The ZIMBABWE Situation Our thoughts and prayers are with Zimbabwe
- may peace, truth and justice prevail.

Back to Index

Back to the Top
Back to Index

Britons arrested in Zimbabwe
(Filed: 10/03/2002)
 

TWO Britons have been arrested in Zimbabwe for allegedly carrying illegal radio equipment.
 
The Foreign Office confirmed two Britons had been arrested and said officials were making inquiries.
 
Reports suggested the British pair and two Americans were arrested in eastern Zimbabwe and accused of attempting to disrupt this weekend's presidential elections.
 
It is understood that the arrested Britons are residents of Zimbabwe, though they hold British passports.
 
The British High Commission is monitoring the situation closely, the Foreign Office said, adding that the consul is in touch with a local lawyer who is trying to get access to the Britons. The consul is also in touch with their families.
================================================================
Back to the Top
Back to Index

Zimbabwe polls reopen but officials block voting
By Nicholas Kotch and Cris Chinaka
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 
 
 
Harare residents, segregated into male and female queues, line up to vote at dusk in the suburb of Kuwadzana.
Photo by HOWARD BURDITT
HARARE, March 11 (Reuters) - Zimbabwe's bitter election went into an unprecedented third day on Monday but witnesses said President Robert Mugabe's officials were defying a High Court order and refusing to accept votes.
 
Thousands of people jammed polling stations in the capital Harare, an opposition stronghold in the southern African country, after polling stations reopened at 7 a.m. (0500 GMT).
 
Witnesses and the Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) opposition charged that presiding officers in several Harare townships had no instructions to allow voting to begin.
 
State radio also said voting would be extended only in Harare and the nearby Chitungwiza settlement, contrary to a High Court order on Sunday night that voting should continue throughout the country because of big queues.
 
The opposition went to the High Court shortly before the scheduled two-day election was due to close to request an extension of the poll. It charged that Mugabe was deliberately slowing the vote to disenfranchise opposition voters.
 
The confusion and problems on Monday were the latest episode in what MDC leader Morgan Tsvangirai says is a systematic attempt by Mugabe to use violence and "dirty tricks" to cling on to power despite deep unpopularity.
 
Mugabe, 78, once seen as a model democrat, has taken the former Rhodesia from civil war to prosperity in the 1980s and now to penury that threatens the stability of the whole southern African region including regional giant South Africa.
 
Tsvangirai poses the toughest challenge to Mugabe's monopoly of power since independence from Britain in 1980 and there are fears of a violent reaction if the opposition's supporters are robbed of a chance to vote.
 
NO INSTRUCTIONS TO RESUME VOTING
 
In Harare's Kuwadzana township, about 800 people queued outside a primary school, watched by half a dozen riot police.
 
The polling station's presiding officer told Reuters he had not received orders from electoral authorities to resume voting.
 
"We have now gone for one hour and 30 minutes and no voting is taking place. That's a flagrant violation of the government's own orders," MDC spokesman Learnmore Jongwe said at 8.30 a.m. (0630 GMT) after touring seven polling stations in Kuwadzana.
 
"They simply don't want people who are going to vote against them to vote," Jongwe added.
 
Benjamin, one of several hundred people waiting outside a polling station in Kuwadzana, said he was determined to vote.
 
"People have decided to stay away from work and vote. People want change. 22 years is too long," he said.
 
The government citing high costs, logistical and administrative problems, said it could not comply with the court order to keep polling stations open outside Harare.
 
Supporters of Tsvangirai said police beat thousands of voters away from polling stations late on Sunday night after the court order, saying they should come back on Monday.
 
Norwegian observer Kare Vollan said 1,000 voters had been turned away at Harare's Warren Park at 11 p.m. on Sunday.
 

RIOT POLICE CLOSED POLLING STATION
 
Witnesses said riot police shut down another polling station about an hour after the court ruling, scattering around 2,500 people who had waited most of the day.
 
Quoting Justice Minister Patrick Chinamasa, state radio said polling stations would reopen on Monday only in the two areas that had the longest queues late on Sunday.
 
"Comrade Chinamasa has said it is impossible to comply with the order to extend the vote nationwide because in some areas, polling has already closed and ballot boxes have already been returned," the radio said.
 
Britain, the former colonial power, and the United States have warned a rigged election could destabilise the country.
 
Neighbouring South Africa, widely criticised for failing to condemn Mugabe's handling of his political and economic crises, fears a meltdown would cause a flood of refugees. The Zimbabwe crisis has battered its currency.
 
Registrar-General Tobaiwa Mudede said that by midday on Sunday barely a quarter of the voters registered in Harare had cast their ballots. The 205,000 votes gathered was about half the number that voted in parliamentary elections in June 2000.
 
Back to the Top
Back to Index

Opposition officials arrested in Zimbabwe
 
 
 
 
Opposition officials in Zimbabwe say two senior leaders have been arrested as polling stations opened for a third day.
 
The elections have resumed with polling booths opening five hours late.
 
The opposition party's secretary-general Welshman Ncube was arrested in the southwestern town of Plumtree. His deputy, Gift Chimanikire, has also been detained in Harare, said David Coltart an opposition legislator.
 
© Copyright Ananova Ltd 2002, all rights reserved
 
==============================================================
Back to the Top
Back to Index

 
 
Voting resumes for unscheduled third day in Zimbabwe's election 
 
ASSOCIATED PRESS
 
HARARE, Zimbabwe, March 11 — Zimbabwe's chaotic presidential elections resumed for an unscheduled third day on Monday, with polling stations opening five hours late. Opposition officials said two senior leaders had been arrested. 
 
 
 
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 
 
   
 
      
     
   
 
  
  
       President Robert Mugabe is facing the toughest challenge ever to his 22-year grip on power from Morgan Tsvangirai, a former trade union leader and head of the opposition Movement for Democratic Change.
       After being chased away from polling stations by police Sunday night, thousands of voters returned Monday morning because the High Court ordered the government to extend voting countrywide for a third day. But the polling stations did not open until noon, after many voters had given up and gone home or to work.
       Justice Minister Patrick Chinamasa said on state television Monday morning that the government would comply with the court order under duress and would only extend voting in Harare and a nearby township, both opposition strongholds. He said many polling stations in the rest of the country had already been dismantled.
       Tsvangirai accused Mugabe and his ruling party of attempting to steal the election by driving opposition observers from 43 percent of the rural polling stations, some of the rural counting stations and discouraging people in urban areas from voting.
       ''If those thousands of people are not allowed to vote, this is a stillborn election,'' he said Monday. ''The MDC will not be part of an illegitimate process to try to disenfranchise people.''
       The opposition party's secretary-general and third ranking official, Welshman Ncube, was arrested Monday in the southwestern town of Plumtree, while his deputy, Gift Chimanikire, was detained in Harare, said David Coltart an opposition legislator. Police gave no reason for the arrests, but Ncube has been charged with treason in a previous case.
       ''We will not succumb to this kind of intimidation,'' Tsvangirai said, adding that he will not appeal to the country's Supreme Court because they consistently rule against the opposition. He appealed to the people to show restraint and avoid confrontation with security forces.
       Government officials were not immediately available for comment.
       Mugabe and his Zimbabwean African National Union Patriotic Front ruled without significant dissent until recent years, when the economy entered its worst-ever crisis. Inflation is over 110 percent, unemployment is 60 percent and hundreds of thousands of people are going hungry.
       Despite pre-election violence and intimidation that opposition officials blame on Mugabe loyalists, voters headed out in record numbers to cast their ballots during the weekend vote — especially in urban areas like Harare.
       The opposition and many observers have accused the government of trying to rig the elections by preventing urban residents — who mostly support the opposition — from voting.
       In the poor Mbare neighborhood of Harare, Duncan Gideon, an unemployed 25-year old who waited all day Sunday to vote, returned to the polling station after his sister called him and said it had reopened.
       ''Others have gone to work, others are hungry, sunburned,'' Gideon said, explaining why many had given up on voting. About 250 people were in line with him.
       The presiding officer of the station, who did not give his name, said the reopening was delayed because officials had just received the order to reopen.
       In Zimbabwe's second city of Bulawayo, observers said most people appeared to have cast their ballot and there appeared to be no need for an extra day of voting. The ballot boxes were kept at polling stations overnight and were being moved to counting centers Monday.
       Also Monday, the government announced turnout figures that showed massive voting in Mugabe strongholds with far fewer voters casting ballots in opposition areas.
       Mashonaland Central, which normally votes strongly for the ruling party, had a 68 percent turnout. Harare had a 47 percent turnout so far, and the city of Bulawayo a 46 percent turnout, the government said.
       Despite the long lines in Harare, Information Minister Jonathan Moyo was quoted in the independent Daily News Monday as saying that reports of high turnout for Harare were ''really pictures painted by people with creative imaginations.''
       Overall, 2.7 million of the nation's 5.6 million registered voters, or 48 percent, went to the polls by Sunday, the government said.
       The Zimbabwe Educational Trust, an independent research group, said last week that the voters' rolls were in such disarray that any turnout higher than 2.6 million could be rigged.
       The state-run Herald newspaper said Monday that white people, opposition officials and an American were deployed to some polling stations in a suspicious manner that led authorities to believe there was a plot to disrupt the elections to give the international community a chance to declare them unfair.
       The Herald also accused the U.S. and British governments of ''setting up the stage for a major military offensive.''
       U.S. Embassy spokesman Bruce Warton called the claim ''ridiculous.''
       Tsvangirai, Mugabe's most competitive challenger since independence in 1980, is promising to revive the economy and end corruption.
       Mugabe, however, has painted Tsvangirai as a servant to white interests and Western powers who want to see the country fail. Two weeks ago, Tsvangirai was charged with treason in connection with an alleged plot to assassinate Mugabe, an allegation he has denied.
       Mugabe has promised public works initiatives if he is re-elected and has pledged to continue his controversial program of seizing white-owned farms and giving them to landless blacks. Whites make up less than 1 percent of the country's population but own about a third of the nation's commercial farmland.
       (Copyright 2002 by The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved.)
 
======================================================
Back to the Top
Back to Index

Monday March 11, 10:14 AM
 
 
 
Mugabe rival urges restraint
 
Click to enlarge photo 
HARARE (Reuters) - Opposition leader Morgan Tsvangirai has called for restraint from his followers despite the arrest of a top lieutenant and charges that President Robert Mugabe is stealing the Zimbabwe election.
 

Movement for Democratic Change Secretary General Welshman Ncube was arrested at a police roadblock southwest of Zimbabwe's second city of Bulawayo, MDC legal secretary David Coltart told Reuters.
 

Police were not available to comment on the reported arrest, which came as Zimbabwe's elections went into an unscheduled third day because of long voter queues in urban areas.
 

The opposition alleges that President Robert Mugabe is systematically slowing down the vote as part of a plot to fix the election.
 

Tsvangirai, Ncube and another MDC official are accused by the government of treason over an alleged plot to assassinate Mugabe. They have denied the allegation.
 

"Restrain yourselves as you do not allow their sinister plans to succeed. As you wait for the results, do not succumb to their provocative traps," Tsvangirai said in a statement.
 

"Yes, we share your fear that the result will be rigged, but let us complete the process we began together in our campaign for a better life for all Zimbabweans."
 

Analysts have expressed fears of violence if thousands of MDC voters are unable to cast their votes or believe the election has been rigged.
 

Tsvangirai, campaigning on the collapse of the Zimbabwe economy under Mugabe, poses the first real challenge to the veteran president's 22-year grip on power.
 

Asked by a reporter if he was considering pulling out of the election given widespread allegations of cheating, Tsvangirai said: "I am not conceding defeat but anyone who thinks he can endorse this process must have his head examined."
 

The run-up to the election was marred by political violence in which independent monitors say 33 people have died, most of them from the opposition.
 

The election was extended into a third day after a successful opposition application to the High Court on Sunday night arguing that long voting delays were disenfranchising its urban supporters.
 

But witnesses said presiding officers refused to take votes when the polls reopened on Monday.
 

MDC spokesman Learnmore Jongwe said details of Ncube's arrest were sketchy, but "they arrested him asking 'Why are you near the border while you are facing treason charges?'".
 
================================================================
Back to the Top
Back to Index

Globe and Mail (Canada)

Opposition member arrested in Zimbabwe
Reuters, AP

Harare — Zimbabwe police on Monday arrested a senior member of the
opposition Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) near the border with
Botswana, opposition officials said.
MDC Secretary General Welshman Ncube was driving on a road southwest of
Zimbabwe's second city of Bulawayo when he was arrested at a police
roadblock, MDC legal secretary David Coltart told Reuters.
Mr. Ncube and two other MDC officials, including party leader Morgan
Tsvangirai, are accused by the government of treason over an alleged plot to
assassinate President Robert Mugabe. They have denied the allegation.
Police were not available to comment on the reported arrest, which came as
Zimbabwe's elections went into an unscheduled third day.
Zimbabwe's chaotic presidential elections dissolved into confusion Monday
morning as the government said voting would be extended an extra day but
most polling officers refused to allow people to vote in this southern
African nation.
The High Court ordered the government to extend voting countrywide for a
third day after thousands of people remained on lines in Harare when the
polls were supposed to close. Many voters returned to vote Monday after
being chased away from polling stations by police Sunday night.
Justice Minister Patrick Chinamasa said on state television Monday morning
that the government would comply with the court order under duress and would
only extend voting around the capital of Harare because many polling
stations in the rest of the country had already been dismantled.
However, by 8:30 a.m. Monday, 1½ hours after polls were to reopen, polling
observers in Harare said they remained closed.
"People have come as early as 4 a.m.. They wanted to vote, but nothing is
happening in the ground," said Derek Madharani, an opposition poll observer.
"I don't know what we can do now. We have exhausted all the channels to plea
with this government to be fair to the people, to give them a chance to
vote, but our pleas are falling on deaf ears."
Harare is a stronghold of the Movement for Democratic Change, led by Mr.
Tsvangirai, who is challenging Mr. Mugabe's 22-year grip on power.
Mr. Mugabe and his Zimbabwean African National Union Patriotic Front ruled
without significant dissent until recent years, when the economy entered its
worst-ever crisis. Inflation is over 110 per cent, unemployment is 60 per
cent and hundreds of thousands of people are going hungry.
Despite pre-election violence and intimidation that opposition officials
blame on Mr. Mugabe loyalists, voters headed out in record numbers to cast
their ballots during the weekend vote - especially in urban areas like
Harare.
The opposition and many observers have accused the government of trying to
rig the elections by preventing urban residents - who support the
opposition - from voting.
Alex Chinhanga, 25, a project co-ordinator for an educational institution
who was chased away from a polling station in the poor Glen View suburb
Sunday night said he was concerned about missing work to vote.
"We don't know what will happen when we go back to work with our bosses. Are
they going to say, `What happened?' or will they just keep quiet?" he asked.
The government announced turnout figures Monday that showed massive voting
in Mr. Mugabe strongholds with far fewer voters casting ballots in
opposition areas.
Mashonaland Central, which normally votes strongly for the ruling party, had
a 68 per cent turnout. The opposition stronghold of Harare had a 47 per cent
so far and the city of Bulawayo a 46 per cent turnout, the government said.
Despite long lines in Harare, Information Minister Jonathan Moyo was quoted
in the independent Daily News Monday as saying that reports of high turnout
for Harare were "really pictures painted by people with creative
imaginations."
Overall, 2.7 million of the nation's 5.6 million registered voters, or 48
per cent, went to the polls, the government said.
The Zimbabwe Educational Trust, an independent research group, said last
week that the voters' rolls were in such disarray that any turnout higher
than 2.6 million could be rigged.
Also Monday, the state-run Herald newspaper said white people, opposition
officials and an American were deployed to some polling stations in a
suspicious manner that led authorities to believe there was a plot to
disrupt the elections to give the international community a chance to
declare them unfair.
The Herald also accused the American and British governments of “setting up
the stage for a major military offensive" into the country.
Mr. Tsvangirai, Mr. Mugabe's most competitive challenger since independence
in 1980, is promising to revive the economy and end corruption.
Mr. Mugabe has painted Mr. Tsvangirai as a servant to white interests and
Western powers who want to see the country fail. Two weeks ago, Mr.
Tsvangirai was charged with treason in connection with an alleged plot to
assassinate Mr. Mugabe, an allegation he has denied.
Mr. Mugabe has promised public works initiatives if he is re-elected and has
pledged to continue his controversial program of seizing white-owned farms
and giving them to landless blacks. Whites make up less than 1 per cent of
the country's population but own about a third of the nation's commercial
farmland.
In the weeks before the vote, pro-Mugabe militants attacked opposition
supporters, while police broke up several opposition rallies and arrested
dozens of Tsvangirai supporters.
Ruling party militants took over two polling stations, stole voting
materials from a third, and at another station, ballots arrived already
marked in favour of Mr. Mugabe, observers and opposition supporters said
Saturday.
In a statement Sunday night, opposition officials said attacks on its
polling monitors and supporters continued throughout the country.

Back to the Top
Back to Index

Bid to extend vote blocked in Zimbabwe
Photo
Movement for Democratic Change leader Morgan Tsvangirai, flanked by his wife Susan, casts his ballot at the Avondale Primary School in Harare on Sunday. Photo: Jerome Delay/AP

Associated Press

Harare — Zimbabwe's chaotic presidential elections dissolved into confusion Monday morning as the government said voting would be extended an extra day but most polling officers refused to allow people to vote in this southern African nation.

The High Court ordered the government to extend voting countrywide for a third day after thousands of people remained on lines in Harare when the polls were supposed to close. Many voters returned to vote Monday after being chased away from polling stations by police Sunday night.

Justice Minister Patrick Chinamasa said on state television Monday morning that the government would comply with the court order under duress and would only extend voting around the capital of Harare because many polling stations in the rest of the country had already been dismantled.

However, by 8:30 a.m. Monday, 1½ hours after polls were to reopen, polling observers in Harare said they remained closed.

"People have come as early as 4 a.m.. They wanted to vote, but nothing is happening in the ground," said Derek Madharani, an opposition poll observer. "I don't know what we can do now. We have exhausted all the channels to plea with this government to be fair to the people, to give them a chance to vote, but our pleas are falling on deaf ears."

Harare is a stronghold of the Movement for Democratic Change, led by Morgan Tsvangirai, who is challenging President Robert Mugabe's 22-year grip on power.

Mr. Mugabe and his Zimbabwean African National Union Patriotic Front ruled without significant dissent until recent years, when the economy entered its worst-ever crisis. Inflation is over 110 per cent, unemployment is 60 per cent and hundreds of thousands of people are going hungry.

Despite pre-election violence and intimidation that opposition officials blame on Mr. Mugabe loyalists, voters headed out in record numbers to cast their ballots during the weekend vote - especially in urban areas like Harare.

The opposition and many observers have accused the government of trying to rig the elections by preventing urban residents - who support the opposition - from voting.

Alex Chinhanga, 25, a project co-ordinator for an educational institution who was chased away from a polling station in the poor Glen View suburb Sunday night said he was concerned about missing work to vote.

"We don't know what will happen when we go back to work with our bosses. Are they going to say, `What happened?' or will they just keep quiet?" he asked.

The government announced turnout figures Monday that showed massive voting in Mr. Mugabe strongholds with far fewer voters casting ballots in opposition areas.

Mashonaland Central, which normally votes strongly for the ruling party, had a 68 per cent turnout. The opposition stronghold of Harare had a 47 per cent so far and the city of Bulawayo a 46 per cent turnout, the government said.

Despite long lines in Harare, Information Minister Jonathan Moyo was quoted in the independent Daily News Monday as saying that reports of high turnout for Harare were "really pictures painted by people with creative imaginations."

Overall, 2.7 million of the nation's 5.6 million registered voters, or 48 per cent, went to the polls, the government said.

The Zimbabwe Educational Trust, an independent research group, said last week that the voters' rolls were in such disarray that any turnout higher than 2.6 million could be rigged.

Also Monday, the state-run Herald newspaper said white people, opposition officials and an American were deployed to some polling stations in a suspicious manner that led authorities to believe there was a plot to disrupt the elections to give the international community a chance to declare them unfair.

The Herald also accused the American and British governments of “setting up the stage for a major military offensive" into the country.

Mr. Tsvangirai, Mr. Mugabe's most competitive challenger since independence in 1980, is promising to revive the economy and end corruption.

Mr. Mugabe has painted Mr. Tsvangirai as a servant to white interests and Western powers who want to see the country fail. Two weeks ago, Mr. Tsvangirai was charged with treason in connection with an alleged plot to assassinate Mr. Mugabe, an allegation he has denied.

Mr. Mugabe has promised public works initiatives if he is re-elected and has pledged to continue his controversial program of seizing white-owned farms and giving them to landless blacks. Whites make up less than 1 per cent of the country's population but own about a third of the nation's commercial farmland.

In the weeks before the vote, pro-Mugabe militants attacked opposition supporters, while police broke up several opposition rallies and arrested dozens of Tsvangirai supporters.

Ruling party militants took over two polling stations, stole voting materials from a third, and at another station, ballots arrived already marked in favour of Mr. Mugabe, observers and opposition supporters said Saturday.

In a statement Sunday night, opposition officials said attacks on its polling monitors and supporters continued throughout the country.

Back to the Top
Back to Index

Yahoo News

Monday March 11, 08:47 AM


Zimbabweans jam polls for third day
By Nicholas Kotch and Cris Chinaka


HARARE (Reuters) - Zimbabwe's bitter election has gone into an unprecedented
third day but witnesses said President Robert Mugabe's officials were
defying a High Court order and refusing to accept votes.


Thousands of people jammed polling stations in the capital Harare, an
opposition stronghold in the southern African country, after polling
stations reopened at 7 a.m. (5 a.m. British time).


Witnesses and the Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) opposition charged
that presiding officers in several Harare townships had no instructions to
allow voting to begin.


State radio also said voting would be extended only in Harare and the nearby
Chitungwiza settlement, contrary to a High Court order on Sunday night that
voting should continue throughout the country because of big queues.


The opposition went to the High Court shortly before the scheduled two-day
election was due to close to request an extension of the poll. It charged
that Mugabe was deliberately slowing the vote to disenfranchise opposition
voters.


The confusion and problems on Monday were the latest episode in what MDC
leader Morgan Tsvangirai says is a systematic attempt by Mugabe to use
violence and "dirty tricks" to cling on to power despite deep unpopularity.


Mugabe, 78, once seen as a model democrat, has taken the former Rhodesia
from civil war to prosperity in the 1980s and now to penury that threatens
the stability of the whole southern African region including regional giant
South Africa.


Tsvangirai poses the toughest challenge to Mugabe's monopoly of power since
independence from Britain in 1980 and there are fears of a violent reaction
if the opposition's supporters are robbed of a chance to vote.


NO INSTRUCTIONS TO RESUME VOTING


In Harare's Kuwadzana township, about 800 people queued outside a primary
school, watched by half a dozen riot police.


The polling station's presiding officer told Reuters he had not received
orders from electoral authorities to resume voting.


"We have now gone for one hour and 30 minutes and no voting is taking place.
That's a flagrant violation of the government's own orders," MDC spokesman
Learnmore Jongwe said at 8.30 a.m. after touring seven polling stations in
Kuwadzana.


"They simply don't want people who are going to vote against them to vote,"
Jongwe added.


Benjamin, one of several hundred people waiting outside a polling station in
Kuwadzana, said he was determined to vote.


"People have decided to stay away from work and vote. People want change. 22
years is too long," he said.


The government citing high costs, logistical and administrative problems,
said it could not comply with the court order to keep polling stations open
outside Harare.


Supporters of Tsvangirai said police beat thousands of voters away from
polling stations late on Sunday night after the court order, saying they
should come back on Monday.


Norwegian observer Kare Vollan said 1,000 voters had been turned away at
Harare's Warren Park at 11 p.m. on Sunday.


RIOT POLICE CLOSED POLLING STATION


Witnesses said riot police shut down another polling station about an hour
after the court ruling, scattering around 2,500 people who had waited most
of the day.


Quoting Justice Minister Patrick Chinamasa, state radio said polling
stations would reopen on Monday only in the two areas that had the longest
queues late on Sunday.


"Comrade Chinamasa has said it is impossible to comply with the order to
extend the vote nationwide because in some areas, polling has already closed
and ballot boxes have already been returned," the radio said.


Britain, the former colonial power, and the United States have warned a
rigged election could destabilise the country.


Neighbouring South Africa, widely criticised for failing to condemn Mugabe's
handling of his political and economic crises, fears a meltdown would cause
a flood of refugees. The Zimbabwe crisis has battered its currency.


Registrar-General Tobaiwa Mudede said that by midday on Sunday barely a
quarter of the voters registered in Harare had cast their ballots. The
205,000 votes gathered was about half the number that voted in parliamentary
elections in June 2000.


Back to the Top
Back to Index

Masvingo voting
About 20 to 30 white voters who had won their Masvingo court appeals on Friday had their names circulated on a list by the registrar general's office of people who were not allowed to vote.This was in contempt of the court order which was issued on Friday. This list was accompanied by a book in which the listed people had to sign. Fortunately some of the people unwittingly were accepted to vote at some mobile stations who did not have the instructions. The lists were kept at the voting centre where those people normally vote. However by late Sunday the lists were distributed to all outstations and I know of one voter who was therefore denied a vote twice. I personally was fearful of this as I am eligible for dual citizenship, but had not received a letter from the registrar like the others. I voted at a mobile station without any problems on Saturday.
Back to the Top
Back to Index

In this issue :

From The Times (UK), 11 March

Mugabe running out of time after judge extends poll

Bulawayo/Harare - Zimbabwe’s presidential elections were extended by another day last night after a judge accepted that the massive turnout in the capital would prevent voters from casting their ballots. At the same time, however, police forced the closure of polling stations in Harare, driving out voters with batons and telling them to return today. An election observer from Norway, Kare Vollan, speaking at Warren Park, a western Harare township, where there was a huge turnout, said: "The authorities are closing all the polling stations in Harare because of the court decision." David Hasluck, director of the Commercial Farmers’ Union, said that he had not been allowed to vote after queueing for 20 hours at Hallingbury primary school, in the Harare suburb of Marlborough. "There were about another 1,000 people behind us waiting to vote," he said.

The Government, which had opposed the application by the opposition Movement for Democratic Change (MDC), to extend the election, said later that it would obey the order only in Harare and the nearby Chitungwiza settlement. Patrick Chinamasa, the Justice Minister, was quoted by state radio as saying that polling stations would reopen in the two areas that had the longest queues late last night. "Comrade Chinamasa has said it is impossible to comply with the order to extend the vote nationwide because in some areas, polling has already closed and ballot boxes have already been returned," the radio said. The High Court judge Ben Hlatywayo made the ruling after he flew in a helicopter at dusk, accompanied by lawyers for the MDC and the State, over polling stations where thousands were waiting to vote. The delays came after the Government’s decision to reduce the number of urban polling stations - by nearly 40 per cent in Harare - and to hold the presidential elections at the same time as local government elections. In urban areas, dominated by Morgan Tsvangirai’s MDC, there was a new mood of angry defiance in the queues, some almost a mile long. The word "change" was spoken openly. There was also a high turnout in rural areas, where President Mugabe’s militias operate with impunity.

Mr Mugabe, 78, who has been in power for nearly 22 years and is seeking a fourth presidential term, suffered a setback when Eddison Zvobgo, a senior member of his Zanu PF party, broke ranks and said that he hoped that he would accept a dignified exit from power in the likely event of defeat. Mr Tsvangirai said: "The old man (Mr Mugabe) is running scared. Time is running out for him." He received cheers of happy birthday when he arrived to vote at Avondale primary school in Harare yesterday morning. He has just turned 50. Mr Mugabe was a victim of confusion when he arrived to vote at a polling station and found his name was on the presidential voters’ roll but not on the municipal list. He had to go to another polling station where he was named on both lists. There is still anxiety over the likelihood of a fraud by the Zanu PF party. Learnmore Jongwe, an MDC spokesman, said that 47 per cent of rural polling stations had no MDC polling officers after a series of arrests, abductions and assaults. Three British citizens were reported to have been arrested. Melanie Patterson, 26, who was born in Zimbabwe, but lives in London, said that her brother and sister, who live in Harare, and her brother-in-law, Will Powell, were detained while driving MDC election observers to polling stations.

Dr Zvobgo, a lawyer by profession, and whose views are respected on both sides of the House, denounced Mr Mugabe’s land-grab scheme as "the devil which has spoilt everything" and condemned attempts at driving through unconstitutional legislation as "bristling with arrows pointed at the heart of freedom". He said that the party’s official position was that it would accept the election result. He admitted that there could be a coup attempt, but seemed confident that few in the Armed Forces would join it. "Even if such a thing happened and succeeded, it would not be permanent," he said. Dr Zvobgo said that the Government should accept the blame for the country’s food and fuel shortages, its 116 per cent inflation and a 70 per cent unemployment rate. "People are angry," he said. "Some factors were beyond our control, but others were within our grasp and we either mismanaged or we hesitated and lost an opportunity." He called for a government of national unity so that "political energies could be harnessed towards state objectives, and we would stand a great chance of being listened to sympathetically by those who have the means to help ... the European Union, the US and so on."

From ZWNEWS, 11 March

Top MDC officials arrested

Two senior officials of the MDC were arrested this morning in what is thought may be the start of a wider swoop on leaders of the opposition party. Welshman Ncube, secretary-general, was arrested as he drove from Bulawayo to Plumtree. Gift Chimanikire, deputy secretary-general, was arrested in Harare. It was not clear what charges had been brought against the two.

From The Guardian (UK), 11 March

Voters defiant in Mugabe heartland

Electorate in rural areas regarded as president's stronghold are resisting intimidation to vote for opposition

Muzarabani - This may be President Robert Mugabe's stronghold but voters in Zimbabwe's rural areas are not likely to deliver the resounding endorsement he is expecting. Voters in the Muzarabani constituency braved gangs of Mr Mugabe's youth militia and intimidation from police and the Central Intelligence Organisation (CIO) to cast their ballots. In interviews with the Guardian, voters refused to declare their support for Mr Mugabe. Muzarabani, in Mashonaland Central, is considered a bastion of the ruling Zanu PF party. The number of polling stations in the constituency was increased by 82%, apparently because the Mugabe government was confident of support there. This increase in the sparsely populated area is in dramatic contrast to Harare and other cities where polling stations were reduced. To further beef up the vote for Mr Mugabe, Muzarabani was declared a "no go" area for Mr Tsvangirai's opposition party, the Movement for Democratic Change (MDC). Open campaigning here was impossible and the MDC's efforts simply to get its polling agents to monitor the voting was met with state-sponsored violence. There are signs that even here, in Mr Mugabe's heartland, support for him is waning. Residents say that hunger and violence are the issues they are most concerned about. "I am not happy with the situation, but I voted for the candidate of my choice," said a grey-haired peasant farmer, who was too frightened to say he supported Mr Tsvangirai. "My vote is my secret."

"Mugabe's militia and war veterans say they don't want to see any MDC here and they say they will kill us," said Peter Mukorera, 32, the MDC's constituency chairman. "And the police don't give us any protection. It is very rough." Mr Mukorera was shot at, stoned and threatened with death at Utete polling station on Saturday while police stood by. Police took the keys to two vehicles he and others were using to transport party polling agents and a few hours later the vehicles were set alight by the Mugabe supporters who had a base camp next to the polling station. "I ran through the bush and I fell down twice from fright when they shot the guns," said Mr Mukorera. "I kept running and finally slept in the bush. Later I hiked out but two of our officials are still missing." Mr Mukorera said his home was burned to the ground six weeks ago. Two more MDC vehicles in Muzarabani were impounded by police yesterday. The violence encountered by Mr Mukorera was part of a systematic nationwide campaign against MDC polling agents in rural areas. In Karoi, in Mashonaland West province, one MDC polling agent was beaten and drowned while another was wrapped in hay and set alight and is now in hospital, according to local residents. Other agents were beaten in nearby Banket. In Shamva, in Mashonaland East, about 20 MDC polling agents were attacked by youth militia on Friday. They got their wounds stitched up and then many returned to their pollings stations for voting on Saturday. In Honde Valley, in eastern Manicaland province, 80 MDC polling agents were illegally detained by the army and several were beaten. Four of the polling officials are still missing, according to the Human Rights Forum. In the southern area of Matabeleland, two vehicles transporting MDC polling agents were attacked and three agents are missing, according to witnesses.

The MDC estimates that more than 50% of the country's rural polling stations have operated without the presence of any opposition representatives. Under new electoral laws decreed by Mr Mugabe last week, all other polling officials are appointed by the government, so the opposition party agents are the only guarantee that there is no ballot stuffing or other irregularities. A threatening atmosphere hung over the Gatu polling station, in Muzarabani, when I visited it yesterday afternoon. Clusters of thuggish youth militia waited around on dusty paths nearby and threatened Peter Mukorera, the MDC official I interviewed, while I was standing just a few feet away. The presiding officer at the polling station was courteous and revealed that 1,400 people had voted. But another government polling official was menacing and tried to get police to detain me. Armed officers came up and tried to detain me again when I was speaking to a local resident about the election. Under such daunting circumstances, the MDC supporters in Muzarabani were pleased to have at least one representative in every one of the constituency's 51 polling stations. "The courage and strength of the local MDC people has taken Zanu PF by surprise," said Chris Pearce, a driver for the Zimbabwe Citizens Support Group which transported the MDC polling agents to the remote polling stations. "The government did not expect to see MDC officials at every polling station. They are taken aback. We feel we have won."

From The Guardian (UK), 11 March

'We won't move from here till we vote'

Samson Kandiyado endured 21 hours under the baking sun followed by a damp night to keep his place in the line to consign Robert Mugabe to history. But when he finally stood before the polling officer yesterday afternoon, she claimed his name was not on the electoral roll. "They said I do not exist," he said. "They use every trick. They pretended they couldn't find my name. They looked under 'Z' when I'm called Kandiyado. I argued with them and then after a long time they found my name." Last night, the Harare high court ordered that Zimbabwe's presidential election be extended to a third day as hundreds of thousands of residents of the capital and its neighbouring townships claimed the ruling party had engineered horrendous queues and laborious voting procedures to keep people away from the polls in urban areas where Mr Mugabe is widely loathed. The government said it would appeal. Shortly before the court ruling, riot police fired tear gas to disperse people protesting at the polls closing while many were still waiting to vote. Tens of thousands more had simply given up and gone home. In the countryside, it was a different story. The government was keen for people to vote in the belief there is either genuine support for Mr Mugabe among the very poor or that months of violence and intimidation will have made people too afraid to vote against him. But there were signs of defiance yesterday among some rural voters.

Mr Mugabe's main rival, Morgan Tsvangirai, persuaded the Harare high court to extend the election into a third day because he said the government was trying to stave off defeat by stripping many of his supporters of the right to vote. "Zanu-PF is now engaged in a last-ditch effort to stop people from voting it out of power by ensuring that the voting process in [opposition] strongholds is slowed down," he said. The US embassy in Harare warned of "massive disenfranchisement of urban voters". Zimbabwe's independent electoral observers accused the government of robbing hundreds of thousands of people of their vote. The South African observer mission calculated that it would take five days for everyone to vote in the capital. General Abdulsalami Abubakar, the former military ruler of Nigeria who leads the Commonwealth observer mission, joined other monitors in calling for an extension of the voting. The ruling Zanu-PF responded by claiming it had uncovered a "white" plot to discredit the election. The government said it had detained two British citizens and two Americans arrested for carrying "illegal radio equipment", but it transpired they were Zimbabwean residents detained with dozens of other opposition activists attempting to monitor the polls. The frustrations of voting are further evidence of the lengths to which Mr Mugabe is going, after 22 years in power, to disenfranchise his opponents. The government and opposition alike implicitly agree that the outcome of the election hinges on the turnout in urban areas. The opposition Movement for Democratic Change believes a substantial vote in the towns and cities, where 60% of voters are registered, will be enough to offset the rigging and intimidation which plague rural constituencies.

The government's own statistics at the end of the first day of voting on Saturday reveal how successful it has been in keeping the urban vote down. Harare and Chitungwiza account for one in six registered electors. According to the state electoral commission's figures, the turnout in the capital and its main township on the first day of voting was 18%, half that of almost every other province. In the traditional Mugabe stronghold of Mashonaland East, the turnout on Saturday alone was officially 44%. But in Mashonaland, ruling party militia and war veterans arrived at some villages before dawn and herded the entire population to the polls with warnings that the vote is not secret. In some rural polling stations, the police and election officials stood over voters as they marked their ballots. Election observers also said there was evidence of ballot boxes already stuffed with votes being carried into polling places.

A key part of the government's strategy to discourage the urban vote was to reduce the number of polling stations and create long queues. In the Zengeza district of Chitungwiza, the government nearly halved the number of polling places. At Zengeza 2 voting station, several hundred people were already in before it opened on Saturday morning. Within hours, the queue stretched hundreds of yards and grew through the day to more than 2,000 people, who were shuffling through the polling station at the rate of less than 50 an hour. "People really know what the government is doing," said Emanuel Nyauagwa. "It's part of the rigging. They don't want us to express what we think. They don't want urban voters to vote. But I tell you one thing, we won't move from here. We won't just accept the situation as it is." The government has tried to explain away the cut in polling stations in Chitungwiza and Harare by saying it was saving money or that additional ballot boxes were needed in rural areas to cut the distance people had to travel. But the empty rural voting stations on Sunday belied that claim. Zimbabwe's information minister, Jonathan Moyo, laid the ground to dismiss the low voting figures in urban areas as the result of apathy. "I have been quite interested to see claims of a massive turnout in urban areas, quite clearly based on the queues instead of numbers. All things being equal, we are expecting a much larger turnout in the rural areas than the urban areas," he said.

From The Daily Telegraph (UK), 11 March

Mugabe's rural voters shun polling stations

Harare/Matabeleland/Mashonaland - The sight of election agents fanning themselves with voter education posters outside deserted polling stations demonstrated graphically the low turnout in President Mugabe's strongholds in rural Zimbabwe yesterday. One polling station after another in Mashonaland was visited by a handful of voters, while election officials sat listlessly on the grass. The schools, farm buildings and local government offices that house the ballot boxes appeared abandoned. In the typical rural constituency of Hurungwe West barely 400 people voted in the 35 polling stations on Saturday, the first day of Zimbabwe's presidential election. This seemed to have declined further yesterday. The constituency has 42,000 electors. In Banket, Lion's Den, Mhangura and Chinhoyi, which all returned MPs from Mr Mugabe's Zanu-PF party in the June 2000 parliamentary elections, polling stations were similarly deserted. During those elections, queues were common. The contrast will worry Mr Mugabe and his men. If the trend is representative, the turnout in Mashonaland West province - Mr Mugabe's home area - is unlikely to exceed 50 per cent. In 2000, the president relied on this heartland to counter-balance the rejection he suffered in the cities. This time, people living in Mashonaland suspect that the voting figures may be massaged to guarantee that Mr Mugabe achieves the majority he needs. "If they announce a high count here, then it's a fact that the ballot boxes will have been loaded. We will all know," said a farmer who has been monitoring the election.

The first figures from election officials did show eye-catching variations. While it was claimed that 44 per cent voted in Mashonaland East during the first day of polling, the figure for the opposition-dominated Harare district was just 14 per cent. Polling agents for Morgan Tsvangirai's opposition Movement for Democratic Change have been unable to cover more than half the rural polling stations. The rest are virtually devoid of independent scrutiny. In some areas of Mashonaland, the government's agents appeared to be breathing down voters' necks. There were six reports of police entering polling booths and "assisting" voters. Police ordered whites to stay away from polling stations, explaining that their presence was "intimidatory". But even if Mr Mugabe has failed to mobilise his voters, the second element of this marred campaign has been going to plan. Opposition supporters were facing overwhelming problems casting their votes in the big cities, including Harare. The queues forced some voters to queue for up to 16 hours. Few managed to vote within eight hours. A polling booth in the Highfield township had queues four abreast and the average waiting time to vote was eight hours. Outside the Highfield High School was a large pile of uncollected, rotting rubbish because the city has been without a mayor and council for three years. The township has become a ghetto, and most of its occupants live in extreme poverty.

Jonathan Chinhoyi, 44, a machinist, arrived at 3.30am at one of only two Highfield polling booths. Thin, cheerful, but desperately tired, he said: "I voted for Zanu-PF in 1980, for independence. I voted for them again in 1985, in 1990, in 1995, and I voted twice before for Mugabe. Two years ago I voted for the others." He laughed. "I don't care if I wait here for another 224 hours," he said. "I will vote. We must have change." In the queue were people too tired to talk, many were fractious, yet all were determined to stay. There was also a hint of future trouble. Kiasi Sithole, 30, had abandoned the queue, and hoped to return when it shortened. "I will come back, but it is too long now. If we are not able to vote, we will take to the streets," he said. At the Batanai Primary School, in Mabvuku, east of Harare, another decrepit ghetto, a queue filled with stoic people, hungry, thirsty, and desperately tired, some with swollen feet from standing so long. The picture was repeated in the wealthy suburb of Avondale, a mixture of some of the most elegant homes in Africa and middle-class flats. Here the queue forced many people to wait for 16 hours.

In the opposition stronghold of Matabeleland, there were reports of MDC polling agents "disappearing" on the way to polling stations; of sealed ballot boxes being reopened illegally; of armed Mugabe supporters lining up voters in groups of 10 to make sure they voted for their man. Aware that the MDC has overwhelming support in the cities, election officials simply cut by half the number of urban polling stations. It was a direct if clumsy way of reducing the urban vote, as the polling stations simply did not have the capacity to deal with the huge flow of voters, many of whom went home without casting their votes. Out in the countryside, the opposite was true. "Every other village has a polling station and how can we possibly monitor them all especially when they are moving from place to place," one MDC activist said. "They are making it very difficult for us but we are doing the best we can."

Back to the Top
Back to Index

Reuters

Mugabe defies ruling on extending voting


11 March, 2002 04:55 GMT

By Cris Chinaka and Stella Mapenzauswa

HARARE (Reuters) - Robert Mugabe's government has defied a court order to
keep all polling stations open to ensure Zimbabwe's presidential election
was fair, though it did agree to extend voting in two key opposition
strongholds.

With long queues of voters still lining up to cast their ballots on Sunday
evening after two days and President Mugabe's challenger saying electoral
officials were on a go-slow to thwart him, a High Court judge ordered a
third day of voting.

But early on Monday, the government said it would extend the election only
in the capital Harare and in nearby Chitungwiza settlement, the two places
originally cited by the opposition Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) in
its plea to the court.

Supporters of MDC leader Morgan Tsvangirai, Mugabe's toughest challenger in
22 years in power, also complained that police were using the court ruling
to stop late-night voting on Sunday and beat away thousands still waiting to
cast ballots.

Quoting Justice Minister Patrick Chinamasa, state radio said the polling
stations would reopen only in the two areas that had the longest queues late
on Sunday.

"Comrade Chinamasa has said it is impossible to comply with the order to
extend the vote nationwide because in some areas, polling has already closed
and ballot boxes have already been returned," the radio said.

It was not clear whether counting would begin on Monday or wait until after
the extended vote in the Harare area.

Political analysts believe Tsvangirai commands a majority but say he is
unlikely to win after two years of intimidation, legal manipulation and
dirty tricks by the ruling ZANU-PF party.

Mugabe, 78, has taken the former Rhodesia from civil war and white minority
rule to prosperity in the 1980s and now to penury that threatens the
stability of the southern African region.

Britain, the former colonial power, and the United States have warned him a
rigged election could destabilise the country.

SOUTH AFRICAN FEARS

Neighbouring South Africa, widely criticised for failing to condemn Mugabe's
handling of his political and economic crises, fears a meltdown would cause
a flood of refugees.

Witnesses said on Sunday that the opposition's court victory might have
backfired within hours.

Riot police fanned out across Harare within an hour of the decision,
shutting down polling stations that the authorities had promised to keep
open all night to process queues of votes. The MDC has done very well in
Harare in previous elections.

"The authorities are closing all the polling stations in Harare because of
the court decision," Norwegian observer Kare Vollan told Reuters at 11 p.m.
(9 p.m. British time) at Warren Park, a western Harare township where there
was a huge voter turnout.

He said at least 1,000 voters had been turned away, adding: "We have reports
of the same closures all over the town."

Witnesses said riot police shut down another polling station about an hour
after the ruling, scattering around 2,500 people who had waited most of the
day.

The MDC had sought the court order on Sunday after thousands of voters had
waited up to 20 hours to vote on Saturday.

Police clashed at least three times with angry voters who suspected a
deliberate bid to undermine the opposition.

OPPOSITION ANGRY

The MDC said in a statement late on Sunday that its court victory was being
undone by the government's decision to close polling stations it had
promised to keep open all night.

"This evening, the government of Zimbabwe took a deliberate decision to deny
hundreds of thousands of Zimbabweans the right to vote by closing polling
stations...despite its earlier undertaking that polling stations would
remain open for as long as there were people still queuing to vote.

"At the time the high court was making the order, police were busy closing
polling stations in Harare and Chitungwiza, beating up people queuing to
vote and ordering them to go home because 'polling was over'," the MDC
statement said.

Election Registrar-General Tobaiwa Mudede said on state television that a
nation extension was unnecessary.

"The whole country has voted, with the exception of about 10 polling
stations in Harare. Those are the reports that we have. But we do not close
out people who are in the queues, they are allowed to vote," he said.

Mudede said, however, that by midday on Sunday barely a quarter of the
voters registered in Harare had cast their ballots. The 205,000 votes
gathered was about half the number that voted in parliamentary elections in
June 2000.

The independent Zimbabwe Human Rights Forum reported attacks on opposition
supporters on Sunday and on MDC election agents and monitors officially
mandated to oversee rural voting.

The forum said at least 58 people, including 11 white farmers, two Americans
and two Britons had been arrested for a variety of alleged offences.
Back to the Top
Back to Index

BBC
 
Monday, 11 March, 2002, 02:16 GMT
Uncertainty clouds Zimbabwe vote
Voters at Mbare
Many voters were still queuing by Sunday evening
Zimbabweans are facing a day of uncertainty following a High Court extension of the weekend's presidential elections.

Supporters of the opposition Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) and observer groups welcomed the decision, which gives hope to large numbers of people still waiting in queues to cast their vote.


[The court] ordered that an extension be granted not only for Harare... but the whole country until close of voting tomorrow

Eric Matinenga
Lawyer for MDC
The MDC has accused the government of deliberately slowing the pace of voting in the capital, Harare, to improve President Robert Mugabe's chances of getting reelected.

But correspondents say it is not clear what exactly will happen on Monday morning- the government could win its appeal against the ruling or simply ignore it.

Morgan Tsvangirai votes
Tsvangirai said he could not "prejudge" the vote's outcome
Justice Minister Patrick Chinamasa had said those still queuing when polls closed on Sunday would be allowed to vote, but that any further extension was unnecessary.

And even if the court's decision comes into force, observers point out it may not be an unmitigated boon for the MDC.

As polling stations across the country will open for a third day, this could allow the ruling Zanu-PF to add votes in rural areas where its support is strongest.

As the time for the official end of voting passed on Sunday at 1900 local time (1700GMT), thousands of people were still waiting to cast their ballot.

Witnesses said that following the court ruling, police dispersed thousands of people waiting to vote at polling stations in Harare that had stayed open after they were due to close.


HAVE YOU VOTED?

Our names had to be checked on four different rolls and as those checking didn't know the alphabet, this took ages

Brian, Zimbabwe
arrow Click here to tell us your experiences

Some 5.6 million people have been eligible to vote in the election, in which President Mugabe faces a strong challenge to his 22-year rule from MDC leader Morgan Tsvangirai.

Mr Tsvangirai celebrated his 50th birthday on Sunday, and voters sang Happy Birthday To You when he visited Evendale polling station in Harare.

Meanwhile two Britons and an American have been arrested in the east of the country after being accused of attending an illegal gathering.

'Not fair'

Election Registrar-General Tobaiwa Mudede said that everyone who wanted to vote would have the chance to do so, but he did not say whether the authorities would comply with the court order.


Zimbabwe votes:
  • Leading candidates: President Mugabe and Morgan Tsvangirai
  • Polling originally scheduled for two days
  • 5.6 million registered to vote
  • 4,548 polling stations in 120 constituencies

    Regional reports

  • He said that by 1400 (1200GMT) on Sunday 2,475,147 people had been to the polls, out of 5.6 million registered voters.

    "The whole country has voted, with the exception of about 10 polling stations in Harare," said Mr Mudede.

    More than 5,000 people were reported to be waiting at one voting station in the Kuwadzana district of the capital late on Sunday.

    "It is not fair. Voting is not a crime. We are not happy at all," said Peter Chiriseri, as he waited to vote.

    Back to the Top
    Back to Index

    The Scotsman

    Why I reject Mugabe, by his ex-mentor

    Jacqui Goddard In Harare


    PRESIDENT Robert Mugabe’s power base was crumbling around him last night
    after one of his party’s key members and founding fathers broke ranks to
    call for the formation of a government of national unity.

    Eddison Zvobgo, a respected political heavyweight known as a "kingmaker" due
    to the influence he commands within the ruling ZANU-PF party, told The
    Scotsman in an exclusive interview of his hopes that Mr Mugabe would accept
    a dignified exit from power in the likely event of a defeat in the weekend’s
    presidential election.

    He also spoke of Mr Mugabe’s controversial land-grab scheme as "the devil
    which has spoiled everything" and condemned attempts at driving through
    unconstitutional legislation as "bristling with arrows pointed at the heart
    of freedom".

    Dr Zvobgo dismissed threats made last week by the government’s external
    affairs chief, Didymus Mutasa, that ZANU-PF would launch a military coup to
    keep Mr Mugabe in power if opposition candidate Morgan Tsvangirai scoops
    victory.

    Hinting at deep rifts among the president’s political and military circle,
    he revealed that the party’s "official position" is that it will abide by
    the result and will not tolerate attempts to subvert it. "There are plenty
    of other sources who strengthen that view," he said. "We are a democratic
    people . I cannot see what would be gained by any attempt to do otherwise."

    He acknowledged that there could yet be an abortive coup attempt, but
    appeared confident that few within the armed forces would actually join it.

    "Even if such a thing happened and succeeded, it would not be permanent. I
    don’t lose sleep over that issue."

    With the country gripped by shortages of fuel and staple foods such as maize
    meal and cooking oil, mired in economic and agricultural crisis and
    suffering an unprecedented 116 per cent inflation and 70 per cent
    unemployment rate, Dr Zvobgo admitted that the government should accept
    blame. "People are angry," he said.

    While Mr Mugabe has regularly claimed that British neo-colonial interference
    is responsible for the state of the country, Dr Zvobgo said: "I am not one
    who believes in blaming the world for the plight in which we find ourselves.
    Sure, some factors were beyond our control, but others were within our grasp
    and we either mismanaged or we hesitated and lost an opportunity.

    "Clearly we have not finished what we set out to do.

    "I believe that because of the magnitude of the problems we face and also
    because of the squeezing and fracturing of society which these problems have
    caused, that a government of national unity would make matters easier. All
    the political energies could be harnessed towards state objectives and we
    would stand a great chance of being listened to sympathetically by those who
    have the means to help - the European Union, the US and so on."

    In particular, he said, the failure to come up with an orderly and legal
    land redistribution scheme - instead allowing the war veterans to launch
    sometimes bloody farm invasions - has caused problems.

    "The devil which has spoiled everything was when we decided to take land,"
    he admitted. "That was really the crunch."

    Despite agreement on all sides that Zimbabwe’s white-owned farmlands needed
    to be more fairly shared out among the majority black community, the search
    for a constitutionally viable method was pre-empted when the war veterans
    finally lost patience.

    As the land question descended into lawlessness, the World Bank,
    International Monetary Fund, financial institutions and foreign donors
    pulled the plug on Zimbabwe.


    ‘The devil which has spoiled everything. That was the crunch’ EDDISON ZVOBGO



    "The pack of cards started crumbling," said Dr Zvobgo. "I had always been
    aware that doing it that way would be a disaster."

    "I spent 10 years in prison during the liberation struggle, but I didn’t go
    through all that personal sacrifice simply for land," said Dr Zvobgo. "It
    was about matters of human dignity, an end to racism, opening up the
    opportunity for the human soul to freely soar so that every person can reach
    their highest capabilities."

    Though careful to avoid direct personal criticism of Mr Mugabe and refusing
    to denounce ZANU-PF as a party, Dr Zvobgo is known to be deeply disappointed
    by the violence that has overshadowed the campaign, at times fanned by
    inflammatory remarks at executive level.

    His tacit withdrawal of support from the president is a devastating blow for
    the man who has led Zimbabwe throughout its 22 post-colonial years. A lawyer
    by profession, Dr Zvobgo is viewed on both sides as a man of integrity whose
    opinions are widely respected.

    In 1963, he announced the formation of the ZANU party - later to become
    ZANU-PF - and wrote the party’s constitution. A former member of the
    politburo, he has served at ministerial level in various government
    departments for over 20 years.

    Crucially, his constituency of Masvingo South holds 600,000 registered
    voters - the third highest concentration in the country. His unspoken
    signals to the electorate have not gone unnoticed: during a public gala
    arranged by ZANU-PF to celebrate a rural electrification project in the MP’s
    home area last month, Dr Zvobgo pointedly declined to take a place on the
    platform, instead choosing to sit among the crowd.

    In recent days, the MDC reported that it has enjoyed the full co-operation
    of ZANU-PF party structures in Masvingo South during its campaign activities
    in the area, saying that Mr Mugabe’s militia and so-called war veterans
    appear to have been reined back.

    Now, says the MP, it is time for the country to move forward by democratic
    and open means.

    "If any minister brings in a piece of legislation which is shoddy,
    badly-crafted, bristling with arrows pointed at the heart of freedom, my
    committee will have no hesitation in saying No," he said, referring to Mr
    Mugabe’s access to information and freedom of the media bill, which the
    parliamentary legal affairs committee of which Dr Zvobgo is chairman
    declared unconstitutional on 20 counts last month.

    He added: "Information cannot be controlled. It’s like fighting the Pope -
    you know you could never win."

    As polling closed last night, with Zimbabweans now awaiting the result of
    the election, expected by tomorrow afternoon at the earliest, Dr Zvobgo
    accepted that there is a mood for change.

    But beneath the tension that obviously exists between them, Dr Zvobgo still
    has not lost respect for the man who led Zimbabwe to independence. "I would
    not want to see him living in exile. I would like to see him remain here in
    the role of an elder statesmen and see Morgan [Tsvangirai] going to his
    house for advice, the kind of role that Nelson Mandela has, a father of the
    nation.

    "People can never say goodbye to their history. Mugabe is part of the
    history of this country - I would wish him well if he would accept it."

    Back to the Top
    Back to Index

    Voters defiant in Mugabe heartland

    Electorate in rural areas regarded as president's stronghold are resisting
    intimidation to vote for opposition

    Andrew Meldrum in Muzarabani
    Monday March 11, 2002
    The Guardian

    This may be President Robert Mugabe's stronghold but voters in Zimbabwe's
    rural areas are not likely to deliver the resounding endorsement he is
    expecting.
    Voters in the Muzarabani constituency braved gangs of Mr Mugabe's youth
    militia and intimidation from police and the Central Intelligence
    Organisation (CIO) to cast their ballots. In interviews with the Guardian,
    voters refused to declare their support for Mr Mugabe.

    Muzarabani, in Mashonaland Central, is considered a bastion of the ruling
    Zanu-PF party. The number of polling stations in the constituency was
    increased by 82%, apparently because the Mugabe government was confident of
    support there. This increase in the sparsely populated area is in dramatic
    contrast to Harare and other cities where polling stations were reduced.

    To further beef up the vote for Mr Mugabe, Muzarabani was declared a "no go"
    area for Mr Tsvangirai's opposition party, the Movement for Democratic
    Change (MDC). Open campaigning here was impossible and the MDC's efforts
    simply to get its polling agents to monitor the voting was met with
    state-sponsored violence.

    There are signs that even here, in Mr Mugabe's heartland, support for him is
    waning. Residents say that hunger and violence are the issues they are most
    concerned about.

    "I am not happy with the situation, but I voted for the candidate of my
    choice," said a grey-haired peasant farmer, who was too frightened to say he
    supported Mr Tsvangirai. "My vote is my secret."

    "Mugabe's militia and war veterans say they don't want to see any MDC here
    and they say they will kill us," said Peter Mukorera, 32, the MDC's
    constituency chairman. "And the police don't give us any protection. It is
    very rough."

    Mr Mukorera was shot at, stoned and threatened with death at Utete polling
    station on Saturday while police stood by. Police took the keys to two
    vehicles he and others were using to transport party polling agents and a
    few hours later the vehicles were set alight by the Mugabe supporters who
    had a base camp next to the polling station.

    "I ran through the bush and I fell down twice from fright when they shot the
    guns," said Mr Mukorera. "I kept running and finally slept in the bush.
    Later I hiked out but two of our officials are still missing."

    Mr Mukorera said his home was burned to the ground six weeks ago.

    Two more MDC vehicles in Muzarabani were impounded by police yesterday.

    The violence encountered by Mr Mukorera was part of a systematic nationwide
    campaign against MDC polling agents in rural areas. In Karoi, in Mashonaland
    West province, one MDC polling agent was beaten and drowned while another
    was wrapped in hay and set alight and is now in hospital, according to local
    residents. Other agents were beaten in nearby Banket.

    In Shamva, in Mashonaland East, about 20 MDC polling agents were attacked by
    youth militia on Friday. They got their wounds stitched up and then many
    returned to their pollings stations for voting on Saturday.

    In Honde Valley, in eastern Manicaland province, 80 MDC polling agents were
    illegally detained by the army and several were beaten. Four of the polling
    officials are still missing, according to the Human Rights Forum. In the
    southern area of Matabeleland, two vehicles transporting MDC polling agents
    were attacked and three agents are missing, according to witnesses.

    The MDC estimates that more than 50% of the country's rural polling stations
    have operated without the presence of any opposition representatives. Under
    new electoral laws decreed by Mr Mugabe last week, all other polling
    officials are appointed by the government, so the opposition party agents
    are the only guarantee that there is no ballot stuffing or other
    irregularities.

    A threatening atmosphere hung over the Gatu polling station, in Muzarabani,
    when I visited it yesterday afternoon. Clusters of thuggish youth militia
    waited around on dusty paths nearby and threatened Peter Mukorera, the MDC
    official I interviewed, while I was standing just a few feet away.

    The presiding officer at the polling station was courteous and revealed that
    1,400 people had voted. But another government polling official was menacing
    and tried to get police to detain me. Armed officers came up and tried to
    detain me again when I was speaking to a local resident about the election.

    Under such daunting circumstances, the MDC supporters in Muzarabani were
    pleased to have at least one representative in every one of the
    constituency's 51 polling stations.

    "The courage and strength of the local MDC people has taken Zanu-PF by
    surprise," said Chris Pearce, a driver for the Zimbabwe Citizens Support
    Group which transported the MDC polling agents to the remote polling
    stations. "The government did not expect to see MDC officials at every
    polling station. They are taken aback. We feel we have won."

    Back to the Top
    Back to Index

    Mugabe's rural voters shun polling stations

    By Peta Thornycroft in Harare, Tim Butcher in Matabeleland and a Special
    Correspondent in Mashonaland
    (Filed: 11/03/2002)


    THE sight of election agents fanning themselves with voter education posters
    outside deserted polling stations demonstrated graphically the low turnout
    in President Mugabe's strongholds in rural Zimbabwe yesterday.

    One polling station after another in Mashonaland was visited by a handful of
    voters, while election officials sat listlessly on the grass.

    The schools, farm buildings and local government offices that house the
    ballot boxes appeared abandoned.

    In the typical rural constituency of Hurungwe West barely 400 people voted
    in the 35 polling stations on Saturday, the first day of Zimbabwe's
    presidential election. This seemed to have declined further yesterday. The
    constituency has 42,000 electors.

    In Banket, Lion's Den, Mhangura and Chinhoyi, which all returned MPs from Mr
    Mugabe's Zanu-PF party in the June 2000 parliamentary elections, polling
    stations were similarly deserted.

    During those elections, queues were common. The contrast will worry Mr
    Mugabe and his men.

    If the trend is representative, the turnout in Mashonaland West province -
    Mr Mugabe's home area - is unlikely to exceed 50 per cent.

    In 2000, the president relied on this heartland to counter-balance the
    rejection he suffered in the cities. This time, people living in Mashonaland
    suspect that the voting figures may be massaged to guarantee that Mr Mugabe
    achieves the majority he needs. "If they announce a high count here, then
    it's a fact that the ballot boxes will have been loaded. We will all know,"
    said a farmer who has been monitoring the election.

    The first figures from election officials did show eye-catching variations.
    While it was claimed that 44 per cent voted in Mashonaland East during the
    first day of polling, the figure for the opposition-dominated Harare
    district was just 14 per cent.

    Polling agents for Morgan Tsvangirai's opposition Movement for Democratic
    Change have been unable to cover more than half the rural polling stations.
    The rest are virtually devoid of independent scrutiny.

    In some areas of Mashonaland, the government's agents appeared to be
    breathing down voters' necks. There were six reports of police entering
    polling booths and "assisting" voters. Police ordered whites to stay away
    from polling stations, explaining that their presence was "intimidatory".

    But even if Mr Mugabe has failed to mobilise his voters, the second element
    of this marred campaign has been going to plan.

    Opposition supporters were facing overwhelming problems casting their votes
    in the big cities, including Harare. The queues forced some voters to queue
    for up to 16 hours. Few managed to vote within eight hours.

    A polling booth in the Highfield township had queues four abreast and the
    average waiting time to vote was eight hours.

    Outside the Highfield High School was a large pile of uncollected, rotting
    rubbish because the city has been without a mayor and council for three
    years. The township has become a ghetto, and most of its occupants live in
    extreme poverty.

    Jonathan Chinhoyi, 44, a machinist, arrived at 3.30am at one of only two
    Highfield polling booths.

    Thin, cheerful, but desperately tired, he said: "I voted for Zanu-PF in
    1980, for independence. I voted for them again in 1985, in 1990, in 1995,
    and I voted twice before for Mugabe. Two years ago I voted for the others."
    He laughed. "I don't care if I wait here for another 224 hours," he said. "I
    will vote. We must have change."

    In the queue were people too tired to talk, many were fractious, yet all
    were determined to stay. There was also a hint of future trouble. Kiasi
    Sithole, 30, had abandoned the queue, and hoped to return when it shortened.
    "I will come back, but it is too long now. If we are not able to vote, we
    will take to the streets," he said.

    At the Batanai Primary School, in Mabvuku, east of Harare, another decrepit
    ghetto, a queue filled with stoic people, hungry, thirsty, and desperately
    tired, some with swollen feet from standing so long.

    The picture was repeated in the wealthy suburb of Avondale, a mixture of
    some of the most elegant homes in Africa and middle-class flats. Here the
    queue forced many people to wait for 16 hours.

    In the opposition stronghold of Matabeleland, there were reports of MDC
    polling agents "disappearing" on the way to polling stations; of sealed
    ballot boxes being reopened illegally; of armed Mugabe supporters lining up
    voters in groups of 10 to make sure they voted for their man. Aware that the
    MDC has overwhelming support in the cities, election officials simply cut by
    half the number of urban polling stations.

    It was a direct if clumsy way of reducing the urban vote, as the polling
    stations simply did not have the capacity to deal with the huge flow of
    voters, many of whom went home without casting their votes.

    Out in the countryside, the opposite was true. "Every other village has a
    polling station and how can we possibly monitor them all especially when
    they are moving from place to place," one MDC activist said. "They are
    making it very difficult for us but we are doing the best we can."


    Back to the Top
    Back to Index

    Mugabe's men lash out at monitors
    BILLY BRIGGS
    THE intimidation of voters trying to oust Robert Mugabe, the Zimbabwean
    president, continued yesterday with human rights monitors and the opposition
    reporting arrests and beatings across the country.

    The independent Zimbabwean Human Rights Forum said at least 58 people had
    been arrested by yesterday, the second day of the presidential election.

    They included 11 white farmers detained while helping opposition election
    monitors, and two Britons and two Americans arrested on charges of having
    illegal radio equipment and dozens of opposition election monitors.

    John Nkomo, Zimbabwe's home affairs minister, accused the four, detained on
    Friday, of seeking to disrupt the weekend election, in which Mugabe faces
    the strongest challenge of his 22 years in power.

    Nkomo said on state TV: "They were found in possession of radio
    communications equipment. The men were armed with security equipment. They
    are working to disrupt the elections."

    A US embassy spokesman confirmed the arrest of one American who faces a
    charge of attending an illegal gathering but said he was not aware of the
    second arrest.

    A spokesman for the British High Commission confirmed the arrest of two
    Britons, but gave no further details.

    The human rights forum said police and liberation-war veterans loyal to
    Mugabe had attacked poll monitors in several areas.

    One of them had his hands tied behind his back before being beaten by
    Mugabe's supporters with iron bars and sticks, according to the forum.

    Their backs were livid with whip marks and some had gashes on their heads
    and arms.

    The opposition Movement for Democratic Change (MDC), whose leader Morgan
    Tsvangirai has the best chance since independence in 1980 of unseating
    Mugabe, yesterday listed attacks around the country.

    The party said in a statement: "The attacks appear to be systematically
    implemented and are clearly aimed at preventing MDC officials from observing
    the voting process."

    It said the homes of several MDC supporters were firebombed in Mashonaland
    West in northern Zimbabwe, where police arrested several groups of MDC
    supporters.

    In Harare, police looked on as Zanu-PF militia attacked people waiting to
    vote in Mbare township, the MDC said.

    The party said MDC polling agents appointed to monitor voting procedures
    were arrested and beaten in Umbanje in rural Manicaland in the east of the
    country.

    The MDC said: "The agents were attacked and severely beaten and had darts
    stabbed into their feet."

    In other areas MDC supporters had their identity cards destroyed to prevent
    them voting.

    Mugabe, 78, and his Zimbabwean African National Union Patriotic Front, have
    ruled this southern African nation since independence in 1980 without
    significant dissent - until recent years, when the economy was thrown into
    its worst ever crisis.

    Tsvangirai is promising to revive the economy and end corruption. Mugabe,
    however, has painted him as a servant to white interests, and has pledged to
    continue the controversial policy of seizing white-owned farms and giving
    them to landless blacks.

    Two weeks ago, Tsvangirai was charged with treason in connection with an
    alleged plot to assassinate Mugabe, an allegation he has denied.

    -March 11th

    Back to the Top
    Back to Index

    Government Will Partially Comply With Court Order
    allAfrica.com

    March 10, 2002
    Posted to the web March 11, 2002

    Ofeibea Quist-Arcton
    Harare

    The Zimbabwe government has agreed partially to comply with a High Court
    ruling extending the vote in the presidential election for a third day on
    Monday. The announcement came in a late night broadcast on state radio,
    hours after the authorities had indicated they would appeal the High Court
    decision.

    The opposition Movement for Democratic Change, led by Morgan Tsvangirai who
    is challenging Robert Mugabe for the presidency, had petitioned the court,
    seeking an extension of voting after long delays prevented tens of thousands
    from casting their ballot at the weekend.

    The MDC had asked for polling stations in its strongholds in the capital
    Harare, and nearby Chitungwiza, to remain open for at least another day on
    Monday. But the court decision ordered that voting centres nationwide should
    open for an extra day to allow people to vote.

    In the one o’clock radio bulletin early on Monday morning, quoting the
    justice minister Patrick Chinamasa, the news reader said: "The government
    will comply with the order in Harare (the capital) and (nearby) Chitungwiza.
    It is complying to avoid confusion. Comrade Chinamasa has said it is
    impossible to comply with the order to extend the vote nationwide, because
    in some areas, polling has already closed and ballot boxes have already been
    returned."

    But the radio bulletin may confuse would-be voters, because it said the
    government had agreed only to the vote continuing in the capital and
    Chitungwiza and not, as they were expecting, in other parts of Zimbabwe.

    By chopping and changing its initial position at the dead of night, the
    government is keeping weary Zimbabweans and the opposition on their toes.
    Most people would have gone to bed on Sunday, expecting the authorities to
    challenge the MDC’s court victory in the morning. They may now wake up on
    Monday not quite knowing whether or not they have the right to vote, and
    where, if they have not already done so.

    The government's detractors see this as a further strategy by the
    authorities to thwart voters who, however, appeared determined to wait as
    long as it took to enter polling stations on Sunday, despite the frustrating
    delays on Saturday.

    Shortly after the court ruling on Sunday, police shut down polling stations
    that had stayed open late, after the scheduled 7pm closing time and told
    voters to return on Monday.

    The opposition has accused Mugabe’s government of deliberately reducing the
    number of polling stations in Harare and other urban MDC bastions to improve
    Mugabe’s chances of winning the election and deny MDC supporters the vote.
    The president draws most of his support from the rural areas, where polling
    proceeded smoothly at the weekend, with more than enough centres to
    accommodate the voters.

    Back to the Top
    Back to Index

    Business  Day

    Credit to Zimbabweans for a peaceful election

    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------
    ----
    It would be folly to assume that the truce' will hold once result of the
    poll is known
    IT IS to the credit of Zimbabweans that despite the violent build-up to the
    weekend's presidential poll, the actual polling days were largely peaceful.

    While fear had been expressed in many quarters that the ballot could turn
    bloody with more than 100 people having died in political violence in the
    past two years only isolated incidents of violence and intimidation were
    reported during voting.

    It would be folly, however, to assume that the "truce" between supporters of
    both Zanu (PF) and the Movement for Democratic Change at the weekend will
    hold once the result of the election is known, or that this commendable
    behaviour by voters will in itself lead to Zimbabwe's myriad problems being
    resolved anytime soon.

    The outcome of the poll and how it will be received by the international
    community will be key to how events in the country unravel in the new few
    days.

    For the main candidates in the poll Robert Mugabe and Morgan Tsvangirai
    winning the vote is likely to prove a relatively easier job compared to the
    task of turning around Zimbabwe's sagging political and economic fortunes.

    This mammoth task will require no less than the biblical wisdom of Solomon
    and the entrepreneurial spirit prevalent during the Industrial Revolution.

    The violence that marked the build-up to the weekend poll will require real
    statesmanship of whoever wins as interparty political tensions are simply
    too high now to just hope that time will heal the wounds. It will demand of
    the victor to extend a hand of reconciliation to the loser and his
    supporters in a real and meaningful way. In this context, some kind of
    government of national unity although not viewed favourably by both
    candidates may not be out of place.

    But the biggest job, of course, will be undoing the damage that the 22 years
    of Zanu (PF) rule have wreaked on the economy. Resuscitating the ailing
    economy and embarking on a new Reconstruction and Development Programme
    reminiscent of the SA initiative in the mid 1990s and Zimbabwe's own
    post-war efforts when Mugabe came to power will also in part mitigate the
    political problems.

    The rampant high inflation, currently at a staggering 117%, and skyrocketing
    prices of basic commodities will have to be brought down as soon as possible
    to bring some relief to long-suffering Zimbabweans.

    This will require outsiders (including the World Bank and the International
    Monetary Fund which have left the country) to come aboard and help. It
    remains doubtful, of course, whether these institutions would come back in
    the event of a Mugabe win.

    That Zimbabweans care about what is happening in their country and who leads
    them has been amply demonstrated by the large turnout of voters at the
    weekend.

    The massive turnout, however, contrasted sharply with a typically crass
    government decision to reduce the number of polling stations in urban areas
    and increase them in the rural areas a move viewed by both critics and the
    opposition as a dirty tactic meant to frustrate urban voters and boost for
    Mugabe from his mainly rural support base.

    But as the international community waits with baited breath for the outcome
    of the poll, spare a thought for President Thabo Mbeki particularly if
    Mugabe is re-elected.

    With the media awash at the weekend with reports of Harare employing these
    sinister tactics to discourage urban voters, and the west having already
    cast doubts on the freeness and fairness of the poll, Mbeki will indeed be
    caught between a rock and a hard place should Mugabe come out victor.

    Whether the SA leader pronounces the ballot free and fair, or disowns
    Mugabe, he will be damned either way.

    If Mbeki gives a "victorious" Mugabe unqualified recognition, he risks being
    painted with the same brush as Mugabe by the west, with ominous consequences
    for SA and the region.

    If he does not recognise the Zimbabwean leader, he could fall foul of the
    other hawkish African leaders, such as Sam Nujoma of Namibia and Angola's
    Eduardo Jose dos Santos, who interpret the Harare crisis as a fight against
    racism and colonialism, and risk being isolated as a "lackey" of British
    Prime Minister Tony Blair as Mugabe's supporters often describe Mbeki when
    he toughens his stance on Zimbabwe.

    Although Mbeki's handling of the Zimbabwean crisis has often been criticised
    sharply in SA, few of these critics have come up with a viable alternative
    that the SA leader could have followed and helped nudge Mugabe in the right
    direction in the process.

    The UK's megaphone diplomacy, for example, has served only to harden
    Mugabe's resolve to expedite his disastrous fast-track land reforms and to
    heighten his hostility towards the opposition.

    The criticism that has been levelled at Mbeki has also seemingly not taken
    into account the fact that Zimbabwe is not just at the heart of the Southern
    African Development Community geographically but also economically and, most
    crucially, politically.

    Until majority rule came to SA eight years ago, Mugabe was the crown prince
    of the region. He set the standards then and continues to wield significance
    influence across the continent as was recently witnessed at the Commonwealth
    Heads of Government Meeting in Coolum, Australia, when all African leaders
    including his supposed enemies such as Yoweri Museveni of Uganda argued
    against Zimbabwe's suspension from the 54-nation body.

    Yet, how SA reacts to the outcome of the poll will be key to how Zimbabwe
    progresses from here and how the international community relates with Harare
    and the region.

    In this vein, the verdict of SA observers on the Zimbabwean poll will be
    crucial to the future of that troubled country, and indeed the region. If
    they mess up, Zimbabwe will slide into anarchy while SA's image will be
    damaged irreparably.

    If their conduct is impeccable irrespective of who wins the ballot the SA
    observers will have made one of the most telling contributions to Zimbabwe's
    rehabilitation. They will also have given further momentum to SA's
    relatively good image in critical markets and our burgeoning democracy.

    It is a tough call.

    Goko is Opinion & Analysis Editor and Dludlu is Managing Editor.
    Mar 11 2002 12:00:00:000AM  Jethro Goko and John Dludlu Business Day 1st
    Edition

       Monday
    11 March 2002
    Back to the Top
    Back to Index

    MEDIA MONITORING PROJECT ZIMBABWE
    Daily Media Update No.9, for March 9th 2002

    DAILY PRINT REPORT FOR MARCH 9TH 2002

    As election day dawned, The Herald continued to devote its pages
    exclusively to promoting the ruling party's candidate.
    The paper led with the story All set for polls, which pretended to be
    an informative piece. However, information on the election was
    confined to its first two sentences providing the number of
    registered voters and the contestants, following which, it became a
    simple story about Mr. Mugabe's Bindura rally. At the rally Mr.
    Mugabe said he wanted peace during and after the elections, but
    demonstrated his insincerity when he revealed his vindictive nature.
    He demonised the MDC, again employing crude and violent
    language: "We want to see if the Movement of Dead Crooks and
    Criminals (MDC) will rise from the dead. If their spirit has the
    capacity to rise, we will deal with them as well. After the election,
    we will not write 'Rest in Peace but Rest in Gehena' (hell)."
    He underplayed the country's economic crisis and took another
    shot at British Premier, Tony Blair: "We got our independence
    when Margaret Thatcher was prime minister but this young fellow
    (Mr Blair) has messed himself again and again over
    Zimbabwe.We doubt his intellectual capacity and integrity."
    The Daily News on the other hand, led its Election Day issue with
    an analysis of the trends in past elections, the number of
    registered voters and their demographic location, and tried to weigh
    the chances of the two main contestants. The high number of
    registered urban voters compared to the rural voters was seen to be
    an advantage to the MDC. The paper noted that MDC's urban
    voters should be prepared to queue for long periods before they
    would be able to cast their votes. (It could not have guessed at the
    extent of the trouble experienced by voters in the capital on polling
    day, as MMPZ's staff experienced at first hand.)  The paper noted
    that urban polling stations have been reduced and said the
    government has been accused of doing this deliberately ".to
    discourage urban voters." (And certainly this turned out to be the
    sentiment in the queues MMPZ visited and joined.)
    The paper also reported that Grace Mugabe had joined her
    husband in insulting the opposition leadership and its supporters.
    She was reported to have told the Bindura rally that: "You cannot
    vote for the MDC because you will be ruled by dogs and cats."
    The Herald also ran a front-page campaign piece for ZANU PF
    masquerading as comment entitled, D-Day for Zimbabwe.
    Hiding behind pan-Africanism, the comment suggested that if the
    electorate did not vote for ZANU PF's candidate, Zimbabwe would
    be doomed to being a ".country where the social and economic
    divide between white and black will be perpetuated". The paper
    also contained another lengthy opinion piece entitled Vote with
    future in mind, which amounted to more unadulterated propaganda
    attacking the MDC as a puppet of imperialist Britain and America.
    The article titled UK Labour Party sends solidarity message to
    MDC, further pushed this idea.
    The Daily News' editorial, You hold your future in your hands today,
    argued that Mr. Mugabe might have himself and his spin-doctors to
    blame at the end of the election: "In desperation, Mugabe has
    allowed himself to be misled and to be lulled into a sense of
    security and supremacy by the overzealousness of the multitude of
    spin-doctors that has surrounded him and blurred his once very
    clear vision and sound judgement."
     The Daily News also carried two promotional pieces for the MDC
    candidate. However, it quoted Tsvangirai speaking in rather more
    rational terms than his rival: "To me this is a watershed election. It
    is a unique opportunity for the people of Zimbabwe to reclaim their
    power and set the country on a new positive course - we cannot
    continue to talk about past victories-problems be solved - the
    power is in the people's hands. They must perform this national
    duty and vote." 
    The Herald reported that the South African and Namibian
    government officials had said the "election will be free and fair." 
    The paper quoted SA's Minister of Safety and Security, Steve
    Tshwete, and the head of the Namibian election observer mission,
    Kaire Mbuende, who had earlier claimed that the media were
    exaggerating political violence in Zimbabwe.
    The Herald story, Political violence declines, seemed calculated to
    paint an image of a free and fair weekend poll. Relying solely on
    police spokesman Tarwireyi Tirivavi, the story said only five cases
    of political violence were reported countrywide the previous day. In
    all the cases, ZANU PF supporters were victims and MDC
    supporters were the perpetrators.
    The Daily News however, carried six articles on political violence in
    which seven incidents were recorded. These included the incredible
    story that ZANU PF youths, the police and soldiers left more than
    100 injured after they beat up singer, Portia Gwanzura and others
    in Gweru, the assault by soldiers on MDC legislator, Evelyn
    Masaiti, at a police station and the confiscation of IDs from
    Dzivaresekwa commuters.
    The Herald also ran an uncritical story, Stage is set for presidential
    poll that painted the image of a flawless electoral process.
    An important article, New regulations limit number of monitors, was
    relegated to inside pages of the paper, stuck between other stories
    and advertisements. Read part of the story: "The Electoral
    (Amendment) Regualtions, 2002 (No 15) gazetted yesterday, gives
    the maximum number of polling agents, monitors, observers and
    journalists who may be present within polling stations. One monitor
    would be required within a polling station at any one time while four
    will be needed per constituency." No journalists would be allowed
    into counting centres.
    The paper also reported that "the Supreme Court reserved
    judgement in several MDC applications seeking .to invalidate
    some of the Electoral Act regulations, which the party felt grossly
    prejudiced it to win the presidential election this weekend."  The full
    complement of the Constitutional Bench was reported to have said
    that it needed time to consider the applications.
    Among other things, the MDC wanted the Registrar-General to
    make available "a copy of the completed common voters' roll, to
    add two days to the polling days, to maintain the same number of
    polling stations as he did in each constituency for the 2000
    parliamentary poll, no votes to be cast outside a polling station,
    and cast other than on March 9 and 10, and that any postal ballots
    be declared invalid."
    The Herald also reported that a Bulawayo High Court judge had
    declared that "foreign nationals" who had been removed from the
    voters' roll should first satisfy the Registrar-General that they are
    still Zimbabweans before they could vote. But the paper didn't
    bother to assess the electoral chaos these last-minute legal
    challenges evidently implied.
    The Daily News missed these important stories, possibly because
    the decisions were made late in the day, after the paper's
    production deadline, which has been compromised ever since its
    presses were bombed in January last year.
    But it did report that the Registrar-General had refused to accredit
    MDC election agents on the basis that their names had not been
    published to match the polling stations to which they were to be
    deployed. The paper quoted MDC spokesman Learnmore Jongwe
    saying Mudede had refused to provide his party with relevant
    information needed to prepare for the poll, such as a list of polling
    stations and voters' rolls.
    The Herald censored news of this extraordinary and unprecedented
    attempt to undermine the democratic process.


    DAILY ELECTRONIC MEDIA REPORT - FOR MARCH 8TH 2002

    THE ELECTORAL PROCESS: ZTV broadcast its second prime
    time programme on voter education. In its Face The Nation
    programme the station interviewed Electoral Supervisory
    Commission chairman Sobusa Gula Ndebele. Viewers who called
    asked Ndebele to tell them who had monitored and observed voting
    by members of the security forces. He expressed ignorance of the
    cases and stated that his commission had only read that in the
    press.  He added that it was irregular for members of the security
    forces to vote before the actual voting day. The interviewer failed to
    ask Ndebele why he was unaware of the issue when Registrar-
    General Tobaiwa Mudede (ZTV, 6/02, 8pm) confirmed private press
    reports that some members of the security forces had already
    voted.
    Ndebele stated the situation on the ground was pointing at free and
    fair elections.
    ZTV (8pm) also attempted to play down allegations of a flawed
    electoral process by quoting regional diplomats who gave the
    process their approval. Two South African ministers Steve Tshwete
    and Membathisi Madladlane were quoted praising the electoral
    process. ZTV quoted Madladlane saying: "We are happy also to
    learn that polling stations are the same as those that were used
    since 1980. And so we don't understand some of these difficulties
    that people are expressing, that they don't know where the polling
    stations are."
    Such a ludicrous statement went unchallenged.
    Immediately after the report, ZTV broadcast a press conference
    addressed by the head of Namibian observer team Kaire Mbuende.
    He said: "We have given the process a benefit of the doubt".
    Mbuende was also quoted as having reiterated his claims that the
    media was exaggerating incidents of violence.
    ZBC ignored the legal changes relating to the electoral process
    during the day. These could only be found in the print media the
    next morning (see above)

    SW Radio Africa carried reports on the situation in various parts of
    the country. The station reported that there was calm and people
    were enthusiastic about the election

    CAMPAIGNS: ZANU PF continued to dominate news coverage of
    campaign related stories. During Newshour the party was accorded
    five minutes 25seconds and five pro-ZANU PF stories were carried
    during the day.
    Radio Zimbabwe carried five campaign related stories and all were
    ZANU PF campaign rallies. The station also covered live Mugabe's
    Bindura rally.
    3FM had nine stories on campaigns. Of these eight were pro ZANU
    PF. One favoured NAGG.
    SW Radio Africa, in its programme Ballot Box, quoted MDC leader
    Morgan Tsvangirai, urging people to turn out in large numbers to
    vote.

    POLITICAL VIOLENCE: There were no reports of political violence.

    ENDS
    Back to the Top
    Back to Index

    BBC
     
    Sunday, 10 March, 2002, 09:45 GMT
    Zimbabwe election in quotes
    Voter queue
    Some people waited overnight to be able to vote
    People in Zimbabwe are voting in the country's presidential election. This is what key figures and voters have to say about how the vote is going.


    President Mugabe on the vote's outcome

    "I will accept it, I will more than accept it, because I will have won."


    Opposition leader Morgan Tsvangirai

    "The polling days should be extended, especially in Harare. If the authorities refuse to extend it would be a tragedy for this country. People have expressed themselves and we are awaiting the outcome."


    Reginald Matchabe-Hove, chairman of the Election Support Network, an independent observer group

    "There is no way this can be completed in two days. The current poll exercise has become a crisis, but could quickly explode unless it is better managed."


    Munyaradzi Makoni, voting on Saturday

    "Some have been at the polling stations as early as 0400. The whole process is being punctuated by calmness, but for a first time in as many years one can rule out voter apathy. In fact the reduced number of polling stations has made queues longer."


    Veronique Wakerley, who tried to vote on Saturday

    "I, as a resident of Harare, rate-payer and property owner, am now denied any say in the election... This is truly outrageous, as these things should have no connection. What depths next?"


    Colin and Debbie Smith, voting in Bulawayo on Saturday

    "We got up at 0630 this morning and waited in a very friendly mixed-race queue. The queue moved slowly but surely and we were back home at 1000 after voting - in time to watch the cricket, South Africa versus Australia."

    Back to the Top
    Back to Index