The ZIMBABWE Situation | Our
thoughts and prayers are with Zimbabwe - may peace, truth and justice prevail. |
Stumbles, who is a
renowned lawyer, says the proposed amendments would
create a dictatorship
within the church structures.
The letter comes at a time when
relations between Kunonga and the
majority of Anglican parishioners have been
severely strained.
Kunonga, a fortnight ago, sent out to
parishioners the proposed
amendments that some within his flock believe would
grant the bishop powers
to ban, dismiss, remove or transfer priests without
approval from other
church structures.
Stumbles wrote in a
letter he has distributed to Anglicans in Harare:
"What the Bishop and his
advisers are proposing may be right in their own
eyes and for their own
purposes, but it is submitted that it is disastrous
for the Church, contrary
to democratic laws and does not achieve what is
best for one another and all
those around the Diocese."
Kunonga, who has clashed with
parishioners since becoming bishop in
2001, could not be reached for comment
on the matter.
Kunonga suspended Stumbles as chancellor of the
Anglican Church in
Harare last June, but the lawyer has challenged the
suspension in court.
According to Stumbles, if the proposed
amendments are passed they
would "thrust much more power and control into the
hands of the Bishop and
deprive others of rights to which they are presently
entitled. The bishop is
anxious to have these changes
adopted".
The amendments also seek to authorise church wardens
and members of
the church council to prevent "demonstrations, disturbances
and strikes
against the incumbent, church leadership and
administration".
Some Anglican parishioners have on several
occasions staged
demonstrations against Kunonga over his management of the
diocese.
Senior Reporter
Daily News
Muzenda receiving intensive care
AILING
Vice-President Simon Muzenda has been transferred to
Parirenyatwa Hospital’s
coronary care unit (CCU), usually reserved for
patients with critical and
life-threatening conditions, according to medical
experts.
Hospital sources told the Daily News that Muzenda, 81, who has been in
and
out of hospital in the past year, was moved from the hospital’s B6 ward
to
the CCU on Tuesday night. Efforts to get clarification on Muzenda’s
condition
from the government and from the ruling ZANU PF party, for which
Muzenda is
also a vice-president, were unsuccessful yesterday.
ZANU PF
chairman John Nkomo, who is also Special Affairs Minister in
President Robert
Mugabe’s office, said he had seen Muzenda in hospital but
he would not be
drawn to give details on the vice-president’s condition.
Nkomo said: "Talking
about his condition would be too personal. I suggest
you talk to his family
members."
Muzenda’s daughter, Tsitsi, yesterday said she was
unable to comment
on her father’s illness because she was "in a
meeting".
A hospital source, who spoke on condition he was not
named, said: "The
VP is in serious condition. We transferred him on Tuesday
night from the D1
Floor to the Coronary Care Unit (CCU) in B6 Ward where he
is now."
Muzenda, who has been in and out of the country,
mostly to China, to
receive treatment for an undisclosed ailment, was
admitted at Parirenyatwa
Hospital over the weekend.
Patients
admitted in the CCU require constant care and should be
monitored by at least
two nurses at any given time. "Usually, the patient
has difficulty in
breathing resulting from a problem either in the lungs,
the heart or the
kidney," said one Harare doctor.
Mugabe’s trusted deputy since
1980, Muzenda is widely seen as a
crucial power broker in the ruling party.
Muzenda is also regarded as a key
player in determining who will take over
from Mugabe, with ZANU PF insiders
saying he prefers Speaker of Parliament
Emmerson Mnangagwa to succeed
Mugabe.
One of the pioneers of
Zimbabwe’s bitter struggle for independence,
Muzenda is believed to have
expressed his wish to retire from active
politics in April citing "‘ill
health and fatigue", but is said to have been
pressured to remain in power by
some of his colleagues in government.
Staff Reporters
Daily News
SADC agenda dodges Zimbabwe crisis
DAE ES
SALAAM – HIV/AIDS, trade-distorting subsidies and regional
food security will
feature high on the agenda of the upcoming meetings of
the Southern Africa
Development Community (SADC) in the Tanzanian commercial
capital, Dar es
Salaam, SADC executive secretary Prega Ramsamy said
this
week.
Briefing journalists on the imminent Council of
Ministers meeting, and
the subsequent summit from 25 to 26 August, Ramsamy
said these issues had to
be tackled by the region, with or without the
support of the rest of the
world.
When asked about Zimbabwe,
Ramsamy played down suggestions that the
regional body might make a statement
on the country’s political and economic
crisis, saying the issue was being
discussed by the Organ on Politics,
Defence and Security, but SADC’s position
had not changed.
"The sanctions (imposed on Zimbabwe) are not
helping the country or
the region as a whole," he said. "We have always asked
for the sanctions to
be lifted."
Following a SADC HIV/AIDS
summit held in Lesotho from 2 to 4 July,
where regional leaders approved a
revised SADC strategic framework for
tackling HIV/AIDS, Ramsamy said the
pandemic had to be addressed
immediately.
"Our active
population is being destroyed. We won’t have people to
work, so we can forget
about development," he warned. "It is true we need
the capacity to cope with
the numerous challenges, but our capacity is being
decimated by HIV/AIDS,
therefore it is something that we have to address."
Current
SADC figures estimate that 14 million people in the region are
HIV-positive,
representing the largest share of infections not only in
Africa but also of
the global total.
The strategic framework focuses on
prevention, care and support to
ensure sustainable human development in the
SADC region. But Ramsamy said it
was difficult to tackle HIV/AIDS when the
costs were so high.
"We should be able to give cheap drugs," he
said. "It makes no sense
if (antiretroviral) drugs cost one dollar a day,
when people don’t have one
dollar a day to give . . . People shouldn’t make
money out of the deaths of
our people."
Ramsamy also
stressed that in the face of growing evidence on the
impact of
trade-distorting subsidies, SADC countries had to consolidate
their position
on world trade and access to markets.
"It is critical that we,
as SADC, agree on one voice and go there (to
the World Trade Organisation)
and say that we don’t want subsidies. We have
to make our voice loud and
clear."
Following last year’s food crisis in the region, the
council would be
discussing food security and measures to avoid potential
crises in the
future, the executive secretary said.
"It was
fortunate that we sounded the alarm bells in March 2002, and
we were able to
get enough food assistance for the 15.2 million people
affected. But these
are short-term solutions – we need long-term development
in
agriculture."
He cited the case of Tanzania, which produced a
surplus last year and
could donate food to the region, but due to poor rains
and failed crops this
year, an estimated two million people would need food
assistance.
"We can’t afford to swing between surpluses and
deficits. We need to
be more consistent . . . It is a contradiction that
people in Africa live in
abject poverty, when we have the resources: water,
fertile land and people.
Agriculture is an area where we (SADC) can make a
difference," Ramsamy
concluded.
– IRIN
Daily News
Mozambique customs impound sugar load
MUTARE – Mozambican customs authorities have impounded six tonnes of
sugar
worth $2.1 million, that was smuggled into that country from
Zimbabwe.
The sugar, sent into Mozambique last Friday, was
seized earlier this
week in Manica town, about 60 kilometres east of
Zimbabwe’s border city of
Mutare.
Mozambican Customs
Director Jose Chicote Caetano, told the Mozambican
news agency, AIM, that
police also impounded a pick-up truck used to
transport the smuggled
products.
However, the police failed to arrest the three people
believed to be
the owners of the merchandise.
It was not
immediately clear whether the culprits were Zimbabweans
or
Mozambicans.
"What we want is to check the source of
sugar smuggling into the
country, that is causing a severe damage to the
national sugar industry.
Thanks to co-operation with the police, our
operations have been a success,
which show in the reduction of cases of sugar
contraband", Caetano told the
news agency.
Smuggling of
sugar and other basic goods into Mozambique is rife as
there is a lucrative
markets for the goods.
Mozambicans rely on Zimbabwean goods
such as sugar, maize meal,
potatoes, tomatoes, eggs, cold meats, tea bags,
cereals, soft drinks and
canned beer.
However, authorities
in Mozambique have launched a campaign against
the smuggling of sugar into
their country in a bid to protect that country’s
sugar
industry.
Mozambicans shun sugar produced by a company in
Beira, preferring to
buy Zimbabwean sugar saying it is of better
quality.
The sugar is used mainly to brew illicit brews such as kachasu.
Wayne Bvudzijena, the police spokesman, yesterday said
police were
arresting an average of 36 people a week for smuggling goods
into
Mozambique.
Bvudzijena said, "We are arresting them. We
have several patrols along
the border area. That is one way we are trying to
contain the problem."
The government accuses illegal cross
border traders of causing the
shortages of basic foodstuffs in the country
and also the local Zimbabwe
dollar which the traders are accused of stashing
out in neighbouring
countries.
Own Correspondent
Daily News
ESC report not helpful – lawyer
AN
ELECTORAL Supervisory Commission (ESC) report requested by the
High Court to
help it determine the case of opposition candidates prevented
from submitting
their nomination papers for local government polls this
month would not be of
much help to the court, a lawyer for the applicants
said
yesterday.
Harare lawyer Sheila Jarvis, representing the 11
opposition Movement
for Democratic Change (MDC) party aspiring candidates,
told Justice Ben
Hlatshwayo that the report by ESC chairman, Sobusa
Gula-Ndebele, did not
have much information but merely confirmed that the
atmosphere was tense at
Chegutu nomination court.
She said:
"In general, the ESC report has not provided the court with
much assistance,
save to confirm the tense environment and the gunfire
dispersing people from
the nomination court and that someone, other than the
applicants, was
prevented from filing his nomination in Chegutu on 21 July
by the
interference there."
Jarvis, of Harare law firm Atherstone and
Cook, urged the court to
"timeously throw the necessary lifeline to democracy
and without further
ado, (and) ensure a further opportunity for submitting
nominations".
The MDC aspiring candidates, who say they were
attacked and prevented
from submitting their nomination papers allegedly by
ruling ZANU PF party
militias, want Justice Hlatshwayo to order
Registrar-General Tobaiwa Mudede
to accept their nominations to contest
council elections in Chegutu at the
end of this month.
Justice Hlatshwayo last week ordered the ESC to submit a report on the
events
at the Chegutu nomination court, saying "their views and observations
would
be critical to the finalisation of this matter".
In his report,
Gula-Ndebele claimed that proceedings inside the
nomination court were
"relaxed and peaceful" and that they were conducted in
an orderly
manner.
Gula-Ndebele, a former military intelligence officer,
told the court:
"In the afternoon, the commission’s representative noted that
the
environment was tense.
"At approximately 1430 hours
(whilst in court), he heard the sound of
gunfire (three
shots).
"He later collected that these shots had been fired in
the air by the
police to disperse people who, it is believed, could have
interfered with
court proceedings. The holding of court proceedings was,
however, not
interrupted.
"In the Commission’s view, the
proceedings of the nomination court
were done in accordance with strict
adherence to provisions of the Electoral
Act."
After MDC
candidates failed to submit their papers, ZANU PF candidates
were then
declared winners in accordance with the electoral law that where
there is no
opposing contestant, the sole candidate be proclaimed
the
winner.
Court Reporter
Daily News
MDC accuses ZANU PF of poll fraud
KADOMA
– The opposition Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) party
yesterday accused
the ruling Zanu PF party of clandestinely registering its
members to vote in
the Kadoma municipal and mayoral elections almost a month
after the
registration exercise was officially closed.
MDC chairman for
Midlands province, under which Kadoma falls, Evans
Ruzvidzo, told the Daily
News that his party had since last week observed
hundreds of suspected ZANU
PF supporters registering as voters at the
Registrar General’s offices in the
mining town.
Ruzvidzo said: "On Monday a group of about 300
Zanu PF supporters
thronged the district registrar’s offices where they were
formally
registered as voters in our presence.
"When we
confronted the district registrar, Mr Kazingizi, for
clarification, he said
the registration was for the forthcoming by-election
for Kadoma
Central."
ZANU PF PF spokesman Nathan Shamuyarira could not be
reached for
comment on the matter by the time of going to print last
night.
The registrar for Kadoma, who would only identify
himself as
Kazingizi, denied that people were still being registered to vote
in the
local government elections scheduled for 30 and 31
August.
He said: "The voter registration exercise was
officially closed on 30
June and has not been extended."
The
government’s Electoral Supervisory Commission (ESC) that is tasked
with
ensuring that elections are free and fair said voters being registered
now
were for future elections and not for the forth coming local
government
elections.
ESC spokesman Thomas Bvuma: "Voter
registration is a continuous
process and people are always registering any
time.
"But for a specific election such as the one in Kadoma,
there is a
cut-off date.
"That cut-off date was 10 June 2003
and those who registered after
date will certainly not vote in this election
but in other future polls."
Reporters from this newspaper on
Monday this week saw truckloads of
suspected Zanu PF supporters disembarking
at the Kadoma registration
offices.
Some of the people, who
were being ferried to the offices wore ruling
ZANU PF party uniforms and most
openly confirmed they had come to register
as voters.
"We
have come here to register and we will vote," one of the suspected
ZANU PF
supporters told this reporter.
Last week the MDC said it had
unearthed about 6 000 ghost voters on
the Gweru voters’ rolls for the
forthcoming council polls.
ZANU PF, which has lost nearly every
other major election in urban
areas to the MDC in the last three years,
battles it out in at least nine
municipalities where new mayors and
councillors will be chosen at the end of
the month.
But the
ruling party has already won at least 30 seats uncontested
after suspected
ZANU PF militias prevented MDC candidates from submitting
names for
nomination in Bindura, Marondera and Chegutu towns.
Meanwhile,
police in Harare yesterday permitted the MDC to mount a
roadshow through
Harare’s central business district and affluent suburbs to
kick-start its
election campaign to retain the vacant Harare Central
parliamentary
seat.
A police vehicle monitored the convoy from close range.
Although the police cleared the opposition party to
proceed with its
roadshow, they did not allow the party to hoot or to address
the public.
A convoy of more than 20 vehicles left the party’s
headquarters at 12
noon yesterday and drove around the streets in central
Harare before the
convoy drove to major business centres in Harare Central
constituency to
unveil their bid to reclaim the seat left vacant by MDC
legislator Mike
Auret who resigned due to ill-health. The MDC’s Murisi
Zwizwai battles it
out with ZANU PF’s William Nhara for the seat. MDC
officials did not address
people during the roadshow but could not resist
hooting to cheering supporte
rs along the route they were cleared to use by
the police. "We wanted to
have another roadshow before the election. But the
police said they were
committed with the agricultural show." Also MDC leader
Morgan Tsvangirai,
vice-president Gibson Sibanda and secretary-general
Welshman Ncube were last
night scheduled to address residents at a Harare
hotel. Zvizwai said his
party’s campaign would focus on ways of combating
crime, political
intolerance among Zimbabweans and cultivating relations with
business,
industry and civic society for the development of the constituency.
Own
Correspondent
Daily News
Is the bank notes crisis a security
threat?
FOR the past few months, the country has been enveloped
in an
unusual crisis: a critical shortage of local bank notes, especially
$500
notes. This is in addition to the now "normal" shortages of basic
food
commodities, inputs of all kinds, forex, the crippling and chronic
fuel
shortages, etc, etc.
But the shortage of bank notes has
taken Zimbabwe by storm; it is the
"mother" of all shortages. This is so
because even where the other scarce
commodities are available, mostly in the
underground economy, one needs cash
to buy them. Zimbabwe is essentially a
cash-run economy in which almost all
transactions are cash
transactions.
Without cash, everything else grinds to a halt.
And "everything else"
includes rent, rates, electricity, mortgages, food,
medicines, and
transport, to mention a few basic essentials. Being unable to
pay for these
items because one does not have any money anywhere is
tolerable.
It’s a totally different situation when you cannot
buy whatever you
want to buy simply because you can’t access your own money;
it’s absolutely
intolerable and dehumanising.
There are few
things as annoying, frustrating and humiliating as not
being able to get your
own money. It’s worse than being unable to access
your own house or being
chased out it.
Many bank account holders have literally been
sent away empty-handed
and their anger has long reached boiling point, and
it’s understandable.
Moreover, the cash crisis affects
virtually everyone (except those who
are hoarding the cash or connected to
the hoarders) from urban workers to
"old" and "new" farmers, from MDC to
ruling ZANU PF supporters, from "Green
Bombers" to uniformed security
forces.
In fact, two days after drafting this contribution, The
Standard (17
August 2003) ran a headline Soldiers run amok over
cash.
It was reported that about 40 soldiers and police
officers ran berserk
after being told that the Chitungwiza branch of Beverley
Building Society
had run out of cash. This prompts the question: who will
guard the guards?
Apparently, the civilians, who were in another queue, did
not run amok.
The simple point is that cash crisis is
non-partisan and
non-discriminatory, and to the extent that it affects all
corners of the
country, it unites all corners of the country in this misery
and
humiliation.
National unity is achieved via the national cash crisis!
I have long subscribed to the thesis that
Zimbabweans are slow to
anger and that we are not mass activists, at least
not in the organised
sense of mass action.
However,
Zimbabweans are perfectly capable, like all human beings, of
spontaneous
outbursts of anger once their frustration has reached
breaking
point.
Further, such sudden explosions of anger are
often not in search of a
political solution in the sense of regime change.
The anger is directed at a
specific grievance or target, but can have
far-reaching political
consequences, including regime
change.
The point here is that a perfectly non-political event
can trigger a
chain of events that have unanticipated political
ramifications.
For one thing, political entrepreneurs, who
never initiated, let alone
anticipated, the riotous behaviour, always stand
ready to fish in troubled
waters.
This then brings us to the
intersection between the cash crisis and
political
upheavals.
I agree (which is very seldom indeed) with
conspiracy theorist
Tafataona Mahoso in his contribution in The Sunday Mail
of 3 August, 2003.
To me, he got the causes wrong but the consequences
right.
He characterised the "cash shortages and the
manipulations of our
currency as a serious security threat" and that "the
so-called cash crisis
is the most lethal and most effective method of doing
the job (of mass
stayaways) so far".
He continued: "Cash
scarcity is more lethal than past stayaways
because, where peasants and newly
resettled farmers used to defy calls for
stayaways to continue with their
normal business, this time they are the
most severely hit by the cash
shortages. No one can escape from taking
part!", including soldiers and the
police.
If anyone had any doubt that the government itself is
acutely alarmed
by the potential political consequences of the cash crisis,
the Press
conference of 29 July 2003 provided ample testimony. The Press
conference
was the occasion at which Herbert Murerwa, the Finance Minister,
announced a
string of new measures to arrest the bank notes
crisis.
The announcement itself was not significant. The
significance was in
the people who flanked him as he delivered the medicine.
These were none
other than the Defence Minister, Sidney Sekeramayi, and the
State Security
Minister, Nicholas Goche. The only security portfolio that
appeared not
represented was the Ministry of Home Affairs, in charge of the
police.
The Zimbabwe Republic Police Support Unit has been summoned
to deal
with riotous crowds at several banking institutions when irate
clients
failed to access their cash. Now the police and their uniformed
colleagues
have proved not immune to the riotous tendency. One of the
measures
announced was the formation of a Cabinet taskforce chaired by
Murerwa with
all the three critical security ministers as
members.
No evidence is more eloquent testimony to the fact that
the government
takes the cash crisis to be a grave security threat to its
political
survival. The stern and worried faces of Sekeramayi and Goche at
the Press
conference betrayed this. What should be noted is that this time
around, the
security forces will not be dealing with the perpetrators of the
cash crisis
as such, but with the consequences of the cash
crisis.
This crisis is, therefore, fundamentally different from
other crises
that are allegedly instigated by the "British-sponsored" MDC.
This one is
home-grown. The perpetrators are invisible, but those reacting to
the cash
crisis are not. Even as the rioters do not necessarily seek
political
change, the consequences of their actions are manifestly political.
This is
the extent to which the cash crisis is a regime threat, that is, a
threat to
the government.
No doubt some of the contingency plans
likely to be considered by the
Murerwa-led taskforce are strategies and
tactics of dealing with the angry
public should the public decide to take
matters into its own hands,
notwithstanding the famed "wrath of the law". The
cash crisis is the most
visible and sharpest manifestation of a deep,
comprehensive and debilitating
national malaise.
The country has
never been in deeper despair. If not managed urgently,
decisively and with
positive results, the cash crisis threatens to wreck the
regime and its
government, succeeding where the opposition has so far
failed.
By Eldred Masunungure
Eldred Masunungure is head of the Political
and Administrative Studies
Department at the University of Zimbabwe
Daily News
Why the silence on RBZ governor?
CLOSE to
a month after the expiry of Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe (RBZ)
Governor Leonard
Tsumba’s term, the government is inexplicably silent about
his replacement,
even though the central bank critically needs someone to
take charge and
restore confidence in an increasingly uncertain
financial
sector.
The financial sector and many Zimbabweans
eagerly awaited the
announcement of a new central bank governor on 1 August,
but the day came
and went with no word from the Finance Ministry about who
has been chosen
for this critical post.
As Zimbabweans have
come to expect from the government, neither the
Finance Ministry nor any
other state official has taken the time to apprise
the nation about what
steps are being taken to fill the post.
Instead, people are
being left to speculate about possible candidates
and the problems that could
be impeding the selection of a new RBZ governor,
which is unlikely to be
instilling confidence in Zimbabwe’s financial
sector.
Yet if
the Finance Ministry was serious about maintaining stability in
this sector,
it would have moved with speed to either install someone in
Tsumba’s place or
to prevent speculation by making a statement to inform the
nation about
whatever is causing delays in the appointment of
his
replacement.
It must be clear to most right-thinking
Zimbabweans, among whom it
seems this country’s leaders cannot be counted,
that the Reserve Bank has
never needed a governor more.
The
institution is battling to alleviate severe cash shortages, partly
attributed
to Zimbabwe’s foreign currency crisis and to rampant inflation,
which some
analysts predict will soon top 1 000 percent.
It is unlikely
that a new governor would come up with a magic solution
to the cash crisis –
this must be obvious to everyone. But that the
government would leave the
central bank rudderless at such a critical time
is the height of
irresponsibility.
Zimbabwe is facing a crisis that is causing
serious inconvenience to
millions of people, but the institution that should
be responsible for
coming up with solutions is blundering without a
substantive head.
While the government takes its time about
filling the post, many
financial institutions are anxiously awaiting policy
decisions that are
unlikely to be made until a new central bank governor is
installed.
For instance, the financial markets have for several
months been
awaiting a new monetary policy statement that they were hoping
would be
announced by a new governor and which they expect to contain
measures to
deal with inflation.
While they wait, many
financial institutions and other local companies
cannot make long-term
decisions and speculators are making a killing at the
expense of the
productive sectors.
If the government is at all serious about
arresting costly speculation
and uncertainty, it has to move with speed to
appoint a replacement for
Tsumba or tell the nation when it is likely to do
so.
Of course, we cannot emphasise enough that whoever takes
over at the
central bank should be given the freedom to take tough decisions
that will
arrest Zimbabwe’s macroeconomic instability.
This
means the government must abandon its puppet master tactics and
allow the
Reserve Bank its autonomy, even if this means allowing it to take
decisions
that will be painful for long-suffering Zimbabweans.
It has
been said before but bears repeating that it is the government’
s
interference and populist policies that have contributed to the mess
that
central bank officials are now being blamed for.
As
Member of Parliament Victor Chitongo pointed out in the House on
Tuesday,
heads should roll because of the cash crisis, but clearly Reserve
Bank
managers alone cannot take the fall for this monumental
disaster.
The government – which, judging from its handling of
the central bank
governorship, has learnt nothing from its past mistakes –
should shoulder a
substantial part of the blame.
But
numerous calls for the government to resign in shame over its
misgovernance
have fallen on deaf ears in the past, so we will not waste our
time even
suggesting such a thing here.
However, if the government does
not care enough to get its act
together and soon, it is likely that
Zimbabwe’s leaders will shortly wish
they had taken the option to bow out
gracefully.
Daily News
Zimbabwe fiasco likely to feature at food
conference
WITH a recovery in agriculture central to a wider
African economic
recovery, it is likely that policy makers will be looking to
this week’s
conference of agricultural economists being held in Durban for
some fresh
ideas.
The urgent need for African economic
recovery is clear. Sub-Saharan
Africa is the only region in the world to have
experienced a large increase
in the number of undernourished people in the
past 30 years.
If this trend continues, Africa cannot possibly
meet one of the
Millennium Development goals of halving hunger in 30
years.
There have been some gains in African agriculture
recently, but there
have been some spectacular disasters
too.
Nine years ago, Zimbabwe’s President Robert Mugabe opened
the meeting
of the International Association of Agriculture Economists, a
body which
brings together international economists from research, academic
and
financing institutions. Then, Zimbabwe was an example to Africa for
both
small- and large-scale agriculture. Today the country is in deep crisis
with
more than half the population dependent on food aid.
Zimbabwe is likely to be discussed at the conference this week,
although it
is not on the formal agenda.
In many ways Zimbabwe shows the
limitations and frustrations of
agricultural economists and that agricultural
recovery is firmly in the
hands of politicians in certain
countries.
"Economists can turn around lots of things, but not
fundamental
governance problems," says the outgoing president of the
association,
Joachim von Braun, who is also the director-general of the
Washington-based
International Food Policy Research
Institute.
He says there are issues that donors and governments
should address as
a matter of urgency to bring rapid, proven results to the
problems and
challenges facing African agriculture. Market access to advanced
industrial
countries is one of the issues near the top of his list for
agricultural
recovery, but the institute’s team is not hopeful the World
Trade
Organisation talks in Cancun next month will solve this
problem.
If agricultural protection is lifted in developing
countries, a number
of studies suggest that Africa will see a US$3 billion
(Z$2 472 billion)
annual increase in national income, as agriculture makes up
30 percent of
the continent’s exports.
Von Braun would like
to see greater public investment in rural
infrastructure, such as roads,
storage facilities, and banking. Although
agriculture makes up between 25
percent and 50 percent of most sub-Saharan
countries’ gross domestic product,
investment in agricultural infrastructure
is only between 4 percent and 6
percent.
During the 1980s and 1990s, most African governments
embarked on
fundamental economic reforms to their pricing regimes to lower
the
discrimination against their domestic agricultural
sectors.
Most governments have depreciated their exchange rates
and allowed
farm gate prices to rise, giving farmers a greater incentive. But
the lack
of infrastructure continues to bedevil efforts to make markets work
more
effectively.
– Business Day
Daily News
Net credit jumps by 136 percent
NET
credit to the government from the Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe (RBZ)
jumped 136.3
percent to $124.6 billion in the first four months of the year,
while credit
to banks shrinked by 37.27 percent to $39.4 billion, according
to latest
figures from the central bank.
Economic commentators said the
trend was worrying, given that the
government had indicated in its latest
economic blueprint, the National
Economic Revival Programme, that it wanted
to see growth in the productive
sector.
They said this was
not being supported by growing funding of the
Treasury – whose appetite for
spending had continued to rise – at the
expense of the country’s financial
sector.
The analysts said diminishing funding of Zimbabwe’s
productive sectors
had contributed to the economy’s negative growth rate,
which is around 14
percent, an indication of critical economic
recession.
Credit to the government is mainly used to finance
consumption
activities, including civil servants’ salaries and other
activities that do
not increase economic productivity.
David
Mupamhadzi, chief economist with Trust Bank Corporation, said
most of the
government’s funds were not channelled to productive sectors,
which is
crucial in eliminating growing poverty in Zimbabwe.
"The
increase in the net credit to government is mainly to finance
consumption
expenditure, which does not directly contribute to economic
growth," said
Mupamhadzi, adding that the government was actually crowding
out crucial
private sector investment.
The government is now heavily
dependent on the domestic market for
funds because of its alienation from
most of the international community.
Balance of payments
support from multilateral institutions such as the
International Monetary
Fund and the World Bank has been suspended for the
past four years because of
huge debt arrears and controversial government
policies.
This has worsened the country’s foreign currency shortages,
contributing to
company closures that have increased unemployment. Ranga
Mandaza, an economic
analyst at Century Holdings, said the country’s
unemployment rate was
unacceptably at around 70 percent and could only be
reduced if the government
used its funds on productive and exhaustive
activities.
Exhaustive expenditure refers to government spending on infrastructure
and
other activities that enhance economic productivity.
"The
government is currently facing a critical budget deficit, which
is a true
reflection of its inability to finance developmental activities,"
said
Mandaza. The budget deficit in 2003 is expected to total $241.9
billion, up
from $136.9 billion last year.
However, analysts said with the
impending supplementary budget that
the Finance Ministry is expected to table
before Parliament, the deficit
would be much higher, putting upward pressure
on inflation.
University of Zimbabwe economist Edwin
Muchapondwa said the allocation
of more credit to the government would lead
to " a huge social loss".
Business Reporter
Daily News
Zimbabwe must pay IMF US$32 m by December
THE Zimbabwe government has to pay up to US$32 million (Z$26.368
billion) by
December in outstanding arrears on debts owed to the
International Monetary
Fund (IMF) to avoid losing its voting rights when the
organisation’s board
sits on 6 December, it was learnt this week.
In a recent
62-page report on Zimbabwe, the IMF said the southern
African country had on
28 May paid US$3 million (Z$2.472 billion) on its
debt after promising to
make quarterly payments to clear its arrears with
the Bretton Woods
institution.
According to the IMF, the US$3 million was the
first significant
payment to the Fund by Zimbabwe since the middle of last
year.
However, up to US$32 million in outstanding arrears to
the Fund should
be cleared by the end of the year, or else the Harare
authorities should
show a strong commitment to clear the
arrears.
If Zimbabwe fails to implement either of the two
options, the IMF
board is likely to suspend the country’s voting rights when
it meets in
early December.
Zimbabwe’s arrears to the IMF
stood at about US$234 million (Z$192.816
billion) as of 31 May this year and
will continue rising until the
government makes significant payments to the
fund.
Zimbabwe was due to pay another US$1.5 million at the end
of June, but
it was not possible to establish yesterday whether the money had
been paid.
It was not possible to obtain the information from
IMF senior resident
representative Gerry Johnson, who flew out of the country
yesterday and will
only be back in on 2 September.
The IMF,
however, noted in its report: "In spite of the problems to be
faced in
honouring their commitment to make quarterly payments of US$1.5
million to
the Fund, they (Zimbabwe government) have resumed payment with a
US$3 million
on 28 May."
"The payment is small compared to debt service
obligations falling due
to the Fund (about US$32 million during June –
December 2003) and to the
stock of arrears (about US$234 million as of end of
May)."
Zimbabwe, which is battling crippling foreign currency
shortages, has
been failing to settle outstanding arrears to the IMF and
other multilateral
donors since 1999.
Balance of payments
support to Zimbabwe from the IMF and other
multilateral institutions has been
suspended partly because of the debt
arrears and also because of government
policies that have eroded property
rights and the rule of
law.
Suspension of the financial aid has worsened the country’s
hard cash
crisis.
Business Reporter
Daily News
Not fooled by ‘money in the bush’ tricks
What idiots does ZANU PF think we are to try to lie to us that
people were
found counting money in the bush?
Where on earth can you find
people, even fools, counting such a large
sum of money in the
bush?
We are not fools. There is nothing like that and you know it.
You did not even bother to show those foolish economic
saboteurs on
the camera.
Most probably we would have seen "Muurayi" (Killer Zivhu) among them.
Hakuna mari, hakuna mari
chete, matadza, siyai basa kupinde vamwe
zvinake munyika yababa (Money just
isn’t there, you have failed so please
quit and give others a
chance)
Jonathan Matariro
Harare
Daily News
Cabs must not turn away cash depositors
I
find it very illogical for the Gweru Main Street branch of CABS to
be turning
away cash depositors during this cash crisis.
I went to the
branch to deposit some money twice, only to be told by
their staff manning
the queue that I had to join the queue with those who
were making
withdrawals.
On 14 August, I tried to explain to the staff
members that I could not
stand in the queue for hours with a bag of cash as
that would compromise my
security, but they would have none of
it.
The following day, I tried again, only to be told the same thing.
I phoned the bank from across the street and I was told
this was a
measure to control the queue and I could as well go away with the
money if
at all I could not join the queue.
I have not tried
to go back and deposit the money in my only account
with them and I am
keeping the money at home and the effects of this on the
cash crisis are very
obvious.
May the CABS management please explain how managing
queues by turning
away cash depositors can contribute to solving the cash
crisis.
Instead, people bringing cash to the banks should be
given prefernce
since this makes it possible for others to withdraw
money.
Frustrated Client
Gweru
Daily News
Of cash shortages, rules and regulations
HAVE you ever realised that things do not just happen haphazardly or
at
random, just like that?
They tend to follow certain rules and
regulations. If you sit down
properly and analyse anything, including events
in your own life, trying to
understand why and how things happened the way
they did and being very
honest with yourself, you will be
astounded.
You will realise that if you had given it time and
thought right at
the beginning, you could have seen it coming and probably
avoided it. But
you did not and now you are in a mess. Too
bad.
It sounds very much like I am talking about our current
cash crisis,
does it not? And yes I am. Here is how and why it
happened.
You see, there are basically two types of laws in the
world. These are
natural laws or laws of nature, and man-made laws. I can
tell you that I am
not talking about man-made laws here. These do not matter
at all since they
do not make a difference in our lives.
Surprised ? Just wait.
We have had a lot of man-made laws
trying to change or govern human
behaviour since time immemorial, but nothing
has ever changed. Man-made laws
say thou shall not steal, though shall not
kill, though shall not commit
adultery, though shall not lie, thou shall not
be corrupt and so forth and
so on.
But ever since the
beginning of time, man is still a thief, a killer,
an adulterer, a lier and
everything else that he is not supposed to be,
according to himself. The only
purpose that man-made laws serve is for those
in power to be able to
prosecute and punish those of us who may break their
laws and nothing more.
They do not prevent anything from happening at all.
For
example, in Zimbabwe today we have had a deluge of laws since our
problems
began in earnest in 1999. Hoarding ( whatever that means) of fuel,
maize,
sugar, cooking oil and now cash was outlawed, but the shortages of
these
things continued unabated.
Foreign exchange bureaux were
outlawed, but there is still no forex in
the country. The black market was
long ago made illegal, but still it’s the
in thing today, even more
so.
You can say that about almost anything and everything that
man has
ever and can ever make laws against. Make all the laws you want and
nothing
will ever change. Things do not happen according to man-made laws,
but
according to the laws of nature.
I wish our government
knew this. Everyday, they gazette another law
about cash, yet everyday cash
gets scarcer and scarcer. Will these guys ever
learn? No amount of laws will
ever bring us back to normal.
If we want to get back to normal
in Zimbabwe today, it’s about time we
started obeying the laws of nature.
Defying them will get us nowhere!
What are these laws of nature
anyway? Funny to ask such a question,
but these are the laws that have made
you and me be here on earth in the
first place. There were no man-made laws
when my father and mother made me.
They just did it naturally and naturally I
was created, and here I am.
So far I have talked about some of
the laws of nature in human
biology. There are also laws of nature in
physics, chemistry, mathematics,
psychology, sociology and so forth and so
on. In fact, there are laws of
nature everywhere, but unfortunately, they are
not written down anywhere and
a lot of us may not even be aware of them and
yet they are definitely there
and they determine and govern our behaviour
everyday.
These are the laws that it would do us a lot of
mighty good if we
tried to obey. But in Zimbabwe today, our very own
government is trying to
defy them every day, without success of course. If
they continue like this,
all our problems will also continue and even
increase and naturally, things
will have to come to an end one
day.
Let me show you how we tried to beat the laws of nature
and failed
here in Zimbabwe. Our government had a noble idea no matter how it
came
about (i.e. honestly or dishonestly) to give land back to the people,
but
against all known laws of nature, vakazorova shumba nembama, and now we
are
in serious trouble, including themselves.
Naturally, you
do not do something for which you are not prepared. Is
it not natural that if
you fail to prepare for something, then you have
prepared to fail, and when
you fail do you get surprised as to why you
failed? Do you then go about
blaming others for your very own failures
caused solely by you when you
failed to prepare adequately for your
endeavour? No, no, no, no, you do not
do that!
Ladies and gentleman, let us be very honest with
ourselves here and
with each other too. Did we adequately prepare for taking
back our land, as
noble an idea as it is, or did we just wake up one day to
grab it back?
If our forefathers had, as ill-prepared as they
were then with their
bows and arrows, decided to continue fighting the
whiteman for the very same
land with his superior weaponry in the first
Chimurenga, would they not have
been naturally wiped out? Where would we be
now if they had done that? Of
course, nowhere and perhaps with no third
Chimurenga either. But our
ancestors chose to be wise and obeyed the laws of
nature that say that guns
are better than spears in any battle and here we
are today in our own
botched third Chimurenga, seemingly trying to defy
natural logic but with
not much success.
So, rather than do
things properly, our government talked long and
loud about their intention to
take back our land without paying for it since
it was similarly taken in the
first place. Well and good about the taking
back of the land bit, but,
naturally, things are not accomplished by words
but by deeds. They should
have done something and not just talked. Naturally
as well, industry did
something about it. There was no response in talking
from industry. Action
chete. They panicked and lo and behold, in no time we
had no forex. Then the
natural progression of things followed according to
the laws of nature. No
forex led to no petrol, which led to no industry,
which in turn led to no
mealie-meal, no sugar, no bread and now no cash.
Very soon, there shall be no
water, no electricity and finally no pay. Mark
my words. By Dr. Cleopas
Sibanda
Daily News
Zimbabwean economy needs socialist
transformation
TWENTY-three years after independence, where is
our economy? It is
in an intensive care unit and it urgently needs to be
saved, only by us
Zimbabweans.
A planned economy is the only
road to success. A planned economy is
possible only if the people have taken
the power into their own hands and
under a socialist system. It is possible
to develop the national economy, in
a planned way.
In 1980,
the power was in our hands as Zimbabweans. Ten years later,
in1990,
corruption was now crippling the country right from the top.
Ten years later, one of the strongest opposition parties to be formed
in
Zimbabwe emerged and from there ,the power of the people
totally
disappeared.
The economic basis of our country will
only be firm and developed if
the people’s democratic system is re-installed
and strengthened.
It has been weakened over 23 years and the
people’s democratic system
has not been consolidated, now it is impossible to
draw up and implement
comparatively long-term plans.As I have mentioned
before, the power must be
in the people’s hands.
There was
absolutely nothing wrong with giving land to the people,
that was a step
towards moving away from colonial industrialisation.
The
problem with the fast-track land redistribution was that it gave
land to
politicians and not to the poorest and deserving citizens
of
Zimbabwe.
A lot of former farm workers are living in
destitution, not even
knowing how they will make a living the next day.
Previously, Zimbabweans
used to live from hand to mouth, now it has gone
below that standard.
A land commission must be run by honest
people from all interest
groups, including women’s representative committees
and chiefs, and they
should recognise all social, economic, cultural and
traditional values and
processes.
A planned way for the
reconstruction of the economy will afford the
prospects of socialist
construction and a bright future for the entire
people and this will confirm
faith in victory. Hence, Zimbabweans can
surmount any difficulty with still
greater courage.
At present, we need to lay foundations of
socialist industrialisation
and basically solve the problem of food and cash
shortages, clothing, and
housing.
This simply means the
country should devote its attention to all
aspects of the problems of
economic construction and the people’s living
standards and solve them in a
proportionate manner by combining them
rationally.
In other
words, while stepping up all work of construction for the
future development
of our country and for the further consolidation of the
nation’s economic
foundation, we should plan simultaneously to solve the
problems of food,
housing, cash problems in order to improve the people’s
material and cultural
life.
Zimbabwe is a rich country in terms of resources and can
be easily
turned into an independent industrial-agricultural
state.
The laying of the foundation of a socialist
industrialisation will
help this transformation. Liquidating
colonial/lopsided industrialisation
and building an independent, modern
socialist industry will help construct
an independent, self-supporting
economy. This means building a country in
which we can earn our own living.
That is, a country which can support
itself.
The creation of
such an economics foundation requires both heavy and
light industries with
modern technological equipment.
We need to build an independent
heavy industry and a developed light
industry.
As for
agriculture, it needs to be revisited and it should be
converted from a
background rural economy.
Now it is hard to anticipate a stable
harvest. The new farmers should
be fully supported by the government and at
the same time, they should also
utilise all the land for mass
production.
An advanced rural economy will enable farmers to work
easily, reap
bumper harvests at all times free from disasters and guarantee
sufficient
food supplies and industrial/raw materials. The government and the
people of
Zimbabwe should respond to such a call, mobilising to build this
kind of
hopeful, joyful and prosperous socialism. People might ask: Can we
reach
this goal? Is it possible to build such a country? It is not a dream.
Of
course it is attainable; it is not at all a dream. At the same time, it
is
important to find a final rational solution to the questions of
economic
construction and the people’s living standard both in financial
policy and
in accumulation and consumption. We cannot follow a policy of
consuming all
we earn without accumulation. We must constantly increase
accumulation for
the future, for our country’s prosperity, for its
industrialisation and for
the sake of further consolidating the basis of
socialism. Accumulation is of
course for the people. It is different from
consumption only in terms of
time. The entire people of Zimbabwe need to be
concerned about the
accumulation and that the country will become rich and
strong once again and
the people’s living condition will improve only when
economic construction
goes and production will steadily rise through
accumulation. This is the law
of economic development and the Government and
the people must be brought to
have a clear understanding of this law. We must
continue to observe the
principle of regulating accumulation and consumption
in a rational way. My
fellow Zimbabweans, the power is in your hands. Let’s
save our economy
before it goes beyond recognition. Prince Chibanda
Chinhoyi
Financial Gazette
(Harare)
August 21, 2002
Posted to the web August 21, 2003
Hama
Saburi
Harare
Zimbabwe's biting economic crisis, the worst in the
country's 23-year-old
post independence history has spawned a vibrant
informal sector where those
made redundant due to the faltering economic
fortunes are trying their hand
in business to survive.
Street corners
have been transformed into vending cites in disregard of
municipal by-laws
while home industries have also mushroomed around
residential
areas.
The furniture and clothing industries have been the hardest-hit,
as
customers are now buying from emerging home industries.
It is
estimated the working population in the formal sector has declined
from 18
percent in 1980 to 10 percent last year.
While there are no official
statistics about informal activities, economic
pundits claim the decline in
the formal job market has to a certain extent
been off set by growth in the
informal sector.
Analysts are, however, divided in their interpretation
of the informal
sector's contribution to the economy.
Critics
described the growth as reflective of the height of desperation
caused by the
biting economic meltdown.
President Robert Mugabe, desperate for quick
solutions to the crisis blamed
on his government, leads a band of optimists
who threw their weight behind
the informal sector.
The 79-year-old
leader told guests invited to witness his inauguration in
March last year:
"Greater emphasis than before will be placed on the
informal sector in order
to adequately revamp it as a vital contributor to
gross domestic
product."
Harare economist, Collin Magurah, described the sector as a
potential growth
area that could turn around Zimbabwe's waning economic
fortunes.
Eighty percent of the volume of business generated in the
United States
comes from the informal sector. The sector has grown ten-fold
in other
industrialised countries such as Japan and Germany in the past two
decades.
"Sentiment is that the growth in the informal sector in Zimbabwe
is more
driven by unemployment than anything else," said
Magurah.
Unemployment has reached over 70 percent, with estimates
indicating it could
leap beyond 80 percent inside the next two
years.
"At the moment, the majority of people operating in the informal
sector are
survivalists and not businesspeople.
"These are people who
are ready to leave whatever they are doing if they get
formal employment
elsewhere," added Magu-rah.
The sector needs to be nurtured into the
formal sector where it can begin to
contribute towards the payment of taxes
and generation of the much-needed
foreign currency.
Analysts said
players in the informal sector were reluctant to join the
mainstream economy
because of huge operational costs involved.
They are content operating in
the peripherals where they escape the tax net
and other
contributions.
Start up costs are also minimal in the informal sector,
while the ease to
exist is another major advantage.
Growth in the
informal sector has, however, had a double-edged sword effect
in that it has
encouraged established companies to go underground.
While it has absorbed
hundreds of thousands of school-leavers and
retrenchees, substantial business
has been lost in the formal market.
A considerable chunk of business
sustaining the informal sector is also
largely unlawful, such as the illegal
trade in foreign currency and fuel.
The huge premiums charged by informal
traders are then added by companies
resulting in spiralling production costs,
relentless price increases and
high inflation.
For instance, while the
official price of United States dollars is $824
against the Zimbabwe dollar,
illegal foreign currency dealers are selling
the same unit for as much as $5
000.
The price of petrol has also gone up on the black market from the
gazetted
pump price of $450 a litre to around $1 700 on the black
market.
Informal traders are also side-stepping price controls by
circumventing
scarce commodities from the formal market and selling them on
the black
market at exorbitant prices.
John Robertson, a local
economic consultant said workers have been exposed
to all sorts of injustices
because of the growth in the informal sector.
Workers are not adequately
protected because they have no access to medical
aid, pensions and are
generally poorly remunerated.
The economic consultant said it would be
difficult to sustain such growth
unless if it is matched by the expansion in
the production base.
"You need producers as well who need huge amounts of
money in machines,
technology and quality control, among other things. Once
we do that, we will
be able to provide something people can trade. Countries
get wealthy by
producing and not trading alone.
"Zimbabwe has a
discriminatory, hostile tax environment, which makes it easy
to stay
informal," Robertson said.
He said there is need to encourage those with
capital to pour more resources
into production.
Robertson said: "The
process is long-term and needs confidence. At the
moment, there is no
confidence and we should build it up starting with
respecting property
rights."
Zimbabwe Congress of Trade Unions (ZCTU) chief economist,
Godfrey Kanyenze,
said people would continue to shun the formal sector until
employers begin
to pay real wages in line with inflation.
Inflation is
now close to 400 percent yet some companies are still awarding
wage increases
below 50 percent.
"It is a sign of weakness in the economy. We are
cascading towards a
volatile situation. These are the things that builds up
towards violence,"
said Kanyenze.
Most workers have turned to
moonlighting to make ends meet amid fears that
the situation could degenerate
into what happened in Uganda in the early
1980s.
During this period,
salaries in Uganda fell far below inflation to an extent
where there was an
exodus of workers into the informal sector.
At one point the United
Nations considered paying its workers additional
money to keep them in formal
employment.
Unlike in the past when a family used to have just one
breadwinner, the
majority of families, particularly those in high-density
suburbs now have
two or three breadwinners to make ends meet.
The ZCTU
chief economist said government actions have also given rise to the
informal
sector because of its failure to address shortages.
For instance, the
introduction of price controls has given rise to shortages
and the
mushrooming of the informal sector trading in scarce commodities
such as
cooking oil, mealie-meal and sugar, among other things.
Zimbabwe workers getting poorer by the day
Charles Rukuni, Staff
Reporter
Barutiwa News Service
Filed on Aug 21, 2003 @ 07:54
hours EST
Harare, Zimbabwe (BNS) - Someone trying to explain
inflation, according to
an article I read in Zambia - I cannot remember
exactly where-had this to
say: When a man went into a coffee shop and ordered
a cup, he was asked to
pay $500. When he went back for a second cup, he was
told the coffee was now
$850. When he pointed out that he had just bought
another cup for $500 a few
minutes before, he was told: "Sir, if you want two
cups of coffee, and want
to pay the same price, you order and pay for both at
the same."
This story must be ringing true to most Zimbabweans. Prices have
become so
unpredictable that one always has to carry extra cash just in case.
But
while most Zimbabweans are whining, cursing ten devils and
some
unmentionables, only at times pacifying themselves with the new
national
anthem, Rambai makashinga (remain steadfast), those with access to
foreign
currency are finding things cheaper by the day.
The worst hit
are workers whose wages are being eroded by the day while
employers complain
about ever increasing labour and production costs, yet
their companies are
making hefty profits.
According to the bread basket compiled by the
Consumer Council of Zimbabwe
(CCZ), the average employee has to work for five
months to afford one
month's basic requirements.
The poverty line by
the Zimbabwe Congress of Trade Unions (ZCTU), which is
based on inflation
figures released by the government, reduces this to two
months.
But
most people argue that the current official rate of inflation is
inaccurate
because the Central Statistics Office uses controlled prices to
calculate
inflation when very few people buy commodities at these prices.
According
to the ZCTU, the national minimum wage in June should have been
pegged at $88
863.25. The Consumer Council says a family of six needed $181
260 to meet its
basic necessities during the same month. The ZCTU figure is
based on a family
of five, the national average family size.
A closer look at the prices
quoted by the CCZ, however, shows that even
their prices are below the
market. For example, the council gives the
impression that the price of
mealie meal has declined from $5 000 for a 20kg
packet in April to $3 700 in
June when one cannot buy a 10 kg packet with
this amount. It puts the price
of bread at $550 a loaf when the cheapest
price one can buy bread for is
$700.
ZCTU figures show that the national urban poverty line almost
doubled in the
first half of the year from $44 697.31 in January. Urban
centres in
Matebeleland South are the cheapest to live in while Bulawayo
remains the
most expensive, beating Harare by almost $2 000 per
person.
According to the ZCTU, the minimum wages announced by the
government in
April in the middle of a three-day stay-away organised by the
labour
movement to protest the arbitrary 300 percent in the price of fuel
should in
fact have been implemented earlier and were based on the poverty
datum line
(PDL) for January. The government gave the impression that the new
minimum
wages had just been agreed upon by the tripartite negotiation forum
(TNF)
which comprises government, labour and business.
According to
the labour movement, the social partners had started
negotiations on
PDL-linked minimum wages soon after the signing of the
Prices and Incomes
Stabilisation Protocol on January 30, but the government
"unilaterally"
increased the price of fuel by almost 100 percent on 25
February before the
negotiations had been concluded.
The labour movement says it complained
to the government that this was in
violation of the Prices and Incomes
Stabilisation Protocol, "but in the
interest of progress", the TNF agreed on
the new minimum wages, which were
to be based on the January 2003 PDL levels
adjusted upwards for the fuel
price increase.
The minimum wages were
to be $23 070 for agriculture, $42 168 for the
agro-industry, and $47 696 for
industry and commerce. The ZCTU says the
government made an about turn and
declined to implement the new wages.
Instead, it invited all national
employment councils to indicate whether
they could meet these new wages or
not.
The ZCTU declined to participate in this exercise insisting the
government
should simply implement the new wages through a statutory
instrument as was
done in 2001. Statistics from the labour movement show that
wages agreed in
2001 saw the workers's lot improve with those in agriculture
getting 97
percent of the food poverty line up from 52.1 percent in 1995
while those in
industry were receiving 94.8 an improvement from 51.3 percent
in 1995. The
wages had, however, plummeted to 22 percent for those in
agriculture and
40.5percent for those in industry by the end of last
year.
According to the ZCTU, the government once again increased the
price of
fuel, this time by up to 300 percent, on 15 March 2003 before any
agreement
was reached. The ZCTU organised a three-day stay-away to protest
the
increase starting April 23-25.
In an effort to win the support of
the workers and break the stay-away, the
government announced new minimum
wages on April 24, but at the same time it
stated that national employment
councils would negotiate new gross minimum
wages which implied that the new
ages were not going to be enforced by law.
The ZCTU rejected the new
wages because they were already outdated. The new
minimum wages announced by
the government in April were 51 percent of the
poverty line for those in
agriculture and 53.6 percent for those in industry
at the end of
June.
The ZCTU says because of hyperinflation, which has seen the poverty
datum
line increasing by an average of $10 000 a month, national
employment
councils should depart from the traditional method of annual
negotiations
and should negotiate at shorter intervals.
This is easier
said than done. Though the business sector has joined hands
with workers in
their proposed stay-aways, they play a different ball game
when it comes to
hiking workers' wages. Most of the companies are making
hefty profits, even
in inflation adjusted terms, largely because they are
laying off
workers.
But even those employed are becoming poorer by the day as their
wages are
eroded by escalating inflation and a weakening currency which has
already
lost more than half its value this year alone.
According to
the ZCTU, the dollar in June was worth only 0.4 cents of the
1990 dollar. In
other words it was worth less than half a cent of 1990. Put
another way, one
needed $250 to buy goods bought with $1 in 1990.
But the dollar could be
worth much less because the ZCTU uses official
inflation figures for its
calculations. Most economic watchers believe
inflation is perhaps double the
official figure.
The erosion of the local currency is easily demonstrated
when one converts
it to foreign currency. The minimum wage for industrial and
commercial
workers in 2000, for example, was $3 109.76. This translated to
about US$39
using the black market rate. The current minimum wage of $47 697
translates
to only US$13 using a very conservative parallel market rate. This
means
that though the minimum wage has gone up more than 15 times in three
years
in nominal terms, it has declined by a third in real, or US dollar,
terms.
This is probably more than most workers can stomach as they
continue to
cling to the belief that their currency still has value when a
million
dollars is only just US$300. In other words, while most workers
are
suffering, those with access to foreign currency are laughing all the way
to
the bank. Things are getting cheaper by the day with stoves now costing
more
than $1 million actually costing them half the price they were five
years
ago.
The bread basket compiled by the CCZ, for example,
translates to only US$50.
Now where in the world would one get 2kg of
margarine, 40 kg of mealie meal,
6 kg of sugar, 500gs of tea leaves, 30 pints
of milk, 5 litres of cooking
oil, 30 loaves of bread, 2 kg of flour, 4 kg of
rice, 1.5 kg of salt, 20
bunches of vegetables, 8 kg of beef, six bars of
soap, and a three-roomed
house, all for US$50?
The problem, of course,
is that Zimbabwean workers are not paid in US
dollars, pula or rand. And they
are getting poorer by the day. The minimum
wage of $70 in 1980, for example,
now translates to a whopping $901 863.90.
Business Day
EU eyes new Zimbabwe food aid
rules
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
----
BRUSSELS-
The European Commission said on Thursday it was studying closely
the impact
of new rules on food aid distribution in Zimbabwe, but said it
would be
concerned if they hamper its operations in the country.
"We're aware of some
changes to the law in Zimbabwe, and we do have some
food aid operations in
Zimbabwe that are ongoing," said commission spokesman
Michael
Mann.
"We would be very concerned if there was some sort of a move to
hamper
ourselves and people like the World Food Programme from distributing
food
aid which is a vital service to the people there."
Aid agencies
in Zimbabwe reported this week that the new regulations
effectively ban
relief agencies from independently distributing
international food aid to
millions of hunger-threatened people.
The order, issued last week, will
see the distribution of international food
aid shift from relief agencies to
local government and village authorities.
"We're asessing exactly what
this law means, when it comes into force and
what it will mean for us," said
the Brussels commission spokesman, adding
that it was too early to give a
definitive judgment on the situation.
AFP
ZIMBABWE: Think-tanks finds talks key to peaceful change
[ This report does not necessarily reflect the views of the United Nations]
JOHANNESBURG, 21 Aug 2003 (IRIN) - In a special
report on the Zimbabwean
crisis, the United States Institute of Peace said
the best means of ensuring
a peaceful political transition was a combination
of increased international
and domestic pressure on the
government.
The Washington-based institute said that although the idea of
a national
government of unity fell out of favour following the breakdown of
talks
between the government and the opposition Movement for Democratic
Change
(MDC) in April 2002, a poll conducted last year showed that the
majority of
Zimbabweans were in favour of this option as a way out of the
political
impasse.
Since a unilateral solution to the political
deadlock was increasingly
impracticable, movement towards a transitional
government or some form of
power sharing has gained ground, the political
think-tank found.
This scenario could include joint parliamentary and
presidential elections,
as well as various constitutional amendments
curtailing the powers of an
executive presidency and changing electoral
laws.
But while media reports exploring this option have increased, so to
have
concerns about transparency and stakeholder participation by civil
society
organisations.
The think-tank remarked that civil society
groups were keen to negotiate
their role in the transition process, aiming to
ensure that they are not
left out by the government and MDC
initiatives.
"Some are arguing that any mediation efforts and transition
dialogue must
formally include representatives of civil society to ensure the
talks move
beyond the narrow balance-of-power concerns of ZANU-PF and the
MDC," the
report noted.
Human rights groups have also called on the
international community and
United Nations to investigate reports of rights
abuses. News reports on
Wednesday said the Zimbabwe Human Rights NGO Forum
will approach the United
Nations Commission on Human Rights to request it to
second a special envoy.
The institute also questioned the impact of
further mass protest action,
saying acts of civil disobedience alone were
unlikely to result in political
change given the government's control of the
security apparatus.
"While there is still a popular view that mass action
may be a necessary
condition for continued dialogue, there is perhaps even
greater fear of
violent government clampdown - particularly against students,
who are at the
forefront of any such action," the report said.
Change
from within ZANU-PF was more likely, given overtures last year by the
chief
of the armed forces General Vitalis Zvinavashe and Speaker of
Parliament
Emmerson Mnangagwa to the MDC. However, the MDC made public the
overture,
which controversially involved early retirement for President
Robert Mugabe.
Mnangagwa subsequently denied approaching the MDC.
The institute
commented that lack of consensus within ZANU-PF could make
interparty talks
less likely and "until the succession battle is resolved,
the anti-Mnangagwa
faction has a strong incentive to block talks mediated by
South Africa or
other regional powers".
Should change come from within ZANU-PF, ruling
party elites would seek
protection from investigations into the acquisition
of personal wealth, and
from potential prosecution for human rights
violations, the report stated.
Despite recent hints by Mugabe that his
party members should discuss the
succession, the "lack of expressed interest
suggests that Mugabe has not
signalled sufficiently to his party members that
he will step down any time
soon".
In the event of a president's
resignation or death, the Zimbabwe
constitution requires a fresh poll within
90 days.
The study found that change via military involvement seemed to
have the
support of some within ZANU-PF in 2002, and would benefit the
current elites
in the country, since such a move was unlikely to bring about
substantive
policy change. However, recent events brought into question
whether a
military coup would indeed be successful.
Deteriorating
conditions of service and real wages have affected morale and
created some
degree of resentment and alienation in the lower levels of the
military, but
while these conditions were worth considering in view of a
possible military
coup, the report downplayed the possibility of collective
action. "Divisions
between the command and rank and file would be expressed
in other ways - for
example, by lower-ranking soldiers refusing to obey
orders to attack unarmed
demonstrators, or stop mass actions," the report
said.
The report
concluded that a negotiated or mediated strategy held the
strongest prospects
for breaking the deadlock between the two parties, and
charting non-violent
change in Zimbabwe.
News24
Zim to discuss food flow
21/08/2003 21:40 -
(SA)
Harare - Zimbabwe has agreed to meet international relief
agencies to
discuss a new law that gives it full control of food
distribution, the World
Food Programme (WFP) said on
Thursday.
President Robert Mugabe's government last week introduced new
regulations
that banned the agencies from independently distributing
international food
aid to millions of famine-threatened people, raising
suspicion that the aid
was likely to be distributed on partisan
grounds.
Luis Clemens, WFP spokesperson in Zimbabwe said his organisation
had held
talks with the Minister of Social Welfare July Moyo on Wednesday to
"express
our concerns about several issues in the policy
document".
The Minister promised he would hold a meeting with all the
donors
distributing food aid in Zimbabwe, where it is estimated some 5.5
million
people, or half the population, will run out of food before the end
of the
year.
"We also made it clear that several donors had contacted
us and pointed out
their concerns," Clemens told AFP.
Zimbabwean
opposition groups have already accused the government of
discriminating
against known opposition supporters in the distribution of
emergency
aid.
There have been reports that local authorities have been asking
people to
produce membership cards for the ruling ZANU-PF party in order to
receive
food.
The European Commission said on Thursday it was studying
the impact of new
rules on food aid distribution, and said it would be
concerned if they
hampered its operations in the country.
The new
policy directive has not yet been implemented at local level.
Meanwhile,
Clemens said the identification of beneficiaries and distribution
of food aid
was continuing to be carried out with full participation of WFP
partner
organisations on the ground.
Currently some 3.5 million Zimbabweans are
receiving food aid, a number
forecast to rise sharply as food stocks dwindle
towards the end of the year.
The government last month launched an appeal
for 700 000 tonnes of aid to
stave off hunger until next year's harvests in
April.
Poor rains have devastated crops and grazing in this southern
African
country, once hailed as the breadbasket of the region.
The
opposition Movement for Democratic Change (MDC), international aid
agencies
and western nations say that a government land reform programme
that has
redistributed former white-owned commercial farms to new black
farmers is
also to blame for the food crisis.
Financial Times
Zimbabwe ups spending by 84% in revised
budget
By Tony Hawkins
Published: August 21 2003 17:37 | Last
Updated: August 21 2003 17:37
Zimbabwe's government is expected
to spend 84 per cent more this year
than envisaged in the national budget but
this will be financed by increased
government borrowing with no tax changes,
according to Herbert Murerwa,
finance minister
Tabling a
supplementary budget in the Zimbabwe parliament on Thursday,
Dr Murerwa
shrugged aside the country’s deepening economic woes. "The major
challenges
we face arise mainly from high inflation and poor foreign
currency
generation,"” he said.
The minister said state revenue in the
fiscal year to December 31
would more than double to Z$1,141bn (US$1.4bn),
chiefly due to inflation
which reached 399.5 per cent year-on-year in
July.
Government spending will be Z$672bn more than originally
budgeted at
Z$1,442bn.
The budget deficit at Z$301bn will be 30
per cent higher than the
initial budget estimate, but as a proportion of GDP
it will fall to 7.3 per
cent from 11.5 percent. This is because the
government is now forecasting a
GDP of Z$4,123bn, almost double the
projection made at the time of the 2003
budget last November.
The minister’s statement was almost completely bereft of details of
the state
of Zimbabwe's economy, though it did reveal that manufacturing
output fell
8.6 per cent in the first four months of 2003.
No official forecast
of the real growth rate of the economy has been
issued and on Thursday Dr
Murerwa failed to update the government’s official
inflation forecast for
2003 of 96 per cent.
In the first seven months of this year,
consumer inflation averaged
over 280 per cent.
The finance
minister said that agriculture would recover 2.3 per cent
this year – in
stark contrast to forecasts by farming organisations who
predict a 25 to 30
per cent decline.
Dr Murerwa conceded that the benefits of
February’s 93 per cent
devaluation of the Zimbabwe dollar had been
“short-lived”, repeating his
promise made at that time to review the “export
support rate” –
government-speak for the official exchange rate.
Government ministries were consulting with stakeholders on the matter,
he
said, fuelling market speculation that a further substantial devaluation
of
the official exchange rate is likely soon.
SABC
Zimbabwe to increase salaries for officials
August 21, 2003,
09:08 PM
Herbert Murerwa, Zimbabwe's Finance Minister, announced in
Harare today that
President Robert Mugabe's cash trapped government has
decided to increase
the salaries of cabinet ministers, MPs and
judges.
Murerwa did not say when exactly this would come into effect and
by how
much. He was addressing Parliament this afternoon during his
presentation of
the government's R5.4 billion supplementary
budget.
Murerwa announced also that next month Zimbabwe will print a new
one
thousand-dollar note as its highest denomination, in attempt to deal
with
the country's worsening cash crisis. Currently, Zimbabwe has a
five
hundred-dollar note as its highest denomination.
ZIMBABWE: Housing backlog grows in tandem with economic
crisis
HARARE, 21 Aug 2003 (IRIN) - Zimbabwe's housing shortage
and economic crisis
has robbed many urban Zimbabweans of the dream of ever
owning their own
home.
Housing minister Ignatius Chombo has admitted
that the government is failing
to match demand, citing among other things, a
lack of resources. The
ministry says the national housing backlog was 1.5
million units in December
2002, and the city council of Harare, the capital,
has a waiting list of
300,000.
Harare has more than 10 major informal
settlements where the poor have been
forced to reside. One of the oldest is
Hatcliffe Extension, which sprouted
in the late 1990s when the government
evicted 800 families from the farm of
an opposition leader who had allocated
free stands, and dumped the squatters
20 km north of Harare.
Residents
of Hatcliffe Extension, located next to plush suburbs, use pit
latrines and
depend on one communal borehole for their water. Accommodation
consists of
wooden shacks and, during the rainy season, the shacks flood and
the pit
latrines overflow. Living alongside the original families are
criminals who
have moved into the settlement to escape the law.
The capital's
traditional working class suburbs are also bursting at the
seams. Thomas
Saizi lives in the crowded Matererini Flats in Mbare, where he
shares one
room with his family of six. The room is divided by curtains, in
attempt to
at least try and provide some privacy for the occupants.
"I grew up here
in Mbare and have been living in this room for the last 30
years. All my
children still live with me because they are unemployed and
cannot find
accommodation of their own," he told IRIN.
Saizi, who earns a living by
selling scrap metal, said his eldest daughter,
aged 27, had recently returned
from her husband with a 10-year old child,
bringing an additional burden to
the limited space.
"I have lost all hope of having my own house because I
do not have the money
to buy a residential stand. I do not see myself joining
the Harare City
Council housing list because it will not help me. I know of
friends who have
been there [on the list] for the past 20 or so years without
getting their
stands. Even if I managed to acquire a stand, where would I get
the money to
buy the material with which to build the house, not to mention
monthly
payments required by building societies?" asked Saizi.
Since
independence over 20 years ago, the city council has been trying,
and
failing, to improve living conditions in Mbare. On several occasions
it
resolved to demolish some of the worst of the accommodation in order
to
build better homes - plans which never materialised.
While few have
much hope of securing a home through the city council, where
officials have
repeatedly been accused of accepting bribes to circumvent the
waiting list,
Zimbabwe's middle class are also feeling the pinch.
Inflation has hit 400
percent and interest rates are around 80 percent. An
increasing number of
families failing to make their mortgage repayments are
losing their homes to
the banks.
For those who do own a plot of land, building materials are in
short supply
and extremely expensive. A 50 kg bag of cement with a gazetted
price of Zim
$800 (US $1) is being sold for Zim $12,000 (US $15) on the black
market.
Portland Cement, Circle Cement and Sino Cement, Zimbabwe's major
cement
producers, have drastically downscaled their operations, citing a
shortage
of raw materials.
George Utaumire, president of the Zimbabwe
Building Contractors’
Association, says the shortage of cement is crippling
any initiative to
build more houses.
"A lot of housing projects have
been shelved, leading to an increased
housing backlog. If by any chance
construction resumes, the houses will cost
more because of increasing costs,"
Utaumire recently told the independent
Daily News newspaper.
Most
house construction is done by private developers. Edith Kagoro,
chairwoman of
the Greater Harare Housing Co-operative Union, says
co-operatives in her
union often complain that private developers charge
exorbitant fees for their
services.
"Many prospective homeowners are finding it difficult to build
houses, even
if they might have acquired stands, because of the high fees
charged by
private developers. Affiliate co-operatives often come to us
complaining
that the cost of developing their stands is too high. There is a
significant
number of people who ended up selling their stands, some of them
with
half-complete structures," Kagoro told IRIN.
She added that some
of those that could afford it were buying stands for
speculative reasons,
thereby worsening the housing crisis. "Many people are
buying stands, but
with no intention of developing them. They simply wait
for a few years before
reselling the stands at exorbitant prices."
JAG OPEN LETTER FORUM
Email: justice@telco.co.zw; justiceforagriculture@zol.co.zw
Internet:
www.justiceforagriculture.com
Please
send any material for publication in the Open Letter Forum to
justice@telco.co.zw with "For Open Letter
Forum" in the subject
line.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Letter
1: Accountable Governance
The President,
CFU.
Dear Mr.
Taylor-Freeme,
My research indicates that:
"The first principle of
good governance is the Rule of Law.
*Everybody should obey the law. No
one should be above the law, no matter
how important or influential that
person is.
*If anyone breaks the law or orders anyone to violate the law,
that person
should be prosecuted.
*The law enforcement agents and the
courts must be impartial, and must not
be subject to political control or
other undue influence in the discharge
of their functions."
May I ask
you as President of the CFU if you, and your Council stand by
these
principles, and in what manner you stand by them? Please could you
reply on
behalf of your Council to justice@telco.co.zw in the interests
of
Transparency?
Yours faithfully,
J.L.
Robinson.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Letter
2: Re: Thought for the Day - 19 August 2003
Hi there
One of my
next projects is to do an audit of all the ridiculous things that
have
happened in Zim over the last 5 years. What I am looking for is info
like
the pensions - the fact that this can only buy 2 loaves of bread.
That it
appears more cost efficient to wipe you bum with Zim dollar notes
than to buy
a roll of toilet paper and other crazy examples like this.
Some serious and
others bordering on the ridiculous.
Please circulate this to as many
people as possible.
Thanks again
Bernadette
Carte
Blanche
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
All
letters published on the open Letter Forum are the views and opinions
of the
submitters, and do not represent the official viewpoint of Justice
for
Agriculture.