The ZIMBABWE Situation
An extensive and up-to-date website containing news, views and links related to ZIMBABWE - a country in crisis
Please note: You need to have 'Active content' enabled in your IE browser in order to see the index of articles on this webpage
81
percent students fail O’Level Exams
http://www.swradioafrica.com
By Violet Gonda
05 February
2013
81.6 percent of children failed their 2012 Zimbabwe School
Examination
Council (ZIMSEC) Ordinary Level examinations, a drop from the
previous year’s
equally shocking 80.5 percent, amid calls for a curriculum
review of
Zimbabwe’s education sector.
Zimbabwe School Examinations
Council director, Esau Nhandara, announced on
Monday that only 31,767 pupils
out of 172,698 countrywide passed in five
subjects.
He attributed the
decline to an increase in the number of students who
registered for the
exam, which went up by over 20,000 from last year.
Surprisingly Shona,
the mother tongue for the majority of the candidates,
the pass rate was only
18%. The pass rate in English was 20% but only 13%
for
maths.
Education minister David Coltart told SW Radio Africa that the
country’s
education sector remains in crisis and there are a variety of
factors that
have contributed to the decline in the pass rate.
He
said Zimbabwe lost at least 20,000 teachers, especially between 2004 and
2009, at the height of the economic and political crisis in
Zimbabwe.
Coltart said it was inevitable that there would have been an
impact. “In
2008 there was hardly any teaching that took place in schools.
There weren’t
textbooks and unfortunately there is a batch of children now
coming through
the system whose education was affected by those calamitous
times.”
The minister blamed the government for failing to make the
education sector
a priority and investing adequately into education. He said
the government
has to cut down expenditure on other sectors, such as the
defence ministry,
and should spend more on education otherwise the results
will continue to
decline.
ZIMSEC has not had a more than 25% pass
rate since its implementation in
2003. Coltart said this was because
Zimbabwe’s education sector had an
academic bias.
The Nziramasanga
Commission on Education reported in 1999 that the education
sector needed to
be more vocationally oriented as not all children are
academically
gifted.
“This is why we need to adjust our curriculum to have far more
vocational
subjects that are examinable at O’Level and A’Level,” Coltart
said.
Some observers say the quality and assessment of the children who
went
through the UK Cambridge system seemed to work well before the
transformation to the ZIMSEC exams.
But Coltart disagreed, saying
ZIMSEC has a very high standard and is an
institution that Zimbabweans
should be proud of and should maintain through
teacher training, curriculum
development and financing.
“Cambridge exams are four times more expensive
than ZIMSEC exams and parents
are struggling as it is to pay ZIMSEC fees.
The minister added: “I think it
is harder to pass a ZIMSEC exam than it is
to pass a Cambridge exam.”
Coltart
admits O' Level results 'crisis'
http://www.newzimbabwe.com
05/02/2013 00:00:00
by Staff
Reporter
EDUCATION Minister David Coltart on Tuesday blamed
the disappointing
November 2012 Ordinary Level examination results on the
“extreme crisis in
education experienced between approximately 2005 and
2009”.
Results released on Monday showed 81,6 percent of the 172,698 who
sat for
the examinations failed to pass at least five subjects with grade C
or
better.
Only 31,767 of that number were successful, translating to
a pass rate of
18,4 percent.
Despite increased investment in education
and a massive drive financed by
UNICEF to supply textbooks to schools, the
2012 pass rate was down from 19,5
percent in 2011.
In 2010, the pass
rate was 16,5 percent when 229,522 pupils sat
examinations, down from 19,33
percent in 2009 when just 87,201 were
examined.
Faced with the
shocking numbers, Coltart admitted the only positive was that
more and more
children were sitting examinations after a decade-long
economic crisis
devastated the education sector and led to massive drop-outs
and teacher
flight.
Curiously, Coltart took partial CREDIT for the low pass rate,
stating: “The
decline in the pass rate is an indication that ZIMSEC have
followed my
instruction that standards are to be maintained so that we have
an accurate
idea of the health of our education system.”
The minister
said the percentage drop in the pass rate could be traced back
to the
education crisis of 2005 and 2009.
“Sadly there is a batch of children going
through the system whose education
suffered during those years when
thousands of teachers left the service and
many teaching days were lost, and
that is reflected in these results,”
Coltart said.
“Another reason
for the decline may be the increase in numbers of children
writing which can
also result in a decline in the pass rate.”
The minister is demanding a
major shake-up of the curriculum to ensure that
pupils who are unsuccessful
academically have a fall-back.
“Our O’ Levels are primarily academically
orientated whereas many children
are more practically orientated.
Inevitably, this academic orientation
results in many children failing whose
talents are not academic,” the
minister said in a statement.
“This
was a flaw recognised by the Nziramazanga Commission in 1999 which we
are
now seeking to address through the programme of comprehensive review and
reform of our curriculum which is now under way.”
In a sobering
verdict, Coltart said: “Whatever the case, the results are a
reminder that
whilst there is still a lot of good in our education system
there is still
much work to be done before we can say that we have restored
excellence.
“The Zimbabwean education sector remains in crisis and it
is going to take a
sustained non partisan effort to regain its status as the
best in Africa.”
RioZim,
Mzembi on collision course after ZANU PF takeover of Renco Mine
http://www.swradioafrica.com
By
Alex Bell
05 February 2013
Tourism Minister Walter Mzembi and the
owners of Renco mine in Masvingo are
on a collision course, after the ZANU
PF minister allegedly instigated the
takeover of the mine.
Last month
ZANU PF’s Chivi South MP, Irvine Dzingirai, declared he was the
new manager
of the mine, which has been the site of a labour dispute for
several weeks.
Production there had ceased after workers’ wives and local
villagers
barricaded the main gate, demanding an improvement in workers’
conditions
and community assistance projects.
Renco owners RioZim have now gone to
the High Court to try and retain their
legal rights to the mine, accusing
Mzembi of instigating the takeover.
“Minister Mzembi arrived at the mine…
He called a public meeting and
announced that RioZim had not complied with
the indigenisation obligations
of the country and hence they were taking
over Renco,” RioZim said in a
statement last week.
It said the
minister had appointed Dzingirai as the general manager and
directed all
staff to work under him. The mining firm added that the MP was
now using
threats and intimidation to bar RioZim directors and management
from the
mine.
Mzembi has denied RioZim’s accusations, saying he only became
involved with
the mine when Renco workers lobbied him, as their local MP, to
intervene in
a pay dispute.
Criticising the RioZim statements he
said: “That’s political slander. I’m
surprised by their statement, which
seeks to politicise what is a dispute
between them and their workers,” he
told Reuters.
He has since retaliated, publicly accusing RioZim of
offering him a
US$100,000 bribe. He was quoted by the state run Herald
newspaper as saying:
“They tried to buy me out of this case, with a US$100
000 brown envelope
which I turned down, preferring to advance community and
worker issues which
they have blatantly violated over the past 40
years.”
“I am not that cheap, neither is my constituency worth so little,
after four
decades of gross neglect and abuse. They must try someone else. I
will not
be bought with filthy lucre to sell an entire constituency’s
aspirations and
dreams about development which they clearly see being
implemented more
responsibly by other corporates like Zimplats and Unki in
areas where they
are operating,” Mzembi said.
The MDC-T spokesperson
for Masvingo province, Harrison Mudzuri, said that
ZANU PF has from day one
tried to openly politicise the labour dispute at
the mine, in order to take
it over.
“Dzingirai is trying to threaten workers to either join ZANU PF
or they will
be fired. We are concerned because this is a labour dispute
that is being
politicised by ZANU PF,” Mudzuri told SW Radio
Africa.
The MDC-T spokesperson said ZANU PF is trying to use “political
muscle to
make sure no one intervenes,” while insisting they are taking over
under the
country’s indigenisation laws.
Indigenisation Minister
Saviour Kasukuwere has since been quoted by the
NewsDay newspaper as saying
this is “irrational” and that he will be
investigating the Renco
situation.
“We want law and order in this country and we don’t want
indigenisation to
be dragged into the mud,” Kasukuwere reportedly said.
I was
offered $100k bribe, says Mzembi
http://www.herald.co.zw
Tuesday, 05 February 2013
00:00
From Isdore Guvamombe in MADRID, Spain
THE saga at Renco
Mine in Masvingo took a new twist on Sunday with Tourism
and Hospitality
Industry Minister Walter Mzembi making sensational
allegations that
shareholders of the mine, Rio
Tinto Zimbabwe, offered him a US$100 000
bribe so that he could abandon the
workers and surrounding communities in a
stand-off over working conditions.
Operations at the RioZim-owned Renco
Gold Mine ground to a halt mid-January
when spouses of miners at the gold
producer besieged the offices demanding
their husbands’ annual bonuses and
better working conditions.
Over 800 women blocked their spouses and the
police from passing through the
gates.
The women organised a night vigil
and vowed to disperse only after their
husbands got their bonuses and if the
mine management addressed them.
They were joined by people from the
surrounding communities who demanded
that the mine be indigenised under the
country’s empowerment laws.
The protests only stopped after Minister
Mzembi urged the demonstrators to
let operations continue while matters of
indigenisation were being
diacussed.
Chivi South legislator Cde
Irvine Dzingirai, who has a background in mining,
was said to have assumed
control of operations until the matter is resolved.
In a statement issued
to journalists here on the sidelines of the Firtur
Travel and Tourism
Exposition, Minister Mzembi said he turned down a bribe
as it would have
weakened the workers and surrounding communities.
However, RioZim chief
executive officer Mr Ashton Ndlovu dismissed the
minister’s
allegations.
Minister Mzembi is the legislator for Masvingo South where the
mine is
located.
“They tried to buy me out of this case, with a
US$100 000 brown envelope
which I turned down, preferring to advance
community and worker issues which
they have blatantly violated over the past
40 years.
“I am not that cheap neither is my constituency worth so
little, after four
decades of gross neglect and abuse. They must try someone
else. I will not
be bought with filthy lucre to sell an entire
constituency’s aspirations and
dreams about development which they clearly
see being implemented more
responsibly by other corporates like Zimplats and
Unki in areas where they
are operating.”
Minister Mzembi said he had
sided with the workers and the community after
realising that their cause
was genuine.
“I will not dignify corporate political slander on my
person, neither will I
be intimidated by litigation from exercising my
representative role as
Member of Parliament.
“This is a classic case
of trying to prevent me from exercising my
legitimate role of interceding on
behalf of the community in their dispute
with RioZim shareholders. Why
should it work for other regions and not
Masvingo? What kind of curse is
this that attracts this kind of investment
which politicise clear corporate
social responsibility issues?
“Well, if I turn out to be the Ken Saro
Wiwa of Masvingo South in pursuit of
justice for our people, so be it,” said
the Minister.
Minister Mzembi said he had informed President Mugabe about
the real
situation on the ground at Renco Mine.
“Instead of resorting
to this vuvuzela approach of splashing litigious
adverts on this matter they
must go to the source and engage the community
for a lasting
community.
“I have no intention of owning a mine, my plate is already
full, with my
calling to represent the people, but if they expect me to turn
a blind eye
to exploitation of our people, then they have got it
wrong..”
Minister Mzembi said he had pleaded with workers to resume work
pending
resolution of their grievances through his office.
“They gave
me their conditions including those of the community which had
joined in the
class action but Riozim have been avoiding dialogue but
instead bragging
about their connections to higher offices.
“I still insist on a 360
degree thorough probe of Riozim. If I am wrong on
what I suspect has been
going on, I will be the first to extend a public
apology to the people of
Zimbabwe.”
Mr Ndlovu, whose company last week splashed adverts in
newspapers accusing
Minister Mzembi of inciting the workers and surrounding
communities to
disrupt operations, said RioZim had engaged Minister Mzembi,
the traditional
and political leaders in the community.
“I do not
know where the minister is getting that (bribery allegations)
from. Any
money spent by the company is accounted for because we are public
listed
company. All the money we give out is not given to individuals,” he
said.
Mr Ndlovu said his company had engaged the community including
its leaders
on how it can assist in development programmes.
“We have
discussed how we could assist the community through the RioZim
Foundation
which has been in existence since 1974 and has assisted the
communities
around the mine. Otherwise we do not deal with individuals but
the community
through its leadership,” he said.
RioZim has also accused Minister Mzembi
of threatening disruptions at the
mine if the workers were not paid their
bonuses.
“The management pleaded with him to help avoid this but to no
avail.”
RioZim stated they were in good standing with all legitimate
stakeholders
and had several engagements with Minister Mzembi.
“On
Saturday January 18 2013, honourable Minister Mzembi arrived at the mine
with Chivi South legislator Cde Irvine Dzingirai and others.
“He
called a public meeting and announced that RioZim had not complied with
the
indigenisation obligations of the country and hence they were taking
over
Renco and MP Dzingirai would be the general manager and all staff would
work
under him,” read part of a press statement published by RioZim last
week.
The company said Chivi South legislator Cde Irvine Dzingirai
had
“unlawfully” assumed executive authority over the mine.
It also
accused Cde Dzingirai of using threats and intimidation to prevent
senior
management from accessing the mine.
The company also accused Minister Mzembi
of issuing inaccurate information
on workers pensions.
NCA
tells Zimbabweans to vote No in constitution referendum
http://www.swradioafrica.com/
By Tichaona
Sibanda
05 February 2013
The National Constitutional Assembly (NCA)
has said ‘No’ to the proposed new
constitution.
The NCA, one of the
leading pressure groups in the country, announced at a
press conference on
Tuesday that they would ask Zimbabweans to reject the
COPAC draft because it
is ‘neither people-driven nor democratic.’
Chairperson Dr Lovemore
Madhuku told journalists they are confident they
will get enough support to
defeat it at the referendum.
The law requires that for the proposed
constitution to pass into law, more
than 50 percent of the voters must
support it.
COPAC co-chairman Douglas Mwonzora gave notice to Parliament
that they would
present a copy of the draft and a full report of the
constitution making
process to both the lower and upper houses on
Wednesday.
Parliament is expected to debate and pass the draft
constitution without any
amendments. An MDC-T MP told SW Radio Africa that
parties to the GPA, who
all support the proposed new constitution, have the
ability to muster more
than enough consensus to get the constitution passed
at referendum.
Some observers believe the document has attractive clauses
and say that it
reduces the power of the president, to some extent, and
expands
parliamentary oversight over the executive, on some
issues.
But the NCA cited 24 reasons why this constitution should be
rejected. One
reason being that this is a constitution imposed on
Zimbabweans by just
three political parties.
The Madhuku led group
also alleges that the proposed constitution still
leaves all the power in
the president, who is allowed to do what he or she
wants.
Other
problems they have with the draft is that it increases the size of
Parliament to 350 MPs (270 national assembly and 80 senators). The NCA say
that Zimbabwe has, ‘no resources for such a huge
legislature.’
Madhuku said the NCA would use their structures to mobilize
their followers
to reject this document, but they also said it was important
that
Zimbabweans understood the contents of the draft and they want all
voters to
fully grasp the provisions it contains.
‘POSA must be
suspended to allow for uninterrupted campaign meetings. If
this is not done,
the NCA reserves its right to campaign without being
restricted by POSA. We
also want equal access to the public media by both
the YES and NO voices,’
Madhuku said.
EU to
send poll observers
http://www.dailynews.co.zw
Tuesday, 05 February 2013 10:08
HARARE - The
European Union (EU) says it is ready to send election observers
to Zimbabwe
to monitor the forthcoming watershed elections.
Aldo Dell’Ariccia, head
of the EU delegation, told the Daily News that the
27-member bloc was
awaiting the invite.
“We do not impose ourselves or force governments to
invite us to observe
their elections,” Ariccia said.
“We wait for the
inclusive government to send an invitation and this must
have a time frame
because we need time for observers to come and observe
activities leading to
the elections.
“An additional team will also come during the actual
elections and remain in
the country until the winner is
proclaimed.”
Rugare Gumbo, Zanu PF spokesperson said the politburo, the
party’s highest
decision-making body outside congress, will have to discuss
the EU role in
the impending elections.
“The politburo will discuss
whether to have EU monitors in our elections. We
will decide on that once
the election date is set,” said Gumbo.
Tendai Biti, secretary-general for
Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai’s MDC,
last week said the country’s
elections will have to be held under the ambit
of the 2004 Sadc principles
and guidelines on free and fair elections that
among other things makes it a
prerequisite to have foreign election
observers and monitors.
The MDC
led by Welshman Ncube has said it wants foreign monitors and
observers in
the country six months before and after the poll. - Bryan Gumbo
Delay
in poll date stalls observer mission
http://www.dailynews.co.zw
Tuesday, 05 February 2013
09:51
HARARE - President Robert Mugabe is delaying announcing poll dates to
forestall the early arrival of foreign observers expected to monitor the
forthcoming general election, analysts have said.
The octogenarian,
facing his greatest challenge in 33 years, has been
accused by the
international community of trying to rig the southern African
country’s
forthcoming watershed presidential election.
Academics and experts in
governance, political economy, constitutional law
and elections led a
critical one-day think tank process in Bulawayo over the
weekend meant to
prepare civil society interventions in the referendum and
the next
election.
The analysts expressed worry that the hold-up in announcement
of poll dates
will have a bearing on the arrival of observer teams in
Zimbabwe before the
election.
Trevor Maisiri, International Crisis
Group (ICG) senior analyst for Southern
Africa, argued that the delay would
eventually lead to late observation of
the forthcoming elections with far
reaching consequences for Zimbabwe.
“There is need to ask the parent
guarantor AU (African Union) to send an
early assessment mission ahead of
the next elections to assess readiness of
Zimbabwe for those elections,”
Maisiri said.
In previous elections, there has been careful
cherry-picking of foreign
delegations permitted to observe the conduct of
the election campaign and
the count.
The Foreign minister has
previously invited observers only from countries
that have either openly
supported the ruling Zanu PF or have maintained
silence about the country’s
prolonged political and human rights crisis.
Maisiri said it was
impossible to think of a new Zimbabwe without taking
into account the stakes
of the military.
He said the Zimbabwean military top hierarchy had
hijacked efforts by Sadc
to achieve security reform in Zimbabwe through a
process of peer talk with
other military bosses in the
region.
Panellists said there was need to improve military and civil
relations.
Ibbo Mandaza, executive director of Sapes Trust and publisher,
argued there
had been an “over-exaggeration” of the military factor in the
democratisation agenda.
Mandaza rubbished the threats by the military
that they would upset the
constitutional order should someone who did not
take part in the armed
liberation war wins the forthcoming
election.
“The military has always been subservient to civilians since
Rhodesian
days,” Mandaza said.
Zanu PF’s opposition has expressed
alarm at statements made by generals —
the real power behind Mugabe — that
they would not tolerate a win by anyone
without liberation war
credentials.
Analysts expressed concern at the potential impact of
partisan natural
resource governance on the forthcoming
elections.
Mugabe is unveiling a cocktail of empowerment strategies to
fight Zimbabwe’s
most tightly contested presidential election in more than a
decade.
Styling himself as a champion of the poor, Mugabe is working on
increasing
access to wealth for many of Zimbabwe’s disadvantaged in a
re-election drive
his party says “has the capacity to appeal to electorate
in a massive way”.
“Zanu PF has used empowerment as an instrument of
patronage, and to increase
its political base,” said Brian Raftopoulous
former University of Zimbabwe’s
Institute of Development Studies associate
professor.
The think tank meeting is expected to leverage the efforts of
pro-democracy
forces ahead of the election expected in 2013. - Gift Phiri,
Political
Editor
Two
youths arrested over ‘voter registration exercise’
http://www.swradioafrica.com/
By Violet
Gonda
05 February 2013
Police arrested two prospective voters over
registration receipts in Lupane,
Matabeleland North Province, according to
the Zimbabwe Lawyers for Human
Rights.
Initially on Monday police
arrested 40 people, who were later released,
leaving Brilliant Goboza and
Ray Ncube from the National Youth Development
Trust in custody. They have
been charged with contravening the Criminal Law
Act for allegedly possessing
voter registration receipts.
The rights group said they were allegedly found
with a number of receipts
issued at the Registrar General’s Office where you
register as a voter.
These latest arrests come not long after the arrest
of ZimRights officials,
including director Okay Machisa, on similar charges
of undertaking an
“illegal” voter registration exercise ahead of the
forthcoming polls.
Machisa was released on bail last week but his Deputy
Programmes Manager,
Leo Chamahwinya and three others, are still in police
custody following
their arrests in December last year.
Charles Moyo
from Zimbabwe Lawyers for Human Rights was only allowed access
to his
clients on Tuesday. The two are expected in court on Wednesday.
Confusion
remains over dual citizenship laws
http://www.swradioafrica.com
By Alex Bell
05 February
2013
There is still serious confusion over whether the new draft
constitution
allows for dual citizenship or not, with the parties in
government appearing
to translate the new rules differently.
The new
document does not explicitly allow or deny Zimbabweans the right to
dual
citizenship, but does recognise Zimbabwean citizenship by birth,
descent and
registration. Section 42 (e) contains the only comment on the
contentious
issue, stating that an act of Parliament can prohibit dual
citizenship.
This is a slight change to the previous draft charter
released last year,
which had said that an act of Parliament may pass
legislation for ‘the
prohibition [or permitting] of dual citizenship in
respect of citizens by
descent or registration’. The change is that the
phrase ‘or permitting’ has
been removed.
But according to the
democracy group OSISA, this deletion “makes no
substantive difference,
merely removing a confusion caused by the suggestion
that legislation would
be needed to permit dual citizenship when the
constitution does not
otherwise forbid it.”
To make matters more complicated, officials in
government are not agreed on
the details, despite agreeing to put the
document forward for a referendum.
The MDC-T has repeatedly stated that dual
citizenship is definitely provided
for with party leader, Prime Minister
Morgan Tsvangirai, telling world
leaders in Switzerland last month that this
was so.
This is contrary to the opinion held by ZANU PF. Most recently,
Justice
Minister Patrick Chinamasa said: “There is no dual citizenship, and
there
will be no Diaspora vote, the country does not have the funding for
it.”
Andrew Makoni from the Zimbabwe Lawyers for Human Rights (ZLHR) said
there
is no clear law on dual citizenship, saying “it seems to me the MPs
responsible for drafting these laws didn’t want to define what dual
citizenship means.”
“There are fears on one side of government about
what dual citizenship would
mean in respect of a Diaspora vote. So the
challenge is that we (Zimbabwe)
have postponed the issue…it has essentially
been parked,” Makoni said.
He added that the confusion is “unfortunate”
especially for the millions of
Zimbabweans living in the Diaspora, “many of
them not out of choice.”
“They are being asked to contribute to a society
that does not recognise
their rights and that is very unfortunate. So it
really doesn’t appear as if
this issue is a priority for the government, but
it needs to be,” Makoni
said.
Zimbabwe London
Embassy Pressured On Diaspora Vote
http://www.zimeye.org
By Eugene Majuru
Published:
February 5, 2013
The Zimbabwean embassy in London was
cornered last week at the Business
Council for Africa (BCA) investment forum
in London, on the matter of the
contentious diaspora vote amidst growing
belief that Zimbabweans in the
diaspora will vote for ZANU PF if allowed to
vote.
This comes as Zimbabweans living in the Diaspora expressed growing
interest
in going to the polls to vote and take part in the forthcoming
elections.
Zimbabwean delegates who attended the BCA investment event in
London
challenged Zimbabwe’s London Ambassador to do something about getting
Zimbabweans in the Diaspora to be given the chance to vote.
An
example of countries like Ghana was given; Ghanaians are able to vote in
their country elections and voting takes place in London at the Ghana
Embassy.
“If Ghana can do it why can’t Zimbabwean?” one of the
attendants raised his
voice towards the ambassador.
Diasporans have
never had the opportunity to vote at all and they feel
missing out. Voting
means a lot when one is able to say; My vote was
counted, I contributed to
the outcome of the election,” said one of the
participants.
Zimbabwe
has not put in place a system to allow Zimbabweans living in the
Diaspora to
vote. The cash strapped country currently facing a challenge to
hold the
long awaited 2013 elections would find it impossible to implement
this
system this year.
Chinamasa,
Biti still to meet over poll funding
http://www.herald.co.zw
Tuesday, 05 February 2013
00:00
Wencesclaus Murape Senior Reporter
JUSTICE and Legal
Affairs Minister Patrick Chinamasa and his Finance
counterpart Tendai Biti
are yet to meet to map out modalities for engaging
the international
community to help fund the forthcoming
constitutional referendum and
elections.
Minister Chinamasa said in an interview yesterday that they were
supposed to
meet last week, but the meeting failed to materialise due to
other pressing
commitments.
“We will be definitely holding the
meeting because funding for the
constitutional referendum and harmonised
polls is of paramount importance,”
he said.
“The US$2 million that
has been availed by the Treasury to the Zimbabwe
Electoral Commission is far
too short of the budget and can only be adequate
for purchasing the
referendum ink and stationery.”
ZEC has presented a budget of US$85 million
for holding of the
constitutional referendum and US$107 million for the
harmonised polls.
Principals in the inclusive Government tasked Ministers
Chinamasa and Biti
to source money for the referendum and elections from
donors.
The funds would come through Treasury for onward transmission to
institutions that run electoral processes, especially ZEC.
The
meeting between the two ministers is expected to come up with modalities
to
be used in sourcing the funds, just like what was done during the
constitution-making process.
Minister Chinamasa said the shortage of
funds would eventually scupper the
referendum and polls.
Zanu-PF
spokesperson Cde Rugare Gumbo said it was imperative for the
referendum to
go ahead before the expiry of the term of Parliament in May.
“We believe
that there are some delaying tactics on the part of the Treasury
so as to
create a crisis upon expiry of the Parliamentary term without the
referendum
being held,” he said.
“There is a need to act with urgency and
seriousness in the fund-raising by
Ministers Chinamasa and
Biti.”
MDC-T spokesperson and Copac co-chairperson Mr Douglas Mwonzora
said after
completion of the constitution draft, they believed that the
stage was set
for a referendum.
“It is imperative that Government
should make sure that the funds are
available,” he said. “We believe that
with serious political will,
harmonised polls will definitely be held this
year.”
Mr Mwonzora said the period of political posturing was over and
there was a
need for Ministers Chinamasa and Biti to work together for the
good of the
country.
Mr Mwonzora appealed for money generated from
diamond sales to be channelled
towards the referendum and polls.
'No
to security sector reforms'- Mnangagwa
http://www.thezimbabwemail.com
Staff Reporter 23 hours 35
minutes ago
HARARE - Defence Minister, Emmerson Mnangagwa
says the country’s military
has a mandate to defend national economic
interests and will not tolerate
any move by the MDC-T to enforce security
sector reforms in the country.
Minister Mnangagwa made the remarks while
presenting a paper on Zimbabwe’s
Defence Policy at the National Defence
College in Harare.
The MDC formations are demanding, among other things,
security sector
reforms before the country holds harmonised elections this
year.
Minister Mnangagwa was yesterday categoric that such reforms would not
be
undertaken as long as the revolutionary Zanu-PF was alive.
“As long as
we are here in leadership, we will make sure the Defence Forces
of the
Republic of Zimbabwe will continue to defend the national interests
and to
safeguard our values and ideals which our people died for,” he said.
Minister Mnangagwa said those advocating for security sector reforms were
trying to bring about regime change in Zimbabwe.
“The current Government
is anxious to reform you. Anxious with security
sector reforms. They do not
want to have a Defence Forces that is
knowledgeable, focused and
revolutionary. We are against it.
“The defence forces are an element of
national power but the inclusive
Government does not want to hear that. They
would want a kind of defence
force that is pliant to foreign interests, that
allows expropriation of
national resources without question,” he
said.
“They want to hear that you are compliant, that you accept security
sector
reforms. What does that mean? It means to have non-governmental
organisations and trade unions operating in the defence forces. Pasi nazvo!
They would want you to say you are non-political, you must serve any
Government.”
He said it was ironic that the USA was part of those calling
for security
sector reforms yet it was not reforming its own
systems.
“Every American civil military says America first. The national
interests of
America come first.
“They are taught as children to die for
America but they come and teach you
differently to uphold international best
practices, what nonsense is that?”
Minister Mnangwagwa said the ZDF cannot
achieve its goals of safeguarding
national interests if it depends on
Treasury for funding and underpinned the
need for the sector to be involved
in the country’s economic development.
“That cannot be achieved if we rely on
Biti. We cannot depend on allocation
from the fiscus alone.
“This is why
I have decided that the ZDF will be involved in economic
development in
order to achieve its vision. This, we will,” Minister
Mnangagwa said.
Political
violence goes down in Mashonaland Central: JOMIC
http://www.thezimbabwemail.com
Staff Reporter
31 minutes ago
Cases of politically motivated violence
are on the decrease in Mashonaland
Central Province, once considered as one
of the political hotbeds in the
country, according to the Joint Monitoring
and Implementation Committee.
This came out at a JOMIC Mashonaland Central
special provincial liaison
meeting held on Tuesday in Bindura.
JOMIC is
the principal body dealing with issues of compliance and monitoring
of the
Global Political Agreement which gave birth to Zimbabwe’s Government
of
National Unity in 2009.
JOMIC co-chairpersons drawn from the MDC-T, Zanu (PF)
and the MDC led by
Welshman Ncube concurred that political intolerance and
violence in the
province had decreased as a result of outreach programmes
meant to preach
peace among communities.
MDC-T Co-chairperson, Godfrey
Chimombe, said: “At the present moment, we
cannot really say that there is
political violence in Mashonaland Central.
Of course there are a few
isolated cases here and there but the environment
is very quiet.
“We are
moving around preaching peace and tolerance and we are urging
village heads
and chiefs to preach the same to villagers. As political
leaders we should
teach our supporters to desist from violence. Even
Tsvangirai and Mugabe are
on record denouncing violence.”
Chimombe said peace was crucial in aiding the
country’s development efforts.
Zanu (PF) Co-chairperson, Everson Tauro,
admitted that many cases of
politically motivated violence were reported in
Mashonaland Central during
the 2008 elections but said the situation had
changed as communities were
beginning to embrace political tolerance.
“We
are saying that as Zimbabwe let’s move away from 2008.We are glad that
people are embracing the call and there is peace in the province.
“Even
during the liberation struggle we used to clash as ZIPRA and ZANLA
forces
but we later realised that there is more that unites us than divides
us.
Even the GNU came after some fighting but the relationship between the
principals now is very cordial and let us follow that example,” said
Tauro.
The MDC-N Co-chairperson, Henry Chimbiri expressed concern that people
were
politicising social issues and the development had led to misleading
reports
on political violence in Mashonaland Central.
“The problem is
that at times people get involved in social arguments and
fight but after
that, one will come to us and report that one would have
been harassed by
Zanu (PF) people but when we go to investigate the matter,
we discover that
the issue was a purely social one which had nothing to do
with politics,”
said Chimbiri.
Zimbabwe
Introduces Tough Regulations Targeting Youth Groups
http://www.voazimbabwe.com
Ntungamili Nkomo,
Gibbs Dube, Jonga Kandemiiri
04.02.2013
WASHINGTON DC — Zimbabwe's
Ministry of Youth Development, Indigenization and
Empowerment has introduced
stringent regulations that compel all youth
organizations to register with
the government-run Youth Council or risk
being shut down.
The
regulations were gazetted January 18, but were only made public Monday,
thanks to Veritas, a civic group specializing in legislative
analysis.
They also dictate that youth groups should submit annual
reports and
accounts, as well as work plans and budgets to the Youth
Council, which is
largely viewed as an extension of President Robert
Mugabe’s Zanu PF party.
Youth organizations are also compelled to pay an
annual levy to the council.
The severe provisions were fashioned by
combative Youth and Indeginization
Minister Savior Kasukuwere, the architect
of the widely-condemned black
empowerment policy that forces foreign-owned
companies to cede a 51 percent
stake to locals.
Veritas described
Kasukuwere’s regulations as “exteremely wide-ranging,”
urging youth groups
to consult their legal advisers and challenge the
validity of the
provisions.
"As a matter of first impression," Veritas said, "the
regulations seem to go
much further than the (Zimbabwe Youth Council) Act
permits."
National Youth Develeopment Trust director, Liberty Bhebhe told
VOA his
organization views the move as an effort by Zanu PF to gag youth
groups
ahead of the referendum and general
elections.
Meanwhile, Zimbabwean youths say they are happy about
employment and
economic empowerment proposals contained in the country’s
final draft
constitution.
They told VOA Studio 7 that this is the
first time youths have been
recognized in the supreme law of the country,
although there may be
challenges in implementing some of the constitutional
provisions.
Chapter Two, Section 20 of the draft stipulates that youths
should be
afforded opportunities for employment and economic
empowerment.
Bulawayo youth, Minenhle Tshuma, said government should
craft vocational
training programs to fully empower young
people.
Jim Kunaka, chairman of Zanu PF’s Harare province, agreed
saying if the
draft charter is passed into law, the constitution could be
amended to
enforce youth economic empowerment.
Police
swoop on homeless people
http://www.dailynews.co.zw
Tuesday, 05 February 2013 10:08
HARARE -
Traffic came to a standstill in Harare as police officers swooped
on
homeless people and street children in an exercise meant to clean up the
city.
The clean-up, code named Usagara Mumugwagwa (Leave the streets)
is targeting
vagrants who have flooded the streets pestering the public for
food and
money.
Some of the vagrants end up snatching items from
unsuspecting motorists,
police said.
Tadious Chibanda, the police
spokesperson, said street urchins are now a
danger to the public as they
have become habitual criminals.
“As police, we have received complaints
from the public about street
children who end up robbing innocent people or
assist criminals in
committing crimes in the CBD (Central Business
District),” Chibanda said.
Plain clothes police officers yesterday
descended on the homeless “families”
and showed no mercy as they grabbed
wailing children from reluctant parents
who vainly tried to resist
arrest.
Blind beggars, the deaf and the dumb were not spared in the
blitz.
Traffic along the busy Samora Machel Avenue came to a halt as some
street
kids tried to flee.
Police had to use handcuffs and sjamboks
on adults who have turned street
pavements into their homes and were
resisting arrest.
A number of civil society organisations are bankrolling
the programme aimed
at ending child abuse.
“It is an offence under
the Child Protection Act to allow a minor to beg for
food in the street.
These children are being abused by their parents and end
up street kids,”
Chibanda said.
Most of the people who now have families living on the
streets are former
street children who continue to wallow in poverty as the
vicious cycle
continues.
A police cell was cleared yesterday to
accommodate the vagrants after
officers had interrogated some of the adults
suspected of being behind
criminal activities rampant in the city
centre.
Investigations to establish the whereabouts of parents of some
minors are
still underway. - Xolisani Ncube
Harare goes
dry as pipe bursts
http://www.herald.co.zw
Tuesday, 05 February 2013 00:00
Evelene
Taadira Herald Reporter
A MAJOR burst at Prince Edward water works over
the weekend has seen
residents in most parts of Harare going without water
and resorting to
unprotected sources. Harare City Council spokesperson
Mr
Leslie Gwindi said yesterday that authorities were hopeful the
situation
would have improved by today as engineers were rectifying the
problem.
“The major burst occurred on Friday night and our personnel has
been on the
ground throughout the weekend. We have been reviewing the
progress at
regular intervals and are satisfied with the progress. Finer
touches are
being put as we speak,” he said.
In the meantime, most
residents in the eastern suburbs have been without
water for the last four
days.
Mr Gwindi said due to the fault, it would take some time before normal
supplies return to the affected areas but expectations were that by the end
of day tomorrow they would have been restored.
“It is a pity that
most of the piping system in the city is old, but we are
progressively doing
the best we can to replace them,” he said.
Bikita
nurse blocking MDC from receiving treatment
http://www.swradioafrica.com/
BIKITA
Tinoonga
Mawere
5th February 2013
MDC supporters have expressed grave concern
at the continued
presence of Martin Mabasa, a general nurse based at Mukore
Clinic- a
well known Zanu PF activist who is denying former
opposition
supporters access to medication.
According to MDC Information
and Publicity secretary for Bikita South
Constituency, Stephen Saidi, Mabasa
is a well known Zanu PF activist
who claims to be a war veteran. He is
allegedly turning away patients
suspected to be sympathetic to the MDC
telling them to go and receive
medication from party president Morgan
Tsvangirai.The clinic is
situated in ward 8, Bikita South
Constituency.
Last year the local community approached MDC Member of the
house
assembly Honourable Janhi Vharandeni who took the matter to
Jomic.It
is understood a Jomic team was dispatched to the clinic but Mabasa
has
reportedly remained defiant. Despite the Jomic visit Mabasa
has
remained unfazed saying he would strive to protect the gains of
the
liberation struggle.
“We are gravely concerned about the situation at
Mukore Clinic because
Mabasa- the nurse in charge -who is a war veteran has
openly declared
his allegiance to Zanu PF.He is turning away MDC supporters
telling
them to go and seek treatment from Prime Minister Morgan
Tsvangirai.We
are worried about the situation because Mabasa cannot be
trusted even
if he agrees to attend to our ailments. You can never know what
he is
up to. The Jomic Team visited the clinic last year but nothing
has
changed because Mabasa says he does not recognize Jomic.The
situation
is very complicated and he tells everyone that the clinic
was
established by Robert Mugabe and nobody has the right to tell him
what
to do. He also claims Mugabe is responsible for sourcing the drugs
and
all MDC supporters should go and seek treatment from their
party
leader,”Saidi.
Saidi further claimed Mabasa has openly declared his
allegiance to
Zanu PF and is using the medical facilities to spruce up Zanu
PF`s
waning image.
“Mabasa is now treating the clinic as a personal
surgery and he
further claims that Zanu PF is providing drugs at the clinic.
The
situation is very sad because people `s lives are at risk. We
were
expecting to see some changes following the Jomic visit, “said
Saidi.
Before GPA consummation, the clinic was literally closed due
to
shortage of drugs and poor sanitary facilities. The clinic only
resumed
full time operations after the formation of the inclusive
government in 2009.
Community Share Ownership Scheme politicised,
polluted
http://www.mdc.co.zw
Tuesday, 05
February 2013
The MDC’s position is that Kasukuwere’s Community Share
Ownership charade is
nothing but another ploy to hoodwink voters ahead of
elections.
The Community Share Ownership Scheme in its current form
is tantamount to
theft by Zanu PF where companies are arm-twisted into
supporting an illegal
scheme that has no credence in a normal country. Zanu
PF is on a crusade to
fleece companies in order to fund its election war
chest. The recent
revelation of corruption in Manicaland where the Zanu PF
provincial leaders
extorted over US$700 000 from mining firms is just a tip
of the iceberg. The
MDC will continue to boldly and candidly expose Zanu
PF’s dishonest and
insincerity in this whole facade of empowering
people.
The MDC has robust policies that will grow the economy for the
benefit of
all Zimbabweans, and not just party cronies. Our mining policy
explicitly
spells out that as part of corporate social responsibility,
mining companies
are to ensure the provision of housing, health facilities,
roads, schools,
water and sanitation facilities in the communities they
operate in.
The MDC will also establish a proper Sovereign Wealth Fund
(SWF) which will
be financed and managed through clearly defined statutes on
Resource Rent
Tax not donations or bribes as manifested in Kasukuwere’s
Community Share
Ownership Scheme. The Sovereign Wealth Fund will be funded
by ring-fencing
the Resource Rent Tax (RRT) to invest in long term projects
and instruments
that ensure economic prosperity beyond the depletion of our
mineral
resources.
Kasukuwere’s empowerment scheme is a replica of
the usual Zanu PF’s
unstructured policies on land expropriation, thus his
indigenisation
programme is carried out in an opaque and often corrupt
manner. Just
recently Kasukuwere “went to town” claiming to have raised US$4
billion for
the government’s National Indigenisation and Economic
Empowerment Fund
(NIEEF) and community trusts.
Surprisingly he has
not given the same publicity of the record of payments
being made nor of the
share transfers to the National Indigenisation Fund.
Therefore the fund
being created by Kasukuwere lacks a clearly defined
structure, financing and
staffing and proper legal existence. The fund
clearly lacks any
institutional structure for transparency and
accountability.
In
normal circumstances, a Sovereign Wealth Fund (SWF) should be responsible
to, but independent of, government ministries. It should be established
under the ambit of the finance ministry, with an autonomous board made up of
professionals just like other quasi-government entities like the Reserve
Bank of Zimbabwe.
The people of Zimbabwe should be made aware that
the issue of Community
Share Ownership Scheme is not a new phenomenon, but
rather has been part and
parcel of corporate social responsibility of
companies since time
immemorial. It is thus very wrong for Zanu PF to now
run with the programme
as if it is their initiative. Instead of supporting
companies who have all
along been carrying out these programmes
professionally and transparently,
Zanu PF has in fact high jacked this noble
undertaking, laced it with
political overtones while at the same time
extorting money from these
companies.
The MDC believes that the role
of the state should be to create conditions
for enterprises and individuals
to flourish and not to decimate existing
businesses under the guise of
empowerment. Following more than a decade of
economic regression Zimbabwe
requires access to investment capital and this
can only be unlocked by a
sound policy regime.
The people of Zimbabwe do not want handouts. They
want a government with
forward looking and sustainable policies to allow
them to live to their full
potential. They want a government with a vision
to drive this country
forward. They want a government with policies that can
create jobs, attract
investment from domestic and international sources, and
put in place
measures towards rural transformation and mass
upliftment.
This is why over 78% of Zimbabweans concur with the MDC that
the current
policy of indigenisation is inimical to development and economic
growth. It
is narrow and only meant to enrich a few politically connected
people. It is
a continuation of a patronage system that has been at the
epicentre of
destroying this economy.
Zimbabweans are not lazy. They
want to work for themselves, to provide for
their families and communities
and they want to develop their country.
The Last Mile: Towards Real
Change!!!
Harare/Beitbridge
road to be upgraded, tolled
http://www.engineeringnews.co.za
By: Natalie Greve
5th February
2013
The Department of Roads in Zimbabwe has commissioned Royal
HaskoningDHV to
conduct a feasibility study to determine the viability of
construction and
tolling to improve the road between Harare and the
Beitbridge border post.
The study – which would be carried out in
association with five Zimbabwean
partner firms – involved traffic studies,
development of a toll strategy,
engineering analysis and concept design,
environmental-impact scoping, an
economic feasibility study, financial
modelling and preparation of a draft
project information memorandum for
investors.
The cost of rehabilitating and improving the road was
estimated to be in
excess of $600-million, some of which would be funded as
a loan against
revenue from the tolls.
The feasibility project was
urgently required to provide an indication of
viability as interested
funders – the Development Bank of Southern Africa
and the African
Development Bank – needed to make a decision about
committing funding by
March 2013.
The Harare to Beitbridge road comprised a portion of the
trunk road network
of Zimbabwe, as well as the North to South Corridor – one
of the major
arterial links in the regional road network.
The road
was the most direct link between the capital cities of Harare, in
Zimbabwe,
and Pretoria, in South Africa, and provided landlocked Zambia
access to the
Indian Ocean ports of Durban and Richards Bay.
“The road carries between
1 000 and 5 000 vehicles a day, with the heavier
flows in the proximity of
Harare. Of significance is the fact that a high
proportion of this traffic
are trucks carrying goods, equipment and
machinery that support the
Zimbabwean economic recovery,” Royal HaskoningDHV
project manager Phil
Hasluck explained.
The 580-km long road project, which started just
outside Harare and ended at
the Beitbridge border post, was a single
carriageway, two-lane road with
numerous bridges.
Although well
maintained in the past, the road was over 40 years old and was
rapidly
deteriorating under increased heavy vehicle traffic.
Alternatives to
improve it as a single carriageway road or to add certain
sections as dual
carriageway would be assessed.
SADC begins
training of Stand by Force in Zim
http://www.news24.com
2013-02-05 10:07
Cape Town –
SADC military inspectors have converged in the Zimbabwe capital
for a
training course aimed at improving the operation and proficiency of
the
military component of the SADC Standby Force (SSF) in war times,
according
to a report.
In 2007, regional countries resolved to contribute troops
under the SSF to
defend members states from revolts and
aggression.
The brigade, under the command of Tanzania, is in the eastern
Democratic
Republic of Congo where M23 rebels had launched an onslaught
against
President Joseph Kabila's government.
Zimbabwe's Herald
online reported on Tuesday that inspectors drawn from all
SADC countries
would inspect different countries' preparedness for any
eventuality.
Those participating will in turn train their colleagues
in their respective
countries.
Their duty will be to inspect physical
military equipment of all countries
that pledged to contribute to the
brigade.
Sadc Defence Inspectorate Working Group chairperson Colonel
Joseph Mathambo
of Botswana said the inspectors would physically examine
military hardware
and personnel to be deployed at the shortest possible time
when needed.
Common understanding
"We have instances where
pledging countries were found lacking when it was
time for deployment and
this inconvenienced the whole brigade so we decided
that we inspect and see
the actual troops and equipment on the ground.
"They will also train the
civilian component of the brigade who comprise the
police, non-governmental
organisations who will be providing critical
services to the brigade such as
humanitarian assistance, dealing with
children and other vulnerable
groups.”
Officially opening the course, acting Zimbabwe Defence Forces
Commander
Lieutenant General Valerio Sibanda said there was a need for SADC
member
states to speak with one voice.
He said SADC members states
should be prepared for any eventuality.
"For this to be effective, we
have to be united and speak with one voice,"
he said.
"In your
various countries you have your own inspectorate format but with
this
working group it was found necessary that you should adopt the same
format
regionally. The course is designed to ensure that we have a common
understanding of the inspectorate procedure so that you can train others in
your respective countries. If we are to harmonise our operations we have to
harmonise our training first."
The training is set to end on 15
February.
Is this Harare's
most famous bin?
All out ... Ambassador Wharton speaks on Tuesday while
Mayor Masunda looks on
|
05/02/2013 00:00:00 |
|
by Staff
Reporter |
| |
HARARE Mayor Muchadeyi Masunda took
time out of his busy schedule on Tuesday to attend a very special engagement –
the donation of a GARBAGE BIN from the United States embassy.
Masunda and Ambassador Wharton, with
their staff and officials in tow, converged at the Harare Gardens for a photo-op
with the green bin made out of a metal drum.
The beaming mayor later cut the
ribbon to officially launch what is now Harare’s most famous
bin.
Ambassador Wharton said he was
“thrilled” to be making the donation which he said demonstrated the embassy’s
support for “community-led cleanup and waste management
activities”.
“I’m thrilled to be here to make
this small token which represents our interest in community-led solutions to
waste management,” the envoy said.
Masunda added: “We all have an
obligation…if everyone did his little bit this place would be totally
different.”
In a statement, the US embassy said
the donation was a small part of an 18-month campaign by staff and their
families to “green” the embassy and its surrounding area.
The campaign is led by American
diplomat, Sanya Hunsucker. She said of Tuesday’s bin donation in the Harare
Gardens, across Herbert Chitepo Street from the main embassy compound: “It’s a
key transit point with a large foot traffic population. It’s a perfect location
to begin.”
A new take on land
reform in Zimbabwe
Agricultural production has returned to pre-2000 levels, according
to a new study
LONDON/HARARE, 5 February 2013
(IRIN) - More than 10 years after the chaotic and often violent farm invasions
that accompanied Zimbabwe’s fast-track land reform programme, a new book argues
that the redistribution programme has dramatically improved the lives of
thousands of smallholder farmers and their families.
Starting in 2000,
the government implemented an initiative to acquire 11 million hectares of
white-owned farmland and redistribute it on a massive scale; the programme was
often carried out in the form of farm invasions led by frustrated war veterans
and supporters of President Robert Mugabe. By its conclusion, only 0.4 percent
of farmland remained in the hands of white commercial farmers, and smallholder
farmers dominated the agricultural sector.
The land reform programme was
followed by years of drought, hyperinflation and an economic
meltdown.
Thirteen years later and more than 8,000km away, it still
raises strong emotions. At a recent event hosted by London’s Chatham House at
which authors of the new book, Zimbabwe Takes Back Its
Land, defended their work, the hall was packed, and a polite but
persistent group of anti-Mugabe protesters occupied the pavement
outside.
The book avoids passing judgement on the often violent manner in
which the programme was executed. “This is not a book about what might have
been, could have been, or should have been,” write authors Joseph Hanlon,
Jeanette Manjengwa and Teresa Smart. Instead, it focuses on the results of a
study they carried out in Mashonaland, a region of northern Zimbabwe covering
three provinces, which found that many of the ‘fast-track’ farmers are faring
much better than has been widely assumed.
Despite receiving very little
government assistance, “we saw that these farmers had a real passion for
farming. We found that farmers are making investments, building houses and
barns… and buying farm implements,” said Manjengwa. “They are making the land
their own, and they are becoming serious commercial farmers.”
Finding success
When Samson Pfumo, a 52-year-old
teacher from Harare, applied for and received a 60-hectare plot in Marondera
District through the land redistribution programme, his expectations were
low.
“My brother, a war veteran, encouraged me to apply to the government
for a piece of land, but I was pessimistic because of the controversy that
surrounded the land reform programme,” Pfumo told IRIN. “When I got an offer
letter for the plot [in 2005], I only set up a small mud-and-dagga [hut] and
hardly visited the farm.”
"We found that farmers are making investments, building
houses and barns...They are making the land their own, and becoming serious
commercial farmers"
When the economy started improving
in 2009, after the formation of a coalition government, Pfumo developed a keener
interest in farming and started raising pigs. A year later, he had 60 pigs, some
of which he sold to buy farming implements and to start growing maize for feed.
Today, he has five large pig pens housing more than 300 pigs, which he
periodically slaughters for sale, with each pig fetching an average of US$150.
He is also rearing about 500 chicks for sale and is considering venturing
into tobacco farming after
noting that many resettled farmers have been making good profits from the
crop.
“I managed to buy a truck to ferry meat to my clients and a luxury
car. My two sons are now studying at reputable universities in South Africa
because I can afford it, thanks to the piggery project,” said Pfumo, who has
left teaching and now lives on the farm with his wife and mother.
Controversial progress
Manjengwa and her
colleagues found that even the less ambitious among the new farmers surveyed,
who mainly received smaller plots of five or six hectares, had greatly improved
their standard of living. After being mostly poor, landless and unemployed prior
to resettlement, virtually all of them were able to grow enough food for their
families, and to sell the surplus to pay for their children’s school fees. But
many were doing much better than that, producing significant quantities of
maize, tobacco and other crops for sale, and building up capital in the form of
livestock, farm buildings and equipment. They were also starting to employ
labour.
The issue of labour is contentious because so many farm workers
lost their jobs and their homes when the old white-owned farms were broken up;
some are stillhomeless and unemployed. However, Hanlon, Manjengwa
and Smart estimate that around 550,000 family members and 350,000 paid labourers
now work full-time on land that previously employed 170,000 workers.
Charles Taffs, president of Zimbabwe’s Commercial Farmers’ Union,
reminded those at the meeting at Chatham House that the workers now being hired
are not the same ones who were driven off the commercial farms. He also asserted
that the figures presented in the study did not add up.
Zimbabwe’s
agricultural production experienced a dramatic drop following the upheavals of
2000, but according to the authors, it is now returning to the levels of the
1990s. This is despite the fact that many rely on a much more labour-intensive
form of farming than that used by the earlier white commercial farmers.
The authors also point out that, although many of the white-owned
commercial farms were efficient and productive, many others were struggling and
had far more land than they could use; some of the most fertile land in the
country had gone uncultivated. The new smallholders have brought much of that
unused land into cultivation.
Dilemma
Manjengwa
and her colleagues are not the first to suggest that Zimbabwe’s controversial
land reform programme has achieved a number of positive results. A 10-year study
of land reform in Masvingo Province, led by Ian Scoones from the Institute of
Development Studies at the University of Sussex and published in 2010,
challenged a number of the “myths” surrounding fast-track land reform, finding
that many of the 400 households sampled were employing labour and expanding
their farming operations.
“The suggestion that the fast-track land
reform programme was not an unmitigated disaster presents dilemmas about whether
to accept this growing body of evidence and risk endorsing the methods used to
achieve the asset transfer,” commented Admos Chimhowu of Manchester University’s
Institute for Development Policy and Management, who pointed out that
neighbouring South Africa has yet to find a solution to its land reform
challenges.
[This report does not
necessarily reflect the views of the United
Nations]
Designers weave partnerships
across continents
A partnership
between Kingston University in London and a craft centre in Zimbabwe has proved
so successful that a group of women from a remote farming community are about to
exhibit their work at one of the world's largest design shows.
The head of
Kingston's Design School, Simon Maidment has been sharing his expertise with the
Lupane Women's Centre whose hand-woven baskets provide a much needed source of
income for many families.
Based in rural
Matabeleland, two hours’ drive from Zimbabwe’s second city, Bulawayo, the centre
gives women an opportunity to earn money at times of year when they cannot farm,
enabling them to send their children to school or simply put food on their
tables.
The products are
sold to tourists visiting southern Africa and are even stocked by Anthropologie
and Conran shops in Europe and the United States. Their work has already been
shown at the London Design Festival and the National Gallery of Zimbabwe and, in
February, some of the craftswomen will be rubbing shoulders with creative
talents from across the globe at Design Indaba in Cape Town, the city which has
been named World Design Capital for 2014.
Mr Maidment said he
found himself not so much lecturing but collaborating with the workers as they
explored new ways of making, transporting and marketing the baskets. “We were
keen to work with the women to help them realise how skilful they really were
and to see the potential value of the items they produce,” he
said.
The success of the
project has attracted continued funding from the British Council. “It has really
given our women the confidence to try new things,” the manager of the Lupane
Women’s Centre, Hildegard Mufukare, said. “The women want to live better lives
and, with the help of Kingston University, now have the confidence to achieve
that.”
Design Indaba takes
place in Cape Town at the end of February. Building Baskets has been jointly
curated by Kingston University professor Catherine McDermott and Candice
O’Brien, who has recently completed the university’s MA in Curating Contemporary
Design.
Students from both
the business and design schools at Kingston University have also been involved
in the initiative. “We challenged our up-and-coming graphic, product, furniture
and fashion designers to solve various problems that limit profits for the
basket weavers, ranging from logistics to product diversity,” Mr Maidment said.
Selected ideas were then presented to the women during two weeks of workshops in
Zimbabwe.
Emma Lawlor, who
recently completed a Kingston University degree in product and furniture design,
was part of a team back in the United Kingdom that investigated how to transport
the delicate woven baskets. “The larger baskets get damaged easily in transit,
so we came up with a way of splitting them into two parts that could be woven
back together later,” Emma, who is from Bristol, explained. “We called the
project Tops and Tails and came up with a solution involving paperclips and
cable ties. We were all so proud when it was adopted by the
centre.”
The workshops had
also prompted the women to give names to their new products, Mr Maidment said.
“They included ‘Alice Bowls’ and ‘Shylet Shopper’. The women hadn’t truly taken
ownership of the work before in this way,” he said. “We also introduced drawing
and dyeing and combined their techniques with new approaches such as weaving
around an object. They’d never drawn, for example, because they’d made the
baskets from memory.”
Professor McDermott
believes that both the craftswomen and the students have benefitted from the
partnership. “Working with the centre has been a two-way flow of creativity,”
she said. “It’s a way for us to begin to change perceptions in the United
Kingdom about African economies. This is not a charity project – it’s a mutual
exchange of knowledge between two equal partners. High quality teaching
transforms lives. We can’t transform the economy of Zimbabwe, but we do feel
that, step-by-step, our impact can help make a difference.”
Zimbabwe's
Marange Diamonds: ZANU-PF's Best Friend?
http://thinkafricapress.com
Concern is growing in Zimbabwe
over missing diamond revenues, which many
believe to be lining the pockets
of ZANU-PF officials.
4 FEBRUARY 2013 - 3:06PM | BY BERNARD
CHIKETO
Mutare, Zimbabwe:
Following last week's admission that the
government's public account
contains only $217, Zimbabwe's Finance Minister
Tendai Biti has stressed
"government finances are in paralysis". He warned
that the “economy needs
every resource it can get”.
Yet several
sources have suggested accessing its resources may be more
difficult than
anticipated. At Zimbabwe’s Diamond Conference in Victoria
Falls last
November, former South African president Thabo Mbeki voiced
concerns that
Zimbabwe’s diamond industry had fallen under the control of a
“predatory
elite”.
Mbeki was alluding to a widespread belief that the Marange
diamond fields
are under the clandestine control of groups of ZANU-PF
officials - using
their access to state power to enrich themselves against
the interests of
the people. Presumably acting in collusion with the mining
companies, many
fear ZANU-PF could even be using these illicit funds to
undermine democratic
processes – particularly concerning with presidential
elections scheduled
for later this year.
Fields of
dreams
Marange’s potential revenues are staggering. Geologists estimate that
the
80,000 hectares of diamond fields at Marange could hold between two and
seven billion carats of raw diamonds and the fields are currently
contributing as much as 25% of global diamond output.
Eddie Cross,
economist and MP for Movement for Democratic Change (MDC-T),
claims that in
2012 alone more than $4 billion worth in diamonds has been
extracted from
Marange. However, his MDC-T colleague and a deputy in the
Ministry of Mines,
Gift Chimanikire, told Voice of America that while he was
unsure of the
source of Cross’s figures they seemed “exaggerated”.
Nevertheless, the
extent to which this is translating into revenue for
Zimbabwe’s state
coffers is another matter. A report published last month by
Partnership
Africa Canada (PAC) claims Zimbabwe may have already lost up to
$2 billion
in diamond mining revenues over the past three years. Many are
suspicious of
ZANU-PF officials’ expenditure and surmise it can only be
emanating from
underhand deals at Marange.
Understandably, the director of the Centre
for Natural Resources Governance
(CNRG), Farai Maguwu, has already expressed
fears that errant diamond
revenue could be used by ZANU-PF to subvert the
country’s democratic
processes in upcoming elections.
ZANU-PF’s best
friend?
Indeed, some fear the rot is already very deep. Earlier last year,
Tendai
Biti, Zimbabwe’s Finance Minister and Secretary General of the MDC-T,
suggested Marange revenues may be funding a “parallel
government”.
Douglas Mwonzora, a spokesperson for the MDC, blamed the
dire state of the
budget on diamond revenue going to ZANU-PF cronies,
explaining "the most
important thing is that money from diamonds is not
being remitted to
government coffers". Last July Biti drew attention to poor
revenue inflows
from the Marange diamond fields. Of the $600 million
expected from diamond
sales revenues in 2012, only $41.6 million had been
received by halfway
through the year. Consequently, the 2012 national budget
was cut from $4
billion to $3.4 billion.
Some believe that ZANU-PF
officials are being helped by international
companies operating in Marange
who are in cahoots with them. The diamond
fields belong to the Zimbabwe
Mining Development Corporation (ZMDC), which
fully owns Marange Resources
Ltd. However, ZMDC also holds 50-50 joint
ventures with three other mining
firms – the Diamond Mining Corporation
(DMC), Mbada Diamonds and Anjin
Investments (a joint venture with a Chinese
construction firm).
Each
of these companies has conspicuous connections to the ZANU-PF
structure.
Mbada Diamonds, for instance, is chaired by Zimbabwe’s former Air
Vice-Marshall Robert Mhlanga – rumoured to have been Mugabe’s personal
pilot. Anjin’s board includes the Permanent Secretary at the Ministry of
Defence, two commissioners of the Zimbabwe Republic Police, and current and
former officers of the Zimbabwe Defence Forces.
Last May, Finance
Minister Biti accused Anjin of having remitted nothing to
the Treasury
despite being the largest diamond producer on the Marange
diamond fields.
However, the Chinese-owned diamond producer claim they
remitted $30 million
and said they were being made a scapegoat for the
government’s
over-estimation of diamond revenues, denouncing Biti as being
“untruthful,
incompetent or illiterate” for allegedly miscalculating what
was
owed.
Mpofu, Cross, Biti: diamond geezers in dispute
Obert Mpofu,
Zimbabwe’s Mines Minister, has also joined in the reaction
against Biti. At
a Mining, Engineering and Transport conference in Bulawayo
last July, Mpofu
maintained that the mining industry was contributing enough
and called Biti
“a liar”. Yet Mpofu has been accused of benefiting from the
Marange diamond
fields himself, and is famously rumoured to own half of the
resort town of
Victoria Falls – expensive property alleged to have been
bought with
ill-gotten gains.
In fact, Mpofu has been accused of being a liar
himself. MDC-T MP Eddie
Cross has accused Mpofu of misleading parliament
when he claimed Zimbabwe
had only realised $200 million from the sale of raw
diamonds over the last
five years. During this time, total payments to the
Treasury had been over
$174 million. Mpofu’s suggestion that the mining
firms had paid out most of
the money earned from the sale of diamonds was,
according to Cross, patently
false.
Cross also suggests that ZANU-PF
granted the Marange fields to compliant
companies to ensure the party would
continue to gain funding after it lost
control of the Treasury and the
National Social Security Authority (NSSA)
with the establishment of the
unity government.
If these allegations are correct, there is little hope
of transparency
around Marange so long as the current actors retain their
licences. This
conclusion forms the basis of the MDC-T’s support for the
nationalisation of
the fields – something on which Cross has claimed
Zimbabwe “can expect
action shortly”.
Tendai Biti strongly advocates
legislative action to shift the current
status quo. Claiming that due
process was not followed in awarding the
concession, Biti has been pushing a
Diamond Control Revenue Bill, introduced
in 2011.
The bill seeks to
void all existing claims to concessions at Marange, while
nationalising the
fields under the joint supervision of both the mining and
finance
ministries.
Carats and sticks
Naturally, ZANU-PF denies the party is
lining its own pockets at Marange.
Tafadzwa Musarara, director at Resources
Exploitation Watch (an NGO partisan
to ZANU-PF), has condemned accusations
of opaqueness in the mining industry.
He insists that mining firms are
protected by law and, like any private
company do not have to make public
their balance sheets. He added that the
Treasury should be more realistic in
its revenue expectations, arguing that
firms were still recuperating their
infrastructural investments.
Another ZANU-PF member – Edward Chininga,
former Minister of Mines and
current chairman for the Parliamentary
Committee on Mines and Energy –
recently blamed the current international
sanctions on Zimbabwe for the
limited revenue flow. Chininga has argued that
sanctions are “creating
loopholes for illegal trade and fiscal leakages” – a
muted confirmation, at
least, of shadowy diamond deals in the
sector.
All four firms operating at Marange were targeted by US
sanctions, with ZMDC
a primary target of the financial restrictions.
However, Chininga has called
for the sanctions to be lifted since the four
companies are now fully
compliant with the Kimberly Process Certification
Scheme (KPCS). He claims
all the sanctions are currently achieving is to
“force companies to
circumvent normal export channels”, perhaps explaining
why their balance
sheets remain so opaque.
Whether or not the
accusations against ZANU-PF’s grounded in any truth, many
are becoming
concerned by the way in which Zimbabwe appears to be
haemorrhaging revenues
from its mining industries. Claims against
controversial figures within
ZANU-PF, such as Obert Mpofu, need to be
further investigated, while the
entire industry needs more accountability.
Whether MDC-T plans to
nationalise the diamond fields are realistic remains
to be seen, but at such
a time of empty coffers, Marange’s massive revenues
are hardly something the
government can afford to be missing out on.
Bill Watch - Parliamentary Committees Series 2/2013 - 5th February [Committee Meetings 4 to 7 February]
BILL
WATCH
PARLIAMENTARY
COMMITTEES SERIES 2/2013
[5th February 2013]
Parliamentary Committee Meetings Will Continue This
Week
Apology
Late
arrival of information from Parliament meant Veritas was unable to circulate
details of the committee meetings open to the public yesterday, Monday 4th
February. The only remaining meetings
open to the public this week are the two detailed below.
Open
Meetings on Tuesday 5th February at 10 am
Portfolio
Committee: State Enterprise and Parastatals
Consideration
of financial statements for October and November 2012
Committee
Room No 2
Chairperson: Hon
Mavima Clerk: Ms
Chikuvire
Portfolio
Committee: Industry and Commerce
Oral
evidence from ZISCO workers unions’ representatives at New Zimbabwe Steel Ltd
regarding resuscitation of operations at the plant
Committee
Room No 311
Chairperson: Hon
Mutomba Clerk: Ms
Masara
The meetings will be open
to members of the public, but as observers only, not as participants, i.e.
members of the public can listen but not speak.
They will be at Parliament in Harare.
If attending, please use the entrance on Kwame Nkrumah Ave between 2nd
and 3rd Streets and note that IDs must be produced.
This
bulletin is based on the latest information from Parliament. But, as there are
sometimes last-minute changes to the schedule, persons wishing to attend should
avoid disappointment by checking with the committee clerk that the meeting is
still on and open to the public. Parliament’s telephone numbers are Harare
700181 and 252941.
Note
on Yesterday’s Meetings
Most
of yesterday’s meetings were in closed session to deal with work plans, but
there were three meetings open to the public:
Public
Accounts Committee:
for Oral evidence from the Ministry of Health and Child Welfare on the 2009 and
2010 annual audit reports
Portfolio
Committee on Public Service, Labour and Social Welfare:
for oral evidence from the National
Employment Council for Willowvale Motor Industry on NEC operations and the
challenges faced by employees in the sector
Portfolio
Committee on Budget, Finance, Economic Planning and Investment
Promotion:
consideration of Microfinance, Securities Amendment and Income Tax Bills. [Note: The Committee will be seeking
expert guidance on these Bills and will return to them in due course and may
hold public hearings. Persons wishing to
make representations should contact the committee clerk, Mr Ratsakatika, on
252941 or 700181.]
Veritas makes every
effort to ensure reliable information, but cannot take legal responsibility for
information supplied