The ZIMBABWE Situation | Our
thoughts and prayers are with Zimbabwe - may peace, truth and justice prevail. |
On 17 August 2004, the Southern African Development Community (SADC) leaders meeting in Mauritius adopted the SADC Principles and Guidelines Governing Democratic Elections. Zimbabwe, as a member of SADC, also signed the Declaration and committed itself to implementing the standards. The Mugabe regime claims that it is compliant with these standards and thereby invites a comparison between its own electoral and security legislation and its actions on the one hand, and the SADC Principles and Guidelines on the other.
“Mauritius Watch” provides a regular, objective and non-partisan assessment of Zimbabwe’s compliance with these principles and guidelines. In the run-up to the 2005 Parliamentary Elections we note any significant failures to adhere to the SADC standards. This is the 20th edition of the special weekly feature, and it should be read therefore in conjunction with the earlier editions. The evidence is cumulative. We invite readers to consider the larger picture, from which a very clear pattern emerges – and on which we comment below, after recording some of the more significant events of the last week.
The Parliamentary Elections are due to take place on March 31, now less than 3 weeks away.
11.03.05 : VOTERS THREATENED WITH
STARVATION
A
ruling ZANU-PF candidate, Sihle Thebe, on March 10 told residents in Makokoba
constituency (Bulawayo) that they would be denied food if they voted for the
opposition in the upcoming general election.
Thebe told the residents that the ruling party controls the government’s Grain Marketing Board (GMB) and would order the food utility to freeze supplies to them if they backed the opposition. Speaking in the vernacular Ndebele language, Thebe said: “The ruling party is in charge and you should be warned that you will not receive any grain from the GMB if you vote for the MDC.”
Thebe was speaking in the presence of ZANU-PF and state second vice-president Joyce Mujuru who neither contradicted her nor ordered her to withdraw her open threat to the voters.
(See the full story in Zim Online: www.zimonline.co.za March 11)
A phrase used by Robert Mugabe and his propaganda machine for several years after independence in 1980 was translated as: “Absolute power is when the people are on their knees asking for a handful of mealie meal and you are the only one who can give it.”
SADC standards breached
11.03.05 : THREAT TO BURN HOUSES OF MDC
SUPPORTERS
Two ZANU-PF supporters in Shumba Ward of Dombashava last week publicly
told a party meeting in Gormonzi that they would beat up people and burn houses
and property belonging to all suspected opposition Movement for Democratic
Change (MDC) supporters in the area if ZANU-PF loses the parliamentary polls
later this month.
The threats were made to about 100 people from four villages in Shumba ward. The councilor for Shumba ward, Gibson Chiwara, and the ZANU-PF youth chairman identified only as Mapurani, also told four headmen who were present at the meeting that they should compile a list of all suspected MDC supporters so that the two officials would make sure that they were not allowed to vote on polling day.
On the same occasion the sister of Luke Tamborinyoka, a prominent Zimbabwean journalist and former news editor of the (now banned) Daily News whose home village is in the area, was told openly that her homestead would be burnt because of her political sympathies and her brother’s anti-ZANU-PF stance.
(Reported in the Daily News Online Edition http://www.daily-news.co.za/ 2.1 of March 11)
SADC standards breached
06.03.05 : THREAT TO
KILL 61 YEAR OLD GRANDMOTHER
A 61 year-old grandmother last week
fled her homestead in a village in ward 15 in Mutare South constituency
following death threats from ZANU-PF youth militia.
Betty Shorishori left behind her two grandchildren – one in Grade III and the other in Form I – after threats that her home would be torched for supporting the opposition (MDC) party. She explained to reporters that her problems began when she attended an MDC rally in the area. She was later informed that her name had been singled out at a local ZANU-PF meeting as an MDC supporter.
“I heard that my grandchildren’s names had been deleted from a list of beneficiaries of free education through BEAM (Basic Education Assistance Module) – a government programme designed to assist orphans and other disadvantaged children to attend school. Shorishori also learnt that she was to be excluded from the food aid programme.
After fleeing her homestead the terrified grandmother sought refuge at the MDC Manicaland offices.
(See the full report in The Standard www.thestandard.co.zw of March 6)
- To see this story in context one should also refer to the front page article in the same edition of The Standard, entitled “Violence flares up”. Numerous other examples of violence around the country are cited in the article which begins: “Political violence has flared up at various flash points around the country with opposition Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) candidates being routinely targeted by suspected ZANU-PF supporters … Police are reportedly reluctant to arrest the ruling party’s supporters.”
- The issue of continuing violence and threats of violence against any who are deemed disloyal to ZANU-PF, is also taken up in an editorial in a Roman Catholic Church publication, “In Touch with Church and Faith” from which we quote on page 9. The article is called “Verbal Violence”.
Iain Kay, the MDC candidate for Marondera East constituency, provided assistance when the building was constructed. The church is also linked to retired Bishop Abel Muzorewa, a political opponent of Robert Mugabe particularly during the first decade of independence. These links have been sufficient to attract the attention of ZANU-PF thugs, and are presumably considered sufficient justification by them for the attack on a house occupied by Pastor Nyasha Kazembe, the head of the congregation. A neighbouring house also caught fire in the attack.
Kazembe was away on business at the time of the arson attack and amid reports that he now fears for his life, he has not returned to his flock.
(Reported in the Zimbabwe Standard www.thestandard.co.zw March 13)
In June 2004 in the Hwedza district close to Marondera, the St Cross Anglican Church, a beautiful little church that had served the community for decades, was desecrated. The hallowed sanctuary was plundered and vandalised by ZANU-PF thugs and tainted with offensive graffiti. It was reported that the ZANU-PF government minister responsible for youth training, Elliot Manyika, had put out the word that party meetings must be held in churches wherever possible to “undermine the authority of the church.”
SADC standards breached
“The so-called war veterans said Tongogara Park was a no-go area (for the opposition),” reported Mafudze.
On the night of March 12 more than 30 MDC supporters were detained at Marimba Police Station while another 20 were taken to hospital.
(Reported in The Zimbabwe Standard www.thestandard.co.zw March 13)
This and similar reports highlighting the partisan stance of the police should be read in the context of the MDC Press Release of March 2 (to which we referred in Mauritius Watch 19), in which the MDC secretary for information and publicity, Paul Themba Nyathi, accused the police of bias, and warned: “The actions of the police thus far in the election campaign have served to further erode public confidence in the electoral process and further undermine its legitimacy.”
SADC standards breached
MDC officials said police vehicles were being used to ferry ZANU-PF candidates and their campaign teams to rallies and meetings with supporters. They also claimed that the police have stood by at such meetings while ZANU-PF militants have threatened villagers with severe retribution if they dare to vote for the MDC in the March 31 poll.
The three MDC candidates for Matobo, Mzingwane and Insiza constituencies (in Matabeleland South) reported that in addition to actively supporting the ruling party’s campaign, the police were also using state security laws to bar the opposition from holding rallies and meetings with their supporters.
Human rights and pro-democracy activists have on numerous occasions accused the police of bias in favour of ZANU-PF. They cite for example frequent cancellations of the opposition party’s meetings by the police, while the law enforcement agency is yet to bar a single meeting called by Robert Mugabe or the ruling party.
(Reported in Zim Online www.zimonline.co.za March 9)
SADC standards breached
The opposition disputes the voter figures that determine the number of constituencies, accusing Registrar-General Tobaiwa Mudede of gerrymandering to tilt the result in ZANU-PF’s favour.
“The entire system is defective because there is still duplication of names. Its defectiveness has been compounded by a deliberately discriminatory policy that makes it difficult for people in urban areas to register, unlike those in rural areas,” says the opposition MDC’s shadow minister of justice, David Coltart.
(For further details and an analysis of the recent moves of the Registrar-General and the (Mugabe-appointed) Delimitation Commission which will clearly benefit the ruling ZANU-PF party at the expense of the MDC, see the full report in the Zimbabwe Independent www.theindependent.co.zw March 11)
SADC standards breached
“It is now evident that the legislative elections will take place in a climate of intimidation and censorship,” the international press freedom organisation said.
Their report continues: “There will clearly be no compliance with the democratic criteria established by the Southern Africa Development Community (SADC) and the Africa Union’s treaties. Robert Mugabe’s government is violating the principles of free expression with impunity and Zimbabweans will pay the price. It is time the countries of southern Africa stopped looking passively on as one of their members sinks into the dark.”
Reporters Without Borders also condemned a threat by the head of the government’s regulatory body, the Media and Information Commission (MIC), to impose sanctions on a new weekly, The Zimbabwean, on the grounds it is a “propaganda tool.” To escape the draconian press laws that apply within the country The Zimbabwean is published outside Zimbabwe, although a small number of copies are on sale locally.
Another independent Harare-based watchdog, The Media Monitoring Project Zimbabwe (MMPZ) reports that during the week of 14 to 20 February, 19 of the 28 articles about the election campaign in the state-controlled press defended ZANU-PF and the other nine disparaged the MDC. During the week of 21 to 27 February, 58 of the 66 articles about the election campaign were devoted to ZANU-PF.
(The full report of Reporters Without Boundaries can be seen on http://www.rsf.fr/content.php3 and of the Media Monitoring Project Zimbabwe on http://www.mmpz.org.zw/ )
SADC standards breached
08.03.05 : SA
EDITORS DEMAND END TO MEDIA SIEGE IN ZIMBABWE
South African editors
have condemned the relentless attacks on the media in Zimbabwe and warned that
this does not augur well for the upcoming parliamentary elections. The editors,
represented by the South African National Editors’ Forum (SANEF), said the
continuing closures of newspapers and harassment of correspondents did not bode
well for a free and fair poll on March 31.
SANEF urged the Zimbabwean authorities to lift all restrictions on journalists and media, including foreign media, as a gesture of goodwill and in the spirit of the SADC principles and guidelines governing democratic elections. The influential body said it regretted public statements by the South African government which seemed not to give any prominence to the importance of Zimbabwe lifting its siege on the media as a precondition for a free and fair election.
(Reported in Zim Online www.zimonline.co.za March 8 and in the Mail and Guardian (SA) www.mg.co.za/ on the same day)
SADC standards breached
12.03.05 : RADIO
JAMMING
SW Radio Africa, an independent radio service that
broadcasts news and commentary daily to Zimbabwe from London on short and medium
wave, reports the jamming of its radio transmissions.
To their listeners in Zimbabwe they say: “We are still being deliberately jammed – which obviously means that we’re doing a good job! Please bear with us while we try to overcome this problem ….”
SW Radio Africa give details of their new broadcast schedule, intended to overcome this form of censorship by the Mugabe regime, in an item carried on ZWNEWS www.zwnews.com on March 13.
- Readers will recall that the last time a desperate regime in Zimbabwe sought to censor what its citizens might hear by jamming incoming radio broadcasts, was when the Ian Smith tried to jam BBC radio transmissions from Botswana in the 1960s and early 1970s.
SADC standards breached
11.03.05 : ARMY
MAJOR TO VET JOURNALISTS
A serving Zimbabwe army major has been
tasked to vet foreign journalists wishing to cover the country’s March 31
general election. Major Anyway Mutambudzi, who is operating from the first floor
of Robert Mugabe’s Munhumutapa Building offices, is being assisted by three
other soldiers.
The army major will be responsible for the accreditation of all foreign journalists wanting to report on the parliamentary election. It is understood that the accreditation of local journalist will remain in the hands of the ZANU-PF controlled Media and Information Commission (MIC).
Mutambudzi is among a long list of other serving and former members of Zimbabwe’s armed forces appointed to take charge of electoral bodies and institutions of government directly or indirectly involved in the running of the election.
Chairman of the Zimbabwe Electoral Commission established earlier this year to run the upcoming election is George Chiweshe, now a High Court Judge and formerly a senior army officer. Chiweshe was also hand picked by Robert Mugabe for the job.
(Reported in Zim Online www.zimonline.co.za March 11)
· An article in the Zimbabwe Independent of March 4, notes how three years after the widely condemned presidential poll, military and intelligence officers, who as election agents helped Mugabe to retain power, remain in charge of the electoral process. Mugabe recently appointed retired Brigadier Kennedy Zimondi chief elections officer replacing Brigadier Douglas Nyikayaramba who was a key agent during the presidential poll.
SADC standards breached
11.03.05 : VERBAL
VIOLENCE
“In Touch with Church and Faith” is a regular publication
of the Jesuit Order within the Roman Catholic Church. We quote here excerpts
from the editorial comment of their issue no. 31 (dated March 11):
“Every Zimbabwean is an ‘election observer’, and you don’t need to be officially accredited, other than the official ones from abroad who need to be ‘politically correct’ people sure to please the host government. There was an election rally in the neighbourhood and it went off quite peacefully, though it was noisy, but there was no physical violence, no passers-by were assaulted, no people with the wrong T-shirt attacked. Making statements demanding non-violence has become fashionable. ‘If you can’t beat them, join them.’ If a slogan becomes popular, never mind you don’t believe in it, you must be the one shouting it loudest.
Walking along a street when you suddenly find yourself surrounded by 100 young people shouting rhythmically: “Hondo – hondo – hondo” (“War-war-war) gives you the creeps. They are too young to know what war is. Nobody has told them that the party line has changed: at least for media consumption, violence is ‘out’ and non-violence is ‘in’.
Nobody seems to have told the musicians either. The lyrics of their party songs are all about shedding blood and taking revenge on ‘Mabhunu’ (Boers). Some so-called Gospel singers, who claim to be Bible Christians, are involved. But according to the New Testament, not just physical violence is condemned but verbal violence and hate speech as well …..”
Editor: And we ask, who taught the ZANU-PF youths to shout “Hondo-hondo-hondo!” and who taught them to sing about revenge and bloodletting?
SADC standards breached
ZIMBABWE ELECTORAL
LEGISLATION : SADC CHECK LIST
SOKWANELE has produced a detailed
analysis of the Zimbabwean statutes that are in breach of the SADC Principles
and Guidelines Governing Democratic Elections and the policy breaches by the
ZANU-PF government.
Entitled "ZIMBABWE ELECTORAL LEGISLATION : SADC CHECK LIST", the document can be seen on our website at www.sokwanele.com
Visit our website at www.sokwanele.com
We have a fundamental right to freedom of expression!
Sokwanele does not endorse the editorial policy of any source or website except its own. It retains full copyright on its own articles, which may be reproduced or distributed but may not be materially altered in any way. Reproduced articles must clearly show the source and owner of copyright, together with any other notices originally contained therein, as well as the original date of publication. Sokwanele does not accept responsibility for any loss or damage arising in any way from receipt of this email or use thereof. This document, or any part thereof, may not be distributed for profit.