The ZIMBABWE Situation | Our
thoughts and prayers are with Zimbabwe - may peace, truth and justice prevail. |
Copyright © 2003, Dow Jones Newswires
HARARE, Zimbabwe (AP)--In
the latest crackdown on free press, a
Zimbabwe government media commission
has appealed last month's court order
lifting the ban on the country's only
independent daily newspaper.
The state-controlled Sunday Mail
reported Sunday that appeal papers
were filed last week at the Supreme Court
under Chief Justice Godfrey
Chidyausiku.
In August, the
commission refused the Daily News and its sister Sunday
newspaper a license
to publish. But the Administrative Court, which handles
disputes over
government decisions, ruled that the commission had exhibited
bias against
the papers and was itself "improperly constituted."
Filing the
appeal effectively puts a freeze on the court's ruling.
Gugulethu
Moyo, lawyer for Daily News owners, Associated Newspapers
Zimbabwe, said the
appeal made his client's position even more complicated.
Hours after the Oct.
24 verdict, the Daily News brought out its first
edition for six weeks but
was promptly shut down by police.
"Whatever the legalities, the
fact is the only independent daily
newspaper has been shut down by the state
and that has huge implications for
the human rights situation in this
country," Moyo said.
"It is quite clear the state is determined to
keep the Daily News off
the streets. We are going to have to keep fighting it
at enormous expense
and it is a huge tragedy," he said.
The
Administrative Court ordered the seven-member media commission
to
reconstitute itself, including independent representatives, by Oct.
30.
State lawyers claimed this meant the Daily News remained banned to Oct.
30,
and had five Associated Newspapers directors detained for publishing
the
Oct. 25 edition.
Meanwhile police spokesman Trust Ndlovu
said he could give no
information on a Zimbabwean journalist based in South
Africa who was
arrested while covering a nurses' strike in Zimbabwe last
week.
Andrew Zhakata was detained under the 2002 Access to
Information and
Protection of Privacy Act, in the southern border town of
Beitbridge and was
due to have appeared in court.
On Monday,
lawyers for the opposition Movement for Democratic Change
begin their long
delayed court challenge of the March 2002 presidential
elections, in which
longtime President Robert Mugabe claimed a further
six-year mandate despite
widespread allegations of intimidation and vote
rigging.
However, there are fears the state will seek further delay tactics
to
increase legal costs for the opposition, which is banned by law
from
receiving foreign funding.ding.
(END) Dow Jones
Newswires
November 02, 2003 10:58 ET (15:58 GMT)
IOL
Tough new visa requirements for
Zimbabweans
November 02 2003 at
11:21AM
By Liz Clarke
Zimbabweans wanting to visit South Africans have to meet tough new
visa
requirements.
It is believed that the measures are to stem the tide
of illegal
immigrants entering the country in the wake of growing economic
turmoil and
human rights abuses in Zimbabwe.
Now, according to
an advisory issued by the South African high
commission in Zimbabwe, holiday
visas can be obtained only if funds
equivalent to a minimum of R1 000 are
endorsed on the passport with the name
of the bank where the currency was
issued. However, a shortage of South
African rands in Zimbabwean banks means
that most people who legitimately
apply for currency will not be able get it
and neither can currency obtained
on the black market be validated by the
mainstream banks as required.
Those seeking medical appointments in
South Africa must provide a
letter from Zimbabwean doctors stating the nature
of their illness. The new
visa regulations also require the patient to state
why they cannot be
treated locally, as well as confirmation of the doctor's
appointment in
South Africa.
Businessmen require a
business letter of invitation from South
Africa
Businessmen require
a business letter of invitation from South Africa
and an accompanying
business letter from a Zimbabwean company.
Zimbabweans applying for
transit visas for connecting flights in South
Africa must prove that they
will be admitted to their destinations and must
be in possession of return
tickets.
Meanwhile, a fire that broke out in the visa-processing
room of the
South African embassy in Harare left hundreds of people unable to
leave the
country during the past two weeks.
A spokesperson for
the department of foreign affairs in Pretoria said
they were awaiting a
forensic report detailing the source of the fire, which
closed the visa
office for more than a week.
A spokesperson for foreign affairs
said reports from Zimbabwean
authorities had stated that "a large stack of
papers" had been placed too
close to the airconditioning plant, which was
left on "by mistake" overnight
and caused overheating, resulting in the
fire.
"We understand that, although fire tenders tried to douse the
flames,
they were unable to enter the high-security building swiftly enough
to save
the documentation," the foreign affairs spokesperson
explained.
He said that the situation was now "back to
normal".
Reuters
Court to hear Mugabe victory challenge
Sun 2 November, 2003
10:27
By Stella Mapenzauswa
HARARE (Reuters) - Zimbabwean
President Robert Mugabe is unlikely to attend
a court hearing this week on an
opposition appeal against his re-election
last year, his lawyer
says.
From Monday, the High Court will hear a challenge by Morgan
Tsvangirai,
leader of the Movement for Democratic Change, against the outcome
of the
March 2002 election in which Mugabe won a new six-year term. The
opposition
and several Western groups say the poll was rigged.
"The
law doesn't require President Mugabe to be at the court...and at the
moment
there is no need for that to happen," Mugabe's lawyer Terrence
Hussein told
Reuters on Saturday.
During the first five days of the hearing, the MDC
plans to present 200
pages of arguments that many of the laws, regulations,
officials and
institutions governing the election were not in line with the
constitution,
and so were invalid.
The opposition will also argue that
Mugabe's party waged a campaign of
violence and intimidation against
opposition supporters, bribed voters and
hogged access to state
media.
African observers said the polls had been free and fair, but
Western
organisations including the European Union and Commonwealth condemned
them
as deeply flawed. The latter suspended Zimbabwe for a year.
The
MDC challenge prompted Mugabe's ZANU-PF party to abandon talks with
the
opposition aimed at pulling the country out of its worst political
and
economic crisis since he assumed power at independence from Britain in
1980.
The MDC says the agenda for future talks should include: new
electoral laws;
a repeal of tough security and media laws widely seen as
intended to stifle
criticism of Mugabe; and the disbandment of pro-government
militias whom it
accuses of spearheading violence against opposition
supporters.
Mugabe, who insists he won the election fairly, dismisses the
MDC as a
puppet of the West and says his party will not talk to it unless
it
recognises him as legitimate president.
He says the economy has
been sabotaged by local and international interests
opposed to his seizure of
white-owned farms for redistribution to landless
blacks.
Zimbabwe is
suffering acute shortages of food, foreign currency and fuel,
unemployment of
around 70 percent and one of the world's highest rates of
inflation at nearly
460 percent.
ABC Australia
November 3, 2003. 1:00am (AEDT)
Zimbabwe media body
challenges order to licence newspaper
Zimbabwe's state-appointed media
commission has challenged a court ruling
ordering it to grant the popular
Daily News a licence, the state-run Sunday
Mail reported.
Newspaper
The Daily News, a harsh critic of President Robert Mugabe, was
shut down for
a second time a week ago and several of its staff and
directors were arrested
after it briefly reappeared on the newsstands.
The paper made a comeback
a day after a court ruled that the Media and
Information Commission (MIC) was
wrong not to grant it an operating licence,
and ordered it to do so by
November 30.
But the MIC on Friday filed an appeal with the Supreme
Court, effectively
suspending the lower court's order, the Sunday Mail
said.
The MIC, Tafataona Mahoso, had earlier indicated that the body
would appeal
the order. The Daily News, founded four years ago, has quickly
become the
country's most popular daily and offered an alternative voice to
the two
state-controlled dailies - The Chronicle and The Herald.
It
was first shut down by armed police in September after the Supreme
Court
ruled it was operating illegally because it did not have a
licence.
The paper then applied for a licence, but was turned down by the
MIC. The
Daily News has a history of clashes with the government, which
accuses it of
being a front for Western interests.
Since its founding,
several of its reporters and photographers have been
arrested, including
prominent former editor and founder Geoff Nyarota.
It has also suffered
two unexplained explosions - one at the paper's offices
and one at its
printing presses. The Daily News and The Daily News on Sunday
employ around
300 full-time staff and around 1,000 vendors sell the paper.
-- AFP
Baltimore Sun
Turn up the volume on 'quiet diplomacy' in
Zimbabwe
Crisis: The world must add more pressure as an African regime
plunges its
citizens into further
chaos.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
----
By
Russell Geekie
Special To Sun
Originally published November 2,
2003
Up until President Bush's Africa trip in July,
the administration was
surprisingly focused on Zimbabwe, where the
government's unruly seizures of
white-owned commercial farms and
three-year-old assault on dissents are at
the heart of a political, economic
and humanitarian crisis. State-sponsored
violence has killed scores of
Zimbabweans, thousands have been tortured, and
millions face
starvation.
Secretary of State Colin L. Powell bluntly wrote that
Zimbabwe's President
Robert G. Mugabe's "time had come and gone," challenging
African leaders to
robustly pressure the ruling party into allowing a
transitional government
to lead the country to fresh elections.
Since
the Africa trip, the administration has sharply toned down the
rhetoric in a
nod to South Africa's President Thabo Mbeki's and other
African leaders'
behind-the-scenes efforts to reform the obstinate Mugabe.
Critics call
"quiet diplomacy" a euphemism for inaction.
The repressive regime shows
few signs of letting up, recently shutting down
the only independent daily
newspaper, the Daily News.
Nor do economic and humanitarian crises show
signs of abating in the face of
drought, AIDS, a political impasse and
drastically reduced output on the
confiscated farms, which were the backbone
of what was once one of Africa's
best performing economies. GDP is expected
to fall by 11 percent this year,
after contracting by 27 percent between 2000
and 2002.
The inflation rate climbed to more than 450 percent in
September. The
unemployment rate is at least 70 percent.
Donors are
handing out food to millions of Zimbabweans amid charges that the
regime
denies its opponents food aid. Donor pressure on the regime has
proved
futile. Observers worry that Zimbabwe has fallen off the
administration's
agenda.
But the United States can still work behind the scenes to forge
consensus on
how to influence the ruling Zimbabwe African National Union
Patriotic Front
(ZANU-PF). The lead player will have to be Zimbabwe's main
trading partner,
South Africa, supported by regional organizations, including
the Southern
African Development Community (SADC) and the African
Union.
Mbeki says ZANU-PF has agreed to negotiate with the opposition,
and Mugabe
reportedly agreed to step down by the middle of next
year.
South Africa's leverage is limited. Drastic action, such as cutting
off
Zimbabwe's electricity - much of which is supplied by South Africa
and
Mozambique - could result in Mugabe unleashing unprecedented waves
of
refugees; a reported 2 million Zimbabweans have fled across the border
to
South Africa in the past few years.
African leaders' approach is
also rooted in colonial memory.
On a continent where societies greatly
respect age, Mugabe at 79 is an elder
statesman. He is also a liberation-era
hero, who spent more than a decade in
prison and led armed resistance against
the white minority regime of
Rhodesia, as the country was called. After
becoming the leader of the new
nation Zimbabwe in 1980, he was a lead
supporter of South Africa's
liberation struggle.
Mugabe's manipulation
of the land issue plays well in countries such as
South Africa and Namibia,
where land redistribution remains contentious.
Land has been at the heart of
conflict in Zimbabwe since white settlers
claimed the territory in 1890. A
system akin to apartheid that gave settlers
the best land continued after
Rhodesia declared itself independent from
Britain in 1965.
Brokered
during peace negotiations, Zimbabwe's constitution contained
provisions to
prevent the government from seizing land or forcing farmers to
sell land for
a 10-year period.
In the first decade of independence, 50,000 families
were resettled on more
than 7 million acres.
Land redistribution
slowed drastically in the 1990s as international donor
support for buying
land dried up amid accusations that the increasingly
corrupt government
parceled acquired land out to ministers and party
officials.
By 1997,
the glaring land ownership imbalance still existed; a million
blacks farmed
the worst land, while 4,500 commercial farmers, the vast
majority of them
white, owned 70 percent of the best land. Demand for land
rose as the economy
soured and a donor-imposed economic program hit
disproportionately at the
poor.
A new opposition party, the Movement for Democratic Change (MDC),
and its
civil society and trade union allies successfully campaigned for a
"no" vote
on a February 2000 referendum on a new constitution, which would
have
greatly strengthened executive power and permitted land confiscation.
Coming
only months before parliamentary elections, the defeat triggered
ZANU-PF's
violent crackdown on dissent and "fast track" land
reform.
By redistributing farms owned by whites - many of whom supported
the MDC -
the government struck at opponents, and played to a land-hungry
rural
support base as well as general resentment of white
privilege.
Mugabe has seized almost all of the white commercial
farms.
International news reports often focused on the plight of white
farmers (a
handful of whom were killed). By charging that racism frames the
West's
response, Mugabe deflects criticism from the disastrous effect his
policies
have on the average Zimbabwean.
Hundreds of thousands of poor
black farmers - whose work on commercial farms
supported as many as 2 million
dependants - lost their jobs during the land
grab.
Redistribution has
benefited few. Fewer than 123,000 of the 300,000
officially resettled
small-scale farming families have moved onto the land,
according to a
recently leaked government report. Less than a tenth of the
50,000 newly
apportioned commercial farms were in use.
State-sponsored militias made
up of independence war veterans and
conscripted youths have carried out much
of the violence. Newspaper offices
have been bombed and human rights
advocates beaten. Draconian laws support
the violence. The MDC's leader,
Morgan Tsvangirai, is being tried for
treason on flimsy charges. Court
rulings are often ignored.
Nonetheless, the opposition maintains support
in cities and the southeast,
where security forces killed thousands in the
early 1980s.
Despite winning 57 of 120 elected seats in the 2000
parliamentary elections,
the opposition has little institutional
power.
Mugabe won an additional six-year term in the March presidential
election,
which SADC, the European Union and the United States condemned
as
fundamentally flawed (many African observers endorsed the result). The
MDC's
court challenge is unresolved.
The opposition proves its
popularity through crippling strikes. But ZANU-PF
maintains its grip on
power, and prospects for meaningful negotiations are
poor.
The best
chance for a breakthrough lies within the ruling party's ranks.
Many
members of the elite have been insulated from the crisis - or benefited
from
it. But party leaders and business associates are increasingly
concerned by
the country's slide.
If carried out with African states, expanding and
strictly enforcing
targeted sanctions that the European Union and the United
States applied
between 2001 and this year - which banned travel and froze
assets of top
officials - would raise the cost of keeping the status quo for
the
privileged elite.
Whether new measures are necessary will be clear
by next month when ZANU-PF
holds its party conference.
The most
important donor role is to provide incentives - including
development and
reconstruction funds - as progress is made. Resolution of
the land issue will
be crucial.
The American administration has made great progress in
helping Africans to
broker an end to the seemingly intractable war in
Sudan.
Similarly, South Africa and the continent's other heavyweight,
Nigeria, have
made strides in ending wars across the continent.
It
would be a costly shame if donors and African leaders wait for Zimbabwe
to
implode before finding a solution.
Russell Geekie is a freelance writer
who specializes in Africa. He was an
editor at Africa Report magazine from
1990 to 1995.
Sunday Times
Bishop of Harare in land grab row
Mugabe ally
'given farm as reward for supporting Zanu-PF policies'
Sunday Times Foreign
Desk
Controversial Zimbabwean Anglican Bishop Nolbert Kunonga has
been accused of
illegally displacing a white commercial farmer from his
property and seizing
it for himself and his family.
Kunonga, the
Bishop of Harare and a close associate of President Robert
Mugabe, this week
allegedly ordered farmer Simon Hale to pack his bags and
leave St Marnock
farm, about 15km from the capital.
According to the London Sunday
Times, Kunonga evicted more than 50 black
workers and their families to make
way for his own staff.
The property was reportedly parcelled out to
the bishop by the Zimbabwe
government two weeks ago.
Land seizures
that began three years ago are continuing unabated in
Zimbabwe, albeit on a
low-intensity scale.
Two businessmen with Zanu-PF links, who had
resettled themselves and
relatives on the same farm, have also reportedly
been booted out by Kunonga.
According to the London Sunday Times, the
bishop took it from the
businessmen who had already seized two
farms.
The paper reported it was believed that the bishop had
received the farm as
a reward for his outspoken support for Mugabe and his
controversial policy
of land seizure.
On Friday, Hale was removing
his equipment and other belongings from the
farm.
Kunonga - one of
Mugabe's associates who has been banned from travelling to
the US and Europe
- will move into the spacious, seven-bedroomed farmhouse.
Hale's son,
Marcus, said his family had been given a Friday deadline by
Kunonga to vacate
the farm - despite the fact that they had not been served
with Section 5 and
Section 8 notices, which are preliminary and final
eviction orders
respectively.
"We have been told to move out by today and we were in
the process of doing
so when police impounded our truck and the irrigation
equipment we were
carrying," he said.
"Right now, I'm going to the
police to try and sort out the issue. But we
will not be able to move out all
our belongings . . . We intend contesting
the eviction in
court."
Marcus said his uncle had also lost a farm to war veteran
leaders Patrick
Nyaruwata and Endy Mhlanga. St Marnock - which was first
seized last year -
is now lying derelict, with fields
unplanted.
Kerry Jay, of the farmers' pressure group Justice for
Agriculture, said
Kunonga's actions were "disgraceful".
"It's
clear theft and absolutely appalling," she said. "Kunonga is supposed
to be a
role model and a righteous person. But what he has done is shameful
and
throws the church's image into disrepute."
Repeated attempts to get comment from Kunonga were unsuccessful.
In addition to the prime land
seized by Mugabe's ministers and members of
the ruling Zanu-PF party, it is
estimated that agricultural equipment worth
Z75-billion has been stolen or
vandalised.
Kunonga's support for the land grabs and his mockery of
Mugabe's black
opponents as "puppets of the West" have divided the Anglican
community in
Zimbabwe.
His pro-Mugabe actions have included the
banning of dissent in the church
and the transfer of clergymen opposed to
Zanu-PF policies.
In August, he was held hostage by parishioners at
the St Philip's Anglican
church in Harare after a row erupted over
misappropriation of church funds.
Zimbabwe will be thrust into the
international spotlight tomorrow as
opposition Movement for Democratic Change
(MDC) leader Morgan Tsvangirai
opens his court battle against Mugabe's
disputed re-election last year.
Tsvangirai's legal team, led by South
African advocate Jeremy Gauntlett,
filed its arguments against Mugabe on
October 13. The team will raise a wide
range of controversial electoral
issues during the initial five days of the
hearing.
MDC attorneys
will argue that the Electoral Supervisory Commission was not
validly
constituted and that electoral laws were manipulated.
The lawyers
will also argue that violence and intimidation tilted the poll
scales in
Mugabe's favour.
iafrica.com
MDC's 2002 election challenge to begin
Posted Sun, 02 Nov
2003
Zimbabwe opposition leader Morgan Tsvangirai is due in court on
Monday to
challenge President Robert Mugabe's contested victory in last
year's polls.
Tsvangirai, leader of the Movement for Democratic Change
(MDC), wants a
rerun of the election that returned his 79-year-old rival to
office. Mugabe
was declared the winner by a majority of some 400 000 votes.
But the MDC
leader, a former trade unionist, filed court papers challenging
Mugabe's
victory in April last year, a month after the election.
He
claims that Mugabe, who has been in power for 23 years, violated
electoral
laws and used dirty tactics to win himself a fifth term in office.
The
long-awaited trial comes after Tsvangirai went to court in July to get
an
order to have the date of the petition set down. His lawyers accused
the
state of employing delaying tactics to hold up the petition. According
to
Zimbabwean law, an election petition should be heard as a matter
of
priority.
Zimbabwe is deeply divided between Tsvangirai's
supporters and those of
Mugabe's ruling Zimbabwe African National Union -
Patriotic Front (ZANU-PF).
Efforts have been made to get the two parties
talking, but Mugabe says he
will not talk to his MDC opponent unless he
accepts him as the legitimate
head of state.
Fledgling inter-party
talks brokered by Nigeria and South Africa last year
were deadlocked after
Tsvangirai filed his petition, angering the ZANU-PF
camp. Tsvangirai has
ruled out dropping his election petition.
MDC lawyers claim Mugabe
tightened electoral laws to disqualify large
numbers of voters. These
included thousands of white voters — perceived to
be opposition supporters —
and millions of black Zimbabwean voters working
abroad.
An estimated
three million Zimbabweans who have escaped economic problems at
home now live
in South Africa, while tens of thousands more have gone to
Botswana,
Mozambique and Britain.
According to court papers quoted in the press
this week, Mugabe's lawyers
have dismissed Tsvangirai's challenge of sections
of the electoral laws as
"misdirected" and "over-ambitious".
The
opposition claims the number of polling stations set up in the
MDC
strongholds of Harare and Chitungwiza were reduced, causing massive
queues
of people, some of whom did not get to vote. They will also argue that
the
supervisory body tasked with overseeing the election was
improperly
constituted, and therefore unqualified to run the polls.
If
the first part of the legal challenge fails, the MDC will argue that
Mugabe's
party used violence, intimidation, bribery and vote-rigging to win
the
election.
AFP
Financial Times
Zimbabwe's banks ready for currency
controls
By Tony Hawkins in Harare
Published: November 2 2003
18:02 | Last Updated: November 2 2003 18:02
Zimbabwe's banks
and businesses are resigned to the imposition of new
foreign currency
controls following a pledge by President Robert Mugabe to
"restructure" the
Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe.
Speaking behind closed doors at a
meeting on Friday of the ruling
Zanu-PF party's central committee, Mr Mugabe
said the process of
restructuring the central bank would start this week.
Other institutions,
including the cabinet, would follow. He promised to make
the bank "much more
of a development institution that protects the national
interest".
The president's announcement followed the appointment of
a taskforce
of nine cabinet ministers to resolve the country's foreign
currency crisis.
The taskforce called for "whistleblowers" to report those
who were "starving
the country of foreign currency".
Bankers and
businessmen believe that the taskforce and the promised
restructuring of the
central bank will lead to new controls on the foreign
currency market and on
the banks.
Economists say the Ministry of Finance's attempts to
review the
overvalued exchange rate have been rebuffed by the
president.
Mr Mugabe is adamant that devaluation is no solution and
that the
foreign currency crisis will be overcome by tightening controls.
The
official rate of the Zimbabwe dollar is Z$824 to the US dollar, but in
the
parallel market the currency is traded at around Z$6,000.
Last month, the Chamber of Mines warned that its members needed an
exchange
rate of Z$3,970 to maintain viability, and tobacco growers are
demanding
either devaluation or a special subsidy.
The president also wants
to force banks to cut their prime lending
rates. Last week, some banks raised
their lending rates to 160 per cent,
which means they have doubled in the
last six months. But with inflation
running at 455 per cent and forecast to
exceed 600 per cent by Christmas,
lending rates remain massively negative in
real terms.
A senior banker, who asked not to be named, said
restructuring the
central bank was unlikely to mean much more than "replacing
seasoned
professionals with party functionaries.
"The president
is right to say the current policies are not working,
but imposing
artificially low interest rates and maintaining overvalued
exchange rates is
no solution either," he said.
Official balance of payments
forecasts predict a current account
deficit in 2003 of US$1.1bn and an
overall deficit of almost US$1.5bn -
approximately 25 per cent of gross
domestic product.
Foreign currency is extremely short just as
farmers are planting their
2004 crops, resulting in serious shortages of
seed, fuel, fertiliser and
chemicals. Foreign currency payments arrears are
currently estimated at
US$3bn or about half of GDP.