The ZIMBABWE Situation | Our
thoughts and prayers are with Zimbabwe - may peace, truth and justice prevail. |
| |
Zimbabwe dramatically withdrew from the Commonwealth last night just hours after Commonwealth leaders decided to extend the country's suspension from the organisation. Michael Dynes, Africa Correspondent, examines the significance of Zimbabwe's decision. Is it a surprise that Zimbabwe withdrew? It was not a surprise at all. Everybody knew it was coming. Mr Mugabe was just waiting for his chance to leave and it was presented to him yesterday when the Commonwealth heads of governments decided to suspend Zimbabwe indefinitely. President Olusegun Obasanjo of Nigeria had been in constant touch with Mr Mugabe throughout the four-day summit and had informed him well before the announcement that an extension of the suspension was the most likely outcome. Mr Mugabe told Mr Obasanjo that if the Commonwealth decided to extend Zimbabwe’s suspension, he would have no choice but to automatically withdraw from the body. Commonwealth leaders, therefore, knew well in advance that extending Zimbabwe’s extension would automatically lead to Harare turning its back on the group. What is the significance of Zimbabwe’s decision? There is not much in the way of practical effect. The most important thing is that Mr Mugabe will not have an international platform through the Commonwealth. He liked that hugely. He liked basking in the reflected glory of his peers. He is one of the oldest of the old-style nationalist leaders in Africa. He is the old man of liberation politics and likes to have other African leaders defer to him. The biggest effect will be on his personal ego. He was told the suspension was going to be extended and he refused to accept that. He does not believe that he has done anything to warrant suspension and that is the most incredible thing. He really believes that. What consequences does his decision have? It simply means that the Commonwealth's membership of nations has dropped from 53 to 52. Zimbabwe will come back at some time in the future when it has a democratically elected Government. Of that there can be no doubt, just like South Africa came back after 40 years of apartheid. How damaging has this week been to the Commonwealth? The leaders had an agenda about democracy and development and it has been completely eclipsed by the Zimbabwe saga and everybody is annoyed about that. They wanted to talk about things that were important to them: international trade, reducing agricultural subsidies and development, but everything has been thrown into the trash can because of Mr Mugabe. The delegates, and I am not exaggerating, are sick to death of it. Mr Mugabe completely sabotaged the summit in abstensia. Could Zimbabwe open up a black-white divide in the group? It is not simply a split between black and white. There are four or five black countries in Africa that supported Britain, Australia and New Zealand on the issue of the continued suspension of Zimbabwe. It is mostly the southern African states, excluding Botswana, who were opposed to the line taken by Tony Blair. | |
Copyright
© 2003, Dow Jones Newswires
LONDON (AP)--President Robert Mugabe
and his people may come to regret
his decision to leave the Commonwealth,
U.K. Foreign Secretary Jack Straw
said Monday.
Straw said
Mugabe's decision -announced Sunday night after
Commonwealth leaders meeting
in Abuja, Nigeria, extended Zimbabwe's
suspension for electoral
irregularities -was "entirely in character, sadly.
"I think it's a
decision which he and the Zimbabwean people will come
to regret," he said.
"Zimbabwe and all its people have strong links with the
Commonwealth," the
54-nation club of the U.K. and its former colonies.
"But President
Mugabe will not be there forever and other countries
have been out of the
Commonwealth -including Nigeria for a period -and come
back, and I look
forward to a time when Zimbabwe has a democratic government
and is back in
the Commonwealth," Straw added.
The decision to extend Zimbabwe's
suspension was opposed by some
African members of the Commonwealth including
South Africa, whose president,
Thabo Mbeki, had hoped to use diplomacy to
persuade Mugabe to implement
reforms.
The Commonwealth -whose
nations represent nearly one-third of the
world's 6 billion people -has
banned Mugabe from its decision-making
councils since 2002, after Mugabe was
accused of using massive force and
fraud to win re-election at
home.
(END) Dow Jones Newswires
December 08, 2003
09:59 ET (14:59 GMT)
MSNBC
Zimbabwe's Mugabe heads to conference in Geneva
HARARE, Dec.
8 — Zimbabwean President Robert Mugabe left Harare on Monday to
attend an
international information technology conference in Geneva, a day
after he
pulled his country out of the Commonwealth.
He was accompanied by his
wife Grace and Information Minister
Jonathan Moyo, state radio
reported.
Mugabe, facing increased international isolation over
charges that he
rigged his re-election last year, has been forced to cut down
his foreign
trips in the last three years after the European Union and the
United States
imposed visa sanctions on him and some of his officials over
his rule.
But Mugabe has managed to get around Europe and the United
States to
attend United Nations-sponsored conferences like the event in
Geneva, which
are exempted from the travel restrictions.
Political
analysts said Mugabe had isolated himself further by
withdrawing from the
Commonwealth.
Stuff, New Zealand
Stricken Zimbabwe becomes an orphan
09 December
2003
The real pity of Zimbabwe's decision to quit the Commonwealth is not
for the
Commonwealth itself, which will survive this damaging upheaval, nor
for
Zimbabwe's President Robert Mugabe, who felt cornered, but for the people
of
Zimbabwe, The Dominion Post writes in an editorial.
Stricken by
famine, poverty and tyranny, Zimbabweans need all the help they
can get, not
further isolation.
Commonwealth leaders would have known as they debated
extending Zimbabwe's
suspension from the Commonwealth that a possible, even a
likely, outcome
would be Mr Mugabe walking out of their grouping. And though
many leaders,
like New Zealand Prime Minister Helen Clark, may have preferred
not to
belong to a club of which Mr Mugabe was a member, she too will rue
his
resignation because it is another blow for Zimbabwe.
Mr Mugabe is
not a man who takes kindly to being told what to do. Not by his
own people,
not by his opposition or neighbours and least of all by a body
which he
perceives to be dominated by an agenda set by the Commonwealth's
"white"
nations. He was quoted at the weekend as likening these countries
to
characters in Animal Farm, where everyone is equal but some are more
equal
than others.
Mr Mugabe sees the Commonwealth as one of
Zimbabwe's problems which he has
just got rid of. Many Commonwealth countries
see Mr Mugabe as Zimbabwe's
biggest problem, and getting rid of him is
anything but simple. He has led
the country for 23 years, becoming more
despotic as each anniversary passes.
But he also commands a considerable
following, not only in his Zanu-PF party
but in other parts of Africa, for
being the big man who tells the white
countries where to go.
Sadly, Mr
Mugabe's image is only enhanced in the eyes of his followers by
events like
his saying at the weekend that he was taking Zimbabwe out of
the
Commonwealth. Like him, they choose to see problems in terms of a legacy
of
colonialism and white dominance, as white against black and rich
against
poor, rather than 20 years of political and economic mismanagement
which has
taken a country once considered the foodbasket of southern Africa
to the
edge of starvation.
Rather like the Pacific, the Commonwealth
prides itself on trying to reach
consensus on issues. This is inherently
difficult, involving, as it must,
mixing national, regional and global
politics. The debate to agree on
suspending Zimbabwe was plainly a fraught
one. Zimbabwe's neighbours, at a
top political level, want to support their
colleague. Their loyalty is
misplaced. It should be to the millions of
Zimbabweans existing on minimal
food and even less hope. It is they who need
support, not Mr Mugabe.
The Commonwealth made the right decision to
extend Zimbabwe's suspension.
Those supporting its readmission to the fold
could point to there being no
improvement in Zimbabwe since it had been
suspended. But the Commonwealth
had to take a stand, however symbolic it
might be.
All international multilateral bodies, including pan-African
groupings,
should treat Zimbabwe the same way, till till even Mr Mugabe is
forced to
see a pattern. In the meantime, ordinary Zimbabweans will recognise
the
Commonwealth's solidarity, but it will not put food on their tables.
And
there is the pity.
New Zealand Herald
Clark worried for Zimbabwe's
people
09.12.2003
By HELEN TUNNAH, NZPA AND REUTERS
ABUJA - Prime
Minister Helen Clark says she worries for the people of
Zimbabwe after
volatile President Robert Mugabe pulled his country out of
the
Commonwealth.
Zimbabwe has not yet formally told the Commonwealth it is
quitting the
54-nation group, which at its summit in Nigeria over the weekend
refused to
end the suspension of Mr Mugabe's regime.
Zimbabwe's rulers
said from Harare it would quit the Commonwealth in
protest.
Helen
Clark said the future of Zimbabwe would be jeopardised if Mr Mugabe
did march
out of the Commonwealth - as he has often threatened to do - and
embarked on
a "more ferocious regime of oppression even than we've seen
to
date".
"That wouldn't make things any easier for Zimbabwe. It'll
only make it
worse."
"I've always worried primarily for the people of
Zimbabwe because this is an
appalling regime."
After learning that
Zimbabwe remained indefinitely suspended from the
Commonwealth, Mr Mugabe's
ruling Zanu-PF party said the African nation would
now walk out of the group,
accusing nations such as New Zealand and Britain
of running a racist agenda
to force them out.
A spokesman said only lifting the suspension would
have been acceptable to
Mr Mugabe.
Last night, Zimbabwe's decision to
walk away was interpreted by some as a
blow to Commonwealth, but that was
rejected by both Helen Clark and
Secretary-General Don McKinnon.
Helen
Clark said Zimbabwe's decision was not a disaster. "The disaster would
have
been if leaders had walked out of here with the suspension lifted. That
would
have shown the Commonwealth to be a joke."
It was "sad" to see Zimbabwe
shut the door on an institution that had helped
the nation achieve
independence from minority white rule.
Mr McKinnon said the Commonwealth
would continue to try to talk with
Zimbabwe.
SABC
Zimbabwe Commonwealth exit hurts SA diplomacy
December 08, 2003,
05:47 PM
Zimbabwean President Robert Mugabe's decision to quit the
Commonwealth has
dented South Africa's policy of "quiet diplomacy" and
undermined its
standing among its African peers, analysts have
said.
President Thabo Mbeki has pursued a non-confrontational approach to
Zimbabwe
and tried to have its suspension lifted at the Commonwealth summit
in Abuja,
but the suspension held and Mugabe swiftly quit the 54-nation
club.
"Mbeki never likes to admit that he's wrong, but the softly softly
approach
hasn't worked. I think that the government's policy is so vague, so
subtle,
so nuanced, that it scarcely amounts to being a policy," said Tom
Lodge, a
political science professor at the University of the
Witwatersrand.
He added: "I think that within Africa Mbeki looks weak and
within the
Commonwealth he will be taken less seriously in the
future."
There is little personal warmth between the two former freedom
fighters, but
Mbeki has stood by Mugabe, shielding him to some extent from
the effects of
Western sanctions.
Some analysts said Mbeki's
commitment to land reform in his own country made
him less inclined to
denounce abuses committed under Zimbabwe's
much-criticised land
redistribution programme.
Landlocked Zimbabwe is economically dependent
on South Africa, from where it
gets much of its power and
fuel.
Analysts say South Africa's policy has become increasingly hard to
justify
as Zimbabwe's shrinking economy sinks ever deeper into crisis with
record
inflation and mass unemployment, and Mugabe's security forces
stifle
political dissent.
"Mugabe has not been helpful to South Africa
and Nigeria. He is also
isolating himself from the leaders on the continent,"
said Sehlare
Makgetlaneng, the head of research for Southern Africa at the
Africa
Institute in Pretoria.
"Humiliation for Mbeki"
In Abuja,
Bheki Khumalo, Mbeki's spokesperson, declined to comment on
Zimbabwe's
withdrawal, but Zimbabwe's shadow foreign minister told Reuters
the summit
had tarnished Mbeki's image.
"It was most humiliating for him and for his
country to attempt to prevent
the decision the Commonwealth took in the first
place, to be seen to be
defending a dictator who has brought ruin to his
country," said Moses Mzila
of the main opposition Movement for Democratic
Change (MDC).
"It was diplomatic bungling at such a high level that Mbeki
will feel hurt
for some time to come that his stand was tossed out the
window," Mzila
added.
Mbeki has repeatedly tried to mollify critics of
his policy, saying Mugabe's
Zanu-PF party was in high-level talks with the
MDC, despite denials by the
opposition party itself.
South African
opposition parties rounded on Mbeki today, deriding his policy
as a
failure.
"The argument by some African states that the readmission of
Zimbabwe into
the Commonwealth would encourage reform is a joke," said the
African
Christian Democratic Party (ACDP). - Reuters
Harsh Times Force Workers Onto the Streets
Zimbabwe Standard
(Harare)
December 7, 2003
Posted to the web December 8,
2003
Caiphas Chimhete
FOR three weeks, workers gathered at the
company's premises each morning,
singing songs denouncing the owner of the
firm.
Around mid-morning, they would retreat into the shade under trees
or nearby
buildings to play games to while away the time. For lunch, some ate
"maputi"
(popcorn) - sucked plastic tubes of fizzy drinks "freezits", while
others
without any money for these "luxuries" just sat around
chatting.
This had become the daily routine at Dunstan Transport
Company in Harare
where the workers had been on strike for three weeks
demanding better wages
and salaries.
The company's managing director,
William Dustan, had not set foot at his
firm's premises since the industrial
action began and the workers were
threatening to take over the beleaguered
transport concern and run it
themselves.
The troubles at Dustan
Transport, say economists, are not unique but a
microcosm of the general mood
among the poverty-stricken workers
countrywide.
Increasing job
actions, with workers from various companies, parastatals and
government
departments demanding salaries that tally with the levels of
inflation and
the soaring cost of basic commodities, are clear signs of the
difficult times
workers are experiencing.
Since two weeks ago, specialist doctors,
nurses, clerks and postmen at the
country's sole postal authority, Zimpost
and Civil Aviation Authority of
Zimbabwe (CAAZ) air traffic controllers are
among those that have been on
strike pressing for better salaries and
allowances.
And just a couple of weeks earlier, workers at National
Breweries, Farm &
City, Zimsec, TelOne, the University of Zimbabwe's
lecturers and pilots at
Air Zimbabwe also stopped work demanding higher
salaries.
The strike actions, say economists, are further damaging a
fragile economy
that has suffered serious decline because of President Robert
Mugabe's
skewed policies which many blame for the economic
meltdown.
For instance, the on-going industrial action by nurses and
doctors has
virtually paralysed the country's health delivery system.
Patients are dying
in clinics and hospitals, as the strike shows no sign of
relenting.
That apart, the strike by Zimpost workers has disrupted postal
services
countrywide and it is feared that it will seriously affect the
movement of
mail during the festive period.
As the economic recession
continues, companies are closing down and
retrenchments are
rampant.
For those lucky to be still in employment, incomes have been
seriously
eroded by the unprecedented 525,8 percent inflation rate resulting
in
skyrocketing costs of basic goods.
As a consequence, many workers
now walk to and from work while others forgo
lunch to save for more pressing
needs.
With the economy expected to shrink by 13,2 percent this year,
poverty is
also expected to claim more victims among ordinary
workers.
"Economically, no one is in control. The economy is being
directed by the
wind to which ever the direction it is blowing," said
Lovemore Matombo, the
president of the Zimbabwe Congress of Trade Unions
(ZCTU).
Attempts by the ZCTU to stage protests last month to force
Mugabe's regime
to address the economic recession, cut taxes and restore the
rule of law,
were ruthlessly put down by the police.
The protestors,
who included civic leaders, journalists and photographers,
were arrested
while others were brutally assaulted for trying to express
their displeasure
over the continued economic decline.
"Government is only concerned with
coming down hard on dissenting voices to
ensure that they survive a day
longer," said Matombo, who was among those
arrested by police for staging the
peaceful protest.
Analysts agree the frequent job stoppages currently
being experienced were a
clear sign of the hard times at hand and urged the
Mugabe government to
urgently address the economic anomalies or face "a
brewing storm" among
millions of hungry workers.
"In 1997, it started
like this but it later became a national strike that
forced the government to
reduce tax in 1998. The government survived by the
use of military force but
I don't think if it happens again it will survive
because everyone is
hungry," said Munyaradzi Gwisai, head of local chapter
of the International
Socialist Organisation (ISO).
Gwisai said strikes are reflective of the
failure by Zanu PF to run the
country and warned Mugabe to take his cue from
recent events in Georgia and
Bolivia, where presidents were overthrown by
angry masses.
"The solution to the workers' crisis is in the streets,
factories and
colleges of our country," said Gwisai.
The dreadlocked
Uni-versity of Zimbabwe lecturer believes there is an unholy
alliance between
Zanu PF and the business community to create divisions
among ordinary
workers.
"So the solution lies in the hands of the workers - they have to
free
themselves," says Gwisai.
Matombo said he believes protest is the
only language Mugabe's government
understands. He said the labour body would
stage another demonstration
within the next few weeks to demand reduction of
tax, respect of human
rights and management of prices of basic
commodities.
National Economic Consultative Forum (NECF) spokesperson
Nhlanhla Masuku,
said the plight of workers could only be addressed through
restoring the
country's macro-economic stability.
"The cost of living
is going up everyday. Supermarkets are raising prices of
goods everyday while
salaries and wages remain stagnant and as a result
workers become frustrated
because they are becoming poorer and poorer," said
Masuku.
Statistics
indicate that 80 percent of the country's population are living
below the
poverty line.
Gwisai urged the government to re-introduce price controls
and subsidies on
transport, food, farming implements and education to cushion
workers from
the spiralling cost of living.
Gwisai, who blasted
government for its high tax regime, said that presently
a worker needed a
salary of at least $1 million a month to live a normal
life.
"How do
you explain a situation whereby a person who earns $375 000 a month
is taxed
the same as one who gets $30 million a month. It's being
insensitive on the
ordinary worker," said Gwisai.
While workers are clamouring for
higher salaries by engaging in industrial
action, the economy continues to
bleed as production and provision of
essential services virtually grinds to a
halt in some areas.
"Companies are not making much profit these days
because the economy is in a
tailspin. How do you expect me to award huge
salaries to my workers when I
am not making any profit," said one
industrialist who declined to be named.
VOA
Obasanjo to Mediate Zimbabwe's Commonwealth Suspension
Nico
Colombant
Abuja, Nigeria
08 Dec 2003, 16:25 UTC
Nigerian
President Olusegun Obasanjo says he will try to get Zimbabwe back
into the
Commonwealth, which renewed the country's suspension during a
divisive summit
in Nigeria. Zimbabwe subsequently announced that it was
pulling out of the
group of mainly former British colonies.
Mr. Obasanjo said Monday
that maintaining the suspension was what he called
a difficult consensus, but
that all Commonwealth nations should accept it,
even if they are
opposed.
"Consensus means, really, that you can smile with one side of
your face, and
frown with the other side at the same time," he
said.
Mr. Obasanjo said he was disappointed Zimbabwe's president, Robert
Mugabe,
reacted to the decision by saying he was pulling Zimbabwe out of
the
Commonwealth entirely.
But the Nigerian president said he would
still act as a Commonwealth
mediator between Zimbabwe's government and its
opposition, so democratic
conditions there could improve and Zimbabwe could
regain full membership in
the group.
"We are determined to do
everything humanly possible within the values and
the principles that we
cherish in the Commonwealth to assist Zimbabwe, to
facilitate the return of
Zimbabwe to the Commonwealth," he said.
Mr. Obasanjo says he will send a
Nigerian official to Harare before the end
of the year to discuss
this.
Australian Prime Minister John Howard, who was in favor of
maintaining the
suspension, was also dismissive of Mr. Mugabe's decision to
pull out of the
Commonwealth. He said extending the suspension was a show of
support for
people in Zimbabwe suffering from what he called a lack of
democracy and
poor governance under Mr. Mugabe.
If the Commonwealth
had walked away from its responsibilities, the essential
hopelessness of
those people would have been increased," he said. "At least
they know that
there are a lot of people around the world inside the
Commonwealth who
believe that and understand that a restoration of proper
democratic
approaches inside their country is necessary, and an essential
precondition
to their lot improving."
Several countries from southern Africa had
called for the suspension to be
lifted, so that Zimbabwe could be less
isolated. They argued its problems
could be better resolved within the
Commonwealth.
The division marred the four-day summit and completely
dominated
discussions.
Late Sunday, Mr. Mugabe told leaders of
Nigeria, South Africa and Jamaica he
was pulling out of the Commonwealth
because of the renewed suspension. He
has said the group is being hijacked by
what he calls racist western
countries opposed to his forced redistribution
of white-owned land to
blacks.
Zimbabwe was first suspended in March
2002, after Commonwealth observers
said Mr. Mugabe's re-election had been
marred by rigging and state
intimidation.
Leaders from many other
African countries say taking part in Commonwealth
summits is very beneficial
to have their voices heard on global issues, and
also to attract investment
from within the group. The next Commonwealth
summit will take place in two
years time in Malta.
IOL
'Western powers bulldozed Zimbabwe exclusion'
December
08 2003 at 04:36PM
By Manoah Esipisu
Abuja - Zambian
President Levy Mwanawasa accused Western Commonwealth
members on Monday of
forcing Zimbabwe's exclusion through a split summit and
said leaders left the
Abuja gathering more divided than when they arrived.
In strong-worded
comments to Reuters before he left the Nigerian capital,
the southern African
leader said: "The Western countries bulldozed the
suspension of Zimbabwe
partly because of their economic muscle.
"I am very disappointed by that
decision and I am disappointed by Zimbabwe's
subsequent decision to pull
out."
Zimbabwe President Robert Mugabe was suspended from the group of
mostly
former British colonies last year because of charges he rigged
his
re-election and persecuted the opposition.
Commonwealth leaders
extended sanctions against Zimbabwe on Sunday despite
strong resistance from
a small but powerful minority of African members who
lobbied for its
readmission.
Mugabe immediately announced his withdrawal from the
Commonwealth,
denouncing a "racist" plot to punish his country for a land
reform programme
that gave white-owned farms to landless blacks.
Some
African countries, including Ghana and Kenya, backed Zimbabwe's
suspension.
But Zambia, South Africa, and Mozambique, among others,
campaigned to lift
it.
Mwanawasa said these countries would remain in the group despite
their
opposition to Sunday's resolution.
"The matter was not handled
as well as it should have been, and on this we
leave Abuja more divided than
when we arrived," he said.
"But I do not believe any other countries in
the region will quit the
Commonwealth in support of Zimbabwe. We will keep
our membership and
complain from within to make our grievances
known."
The Commonwealth declaration on Zimbabwe opened the way for it to
return
swiftly, but only if Mugabe engaged in political reconciliation and
stuck to
other Commonwealth principles including respect for human
rights.
Mwanawasa said the African caucus within the Commonwealth will
use the
African Union and other venues "to express our disappointment
and
disassociate ourselves" from the Commonwealth decision on
Zimbabwe.
Reuters
Zimbabwe Defiant After Pullout from 'Lynching Club'
Mon
December 8, 2003 11:49 AM ET
By Cris Chinaka and Randall
Palmer
HARARE/ABUJA (Reuters) - President Robert Mugabe's ruling party railed
at
Britain and its "white allies" Monday, saying they had forced Zimbabwe
into
a no-win situation which had left it with no choice but to pull out of
the
Commonwealth.
"Whatever our detractors and critics are saying, for
us this is like an
escape from hell because Britain and its white allies have
turned the
Commonwealth into a Zimbabwe lynching club," Didymus Mutasa,
external
affairs secretary of Mugabe's ZANU-PF party, told
Reuters.
The group of 54 mostly former British colonies renewed
Zimbabwe's suspension
Sunday, demanding that Harare seek reconciliation with
the opposition and
respect human rights, prompting a furious Mugabe to carry
out a threat to
withdraw.
Zimbabwe was suspended early last year on
the grounds that Mugabe, 79, who
has ruled the country since independence in
1980, rigged his re-election in
2002 and persecuted his
opponents.
Commonwealth leaders said they regretted Mugabe's response,
with British
Foreign Secretary Jack Straw warning it would hurt Zimbabwe's
people the
most.
"It's entirely in character, sadly, with President
Mugabe," Straw said. "I
think it's a decision which he, and particularly the
Zimbabwean people, will
come to regret," he added.
Membership in the
Commonwealth confers political prestige on an
international stage for poor
nations and some modest trade and aid benefits.
Members see exclusion from
the "gentleman's club," which highly values
cordial diplomacy, as an
insult.
But ZANU-PF's Mutasa was non-plussed by what he saw as the
Commonwealth's
"hypocrisy." "We withdraw our membership and they say we are
wrong and we
should stay, but stay suspended so that they can demonize our
government,"
he said.
"NOT IRREVERSIBLE"
Australian Prime
Minister John Howard noted, however, that it was not the
first withdrawal
from the Commonwealth nor was it irreversible.
"Nothing is permanent,"
said Howard, who took a hard line against Mugabe.
"You have to have
consistent standards in these matters."
Talks on Zimbabwe dominated a
four-day Commonwealth summit in the Nigerian
capital Abuja which closes
Monday, causing the worst split since South
Africa's apartheid policies in
the 1970s and 1980s and dividing members
roughly on color
lines.
Commonwealth leaders spent three days carefully crafting a
face-saving
declaration, which did not mention the word
"suspension."
It only talked of the hope for Zimbabwe's return on
condition that it engage
in political reconciliation and stick to
Commonwealth principles including
respect for human rights.
Most of
Zimbabwe's backers, including South Africa, declined to comment on
its
decision to withdraw, but one key ally, Mozambique President
Joaquim
Chissano, told reporters on entering the summit's final meeting: "We
are
upset."
Once southern Africa's breadbasket, Zimbabwe now relies on
aid to feed
millions. Unemployment is running at more than 70 percent and
inflation is
above 500 percent.
Mugabe accuses Britain and its allies
of punishing him for land reforms that
have given white-owned farms to
landless blacks, an argument that finds
resonance with other
Africans.
Zimbabwe's main opposition Movement for Democratic Change (MDC)
applauded
the Commonwealth's decision but said Mugabe's response was not in
the
country's interests.
"We congratulate the Commonwealth for
standing firmly on the side of the
people of Zimbabwe, and strongly urge the
rest of the international
community not to be bullied into turning a blind
eye to dictatorship,
genocide, murder and torture under the guise of
sovereignty," the party said
in a statement
IOL
'Zimbabweans will feel Commonwealth exit'
December 08
2003 at 12:30PM
By Reuters
Brussels -
British Foreign Secretary Jack Straw said on Monday Zimbabwe
would come to
regret its decision to quit the Commonwealth, but voiced
confidence that it
would eventually rejoin under a democratic government.
Zimbabwe quit the
54-nation group of mainly former British colonies on
Sunday after the
organisation said it was extending a suspension of the
country on grounds
that President Robert Mugabe rigged his re-election and
persecuted his
opponents.
"It's entirely in character, sadly, with President Mugabe,"
Straw told
reporters on his arrival in the Belgian capital for a meeting of
European
Union foreign ministers.
"I think it's a decision which he,
and particularly the Zimbabwean people,
will come to regret," Straw added,
noting the southern African country's
traditionally strong links with the
Commonwealth.
Amid sharp divisions at a four-day Commonwealth summit, the
organisation
decided to extend Zimbabwe's suspension but opened the way for a
possible
return if Harare engaged in reconciliation with the political
opposition.
"President Mugabe will not be there forever," Straw
said.
"And other countries have been out of the Commonwealth, including
Nigeria
for a period, and come back. And I look forward to a time when
Zimbabwe has
a democratic government and is back in the
Commonwealth."
Mugabe's information minister Jonathan Moyo told Reuters
the suspension
proved that "racist leaders in Britain and Australia" had
taken over the
Commonwealth.
Radio Netherlands
A pariah's powers of
division
by our African affairs editor Pieternel Gruppen, 8 December 2003
Zimbabwe's president Robert Mugabe has
withdrawn his country's
membership of the Commonwealth. The move came after
the grouping voted to
extend Zimbabwe's suspension over accusations that the
president rigged the
2002 elections.
Analysts warn that the
pullout will further increase Zimbabwe's
isolation. But it also leaves the
Commonwealth divided, virtually along
racial lines, with the UK and Australia
taking a tough line on President
Mugabe and many African states calling for
Zimbabwe's suspension to be
lifted.
In a damage-limitation
exercise, Commonwealth leaders said at their
Abuja meeting on Monday that
Zimbabwe would be welcome back if it made
democratic reforms.
President Mugabe´s re-election in March 2002 was dominated by fear.
Both the
opposition and a team of foreign observers reported widespread
fraud and
intimidation. This prompted the 54-nation Commonwealth to suspend
Zimbabwe
from its ranks.
On the eve of this year's annual meeting, the
grouping's heads of
government decided that Mr Mugabe doesn't yet deserve to
return to the fold.
The move came as a bitter blow for the president, says
Iden Weatherall of
Zimbabwe's Independent Newspaper:
"His
exclusion was a very serious blow to his prestige. He likes to
strut upon the
international stage and this must be a very big setback for
him. He spent
every waking hour in the last two or three months
concentrating on getting an
invitation to Abuja."
White punishment
President Mugabe
accused "white powers" within the Commonwealth, such
as Australia, Britain
and Canada, of extending his suspension as punishment
for his controversial
programme to seize white-owned farms and distribute
the land to blacks. The
programme has brought chaos to the economy of what
was once considered "the
breadbasket of Africa".
Professor Jack Spence of the London-based
Royal Institute of
International Affairs says the former colonial power,
Britain, is deeply
worried about the fate of white farmers in Zimbabwe and
about the crackdown
on the country's opposition forces.
"I
think the problem is that Britain and Australia, and Nigeria for
that matter,
would like the local leaders in the Southern Africa Development
Community to
put pressure on Mr Mugabe. But they have shown a real
reluctance to impose
sanctions on Zimbabwe; they have preferred the option
of quiet diplomacy and
that doesn't seem to have worked."
The poor will suffer
South Africa, in particular, was keen to keep Mr Mugabe on board.
Mozambique,
too, was vehemently opposed to renewing the suspension. Other
former colonies
within the Commonwealth argued that it had taken Britain
many centuries to
develop into a genuine parliamentary democracy.
Emotions ran deep
during the discussions, sparking the worst
Commonwealth crisis since the rift
over South Africa's Apartheid system in
the early 1990s. Smaller members
within the organisation are set to suffer
most from the current upheaval,
opines Prof Spence.
"The pity of it is that the Commonwealth does
have considerable
utility, especially for small poor states. The Commonwealth
does provide a
range of services, technical assistance, professional
involvement, and
that's valuable. It helps these small states. But if an
issue of Zimbabwe
dominates, then much of the value of the Commonwealth gets
dissipated."
Other topics of prime importance to these poor
countries, such as AIDS
and fair trade, failed to receive proper attention at
the Arusha conference.
In that sense, President Mugabe got his way after all.
Without attending, he
again managed to set the agenda of a key international
summit.
IRIN
Mixed reactions over Commonwealth
withdrawal
JOHANNESBURG, 8 Dec 2003 (IRIN) - Zimbabwe's human
rights and pro-democracy
groups said on Monday they were concerned that
President Robert Mugabe's
decision to pull Zimbabwe out of the Commonwealth
had scuppered hopes of
dialogue between the government and the main
opposition party, prolonging
the country's political crisis.
"It's
disappointing and it's distressing. It means that Zimbabwe is now out
of an
organisation that had the potential to resolve the current political
crisis,"
Tawanda Hondora of the umbrella NGO, Crisis in Zimbabwe Coalition,
told IRIN.
"From Mugabe's perspective it's a great Houdini act, stifling
international
criticism."
Mugabe said on Sunday he would not accept a decision by
Commonwealth leaders
meeting in Abuja, Nigeria, to reaffirm Zimbabwe's
suspension and the country
would leave the 54-member group with immediate
effect. He described the
Commonwealth's position, promoted by Britain and
Australia, as "pure
racism".
Zimbabwe was originally suspended from
the councils of the Commonwealth
after presidential elections in March 2002,
which a Commonwealth observer
mission said were neither free or fair. A
six-member panel, formed in Abuja
to deliberate on Zimbabwe's reinstatement,
ruled that not enough progress
had been made on issues of governance and the
suspension should be
maintained.
As a result of Zimbabwe's withdrawal
from the Commonwealth, "we are moving
to a very, very serious stage of
isolationism. We are at a dangerous stage
where [the government] doesn't
think it's now accountable to the
international community or that it can be
judged by those norms and
standards," said Phil Matsheza, director of the
Harare-based Human Rights
Trust of Southern Africa,
Matsheza commented
that there was little prospect at the moment of any
meaningful dialogue
between the ruling ZANU-PF and the main opposition
Movement for Democratic
Change (MDC).
"Talks are going to be a casualty [of Zimbabwe's
withdrawal]; human rights
and the rule of law are going to be a casualty.
Definitely, there's going to
be less conciliation and more nationalism, with
the government portraying
itself as a victim of racism," he told
IRIN.
Mugabe stated that a proposed Commonwealth mission to Zimbabwe to
promote
national reconciliation would not be welcome.
Political
analyst and pro-ZANU newspaper publisher Ibbo Mandaza said the
Commonwealth
had left Zimbabwe no other option but to quit, and called on
other African
countries to follow suit. Several Southern African leaders
said in Abuja they
were unhappy with Harare's continued suspension.
"There is a question
mark over democracy in almost all countries of the
Commonwealth, including
the host [of the summit] Nigeria. It's hypocrisy.
The Harare Declaration [the
Commonwealth's principles on good governance] is
a subterfuge to be used by
the white Commonwealth when it's convenient,"
Mandaza told IRIN.
"The
bottom line is: the real issue is not about democracy but regime
change, and
the issue of land [redistribution instituted by the government
in 2000]," he
charged.
Faced with political stalemate, MDC leader Morgan Tsvangirai
said on Friday
that his party would assess "our options, with a view to
unveil a detailed
programme of rolling mass action in 2004. The suffering
majority is ready
for such action".
Hondora thought such an attempt
would likely be "brutally suppressed" by the
government.
Mandaza said
he believed that after a similar attempt at public protest by
the MDC in June
was declared illegal and broken up by the security forces,
the party did not
have the capacity to mount an effective
disobedience
campaign.
Irate Bishops Issue a Hard-Hitting Pastoral Statement
African
Church Information Service
December 8, 2003
Posted to the web December
8, 2003
Osman Njuguna
Harare
Catholic bishops in Zimbabwe have
issued a pastoral statement calling on
Zimbabwean authorities and the
community at large, to uphold the four
pillars of peace, namely truth,
justice, love and freedom, in commemoration
of a 40-year old Encyclical by
Pope John XXIII.
The pastoral statement, titled Peace in a Divided
Zimbabwe, was released
here on November 30. It talks of the current social
and political ills the
southern African country is currently
facing.
"We cannot have a lasting peace without truth, justice, love
and freedom.
These four pillars enable us to build a society that is more
humane and
peaceful. The Government has a responsibility to create an
environment where
individuals , children, men and women , learn, appreciate
and develop in
them, a culture of truth, justice, love and freedom," say the
Catholic
clergymen in their four-page document.
The statement
continues: "We, the Catholic Bishops of Zimbabwe, speak to you
at a time when
life in Zimbabwe is at its lowest ebb. The political
situation is tense, the
economic situation is chaotic, and the social
situation is unbearable for the
majority of the people."
In the hard-hitting statement, the bishops
have noted that Zimbabweans are
suffering economic, social and political
ills, saying: "The poor are getting
poorer, while the rich are getting
richer....Inflation has gone out of hand,
(there is ) scarcity of cash, taxes
erode salaries, and the poverty datum
line is unmanageable."
The
clergymen have urged Zimbabweans to make serious effort to redress
these
elements, which will disrupt peace during the forthcoming Advent
(Christmas)
season.
Stuff, New Zealand
'Heartbreaking' drama for Zimbabwean expats
09
December 2003
By ANNA CLARIDGE
Watching the Commonwealth drama unfold
from her Christchurch home has been
"heartbreaking" for Zimbabwean journalist
Noreen Welch.
She left Zimbabwe in 2000 and says more than a decade of
political unrest
has left her homeland "decimated", and the country's
withdrawal from the
Commonwealth will not change
anything.
"(Withdrawing from the Commonwealth) means nothing to
(President Robert)
Mugabe. Don't think it's going to change things. This is
an issue that has
been ongoing since 1992 and it has only become news in the
last four or five
years. It's never been black against white. It's been
(about) greed and
corruption. Mugabe doesn't care what the rest of the world
thinks."
News of the Commonwealth's continued suspension of Zimbabwe, and
President
Mugabe's subsequent withdrawal from the organisation, was not
surprising,
Welch said.
"It's too late for something to be done. The
country is so decimated. It's
hard to believe it was once known as the jewel
in the crown of Africa."
Welch said she was still in contact with friends
in Zimbabwe who all said
they felt "helpless".
"It's heartbreaking. It
makes me sick that he has been able to get away with
it. The world has been
concerned with Iraq and before that Afghanistan, and
Zimbabwe has been left
behind in some respects."
To nurse Zimbabwe back to health, Welch said
the United Nations would have
to step in and hold "free and fair
elections".
Fellow Christchurch immigrant Angela Baldwin said last night
the withdrawal
would make no difference to families left living in
Zimbabwe.
"I don't think anything will change ... The UN or anyone could
impose
sanctions but the only people it would hurt are the citizens. There is
no
economy left whatsoever, it's pathetic. It doesn't bare thinking
about."
Mrs Baldwin's mother-in-law was still living in Zimbabwe,
fighting for her
land through the court system. She refuses to leave her farm
and says she
will fight to the death.
"We have made the whole world
aware of what is going on but what else can we
do. We feel so helpless. When
someone like Mugabe is getting away with
murder, what can you do? What does
it take to bring this person to justice?"
Solving Zimbabwe's problem
would take decades.
"There is no simple answer," Mrs Baldwin said. "If
they get rid of Mugabe,
it's also a question of who will take
over.
"And the country is going to need such a big cash injection from
outside to
get going again."
New Zimbabwe
Hoogstraten released from jail
By newzimbabwe.com
staff/BBC
08/12/03
PRESIDENT Robert Mugabe's friend and financier,
property tycoon Nicholas van
Hoogstraten who was jailed for killing a
business rival has been set free
after winning a legal battle to clear his
name in the UK.
The Court of Appeal agreed on Monday that the
prosecution's case against him
did not stand up.
He had been cleared
of murder but convicted of the manslaughter of
father-of-six Mohammed Raja at
the Old Bailey last year.
During the war of independence from Britain,
van Hoogstraten supplied money
to the liberation war movement. At the time,
van Hoogstraten pretended to be
a part of the white establishment
there.
Leaked Zimbabwean intelligence documents have revealed that in
return for
underwriting a 380 million dollar purchase of 14 MiG-29s from
Russia,
Hoogstraten would receive 500 000 hectares of prime ranching
property. The
deal would make Hoogstraten the largest landowner in
Zimbabwe.
Jailed for 10 years, Mr van Hoogstraten, 58, from Uckfield,
East Sussex,
served a year in prison before winning the right to a retrial
when his
conviction was quashed in July by the Court of Appeal.
The
man once described as Britain's youngest millionaire may now consider
suing
for wrongful imprisonment.
In July, Judge Sir Stephen Mitchell agreed
with Mr van Hoogstraten's
counsel, Geoffrey Cox QC, there was no foundation
for a manslaughter case.
There was a complete lack of evidence on which a
jury could convict, the
defence team had argued.
Prosecutor David
Waters QC immediately asked to seek leave to appeal against
the judge's
ruling.
The judge allowed the prosecution to seek leave to appeal - but
on Monday
the appeal court judges decided they had no jurisdiction and
referred the
matter back to Justice Mitchell.
As Justice Mitchell was
not available in court on Monday, Mr van Hoogstraten
was given bail by Mr
Justice Keith on condition he returned to the Old
Bailey on Tuesday to have
the case formally dropped against him.
Mr Raja's son Amjad, 42, said his
family were "shocked" by the development.
"Our family have now been
deprived of an opportunity to have the case heard
by a jury on what we see as
a legal technicality," he said in a statement.
"The family are devastated
that the extremely hard work of the police
officers involved in the case has
been totally undone by what we believe to
be a catalogue of mistakes by the
Crown Prosecution Service which resulted
in today's decision.
"We also
do not understand how or why key witnesses for the prosecution
decided to
retract or decline to give evidence at the trial, nor do we
understand how
some of the defence costs of a self-promoted
multi-millionaire were funded by
legal aid.
"We feel that these matters should be promptly and fully
investigated by the
authorities."
Mr Raja was stabbed five times and
shot in the face at point-blank range
with a sawn-off shotgun by Robert Knapp
and David Croke.
The 62-year-old businessman had begun court proceedings
against Mr van
Hoogstraten alleging fraud.
And Mr van Hoogstraten had
allegedly asked Knapp, whom he had met in prison
decades earlier, to teach Mr
Raja a lesson. He was alleged to have paid him
£7,000.
But his defence
team argued Mr van Hoogstraten could not have foreseen the
attack on Mr Raja
would inevitably end in death.
And in July Justice Mitchell agreed that
Mr van Hoogstraten could not
therefore be guilty of
manslaughter.
Knapp, 59, of Abbeyfeale, County Limerick, in the Irish
Republic, and Croke,
54, of Bolney Road, East Moulsecoomb, Brighton, were
both convicted of
murder and sentenced to life imprisonment.
Study to Assess Extent of Poverty in Zimbabwe
The Herald
(Harare)
December 8, 2003
Posted to the web December 8,
2003
Harare
THE Ministry of Public Service, Labour and Social
Welfare has appealed to
members of the public to assist its fieldwork teams
who are gathering
information for the Poverty Assessment Study (PASS II), a
socio-economic
survey.
The ministry's permanent secretary Cde Sydney
Mhishi said in a statement the
objective of the study was to assess the
current socio-economic situation of
households and communities in
Zimbabwe.
Information collected through this survey would be a major
input into the
National Poverty Reduction Strategy that would be formulated
after the
survey through a broad national participatory process involving
all
stakeholders.
The study would collect information on access to
education, health services,
employment, income, food security, housing and a
number of other
socio-economic characteristics.
PASS II, Cde Mhishi
said, aimed to interview more than 30 000 households
throughout the
country.
He said all information collected during the survey will
remain
confidential.
PASS II started last month and is expected to end
towards the end of this
month. The ministry in conjunction with other line
ministries and agencies
is conducting the poverty assessment
survey.
The study is being funded by various United Nations service
organisations
that include the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP)
and the United
Nations Children Education Fund (Unicef).
It is
estimated that more than 70 percent of Zimbabwe's population is now
living
below the poverty datum and this has been attributed to economic
hardships
prevailing in the country.
Doctors' Trial Set to Start
The Herald (Harare)
December
8, 2003
Posted to the web December 8, 2003
Diana
Nherera
Harare
THE trial of seven executive members of the Hospital
Doctors Association
arrested over allegations of allegedly contravening the
Labour Relations Act
is expected to start tomorrow at the Harare Magistrates
Court.
The doctors who include HDA president Phibion Manyanga, vice
president Akim
Mashoko, Tapuwa Musuka, Toziveyi Muchenje, Leolin Katsidzira,
Onesai Chihaka
and Tinashe Kanyowa were arrested for organising a strike by
professionals
who provide an essential service in breach of the Labour
Relations Act.
The trial comes at a time when salary negotiations
between Government and
the striking health staff are taking place.
The
seven who are part of the striking junior and middle level doctors
were
called for questioning by police last month for contravening some
sections
of the Labour Relations Act.
They appeared in court on
November 18 and were granted $50 000 bail each and
remanded to
tomorrow.
It is alleged that on a date unknown to the State, the seven
doctors from
major referral centres resolved to go on an unlawful collective
job action
to press the Government for a monthly salary of $30
million.
The State further argues that according to a section of the
Labour Relations
Act under Declaration of Essential Services, doctors are
described as an
essential service, which therefore makes it illegal for them
to go on
strike.
Junior and middle level doctors went on strike in
October demanding a
monthly salary of $30 million.
They defied a
Labour court order for them to report for duty on November 7
saying they
would only resume duties when they received a written
undertaking from their
employer, the Public Service Commission that their
grievances would be
addressed.
In a related matter, the Zimbabwe Nurses Association national
executive
which was supposed to meet at the weekend postponed its meeting to
tomorrow
.
The meeting will discuss whether the nurses should resume
duty or continue
with the strike.
Zina acting president Mrs Juliana
Njubani said the meeting, which was
scheduled for Saturday, did not take
place, as some members of the national
executive did not turn
up.
"Four members of the Zina national executive failed to turn
up.
"We have therefore postponed the meeting to Tuesday and hopefully we
would
be able to decide whether to return to work or continue with the
strike,"
said Mrs Njubani.
Nurses at some referral centres went on
strike on November 22 barely three
weeks after ending another strike
following an agreement between their
representatives and the Government for a
review of their salaries.
Patients at the affected referral centres are
only being attended to by
senior doctors, health staff from the uniformed
forces and student nurses.
New Zimbabwe
Mugabe pull out illegal - MDC
By newzimbabwe.com
staff
08/12/03
PRESIDENT Robert Mugabe's decision to leave the
Commonwealth was illegal,
Zimbabwe's main opposition party said today, urging
the world to help return
democracy to the impoverished nation.
"The
decision to withdraw from the Commonwealth was taken without cabinet
approval
in terms of the constitution of Zimbabwe and is therefore
unlawful,"
secretary general of the Movement for Democratic Change (MDC),
Welshman
Ncube, said in a statement.
Mugabe announced his country's withdrawal
today after the Commonwealth Heads
of Government Meeting in Nigeria chose to
prolong Zimbabwe's suspension
indefinitely and set up a committee to review
its progress toward political
reform.
Zimbabwe, which like most
members of the Commonwealth is a former British
colony, was suspended in
March last year after Mugabe was reelected in a
vote observers said was
marred by violence and fraud.
Ncube's statement said all that the "the
international community and the
people of Zimbabwe require Mugabe to do is to
restore ... the right to elect
a government of their choice free from
intimidation, violence and electoral
fraud".
"Mugabe still wants to
play politics at the expense of the people," it
added.
The decision to
pull Zimbabwe out of the Commonwealth was a "knee jerk
reaction" by Mugabe,
said MDC spokesman Paul Themba Nyathi, speaking in
Abuja, where the
Commonwealth summit was being held.
"We all knew that is how he would
react, in a knee jerk manner. After all,
this is a man who specialises in the
destruction of his own country, so
we're not surprised that this is the step
that he has taken," Nyathi said in
an interview with the BBC.
"We
think if there was anybody who still had doubts that they were dealing
with a
man who has lost the plot, whose sense of reality is totally bizarre,
now
they know exactly what they're in for," he said.
Nyathi also called on
the international community not to allow the pull-out
to force Zimbabwe into
even deeper isolation, and to put pressure on the
government to end rights
violations.
"Zimbabwe still has bilateral connections with a number of
countries who
must exert pressure regarding the abuse of human rights," he
said.
Zimbabwe has been mired in economic crisis, against a background
of
political repression and unrest triggered by a controversial program
to
seize white-owned farms and distribute the land to blacks.
From The Sunday Mirror, 7 December
Move to oust Msika as Mugabe rules out departure
Felix Njini
Masvingo - The Zanu PF annual
people’s conference came to an acrimonious end
yesterday with a shadowy group
calling for the ouster of vice president
Joseph Msika from the party for
allegedly supping with whites. President
Robert Mugabe also reiterated his
unwillingness to relinquish power, a
development that is set to push
intra-party debate on succession underground
and anger his critics, who
anticipated that the modalities of his exit from
power would feature
prominently at the conference. The ruling party held its
three-day summit,
which is supposed to take stock of the achievements,
problems and failures of
Zanu PF in the past year, in the ancient city of
Masvingo from Thursday. The
lobby by the shadowy group invited ire from
Msika, who hit back by calling it
a bunch of "stupid mafikizolos". The
Sunday Mirror learnt that some people
from within the party, with the
reported involvement of Zanu PF intelligence
staff, circulated a document
that claimed that Msika was "too friendly" to
former white commercial
farmers who were ejected from their properties during
the accelerated land
reform programme that kicked off in 2000 and officially
ended in August last
year.
The document was reportedly availed to
Mugabe, who made no comment on it
during the conference. However, while
talking about the land question,
Mugabe expressed disapproval with party
officials who had collaborated with
the white farmers who intended to stay on
gazetted farms. He also accused
senior party officials of hypocrisy and
double-dealing, pointing out that
some of them collaborated with the Movement
for Democratic Change (MDC),
Zimbabwe’s main opposition political party,
which Mugabe has often described
as an appendage of white interests. "I say
this because I know what is
happening," Mugabe said in his swipe against
"those who want to use money to
disrupt our party and create in it a new
ideology". Msika, who looked edgey
on the last day of the conference
yesterday, lashed out at his "detractors"
and delivered a strong warning that
observers say verged on a threat. He
said the originators of the document
were merely bent on smearing his image
and denting his liberation war
credentials.
"Beware of (a) backlash! A lot of things are happening
in the party and some
people have prepared a document, which has been
presented to the president.
(The detractors) say Msika is eating with whites,
Msika is getting whisky
from whites. That’s nonsensical and insulting. I am
very clear and straight.
I am not a sellout (as you will see when you) look
at my records," said the
eighty-year old Msika, who in recent months told the
Herald newspaper that
he was ready to take over from Mugabe when he finally
stands down. That
document was written by stupid people. Mafikizolos
(Johnny-come-latelies), I
won’t agree with you on that. I think the party is
infiltrated," fumed the
livid Msika. He went on to crack the whip over the
issue of Mugabe’s
succession, warning party members to desist from agitating
for the early
retirement of the 79 year-old president. On the eve of the
conference,
documents were circulated calling for the succession issue to be
a top item
on the agenda of the summit.
The document purported to
have been written by party members, but senior
Zanu PF officials claimed it
was the MDC that was trying to sneak the issue
in through the back door. The
vice president said those who were calling for
Mugabe’s exit belonged in the
same category as British premier, Tony Blair,
US president, George Bush as
well as the MDC, who the ruling party often
single out as being bent on
undermining the country’s sovereignty. Without
mentioning the name, Msika
claimed he was aware that there was a senior
party official who wanted to
have the issue discussed, saying he chickened
out at the last moment. "All
those who talk of succession are bloody
sellouts. There was someone who
wanted to bring up the issue here at the
conference. We were going to deal
with him if he had brought up the issue,"
remarked Msika. "Mugabe cannot go
whilst things are as they are." Wrapping
up the conference, Mugabe accused
party officials of discussing his
succession behind his back, implying that
that amounted to conspiracy.
"I will tell you when I feel I need
rest, but I haven’t told you that yet. I
am still mandated to rule. I have
said those who want to talk about
succession are free. They should not do it
Nicodemusly. Why should you talk
about it behind closed doors if you are
genuine?" said Mugabe, who has ruled
Zimbabwe for the past 23 years. "If you
think that Zimbabwe can do better by
change of leadership, why not discuss
that openly as opposed to
clandestinely," Mugabe asked. Early this year he
encouraged party members to
discuss his exit. This led to reported jockeying
and jostling amongst those
with presidential ambitions. A succession
committee was subsequently formed,
but it was disbanded when it was
discovered that the group was fuelling
intra-party fighting.
From ZWNEWS, 8 November
The split
Last Friday, Don McKinnon was re-elected for a second term as Commonwealth secretary-general. The challenge to his position was highly unusual - secretary-generals are usually returned unopposed for a second term. The challenge, by former Sri Lankan foreign minister Lakshma Kadirgamar, was, however, also seen as a test of opinion within the wider Commonwealth with regards to whether Zimbabwe's suspension should be extended. McKinnon won the vote by 40 votes to 11. The vote was held behind closed doors, and details as to which countries voted for which candidate have not been made public. Nevertheless, below is an analysis of how the vote probably went. It shows that while Mugabe had some success in garnering support from SADC countries, many African states did not support the challenge to McKinnon. Nor did countries from the Caribbean and the Pacific. In other words, the racial split which Mugabe tried to engineer did not materialise:
For McKinnon:
Antigua and Barbuda; Australia; The Bahamas; Bangladesh; Barbados; Belize; Botswana; Brunei Darussalam; Cameroon; Canada; Cyprus; Dominica; Fiji Islands; The Gambia; Ghana; Grenada; Guyana; India; Jamaica; Kenya; Kiribati; Malawi; Maldives; Malta; Mauritius; Nauru; New Zealand; Papua New Guinea; Samoa; Seychelles; Sierra Leone; Solomon Islands; St. Kitts and Nevis; St. Lucia St. Vincent and the Grenadines; Tonga; Trinidad and Tobago; Tuvalu; United Kingdom; Vanuatu
For Kadirgamar:
Lesotho; Malaysia; Mozambique; Namibia; Singapore; South Africa; Sri Lanka; Swaziland; Uganda; United Republic of Tanzania; Zambia
Pakistan; Zimbabwe: Suspended
Nigeria: Host