The MDC-T released a press statement earlier this morning saying that the police have raided their Avondale based communications office and arrested three officials:
A total of 15 police officers in plain clothes have raided and are currently searching Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai’s communications office in Avondale, Harare.
Early this morning, the police arrested three officials from the PM’s office, Thabani Mpofu, Anna Muzvidziwa and Felix Matsinde. Reasons for the arrests and the whereabouts of three are unknown.
Since then, Beatrice Mtetwa, a lawyer acting on behalf of the MDC for the three arrested, has also been arrested. Her crime? For daring to ask why her client - Thabani Mpofu - has been arrested. She is being held for 'obstructing justice'.
Lydia Polgreen, a journalist for the New York Times has since tweeted that Mtetwa's response to this is to say "Of course the view I take is they have been obstructing me in my duties as a lawyer".
This via the MDC:
Beatrice Mtetwa, a human rights lawyer has been arrested after she tried to make enquiries as to the reason why her client Thabani Mpofu was under arrest.
She is detained at the Harare Central Police Station. Mpofu a senior official in Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai’s office together with Anna Muzvidziwa and Felix Matsinde were arrested early this morning under unclear circumstances.
When Mtetwa tried to understand the reasons for the arrest of her client, Mpofu, she too was arrested for what the police said was obstruction of the course of justice.
The police also raided the offices of the communications office of the Prime Minister in Avondale, Harare.
The whereabouts of Muzvidziwa and Matsinde are not known although it is certain they are in police custody.
Beatrice Mtetwa is an extraordinarily committed and fearless lawyer, always fighting for Zimbabwe's rule of law to be properly upheld. A film has been made about her - the trailer is below:
Beatrice Mtetwa and the Rule of Law-Trailer from Lorie Conway on Vimeo.
Zimbabwe Top Lawyer Arrested Soon After Referendum
17 March 2013
Simon
Muchemwa
A top lawyer, Beatrice Mtetwa, is being held by Harare police after she reacted to early morning raids leading to the arrest of Thabani Mpofu, Principal Director in Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai’s Office, a day after Zimbabweans voted in a constitutional referendum.
Thabani Mpofu, the Principal
Director for Research and Development in Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai’s
office, was taken from his home at 6am.
The police, led by Inspector Mirimbo
from Law and Order Harare Central, later raided the Prime Minister’s office in
Bath Road in Belgravia, leading to the arrest of feisty human rights lawyer. The
police, who did not have a search warrant, are said to have been looking for
shortwave radios.
Mtetwa is being detained at the Harare Central Police Station together with three more MDC-T officials, Anna Muzvidziwa, Felix Matsinde and Worship Dumba who were also arrested early this morning.
Meanwhile Zimbabwe Republic
Police spokesperson Assistant Commissioner Charity Charamba has denied Mtetwa’s
arrest is politically motivated.
During a media briefing at the police head
quarters Charamba said Beatrice Mtetwa went beyond her legal mandate and shouted
at police officers investigating at a crime scene.vResponding to questions
whether the arrests were politically motivated she said: “Where actually an
offence has been committed it is not the police that commit the offence. Police
in this case have responded because the law has been contravened, so there is no
way it can be politically motivated persecution whatever you call
it.”
“Police are actually responding to credible information about offences that have been committed, so if people commit offences and then they start talk about persecution then it’s something else,” Charamba said.
Meanwhile Zimbabwe Lawyers for Human Rights, Jeremiah Bhamu castigated the police for carrying out the arrest at a time when Zimbabwe is waiting for the referendum results. “My point is the timing itself was not the correct time to do so, right now the focus was on the referendum on how free and fair it could be, they could have waited until the referendum results are out,” Bhamu said.
Sound files
Police raid PM’s communications office
http://www.thezimbabwemail.com
Staff Reporter 7 hours 25 minutes
ago
THE MDC-T said Sunday three senior officials from
Prime Minister Morgan
Tsvangirai had been arrested as police confirmed
picking up another party
official in Headlands.
In a statement Sunday,
the party said: “A total of 15 police officers in
plain clothes have raided
and are currently searching Prime Minister Morgan
Tsvangirai’s
communications office in Avondale, Harare.
“Early this morning, the police
arrested three officials from the PM’s
office, Thabani Mpofu, Anna
Muzvidziwa and Felix Matsinde. Reasons for the
arrests and the whereabouts
of three are unknown.”
On Saturday, the MDC-T said gunmen also abducted
Samson Magumura, the party’s
secretary for Headlands, as the country voted
on a new constitution amid
seething political tensions.
However police
later said the gunmen were plainclothes detectives.
Police spokeswoman
Charity Charamba told AFP that Magumura had been arrested
on charges of
attempted murder in connection with a firebomb attack.
He was seized at his
home in Headlands before dawn, according to party
spokesman Douglas
Mwonzora.
"Our district secretary for Headlands was kidnapped this morning.
He was
taken from his home by armed people," Mwonzora told AFP. Magumura's
whereabouts remain unknown.
The MDC suggested his assailants, four armed
men driving a white four wheel
drive, where linked to President Robert
Mugabe's Zanu PF party.
The incident came as polls opened in a key referendum
on a new constitution
that would curb Mugabe's powers and pave the way for
fresh elections.
A "yes" vote is widely expected but political tensions
seethed beneath the
surface.
The new constitution would for the first
time put a definite, if distant,
end date on Mugabe's 33-year rule.
A
general election slated for later this year is likely to end that often
acrimonious power-sharing arrangement between Mugabe and
Tsvangirai.
Rights groups fear the government harassment seen ahead of the
referendum
vote could be a prelude to a more serious crackdown on opponents
in the
run-up to the general election.
Observers also fear there will not
be enough time to apply all the necessary
reforms to ensure a healthier
political environment before the next
elections.
Zim police charge lawyer with 'obstructing justice'
http://mg.co.za/
17 MAR 2013 19:41 -
SAPA-AP
Zimbabwe police arrested the country's most prominent
rights lawyer and four
senior officials with the prime minister's party on
Sunday, a day after the
nation voted in a referendum on a new constitution
that calls for more
protection against human rights violations.
Prime
Minister Morgan Tsvangirai's chief legal adviser, Thabani Mpofu, is
accused
of impersonating police by compiling dossiers on unspecified crimes,
a
police official said.
Mtetwa was called to an address in Harare where
police were searching an
office used by Mpofu and began "shouting at
officers and preventing them
from doing their duties", police official
Charity Charamba said on Sunday.
She said all of those arrested were
being held for questioning on Sunday.
Police had been instructed to search
the offices of a private group, the
Democratic Alliance of Zimbabwe, where
it was believed some information on
alleged crimes was being illegally held,
she said.
Police removed unspecified "exhibits" for evidence against the
group that
they were engaged in police-type investigations, she said.
Witnesses said
computer equipment and mobile phones were
seized.
Democracy and rights groups routinely gather witness accounts of
alleged
crimes and abuses of power in state institutions, including the
police
force, controlled by President Robert Mugabe. Obstructing justice and
impersonating police officers carry a penalty of imprisonment or a
fine.
Search warrant
Witnesses said on Sunday that Mtetwa demanded
that police produce a search
warrant at the suburban house used by Mpofu.
Officers accused her of trying
to take photographs of a security detail on
her mobile phone and she was
forced into a police vehicle, the witnesses
said.
Mtetwa has won an array of awards from international bodies,
including the
American Bar Association and the European Bar Human Rights
Institute, during
her legal career of three decades. She has represented
Prime Minister Morgan
Tsvangirai and his supporters in high profile cases
where she has accused
police of the wrongful arrest and detention of
Mugabe's perceived opponents
without sufficient evidence.
Mpofu is a
senior attorney who is the head of the research and development
department
in the prime minister's office.
Police on Sunday also raided and searched
Harare offices of Tsvangirai's
media and communications unit. Three other
members of Tsvangirai's personal
staff were arrested on Sunday morning, the
independent Zimbabwe Lawyers for
Human Rights said.
They were
identified as Warship Dumba, Felix Manditse and Annah Muzvidziwa,
all close
aides of Tsvangirai.
Voting in a referendum on a new constitution ended
late Saturday. All main
party leaders called for a "Yes" vote on
constitutional reforms.
Another official of the former opposition party,
the Movement for Democratic
Change, was arrested before polling began on
Saturday. No reasons were
immediately given for the arrest by four armed
police of Sampson Magunise, a
party organiser in eastern Zimbabwe, but
Charamba said on Sunday he was a
suspect in an alleged gasoline bomb attack
on a the car of a Mugabe party
official.
Zimbabwe's official election
body said on Sunday an estimated 2-million
people cast their vote in a
referendum on a new constitution that seeks to
curb presidential powers and
strengthen human rights.
Judge Rita Makarau, head of the electoral
commission, said the low estimate
came from early returns from the nation's
9 400 polling stations.
Referendum vote
Zimbabwe has an estimated
6.6-million registered voters. Full results from
isolated areas are expected
within five days.
Police enforced a clampdown on rights and pro-democracy
groups in the run-up
to the referendum vote. In recent weeks, police have
seized documents,
equipment and cheap wind-up radio receivers from the
offices of several
rights and pro-democracy groups.
The radio
receivers, capable of receiving broadcasts not controlled by
President
Mugabe's state broadcasting monopoly, were declared illegal by
police under
broadcast regulations.
The broadcasts were used for Mugabe's Zanu-PF
party propaganda and were
intensified around the referendum
vote.
Rights groups have challenged the legality of the radio ban,
arguing that
regular short-wave receivers and satellite television are not
outlawed as
long as they are covered by routine state listeners'
licenses.
Police regularly mount searches without complete warrants
looking for
allegedly subversive materials said to be a threat to national
security.
They insist private rights and media freedom groups are trying
to incite
tensions between political parties ahead of crucial national
elections later
in the year to end a shaky and acrimonious coalition between
Tsvangirai and
Mugabe. The coalition was formed by regional mediators after
the last
violent and disputed elections in 2008. – Sapa-AP
Zimbabwe Police Arrest Pm'S Officials, Top Lawyer
By ANGUS SHAW
— Mar. 17
1:08 PM EDT
HARARE, Zimbabwe (AP) — Zimbabwe police arrested the
country's most
prominent rights lawyer and four senior officials with the
prime minister's
party on Sunday, a day after the nation voted in a
referendum on a new
constitution that calls for more protection against
human rights violations.
Rights lawyer Beatrice Mtetwa is being charged
with allegedly "obstructing
or defeating the course of justice" and Prime
Minister Morgan Tsvangirai's
chief legal adviser, Thabani Mpofu, is accused
of impersonating police by
compiling dossiers on unspecified crimes, a
police official said.
Mtetwa was called to an address in Harare where
police were searching an
office used by Mpofu and began "shouting at
officers and preventing them
from doing their duties," police official
Charity Charamba said Sunday. She
said all of those arrested were being held
for questioning Sunday.
Police had been instructed to search the offices
of a private group, the
Democratic Alliance of Zimbabwe, where it was
believed some information on
alleged crimes was being illegally held, she
said. Police removed
unspecified "exhibits" for evidence against the group
that they were engaged
in police-type investigations, she said. Witnesses
said computer equipment
and mobile phones were seized.
Democracy and
rights groups routinely gather witness accounts of alleged
crimes and abuses
of power in state institutions, including the police
force, controlled by
President Robert Mugabe.
Obstructing justice and impersonating police
officers carry a penalty of
imprisonment or a fine.
Witnesses said
Sunday that Mtetwa demanded that police produce a search
warrant at the
suburban house used by Mpofu. Officers accused her of trying
to take
photographs of a security detail on her mobile phone and she was
forced into
a police vehicle, the witnesses said.
Mtetwa has won an array of awards
from international bodies, including the
American Bar Association and the
European Bar Human Rights Institute, during
her legal career of three
decades. She has represented Prime Minister Morgan
Tsvangirai and his
supporters in high profile cases where she has accused
police of the
wrongful arrest and detention of Mugabe's perceived opponents
without
sufficient evidence.
Mpofu is a senior attorney who is the head of the
research and development
department in the prime minister's office. Police
on Sunday also raided and
searched Harare offices of Tsvangirai's media and
communications unit.
Three other members of Tsvangirai's personal staff
were arrested Sunday
morning, the independent Zimbabwe Lawyers for Human
Rights said. They were
identified as Warship Dumba, Felix Manditse and Annah
Muzvidziwa, all close
aides of Tsvangirai.
Voting in a referendum on
a new constitution ended late Saturday. All main
party leaders called for a
"Yes" vote on constitutional reforms. Another
official of the former
opposition party, the Movement for Democratic Change,
was arrested before
polling began Saturday. No reasons were immediately
given for the arrest by
four armed police of Sampson Magunise, a party
organizer in eastern
Zimbabwe, but Charamba said Sunday he was a suspect in
an alleged gasoline
bomb attack on a the car of a Mugabe party official.
Zimbabwe's official
election body said Sunday an estimated 2 million people
cast their vote in a
referendum on a new constitution that seeks to curb
presidential powers and
strengthen human rights.
Judge Rita Makarau, head of the electoral
commission, said the low estimate
came from early returns from the nation's
9,400 polling stations.
Zimbabwe has an estimated 6.6 million registered
voters. Full results from
isolated areas are expected within five
days.
Police enforced a clampdown on rights and pro-democracy groups in
the run-up
to the referendum vote.
In recent weeks, police have
seized documents, equipment and cheap wind-up
radio receivers from the
offices of several rights and pro-democracy groups.
The radio receivers,
capable of receiving broadcasts not controlled by
President Mugabe's state
broadcasting monopoly, were declared illegal by
police under broadcast
regulations. The broadcasts were used for Mugabe's
ZANU-PF party propaganda
and were intensified around the referendum vote.
Rights groups have
challenged the legality of the radio ban, arguing that
regular short-wave
receivers and satellite television are not outlawed as
long as they are
covered by routine state listeners' licenses.
Police regularly mount
searches without complete warrants looking for
allegedly subversive
materials said to be a threat to national security.
They insist private
rights and media freedom groups are trying to incite
tensions between
political parties ahead of crucial national elections later
in the year to
end a shaky and acrimonious coalition between Tsvangirai and
Mugabe. The
coalition was formed by regional mediators after the last
violent and
disputed elections in 2008.
------------
Associated Press reporter
Gillian Gotora in Harare, Zimbabwe, contributed to
this report
Biti accuses Zanu PF of intimidation
http://www.newzimbabwe.com
17/03/2013 00:00:00
by Staff
Reporter I Agencies
ZIMBABWE’S longtime political rivals came
together to vote 'Yes' in a
referendum to accept a new constitution
Saturday, but the rare consensus
does not guarantee an end to political
violence and intimidation ahead of
crucial elections later this year, the
prime minister's party said.
Constitutional reform was a key demand of
regional leaders mediating in the
southern African nation's decade-long
political and economic crisis. Reform
was also a requirement for fresh
elections to end a shaky and acrimonious
coalition they brokered after the
last violent and disputed national polls
in 2008.
The new
constitution allows for more democratic reforms that would curb long
entrenched presidential powers and punish perpetrators of human rights
violations.
However, Tendai Biti, the third ranking official in Prime
Minister Morgan
Tsvangirai's party, said Saturday that political
intimidation continued into
the vote.
Biti said the arrest of a
senior provincial official for the Movement for
Democratic Change party by
President Robert Mugabe's loyalist police on
Saturday, casts doubt on the
prospect of free and fair elections slated for
around July.
Sampson
Magunise, the party official in Headlands, was seized by four armed
police
before referendum polling stations opened in the morning across the
country.
No reasons for his arrest were given.
"This is illegal and unacceptable
but it is typical of the environment we
are living in," Biti
said.
Magunise's arrest followed attacks on four party's supporters putting
up
referendum posters in Kariba and scuffles between rival youth groups in
Harare and Bulawayo on Friday.
Past elections
Past elections
have been marred by violence and alleged vote rigging blamed
mostly on
Mugabe's Zanu PF party.
Both President Mugabe and Prime Minister Tsvangirai
said they voted 'Yes'
Saturday after all main party leaders called for the
170-page draft
constitution to be adopted.
"We will celebrate a 'Yes'
vote but we cannot accept intimidation of any of
our members and then
declare an election to be credible," Biti said.
Biti said regional
polling observers will likely report Saturday's vote as
acceptable compared
to "low standards of behavior" expected of Zimbabweans
seen at previous
polls.
"We can't accept mediocrity when it comes to elections that
wouldn't be
tolerated in other countries" during polling, he said.
He
also claimed Zanu PF officials had campaigned for a ‘No’ vote in the
Midlands province.
“We have some Zanu PF officials campaigning for a NO
vote in the Midlands
Province though the three political parties agreed to
campaign for a YES
vote but because of factionalism in Zanu PF some are
campaigning for a NO
vote in the Midlands province and have been
intimidation voters” he said.
Mugabe said he voted 'Yes' to the
home-grown constitution to show how
Zimbabwe mapped out its own future
without outside interference.
"It gives us the right to determine
together which way to govern ourselves,"
he said.
Mugabe, 89, who led the
nation to independence from Britain in 1980, has
repeatedly accused Western
governments of supporting efforts to oust him.
Mugabe, who voted at a
school in western Harare with his wife Grace and his
daughter Bona, 22, said
he wanted peace in all polling.
Turning point
"Those who want to fight
are allowed to if they are boxers or wrestlers, but
to go about beating
people in the streets, that's not allowed," he said.
Tsvangirai, 61, said
a 'Yes' vote marked a new turning point "and one of the
most important
historical steps" for the country after years of political
and economic
turmoil. He said it paved the way for a new chapter of the rule
of
law.
His supporters who have been killed in political violence over the
past
decade "will rest in peace because this is the most important stage we
have
been fighting for," Tsvangirai said. "I hope everyone will exercise
their
vote as a preliminary step to free and fair
elections."
Officials said polling was busy in populous districts, and
small knots of
voters turned out early in remote areas and less populated or
wealthier
suburbs.
The voting day was announced exactly a month ago,
and critics say voters
were not given enough time to study the
constitutional proposals in detail.
About 9,400 voting stations were set up
and 12 million ballot papers have
been printed. Results are expected within
five days.
Abigail Punungwe, a young mother with a baby on her back in a
line at one
voting station in Harare, said she hadn't read the 170-page
draft
constitution "but everyone is saying we must vote for
it."
Elections monitors say printed copies were woefully inadequate in
the two
main local languages. Many rural Zimbabweans don't speak or read
English.
Monitors also pointed to only 200 braille copies being produced for
the
country's 40,000 blind people.
Cumbersome voters' lists were not
used. The country has 6.6 million
registered voters, but on Saturday all
Zimbabweans over the age of 18
carrying a valid identification document were
able to vote during more than
12 hours of polling.
Polling stations
using indelible finger ink on the hands of those who have
already voted will
stay open later into the evening if voters are still in
line at the closing
time.
Presidential powers
Voting lines over 200 meters long in
Harare had tapered off by Saturday
afternoon.
Munganyi Nyarai, a
polling officer in Mbare, said more young people voted
early at her post
than in usual elections.
The draft constitution reduces presidential powers
to pass authoritarian
decrees and paves the way for a National Peace and
Reconciliation Commission
on past violence and human rights
violations.
It also strengthens the bill of rights to protect all
Zimbabweans from
"torture, cruel, inhumane and degrading treatment or
punishment" that would
be enforced by a new Constitutional Court with powers
above the main
existing highest court of appeal, the Supreme
Court.
In urging supporters to vote 'Yes,' Mugabe's party says the draft
recognizes
as irreversible the seizure of thousands of white-owned
commercial farms
which have since 2000 been handed over to
blacks.
Black empowerment programs and the taking of control of
foreign-owned mines
and businesses by locals would also be
irreversible.
Zanu PF says the draft honors fighters who ended colonial
rule after a
seven-year bush war with white-led troops of the former colony
of Rhodesia,
as Zimbabwe was known before independence in 1980.
Small
groups who have campaigned for a 'No' vote say the referendum is a
compromise that doesn't meet the aspirations for change of ordinary
Zimbabweans.
"The constitution has been taken over by politicians and
doesn't reflect the
true wishes of the people. It is a betrayal of
generations to come," said
voter Philimon Jambaya, 23.
2 million voted in referendum
http://www.news24.com/
2013-03-17 20:34
Harare - Zimbabwe's official
election body says an estimated two million
people have cast their vote in a
referendum on a new constitution that seeks
to curb presidential powers and
strengthen human rights.
Judge Rita Makarau, who heads the electoral
commission, said on Sunday the
low estimate came from early returns from the
nation's 9 400 polling
stations.
Zimbabwe has an estimated 6.6
million registered voters.
All main political parties had called for a
"Yes" vote amid fears of a low
voter turnout.
Zimbabweans were given
just three weeks to read the 170 page draft of the
constitution.
Makarau said the voting was carried out
peacefully.
Vote counting began late on Saturday and full results from
isolated areas
are expected within five days.
Confusion over ‘aliens’ in referendum poll
http://www.dailynews.co.zw
By Richard Chidza, Staff Writer
Sunday,
17 March 2013 13:04
HARARE - The issue of Zimbabwean citizenship once again
came to the foe
yesterday as confusion reigned supreme in a poll to adopt or
reject a draft
charter crafted by a committee of
Parliament.
Unspecified but large numbers were turned away because they
did not qualify
as citizens.
Zimbabwe Electoral Commission
spokesperson Lovemore Sekeramayi confirmed the
referendum was open to
citizens only.
“Prospective voters have to produce a plastic or metal
identity card, a
green waiting pass with a picture affixed or a passport
that indicates if
they are a citizen.
“Those with an ‘Alien’
classification are not eligible to vote. On whether
they will vote if the
draft is adopted is entirely another matter,”
Sekeramayi said.
Across
the country, reports indicated that hordes of Zimbabweans of foreign
descent
were turned away while those that had brought their driver’s
licences could
not vote because the metal disc did not indicate whether one
is a citizen of
not.
“We have turned away some people because they did not meet the
criteria but
I do not have the numbers now,” Simon Saunyama, polling officer
in charge of
Marondera Central command centre, told the Daily
News.
At Ruwa Polyclinic in Goromonzi South, 20 people had been turned
away by
mid-morning, according to officials while in other areas officials
refused
to provide figures.
The new draft constitution, if adopted,
will allow dual citizenship and the
debate that raged during its crafting
might have aroused the interest of
citizens.
Zimbabweans in the
“alien” category voted in the early years of independence
before authorities
invoked a constitutional clause that disenfranchised a
very large section of
society.
Critics accused President Robert Mugabe and Zanu PF of punishing
people of
foreign descent because they voted against his party in the 2000
referendum
that rejected a government sponsored draft and subsequent
elections before
the “ban”.
In a moment of anger following his
referendum loss in 2000 Mugabe described
this group of citizens as
“totemless people”.
Zim referendum count under way
http://www.iol.co.za
March 17 2013 at 11:31am
By SAPA
Harare -
Zimbabwe was on Sunday tallying the ballots from a constitutional
referendum
that looked set to curb President Robert Mugabe's powers and tee
up crucial
elections in the violence-plagued nation.
The first incomplete trickle of
results pointed to landslide backing for the
text, which would introduce
presidential term limits, beef up parliament's
powers and set polls to
decide whether the 89-year-old Mugabe stays in
power.
Mugabe has
ruled uninterrupted since the country's independence in 1980,
despite a
series of disputed and violent polls and a severe economic crash
propelled
by hyper-inflation.
The draft constitution is part of an internationally
backed plan to get the
country on track. Zimbabweans' verdict on the draft
is expected to be known
within five days of the voting.
According to
the Movement of Democratic Change, the party of Prime Minister
Morgan
Tsvangirai, of nearly 90,000 votes intially counted in the second
city of
Bulawayo only 6,250 were against the draft.
Mugabe has backed the
proposed constitution, which enshrines his drive to
put land in the hands of
black Zimbabweans. Also, the clauses are not
retroactive so he could if
re-elected remain president for another 10 years.
His political rival
Tsvangirai has also lent his support to the text,
although turnout is
expected to be low.
But that has not prevented the threat of violence
from looming over the
vote, as party militants keep one eye on the general
election.
A vote is expected to take place in July, but doubts remain
about whether it
can take place as planned.
Shortly before polls
opened Saturday, gunmen later identified as
plainclothes police detectives
seized a member of Tsvangirai's Movement for
Democratic Change (MDC) from
his home northeast of Harare.
Police spokeswoman Charity Charamba told
AFP Samson Magumura had been
arrested on charges of attempted murder in
connection with a recent firebomb
attack that injured a Mugabe
ally.
While casting his vote on Saturday, Mugabe, whom many blame for
past unrest,
urged Zimbabweans to ensure the referendum proceeded
peacefully.
“You can't go about beating people on the streets, that's not
allowed, we
want peace in the country, peace, peace,” he
said.
Mugabe, the target of 11 years of Western sanctions over political
violence
and rights abuses, also used the opportunity to vow the United
States and
European countries would not be allowed to monitor the upcoming
general
election.
“The Europeans and the Americans have imposed
sanctions on us and we keep
them out in the same way they keep us out,” he
said.
Tsvangirai on Saturday expressed hope that a positive outcome would
help
catapult the country out of a crisis marked by bloodshed and economic
meltdown.
He hoped the vote would move Zimbabwe “from a culture of
impunity to a
culture of constitutionalism”.
Turnout, which was slow
at first, picked up slightly as the day progressed,
said Rita Makarau,
chairwoman of the Zimbabwe Electoral Commission, which
has registered around
six million eligible voters.
School teacher Petronella Dzikiti said she
voted in favour of the new
constitution, in part because it would introduce
presidential term limits.
“We don't want a situation like we have today,
where some of us knew one
leader as a child who remains there when we are
grown-ups,” the 36-year-old
said outside a polling station in Chitungwiza,
near the capital.
Ä Mugabe could rule until 99 Ä
The new
constitution would for the first time put a definite, if distant,
end date
on Mugabe's rule.
Presidents would be allowed to serve two terms of five
years each, meaning
Mugabe could rule until 2023, when he would be
99
years old.
The text would also strip away presidential immunity
after leaving office,
bolster the power of the courts, and set up a peace
and reconciliation
commission tasked with post-conflict justice and
healing.
In the run-up to the vote, violence did not approach the levels
seen in the
disputed 2008 elections.
At least 180 people were killed
then and 9,000 injured in a crisis that
ultimately forced Mugabe and
Tsvangirai into a power-sharing government.
Fears of a return to bloodshed
are rife.
“The situation will get more politically tense, but it won't be
as violent
as in 2008... because of the politics of inclusive government,”
said
commentator Takura Zhangazha.
On the eve of the referendum,
several MDC members, including a parliamentary
candidate, were beaten up as
they put up posters backing the draft
constitution.
The authorities
have also been accused of targeting pro-democracy groups by
arresting their
leaders and seizing equipment.
Tsvangirai called on SADC leaders to meet
for an urgent summit, to help
ensure the election is fair and free of
violence and intimidation.
Observers fear there may not be enough time to
apply all the necessary
reforms to ensure a healthier political environment
before the next
elections. - Sapa-AFP
Early results point to 'Yes' vote landslide
http://www.newzimbabwe.com
17/03/2013 00:00:00
by Agencies
ELECTION officials were on Sunday tallying the ballots
from a constitutional
referendum that looked set to curb President Robert
Mugabe's powers and tee
up crucial elections in the violence-plagued
nation.
The first incomplete trickle of results pointed to landslide
backing for the
text, which would introduce presidential term limits, beef
up parliament's
powers and set polls to decide whether the 89-year-old
Mugabe stays in
power.
Mugabe has ruled uninterrupted since the
country's independence in 1980,
despite a series of disputed and violent
polls and a severe economic crash
propelled by hyper-inflation.
The
draft constitution is part of an internationally backed plan to get the
country on track. Zimbabweans' verdict on the draft is expected to be known
within five days of the voting.
According to the Movement of
Democratic Change, the party of Prime Minister
Morgan Tsvangirai, of nearly
90,000 votes intially counted in the second
city of Bulawayo only 6,250 were
against the draft.
Mugabe has backed the proposed constitution, which
enshrines his drive to
put land in the hands of black Zimbabweans. Also, the
clauses are not
retroactive so he could if re-elected remain president for
another 10 years.
His political rival Tsvangirai has also lent his
support to the text,
although turnout is expected to be low.
But that has
not prevented the threat of violence from looming over the
vote, as party
militants keep one eye on the general election.
A vote is expected to
take place in July, but doubts remain about whether it
can take place as
planned.
Shortly before polls opened Saturday, gunmen later identified as
plainclothes police detectives seized a member of Tsvangirai's Movement for
Democratic Change (MDC) from his home northeast of Harare.
Police
spokeswoman Charity Charamba told AFP Samson Magumura had been
arrested on
charges of attempted murder in connection with a recent firebomb
attack that
injured a Mugabe ally.
While casting his vote on Saturday, Mugabe, whom
many blame for past unrest,
urged Zimbabweans to ensure the referendum
proceeded peacefully.
"You can't go about beating people on the streets,
that's not allowed, we
want peace in the country, peace, peace," he
said.
Mugabe, the target of 11 years of Western sanctions over political
violence
and rights abuses, also used the opportunity to vow the United
States and
European countries would not be allowed to monitor the upcoming
general
election.
"The Europeans and the Americans have imposed
sanctions on us and we keep
them out in the same way they keep us out," he
said.
Tsvangirai on Saturday expressed hope that a positive outcome would
help
catapult the country out of a crisis marked by bloodshed and economic
meltdown.
He hoped the vote would move Zimbabwe "from a culture of
impunity to a
culture of constitutionalism".
Turnout, which was slow at
first, picked up slightly as the day progressed,
said Rita Makarau,
chairwoman of the Zimbabwe Electoral Commission, which
has registered around
six million eligible voters.
School teacher Petronella Dzikiti said she
voted in favour of the new
constitution, in part because it would introduce
presidential term limits.
"We don't want a situation like we have today,
where some of us knew one
leader as a child who remains there when we are
grown-ups," the 36-year-old
said outside a polling station in Chitungwiza,
near the capital.
The new constitution would for the first time put a
definite, if distant,
end date on Mugabe's rule.
Presidents would be
allowed to serve two terms of five years each, meaning
Mugabe could rule
until 2023, when he would be 99 years old.
The text would also strip away
presidential immunity after leaving office,
bolster the power of the courts,
and set up a peace and reconciliation
commission tasked with post-conflict
justice and healing.
In the run-up to the vote, violence did not approach
the levels seen in the
disputed 2008 elections.
At least 180 people were
killed then and 9,000 injured in a crisis that
ultimately forced Mugabe and
Tsvangirai into a power-sharing government.
Fears of a return to bloodshed
are rife.
"The situation will get more politically tense, but it won't be
as violent
as in 2008... because of the politics of inclusive government,"
said
commentator Takura Zhangazha.
On the eve of the referendum,
several MDC members, including a parliamentary
candidate, were beaten up as
they put up posters backing the draft
constitution.
The authorities
have also been accused of targeting pro-democracy groups by
arresting their
leaders and seizing equipment.
Tsvangirai called on SADC leaders to meet for
an urgent summit, to help
ensure the election is fair and free of violence
and intimidation.
Observers fear there may not be enough time to apply
all the necessary
reforms to ensure a healthier political environment before
the next
elections.
SADC electoral commissions commend referendum handling
http://www.thezimbabwean.co.uk/
17.03.13
by
Edgar Gweshe
The voting process in Zimbabwe’s constitutional referendum
was peaceful and
orderly, the Electoral Commissions Forum of the Southern
African Development
Community has said.
The ECF-SADC comprises 15
SADC member states and was launched in 1998. It
aims to promote conditions
conducive for free, fair and transparent
elections in southern
Africa.
The ECF-SADEC commenced its work on 13 March and was composed of
Electoral
Commissions from the Democratic Republic of Congo, Lesotho,
Mozambique,
Namibia, Zambia and South Africa.
The head of the
Commission, Fako Likoti, commended the manner in which the
referendum was
held while addressing journalists in the capital today.
“The mission
observed that the voting process was peaceful and orderly.
Voters cast their
ballots freely and without any intimidation. Secrecy of
the ballot seemed to
have been well protected and voters needing assistance
were duly assisted
throughout the polling stations visited,” said Likoti.
He said that
counting of votes at polling stations was carried out
transparently and
meticulously. However, Likoti said that observers were
more visible at
polling stations in urban areas than at centres in rural
areas. He said that
there were isolated cases of voting centres opening
late.
He added:
“Indelible ink was used but its usage was not uniform in that it
had the
potential of spilling on electoral material. In addition, the unsafe
hygienic use of the ink could be a health hazard.
Signage was
provided at all polling stations but was not visible enough.”
The ECF-SADEC
recommended that the Zimbabwe Electoral Commission should
enhance its
readiness to handle polls.
“The Commission recommends that ZEC enhances
its poll readiness to ensure
timely dispatching of election material to
polling stations.
This should include contingency planning and ensuring
the arrival of polling
material well ahead of polling day.
“Greater
attention should be given to voter education especially on the
identification requirements to vote,” said Likoti.
He emphasised the
need for more practice oriented training to ensure
consistency and
uniformity in the handling of the polling process.
Referendum was “smooth” despite some hitches-ZESN
http://www.thezimbabwean.co.uk
17.03.13
by Tarisai
Jangara
The referendum on a new constitution that was held yesterday
was generally
peaceful and smooth with very few incidents of violations,
says the Zimbabwe
Election Support Network.
ZESN was an
independent election observer during the referndum.
Addressing
journalists at a press conference today on the preliminary
findings of the
constitutional referendum that was held yesterday, ZESN
Chairperson, Solomon
Zwana, commended the Zimbabwe Electoral Commission for
putting together
logistical support within a short period.
ZESN deployed 600 observers
across the country to monitor the voting process
yesterday.
“Though
the process is not yet over, we commend ZEC for responding timeously
and
professionally to concerns of the observers,” he said.
Zwana said the
opening of polling stations was smooth with stations having
adequate
materials to commence voting process.
“There were a few reports of
missing materials at polling stations, such as
the ZEC stamp and indelible
ink but the vast majority of the stations were
properly set up. The
processing of voters was efficient which reduced the
waiting time for most
voters,” Zwana said.
However ZESN expressed concern over reports relating
to violations of
procedures at some polling stations.
“ There were
reports of unauthorised persons in the polling stations, ZEC
officials
lacking identification badges and an incident of a Zanu
(PF) supporter in
Mataga, Midlands Province who was taking down names of the
people who had
voted,” explained Zwana.
ZESN urged ZEC to address the referendum
shortcomings before the harmonised
elections which are expected later this
year.
“Police officers should be deployed outside polling stations,
sufficient
voter education should be conducted and there should be early
decentralisation of the accreditation process,” he said.
Mugabe to attend Pope’s inauguration
http://www.newzimbabwe.com/
17/03/2013 00:00:00
by Staff
Reporter
PRESIDENT Robert Mugabe would attend this week's
inauguration mass for Pope
Francis, a presidential official said, with the
staunchly Catholic leader
set to leave for Rome on Sunday.
"Yes, he is
attending," the official told AFP, adding that the veteran
leader's trip
would not be affected by the European Union travel ban because
"the Vatican
is a state on its own".
Argentina’s Jorge Mario Bergoglio was elected
Pope Francis I last Wednesday,
becoming the first Latin American pontiff in
a surprise decision that
signalled a desire for a more open Catholic
Church.
The Vatican is preparing for his inauguration on
Tuesday.
Francis replaced 85-year-old predecessor Benedict XVI, who shocked
the world
last month by becoming the first pope to resign for seven
centuries.
Mugabe visited the Vatican in May 2011 for the beatification
of the late
pope John Paul II. In 2005, he attended John Paul II's funeral
on a visit
that drew controversy after Britain's Prince Charles shook hands
with him.
The 89-year Mugabe has been barred from travelling to the EU
for more than a
decade because of concerns about vote rigging and rights
abuses.
The Vatican is a sovereign city-state that is not part of the
European
Union, although to attend the ceremony Mugabe would have to transit
through
Rome.
Travelling under UN auspices, Mugabe also went to Rome
in 2008 for a summit
of the UN Food and Agriculture Organisation.
He was
flying out on Sunday, a day after Zimbabwe held a referendum on the
constitution that saw aides of his rival and coalition government partner
Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai arrested.
The new constitution,
which is expected to be adopted, would dramatically
trim Mugabe's powers and
limits presidential terms.
Referendum no litmus test – Zimbabwe Vigil Diary: 16th March 2013
Mark
Beacon (ACTSA) with ballot box
One
polling station where there was no apathy was outside the London Embassy where
more than 100 Zimbabwean exiles gathered on Referendum Day. We were joined by
Mark Beacon of Action for Southern Africa (ACTSA), formerly the Anti-Apartheid
Movement, who said ‘we must make sure that the world does not see the referendum
as a litmus test for the elections’.
Mark
said a peaceful referendum was no guide to what will happen in the coming
elections. The next few months would be crucial given the telltale signs already
present of intimidation and violence which characterized Zanu PF’s
electioneering in the past. He insisted that for the elections to be credible
there would have to be assurances that the security forces were prepared to
accept democratic change and that the army and the police would not be partisan,
that there would be an accurate voters’ roll, a free media with equal access by
all parties, a repeal of restrictive legislation and international as well as
regional observers in place 3 months before and 3 months after the elections.
The
Vigil and ACTSA marked Referendum Day by inviting people to write messages of
hope for free and fair elections on red paper roses which were deposited in a
transparent voting box. They will be used to form a montage which we will
display before the elections expected in July. The only sour note was cast by
President Mugabe (played by Fungayi Mabhunu in our Mugabe mask) who, asked to
vote for freedom, voted no.
The
main event of the day was the presentation of a petition to 10 Downing Street by
the Vigil’s sister organization Restoration of Human Rights in Zimbabwe (ROHR).
The petition appealed to the UK government not to send home failed asylum
seekers in the face of likely election violence.
A letter to the Prime
Minister, David Cameron, said there had been a disturbing campaign of police
harassment of civil society organisations ahead of the elections, accompanied by
increasing violence. The letter went on ‘We
expect the situation to worsen as polling approaches because President Mugabe’s
Zanu PF thugs are given impunity by the police to terrorise opponents’ (for text
of letter, see: http://www.zimvigil.co.uk/vigil-news/press-releases/480-uk-zimbabweans-appeal-to-cameron).
An arresting image
were the skirts in Zimbabwean colours worn by ROHR ladies. They treated us to an
exuberant dancing display outside 10 Downing Street. Thanks to Consolata Ngwenya
for making the skirts. She was one of the 6 delegates who presented the
petition. The others were: Cynthia
Mutede, Zenzile Chabuka, Helen Rukambiro, Mary Muteyerwa and Bryne
Mashonganyika.
ROHR
spokesperson Fungayi summed up our view: ‘The referendum is a charade. President
Mugabe has once again outwitted the Movement for Democratic Change. Four years
and more than $100 million have been wasted on this defective constitution when
what is really needed is action to ensure free and fair
elections’.
Other
points
·
We were happy to be
joined by David Wilkins who has taken a close interest in Zimbabwe. David is
blind with a genetic defect which also affects his brother – Norrie disease. He
interviewed some of us for a BBC World Service programme.
·
Vigil
supporters read with interest a report that SADC leaders are in despair at the
MDC’s failure to insist on implementation of GPA measures which would help
secure free and fair elections (SADC leaders lose faith in MDC parties – https://www.zimbabwesituation.com/old/mar16b_2013.html#Z5
and Editor’s Memo: Tsvangirai won’t have anyone to blame – https://www.zimbabwesituation.com/old/mar16b_2013.html#Z12).
As we gathered on Referendum Saturday there was speculation about which job
Tsvangirai will be given in the next GNU. Second Vice President was thought the
most likely. It would recognize his contribution (yet keep him safely away from
power). The MDC can argue that he will be able to restrain the worst excesses of
Zanu PF and gain recognition from African leaders. The good thing about GNU2,
the MDC will say, is that it has avoided genocide / economic collapse /
starvation / the assassination of MDC leaders etc. And yes, they will point out,
the constitution can be amended by a two-thirds majority to provide for 1,000
more MPs to reward hard working party members. Harare wasn’t built in a day . .
.
·
The Zimbabwe
Association has sent us some new information on the situation of asylum seekers
and other matters which can be accessed on the following
links:
-
http://zimbabweassociation.org.uk/detention/detainee-and-removals-update/
– new briefing
-
http://zimbabweassociation.org.uk/drop-in-centres/jobs/
– more jobs
-
http://zimbabweassociation.org.uk/information/country-information/
– new information on Zimbabwe
For
latest Vigil pictures check: http://www.flickr.com/photos/zimbabwevigil/.
Please note: Vigil photos can only be downloaded from our Flickr website – they
cannot be downloaded from the slideshow on the front page of the Zimvigil
website.
FOR THE
RECORD: 98
signed the register.
EVENTS
AND NOTICES:
·
Round
15 of the Free Zimbabwe Global Campaign (FZGC). Saturday
23rd March. Meet at the Zimbabwe Embassy at 2 pm.
·
ROHR
Leicester Branch meeting.
Saturday 23rd March from 1 – 4.30 pm. Venue: The Brite Centre,
Braunstone Ave, Braunstone LE3 1LE. Contact: Christopher Kamuzonde 07449150041,
Enniah Dube 07403439707 and Brain Mashonganyika
07450547313.
·
Zimbabwe
Action Forum (ZAF). Saturday
6th April from 6.30 – 9.30 pm. Venue: Strand Continental Hotel (first
floor lounge), 143 Strand, London WC2R 1JA. The Strand is the same road as the
Vigil. From the Vigil it’s about a 10 minute walk, in the direction away from
Trafalgar Square. The Strand Continental is situated on the south side of the
Strand between Somerset House and the turn off onto Waterloo Bridge. The
entrance is marked by a big sign high above and a sign for its famous Indian
restaurant at street level. It's next to a newsagent. Nearest underground:
Temple (District and Circle lines) and Holborn. Next ZAF: Saturday
20nd April same time and venue.
·
Launch of ROHR Leeds
Branch. Saturday
6th April. More details to follow.
·
Zimbabwe
Vigil Highlights 2012 can be
viewed on this link: http://www.zimvigil.co.uk/the-vigil-diary/467-vigil-highlights-2012.
Links to previous years’ highlights are listed on 2012 Highlights
page.
·
The
Restoration of Human Rights in Zimbabwe (ROHR) is the
Vigil’s partner organization based in Zimbabwe. ROHR grew out of the need for
the Vigil to have an organization on the ground in Zimbabwe which reflected the
Vigil’s mission statement in a practical way. ROHR in the UK actively fundraises
through membership subscriptions, events, sales etc to support the activities of
ROHR in Zimbabwe. Please note that the official website of ROHR Zimbabwe is http://www.rohrzimbabwe.org/. Any other website
claiming to be the official website of ROHR in no way represents the views and
opinions of ROHR.
·
Vigil
Facebook page:
http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=8157345519&ref=ts.
·
Vigil
Myspace page: http://www.myspace.com/zimbabwevigil...
·
Useful
websites: www.zanupfcrime.com which reports on Zanu PF
abuses and www.ipaidabribe.org.zw where people can report
corruption in Zimbabwe.
Vigil
co-ordinators
The
Vigil, outside the Zimbabwe Embassy, 429 Strand, London, takes place every
Saturday from 14.00 to 18.00 to protest against gross violations of human rights
in Zimbabwe. The Vigil which started in October 2002 will continue until
internationally-monitored, free and fair elections are held in Zimbabwe. http://www.zimvigil.co.uk.
Problems with Observer Accreditation
CONSTITUTION WATCH
23/2013
[16th March
2013]
The
Referendum – Progress Review
Problems with
Observer Accreditation
Accredited
observers were invited by the Zimbabwe Electoral Commission [ZEC] to witness the
sealing of ballot boxes by returning officers at all polling stations at 6.30 am
on Referendum polling day, 16th March.
This sealing is done prior to start of polling in the interests of
transparency – to ensure the box is empty to start with and to avoid allegations
of ballot boxes being stuffed. In many
cases, however, the sealing will have proceeded without observers present,
because not enough observers were accredited to cover all 9 456 polling
stations.
In
fact the restriction on observer accreditation, especially those from the EU and
its member states and the USA, meant that there were just too few observers to
guarantee real credibility of the process.
The restriction also excluded many experienced observers with world-wide
experience of election monitoring to international standards.
African Observer
Teams
The
following African observer teams were present for most of Referendum week, the
first two at the invitation of the Government:
·
SADC The 100-strong SADC observer mission is headed
by Tanzanian Foreign Minister Bernard Membe, representing President Kikwete, who
is the current chairperson of the SADC Organ on Politics,
Defence and Security. Mr Membe
acknowledged in an interview that 100 observers were not enough to cover all the
polling stations – that would require 1 000 observers, a number beyond SADC’s
capacity. The team will be in the
country until 20th March. [ZEC has said
it will announce the result within five days of polling.]
·
SADC Parliamentary
Forum This
is a 40-member
team including parliamentarians from 11 SADC countries. They have stated they will be guided by
international and regional instruments guiding the conduct of credible
polls.
·
Election Commissions
Forum of SADC Countries [ECF-SADC], which was invited to
observe the Referendum by ZEC. The Forum is a well
respected and recognised body that was established in 1998 and is based in
Botswana, where it is housed by the Botswana Independent Electoral
Commission.
Other
African countries seem to be relying on their embassies here to field observers
from staff stationed in Zimbabwe.
African
observer teams and individual observers from African countries and African
organisations have not been subjected to the same restrictions as those from
certain countries outside Africa
[see
below].
Observers from
Countries Outside Africa
Discrimination
against US and EU member states
ZEC
seems to have followed one particular political party line and divided this
category into “friendly” countries and others, the other countries being those applying restrictive measures/sanctions
against certain Zimbabwean individuals and organisations, i.e., the United
States and member states of the European Union.
As a result the USA and the EU countries have been subjected to severe
restrictions on their observers. The
“friendly countries” have not. All this
is in spite of the fact that the Prime
Minister has said the discrimination against the other countries is not an
agreed inclusive Government
policy. [See
extract from Prime Minister’s statement below]
The
effect has been as follows:
·
“friendly” countries”
No restrictions on sending in observer teams,
but as most of these countries have embassies in Zimbabwe,
they have been content with getting observers accredited from their
embassies.
·
US and EU member
states: The
restrictions applied have included a ban on sending in observer teams,
large or small, from outside, and limiting observers from embassies in Harare to
five persons per embassy, who must be nationals of the foreign countries
concerned. So the United States and the
EU and its member states have not been allowed the large teams of observers they
had applied for.
The
ZEC press notice inviting applications from would-be observers did not mention
these restrictions, but they were spelled out by ZEC acting chairperson Joyce
Kazembe in a press interview last weekend.
She also said Western embassy nominees
would
be vetted with the assistance of the Immigration
Department.
[Comment:
The exclusion of observers from the EU does not make sense, and is in stark
contrast to the Government’s readiness to accept staggering amounts of funding
from EU countries for the constitution-making
process itself. It is ironic that benefactors of the process
are now unable to undertake the comprehensive observation they would wished of
its completion – the Referendum at which the product of the constitution-making
process
is to be judged by the people of Zimbabwe.
Zimbabwean NGO
Observer Teams
Restrictions
on civil society observer teams:
Zimbabwean
civil society organisations have also suffered setbacks in getting
representatives accredited as observers:
·
the
Zimbabwe Election Support Network [ZESN] asked for 700 observers to be
accredited. It was told its member
organisations should apply in their own names.
This
was an unnecessarily obstructive attitude, as the
whole point in having an administrative network such as ZESN is to avoid this
and for ZESN to ensure that its network
members are represented by genuine, trained observers. Also, it
disadvantaged organisations and
individuals based too far from the accreditation
centres to get to those centres on time. In the end, however, ZESN had over 600
observers accredited.
·
the
application for observer accreditation by the Zimbabwe Human Rights
Association [ZimRights] was rejected out of hand, on the ground that it and
its Director and other members had been charged by police with serious offences
involving allegations of forgery, fraud and publishing false information in a
voter-registration context. [Question:
What happened to the presumption of innocence until proved guilty in a
court of law?] On 15th March
ZimRights succeeded in its High Court challenge of this blanket ban, with ZESN
consenting to a court order obliging it to consider the ZimRights application
properly. But by 10 am on polling day,
the accreditation of ZimRights observers was “still under consideration” and by end
of polling had still not been granted.
·
Zimbabwe
Peace Project
observers were also denied accreditation.
The organisation’s Director, Jestina Mukoko, has been interviewed by
police over allegations of illegal importation of short-wave radio
sets.
Civil
Society Threatens Referendum Boycott: Zimbabwean
civil
society threatened to boycott the Referendum over ZEC’s exclusion of some civil
society players accreditation. They
wrote a letter of protest to the three “principals” but did not receive a
response [protest letter
available from veritas@mango.zw]. In fact after the ZimRights court case most
assumed that the exclusion would be over and did not boycott, though in reality
accreditation of two major organisation, each having large numbers of trained
monitors, was denied.
ZLHR lawyers:
were on standby to provide legal assistance
people arrested and subsequently detained as they exercised or attempted to
exercise their right to vote during the referendum
Political party
observers: In
a Parliamentary election political party candidates and their election/polling
agents are directly entitled to observe proceedings in polling stations and
counting centres. There is no equivalent
entitlement for YES and NO campaigners in a Referendum. The only solution was for parties and
organisations interested in the Referendum to have representatives accredited as
observers, and many such observers were accredited. It must be borne in mind that such observers
cannot be expected to be disinterested, independent observers of the process.
Objection to ZEC
Restrictions on Observers
Ideally
there should be twelve-hour plus coverage of all polling and counting of votes,
but that would obviously require a very much larger number of observers than
those actually accredited. That ideal
may have been difficult to achieve, but ZEC’s approach to the accreditation
process must have contributed to keeping numbers down.
This
has resulted in criticism and protests, not only from civil society
organisations but also from the MDC parties, and the Prime Minister [see below]. Although ZEC is a constitutional body, not
subject to direction by any other person or authority, both ZEC and its
Observer
Accreditation Committee have attracted the criticism that they seem
to have followed the ZANU-PF
party line on observers. [Vice-President Mujuru set the tone a few
weeks ago when she said publicly that no observers from EU or Western countries
would be allowed. This was backed up
Foreign Affairs Minister Mumbengegwi on 4th March when
he said Zimbabwe would only allow observers from SADC, COMESA, African Union and
other countries that were “not hostile” to it.
The
position announced by ZEC acting chairperson Joyce Kazembe ahead of the
commencement of the observer accreditation process on Thursday 7th March echoed
what had been said by the Vice-President and Minister
Mumbengegwi.]
Prime
Minister’s Statement
In
a statement issued on Tuesday evening, 12th March, the Prime Minister made it
clear that the exclusion of international observers is not an inclusive
Government policy, and that MDC-T had very different ideas from ZANU-PF
on both civil society and international observers:
“3.
Civic society participation as observers: The
Principals agreed that ZEC must not prohibit local civil society organisations
and NGOs from accreditation on the basis that they are facing investigations,
charges or prosecution by the police because that would be contrary to the Bill
of Rights and the cardinal rule of natural justice that every person is presumed
innocent until proven guilty. The
Principals want this process to be as transparent as possible and no local
persons must be banned from accreditation on this basis.
4.
International observers: Contrary
to recent public statements by some Government officials, there is no agreed
government policy on the banning of international observers from accreditation
to observe the referendum and elections in Zimbabwe. While they can express
their own opinions, no single party is entitled to make public pronouncements of
government policy without the agreement of the other parties in the Inclusive
Government. One party’s policies on the issue of international observers do not
represent government policy. Currently,
there is no agreement on this issue and discussions between the Principals are
still taking place. An announcement on the issue of international observers will
be made at the appropriate time when consensus has been
reached.”
No
such announcement was made.
Outrage at ZEC
Treatment of Media
Media
individuals and organisations have reacted strongly to the difficulties placed
in their path by ZEC policy towards them.
Double accreditation
from ZEC and Zimbabwe Media Commission required: There
seems little point in requiring journalists, whether local or international, to
have two accreditations.
Exorbitant ZEC
accreditation fee for foreign media: As
pointed out in Constitution Watch, a foreign journalist wanting accreditation to
enter polling stations and collation centres had to get both Zimbabwe Media
Commission and ZEC accreditation, which could cost him or her in excess of
US$600,00 altogether. As the
administrative costs involved in accreditation cannot amount to anything like
this amount, this requirement seems unreasonable.
Ministry of
Information clearance
had to be obtained for foreign journalists, as a pre-requisite to
accreditation. At least one – a
Voice of
America correspondent based in Johannesburg was denied clearance by the
Ministry.
Veritas makes every effort to ensure
reliable information, but cannot take legal responsibility for information
supplied