☰
Zimbabwe Situation

No appeasement – Zimbabwe Vigil Diary: 7th March 2015

ZimSitRep_M

via No appeasement – Zimbabwe Vigil Diary: 7th March 2015 08 March 2015

Strong support for the Vigil’s criticism of the European Union’s new policy of ‘re-engaging’ with the Mugabe regime has come from a former senior American official.

 

‘To appease a brutal dictator and his henchmen is to wind up on the wrong side of history’, warns the former Deputy Assistant Secretary of State for African Affairs, Todd Moss (see: http://foreignpolicy.com/2015/03/03/mugabes-new-best-friends-in-brussels/). Mr Moss’s article appears in ‘Foreign Policy’ magazine with the sub title ‘Why is Europe suddenly cozying up to Zimbabwe’s nonagenarian kleptocrat’? He says Mugabe’s lavish birthday celebration ‘was yet another reminder of the stark contrast between the increasingly venal lifestyles of the country’s politically-connected nouveau riche and regular Zimbabweans, who are now poorer than they were when Mugabe came to power nearly 35 years ago’.

 

With President Obama renewing American sanctions for another year, Mr Moss says that it is perplexing that Europe is now choosing to break ranks and resuming aid, signalling a shift in approach from sticks to carrots.  Europe, he says, is wilfully blind to what is happening and who is responsible for the worsening conditions in Zimbabwe. ‘Any new support for the current government will likely only further entrench the current coterie around Mugabe.’

 

He notes: ‘When announcing the resumption of aid, a jovial EU ambassador to Zimbabwe, Phillip van Damme, claimed, “In a true partnership among equals, we may sometimes diverge in opinion and vision. But those divergences can be overcome through real, frank and open dialogue without taboos. It’s like in a marriage.” While diplomats in the field sometimes get lost in their bubble or mistake cocktail parties for real politics, I just cannot believe that European policymakers are under the illusion that the problems in Zimbabwe are from a lack of communication. Do the Europeans really believe they will overcome their differences with the government of Zimbabwe on torture, land grabbing, vote stealing, and diamond theft via open dialogue? Surely not.’

 

Mr Moss concludes that ‘the ethical and strategic move is to keep Mugabe and his birthday party guests at arm’s length’.

 

A different view is taken by Dr Tapiwa Shumba, former spokesperson for the MDC in South Africa, who says opposition parties must realise that Zanu PF and Mugabe are in power and stop being confrontational. ‘It is because of this confrontational strategy that the opposition must also partly take responsibility for the obvious polarisation in the country’, say Dr Shumba who has taken a one year sabbatical we presume to work out how the opposition can help run the gas chambers in Zimbabwe more economically. ‘Opposition with co-operation’ as he put it (see: http://nehandaradio.com/2015/03/05/zimbabwe-opposition-must-change-from-confrontation-to-cooperation-shumba/).

 

Whatever the differences of opinion over re-engaging Mugabe, no one can deny the rampant corruption in Zimbabwe. But despite this, Britain’s Department for International Development (DFID) continues to pour money into Zimbabwe which we have long argued serves to prop up the regime. The author Jonathan Foreman says DFID is willfully naïve.

 

‘The reason is that DFID staff, like so many people in Big Aid, are wearing ideological blinkers. They have to keep on giving money to governments that are ravaging their own societies, and they have to pretend that local officials are akin to our own, rather than bandits and exploiters. Otherwise they would have to surrender their core conviction that “fragile” (i.e. chaotic, corrupt, impoverished and dysfunctional) states are that way not through the fault of their own governments and elites, but only because of a lack of money, resources or technology, and/or because evil foreigners have wrecked them . . . It’s why the UK’s bloated aid effort will continue to be wasteful, inefficient and a kick in the teeth for the British taxpayer’ (see: http://www.breitbart.com/london/2015/02/13/britains-bloated-wasteful-foreign-aid-programme-is-next-to-useless/ –Incompetent British Aid Agency Overwhelmed By Too Much Money).

 

The Zimbabwe Peace Project complained only this week that children of MDC members in Bindura South are being denied access to educational assistance under the Basic Education Assistance Module (BEAM). The British taxpayer has been the main sponsor of this project (see: https://www.zimbabwesituation.com/news/zimsit_w_opposition-party-members-children-denied-access-to-educational-assistance-zpp-newsday-zimbabwe/).  British diplomats could take the matter up with the Zimbabwe Anti-Corruption Commission, but its Chief Executive Ngonidzashe Gumbo has just been jailed for – you guessed it – corruption (see: http://www.herald.co.zw/anti-corruption-commission-boss-jailed/). Not surprisingly, Mr Gumbo is a former Senior Assistant Commissioner of Police.

 

Other points

·         We had a chaotic start to the Vigil because all traffic was disrupted by a big demonstration over climate change. A police van was parked in the middle of our space.

·         On a lovely sunny day (at the request of Enniah Dube, Vice-Chair of ROHR) we marked International Women’s Day in support of Women of Zimbabwe Arise (WOZA) who were beaten by police during a Valentine’s Day protest in Bulawayo (see report from Amnesty International on our campaigns page: http://www.zimvigil.co.uk/vigil-news/campaign-news/665-zimbabwe-update-from-amnesty-international-uk-woza-action-march-2015-).

·         A meeting of the Zimbabwe Action Forum after the Vigil heard a preliminary report of a working committee set up to formulate a charter for the Zimbabwean diaspora.

·         Thanks to a regular supporter who brought a number of Zimbabwean caps for us to sell in support of our activities.

·          The Vigil has protested to the British Home Secretary Theresa May at an asylum judge’s ill-informed criticism of us. You can see the letter on our campaigns page: http://www.zimvigil.co.uk/vigil-news/campaign-news/666-a-discredited-judge–letter-to-the-uk-home-secretary).

·         Thanks to Deborah Harry, Epiphania Phiri and Hilda Gwesele who sold drinks and snacks to fundraise at the Vigil. Thanks also the Eunice Mucherechedzo and Helen Rukambiro for taking care of the front table.

 

For latest Vigil pictures check: http://www.flickr.com/photos/zimbabwevigil/. Please note: Vigil photos can only be downloaded from our Flickr website.

 

FOR THE RECORD: 54 signed the register but there were many more at the protest.

 

EVENTS AND NOTICES:

No related posts.

Back to Home page