A constant. My vote won't make a difference.
These words have been around for
a while and needed a title and a graphic
treatment. We need to be
reminded.
EU in fresh showdown with Mugabe on observers
Jane Fields In Harare
THE EU headed for a new showdown with
Zimbabwe over election-monitoring yesterday, insisting that a Swede would lead
its team despite Harare pointedly not including Sweden in a list of invited
countries.
The European Commission spokeswoman, Emma Udwin, said former
Swedish government minister Pierre Schori would travel to Zimbabwe tomorrow to
head the 150-EU monitoring team.
Ms Udwin repeated EU threats of
sanctions on the president, Robert Mugabe, and his inner circle if he blocks
deployment of the monitors or if there are election abuses.
In the 9-10
March poll, Mr Mugabe faces his stiffest challenge in the 22 years since he led
the country to independence. Zimbabwe’s opposition charges that Mugabe and his
ruling ZANU-PF party intend to rig the elections.
Ms Udwin said Mr
Mugabe’s government earlier this week invited monitors from nine of the 15 EU
countries, but left out Sweden, Denmark, Finland, Britain, Germany and the
Netherlands.
"We believe it is up to the EU to determine who takes part
in its mission," Ms Udwin said. "We are continuing all the arrangements to
deploy our observers as planned."
Zimbabwe state radio reported last
month that Mr Mugabe has invited foreign observers but would not allow election
monitors from former colonial power Britain. Mr Mugabe accuses London of seeking
to undermine his rule after disputes rooted in often-violent seizures of
white-controlled land since 2000.
Ms Udwin said the EU had taken the
necessary steps to invoke sanctions on Zimbabwe as early as next week if Mr
Mugabe obstructs the observer mission. "Preparations for sanctions - should they
be needed - are very well in hand," she said.
The so-called "smart
sanctions" unveiled by the EU last month would freeze the foreign assets of Mr
Mugabe’s family and inner circle and bar them from travel.
The EU would
also ban exports of arms and other equipment that could be used for internal
repression.
Ms Udwin said the sanctions could be invoked if the EU finds
a deterioration of human rights or signs of intensified attacks on the
opposition. She said that sanctions also could be imposed after the elections if
they were found not to be free and fair, or if international media were
prevented from covering the vote.
"A decision on Mugabe’s actions can be
taken at any point," Ms Udwin said.
In Harare, the opposition leader,
Morgan Tsvangirai, accused Mr Mugabe of turning the country into a "basket
case".
"I’ve never seen a country that has developed by taking people
from the industry to the land," 49-year-old Mr Tsvangirai said to roars of
applause, as he stood against a wooden crucifix, a giant poster of himself and a
map of Zimbabwe at a rally in Harare’s Borrowdale suburb, the heart of his
Movement for Democratic Change (MDC).
Mr Tsvangirai, who is being
portrayed in the state press as Tony Blair’s "baas boy" or colonial-style
servant, said he had no quarrel with the need for land reform in a country where
whites own some 70 per cent of the most fertile land.
"Where we differ
is the method," he stressed, "the method by which he [Mr Mugabe] has turned this
country into a basket case."
Hundreds of people began piling into the
red-brick church building an hour before the meeting began in Borrwdale’s
Northside Community Church yesterday evening.
Among the 600 or so
attending were expensive-suited and mobile-phone carrying businessmen, both
black and white. But there were school children too, powdered old white ladies
in their Sunday outfits and local market sellers.
Together they raised
their palms in the trademark MDC salute and chanted the party slogan, Chinja
matiro, which in the local Shona language means "Change your ways".
Mr
Tsvangirai, who was on his third rally of the day, accused the government of
turning the country into "a land of peasants."
"We’re living in anxious
times," Mr Tsvangirai said. But elections at the beginning of March are not
about "a choice between Morgan Tsvangirai and Robert Mugabe", he stressed. He
said the choice was "for the future of the country."
EU threat to
freeze Mugabe's assets over observers
The Irish Examiner 09 Feb 2002
By Ann Cahill, Europe Correspondent, Caceres, Spain
THE EU is
threatening to freeze the assets of the Zimbabwean president, his family and
cronies and refuse them visas if the EU mission to oversee the coming election
encounters any problems.
Robert Mugabe has been president and virtual dictator in the African country
for the past 22 years and has been using the security forces and his political
party to intimidate opposition politicians and candidates in next month's
election.
While the EU received an official invitation from Zimbabwe to send election
observers, according to EU diplomatic sources, Mr Mugabe has made it clear he
does not want any Germans, British, Danes, Swedes, Dutch or Finns included.
The head of the 150-strong EU mission is Swedish and there are also a number
of Dutch members. An EU spokesperson said yesterday they will not tolerate
efforts to dictate which countries take part - the mission is to represent the
EU and not their individual countries.
EU Foreign Ministers, meeting in Spain, are expected to agree today to
sanctions against Zimbabwe in the event of any observers having problems. They
want the initial core group of 14 observers - expected to arrive in the country
today.
Mr Mugabe, whose supporters have been orchestrating a reign of terror against
white farmers in the country, has salted away many millions of euro in banks and
companies throughout the EU.
The EU foreign ministers are being asked to agree to the sanctions - to be
brought into force through a special meeting of EU ambassadors on Monday if the
observers encounter any problems. But diplomatic sources do not want to be seen
to be precipitating anything. "We may be witnessing the last weeks of an ailing
dictatorship and don't not want to do anything premature", one source said.
CNN
Zimbabwe prepares for elections
February 9, 2002 Posted: 3:45
PM EST (2045 GMT)
BLANTYRE, Malawi (AP) -- Despite mounting
tension and ongoing political
violence ahead of next month's presidential
elections in Zimbabwe, a
southern African ministerial group said Saturday
they were confident a free
and fair poll was still
possible.
Zimbabwe's President Robert Mugabe had followed through on
almost all
promises he had made to regional leaders at a recent summit in
Malawi to
ensure the election was legitimate, said Lillian Patel, Malawi's
foreign
minister.
Patel headed a ministerial taskforce from the
14-nation Southern Africa
Development Community, or SADC, which recently
visited Zimbabwe to review
election preparations. Patel said she was
impressed.
"For instance, Harare has already invited international
observers and
journalists to monitor the elections," she said.
The
taskforce unanimously opposed any form of sanctions against Zimbabwe
and
agreed that the SADC chairman, Malawian President Bakili Muluzi,
should
officially write to the European Union expressing this
view.
The EU has threatened targeted sanctions against Mugabe and his
close allies
unless the elections are free and fair, and election monitors
are allowed to
work unhindered.
Mugabe, 77, who has ruled Zimbabwe
since 1980, is fighting for political
survival in the election. He faces a
strong challenge from former trade
unionist Morgan Tsvangirai, who now leads
the Movement for Democratic
Change.
Zimbabwe's opposition and human
rights groups complain of a
government-sponsored campaign of terror against
its opponents, and say a
free and fair election is highly
unlikely.
But Southern African nations, which have longstanding political
and economic
ties with Mugabe, have been reluctant to criticize
him.
Patel said it was Harare's prerogative to decide which nations
should be
invited to observe the elections, due to take place March
9-10.
The Southern African Development Community parliamentary forum
plans to send
39 lawmakers to monitor the elections, while regional electoral
commissions
will send separate delegations.
Dear Family and Friends,
132 people have been killed in politcial violence in
Zimbabwe since March
2000, 15 of those people died last month in what is
being called Bloody
January. It was with great sadness that, with the
assistance of the Zimbabwe
Human Rights Forum, I updated the roll of honour
on my website this week.
They may just be names and dates to a lot of people
but the details behind
these deaths are horrific and barbaric, the reasons so
unnecessary. I would
like to quote just one brief excerpt from the January
ZHR Political Violence
Report. " They demanded to know the names of the
people in the MDC party
structures... then he was tortured by being squeezed
with great pressure
around his diaphragm and then had electrodes from the
battery of the car
attached to his inner thigh and under his fingernails and
was given electric
shocks. They beat him on the head and legs with sticks and
then forced him
to swallow a herbal mixture that caused severe diarrhoea.
T.K. subsequently
died..." As I have done many times in the last two years, I
dedicate my
letter this week to the lives, loves and in memory of all who
died in
political violence in January 2002.
So many people are suffering
and yet every night this week our State run
television news has told us
categorically that political violence in the
country is declining. Every day
this week the newspapers have been filled
with reports of beatings, burning,
stoning and torture. The titles of items
in Friday's newspaper paint the most
accurate picture of every day life in
Zimbabwe: "Villagers starving in
Matabeleland North .... Soldiers torture
MDC MP's...Youths terrorize Chivhu
villagers...MDC says assaults on
supporters increase in Manicaland...
Homestead gutted as violence grips
Sanyati..."
Not a single area of the
country is untouched and there are increasing
incidents of teachers and
students in rural schools being harassed,
intimidated and forced to attend
political re-education meetings on sports
fields and play grounds. The
education of a huge number of Zimbabweans is
under threat and the recent 300%
rise in the fees at Zimbabwe's Open
University will have far reaching
implications for the future. Sometimes it
is a bit like living in a goldfish
bowl in Zimbabwe. With horrific reports
of outrages in local schools, the
Daily News yesterday reported on an item
in the South African Sunday Times:
13 Zimbabwean government ministers, the
Speaker of the House of Parliament
and a Provincial governor have their
children studying in schools and
universities in Switzerland, the UK,
America and South Africa. It would seem
that our schools and universities
are not good enough for our leaders'
children.
This entire week there has been no cooking oil, milk or refined
maize meal
in Marondera. The queue outside our towns' Grain Marketing Depot
was 250
strong on Monday morning. It took two of my friends 5 hours to get to
the
front of the line where they had to fill in a form with all their
personal
details before they were allowed to buy a 50kg bag of unground
maize. A
couple of days later there was no queue as the grain had completely
run out
and the government helicopters clattered overhead, taking the
President to
political rallies in Manicaland. The State television reporter
that night
said it was shocking to see the state of drought affected crops in
our area.
He did not say that hundreds of farmers with state of the art
irrigation
equipment have been prevented from farming who, with their
knowledge,
experience and equipment could, right now, be saving our dying
crops.
There are now 27 days until the Presidential Elections and every day
is one
of disbelief. Yesterday, in the space of ten minutes I met two
people, the
first a white farmer who was recently shot by armed men who had
ambushed him
outside his farm gate.The farmer is back on his land and waiting
to be
allowed to grow food. My second meeting was with a "real" war veteran
who
has had nothing to do with the insanity of the past two years and is
waiting
to be able to have a normal life and carry on with his small
business. We
are all waiting now and I continue to wear a small yellow ribbon
pinned to
my shirt in silent protest at the suffering in my country - I hope
in 27
days I will be able to take it off. Until next week, with love,
cathy.
http://africantears.netfirms.com
The Financial Gazette
Posted
Thursday 7 February 2002
Time is almost up
2/7/02
1:10:42 AM (GMT +2)
EDITOR — The Commonwealth and the rest of the international community have
been making promises to help bring peace to Zimbabwe for almost two years
now.
The British Secretary for Foreign Affairs, Jack Straw, and his
predecessors have been threatening unspecified action against the Robert Mugabe
regime for equally a long time. Such action would be taken, he said, if the
current political violence continues.
I often ask myself: but for how long and after how many deaths at the hands
of the terrorists threatening stability in Zimbabwe?
The so-called pioneer for African Renaissence, President Thabo Mbeki of
South Africa, and his team in the Southern Africa Development Community (SADC)
"Old Boys Association" still believe that Mugabe deserves another chance, even
after more than 100 Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) activists have been
brutally "butchered" by ZANU PF-sponsored thugs.
Let me warn the SADC leadership and those who are expected to protect the
terrorised Zimbabweans that time is almost up.
We must now ask the USA, UK, Canada, Nigeria and other peace-loving nations
to prepare to bring in their armies and use force to bring democracy and peace
in Zimbabwe. The alternative can be very unpleasant, for we (Zimbabweans)
reserve the right to do whatever we can to bring sanity and peace ourselves.
There is overwhelming support for the imposition of smart sanctions against
senior government and ZANU PF officials. The MDC and other progressive
institutions must educate ordinary people that these sanctions are targeted at
the "chefs only" and will never harm ordinary citizens.
I have already started, with the help of friends, compiling a register for
names of children of these "chefs" who are in the UK. Our intention is to hasten
the pace of the effects of the smart sanctions.
Kumbirai Kangai’s children in London and Enos Chikowore’s daughter at
Salford University, Manchester, will also be included. Why do ZANU PF officials
send their children to Europe, seek medication and invest in the Western
countries if they are that much against the West? Why don’t they go to Libya and
Malaysia where their friends are?
The struggle continues until ZANU PF becomes history.
Jennings Rukani
United Kingdom.
You’re not alone
2/7/02 1:10:03
AM (GMT +2)
EDITOR — This letter is in support and sympathy of the Financial
Gazette’s Special Projects Editor, Basildon Peta. You are not alone
weZimbabwe.
Peta was arrested by the ZANU PF police because of his
alleged leadership role in the organisation of a demonstration by independent
and foreign journalists against the draconian Information Bill which was passed
into law recently.
The ruling party is using all the tactics that can be found in the book to
curtail any freedom of expression and association ahead of the historic and
no-holds-barred March plebiscite. Peta was arrested, not because of his role in
the demonstration, but because of his fearless investigations and stories about
the ailing ZANU PF government.
I applaud the unwavering and unequivocal stance taken by the independent
Press in Zimbabwe in laying bare the inadequacies of the moribund ZANU PF
government. The resilience of Peta and the support that he is getting from other
open-minded journalists reminds me of the jailed personae in Maina Kinyatti’s
poem "The Monstrous Instrument".
Mairos Gokoko
Ohio, USA.
Shut up now Mbeki
2/7/02 1:09:13 AM
(GMT +2)
EDITOR — South African President Thabo Mbeki should now just keep his mouth
shut, leave Zimbabwe alone and divert his energy towards saving the
rand.
Mbeki is so pompous he is now acting god to the suffering
Zimbabweans and wants us to pray to him until we run out of prayers before he
can whisper something to President Robert Mugabe — after all it’s called quiet
diplomacy.
His attitude is that we should be thankful for just being neighbours with
South Africa and we should behave ourselves lest that privilege is taken away
and bestowed to other far away poor African countries which would do anything to
be neighbours to Big Brother.
Daily reports of state-sponsored violence, killings and abductions of
innocent people in Zimbabwe are becoming an irritation to you rather than a
cause for action. All you say is: "I have talked to him and he seems not to
listen." Thank you very much Mr President, I wish we could have said the same to
you during your days of struggle.
We are tired of your quiet and non-effective diplomacy and we urge you to
call it off because we shan’t beg you anymore. We have been on our knees for the
last two years and you are more preoccupied with repatriating farm labourers
back to Zimbabwe (a petty issue) than solving a problem which befits your
stature, and it’s time as a nation that we stopped looking expectantly for
assistance from the other side of Limpopo.
With hindsight, I think it was rather myopic on our part for poor,
ordinary, defenceless and brutalised Zimbabweans to call on the might of your
country to help us fight a dictator of our own creation. After an event of equal
magnitude in Lesotho, your government did not have the time for any diplomacy —
loud or quiet — as South African tanks rumbled through the streets of Maseru to
restore order and democracy.
Today, democracy and all its supporting institutions are under severe
threat in Zimbabwe and you selectively choose to stand aloof. Perhaps we have
not suffered enough or perhaps the number of political deaths so far is still
"manageable" as you once said of the situation in Zimbabwe.
Is this what African Renaissance is all about — minding one’s own business
and lending morale support to a corrupt government, which has succeeded in
suppressing all known freedoms and basic human rights?
Maybe you are inspired and amused by Mugabe’s antics and taking lessons on
how much punishment people can take before they reach the threshold level and
hoping to apply the same prescription to your people at a time convenient to
you.
Mbeki, we will always be "indebted" to your response in our hour of need
and the quiet support you have given us. Your non-action has instead spurred us
to realise that it’s none but ourselves who will set ourselves free.
We painfully draw some encouragement from your response as we bury our
beloved, being killed on a daily basis by an inhumane government which has
turned against its own people. With or without your assistance we will fight our
own struggle and one day when we have triumphed (and that is inevitable) we will
take count of those who fought with us and those who fought against us.
Andrew Tsiga,
Harare.
The Daily
News
Traumatised by State
violence
2/9/02 10:08:22 AM (GMT +2)
The people who stayed in my
house at the time of the last election were indeed running away - from brutal
government-inspired political violence.
They were initially shocked and
frightened and later, when the relief of escaping with their lives gave way to
the realities of all that they had lost, they became depressed.
The men felt useless, the children were unnaturally quiet and women who had
lost good jobs took to making peanut butter to survive. This is the reality and
they were the lucky ones.
Care Giver
Amani Trust
Soldiers won’t shoot their
relatives
2/9/02 10:09:20 AM (GMT +2)
On behalf of all the
Zimbabwean community, we learnt with heartfelt sorrow, disbelief, shock and an
infuriating burning remorse of what has happened to our beloved country,
Zimbabwe.
We all saw the BBC news of General Vitalis Zvinavashe
announcing his allegiance to President Mugabe, and that the army would not
accept the people’s choice! What a fox!
Has the general forgotten what our true comrades and real founding fathers
of this nation fought for? Has he forgotten the slogans on the first T-shirts
worn at the pro-independence rallies, when the real vakomana (The Boys) came
from the bush and Mozambique?
Surely this shows that he is not part and parcel of the revolution. I was
shocked to be told at the High Commission of Zimbabwe in the Strand, London,
that I am not allowed to vote!
What? How can Mugabe take away my right to vote just because I am in a
foreign country?
I have totally lost all the respect I ever had for him.
I realise now
that it’s true what your peers say, that “you came out of the bush without
knowing how to salute or even how to hold a gun”. The new generation cannot
allow you to betray your comrades such as Herbert Chitepo, Josiah Tongogara,
Nikita Mangena, Jason Moyo and Leopold Takawira. I won’t even mention Joshua
Nkomo because he was on his own level!
I guess I will have to come back and
jump into the trenches with my fellow brothers and sisters.
It is a new age, and do you honestly think that our brothers in the army
will shoot us, the civilians their family members! Maybe that happens elsewhere,
Mr President.
But nowhere else would soldiers turn their guns on their own parents,
brothers and sisters in defence of one man, Mr President.
Anyone who believes such a thing can happen is a lunatic. It is going to be
a bloodless revolution.I can put my money on that! Ask Mengistu Haile Mariam,
Kwame Nkrumah, Idi Amin and Mobutu Sese Seko wherever they may be.
Remember Milosevic
London
Since when did mere boys
become war vets?
2/9/02 10:10:26 AM (GMT +2)
Somebody correct me
if I am wrong, but the liberation war was fought more than 22 years ago which
means those heroes who were brave enough to have fought in it one way or the
other must be in their mid-30s going up.
So I watch with great
disbelief, shock and amazement when young men (or should I say boys) in their
late teens and 20s go around abusing good law-abiding citizens of our great
nation under the banner of war veterans.
Zimbabwe rightly boasts of having one of the highest literacy rates in
Africa and among Third World countries.
I think we also have one of the highest rate of ignorant people.
When I was growing up, I learnt to respect, admire and appreciate all the
sacrifices made by the liberation war heroes from all the literature I read and
tales I heard.
I really wonder if these so-called war veterans did anything during the
struggle, because if they did for reasons we all know why people lost their
lives 22 years ago, then they seriously wouldn’t like to see our country, which
they helped, build fall apart.
BK
Bulawayo
Have already swallowed bitter pill
2/9/02 10:11:01 AM (GMT +2)
I thought people were joking when they told me that The Herald was full of
funny stories. I recently saw the funniest and most stupid presidential campaign
advert in The Herald recently: “Tsvangirai’s Bitter Pill”.
I am sorry Zanu PF, but we have already swallowed that bitter pill,
courtesy of RGM. If it was the ruling party’s way of saying “yes, this is what
we have done for Zimbabweans”, then for once they are right. I’m still laughing.
Can’t Vote
Cape Town
Mugabe knows he is the pariah of the Commonwealth
2/9/02 10:12:02 AM (GMT +2)
President Mugabe should not take satisfaction from the decision not to
suspend Zimbabwe from the Commonwealth.
On the contrary, he should have more feelings of shame than if the decision
had been made to suspend us.
He has the responsibility for bringing the Commonwealth into disrepute
because there is an increasing clamour now in Britain for it to leave this
partly disreputable group.
The Commonwealth has as its cornerstone the Harare Declaration, of which
every Commonwealth country is a signatory. Mugabe has broken this accord in
every conceivable way from the very early days after he signed it, just as he
has broken every other international and Commonwealth agreement, the Abuja
agreement being but one more example.
Central to the Harare Declaration is the requirement for all Commonwealth
countries to be governed along democratic principles based on human rights and
the rule of law.
Those that voted not to expel Zimbabwe should be cast in the same light as
Zimbabwe, as being an affront to every other decent member of the Commonwealth.
That is not to say all is lost in this regard. While he still can do
anything, including going to meetings where he is not wanted, it is unlikely
that he will attend the Commonwealth Heads of Government Meeting (CHOGM) in
Australia.
It is too close to the election and Zanu PF will require his personal
inspiration in order to subjugate the opposition. Secondly, to say that he will
be “cold-shouldered” if he does attend the CHOGM is an understatement.
As Australia was one of the prime movers to get him suspended, I suspect
that he will be confronted by massive demonstrations, which are already being
planned.
He knows that he is the pariah of the Commonwealth and is now spoken of in
the same breath as Idi Amin and Jean Bedel Bokassa. Knowing this, how could he
mix with other reputable Commonwealth leaders?
The CHOGM, therefore, will probably not have to put up with his presence.
So, whether Zimbabwe was suspended or not, his personal shame is of the
same degree.
Zimbabweans should not regard either the United Kingdom or Australia - or
any other Commonwealth country for that matter - working for the exclusion of
their country to be anti-Zimbabwe. They are not.
Indeed, once Mugabe goes as he surely will, Zimbabweans will see
improvements resulting from his downfall at the elections and much assistance
will come from those countries. The UK, Australia, Canada, New Zealand, many of
the Pacific states, yes, and many of the African states are anti-Mugabe, not
anti-Zimbabwe, the country that he has ruined and so shamefully represents.
Member states of the Commonwealth watch with interest whether Mugabe will have
the courage to attend CHOGM.
M Clift
UK
The following news updates from the MDC are below:
1. Political White
Water
2. 3 MDC MPs Assaulted
1. Political White Water
Rafting
They say (the pundits) that we have the best white water rafting
conditions
in the world at the Victoria Falls and into the Devils Gorge on
the Zambezi
River. I have done the run – with a white water rafting guide
from the
Colorado River in the USA and she said it was the best in the world
from her
perspective. She was a geologist who did nothing else but guide
"dudes"
through the white water experience all over the world.
If you have
not done it, it’s a wonderful and exhilarating experience. The
river is huge
– 1,7 kilometers wide at the falls, which plunges a 1000 feet
into the pools
below and then runs through gorges that at times are less
than 50 meters
across. Here the water is deep and fast and the existence of
huge boulders in
the riverbed creates white water conditions like you have
never seen. Some of
the rougher areas are best traversed by foot along the
edge – it’s just too
dangerous for most ordinary mortals. When I did it I
was thrown out a couple
of times and received a huge bruise across my torso
and face from an
encounter with an oar, saw the odd crocodile but no
encounters of that kind
while in the water. Stimulating, fast, unforgettable
and at the end – too
short! Climbing out of the gorges was the worst part.
The present political
campaign in Zimbabwe is much the same sort of
experience. Its fast,
exhilarating, dangerous and a never to be forgotten
experience. The water
rushes on, unscathed by the white water experience and
emerges at the end
unaffected. So it is going to be here with the vote – the
voters are running
the gauntlet of Zanu PF obstacles and violence, but will
emerge at the end
intact and when they vote it will change everything.
Suddenly we will be out
in open country again, into silent pools and the
sunshine, out of the
darkness of the gorges. Climbing out of the hole we are
in is going to be the
tough part – one where we will need help. In the
gorges, nobody can really
help except those in the water with us.
We are all in different rubber
dinghies for this trip – one for the lawyers,
another for the actual
politicians another for the economists – I sit in the
latter with as fine a
team of economists that have been assembled anywhere.
Talking to David
Coltart – who leads the lawyers raft, we agreed that we are
having such fun –
it’s a sin to be enjoying the ride so much. Sure it’s
rough and dangerous and
the risks are great – even life threatening at
times.
In Dave’s raft are
some of the best legal brains in the country – Adrian de
Bourbon, Brian
Elliott, Tendai Biti, Welshman Ncube and ream of others – all
of whom are
working for a quarter of what they would charge otherwise or (in
Dave’s case)
working for free. The lawyers are engaged in their own struggle
within this
campaign – and what a fight they are putting up. The electoral
act is
bombarded every day – we have the Registrar General on the ropes and
even
threatened with jail for contempt of Court. Edison Zvobgo, not a member
of
the team -–but a helpful bystander, single handedly ran rough shod over
the
Media Bill last week damaging ego’s all over the place. The fight in
the
courts for justice and for the basic rights – daily struggles in the
courts,
bail hearings and worse. We can be justly proud of our legal
profession and
at the end of this all we will have something even better, a
country that
appreciates the value of the rule of law and the need to
protect, with our
lives if required, our basic human rights. Never again will
we take the
principles of equality before the law, the rights to freedom of
speech and
association lightly.
In the political raft are collections of
former trade unionists that have
worked and struggled together for the past
20 years. Led by Morgan their
work is dangerous and the water as rough as it
gets anywhere in the world.
They hold onto each other, support each other and
laugh a lot. That’s
important – prayer and laughter whilst we are in the
struggle. What do they
face – gunfire from the sides of the river,
impediments in the form of the
new draconian media and security legislation,
arbitrary arrest and
detention, beatings and worse. Threats to their
families, their homes burned
down and a publicly owned media that screams
abuse at every turn. If they
fall into the water and struggle to the side,
people on the shore simply
push them back into the river with the injunction
that they must find their
own way out. When this raft gets to the end of the
gorge they will know they
have been in a fight. Bruised but exhilarated, a
sense of loss for the
casualties and grief for their families, but a deep
commitment that it was
all worthwhile in the pursuit of a better life for the
water they have swum
in. This will be one crew of political leaders who will
know what is
important and what is irrelevant, what works and what does not
work, what to
do and what to stop doing.
In my raft our main concern has
been to plot the gorge ahead and warn the
other rafts of what lies ahead –
joblessness, hunger, lower life
expectancies, corrupt practices and the
failure of current strategies. Our
other job is to prepare the way out of the
gorge. We know the crews will be
exhausted when we get there – they will need
a clear route to the top. They
will need to know what has to be done and by
whom. I can tell you, there has
never been in Africa, a political movement or
Party that has been as well
prepared as the MDC is to take power and climb
out of this gorge we are in.
It’s deep and hot and dry, but there are lots of
people who will help and
they need to know what sort of help we will
need.
In the media raft there are some really fine people with excellent
minds –
Trevor Ncube at the Independent, Geoff Nyarota at the Daily News,
Mdlongwa
at the Gazette. To this list we must now add Georgina Godwin and the
blond
bombshell, Jerry Jackson at SW Radio Africa in London, not to mention
the
Voice of the People out of Holland. Then there are the dozens of
journalists
who defy the odds every day to tell the truth and to cover the
expedition.
We respect these guys very much and will never again take lightly
the issue
of the freedom of the press and the right to impartial information
as a
foundation stone of democracy in a free society.
The raft that
attracts a lot of attention and has more than its share of
characters is the
farmers raft – full of guys who know the water backwards
and wear strange
things like veldskoens without socks and floppy hats on
brown heads. They are
deeply bruised and have taken some tragic casualties
but exhibit great
determination and courage at every bend. There is Roy
Bennett in full sail –
bellowing orders in fluent Shona. Their raft is full
of tough guys – not able
to farm at present so they have thrown themselves
into the challenge of the
white water in the hope that there will be some
sort of future for them at
the end.
When we get out of the gorge hopefully we will then be able to stand
on our
own two feet again and perhaps help others who are in the river or on
their
own way out – just as we have been in the past two years. 27 days to go
and
counting. Had a bit of rain last night – 2 mm. The weather is behaving
like
the government – promising much, delivering little.
Eddie
Cross
Secretary for Economic Affairs
Bulawayo, 8th February 2002.
This
message reflects the views of the individual, and not necessarily
the
position of the Movement for Democratic Change
2. Zimbabwe
MPs tortured in new wave of terror
From The Guardian (UK), 8
February
Harare - Three Zimbabwean opposition MPs campaigning for next
month's
elections have been abducted, beaten and tortured for two days by
supporters
of President Robert Mugabe in a remote town, according to the
Movement for
Democratic Change. The three were paraded, injured and bleeding,
wearing
handcuffs in front of the police station in Nkayi yesterday while 37
other
opposition party officials and supporters were also held, the MDC says.
The
attack marks an escalation of political violence in the run-up to the
poll.
Until now, the ruling Zanu PF's militia has reserved its attacks for
less
prominent opponents. The MDC also says at least four party supporters
have
been beaten to death this week, and a new wave of political terror
is
sweeping through Matabeleland in southern Zimbabwe, a key area of
opposition
support.
The three politicians - Abednico Bhebhe, MP for Nkayi,
Peter Nyoni, MP for
Victoria Falls, and Joel Gabuza, MP for Binga - led a
convoy to distribute
leaflets for Morgan Tsvangirai, the MDC leader who is
challenging Mr Mugabe
in the presidential poll on March 9 and 10. The tyres
of their cars were
shot at by soldiers and they were attacked by Mr Mugabe's
youth militia
working with the army, according to local residents. Mr Bhebhe
was among
those seriously injured, said the residents. The MPs and other MDC
officials
were eventually taken to the Nkayi police station where they
were
interrogated and held overnight on Wednesday. Some of the MDC members
were
taken to the local hospital yesterday and returned to the police
station,
say the residents. "It is frightening," said one resident. "We don't
know
what is going to happen to them. The army is here, the youth militia is
here
and they are beating so many people."
Police in Nkayi said the MPs
had been arrested for carrying dangerous
weapons such as catapults,
knobkerries (walking-sticks with knobs at the
end) and stones. A police
spokesman, Wayne Bvudzijena, denied that the
politicians were beaten. In May
last year Mr Bhebhe was abducted and beaten
unconscious in Nkayi. Although
many bystanders witnessed the daylight
assault, no one was arrested.
"Abednico is one of our best MPs and he has
been planning this return to
Nkayi, which is in his constituency, for some
time," said David Coltart, the
opposition MP for Bulawayo South. "He felt
that this car rally, as he called
it, would give him safety in numbers to be
able to campaign for Morgan
Tsvangirai. We are very concerned about him and
all those with him." Mr
Coltart accused the army and ruling party militia of
beginning "a new wave of
terror" across rural Matabeleland. Earlier this
week two MDC supporters were
reportedly beaten to death in separate
incidents in the Matabeleland towns of
Lupane and Tsholotsho.
Another MDC member of parliament, David Mpala, was
abducted and stabbed two
weeks ago. He is still recovering from the attack.
In other incidents, a
schoolteacher in the northern Mount Darwin area an
opposition supporter in
the Mhondoro area were beaten to death, according to
the MDC. "The MDC urges
all international monitors who have arrived in
Zimbabwe to go to Nkayi and
witness Zanu PF's brutality at its best," said
Welshman Ncube, the MDC
secretary general. The first four members of the
Commonwealth team who will
oversee the presidential elections received
government accreditation
yesterday. Eventually they will lead a team of about
50 observers. They met
the registrar-general, officials of the state
electoral supervisory
commission and arranged meetings with political
parties, according to the
Commonwealth press liaison officer, Mwambu
Wanendeya. Last night, the
Commonwealth team was not aware of the violence
against the MPs in Nkayi.
The Irish Independent
Sanctions move closer as Mugabe spurns
observers
THE European Union moved a step closer to imposing
sanctions on Zimbabwe
last night after Harare refused to give unimpeded
access to an EU observer
mission for next month's elections.
Stan
Mudenge, the Zimbabwean Foreign Minister, said observers from only nine
of
the 15 EU countries would be admitted, and that they should form part of
a
joint mission led by the African, Caribbean and Pacific group
of
countries.
Twelve days ago the EU's Foreign Ministers
unanimously agreed to impose
sanctions on President Mugabe and 20 of his
closest associates if Zimbabwe
blocked the work or deployment of the EU
observer mission. The same
ministers are meeting in Spain
today.
The ministers cannot trigger the sanctions themselves because
they are
meeting informally, but sources said they may ask a special meeting
of EU
ambassadors in Brussels to do so on Monday.
Another key test
of Mr Mugabe's intentions will come tomorrow when Pierre
Schori, the Swedish
head of the EU mission, tries to enter Zimbabwe to begin
his
work.
Sweden is one of the six EU countries that Zimbabwe deems
unacceptable.
In addition to Britain and Sweden, Mr Mudenge
identified Denmark, Finland,
Germany and The Netherlands as countries whose
observers would not be
welcome. EU diplomats said Zimbabwe wanted to exclude
member states who had
been most critical of the Government's
repression.
Next week more than 30 EU observers are due to fly to
Zimbabwe, many of whom
are from the blacklisted
countries.
Meanwhile, President Mbeki of South Africa appealed to
President Mugabe
yesterday to end the violence in Zimbabwe and "let the
people speak through
the ballot box."
Mr Mbeki said it was vital
for Zimbabwe and the southern African region for
the government that emerges
after the poll to be legitimate in the eyes of
the people of
Zimbabwe.
He failed, however, to make any direct criticism of Mr
Mugabe. ( The Times,
London)
Martin Fletcher in Brussels
Telegraph
Women fight Mugabe with 'chitter-chatter'
by Jane
Flanagan
(Filed: 10/02/2002)
FEMALE members of the Movement for
Democratic Change are taking a new
frontline role in the opposition party's
attempt to defeat President Robert
Mugabe in Zimbabwe's elections next
month.
Intimidatory tactics by pro-Mugabe supporters and new laws
restricting
anti-government demonstrations have made orthodox electioneering
virtually
impossible in much of Zimbabwe.
In the first few weeks of
2002, according to an independent human rights
group, 19 opposition
supporters, all of them men, have died in political
violence.
In
response, the MDC women's alliance has a launched a
so-called
"chitter-chatter campaign", based on informal meetings of women
over cups of
tea and plates of maize meal.
Even local knitting groups,
a traditional meeting place for rural Zimbabwean
women, are being used to
spread the MDC's message and mobilise voters.
Organisers believe that
female activists are more likely to escape the
attentions of the police and
Mr Mugabe's notorious "youth groups", who have
terrorised voters across the
country.
"Women are going to be the most effective campaigners in this
election,"
said Lucia Matibenga, the chairman of the MDC's women's alliance,
"because
they're not as visible.
"They can slip into houses and
arrange meetings discreetly. Men like the big
rally approach. But women
generally prefer to chat together about issues
that will affect our families.
With Mugabe's new laws we have to campaign
the women's way or not at
all."
Across Zimbabwe, MDC officials have reported a boom in female
volunteers,
eager to contribute to the "chitter-chatter"
initiative.
The small town of Chitungwiza, south of Harare, witnessed the
women's
alliance in action last week. More than 30 activists gathered to
knock on
doors before attending a knitting meeting in the town.
Before
the campaigners went on the streets, they each received an MDC wrap
and
headscarf, in vivid green, red and yellow. The day began with
anti-Mugabe
songs and the usual MDC mantra: Chinja - or change.
Miriam Mushaya,
another activist, told her colleagues: "Go out and tell your
friends and your
neighbours that if they don't vote this year they are
condemning their
children to a life not worth living.
"Let us have sugar on our table
before we talk about dividing up the land.
If the kitchen is not right then
there is nothing we can do."
Under Mr Mugabe's increasingly paranoid
regime however, even a meeting of
middle-aged women is in danger of being
viewed as a threat to the state.
Within hours, one of the women
campaigners had been arrested, although she
was later released without being
charged. The leaflets of other volunteers
were confiscated along with party
insignia.
The women's alliance has also discovered that the notorious
list of "Wanted
MDC Terrorists", which has been handed to the government's
self-styled war
veterans, features Mrs Matibenga and offers a reward for her
capture.
Mrs Matibenga is now protected by a team of bodyguards, while
her three
children live at a safe house, seeing their mother
rarely.
Mrs Matibenga, who stood as an MDC MP in the June 2000
parliamentary
elections, said: "It is not us who are brave, but the women
working for us
at the grassroots. They do not have phones and security for
protection.
"They know that there is a risk and they are prepared to take
it because it
is the only way they can make a difference."
The day
after the police raid, the women were back again, in party
headscarves and
wraps, continuing their work.
"Even the threat of arrest has to be better
than the thought of Mugabe
winning again," said one.
Urban Consumption Cost Soars in Zimbabwe
HARARE, February 9, 2002
(Xinhua via COMTEX) -- The monthly cost of the
minimum
consumption basket
for Zimbabwe's urban families has leapt by 57 percent to
6,300 Zimbabwean
dollars (about 114.5 U.S. dollars), the Zimbabwe
Inter-Africa
New Agency
reported on Saturday.
Victor Chisi, a senior manager of the Consumer
Council of Zimbabwe (CCZ) was
quoted as saying that the number of households
unable to afford basic goods
and
services in Zimbabwe's urban areas have
doubled over the last six months.
The minimum consumption basket
comprises commodities and services like
accommodation, food, clothing,
education, health and transport, said Chisi.
He noted that a lot of
people in the urban areas are living below the
poverty
datum line of 9,000
Zimbabwean dollars (163.6 dollars) per month.
He appealed to the business
sector to be sympathetic to consumers by not
over
charging on those
commodities which do not appear on the price control list.
Despite the
re-introduction of price controls on basic commodities by the
government,
many consumers are failing to purchase them because most have
salaries below
the poverty datum line.
Chisi said that at the end of last year, the CCZ
carried out a survey which
revealed that half of Harare's residents were
unable to afford basic
necessities.
The number of the jobless in the
country has continued to grow as companies,
reeling under the harsh economic
climate, continue to retrench.
CNN
Zimbabwe prepares for elections
February 9, 2002 Posted: 3:45
PM EST (2045 GMT)
BLANTYRE, Malawi (AP) -- Despite mounting
tension and ongoing political
violence ahead of next month's presidential
elections in Zimbabwe, a
southern African ministerial group said Saturday
they were confident a free
and fair poll was still
possible.
Zimbabwe's President Robert Mugabe had followed through on
almost all
promises he had made to regional leaders at a recent summit in
Malawi to
ensure the election was legitimate, said Lillian Patel, Malawi's
foreign
minister.
Patel headed a ministerial taskforce from the
14-nation Southern Africa
Development Community, or SADC, which recently
visited Zimbabwe to review
election preparations. Patel said she was
impressed.
"For instance, Harare has already invited international
observers and
journalists to monitor the elections," she said.
The
taskforce unanimously opposed any form of sanctions against Zimbabwe
and
agreed that the SADC chairman, Malawian President Bakili Muluzi,
should
officially write to the European Union expressing this
view.
The EU has threatened targeted sanctions against Mugabe and his
close allies
unless the elections are free and fair, and election monitors
are allowed to
work unhindered.
Mugabe, 77, who has ruled Zimbabwe
since 1980, is fighting for political
survival in the election. He faces a
strong challenge from former trade
unionist Morgan Tsvangirai, who now leads
the Movement for Democratic
Change.
Zimbabwe's opposition and human
rights groups complain of a
government-sponsored campaign of terror against
its opponents, and say a
free and fair election is highly
unlikely.
But Southern African nations, which have longstanding political
and economic
ties with Mugabe, have been reluctant to criticize
him.
Patel said it was Harare's prerogative to decide which nations
should be
invited to observe the elections, due to take place March
9-10.
The Southern African Development Community parliamentary forum
plans to send
39 lawmakers to monitor the elections, while regional electoral
commissions
will send separate delegations.
SADC Happy With Zimbabwe Election
Preparation
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Xinhuanet
2002-02-10 02:11:57
LUSAKA, February 9 (Xinhuanet) -- The Southern
African Development
Community (SADC) Ministerial Taskforce on Zimbabwe has
expressed
satisfaction with Zimbabwean President Robert Mugabe's
fulfillment
of his pledge on the country's March 9-10 presidential
election.
Malawi Foreign Minister Lilian Patel, who led the taskforce
to
Harare on an assessment visit, said Saturday in Lilongwe that
her
delegation was impressed with the arrangements, according
to
information reaching here.
"For instance, Harare has already invited
international
observers and journalists to monitor the elections," she
said.
In addition to the representatives to be sent into Zimbabwe
by
electoral commissions in the sub-region, the SADC parliamentary
forum
would also send a group of 39 MPs, Patel said.
She stressed that the
taskforce was opposed to any sanctions
against Zimbabwe and agreed that the
SADC chairman, Malawi
President Bakili Muluzi, should officially write to the
European
Union to protest recent threats of targeted sanctions
against
Mugabe.
Mugabe faces a critical challenge to his two-decade
of
uninterrupted reign in the March elections, which pitted him
against
former Trade Unionist Morgan Tsvangirai of the Movement
for Democratic
Change.
Zimbabwean Opposition Party Stages Campaign Rally in
Harare
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Xinhuanet
2002-02-10 02:14:39
HARARE, February 9 (Xinhuanet) -- The opposition
Movement for
Democratic Change (MDC) staged a campaign rally here on
Saturday,
in which party senior officials urged supporters to protest if
the
party lost in what they termed a flawed process in the
presidential
election set for March 9 and 10.
During the rally, which was attended by
about 600 people, the
speakers, including national youth chairman Nelson
Chamisa, took
turns to berate the government instead of articulating their
party
's policies.
They failed to spell out what they would do for the
electorate
if they won the election and did not outline the measures
they
would take to address the economic problems gripping the country.
Instead, they attacked the government's land reform program
which has already
received a lot of support from many including
the Southern African
Development Community.
Besides President Robert Mugabe and MDC leader
Morgan
Tsvangirai, three others will also run for the presidency in
the
upcoming elections.
BBC
Saturday, 9 February, 2002, 14:22 GMT
Scotland's vigil for Zimbabwe
Zimbabwe's elections take place next
month
A vigil has been held in Edinburgh in support of free and
fair elections in Zimbabwe.
Human rights groups have warned of an alarming increase in
politically-motivated violence in the run-up to voting on 9 and 10 March.
Foreign election observers have only been allowed into the country after
intense international pressure.
Campaigners said hundreds of thousands of young people without jobs will
effectively be denied the vote under an electoral law pushed through the
parliament.
Right Reverend John Miller visited the
country
|
There have also condemned what they said are efforts to
curtail the freedom of the press, with another law stopping independent
journalists from writing stories which do not meet with official approval.
The Moderator of the General Assembly of the Church of Scotland, the Right
Reverend John Miller, expressed concern about the possibility of free and fair
elections in Zimbabwe after visiting the country three weeks ago.
On Saturday, representatives from the church and the British Zimbabwe Society
joined MSPs and members of Amnesty International for a vigil at the Mound in
Edinburgh.
Supporters planned to wear gags to demonstrate what they describe as the lack
of free speech in Zimbabwe.
President Robert Mugabe is facing his strongest political challenge in 22
years in the shape of the Movement for Democratic Change's Morgan Tsvangirai.
Political violence
The Zimbabwe Human Rights Forum has warned of a rise in politically-motivated
violence in the lead-up to the poll.
It said 16 political deaths were recorded in January 2002 - the highest
monthly total since the political violence began two years ago.
The group blames supporters of President Mugabe for most of the violence, but
said three activists from his Zanu-PF party were among the dead.
The government has claimed that political violence is lessening ahead of the
presidential elections.
International groups such as the European Union and the Commonwealth have
threatened to impose sanctions on Zimbabwe's leaders unless the elections are
free and fair.
CNN
Mugabe pressed again on violence
February 9, 2002 Posted: 11:13 AM
EST (1613 GMT)
Mugabe says it is his opponents who are fuelling
unrest
GWERU, Zimbabwe -- Main Zimbabwean opposition leader Morgan
Tsvangirai has
again demanded President Robert Mugabe put a stop to violence
gripping the
country ahead of presidential elections on March
9-10.
Tsvangirai, head of the Movement for Democratic Change (MDC), told
a party
rally that elements close to Mugabe's ruling ZANU-PF party as well as
some
police officials had deliberately targeted Mugabe's
opponents.
"There are people in this country who have been killed, raped
and assaulted
and we're saying the government must take responsibility,"
Tsvangirai told
8,000 MDC supporters in the central city of Gweru on
Saturday.
On Friday Tsvangirai told a campaign rally that Mugabe appeared
"married to
violence."
The MDC says more than 100 people have been
killed in the last two years and
that despite ZANU-PF pledges to rein its
supporters violence had increased
in the past month.
Tsvangirai said
Mugabe's "green bombers" -- the nickname given to graduates
of a national
youth service which critics say has been turned into a private
party militia
-- were still terrorising opposition supporters across the
southern African
country.
"If Mugabe wants to prove that he is committed to running a free
and fair
election, he must disband these armed bandits," Tsvangirai
said.
Tsvangirai poses the main threat to the president's quest to extend
his
22-year rule. Mugabe has been at the helm since co-leading the then
Rhodesia
to independence in 1980 after a protracted 1970s guerrilla war
against white
minority rule.
Tsvangirai told Saturday's Gweru rally
that, if elected president, he would
set up a Truth and Justice Commission to
allow perpetrators of the violence
"to come clean" on their activities as
part of a national healing process.
"We want peace in this country and we
want national healing," Tsvangirai
said. The MDC, which narrowly lost a June
2000 parliamentary election to
ZANU-PF, says it would have won had it not
been for a bloody campaign which
left at least 31 mainly opposition
supporters dead.
Mugabe accuses the MDC of being a front for local whites
and his
international opponents led by former colonial ruler Britain who he
says
want to unseat him in retaliation for the land seizures.
The
veteran leader, who turns 78 later this month, denies responsibility
for
bringing a once-vibrant national economy to its knees, and says it has
been
sabotaged by his enemies.
The Zimbabwe Human Rights
Non-Governmental Organisations Forum said this
week that 16 politically
motivated murders had been recorded in January, the
highest monthly toll
since it began logging incidents two years ago. It said
13 of the dead were
MDC members.
Mugabe has said he will allow foreign observers to the
elections, but will
not admit members from Britain, which he accuses of
backing the opposition.
Zimbabwe has fended off a threat of European
Union sanctions by allowing the
15-nation bloc to send in observers for the
March 9-10 elections.
Daily News - Leader Page
Playing games with Harare’s
residents
2/9/02 10:14:03 AM (GMT +2)
The residents of
Harare will, naturally, have been pleased by the Supreme
Court ruling on
Wednesday which was, however, dampened by the same court’s
decision yesterday
that President Mugabe does not have the power to
determine the running of the
affairs of the City of Harare.
In the eyes of many, it was made
all the more significant by the fact that
the full Bench of the Supreme
Court, which was sitting as a constitutional
court, was presided over by the
Chief Justice, Godfrey Chidyausiku, who is
widely regarded as a close ally of
Mugabe.
Looking at it in that light, the average person will be forgiven
for seeing
the ruling as a major triumph for the Judiciary over the
Executive,
notwithstanding the fact that it would have been impossible, given
the
virtually strait-jacketed provisions of the Constitution, for the court
to
have arrived at any other decision.
The truth, however, is that the
ruling was only the latest in what would
appear to be a carefully woven plan
by the government to play a
long-drawn-out game of hide-and-seek with the
residents of the City of
Harare to prevent the holding of elections for as
long as possible.
As such, therefore, there is little to cheer over this
latest development as
it looks suspiciously to fit neatly into that general
plan to hoodwink the
residents of Harare.
It was pointed out soon
after the expiration of the first term of the
commission running the affairs
of the City of Harare that the commission
could lawfully be in place for a
maximum of six months only and that
extending the life of that commission
beyond that would be unconstitutional.
But because, it had sensed a
pronounced change in political mood among the
people of Harare which had
become discernably hostile to Zanu PF, the
government decided to ignore the
law and went ahead to extend the commission
’s life by a second, then third,
fourth and now fifth term.
Intrepid individual residents, such as Trudy
Stevenson, who is also the MDC’
s MP for Harare North, have tried to fight
the continued illegal existence
of the commission in courts, but the system
made sure the interests of those
in power, that is, reaping material benefits
for the ruling elite through
their hand-picked commission, were protected at
all costs.
Of greater significance have been the sustained court battles
by the mighty
Combined Harare Residents and Ratepayers’ Association, ably led
by David
Samudzimu, to have the commission’s tenure ended.
These
finally appeared to be paying off when Justice Charles Hungwe ruled in
the
association’s favour. He ruled some time last year that the commission
was
now in office illegally and ordered Registrar-General Tobaiwa Mudede to
hold
elections as soon as possible.
The government, knowing fully well it had
no chance of winning the case,
still went ahead and appealed against the
ruling, triggering the
now-they-are-on-now-they-are-off circus that has
characterised the Harare
municipal and mayoral elections to this day. The
people of Harare deserve
better. All the ommission’s extensions were effected
in full knowledge and,
thus, also in total defiance of the law through the
inordinate use of
Presidential powers to override the Constitution when, in
fact, those powers
should only be invoked within the trict confines of the
Constitution and for
very special reasons which normally would be for the
good of the citizens.
It is a sad commentary on the Presidency that those
powers have always been
invoked, not to enhance democracy, but to defeat the
course of justice and
trample upon the rights of the people in pursuance of
one and only one
thing: power for an individual.
It was in pursuit of
that selfish goal that Mugabe ordered the police to lay
their hands off when
his self-styled war veterans began the terror campaign
on white-owned farms
two years ago, degenerating into the countrywide
lawlessness we see today. We
think it is a crying shame.
Daily News
LEADER PAGE Saturday 9 , February
Outcomes after
presidential election
2/9/02 10:15:57 AM (GMT +2)
By Greg
Mills
IT WILL be harder for South Africa to avoid acting against Robert
Mugabe if
the 9-10 March presidential election is seen as fraudulent. At this
month’s
World Economic Forum, President Thabo Mbeki confirmed that Pretoria
and the
Southern African Development Community (Sadc) were focused on trying
to
ensure that the election in Zimbabwe is free and fair.
This
was also the intention of three days of deliberations at the start
of
February of the Sadc task team on Zimbabwe. For many observers,
such
pronouncements are too little too late, given the ruling Zanu PF’s
disregard
for the rule of law and violent intimidation tactics of
Zimbabwe’s
opposition over the past 18 months.
It also raises
questions about why southern African leaders have been so
slow to condemn
Mugabe’s tactics. Even to the most autistic of observers,
for a long time it
has been evident that Mugabe is out of control, quiet
diplomacy will not
work, and South African policy is pivotal to ensuring a
free and fair
election and yet is
wholly ineffectual.
Moreover, as Mbeki himself
hinted at the forum, the Zimbabwe crisis has
adversely affected the promise
of the New Partnership for Africa’s
Development (Nepad) and the related
confidence in African guarantees of good
governance and
self-regulation.
Nepad’s origins might, however, partly explain the
continent’s reluctance to
appear more strident in their dealings with Harare
where Sadc wants to be at
least seen to be providing an African solution and
not be seen to be
dictated to, especially by the West.
Some Sadc
leaders might also fear a precedent for a more interventionist
stance against
Harare given that more than half of the regional body’s
14-member states have
questionable democratic credentials.
The outcome is rhetoric and
inaction. Whatever the failings of analysis and
of quiet diplomacy, the
damage is now largely done. Assessing a way forward
beyond the election is,
however, tied to the outcome. Here two scenarios
emerge, with quite different
implications.
The first of these is that the election is declared to be
substantially free
and fair, principally due to two interventions: one, the
role of
international observers and two, the upholding of the Zimbabwe
Supreme Court
decision allowing voters to use registration documents as proof
of
citizenship.
If Mugabe wins in this scenario, the outcome and the
relationship with the
donor community is clearly less sanguine than an
opposition Movement for
Democratic Change (MDC) victory. Focus would probably
have to shift to
trying to find a way to “encourage” Mugabe to step down,
without which the
economy will continue its long-term decline.
In the
event of an electoral win by MDC leader Morgan Tsvangirai, the focus
will
shift to immediate food and fuel needs and shipments and, in the longer
term,
the reorganisation of the Zimbabwean political economy, including the
civil
service.
Whoever wins, following poor rains and the disruption caused to
commercial
farming by the activities of Mugabe’s war veterans, the MDC
estimates that
there is a requirement to import 2 million tonnes of maize the
staple of
most Zimbabweans’ diets between now and mid-2003, and about 150 000
tonnes
of wheat and 120 000 tonnes of soya.
What happens personally to
Mugabe and his Zanu PF cadres will, to a great
extent, probably depend on the
manner of their political departure the more
graceful, the less likely a
Pinochet/Milosevic-type trial, though this can
be no guarantee of what steps
other nations might take in this respect.
The second, less positive,
scenario is that the election is defrauded and
won by Mugabe in a blatant
manner. What happens next will to a great extent
depend on whether Africa
declares the election result acceptable (or not),
and what the reaction of
the West will be. This might lead to a North-South
split on the issue, with
devastating impact on Nepad and on southern Africa’
s investment
prospects.
The Commonwealth will likely be split down the middle.
External reaction
will no doubt, however, be overshadowed by internal
developments, with a
rapid deterioration in social, economic and security
conditions, and with a
direct impact on South Africa in the form, for
example, of increased refugee
flows.
The factor that appears to lie
between chaos and an orderly transition is,
thus, the role to be played by
the external community in saturating Zimbabwe
with election
monitors/observers, and in providing media coverage of the
election and
putting on pressure for accreditation, not least so that Africa
cannot ignore
a blatant fraud.
Here Sadc and others share the same method to get out of
the mess, even
though they have got to this juncture along quite different
paths. South
Africa will, of course, find it much more difficult to avoid
dealing
directly with a fraudulent outcome, not least because of its status
in the
region, its own democratic credentials and its leadership role in
Nepad.
Like others, it will have to consider what mechanisms it could use
to
reinstate the rule of law and democratic process in Zimbabwe, including
the
possible application of sanctions, smart or otherwise.
Put simply,
following the poll, Pretoria, like others, will not simply be
able to dodge
acting against Mugabe on the basis that this could jeopardize
the election
process.
N Mills is the National Director of the South African Institute
of
International Affairs based at the University of the Witwatersrand.
Business
Day (Johannesburg)
Daily News
Judgment overturned
2/9/02 8:53:17 AM (GMT
+2)
Court Reporter
IN an unprecedented move, Chief Justice
Godfrey Chidyausiku and three other
judges of the Supreme Court Justices
Vernanda Ziyambi, Luke Malaba and
Misheck Cheda yesterday set aside the
court’s earlier ruling that the Harare
mayoral and council elections be held
before March.
Instead, the judges agreed with President Mugabe’s notice
to have the
elections held on 9 and 10 March 2002.
On 7 December 2001,
Chidyausiku, Ziyambi and Justice Wilson Sandura ordered
Tobaiwa Mudede, the
Registrar-General, to hold the elections by 11 February
2002.
Mudede
had appealed against High Court ruling by Justice Charles Hungwe that
the
elections should be held by the end of last December.
Sandura was not
part of the proceedings in this latest ruling.
However, Justice Ahmed
Ebrahim disagreed with his four colleagues. Ebrahim
said Mudede should have
implemented Justice Moses Chinhengo’s High Court
ruling ordering him to have
the elections by Monday as was ordered by the
Supreme Court last
December.
Daily News
Moyo allegedly sends Zimpapers boss Kamudyariwa on forced
leave
2/9/02 9:32:38 AM (GMT +2)
By Columbus
Mavhunga
UNCERTAINTY surrounds the fate of Bramwell Kamudyariwa, the
chief executive
officer of Zimbabwe Newspapers (1980) Limited amid
conflicting reports that
he was sent on forced leave by Jonathan Moyo, the
Minister of State for
Information and Publicity.
Sources said
Enoch Kamushinda, the Zimpapers board chairman, had assumed the
role of
acting chief executive officer. But contacted for comment from
Malaysia,
Kamushinda said he was not aware of the development.
“How come I have not
signed a letter to that effect?,” he asked. “I am not
aware of anything of
the sort. I cannot assume the post of acting chief
executive officer when I
am here.”
While Kamushinda said he was not aware of Kamudyariwa’s
dismissal, The
Herald on Thursday said Moyo had rejected Kamudyariwa’s
resignation letter.
It could not be established why Kamudyariwa had forwarded
his resignation to
Moyo and not to Kamushinda and the Zimpapers board. The
article strengthens
unconfirmed reports that Kamudyariwa was told to vacate
his office on
Tuesday by 11am or the army would be called in to evict him by
1pm.
Sources said Kamudyariwa was refusing to implement some of Moyo’s
decisions,
arguing that business decisions were being compromised by the
minister’s
constant meddling in company affairs, sources said. Last week,
Zimpapers
workers went on a go-slow on Thursday and Friday demanding between
47 and 60
percent salary increments.
Sources at Herald House alleged
that Kamudyariwa clashed with Moyo after he
refused to buy Brezhnev Malaba,
The Sunday News editor, a company car
because the company had no money.
Clarson Taruza, the acting company
secretary, would not comment on the issue.
Contacted for comment yesterday
Kamudyariwa said: “I do not share my
professional life with reporters. I am
a nonentity, so there is nothing that
is news if I lose a job or not.”
Moyo’s mobile phone was not taking any
incoming calls. His personal
assistant said Moyo was out of town on business.
Kamudyariwa joined
Zimpapers in the audit department in 1998. He rose to the
position of acting
company secretary, becoming acting chief executive officer
in April 2001.
He was appointed chief executive officer in September last
year. Kamudyariwa
took over from the late George Capon, who was appointed
acting chief
executive in November 2000, replacing Matthews Kunaka who is now
a director
of the Associated Newspapers of Zimbabwe, publishers of The
DailyNews.
Daily News
ZBC urged to give equal coverage to all political
parties
2/9/02 9:30:25 AM (GMT +2)
By Ray Matikinye Features
Editor
CIVIC groups working under the umbrella of the Zimbabwe Election
Support
Network (ZESN) have called for an equitable allocation of airtime on
the ZBC
to all political parties.
The groups say this would
provide voters with information that enables them
to make informed choices.
The sole broadcaster, ZBC, this year announced new
rules on direct access and
political advertising ahead of the 9 and 10 March
presidential
election.
Since independence in 1980, ZBC has come up with different
standards and
rules on election campaigning on radio and television.
According to the
Media onitoring Project Zimbabwe, an independent media
research
organisation, these rules increasingly deny the opposition airtime
on radio
and television.
The media research organisation analyses
information output of all the
Mainstream media in Zimbabwe. Civic groups
argue that ZBC should offer free
airtime and space to political parties to
advertise their material because
it is a parastatal which survives on public
funds.
They say it should devise a system that allows both paid and free
access to
the media. ZESN voter education material could not be broadcast on
some
radio stations because of bureaucratic bungling in the application of
the
“ten golden rules”.
The system of allocating time and vetting
material, according to the civic
groups, should instead be devised by the
Electoral Supervisory Commission
(ESC), to forestall the minister in charge
of ZBC from getting absolute
discretion in awarding airtime to political
parties.
Civic organisations have recommended that political advertising
spending
should be regulated to allow for balanced access to the media for
all
candidates. They dispute the rule which says such advertising would
be
accepted provided it upheld and conformed to ZBC’s directives.
They
say the ESC should place a limit on the amount of private advertising
allowed
for each candidate, to minimise unfair advantage to parties which
have
extensive campaign funds.
Daily News
Top soldiers ready to serve MDC government
2/9/02
9:25:02 AM (GMT +2)
From Our Correspondent
MDC vice-president,
Gibson Sibanda, said this week several top army officers
had approached him
and his party’s leader, Morgan Tsvangirai, to assure them
they were ready to
serve under an MDC government if the party won the
presidential election in
March.
Sibanda said in an interview in Bulawayo, the colonels and
majors distanced
themselves from the controversial statement by General
Vitalis Zvinavashe,
the Commander of the Zimbabwe Defence Forces, last
month.
Speaking in the presence of his security chief colleagues,
Zvinavashe
virtually declared they would not accept an MDC victory in the
election.
Zvinavashe sparked international outrage when he avowed the
service chiefs
would not salute a leader with no liberation war credentials,
a
thinly-veiled reference to Tsvangirai. The MDC described the statement
as
treasonous.
It was also roundly condemned by regional and
international leaders.
Sibanda said this week: “Some army and police chiefs
have distanced
themselves from that statement. “They denied ever drafting it
and totally
disowned it.
It’s now clear that the statement was
authored by Zanu PF in a bid to
intimidate voters and create unnecessary
panic. “In fact, from the onset we
did not believe Zvinavashe’s utterances
because military coups are not
announced at glittering media conferences but
implemented in secrecy.”
Army sources this week said Sibanda’s
revelations exposed a widening rift
between top military chiefs aligned to
Zanu PF and an elite corps of modern
officers who believe President Mugabe
has overstayed in power.
They said even in the event that Zvinavashe
tried to stage a coup, he could
not be assured of backing from junior and
middle-rank officers.
Tsvangirai told over 7 000 party supporters during the
launch of his
presidential campaign in the south-western district of Gwanda
last weekend
that a coup was not possible.
Tsvangirai said if the MDC
won the poll, he would immediately and duly take
over the constitutional
reins as Commander-in-Chief of the Zimbabwe Defence
Forces.
Military
officers “tired of work” or not ready to serve his government would
be asked
to leave, he said. “We would take those who would not salute an
MDC
government for people who are tired of work,” said Tsvangirai, responding
to
concerns raised by villagers following Zvinavashe’s threats.
He
said his party had no plans to create new defence structures and
expected
army, police and intelligence officers to carry on with their
professional
duties of defending the country’s sovereignty.