congo, Zimbabwe's vast, mineral- rich neighbour. Zimbabwe is a key ally of Congo President Joseph Kabila.
Belgian officials quoted Mugabe as saying he was ready to withdraw Zimbabwean troops from Congo in the right conditions.
"He fears a political and military vacuum if the troops pull out," said Foreign Ministry spokesman Koen Vervaeke, adding that Mugabe had stressed the need for dialogue between all parties to the Congolese conflict.
Belgian Foreign Minister Michel also held talks on Monday with Ketumile Masire, the former Botswanan president who is now mediator in the Congolese conflict. Masire told Michel he would return to Kinshasa, the Congo capital, later this month.
Hopes for peace in Congo have risen since Kabila succeeded his slain father as leader in January. Rwanda and Uganda, which back the rebels, have begun withdrawing their troops.
BRUSSELS, March 5 (Reuters) - A prominent British gay rights campaigner tried to make a citizen's arrest of Zimbabwe's Robert Mugabe on Monday over his human rights record, but was knocked to the ground by the president's bodyguards.
Mugabe, who is on a one-day visit to Belgium for talks about the central African peace process, is a hate figure for many homosexuals, whom he has branded as "dogs."
Peter Tatchell of the British gay rights group Outrage yelled "Arrest Mugabe, arrest the torturer" as the veteran African leader left the Hilton Hotel in Brussels.
In the ensuing scuffle, Tatchell was pushed to the ground.
"I am OK, I fell down," he told reporters afterwards.
"I said the president should be arrested for the crime of torture under the 1984 United Nations' Convention on Torture of which Belgium is a signatory," Tatchell said.
He accused the Belgian police of allowing Mugabe's security guards to physicallly assault him.
Tatchell and two other members of the Outrage group tried to effect a citizen's arrest in October during a private visit by Mugabe to Britain.
After the incident on Monday in Brusssels, Mugabe held talks with Belgian Prime Minister Guy Verhofstadt and Foreign Minister Louis Michel about the peace process in the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC), a former Belgian colony.
Zimbabwe is a key ally of the DRC's President Joseph Kabila, who is struggling to put an end to Africa's biggest war.
Separately, European Development Commissioner Poul Nielson pressed the concerns of the European Union about human rights in Zimbabwe during a lunchtime meeting with Mugabe.
"It was a frank and very open discussion," Commission spokesman Reijo Kemppinen told Reuters.
He said the two sides had agreed to open a "political dialogue" to examine the EU's concerns, which include freedom of the press and of the judiciary in Zimbabwe and also Mugabe's drive to seize white-owned farms without compensation.
Zimbabwe last week averted a constitutional crisis by reinstating Chief Justice Anthony Gubbay until July 1 and withdrawing allegations of bias against him.
For two days, Gubbay, 69, had defied a government order to take early retirement from March 1 while the government insisted he had retired and that would appoint a successor.
President Robert Mugabe's supporters have threatened to chase some white judges out of courtrooms and to invade the homes of those seen as opposed to the government.
Harare, Mar 05, 2001 (Zimbabwe Standard/All Africa Global Media via COMTEX)-- The government has approached several senior black lawyers to sit on the High Court and Supreme Court benches to replace judges earmarked for retirement, The Standard has learnt.
According to sources, the minister of justice, legal and parliamentary affairs, Patrick Chinamasa, held a series of meetings with black lawyers last week, in an attempt to induce them into taking up the offers.
The highly placed sources said most of the senior lawyers were considering the offer but first wanted to see how the impasse between the judiciary and executive would be resolved.
Amongst the senior lawyers that are for consideration on the bench are: Aston Musunga, Simplious Chihambakwe, George Chikumbirike and William Chirambasukwa.
Contacted for comment on the issue, Aston Musunga denied ever being approached by Chinamasa: "It is only a rumour. I was never approached to take up the post at the bench. Of course with the years of my experience in law, I qualify, but I have not been approached."
When contacted for comment on Friday, Chihambakwe's secretary said he was in a meeting, and was to contact the paper when he was free, which he never did.
Contacted for comment on Thursday, Chinamasa said: "I don't want to discuss the matter with the press. We shall be making a statement on the issue".
The High Court judges being targeted are Michael Gillespie, Mohamed Adam, Fergus Blackie and George Smith. The justices from the supreme court are Wilson Sandura, Simba Muchechetere, Nicholas McNally, Ahmed Ebrahim, while Chief Justice Anthony Gubbay has said he will retire in July.
The government had initially tried to push Gubbay out of office, but the Chief Justice stood his ground and vowed that he would not be pushed from office unceremoniously.
Such was the hostility against Gubbay and the judiciary that government ministers, war veterans and Zanu PF supporters had developed the habit of making derogatory statements against the judiciary without fear.
But on Friday the government was forced to swallow its pride: "All public statements, pronouncements and other language used by the minister or any other members of government or Zimbabwe, whether privileged or not, impugning, demeaning or putting in question the good name, reputation, honour and integrity of the Chief Justice, either in his official or personal capacity, have been withdrawn without reservation.
"It is agreed that no further statements of this nature will be made," said a Chinamasa.
Even the minister of state information and publicity, Jonathan Moyo, was uncharacteristically humble: "We need to give each and all of them (judges) the respect they deserve and for this reason we pay tribute to the Chief Justice and the contribution he has made to the development of the judiciary of Zimbabwe."
Please redistribute it as widely as possible to all interested persons.~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~After speaking with Charing Cross Police events room on 020 7321 7524 this morning 7th March at 09.20am and notifying of the details. We will have to change the times only as per the new schedule.
Please send out the message.
SOLIDARITY
DEMONSTRATION - FREE ZIMBABWE
1. Commonwealth Offices, Marlborough House, Pallmall, London. Monday 19th March 2001 starts 11.00am - 14. 00hrs.
2.
Zimbabwe High Commission, 429 Strand, LondonTuesday 20th march starts 1 1.00am - 14.00hrs and should continue for the rest of the week.
Come with placards, come as farmers, come as individuals,
come as political activists. Be there united in one voice, for the freedom to express your views without fear of intimidation, reprisal, or persecution.
YOU CAN MAKE A DIFFERENCE: THROUGH CONTRIBUTION.
Sincerely
Albert Weidemann
Mr Tatchell, who tried to arrest Mr Mugabe in London in 1999, made his latest attempt as the President walked through the Hilton Hotel lobby after lunching with Poul Nielson, the European Commissioner for Development. He moved towards Mr Mugabe, shouting “I arrest you for torture”, but was bundled into a corner by several of the bodyguards ringing the President.
He was kept there until Mr Mugabe had gone out through the revolving door. Mr Tatchell then pursued him outside shouting “torturer” and “murderer”. This time he was pinned against a wall, slapped and punched around the head. The bodyguards also threatened to find him and kill him.
Mr Mugabe, looking shaken, was hurried into the silver BMW waiting to take him to a meeting with the Belgian Prime Minister.
As his motorcade moved off, Mr Tatchell ran in front of the car, but was grabbed and punched by another bodyguard who left him lying in the gutter. He ended up with a bruised head and black eye, but said: “I hope this showed President Mugabe that he can’t swan around the capitals of the world without being challenged.”
The Brussels police said they had no plans to take the matter further.
TUESDAY MARCH 06 2001
From The Times [UK]
|
Mugabe bodyguards beat Tatchell |
BY MARTIN FLETCHER, EUROPEAN CORRESPONDENT |
PETER TATCHELL, the militant gay campaigner, tried one
publicity stunt too many yesterday when he attempted to perform a citizen’s
arrest on Robert Mugabe in Brussels. He was beaten up by the President’s
bodyguards in a display of the sort of violence and intimidation with which Mr
Mugabe increasingly rules Zimbabwe.
Mr Tatchell, who tried to arrest Mr Mugabe in London in 1999, made his latest attempt as the President walked through the Hilton Hotel lobby after lunching with Poul Nielson, the European Commissioner for Development. He moved towards Mr Mugabe, shouting “I arrest you for torture”, but was bundled into a corner by several of the bodyguards ringing the President. He was kept there until Mr Mugabe had gone out through the revolving door. Mr Tatchell then pursued him outside shouting “torturer” and “murderer”. This time he was pinned against a wall, slapped and punched around the head. The bodyguards also threatened to find him and kill him. Mr Mugabe, looking shaken, was hurried into the silver BMW waiting to take him to a meeting with the Belgian Prime Minister. As his motorcade moved off, Mr Tatchell ran in front of the car, but was grabbed and punched by another bodyguard who left him lying in the gutter. He ended up with a bruised head and black eye, but said: “I hope this showed President Mugabe that he can’t swan around the capitals of the world without being challenged.” The Brussels police said they had no plans to take the matter further. |
The two men meet at the Elysee palace in Paris, in a meeting which attracted widespread international criticism following Mr Mugabe controversial land reform programme.
It was an excellent meeting, very good, very
friendly |
Robert Mugabe |
British Prime Minister Tony Blair said he expected Mr Chirac "to underline international concern at what is happening in Zimbabwe".
The British press spoke more bluntly, with The Daily Telegraph saying:
"Rather than being welcomed at the Elysee, Mr Mugabe deserves to be treated as a pariah."
No details have emerged about the meeting, which lasted for an hour, but Mr Mugabe left in a good mood.
"It was an excellent meeting, very good, very friendly," he said.
Reassurance
In Belgium on Monday, a meeting with Belgian Prime Minister Guy Verhofstadt covered the recent expulsion of foreign journalists from Zimbabwe, and Zimbabwean Government pressure on the judiciary.
|
He also said Mr Mugabe had reassured Belgium about the freedom of Zimbabwe's judiciary, mentioning last week's decision to "reinstate" Chief Justice Anthony Gubbay until 1 July.
Judge Gubbay had originally been instructed by the government to quit his office by the end of February - the extension to July came as part of a deal whereby he would take the intervening period as leave, after he had been threatened by a government supporter who forced his way into his office.
Another purpose of Mr Mugabe's Brussels visit was to discuss the peace process in the Democratic Republic of Congo - a former Belgian colony where Zimbabwean troops are playing a key role in defending the government of President Joseph Kabila against Rwandan-backed rebels.
Belgian Foreign Ministry spokesman Koen Vervaeke said Mr Mugabe had stressed the need for dialogue between all parties to the Congo conflict, but fears "a political and military vacuum if the troops pull out".
Tatchell scuffle
Mr Tatchell used the opportunity of Mr Mugabe's presence in Brussels to attempt a citizen's arrest.
He approached the president outside his hotel, shouting "arrest Mugabe, arrest the torturer".
|
"I said the president should be arrested for the crime of torture under the 1984 United Nations' Convention on Torture of which Belgium is a signatory," Mr Tatchell said.
Mr Mugabe has attracted protests from gay rights activists for several years, since branding homosexuals "worse than pigs or dogs".
Mr Tatchell previously attempted a citizen's arrest on him in London.
But there was an angry confrontation with British gay rights campaigner Peter Tatchell, who tried to carry out a citizen's arrest on Mr Mugabe.
A meeting with Belgian Prime Minister Guy
Verhofstadt covered the recent expulsion of foreign journalists from Zimbabwe,
and Zimbabwean Government pressure on the judiciary.
"President Mugabe denied rumours that he was planning to expel all foreign
journalists from Zimbabwe," Mr Verhofstadt's spokesman Alain Gerlache told
Reuters news agency.
He also said Mr Mugabe had reassured Belgium about the freedom of Zimbabwe's
judiciary, mentioning last week's decision to "reinstate" Chief Justice Anthony
Gubbay until 1 July.
On Tuesday, Mr Mugabe is due to meet French President Jacques Chirac.
Tatchell scuffle
Mr Tatchell used the opportunity of Mr Mugabe's presence in Brussels to
attempt a citizen's arrest.
He approached the president outside his hotel, shouting "arrest Mugabe,
arrest the torturer".
"I said the president should be arrested for the crime of torture under the
1984 United Nations' Convention on Torture of which Belgium is a signatory," Mr
Tatchell said.
Mr Mugabe has attracted protests from gay rights activists for several years,
since branding homosexuals "worse than pigs or dogs".
Mr Tatchell previously attempted a citizen's arrest on him in London.
Congo peace process
One purpose of Mr Mugabe's Brussels visit was to discuss the peace process in
the Democratic Republic of Congo - a former Belgian colony where Zimbabwean
troops are playing a key role in defending the government of President Joseph
Kabila against Rwandan-backed rebels.
Belgian Foreign Ministry spokesman Koen Vervaeke said Mr Mugabe had stressed
the need for dialogue between all parties to the Congo conflict, but fears "a
political and military vacuum if the troops pull out".
Rwanda and Uganda, which support opponents of the Kinshasa Government, began
withdrawing troops last week following UN Security Council approval of a
peacekeeping plan.
Zimbabwe, along with fellow Kabila allies Angola and Namibia, has not yet
begun withdrawing troops.
Judge Gubbay had originally been instructed by the
government to quit his office by the end of February - the extension to July
came as part of a deal whereby he would take the intervening period as leave,
after he had been threatened by a government supporter who forced his way into
his office.
A scuffle followed during which the gay rights campaigner
said he had been punched by a bodyguard and had fallen to the ground, but was
not badly hurt.
Gloria Olds, 68, was shot dead by unidentified gunmen on her farm near Bulawayo, where she had lived alone since her son, Martin, was killed last year.
She was found dead with multiple gunshot wounds on Sunday.
Mr Olds's widow, Kathy, who fled to Britain with her two children after her husband's murder, is now being comforted by friends. She has sought political asylum in Britain.
"Kathy has had just a year to get over Martin's death and now she has to face this. She is devastated," a close friend told PA news agency.
Relatives are blaming self-styled war veterans for the shooting, but police are treating the incident as murder and armed robbery.
Violence
Mrs Olds is the eighth white farmer amongst more that 30 Zimbabweans who have died in politically related violence in the past year.
Her son, Martin, was the second white farmer
killed when squatters began taking over white-owned land with the encouragement
of President Robert Mugabe.
The murder of Gloria Olds comes as the government's campaign to seize
white-owned farms for redistribution is being stepped up.
Last week, the government succeeded in forcing the country's chief justice,
Anthony Gubbay, to agree to take early retirement after he had ruled against the
forcible seizure of white-owned farms.
David Coltart, a friend of the Olds family and an opposition MP, has said he
believes the murder is political.
"I have no doubt that (the latest killing) is politically motivated and is
designed to provoke farmers into reacting, to give the government grounds to
clamp down further and intimidate the farming community," he said.
From The Guardian (UK), 6 March
Mugabe men beat up Tatchell
Second attempt at 'citizen's arrest' ends in assault at hotel
Brussels/Paris - The gay and human rights campaigner Peter Tatchell was savagely beaten by bodyguards protecting President Robert Mugabe of Zimbabwe as he tried to make a citizen's arrest yesterday of the African leader during an official visit to meet a senior European Union commissioner. As Mr Tatchell attempted his citizen's arrest he was repulsed forcefully and left lying semi-conscious in the gutter after receiving at least three blows to the head.
In the lobby of the Hilton hotel in Brussels, Mr Tatchell managed to push past several of Mr Mugabe's burly minders and demanded that the African leader be arrested under the 1984 UN Convention against torture but was swiftly bundled into a corner. After the attack, a dazed Mr Tatchell, who attempted a similar citizen's arrest of Mr Mugabe in London in October 1999, claimed that one of the bodyguards had issued him with a death threat saying: "We will find you and kill you."
"People who I believe were President Mugabe's agents attacked me and punched me around the face even though I was no physical threat to Mr Mugabe," said Mr Tatchell, his nose bloodied and his face bruised. The Belgian police allowed the Zimbabwean agents to have a free go and to beat me with impunity and yet President Mugabe is complicit in the use of torture which is a crime under international and Belgian law." Mr Tatchell suspects Mr Mugabe ordered the torture of two Zimbabwean journalists.
Moments before the attack Mr Mugabe had finished off a lunch of smoked salmon and chicken with wild mushrooms in the company of the EU's development commissioner, Poul Nielson, who has been severely criticised by Zimbabwe's democratic opposition for agreeing to meet Mr Mugabe at all. For one bizarre moment Mr Mugabe and his large en tourage were trapped in the revolving door of the Hilton as they hastened to beat a retreat from Mr Tatchell's approach, allowing him to exit the hotel by a different door and attempt a second "arrest". But the campaigner was viciously beaten by a man who refused to identify himself but who later got into one of Mr Mugabe's limousines and left Mr Tatchell lying in the gutter almost under the wheels of one of the waiting BMWs. Mr Mugabe laughed and joked with one of his minders in the back of his limousine as Mr Tatchell was beaten.
Mr Nielson later claimed he was unaware of the incident but said he was unrepentant about lunching with Mr Mugabe, who stands accused of orchestrating a campaign of violence and intimidation against the Zimbabwean media, judiciary and white farmers. "I think it's a big mistake not to listen to what he has to say. It's not a government we are relating to, it's a nation," Mr Nielson argued, adding that Mr Mugabe had agreed to enter into a critical dialogue with the EU. He later told the European Parliament, however, that if Mr Mugabe did not act soon the EU would consider suspending its £6m a year aid programme to Harare.
Tory MEP Nirj Deva was one of several deputies to subject Mr Nielson to hostile questioning. "He (Mugabe) has to be told there is a line in the sand across which he cannot walk. Would you have discussed matters with Stalin and Hitler?" he asked the Dane. Morgan Tsvangirai, the main opposition leader in Zimbabwe, also condemned the meeting. "I think it is a slap in the face for Zimbabweans," he told BBC Radio 4. "To me and the majority of Zimbabweans that is endorsing and condoning his actions." Mr Mugabe later held talks with Belgium's prime minister, Guy Verhofstadt, discussing the nascent peace process in the Democratic Republic of Congo, a former Belgian colony, where Zimbabwean troops are stationed. Mr Mugabe is due in France today where he will meet President Jacques Chirac.
From The Times (UK), 6 March
MEPs protest over Mugabe meeting
Brussels/Paris - Belgium's Prime Minister and a European commissioner caused international outrage by meeting President Mugabe of Zimbabwe in Brussels yesterday, before a further controversial meeting with President Chirac today. Mr Mugabe, who is waging a campaign of intimidation against Zimbabwe's judges, journalists, political opposition and white farmers, spent five hours in Brussels, meeting first Poul Nielson, the European Development Commissioner, and later Guy Verhofstadt, the Belgian Prime Minister.
He ignored all questions from journalists, including one about Sunday's murder of the 68-year-old white Zimbabwean farmer Gloria Olds. When he caught the train to Paris he left Mr Nielson facing outraged MEPs in the European Parliament. The commissioner insisted that he had expressed the EU's concerns about events in Zimbabwe, and that Mr Mugabe had agreed on the need for "political consultations" to discuss those concerns. He said he believed that dialogue was necessary to "build confidence" between the EU and Zimbabwe, but declined to elaborate further on their lunch because he believed that "professional diplomacy" was more important than transparency in this case.
"Would we have a dialogue with Hitler and Stalin too?", Nirj Deva, a British Conservative who had demanded that Mr Nielson cancel the meeting, said. For the EU to extol human rights, then consort with Mr Mugabe would make it "the laughing stock of the world", he said. Michael Gahler, a German Christian Democrat who monitored Zimbabwe's parliamentary elections last year, said Mr Nielson's "professional diplomacy" was useless as Mr Mugabe "doesn't listen to his own people, let alone anyone else. . . The only language he understands is language which says if we don't get immediate change our aid programmes will be suspended."
The Commission appeared embarrassed and defensive about the visit. It omitted to announce the meeting in advance, stonewalled journalists' inquiries and arranged no press conference afterwards. The Belgian Government acknowledged the awkwardness of Mr Verhofstadt, a human rights champion, receiving Mr Mugabe. But it was necessary because Zimbabwe could play a key role in bringing peace to Belgium's war-torn former colony of the DRC. A spokesman said Mr Verhofstadt and Louis Michel, Belgium's Foreign Minister, also raised three specific issues at the request of Robin Cook, the Foreign Secretary. They were the "unacceptable" treatment of Zimbabwe's white farmers, the intimidation of judges culminating in last week's ousting of the chief justice, and the harassment of journalists.
The spokesman said Mr Mugabe replied that the problems with the Supreme Court were now over, and that the recent expulsion of a BBC correspondent was for administrative, not political, reasons. In Harare Morgan Tsvangirai, the leader of the opposition MDC party, said it was "a slap in the face for the French Government or any government in Europe to be accommodating him. . . Mugabe is beating up people in the townships left, right and centre. People are being murdered, culprits are being allowed to go scot free, and yet these issues go unnoticed." Donald Anderson, the Labour MP who chairs the Commons Foreign Affairs Committee, accused the French and Belgian Governments of a "crass error of judgment". Francis Maude, the Shadow Foreign Secretary, called for Zimbabwe's suspension from the Commonwealth.
Efforts by France to take a leading role in settlement of the Congo civil war and restore its influence in south-central Africa will be at the heart of the talks between M Chirac and Mr Mugabe. French officials said that M Chirac would remind Mr Mugabe of international anger over his Government's human rights record. But the French are grateful to Mr Mugabe for using his armed forces to support the new administration of Joseph Kabila in the DRC.
From The Daily News, 5 March
Riot squad unleashes terror in Chitungwiza
Hundreds of armed riot police descended on St Mary's suburb in Chitungwiza on Saturday and beat up hundreds of residents who had gathered at Huruyadzo shopping centre for the official opening of a marketplace by MDC president Morgan Tsvangirai. Tsvangirai, according to his spokesman, was forced to abandon the function to avoid an escalation of police brutality in the event that MDC party youths fought back in defence.
Learnmore Jongwe, the MDC's secretary for information and publicity, yesterday said: "Our president cancelled the meeting in order to avoid clashes between the police and our youths. The St Mary's MP, Job Sikhala, has implemented good developmental work for his constituency. He wanted the vendors to have a decent place to sell their goods, but we have a government that unlawfully sends the police to beat up innocent people and disrupt the official opening of the sheltered marketplace. This is unacceptable." Jongwe said the marketplace would now be officially opened at a date to be determined.
Earlier, thousands of residents braved the heavy downpour to witness the official opening of the marketplace. They converged at the venue well before 10am. By 11am, a large crowd had already gathered at the shopping centre for the meeting, scheduled for 12 noon. About 60 armed riot police were also present. By 1pm the crowd had swelled to more than 3 000 people. Then suddenly 10 police Puma vehicles carrying more armed riot police arrived at the centre. Shortly after this more riot squad officers arrived in 20 Land-Rover Defender vehicles, some of them with police dogs. One of the police officers declared: "We are under instructions from our superiors not to allow Tsvangirai to address rallies in Chitungwiza. We will make sure this will not happen."
Then all hell broke loose as the wanton beatings began. Without any warning or provocation, the riot police charged into the crowd, attacking the residents with baton sticks. As the crowd fled in all directions, the police stormed into a nearby supermarket beating shoppers and revellers at the centre. Businesspersons at the centre immediately closed their premises fearing destruction of their properties. "These people are dangerous. Look at what they are doing. What crime did we commit here? The government accuses MDC MPs of not working hard and when we do something for the people they harass us," said Sikhala before fleeing for his life.
The riot squad then separated into groups of 10 as they patrolled the streets of St Mary's beating anyone on sight. The beatings in the streets continued for about three hours. The riot squad also unleashed their terror on unsuspecting commuters as they disembarked from buses, accusing them of travelling to St Mary's to witness the MDC event. "I was not even aware of the MDC event. I was attacked by the police as I disembarked from a commuter omnibus. They ignored my protestations that I was coming from Mbare Musika where I had gone to order vegetables," said Jairos Masonga.
Residents told The Daily News that some of them found mysterious letters under their doors when they woke up on Saturday morning. The letters advised the residents to visit the Criminal Investigation Department at Harare Central Police Station for unspecified reasons. Police spokesperson Wayne Bvudzijena told The Sunday Mail MDC meetings were banned in Chitungwiza after the opposition party's members allegedly disarmed a policeman at one of their rallies. But Jongwe said he was not aware of the ban on MDC meetings or the incident in which a policeman was reportedly disarmed. Jongwe said: "Bvudzijena's allegations are nonsensical. The truth of the situation is that the police officers are taking instructions from Zanu PF and war veterans to harass opposition supporters. He should behave like a professional policemen and tell his officers to respect human rights."
Police and army brutalities in St Mary's have become a weekly occurrence, with Sikhala and his pregnant wife falling victim to the terror tactics twice in the last two months. Some MDC youths have fled into the bush as members of the police, the CIO and the army harass them because of their political affiliation. Others are reportedly still missing after they were allegedly taken away from their homes in the dead of the night by people believed to be CIO agents acting in collusion with the police.
From The Times (UK), 6 March
Radio links give white farms only hope of safety
Nyamandlovu - Anxious radio messages flew between farmhouses yesterday after the murder of Gloria Olds dealt a fresh blow to the morale of the beleaguered white community in Zimbabwe. The 45 white-owned farms around Nyamandhlovu, 350 miles south-west of Harare, have been among the worst hit by the land invasions. All but a handful have been occupied by squatters who have been responsible for countless acts of theft, vandalism and assault. Farmers are close to breaking point after months of harassment and say that tensions are higher now than during the guerrilla war against white rule in the Seventies.
Nyamandhlovu is the only farming community to have endured the murder of a mother and son. Martin Olds, 43, was killed by 70 gunmen on April 18 last year, the second landowner to be murdered since the start of the occupations last February. His mother, Gloria, 68, lived alone on the neighbouring farm and was shot dead on Sunday. Her death has shocked the community. All farmers are linked by a radio network, and roll-call messages are transmitted every day at 7pm and 7am. If anyone fails to reply, their neighbours assume the worst and rush to the rescue. Wives and children are never left alone and anxious ears are always alert for an emergency radio message.
Wally Herbst, 51, who lives on Porter Farm, 10 miles from where Mrs Olds was killed, said: "It's much worse than during the war because we haven't the support of anybody. If someone shoots at your house, the police won't react. The only people who will help are neighbours." Eight miles down a bumpy track is Mr Herbst's nearest neighbour. The Wood family have lived at Glen Curragh Farm since 1896 and now share their land with about 15 squatters, who vandalise fences and issue blood-curdling threats. After the murder of Mrs Olds, Mike Wood, 62, joined other farmers in tracking the killers. The victim's pick-up truck, which was stolen by the culprits, was found in Bulawayo yesterday and taken to the police.
Mr Wood said: "Nobody must have any illusions. This was not a murder and robbery. It was purely political and designed to intimidate the farmers and force us out." Mrs Olds recently angered a prominent supporter of the ruling Zanu-PF party. She rented a property to him and had demanded money after months of non-payment. But landowners suspect that the guiding hand behind all the violence is Obert Mpofu, the provincial governor, who publicly blamed white farmers for his defeat in parliamentary elections last June. The wave of violence is believed to be his revenge and the objective is clear: to force terrified white farmers off their land.
From The Star (SA), 6 March
Kagame demands Kabila acts on Hutu militia
Rwanda's president said on Sunday that he would complete withdrawal of his troops from the DRC as soon as DRC President Joseph Kabila secured the border between their countries. Major-General Paul Kagame, whose tiny but militarily powerful nation was the scene of a ghastly 1994 genocide that cost 800 000 lives, said he believed Kabila, unlike his late father, Laurent Kabila, wanted to work for peace in the war-torn region. He said the Hutu militia and Rwandan Hutu ex-soldiers, who fled to the DRC in 1994 when Kagame's advancing rebel army ended the mass slaughter, were still actively fighting alongside Kabila's forces in a many-sided war in the DRC.
Rwanda and Uganda have deployed troops in the DRC to secure their borders against Hutu militia and rebels threatening their governments. "Our stay in the Congo directly hinges on the security concerns created by the government in the Congo and that government's active support for the militia," said Kagame in a telephone interview from the Rwandan capital. "He (Kabila) should have the courage to deal with the problem created by his late father. He should dismantle the militia network in the Congo, and Rwanda would have no reason for staying in that country," he added. "Once the militia are dealt with, once Kabila moves on them, Rwanda would pack up and leave. That decision, well within Kabila's power, would end the war and bring peace to the Congo."
Kagame said it would be naive for him to withdraw Rwandan troops before Kabila acted. "Our presence in the Congo is a mere reaction to a problem imposed on us, a problem of national security, a problem that constantly threatens to repeat the events of 1994," he said. Kagame spoke four days after Rwanda pulled 3 000 troops back from the key south-eastern Congolese town of Pweto, clearing the way for UN observers to deploy and marking the most significant step towards ending= the war. Kagame said the Pweto pullback was Rwanda's goodwill gesture towards ending the conflict, which erupted in 1998, and he urged Kabila to open dialogue with the armed and political opposition. "We plan to work for peace in Congo. We hope Kabila can support these efforts by opening up dialogue with the opposition and the armed groups fighting his government. This would put the whole peace plan into an irreversible action," he said.
Momentum towards peace has picked up sharply following January's slaying of Laurent Kabila by a bodyguard, which elevated his son Joseph to power. Joseph Kabila has reversed key policies of his father and authorised the start of a dialogue with political foes while inviting in UN peacekeepers without the precondition that foreign forces first leave Congolese territory. Rwanda and Uganda have intervened in the Congo twice over the past four years. First they backed Laurent Kabila in an eight-month blitz that overthrew dictator Mobutu Sese Seko in May, 1997. But differences soon emerged amid claims by both countries that Kabila was ignoring a promise to rein in the Hutu militia, who had set up bases to strike back at Kigali and Kampala.
Kagame ordered a second invasion of the Congo. But his advance was quickly checked by troops from Angola, Namibia and Zimbabwe, who backed Kabila. The multi-national war has since been dubbed Africa's "World War One" because of the number of nations involved. Congolese rebels backed by Rwanda, Uganda and Burundi have since occupied the east, south-east and large parts of the north of the DRC. A peace deal to end the war was signed in Zambia in 1999, but Laurent Kabila refused to implement it, saying the three countries must first withdraw their troops.