http://mg.co.za
HARARE, ZIMBABWE - Feb 23 2012
12:47
Zimbabwe's President Robert Mugabe's party said on Thursday
it was pushing
for a raft of changes to a draft constitution, meant to pave
the way to new
elections to replace a rocky power-sharing regime.
"Of
the six chapters we have reviewed, we have made a lot of changes because
we
have discovered that the drafters had ignored what we instructed them to
do
and 70% of their content was of their own invention," Paul Mangwana,
Mugabe's point man on the Constitution, said in the Herald
newspaper.
"We have evidence that they were careless with their job and
we had no
option than to make plenty of changes," he said in the paper,
which normally
reflects the views of Mugabe's Zanu-PF party.
The
paper has published what it said was a draft of the Constitution, which
included a two-term limit for president. That would prevent Mugabe from
running again, since he has been in power since 1980.
Mangwana said
the party also wanted a clause to protect Mugabe's land
reforms, which
resettled black people on thousands of white-owned farms a
decade
ago.
'Totally incorrect'
Zimbabwe's three-year-old unity accord, which
put Mugabe with his rival
Morgan Tsvangirai in a power-sharing government,
requires a new constitution
with democratic reforms before holding new
elections.
Jessie Majome, who represents Tsvangirai's party on the
drafting committee,
refuted Mangwana's claims as "totally
incorrect".
"First of all we don't have a draft except for the leaks of
confidential
work-in-progress by people who are causing unnecessary
confusion,
pandemonium and acrimony," Majome said.
"The draft goes
through several runs and at the moment there is nothing to
get excited
about."
"We should allow the process to progress without interference. We
should not
be drafting in the public arena. This leaking is meant to
influence the
process and it's totally out of line."
Work on the
Constitution has run in fits and starts, hindered by attacks on
meetings by
supporters' of Mugabe's Zanu-PF party.
Mugabe has pushed for new
elections this year, but the constitution-drafting
commission says a
referendum on the charter could not be held before August,
meaning that
elections would likely not take place until next year. -- AFP
http://www.nation.co.ke
By KITSEPILE NYATHI NATION
Correspondent
Posted Thursday, February 23 2012 at
19:00
HARARE
A parliamentary committee leading Zimbabwe’s
constitution making has been
forced to drop a number of provisions,
including one that would have locked
President Robert Mugabe out of future
polls.
A representative of Mugabe’s Zanu PF party in the Constitution
Select
Committee, Paul Munyaradzi Mangwana, said they had made a raft of
changes to
the draft supreme law.
He said this was done after
realising that 70 per cent of the information
used by the drafters was not
part of the people’s views obtained from a 2009
outreach
programme.
Mangwana said they had reviewed six of the 18 chapters of the
first draft,
including the one dealing with presidential term
limits.
Another contentious clause sought to bar candidates above 70
years of age
from participating in future polls and was seen as targeted at
President
Mugabe who turned 88 on Tuesday. (READ: Law bars Mugabe from
Zimbabwe polls)
“Of the six chapters we have reviewed, we have made a lot
of changes because
we have discovered that the drafters had ignored what we
instructed them to
do and 70 per cent of their content was of their own
invention,” Mangwana
told The Herald newspaper.
“We have evidence
that they were careless with their job and we had no
option but to make many
changes.”
He also accused the drafters of trying to sneak in a clause
that would have
legalised homosexuality and dual
citizenship.
President Mugabe’s coalition partners, however, dismissed
the claims, saying
the draft constitution was not yet ready.
23 February
2012-02-23
MDC has advised Zimbabweans not to take allegations
emanating from the so-called public media that the Constitution Select Committee
(COPAC) has overhauled the draft constitution seriously.
COPAC
spokesperson, Hon. Jessie Majome said Zimbabweans are well-informed to the
extent that they are able to define a constitution that represents their
interests. She said the misleading reports are a result of ZANU (PF)’s strategy
to gag the constitution-making process, manipulate public discourse and
misinform the people thereby, causing mayhem.
“Drafting of the
constitution is a process and not an event. ZANU (PF) through The Herald should
not highjack a process in which they are not the only stakeholders. The Herald
has neither business, authority, mandate nor understanding to publish, analyse
or comment on any document purported to be a draft constitution. The failed
political party is attempting to drive the constitution-making process from The
Herald. The Select Committee is the only legal entity able to present the
draft,” said Hon. Majome.
Responding to allegations that clauses to do
with presidential term, dual citizenship, homosexuality, land reform and
devolution of power had been altered, Hon. Majome said whoever was leaking
information has lost it and received a backlash as the public likes the draft
constitution. She said,
“There is nothing spectacular about a particular
clause or section in the draft. The drafting of the constitution is a
confidential process and is out of order to present an issue to the media or
public. The process must be private until finished. The Herald is undermining
the process and pushing the ZANU (PF) agenda.”
Hon. Majome said ZANU (PF)
is terrified with the process, thereby trying to discredit it. It even wants to
monopolise debate surrounding the constitution through The Herald. She
challenged the publisher to stop pre-emptying debate forthwith and refrain from
maintaining a stronghold on public media.
The spokesperson also urged
ZANU (PF) and the public media to let COPAC do its work without
hinderance.
The people’s struggle for real change – Let’s finish it!
--
MDC Information & Publicity Department
http://www.swradioafrica.com/
By
Tererai Karimakwenda
23 February 2012
Senior politicians who do not
pay their electricity bills will be treated
like any other consumer and be
disconnected, the Energy and Power
Development Minister Elton Mangoma has
said.
Last week Mangoma told the Parliamentary Portfolio Committee on
Mines and
Energy that some cabinet members, MPs and senior civil servants
were
refusing to pay money owed to the Zimbabwe Electricity Supply Authority
(ZESA). One unnamed official owed as much as $100,000.
Mangoma told
SW Radio Africa on Thursday that disconnections had already
started and were
being applied equally to all those who fail to pay ZESA.
But he would not be
drawn on naming exactly which politicians had already
been disconnected or
how much they owed.
“I will not say this one was disconnected or that one
will be disconnected.
That’s not my business. Whatever we say is the policy
is being applied to
everyone,” the Minister said.
Mangoma made the
comments following complaints by the Combined Harare
Residents Association
(CHRA), who told SW Radio Africa that their members
were being disconnected
while “chefs” who owed more still had electricity.
Mangoma admitted this
had been true, saying: “There had been some people,
whatever category and
however chosen I wouldn’t know, who were not being
treated the same as
others. A consumer is a consumer and they must be
treated
equally.”
ZESA is implementing a new policy, which requires 25 percent of
outstanding
bills to be paid to avoid disconnection or before power is
reconnected. The
balance is to be paid in agreed amounts for a period of no
more than six
months.
Mangoma explained that this initiative aims to
make it easier for customers,
because ZESA employees were at times just
switching off power without first
notifying people. “We want to mold and
change that culture in order to give
customers recourse,” he
added.
ZESA is owed $450 million in outstanding bills and Mangoma said
the money is
needed to make repairs, buy spares and service a debt of over
$80 million,
owed to the Cahora Bassa dam project in Mozambique.
The
Minister said Zesa’s infrastructure had been neglected for years and a
huge
debt had been allowed to accumulate.
http://www.swradioafrica.com/
By Tichaona
Sibanda
23 February 2012
Air Zimbabwe flights will continue to be off
the radar after the airline
indefinitely suspended its
operations.
The troubled airline vanished from the skies late last year
following a
series of strikes by its workers, including pilots protesting
non-payment of
their salaries and allowances.
Workers from the
national carrier have not received salaries since September
2011 and are
owed over US$35 million. Acting CEO Innocent Mavhunga,
confirmed to the
state media on Thursday the indefinite suspension of all
flights, blaming it
on cash flow problems.
‘We failed to resume flights as planned on Monday
as we still have
challenges relating to payment of salaries. Part of our
workers did not
report for duty. We are now grounded indefinitely,’ Mavhunga
said.
There are reports management are to blame for the latest debacle
after
consulting pilots only, and not all the other workers, when they
announced
plans to resume flights on Monday. A member of the National Air
Workers
Union said they only read about the resumption of flights in the
newspapers.
The ongoing crisis comes as a new airline has started
operating into the
country. Emirates made its maiden voyage to Harare early
this month. The
airline flies between Harare, Lusaka and Dubai five times a
week.
Air Zimbabwe’s future now looks uncertain, as a new local airline
has been
granted a licence by the Civil Aviation Authority of Zimbabwe. Sol
Air is
expected to service the Harare to Bulawayo and Harare to Victoria
Falls
routes.
http://dailynews.co.zw/
By Bridget Mananavire, Staff
Writer
Thursday, 23 February 2012 09:32
HARARE - A public
prosecutor was yesterday allegedly caught red-handed
taking bribes from
accused people by officers from the Anti-Corruption
Commission
(ACC).
Moffat Makuvatsine was arrested yesterday morning at the Harare
Magistrates’
Courts for soliciting for a $500 bribe from the wife of an
accused person
who is in custody, an ACC official told the Daily
News.
“We received a tip-off from the wife who was going to pay the bribe
and we
trapped him,” the official said.
“He put up a strong fight
against our investigators resisting to be
arrested. Some of our
investigators were injured trying to pin him down.”
Chris Mutangadura, a
senior official from the attorney general’s office
confirmed the
arrest.
“I can confirm that a prosecutor was arrested today but I’m not
sure of the
circumstances surrounding his arrest,” said
Mutangadura.
Makuvatsine was yesterday evening said to be detained at
Highlands Police
Station.
ACC chairman Stanford Chirinda could
neither deny nor confirm the arrest but
said the commission is not going to
hesitate arresting suspects.
“There are no sacred cows. If anyone is
found on the wrong side of the law,
we will not hesitate to do our job,” he
said.
The Anti-Corruption Commission was established under the Global
Political
Agreement (GPA) to investigate cases of corruption in both the
public and
private sectors and to combat corruption and abuse of
power.
Moreover, it was meant to promote honesty, financial discipline
and
transparency in the public and private sectors and to give tips to the
police to investigate cases of suspected corruption.
http://www.radiovop.com/
Bulawayo, February 23, 2012-
Zimbabwe’s inflation rate is set to return to
double digits by year-end
pushed up by varying rising costs, according to a
research paper by a
University of Zimbabwe (UZ) economic analyst, Professor
Tony
Hawkins.
Hawkins said predictions by Finance Minister, Tendai Biti that
the country’s
inflation rate currently at 4.3% will close 2012 at below 5%
are a pie in
the sky, arguing that the latter’s protectionist policies will
eventually
drive up inflation.
“The 25% import surcharge and a number
of import duty increases will have
knock-on effects on prices, while the 35%
increase in government spending
will increase aggregate demand at least
twice as fast as aggregate supply
increases.
“Unfortunately the
recent lurch towards protectionism – Biti’s 25% import
surcharge - will push
up costs and prices, protect the inefficient and fuel
inflation. Accordingly
inflation is likely to be significantly higher than
the 5% projected in the
budget, possibly returning to double figures before
the end of 2012,”
Hawkins noted.
Hawkins also dispelled Biti’s predictions that the
country’s economy will
grow by between 7.8%-9% this year, noting that utmost
the economy will grow
by only 5% because of the tight liquidity conditions
and domestic political
tensions.
“To expect that without convincing
there will be sufficient investment to
sustain 8% growth is pie-in-the-sky.
More likely in 2012 is below trend
growth (4% to 5% at best) because of the
reportedly-low level of
agricultural plantings, the uncertain global
economy, tight market liquidity
conditions and domestic political tensions,”
Hawkins indicated
“As capacity utilisation increases – in industry and in
finance – so the
recovery trajectory will flatten out, especially given the
two binding
constraints on expansion – electricity supply and long-term
capital.”
Economic experts have already warned that failure to introduce
policies
aimed at increasing cash inflows within the economy will hinder
efforts to
consolidate economic gains.
http://www.dailynews.co.zw
By Gift Phiri, Senior Writer
Thursday, 23 February
2012 12:00
HARARE - Zimbabwe's underperforming farmers have received
over $2 billion
since the formation of the coalition government in 2009,
laying bare claims
by President Robert Mugabe that Finance minister Tendai
Biti is deliberately
starving newly resettled farmers.
The farmers,
who received large swathes of land under the controversial land
reform
programme, include many of Mugabe’s ministers, military and police
commanders, intelligence officers and Zanu PF officials.
Biti said
the over $2 billion pumped into agriculture in the past three
years excluded
millions of dollars worth of freebies that included fuel,
tractors, and
other farming implements dished out during the Reserve Bank of
Zimbabwe
(RBZ)’s runaway days before the formation of the coalition
government.
Mugabe last week heaped blame on Biti to justify the poor
performance of new
farmers, many who have abandoned farming operations to
leave the country
fighting a perennial food deficit.
But Biti
yesterday rubbished Mugabe’s accusations that he was deliberately
withholding state loans to farmers from Zanu PF who seized white-owned
commercial farms under a land reform project described by critics as
haphazard and often violent.
Mugabe says the mass eviction of white
farmers to resettle blacks was
necessary to address colonial imbalances,
although most beneficiaries have
little to show for the free windfalls they
have been getting from
government.
Biti said he had actually scaled
up funding for agriculture from $18,9
million in 2009 to $615 million in
2011.
“In addition to direct budget support amounting to about $615
million
between 2009 and 2011, the private sector and international partners
have
also been supporting agriculture, making total support to the sector of
more
than US$1,9 billion during the same period,” Biti
said.
Agriculture contributes an average 15 percent to GDP but could be
doing more
if resettled farmers worked harder, according to
Biti.
“The growing support to agriculture also reflects government’s
commitment to
implement and fulfil obligations with regards to meeting the
stipulated
funding threshold under the Maputo Declaration of 2003 on
Agriculture and
Food Security which Zimbabwe is signatory to.”
The
Maputo Declaration requires that expenditure on land, agriculture and
water
must be at least 10 percent of the budget.
Mugabe, who turned 88 on
Tuesday, told state-run media in a birthday
interview that Biti was not
making policies that were economically
beneficial to the agriculture-based
economy.
“Farmers are always ready, raring to go,” Mugabe
said.
“But we fail them. They do not have inputs, even where they have
the money.
Just imagine — they could not get fertiliser for two reasons:
fertiliser was
scarce and where it was available, they did not have money to
purchase it.
Why?"
Because their money was locked up in deliveries of
maize and wheat that have
not been paid for by the minister of
Finance.
“You have maize that was grown last year that was paid for
partially. All
the wheat of last year has not been paid for.”
But
Biti insisted that Zimbabwe’s slow recovery from a decade of severe
economic
meltdown was a direct result of Mugabe’s refusal to implement
reforms
envisaged under the power-sharing Global Political Agreement.
The
minister said government was cash-strapped, with 260 000 civil servants
gobbling 70 percent of the national budget, leaving very little cash to
bankroll agriculture.
He said payment for grain deliveries made to
the Grain Marketing Board (GMB)
towards the Government’s Strategic Grain
Reserve will be disbursed this week
after he accessed cash from the IMF’s
Special Drawing Rights accounts.
“As of February 17, 2012, farmers are
owed a total of $30,5 million against
2011 grain deliveries to the GMB as
follows: $24,935 million for 2011 maize
and small grains; and $5,557 million
for 2011 wheat deliveries,” he said.
“Treasury has instituted measures to
liquidate the above grain payment
obligation to farmers. These will take the
combination of direct budget
disbursement to the GMB for payment to farmers
as well as utilisation of
some of the GMB grain sales
realisations.”
"Biti said he was allocating $20 million from the $110
million withdrawn
from the IMF'’s SDR account to bankroll the outstanding
GMB payments. Mugabe
had accused Biti of “just sitting on the
SDR”.
“With regards to the fiscus, resources amounting to US$20 million
(from the
IMF SDR account) announced in my press statement of January 25,
2012 towards
support to agriculture will be disbursed this week towards
payment of
farmers’ deliveries to the GMB,” Biti said.
Biti said he
would settle the balance of $10,5 million, by raising
additional resources
through GMB grain sales to millers out of the
Government’s Strategic Grain
Reserve holding.
“Out of negotiations with grain millers, GMB will sell
140 000 tons of maize
to millers at a price of $275 per ton,” Biti
said.
“This is also on condition that the millers will maintain the
current market
price of mealie meal. As a result, this enables us to realise
$38,5 million
that is enough to liquidate the balance of $10,5 million for
grain
deliveries. This will leave a balance of about $28 million, which will
be
utilised to liquidate other obligations to seed and fertiliser
companies.”
He said to ensure accountability of these resources, the GMB
will be
directed to deposit all the proceeds realised into its CBZ account
and make
the necessary arrangements for farmers to be
paid.
“Furthermore, the GMB will be required to update Treasury on the
utilisation
of the funds on a weekly basis,” he said.
Government
obligations to seed houses currently stand at $27,7 million for
maize and
small grains seed delivered for the 2011/2012 Summer Crop.
Of this, $5,2
million was due in December 2011, $4,8 million in March 2012
and $17,8
million in May 2012.
Biti insisted that he has been prioritising the
agriculture sector through
various support initiatives and programmes,
rejecting Mugabe’s accusations
as “electioneering”.
He said key
support programmes include the provision of Research and
Extension Services,
including training and availing of relevant information
to farmers; crop
input pack schemes for vulnerable groups; subsidised inputs
such as seed and
fertiliser; guaranteeing a market for farmers through
purchasing of grain
for the Strategic Grain Reserve; livestock development
programmes; and
rehabilitation of irrigation infrastructure among other
support initiatives.
http://www.radiovop.com/i
Harare, February 23,
2012 – President Robert Mugabe’s Zanu PF which is
feared for unleashing
violence to its opponents is forcing people to attend
its political meetings
as well as to buy party cards, the Zimbabwe Elections
Support Network has
revealed.
In a 15 page report titled “Respect for human rights and
implications for
free and fair elections consolidated ballot report update
2011”, ZESN said
political tolerance is still very low in Zimbabwe as the
country prepares to
hold elections to end the coalition government formed by
Mugabe and Prime
Minister Morgan Tsvangirai.
The pressure group said
it deployed 210 “long term” observers in 2011 to
monitor different
constituencies from April to December the same year and
that “1800
questionnaires were collected and analysed using Statistical
Package for
Social Sciences (SPSS).”
“33% of reports revealed that people were forced
to attend Zanu PF meetings.
27% of reports showed that citizens were forced
to buy Zanu PF party cards,”
ZESN said.
“Asked if people were able to
exercise their right to free expression, 64 %
of reports show that citizens
were unable to express themselves freely.”
“The political landscape of
Zimbabwe was such that citizens were not able to
express themselves even
through wearing their party regalia. 53 % of reports
show that citizens are
not free to wear party regalia unless it is Zanu PF,”
the pressure group
said.
ZESN said parties such as the Movement for Democratic Change formations
including the civic society have been banned by police from holding
political rallies or meetings while Zanu PF holds meetings
unhindered.
“To bring finality to the Zimbabwean crisis, there is need
for an election
that ushers in a legitimate government chosen by the people.
Elections are
meant to provide citizens with real and genuine opportunities
to make
choices,” ZESN said.
“Let the citizens speak through the
ballot.”
Zimbabwe which held disputed polls in 2008 marred by violence
blamed on Zanu
PF supporters will hold fresh elections after a new
constitution has been
adopted.
Mugabe has said he wants elections
this year while Tsvangirai has said
reforms must be implemented in the
electoral, security and broadcast media
sectors to have free and fair
elections.
http://www.swradioafrica.com
By Alex Bell
23
February 2012
Zimbabwe’s government is being urged to prioritise its
human development
goals, after the country was ranked near the bottom of an
international
development report last year.
The 2011 Human
Development Report, launched by the United Nations
Development Programme
(UNDP) late last year, lists Zimbabwe at 173 out of
187 countries. It is
also listed among the 45 nations ranked under the ‘Low’
human development
title.
The highest in the HDI Report for 2011 is Norway, followed by
Australia, The
Netherlands and the US. At the bottom of the list is the
Democratic Republic
of the Congo (187). Zimbabwe meanwhile is ranked lower
than countries like
Sudan and Afghanistan, while even Libya, which is still
recovering from the
revolution that ousted Colonel Muammar Gaddafi, is
listed at number 63 under
the ‘High’ human development ranking.
The
HDI report links human development with global sustainability, arguing
that
such sustainability “can be most fairly and effectively achieved by
addressing health, education, income, and gender
disparities”
“Despite the human development progress of recent years,
income distribution
has worsened, grave gender imbalances still persist, and
accelerating
environmental destruction puts a ‘double burden of deprivation’
on the
poorest households and communities,” the report says.
The
MDC-T’s Bulawayo East MP, Tabitha Khumalo, said that the basic rights of
Zimbabwe’s public are not being addressed, calling the country’s ranking
“totally unacceptable.” She said in Zimbabwe’s particular case, with its
wealth of natural resources, there should be no excuse to rank so low on the
scale of human development.
“It is sad that any country should be so
low on such a scale in this day and
age, but Zimbabwe, which has such
wonderful natural resources like diamonds,
it is just unacceptable,” Khumalo
said.
Khumalo was speaking just hours after visiting with homeless people
in her
constituency, calling the conditions “appalling.”
“They have
no running water, no food, terrible health, and not even the
means to get to
free clinics. It is so sad that people face such a plight
when we could
harness our natural wealth and develop our country,” Khumalo
said.
When asked about the government’s priorities in terms of human
development,
Khumalo said that the priority must be “the needs of the
majority, not the
wants of the few.”
She added that development, even
in terms of the most basic needs, could be
easily catered for with money
from Zimbabwe’s diamond industry.
“This could be solved with government
accessing funds from Chiadzwa, These
resources must be tapped into and
prioritised for the country’s
development,” Khumalo said.
See http://hdr.undp.org/en/media/HDR_2011_EN_Summary.pdf
http://www.swradioafrica.com/
By Lance Guma
23
February 2012
A member of the Central Intelligence Organisation
implicated in the gruesome
murder of two MDC activists 12 years ago has
still not been prosecuted
despite a High Court judge having recommended he
be brought to book.
Joseph Mwale and his fellow accomplice, war vet
Kainos ‘Kitsiyatota’
Zimunya, were identified as having petrol bombed a
vehicle driven by
Tichaona Chiminya and Talent Mabika. Both activists were
campaigning in
Buhera for MDC president Morgan Tsvangirai in the run up to
parliamentary
elections in 2000.
According to witness testimonies a
convoy of two MDC vehicles was stopped by
a mob of ZANU PF militants. Two
men armed with AK47 rifles and others
bearing iron bars emerged from the
ZANU PF car. Mwale and Zimunya started to
attack the MDC vehicle with iron
bars forcing the MDC youths at the back of
the truck to flee. Chiminya and
Ms Mabika were trapped in one of the
vehicles.
Sanderson Makombe who
survived the ambush told SW Radio Africa that he
escaped into the bush and
watched as Mwale and Zimunya threw petrol into the
car and set it alight.
Vastly outnumbered and faced with thugs armed with
AK47’s he watched
helplessly as his colleagues Mabika and Chiminya got out
of the car and ran
‘across the fields burning like balls of flames.’
When the mob left
Makombe ran to Chiminya who was already dead, but Mabika
was still alive and
shouting out the names of her attackers. She was to die
later in hospital.
Makombe said there was a police vehicle “parked a few
metres down the road
and they actually witnessed everything that was
happening.”
Makombe
said the police came to where they were and instructed them to put
the
bodies in the back of the truck. “So the task was for us to lift our
colleagues, you know, with our own bare hands, they were still burning, you
know. Talent was still screaming, she was not dead yet, she had been badly
burnt.”
In 2006 SW Radio Africa reported how police were too scared
to enforce a
written order from the Attorney General’s office to arrest
Mwale. Then High
Court Judge James Devitte ordered Mwale be brought to trial
for the murders.
Efforts by former Manicaland prosecutor Levison Chikafu, to
bring Mwale to
justice, were also frustrated.
In September 2006
Chikafu wrote to the then police chief in Manicaland
Province saying: “The
accused faces a charge of murder which was committed
in the year 2000. The
docket was referred to your office with instructions
that you arrest Joseph
Mwale and bring him for initial remand.”
The docket disappeared from the
police station and Chikafu was himself
arrested on charges of ‘corruption
and soliciting bribes from suspects’.
Instead of Mwale being brought to
justice he was promoted within the CIO and
enjoys high level protection from
the Mugabe regime.
Reports at the time suggested he was put in charge of
the President’s Office
for Manicaland Province and lavished with several
posh cars for his use.
That promotion came to the fore when Prime Minister
Morgan Tsvangirai
recently toured the diamond fields in Marange. SW Radio
Africa reported how
Mwale was part of the security entourage during the tour
last Thursday.
On Thursday SW Radio Africa spoke to Adella Chiminya, who
is Tichaona
Chiminya’s widow and she spoke of her horror at reading our
story on Mwale
being in Marange during the PM’s tour.
Adella said it
was clear ‘provocation’ from ZANU PF and an attempt to show
that ‘nothing
will happen to Mwale’. She however said: ‘I am now a Christian
and vengeance
belongs to God. He (Mwale) will get his just desserts one
day.”
Meanwhile an official in the PM’s office has told SW Radio
Africa they were
not aware Mwale was part of the security entourage during
the tour. “It was
pointed out to us at the end of the tour that Mwale was
there and we got our
guys to take pictures of him.”
http://www.swradioafrica.com/
By Alex Bell
23 February
2012
A former farmer who was arrested for fighting to remain in his Vumba
home
now faces a third weekend behind bars, after his bail hearing was once
again
postponed on Thursday.
74 year old Peter Hingeston was arrested
almost two weeks ago after failing
to appear in court, in connection with
the legal battle over his rights to
his property.
His absence from
court was on medical grounds, but instead of being fined or
reprimanded as
is usually expected under these circumstances, Hingeston was
thrown behind
bars.
Hingeston’s stay in custody has been drawn out for almost two
weeks, with
repeated delays to his bail hearings. Last Friday, after a week
behind bars,
his bail was postponed because the police ‘mislaid’ his case
documents.
On Tuesday efforts to have him released were once again
delayed when the
hearing was postponed to Thursday, with no reasons given
for this decision.
The hearing has now been postponed once again, this time
to next week
Monday, meaning Hingeston will stay in custody for a third
weekend.
Meanwhile his trial for prosecution under the Gazetted Land
(Consequential
Provisions) Act for his alleged illegal occupation of his
retirement home in
the Vumba Mountains is due to start on
Friday.
Hingeston was forced off his Lowveld sugar cane farm in the mid
2000s and
‘retired’ to a house and plot of land in Vumba. But it’s believed
that a top
police official wants that property and for the last four years
Hingeston
has been fighting to stay there.
Charles Taffs, the
President of the Commercial Farmers Union (CFU), told SW
Radio Africa this
week that ‘the game’ being played to keep Hingeston behind
bars is an
attempt to force him to hand over his land.
http://www.radiovop.com
Harare, February 23, 2012 - THE
Zimbabwe Teachers Association (ZIMTA), the
country’s largest teachers’
labour body, has asked its negotiators with the
coalition government over
salary increments to push for a significant salary
increment by July
2012.
Last week civil servants representatives under the Apex Council –
the
negotiating umbrella body of all public workers except the armed forces
–
held a meeting with Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai in desperate attempts
to force the government to increase their low salaries.
However, they
came out of the meeting empty-handed as the PM told them that
the government
had no money to bank-roll any salary increments.
Instead PM Tsvangirai
assured them that he would raise the issue of salaries
with his Cabinet
colleagues.
In a circular to members dated 16 February 2012, a day after
their
representatives met with the PM, ZIMTA chief executive officer Sifiso
Ndlovu, said the consultative meeting with the premier was effective in as
far as presenting the public service workers appeal to his office as well as
gaining his support on the issues.
“However, as this was not a
negotiating forum no commitments were obtained,
save for promises to lend
support by the Prime Minister. Meanwhile, ZIMTA
will urge members of Apex to
stoke the salary brazier for positive results
by July 2012,” Ndlovu wrote to
members.
He further told members that the APEX council nonetheless
informed the PM
that the 2012 budget was exclusionary as it gave little
thought to
government workers’ needs.
“Government negotiators seemed
not to have been mandated to advance any
government position. Apex Council
also observed that governmentwas long on
rhetoric regarding non-monetary
awards, which to date had not been auctioned
and where an attempt to
implement some of the recommendations was made,
government had done so with
little impact in improving conditions of
service,” reads part of a document
handed to the PM.
In his response the PM is said to have been receptive
and accommodative and
ultimately committed himself to present the issues to
the Cabinet Task Force
on Salaries and Conditions of Service.
He
allegedly reiterated the government position on its lack of capacity to
meet
workers demands due to the alleged under performanceof the economy.
Civil
servants want the least paid to get US$538 a month against the present
monthly salary of US$250. They are also demanding better housing and
transport allowances.
In his birthday interview with the state media,
President Robert Mugabe also
stated that the coalition government has no
financial wherewithal to fund
salary increments. But the civil servants are
pinning their hopes on
proceeds from diamond sales.
According to
Mines Minister Obert Mpofu, the country has the potential of
generating at
least US$2 billion annually from the sale of Marange diamonds.
http://www.dailynews.co.zw
By Bridget Mananavire, Staff
Writer
Thursday, 23 February 2012 14:08
HARARE - Zimbabwe Public
Protector’s office previously known as the
Ombudsman is not as visible as it
should, a situation which leaves citizens
without a channel through which
they can register their complaints against
the executive, deputy minister of
Justice Obert Gutu has said.
The office which was established by the
coalition government is tasked with
investigating cases of administrative
malpractices and alleged contravention
of the Declaration of Rights by
members of the defence forces, police,
government departments and the prison
service.
Bridget Chanetsa is currently running the office, which is often
accused of
being far from the reality on the ground.
Gutu told the
Daily News that very few people are aware of the existence of
the office of
the public protector.
“Very few people are actually aware of the fact
that we have a Public
Protector. The Public Protector has somehow retreated
into a shell and this
is of course not healthy for the promotion of human
rights,” Gutu said.
“I cannot even remember the last time the Public
Protector presented a
report before the Parliament of Zimbabwe. One wonders
therefore, whether the
office has played any meaningful role in the
democratisation of the country
since it was created,” he said.
The
Public Protector is expected by law to present a report before
Parliament
every year which according to Gutu has been done only once since
its
establishment in 2009.
Gutu said it is the responsibility of the Public
Protector to ensure that
her office works citing the example of the office
of the Public Protector in
South Africa whose investigations recently led to
the suspension of a
cabinet minister and the country’s police commissioner
general, Bheki Cele
over maladministration charges.
“I am actually
reminded of the excellent work that Advocate Thuli Madonsela,
the South
African Public Protector, is doing in fighting corruption and
human rights
abuses in her country,” Gutu said.
Efforts to get a comment from Chanetsa
were fruitless as she was said to be
out of office.
http://www.dailynews.co.zw
By Pindai Dube
Thursday, 23 February 2012
14:06
BULAWAYO - Eight MDC members who say they were assaulted by
police in Nkayi,
Matabeleland North province in December last year, are now
dragging the
implicated police officers to court on their individual
capacities, seeking
compensation.
There was chaos at Nkayi Growth
Point on December 26 when a group of heavily
armed police officers in
anti-riot gear allegedly went on the rampage
beating up residents, in
revenge after one of their colleagues — a constable
Gumpo was assaulted at
Mbali Night Club at the business centre.
However, eight MDC Nkayi members
who are the victims say they are now suing
more than five junior police
officers who assaulted them.
These MDC members are Limukani Moyo,
Nkazimulo Ncube, Polite Khumalo, Lyton
Bhebhe, Sibusisiwe Moyo, Clement
Tshuma, Khumbulani Dube and Mlindeli
Maseko.
Speaking to the Daily
News yesterday, MDC Matabeleland North provincial
chairman Sengezo Tshabangu
said they are already engaging the Zimbabwe
Lawyers for Human Rights (ZLHR)
to deal with the case.
He said some of the members sustained permanent
injuries due to police
beatings.
“We are suing these police officers
in their individual capacities for
brutalising our members. They should pay
for abusing their authority,” said
Tshabangu.
“We have compiled names
of these officers and we are also engaging ZLHR to
deal with the case. It’s
high time police brutality was stopped.”
Nkayi district is now regarded
as a “hot spot” for the two MDC formations
and human rights activists as
police have blocked several meetings in recent
months.
Recently,
police in the district raided the homestead of deputy Foreign
Affairs
minister Robson Makula of MDC faction after banning the party’s two
rallies
which were scheduled to take place in the district.
In October last year,
Nkayi police also disrupted Prime Minister Morgan
Tsvangirai rally at
Nesigwe Business Centre despite a High Court order
allowing the rally to go
ahead.
After the disruption of his rally, an angry Tsvangirai said he did
not need
police clearances to hold meetings because he has the same powers
as
President Robert Mugabe whose rallies are allowed by the same security
agents without clearance.
Co-Home Affairs minister, Theresa Makone,
who is also an MDC member,
recently said she will approach Mugabe and police
commissioner-general
Augustine Chihuri over the partisan conduct of the
police especially those
in Matabeleland North province.
http://www.newzimbabwe.com
22/02/2012 00:00:00
by Staff
Reporter
AN MP appeared in court on Tuesday to answer criminal abuse
of duty charges
and at least three others face arrest after failing to
account for grants
made under the Constituency Development Fund.
St
Mary's MP Marvellous Khumalo (MDC-T) was arrested on Monday after
Parliamentary and Constitutional Affairs Minister Eric Matinenga called in
the police.
Khumalo, 36, is accused of converting part of a US$50,000
grant to his own
use.
He was remanded to March 7 on US$300 bail. No
plea was entered.
Detectives are also expected to quiz at least three
other legislators -
Peter Chanetsa (Zanu PF, Hurungwe North), Franco
Ndambakuwa (Zanu PF,
Magunje) and Cleopas Machacha (MDC-T, Kariba) after
they all failed to
account for US$50,000 each they received from the fund to
support
development projects in their constituencies.
Machacha has
however denied the allegations insisting: “I was one of the
first people who
submitted returns to the ministry. I went to the shop where
I bought my
hardware and asked them for cash register receipts.
“They couldn’t
produce them and they gave me duplicates. But the issue is
the chief auditor
Mudzungairi said my receipts were not tallying and would
not accept the
duplicates.”
Matinenga, who was asked by Finance Minister Tendai Biti to
look into the
abuse of the fund, last week said 10 legislators — six from
Zanu PF and four
from then MDC-T — had failed to submit returns proving that
they used their
2012 CDF funds for developmental projects.
“Out of
the 65 internal audits done, satisfactory responses have not been
received
from four constituencies — St Mary’s, Hurungwe North, Magunje and
Kariba —
and these matters have been handed over to the appropriate
authorities for
their information and, where appropriate, further
investigation,” he
said.
He also warned that MPs who failed to account for the money would not
be
considered for the next allocation.
Khumalo arrived at the Harare
Magistrates' Court accompanied by his lawyer,
Emmanuel Samudombe, and CID
detectives.
Prosecutor David Magwegwe read him four charges: one count of
criminal abuse
of duty as a public officer and three counts of
theft.
The court heard that Treasuery moved US$50,000 in three batches
between
November 12, 2010, and December 30, 2010, into an account held with
the
Metropolitan Bank, opened in the name of the St Mary’s CDF
committee.
On January 2 last year, Khumalo reportedly used the funds to
buy a Bedford
lorry registration number 538-649 M from United Tyre Services
without the
knowledge of both the constituency committee and the national
management
committee.
Investigations revealed that Khumalo was hiring out
the truck for personal
gain.
On the other count of theft, the State
alleges that between November 2010
and February last year, Khumalo made
councillors to sign blank withdrawal
slips and made various withdrawals
amounting to US$5,000 from the
constituency’s CDF account.
He converted
the money to his personal use.
The offence came to light following an
audit by the Ministry of
Constitutional and Parliamentary
Affairs.
After the discovery of the offence, Khumalo is said to have
tendered a
quotation from Madedale Enterprises (Pvt) Ltd, purporting that a
payment of
US$5,000 had been made for the sinking of a borehole in his
constituency.
The said company disowned the transaction and
investigations revealed that
the borehole had been sunk by a
non-governmental organisation called Germany
Agro Action.
It is
further alleged that Khumalo withdrew US$20, 705 on the pretext that
it was
for drain cleaning in six wards in the constituency.
Five councillors got
their shares of US$3,000 apiece to use in their wards
but Khumalo kept
US$3,000 which was meant for Councillor Adam Puzo of Ward
One who was absent
on the day.
He allegedly converted the money to his own use.
The audit
established that Khumalo had fabricated cash payment vouchers with
forged
signatures, address and a false identity number, purporting Puzo had
received the money.
On another date, Khumalo, the State alleges, gave
Councillor Darlington Nota
US$3,000 for drain cleaning in his
ward.
He then manufactured cash payment vouchers with forged signatures,
address
and a false identity number purporting that Nota had received
US$3,850 yet
in actual fact he had given him US$3 000.
He pocketed the
difference, it is alleged.
(additional reporting Herald)
http://www.thezimbabwean.co.uk
Gone are the days when inflation used to be
labeled the “number one enemy”.
Unemployment is now not only the “number one
enemy,” but an aggressive
terrorist, anxious to blow up our macroeconomic
tower.
22.02.1206:55am
by Chief Sub-Editor UK
Unemployment,
according to its broad definition, refers to the population
age fifteen
years and above, who during the seven day reference period did
not work and
had no job or business to go back to, but who were available
for work
(ZIMSTAT, 2006). A lower unemployment rate is regarded as one of
the key
macroeconomic fundamentals.
The Ministry of Labour and Social Services,
in 2009, estimated that
structural unemployment was 85 percent. Youths aged
15–24 years accounted
for 62.1 percent in 1994, 65 percent in 1999, 67.5
percent in 2002 and 59.6
percent in 2004 (Kanyenze, 2009).The graph below
shows the unemployment rate
between 1998 and 2004 (when the last official
figure was recorded).
Every year Zimbabwe is creating thousands of
potential employees through its
universities, colleges, vocational and
training centers. We had a surplus of
bonded nurses in 2011 and the
Government is currently looking at exporting
some of the nurses
abroad.
What really is the government doing to create adequate jobs for
the young
people entering the job market every year? Young people who have
spent 18
years of their lifetime going to school in the hope of finding a
good job to
improve their livelihoods, are now selling recharge cards and
newspapers at
road intersections in town.
Many are seen hanging
around all day, where some will end up abusing drugs
or forming crime gangs.
Due to persistent unemployment, some youths have
suffered melancholy and
distress and ended up committing suicide. Young
female graduates have been
left particularly vulnerable and desperate – and
some have resorted to
prostitution.
The current youth empowerment programmes are just not
enough to do the
trick. Some youths may not be entrepreneurial enough to
succeed in
business – all they need is a job, to practice what they have
learnt at
college – as accountants, economists, nurses, engineers and the
like. We
cannot all be entrepreneurs, at the end of the day, some are just
meant to
be professionals.
Employers have been arguing that the
current labour laws favor jobless
growth, whereby labour is replaced by
capital. According to employers; the
labour laws are inflexible, as they
make it difficult for them to fire
employees. Hiring is even more difficult.
According to the Confederation of
Zimbabwe Industries’ 2011 Manufacturing
Sector Survey, wages and salaries on
average constitute 25% of total
expenses, and even as high as 60% for some
companies. This scenario is not
good for job creation prospects.
Government, as a policy maker, has a
responsibility to come up with a job
creation policy. The Millennium
Development Goal 8 on global partnerships
makes reference to the need to
develop and implement strategies that give
young people everywhere a real
chance to find decent and productive work.
The policy should be crafted
in consultation with the youths, to ensure that
their views are taken on
board. Addressing a business gathering recently, US
President, Barack Obama,
said “Ask yourself what you can do to help create a
job, and your country
will help you every way it can to help you succeed.”
Our government should
have that kind of attitude.
Youths are tired of the government’s failure
to solve their real issues. For
suicides they get counseling, for crimes
they are punished by the law, for
prostitution they are given condoms.
Government should make it a matter of
policy that every company should
employ at least one college or university
graduate in every department, for
at least one year; earning a minimum wage.
Doing so will ensure that
virtually all unemployed graduates get swallowed
in the private and public
sectors. To complement such a policy, there would
be a need to scrap
attachment from degree programmes, since the objectives
of attachment can
still be achieved during formal employment.
The social contract, which
has been gathering dust, should be now
reactivated. The current environment
is much more conducive to work,
compared to the environment under which it
was signed. Inflation is no
longer running away, and we no longer have price
distortions, as market
forces are now operating at full
throttle.
Government should also put in place safeguards that protect
local companies
that have been unfairly forced to close or downsize and
retrench employees
due to competition from imports. In granting that
protection, they will have
to ensure that it is compatible with the
country’s commitments to regional
and international organizations such as
SADC, COMESA and WTO.
Most importantly, protection should be only granted
to companies that have a
concrete plan to create jobs and be able to
adequately and competitively
service the local market.
Government
should also say no to hiring from outside the country. Many
foreign
companies are bringing in employees from outside the country to do
jobs that
can done by local people. We have many people who are currently
unemployed
but are qualified to work with same level of competence as
foreigners. - cmachadu@ovi.com
http://www.thezimbabwean.co.uk
Hospitals across the country have been
refusing to implement the government
policy to provide free tuberculosis
medication, putting patients at serious
risk.
20.02.1207:45am
by
Talent Bhachi
Dr. Charles Sandy, deputy director of AIDS and
tuberculosis programmes at
the Ministry of Health and Child welfare, said
the failure by the government
to ‘shepherd’ its policy was to
blame.
“Provincial health offices should supervise how the hospitals are
doing.
Hospitals are taking advantage of the loopholes,” said Doctor
Sandy.
He warned the hospitals not to ignore the government policy as it
compromised patients’ treatment.
Patients at risk
“The hospitals
should stop charging fees on treatment that should be free.
Although there
are no fines for the transgressors, the government will soon
step in to deal
with hospitals who continue to disregard policy directives,”
he
said.
Mission hospitals in remote areas have been criticized for charging
tuberculosis patients consultation fees.
“Hospitals such as Mashoko
Hospital, St Albert and Silveira Mission have
been charging consultation
fees on what is supposed to be free treatment,”
said Sandy. According to
statistics from the Ministry of Health and Child
Welfare, the disease is
claiming more than 83 000 people annually, with two
thirds of patients not
receiving treatment. Zimbabwe’s current infection
rate is about 47 000 per
year.
Fighting TB
To fight TB, Dr. Charles Sandy said his Health
Ministry department was
decentralizing care, especially in rural
communities, and distributing
motorcycles to rural health
staff.
Tuberculosis is a major public heath problem. Zimbabwe is ranked
17th on the
list of 22 high-burden TB countries in the world. According to
the World
Health Organization’s Global Tuberculosis Control Report 2009,
Zimbabwe had
an estimated 71,961 new TB cases in 2007, with an estimated
incidence rate
of 539 cases per 100,000 population.
The number of new
reported TB cases in Zimbabwe declined 2.6 percent between
2006 and
2007.
However, the DOTS (the internationally recommended strategy for TB
control)
case detection rate declined from 46 percent in 2002 to 27 percent
in 2007.
The treatment success rate also declined from 71 percent in 2001 to
60
percent in 2006. These declines reflect the deteriorating socio-political
context, which has a direct impact on health service delivery in Zimbabwe.
http://www.newzimbabwe.com/
23/02/2012 00:00:00
by Nokholo
Mhluzani
THE government announced recently that it does not have the
capacity to hire
and remunerate 2,000 state registered nurses who were
issued with their
diplomas in 2010 and 2011.
This assertion, which
amounts to an acceptance by the government that it is
abdicating its duties,
is in bad taste especially in view of the fact that
it is premised on the
spurious excuse that the government has no resources
to pay
nurses.
The move paves way for nurses – trained with tax payer dollars –
to seek
greener pastures in neighbouring countries, putting at risk the
lives of
Zimbabweans who are left with ill-equipped and under-manned
hospitals.
Previously, the government would withhold diplomas for nurses
who completed
their training so that they could be bonded to local health
institutions for
at least three years. This, of course, is necessary, not
least because the
government met the full cost of the nurses’
training.
The recent move to release these nurses before they have done
their time
clearly strikes me as an easy exit for a government which has
developed a
penchant for running away from its responsibilities (remember
the teachers’
incentives). It is also a perpetuation of the old syndrome
where patients
are left to suffer because there are no nurses to attend to
them, and the
results have been very glaring considering infant, child and
maternal
mortality rates in the country.
At a time when HIV/AIDS has
stretched our health sector, the government
needs to find a way of
harnessing all the resources at its disposal to
develop the sector. This
involves getting more nurses on the job, not taking
them away!
In its
insincerity, the government wants Zimbabweans to believe that it
cannot
continue bonding nurses, who have played a pivotal role in as far as
reducing the health crisis is concerned, because of lack of resources. This
cannot be the case because Zimbabweans are aware of the diamonds being
looted at Marange and the leakages that have become the order of the day in
most of Zimbabwe’s border posts.
While money is available to pay
Members of Parliament, senators and
councillors who are ill-equipped for
governance tasks (judging from the
little that the GNU has done), it is
tantamount to betrayal for the
government to claim inadequacy of funds to
save lives.
The Public Service Commission conducted an audit in January
2011 which
revealed that there are between 45,000 and 70,000 “ghost workers”
on the
government payroll. These people who could not be traced impact
heavily on
the state’s already dry coffers. The government, through the
Public Service
Commission, should ensure that these people are removed from
the payroll as
the salaries accorded to them could benefit hospitals that do
not have
adequate nursing staff.
The flimsy resources argument fails
to hold any water especially in view of
the fact that Zimbabweans are aware
that police station walls across the
country are awash with advertisements
of vacancy notices in the security
forces. Clearly, if there are resources
to continue recruiting for the army
and the police why should the government
fail to allocate resources to an
essential sector like health?
The
Zimbabwean government is indicating left and turning right in its
purported
fight against brain drain. History is replete with statements of
complaint
about the brain drain and the many steps that the government is
taking to
avert it. Its actions on the nurses indicate that the brain drain
argument
is superficial and a political excuse for failure to provide
essential
services.
Our nurses, trained at public expense, will now move on to
benefit countries
like Botswana, South Africa and Namibia where they will
not only be
appreciated but also paid handsomely. The government invests a
lot into the
development of nurses’ skills but instead of making use of the
nurses so
that they plough back into the state coffers through tax and also
assist in
improving service delivery, we are closing the door on
them.
The importance that the government should attach to the revival of
the
health sector cannot be over emphasised. The contribution of nurses
towards
achieving that should not be overlooked. The expectation is that for
the
government, it should be business as usual. Efforts should be made to
ensure
that the money leakages in our economy are blocked, so that resources
can be
channelled to essential sectors such as health and the lives of the
people
of Zimbabwe improved.
In addition to that, alternative means
of resourcing key sectors, like
public-private partnerships, should be
employed to augment available funds.
Otherwise even major referral hospitals
will be reduced to clinics, and
ineffective ones at that.
Nokholo
Mhluzani is the Information Officer at Bulawayo Progressive
Residents
Association (BPRA). She writes in her personal capacity. She can
be
contacted on finkymhl@gmail.com
Last updated at 6:50 PM on 23rd February 2012
The world’s
oldest man is a Zimbabwean teacher who claims he is 115 years old and taught the
country’s president Robert Mugabe as a young schoolboy, it has been claimed.
Oscar Munyoro
Katsukunya claims he was born in 1897 in Kutama, around 30 miles west of the
capital Harare.
This would make him 115 years old – matching the undisputed oldest age reached by Christian Mortensen from the U.S., who lived for 115 years and 252 days before his death in 1998.
The claim is particularly surprising considering the low average life expectancy in Zimbabwe. At just 47 years, it is one of the lowest in the world because of the country's poverty - due to its crumbling economy, deaths from Aids and almost non-existent healthcare.
Centenarian? Oscar Munyoro Katsukunya claims he was born in 1897
Birthday celebrations: Zimbabwe's President Robert Mugabe turned 88 this week
The retired
teacher, who now moves around with the use of a wheelchair, claimed on state
television he vividly remembers teaching Mugabe in 1931 at a primary school in
Zvimba, where the future President grew up.
Mr Katsykunya
claims he was 34 years old at this time and Mugabe aged just seven.
The frail
pensioner spoke in an interview with the Zimbabwe Broadcasting Corporation to
recount his memories of the future president.
The ZBC reported: 'Born in 1897, Mr Katsukunya says the story of his life saw him train as a teacher at Kutama and was then posted to Murombedzi which is within Zvimba district as part of his teaching practice.
'Telling his story with difficulty now because of advanced age, he remembers vividly that the Robert Mugabe he taught at Sub A was an intelligent young boy.'
The programme was broadcast as part of a series of programmes on the station to mark Mugabe’s 88th birthday on Tuesday.
Mr Katsukunya claimed he was invited two times to meet Mugabe after he was elected head of state when Zimbabwe gained its independence in 1980 when the President ‘requested for his teacher’.
However Mr Katsukunya admitted his birth date would be difficult to prove.
In the year Oscar Munyoro Katsukunya claims he was born...
The station
reported that the colonial era government rarely issued birth certificates to
black Africans and added that most nineteenth century births took place
unrecorded in homesteads or huts.
The
government-controlled network added that those birth certificates which were
issued were usually done so several years after a child was born and that the
exact date of birth was estimated by members of their
family.
If Mr
Katsunkunya's claim is correct, the centenarian was born less than a decade
after the country of Rhodesia was founded by British colonialist Cecil Rhodes in
1888.
The territory
remained under British control until it was granted independence and renamed
Zimbabwe in 1980.
The frail
pensioner's son told of his pride at his father's achievements.
Emmanuel
Katsukunya, 62, said: 'I think he is a legend and hero in his own right. After
all, he taught a head of state.'
ZBC reported the
elder Katsukunya ‘wishes he could meet his student again one day before destiny
catches up with him.'
The title of the
world's oldest man is currently held by Japanese centenarian Jiroemon
Kimura.
Step back in time: Queen Victoria's Diamond Jubilee procession passes the National Gallery, Trafalgar Square, London on 22nd June 1897, the year Mr Katsukunya claims he was born
The former
postman's date of birth has been verified as April 19 1987, making him 114 years
and 309 days old.
Mr Kimura
assumed the title last year following the death of American Walter Breuning, who
was born on September 21 1896 and lived to the age of 114 years, 205
days.
The world's
current verified oldest person is American Besse Cooper, from Monroe,
Georgia.
The retired teacher's birth date has been verified as August 26 1896, making her 115 years and 180 days old.
By Clifford Chitupa Mashiri, 23/02/12
In view of Robert Mugabe’s
reluctance to reform ahead of elections, the only
remaining effective option
is for more targeted sanctions on him and his
inner circle.
More
restrictive measures by the EU and the United States are urgently
needed on
Mugabe and his allies, to prevent the country from sliding into an
unstable
kleptocracy.
The basis for that observation is three-fold - Mugabe’s
moves to amend the
draft constitution unilaterally; his threat to disown
S.A.’s President Jacob
Zuma as the mediator and his push for elections
regardless of key reforms.
It is clear that Mugabe is trying to transform
the draft constitution into a
Zanu-pf election manifesto in the run-up to a
referendum and elections. That
will be resisted and will have potential for
greater instability.
The dictator is diverting attention from the real
issues which are his poor
human rights record, bad governance, flouting of
the rule of law, abuse of
presidential powers and making a mockery of the
justice system for as long
as he lives.
Mugabe’s recent threat to
disown Zuma as the mediator on the Zimbabwe crisis
for demanding key reforms
before elections should not be dismissed as hot
air because he has thrived
on high profile political controversy for the
greater part of his
rule.
Hopes that Zuma would be tougher with Mugabe were flawed and
wishful
thinking because they overlooked the mutual interests of the ANC and
Zanu-pf
in the post-colonial discourse in terms of their real and imagined
enemies
in Zimbabwe and beyond.
It is important to note that an
equitable and transparent land
redistribution programme with fair
compensation supported by donor countries
remains unfinished business in
Zimbabwe, and no shortcuts through
constitutional clauses can override that
reality.
As Mugabe’s age advances and his health deteriorates (based on
the
mysterious 10 long haul flights to the Far East in one year), his
well-provided-for inner circle is increasingly anxious about the prospects
of indictment to the Hague.
Not only will history judge Mugabe as a
‘people’s oppressor’ but also as
‘Africa’s most uncharitable bully’, in the
wake of his attacks on other
countries calling them fronts of the
West.
The people of Zimbabwe inevitably need help of Western countries in
safeguarding the unsteady peace in the country. Pretending otherwise would
be self-deception.
Clifford Chitupa Mashiri, Political Analyst,
London,
zimanalysis2009@gmail.com
COURT WATCH 3/2012
[23rd February 2012]
This bulletin outlines two cases involving deaths arising from
inter-party political violence – both of which were eventually heard and
resulted in convictions in the High Court.
The first case took an extraordinarily long time to come to trial – just
under 10 years from original arrest to trial.
The second case took over two years from arrest to
trial.
Killings in 2002 - Convictions in 2012
Background The run-up to the 2002
Presidential election was characterized by many violent clashes between
supporters of different political parties.
One such incident, in Zaka district in Masvingo province in March 2002,
led to the deaths of two MDC supporters.
Arrest and detention The three accused, one of
them the ZANU-PF
Zaka district political commissar Muchakata Mupfiga, were arrested in
2002 and initially remanded in custody.
Released on bail After six weeks they were
freed on bail and remained on remand for 5 years until further remand was
refused by the magistrates court, as a result of which they were discharged and
remained at liberty until late 2011.
Delays in the hearing of the case There has been no explanation why the State
did not have the case ready for so many years.
For the first 5 years the accused were on remand having been given
bail. [In murder cases it is unusual to
grant bail because of the seriousness of the crime and risk of flight or
intimidation of witnesses.] For the next
five years they were at liberty in spite of having been accused of murder,
because the state did not proceed. Such
unexplained delays are inexcusable especially in serious cases as they may
result in witnesses becoming unavailable or forgetting important details of
events – quite apart from opening the door to nullification of proceedings on
constitutional grounds [see
below].
Case revived, accused
indicted
The State revived the case in 2011 and in September the accused were
summoned to the magistrates court and indicted for trial before the High Court
on two charges of murder. They were then
re-detained and remained in custody awaiting trial.
Trial The trial took place at the
High Court circuit in Masvingo earlier this month. Evidence established that the deceased, both
MDC activists, had been accused of stealing cattle from a ZANU-PF
base commander. Mupfiga led a
group of militia in storming the first victim’s homestead and force-marching him
back to their base. There he died after
being comprehensively assaulted over a period of three days: kicked, punched,
hit with bricks, knobkerries, sjamboks and pieces of wood, stripped and his back
burnt with burning plastic. The second
victim was also seized from his home and subjected to similar assaults at the
camp over a period of two days ; he, too, died as a
result.
Conviction and sentence Mupfiga was acquitted of murder but convicted on two counts of the
lesser crime of culpable homicide [newspaper reports were wrong in saying that
he was convicted of murder]. His two
accomplices were convicted on one count of culpable homicide. Mupfiga was sentenced to 12 years’
imprisonment, 2 of them suspended on condition of good behaviour. The others were each sentenced to 5 years’
imprisonment, one year suspended. [Note: The difference between murder and culpable homicide lies in
the mental state of the accused. Murder
is causing the death of another person intending to kill, or recklessly
continuing a course of conduct despite realising that it may cause death the
death of that person. Culpable homicide
is causing death negligently failing to realise that one’s conduct may cause
death; or causing death realising that one’s conduct may cause death, but
negligently failing to guard against that possibility. Murder can be punished by the death penalty;
the maximum penalty for culpable homicide is life imprisonment. Criminal Law Code, sections 47 and
49.]
Judge condemns lawlessness, urges acceptance of
diversity In passing the court’s
judgment Justice Karwi:
· condemned the accuseds’ conduct in usurping the powers of the police
and causing lawlessness in the area during the election
period
· urged people to accept political diversity and put an end to
political violence.
Convicted persons to appeal to Supreme Court Mupfiga and his two
accomplices plan to challenge the validity of the trial in an application to the
Supreme Court, claiming infringement of their constitutional right to be tried
within a reasonable time [Constitution,
section 18].
2009 Gokwe Murder
Background On 21st March 2009, Moses Chokuda, the MDC Gokwe
District organizing secretary, was on his way to attend a MDC council meeting, when he was seized
at the Gokwe Business Centre, forced into a white ZANU-PF
vehicle and driven away. His
lifeless body was found abandoned in the bush two days later, 23rd March. He had sustained serious
injuries. A medical report gave the cause of death as
severe cervical spinal injury. It later emerged that Chokuda
had died on the night of 22nd March after a severe beating at the homestead of
headman Esau Ndokwane in Nemangwe.
Arrest and detention The six accused
were only arrested on 2nd June 2009, almost two months after the death of Mr
Chokuda: Farai Machida [son of Midlands Governor Jason
Machaya], Edmore Gana [a member of
the Zimbabwe National Army [ZNA] and ZANU PF Midlands province youth secretary
and son of ZANU-PF Gokwe District coordinating chairperson], his brother
Bothwell Gana [also a ZNA soldier],
Abel Maphosa, Obert Gavi and Tirivashoma Mawadze [the two last-mentioned both ZNA lance
corporals]. They were soon
released
on bail.
Delays in the bringing case to court The case lay unattended and unheard by the
courts for the rest of 2009, all of 2010 and into 2011. Moses Chokuda’s body continued to lie in the
Gokwe District Hospital mortuary – his family had refused to bury him until
restitution and an open and public apology had been given for his killing; full
disclosure made of the circumstances and motive leading to his death; and the
case heard by the courts and justice done. On 26th April 2011, Chokuda’s father, Tawengwa
Chokuda, wrote to the Attorney-General pleading for the State to bring the case
before the courts so that the family could have closure.
Accused indicted for High Court trial In August 2011 the accused
were taken before the magistrate’s court and indicted for trial for murder at
the next High Court circuit in September. The delay that had occurred
was explained by reference to witnesses having been unavailable and failure to
complete the necessary paperwork. The
accused were remanded in custody and taken to prison to await trial. On 16th September Machaya and three of the
other accused were released on bail by Justice Musakwa, despite State opposition
to bail being granted.
Trial On 21st September the case
began before Justice Mathonsi and two assessors. The accused pleaded not guilty. All the accused were legally
represented. During the six-day trial it
emerged that Chokuda had been accused of stealing from Machaya’s supermarket and
assaulted by all the accused.
Conviction and sentence On 26th September Justice Mathonsi handed
down the court’s verdict. Farai Machaya, Abel Maphosa, Bothwell Gana and
Edmore Gana were found guilty of murder and sentenced to 18 years in
prison. Obert Gavi and Tirivashoma Mawadze were
acquitted of murder but found
guilty
of the
lesser offence of assault and sentenced to 12 months in prison; they were found
to have assaulted Chokuda at the business centre before the later, fatal, assault.
Judge condemns lawless behavior by accused soldiers Justice Mathonsi told the four accused ZNA
members that they had chosen to behave like privately hired soldiers and that
such a flagrant disregard of the law would not be tolerated
Judge criticizes police conduct of
case In his judgment Justice
Mathonsi also criticized the police investigation of the case, referring to
evidence heard from State witnesses that they had given the police vital
information which had been omitted from their formal witness statements produced
in court: “we cannot exclude the fact that the police attempted to downplay
what happened in favour of the defence. The police omitted vital
evidence which was led by State witnesses and this is not
acceptable.” Referring to crucial events related in court by
the witnesses, the judge said: “All this was missing from their statements which they were made to
sign without reading them.”
Compensation and traditional restitution paid to Chokuda
family After the trial Provincial
Governor Machaya said he accepted the court’s verdict on his son, and
negotiations commenced between the Machaya and Chokuda families over
compensation for the death of Moses Chokuda.
The negotiations were facilitated by Chief Njele. Mr Machaya took full responsibility for
compensating the Chokuda family, saying that the other accused had only become
involved because they were assisting his son.
He would pay all the restitution required by the Chokuda family for his
son and the co-accused. On 16th October
2011 the families reached an agreement.
Mr Machaya agreed to compensate the Chokuda family with $15 000 and 35
head of cattle, 20 of which were delivered on the day with the remainder to come
at a later stage. The Governor also
agreed to finance all the arrangements for the funeral of Moses Chokuda. The Chokuda family accepted the compensation
and apology. [Comment: A criminal
conviction a does not preclude separate civil proceedings for compensation or
other redress for the wrong committed, whether the claim is under customary law
– as in this case – or under the general law of Zimbabwe. Under the Customary Law and Local Courts Act,
customary law enjoys wide application, especially, but not exclusively, in
disputes between indigenous Zimbabweans.
It is the only law applied in the “local courts” – courts of chiefs and
headmen – which are part of the general court system. Other courts apply customary law in
appropriate cases.]
Burial after two and a
half years Moses Chokuda was finally
buried at Chipere village, Gokwe, on 22nd October 2011, giving the Chokuda
family closure and peace nearly two and a half years after his
death. He was 25 at the time of his death and was
survived by his widow and two year old son.
Comment
In both cases the facts suggest a reluctance on the part of the
police to pursue this sort of criminal case.
This has been a perennial MDC complaint against the police.
The GPA records the commitment of the three GPA parties to “ensuring that all state
organs and institutions strictly observe the principles of the rule of law and
remain non-partisan and impartial.” Bringing perpetrators to
justice regardless of political affiliation is essential if Zimbabwe is to throw
off its long-standing reputation for impunity for the powerful. The police need to take Justice Mathonsi’s criticism in the Machaya
case seriously. And it is hoped that the
Attorney-General’s
Office and the justice system will play their part in ensuring that
criminal cases are dealt with expeditiously and with even-handed
justice.
Veritas makes every effort to ensure reliable information, but cannot
take legal responsibility for information
supplied.