International Herald Tribune
The Associated
PressPublished: November 15, 2007
MBARE, Zimbabwe: Buses pull in
at the chaotic terminus here, roofs stacked
with supplies of rice, sugar,
corn, salt, soap, powdered milk and soft
drinks from crisis-hit Zimbabwe's
eastern neighbor, Mozambique.
They were the latest arrivals from Mutare,
a former sleepy Zimbabwean border
town 260 kilometers (160 miles) from
Harare, transformed this month into a
busy trading hub after Mozambique
scrapped visas for Zimbabweans.
A 25-kilogram (55-pound) bag of Pakistani
rice was on offer this week in
Harare's western suburb, Mbare, for 25
million Zimbabwe dollars, twice the
monthly salary of a teacher. That amount
is US$25 (€17) at the dominant
black market rate but US$830 (nearly €570) at
the official rate.
Regular buyers at the bus station could probably get
the rice for less and
double their money on the black market. White
shoppers, presumed to be
better off, generally pay more.
"Thirty
meters. Take it or leave it!" said a vendor who gave his name only
as
Ephraim. In street parlance, a million Zimbabwe dollars is a
meter.
Just across the border from Mutare, a trading post has sprung
up in a
wasteland known as Pamimango, or "the place of the mango trees" in
the local
Shona language.
The nearest town, Manica, lies 18 kilometers
(12 miles) inside the border.
While Mozambique is among the world's poorest
countries, devastated by three
decades of civil war that ended in 1992, its
currency is stable and official
inflation is close to single
digits.
Zimbabwe's worst economic crisis since independence in 1980 has
spurred
official inflation of nearly 8,000 percent, the highest in the
world.
Mozambique is closer to Harare, the capital, than South Africa,
Zambia and
Botswana, which are the usual destinations for Zimbabweans
shopping for food
and other essentials.
Police at Mbare bus park and
an adjacent market have been given the power to
enforce a ban on carrying
firewood without a permit from the state Forestry
Commission.
Authorities said the move this week was meant to stop
indiscriminate tree
felling. But with daily power outages across the
country, wood has become
the most common fuel for cooking. Cooking fires
have appeared even on the
balconies of city apartments.
Ephraim, the
vendor, said he bought wood from bus drivers and hauled it on a
cart to the
nearby market.
"What will people do now?" he asked, but added that in a
few days police
likely would turn a blind eye in return for a bribe.
Reuters
Thu 15 Nov
2007, 15:34 GMT
By Nelson Banya
HARARE (Reuters) - Zimbabwean
President Robert Mugabe said on Thursday that
the country would soon boost
agricultural production to survive what he said
was a plot by "Western
destructive forces" to bring about its collapse.
Speaking as his
government launched a $6 million bio-diesel refinery built
as a joint
venture with a South Korean firm just outside of Harare, Mugabe
said his
land reforms -- blamed for Zimbabwe's economic crisis -- would soon
begin to
bear fruit.
"Zimbabwe was never there to collapse and shall never be
there to collapse,"
he said.
Mugabe's critics say his controversial
policy of seizing white-owned farms
to resettle landless blacks with little
farming experience has brought the
economy to its knees.
Zimbabwe
suffers from the world's highest inflation rates and chronic food,
fuel and
foreign currency shortages.
Mugabe, 83, accuses Western powers, mainly
Britain and the United States, of
sabotaging the economy to undermine his
administration. He faces few
political challenges at home.
Analysts
say the country's economic woes pose the biggest threat to his rule
but the
veteran leader vowed Zimbabwe would never crumble under their weight
and
scoffed at international sanctions against his government.
"We have once
again demonstrated that the ill-fated illegal sanctions
against the innocent
people of Zimbabwe can never subdue our resilience and
inner propulsion to
succeed and remain standing as a nation," he said.
The fuel plant, with a
capacity to produce 100 million litres of diesel
annually, should mainly
provide fuel to farmers resettled under the land
grabs.
Official
statistics say the farming sector requires almost 120 million
litres of
diesel annually, while the country's total diesel demand is
estimated at
about 1 billion litres.
"Once wholly customised, this plant will, at full
capacity, yield a
production level of 100 million litres of diesel per year,
meeting virtually
all the agricultural sector's diesel requirements," Mugabe
said.
"As government, we are also working tirelessly to ensure that this
coming
agricultural season marks a lasting turning point in the country's
economic
fortunes."
The southern African country, once one of
Africa's most promising economies,
suffers from the world's highest
inflation rate and food, fuel and foreign
currency shortages.
Yahoo News
Thu Nov
15, 9:51 AM ET
MOUNT HAMPDEN, Zimbabwe (AFP) - President Robert Mugabe on
Thursday
commissioned the first biodiesel production plant in oil-starved
Zimbabwe,
vowing that the country would "never collapse."
"As a
nation we have once again demonstrated that the ill-fated sanctions
against
the innocent people of Zimbabwe can never subdue our resilience and
inner
propulsion to succeed and remain on our feet as a nation," Mugabe told
guests at the plant's official opening.
"Soon, our economy will be
paying us back the dividends of the seedlings of
progression we are planting
across different productive sectors.
"Zimbabwe was never there to
collapse, is never there to collapse and will
never be there to
collapse."
The Transload biodiesel plant, 15 kilometres (10 miles)
northwest of Harare,
is a joint venture between a Zimbabwean and South
Korean firm.
Mugabe said the plant could pump 100 million litres of
biodiesel annually at
its peak from cotton seed, soya beans, jatropha and
sunflower seed.
The project could save the country 80 million US dollars,
he said.
"As a people, we have demonstrated that the dark clouds of our
hard times,
particularly those sown by Western destructive forces, have
their silver
lining by way of not just strengthening our resilience, but
also of
deepening our scientific research and stimulating our
innovativeness,"
Mugabe said.
Zimbabwe is in the throes of an
economic crisis characterised by high
inflation perched at nearly 8,000
percent, mass unemployment and chronic
shortages of fuel and basic
foodstuffs like sugar and cooking oil.
Fuel stations often go for months
without deliveries while long queues form
at the few that do receive
supplies.
Mugabe blames the economic collapse on targeted sanctions
imposed on him and
members of his ruling elite by the European Union and the
United States
following presidential polls in 2002 which the main opposition
and Western
observers say were rigged.
VOA
By Peta Thornycroft
15 November
2007
After many delays negotiations in Harare between the
ruling ZANU-PF and the
opposition Movement for Democratic Change have
reached a critical point and
the parties have reportedly agreed to new laws
governing elections due next
year. Peta Thornycroft reports for
VOA.
Robert Mugabe (file photo)
President Robert Mugabe's
ZANU-PF and the two factions of the opposition
Movement for Democratic
Change are considering a set of new election laws
likely to be presented to
parliament in the next few weeks.
Southern African diplomatic sources say
the measures were agreed in South
Africa-facilitated talks between the
parties which have been under way since
March.
Revising the electoral
laws is seen as essential by government critics
because last-minute changes
introduced by Mr. Mugabe in the 2002
presidential election prevented
thousands of people from voting. The changes
included dramatic reductions in
the number of polling stations in urban
areas, considered opposition
strongholds. The remaining polling centers were
unable to cope with the
number of voters.
Other amendments to laws governing the pre-election
period reportedly are
already at the government printer. These include
reforms to allow all
contesting political parties greater access to state
media.
Sources say the new legislation, the first item on the negotiating
agenda,
could be presented to parliament within weeks, providing
negotiations do not
break down. A new interim constitution is also being
considered.
The next three items on the negotiation agenda include
reforms to
legislation governing media, security and property
laws.
The fifth item on the agenda is called political
climate.
During elections since 2000 opposition supporters have been
killed,
kidnapped, beaten and arrested when they campaigned in traditional
ZANU-PF
strongholds in rural areas.
Observers say South Africa will
have to play a decisive role to improve the
political climate and ensure
Zimbabweans experience freedom of political
choice.
However, the
simultaneous presidential, parliamentary and senate elections
must be
announced next month, ninety days ahead of polling day which is
currently
scheduled for March. President Mugabe's term also expires in
March.
Observers say this leaves very little time to legislate and
implement every
thing agreed at the talks. They warn that South African
mediators will
likely have to persuade ZANU-PF to delay elections beyond
March, so that the
effects of new electoral freedoms can take
hold.
Political observers say the final agreements reached by the parties
are
likely to include several major compromises which may not be acceptable
to
their supporters in both parties. This could also cause delays as party
leaders lobby for support for the deals among the rank and file. But they
say the negotiations present an opportunity for a new
beginning.
African diplomats from the region who asked not to be named
but are closely
following the talks say they are encouraged by the progress
aimed at ending
Zimbabwe's political and economic crisis.
President
Mugabe, 83 years old and in power for nearly 28 years, is expected
to be
endorsed as the ZANU-PF presidential candidate during a party congress
next
month.
News24
15/11/2007 12:00 -
(SA)
Pretoria - South Africa is happy with the progress that has been
made
regarding efforts to resolve the problems currently facing Zimbabwe,
says
Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs Aziz Pahad.
President Thabo
Mbeki was mandated by the Southern African Development
Community (SADC)
heads of state and government extra-ordinary summit held in
Dar-es-Salaam,
Tanzania, in March this year to facilitate talks between the
Zimbabwean
government and the opposition Movement for Democratic Change
(MDC).
In that light, Mr Pahad said the government believed it had
been
consistently working to meet the mandate handed out to SA at the SADC
extraordinary summit.
Mr Pahad was addressing the media on the
progress made by the International
Relations, Peace and Security (IRPS)
Cluster in the implementation of their
Programme of Action (POA) and the
consolidation of the African Agenda, in
Cape Town, on Wednesday.
'SA
to facilitate dialogue'
He cited as a reflection of the progress made,
the unanimous acceptance by
all relevant stakeholders in Zimbabwe, of the
Constitutional Amendment Bill
No 18, which sought to harmonise presidential,
parliamentary and local
government elections as from 2008.
Pahad
said: "SA will continue to facilitate dialogue between the government
and
opposition parties, including representatives from civil society in
order to
resolve the remaining challenges facing Zimbabwe leading up to the
2008
general elections.
"Our primary focus remains ensuring an outcome that
expresses the free will
of the people of Zimbabwe as a critical element of
opening avenues to tackle
the serious socio-economic crisis."
He
further expressed government's confidence that many of the outstanding
issues that were being discussed would be successfully resolved to ensure
that free and fair elections were held next year.
Finance ministers
meet in Zambia
The deputy minister said: "We are focusing on ensuring an
outcome that will
determine that the free will of the people of Zimbabwe is
expressed and that
avenues to tackle the socio-economic challenges will be
found."
Mr Pahad explained that SADC finance ministers had met in Zambia,
where they
reviewed the report by the SADC Executive Secretary Tomaz Augusto
Salomao on
the economic situation in Zimbabwe and what SADC could do to help
the
Zimbabweans emerge from that crisis.
"All the finance ministers
have now returned to their capitals and after
consultations with their
capitals they will determine the next step.
"SA is quite happy with the
progress being made in the facilitation efforts
and we think even if there
are some difficulties, the process has been
placed on the right track,"
emphasised Pahad.
Regarding the progress with respect to the SADC
Regional Economic Agenda,
Pahad said the SADC had noted that there was
considerable basis for
declaring the SADC Free Trade Area by the time of the
2008 SADC Summit,
which would be hosted by SA in July.
News24
15/11/2007 11:30 -
(SA)
Chris Muronzi
Harare - The National Incomes and Pricing
Commission (NIPC) has ordered
retailers selling imported goods to clear
existing stocks by next week and
adopt a new pricing model based on the
official exchange rate.
NIPC chairperson Godwills Masimarembwa told the
state daily, The Herald,
that all businesses with imported stock must sell
it by Thursday next week
to allow for a new pricing model.
"We held a
meeting with business last week on Friday informing them to clear
stocks by
November 22 on the basis of existing prices. From November 23
restocking
should be on the basis of the official exchange rate," he
said.
Masimirembwa also warned that buying or sourcing foreign currency
on the
black market and factoring it into the price would not be tolerated,
saying:
"We want to stop this nonsense."
He attacked companies for
depending on foreign currency handouts from the
central bank saying firms
should generate their own forex.
The head of the price control commission
added that prices should not be
indexed using parallel market rates
regardless of the source of foreign
currency.
Zimbabwe is facing an
acute foreign currency shortage made worse by the
withdrawal of balance of
payments support by the IMF after the troubled
country refused to institute
sound economic reforms.
Masimarembwa said imported products with local
equivalents will be priced at
par, whilst imports without local equivalents
will attract a 50% mark-up
based on the official rate.
"In respect of
manufacturers who are exporters and acquit earnings with the
Reserve Bank we
will adopt opportunity cost in the model, using an
investment window as a
basis for costing. Instead of using 30% we shall use
an opportunity cost
window that translates to 270%," he said.
Although Masimarembwa said his
commission was keen to work with business in
pricing goods, the announcement
last month triggered many angry responses
from the troubled business
community.
"The businessman deserves a reasonable return on investment,
but consumers
should be able to afford the goods. Under the current pricing
formulas it is
like a dog chasing its tail and the burden is being passed
onto the
consumer," added Masimarembwa.
The paper added that
businesses are shedding crocodile tears while raking in
profit margins in
excess of 100% through rampant price hikes, some of them
unsanctioned by the
price monitoring commission. However, businesses say the
NIPC is not
reviewing prices with the urgency required.
President Robert Mugabe four
months ago ordered prices of goods to be
slashed by 50%, an order that
caused massive shortages of goods.
Zimbabwe has the highest inflation
rate in the world now close to 8 000%
UN Integrated Regional
Information Networks
15 November 2007
Posted to the web 15 November
2007
Harare
Zimbabwean non-governmental organisations (NGOs) claim
their operations have
been paralysed since the Reserve Bank raided their
foreign currency accounts
(FCAs).
In his mid-year Monetary Policy
Statement at the beginning of October,
Gideon Gono, governor of the Reserve
Bank of Zimbabwe (RBZ), said NGOs would
now maintain 'mirror accounts' that
would reflect how much money they had in
the bank while the actual money
would be kept by the RBZ.
Under the new arrangement NGOs have to seek
the reserve bank's permission to
use their money. NGOs who spoke to IRIN
said many of their programmes had
ground to a near standstill, as the
central bank was taking as long as 3
weeks to approve the release of foreign
currency.
In justifying the swoop on NGO funds, Gono said the move, which
affected all
corporate FCAs, had been taken to ensure "judicious allocation
of the scarce
foreign currency reserves", besides boosting
exports.
"What this means is that with immediate effect all corporate
foreign
currency account balances at authorised dealers are to be lodged at
the
Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe, such that each bank maintains mirror accounts
for
transactions tracking purposes," he said.
"It is important to
note that while individuals, embassies and international
organisations' FCAs
will remain with authorised dealers, balances for all
non-governmental
organisations are to be transferred and centralised at the
Reserve Bank."
FCAs belonging to UN agencies were also spared.
In return, Gono offered a
range of investment deals in the "spirit of
preserving and promoting the
welfare of our generators of foreign currency,
who are the geese that lay
the golden eggs."
Predictably, the NGO community is concerned about these
developments.
Control over programmes
Fambai Ngirande,
communications and information manager of the National
Association of Non
Governmental Organisations (NANGO), an umbrella body for
all NGOs operating
in Zimbabwe, told IRIN an emergency meeting was held by
members after the
announcement.
"At the meeting there was speculation that the reserve bank
would end up
deciding on behalf of NGOs whether programmes being undertaken
were relevant
or not," he said.
"Another concern was that the Reserve
Bank of Zimbabwe would end up taking
over foreign currency belonging to NGOs
from the FCAs at compulsory exchange
rates, in line with the spirit of the
Indigenisation and Economic
Empowerment Bill." The bill intends to ensure at
least a 51 percent
shareholding by indigenous black people in most
businesses.
Several NGOs that spoke to IRIN said although it was
initially implied that
the RBZ would take only 2 days to approve NGO funds,
delays of between 2
weeks and up to a month were being
reported.
"There are concerns regarding the inexplicable delays on money
transfers.
Some NGOs mentioned 2-week delays, while others said traveller's
cheques for
NGO officials travelling across the world for meetings were
being turned
down," said Ngirande.
An NGO working in the
food-security sector is still waiting for approval of
a request for funds
for research on the levels of nutrition among children
in rural
areas.
"It has been 3 weeks since we submitted our request for our money.
Our
problem is that we cannot speak out because we could be deregistered,
but
the truth of the matter is that the welfare of thousands of children is
being compromised by the takeover of FCAs by the Reserve Bank," said a
senior official of the NGO.
The NGOs said they were suspicious about
the move targeting them amid
regular attacks by the government, which
accuses NGOs and civil society of
supporting the main opposition party, the
Movement for Democratic Change,
and of using their resources to campaign on
behalf of the opposition.
Although the official exchange rate is Z$30,000
to US$1, on the illegal but
thriving parallel market US$1 is fetching Z$1.5
million.
Two years ago, President Robert Mugabe did not assent to the NGO
Bill,
which, among other things, sought to control funding destined for
NGOs. The
bill was brought before parliament amid strident accusations that
NGOs were
supporting the opposition.
Election ploy?
An
official of a human rights NGO told IRIN that the reserve bank policy
appeared to have been designed to frustrate their operations. "There was a
huge outcry when the government tried to deregister NGOs through the NGO
bill, but it is our belief that the current move is designed to ensure that
we do not operate to expected capacities," the official
commented.
"There appear to be punitive measures against the NGO
community by the
government through the central bank. Strangely, the policy
was announced a
few months before next year's elections."
An official
at a commercial bank, through which requests for foreign
currency are made
by NGOs, said the RBZ demanded to know three issues: "The
RBZ insists on
knowing the identity of the NGO, the amount required and who
the
beneficiaries are, before processing the requests."
[ This report does
not necessarily reflect the views of the United Nations ]
By Tsitsi Singizi BULAWAYO, Zimbabwe, 14 November 2007 ' Twice each day, Emily Ncube,
72, struggles to hoist a 25-litre bucket of water onto her head. It is a
gruelling chore for the frail women but a better option, she says, than making
another trip to the clinic with a sick grandchild. 'I look after four orphaned grandchildren,' said Ms. Ncube. 'Last week, the
smallest one, Nobuhle, had a serious stomach ache. I know it was caused by the
water from the nearby wells. That water is not clean.' The water and sanitation situation in Zimbabwe's second largest city is dire.
Residents of Bulawayo have access to just one-third of the globally accepted
20-litre minimum for daily water usage ' a situation that is complicated by
nearly four years of drought, economic difficulties and the AIDS pandemic
here. Long queues at the few functioning water points can be seen as early as dawn.
After school, children with huge containers line up to collect water for the
next day's supply. As desperate residents seek alternative sources of water, unsafe shallow
wells are being dug in many of the city's high-density suburbs. Meanwhile,
sanitation conditions have become threatening because, lacking water, residents
can no longer use the latrines in their homes. Unsurprisingly, incidents of diarrhoea are rising as a result of contaminated
water and poor hygiene. Improving hygienic practices 'Where there is a lack of safe water and sanitation together with poor
hygiene practices, conditions become hazardous for women and children,' said
UNICEF's Representative in Zimbabwe, Dr. Festo Kavishe. 'Illnesses and diarrhoea
outbreaks such as these significantly contribute to child mortality.' According to the Bulawayo health authorities, more than 2,500 cumulative
cases of diarrhoea have been reported since the end of August, an average of
around 40 per day. In response, vital information on hygiene and diarrhoea is being circulated
to improve hygienic practices in the community. Provision of safe, clean water With assistance from the Canadian International Development Agency, the UK
Department for International Development and the Swedish AID Agency, UNICEF
continues to work to improve the situation in Bulawayo. Working with a coalition of non-governmental organizations based in Bulawayo,
UNICEF has drilled 10 boreholes and is rehabilitating 75 others. Seven 10,000-litre water tanks have been provided to some of the city's
schools. Oral rehydration salts to treat diarrhoeal dehydration, water treatment
tablets and washing soap have also been distributed. 'We've worked around the clock, but there remains a need for investment in a
much more sustainable water and sanitation system,' said UNICEF's
Officer-in-Charge of Water, Sanitation and Hygiene, Maxwell Jonga.
' Tsitsi Singizi
Twice each day, Emily Ncube, 72, travels five km with a
25-litre bucket of water in order to ensure that her four grandchildren have
safe water.
Families desperate for water
Africa News, Netherlands
Posted on Thursday 15 November 2007 - 09:55
Fidelis Zvomuya, Pretoria,
South Africa
Justine Chikomo is an ex Presidential Guard in his home
country,
Zimbabwe. Like many of other soldiers, he has deserted the army to
settle in
neighbouring South Africa, where he hopes he can find a better paid
job and
take care of his family.
Apart from the economic meltdown,
a pre-emptive military coup is also
thought to be another reason behind this
desertion. Most of these deserters
are too young to be wedded to the
liberation struggle as their families are
suffering the same economic
deprivation as many other Zimbabweans.
Despite the doubling of their
salaries, the uniformed forces are very
unhappy and are seeking economic
refuge in neighbouring countries. It is
reported that more and more officers
are leaving the once committed and
brutal government security agency, the one
held responsible for the climate
of terror in the country.
He
says even though he might be getting enough money to put in his pocket,
have
food on his table everyday, his thoughts are always back home to his
family
wondering what they are having at the moment.
Media Institute of Southern Africa
(Windhoek)
PRESS RELEASE
15 November 2007
Posted to the web 15
November 2007
The government has controversially retained Dr.
Tafataona Mahoso as the
chairperson of the restructured state-controlled
Media and Information
Commission (MIC) which will look into the Associated
Newspapers of
Zimbabwe's (ANZ) application to be duly licensed despite court
findings on
his bias against the publishing company.
On 30 October
2007, Dr. Sikhanyiso Ndlovu, the minister of information and
publicity, said
the new MIC board had been constituted in line with court
rulings directing
ANZ, publishers of the banned "Daily News" and "Daily News
on Sunday", to
approach the ministry in respect of its application for
registration as a
publishing company in terms of the repressive Access to
Information and
Protection of Privacy Act (AIPPA).
Ironically, the minister directed
the new board to deal with the ANZ
application and pay "particular attention
to the law and parameters set by
all court rulings made on the
matter".
While the Media Institute of Southern Africa (MISA) Zimbabwe
welcomes Dr.
Ndlovu's directive for the board to look into the ANZ
application in line
with the "parameters set by all court rulings", the
minister should however,
clarify the terms of reference that will govern the
adjudication of the ANZ
application in view of the existing court findings
against Dr. Mahoso's bias
in the matter. It should also be made clear
whether a reconstituted MIC
which is still answerable to the minister and
the Executive can be trusted
with the independent and impartial adjudication
of the ANZ application in
view of the courts' findings against Dr.
Mahoso.
This is an issue that is central and key to the impartial
resolution of the
ANZ matter. The question that should then be addressed is
whether the
ministry is complying with judicial decisions by allowing a
reconstituted
MIC chaired by Dr. Mahoso to preside over the ANZ
case.
The role that Dr. Mahoso will play in the ANZ matter should be made
public
as it has a bearing on the government's respect and adherence to
decisions
made by the courts, especially where it concerns his bias against
the
publishing company.
The government should clearly and
unambiguously demonstrate its sincerity
and impartiality towards final
resolution of the ANZ legal battle to be
declared duly licensed as directed
by the courts. To allow Dr. Mahoso to be
involved in this matter, unless we
are advised otherwise, does not inspire
confidence that the process will be
impartial.
MISA-Zimbabwe also notes with concern that as executive
chairperson of the
MIC, Dr Mahoso wields tremendous power which might have a
bearing on the
outcome of the adjudication of the ANZ
application.
The minister should also make public the criteria he used in
appointing
Chinondidyachii Mararike, Charity Sally Moyo, Edward Dube, Tendai
Joseph
Chari and Ngugi Wa Mirii to the new MIC board and whether the
appointments
were made in compliance with the provisions of the repressive
and
restrictive AIPPA. Section 40 of AIPPA, which deals with the appointment
and
composition of the MIC, stipulates, among other things, that at least
three
members of the board should be nominated by an association of
journalists
and appointed by the minister after consultation with the
president and in
accordance with any directions that the president may give
him.
These issues should be done in the spirit of transparency and
accountability; otherwise the whole process will be a farcical charade.
By Tichaona
Sibanda
15 November 2007
South African President Thabo Mbeki on
Wednesday gave a hint there could be
political and electoral reforms in line
with the SADC election guidelines,
before next year’s general elections in
Zimbabwe.
He was responding to a question raised in parliament in South
Africa.
In a written reply to a question by Cheryllyn Dudley, MP and chief
whip of
the African Christian Democratic party, Mbeki disclosed that
negotiators
were crafting the conditions necessary for holding free and fair
elections,
by drawing guidance from the SADC guidelines
governing
elections.
‘These principles, among others, advocate for the
adherence to principles
such as full participation of the citizens in the
political process, freedom
of association, political tolerance, equal
opportunity for all political
parties to access the state media and equal
opportunity to exercise the
right to vote and be voted for,’ Mbeki
said.
Cheryllyn Dudley told Newsreel on Thursday that Mbeki’s pronouncement
on
next year’s polls was significant because it would force the Zanu-PF
government to adopt the SADC election guidelines, to which they’re a
signatory. But she argued the outcome of the negotiations should be the
barometer of whether or not Zimbabwe would have free and fair
polls.
‘Though I’m not yet convinced Mugabe will comply with the
guidelines, at
least it gives us the necessary ammunition should the
elections be disputed.
In a way what this also means is that the political
situation on the ground
today cannot be ignored where the ruling Zanu-PF has
an upper hand against
the opposition,’ Dudley said.
She said Zanu-PF
still has unfettered access to state resources and public
media for its
campaigns, while the majority of the opposition survived on
shoestring
budgets. Dudley also argued that there was a real need to level
the playing
field, which is currently tilted very far in favour of the
ruling
party.
Mbeki was appointed by SADC in March to mediate between Zanu-PF
and the MDC
in a bid to find a solution to the country’s political and
economic crisis.
Justice Minister Patrick Chinamasa and Social Welfare
Minister Nicholas
Goche are attending on behalf of the government, while top
officials
represent the MDC from its two factions, Tendai Biti and Welshman
Ncube.
South Africa’s Local Government Minister Sydney Mufumadi is chairing
the
discussions.
The MDC is demanding that elections due in March
next year be free and fair.
Their other demands include international
control of the elections that
millions of Zimbabweans abroad be allowed to
vote, a new voters’ roll and
the appointment of an independent Zimbabwe
Election Commission to supervise
the polls.
SW
Radio Africa Zimbabwe news
November 2007 (PlusNews) JOHANNESBURG, A year and a half
ago, *Wilson Moyo,
45, was a white-collar worker enjoying a comfortable life
in Bulawayo,
Zimbabwe's second city. After fleeing the country for political
reasons he
is now homeless, jobless and living in a shelter in
Johannesburg's inner
city.
He is also HIV-positive, but with no
documentation and no income, he has
been unable to access antiretroviral
(ARV) treatment or even consult a
doctor. He is now facing a long wait to
obtain the asylum-seeker papers that
would grant him the same rights to
treatment as a South African.
"I was staying in Bulawayo; I had my own
house there and I was married with
two kids, a boy and a girl. I'd been
working as a credit controller for
almost 17 years. Then I got involved in
political activities and from that
time my life was threatened. Some time
last year, around May, when things
got really bad, I decided to leave my
country and come to South Africa.
"At that time I wasn't all that sick,
but I thought at least it's better, in
a foreign land, to know you're
healthy, and I like to read a lot, so I was
coming across these issues
dealing with HIV and AIDS. I thought, let me just
go and check so I'm in a
position to protect myself. I passed through Park
Station [Johannesburg's
central train station] one day and they'd put tents
there for testing so I
went in.
"It was a big shock [to learn my status], especially with all
the problems I
had by then. The place I was sleeping, we were staying three
to a bed and I
was used to having my own bed and my own things, so already I
was stressed.
I didn't tell anyone, even my family back home. The first
people I told was
when I went to a support group because there I met people
who had the same
problems like me.
"I was referred to Hillbrow Clinic
[in an inner-city suburb]. I went to the
reception and the clerk there said,
'Can I have your ID [identity
document]?' and when I said I didn't have any
ID, they said, go and bring
it. I couldn't explain further because I knew I
wouldn't get anywhere.
"After that I was disappointed, because I'd
thought about it and found that
this was not the end of the road, there was
still life after HIV. The best
thing was to fight on and get treatment and
continue living a normal life,
but the problem was how to get the proper
documentation to get treatment.
"At that time I didn't even know there
was asylum - I found out from the
support group. They told me about how the
permit allows you the same rights
as a citizen, including the right to
treatment. I tried to go to [the
Department of Home Affairs in] Pretoria on
several occasions, but it was so
difficult because the queues were so
huge.
"I once slept there for three days, having nothing to eat and
without having
washed. The last day, when I was number eight in the queue, I
was pulled out
by these guys who were getting bribes from people. They said
I should give
them R100 (US$15) to be in that queue, which I didn't
have.
"I started not to feel well, so I tried Johannesburg Hospital but
they told
me I needed to be referred from Hillbrow Clinic. You have this
fear that if
you tell them the truth they will call the police.
"My
hope is that if the situation at home can change, at least I'm a
qualified
somebody there. If I was there doing a good job, I could pay for
ARVs. Here,
even if I'm documented, I'll end up doing menial work because
most people
here, they detest foreigners; it's very unlikely I'll get a job
that demands
my skills and experience."
*Not his real
name
ks/he
[ENDS]
[The above testimony is provided by
IRIN, a humanitarian news service,
but may not necessarily reflect the views
of the United Nations.]
New Zimbabwe
By Lebo
Nkatazo
Last updated: 11/16/2007 02:16:55
AN AIR Zimbabwe plane was
seconds from a runway crash at the country’s main
airport on Wednesday night
due to a power cut, it was confirmed Thursday.
Zanu PF’s national
chairman and the speaker of the House of Assembly John
Nkomo was among the
passengers who were travelling from Bulawayo to Harare.
At the time
the incident occurred some parts of Harare, including the Harare
International Airport, were experiencing heavy rains.
The plane, a
Chinese-built MA60 which has a capacity of 60 passengers, was
saved from
crashing on a blacked-out runway when the pilot was notified of a
power cut
shortly before landing.
Air Zimbabwe’s corporate communications manager
Pride Khumbula said: “Upon
approach to land at Harare International Airport,
Air Zimbabwe flight UM232
from Bulawayo to Harare on Wednesday 14 November
2007 was advised by Civil
Aviation Authority of Zimbabwe (CAAZ) Air Traffic
Control that there was a
power outage at Harare International Airport. The
flight was asked to hold
back from landing for 10 minutes, and landed on
back-up.”
She added that questions regarding supply of power to the
airport must be
referred to CAAZ.
A New Zimbabwe.com reader who was
on the plane wrote on our discussion
forums: “On the MA60, from Byo, on the
descent into Harare Airport, suddenly
(from what we were told later) the
pilot it seems realises there is
insufficient light on the
runway.
”We circle for a few moments, but the pilot has to put the bird
down because
of strong winds.
”Not a smooth landing at all, bumping
up and down and nearly sliding off to
the side of the south runway. Except
for one minor injury, everybody safe.
Not once have I've ever felt so
helpless. I am to travel to Byo again next
Monday for some seminar, but just
the thought gives me the jeepers!”
Our reader added: “But I can say one
thing: We do have some damn good pilots
around.”
Zimbabwe is
experiencing daily black-outs. The country's regular cuts in
power and water
supplies are blamed on acute shortages in hard currency,
gasoline and
imported spare parts.
The country imports around 40% of its power from
South Africa, DR Congo and
Mozambique.
African Path
November 15, 2007
10:36 AM
Izzy Mutanhaurwa
MDC has been in the news
lately; most of the reports have been negative. The
arm-chair pundits have
come out in full force, some going as far as saying
that MDC lacks the
capacity to govern all based having read a few negative
newspaper reports.
Some have gone on to say that the President is not
capable of leading, we
should find a new candidate for 2008. For the real
comrades, the genuine
party cadres the issue has been the same, remember how
negatively MDC was
portrayed after Chikwata left in 2005 they professed the
death of MDC, when
some of the misguided elements within the dissolved UK
executive leaked
confidential internal emails to The Herald we survived
another onslaught of
negative media focus.
Then last month everyone had an opinion
on the 18th Amendment, the
negotiations, after Lucia Matibenga was relieved
of her post as Chairwoman
for the Women's Assembly, the Anti-Tsvangirai
coalition came out some saying
the party has split, it did not help that
here in UK we have negativity
attracted by the antics of our little Mugabe
the man who says he wont go
Ephraim Tapa, defying the vote of the province
to step down, arranging
illegal meetings plotting mini-insurrections all
being reported by the
media.
MDC has never been the darling of the
media, the only sympathetic voice was
the yester years Daily News, with
exceptions from Trevor Ncube's owned
titles. We are threat to Zanu PF we
have always been since the formation of
the party so Zanu Pf through its
state machinery of the CIO they plant
negative stories meant to portray MDC
as weak, being led by a weak leader
they say. Some have gone as far as to
say MDC will not win the forthcoming
elections. But true proponents for
change will know that the real MDC led by
Morgan Tsvangirai is the only
viable solution for Zimbabwe. We are almost
there as it dawns on Zanu PF
that its era is tethering to an end they will
always churn out rubbish
reports printed in their government mouth-piece The
Herald, the Gono
bank-rolled New Zimbabwe and all the other outlets that do
not see it as
smear campaign meant to weaken MDC's position as we gear
towards 2008
elections.
People have been asking me what is my opinion on the rumours
that Simba
Makoni wants to start a new party. I think people should be
alerted that
this could be a ploy by Zanu PF together with the CIO to divide
the votes
ahead of the forthcoming 2008 elections. With the outcome of the
negotiations determining whether MDC will participate into the forthcoming
harmonised elections then Simba Makoni's reported party must be another Zanu
PF extension meant to hoodwink the electorate and in the event that MDC does
not participate then Simba Makoni's party will offer legitimacy to the
result that Thabo Mbeki wants so much to be legitimised irregardless of the
outcome.
Surely if its not that, why today in 2007 when half
of the population of
Zimbabwe have fled the country? What sudden revelation
has inspired Simba
Makoni to form his own party? There are others that are
saying this what
Zimbabwe needed, really is what we needed? Some have gone
on to say this is
the only man that can beat Mugabe, is he really? Because I
will tell you
that President Tsvangirai is the only person that has beaten
Mugabe in the
stolen 2002 Presidential election. The same saviour tag was
attached to
Professor of Robotics Arthur Mutambara when arrived on the scene
to lead the
dissidents together with Weshman Ncube, Trudy and others that
are inspiring
Tapa and Co in UK. There is only ONE MDC, that lead by Morgan
Tsvangirai
anything else is cannon fodder.
New Zimbabwe
By Lebo
Nkatazo
Last updated: 11/16/2007 03:48:37
THE Zimbabwe government is
unable to award striking magistrates any salary
hikes this year, a top
government official said Thursday.
Chisi Chaitezvi, the acting secretary
in the Ministry of Justice told the
parliamentary portfolio committee on
justice that treasury had told him that
there was no money to meet the
magistrates’ wage demands.
Salary increments could only be effected in
January next year, he said.
The revelations will escalate the
stand-off between the government and
magistrates who have been on strike for
the past two weeks, demanding
increased pay.
Zimbabwe is going
through its worst economic crisis in history, with
inflation of over 8000%.
Salaries are immediately wiped off by the runaway
inflation.
Chaitezvi said even though there was no money, “the
employer” had admitted
that salaries that were being given are
low.
“Today I discussed with the Public Service Commission (PSC). The
employer
said they are going to rectify the problem, but are not able to do
so this
year because the budget is constrained,” Chaitezvi said.
Chef
magistrate Herbert Mandeya said the strike started at Rotten Row Court
in
Harare before spreading.
He described the situation as bad and added that
“people were rotting and
rotting in police cells” as there was no one to
attend to cases.
Heads of station at magistrate’s courts around the
country have been told to
report for work and in some cases, police
prosecutors have been asked to
help by processing remands for all cases, the
committee also heard.
A trigger to the strike action, according to some
court officials, was a
government decision to award salary increases to
regional magistrates and
chief law officers in the Attorney General's
Office.
The two groups are understood to have been awarded salary
increments of
between $90 and $140 million, effective last month. Officers
in the
provincial courts were left out of the deal.
Magistrates earn
about $20 million, (about £6.50) on the thriving parallel
market.
Zimbabwe’s judiciary system is currently faced with a high
turnover of
senior and experienced staff who are leaving in droves in search
of greener
pastures in neighbouring countries like Botswana, South Africa
and Namibia.
The Bulawayo Magistrates' Courts are operating with 11
magistrates instead
of a prescribed establishment of 20. Graduates from the
University of
Zimbabwe's law department hardly spend a year with the public
service as
they quickly resign to join private practice where the
remuneration is
better.
Zimbabwe’s public sector workers bear the
brunt of the country's economic
collapse. Teachers and health workers
routinely go on strike.
Financial Gazette
(Harare)
15 November 2007
Posted to the web 15 November
2007
Stanley Kwenda
Harare
Police in Mutare on Monday stopped
the staging of the politically-charged
play, Final Push, produced by
Silvanos Mudzvova of Vhitori Entertainment.
The play was supposed to have
been performed at Courtauld Theatre in Mutare
but had to be stopped at the
last minute after suspected state security
agents threatened the theatre
house with closure if it hosted the play.
Mudzvova and a fellow
actor, Antony Tongani and cameraman James Jemwa were
last month arrested
while performing the play in Harare. They were
subsequently forced to
perform the 45 minute long play 12 times while in
police
custody.
Mudzvova said," The show was supposed to have been staged at 7
pm in Mutare
but, on the day, I received a phone call from Nicholas Moyo of
the National
Arts Council (NAC) warning us not to go ahead with the play,
ostensibly
because our organisation was not
registered."
Surprisingly, the play had premiered in Harare and was
performed for a few
days before the arrest of the trio. The Media Institute
of Southern Africa
(MISA) then took it to Quill Club. Despite the harassment
and intimidation,
Mudzvova has vowed to continue a scheduled national tour
to stage the play.
"A NAC official, Ruswa in Mutare, alerted the Law and
Order section but
despite such threats we will not be intimidated and won't
bow to this kind
of harassment," said Mudzvova.
"The state security
agents might not like the play but we will take it take
it to the people.
They could try anything but what we know is that they
don't have laws to
stop us. This is our work and we know no other."
Theatrical plays have
become a platform for actors to "freely" express
political views as other
avenues of free speech have been closed by
draconian laws.
15 November 2007,
Residents in Belvedere have threatened to demonstrate against
the Zimbabwe
National Water Authority (ZINWA). The threats come following
water cuts that
are making life unbearable. Residents in Belvedere have gone
for the last
one week without tape water. A month ago residents in the same
area went for
two weeks without water. The water cuts caused cholera
outbreaks and
disturbed the normal flow of life. Women with infants had
trouble washing
napkins and bathing school going children. There was no
drinking and bathing
water.
CHRA Ward five members wrote a petition
to ZINWA which has not had a
response. It is against this background that
residents in the area have
agreed to mobilize each other and demonstrate
against ZINWA. Belvedere
residents also complain about unattended to sewer
bursts which pose health
hazards. Despite the poor services offered by ZINWA
residents continue to
receive ballooned bills of between 5 and 25 million
dollars. The Minister of
water resources and infrastructure development
Engineer Munacho Mutezo has
condemned the bills as highly unrealistic. He
ordered the ZINWA board to
investigate allegations that bills are being
illegally inflated by ZINWA
staff. It remains to be seen whether any
perpetrators will be brought to
book.
Water cuts are not peculiar to
Belvedere as most suburbs in Harare are
plagued by nauseating water cuts.
CHRA receives reports of water cuts daily
and encourages residents to
challenge the incompetence of ZINWA. CHRA
continues to advocate for the
reversal of the administration of sewer and
water services to local
authorities. These local authorities must be run by
democratically elected
leaders who are not driven by the whims and caprices
of party political
patronage. Local authorities and the Minister of Local
government Dr Chombo
must employ Town Clerks and other critical staff on the
basis of merit and
qualification and not on the basis of political party
affiliation.
Farai Barnabas Mangodza
Chief Executive
Officer
Combined Harare Residents Association (CHRA)
145 Robert Mugabe
Way
Exploration House, Third Floor
Harare
ceo@chra.co.zw
www.chra.co.zw
Landline: 00263- 4-
705114
Contacts: Mobile: 0912638401, 011443578, 011862012 or email info@chra.co.zw,
programs@chra.co.zw and admin@chra.co.zw
IOL
November 15 2007 at 03:24PM
By Lavern de Vries
In the
wake of the death outside Home Affairs offices of Zimbabwe
seeking refugee
status, many people queueing for legal documents at Home
Affairs offices in
the province could be arrested and deported.
A joint R800 000
operation has been launched in the province by police
and the Department of
Home Affairs which will target:
.. "Hotspots" of illegal
immigrants.
.. People who have already been denied refugee
status.
.. Marriages of convenience.
..
Foreign nationals engaged in criminal activities.
The
drive, named Operation Umbrella, was due to have kicked off at the
beginning
of this month, but has been delayed.
About 12 specially trained
police officers, all highly skilled, were
being diverted from their normal
duties to head the unit, sources said.
Home Affairs
spokesperson Jackie Mashapu said: "The strategy is to
deal with illegal
immigrants, not refugees.
"Refugees are legal. They get the papers
to confirm their status. We
want to deal with illegal
immigrants.
"When a person is arrested, that person will be
questioned to
determine his intentions (for being in SA). Each case will be
dealt with on
its merits."
But Mashapu was unable to explain
how refugees who had yet to obtain
papers would be dealt with.
"A person is a refugee when he or she had been awarded refugee status
by
obtaining the correct papers and a refugee is therefore legally in the
country."
According to a source who declined to be named, R600
000 would be
spent on deportation costs, while R200 000 was to be spent on
administration, such as overtime pay and travel expenses for visits to
outlying areas such as George and Paarl.
Community Safety MEC
Leonard Ramatlakane would not comment on the
cost, saying only that the
project was "well-resourced for delivery".
"It is a project which
requires two departments to work together for
the challenges we face ... it
is difficult to manage the challenge of crime
with those who have no status
or those with some status, especially in the
period we are heading into,
which is one where crime peaks," Ramatlakane
said.
Operation
Umbrella was already functional, he said.
But sources close to the
project claimed several problems had caused a
delay.
These
included an inability to find drivers for two trucks meant to
transport
illegal immigrants and the recent flooding of the Home Affairs
offices in
Barrack Street in the city centre.
Refugee advocacy group People
Against Suffering, Suppression,
Oppression and Poverty (Passop) has slammed
the plan, saying that if the
government intends deporting illegal
immigrants, the group would mobilise
the masses in protest
action.
Passop's head, Braam Hanekom, said the information had come
as a great
shock.
He said he would meet Home Affairs portfolio
committee chairperson
Patrick Chauke to obtain his opinion on the planned
operation.
The Consortium for Refugees and Migration in SA (Cormsa)
also
criticised the initiative, labelling it unfair.
"There is
no efficient and effective service in place that allows for
refugees to
apply for status," said spokesperson Duncan Breen.
He said the
organisation called for the suspension of the campaign
"until the department
allows for free and fair access for all applicants".
The consortium
has requested that if the initiative goes ahead as
planned, police will
handle the arrests appropriately, as "people are being
arrested for
immigration irregularities and not crimes".
This article
was originally published on page 1 of Cape Argus on
November 15,
2007
The First Post
Moses Moyo in
Harare
His plans to kill or discredit his critics destroyed by leaks,
Zimbabwe's
dictator is losing his grip
The First Post's exclusive
reports of Robert Mugabe's plots - first to
assassinate his critics,
including ex-Archbishop Pius Ncube, then to destroy
Ncube with charges of
sexual misconduct - have enraged Zimbabwe's President.
But publication has
caused him temporarily to call off the conspiracies.
Scenes reminiscent
of the last days of Hitler were witnessed at a late-night
meeting at State
House, called by Mugabe on Monday. The President raved and
screamed at his
top security men, threatening to sack some of them,
including Central
Intelligence Organisation boss Happyton Bonyongwe, unless
they put a stop to
the damaging leaks.
Bonyongwe confessed to the president that the latest
plots against Ncube
which were attempting to link the former Catholic
Archbishop of Bulawayo
with false charges of sodomy, adultery and
deliberately spreading Aids, had
all fallen apart, thanks to The First
Post's reports. Several of those lined
up to make accusations against Ncube
had already disappeared.
Mugabe, frothing with rage, screamed at the
hapless chief: "Get out of the
kitchen if you cannot handle it, Bonyongwe.
Since when have you failed to
handle your boys? Or maybe you are one of
those that think I should leave my
job."
Then he ordered a visibly
shaken Bonyongwe to call off the anti-Ncube
campaign for the moment, and
instead launch a manhunt to track down the
informants who gave information
to The First Post - and "deal with them
first."
The government has
been unable to pass off the reports about the Ncube
honeytrap and the
attempts on his life and reputation as fiction, because
The First Post
showed documents about the plans, passed to me at great risk
by my
sources.
Mugabe has now ordered that in future there must be no paperwork
about such
plots, and all briefings must be made strictly by telephone or in
person,
face to face.
The Monday night meeting was at the highest
level of government. It
included, apart from Bonyongwe, the defence forces
commander General
Constantine Chiwengwa, the army chief Phillip Sibanda, air
force chief
Perence Shiri, police commissioner Augustine Chirhuri, and the
home and
defence ministers, Kembo Mohadi and Sydney
Sekeramayi.
Significantly absent was Security Minister
Didymus
Mugabe planned to link Pius Ncube with false charges of
sodomy, adultery and
deliberately spreading Aids
Mutasa, who is out
of favour because of his involvement with the 'magic
diesel'
affair.
When I spoke to Pius Ncube yesterday I warned him that the hiatus
in the
attacks on his reputation was only temporary. He told me: "I am not
worried.
I have said before that I only fear God, and Mugabe is not God. I
will
continue to fight for a better life in Zimbabwe."
FIRST POSTED
NOVEMBER 15, 2007
http://www.thefirstpost.co.uk?storyID=9517
November
15, 2007
UN Integrated Regional
Information Networks
15 November 2007
Posted to the web 15 November
2007
Johannesburg
Namibia's land reform programme is a "zero sum
game" that merely swaps one
form of poverty for another in its current
resettlement programme, according
to an independent report on attempts to
find a equitable solution to
racially skewed land ownership.
The
Legal Assistance Centre (LAC), a non-governmental human rights
organisation
based in the capital, Windhoek, said in a report reviewing the
achievements
so far of Namibia's land reform programme, No Resettlement
Available, that
"most [resettlement farms] are not doing very well; in fact,
it is not
apparent that any are."
The size of the farms allocated and the
agricultural methods practiced were
among the problems identified. "Black
farmers get smaller units than white
farmers held, but remain stuck with the
same plan to be livestock farmers,"
said the report.
"Since even the
larger white farms were not very profitable, this
apportionment is both
setting black farmers up to fail, and failing to
reconceptualise a new
Namibian agricultural order that could both feed the
growing population and
provide reasonable incomes to the new black
commercial
farmers."
Namibia, which won its independence from apartheid South Africa
in 1990,
inherited a colonial division of land in which about half the
agricultural
land is owned by 3,500 white farmers. Farms average about 5,000
hectares in
the north of the country and 10,000 hectares in the south, while
nearly 1
million black Namibians live on "heavily overgrazed" communal
lands.
The large commercial farm of the apartheid era, an old an
inefficient
structure of agriculture, is being reproduced in a diluted
form
The report by Willem Odendaal, of the LAC's Land Environment and
Development
Project, and Sidney Harring, Professor of Law at the City
University in New
York, said the government's agrarian policy had failed to
adapt to the
demands of a modern Namibia or benefit African
farmers.
"Dividing large farms into units of one-fifth to one-seventh the
size [of
the original farm] - being the typical resettlement farm size - not
only
applies the failed colonial model [of cattle farming], but further
weakens
it, in that farms of such small sizes cannot succeed. The large
commercial
farm of the apartheid era, an old and inefficient structure of
agriculture,
is being reproduced in a diluted form."
Namibia is an
arid country of about 825,400sq km, of which only about 100sq
km are
suitable for dry [non-irrigated] crop cultivation; it suffers drought
in six
out of every 10 years and its growing population of about 2 million
people
has seen "several hundred thousand blacks ... crowded off ...
communal lands
and move to sprawling squatter camps surrounding every town
in Namibia," the
LRC report said.
Slow pace of land reform
The Namibian government,
like those of neighbouring South Africa and
Zimbabwe, has made land reform a
central policy tenet, and "government's
resettlement scheme has placed 800
farms in black hands in the 17 years
since independence", the report
noted.
"This is about 12 percent of all farms, or less or than one
percent a year,
so the process will take over 100 years to complete,
depending on what
proportion of white commercial farms the government plans
to place in blacks
hands before deeming the process complete."
Sakkie
Coetzee, executive manager of the Namibian Agricultural Union, which
draws
it membership from mainly white commercial farmers, told IRIN that
according
to their records, "more than 1,000 farms" or about 16 percent of
commercial
farmland, had been transferred to previously disadvantaged
people.
He
said the agricultural capacity of the country was "overstated" and the
"perception of large [farms] is not necessarily the right perception", owing
to the country's predominantly dry climate and paucity of surface water,
which required economies of scale to produce sustainable farming. The policy
of subdividing farms was "devastating" and under such a regime the new
"farmers would never make it".
Coetzee, whose farmers' union
officially supports land redistribution,
attributed the policy of creating
smaller farming plots to the influence of
such institutions as the World
Bank's one-size-fits-all approach, which
meant that while a small plot in
Ghana might be sustainable, this was not
the case in Namibia.
He said
the union was attempting to "convince the government to rethink and
redesign
their policies, as the global practice was seeing farms getting
bigger and
bigger because of the higher production costs".
New agrarian model
required
The report recommends an overhaul of the agricultural sector,
from the
"apartheid era" agricultural colleges emphasising cattle farming,
to new
farming methods such as "crop cultivation and tropical
agriculture".
Tropical agriculture is usually labour-intensive
subsistence farming and
cash-crop production, using techniques like moveable
cages that confine
animals to feeding on weeds, the use of crop residues as
litter in the
cages, disposal of human waste in deep pits that are later
planted with
trees, and the use of ashes as fertiliser and in soap
production.
The LAC cited numerous failures in the division and
resettlement of
commercial farms, from not granting land title and "leaving
poor people in
some kind of tenant relationship with the government [which]
is not
empowering them," to a lack of transparency, the absence of any
support for
resettled farmers and the overblown bureaucracy of "the Ministry
of Lands
and Resettlement - and the government generally".
"Given the
small number of people involved, what the ministry and staff
actually do is
not apparent. For example, resettling 9,000 people in 12
years amounts to
fewer than 800 a year, hardly more than 125-130 families.
Yet it takes a
staff of perhaps 1,000 government employees to do this work,"
the authors
pointed out.
"Almost all of the 209 or so resettlement farms have staff
of the ministry
on their premises or in a nearby town, yet it is not obvious
that these
people are well trained and performing their
duties."
Resettlement Farms
The "poor record keeping" also meant
that the exact number of people
resettled on these farms was uncertain, and
"many have already left the
rural poverty of the resettlement farms, and
more leave every day," the LAC
said.
While white commercial farmers
were heavily subsidised with both capital and
large numbers of livestock by
past German and South African colonial
governments, "resettled farmers have
neither, and are left to an
impoverished lifestyle which is often as bad or
worse than the one they had
prior to joining the resettlement
programme".
The report identified an unpalatable conundrum: "Any
'average' resettlement
process will move five 'disadvantaged' families to a
farm at the same time
that it removes six farmworkers and their families to
homelessness and
poverty ... each resettlement process displaces as many as
it resettles."
Commercial farms are one of the country's major employers,
while farmworkers
and their dependents comprise an estimated 222,000 people,
but many
farmworkers do not want to be resettled because of negative
experiences
suffered by others.
Even as poorly paid farm workers,
they have their basic needs met: they
receive a regular salary, are allowed
to have chickens, small stock and
perhaps even cattle, and live in
reasonably good housing. All of this
disappears on a Namibian resettlement
farm
"Even as poorly paid farm workers, they have their basic needs met:
they
receive a regular salary, are allowed to have chickens, small stock and
perhaps even cattle, and live in reasonably good housing. All of this
disappears on a Namibian resettlement farm."
The authors suggest the
adoption of a land-reform model used in South Africa
as alternative:
farmworkers are trained to perform management roles and
provided with higher
skills levels, with the intention that land title could
gradually be handed
over to farmworkers or other poor people with the
requisite skills to
operate the farm.
Both South Africa and Namibia have trod delicately
around the issue of
expropriation, given the experiences of neighbouring
Zimbabwe, and both
countries place great emphasis on the rule of
law.
The LAC report recommends an "increased pace of expropriation", but
that
pace "depends on public confidence that land reform is being
successfully
implemented at grassroots level, i.e., that small black-owned
farms are
being created successfully."
The Ministry of Lands and
Resettlement was not available for comment.
[ This report does not
necessarily reflect the views of the United Nations ]