The ZIMBABWE Situation
An extensive and up-to-date website containing news, views and links related to ZIMBABWE - a country in crisis
Please note: You need to have 'Active content' enabled in your IE browser in order to see the index of articles on this webpage
SADC urged to deploy Zim mission
http://www.zimonline.co.za
by Own Correspondent
Thursday 05 November 2009
JOHANNESBURG - The SADC should
deploy a standing mission in Zimbabwe to
ensure full implementation of the
country's troubled power-sharing
agreement, the Open Society Initiative for
Southern Africa (OSISA) said on
Wednesday.
In a paper released ahead
of Thursday's mini-summit of SADC leaders in
Maputo to discuss Zimbabwe,
OSISA urged regional leaders to adopt a "new
approach" on the country that
it warned could slide back to violence unless
action was taken urgently to
put the Harare coalition government back on the
tracks.
OSISA said
Zimbabwe's rival political parties could not on their own oversee
implementation of the power-sharing pact or global political agreement
(GPA), placing the burden of saving the accord on the SADC (Southern African
Development Community) that together with the African Union (AU) is a
guarantor of the agreement.
Such a SADC mission would comprise
experts and observers while the
international community would step in with
funds and other support for the
mission that will among other things work to
ensure that education, health
care, water sanitation services and food
distribution remain uninterrupted.
The OSISA paper entitled Zimbabwe: A
Way Forward, said: "A comprehensive,
standing presence of SADC and/or the AU
be stationed in Zimbabwe until such
time as a new constitution has been
drafted, that the draft has been
submitted to referendum and that free and
fair presidential and legislative
elections have been held."
The
SADC's special organ on politics and defence, also known as the Troika,
meets Thursday to discuss Zimbabwe's power-sharing government that was
almost three weeks ago plunged into its worst crisis when Prime Minister
Morgan Tsvangirai and his MDC party stopped attending Cabinet to protest
President Robert Mugabe's refusal to fully implement the GPA.
While
Tsvangirai has insisted he remains in the unity government despite his
Cabinet boycott, analysts and human rights groups say the GPA is facing its
most critical moment especially as hardliner elements in Mugabe's ZANU PF
party and in the military have stepped up violence and farm invasions since
the MDC boycott.
OSISA said unless SADC leaders moved with speed to
halt the "military
build-up in Zimbabwe" the country could be plunged back
into the type of
political violence that engulfed the nation last year and
saw at least 200
MDC supporters murdered and thousands of others displaced
from their homes.
A fresh outbreak of violence will reverse gains made by
the unity government
in such important sectors as health and education,
OSISA warned.
To stop the slide to violence OSISA called for the
immediate deployment of a
smaller, ad-hoc delegation to monitor and report
on incidents of political
violence in Zimbabwe.
Sisonke Msimang,
executive director of OSISA, said: "Despite the horrific
levels of violence
in 2008, we know that outside observers acted as a
deterrent and saved
lives. If there is to be no return to the brutality of
2008, that delegation
needs to be put on the ground now."
Msimang said inability to change tack
by SADC could be a sure recipe for
failure, adding: "If the GPA can't be
rescued, it will be a colossal failure
for SADC."
The OSISA director
conceded that the proposals made by his group were
"ambitious" but he said
there were many precedents where observer missions
were successfully
deployed in troubled countries such as the United Nations
Observer Mission
in South Africa from 1992 to 1994.
There was no immediate response from
President Robert Mugabe's office to
OSISA's calls for a standing SADC
mission in Harare to monitor the shaky
unity government. The veteran leader
has in the past scoffed at any
suggestions of foreign supervision of
Zimbabwe's affairs including by
African allies.
Mugabe only bowed to
SADC pressure to form a unity government with
Tsvangirai last February
because an inconclusive election last year in which
he was defeated by his
old foe in the first round ballot had left him
exposed and with no
legitimate claim to the presidency.
There was also no reaction to OSISA's
calls from Tsvangirai or Deputy Prime
Minister Arthur Mutambara, who is
third signatory to the GPA.
Zimbabwe's three main political leaders will
attend the Mozambique summit -
ZimOnline.
'Troika must press Mugabe to end abuses'
http://www.zimonline.co.za
by Cuthbert Nzou
Thursday 05 November 2009
HARARE - The Southern African
Development Community (SADC) peace and
security organ meeting in Mozambique
today over the deteriorating political
situation in Zimbabwe should press
President Robert Mugabe's ZANU PF party
to end ongoing human rights abuses,
an international rights watchdog said on
Wednesday.
"Recent reports
that ZANU PF continues to arrest and harass human rights and
civil society
activists should act as a warning to the regional leaders that
Zimbabwe may
slide back into violence and chaos if they do not take decisive
action,"
said Georgette Gagnon, Africa director at Human Rights Watch.
"Regional
leaders should set concrete benchmarks and consider targeted
sanctions if
any of Zimbabwe's parties do not comply with the provisions of
the
power-sharing agreement."
President Armando Guebuza of Mozambique, King
Mswati III of Swaziland and
President Rupiah Banda of Zambia who make up the
SADC organ - also known as
Troika - meet with Mugabe, Prime Minister Morgan
Tsvangirai and Deputy
Premier Arthur Mutambara in Maputo to address the
political standoff
threatening to collapse the Harare coalition.
The
Tsvangirai-led Movement for Democratic Change (MDC-T), one of three
parties
to Zimbabwe's power-sharing government - Global Political Agreement
(GPA) -
announced last month that it was boycotting Cabinet meetings to
protest
Mugabe's continued flouting of the GPA.
The MDC-T leader said although
his party will continue with government
business, it will not cooperate with
ZANU PF and also suspended the council
of ministers meetings that he
chairs.
ZANU PF wields significantly more power than the MDC in the unity
government
formed last February, and ZANU PF supporters continue to commit
abuses
freely against their perceived political opponents.
On
Tuesday, for example, a prominent human rights and media lawyer, Mordecai
Mahlangu was arrested by detectives from the Criminal Investigations
Department in Harare for writing a letter protesting the use of testimony
extracted through torture in a trial.
Two weeks earlier, government
intelligence agents assaulted and detained two
journalists for Al-Jazeera
who were covering the Cabinet boycott.
In addition, two civil-society
leaders meeting in Victoria Falls on October
25 were arrested after issuing
a statement calling for the intervention of
the SADC and the African Union
to ensure that the power-sharing agreement is
fully implemented. They were
allegedly arrested under the Public Order and
Security Act, which ZANU PF
continues to use to quash peaceful dissent.
At least 17 MDC legislators
have been arrested since the beginning of the
year on charges ranging from
theft and public violence to rape and playing
music that denigrates Mugabe.
- ZimOnline
South
Africa's Zuma Brought Into Regional Talks on Zimbabwe Political
Crisis
http://www.voanews.com
By Blessing Zulu
Washington
04
November 2009
The Southern African Development Community has drafted
South African
President Jacob Zuma into Thursday's meeting of SADC's troika
on politics,
defense and security in Maputo, Mozambique, on Thursday,
regional sources
said, increasing the leverage of the heads of state who
will be trying to
resolve the crisis in Harare's unity
government.
Heads of state meeting in Maputo will also include President
Joseph Kabila
of the Democratic Republic of Congo, who is currently SADC's
chairman.
Presidents Kabila and Zuma will join Mozambican President Armando
Guebuza,
who is chairman of the troika or committee, President Rupia Banda
of Zambia
and King Mswati of Swaziland.
Informed sources said SADC
has become concerned at the crackdown on
political and civil opponents of
President Robert Mugabe and his ZANU-PF
party following the declaration Oct.
16 by Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai
of a "disengagement" by his Movement
for Democratic Change from ZANU-PF, its
partner and adversary in the
inclusive government.
Mr. Tsvangirai and Deputy Prime Minister Arthur
Mutambara, head of a rival
MDC grouping, arrived in Maputo on Wednesday
along with Finance Minister
Tendai Biti, secretary general of Mr.
Tsvangirai's MDC formation, and and
Industry and Commerce Minister Welshman,
secretary general of the Mutambara
MDC wing, among other top
officials.
President Mugabe was expected to fly to Maputo Thursday with
Defense
Minister Emmerson Mnangagwa and Justice Minister Patrick Chinamasa,
Harare
sources said.
SADC Executive Secretary Tomaz Salomao confirmed
to reporter Blessing Zulu
of VOA's Studio 7 for Zimbabwe that Presidents
Zuma and Kabila will be in
attendance adding that while in Maputo the heads
of state will also discuss
democratic issues in Lesotho.
Political
analyst Teresa Mugadza of Harare said the direct involvement of
Presidents
Zuma and Kabila shows that SADC is taking the Zimbabwe political
crisis
seriously.
Elsewhere, the Open Society Initiative for Southern Africa has
called on
SADC to deploy an ad hoc delegation to Zimbabwe to probe reports
of
political violence while regional leaders continue to seek a solution to
the
power-sharing crisis.
Open Society spokeswoman Nicole Fritz told
VOA Studio reporter Ntungamili
Nkomo that her organisation is concerned
Zimbabwe could slide back into the
political chaos seen in 2008 following
national elections if the government
crisis is not ended soon.
'CIO wants me silenced at KP summit'
http://www.zimonline.co.za
by Andrew Moyo
Thursday 05 November 2009
HARARE - A top Zimbabwean
human rights campaigner on Wednesday said
the country's Central Intelligence
Organisation (CIO) spy agency has tracked
him to an international summit in
Namibia to try to stop him from exposing
the serious human rights violations
his organisation has compiled in the
controversial Marange diamond
fields.
Farai Maguwu, who heads the Centre for Research and
Development (CRD)
in Zimbabwe's eastern border city of Mutare said yesterday
from Namibia he
had been followed by suspicious people and threatened by
senior security
officials since leaving for the Kimberley Process (KP)
meeting that will
decide whether to ban Zimbabwe from the world diamond
market.
"My presence has not gone down well with the regime,"
Magawu said,
adding; "They have been following me. There are powerful people
making money
out of diamonds (and) they would want me
silenced."
The CRD has been compiling evidence of heinous killings,
torture,
beatings, rape, kidnapping and kleptocracy by members of Mugabe's
inner
circle since Harare ejected a British firm, Africa Consolidated
Resources
(ACR) from the diamond fields in 2006 to pave way for the
state-run Zimbabwe
Mining Development Corporation (ZMDC).
Thousands of illegal diamond miners and dealers soon descended on
Marange to
mine and sell the precious stones that at the height of the
diamond rush
were being sold to traders coming from all over the world
including Israel,
Lebanon and Guyana.
The lawlessness on the diamond fields that
Zimbabwe's central bank
estimates has led to the country losing US$1,2
billion per month in
potential revenue from the precious metal, resulted in
Mugabe's government
sending soldiers and police to Marange to flush out the
illegal miners,
dealers and traders.
But human rights groups
and the KP review mission say police and
soldiers used excessive and brutal
force to take control of the diamond
field and that the security forces have
themselves taken over smuggling of
diamonds from Marange.
The
KP - a grouping of diamond trading countries and civic society
groups set up
to prevent trade in conflict or blood diamonds - has been
expected to use
this week's meeting to impose an export ban on Zimbabwean
diamonds.
But sources in Namibia said Zimbabwe looked set to
escape the ban
after its case was referred to an oversight committee, which
is normally the
last step before action can be taken.
The KP
review mission that visited Zimbabwe at the end of June said in
report that
Zimbabwean security forces and other government entities had
taken part in
extra-judicial violent attacks on illegal diamond miners and
smuggling of
the precious stones from Marange.
The mission called for a
temporary ban of six months or more to allow
Zimbabwe time to comply with KP
standards and said should the southern
African nation volunteer to stop
selling diamonds, the KP should monitor the
"self-suspension" to ensure
Harare implements all necessary measures to
comply with required standards
before it can resume trade in diamonds.
But civic society groups
are demanding the KP suspends Zimbabwe,
saying Harare had reneged on
previous promises to withdraw the army from
Marange and that only full
suspension could force the Zimbabwean authorities
to act to end rights
violations at the diamond field that is also known as
Chiadzwa. -
ZimOnline
Mugabe's
heavy tactics to stay in gem market
http://www.nzherald.co.nz
10:34AM Thursday Nov 05, 2009
By
Daniel Howden
Zimbabwe looks set to escape any punishment over its trade in
blood diamonds
after a ruthless lobbying campaign by Robert Mugabe's regime
that included
intimidation of a key witness at an international summit in
Namibia.
The member states of the Kimberley Process, the system set up to
regulate
the diamond trade, had been expected to use this week's meeting to
impose an
export ban on Zimbabwe after evidence of gross human rights abuses
at its
diamond fields.
However, campaigners fear that Zimbabwe will
be let off in a move that could
damage the credibility of the
ground-breaking effort to sever the link
between gems and violent conflict
in Africa.
Harare intimidated Farai Maguwu, a campaigner from the mining
district in
eastern Zimbabwe, who travelled to the Windhoek summit to give
evidence.
Maguwu, who runs the Centre for Research and Development in
Mutare, said:
"My presence here didn't go down too well with them and
they've had me
followed."
His organisation has been compiling
evidence of wrongdoing in Marange, an
area taken over by the military since
major alluvial diamond deposits were
found there in 2006.
The
slaughter by the Army of hundreds of itinerant miners drew worldwide
condemnation last year. "There are strong people making money out of
diamonds and they want to silence me," said Maguwu.
The researcher
was summoned to a meeting with Zimbabwe's ambassador to
Namibia where he
says he faced hysterical accusations.
"He was screaming at me and calling
me names, saying I was trying to please
white people, saying I don't love my
country ... He's paid by the people who
are looting our country. No one's
paying me to be here," he said.
The Kimberley safeguards agreed in 2003
helped to restore consumer
confidence in precious gems. But this year one of
the architects of the KP,
Ian Smillie, quit the scheme saying it was
"letting all manner of crooks off
the hook".
Kimberley members agreed
to send a mission to Zimbabwe last year after
reports of abuse in the
Marange fields. The delegation found evidence of a
string of gross
violations.
The summit ends tomorrow. Yesterday Zimbabwe was referred to
an oversight
committee, the last step before any action would be
taken.
"It's been a small victory as at least there will now be a
discussion," a
source said. "But the likelihood remains that no action will
be taken."
- INDEPENDENT
Suspend
Zimbabwe now, says diamond group
http://www.iol.co.za
November 05 2009 at
01:12AM
By Donna Bryson
Johannesburg -
Investigators for the world's diamond control body say
Zimbabwe should be
suspended because its security forces are raping women,
killing illegal
miners and smuggling gems out of a diamond field in the
troubled country's
east.
Human rights groups have made similar accusations, but the
charges
carry particular weight coming from Kimberley Process investigators
who
visited Zimbabwe in June and July. Their recommendations are in a
confidential report obtained by The Associated Press on
Wednesday.
Zimbabwean authorities have repeatedly denied such
charges, including
in statements to Kimberley Process investigators and
officials. The
investigators said they found evidence contradicting the
official account,
and that information provided by Zimbabwean authorities
"was false, and
likely intentionally so".
The report was
presented to Kimberley Process Certification Scheme
officials, who were
expected to decide this week on what to do about the
southern African
country. Their investigators recommended that Zimbabwe
either be suspended
or voluntarily suspend itself until it has met minimum
standards for
remaining part of the process.
The Kimberley Process was
established in 2002 in an attempt to stem
the flow of "blood diamonds" -
gems sold to fund fighting across Africa.
Participants must certify the
origins of the diamonds being traded.
Suspension could result in buyers
shunning Zimbabwe's diamonds.
While the rough gems flowing from
Zimbabwe's Marange field do not fit
the strict Kimberley definition of
conflict diamonds, the investigators said
the lawlessness in the area would
make it easy for traffickers to bring in
such gems from other countries and
then export them as Zimbabwean.
"Lawlessness, particularly when
combined with violence and largely
overseen by government entities, should
not be the hallmark of any system
deemed to be compliant" with the Kimberley
process, the investigators added.
The investigators interviewed
witnesses, victims and survivors of
victims.
While illegal
miners often fled when team members approached, seven
told of working for
soldiers who allowed them to keep only 10 percent of the
proceeds of any
diamonds recovered.
"Each one of these illegal miners reported
seeing people killed and
the numbers they cited ranged from one to seven,"
the report said. "This
group also told members of the team that they
observed extreme violence
against illegal miners" by soldiers using rifles,
dogs, batons and teargas.
The report said women "reported that,
while under the custody of the
security forces, they were raped repeatedly
by military officers and that
they have been forced to engage in sex with
illegal miners. One victim told
the team that she tested HIV-positive after
she had been forced to have sex
with two men and then raped by a military
officer".
The investigators said it was "credible" that syndicates
operated by
police and soldiers have been smuggling rough diamonds out of
Marange since
at least 2008, and likely since formal production began in
2007.
"The team concludes that the government of Zimbabwe
authorities are
aware of these syndicates and ongoing smuggling operations
and have
permitted them to continue," the report said.
London-based Global Witness, a human rights groups that tracks how
Africa's
mineral wealth is misused, has complained that the Kimberley
Process has so
far failed to address smuggling, money laundering and human
rights abuses in
Marange.
Human Rights Watch called last week for Zimbabwe to be
suspended from
the Kimberley Process. The international rights watchdog has
said repeatedly
that Zimbabwean soldiers are smuggling diamonds and killing
and beating
civilians to consolidate a hold on Marange that benefits the
Zanu-PF party
of long-time President Robert Mugabe.
Mugabe
entered into a coalition with his rival Morgan Tsvangirai in
February, but
Tsvangirai this month suspended his participation, accusing
Mugabe of
continuing human rights abuses and undermining the unity
agreement.According
to Kimberley process officials, Zimbabwe exported nearly
800 000 carats of
diamonds from three fields, including Marange, last year.
Zimbabwe has no
diamond processing facilities, so exports only rough gems. -
Sapa-AP
Diamond Trade Finds Regulatory Loophole in
Mozambique
NOVEMBER 5, 2009
By SARAH CHILDRESS
MANICA, Mozambique -- This dusty border town in
southern Africa has become a major hub for trading rough diamonds, but there is
a problem: Mozambique doesn't produce any of the sparkling stones.
The diamonds come from neighboring Zimbabwe, smuggled
illegally along a pipeline that Mozambican officials say they are powerless to
stop.
The Kimberley Process, an international regulatory
body that polices the diamond trade, is set to decide Thursday at a meeting in
Namibia whether to suspend Zimbabwe's membership, which allows it to certify
that its diamonds are conflict-free. Earlier this year, its investigators
documented human-rights abuses by the Zimbabwean military against diamond miners
in some fields, which the military and government have denied.
If the group rules against Zimbabwe, the country will
lose its Kimberley certification, an internationally recognized stamp of
approval sought by middlemen, retailers and consumers as a way of avoiding
so-called blood diamonds -- gems mined amid violence, sold to fund conflict, or
both.
The rampant smuggling through Mozambique, however,
could undermine any sanctions the Kimberley Process puts on Zimbabwe. And
whether or not the group votes to sanction Zimbabwe, the smuggling route is
complicating regional efforts to clean up the image of African
diamonds.
Other nearby Kimberley Process members -- such as
Botswana, South Africa and Namibia -- have been at pains to assure consumers
that their own gems are conflict-free. Smuggled Zimbabwean stones can be sold as
if they came from some of these neighbors, confusing buyers who might stay away
from Zimbabwean stones no matter what Kimberley officials rule this
week.
Murisi Zwizwai, Zimbabwe's deputy mining minister,
declined to comment on allegations made by the Kimberley Process, including
complicity in the smuggling trade. He said the government would respond to the
charges at this week's Kimberley meeting. "Our diamonds are not blood diamonds,"
he said.
Starting late last year, the Zimbabwean military and
police moved into diamond fields near the Mozambican border. Zimbabwe said the
operation was aimed at relocating hundreds of thousands of artisan miners who
had swarmed the region.
But human-rights groups said the authorities forced
miners to dig for the benefit of senior government officials or military
commanders under the threat of violence, allegations the government has
denied.
Many of these stones are smuggled across the border,
Mozambican officials say. Here, middlemen resell them to dealers, who then ship
them out of Mozambique to be cut, polished and sold on the world
market.
It is difficult to know how many diamonds are being
smuggled through Mozambique. Kimberley Process investigators said that according
to government statistics, 59% of Zimbabwe's production in 2008 wasn't exported
through official channels.
Pedro Jemusse, a Mozambique district police spokesman
in the provincial capital of Chimoio, about an hour away from Manica, said it is
hard to crack down on the trade because foreign buyers usually have appropriate
immigration papers, and it is difficult to catch smugglers in the
act.
Mr. Jemusse also acknowledges police and border
guards can be bribed. The first point of sale for rough Zimbabwean diamonds is
Manica, according to interviews with the Mozambican government, police and
border officials, as well as some diamond buyers.
Diamond traders from Lebanon, Israel, Somalia and
West African nations like Nigeria and Guinea have flocked to the town, dotted
with traditional mud-and-stick homes. Driving shiny new cars, they rent
elaborate, freshly constructed houses, painted in pastels.
Zimbabweans and Mozambicans carry rough stones across
the border checkpoint near Manica. They hide them in their mouths or in bandages
wrapped around their legs.
One Mozambican man who lives in Zimbabwe said he
walks across the border nearly every day, introducing Zimbabwean diamond sellers
to mostly Lebanese buyers, who wait on the shaded terrace of the Flamingo
Restaurante and Bar. Marked by a giant white flamingo signboard along one of
Manica's main streets, it is one the town's best-known spots for meeting
black-market diamond dealers.
On a recent afternoon, several men gathered around a
plastic lawn table at another fixture of the smuggling route, the Manica Lodge,
holding up stones to the light. Deals range from a paltry $1 a carat to $3,000
or $4,000 a carat for a good stone. One buyer said that they can make as much as
$100,000 a month in the trade here.
Around midnight on a recent Friday at Coquiero, a
popular nightclub outside town, three locally well-known Lebanese diamond buyers
settled into the red couches in the VIP lounge, mixing vodka tonics from a
bottle of Smirnoff on the mirrored tabletop. They scrolled through their
BlackBerrys as they checked out girls on the dance floor.
One of the buyers told a reporter that he and his
companions had been buying diamonds for the past one or two years, but said they
weren't doing anything wrong. "I'm just trying to make a living," he
said.
—Farai Mutsaka in Harare contributed to
this article.
REPORT: Zimbabwe - Way forward
http://www.zimonline.co.za
Wednesday 04 November
2009
Executive Summary
The Open Society Initiative for
Southern Africa (OSISA) makes the following
recommendations:
That an
ad-hoc delegation (sourced from South Africa in support of its
mediation
role or from SADC or the AU) be deployed with immediate effect to
monitor
and report on incidents of political violence and intimidation.
That
SADC, as guarantor of the Global Political Agreement (and in its
absence
other regional or international entities), ensure effective
implementation
of the GPA and a definitive resolution of the outstanding
issues as per the
SADC communiqué of 26-27 January 2009, and in particular,
secure an end to
political violence and to partisan use of security forces,
the legal system
and other state apparatus.
That a comprehensive, standing presence of
SADC and/or the AU be stationed
in Zimbabwe until such time as a new
Constitution has been drafted, that the
draft has been submitted to
referendum and that free and fair presidential
and legislative elections
have been held. And that the standing presence be
coupled with a pooled
fund, supported by the international donor community,
overseen by sector
experts, to ensure that education, health care, water
sanitation services
and food distribution remain uninterrupted.
Zimbabwe today
The
Global Political Agreement (GPA), between ZANU PF, MDC-T and MDC-M, and
guaranteed by SADC, while always tenuous, faces a greater prospect of
unravelling today than at any previous time - plunging the country back to
the crisis levels of 2008, characterised by a breakdown in service delivery,
economic collapse, food shortages and an outbreak of cholera. The
prospective fallout also portends a return to widespread, even increased,
political violence.
During its short tenure, the inclusive government
- established under the
GPA - has made demonstrable progress: stabilizing
inflation, bringing down
the price of food (although this remains high) and
allowing for a return to
work of doctors who had been on strike and teachers
who had abandoned their
posts. And although the process and progress leaves
much to be desired, it
has begun the important work of developing a new
constitution.
However, the parliament - having met only intermittently -
has failed to
repeal repressive legislation such as the Public Order and
Security Act
(POSA) and the Access to Information and Protection of Privacy
Act (AIPPA).
As such, the environment continues to be one in which freedom
of expression
and assembly are severely curtailed. In addition, the
state-owned media
remains strongly biased in favour of ZANU PF, raising
questions about the
credibility of the constitution-making
process.
In recent weeks, the MDC has announced a policy of
non-cooperation in
respect of working with ZANU-PF in government - retaining
its cabinet posts
but withdrawing from cabinet meetings and active
cooperation with ZANU-PF
ministries. Of great concern are accounts of
increased abductions carried
out by state agents against political
opponents, and the reports of
increased violence by soldiers against
villagers - particularly in
Mashonaland East.
In recent days, UN
Special Rapporteur on Torture, Manfred Nowak was denied
entry into Zimbabwe,
despite an earlier invitation.
In order to rescue the GPA, to ensure that
the inclusive government
continues to function and that effective response
to key aspects of the
crisis is ensured, OSISA makes the following proposals
- the first two
requiring immediate realisation and the third proposal
needing to be enacted
over the medium-term. ?
Immediate
proposals
A Delegation to Guard against Renewed Political
Violence
Warranting greatest concern over the next few weeks is the
prospect that
Zimbabwe will see a return to intensive, widespread violence.
Credible
reports indicate that youth and 'war veteran' militias are
currently being
deployed in the three Mashonaland provinces.
These
reports are consistent with previous outbreaks of politically directed
violence that have originated in the Mashonaland provinces.
That the
country is set to experience renewed widespread, politically
motivated
violence seems consistent too with the flagrancy of certain recent
public
actions: such as the denial of entry, despite his invitation, to UN
Special
Rapporteur on Torture, Manfred Nowak; the police raid on an
MDC-owned
property in Harare on the grounds that police suspected the
stockpiling of
arms; the recent abduction of the MDC's transport manager,
Pascal Gwezere,
arrest of civil society personalities such as Zimbabwe
Election Support
Network officials, NANGO Director and Board chairperson,
and human rights
lawyer Modecai Mahlangu among others.
In order to guard against the
outbreak of renewed, politically motivated
violence, it is recommended that
a delegation be deployed to monitor
military build-up and to report on
incidents of political violence.
Ideally such a delegation would be a
SADC-mandated delegation, but given the
immediacy of the threat, those
actors best placed to dispatch a delegation
are those able to do most
rapidly. South Africa, in support of the mediation
role it has played, could
do so. SADC and the AU are also possible sources.
Assurances of an end to
political violence for a return to inclusive
government
The MDC has
adopted a position of non-cooperation in respect of working with
ZANU PF in
government, in protest at increased political violence, targeting
of MDC
office-bearers and failure to resolve outstanding issues under the
Global
Political Agreement. Yet there will be no meaningful progress in
complying
with the GPA until there is renewed full engagement in the
government.
SADC, as guarantor of the GPA, must, as a threshold for
return to full
cooperation, ensure effective implementation of the GPA and a
definitive
resolution of the outstanding issues as per the SADC communiqué
of 26-27
January 2009, and in particular, secure an end to political
violence and to
partisan use of security forces, the legal system and other
state apparatus.
The policy of selectively arresting MDC officials and
members of parliament
as well as human rights defenders must stop, every
effort must be made to
bring to justice those responsible for the abductions
and attempted
abductions of MDC officials, and politically motivated charges
against MDC
officials must be dropped.
In the event that there is
demonstrable progress in resolving the
outstanding issues, it is urged that
there be full and renewed engagement
with the Global Political Agreement and
New Government, as set out therein,
by all political actors.
SADC,
upon re-engagement, must play a more active role than it has
previously in
continuing to facilitate and monitor progress under the GPA.
Medium-term
proposal
A comprehensive observer mission
Should the GPA collapse,
there is a real danger of continued violence across
the country, escalating
food prices and a return to hyper inflation. The
state would no longer be
able to afford the allowances that it has been
paying to civil servants, and
this would lead to the discontinuation of
teaching and learning and severe
disruptions in the ability of state
hospitals to function. There is also
the likelihood of a further breakdown
in water and sanitation services,
resulting potentially in another
devastating cholera outbreak (the last
outbreak began in September 2008 and
ended in February 2009, killing over 3
000 people across the country).
In order to avert the collapse of the
state, it is crucial that the
inclusive government not only continue to
function but that it be
capacitated to respond to key aspects of the crisis.
However, the
intractable differences that exist between the parties, the
recurring
deadlock, has meant that while some gains have been made, ordinary
Zimbabweans are frustrated at the absence of real measurable
improvement.
The parties have shown an inability to effectively and
efficiently address
differences relating to the interpretation and
implementation of the GPA -
as witnessed by the most recent
deadlock.
It is thus imperative that oversight of the GPA not rest with
the parties
themselves, but that a comprehensive, standing presence/observer
mission of
SADC and/or the AU be stationed in Zimbabwe until such time as a
new
Constitution has been drafted, that the draft has been submitted to
referendum and that free and fair presidential and legislative elections
have been held.
The mission would have a dedicated presence of
experts and observers across
the country to monitor and oversee the
constitution-making process. Observer
presence would help guarantee the
safety of communities participating in
consultations related to the making
of the constitution, the constitutional
referendum anticipated in the GPA,
and the elections that would follow.
Furthermore, AU expert military
personnel would be deployed to the army and
the police to lead a process of
security sector reform. This reform process
would ensure the implementation
of section 12.1(b) of the GPA which states
that "the Government shall
undertake training programmes, workshops and
meetings for the police and
other enforcement agencies directed at the
appreciation of the right to
freedom of assembly and association and the
proper interpretation,
understanding and application of the provisions of
security legislation."
The mission would also comprise experts from the
United Nations, SADC and
the AU who would oversee a process to ensure the
repeal of all repressive
laws using parliamentary processes.
Experts would also be deployed to
support the sectors of water and
sanitation, education, health and
agriculture so as to ensure that basic
services are not interrupted. Sector
experts would manage a pooled fund -
the Zimbabwe Humanitarian and Emergency
Relief Fund - supported by the
international donor community - to ensure
that education, health and water
sanitation services remain uninterrupted,
while with the support of the
United Nations World Food Programme, the
mission would ensure the fair
distribution of foodstuffs to communities
affected by food shortages.
It is envisaged that the mission would
comprise some 75 experts from SADC
and the AU, and an additional 300
observers. The mission would be
head-quartered in Harare with a presence
across the country for a period of
2 years, tasked with ensuring the
implementation and interpretation of the
provisions of the GPA, overseeing
the constitution-making process (including
the constitutional referendum)
and the next national elections, as well as
with supporting and supervising
the repeal of repressive legislation,
guiding electoral and security-sector
reform, and ensuring uninterrupted
basic health and educational services
through the management of a
donor-funded Zimbabwe Humanitarian and Emergency
Relief Fund. - ZimOnline
Zanu (PF) misinforms villagers
http://www.thezimbabwean.co.uk
Written by Taurai Bande
Wednesday, 04 November 2009 13:43
WEDZA - Zanu (PF) has been
misinforming villagers about the
implications of MDC disengagement from the
inclusive government, to win back
lost support among the
electorate.
War veterans and Zanu (PF) militia have told rural
communities that,
Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai and the MDC have resigned
from the
inclusive government and that Zanu (PF) was going it alone. The
falsehoods
are intended to create despondency among MDC supporters.
"Zanu (PF) youths are moving around villages warning people that,
since the
MDC no longer work together with President Mugabe, the political
situation
has returned to that prevailing before the Global Political
Agreement, GPA,
was signed in September last year. We are told that Morgan
Tsvangirai has
ceased to be prime minister and MDC cabinet ministers no
longer hold public
offices," said a villager last Friday. The man added
that, traditional
leaders had resumed threatening suspected MDC supporters
with evictions.
Bloodbath on the ZSE .. as market finally succumbs to political
pressure
http://www.thezimbabwean.co.uk
Written by Hillary Chindodo
Wednesday, 04
November 2009 12:34
The Zimbabwe Stock Exchange appeared to have
finally succumbed to the
uncertainty created by the political stand-off
within the fragile inclusive
government.
The market experience one
of its most volatile month as the political
front continues to go through
its most turbulent period since the inclusive
government took office. The
market had shown a bit of resistance in the
first two weeks of October but
eventually capitulated into a sea of red
across both the Industrial and
Mining indices. In the last week of October
alone, the mining index dropped
19.28% to close the month on 182.15. Adding
on to the third week's loss of
10.33%, the index lost 27% of its value
within a space of two weeks. In the
entire month of October, the industrials
have gone down by 15.09% having
peaked at over 250.00 points in week two.
The gain in the month of
22.22% by Falgold did little to stifle the
loss in the mining sector where
Hwange was the biggest loser with a drop of
40.62%. The other two counters
that make up the index, Rio Zim and Bindura
lost 10.81% and 8% respectively.
The Industrial index lost 11.48% in the
last week to close the month of
October on 149.03. This index had resisted
political pressure to sustain
positive growth up to the end of the third
week of the month peaking at just
over 170.00 points. ZECO has continued to
surprise surging an impressive
42.86% in the month under review. The counter
has had a 200% year to date
increase. Old Mutual, the only counter with any
real correlation with the
developed markets held steady throughout growing
13.10% in a month which saw
London's FTSE 100, where it is also listed,
reaching a 52-week
high.
A SADC extra-ordinary meeting has been announced for this week to
help
Zimbabwe's political protagonists resolve their differences. A
continued
stand-off, as reflected by the bloodbath on the ZSE, will badly
hurt the
confidence which the country was beginning to re-build following
ten years
of economic decline. Courtesy of Zimbabwe Investor Magazine,
incorporating
the Zimbabwe Investor Research Institute®. Website:
www.zimbabweinvestor.com, Email: research@zimbabweinvestor.com.
Hundreds of vehicles impounded
http://www.thezimbabwean.co.uk
Written by Staff Reporter
Wednesday, 04 November 2009 14:05
BULAWAYO - Zimbabwe Revenue Authority
(ZIMRA) Vehicle Inspection
Department (VID) officials and traffic police
went on the rampage last week,
impounding hundreds of vehicles in the city
for not paying tax.
Several residents who had their vehicles impounded
said they were
being asked to pay amounts ranging from US$200 to US$500 to
have their cars
released. "They impounded all three of my commuter omnibus
vehicles and
right now I don't know what to do because they are demanding
exorbitant
amounts for the release of the vehicles," said Fatima Tshuma, a
commuter
omnibus operator from Nkulumane High density suburb.
Another resident Mike Moyo said: "They should have warned us, not just
impound our vehicles like that. After all figures there are demanding is too
much, where I will get such money?"
A ZIMRA official who spoke to
The Zimbabwean said they had embarked on
this operation after realizing that
most vehicles owners were not paying
tax. "People are not paying tax and
insurance for their vehicles and we have
no option but to do this," said the
ZIMRA official.
Meanwhile, several driving schools and hair salon
operators in the
city have called upon ZIMRA to reduce the presumptive
taxing system used on
informal traders, saying the amount is exorbitant.
Each driving school or
hair salon owner is required to pay presumptive tax
amounting to US$1500
every quarter of the year.
Diamonds belong to the people of Zimbabwe
Written by Braam
Hanekom |
Wednesday, 04 November
2009 12:31 |
We must keep our Diamonds in Zimbabwean soil until we are rid of the
thieves that govern our country. It is clear that the corruption bridges across
the political divides. (Pictured: ‘Joice Mujuru and Augustine Chihuri, who are
the biggest beneficiaries, are uncontrollable) If some MDC officials were not
involved then why would Tsvangirai’s official, Deputy Minister of Mines, Murisi
Zwizwai, deny that Mugabe’s government ever killed any alluvial diamond miners
in the Chiadzwa area? In the Marange District of Eastern Zimbabwe, where
Chiadzwa is located, the community was victim to the notorious operation
Kakudzokwi “do not return” last year. I thought that this was common knowledge,
just about all Zimbabweans know about this operation. From the reports we have
seen and from what the community has said at least 100 people were killed by
soldiers who flew over the area in helicopters with automatic machine guns
shooting everyone in attempt to take complete control over diamond panning.
Recently we conducted an investigation into the conditions and were told,
even by police, that there could have been about 1,000 killed during the
operation. It is absolutely unacceptable, soldiers cannot kill people for mining
– this is murder. The same soldiers, and now police, beat and kill the
community for panning in the area, recruit and enslave them as panners. It’s
a game of cat and mouse. Every week the community of panners are chased and then
called back into the area - now called Pa MaiMujuru. It is there that people
work, month on end. If panners were to think of the work they do as a job they
would never accept such conditions, but they are conned into thinking that they
will earn a fortune when or if they stumble across a big diamond. Instead of
this new life, they all end up finding only the cheap industrial diamonds and
selling them for US$10 a gram and then having to give half of the money to
soldiers and police. The remaining money is divided by 20 or 30 depending on
how many panners are in their “syndicate”. The whole Chiadzwa and Murange
diamond business is corrupt with people being beaten and often having their hard
earned diamonds “confiscated” by police or soldiers after months of unpaid work.
It is not surprising that Mugabe is unable to move his soldiers and police,
because Chihuru and Mujuru, who are the biggest beneficiaries, are
uncontrollable. Either this or Mugabe has a share of the profit and,
interestingly, so must MDC’s Murisi Zwizwai. It is also interesting that Chihuru
and Mujuru are unable to control their soldiers and police who openly sell
diamonds, while ‘securing’ their areas. The dirty business has torn apart
many lives, while certain individuals have made their millions. While the
country has been worrying about who is in charge of government, certain
calculating and murderous people have been stealing our God-given resources and
exporting them for their personal financial gain. All Zimbabweans need to
stand against the diamond trade from Marange - it is one big lie that Zimbabwe
will benefit. We need to be clear that there are no benefits for ordinary
Zimbabweans. Instead the money is further strengthening the ruling elite. We
need to stand against this trade until human rights are being respected, until
the police and soldiers stop being businessmen, until the soldiers leave the
area or allow international organisations to monitor their behaviour in the
area. It is better that the diamonds stay in the soil than for them to be used
to kill our people. |
Petina Gappah makes Guardian shortlist
http://www.thezimbabwean.co.uk
Written by Tinashe
Mushakavanhu
Tuesday, 03 November 2009 11:12
LONDON - The last
Zimbabwean writer to win the Guardian Fiction Prize
was the late Dambudzo
Marechera in 1979 with his debut novella, The House of
Hunger.
Switzerland-based fulltime lawyer, Petina Gappah, burst on the
literary
scene with a collection of short stories, An Elegy of Easterly, and
has made
the final shortlist of the same prize, to be awarded on December 2
in
London.
The other writers who have made the Guardian shortlist include
novelists Samantha Harvey for The Wilderness, Eleanor Catton for The
Rehearsal, Reif Larsen for The Collected Works of TS Spivet and non-fiction
writer Michael Peel for A Swamp Full of Dollars.
Since An Elegy for
Easterly was released by Faber and Faber in April,
it has been widely
praised as a literary gem for its 'great insight, humour
and energy'. Gappah
has already scooped translation deals in Europe, been
short listed for
international awards and toured around some of the world's
famous literary
festivals.
Gappah is set to attend a festival celebrating African
Literature in
Oslo, Norway from November 17-19 where she will be launching,
Klagesang for
Easterly, the Norwegian version of her book. Other notable
writers in
attendance will include novelist and filmmaker Tsitsi
Dangarembga, Orange
Prize winner Chimamanda Adichie Ngozi, 2002 Caine Prize
winner Binyavanga
Wainaina and Niq Mhlongo.
She is currently
finishing work on her forthcoming novel, which is
also set to be published
by Faber and Faber in London as part of the
two-book deal she signed with
them.
The need for honest opinions and transparency
http://www.thezimbabwean.co.uk
Written by Braam
Hanekom
Wednesday, 04 November 2009 11:28
CAPE TOWN - I was
greatly disappointed by the way Zanu (PF) supporters
so blindly supported
their leaders, but I have come to be even more
disturbed by the manor in
which MDC supporters now so blindly support their
leaders. How will any
leadership be accountable to its citizens if people
are so afraid of
speaking out, or are people really so blind? I have been
shocked at how
easily I have been accused of being Zanu (PF). Whenever I am
critical of MDC
I am met with much suspicion. Is it really so polarized that
you are either
a blind sheep in one camp or a blind sheep in the other camp?
If you speak
out against what you see as wrong in both the MDC and Zanu
(PF), you are in
neither camp and thus you are an outcast.
I have supported MDC in many
ways-in actual fact, I have, on several
occasions, risked my life for the
MDC, but I also have the right to exercise
my freedom of speech. I have
tried to engage the MDC and expressed many of
my concerns with very few
results. My critical response to what I see as
their failures is aimed to
influence public opinion, so that hopefully
public opinion will hold the
leadership responsible for their actions,
giving them guidance and
ultimately leading to a stronger, more transparent
and accountable
leadership.
Not accustomed to criticism
If the MDC is not
accustomed to criticism, when it makes mistakes, it
can blame those who have
become blind followers. Surely every MDC supporter
can recall times when the
MDC made mistakes? For example, the MDC called for
Zimbabweans in Joburg to
return to Zimbabwe for the run off elections- with
NGO's even supplying free
busses for the journey.
Then the MDC withdrew from the elections,
leaving many who had heeded
the calls from the MDC unable to vote and
without money of transport to
return to South Africa. The very fact that the
MDC is its current situation,
one in which, as Mugabe put it, it has 'one
foot in and one foot out', means
it is not in full control. They have not
yet succeeded in fulfilling their
mandate, that of the people, whose
collective support has given MDC more
than enough authority and credibility
to overthrow Mugabe and his gang of
thieves. In fact this support has given
MDC so much credibility that they
are now even able to gain an audience with
leaders such as Presidents Obama,
Brown, and Zuma, but to mention a few.
That the MDC has not fulfilled its
mandate after 10 years proves that
patient silence and blind support has not
worked.
When will people
really take ownership of the MDC? When will we hold
them accountable? When
will we demand of them what we paid for though our
flesh, blood and
votes-freedom and an end of Zanu (PF)'s reign of
unaccountable
governance?
The MDC is a political party, but it is also the face of
the will of
the people-a channel through which so many angry, frustrated,
desperate and
hungry people express their demands for change. If the channel
can no longer
represent their demands eventually people will find other
means, or possibly
other organizations, to express their needs. It is
important that people try
to guide the MDC before the party is completely
lost or people are so
frustrated that they turn their backs on the
MDC.
It was a mistake to enter the power sharing agreement and it is
mistake to 'half withdraw'. It is time to end the agreement completely or
return to cabinet meetings. Call me an outcast if need be, but I cannot
stand and watch silently while I see such mistakes unravel. I see the
jellyfish behaviour of leaders who are afraid to make solid decisions. If
they are afraid the decision to withdraw will lead to a divide in MDC. They
should not be afraid, for if it does divide, they will have successfully
identified who has money and wealth in their hearts in place of where the
will of the people should be. Indeed, a divide of such a nature could
strengthen those that remain true to the will of the people, as people have
noticed certain elements amongst MDC cabinet members that are behaving like
thieves
Elections will never be stolen again
http://www.thezimbabwean.co.uk
Written by Special
Correspondent
Wednesday, 04 November 2009 11:33
HARARE - Zanu
(PF) reacted with characteristic arrogance and a sense
of exaggerated
over-confidence to Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangira's
announcement of his
party's partial withdrawal from the so-called inclusive
government.
In short, President Robert Mugabe and his party are letting it be
known
that, contrary to fears being expressed in certain quarters, the
decision
will not make any difference. The government will continue as
before, "with
or without the MDC, as in the past".
How can the government continue to
function when Mugabe says
Tsvangirai and Arthur Mutambara of have "one leg
in and one leg out" of that
government?
After what happened at the
harmonised elections, it is strange that
Zanu (PF) is confident it will be
"business as usual" minus MDC. How can
the status quo continue when Zanu
(PF) was shaken to its very foundation by
the MDC and especially that its
leader was rejected? Zimbabweans vowed then
that what happened over the
past 10 years will never happen again (just as
"Zimbabwe will never be a
colony again").
How can the country do without the MDC? Mugabe
acknowledged at a party
meeting at the weekend that "Zanu (PF) is not
government but in government",
adding: "It is part of a government like the
other two." Later in a speech
at Heroes Acre Mugabe referred to Zanu (PF) as
"the important party in the
government". A case of some partners being more
equal than others? Herein
lies the root cause of all the squabbling that
has dogged the inclusive
government from the start.
Put another
way, although the government is three-legged, Zanu (PF)
says it is equal to
two legs and the MDC formations are one leg. But just
what does a government
without the MDC mean? To the generality of
Zimbabweans, the following come
to mind:
. collapsed social services (health, education)
. endless queues for the little cash to get the few basic
commodities
available
. gross human rights violations/abuses (against ordinary
people,
"opponents", civic leaders, journalists)
. corruption,
looting and nepotism in government institutions and
programmes
.
an undemocratic electoral and political environment
. blatantly
selective application of the law
. world record hyperinflation and
an ever-crumbling infrastructure
. abductions, violence,
intimidation and brutality perpetrated by
state agents and war veterans (who
know they will go unpunished).
. unashamedly biased media that is
bent on convincing us all to
think the alike.
The list is
unlimited. The status quo means putting the clock
backwards to the hell-hole
Zimbabwe was until recently. The country has
surely changed for the better
since the signing of the three-party accord,
lop-sided as it is. Can all
these impressive gains, achieved in a relatively
short period, be thrown
down the drain just like that? God forbid!
The sooner Zanu (PF) stops
believing it was anointed to rule for all
time because of its role in the
liberation war, the better for Zimbabwe.
From inclusive to parallel government
http://www.thezimbabwean.co.uk
Written by John Makumbe
Tuesday, 03 November 2009 12:58
At last the MDC has had the courage to
exercise power and make Mugabe
and Zanu (PF) scream and cringe with the fear
that the GNU is on the verge
of collapse. This is good thinking on the part
of the MDC. Robert Mugabe is
shocked by the MDC's move. For nearly 30 years
he has always done things his
own way and none of his "wives" has ever dared
to challenge him on anything.
Now comes this bunch of younger and more
articulate workers and civilians
who seem to have a mind of their
own.
They have placed the old man between a rock and a hard place and
this
has the potential of embarrassing him no end. Mugabe and Zanu (PF) know
very
well that they have no mandate from the people of this country outside
the
GPA. They lost the 2008 elections big time, and a recent survey by the
Mass
Public Opinion Institute indicates that their support is about 10% or
less
even in rural Zimbabwe. It would therefore be unthinkable to call for
national elections and expect Zanu (PF) to win and remain in power. So the
inclusive government must be saved at all cost.
But this is exactly
where Mugabe and his bunch of wimps come face to
face with reality. Past
elections have witnessed the Zanu (PF) "Father
Christmas", aka Gideon Gono,
dishing out all kinds of incentives, bribes and
other forms of corruption to
ensure that Mugabe and his dead wood win such
elections. This time around,
Tendai Biti is firmly keeping the keys to the
granary and no war veteran or
Zanu (PF) militia is going to get even one
cent from state coffers.
Without inducement money and the usual gravy, it is unlikely that the
Zanu
(PF) hoodlums would campaign for the outgoing political party in the
same
manner as they did in June 2008. But then they can always resort to the
national army and the police to do their bidding. After all, these elements
are receiving the monthly $150 to $200, so they will obey the "commander of
defence forces" and go out and beat up their mothers, fathers, grandfathers
and even their children to make them vote for Mugabe and Zanu (PF). Will
they?
Perhaps they will resort to the CIO and the prison service
officers.
These are also receiving the usual monthly pittance and should be
grateful
to the "supreme leader" and willingly go and campaign for him to
win the
next election. Fat chance Bob! Some of us know that the majority of
the
civil servants are now subtly opposed to Zanu (PF) and are co-operating
very
well with these new MDC "ministers" and their deputies. Who then will
do the
rigging for the old men and women of a dying political party? No,
elections
right now are not the best option for Zanu (PF).
The MDC
must begin to think quickly about their next move. They have
done the right
thing to place Mugabe and Zanu (PF) in a no-win situation.
Let Mugabe fully
express his foolishness by appointing acting ministers and
the GPA will be
history. Mugabe will be completely without any legitimacy.
Sanctions will
not be removed; instead, they will be tightened further.
The SADC is
unlikely to rescue Mugabe and his sinking Titanic. Ian
Seretse Khama of
Botswana has already said without the GPA, he is not going
to recognise
Mugabe as President of this country. Jacob Zuma is only waiting
for the
right time to say the same thing, and Jakaya Kikwete will not need
any
serious persuasion to follow suit. Slowly, Mugabe and his minions are
being
squeezed out of the little political space they have in the region.
MDC must
now come up with the best way forward for this country. Time is of
the
essence. God bless Zimbabwe.
SADC now part of the problem
http://www.thezimbabwean.co.uk
Written by The Editor
Wednesday,
04 November 2009 14:00
Zimbabweans should not hold their breath for the
SADC meeting in
Maputo today. The chances of something decisive in favour of
the majority of
Zimbabweans being agreed there are slim indeed. SADC is now
part of the
problem.
The regional body's leaders have demonstrated
on numerous occasions
that they are utterly spineless when faced with a
recalcitrant Robert Mugabe
on his anti-colonialism hobby-horse.
Their last meeting in Kinshasa, where they could have prevented the
current
impasse in the GNU, was a case in point. Their inaction at that
meeting is,
in fact, what has forced the MDC's hand and resulted in the
disengagement.
The MDC had nowhere else to go.
SADC is supposed to be the guarantor of
the Global Political
Agreement - but they have persistently sidestepped the
MDC's legitimate
complaints about Zanu (PF)'s non-compliance while
entertaining Mugabe's
ludicrous "sanctions" posturing. Their pro-Mugabe bias
is evident to all.
Over the past five years, this editorial column has
catalogued countless
instances of SADC failing the people of Zimbabwe. Their
record of kowtowing
to Mugabe, for whatever reason, has been well
catalogued. We had hoped that
with the departure of Thabo Mbeki and the
advent of Jacob Zuma, there would
be a new approach - a more even-handed way
of dealing with Zimbabwe. But our
hopes have been dashed.
We were
disappointed to note that even the South African officials
assisting the
Troika's foreign ministers, who were in Zimbabwe last week,
were from the
original Mbeki team. What we can hope in, however, is a
meeting taking place
today thousands of kilometres away - in Washington -
where Botswana's
President Ian Khama is meeting US President Barack Obama to
talk about good
governance in Africa. We understand Zimbabwe will feature
prominently on the
agenda. Khama's principled stance on refusing to
recognise Mugabe as
president of Zimbabwe after he stole the 2008 election
has been
internationally commended. And he has already said that if the MDC
pulls out
of the GNU, Mugabe will no longer be the legitimate president. His
meeting
with Obama, whose stance on Zimbabwe is similarly principled, will
have
far-reaching consequences. We are holding our breath for that. Zimbabwe's
time must surely come soon.
Zim: mellow days and heady nights
'I have heard Africa described as the continent of abundant life and speedy
death. Like many around the world who love Zimbabwe I am waiting for a
resurrection.'
By Matthew
John Lee
Published: 9:31AM GMT 04 Nov 2009
It was in 1989 that I started to experience a gradually increasing sense of
alarm. Having landed a good first teaching position at a respectable
Northamptonshire comprehensive my future, always somewhat nebulous till then,
suddenly became a lot clearer and I could see myself doing much the same thing
for the next forty years.
It was at this point that I responded to an advertisement in the TES for a
maths teacher in Zimbabwe.
Zimbabwe, the country, conjured up few visions for me as the extent of my
foreign travel up to that point had been the day trip to Boulogne with Townsend
Thoresen.
Arriving in Harare in January 1990, the climate reminded me of the best days
an English summer had to offer. Even the torrential downpours were of no
consequence as they only lasted a short time and were soon replaced by blue
skies.
Harare seemed to me to be a clean, well-ordered city. The shops, if a little
old fashioned, were well stocked with an adequate variety of local goods,
although imported items were difficult to obtain.
The parks were well-tended and contained a profusion of tropical plants and
flowers of intense colour. I preferred however to visit the wide tree-lined
avenues away from the city centre where life was a bit quieter.
The Terreskane Hotel was situated here and, sitting outside on its large
terrace with a busy brai smoking behind, it became a favoured place to enjoy a
Castle (beer). The waiters rushed to serve you at first but quickly lost
interest if you didn’t tip.
My posting was to Murewa High School about ninety kilometres east of Harare.
The road there passed large, white-owned farms as well as rural African
settlements identified by a collection of huts. What struck me was the greenery
- nothing like the dusty, brown landscapes on television reports of Africa.
A German biology teacher was a keen gardener and enthused about how
everything grew in Zimbabwe during the rainy season. Each teacher’s house had
its own plot of maize plants, which could grow a foot in one week, and a chicken
coop to provide a daily supply of eggs.
Murewa High School was well-equipped and well built. It overlooked a huge
dome-shaped granite mountain, which never ceased to inspire awe during the daily
assemblies held outside.
The government of Robert Mugabe had made education a priority and devoted 25
per cent of the national budget to it. At the time I couldn’t help marvelling at
this noble policy. The desire for education permeated all sections of society
and the students showed a real passion for learning.
This is not to say that the school was without problems: class sizes could
reach sixty and there was little alternative to the Cambridge O' and A' levels.
Corporal punishment was commonplace and soon after arriving the deputy
headteacher visited my class, bunsen burner rubber tubing in hand, to deal with
those students who hadn’t completed their homework.
After that I attempted to introduce a system of detention but this had
limited success since African children are quite used to standing around for
long periods doing nothing. I received the distinct impression that the rather
bemused students sitting in silence in my classroom during the afternoon didn’t
realize that they were being punished.
This was teaching stripped down to its bare bones: no long curriculum
meetings, cross-curricular links, brain-based learning or multiple
intelligences. It is interesting to speculate how much the Zimbabwean students
were affected by the absence of these. Being a teacher on the international
circuit, I will not commit professional suicide by attempting to answer that
question. What I will say, however, is that teachers were not as stressed as
those I have observed in more developed schools despite the large numbers of
students they were teaching.
At the time the government was held in high esteem internationally. Of course
there was corruption and inefficiency, ample fodder for disaffected Africans to
complain, or for the "Rhodies" to say "I told you so".
But that being said, the country seemed to work: it was more or less at peace
and you never saw anyone without enough to eat. The last vestiges of white
minority rule could still be glimpsed. It was the kind of society where, as a
hitch hiker, a white driver would offer me dinner and a place to sleep. At the
same time black workers would be sat in the back of a pick up during a heavy
downpour, without it occurring to the driver to offer any kind of shelter.
I would often walk with my fellow teacher, Shingirai, to Murewa township
after work. Our route took us first to Matamba bottle store, which technically
being a shop was not supposed to host us. The lure of the cheapest, coldest beer
in town however was irrestible and only occasionally did the police turn up to
pour away our Castle and quiz the owner why he owned a bottle opener as we ran
for cover.
It didn’t pay them however to be too zealous in their duty, especially if
they wanted to drink there later. Shingirai told of raids in Harare where law
enforcement officials beat inebriated patrons with batons.
The greatest commodity Africa seemed to possess was time. There was time to
enjoy each other’s company and time to sit on the low concrete wall outside
Matamba’s bottle store to gaze at the silhouettes of flat-topped, spindly trees
set against the darkening sky. Later on we would make the short trip to Gapara
night spot where there was music, dancing and women. A fight tended to break out
there about once a week.
I remember one colleague, Mr Gutsa, who had been prohibited from drinking by
a witchdoctor. When he visited Matamba’s evil spirits took possession of him
with a force proportional to the amount of alcohol consumed. By the time he
reached Gapara night spot he was out of control and hurling insults at everyone.
One Monday he didn’t show up at school. Last seen boarding a bus after
drinking in his home area, there was speculation that members of the Central
Intelligence Organisation had been fellow passengers and had taken exception to
his comments. Shingirai would slowly drink his Castle and wistfully say: "Those
people can make you disappear."
Many of my friends from those days are now dead. The farms aren’t as verdant
as they once were but I don’t know whether Gapara night spot still hums to the
music of James Chimombe.
I have heard Africa described as the continent of abundant life and speedy
death. Like many around the world who love Zimbabwe I am waiting for a
resurrection.