http://www.voanews.com
By Peta
Thornycroft
Southern Africa
11 November 2009
A
Zimbabwe High Court judge has ruled Movement for Democratic Change
treasurer-general Roy Bennett may raise allegations of torture during his
treason trial. This long-delayed trial has strained Zimbabwe's power-sharing
government.
Roy Bennett's defense lawyers had asked state witness
Michael Hitschmann be
barred from testifying, because they said he had been
tortured into making a
confession, had not signed that statement, and did
not implicate Bennett in
it after he was arrested in
2006.
Hitschmann, a gun dealer and collector, was acquitted of the same
terrorism
charges Bennett now faces, but served a two-year sentence for
possession of
unlicensed guns, including several automatic
weapons.
Judge Chinembiri Bhunu said the charges against Bennett are
serious and
therefore technicalities should not stand in the way of
evidence, indicating
Hitschmann will have to testify at some point. But
Judge Bhunu said he
would allow questions about torture allegations made by
Hitschmann.
Hitschmann submitted an application to the court claiming the
statement he
made when he was originally detained in eastern city of Mutare,
was obtained
under duress. Hitschmann said he was tortured after he was
arrested.
The lawyer who submitted Hitschmann's application last week was
later
detained for 48 hours, accused of obstructing justice.
After
the Judge Bhunu's ruling, Attorney-General Johannes Tomana, who is
leading
the prosecution, asked for time until Thursday to arrange his
prosecution.
The state has listed eight other witnesses, all policemen or
members of
Zimbabwe's spy agency, the Central Intelligence Organization.
Bennett's
arrest last month led Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai to
partially
disengage from the 10-month-old unity government that includes his
Movement
for Democratic Change and President Robert Mugabe's Zanu-PF.
After South
Africa said last week it would more closely monitor progress in
resolving
outstanding issues of the political agreement that led to
formation of a
power-sharing government, Mr. Tsvangirai ended his boycott of
Cabinet
meetings.
http://www.thezimbabwetimes.com/?p=24845
November 11, 2009
By Our
Correspondent
HARARE - High Court judge Chinembiri Bhunu has berated
Attorney General
Johannes Tomana and Beatrice Mtetwa, the lead defence
counsel in the
high-profile Roy Bennett terrorism case, for seeking to
outperform each
other before a packed court instead of concentrating on the
merits of the
arguments they are presenting.
Bhunu then ruled on
Wednesday that Peter Michael Hitshmann, the state's key
witness in the MDC
treasurer general's high-profile trial, should be called
to testify in
court.
The ruling put paid to strong contentions by defence lawyers at
the
beginning of the trial that the firearms dealer must not testify in the
Bennett case as he had already disowned statements attributed to him by the
State in Bennett's indictment papers.
Bennett's trial opened on
Monday with attorneys for both the State and the
defence filing applications
to challenge both the contents and the legality
of each other's
outlines.
On Wednesday Justice Bhunu said Tomana and Mtetwa appeared more
motivated by
the need to outdo each other at all costs in court as opposed
to
concentrating on the merits of their legal arguments.
He berated
both counsel for displaying open hostility towards each other
during
Monday's court proceedings, warning that they should desist from
allowing
themselves to be unnecessarily unsettled by the packed court.
Bennett,
the deputy Minister of Agriculture-designate faces charges of
possessing
firearms for purposes of deposing a lawful government through the
use of
violence, insurgence, banditry, sabotage and terrorism. Bennett
denies these
charges.
The lead defence counsel, Beatrice Mtetwa made an application
that the State
be compelled to strike off certain portions of the State
outline arguing
that Hitshmann had, in an affidavit deposited with the
courts, disowned an
earlier confession that he had connived with Bennett in
the actions he now
stands accused of.
Hitshmann claimed he had signed
the statement in which he purportedly
confessed to being Bennett's
accomplice after being tortured and abused at
the hands of the police and
state security agents.
He described his statements as "pure fiction that
bore no relationship at
all to any reality" and prayed that the court
should disregard them.
On the other hand, the State, represented by
Tomana, filed its own
application to compel the courts to strike off the
defence outline which it
said was filed well out of the stipulated period,
while failing to address
the issues raised in its own outline. The
appearance of the Attorney General
himself, Tomana, to direct the State's
prosecution of Bennett has raised
eyebrows in legal circles.
After a
fierce argument which lasted over two hours on Monday, Justice Bhunu
deferred his judgement to Wednesday, whereupon he dismissed the two
applications.
Following Bhunu's ruling on preliminary issues raised
by both counsel,
Bennett's trial starts in earnest Thursday morning when
Hitshmann is
expected to testify.
In dismissing the applications,
Justice Bhunu said both applications were
not consistent with the statutes
cited by the parties in advancing their
arguments.
He said the case
should be balanced on the accused person's right to liberty
as well as the
need for State security. Bhunu said Bennett's guilt or
innocence should be
determined more on merit than or technicalities.
"I fail to see how the
calling of a witness who says that he has no relevant
evidence to give can
be prejudicial to the accused," said Bhunu.
http://www.swradioafrica.com
By Alex Bell
11
November 2009
Yet another corporation is coming under fire for its direct
involvement with
the Robert Mugabe regime, after South African insurance
giant Old Mutual
admitted it is a major shareholder in Zimpapers.
Old
Mutual this week confirmed its business interest in the publishing group
which produces, among others, the state's mouthpiece Herald newspaper. South
African refugee rights group, People Against Suffering, Suppression,
Oppression and Poverty (PASSOP) explained that Old Mutual is the second
largest shareholder in Zimpapers, essentially using insurance policy
holders'
money to prop up Mugabe's vehicles of propaganda and hate
speech.
PASSOP's Braam Hanekom, a Zimbabwean born activist, told SW Radio
Africa on
Wednesday that Old Mutual was essentially 'arming' the state
media, arguing
"this is politically equivalent to putting bullets into the
guns that kill
opposition voices in Zimbabwe." Hanekom has demanded that Old
Mutual
publicly withdraw its stake in Zimpapers, saying the group's refusal
to do
so will point towards a business relationship based purely on
corruption.
"Old Mutual is not making money out of selling newspapers in
Zimbabwe, not
so much that they can't, on moral grounds, withdraw their
stake," Hanekom
said. "There's no other reason to protect its stake unless
there is
corruption."
PASSOP started an online petition on Tuesday
night, which calls for Old
Mutual to withdraw its Zimpapers investment and
publicly apologise. The
petition is set to be delivered to Old Mutual
management within the next
seven days. Hanekom warned on Wednesday that the
group will start protest
campaigns against Old Mutual if their calls and the
petition are ignored.
"Companies cannot continue to plead ignorance about
their business
relationships, when they know these relationships are not
morally
supported," Hanekom said.
The controversy is reminiscent of
the Nestlé saga that erupted last month,
after it emerged that the food
giant was buying milk from a dairy farm,
seized during the land 'reform'
programme and owned by Grace Mugabe. Scores
of people and organisations
called for a boycott of Nestlé products, if the
company did not stop buying
milk from the Mugabe's Gushungo Dairy Estate.
The company eventually severed
its commercial ties with the Mugabes, amid
intense pressure from concerned
individuals and rights groups. Critics had
lashed out at the food group over
its disregard for basic corporate
responsibility, saying multinational
support of the Mugabes would ensure
their continued corrupt
practices.
Meanwhile, more concern has been raised over the inaction of
the Mayor of
Harare, Muchadeyi Masunda, who is also a Chairman of the
Zimbabwe branch of
Old Mutual. Masunda has been facing increasing criticism
for not doing more
in his position as Mayor to make changes in the capital,
where rampant abuse
of resources by the council has seen the city continue
to deteriorate.
Questions are now being raised as to why Masunda has not
spoken out about
Old Mutual's financial support of Zimpapers and why he has
not persuaded
them to divest their Zimpapers shares. We tried
unsuccessfully to contact
the Mayor for comment.
http://www.therichmarksentinel.com
Michael Trapido
Wednesday,
November 11, 2009
" Old Mutual says its investments are dictated by
profit and not political
considerations.
The insurance giant was
reacting to a call to shed its investment in the
Zimbabwean company that
prints the Mugabe government's propaganda
mouthpiece, the Herald
newspaper.
"Our investments are made for the benefit of our
policyholders, meant to
meet needs and expectations in terms of return and
not contingent upon
political consideration," OM Zimbabwe group chief
executive Luke Ngwerume
said in a statement on
Wednesday."(sapa)
Anyone who has been living in Southern Africa for more
than an hour would be
aware of the atrocities that have been committed by
the Zanu-PF and
President Robert Mugabe in Zimbabwe in order to cling to
power.
One of the most important cogs in the machinery that they employ
in order to
achieve this is the Mugabe mouthpiece the Herald.
It
ensures that only the information and disinformation he wants circulated
goes out to the people through the major newspaper of that
country.
Moreover the government censor, to a large degree, anyone who
dares to take
up an anti-government position.
This is not rocket
science and everyone knows it.
Accordingly Old Mutual are acutely aware
that this particular investment of
theirs is occasioning untold hardship on
the people of that country.
Personally I was shocked to hear that one of
our major corporates was
involved with a Mugabe propaganda
machine.
It is totally unacceptable.
What is worse is that they
try to justify the indefensible by saying that
they have a duty to their
shareholders to ensure that they retain profitable
assets and anyway it's an
investment dictated by money not politics.
What a load of
crap.
There are many corporate monsters that have tried singing the exact
same
song before and their conduct was equally disgusting. Let's look at one
example.
Zyklon-B was a commercial rodenticide and pesticide in
common use before
World War II.2 The active lethal ingredient in the product
is hydrogen
cyanide, which is deadly to warm-blooded animals in very low
concentrations,
and to insects in considerably higher
concentrations.
DEGESCH (Deutsche Gesellschaft für Schädlingsbekämpfung
mbH / German Vermin
Controlling Company), a subsidiary of IG Farben 4,
licensed two German
companies for the manufacture and distribution of
Zyklon-B: Tesch und
Stabenow (Testa) and Heerdt-Lingler
(Heli).
Zyklon-B was also manufactured in one of its forms in the United
States by
the American Cyanamid Company 5 under license from the patent
holders, I.G.
Farben.
Hydrogen cyanide has historically been employed
for the destruction of
rodents and insect pests.
When however the
Nazis were looking for an effective method of gassing the
Jews and other
undesirables in their concentration camps they chose Zyklon-B
as the most
suitable for that purpose.
As a result huge orders went out to the
suppliers who naturally also
considered themselves indebted to their
shareholders and only interested in
profits and not politics.
Or
that's their version and they're sticking to it.
If the comparison makes
anyone uncomfortable it's meant to.
In Zimbabwe we have 5 million people
on the brink of starvation, political
murder, millions in exiles and on and
on.
The part that the Herald has played in promoting Mugabe and the
Zanu-PF can
never be underestimated. Despite millions starving, other
millions leaving
the country and their countrymen's terrible suffering they
simply keep
pumping out the "good word".
Old Mutual is an insurance
company which weighs up risk very carefully
before spending their money. In
order to do this they need information in
depth.
Accordingly if they
invested heavily in the Herald they know far more about
the horrendous
goings on in Zimbabwe than almost
anyone else.
Yet they say they are
not concerned about politics merely profits.
I hope they've heard of
Dormicum or falling asleep every night must be a
bitch.
http://www.zimonline.co.za
by Cuthbert Nzou
Wednesday 11 November 2009
HARARE - Zimbabwe's
three governing parties are expected to begin
negotiations before weekend in
line with a SADC recommendation to tackle a
power-sharing dispute
threatening to tear apart their shaky coalition
government.
According to sources, senior officials from President Robert Mugabe's
ZANU
PF party and the two former opposition MDC formations are expected to
meet
before Friday to make proposals how on to resolve a host of outstanding
issues from last year's global political agreement (GPA) that gave birth to
the nine-month old power-sharing government.
The proposals will
be forwarded to Mugabe, main MDC leader and Prime
Minister Morgan Tsvangirai
and Deputy Prime Minister Arthur Mutambara, who
heads the smaller MDC
party.
The sources said Mugabe, Tsvangirai and Mutambara did not
hold their
normal Monday meeting because the President was away in
Egypt.
"The negotiators should meet by Friday to reduce areas of
differences
on the outstanding issues," one of the sources said. "Proposals
on how to
resolve the issues will then be sent to the principals who have
the final
say."
The Southern African Development Community
(SADC)'s organ on defence
and politics gave Mugabe, Tsvangirai and Mutambara
30 days to resolve
outstanding issues.
The sticking points that
saw Tsvangirai and his MDC party boycotting
Cabinet more than three weeks
ago include Mugabe's refusal to rescind his
unilateral appointment of two
top allies to head Zimbabwe's central bank and
the attorney general's
office.
Mugabe has also refused to swear in Tsvangirai ally Roy
Bennett as
deputy agriculture minister while the MDC is also unhappy by what
it says is
selective application of the law to target its activists and
officials.
ZANU PF, which insists it has met all its obligations
under the GPA,
accuses Tsvangirai and the MDC of not living up to their
promise by refusing
to lead a campaign for lifting of Western sanctions
against Mugabe and his
top allies.
Nelson Chamisa, the
spokesman for Tsvangirai's MDC-T party, confirmed
yesterday that the
negotiators would meet before the weekend to come up with
proposals to
resolve the sticking points.
"In line with the resolutions of the
SADC organ, the negotiators
should meet and make proposals on how to tackle
the issues now affecting the
survival of the inclusive government," Chamisa
said.
"According to SADC's timelines, principals should resolve the
outstanding issues in 15 days and if there are no solutions, the next 15
days would be used for mediation by the facilitator," he added.
The facilitator, Chamisa said would be South African President Jacob
Zuma.
"It was agreed in Maputo that the facilitator is South
Africa, hence
President Zuma will mediate in the event of a deadlock instead
of Thabo
Mbeki who brokered the GPA," Chamisa explained.
Mbeki
facilitated the GPA when he was the president of South Africa.
Chinamasa confirmed that negotiators have to meet first to deal with
the
outstanding issues, but declined to give details.
Besides the
outstanding issues, the organ asked the inclusive
government to immediately
set up the national economic council in line with
the GPA in a move meant to
come up with sound policies to revive the country's
comatose economy. -
ZimOnline
http://www.swradioafrica.com
By Tichaona Sibanda
11
November 2009
Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai and ministers from his
party attended a
cabinet meeting on Wednesday following their
're-engagement' with ZANU PF.
The MDC leader last week Thursday ended a
three week boycott of the shaky
inclusive government after disengaging from
Robert Mugabe's 'dishonest and
unreliable' ZANU PF party in the unity
cabinet, set up in February. The
boycott sparked the biggest crisis since
the new government was formed.
Tsvangirai had vowed he would boycott the
power-sharing government until all
sticking points had been resolved and a
political deal reached. But a
regional SADC summit on Zimbabwe in Maputo
last week set a deadline for the
three parties in the government to meet
within 15-30 days to discuss how to
resolve the conflict. Because of this,
Tsvangirai decided he would re-engage
with ZANU PF.
James Maridadi,
Tsvangirai's spokesman, told SW Radio Africa that Wednesday's
meeting would
have covered government business only and that it would not
cover other
issues, especially those to do with the Global Political
Agreement.
Normally Mugabe, Tsvangirai and Arthur Mutambara meet
every Monday to
discuss issues contained in the GPA. But this week's meeting
was postponed
because Mugabe was away in Egypt on official business. The
three political
leaders are now due to meet next week Monday. Party
negotiators are expected
to meet to work on the agenda and modalities of the
talks.
The guarantors of the political agreement - SADC- say they are still
hopeful
the deadlock between Mugabe and Tsvangirai can be resolved.
South
African President Jacob Zuma, whose country facilitated the unity
agreement,
is to visit Harare in two weeks' time to review progress.
Political analyst
Gabriel Shumba told us the 15 day timeline was unrealistic
to expect a
concrete resolution on all outstanding issues.
'It's just an impossible
timeline. Remember we are looking at issues that
have dragged over a period
of time. My guess is Mugabe will try and drag his
feet again because of an
upcoming ZANU PF congress where I'm sure his
position would be shaky if he
makes major concessions to the MDC,' Shumba
said.
Shumba, who is also a
lawyer by profession, said it takes times to reform
institutions that have
been pro-Mugabe. He said at institutions like the
police and the Reserve
Bank there was a need also to change the 'main actors',
which has been one
of the MDC's demands.
It was reported that Finance Minister Tendai Biti
briefed Parliament on
Tuesday on the RBZ Amendment Bill that seeks to limit
the functions of the
central bank and bring the powers of Governor Gideon
Gono under the control
of a board.
Gono's first five-year tenure at
the helm of the bank was directly blamed
for the supersonic hyperinflation
of unprecedented proportions in the
country.
On Tuesday, Biti told
legislators that the proposed legislation was a
'firefighting Bill', as
members of the public would be asked what the
central bank should be like
during the forthcoming constitution-making
process.
http://www.swradioafrica.com
By Lance Guma
11 November
2009
Mutare Central MP and MDC-T Chief Whip in Parliament, Innocent
Gonese, last
week Thursday sought Parliament's permission to present a Bill
amending the
repressive Public Order and Security Act (POSA). Since the Act
was passed
Mugabe's regime has used it to harass, arrest and detain
opposition and
trade union activists either wanting to have public meetings
or participate
in demonstrations.
Veritas, a group that monitors
legal and parliamentary issues in the
country, says Gonese's Bill could be
the first 'Private Members Bill' since
independence. Under the rules,
government ministers do not require
permission to present bills in
Parliament but with Gonese not running any
ministry he effectively presents
his Bill as a 'Private Member' of
Parliament. His motion will be debated,
before it is approved. This debate
is expected to take place this week. If
approved the Bill would be gazetted
and go through the normal parliamentary
stages.
Speaking in Parliament Gonese said the police had used POSA over
the years
to arrest and detain hundreds of people but had so far never
successful
prosecuted anyone. He also said the Act has never been used to
arrest any
ZANU PF officials or supporters. The MP said his Bill aims "to
ensure that
public gatherings are regulated in a manner that will allow
Zimbabweans to
fully exercise their fundamental democratic right to engage,
to express
themselves through the medium of peaceful assembly and
association and to
clarify some of the existing provisions in the current
Act".
Gonese said the Bill would seek a reduction in police powers and
give
magistrates the power to prohibit meetings instead. Other amendments
sought
include repealing a provision that penalises people for not carrying
their
ID documents.
This week Zimbabwe Lawyers for Human Rights
(ZLHR) condemned the unlawful
arrest of labour leaders by police in Victoria
Falls over the weekend. ZLHR
cited this as another abuse of POSA and said
they welcomed attempts by
Gonese to introduce a Bill amending the repressive
law.
ZLHR went further to suggest the urgent establishment of an
Independent
Parliamentary Committee inquiry, into the continuing unlawful
actions of the
police. "This inquiry should also include an investigation
into the actions
of the Director of Public Prosecutions and the Attorney
General who, as the
legal representatives of the ZRP, have failed and/or
refused to execute
their constitutional and professional duty to advise the
police of their
continued misinterpretation and misapplication of the law,"
ZLHR said in
statement.
http://www.swradioafrica.com
By Alex Bell
11 November 2009
Four
students arrested in Bindura on Monday have been released after a night
behind bars, as the harassment of activists across the country continues to
intensify.
The four were arrested during a campaign meeting at the
Bindura University
of Science Education, where SRC elections have been
underway. The group,
including outgoing SRC President Respect Ndanga, had
just finished
addressing students at a campaign rally for one of the new
presidential
candidates, Paul Dakarai. They were detained at Mashonaland
Central police
station, where they were charged under the Criminal law
Codification and
reform Act, allegedly for "participating in a gathering
likely to cause a
breach of peace or bigotry."
The arrests come after
nine other students were arrested last Friday,
reportedly by five members of
Robert Mugabe's presidential guard. The nine,
who had been holding a
discussion outside the Bindura University's premises,
were detained on
allegations that they wanted to disrupt a graduation
ceremony being held
that day. All nine were eventually released.
The Zimbabwe National Students
Union (ZINASU) meanwhile expressed concern
Wednesday that its President,
Clever Bere, is still being hunted by police.
The union said that police
details at Mashonaland Central Police Station
said that they were still
looking for Bere, apparently to interview him on
charges of inciting
violence. The president was one of the speakers at the
campaign rally on
Monday where the other four student leaders were arrested.
On Monday night
police in Bindura launched a manhunt for the ZINASU leader,
mounting
roadblocks around the town with search lights, guns and police
dogs, all in
a desperate bid to arrest Bere. The ZINASU president managed to
escape the
town and is now in Vienna Austria where he is representing ZINASU
at the
World Justice Forum conference.
At the same time, five members of the
Zimbabwe Congress of Trade Unions
(ZCTU) are still being held in custody in
Hwange, after they were arrested
in Victoria Falls on Sunday. The group,
including ZCTU President Lovemore
Matombo, has not been taken to court,
despite being set to appear on
Tuesday. Zimbabwe Lawyers for Human Rights
(ZLHR) Director Irene Petras
explained that police managed to secure a
warrant for further detention on
Wednesday, on unexplained grounds. Petras
and her ZLHR team have filed an
urgent application for their clients'
release.
http://www.swradioafrica.com
By Alex Bell
11
November 2009
The Secretary General of the General Agriculture and
Plantation Workers
Union of Zimbabwe (GAPWUZ), Gertrude Hambira, has spoken
of her family's
distress after she was targeted for abduction by suspected
state security
agents a week ago.
Hambira has been in hiding during
the past week after the failed attempt to
abduct her from her Harare home
last Tuesday. She was not at her house when
three armed men broke in, and
demanded to know where she was. But her
husband and children were, and
Hambira told SW Radio Africa on Wednesday
that they have been left
traumatised by the incident. The men who broke into
her home threatened to
shoot her husband, before fleeing with mobile phones
and pictures of
Hambira. She immediately went into hiding fearing for her
life.
But
Hambira risked possible arrest this week by coming out of hiding to
launch a
damning report and documentary exposing the devastating effects of
the so
called land 'reform' programme on the livelihood of farm workers. It
is
widely believed that the documentary is the reason behind Hambira's
attempted abduction, because it exposes top government officials'
involvement in the torture, harassment and eviction of farm workers in the
chaotic land seizures. The documentary entitled 'House of Justice' contains
26 minutes of footage laying bare the evidence of human rights violations
targeting farm workers, over ten years of Robert Mugabe's land grab
campaign.
Speaking from South Africa where the documentary is being
screened on
Thursday, Hambira said the film is a vital tool to try and
pressure regional
governments to intervene in the spiraling land crisis in
the country. In the
documentary Hambira appeals to the leaders of the
Southern Africa
Development Community (SADC) to pressure the Zimbabwe
government to end the
ongoing violence on farms across the country. SADC has
come under fire for,
among other issues, not acting on Zimbabwe's 'pull out'
from the SADC
Tribunal, a human rights court set up by the nine member body
to deal with
judicial disputes in the region. Last year, in a landmark
ruling meant to
protect more than 70 commercial farmers and their rights to
their land, the
SADC Tribunal ruled that the government should stop land
attacks.
But Zimbabwe has refused to abide by this ruling and has pulled
out of the
Tribunal, effectively opening the door for an escalation of
attacks on
commercial land this year. GAPWUZ has already said that more than
60 000
farm workers have been left with jobs as a result of the land attacks
this
year alone, with hundreds of workers being beaten and arrested. 'House
of
Justice' questions what the ultimate point of SADC is, if member states
will
not stand up for justice and the official SADC court.
The report
'If Something is wrong', which is accompanying the documentary,
also
highlights the impact of the land reform exercise on the farm workers
during
the past ten years. This is the first report on so called 'land
reform' to
deal solely with the experiences of farm workers and makes for
sobering
reading. The report balances statistical evidence from farm workers
with
shocking narrative examples of the types of violations they have
experienced. It also provides damning evidence that the violence perpetrated
on the farms has been largely targeted on farm workers.
Hambira said
she hoped the documentary and report were going to go a long
way in raising
regional and international pressure on Zimbabwe to start
respecting basic
human rights.
"We want them to start seeing farm workers as people and to
recognise their
genuine need for the basic things like shelter and source of
livelihood,"
she said.
HARARE, 11 November 2009 (IRIN) - An acute
shortage of labourers on Zimbabwe's newly resettled farms, combined with the
farmers' inability to raise loans from financial institutions to purchase
agricultural inputs, and money owed to them by the Grain Marketing Board (GMB),
do not bode well for food insecurity.
Photo:
IRIN
Staving
off hunger
"The majority of our members have
indicated that their farming activities have been severely affected by the
shortage of manpower to use on the farms. We are poorly prepared, and our hands
as farmers are tied because we don't have the money to keep the farm workers,"
said Denford Chimbwanda, president of the Grain and Cereal Producers Association
(GCPA).
Chimbwanda told IRIN that although banks have finally agreed to
provide loans, with the government's offer letters on the land as collateral,
the slow pace of approving loans was not taking into account the window period
of the main planting season.
Offer letters, or 99-year leases, have been
issued to farmers settled on land redistributed from white-owned commercial
farms to landless blacks in President Robert Mugabe's fast-track land reform
programme, which began in 2000. Banks have only recently started accepting the
offer letters as collateral for loans.
Renson Gasela, an agricultural
analyst and the secretary for agriculture in the breakaway faction of the
Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) led by Arthur Mutambara, told IRIN that
many farmers who had sold their previous harvest to the GMB - the sole grain
purchaser in Zimbabwe - were still awaiting payment, further turning the screws
on their cash flow.
"Farm workers are deciding that enough is enough. I
am aware that some farmers have managed to keep some of their workers, on the
promise that once they get paid by the GMB they will settle the wage arrears,
but these promises have gone for too long, forcing them [workers] to look for
other sources of income," he said.
In some cases wages had not been paid
for three months, "and this has led to frustration among the employees, who,
together with their families, need to subsist on a daily basis," Gasela said.
In the first quarter of 2009 nearly seven million Zimbabweans depended
on food aid, but a relatively successful harvest of 1.14 million metric tons of
maize, the staple food, in June 2009 - a two-fold increase on the previous year
- brought optimism that the country was turning the corner on its food
insecurity.
It is easy to notice the
absence of farm workers, who, in the past, would be seen busy in the fields at
this time of the year
"Moving across the country, you cannot
believe that we are already in the main farming season. Only a privileged few
have managed to till their land, using tractors and the diesel that they managed
to buy, but the story is different with the majority of farmers," Gasela said.
"It is easy to notice the absence of farm workers, who, in the past,
would be seen busy in the fields at this time of the year. Instead, they can be
found by the roadside selling firewood, or fish from nearby dams," he commented.
Fleeing farms
Tapiwa Zivira, spokesperson for
the General Agricultural and Plantation Workers Union (GAPWUZ), told IRIN that
labourers were "fleeing" farms because wages were not being paid.
"Farming should be for those who are prepared to meet the costs that go
with agriculture. It is disturbing that the wages we are asking them to pay our
members are way below the poverty datum line, but the farm owners still insist
that they are too much," Zivira said.
Farm workers are paid a maximum of
US$30 a month, when they are paid, and the GAPWUZ bid for a minimum monthly wage
of US$50 has so far fallen on deaf ears.
Low wages, non-payment of
wages, and poor living and working conditions were accelerating the flight of
farm labourers. Zivira said children were being employed in their place "because
they [farmers] know that these minors lack the capacity to demand what is due to
them".
Another round of "farm invasions" by high-ranking officials in
Mugabe's ZANU-PF party - after the formation of the unity government in February
2009 - meant ongoing instability on farms. More than 3,000 families had been
forced to migrate from farms whose ownership had changed since February, with
some finding refuge by the roadside, Zivira said.
Making ends
meet
Ennia Samson, 40, a widow of Malawian origin, moved to a
business centre in the Murombedzi district of Mashonaland West Province, about
65km northwest of the capital, Harare, because ownership of the farm she was
raised on changed hands in March.
"When the new farmer arrived he
encouraged us to stay, saying he would look after us well, but by the time I
left in September only a few workers had been given a maximum of US$15," Samson
told IRIN.
Other women and girls had left the farm and were now domestic
workers or had gone into commercial sex work. Samson had cleaned shops at the
business centre and managed to raise the capital to start a small second-hand
clothes business
She now lived in a makeshift shelter with her two
school-going children. "Even though we are living as squatters, life is much
better here than on the farm, where we were almost starving," Samson said.
http://www.zimonline.co.za
by Simplicious
Chirinda Wednesday 11 November 2009
HARARE - An organisation
representing workers in the agricultural sector on
Monday launched a
scathing video report highlighting human rights abuses
that took place on
Zimbabwe's commercial farms between 2008 and 2009.
General Agriculture
and Plantation Workers Union of Zimbabwe (GAPWUZ)
spokesperson Tapiwa Zivira
told ZimOnline on Tuesday that the 26-minute
video titled "House of Justice"
highlights some of the worst abuses against
farm workers in the wake of the
controversial land reform programme launched
by President Robert Mugabe's
government in 2000.
"The report features the gory acts of what has been
happening on the farms
throughout the country since last year," said
Zivira.
"It exposes the human rights violations which are still being
committed by
marauding mobs and some senior politicians against farm
workers. The report
also urges regional bodies such as the Southern African
Development
Community and African Union to look into the plight of these
people and urge
the government of Zimbabwe to respect the rule of
law."
GAPWUZ said several government officials from the ministries of
home
affairs, agriculture and national healing who were invited to the event
did
not turn up.
"Only a representative of Prime Minister Morgan
Tsvangirai came but we would
have wanted the government officials to see for
themselves the abuses on the
farms," said Zivira.
The organisation
will next week host a regional launch of the report in
Johannesburg, South
Africa.
GAPWUZ also launched at the same occasion another report titled
"Is
something wrong", which highlights how Zimbabwe's chaotic and often
violent
land reform programme has affected farm workers since
2000.
Individual workers give testimonies on how they were affected by
the farm
seizures which were spearheaded by mobs of war veterans and ZANU PF
party
supporters.
The report also highlights how labour laws and
basic human rights of farm
workers have been violated. It also contains
evidence of people who were
beaten up, harassed and sometimes shot at by
Mugabe's militia under the
guise of redistributing arable land previously in
the hands of whites.
Fresh farm disturbances in Zimbabwe have reportedly
rendered over 4 000 farm
workers homeless since the formation last February
of the unity government
by Mugabe and his once bitter rival
Tsvangirai.
The decade-long farm invasions which the 85-year-old Mugabe
says were
necessary to ensure blacks also had access to arable land that
they were
denied by previous white-led governments have been blamed for
plunging
Zimbabwe into food shortages.
Once a net food exporter
Zimbabwe has avoided mass starvation over the past
decade only because
international relief agencies were quick to chip in with
food handouts. -
ZimOnline
Harare 11 November 2009 |
Zimbabwe farm |
Temba Mliswa |
John Worsick |
Virginia Sibanda |
http://www.voanews.com
By Scott Bobb & Jonga Kandemiiri
Harare,
Washington
11 November 2009
Zimbabwe's few remaining
commercial white farmers said they are under
increasing pressure, some of it
violent, to leave their land in the latest
surge in farm seizures since
President Robert Mugabe launched fast-track
land redistribution about a
decade ago.
The program was intended to right a wrong of the colonial era
when mainly
British whites dispossessed indigenous blacks in the former
Rhodesia, but
many blame land reform for Zimbabwe's precipitous economic
decline, reports
VOA correspondent Scott Bobb.
The General
Agriculture and Plantation Workers Union of Zimbabwe this week
released a
documentary and a report on the impact of land reform on farm
workers. It
said the initiative has driven many farmworkers into poverty by
eliminating
their source of income, and that the government has not
addressed the dire
plight of many thousands of rural workers.
The documentary, called "House
of Justice," and the report, entitled "If
Something is Wrong," was launched
on Tuesday in Harare at a gathering
attended by representatives of civil
society organizations, labor unions and
members of the diplomatic
corps.
Gender and Child Labor Coordinator Juliet Sithole of the
farmworkers union
told VOA Studio 7 reporter Jonga Kandemiiri that the
organization wants to
increase regional and international pressure on the
government to respect
basic human rights.
from VOA's Studio 7
http://www.swradioafrica.com
By Tichaona
Sibanda
11 November 2009
A pride of lions has since August this year
killed 45 cattle and terrorized
villagers in Chipinge, where a herd of
marauding elephants has also caused
massive destruction to crop
fields.
The MDC MP for Chipinge West, Bonile Nyamudeza, told SW Radio
Africa on
Wednesday that four lions have been invading resettlements in
Maronga,
Tongogara, Mutema, Chaona and Charume, killing cattle and donkeys
belonging
to villagers. Luckily no human life has been lost to the
animals.
'Most of the cows were just killed and left there while some
were eaten. So
far villagers have lost seven donkeys to the lions,' the MP
said.
Nyamudeza said National Parks officers have so far failed to track
down the
lions, but have killed two elephants, after attempts to drive them
back to
the sprawling Save conservancy park from where they had strayed
proved
difficult and dangerous.
The MP blamed poachers and some ZANU
PF war veterans for destroying the
electrical fence that borders the
conservancy. The war vets and a well known
ZANU MP have invaded land on the
conservancy and have been cutting down the
fencing. At least 5 hectares of
farmland have been destroyed by a large
group of elephants which invaded the
villages of Goko, Nyunga and Musani.
The MDC legislator said more than 60
elephants had ravaged bean, tomato and
wheat fields, several times since
October, and local villagers' attempts at
driving the animals away had
proved futile.
The Department of National Parks had intensified
surveillance in the area to
protect locals against marauding animals.
Hundreds of people from several
villages along the Middle Sabi region, that
straddles the Save conservancy,
are spending sleepless nights guarding their
crops.
Nyamudeza said that the gravity of the situation jeopardises the
communities
food supply. He also described the situation as alarming and
called for
urgent intervention.
'The situation is quite serious and
alarming. We need helicopters to
ascertain the exact number of the elephants
that fanned out in all areas of
the district,' he said.
He said
people in the district were living in fear as the presence of the
jumbos is
leading to human-animal conflicts. The MP said most farmers would
harvest
little if the situation was not controlled.
The problem remains the
chaotic, violent, so called land reform. Until this
basic problem is
resolved nothing can be dealt with effectively.
http://www.bloomberg.com
By Brian Latham
Nov.
11 (Bloomberg) -- Zimbabwe's government won't export diamonds from its
disputed Marange diamond fields until it has put in measures to better
monitor trading in the gems.
"Zimbabwe agreed not to export Marange
diamonds until the monitoring
mechanism is established," Ian Kelly, a
spokesman for the U.S. State
Department, said in an e-mailed statement
yesterday.
The Kimberley Process, a global body created to curb trade in
gems mined to
fund conflict, on Nov. 5 decided not suspend Zimbabwe's
membership, saying
it supports the nation's attempts to work toward
compliance with the group's
requirements.
Marange was seized by the
Zimbabwe government from Maidstone, England-based
African Consolidated
Resources Plc in 2006 after gems were found. As many as
20,000 illegal
miners besieged the area, also known as Chiadzwa, and were
later cleared off
by the army and police. New York-based Human Rights Watch
says more than 200
were killed last year. Zimbabwe's police say they have
had no reports of
atrocities.
http://www.eyewitnessnews.co.za
Eyewitness News | 5 Hours
Ago
Zimbabwe's government has named the two companies mining in the
eastern
Chiadzwa diamond fields where human rights abuses have been
reported.
Neither of them are the legal owner of the diamond
claim.
Mines Minister Obert Mpofu named Mbada Minerals and Canadile
Miners Private
Limited which is reported to have South African
shareholders.
He said the companies have already started mining in
Chiadzwa, in
partnership with the state-run ZMDC.
Mutare residents
say the new investors have booked out a holiday resort near
the diamond
fields.
What is not being mentioned is the legal battle over the Chiadzwa
claim.
President Robert Mugabe's government evicted Africa Consolidated
Resources
three years ago as the diamond rush began.
The Harare High
Court confirmed in September ACR was the legal owner of the
claim.
The battle for Zimbabwe's diamonds is clearly far from
over.
http://www.voanews.com
By Sandra Nyaira
Washington
10 November
2009
Responding to critics of last week's decision by the Kimberly
Process
Certification Scheme not to suspend Zimbabwe over charges of human
rights
abuses in the eastern Marange diamond field, outgoing Kimberly
Process
Chairman Bernard Esau said that the Harare government has done much
to
address problems in the Manicaland province district.
Esau added
in an interview with VOA Studio 7 reporter Sandra Nyaira that
diamonds from
the field are not funding conflict and Harare needs help to
comply with
Kimberly standards.
But Mutare-based analyst Farai Maguwu of the Center
for Research and
Development said Esau's explanation won't keep independent
groups from
speaking out on Marange, where Human Rights Watch says the
military in
control has killed more than 200 people.
from VOA's
Studio 7
http://www.rfi.fr
Article published on the 2009-11-10 Latest update
2009-11-10 19:30 TU
Zimbabwe has launched a six-year economic blueprint
aimed at reviving the
country's moribond economy. The plan seeks to improve
the investment climate
in the country, starting with the signing of an
investment deal with South
Africa, expected later this month.
The
Minister for Economic Planning and Investment Promotion Elton Mangoma
unveiled the plan in Harare on Monday.
Mangoma told RFI that the
strategy was designed to end Zimbabwe's reliance
on its raw materials, which
have traditionally been its main source of
income.
"We are going to
see a transformation of the Zimbabwean economy, from
largely relying on
primary products [...] to value-added manufacturing
through the adoption of
new technologies, so that we beceom a global
competitor," he
says.
Interview: Elton Mangoma, Zimbabwean Minister of Economic
Planning
10/11/2009 by William Niba
Mangoma also rules out
any return to the local currency banished in January
due to
hyperinflation.
He believes Zimbabwe can fast track its economic recovery
through the
multi-currency system marked by trading in US dollars and the
South African
Rand.
Zimbabwe's economy is expected to post a 3.7 per
cent growth rate this year,
the first positive figures in a decade,
according to the International
Monetary Fund.
With the new strategy
in place, Mangoma is hoping for 12.5 per cent growth
in gross domestic
product in 2010.
http://www.voanews.com
By Patience Rusere
Washington
11
November 2009
Zimbabwean Finance Minister Tendai Biti has told
Parliament that he is
unable to persuade international donors to provide "a
single cent" for the
country's 2010 budget - as opposed to food aid or other
humanitarian
assistance - out of fear funds could be diverted.
He
made the comment in parliamentary debate on legislation to reform the
Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe, according to the Web news agency ZimOnline, which
quoted Biti as saying donors' first question was whether their funds would
be in RBZ hands. RBZ Governor Gideon Gono has acknowledged that he diverted
donor and other funds to government uses.
Biti said the solution is
reform of the central bank. Biti, who is also
secretary general of the
Movement for Democratic Change formation of Prime
Minister Morgan
Tsvangirai, has urged that Gono be replaced. The issue is
among those deeply
dividing the Tsvangirai MDC and the long-ruling ZANU-PF
party of President
Robert Mugabe, who has defended Gono.
VOA could not immediately reach
Biti for confirmation of the attributed
remarks.
Economist Nhlanhla
Nyathi told VOA Studio 7 reporter Patience Rusere that he
agrees with Biti,
as donors must have confidence the central bank will
properly handle
funds.
from VOA's Studio 7
http://www.thezimbabwetimes.com/?p=24862
November 11, 2009
By Ntando
Ncube
JOHANNESBURG - South Africa's labour movement COSATU and civil
rights
pressure group People Against Suppression, Suffering and Oppression
(Passop)
on Wednesday made a public appeal to insurance giant, Old Mutual,
to
withdraw its stake-hold in Zimbabwe Newspapers (1980) Ltd.
If Old
Mutual ignores the call the pressure groups are threatening to
mobilise
protests against over its business interest in Zimbabwe's
state-owned media
group, the largest newspaper publishing company in the
country.
Old
Mutual on Tuesday confirmed that it is a major shareholder in Zimpapers
which publishes The Herald, The Sunday Mail, The Chronicle and other
newspapers in Harare, Bulawayo and Mutare. The newspapers are now largely
viewed as propaganda mouthpieces for Zanu-PF and President
Robert.
'We are shocked and dismayed that a company with so much to lose,
considering its international profile, has chosen to include the Mugabe
regime's propaganda newspapers in its investment portfolio. We demand that
Old Mutual publicly withdraw its stakes in Zimbabwe Newspapers Ltd and
openly apologise for an investment that we sincerely hope was an accidental
oversight on your part. Should Old Mutual ignore this request, we will be
forced to embark on protest actions, and plan to engage as many Old Mutual
policy holders as possible," Hanekom wrote in a letter addressed to Old
Mutual Chief executive officer Julian Roberts.
We have a copy of the
letter.
Old Mutual was, in fact, already a shareholder in the original
Rhodesian and
Printing and Publishing Company, the forerunner of Zimpapers.
Soon after
independence the new government of Zimbabwe created the Zimbabwe
Mass Media
Trust, which acquired the majority of shares in the company from
the Argus
Publishing company of South Africa.
Zimbabwe's independent
newspapers have been subjected to a campaign of
threats, intimidation and
violence by the Mugabe government. In 2003 the
government banned the popular
Daily News and its sister paper, the Daily
News on Sunday as well as The
Tribune.
"While the international community, appalled by the actions of
the Zanu-PF
leadership, imposes sanctions on Zimbabwe, your company's
investment is
essentially arming Mugabe propaganda machinery, the equivalent
of loading
bullets into the guns that kill oppositional voices in Zimbabwe.
In light
of the detrimental effects of forced migration of recent years, we
consider
your interest in the company a direct attack on the impoverished
people of
not only Zimbabwe, but also those of South Africa.", the letter
added
Jonas Mushosho Managing Director of Old Mutual Life Assurance
Company
Zimbabwe said Old Mutual Zimbabwe's investment in Zimpapers, dates
back to
the pre-independence era.
"This shareholding in Zimpapers of
19 percent is held on behalf of our
policyholders and therefore this is a
portfolio investment and as a result,
we do not influence or involve
ourselves in their operational policy or
practice," Mushosho
said.
After the government, Old Mutual is the next largest shareholder in
Zimpapers.
Mushosho added that from a top-down approach, Old Mutual
was limited in the
choice of print and media investment assets in the
country and Zimpapers is
the only substantial printing and media asset type
that is available to
policyholders in terms of exposure to that
sector.
"Old Mutual Zimbabwe will continue to hold this investment for as
long as it
continues to make investment sense for our policyholders," he
added.
Zimbabwe Newspapers has for a long period now, not been a
profitable
organisation, mainly because of the flight of advertising away
from the
company's
newspapers. Sales of the company's publications
have also plummeted. The
Herald had a circulation of more than 160 000 in
the 1980s. Now the company
prints less that 20 000 copies of its flagship a
day.
COSATU high ranking official, Western Cape Provincial Secretary Tony
Ehrenreich, expressed outrage that Old Mutual has a stake in state-owned
media in Zimbabwe.
"These newspapers are responsible for spreading
the propaganda of the Mugabe
regime and Old Mutual should, as a matter of
urgency, disinvest in the
company," he said.
November 11, 2009
President Mugabe makes surprise announcement in Zhombe
By Takarinda Gomo
SOME overzealous peasants in the Zhombe area of Zimbabwe were itching to curry favour with the head of state and government and commander-in-chief of the armed forces, President Robert Gabriel Mugabe.Recently, they invited him to their sleepy village in order to donate 65 tones of maize and thank him for his everlasting benevolence.
After showering the villagers with accolades and their enduring patriotism, President Mugabe departed from his prepared speech and made a surprise announcement that the Zimbabwe dollar was coming back before the end of the year. Come hell or high water and damn the consequences!
The stock market panicked and shares nose dived by more than 12% compared to the previous week. Not only did investors flee, but corporates and individuals started withdrawing all their money from financial institutions. Business confidence had been eroded. Such, is the price Zimbabwe has to pay for impromptu policy announcements.
Economist Dr Eric Bloch, in his weekly column published in the Zimbabwe Independent, said President Mugabe and Zanu-PF demanded the reinstatement of the Zimbabwe dollar because usage of any other currency constituted surrender of national sovereignty.
“But the Zimbabwe dollar is so appallingly worthless that its usage at the present time represents naught, but sovereignty over nothing,” wrote Dr Bloch.
The Harare rumour mill is awash with juicy street talk that the Governor of the Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe (RBZ), Dr Gideon Gono, a taking cue from the President’s off guard remarks in Zhombe, ordered Fidelity Printers, a subsidiary of RBZ to go overdrive in printing useless Zimbabwe dollars.
Dr Gono still treasures fond memories of 2008 when he just printed worthless “bearer cheques” that he used to mop up US dollars on the parallel market. His ego was massaged as everybody depended on him because he dispensed largesse to government ministries, banks, state enterprises and even private companies. Gono became a household name and his delusion made him to actually believe he was on top of the situation, despite the pain and suffering among innocent people who slept in the queue to withdraw very little cash that was not even enough for bus fare.
Salvation came with the advent of the inclusive Government, which brought in a no-nonsense Finance Minister, Tendai Biti. He quickly dumped the Zimbabwe dollar and introduced a basket of currencies as legal tender. Hyperinflation which had exceeded 200 percent was wiped out overnight and stability in the market slowly picking up.
The bone of contention is for how long Zimbabwe will continue using a multi-currency regime? There are serious problems with either adopting a single currency, either the US dollar or the South African Rand, as the currency of preference. The other option is the rank madness of re-introducing the Zimbabwe dollar. Let us examine the arguments of adopting either the US dollar or the South African Rand as single currencies for Zimbabwe.
The US dollar dilemma
The status of the US dollar as an international currency has been damaged by the global credit crunch of 2007- 2009. However, this has not stopped the appetite for US dollars. It can be argued that countries need foreign reserves in order to intervene in the foreign exchange market, to prevent shocks on trade and financial flows that cause uncontrollable currency fluctuations.
Any system that uses the US dollar as its national currency is seriously flawed. In order to acquire large reserves of the US dollars, a country needs to run current account surpluses with the USA. But, global imbalances have created a crisis for US dollar, to such an extent, that the political logic for a US dollar based monetary and financial system is now less compelling.
Behind all the problems for the US dollar, an inconvenient truth is that the importance of the US dollar to many countries has not diminished. In foreign exchange markets, the dollar actually strengthened after the financial crisis. As the US dollar exchange fluctuated, the anticipated crash did not happen.
It follows that, the US dollar as a currency, is usable because it dominates foreign debt and trade, whilst governments use the US dollar to smoothen debt flows, and at the same time intervening on the exchange market. Despite the rise of the more appealing Euro, most countries still prefer to use the US dollar, which remains the exchange rate anchor. The problem is when the domestic inflation begins to track the US dollar inflation.
The choice of what mix of currencies, maximizes a particular combination of risks and always assume that all currencies are equally easy to use. Foreign investors conduct transactions and concentrate their holdings in US dollars because they are easy to buy and sell, whilst other currencies have to struggle to compete against the US dollar.
For all practical purposes, the US dollar is the first among equals.
Since the First World War (1914-18), use of multiple currencies has been functional. Currency units co-existed peacefully, each with its own constituency. For Zimbabwe, since the advent of the inclusive government, multiple currencies led to the avoidance of instability within markets and retching up of market discipline. The choice of full dollarised currency is no longer in Government control as money is out of government hands. Zimbabwe is effectively on a currency board footing, because the money is determined by foreign reserves.
The only money that can circulate is export earnings, capital inflows, foreign remittances and offshore lines of credit. This situation can only change when local financial institutions can accumulate foreign currency from exports and be able to dispense loans in foreign exchange at a lending rate that depends on statutory reserve ratio set by the central bank. This creates credit and expands money supply.
The monetary dilemma that bedevils Zimbabwe is that, at present, there is no lender of last resort to act as a buffer or safety net. RBZ has mortgaged its control over monetary policy. Nothing will really change in Zimbabwe if the central bank is closed today!
Banks are approaching this policy flaw with extreme caution because of low loan-to-deposit ratios. Loans are attracting at least 7 percent interest per annum against the background of liquidity problems affecting the country.
So what are the problems of using only the US dollar? At a glance these include:
The Rand Dilemma
According to Erick Bloch, many people living in Zimbabwe’s second city Bulawayo, and the surrounding southern areas, where the South African Rand (ZAR) is widely used, suffer a major reduction in spending power. This is a result of the strengthening of the Rand against the US Dollar during the last six months, which moved from ZAR 10: US$1 to ZAR 7.2: US$1 representing 28 percent in Rand terms.
People who live in the Southern and Western districts of Zimbabwe and earn US dollars, are very bitter because of the movement of currency cross-rates and they are demanding that the government abandons use of the multi-currency basket and use only the Rand.
For all practical purposes, the strengthening of the Rand against the US dollar should not be viewed as permanent. It emanated from the current rise in the price of gold on the world market. Demand for gold has driven the price of gold from US$900 to over US$1040 hence the windfall for South Africa, a major gold producer.
Bloch argues that should the price of gold fall, it would mean weakening of the Rand against the US dollar. If Zimbabwe had adopted the Rand as its only currency, it will be adversely affected. This is happening in the South African diamond sector, where the prices are falling.
The Rand is a volatile currency, which already complicates cross-border trading and investment decisions. Besides, there are serious perceptions about where South Africa is heading politically and economically. Bloch assets that 70 percent of South African textile industry has collapsed due to cheap imports from the East, especially China. Also, the boon enjoyed in the construction sector that came as a result of the 2010 World Cup, will soon be over as projects are completed. Future demand in that sector is highly improbable.
Sadc Regional Currency
The third option for Zimbabwe currency reform is to wait until Sadc has introduced a regional currency along the same lines as the Euro is the currency of most European countries. The down side is that the Zimbabwean economy is so volatile and, if it takes five years before the Sadc regional currency to be introduced, a lot of harm will have happened to the country.
From this analysis, it would be sheer recklessness and typical lunacy to re-introduce the Zimbabwe dollar just to boost some people’s bruised egos. It follows that adoption of any single currency now, has very negative impacts on the economy. Zimbabwe should continue using multiple currencies until it meets certain benchmarks, which include:
The hapless villagers at Zhombe, who cheered President Mugabe when he punched the air declaring the return of the ghost of the Zimbabwe dollar, should be forgiven, for, as the Bible says, they do not know what they are doing!
The Zimbabwe dollar is as dead as a dodo.
Power-sharing has not loosened Mugabe’s iron grip, says Ben Freeth, a farmer whose home and livelihood were destroyed by Zanu-PF militants
On Sunday 30 August last year, as we drove back from church to our home in Chegutu, northern Zimbabwe, my wife and I spotted a large swirl of white smoke in the distance. We soon realised, to our horror, that the thick fumes were coming from our property. Our farm was on fire.
By the time we reached the drive, the flames were tearing across our land, heading towards our workers’ homes, the orchards and our own house. We needed water, and lots of it, fast. But we were at a major disadvantage. Several weeks earlier the Zanu-PF militants (the same men who, we can be certain, started the fire) had stolen our tractors, water carts and fire-fighting equipment, leaving us no means of dousing the flames. In desperation, we took some green branches and beat frantically at the fast-advancing walls of flame. It was no use: the wind was strong and in a matter of minutes the blaze had spread to our thatched roofs. I ran in and out of the house twice, grabbing our most important documents and our computers. But the heat was unbearable, and soon it was impossible to go back in.
Two of our workers managed to remove some chairs and a table from the house. All we could do was sit down and watch hopelessly as the fire devastated everything: the little linen factory we ran on the farm, our possessions and our home. Our life’s work — our history — was consumed in about half an hour. A few hundred yards away, I saw one of the thugs sitting on one of our tractors, laughing at us. After the fire, my nine-year-old son Joshua approached me and asked, ‘Is water stronger than fire, or is fire stronger than water?’ I thought a bit and said, ‘fire is very strong... but if there is water then fire is weaker.’ I think he understood. Two days later, they burnt down my parents-in-law’s house as well.
Fire is only the latest ordeal that our family has had to endure under Robert Mugabe’s regime. In the last ten years, we have been remorselessly harassed and persecuted on our property by violent men who think white people don’t belong in Zimbabwe. On 29 June last year, the day before Mugabe was sworn in as President for a sixth term, a group of armed militiamen raided our farm, kidnapping my wife’s parents, Mike and Angela Campbell, and me. We were badly beaten, abducted and dragged to a pungwe — a mass all-night indoctrination meeting led by a brainwashed nationalist mob — then beaten again. Angela, 67, had her arm broken twice and a red-hot stick thrust into her mouth. Mike, 74, had his ribs smashed and bones broken in his hands and feet. He suffered brain damage from repeated blows to the head.
We are not the only ones, of course. Many other farming families have been through similar experiences. Some of my friends have been killed; many more have been left traumatised or debilitated. More than a million Zimbabwean farm workers have been forced from their homes.
My family has tried to resist, but with little success. After the latest invasion that started in April this year, we won two high-court orders decreeing that the criminals occupying our land should be removed. But the police refused to obey them. Last year, the Southern African Development Community Tribunal issued a ruling supporting our family’s property rights, and later pronounced the Zimbabwean government in contempt of court for failing to comply with the judgment. The SADC’s intervention seemed a major breakthrough for Zimbabwe’s farmers, the first time that an international court had condemned Mugabe’s appropriation of our land. Again, though, nothing happened.
We’ve filed other suits, including one against our local police department head, Chief Inspector Manika, who on countless occasions has looked the other way as the invading brutes have destroyed our property and brutalised our workers. The authorities, perhaps sensing some pressure on Manika, elected to dispatch him to Liberia — to serve a UN peace-keeping mission.
This is the madness of Zimbabwe, where small currents of order and justice appear only to vanish into a hellish swamp of oppression and corruption. In the eyes of the outside world, our country has recently improved. The so-called ‘unity government’ that emerged in February, with opposition leader Morgan Tsvangirai as Prime Minister, was greeted as a great triumph for free people everywhere. Hyperinflation stopped with the final collapse of the Zimbabwe dollar, and everyone thought the economy might show signs of growth. The European Union, apparently convinced that Zimbabwean democracy is on the mend, has re-entered negotiations with Mugabe, who in reply makes noises about ‘fresh and co-operative relations’.
Don’t believe a word of it. In rural areas, Zanu-PF is consolidating its power with a terrifying zeal. Tsvangirai may be prime minister, but he has little or no real influence. Mugabe still controls the army, the police, and the Ministry of Justice; and he still has his appointees in the Supreme Court. In Chegutu, I see children as young as ten being trained at the police station. They are being prepared, we fear, for the next election, when Mugabe will squash whatever democracy is left.
For all the talk of progress, Zimbabwe — a rich agricultural land — remains one of the nations most dependent on food aid. That problem is not going to resolve itself while the vicious destruction of the farming industry continues. This year, we expect the national wheat harvest to be less than a tenth of what it should be, because so much equipment has been destroyed, so many crops damaged.
On that terrible day in August, one of the many treasured possessions my family lost was a battered old wallet belonging to my mother-in-law. In it, she kept a heavily creased black-and-white photograph that she had recently inherited from her father. The picture was of Angela as a young girl. On the back was marked ‘Stalag 4’, the name of one of the Nazi camps where her father, a South African prisoner of war, had been incarcerated. He used to tell us about his wartime experiences. He would describe how, interned next to the concentration camp at Dachau, he could smell the bodies burning in crematorium incinerators.
When I look at the charred ruins of our home, I think of him and the horrors he witnessed. It is hard for me not to see a parallel between the situation of white farmers in Zimbabwe and that of Jews under Hitler. Zimbabwe’s nationalist leaders today hate the white man just as Nazis despised the Jew. Mugabe blames us for the chaos he has created, just as Hitler pinned all the problems of Germany on to a small Jewish minority.
The white population of Zimbabwe, which at its height numbered about 270,000, has now been whittled down to around 20,000. Only a few hundred farmers remain. Our tormentors grow bolder and more violent. We wonder how it will end.
"The worst fear is that petty squabbling and politicking among leaders will lead to squandering of resources," Department of International Relations director-general Ayanda Ntsaluba said.
He said the tight time frame of 30 days in which to settle the disagreement over key posts in the unity government in Zimbabwe was indicative of the impatience felt by regional leaders.
"The fact that there are clear time frames signifies the degree of impatience that Zimbabwean political leaders must not squander what appears to be an opportunity - the only opportunity - to pull their country out of the abyss," Ntsaluba said.
Last week, at a Southern African Development Community summit, it was agreed that Zimbabwe's leaders would commit themselves to fully implementing the unity government within 30 days.
"The inclusive government, essentially, is the only game in town," said Ntsaluba.
He said, however, that it was understood that implementation would not be easy.
"The political temperature was a bit higher than normal," he said after a visit to Zimbabwe. "We are dealing with a fragile process. The levels of trust are not exactly where they should be, dealing with people who were virtually at war," said Ntsaluba.
Some of the "impediments" noted by the SADC ministerial delegation after meeting with the Movement for Democratic Change included the appointments of the reserve bank governor, the attorney-general and a provincial governor.
SADC raised concerns that there might be a re-emergence of political instability and new land invasions.
Zanu-PF has attacked the MDC for its "failure" to help it get sanctions lifted, and disputes the MDC's interpretation of the power-sharing agreement.
Email: jag@mango.zw; justiceforagriculture@zol.co.zw
Please
send any material for publication in the Open Letter Forum to
jag@mango JAG OPEN LETTER FORUM - No..zw with "For
Open Letter
Forum" in the subject line.
To subscribe/unsubscribe to
the JAG mailing list, please email:
jag@mango.zw with subject line "subscribe" or
"unsubscribe".
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1.
Ben Freeth letter to the Prime Minister
2. P. Cory - Cruelty to
animals
3. Cathy Buckle
4. Bill Carter
5. Richard &
Sue Arkell
6. Meryl Harrison
7. Philip Barclay
8. Stuart
Mattinson
9. Bruce Masson
10. Noeline van Rooyen
11.
Chris Scotcher
12. Graham
Walcott
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1.
Ben Freeth letter to the Prime Minister
A call for the Prime Minister to
act In a Time of "Controlled
Anarchy" where crimes against humanity are being
committed in
Zimbabwe.
A letter to the
"PrimeMinister."
5 November 2009.
Dear Prime
Minister Tsvangirai,
As a very concerned person I write to you, the Prime
minister, an open
letter asking that something be done about the continued
destruction of
Zimbabwe and the lives of its people that some of your
Government
employees are participating in.
Countrywide, elements
within the police are assisting in the rule of law
break down. I have asked
for a full investigation into the nefarious
activities of elements within the
Chegutu police on a number of occasions
but nothing is being done. Instead
the Officer in Charge, Chief
Inspector Manyika, appears to have been rewarded
by being transferred to
the UN as a peace keeper in Liberia. The man who
appears to be behind
most of the State inspired lawlessness in Chegutu,
Assistant Inspector
Bepura, is still in position.
Whilst we understand
the difficulties that you face, I believe it is
important that you at least
expose the reasons why some of your employees
in the police continue to get
away with allowing lawlessness and also
participating in it. If you cannot
bring the rule of law back you owe an
explanation to those that supported you
as to why over the last few
months, tens of thousands of your supporters are
suffering from having
lost their homes and livelihoods due to the activities
of your police
employees.
Where it comes to white farmers and their
workers and their families,
High Court orders are being ignored in case after
case. The SADC
Tribunal Judgment has been ignored. In June your Government
was found in
contempt of this international court and your Minister of Home
Affairs,
Giles Matsekwa, has yet to mention this fact. Legal bodies from all
over
Africa have expressed their concern about the way your
government
employees have ignored this Judgment. It appears that there has
been no
move to re-establish the rule of law and there have been no
repercussions
or even investigations into your police employees participating
in its
break down where white farmers and the farm workers on their farms
are
concerned. Just as so many Europeans turned their backs on the Jews
and
allowed their utter destruction at the hands of the NAZI
nationalists,
so, it seems, you are doing the same to hundreds of thousands
of farmers
and their workers in the in the face of the ZANU African
nationalists in
Zimbabwe.
Such a state of affairs is extremely
concerning. It is very negatively
impacting directly on food security,
employment, and economic growth and
development. The indirect effects on the
government health service and
education are manifest. Your people are
suffering and leaving Zimbabwe
as a result. The children of our country are
being left without a
future.
Decades of agricultural development are
being lost as I write.
Individual case details can be supplied to those that
may care, but to
summarize:
. Thousands of tons of complete crops
have been allowed to be looted
through this harvest season;
.
Hundreds of thousands of trees in established productive orchards are
being
allowed to die this season;
. Asset stripping of the few remaining
productive farms is taking place
in numerous cases right now;
.
Scores of tractors and implements and other agricultural equipment are
being
looted with assistance from police with no compensation at
the
moment;
. At the moment workers are being threatened, severely
beaten and
evicted by farm invaders in hundreds of cases with absolute
impunity
- some have been killed;
. Many farmers and farm workers
houses have been looted and others have
been burnt down recently;
.
Jambanja style illegal evictions of farmers and farm workers continue
to take
place with police and army - tens of thousands of people have had
their homes
and livelihoods lawlessly forced from them since you became
Prime Minister
and there has been no thought of compensation;
. Over a million people
[farmers, farm workers and others] currently on
"contested" farms have no
offer letter, lease or permit and
under the draconian laws of Zimbabwe [that
were struck down by the SADC
Tribunal but continue to be ignored] stand to
face a fine and or up to 2
years in prison. Many of these people, both
farmers and farm workers,
are being convicted in the courts in defiance of
the SADC Tribunal at the
moment.
. Little children are being trained
up for goodness knows what even in
your police camps.
None of the
perpetrators of these crimes are being arrested and in many
of the listed
instances above police and army are directly committing
these
crimes.
Prime Minister, I am a Christian and it is my duty to try to do
something
against injustice and evil. If nothing is done or said about
this
controlled anarchy that is being manipulated under your leadership,
and
no independent internationally led judicial enquiry is set up to
verify
what I am saying is happening right now so that something can be done
to
stop it, the consequences for the children of Zimbabwe will be a
very
grim one indeed. I infer from your reticence to answer letters or
visit
a single commercial farm during your time as Prime Minister or
speak
about the widespread humanitarian disaster through the rule of law
break
down on the farms that you know that there is a problem; but it
appears
you don't want to face it. We owe it to the next generation
and
to God, to do something about this problem now. I pray that you will
act
with courage and decisiveness to bring accountability to the
perpetrators
of what amounts to crimes against humanity within elements of
your police
force.
Yours sincerely,
Ben
Freeth.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2.
P. Cory - Cruelty to animals
The Editor
Sir
As an animal
lover and one time supporter of the Zimbabwe National
Society for the
Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (ZNSPCA), I have been
appalled to learn of
the plight of hundreds of pigs at Mr Fick's
Friedawil Farm in
Chinhoyi.
For over a week now, the pigs have been without food or water,
due to
political wranglings over farm ownership. Sows are currently
farrowing
in this sweltering heat, with no access to water of any kind. As
they
are being confined in communal pens and not individual farrowing
pens,
mortality will be even higher, especially amongst the
piglets.
The ZNSPCA is the one independent, impartial organisation in the
country
which can and should take control of this animal welfare
crisis.
However, it appears this has not been the case.
In spite of
the serious plight of the pigs being reported to ZNSPCA last
week, together
with a request for assistance - as the owner has been
prevented from entering
the farm - the suffering of the pigs grows worse
every day.
Surely
the organisation has policies and procedures to deal with just
such a
situation as this as they have done so successfully in the past.
We trust
that the unimaginable suffering of the animals on this farm will
be dealt
with as urgently as possible.
P
Cory
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
3.
Cathy Buckle
Dear Jag Team
I am delighted to hear of the vote of
confidence in you. Your voice and
the role of JAG has been the only
consistent, honest and unwavering
representation for agriculture, farmers and
farm workers in the country
since 2001. Undoubtedly your personal and private
sacrifices have been
immense. Thank you John - this jambanja is over and you
have emerged with
your head held high.
In appreciation, Cathy
Buckle
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
4.
Bill Carter
Dear Jag Team
Congratulations !! I am delighted at
the result. You have won a major
battle, but not the war, yet. May the Good
Lord give you strength to
regroup and carry on doing what you have been doing
with such dedication
and so magnificently over these past years.
Yours
very sincerely,
Bill
Carter
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
5.
Richard & Sue Arkell
Dear JAG Team,
Congratulations.
We
look forward to seeing you all again on our return to Zim in
December.
Love for now
Richard and Sue
Arkell
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
6.
Meryl Harrison
Hi Jag Team
Fantastic news!!! - was thinking of you
on the 7th & saying lots of
prayers - but was totally confident that you
would win the day -
Congratulations! - as you know you have always had my
100% support.
See you in the New Year!
Love
Meryl
Harrison
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
7.
Philip Barclay
Dear Jag Team
Congratulations on your vote of
confidence. It must have been an ordeal
for you and all at JAG to go through
this. I am sure you're keen to get
on with the real work again - good
luck!
All the best,
Philip
Barclay
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
8.
Stuart Mattinson
Dear Jag Team
Congratulations on the outcome of
the meeting. I am sorry that it came to
the situation that prevailed and I
hope that you can now get on with the
invaluable work that you have been
doing for Zimbabwe and the farming
sector in particular.
Please be
assured of our continuing support for the work that JAG does.
Best
wishes,
Stuart
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
9.
Bruce Masson
Dear Jag Team
I am still commuting between Mutare and
Jhb, and I have been following
all the correspondence on the email. I am
absolutely delighted to read
this email, and I have every confidence that you
and the new team will
continue to steer JAG in the direction that we all
desire.
I will call in have a cup of coffee when I am in
Harare.
Kind regards,
Bruce
Masson.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
10.
Noeline van Rooyen
Dear Jag Team
You see your JAG TEAM name in
capitals because you are bigger than all
the accusations. Congratulations we
are so relieved for you that this
horrible evil mess is over and you were
vindicated. Truth always prevails
in the end. With this clean slate you can
only now go forward. When next
in town we will come and see you. Again
congratulations!!!!!!!!
God bless you all at Jag
Noeline van
Rooyen
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
11.
Chris Scotcher
Please send my congratulations to the JAG
TEAM.
Many thanks
Chris
Scotcher
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
12.
Graham Walcott
Dear Jag Team
CONGRATULATIONS
Graham
Walcott
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
All
letters published on the open Letter Forum are the views and opinions
of the
submitters, and do not represent the official viewpoint of Justice
for
Agriculture.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Yesterday we were out in the bush, some 220
kilometres from Bulawayo
speaking at a MDC rally in a tiny village. A fairly
large crowd had gathered
with villagers walking into the site from many
kilometres in every
direction. After the meeting we had a meal together and
then they walked
home and I drove back to the City.
When we set out I
had no idea that we would find ourselves at the site where
some 114 years
ago, a small detachment of part time soldiers would attempt
to capture the
King of the Amandebele people who had just fled his capitol,
Gubulawayo,
some 10 kilometres from where I write today. The site was just
500 metres
from the rally and afterwards we walked across to it and were
told the story
of that battle - the final battle with the Ndebele that
opened the way to
white settler domination for the next 80 years.
The site is vandalised
and all that remains is a small monument to the 34
white men killed in the
battle and a nearby mound of soil that holds the
mass grave of up to 400
Ndebele men killed at the same time. Three battles
were fought in that brief
campaign - the first at Shangani, the second at
Gubulawayo (the "Place of
Slaughter") and then the final skirmishes over the
other side of the
Shangani River in the Lupane District.
Lobengula, the King of the Ndebele
was fleeing his home which had been
captured and burnt, with four regiments
or "Impi's" - each comprising
several thousand men. These were the finest
fighting men of the region at
the time and had dominated much of central
Africa for the 19th century. Now
that domination was confronted by new
threat - white men with modern
weapons. After the final battle, Lobengula
travelled north and died near the
Zambezi where he was buried with his
personal possessions.
The Nduna's who led the Ndebele regiments in the
fight disembowelled those
killed to allow their spirits to depart but
otherwise did not do anything to
the bodies simply recording, that "these
were brave men" and leaving a
single man at the site to tell the troops that
were following up, what had
happened. The remains of those men are now
buried in the Matopo Hills
outside Bulawayo.
One of our party said
that she had been present at the religious ceremony
held on the site to
commemorate 100 years after the battle. She said she
could feel the spirits
of those killed at the site. Our guide to the site
insisted we pray there
out of respect.
A thousand years ago, a battle took place against the
English and the Scots
were led by Robert the Bruce - a direct ancestor of my
family. We travelled
to that site some 30 odd years ago as a family and it
may sound weird, but
when I stood on that ancient battle ground I had a
feeling that I knew that
place, even though I had never been to that country
before.
No African would dispute that the spirits live on and should be
respected. I
think it is important that sites such as that at the Shangani
in Lupane are
both maintained and protected and as soon as we can find the
resources I
would like to see us rebuild the memorial - but not just to the
whites who
died there but also to the Ndebele who gave their lives
protecting their
leadership and way of life. There were brave men on both
sides.
The savage campaign to suppress the Ndebele people from 1983 to
1987 was
called Gukurahundi (the storm) and was led initially by a North
Korean
trained brigade of the Zimbabwe army. It started in the Lupane
District
where 2000 people died in targeted killings in six weeks. The
campaign went
on for four years and tens of thousands were killed - men,
women and
children, unarmed and unresisting. We now recognise this as
genocide.
The spirits of that campaign also live on in that region of the
country and
it is unlikely that Zanu PF will win any seats in Matabeleland
in the next
election. If I was in Zanu I would be hesitant about travelling
through
those remote villages.
Another sort of battle is being waged
right now in Zimbabwe. This may not be
in the form that it took at Shangani,
but it is just as savage and takes no
prisoners. On Thursday regional
leaders met in Maputo with the three Party
leaders from Zimbabwe and after a
tough session they agreed to give the
Parties to the GPA 15 days to settle
all the outstanding issues. They
appointed the President of South Africa as
the facilitator to ensure that
progress was made and agreed to review the
situation in 30 days.
Just as significant, the regional leaders accepted
the MDC interpretation of
just what represents the GPA and of our analysis
of what has not been done.
In our view, the GPA has 34 specific areas where
the three Parties have
agreed there will be reform under the GPA. Of these 4
have been fully
implemented, 13 partially and 17 not at all - in fact we
argued that in many
areas the situation has regressed (the rule of law and
farm insecurity for
example).
On the strength of the regions
undertakings, today the MDC will resume
normal government activity and will
attend Cabinet. But the situation is on
a short fuse and if we face the same
reluctance on the part of Zanu PF to
fulfil their obligations under the GPA,
then the crisis here will deepen.
The markets have interpreted this and
all economic indicators are negative
again. This is not being helped by a
covert attempt by Zanu elements in the
government to revive their proposal
to take over 51 per cent of major
companies - the only change is that they
are threatening foreign owned
companies this time.
Sitting in
Parliament I sometimes wonder if the Zanu people really
understand the
damage they have done to the country in the past 30 years. Do
they have any
understanding of the poverty and suffering they have brought
to millions of
people? Do they understand what drives a successful economy
and what we must
do to get our system back up and running? Not if they
continue to do such
stupid things such as these proposed regulations.
I am sure we will be
able to sort this out - but the signal is still there,
Zanu PF has not
learned its lessons and still has enough control of the
State to wreck our
recovery efforts. I was working out that the meagre 5 per
cent growth we
expect this year (the first year of expansion since 1997 -
last year the
economy shrank by nearly 15 per cent) translates to less than
2 per cent of
the economic space we have lost since 1997. At that rate it
will take us a
100 years to make up for what Zanu PF has done in ten.
Eddie
Cross
Bulawayo, 9th October 2009
Posted by ZDN on November 11, 2009
Politics