http://www.voanews.com
By Peter Clottey
Washington, D.C
20 May
2009
Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai's political party is coming
under intense
criticism after calling for the African Union and the Southern
African
Development Community (SADC) to intervene in resolving a deadlock in
Zimbabwe's unity government.
The move is reportedly generating more
friction in the unity government
after supporters of President Robert
Mugabe's ZANU-PF party dismissed the
call as bogus and premature, a charge
the prime minister's party denies.
Mugabe supporters contend that
discussions between the principals within the
unity government have not yet
reached a stage where there is a need for
arbitration. But the Movement for
Democratic Change (MDC) says there is a
deadlock that needs to be
addressed.
Political analyst Rejoice Mbowenya told VOA that the time for
arbitration is
now.
"The MDC has got a right to turn to the SADC for
arbitration because in
terms of the Global Political Agreement and the MOU
(Memorandum of
Understanding) the SADC is guarantor of the success of this
agreement,"
Mbowenya said.
He said the MDC is in the right direction
by calling for international help
to resolve the deadlock with President
Mugabe's ZANU-PF in the unity
government.
"Morgan Tsvangirai and his
team have got the right to turn to SADC and I
believe they are doing the
right thing because that is the only transient
escape route they might have
at the moment," he said.
Mbowenya described as unfortunate accusations
that the prime minister's
party overstated it bounds by calling for
international intervention to help
resolve the deadlock in the unity
government.
"That is an unfortunate position because what the MDC is
asking for is the
basic acknowledgment that the political agreement was
based on an
understanding of a gentleman's way of doing business," Mbowenya
said.
He denied speculations that both the African Union and SADC do not
have
leverage to use against President Mugabe and his ZANU-PF
party.
"I believe that is a misinterpretation. We know that there are
certain
things that SADC cannot do as a collective entity, but the most
powerful
force in SADC is South Africa. in the first place that
singlehandedly
brought Mugabe to the negotiating table when he said he was
not going to
have Morgan Tsvangirai to the party," he said.
Mbowenya
described as best the agreement that led to the formation of the
unity
government.
"This agreement is good for everybody. It's as good for MDC
as it is for
ZANU-PF because if Mugabe had not entered into this agreement,
his political
career would have been effectively over because the crisis
would have
completely paralyzed him," Mbowenya said.
He urged the
prime minister to be more forceful to have ZANU-PF cede some
grounds to his
party in the unity government.
"I believe that Morgan Tsvangirai still
has got an opportunity to use that
critical leverage. to push the deal
further and with a bit of pressure from
himself and his executive committee
and SADC for Mugabe's empire would
crumble," he said.
The National
Executive of the MDC over the weekend referred to what it
described as
outstanding issues in the Global Political Agreement to SADC
and the African
Union for arbitration was to address a deadlock within the
unity
government.
The party said the appointments of Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe
governor Gideon
Gono, Attorney-General Johannes Tomana, provincial
governors, ambassadors
and permanent secretaries be revisited, with all the
three parties having a
say and benefiting from the appointments. The party
also said it wanted a
stop to what it said are political arrests of its
members.
The MDC has often accused President Mugabe and his ZANU-PF party
of dragging
their feet on the matter.
Meanwhile, the Global Political
Agreement which paved the way for the
inclusive government also created The
Joint Monitoring and Implementation
Committee (JOMIC), comprising and
co-chaired by members from the three
parties to ensure the implementation of
the agreement.
http://www.zimonline.co.za/
by Andrew Moyo
Wednesday 20 May 2009
HARARE - Zimbabwe's central bank has
been operating outside the law, in the
process undermining and weakening the
country's banking and financial
system, according to Finance Minister Tendai
Biti.
Biti - who said as a result of illegal activities of the central
bank most
of Zimbabwe's banks would fail a distress test - said a team from
the
International Monetary Fund (IMF) that arrived in Harare on Monday would
review the operations of the Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe (RBZ) and recommend
reforms needed to restore credibility to the central bank.
"The RBZ
has been operating outside the law," Biti told reporters in Harare
on Monday
night.
"Our challenge is to make the RBZ a credible institution
consistent with
best practices . . . their (IMF) terms of reference are
centred on the
credibility of the RBZ," said Biti, adding that he would soon
propose
legislative changes to bring RBZ operations in line with the
functions of a
central bank.
The IMF team, whose visit to Harare
comes two weeks after the fund's board
lifted a ban on technical assistance
to Zimbabwe, will stay in the country
until May 29 during which it will
assess the banking system, the national
payments system, examine the RBZ's
balance sheet and recommend governance
reforms needed at the central
bank.
In a statement released by the IMF before dispatching its team of
experts to
Harare, the Fund called for an independent audit of the RBZ,
saying this was
necessary to enhance the credibility of the country's
economic turn around
programme and also to help attract donor support for
the unity government of
President Robert Mugabe and Prime Minister Morgan
Tsvangirai.
Among concerns key Western donor governments want addressed
before they can
support the unity government is reform at the central bank
where governor
Gideon Gono is accused of stoking up the country's economic
meltdown through
quasi-fiscal activities, including funding Mugabe's
political programmes.
Gono has also come under fire for printing money to
fund activities
ordinarily undertaken by government ministries through
allocations from the
national budget.
Meanwhile Biti said the
government was making progress in its efforts to
raise budgetary support
from donor countries and international institutions
but declined to say
exactly how much the administration had been promised
and by who, saying
such details would be released through Tsvangirai's
office.
"We are
making strides on BOP (balance-of-payments support). We are talking
big
figures here but I think we will be making an announcement through the
Prime
Minister's office," he said.
There has been a trickle in recent weeks of
donor funds to Harare mostly
targeted at specific humanitarian needs. For
example, Germany this week
announced a Euro10 million (about US$13 million)
financial package for
Zimbabwe most of which Berlin said would go to
improving water treatment
facilities to prevent recurrence of
cholera.
While the World Bank announced on Monday that it would provide
US$22 million
in grant money to Zimbabwe in the next few
weeks.
However, the IMF has made it clear it will not resume
balance-of-payments
support to Zimbabwe until Harare clears outstanding
arrears of about US$133
million. The IMF stance will influence other donors
and multilateral
funders, who take a cue from the institution, to also
withhold any
substantial financial support to Zimbabwe. - ZimOnline
http://www.voanews.com/
By Jonga Kandemiiri
Washington
19 May
2009
The Harare City Council said it needs some US$46 million to
repair the
Morton Jaffray water treatment plant, rehabilitate waste water
management
equipment, and provide water to Ruwa, Chitungwiza and Norton
separately.
The city has launched major repairs at the Morton Jaffrey
plant, built half
a century ago. But officials said nearly half the water
pumped out of the
plant is lost through pipe leaks. A city council source
said officials have
met with the finance minister to outline funding
needs.
Most of the Zimbabwean capital has been experiencing water
shortages for
years. Areas such as Mabvuku, Tafara and Greendale have been
particularly
hard hit.
Clean water has become a major focus for the
country, which has just gone
through a major cholera epidemic that has
claimed more than 4,000 lives
since late 2008.
Water Minister Samuel
Sipepa Nkomo told reporter Jonga Kandemiiri of VOA's
Studio 7 for Zimbabwe
that the city has gotten funds from donors and its
short-term objective is
now to significantly improve water operations over
the next six weeks.
http://www.radiovop.com
HARARE, May 19 2009 - A
delegation of South African Information and
Communication Technology (ICT)
experts are set to visit Zimbabwe this week,
in order to help restore
trans-border trade relations between Zimbabwe and
South
Africa.
In an interview with IT News Africa, Kenna
Consulting Chief Executive
Officer, Kelvin Onuoka, says the team is inviting
relevant stakeholders to
participate in re-building the Zimbabwean ICT
infrastructure.
Participants in the initiative include
Zimbabwean Minister of
Information and Communication Technology, Nelson
Chamisa, Permanent
Secretary in the ministry of ICT, Engineer Sam
Kundishora, Kenna Consulting
CEO Onuoka, Chief Executive Officer for CGF
Research Institute, Terry
Booysen, Managing Director for Palladium
Consultants, Paul Aucaamp and
Maxwell Ramutla, who is the Chief Executive
Officer for Afrovation.
Says Onouka: "The team is expected to
liaise with interested South
African companies wishing to invest in Zimbabwe
and advise the Zimbabwean
ICT ministry on policy matters, Public-Private
Partnership models, Corporate
Governance best practices and IT
solutions,"
"Kenna Consulting and its team of leading
independent firms are
positioned to provide business advisory services and
strategy to assist
potential investors in making critical decisions in
trans-border business
transactions as well as understanding the dynamics of
doing business in
Zimbabwe, value and cost central to all business
transactions and the
underlying risk potential,"
During his
visit to South Africa last week, Chamisa highlighted the
role of ICT in the
development of any nation, and outlined future plans that
include a massive
campaign to establish PCs and internet connectivity in
schools, government
offices and households.
Chamisa urged regional and
international companies to invest in the
revival of the ICT sector,
particularly in the rural areas where a
significant number of professionals
such as teachers, health, agricultural
experts, scholars and other
individuals require internet connectivity and
telephony.
Acknowledging the political challenges in his country, Chamisa further
assured investors that the Zimbabwean government was committed to creating a
stable environment conducive to foreign investment. (IT News Africa)
http://www.zimonline.co.za/
by Norest
Musvaba Wednesday 20 May 2009
JOHANNESBURG - A South African
civic group has opened a school in central
Johannesburg for about 350 young
Zimbabwean refugees and asylum seekers
residing at the city's Central
Methodist church, the organisation said on
Tuesday.
The Solidarity
Peace Trust (SPT) deputy director Selvan Chetty told
ZimOnline that the
non-governmental organisation opened the school in
February, with the full
support of the church's Bishop Paul Verryn who has
been at the forefront in
assisting Zimbabwean refugees in South Africa.
Albert School - a primary
and secondary school facility - also spends more
than R20 000 per week on
food for the refugee students who would otherwise
have been on the streets
scrounging for food.
"Our idea is to empower these students and the only
way to do that is to
avoid giving charity and hand outs everyday but to
provide love and
education to them. That's why we have opened this school
for them to access
education," Chetty said.
Chetty said the majority
of church residents faced difficulties in accessing
local schools because
they did not have temporary residence permits to allow
them to enroll in
South African schools.
"It is not easy for many of them to access local
schools because they don't
have funds and proper documentation."
SPT
is a coalition of churches in Southern Africa and other organisations
involved in campaigning for human rights, freedom and democracy in the
region.
"I am really happy with this organisation. It has come to the
rescue of many
school loving Zimbabweans at the church," said
sixteen-year-old Wilson
Muradzikwa who left his Zimbabwean hometown of
Kadoma for South Africa when
he was doing Form Three after his uncle failed
to pay his fees in foreign
currency.
"Everyone is committed to
schoolwork, yes we don't have any problem all our
breakfast, lunch and
supper we get it here. Our duty is to learn only," he
added.
More
than 3 000 migrants from Zimbabwe and other parts of Africa stay at the
Johannesburg Central Methodist church.
In March a law firm occupying
a building adjacent to the church has been
pushing to have the refugees
evicted alleging that they were making the firm
lose business as a result of
the filth at the church premises but Verryn has
been fighting to keep the
migrants at the church because it is the only
shelter they have.
At
least three million Zimbabweans are said to be living outside the
country,
the majority of them in South Africa, having fled political
repression and
poverty after a decade-long economic crisis blamed on
President Robert
Mugabe's controversial policies.
A unity government formed by Prime
Minister Morgan Tsvangirai and Mugabe in
February is yet to convince rich
Western nations that the southern African
country is firmly on the path to
genuine reform for them give it much needed
financial support to resuscitate
its shattered economy. - ZimOnline
http://www.zimonline.co.za/
by Cuthbert Nzou Wednesday
20 May 2009
HARARE - Deputy Prime Minister Arthur Mutambara
has described claims that
the Zimbabwe dollar is dead as "nonsensical and
unacceptable" and said the
government was still debating the future of the
currency that has been
virtually muscled out of the market by more stable
foreign currencies.
Asked by Mudzi South constituency representative Eric
Navaya to explain to
Parliament why the government continued to pay Members
of Parliament and
civil servants in local currency when the Zimbabwe dollar
was no longer in
circulation, Mutambara said the issue of the local currency
was
"work-in-progress" in Cabinet.
"This discussion or debate around
the Zimbabwe dollar is work-in-progress.
It does not make sense to say the
Zimbabwe dollar is dead because pensioners
are being paid in Zimbabwe
dollars," Mutambara said.
"So, it is a nonsensical and unacceptable
concept to even say the Zimbabwe
dollar is dead or dead for a year. We must
make sure we honour the amounts
in the banks which is in Zimbabwe dollar, we
honour the amount being paid to
people in Zimbabwe dollar," he
added.
Mutambara's assertions however clearly contradicted declarations
in recent
weeks by Finance Minister Tendai Biti and his Economic Development
counterpart Elton Mangoma that the local currency was temporarily dead after
the government allowed the use of a basket of foreign currencies earlier
this year.
Mangoma said the government looked to bringing back the
local dollar into
circulation after 12 months but last week indicated that
this could take
longer if economic production - necessary to bolster the
value of the
currency - did not pick up.
Mutambara expressed hope
that the government would be able to reach a final
decision on the local
dollar that should be satisfactory to Zimbabweans.
Since January,
Zimbabwe has resorted to using multiple foreign currencies -
mainly the
South African rand and the United States dollar - to try to pluck
the once
prosperous country out of a crisis brought about by a decade-long
economic
recession. The rand is used as the reference currency.
The unity
government of Mutambara, Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai and
President
Robert Mugabe has promised to revive Zimbabwe's comatose economy
and said it
wanted the local dollar re-introduced only when industrial
output reaches
about 60 percent of capacity from the current 10 percent
average.
But
the capacity of the administration to turn around the economy hinges on
its
ability to raise financial support from rich Western countries that have
however said they will not immediately help until they are convinced Mugabe
is committed to genuinely share power with his former opposition foes. -
ZimOnline
http://www.herald.co.zw
Wednesday,
May 20, 2009
Business
Reporter
BUREAUCRATIC bungling in the payment system has caused a number
of farmers
to spend days camped at the tobacco auction floors, after selling
their
produce.
The delays are so far said to be Inexplicable, with
farmers waiting for two
days on the floors to get paid.
A
verification process is reported to be the major cause of the delays.
A
number of tobacco growers failed to register before delivering their crop
to
the floors because they could not afford the US$10 required. They are
paying
the fee through a bureaucratic stop-order system.
Another problem is that
there have been two groups of buyers in rotation at
the three auction
floors.
They are alleged to arrive at some floors late, thus slowing down
the start
of the sales, which leads to the subsequent payment
delays.
Zimbabwe Industry Tobacco Auction Centre public relations
officer, Ms
Kudzayi Hamadziripi confirmed the delays, saying the company was
not paying
farmers "after hours" for security reasons.
"Our bank is
stretching the working hours to serve many farmers, but
sometimes the
payment process will be extended to the following day," she
said.
"We
do not give farmers their vouchers to take them home because we want to
prevent the origination of fake payment vouchers."
Mr Shingirayi
Fusire of Macheke said he came to the floors on Wednesday last
week but by
Friday afternoon had still not received his money.
"On Wednesday I
renewed my grower's number and sold tobacco on Thursday, but
up to now I
have not received my cheque," he said.
He said he was buying food on
credit from the vendors and had gone for days
without a bath.
Mrs
Dorothy Tsvere of Mvurwi said she was worried about buying food being
prepared in the open, because she had not brought.any
"The other
problem is that we do not have toilets here and people are
relieving
themselves in the bush, exposing us to cholera."
She said the situation
was likely to improve as the buying teams were
increased to
three.
This season tobacco growers are entitled to 100 percent of their
foreign
currency from the sales.
They are being paid US$1500 on spot
while the rest is deposited in their
foreign currency accounts.
This
system was expected to improve conditions for the farmers, as they were
no
longer expected to spend days at the floor waiting for their cash.
Last
season tobacco growers spent days waiting to cash their cheques.
Some
tobacco stakeholders have put in place measures to avert cholera,
includes
offering clean water, while some will be working with the Harare
City
Council throughout the marketing season to ensure vendors do not sell
food
at the floors.
Affordable food is being made available at the auction
floors' canteens
while another floor opened a clinic in case of a disease
outbreak.
http://www.thezimbabwetimes.com/?p=16664
May 19, 2009
By Our
Correspondent
PRETORIA - Pretoria High Court has ordered a permanent
closure of the Musina
detention centre used for holding foreign nationals
caught in the country
without proper documentation. Lawyers for Human Rights
approached the High
Court in February this year seeking an order to have the
centre shut down.
They argued that the centre was overcrowded, filthy and
had in adequate
toilets. They also informed the court how children and
adults were cramped
together in a clear breach of the Immigration Act. Food
shortage and illegal
detention were also used by the lawyers to strengthen
their case against the
centre.
Gina Snyman of the Lawyers for Human
Rights says the court found that the
government departments running the
centre had reneged on their
responsibilities and this had resulted in the
violation of the rights of
detainees.
He expressed outrage at the
time and resources spent by the government in
trying to stop the closure of
a centre that contributed to human rights
violations and ill-treatment of
foreign nationals. Most of the detainees in
this centre are Zimbabweans
arrested while trying to enter the country
illegal.
"We call on the
new Minister of Home Affairs to revisit the policy of
detention and to
review the conditions of detention in all immigration and
police
facilities," said Snyman.
Meanwhile, both Zimbabweans and South Africans
have welcomed the closure.
"The centre should have been closed when the
government pronounced that
Zimbabwean illegal immigrants will no longer be
arrested or deported. I'm
happy that the court decision demonstrates that
Zimbabweans are people like
us who should be treated with dignity," says
Yonela Zumana a South African
national.
The court order has also come
as a relief to thousands of undocumented
Zimbabweans who have been forced to
pay bribes every time they come across
the police. "We want the government
to go on and close the Lindela
Repatriation Camp as well. Every time you
have no money for bribe, the
police arrest and send you to Lindela only to
be released after a week or
two," fumes Sibusisiwe Mdluli.
Although
the government declared a temporary amnesty for all Zimbabwean
immigrants,
police continue to arrest and sending them to Lindela
Repatriation Centre
only to be released in a week or two.
http://www.radiovop.com
HARARE, May 19 2009 - Zimbabwe
Liberation War Veterans Association
(ZLWVA), vice chairman, Joseph
Chinotimba, has blasted Tourism minister
Walter Mzembi for accusing him of
tarnishing the country's image by leading
fresh land
invasions.
Mzembi told a National Economic Forum recently that
Chinotimba and
other war veterans, who are currently invading farms, were
discouraging
potential investors as the inclusive government battled to
secure crucial
financial lifelines.
But in a hard-hitting
statement on Tuesday made available to RadioVOP,
Chinotimba said Mzembi had
no right to reproach him, as he was a newcomer in
ZANU PF.
"The Honourable Minister should be reminded that war veterans, of
late, have
not been getting their pensions and schools feels for their
children and
these issues have not be addressed despite several efforts on
our part,"
said Chinotimba.
"As learned as he is, I would have expected
him to be professional by
engaging war veterans and try to give constructive
ideas and solutions to
their plight than to try and please his audience at
the conference by
attacking me," he said.
Chinotimba
reminded Mzembi that war veterans played a leading role in
repossessing land
from the whites.
"And I am in no doubt that the honourable
Minister Mzembi is one of
those who immensely benefited. For Mzembi to try
and be a good boy today at
the expense of war veterans' welfare is very
unfortunate and unexpected from
a man of his competence. If the truth be
told the Honourable Minister Mzembi
is the least qualified to preach to the
war veterans because he is just a
young guy in the party who surfaced after
the death of Cde Zvobgo.
Is Mzembi aware that there are
hundreds if not thousands of war
veterans who are reeling in poverty around
the country? he said.
Chinotimba said he was very angry that
Mzembi told the media not to
cover him or war veterans.
"Maybe Mzembi believes he is the only one who should be given media
coverage
because he is unique and superior. Being a son-in-law to a foreign
land does
not make the Honorable Minister peculiar." Mzembi is married to a
Cuban
national.
Chinotimba warned that war veterans would march to
Mzembi's office to
have their problems solved because "he knows it all when
it comes to repair
the country's battered image. "One again, let me give a
stern warning to the
Honourable Minister to stop attacking me and war
veterans."
http://www.voanews.com/
By
Marvellous Mhlanga-Nyahuye
Washington
19 May
2009
Zimbabwe Tourism Minister Walter Mzembi said Tuesday
that his ongoing visit
to Brazil could pay off for the Southern African
country's battered travel
sector in the months to come.
Mzembi told
VOA that his delegation has entered marketing agreements with
Brazil and is
lining up a visit by a trade delegation from the South
American
country.
The minister told reporter Marvellous Mhlanga-Nyahuye of VOA's
Studio 7 for
Zimbabwe that he has invited Brazil's national soccer team to
hold its
practice sessions in Zimbabwe ahead of the 2010 World Cup in South
Africa -
but faces plenty of competition.
http://www.timesonline.co.uk
May
21, 2009
Jan Raath in Harare
A small piece of history was made in Harare
yesterday when the Zimbabwe Law
Society was able to stage a demonstration
without getting beaten up. The
last time they tried, two years ago, they
were set upon by riot police and
lashed until they had welts and
bruises.
Yesterday's protest was over the arrest of Alec Muchadehama, a
senior human
rights lawyer. Lawyers marched to the Ministry of Justice
carrying placards.
As they arrived, they were met by four riot policemen,
with batons, and a
senior officer. No one was assaulted.
The officer
escorted Chris Mhike, the head of the local chapter of the law
society,
upstairs to the Minister's office to deliver the petition. Mr Mhike
returned
in five minutes. "Unfortunately the Minister was not there," he
said. "So I
pushed it under his door." The lawyers cheered and dispersed,
happy not to
have been assaulted.
Before undertaking the action Mr Mhike took a vote
among the 100 lawyers,
pointing out that police had not sanctioned the
demonstration. "There is a
risk," he said. There were no dissenting
voices.
At the same time, two human rights lawyer were on trial
nearby for "public
violence." In March, they were walking back to work after
lunch and passed a
demonstration being broken up violently - one of many
squashed since the
power-sharing government was formed - and got arrested.
"At one level things
have changed," said lawyer Innocent Gonese. "At
another, everything is the
same".
Source: Government of Zimbabwe; World Health Organization (WHO) Date: 18 May 2009 ** Daily information on new deaths should not imply that these deaths
occurred in cases reported that day. Therefore daily CFRs >100% may
occasionally result A. Highlights of the day: - 50 Cases and 1 deaths added today (in comparison with 13 cases and 1 deaths
yesterday) - Cumulative cases 98 294 - Cumulative deaths 4 283 of which 2 626 are community deaths - 98.3 % of the reporting centres affected have reported today 59 out of 60
affected reporting centres) - Cumulative Institutional Case Fatality Rate = 1.7% - Daily Institutional CFR = 18.0 %. - Back reporting of cases and deaths from Chiredzi and Masvingo - No report received from Mberengwa District - Data Cleaning - Masvingo denotified 4 deaths
* Please note that
daily information collection is a challenge due to communication and staff
constraints. On-going data cleaning may result in an increase or decrease in the
numbers. Any change will then be explained.
- Chipinge denotified 7 cases
http://www.voanews.com/
The
Following is an Editorial Reflecting the Views of the US Government
19 May 2009
World Press
Freedom Day, celebrated every May, was established by the United
Nations to
raise awareness of the role that a free press plays in
strengthening
democracies and fostering development through increased
transparency and
accountability in government.
Major advances in communications
technologies such as satellite television
and the Internet have furthered
the cause of a free flow of news and
information that are important to a
free society. But media freedom remains
seriously constrained by regimes in
many parts of the world that seek to
quash the criticism that their harsh
actions and policies may produce.
Marking the day earlier this month,
President Barack Obama noted that since
the event was created in 1993, 692
journalists have been killed in the line
of duty. "Only a third of those
deaths were linked to the dangers of
covering war," the president said. "The
majority of victims were local
reporters covering topics such as crime,
corruption and national security in
their home countries."
Hundreds
more face arrest and intimidation, however. It is censorship at its
most
dangerous. Journalists are in jail or are being actively harassed in
Azerbaijan, Zimbabwe, Burma, Uzbekistan, Eritrea and Cuba - 125 alone in
just 2008.
World Press Freedom Day 2009, then, didn't so much offer a
cause to
celebrate than an opportunity to reflect on the need to be
constantly
vigilant about core human rights. Press freedoms are under attack
even in
some advanced democracies, showing how easily many fundamental
rights, not
just those of the press, can be taken away.
Shungu Sabeta interviews VALERIE TAGWIRA,
author
DURBAN, May 20 (IPS) - Valerie Tagwira, a Zimbabwean doctor
living in London, chose Operation Murambatsvina as the backdrop for her first
novel, a painful story of domestic abuse, poverty and the fragility of survival
in Zimbabwe's high-density suburbs.
In 2005, Zimbabwe's government
unleashed Operation Murambatsvina ("clean out the filth" in Shona) on cities
across the country. In less than a month, an estimated 700,000 people lost their
homes, their livelihoods or both as goods were seized and structured deemed
illegal demolished.
The operation fell hardest on urban neighbourhoods
like Mbare in the capital Harare - often perceived to be sympathetic to the
Movement for Democratic Change party that was then in opposition - and where
deepening economic crisis had left millions to daily reinvent their survival,
earning a living as best they could in the informal sector.
This is the
setting for "Uncertainty of Hope", Tagwira's first novel, which centres on two
friends and market women, Onai Moyo and Katy Nguni, struggling to make a life
for themselves.
Shungu Sabeta spoke to Tagwira at the "Time of the
Writer" festival in Durban, South Africa in March. Excerpts of the interview.
IPS: How was the "Uncertainty of Hope" born?
Valerie
Tagwira: Initially when I started writing, it didn’t even have a title that I
thought I would eventually use. It was called "Picking up the Pieces". It was a
story about domestic violence and about how a woman rebuilds her life and that
of her children after undergoing family conflict and marital breakdown.
While I was working on this story, Operation Murambatsvina happened and
I happened to be in Zimbabwe two weeks after it had started. So because my main
character was from Mbare and Mbare was affected so much by this "clean-up
operation", it was a natural next step to include what had happened in Zimbabwe
and put it in the story.
IPS: Do you know people such as extended
family friends, neighbours who have been through domestic violence?
VT: Domestic violence is very much part of every day life in
Zimbabwe. What has always struck me about it is that it is unreported, it’s
almost accepted that men should "discipline" their wives, from observation
around me within the family and from outside the family.
And then as a
medical doctor when I worked in Casualty, I used to meet women who were acutely
unwell with injuries sustained in fights with their spouses, which is basically
domestic violence.
What also struck me about these women was that they
didn’t want the police involved, you know? All they wanted was to get treatment
and go back home and continue with their lives, because reporting it officially
as domestic violence would probably lead to friction within the home and make
their situation worse.
IPS: Going back to your book, was it written
out of a personal need to speak out on certain issues, was it an education piece
to galvanise the minds of Zimbabweans to various struggles personal, societal
and political or was it written to inform the international audience about these
issues? Who was your primary audience?
My primary target audience
was Zimbabweans, actually (chuckles). I also had a desire to inform people
outside Zimbabwe.
Having said that I do not want to stereotype Zimbabwe
as the story is presented in the book. I have taken a particular type of woman,
a woman who is poor, less formally educated, and homeless or (who) doesn’t have
a secure home and (who) is facing problems related to HIV/AIDS.
I
suppose the reason why this is being depicted as a Zimbabwean story is because a
lot Zimbabweans are poor and the people who are suffering most are women and
children. I definitely don’t want to generalise this as the story of Zimbabwe.
I also tried to put in different characters, I have a supporting
character who is a doctor, another who is a law student, another who is a
university student and you also have a young farmer, a new Zimbabwean black
farmer, another person who is wealthy and a beggar who lives on the street who
is sort of a significant character. I tried to look at different angles.
IPS: How do you think we can stop the cycle of abuse of women in
society, at work and in the homes? Too often we see the notion of the ideal
woman, ideal mother holding women prisoner as Onai, one of your characters is
held prisoner - by the idea of what kind of woman she is supposed to be.
Men have their expectations and demands where women are concerned,
yet you find at times other women are the ones that are most critical and who
perpetuate sexist ideology.
VT: It starts with us women ourselves. Right
from when we are raising our sons, we have to bring them up with that notion
that men and women are equal. Because that’s what we are.
As we are
raising our children in the homes assigning duties, the boy should not be
sitting there and reading his books while the girl has to wake up early, clean
the house, make the meals, feed her siblings before she can then have time to
sit down and read. The boy should also be taught the same tasks the girls are
learning.
This is not demeaning or taking away their future manhood, it
is equipping them for life. My mother used to make a comment about how the boys
should able to do what the girls do in the home so that when are grown up and
they leave home they will not get married necessarily to find somebody to cook
their meals, wash their plates and their clothes.
So it is us women who
should encourage and teach our sons as they grow up.
When it comes to
promoting equality, there are a lot of women activist groups who are doing a lot
of work. Seminars and workshops that they hold should not only be targeted at
women but men as well.
While we are teaching women supposedly how to
survive, how to continue with life when things are difficult, we should teach
each other the power of negotiation. [Women] shouldn’t be taught that you have
to fight with the man; they have to negotiate with the man even when it comes to
roles in the home.
IPS: Do you feel that the arts are a good way to
reach the grandparents, the parents - particularly the mothers - and the
children who are heading families in order to raise children in a positive way?
Is it through books or radio shows, television shows or drama that the teachings
be conveyed since some people are illiterate? Which medium should we focus on?
VT: We can use all forms. All forms of art are very useful. People
might find it boring to sit and listen to lecture about domestic violence. Such
things have been adopted in various ways and used usefully but I also think that
if you use something that entertains as well as educate, it can have a lasting
effect. And you can use all forms of art really, to create positive images to
educate people.
IPS: When you look at social activism through your
writing would you like to challenge more issues that push the cause further in
terms of the emancipation of women? In this book, the Uncertainty of Hope, you
raise many issues but one huge issue is lack of ownership of property and land
by women hence they are inherently financial dependent. Are these issues that
you may want to tackle?
VT: Yes these issues that I would like to
tackle. Anything that addresses equal opportunities, equality between men and
women, I am very passionate about. If I get the opportunity, yes I will.
At the moment I am living out there [in London] and maybe some people
might look and say, "Oh who is she sitting there thinking she can say this and
say that?", but I am very passionate about Zimbabwe and about the Zimbabwean
woman and I have very strong sense of belonging. In England I am an outsider,
where I belong is Zimbabwe.
I would like to see the future generations,
both boys and girls growing up to become people who are better and live and work
together and interact in effective ways, because where there is conflict between
men and women that brings us backwards. We don’t develop as a society as much as
we should, were we to be united and work together.
IPS: Are they
other Zimbabwean voices in terms of literature, music that you feel are
currently conscientising the minds of Zimbabweans and engaging them into
critical analysis and discussion?
VT: Because I am out of the
country at the moment, I don’t know what is happening in terms of music or art
scene. As far as theatre is concerned I have read bits here and there about
Amakhosi theatre and the work that they do. [Oliver] Mtukudzi’s music carries a
lot of educational issues and touches on social problems and on how they can be
solved. Same as Tongai Moyo. I am not very aware of the other singers and what
they are doing at the moment.
IPS: What about writers?
VT: There are loads of writers. Because of blogs and the internet
you have a lot of short stories being posted by young and upcoming Zimbabwean
writers. It always amazes me how much of talent there is in Zimbabwe and they
are all writing pertinent day to day issues. They are found for example on sites
like Munyori.com and Zimbablog …there quite a number is you simply google
Zimbabwe short stories you get a whole lot of sites. I haven’t been able to
participate on any of them because I have been doing other things.
IPS: Maita Zvikuru (Thank you so much). Hopefully one day I will be
able to conduct the entire interview in Shona.
VT: (Laughs)
Hopefully we will be able to do it in Harare. (Laughs some more)
IPS:
I know, having had the instructional language being English, it’s so much easier
to communicate and express yourself in that language.
VT: It’s so
much easier, that’s why our Shona and our Ndebele are littered with English.
IPS: I forgot to ask you one very important question, my grandmother
asked me once, "Iwee unorota nechirungu kana nechiwanhu? (Do you dream in
English or in our mother tongue?)". Meaning, could you be so colonised that even
your dreams are in a foreign tongue! I always carry that question with me every
day, and I have to always remind myself to speak Shona to my two daughters. So
when you were writing were the words coming to you in English or in Shona?
VT: I must say they were coming in English.
Email: jag@mango.zw; justiceforagriculture@zol.co.zw
Please
send any material for publication in the Open Letter Forum to
jag@mango.zw with "For Open Letter Forum" in the
subject
line.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1.
Mike McGregor Edmond Oklahoma
2. "Deliver us from Evil!" - Ben
Freeth
3. No going back - Cathy Buckle
4. ASSIMILATION
5.
Farai Madzongwe
6. Dear JAG
7. Tetrad
rebate?
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1.
Dear Jag,
Tho we are far away from your struggle here in Oklahoma, I
want to
encourage you in the battle you are waging for justice and wholeness
as a
nation. I am praying for you often and fervently. Many times I wish
I
could come and bear the burden for those battling to stay on the
farms
that have been theirs and their family's for generations. The
miles
between us press and constrain me to fight in the only way that
is
available to me and that is to pray against the demonic strongholds
that
want to destroy your precious nation of Zimbabwe. I believe that
God
hears your prayers and ours and that His plan to "heal and restore
your
land" will come to pass.
God bless and strengthen you is this
struggle for Justice and healing for
Zimbabwe.
Your friend and brother in
this great fight,
Mike McGregor
Edmond
Oklahoma
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2.
Dear JAG,
"Deliver us from Evil!"
Everyone know the final words in
the Lords Prayer the Jesus taught us:
"deliver us from evil." We have all
said them a thousand
times. They are poignant words for us in Zimbabwe today
when we see how
evil has affected the land.
But how much do we really
mean those words? What is evil?
In my understanding, evil is anything
that is not Godly. Evil is
everything that is bad and wrong. The word
"evil" is one
letter away from "devil" just as "good" is one
letter away
from God.
So "evil" and "devil" become synonymous. Another
word that
Jesus used for the "devil" is
"Beelzebub" which means "Lord of the
Flies."
Flies are associated with the stench of decay and rotting flesh.
Evil
thus becomes synonymous with decay. William Goldings book "Lord
of
the Flies" depicts the decay that comes when there is no
moral
leadership or strength amongst a group of children who get stranded on
an
island without any adults. What happened in the book as a result
was
disastrously evil.
We had a visiting Greek Church leader this
weekend who can read the New
Testament from the original Greek. The word for
"evil" in
the Greek is "ponos" which means "poverty." The
root is from
the word "penes" which mains "pain."
It is absolutely clear for all to
see on the island called Zimbabwe how
"evil" has brought "poverty"
and
"pain." As the evil continues so the poverty and pain gets
worse.
History dictates it. No country on earth has ever prospered
where policies
and practices from the leadership have remained evil and
the law as
epitomised in the Ten Commandments has been cast aside. Decay
sets in; and
with that poverty and pain.
So Jesus taught us in the Lord's prayer to
pray "deliver us
from evil." We need to be delivered from the
"poverty"
and the "pain" that makes up the very of fabric of life
in
Zimbabwe today under an unjust and self seeking regime.
The Lord's
prayer also asks "your kingdom come." His
kingdom can only come if we do His
will. Where laws are plainly wrong
and unjust they need to be struck down.
Where evil practices continue
they need to be stopped. Law enforcers and law
makers need to resist
lawlessness and immorality and the corrupt practices
that continue to
destroy the nation. Right now, as a result of the
lawlessness and
corruption on the land, no wheat has been planted.
The
word of God says "resist the devil and he will flee from
you" [James 4:7].
The problem in Zimbabwe today is that the fear
of the evil that man has been
meting out, has become so seeped in the
psyche of the people that most people
do not resist it. Rather they
comply with evil dictates and by so doing
allow evil to advance its
shadow of decay further across the landscape. The
Proverbs say that
"the fear of man will prove to be a snare" but that
the
"fear of God is the beginning of wisdom."
Here on Mount Carmel
Farm, as on so many others, we have seen all our
wildlife snared or shot by
the invaders. To see an animal die in a snare
is a dreadful thing. It is a
slow and torturous death. So it is in the
nation as people remain so
terribly fearful of the thugs and the
officials that get their protection
from the ruling Party. The only
thing that will drive out the fear that is
proving to be such a snare for
the nation is the fear of God. By learning
the power and the might and
the love of an awesome God we learn true wisdom
and are able to become
freed-up from the snare that throttles us and brings
us into further
"pain" and "poverty."
It is time that Zimbabweans
stood up and resisted the evil. It is time
that we all disassociated
ourselves with the decay and rose against the
evil with courage. As Joshua,
the "Jesus" of the old
testament was exhorted to be "strong and courageous,"
so must
we be so that we will be delivered from evil.
If we are going
to be delivered from the evil and the poverty and pain it
is bringing we
must report the evil to the whole world in truth and with
conviction. The
courts must be applied to widely. Prayer must be used
with power. We must
bring God on to the throne of the nation.
Ben freeth -
Chegutu
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
3.
No going back
http://www.moneyweb.co.za
Ultimatums
and deadlines still don't work against Zimbabwe's old order.
Cathy
Buckle
18 May 2009 04:45
We were disappointed but not surprised
when Prime Minister Tsvangirai's
planned address to Parliament on the 13th
May was cancelled. By then the
deadline given by the MDC to resolve
outstanding issues in the very
unequal power sharing had passed but,
surprise, surprise, nothing
happened.
Ultimatums and deadlines still
don't work against Zimbabwe's old order -
everyone knows that, or almost
everyone it seems!
Then we were told that Prime Minister Tsvangirai would
make a statement
on Friday the 15th May announcing what's to be done about
Provincial
Governors, Foreign Ambassadors, the Reserve Bank Governor and
Attorney
General, all of whom were appointed unilaterally by Mr Mugabe.
That
statement also didn't happen and so we are left to speculate and
remain
stuck in no-man's land as the struggle for real power
continues.
Even as the stalemate continues everyone looks at the MDC to
DO SOMETHING
but no one looks at Zanu PF to do anything. It's like we
have
collectively stopped expecting anything from Zanu PF. Almost every
day
Zanu PF wail about sanctions and no one even bothers to correct
them
anymore and say: sanctions are not imposed on Zimbabwe but on
specific,
targeted individuals.
'Shall we come home?' is a question
some Zimbabweans living in exile are
already asking but so far there's not a
sensible answer to give them. To
people who grow food for a living we can
only say: farm seizures are
continuing; Title Deeds are still worthless;
police still don't get
involved because "it is political." To professionals
we can only say:
government teachers, nurses and civil servants earn just 100
US dollars a
month; lawyers get arrested for defending their clients and
people go to
prison for months at a time for their political beliefs; none of
the
repressive and oppressive legislation has been repealed and
dual
citizenship is still outlawed. To everyone we have to say: there are
no
jobs; the cost of living is crippling; there is often no water
and
electricity and infrastructure is in a state of near collapse.
Its
not all bad though because despite the tragic loss of both his wife
and his
grandson in the last three months, Prime Minister Morgan
Tsvangirai is still
saying he's not giving up. "There's no going back" is
the phrase he keeps
repeating and it is the hope that we keep holding on
to. Until next week and
from under a wide blue sky, thanks for reading,
love
Cathy.
(C)Copyright Cathy Buckle 16th May 2009. www.cathybuckle.com
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
4.
Dear JAG,
ASSIMILATION
May 15, 2009
With the 100 days
of the Government of National Unity (GNU) approaching,
it is clear that the
GNU is anything but. Mugabe has shown in numerous
ways that he is not abiding
by the Global Political Agreement, whether it
is by appointment of governors,
detention of political opponents,
cessation of farm land grabs or the
swearing in of Roy Bennett.
And with each passing day, Morgan Tsvangirai
shows himself to be weaker
and more ineffective. His statements that he and
Mugabe agree with one
another's actions and policies are laughable. He and
his party sold
out when they joined with ZANU-PF, giving up any leverage that
they may
have had in effecting change in Zimbabwe. This
"African
solution", where the election victors become the minority
in
government and the loser remains president, is only postponing
the
inevitable as the system falls apart. Kenya's unity government is
a
prime example of this, becoming less effective by the day.
So what
has become of the GNU? Mugabe states that he is "totally
committed to the
unity government." But has anyone asked him what
his concept of the GNU is?
Plainly, it is the co-option and assimilation
of the MDC into the previous
ZANU-PF system in a subservient role,
resulting in the absence of any
effective opposition.
Will this work? Obviously not, since the major aid
providers - the EU,
Britain and the US - will only give support if serious
changes are made
to the previous ZANU-PF regime. If they stick to their guns,
that is, as
I fervently hope that they do. Tsvangirai is saddled with the
unenviable
task of selling the case for reconstruction to the major donors.
As yet
he and his ministers have been ineffective at this, and only
minor
amounts of funding support - a few hundred million US dollars,
when
billions are required - having been committed. First it was a
request
for US$1 billion, then US$2 billion, then US$5 billion. Now the
IMF says that
it will take US$45 billion over the next five years to
bring the country back
to mid 1990 levels.
The world financial situation is not conducive to
providing major funding
to a country which, in the world's eyes, has
self-destructed. The
developed nations are saying, "Why should we support an
old regime
that has not changed its ways, nor seen the effectiveness of the
promised
change? Let us see some meaningful change from Zimbabwe before we
can
trust the commitment of major funding."
And if Tsvangirai is
unable to bring about the financial rescue, he will
be perceived to have
failed, and, under the terms of the GPA, will be
removed by Mugabe as
ineffective. So then where will the MDC be?
The only course that the MDC
has of rescuing its legitimacy is to
withdraw from the unity government,
become the loyal opposition, albeit
with a majority in Parliament, and
provide a reasonable alternative to
the current sham of a unity
government.
If the MDC does not do this, they will go the way of ZAPU and
some other
party will rise in opposition. And in the meantime, the suffering
of the
population will continue and worsen.
An American
Perspective
(Name Withheld By
Request)
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
5.
Dear JAG,
Farai Madzongwe who defended her mother Senate President Edna
Madzongwe's
takover of a citrus farm in Chegutu to the media last month is a
holder
of an American passport since she was born in the US. She has also
lived
in Germany for some years and has permanent residence there. She was
on
the farm on the night her mother's guards murdered somebody
for
'stealing' oranges from the orchard.
Also, she has been selling
oranges from the farm for US$5 a pocket and is
trying to organize for them to
be exported. She is also busy looking for
a job with international NGOs and
the UN agencies. I think it is in
everyone's interest that she be stopped and
I hope that you as JAG can
inform ALL the UN agencies and relief agencies
that this is who she is
just in case they consider her for a
job.
Regards
Gerald
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
6.
Dear JAG,
Yes I had the fortune (?) to meet this woman recently returned
from
Germany at her behest in a coffee shop on Cork road. She was telling
me
how she represented a group of investors and was keen to get into
Kapenta
fishing in Kariba and wanted to pick my brain.
She is one year
older than my sister and was at Chisipite girl's
high school graduating in
1988/9: certainly not a war vet by any stretch
of the imagination. Certainly
very well spoken and has a plausible story.
She did not divulge who she
was until mid way through the meeting, which
got me thinking that maybe she
had been deported from GE because of
sanctions and was looking for
alternative employment.
Given this latest NGO infiltration story, the
Cork road meeting makes
sense now to me as I think she was thinking along the
lines of using
the Chalala fishing villagers as a front to get her hands on
some NGO
money.
Given her mom's latest activities in Chegutu, I am not
very kindly
disposed to this
family.
Yours
Guy
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
7.
Dear JAG,
Have you had any communication from Tetrad regarding your
rebate? If you
have you will be in the picture. If not see below.
If
you grew tobacco from the 1995 season onwards and you insured with
Tobacco
Hail Insurance Co Pvt Ltd, you are due a rebate.
The rebate will be in
the form of units in Capricorn Unit Trust, which
was formed by
THI.
These units were worth 7,5 US cents each prior to the Stock
exchange
debacle.
They are currently value at about 4 US cents each,
but are going up very
slowly. They will hopefully improve on their original
value of 7,5 US
cents. I would not advise you to trade these at present
unless you are
desperate.
You have been allocated 200 units for every
Ha that you grew, so at their
original value it amounted to US $ 15 per Ha. A
worthwhile amount.
Please contact Judy Conway at Tetrad to sort out how
these units are to
be allocated, and in what name you would like to have them
in
Her email address is judy@tetrad.co.zw
Please send this
email on to ex tobacco farmers on your mailing list. We
will have a lot of
people that we are unable to trace, and it would be a
tragedy if they were to
miss out.
Kind regards Alan
Ravenscroft.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------