"The Zimbabwe Situation" news page

Back to Index

Back to the Top
Back to Index


Zimbabwe Dismisses Speculation Mugabe ill
HARARE, Sept 5 (Reuters) -
Zimbabwe government officials dismissed on Tuesday reports that President Robert Mugabe collapsed in Libya while travelling to a U.N. General Assembly in New York.
"Contrary to the rumours flying around, the president is in good health," said a senior official who declined to be named.
The independent Daily News quoted presidential spokesman George Charamba as dispelling speculation on Sunday that Mugabe had collapsed and died in Libya.
"That is not true at all. Unfortunately we seem to have a lot of April fools around. He is well enough to attend the funerals of those April fools," Charamba told the newspaper.
Charamba was not available for comment on Tuesday.
Foreign exchange traders said talk of Mugabe's alleged ill-health was swirling around the market, but had not affected the Zimbabwe dollar, whose trading rate against the U.S. dollar has been managed since January 1999.
"The talk is there, but it has not had an impact on the dollar which is being managed and at any rate traditionally does not react to politics," a dealer said.
A stockbroker said the speculation had not affected the equities market because "no one is really taking it seriously."
The official Herald newspaper reported that Mugabe arrived in New York on Monday.
Mugabe, 76, has ruled the southern African state since independence in 1980 and denies charges that his ZANU-PF government has brought a once-vibrant economy to its knees through rampant mismanagement.
His controversial plans to seize white-owned commercial farms to resettle black peasants are seen as damaging the key agriculture sector which is already threatened by illegal farm occupations by war veterans enjoying Mugabe's support.
Some political analysts say he is likely to retire before his six-year presidential term expires in 2002, but Mugabe has always refused to say what his plans are, or to discuss a possible successor.
African Leaders to Meet Annan, Discuss Flash Points
UNITED NATIONS, (Reuters) - Four African presidents meet U.N. Secretary-General Kofi Annan Tuesday to discuss flash points in the world's poorest continent, debt relief and the scourge of HIV/AIDS, diplomats said.

The presidents, meeting in advance of the U.N. Millennium Summit Tuesday, the largest gathering of world leaders in history, intend to review the many-sided war in the Congo, as well as festering conflicts in Angola and Sierra Leone.

But talks on the Democratic Republic of the Congo will yield little or nothing in the absence of its president, Laurent Kabila, who is not coming to New York.

Meeting Annan are Presidents Thabo Mbeki of South Africa, Bakili Muluzi of Malawi as well as Sam Nujoma of Namibia and Robert Mugabe of Zimbabwe, who have sent troops to the Congo.

Mbeki will later chair an 11-member committee of heads of government to review the role and operations of the Commonwealth, a grouping of mainly English-speaking countries, most of them former British colonies.

The committee which also includes India, New Zealand, Tanzania and Australia, has a mandate to ensure the Commonwealth's relevance in the 21st century.

Zimbabwe's controversial land policy, which has seen more than 1,000 white-owned farms illegally occupied by self-styled veterans of the country's 1970s liberation war will also be discussed at the meeting with Annan, African diplomats said.

"Zimbabwe is on the agenda and the idea is to see how the United Nations can help with an organized land redistribution program in the country," a diplomat said.

"The African leaders will also convey to Annan the views of the southern African region with regards to the land crisis in Zimbabwe," he added.


Leaders of the 14-nation Southern African Development Community (SADC) last month mandated Mbeki and Muluzi to spearhead an African campaign to obtain international funding for Zimbabwe's controversial land redistribution program.

At least 31 people, mostly opposition supporters and five white farmers, were killed during the farm invasions and in a wave of violence across Zimbabwe before a general election in June that Mugabe's ruling ZANU-PF narrowly won.

Former colonial power Britain says it will not fund land reform in Zimbabwe until the invasions are ended and Harare returned to the rule of law. The U.N. Development Program (UNDP) has expressed similar views.

Rebel leaders said they were looking to the United Nations to rescue Congo's collapsing peace deal and avert a resumption of full-scale war in Africa's third largest country.

Implementation of the Congo deal has stalled over Kabila's rejection of a U.N. deployment in the Congo and the choice of an organizer of internal all-party talks, former Botswana President Ketumile Masire.

A U.N. Security Council statement that may be adopted by the Council's 15 members this week's firmly supports the cease-fire agreement signed in the Zambian capital of Lusaka last year. But Kabila wants amendments to the accord, saying the document had been overtaken by events in the Congo.

Kabila now wants direct talks between his government and the government of Burundi, Rwanda and Uganda which back rebels fighting to overthrow him and separate direct talks with the rebels. Rwanda and Uganda have rejected Kabila's latest demand.

Annan and the African leaders will also tackle debt relief and AIDS, which has affected 24.5 million Africans out of the world's 34.3 sufferers. Africa needs $3 billion a year to fight the disease.

Debt costs Africa more than $10 billion a year while millions still live on less than $1 a day.

African leaders meet Annan to discuss Zimbabwe
Reuters - Sep 5 2000 2:52PM ET

UNITED NATIONS, (Reuters) - Four African presidents started talks with U.N. Secretary-General Kofi Annan Tuesday to discuss Zimbabwe's land program, which has put the former British colony on a collision course with the international community.

The four leaders -- Malawi's Bakili Muluzi, South Africa's Thabo Mbeki, Namibia's Sam Nujoma and Zimbabwe's Robert Mugabe -- will also tackle regional flash points in Africa, debt relief and the scourge of HIV/AIDS, diplomats said.

``This is a regional mini-summit to discuss the land reform program in Zimbabwe,'' Zimbabwe's Information Minister Jonathan Moyo told Reuters shortly before the talks started.

``His excellency (Mugabe) will brief the secretary-general on the Zimbabwean experience and what he thinks is the way forward,'' Moyo added.

Zimbabwe was rocked in February when Mugabe's supporters and self-styled veterans of the country's 1970s liberation war began seizing land from white farmers.

At least 31 people, including 26 opposition activists and five white farmers, were killed during the farm invasions and in a wave of violence across Zimbabwe before a general election in June that Mugabe's ruling ZANU-PF narrowly won.

Mugabe said that the land seizures would continue. To date, Mugabe has served notice that the government plans in the near future to seize 1,952 of 3,041 farms earmarked for the resettlement of landless blacks.

The Commercial Farmers Union, which represents 4,500 mainly white farmers, has lodged objections to plans to acquire 593 farms on a list of 804 properties that the government said in June that it would acquire.

Mugabe's government has started resettling peasants on 211 farms seized under a program to resettle people on about 800 farms before the onset of October rains in the largely agricultural country.

Mugabe has passed controversial legislation allowing him to acquire the farms with no obligation to pay compensation for the land if former colonial power Britain does not provide the funds.

But Britain says it will not fund land reform in Zimbabwe until the invasions are ended and Harare returned to the rule of law. The U.N. Development Program (UNDP) has expressed similar views.


The Zimbabwean leader plans to acquire nearly half the 30 million acres owned by about 4,500 white farmers to resettle peasants as redress for the seizure of land by British colonists more than a century ago.

The International Monetary Fund (IMF) has led other Western donors in suspending key aid to Zimbabwe mainly over the land issue and the country's costly military involvement in the Democratic Republic of the Congo.

Leaders of the 14-nation Southern African Development Community (SADC) in August asked Mbeki and Muluzi to spearhead an African campaign to obtain international funding for Zimbabwe's land redistribution programme.

Moyo said Mugabe would brief Annan on Harare's three-pronged strategy to negotiate with the IMF, the World Bank and the UNDP separately on the crisis facing the country.


The presidents, meeting in advance of the U.N. Millennium Summit Tuesday, the largest gathering of world leaders in history, intend to review the many-sided war in the Congo, as well as festering conflicts in Angola and Sierra Leone.

Zimbabwe, Angola and Namibia have deployed troops in the Congo against an array of rebel groups backed by Burundi, Rwanda and Uganda.

Zimbabwe's Finance Minister Simba Makoni revealed a week ago that the war had cost cash-strapped Harare more than $200 million in the past two years.

Analysts have said Zimbabwe -- suffering its worst economic crisis in decades which has shown itself in acute fuel, electricity and foreign currency shortages -- could not sustain its military presence in the former Zaire much longer.

But talks on the Congo will yield little or nothing in the absence of its president, Laurent Kabila, who was not coming to New York.

Mbeki will later chair an 11-member committee of heads of government to review the role and operations of the Commonwealth, a grouping of mainly English-speaking countries, most of them former British colonies.

Annan and the leaders will also tackle debt relief and AIDS, which has hit 24.5 million Africans out of the world's 34.3 sufferers. Africa needs $3 billion a year to fight the disease.

Back to the Top
Back to Index


5 September 2000

In this issue :

From The Star(SA), 5 Sptember

Tired Mugabe 'collapses' three times - report

Harare - President Robert Mugabe has been unwell and has collapsed three times during the last few weeks, an authoritative source in the Zimbabwean president's office disclosed. But others in Mugabe's office dismissed reports of his ill-health as "cheap beerhall talk". The source in Mugabe's office said Mugabe's doctors had advised him not to travel to New York for the United Nations Millennium Summit this week, but he insisted on going so he could personally fight against the Zimbabwe Democracy Bill, now under consideration in the United States Congress. The bill calls for sanctions against Mugabe's government because of its human rights violations. "The president (Mugabe) has been sick. It's mainly due to fatigue and exhaustion," an authoritative source said.

Mugabe is reported to have collapsed and been unconscious in his hotel room during a conference in Maputo over a week ago. He collapsed twice more while in Libya over the weekend, and was later taken to Paris for medical treatment en route to New York, where he arrived on Monday. Rumours about Mugabe's health have been circulating for some time in Zimbabwe, and the nation almost came to a standstill on Saturday after a rumour that he had had a stroke in Libya. The source in the presidency said, however, that the cause of Mugabe's collapses was not a stroke. Presidential spokesperson George Charamba dismissed all the reports as "cheap beerhall talk", insisting that Mugabe is "as fit as a fiddle".

From The Economist, 2-8 September

Zimbabwe's non-farmers - Robert Mugabe's accelerated land-reform program will be a disaster if its primary motive is to reward party loyalists.

Wakefield Farm, Manicaland - It was a rollicking party. Robert Mugabe, Zimbabwe's president, arrived in one of his helicopters. Cows were slaughtered, beer gushed, crowds danced and ululated, and television cameras recorded the joyful event for posterity. The occasion was the resettlement of 51 black families on Wakefield "A", a large commercial farm, bought by the government from willing sellers two years ago. The aim was to build a class of successful, independent black farmers in Zimbabwe. The government promised the new smallholders seeds, fertiliser and all the help necessary to get them started. It then forgot about them. The farmers, most of whom knew little or nothing of farming, got no advice, support or equipment. A local white commercial farmer, Andrew Dawson, stepped in. He offered to plough his new neighbours' fields with his tractor and supply them with fertiliser. When their crops were ready, he said, they could repay him, interest-free, in maize. Although his offer was taken up by 12 farmers, only one or two are likely to be able to repay the debt. Most of the 51 plots have produced little or no crop, and the land is now largely derelict.

Wild grasses have reclaimed what were once prime tobacco fields. Many of the resettlers have drifted away. This is the land-reform programme that Mr Mugabe is now seeking to accelerate. Everyone agrees that land reform is necessary in Zimbabwe. Commercial farmers continually suggest practical ways in which it might be carried out. Foreign donors offer to finance orderly reform. The farms that were redistributed in the early 1980s turned many peasants into successful smallholders. But, at that time, the beneficiaries were selected carefully and received material support. Now, they are chosen not for their farming skills but for their loyalty to the ruling party, ZANU-PF. Mr Mugabe's motives are political, not economic. Incomes have fallen by a third under his rule, and he feared that the voters would show their displeasure by rejecting ZANU at the parliamentary election in June. So he decided to inflame the land issue. In thunderous speeches, he urged his people to reclaim the soil that white colonialists stole from them a century ago, reminding them that whites, despite being less than 1% of the population, still own about 70% of the best farmland. He organised a series of "spontaneous" invasions of white-owned properties, selecting farmers who were known to support the opposition MDC. The 10,000-14,000 invaders - veterans of the country's wars and assorted bruisers - prevented the opposition from campaigning in much of the countryside. Paid and transported by the secret services, they moved from farm to farm, beating suspected MDC supporters, burning their huts and occasionally killing them.

After the election, Mr Mugabe wanted to reward his foot-soldiers and punish his enemies. On July 31st, the government announced that over 3,000 farms, up from a previous target of 804, would be seized without compensation and distributed among the landless. This represents more than half the country's commercial farmland. The government insisted that the farms selected would be largely idle, belonging to absentee landlords, or else adjacent to crowded communal land. The full list has not yet been released, but the 1,500 or so addresses published so far include many thriving exporters. Once again, farmers who actively support the MDC appear to have been singled out. The beneficiaries of land reform are supposed to be the needy. But Obert Mpofu, the governor of Matabeleland North, a province where the opposition won all seven seats in June, has openly admitted that only ZANU supporters will benefit. A few hundred handover ceremonies have taken place since the election, some of them consisting of war veterans picking bottle-tops out of a hat to decide who will receive which plot.

The government promises to provide the new farmers with infrastructure and support. Maybe it will, but its record suggests it will not. Mr Mugabe's stated aim is to resettle 500,000 families - about a sixth of the population - before the rains start in November. In other words, he hopes to achieve in two months more than he has in 20 years, and to do it without donor support and despite the government's near-bankruptcy. The scheme imperils the whole economy. Mr Dawson, for example, has heard that the government may soon seize his farm. If it does, his 300 black employees and their 1,500 dependants face destitution. All over the country multitudes of farmworkers are to be displaced to make way for smaller numbers of ZANU loyalists. Banks hesitate to lend to farmers whose collateral could be confiscated tomorrow. Newly-resettled farmers also lack secure title to their land, and have even less chance of raising capital to develop it. Output is shrinking, and with it the industries that supply, or buy from, farmers: fertiliser wholesalers, bakeries, tractor-repair shops and so on. Probably more than half of Zimbabwean industry depends on agriculture.

The country's nature reserves are threatened, too. Chunks of the Save Valley conservancy have been earmarked for resettlement, although the area is unsuitable for farming. An influx of veterans with a taste for game has depleted wildlife stocks and scared off tourists. To make snares, the poachers tear down the wire fences that keep wild animals away from cattle farms. This threatens beef exports: European Union rules bar mixing cattle with beasts that may have foot-and-mouth disease. The government devalued the Zimbabwe dollar by 24% in August, and promises further devaluation, hoping to boost exports and so raise sorely-needed hard currency. But shortages of imports, such as fuel, have yet to ease. Motorists queue for hours for petrol; housewives battle for paraffin for their stoves. The government's foreign debts go unpaid and its domestic ones are met by printing money. Cash machines in Harare spill out wads of notes with consecutive serial numbers. Hyperinflation looms. Clear thinkers within the ruling party have tried to warn Mr Mugabe of the consequences of his actions. He refuses to listen. The main hope seems to be that incompetence will slow the execution of his policies.

From The Daily News, 4 September

Msika's farm under-utilised

AS Vice-President Joseph Msika officially opened this year's Harare Agricultural Show at the Exhibition Park on Saturday, The Daily News visited his 80-hectare farm in the rich farming belt of Glendale in Chiweshe described as under-utilised by his workers and neighbouring farmers. Msika bought the farm in 1980 with a loan from the then Agricultural Finance Corporation, now Agribank. The farm is about 100 km outside Harare, and is visited by its owner at least once a month. He had been there a few minutes before The Daily News crew arrived on Saturday.

Msika is also chairman of the government's land acquisition committee. More than half of the vast farm is not fully utilised. It stands in sharp contrast with nearby properties where lush green foliage suggests thriving commercial farming. A farm manager at a commercial farm near Msika's, John Chituku, said: "Most of the land is arable but he is using it for grazing and that explains a lot to a farmer. The farm doesn't seem to be properly managed." Indeed, Msika does not have a qualified farm manager and does not even have a house to accommodate the manager. He started to build one but it did not rise beyond window level. The house now lies in ruins, submerged in tall grass, on a neglected part of the farm.

While his white neighbours have tried to provide decent housing for their staff, Msika has failed to adequately cater for his. The houses are in a sorry state and badly need refurbishment. The compound is filthy. The general state of the farm does not reflect ownership by one of the most influential and powerful people in a government engaged in a massive land redistribution programme. Workers at the farm said they grow tobacco, paprika, potatoes, maize and cotton, but mainly on a small scale. They said there are about 80 cattle on the farm, but complained that Msika did not provide decent houses for them. Msika employs about 25 families while his neighbours have an average of 150 families on their properties. James Sharai, from the nearby village, said they were not many workers at Msika's farm because the Vice-President did not produce much. Most of his labour was from the surrounding Chiweshe communal lands, his original home.

The Daily News saw vast tracts of virgin land at the farm. There was no activity, although neighbouring farmers were busy planting tobacco. The workers at Msika's farm said they would soon prepare the land for tobacco. Most implements are dilapidated and rusty. Workers said they sometimes have to borrow implements and diesel from neighbours. "He just tells us that he will do something about the housing problem but nothing is being done," said one of Msika's workers. "I am living in the tobacco barn together with the farm supervisor." Some of the workers said they regretted working for the Vice-President because he pays them less than what their colleagues at neighbouring farms earn. The workers alleged that they lived under poor conditions. They claimed that a few of them earned at least $2 000 a month, with the majority earning less than that a month.

A commercial farmer in the area said Msika was not practising the type of farming suited to the area. Most farms in the Glendale area were invaded by the war veterans but Msika's farm was spared. Another farmer said he understood that the war veterans wanted to invade Msika's farm but were warned against it. There are war veterans occupying a farm next to Msika's. The farmer said Msika bought the farm in 1980 through a loan provided by the former Agricultural Finance Corporation now operating as Agribank and of late has been finding it difficult to keep up with repayments. The Daily News just missed the Vice-President who had visited the farm earlier in the day. Msika could not be contacted for comment by yesterday evening. He reportedly visits the farm once a month. While officially opening the just ended Harare Agricultural Show, Msika urged farmers to fully utilise their land.

From The Daily News, 4 September

Chombo attacks MDC supporters

A Cabinet minister at the weekend launched an astonishing attack on the opposition MDC, saying its mostly urban supporters should "turn their tarred roads" into land because the Zanu PF government would not give them any. Ignatius Chombo, the Minister of Local Government, Public Works and National Housing, was the second government official to declare in public the government would not include MDC supporters in its land redistribution programme. Obert Mpofu, the governor for Matabeleland North, defeated in his Bubi-Umguza constituency by an MDC candidate, stunned the country last month when he said MDC supporters would have to wait for their own party to come to power because they would not get any land from the Zanu PF government.

Chombo was speaking at Maungwa business centre in Gutu South at celebrations led by Shuvai Mahofa, the victorious Zanu PF MP for the constituency. Chombo said MDC supporters, most of them in the urban areas, should convert the tarred roads into land. "They were clamouring for change and now we are saying turn the tarred roads in the urban areas into land," he said. Chombo said the government would thwart any fresh farm invasions because it was convinced that MDC supporters were behind them. He said landless villagers had moved onto the farms before the June election and those doing so now were MDC supporters, not genuine land-hungry villagers. "We are saying 'No' to fresh invasions. We have discovered that those who are invading farms are MDC supporters and we are going to chase them away. Our genuine land-hungry people went into the farms before the election and they should remain there," said Chombo. He said Zanu PF survived near defeat in the election. "The country nearly went into the wrong hands. Our party nearly fell. We have to thank the war veterans for their role in the election period," he said.

From The Daily News, 4 September

MDC presses for ZBC coverage of Parliament

THE opposition MDC is pushing for a mandatory live radio and television transmission of all parliamentary sessions by the State-owned ZBC. David Coltart, the MDC shadow minister for justice and constitutional affairs, last week tabled a notice in Parliament to move a motion on the ZBC. He said it was desirable that parliamentary debates be seen and heard by as many Zimbabweans as possible so that they are kept accurately informed about issues facing the nation. He said: "It is common practice throughout the world that parliamentary debates are broadcast live by radio and television. No such coverage is presently given by the ZBC." Coltart said Parliament should resolve that the government and the ZBC be called upon to conduct, with immediate effect, live television and radio transmissions of all parliamentary proceedings, particularly the parliamentary Question Time set aside on Wednesday each week. The ZBC has only provided live coverage on special occasions such as the official opening of Parliament by President Mugabe, the presentation of the national budget and the state of the nation address, again by the President. Since the Fifth Parliament opened in July, ZBC news crews have turned up to cover parliamentary business only on two occasions. The Speaker of Parliament, Emmerson Mnangagwa recently threw out a ZBC news team after complaints by MPs that the state-funded network was filming "favoured" MPs.


Mvurwi - The manager of Forrester Section I has received a written death threat with a bullet enclosed, demanding $200 000 by Friday. If not paid either he will be shot or his children will be kidnapped.  It is unknown whether this is connected to the war vet activity.  Police have been informed and are investigating.
Mazowe/Concession - Cardiff Farm, Amatola Farm and Summersdale Farm were visited and pegged.
Harare West/Nyabira - Three vehicles with an unknown number of people visited Calgary Farm forced the labour to sing.
Marondera - On Friday Wilfred Marimo told the labour on Chipesa to leave the farm as with them still there, Iain Kay would return to the farm. Two tractor loads were taken off the farm with their property. Some of the labour went home, and some waited at Igava to see what would develop. Today they are all back on the farm,
Harare South - On Dunnotar there is continued house building on one of the tobacco lands.  About 200 people were rushing around Stoneridge waving Friday's newspaper around and telling the labour not to go to work on Saturday as the farm is now theirs. The tractor drivers were told to get out of the land and to stop ploughing or else their tractors would be burnt.
Wedza - All work has been stopped on Rapako. The Member in Charge claims that he cannot do anything about it as it is a political issue, despite the recent directive from the Taskforce.
Enterprise - The base commanders attended the meeting with Hunzvi.
Bromley/Ruwa - On Sunday occupiers from Nyamasanga went to Leister Farm and told the manager they would be bringing people to occupy the farm on Monday. They wanted the cattle moved from the paddocks in which they were going to settle.
Macheke/Virginia - Occupiers on Castledene Pines have threatened the labour if they do not leave the farm. They have also put up a sign saying that the farm is a no go area. The farm now belongs to the war vets. They then went onto Chikambukwe and are pegging. Propol has been informed and the MIC has asked that this is dealt with at a higher level as the war vets are in direct confrontation with the law as the Section 8 Orders were lifted by the High Court of Zimbabwe. 
Nothing to report. 
Norton - The situation appears relatively quiet.  On one property there was a visit by Zanu PF making demands, but the situation is stable.
Selous - On Mount Carmel hut building continues as it does on Wicklow Estates.  Police are not interested.  War veterans are paying people to build huts and there are reports of attempted extortion from the war veterans. 
Chegutu/Suri Suri - There have been new occupations on The Grange and Aitape.  Police say that they can do nothing as the original directive from PGHQ regarding new invasions has been rescinded.  On San Fernando war veterans are threatening to drive cattle through the paprika which is currently being planted out. On Just Right, Gilbert Moyo has given the owner one week to vacate his home.  A Rio Tinto lorry has been seen carting wood off the property into Kadoma. 
Kadoma - There are reportedly 2 00 people on Protea and White Water and new occupations on Wiltshire, Coronation and other properties.  On Milverton Estates there are still 200 cattle missing and more going missing each day.  The owner is going to have to bring all cattle into the feed pen area for security reasons . 
Chakari -  On Blackmorvale there are now 660 permanent houses and many other shelters.
The situation remains the same in the Province - tree cutting and the building of structures continue throughout, and there are many veld fires in Masvingo East and Central.
Nothing to report. 
No report. 
Lower Gweru - On Yorkshire Farm 100 acres of maize lands in the process of being reaped have been burnt. The fire is being fought at the time of writing. The fire originated in the area where the war vet housing is.

Public Beat Up Police in Zimbabwe


Zimbabwean police officers are in trouble with the public, and are blaming the law for it.

The law allows the public to ask police officers for their official identity cards, and many of them do not have them because the machine, which prints the IDs, is broken down.

There is only one machine, which prints the cards in the country.

For weeks, offending members of the public have been able to get away with their offences, and sometimes even put police officers on the receiving end of mob justice, for failing to produce their official identity cards.

By law, every police officer is required to carry his or her official identity card while on duty, but newly graduated officers have been deployed without the IDs because spare parts for the machine cannot be procured due to lack of foreign currency.

More and more Zimbabweans are asking police officers, even those driving clearly marked official vehicles, to produce their IDs, and those unable to produce these are subjected to instant mob justice on suspicion they were mere criminals masquerading as police officers.




Watching the Rocks Grow-White guilt and black hypocrisy

The Voyager

FOR any vaguely sentient individual living in Zimbabwe, the matter and
question of racism must constitute a topic on which an opinion needs to
be formed, with emphasis on the 'needs'. Examples of racism from which
to develop such an opinion would appear, at first glance, to be
available in abundance. The problem with emotive examples is that they
are exactly that, emotive, and any form of in depth questioning tends to
get no further than the socio-political, ritualistic sloganeering and
reverse racism that is this country's legacy from, not Ian Smith, but
the swarms of knee-jerk pseudo-liberals that have infested Zimbabwe
since independence.

A recent column by The Daily News' Bill Saidi on racism has raised a
number of points, and presented a perspective that requires some
alternative opinion.

A number of the more obscene examples of local racism have been
mentioned within this column, usually in the context of an argument
against destructive behaviour on the part of whites. However, one
example of the brutal reality of racism that has stayed with Voyager
across the years appears, initially, to be less emotionally violent
than, say, the image of a white man urinating in a black man's mouth in
the name of genetic superiority.

It was the description, from the person involved, of his first childhood
experience of racism.

A CHILD (black) was waiting on a railway station with his mother. This
would be about 45 years ago. The child, eyes wide and fascinated by the
bustle and sounds, awed by a previous sighting of the enormity of a
gigantic steam locomotive with its roaring, hissing exhibition of
apparent life, wandered up onto a platform, totally absorbed by this
alien environment. Suddenly, without any warning, the child was dealt a
stunning blow across the side of his head, a blow that literally sent
him reeling. "Get out the way you f****** kaffir, get off the platform
now!", screamed a white porter with a baggage trolley. The child ran
crying to his mother, and they both moved quickly away.

The memory that stayed with the child into adulthood was not just of the
blow, but of his frantic bewilderment, his frightened questioning of his
mother, that foundation around which his life revolved. "Why? What
happened, and why?", he innocently questioned his mother, who could not
answer, and the boy realised there were things in life that his mother
could not protect him from. So, a child scarred for life, which is one
thing, and a mother humiliated and terrorised in the most painful
circumstance possible for her, as she saw her child beaten and
terrified, yet could do nothing about it.

A painful episode in a man's life, and it is interesting to note that
this man today argues strongly against racism, rather than, say, leading
a marauding band of war vets onto a white farmer's land.

This story, then, reaches to the fundamentals of why civilised society
rejects the principle of racism in any manner or form.

But does this example, and all the other examples of racist violence,
constitute some form of indictment of the white race, a factual proof of
how despicable whites are, and, obviously the implicit flip side of the
coin, how despicable blacks are not?

WHILE those neurotic members of the white tribe whose main purpose and
indulgence in life is to find excuses to feel guilty about the colour of
their skins would leap at the opportunity to enjoy some breast-beating,
attention-grabbing, self-flagellation, the facts of the matter present a
somewhat different picture.

Voyager once used the example of a writers meeting to show the dangerous
folly of setting artificial standards for the short-term sake of
mouthing a slogan. A comment from Voyager about the 'fact' that Zimbabwe
had no history of the development of writing in any defined form, and
thus had not developed, for example, technology to any degree, was met
from the floor with a vehement claim that such a statement was 'racist'.

In other words, to say that a particular culture had not developed
writing, was to define that culture as inferior, according to the
dread-locked black man in the audience. This spokesman for black Africa,
not Voyager, was defining cultures without a history of writing skills
as inferior, which therefore applies to Zimbabwe. Whose, therefore, was
the racist perspective? And if brutality to men women and children,
ethnic cleansing, murder and the deliberate scrapping of human rights in
the name of greed for money and power; if systematic rape, and the
killing and mutilating of children, if all these parameters are going to
be applied to the whites of Africa as an assessment of their worthiness
as human beings, then so be it. However, black Africa must be prepared
to be judged by exactly the same standards, and on that set of
parameters, Black Africa is an ongoing horror story, unparalleled in
human history in terms of its consistency, and the whites of Africa are
the last best hope for any so-called African Renaissance.

WHICH brings us onto Mr Saidi's article on racism, which may be a racist

Saidi appears to be somewhat annoyed because a group of whites in South
Africa have put their perspective up on a Website, and "are insulting
blacks by apologising for everything they say they did for us in 90
years of colonialism. They cite education, health, the economy,
agriculture and industrialisation. They then suggest that, if they
could, they would take all these contributions back, and "leave them
(blacks) where we found them". Mr Saidi responds to this by giving a
somewhat potted account of his understanding of just how worthless a
group of people, whites have been historically-whilst carefully saying
that anti-white racism is as bad as anti-black, and comments that these
"insults (on the Website).......are particularly sickening and

Insults? Since when has putting an opinion opposing a prevailing and
hypocritical set of, in this case, anti-white slogans insulting? Are
these people suddenly Nazis because they feel there is a bit more to the
history of white Africans than is presently being put forward on a daily

Voyager would like get this straight; Whites have been and are being
insulted every single day on the basis of their so-called colonial
barbarity, by black Africans whose degree of ongoing barbarity across
most of non-Arabic Africa is consistently increasing on a daily basis.

WHITES are being pilloried, daily, because at the time of colonising
Africa they did not extend to the indigenous people, the spectrum of
social structures that today are called human rights, social structures
that were only just being developed within their own societies, for
their own ethnic grouping, yet somehow, according to Black Africa, these
principles should have been immediately applied.

'One Man One Vote', for example, when that had not even been properly
implemented in Europe and England. There should, apparently, have been
no exploitation of the uneducated African, at a time when uneducated
whites-the majority of people in England-where being flogged, sentenced
to life on a penal colony for stealing bread when starving, and sold as
'indentured' servants. And because these structures were not immediately
implemented for the poor little Africans, somehow whites have committed
some generationally constant and absolute sin. What hypocritical,
sloganeering nonsense. And, by the way, what was the human rights
situation in Africa before the colonists came? Or is that one of those
awkward questions that must be 'racist' if they are asked?

But let's ask it again in a different form, just for interest, and
consider slavery- that other good old reliable excuse for touting
self-pity as an excuse for failure. Here is a nice simple question: Who
was selling the bulk of the slaves to the slave traders? What colour
were they, what continent did they reside on? This is a topic that been
conveniently ignored in the mindless white-bashing rhetoric that has
come to pass for Black Africa's thought process. Britain demanded the
implementation of majority rule for Rhodesia, and then imposed harsh and
effective sanctions on Rhodesia because Smith would not acknowledge the
need for change. The change that was argued for, indeed insisted upon by
Britain, was for the benefit of the black population of this country,
obviously not-surely it is obvious to any honest observer-for the
benefit of a handful of whites that were totally out of step with their
parent culture.

Black Africa is drowning in hypocrisy.

ACROSS this continent pathetic losers are relying on the whining theme
of: "Oh! We had such a hard time when we were colonised. Give us some
money, please Baas, Oh Thank you, Ishe!", instead of doing what every
other successful society has done throughout history, and that is work
to build its own success.

For any Black African to indulge in masturbatory moral high-grounding on
the basis of 'colonial brutality' is pathetic hypocrisy.

Africa, now, today, after all the billions of dollars of aid money, and
the introduction, time and time again, from the whites, of the
principles of human rights and dignities, the very concepts that these
mewing parasites constantly bleat should have been present during the
colonial period, after all this principled and honest endeavour by
principled and honest whites, Africa is a cesspit of brutality and
barbarism. With all this postured moral finger-pointing at the whites,
what is the reality of Black Africa's immediate history, and what has
actually been achieved, in terms of the moral worthiness that these
talking heads claim as a foundation for moral outrage against the

ANSWERS to those questions may begin to be found with the limbless
infants of Sierra Leone, and any honest African can then move North and
East from there without running out of material in a lifetime, and all
this African history-reality-has been written in blood and terror
without the convenient benefit of resident colonials to blame for the
continually disgusting behaviour of blacks to blacks.

Before Mr Saidi or anyone else starts pointing moral fingers at the
whites of Africa, thus defining certain standards of worthiness, he
should look to the worthiness of his own ethnic grouping, as it stands
right now, not even with reference to the past, and see if he is
honestly able to cast the first or any stones.


L.A. Times.com Friday, August 25, 2000 By ROBIN WRIGHT, Times Staff

African Renaissance' Hailed by Clinton Now a Distant Memory

WASHINGTON--Forty years after the first wave of independence sparked
great hopes for the continent, Africa faces a bleaker future than at
any time in the past century, according to a recent U.S. intelligence
assessment, Clinton administration officials and experts on the region.

Just two years ago, during a six-nation tour of the continent,
President Clinton hailed what he called an "African renaissance." But
as he prepares for a quick trip to Nigeria and Tanzania this weekend,
the sub-Saharan region is backsliding on virtually every front.

"The number of simultaneous, multiple crises that the continent faces
right now is unprecedented," said Stephen Morrison, director of African
studies at the Center for Strategic and International Studies, a
Washington think tank. "Africa is in worse condition than ever before.
And it's only going to get worse over the next generation."

The dire situation is outlined in a recent U.S. government assessment
called a National Intelligence Estimate. Its findings were echoed in
interviews with administration officials and other experts.
Politically, only eight of sub-Saharan Africa's 48 countries fully
embrace pluralism. And all eight are still hobbled by corruption, weak
leadership and chronic deterioration of basic education and health

The problem is not just one-party governments and autocratic regimes;
some states are imploding. "Even if you hold a free election in a
collapsed state and elect a Nelson Mandela, he'll be doomed to failure
if there's no government structure," said Pauline Baker, president of
the Fund for Peace, an independent research and advocacy group here.
"One man alone can't rule without institutions, many of which have
eroded since independence."

The limited good news is that two sub-Saharan giants--Nigeria and South
Africa?? - are gradually making the transition to democracy, U.S.
officials say. To varying degrees, so are Senegal, Mali, Malawi,
Tanzania, Botswana and Namibia, although none is a strong enough
regional power to have much impact.

But two key states with long records of Western-oriented policies and
market-based economies have experienced serious setbacks. Ivory Coast,
which boasts sub-Saharan Africa's third-largest economy and was once
considered an island of regional stability, underwent a military coup
last Christmas Eve.

Similarly, Kenya was once seen as a potential regional model and engine
of change, partly because it has the ports and transportation needed to
link African trade with the outside world. But political conditions
there have steadily deteriorated, making it a symbol of the continent's
failures. In the capital, Nairobi, there are an estimated 100,000
street children, according to U.S. figures.

Militarily, about half the nations in sub-Saharan Africa are engaged
either in open conflict or heated disputes, some with internal factions
and some with neighboring states. Ethnic and religious strife is
rampant, producing some of the world's worst cases of genocide,
particularly in Central and East Africa.

The government chiefs of Ethiopia and Eritrea, heralded by the Clinton
administration in 1998 as leaders of the future, have since dragged
their countries into war. "Even the 'new' leaders, hailed by some in
the international community for bringing better leadership to places
like Uganda, Rwanda and Ethiopia, entrenched their positions through
tactics that differed little from their more authoritarian neighbors,"
Human Rights Watch, an international monitoring group, concludes in its
latest annual report.

The breakdown or deterioration of numerous governments has left vast
swaths of Africa without any state presence. Regarded as a continent of
promise and adventure in the 1960s and 1970s, it is now considered a
dangerous place for both inhabitants and visitors as economic
desperation spawns widespread crime, according to the National
Intelligence Estimate.

Average per capita income in sub-Saharan Africa is $1,600 a year, the
U.N. has reported, making Africa the world's most impoverished region,
even though it has the world's richest array of natural resources, from
oil to diamonds to gold.

When it attained independence in 1957, Ghana had more than $400 million
in foreign exchange reserves and a higher per capita income than South
Korea. Today, it is one of the world's most impoverished nations, with
a per capita income of only $145 a month by some estimates.

Much of Africa's most profitable business activity is illicit. About
30% of the heroin intercepted at U.S. ports of entry, for example, is
seized from African syndicates, according to the State Department.

Corruption is the most pervasive problem, experts say. "New elites are
running the same scams as the colonial powers, only on a broader
scale," said Baker, the Africa specialist at Fund for Peace.

The combination of political deterioration and vast mineral resources
has prompted a new competition to divide up the continent's resources,
exacerbating the economic challenges. Many of today's conflicts, in
fact, are not about ideology, but about control of diamonds, oil or

"The first scramble for Africa was in the late 19th century, when the
Europeans carved out colonies in a race for wealth in resources," Baker
said. "This is the second scramble, only this time it's by the Africans

Competition for Zimbabwe's rich farmland has led to violence and state
seizure of white-owned farms. U.S. officials predict that the crisis
will lead to critical food shortages within six to nine months and
eventually displace 2 MILLION people, including farm workers and their

Socially, Africa's future is jeopardized by demographic changes and
substandard education, according to the National Intelligence Estimate
and regional experts.

More than half of the continent's residents are younger than 15. But
its school systems, from primary through university level, are rapidly
deteriorating. In many countries, average class size has doubled or
even tripled during the past decade. The average number of students per
room in Ugandan schools, for example, has soared from 35 to 100,
according to U.S. figures.

"The degradation of the African education system is one of the major
crises as we look to 2015," said a senior U.S. official who monitors
Africa, speaking on condition of anonymity. "No one wants to 'fess up'
to the fact that there are fewer [students] in schools, and they're
staying in school fewer years...That's going to have a major impact on
leadership potential."

Finally, the AIDS pandemic is taking a staggering toll. Recent
estimates predict that 25% of the continent's more than 700 million
people will have died of acquired immune deficiency syndrome by 2010,
leaving behind 35 million orphans and slashing the region's economy by
a quarter.

The combination of AIDS, resurgent cholera and malaria, and infectious
diseases such as E. coli have caused average life expectancy to decline
to just over 48 years, compared with 76 years in Western industrialized

"Africa has not yet fallen off the edge of the world," the senior
official said. "But the gap between it and the rest of the developing
world is getting wider and wider by the day."


Back to the Top
Back to Index

Back to the Top
Back to Index

Back to the Top
Back to Index

Back to the Top
Back to Index

Back to the Top
Back to Index