New York Times
By THE ASSOCIATED PRESS
Published: July 30, 2008
Filed at 1:34
p.m. ET
HARARE, Zimbabwe (AP) -- Zimbabwe will drop 10 zeros from its
hyper-inflated
currency -- turning 10 billion dollars into one -- the
country's reserve
bank said Wednesday. President Robert Mugabe threatened a
state of emergency
if businesses profiteer from the country's economic and
political
unraveling.
Shop shelves are empty and there are chronic
shortages of everything
including medication, food, fuel, power and water.
Eighty percent of the
work force is unemployed and many who do have jobs
don't earn enough to pay
for bus fare.
One third of Zimbabweans have
become economic and political refugees.
Another third is dependent on
foreign food aid. But Mugabe barred
non-governmental organizations from
handing out food last month, claiming
they were supporting the
opposition.
On Wednesday, central bank governor Gideon Gono announced he
was dropping 10
zeros from the currency, effective Friday. That comes a week
after he
introduced a 100 billion-dollar note which was not enough to buy a
loaf of
bread.
Mugabe went on television immediately after Gono's
announcement to warn
against illegal money dealings and
profiteering.
''Entrepreneurs across the board: Don't drive us further,''
he warned. ''If
you drive us even more we will impose emergency
measures.''
Gono said new money would be launched Friday with 500-dollar
bills. He also
said he was reintroducing coins, which have been obsolete for
years.
Gono said the high rate of inflation was hampering the country's
computer
systems. Inflation is officially running at 2.2 million percent in
Zimbabwe
but independent economists say it's closer to 12.5 million
percent.
Computers, electronic calculators and automated teller machines
at
Zimbabwe's banks cannot handle basic transactions in billions and
trillions
of dollars.
Mugabe has blamed profiteering and sanctions by
the United States and the
European Union for Zimbabwe's economic collapse.
Critics have blamed
mismanagement by Mugabe's government and a land reform
program that has
slashed Zimbabwe's agricultural output.
Both Mugabe
and Gono are targeted by the sanctions, which impose travel bans
and asset
freezes on more than 170 people, companies and farms.
''The country is
under illegal sanctions. These are intended to achieve
regime change,''
Mugabe charged. ''We must strengthen our will and
resistance so we can go
through this time of difficulty.''
Mugabe went on television just as
South Africa's President Thabo Mbeki was
jetting in to meet with him about
stalled power-sharing talks. Mbeki was
greeted by Mugabe at Harare airport
Wednesday afternoon. The two shook hands
and briefly embraced before leaving
together.
Mbeki has insisted the power-sharing talks which started last
Thursday were
going well and had simply adjourned on Monday.
But
several officials said Mugabe's negotiators returned home and opposition
leader Morgan Tsvangirai went to South Africa, the venue of the talks, after
they deadlocked over who would lead the ''inclusive'' government under
negotiation. The officials spoke on condition of anonymity because all
parties agreed to a media blackout surrounding the talks.
''We are
still negotiating, we want to succeed,'' Mugabe said in his
televised
address. ''You find room for compromise but sometimes compromise
is
difficult ... So things are never easy.''
A South African statement said
Mbeki would meet with Mugabe and the leader
of a breakaway opposition
faction, Arthur Mutambara. It said Mbeki met
Tuesday with Tsvangirai and his
negotiators.
Mugabe and Tsvangirai, bitter rivals, agreed last week to
have their
negotiators hammer out a formula to share power to resolve a
deadly
electoral dispute that has left more than 120 opposition activists
dead,
thousands injured and tens of thousands homeless.
Two more
opposition supporters were killed last week, allegedly by Mugabe's
followers, Tsvangirai's party said Wednesday.
''The deaths show that
there is no sincerity on the part of ZANU-PF'' party,
the opposition said in
a statement.
Both Mugabe and Tsvangirai say they won the elections and
should lead the
government.
The Telegraph
Zimbabwe's ravaged currency is to be revalued from Friday, the
government
has announced, slashing 10 zeros off all prices and
values.
By Sebastien Berger, Southern Africa Correspondent, and Peta
Thornycroft
Last Updated: 5:55PM BST 30 Jul 2008
Hyperinflation has
destroyed savings and reduced the economy to subsistence
levels, with bricks
of banknotes needed for even basic transactions.
The Zimbabwe dollar was
worth more than the American greenback at
independence in 1980, but Robert
Mugabe's misrule has seen it plunge to a
point where one pound is worth
around Z$200 billion, and accelerating
downwards.
Officially,
inflation is now running at 2.2 million per cent a year, but
independent
economists estimate it is far higher.
Last week a packet of locally
manufactured biscuits cost Z$489 billion. A
teacher at a private primary
school earned Z$485 billion a month,
illustrating the impact of the price
rises on salaries paid in arrears.
Bread - on the rare occasions it is
available - was costing Z$200 billion a
loaf, a can of Coca-Cola Z$600
billion, a plate of rice and scrawny chicken
Z$800 billion, a beer Z$1.8
trillion and a local ride in a shared minibus
Z$2 trillion - the same as a
civil servant's monthly wage.
The largest note is the newly-introduced
100 billion dollar bill, and most
cash-handling machines, such as shop
tills, are only designed to cope with a
maximum of 14 digits, so even
shopping is a challenge.
"The Zimbabwe dollar will be redenominated by a
factor of one to 10, which
means we are removing 10 zeros from our monetary
value. Ten billion dollars
today will be reduced to one dollar with
effective from August 1," said
Gideon Gono, the central bank
governor.
The largest new note will be worth 500 new Zimbabwe dollars, or
five
trillion current dollars. Coins, which have been obsolete for years,
will
also return, and existing notes will be valid until the end of the
year.
The German company supplying the paper for Zimbabwe's banknotes
recently
said that it would stop doing so, but it is understood the new
currency was
printed some time ago and has been held in storage in the
meantime.
The revaluation comes two years after the last such exercise,
when three
zeros were taken off the currency in a move dubbed "Operation
Sunrise".
But it proved to be a false dawn, and economists have warned
that simply
issuing new notes will be merely cosmetic without fundamental
accompanying
reforms, such as the government ceasing to print ever more
bills simply to
meet its own needs.
"This is just to overcome the
absurd difficulty of having to deal with all
those zeros but it does not
address the root cause of the problem," said
John Robertson, an economic
consultant. "The problem is of scarcity of
foreign earnings and investment
inflows."
A Harare-based finance specialist added: "At least three zeros
will be back
by the end of August."
Immediately after the
announcement, Mr Mugabe, who blames Western sanctions
and profiteering
businessmen for the economy's travails, went on television
to warn:
"Entrepreneurs across the board: Don't drive us further. If you
drive us
even more we will impose emergency measures."
Reuters
Wed 30 Jul
2008, 14:05 GMT
By MacDonald Dzirutwe
HARARE (Reuters) - Talks
between Zimbabwe's ruling ZANU-PF party and the
opposition MDC aimed at
resolving the country's political crisis will resume
on Sunday, South
African President Thabo Mbeki said on Wednesday.
Mbeki said after an
hour-long meeting with Zimbabwe's President Robert
Mugabe that the talks,
which adjourned for a couple of days on Tuesday to
allow negotiators to
consult with their respective leader, were going well.
"It is work in
progress. The negotiators are working hard and have committed
themselves to
the time-frame. They will resume on Sunday," Mbeki told
reporters after
meeting Mugabe, who said earlier that he wanted the
negotiations to
succeed.
In a sign of the economic collapse that has been worsened by the
political
turmoil, the central bank said it would redenominate the worthless
currency
to cut 10 zeroes from the Zimbabwe dollar, but analysts said that
would do
nothing to help the economy.
Mugabe's party began
power-sharing talks with the opposition in South Africa
last week, but
doubts have surfaced over progress after they were adjourned.
"We're
still negotiating, we want to succeed. Negotiations are negotiations,
they
are not a card game... You find room for compromise, sometimes
compromise is
difficult and you stand by your proposals as presented,"
Mugabe said in his
first public comments on the talks since a framework for
discussion was
signed on July 21.
"You debate again and again and reach a compromise. I
understand the talks
are going well," Mugabe said.
Mbeki denied on
Tuesday that talks had reached a deadlock.
On Wednesday Mbeki said he had
travelled to Harare to brief Mugabe on the
talks, adding that there were
some matters on which the rival negotiators
needed to consult their
respective leaders.
South Africa's department of foreign affairs said in
a statement that Mbeki
had met opposition Movement for Democratic Change
leader Morgan Tsvangirai
and his negotiating team in Pretoria on
Tuesday.
PRESSURE
A two-week deadline for completing the talks
runs out on August 4, but it
could be extended.
Mugabe and Tsvangirai
are under pressure from within Africa and the rest of
the world to negotiate
a national unity government to end a crisis that has
ruined Zimbabwe's
economy and flooded neighbouring states with millions of
refugees.
Central bank governor Gideon Gono said on Wednesday the
currency would be
redenominated by removing 10 zeros from August 1 in the
government's latest
bid to prop up the failing economy.
A loaf of
bread currently costs around 250 billion Zimbabwe dollars -- $4
using the
official bank rate and between $0.04 and $2 on the thriving black
market.
The highest denomination bill is 100 billion dollars.
Zimbabwe last
redenominated its currency in 2006, removing three zeros, but
this was
followed by sharp price increases.
John Robertson, an economic consultant
in Harare, said the latest
redenomination would not address the root causes
of the crisis in a
once-prosperous country suffering food shortages and
inflation at over 2
million percent a year.
"This is just to overcome
the absurd difficulty of having to deal with all
those zeros," Robertson
said.
It is unclear what compromise could be reached at the power-sharing
talks.
The MDC says only Tsvangirai can lead a new government because he
won a
first round presidential vote in March and only pulled out of a June
run-off
vote because of violence he says killed 122 of his
supporters.
ZANU-PF has said it will not accept any deal that fails to
recognise
Mugabe's re-election.
The parties also disagree over how
long a national unity government should
remain in power. The MDC wants new
elections held as soon as possible while
Mugabe, who has ruled since 1980,
wants to carry on with his new five-year
mandate.
Monsters and Critics
Jul 30, 2008, 14:29 GMT
Harare - Zimbabwean President
Robert Mugabe downplayed the suspension of
talks between his party and the
opposition on a unity government, echoing
South African President Mbeki in
assuring the negotiations were going
'well.'
'We are still
negotiating and want success... Some areas are debatable but
we debate. It
is not easy but I hear they are proceeding well,' Mugabe told
a press
conference at the Reserve Bank in Harare.
'Speaking for Zanu-PF (his
party) and myself we are committed and want to
see the speedy and successful
conclusion of the talks so that we can focus
on the turnaround of our
economy,' Mugabe said.
Mugabe was speaking ahead of a meeting with Mbeki,
who travelled to Harare
to try to revive the stalled talks between Zanu-PF
and the Movement for
Democratic Change (MDC).
On Tuesday Mbeki met
with MDC leader Morgan Tsvangirai in Pretoria to
discuss the abrupt
suspension of the talks on Monday.
MDC sources said the talks reached an
impasse on the issue of who should
lead the next government.
The MDC,
backed by Western powers, is calling for Tsvangirai to have the
leading
role, given that he and his party took the most votes in multi-party
March
elections.
Zanu-PF says Mugabe should lead after he won the second round
of voting for
president in June without a contest. Tsvangirai boycotted the
vote after
dozens of his supporters were killed by Mugabe
loyalists.
Negotiators from Zanu-PF allegedly called for time to consult
with Mugabe
after the MDC rubbished their offer to make Tsvangirai a third
vice-president under Mugabe.
Mbeki said Tuesday the talks would
resume by the weekend, but a source in a
smaller MDC faction led by Arthur
Mutambara, whom Mbeki was also due to meet
Wednesday in Harare, said the
talks would only resume next Monday after a
week's hiatus. Mbeki also said
the talks were 'doing very well.'
Meanwhile, in a reflection of
Zimbabwe's ever-worsening economic crisis
Reserve Bank governor Gideon Gono
announced he was stripping ten zeroes off
the battered Zimbabwe
dollar.
The current 10 billion Zimbabwe dollar notes would be replaced by
new one
dollar notes on August 1, he said.
Mugabe used the occasion
of the announcement to warn business against
overcharging.
'Don't
drive us further than you have done in the past. We'll impose
emergency
measures. but we don't want to place our country under emergency
rule, which
can be tough,' Mugabe warned.
Zimbabwe is crippled by hyperinflation of
several million per cent that has
seen the Zimbabwe dollar hurtle from 1 US
to 5,300 Zimbabwean at the
beginning of the year to as as much as 800
billion Zimbabwean dollars for a
single greenback in the past few
days.
Mugabe has accused business of profiteering by jacking up prices
but
business owners say they are just trying to keep their heads above
water.
Most observers say the crisis began in earnest when 84-year-old
Mugabe, who
has ruled Zimbabwe since independence in 1980, gave the nod to
ruling party
members and cronies to begin seizing white-owned farms in
2000.
Gono agreed the lasting solution to inflation was to increase
output,
particularly agricultural output.
'We've not done enough
since we started our agricultural reform,' Gono said,
referring to the
seizure of thousands of white-owned farms by ruling party
members and
cronies since 2000.
The seizures decimated commercial farming, once the
country's economic
mainstay.
VOA
By Delia Robertson
Johannesburg
30 July
2008
South African President Thabo Mbeki met in Zimbabwe with
President Robert
Mugabe to discuss the stalled negotiations aimed at ending
the country's
political crisis. He says the talks are to resume Sunday.
VOA's Delia
Robertson reports from our southern Africa bureau in
Johannesburg.
Following his meeting with Mr. Mugabe, the South African
president repeated
his earlier assurances that negotiations between
Zimbabwe's political
parties are going well. On Tuesday he said the talks
were merely adjourned.
"They will be adjourning shortly for a couple of
days because they want to
go back Harare to go and consult with their
principals about the work that
has been, and then come back by the end of
the week to resume the
negotiations," President Mbeki said. "But they are
proceeding."
President Mbeki is evidently more concerned about progress
in the talks than
he concedes in public. Before flying to Harare, he met in
Pretoria with the
MDC's Morgan Tsvangirai.
The talks stalled earlier
this week after Mr. Mugabe's ZANU-PF negotiating
team offered Tsvangirai a
vice presidency in a proposed government of
national unity. It was rejected
by the MDC leader. Mr. Mugabe already has
two vice presidents who are merely
figureheads without any executive
authority.
Speaking earlier at a
monetary policy meeting in Harare, the Zimbabwean
leader said he is
committed to achieving a negotiated outcome to the
country's
crisis.
"We committed ourselves to a process of dialogue under the
facilitation of
President [of South Africa, Thabo] Mbeki, whom I expect
today anyway," he
said. "There is total commitment on the part of government
and ZANU-PF and I
hope there is similar total, there is similar commitment
on the part of the
other parties."
But analysts have warned that
Mr.Mugabe is determined to hang on to
executive power.
Tsvangirai
believes that he should head a transitional unity government
because he got
most of the votes in the preliminary presidential race in
May. His majority
in that poll was not enough to avoid a runoff.
Experts have warned that
in addition to convincing Mr. Mugabe of the need
for compromise, Mr. Mbeki
will have to find a way of drawing in the security
forces, particularly the
Joint Operations Command, widely believe to be the
real power in Zimbabwe.
The Joint Operations Command is run by a senior
party official, the various
military commanders, the chiefs of police and
prisons, and the country's
senior intelligence official.
http://www.sokwanele.com/thisiszimbabwe/archives/1366
This blogger
listened to the radio today in amazement.
Part one aired on the radio
this morning was a brief monetary statement from
Gono - a digestible 20
minutes. Part two was a long, boring, dragged out
drone from Robert
Mugabe.
"Food Security: the Answer to Disinflation" - this grand
statement is the
title for Gono's mid-term budget.
Gono started, with
his normal salutations to the representatives of
government, journalists and
diplomats. He even had the grace to thank
representatives of both formations
of the MDC when he said to them,
"Welcome, this is how it should be". But he
showed his true sycophantic
colours with his demand that a special round of
applause be awarded to
Mugabe, the special guest, whom he admitted is under
extreme pressure.
Gono went on to emphasise that the future of the
economy is dependent on
political stability. Predictably, he laid the blame
of the country's
economic woes on sanctions, the tired and worn excuse
dredged up by those in
power at every possible opportunity to absolve
themselves of any
responsibility. He ended with the hackneyed warning that
those in the
international community, our enemies, are keen to see Zimbabwe
fail.
Finally Gono got to the meat of the budget.
Cash
Limits
Gono lamented the voices that have accused him of manipulating
cash limits,
and he cannot understand the criticism. He levelled blame for
the shortages
squarely on the shoulders of the German paper suppliers, with
their 'illegal
refusal' to supply paper already paid for, but he is happy
with the
solutions they have come up with.
The Governor made a
puerile attempt at humour when he claimed that he too
has lost zeroes, for
he is now being called Gideon gn, not Gono, and his
family are gn 1, gn 2,
gn 3, gn 4 and gn 5.
Lets hope he will soon be Gone - oh.
Finally
he got to what we have all been waiting for - the great zero slash.
This has
been made critical as banking systems are unable to cope with the
number of
zeros required. (ZSE collapsed last Friday for that very reason)
Z$10
billion will now be valued as Z$1.
A new currency is also to be launched
from the above date, so no more bearer
or agri-cheques (which are easy to
counterfeit) will be accepted from
December 2008.
New currency
Old cheque value
$500 5 trillion
$100 1 trillion
$20
200 billion
$10 note and coin 100 billion
$5 note and coin 50
billion
$2 note and coin 20 billion
$1 note and coin 10
billion
50c 5 billion
20c 2 billion
10c 1
billion
The biggest laugh is for those people who did not throw out the
erstwhile
useless coinage from long ago, which Gono stated was never
demonetised and
will now be back in circulation as legal tender. Gono
mentioned specifically
people who either threw away these coins or gave them
to domestic workers.
Dual Pricing
All retailers will be required
to display prices in old and new values until
December.
Cash
Withdrawals
The maximum has been extended to $200 (ie $200 trillion) and
he quipped that
the only limit will be how much one has in the
bank.
Export Promotion Growth
As of 1st August up front market
disposal is set at 35-45% and export
retention has been reduced to 55%.
FCA's have been extended from 21 to 30
days (ie companies have to dispose of
any funds in their Foreign Currency
Accounts within 30 days or forfeit the
sum to Reserve Bank). In layman's
terms this means that exporters will only
be allowed to retain 55% instead
of the previous 65% of their forex
reserves, and the balance has to be
"given" to the reserve bank for their
use at the interbank rate, which is
now at about 70% of street
rate.
This move will NOT be welcomed by the few exporters left in the
country as
they are having money taken away from them once
again.
Financial Sector
There has been an increase in minimum
capital requirement to between 10
million to 12,5 million depending on the
type of financial institution you
are.
Inflation
Gono clearly
stated that the only cure is increased productivity, especially
in
agriculture. He is mobilising inputs by using the Bakosi framework to
distribute implements, fertiliser etc. On Monday they gave the fertiliser
industry $3 million and they foresee a huge increase in
productivity.
Social Contract
The government will have to continue
to control prices but Gono says that
the Bakosi system will ensure that all
are taken care of. Unfortunately the
Bakosi shops will have to rely on
imports but will not favour them. The
launch of a mechanisation programme
will apparently ensure that by 2010,
70 - 80 % of farmers will have access
to equipment.
Gono ended his presentation with some philosophising of the
choices
Zimbabweans can make: to take the road to success or the road to
victimhood.
He once again placed huge significance on unity, within civil
society and in
government, but said Zimbabwe faced the maximum dangers from
the
international community. He recalled the spirit of liberation, that we
are
"our own liberators", that we need to show our detractors who want to
see us
fail that we can choose the right way.
Finally Gono "committed
to God's hands" the monetary statement.
This entry was written by
Still Here on Wednesday, July 30th, 2008 at 2:11
pm
http://www.zimonline.co.za/Article.aspx?ArticleId=3487
by
Wayne Mafaro Wednesday 30 July 2008
HARARE - Zimbabwean
President Robert Mugabe on Wednesday warned that his
government might have
to declare a state of emergency in order to contain an
economic crisis that
has seen prices rise on a daily basis while inflation
has shot to 2.2
million percent, the highest in the world.
Mugabe, who has in the past
accused the mainly white-controlled business
sector of colluding with his
Western enemies and hiking prices in order to
incite civil revolt against
his government, warned business to be
"disciplined and charge affordable
prices" or face a state of emergency.
He said: "The time has come for us
to be disciplined and to charge prices
that are affordable. Do not drive us
further than you have done in the past.
"We will impose emergency
measures under a state of emergency. We do not
want to place our country
under a state of emergency where we will tell you
what price to charge and
nothing else. In a state of emergency rules can be
tough and we have to say
take care. We might have to do that, so please take
care."
Mugabe
said he was committed to power-sharing talks with the opposition
Movement
for Democratic Change (MDC) party aimed at resolving his country's
crisis.
But he accused Britain and America of meddling in Zimbabwe's affairs
and of
trying to mislead the United Nations into imposing sanctions against
the
southern African country.
He said: "They (US and British governments) are
dishonest, hypocritical . .
. they never tell the truth and lie openly about
our situation. They wanted
to invoke UN Chapter 7 which applies to countries
which are a threat to
world peace. Are we a threat to world
peace?"
Mugabe was speaking in Harare after Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe
(RBZ) governor
Gideon Gono announced that he would on August 1 introduce new
currency as
well slash 10 zeroes on bearer cheques.
Bearer cheques
are promissory notes first introduced by the RBZ at the
height of cash
shortages in 2003. They function the same as actual money.
Gono said:
"With effect from 1 August 2008, all monetary valuations have
been
re-denominated by a factor of 1:10 000 000 000 which effectively means
the
removal of ten (10) zeros from all monetary values. What this means is
that
$10 000 000 000 (ten billion dollars, therefore will translate to $1
(one
revalued dollar) with effect from 1 August, 2008.
"With effect from 1
August, 2008, the RBZ is issuing new currency, in the
following new revalued
denominations: $500 note, $100 note, 25 coin, $20
note, $10 note and coin,
$5 note and coin."
The new currency will eventually replace bearer
cheques, which Gono said
would be taken out of circulation by
December.
Zimbabwe, which was once a model African economy is in the grip
of an
unprecedented recession that in addition to hyperinflation is also
dramatised by shortages of food, rising unemployment and
poverty.
Western governments and the opposition MDC party blame Mugabe,
who has ruled
Zimbabwe since independence from Britain in 1980, for ruining
the economy
through repression and wrong policies such as his farm seizures
that have
led to food shortages mainly due to failure by new black farmers
to maintain
production on former white farms.
Poor performance in the
mainstay agricultural sector has also had far
reaching consequences as
hundreds of thousands have lost jobs while the
manufacturing sector, starved
of inputs from the farming sector, is
operating below 30 percent
capacity.
Mugabe denies ruining the economy and instead says his
country's problems
are because of sanctions and sabotage by Britain and its
Western allies
opposed to his land reforms. - ZimOnline.
IOL
July 30 2008 at
09:37AM
By Peta Thornycroft
Peter Choto's take-home
pay after nearly 10 years of service in the
Zimbabwe National Army is R200 a
month.
He stays in the army only because any job is better than
none, with
more than 2-million percent inflation, and prices doubling
several times a
week.
He and three-quarters of his colleagues
will not go to war for
President Robert Mugabe, because they are "tired of
him", and "want change".
Choto was paid on July 16 directly into
his building society account,
but for the second month got no pay
slip.
The army has an arrangement with banks allowing troops to
draw a
trillion dollars a day while the public can only pull a hundred
billion, not
enough for a loaf of bread if there is any.
Choto's previous salary, for June, was 120-billion Zimbabwe dollars,
and
before the elections lower ranks were paid twice a month.
Tall,
skin stretched tight across high cheekbones, he says he has been
hungry for
"at least a year".
His wife, who lives in his tribal home about
80km south of his
barracks, has a duplicate building society withdrawal
card. "She needs it
all to survive."
A private in the army
earns R165 a month as of last Friday.
"On a good day breakfast is
black tea. There is never milk and sugar.
On a bad day we go to parade with
nothing.
"Three years ago we got porridge, sausage, bacon sometimes
eggs. We
always got meat at least once a day.
"At lunch and at
dinner we get a small plate of sadza (cooked maize
meal) and cabbage. There
is no cooking oil in the food.
"So when we are talking about food
we say 011 equals lunch and supper,
but not breakfast. 001 means no
breakfast, no lunch, but supper. The number
000 means nothing all
day."
The first election on March 29 was won by the opposition
Movement for
Democratic Change, and its leader Morgan Tsvangirai beat
President Robert
Mugabe, but with not enough votes to avoid a
run-off.
"We had meat twice before the first election, and we got
some strange
meat another day. There was nothing on the plastic (wrapping),
so we think
it was Chinese geese because it wasn't chicken, but it was a
bird, and it
was another colour. Maybe it was a penguin?
"There
are 500 recruits at the cantonment. If the world saw pictures
of them, the
world would be shocked, as they are so thin.
"At least 100 report
sick every day.
"They are passing out next week and they haven't
been to the rifle
range even once, because that ammo is being reserved for
emergencies, in
case MDC wins, or the British come to fight. They believe
there is going to
be trouble.
"We will not shoot our people. At
least three-quarters of us would not
take up arms for Zimbabwe. We will not
go to war for Zimbabwe, I am not
going to take a risk with a rifle for
Zimbabwe. That time is gone.
"Our boots are Chinese plastic. I
borrow friends' boots when they are
away, because Chinese boots only last a
few days on patrol before they are
in ribbons.
"I have only one
camo uniform (camouflage) and wear it for the week.
There are no berets, so
we have a camo cap.
"We have to provide our own soap.
"I cannot go home because I cannot afford the transport. There is a
television at the mess, but there is never power so there is nothing to do,
nothing."
Before the March 29 election he was on duty far from
his base, and no
postal votes were provided, so he did not vote. "It was
peaceful.
"On April 5 we were back at the barracks ... the
(presidential)
results were not yet out."
But the parliamentary
results were, and three-quarters of the
brigade - now half the size it was
three years ago - had voted for MDC in
the simultaneous parliamentary
election.
Justice minister Patrick Chinamasa, who lost his
parliamentary seat,
went to campaign for Mugabe in the cantonment ahead of
the second round of
the presidential poll on June 27.
The
brigade commanding officer, who cannot be named for fear of
identifying the
soldier telling his story, pledged his men would vote for
Mugabe in the
run-off.
The soldiers were deployed into the large dry Buhera
district, about
240km south of Harare, which had turned out strongly for MDC
on March 29.
Corporal Choto and his colleagues concentrated around
the business
centre and in two townships, Murabinda and Mukombo, and 120 of
them lived in
six small rooms for the next six weeks.
"Our job
was to support the militia and Zanu PF youth, intimidate the
MDC people and
do a lot of beating.
"I was deployed to intelligence, in plain
clothes, so I didn't have to
do the beating myself, but I saw
it.
"You have to do the beating or you are labelled MDC. Then you
will
just be discharged and sent to prison.
"We took the ID
(identity discs) of people so they couldn't vote. We
only got a few minutes'
notice before we went on every operation, so we
couldn't warn
people.
"One night the dog section went to this MDC's man's house.
They broke
his windows, and the person came out and he was bitten all
over.
"There was this woman in her 60s or 70s. She died after
beating. My
friend came back and confessed and was shaking.
"We
spoke and we said this was not the way it should, be as we were
supposed to
be protecting, not making people suffer.
"The colonel was there.
The youth and the green bombers were paid much
more than us.
"It was Zanu-PF people provoking MDC. Sometime the MDC reacted, but
not
much. They arrested this (MDC) MP (Eric) Matinenga, and they accused him
of
giving MDC people money to do violence. It wasn't true, it was us doing
the
violence.
"Now I am on rest and recuperation from Buhera. I am
tired now. I will
leave the army next year. Most are leaving, or going Awol,
or dying. Many
are dying.'
He said ZNA colonels and above had
been given Japanese 4 x 4
double-cabs ahead of the elections.
He suspected their salaries were large enough to convert to foreign
currency
on the streets, as the Zimbabwe dollar becomes increasingly
irrelevant.
Choto said he had admired Zanu-PF and Mugabe during
the 1980s and
'90s, and respected the struggle against minority white
rule.
The MDC has the names of 80 percent of perpetrators of the
violence
which followed the first round of elections. - Independent Foreign
Service
This article was originally published on page 15 of The
Star on July
30, 2008
http://zimbabwemetro.com/politics/zanu-pf-afraid-of-an-mdc-government-in-exile/
By Raymond Mhaka ⋅ © zimbabwemetro.com ⋅ July
30, 2008 ⋅
The ruling ZANU PF party has expressed fears that Morgan
Tsvangirai might
form a government in exile. Tsvangirai left Zimbabwe on
Monday together with
his entire National Executive Council including Vice
President,Thokozani
Khuphe.
Under normal circumstances when
Tsvangirai travels abroad Khuphe remains
acting president and the pair are
never outside the country together.
Mugabe’s spokesman George
Charamba did not hide the regime’s fears that
Tsvangirai could form a
government.
“Now that Tsvangirai has a new passport he will have to
resist the tempting
idea of leaving the country to launch a
government-in-exile, which for the
British is a precursor to insurgency
here, and more forays into the Security
Council. Charamba wrote in the
government mouth piece The Herald.
He warned,’It will be a ruinous route
to follow, one which would bring
personal grief to Tsvangirai. After Monday,
his best chances are with
President Mugabe”
Talks stalled yesterday
and were adjourned and South Africa president Thabo
Mbeki tried to portray
the adjournment as a minor interruption.
The unplanned adjournment on
Monday forced Mugabe negotiators Justice
Minister Patrick Chinamasa and
Social Welfare Minister Nicholas Goche to
abruptly fly back to Harare to
consult with the president Mugabe.
As the talks were going on in Tshwane
ZANU-PF last week declared it will not
accept a deal that fails to recognize
Mugabe’s reelection in the June 27
runoff election – which was widely
condemned as fraudulent – or seeks to
reverse the land reform program. These
conditions, agreed at a ZANU-PF
politburo meeting last Wednesday further
dimmed prospects for a deal,
analysts say.
Meanwhile Britain’s deputy
UN ambassador warned Tuesday that the UN Security
Council will have to take
up the Zimbabwe crisis again if ongoing talks fail
to resolve it.
“We
wish these (South African) efforts well,” Karen Pierce told reporters.
“But
it is clear that if we don’t make progress soon or don’t see progress
soon
in Zimbabwe, the Council will need to come back to this
issue.”
Governments in exile are formed by political parties that claim
to be a
country’s legitimate government, but for various reasons are unable
to
exercise their legal power, and instead reside in a foreign country.
Governments in exile usually operate under the assumption that they will one
day return to their native country and regain power.
The MDC
president Morgan Tsvangiari won the presidential election on March
29 and
his party won control of parliament.
This report draws upon 3320 formal interviews with victims of human rights
abuses over the last three months. This figure represents a fraction of those
directly affected by violence, the majority of whom are likely to have failed to
access appropriate medical assistance. Download and read the report here.
nasdaq
HARARE, Zimbabwe (AFP)--Zimbabwe's opposition Movement
for Democratic Change
Wednesday said two more of its activists were killed
by suspected ruling
party militias since a July 21 agreement signed in
Harare allowing
power-sharing talks to begin.
"The deaths show that
there is no sincerity on the part of ZANU-PF. The
death of the two brings to
122 the number of MDC activists who have been
murdered since the March 29
harmonized elections," the MDC said in a
statement.
The body of an
activist abducted from her home on July 23 was discovered in
a maize field
Saturday.
"A report was made about the murder to the police but no
arrests have been
made," spokesman Tapiwa Mashakada said.
He said a
policeman died in a private hospital in the capital Harare
Saturday after
being attacked at a rural homestead, where he had gone to
visit his mother,
a known MDC activist.
"The MDC has asked ZANU-PF to show its sincerity to
the dialog process by
stopping violence, disbanding all militia bases and
prosecuting all
perpetrators of political violence."
MDC leader
Morgan Tsvangirai and President Robert Mugabe agreed to begin the
talks
aimed at ending the country's political crisis at a landmark meeting
on July
21.
Click here to go to Dow Jones NewsPlus, a web front page of today's
most
important business and market news, analysis and commentary: http://
www.djnewsplus.com/al?rnd=RpBLwY2%2BwBMpPkHqa4Duuw%3D%3D.
You can use this
link on the day this article is published and the following
day.
(END) Dow Jones Newswires
07-30-081238ET
http://www.thezimbabwean.co.uk/
Wednesday, 30 July 2008 16:40
Approximately
300 WOZA members marched through the streets of central
Bulawayo this
afternoon.
The aim of the march was to draw the attention of
preoccupied
politicians to people's needs, namely bread and butter issues;
or as WOZA
likes to put it, bread and roses issues - bread representing food
and roses
representing the need for lasting dignity. No arrests have been
reported at
the time of this release although police were seen to respond
after the
demonstrators dispersed showing intention to arrest
participants.
The protest also sought to test the Memorandum of
Understanding (MoU)
recently signed by Zimbabwe's politicians to determine
whether freedoms of
expression and assembly truly have opened up. The MoU
stated that there
would be freedom of political activity and security of
persons and
prevention of violence. It further followed that there would be
statements
calling for an end to violence but Zimbabweans have yet to see
this in word
and deed.
The representative group of women and
men marched to the offices of
the Chronicle, the state-owned newspaper. As
the peaceful activists marched,
they distributed a newsletter detailing
their demands. By completing the
march without incident, WOZA members have
finally laid to rest the ghost of
the International Women's Day protest on
8th March 2008 where over 50
members received medical attention for the
brutal beating they received from
riot police when attempting to reach the
Chronicle offices.
As they marched the members sang an Ndebele song
with the words: "we
are going to Pretoria - even if they arrest us or beat
us and even if they
have not invited us." Signifying the need for
representation at the
negotiation table to ensure a lasting solution to the
crisis in the country
or else the only other option left to Zimbabweans is
going the unofficial
way - by border jumping as political or economic
refugees. These are the
bottom line choices for the
negotiators.
Today's march is also the first protest conducted by
WOZA after the
28th May demonstration in Harare that resulted in 14 members
being
incarcerated in remand prison for several weeks.
WOZA
intend to organise more protests over the next few weeks to press
for civic
representatives to be involved in the talks and to continue to
'test' the
politician's commitment to a non-violent solution.
Ends
For more information, please contact either Jenni Williams on +263 912
898
110, Magodonga Mahlangu on +263 912 362 668 or Annie Sibanda on +263 912
898
112.
Excerpts from the Memorandum of Understanding between the
Zimbabwe
African National Union (Patriotic Front) and the two Movements for
Democratic Change formations - 21 July 2008
Interim measures -
Security of persons
(a) Each Party will issue a statement condemning
the promotion and use
of violence and call for peace in the country and
shall take all measures
necessary to ensure that the structures and
institutions it controls are not
engaged in the perpetration of
violence.
(b) The Parties are committed to ensuring that the law is
applied
fairly and justly to all persons irrespective of political
affiliation.
(c) The Parties will take all necessary measures to
eliminate all
forms of political violence, including by non-state actors,
and to ensure
the security of persons and property.
(d) The Parties
agree that, in the interim, they will work together to
ensure the safety of
any displaced persons and their safe return home and
that humanitarian and
social welfare organisations are enabled to render
such assistance as might
be required.
Excerpts from Freedom in a fortnight? A view from the
trenches 23 July
2008
We therefore demand that:
· The
Africa Union and SADC have provided a reference group to the
mediation team
and it is our view that the political parties also need an
on-the-ground
reference group made up of civic society representatives who
can provide
input and receive feedback.
· The status of the second SADC team
dealing with the economy is
clarified and their recommendations be made
public so Zimbabweans can know
what is to be done about the crashing
economy.
· The United Nations is allowed to come in to assess
humanitarian
needs and set up structures to address these
urgently.
We would want an engendered transitional authority to
have the
following mandate during their eighteen-month term of
office:
a. Stop the political violence. Depoliticise the police, army
and
other defence forces. Any political violence must be reported,
investigated
and prosecuted through the courts without any form of favour or
political
influence.
b. Dialogue with the business and professional
community to develop
policy designed to bring about economic
recovery.
c. Supervise the addressing of the humanitarian crisis
together with
the United Nations.
d. Even constitution making has
become the sole preserve of
politicians. It was the constitutional
referendum in 2000 that intensified
political violence with catastrophic
results and therefore we need an
independent person to oversee the
consultative process. A transitional
authority must neutralise this position
and return constitution making back
to the people of Zimbabwe.
e.
Depoliticise the issue of land reform, conduct a land audit and
consult on a
fair and equitable land reform programme. If the economy is to
be
stabilised, we need our land to be made productive fast.
f. Form a body
to consult and develop a transitional justice plan of
action designed to
bring healing and reconciliation and then deal with
justice and restitution
for victims in the new Zimbabwe.
g. Bring about a truly independent
electoral commission to oversee
first a referendum on the new constitution
and then a truly free and fair
election process and a peaceful transition to
the winner.
Thousands of WOZA members have been arrested for
exercising their
freedoms of expression and assembly. Some were even denied
bail and
imprisoned for marching to the Zambian Embassy to deliver a
petition to the
SADC chair, Zambian president Levy Mwanawasa. They remain
undaunted by this
repression and fully intend to continue to peacefully
march for bread and
roses, placards held high until their messages are taken
seriously at the
negotiation table and in the corridors of power. Of course
if they had civic
representatives at the table, their voice would be better
heard than from
the streets.
Woza Moya!
http://www.thisislondon.co.uk/news/article-23523693-details/article.do?ito=newsnow& It is without doubt the largest cheque ever seen. But it’s worth little more
than the paper it’s written on. The astronomical sum of one quadrillion, seventy-two trillion, four hundred
and eighteen billion and three million dollars only – note the only – was drawn
on the MBCA Bank in Zimbabwe, part of one of the largest banking groups in
Africa. Enlarge The biggest cheque ever?: The amount is incomprehensible
It was paid by Kasawe Estates, a property company, and was emailed to the
Daily Mail by a group of former Rhodesian expatriats who are horrified at
Zimbabwe’s incredible rate of inflation – officially 2.2 million per cent,
but, British experts say, closer to 12.5 million per cent. Currency dealers said the plunging value of Zimbabwe dollars made it almost
impossible to estimate its value, but some thought it would have been worth no
more than a few pounds yesterday -- and certainly even less today. The incredible cheque, which is believed to be a payment as part of a
property deal, was revealed as the Zimbabwe central bank decided to reduce the
huge sums that hard-pressed citizens have to deal with by simply knocking 10
zeros off the end. Enlarge Desperate measures: The new Zimbabwean one dollar note That means that from Friday, when new bank notes are printed, 10 billion old
Zimbabwean dollars become a single dollar. The desperate move was taken by bank governor Gideon Gono because the
nation’s computers, calculators and ATMs faced meltdown because they can’t
handle all the zeros involved when bread and staple foods cost billions and
trillions of dollars. The move came a week after Dr Gono introduced a 100 billion-dollar note which
is now not enough to buy a loaf of bread. But analysts said the move would do nothing to end an economic disaster
blamed on President Robert Mugabe's land-grab policies which have caused chronic
shortages of food and foreign currency. The Guinness Book of Records says the greatest amount in real money paid by
a single cheque in the history of banking was £2,474,655,000 (two billion four
hundred and seventy four million, six hundred and fifty-five thousand pounds).
It was issued in March 1995 as part of a share deal between Glaxo and the
Wellcome Trust. "The Zimbabwe dollar will be redenominated by a factor of one to 10, which
means we are removing 10 zeros from our monetary value. Ten billion (Zimbabwean)
dollars today will be reduced to one dollar with effective from August 1," Gono
said in a television broadcast. Fault: Robert Mugabe in Harare today. Analysts have blamed
the hyperinflation on his economic policies "The new currency will co-circulate together with the family of bearer
cheques ... which shall cease to be legal tender on the 31st of December 2008,"
Gono said. Prices are rocketing on a daily basis as ordinary Zimbabweans struggle to
survive. Gono in mid-2006 removed three zeros from the local dollar to make life
easier for shoppers forced to carry huge piles of cash to make even the simplest
purchases, but the move was followed by sharp price rises. The government this month started distributing subsidised basic goods and
quietly hiked salaries for its workers to an average 2 trillion Zimbabwean
dollars, worth £17 dollars on the official market and as low as £1.50 on the
parallel market. The salary is enough to pay for 10 trips to work at today's fares or buy
eight loaves of bread. Mugabe accuses businesses of unfairly increasing prices as part of a wider
plot to incite people against his government and today warned companies that
authorities would impose emergency measures if they continued profiteering. Gono raised the daily cash withdrawal limit from 100 billion Zimbabwean
dollars to 2 trillion Zimbabwean dollars, which analysts said was still far
short of individual daily cash requirements. "This (re-denomination) is just to overcome the absurd difficulty of having
to deal with all those zeros but it does not address the root cause of the
problem," John Robertson, an economic consultant, said. "The problem is of scarcity of foreign earnings and investment inflows. I
would like to see the government remove its 51 per cent empowerment requirement
on all new investments." Mugabe early this year signed into law a bill giving local owners majority
control of foreign-owned firms, including mines and banks.
Businesses justify price hikes as the only measure to avert
collapse.
http://www.newzimbabwe.com/pages/markets28.18554.html
By Lance Mambondiani
Last
updated: 07/31/2008 13:57:14
THE Zimbabwean financial market is not for the
fainthearted. It is often
said if you can do business in Zimbabwe, you can
do business anywhere in the
world.
Frequent policy shifts render
business forecasting useless. On Wednesday,
July 30, 2008, the Reserve Bank
introduced a number of currency reforms
intended to stabilise the Zimbabwe
dollar and deal with perennial cash
shortages due to an inordinate number of
zeros in the payment system.
Gideon Gono, the governor of the central
bank said: "The Zimbabwe dollar
will be redenominated by a factor of one to
10, which means we are removing
ten zeros from our monetary value. Ten
billion Zimbabwe dollars today will
be reduced to one dollar effective 1
August."
Although this move has been highly anticipated within business
circles, it
is the number of zeros removed which seems to grab all the
headlines. Whilst
reflecting the deep economic problems, Zimbabwe may again
have scored a
world first in its latest currency surgery. There are few, if
any, cases of
a country slashing ten zeros from a currency as a currency
measure.
The crippling cash crisis in the country had made the slashing
of zeros
inevitable. Long queues have become a permanent feature in
commercial banks;
the RTGS payment system has been overloaded, with delays
of up to a week in
the processing of payments.
There are numerous
explanations for the cash crisis, from the bank
conspiracy theory to the
monetary policy mismanagement theory. In basic
terms, the persistent cash
crisis reflects the problem with a
hyperinflationary environment where
economic agents demand more money for
transactionary purposes. The cash
crisis also reflects the extent of the
Zimbabwean economy's
informalisation.
With most of the commodities available on the black
market, consumers would
prefer to keep their money out of the banking system
in case they find
scarce commodities where they need to pay for them in
cash. Reports suggest
that 90 percent of all economic activity is
consummated in the black market.
It's not difficult to see how this can be
the case.
The other explanation for the cash crisis is a general loss of
confidence in
the financial sector; negative real interest rates have meant
that investors
have no incentive to put their money in the formal banking
sector, as there
are no viable investment options.
The artificial
withdrawal limits, previously set at Z$100 billion per day
have also
attracted widespread criticism. That amount is only sufficient to
buy a box
of matches. A loaf of bread now costs Z$200 billion whilst
transport to and
from work costs around Z$150 billion on average.
Recent reports suggest
that the Zimbabwe Congress of Trade Union (ZCTU) had
threatened unspecified
action against the Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe (RBZ) if
the central bank did
not raise the daily cash withdrawal limit from banks.
Whilst the low cash
withdrawal limits were put in place to curb speculative
activities, such
ridiculously low withdrawal limits are equal to state
sponsored theft and
threaten the very survival of the banking sector. There
is no economic
justification for members of the public putting money in the
banking system
if they are not able to withdraw it.
Zimbabwe has not had a proper
currency for sometime. Unless inflation is
curbed, there is no economic
logic in thinking of introducing one in the
near future. Hyperinflation
makes the replacement value of a new currency
extremely prohibitive. The
central bank's plans to introduce a new currency
last year were shelved
after the strategy proved unsustainable.
Whilst base transactions suggest
that transactions are edging towards
dollarisation, the central bank is
caught between a rock and a hard place.
The inflation war seems more like an
unwinnable battle, much like fighting
against the insurgents in
Iraq.
The payment system and the computing system of banks was now unable
to
handle the number of digits required for accounting purposes threatening
transaction processing with total collapse. Reprogramming the computer
systems to expand the size of fields required for the zeros would have
required significant expenditure of foreign currency, which the country
doesn't have.
The introduction of higher denominated currencies or
the slashing of zeros
is dependent on the printing of new notes which has
also become temporarily
impossible due to the paper shortages.
The
slashing of zeros or the intermittent increase in withdrawal limits
cannot
be the solution to solving the cash crisis. A long-lasting solution
has to
be found in the stabilisation of the economy through reducing
inflation and
the re-establishment of positive real interest rates.
The governor of the
central bank is an interview with New Zimbabwe.com also
highlighted the
urgent need to resolve the political impasse for any
meaningful economic
regeneration to take place. Given that the amount of
money held for
transactions and precautionary purposes depends, among
others, on the
movements in prices, the current hyperinflation environment
will soon render
the new and higher cash withdrawal limit inadequate.
At the rate at which
inflation is galloping even an adjustment of the
withdrawal limits every
month is unlikely to keep up with demand. The
hyperinflationary environment
coupled with low nominal investment rates has
caused serious negative real
investment rates. These negative returns on
investment have significantly
reduced banking habit as the resultant
reduction in the opportunity cost of
holding cash has given rise to
significant speculative activities worsening
the inflation situation through
an increase in asset price inflation. Such
financial dis-intermediation
debilitates monetary policy effectiveness of
banks in the central payment
system.
TO ACCESS OUR ARCHIVED REPORTS
VISIT
http://www.coronationfinancial.com
Previous
attempts to rescue Zimbabwe's stratospheric inflation have failed.
In 2006,
the central bank slashed three zeros from the currency when
inflation then
only stood at a few hundred percent. Inflation is now at 2,2
million percent
although independent analysts put it at well over 5 million
percent.
The recent currency reforms will certainly bring temporary
relief to people
in Zimbabwe. And if the power-sharing talks in Pretoria
were to be
successful, it may be the shock therapy that the country
needs.
However, like the slashing of zeros in 2006, if unsupported by
meaningful
economic change, this latest move may well be just that - a
fixation with
zeros with no real consequence.
Lance Mambondiani is an
Investment Executive at Coronation Financial Plc, an
International Financial
Advisory company registered in the UK trading in
Southern Africa and the
United Kingdom. He can be contacted at
coronation.uk@btinternet.com.
Please contact us should you wish to subscribe
to our mailing list. You can
also contact the Coronation team on; Business
lines +44 161 346 9559 or
mobile +44 790 3293 227.
_____________________
The foregoing has been
prepared solely for information purposes only based
on independent research
by Coronation, no representation or warranty;
express or implied is made to
its accuracy or completeness. Coronation
therefore accepts no liability for
any loss arising, whether direct or
indirect, caused by the use of any part
of the information provided. To
discuss any of these investment options in
detail please contact Coronation
Advisory © 2008 Reg No. 06342947
SW
Radio Africa (London)
30 July 2008
Posted to the web 30 July
2008
Lance Guma
Serving policeman Kingsley Muteta died at the
Avenues Clinic on Saturday,
after a mob of 12 Zanu PF youths attacked him at
his parents homestead in
Mudzi. The mob accused Muteta who worked in Harare,
of visiting his mother,
despite him knowing she was a prominent MDC activist
in the area.
A statement from the MDC said a badly beaten Muteta was
admitted at Kotwa
Hospital in Mudzi before being transferred to Harare where
he later died
from his injuries.
Meanwhile the body of Fungisai
Ziome, an MDC activist abducted from her home
on July 23, was discovered in
a maize field Saturday in Glendale, Mazoe. She
was an active member of the
party in Glendale's Ward 13 in Mashonaland
Central province. The MDC say her
body was burnt and showed signs of
mutilation. Passersby in the area
realized a body had been dumped and made a
report to the police. So far no
arrests have been made and the family awaits
a post-mortem before burial
arrangements can be made.
The news once again highlights the lack of
sincerity on the part of Zanu PF,
despite ongoing talks with the MDC in
South Africa. 'The MDC has asked Zanu
PF to show its sincerity to the
dialogue process by stopping violence,
disbanding all militia bases and
prosecuting all perpetrators of political
violence,' the party said in a
statement. Analysts however criticized the
opposition for engaging in the
talks before ZANU PF had dismantled its
structures of violence. Reports that
ZANU PF were dismantling militia bases
have turned out to be nothing but a
PR stunt. Small bases are being closed
but militants are being transferred
to bigger bases, known as District
Command Centres.
On Tuesday we
reported how 17 MDC activists, badly beaten by ZANU PF militia
in Buhera
South, remain marooned in the area with army Colonel Morgan
Mzilikazi still
blocking their transportation to hospital. The MDC have made
several
attempts to get them out but each time the rescue teams are harassed
and
threatened. The local MP for Buhera South, Naison Nemadziva, remains
holed
up in Mutare fearing for his safety. The picture is the same
countrywide
with ZANU PF maintaining at least one big militia base in every
constituency. These are being used to launch intermittent attacks on
suspected opposition supporters.
By Alex Bell
30
July 2008
Political game playing continued on Wednesday as the state of
the crucial
talks between ZANU-PF and MDC remained unknown - this as it
emerged that an
emergency SADC summit has been called to discuss the
Zimbabwe crisis.
The ongoing speculation surrounding the state of the
negotiations has been
further fuelled by conflicting reports about the fate
of Theresa Makone,
leader of the MDC Women's league. New Zimbabwe.com
reported on Tuesday night
that Makoni had been "trapped and exposed as a
mole feeding information
about proceedings at the crucial talks to the
media". The report came after
Monday's breaking news story that the talks
had broken down - a story that
was blamed on a false media leak on Makone's
part. The website also reported
that she had been sent back to Harare while
the talks continued. The MDC
however on Wednesday denied the reports,
dismissing them as "completely
false".
Party negotiators flew back to
Zimbabwe on Tuesday, while Tsvangirai flew to
South Africa shortly after the
reports, but South African President Thabo
Mbeki, who is continuing his role
as SADC appointed mediator in the talks,
denied that the negotiations had
broken down and insisted things were going
well. However, despite this
insistence Mbeki reportedly rushed to meet with
Morgan Tsvangerai in South
Africa on Tuesday before flying last minute into
Zimbabwe on Wednesday to
meet with the other key role players, Robert Mugabe
and Arthur
Mutambara.
The South African President's rush to meet the party leaders
was described
on Wednesday as a "make or break" move for the talks that are
at a critical
stage. At the same time as Mbeki reported that the inter-party
negotiations
were "going well" and had merely been adjourned, an emergency
SADC summit
meeting has been called to discuss the Zimbabwe situation, in
light of the
talks. At the same time, Britain's deputy ambassador to the
United Nations
warned on Tuesday that the United Nations Security Council
will have to take
up the Zimbabwe crisis again if ongoing South
African-mediated talks fail to
resolve it.
Meanwhile, the Zimbabwe
National Students Union has added it's voice to the
growing chorus of groups
criticising the state of the talks. The Union's
President, Clever Bere, told
Newsreel on Wednesday that it was unacceptable
for "political playing" while
the fate of the Zimbabwean nation hangs in the
balance. He added that people
"must be informed, but not through
speculation" and called on the parties
to be more transparent during the
crucial talks. Bere added that only a
transitional government with Morgan
Tsvangerai at its head would be
accepted, because it will be a result that
"respects the vote of the people
as reflected in the March elections".
The talks are set to resume in
South Africa on Sunday.
SW Radio Africa Zimbabwe news
http://www.thezimbabwean.co.uk/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=14435:south-africa-net-beneficiary-of-zimbabwe-crisis&catid=31:top%20zimbabwe%20stories&Itemid=66
Wednesday,
30 July 2008 11:25
It is difficult for any one to appreciate the position so firmly
held by
Mbeki and equally so firmly despised by his critics. We have been
investigating his undeclared reasons for his controversial stance on
Zimbabwe, while at the same time clinging to an untenable mediation
role.
The first authoritative statement of the underlying motive for
insisting on
being the sole mediator of the Zimbabwe political impasse was
his outburst
that Zimbabwe was not a province of South Africa. What
President Mbeki meant
was that he was going to ensure that by the time he is
through with his
mediation, Zimbabwe would be a de facto economic province
of South Africa.
He has succeeded in doing so well ahead of his departure as
the South
African President. Here is the Thabo Mbeki Agenda for
Zimbabwe.
Firstly, after 7 or so years of on-and-off mediation, his
'quiet diplomacy'
has yielded bankable benefits. Over 70% of Zimbabwean
groceries are now
imported from South Africa. A nation that used to boast of
ability to feed
her people and others in parts of Southern Africa, now
depends on South
Africa for almost three-quarters of its processed
groceries- worth hundreds
of millions of US dollars.
Secondly, the
main supermarket-chains in Zimbabwe have been reduced to mere
retail shops-
operating at one-tenth capacity. The only supermarkets that
are fully
stocked are South-African-controlled. They, alone, can afford to
source the
cheapest commodities from South Africa and offload to the
Zimbabwean outlets
at ridiculously inflated prices. Thousands of workers
have been retrenched
or sent on compulsory leave. The country had been
'supermarketized' to a
very dangerous extent. Beggars and rich Zimbabweans
were all buying from the
supermarkets. Now the public has nowhere to turn
to- except of course, the
elusive black market. The losers are not just the
public. The Zimbabwe
Revenue Authority is suffering silently.
It is only now that the Central
Bank-led Peoples' shops are being
introduced- 40 years after Kamuzu Banda
introduced them in Malawi and over
40 years since Julius Nyerere introduced
the idea in Tanzania (without much
success) and 30 years after Samora Machel
had done the same thing in
Mozambique. It is not a novel idea developed by
Governor Gono! What is new
is the fact that unlike socialist Tanzania and
Mozambique and Banda's
kleptocracy, neither the Zimbabwe Government nor
Governor Gono has any
control over the means of production or the labour or
the distribution. He
hopes to create a communist model in capitalist
Zimbabwe. If it had been
done in 1980 it might very well have worked. Good
luck Governor!
Why was it not done in 1980? Quite simply because the new
post-independence
government found a working system that ensured
maximum-almost punitive,
taxation in place, courtesy of the Smith regime.
For that very reason he
postponed 'total empowerment' of the poor
Zimbabweans through land
re-distribution. In due course, he forgot the poor
landless Zimbabweans
altogether! That is, until the masses themselves
invaded the white-owned
farms in 2000. Talk of a revolutionary bereft of any
revolutionary soul! He
alone postponed the realization of the cardinal aim
of the bush war: the
land issue! And for 20 years! Longer than the period of
the liberation
struggle itself. And some people mistakenly or blindly still
call him a
liberator of Zimbabwe! In a true socialist state he would have
been shot as
a counter-revolutionary-a traitor to the forward march of the
revolution.
Surely, a winning General who commands his soldiers to retreat
and let the
enemy pillage and plunder Zimbabwean resources for a further
twenty years
(1980-2000) deserves no less a punishment!
Anyway, I
digress. I am bitter- very bitter!
To return to the Mbeki Agenda: he has
succeeded in the recruitment of cheap
but skilled manpower. He now has
properly qualified black doctors, teachers,
nurses, engineers, insurers,
bankers, managers, plumbers, joiners-all the
artisans that South Africa so
badly needs. All manner of blue-collar
personnel lacunae have been filled
thanks to the meltdown in neighbouring
Zimbabwe. The migration has been so
intense that ordinary South Africans
have felt it and expressed their anger
and grief through the recent
disturbances in South Africa. I choose not to
call it xenophobia. Over ten
thousand white professionals have left South
Africa since the end of
apartheid in 1994. Tens of thousands Zimbabwean
professionals have entered
as replacements. I am aware that other foreigners
also work in South Africa,
especially Nigerians, Kenyans,
Ghanaians.
Mbeki has calculated well. He knows that South Africa can
absorb thousands
of useful foreigners without feeling the pinch, because
their toil and
labour far outweigh the cost to the nation. When the time
comes, the South
African government will simply terminate the contracts of
those that are
superfluous and ship them back home. But- and this is the
point I want you
to get- they will have helped in capacity building for
South Africa in the
interim! They will have provided training and education
for South Africans.
They will have helped with the construction of the
stadiums for the 2010
World Cup. This stop-gap measure has been a Mbeki
priority all along. He saw
the opportunity and grabbed it. That is why he
growls at the mention of an
additional mediator!
Then there is the
hot issue of tourism. For some reason, Zimbabwe believes
that it is the
paradise of Africa in tourism terms, dwarfing all other
countries in
Southern Africa. That myth is one that Mbeki set out to
destroy. He has
largely succeeded in selling the idea that Victoria Falls is
part of South
Africa's tourist menu. Thanks to aggressive South African
marketing,
Victoria Falls is just one of the Southern Africa's prime
destinations- best
organized from Johannesburg, South Africa. That is the
best way to do
Victoria Falls. In the confusion Hwange has lost its appeal.
In any case,
the Limpopo Trans-frontier National Park has plenty of animals.
As for
Kariba, well, Mozambique (and its pristine beaches) is open for
business!
Check it out. If you want to know how serious the South Africans
are, just
check the Botswana side of the Zambezi River!
We keep hearing that
Zimbabwe was a breadbasket of Southern Africa- some say
(erroneously) even
of Africa. However, that was the time when South Africa
was at war; Namibia
was at war; Angola was at war and Mozambique was at war.
Zambia was then a
casualty of all those wars. Simba Makoni believes that it
still can be the
breadbasket of Africa. By what miracle he does not say. Be
reminded that it
is not a question of land per se. Zambia and DR Congo have
by far richer
soils! Zimbabwe soil is of little value without extensive use
of
fertilizers. By sub-dividing all the land, Zimbabwe has lost an
opportunity
to develop large-scale farms that could rival USA corn, cotton,
peanut and
other farms. There is enough land for all Zimbabweans' needs but
not enough
for their greed! Mbeki and the ANC know that. They would rather
you destroy
yours now, so that they can convince their people otherwise in
the future.
South Africa has no wish to go the Zimbabwe route. It is not
only thorny and
pot-holed; it is a cul de sac.
People tend to forget that Mbeki lived
in Zimbabwe for sometime- long enough
to know how Zimbabweans feel about his
countrymen. The general feeling is
that South Africa cannot survive without
Zimbabwe; that it is the
Zimbabweans who provide the top brass of South
Africa's business and other
sectors, both public and private because they
are better educated. Well,
Mbeki believes otherwise and he wants to put to
shame all those inclined to
contradict him. Mugabe thinks he is using
Mbeki. Mbeki knows that he is
using Mugabe!
How do I know that I am
right? Ask Jacob Zuma. The moment it was explained
to him, Zuma understood
and stopped pushing Mbeki over the top! Remember,
Zuma is a patriot and a
freedom fighter. If the policy is good for the
country, why not give it
tacit support-at least?
Lastly, South Africa wants to exert its
influence over Southern, Central
and Eastern Africa. It wants to flex its
economic muscle all over. Until
recently, only Mauritius, Zimbabwe and Kenya
stood in her way. With Zimbabwe
out of the way, South Africa can concentrate
on any challenge from Kenya and
Mauritius.
It is not that Thabo Mbeki
has little love for Zimbabwe. Rather, it is
precisely because he loves and
envies Zimbabwe that he would like it
wrestled out of the jaws of
unpatriotic ZANU-PF politicians who cannot
appreciate how horrific it is to
bring a beautiful country like Zimbabwe to
ruin. He seriously wants to make
it a province of South Africa and Robert
Mugabe is either unwittingly, or
out of sheer ignorance, obliging. That is
why I believe Mbeki cannot mediate
in good faith!
Institute for War and Peace Reporting (IWPR)
Date: 29 Jul
2008
Critics fear
talks will hand the opposition a slice of power without
achieving radical
change
By Mike Nyoni in Harare (ZCR No. 157, 29-Jul-08)
After the
euphoria which accompanied last week's agreement by Zimbabwe's
parties to
discuss a peaceful end to the political crisis, some analysts are
warning
that the negotiating process may be less productive than is hoped.
Some
fear that President Robert Mugabe - re-elected on June 27 in a
controversial
run-off ballot from which his opponent Morgan Tsvangirai
pulled out - will
try to manipulate the talks process to achieve cosmetic
improvements while
remaining firmly in control, and suggest the opposition
may be complicit in
this process.
Others note that the talks agenda contains little new, as
much of it has
already been agreed in earlier negotiations between ZANU-PF
and the
opposition Movement for Democratic Change, MDC.
The
memorandum of understanding, MoU, was signed on July 21 by President
Mugabe,
MDC leader Tsvangirai and Arthur Mutambara, who heads a minority
faction of
the MDC, under the watchful eye of the chief mediator, South
African
president Thabo Mbeki.
The document committed the opposing political
forces to a dialogue resulting
in 'a viable, permanent and sustainable
solution' to Zimbabwe's problems.
After the signing, Tsvangirai declared
that failure to find a solution to
the crisis was 'not an
option'.
However, Lovemore Madhuku, chairman of the National
Constitutional Assembly,
a non-government group which has lobbied for a new
constitution, warned that
the negotiations currently under way in Pretoria
might not amount to much.
The agenda for the talks, and the fact that
negotiators were given just two
weeks to achieve a deal, suggests to Madhuku
that it will be hard to 'come
up with anything sustainable, let alone
permanent'.
Madhuku argues that the MoU gets things wrong from the start
since its first
item - 'the objectives and priorities of a new government' -
makes too many
assumptions, when in fact the composition of such an interim
administration
is crucial and likely to be hotly contested.
'The
underlying assumption is that a government of national unity already
exists,
and Mugabe sees himself as head of that government,' said Madhuku.
'His task
is straightforward - to sort out the economic and political crisis
and
secure the lifting of sanctions.'
Madhuku believes Mugabe sees himself
presiding over the drafting of the new
constitution mentioned in the MoU
agenda.
'It is impossible to come up with a new constitution in a space
of two weeks
and any constitution they [the negotiators] come up with which
is not
subjected to a popular referendum will not be acceptable to the
people of
Zimbabwe,' he insisted.
The leading historian Professor
Terence Ranger argues that there is no basis
for negotiations as Mugabe is
not amenable to compromise.
'There is nothing to be gained by calling for
a government of national unity
in Zimbabwe when Mugabe makes it clear that
it can only come into existence
on his terms,' he wrote in an article for
The East African.
One important provision in the MoU comes in section 9,
which says that as
long as the talks are going on, neither side can make
unilateral decisions
that have a bearing on the agenda - for example
convening parliament or
forming a government.
Madhuku believes this
was included at the MDC's insistence, reflecting its
'deep fears and
anxieties. that Mugabe might proceed to swear in parliament
and appoint a
new cabinet without it'.
He suspects the MDC is out to secure a share of
power for itself, and notes
that there is talk of Tsvangirai becoming
vice-president.
He warns that while such manoeuvring is 'typical of
politicians', the MDC
may end up settling for something that falls far short
of the comprehensive
change people have been hoping for.
'To me this
is a sham process designed to defraud the people of Zimbabwe
through a
fraudulent political settlement,' he said.
Madhuku and a group of other
civil society leaders are unhappy that the
talks are taking place in such a
narrow format, involving only the main
political parties, and that they are
subject to a media blackout. They have
been demanding that the negotiating
process be broadened to include
non-government groups, women's
organisations, churches and others. On July
15, they issued a demand that
any transitional administration should be
headed by neither Mugabe nor
Tsvangirai, but by a neutral figure.
Not everyone is so pessimistic about
the process. Eldred Masunungure, who
lectures in politics at the University
of Zimbabwe, argues that the MoU
'layed a solid foundation' for a lasting
peace.
He does not see the two-week deadline as a major problem. 'Most of
the
issues in the MoU have already been agreed on during previous talks,'
said
Masunungure, referring to talks that took place between ZANU-PF and MDC
in
the months leading up to the March elections.
A senior official in
Mutambara's faction of the MDC, who did not want to be
named, said it was
immaterial what form the proposed new government took as
long as it resolved
Zimbabwe's problems.
'You can call it a government of national unity or a
transitional authority,'
he said. 'What is needed urgently is to get us out
of this hole, by whatever
means.'
Mike Nyoni is the pseudonym of a
reporter in Zimbabwe.
Institute for War and Peace Reporting
Zimbabwe's independent media say it is in no one's interests for
crucial
talks to take place out of the public eye.
By Jabu Shoko in
Harare (ZCR No. 157, 30-Jul-08)
Journalists in Zimbabwe are seething with
anger at a blanket ban on
negotiators talking to the media while talks are
under way between President
Robert Mugabe's ZANU-PF and the opposition
Movement for Democratic Change,
MDC.
The talks, scheduled to last a
fortnight, opened in Pretoria, South Africa
on July 24, but the memorandum
of understanding signed three days earlier
made it clear the dialogue was to
remain confidential.
Clause 8 of the document says specifically states
that as long as the talks
are going on, neither side should "directly or
indirectly communicate the
substance of the discussion" to the media, nor
should they use the media as
a negotiating platform.
Media
representatives who spoke to IWPR complained that this provision was
tantamount to stifling freedom of expression, as well as denying Zimbabweans
the right to information about a process that could decide their
future.
Iden Wetherell, chairman of the Zimbabwe National Editors' Forum,
said
denying reporters access to information about the talks was "unhealthy
and
unacceptable".
"There should be intense debate in the media
around the issues contained on
the MoU," he said. "The MoU has been made
public, so as editors we believe
it should be debated in public. There
should be frequent briefings on what
is going on behind closed doors. The
public have a right to comment on it
and on other issues."
Wetherell
said the editors' forum believed reporters should not be shut out,
especially since the agenda for the talks suggested that a new government
look at media as a priority issue. Current legislation covering media and
communications is restrictive so any change will be a matter of interest to
journalists themselves.
"The media has legitimate concerns, for
instance the tough media laws and
the issue of the public media, which has a
duty to inform the nation but
abuses it. Currently the public media parrots
only the voice of the
incumbent," he said.
Foster Dongozi, secretary
general of the Zimbabwe Union of Journalists, ZUJ,
agreed, saying, "The
media is being denied access to information. It is
totally unacceptable. We
will not be able to know what they are plotting
about our future as
journalists and the media."
During negotiations late last year, the MDC
and ZANU-PF agreed amendments
slightly softening the Access to Information
and Protection of Privacy Act -
a tough law used to restrict media rights
since 2001. But as Dongozi said,
there was no consultation with media
stakeholders when the parties agreed
this deal.
In the current round
of talks, he said, "We need to know what's going on,
especially if there are
discussions on media law reform."
In 2003, the information and privacy
law was used to close down the popular
Daily News and its sister paper The
Daily News on Sunday, The Tribune and
The Weekly Times.
The closure
of these newspapers dealt a severe blow to the MDC, which is
covered
unfavourably in the state-owned newspapers and the public Zimbabwe
Broadcasting Corporation. The Broadcasting Services Act has allowed
government to perpetuate the monopoly enjoyed by ZBC, an institution the
opposition accuses of naked bias.
Loughty Dube, who heads the
Zimbabwe chapter of the Media Institute of
Southern Africa, a regional
watchdog, welcomed the signing of the MoU but
insisted that negotiators
should ensure the "transitional process" enjoyed
public
confidence.
"This can only be achieved in an environment that immediately
allows
citizens to enjoy their fundamental right to freedom of expression,
association, assembly, access to information and media freedom," said
Dube.
Citing the need to end harassment, arrest and assaults against
journalists,
to repeal repressive laws and to allow unrestricted reporting
in Zimbabwe,
Dube said media freedom must in future be enshrined in a new
constitution.
Despite attempts to starve them of infomation, journalists
working for
independent media in Zimbabwe look set to continue reporting on
the talks
process as best they can.
"The parties to the negotiations
want to turn journalists and the media into
fiction writers," said Nelson
Chenga, a journalist with the privately owned
Financial Gazette "Naturally
we will speculate due to the gravity of the
talks, which is a historic event
that holds the key to the Zimbabwe crisis."
According to Wetherall,
"Nothing should be hidden from the public. The media
have a duty to inform
the population of what is happening behind those
closed doors in
Pretoria.
Attempting to silence the media, he said, would merely
encourage
"disinformation, half-truths and speculation, which is not very
helpful at
all".
Jabu Shoko is the pseudonym of a reporter in
Zimbabwe.
http://zimbabwemetro.com/featured/august-could-produce-a-government-that-cares-about-the-poor/
By Eddie Cross ⋅ ©
zimbabwemetro.com ⋅ July 30, 2008 ⋅
I take the fact that the MDC has not
walked out of the talks in South Africa
as a very positive sign. They must
be making progress and despite the
propaganda put out by both the SABC and
the Zanu PF in recent days, I think
this progress is towards a transitional
government that will be led by the
MDC. Another feature of this situation
that people are not picking up on, is
that for the first time the AU and the
SADC have guaranteed the
implementation of the agreements reached in the
talks.
We will have to wait for the final outcome - no one is talking
about what is
going on behind closed doors and that might be a good thing,
providing the
final outcome is acceptable to the rest of us after all our
sacrifice and
pain.
While focus is on the talks (and rightly so) we
must not lose sight of what
is going on here at home. After 4 months the
local government councils are
being sworn into office and as I write, the
MDC has taken over the
administration of all urban councils in the country.
Since 60 per cent of
the population lives in the urban areas, this means
that the majority of the
people now live under an MDC controlled
administration.
We still have to contend with Chombo who continues to
pretend he is the
Minister and in charge. He was defeated in the elections
on the 29th March
and holds his portfolio only because the Zanu PF
leadership has tried to
hold onto power for as long as possible - illegally.
At best he is a
caretaker administrator waiting for a new Minister to be
appointed in the
talks. Most probably the new Minister will come from the
MDC.
We also control a significant number of the Rural District Councils
and in
all hold 700 of these posts throughout the country. Where Zanu PF
controls
the councils in the rural areas they will soon discover that they
are under
new management from a central government point of
view.
This is a very significant shift in power and gives the MDC its
first real
chance to start to make a difference in peoples lives. We are
taking the
first steps to make that a reality and our Secretary for Local
Government is
about to go full time with a small staff to start coordinating
what the
councils will be doing. Local government in many ways, is almost
more
important to peoples lives than central government. It is the local
authority that delivers water, effluent and waste management, housing,
electricity and roads. It is the local authority that manages primary health
care and educational and social amenities.
The MDC is a Party of the
poor - I am sure I have often stated that. So many
urban areas find
themselves with councilors who are drawn from street
vendors, blue-collar
workers and even the unemployed. In my district I have
two councilors - one
a retired lady with very sparse resources and no
transport and the other a
vendor also with few resources. They are, however
both excellent
individuals, with integrity and a real commitment to their
communities and I
am looking forward to working with them.
We have huge challengers - many
urban centers are short of water, roads are
in an appalling state, mass
transit systems non-functional, effluent systems
broken down and a threat to
public health. 40 per cent of the urban
population is not properly housed;
we have a backlog of a million housing
units let alone any future growth in
demand. Staff are demoralized,
financial systems have broken down, assets
looted and there are many
political appointees who are not going to welcome
the new administration.
But at least we can now start to tackle these
issues and do something about
them. Once the transitional government is in
place (in August?) then we can
really start to do things - especially if the
new arrangements reflect the
March elections and are accepted by the
international community as having
some legitimacy.
In anticipation of
a new day dawning, we are now working on how to mobilize
the collective
energies of our much-diminished community to start to make
things happen.
What I would like to say to every Zimbabwean - at home or
abroad, get
involved.
This morning I went to a local picnic site - Hillside Dams.
There a group of
local businessmen plus a motley collection of volunteers
are cleaning them
up - they have been given a lease over 45 hectares and are
building a
restaurant, picnic sites and cleaning up the gardens and the
amenities such
as toilets. The roads and paths are being repaired. When I
left there were
many cars in the parking area, hundreds of kids and adults
playing in open
areas and many braai fires going with a smell of wors and
steak.
If you are outside the country - adopt a councilor and support him
or her
with funds to run a small office and meet their expenses. Small sums
of
money can make a huge impact in this area and is critical to making
democracy work for the people and to improve their lives.
A group of
businessmen are right now forming a Trust to mobilize the whole
business
community behind community development and the strengthening of the
democracy we are building. Making democratic practice work for everyone -
creating servant leaders who will be honest and accountable. They are
identifying projects - small and large, that can be tackled by the public
and the private sector to their mutual benefit. One group in Bulawayo is
doing a joint venture with the City to manage and recycle
wastewater.
We have a country to rebuild - not had a chance to do
anything up to now
because of the crazy politics and the imbecilic
economics. This is both an
exciting and a challenging task. The
international community will help us
get back on our feet and after that it
is up to us - we are a rich country
made poor by bad leadership. That must
never happen again.
Democracy and development are the key to this.
Democracy to hold leadership
accountable to the people they serve and
development to lift everyone out of
the cycle of poverty and deprivation
that has been our lot for too long.
Eddie Cross is the MDC Member of
Assembly elect for Bulawayo South,and the
MDC Policy Coordinator he writes
in his personal capacity.
http://www.newzimbabwe.com/pages/mbeki115.18553.html
By Lebo Nkatazo
Last
updated: 07/31/2008 13:02:17
SOUTH African President Thabo Mbeki was expected
in Harare on Wednesday for
final discussions with President Robert Mugabe
over a power-sharing deal
with the opposition which could be signed as early
as next week.
Mbeki, who is mediating an end to a decade-long political
crisis, met
opposition Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) leader Morgan
Tsvangirai in
Pretoria on Tuesday, his spokesman added.
In Harare,
Mbeki will also meet Arthur Mutambara, leader of a faction of the
MDC.
Mutambara confirmed to New Zimbabwe.com on Wednesday that he would be
meeting Mbeki. He denied reports that the talks were deadlocked, saying
"tremendous progress had been made".
Three teams of negotiators from
the three main parties who have been meeting
in Pretoria, South Africa,
since Thursday last week have withdrawn to brief
their principals and will
be reconvening on Sunday.
Dumisani Muleya, the news editor of the
Zimbabwe Independent newspaper said
by telephone from Harare that the
negotiators had "agreed on most of the
things" and Mbeki would be clearing
"a few minor hurdles".
"President Mbeki wants to clear up a few things,
mainly on positions and
powers, before a final agreement is signed. The
negotiators have agreed on
most of the things that were up for discussion
and Mbeki's trip should be
seen as a clincher. The outstanding issues are
definitely not
insurmountable. they should be easily resolved," said Muleya,
also the
Zimbabwe correspondent for South Africa's Business Day
newspaper.
President Mbeki said Tuesday that the talks were progressing
well,
notwithstanding reports that the negotiators were
deadlocked.
Mbeki told reporters: "The negotiators are negotiating. As
you know they
have been meeting here now for a number of days and they are
continuing to
do that. They are doing very well."
And in Harare, MDC
spokesman Tapiwa Mashakada quashed speculation that the
talks were
deadlocked.
"Negotiators have taken a break. It is just an ordinary
recess," said
Mashakada.
He said claims that the talks had broken
down were "not true", adding:
"Negotiators just took a break and they would
further be consulting their
principals during the break.
"Parties to
the negotiations agreed at the signing of the MoU that
negotiators would
need to brief their parties after a few days of talks."
On Friday,
President Mbeki will brief an emergency gathering of the Southern
African
Development Community (SADC) organ on politics, defence and security
in
Angola on the progress made so far in the talks.
http://www.thezimbabwean.co.uk/
Wednesday, 30 July 2008 10:38
JOHANNESBURG, --The Congress of South
African Trade Unions (COSATU) is
confident that the talks between ZANU (PF)
and MDC will bear fruit.
The organisation, which is one of the
fiercest critics of the Robert
Mugabe government, called on the warring
parties to commit themselves to the
talks and work together with Southern
African development Community and
African union to find a lasting solution
to the crisis in that country.
Talks between ZANU (PF) and the two
factions of the MDC are currently
taking place in South Africa following the
signing of a memorandum of
understanding by the party leaders in Harare
recently.
"We are confident that the people of Zimbabwe are best
placed in
resolving their challenges. In this regard, we further call upon
both the
MDC and ZANU-PF to respect the institutions and processes of the AU
and SADC
and work with African leaders to find a lasting solution," said
COSATU.
Zimbabwe is experiencing its worst political crisis
following the June
27 re-election of Mugabe as president after a
widely-condemned presidential
runoff election that was marred by violence.
MDC leader Morgan Tsvangirayi,
winner of the first round of elections,
pulled out of the elections.
The economic landscape is not rosy
either with inflation reaching
seven-digit figures--CAJ News
MUTARE, 30 July 2008 (IRIN) - Dereck Gurupira,
50, was bathing in the river near his home in Zimbabwe's Manicaland Province
late one afternoon when he saw a woman on the opposite bank begin to undress,
apparently oblivious of his presence.
Photo:
Julius Mwelu/IRIN
Food
scams
Usually the women in Manicaland's
Odzi district, about 55km northwest of the border town of Mutare, wash
downstream in a more secluded part of the river, but after undressing completely
the woman greeted him by name and then suggested to Gurupira that he should join
her.
He went and sat near her as she bathed in the river and was taken
by surprise when a man wielding an axe emerged from the bush and accused
Gurupira of having a sexual relationship with his wife. The matter was taken to
the traditional court, where Gurupira was fined two cows and a goat for the
"illicit relationship", to which the woman even confessed.
"I was a fool
to fall into the trap. The shameless husband used his wife as bait to extort the
livestock from me, and even though I hardly knew the woman, many people now
think I had a love affair with her," Gurupira told IRIN.
Having to
forfeit the cattle means that he will not have enough draught power to prepare
his land for the agricultural season beginning in September, although he may
find solace in the fact that he is not the only person to have fallen for the
scam.
Imbayago Chikuni, a messenger for one of the local headmen, told
IRIN that the number of cases brought before the traditional courts by husbands
alleging infidelity by their wives was increasing.
Cases of
alleged infidelity rising
"In the past, I used to bring at most
one case of infidelity a year to my headman's court, but I am now dealing with
several such trials a month. It is difficult to tell between a genuine case and
a staged one because, in all cases, the women are found in compromising
positions by their husbands or the husbands' relatives," Chikuni said.
Those being targeted are villagers
considered to have means, and while the river was one location often used for
the ruse, women were also frequenting shebeens [informal taverns] to lure
unsuspecting men into their schemes, he said.
In the past, I used to bring at
most one case of infidelity a year to my headman's court, but I am now dealing
with several such trials a month. It is difficult to tell between genuine cases
and a staged one
Hunger was forcing people
"to use bizarre ways to get any form of foodstuffs or money" from "offending"
men. "In this part of the province we hardly harvested anything, since the rains
were erratic, there was no fertiliser and humanitarian aid is not forthcoming.
Those who can manage a full meal of sadza [thick maize-meal porridge] and boiled
vegetables a day are considered lucky," Chikuni said.
In June, the Food
and Agriculture Organisation (FAO) and the World Food Programme (WFP) said about
2 million Zimbabweans would be facing hunger before September, increasing to 3.8
million by the end of the year, and to 5.1 million by March 2009.
Zimbabwe's precarious food security was exacerbated by a government
order banning humanitarian organisations from operating, including those
supplementing food stocks in rural areas, on allegations of engaging in
political activity.
Most of the villagers in the district depend on
gathering wild fruits and roots for food, while others illegally pan for gold
and diamonds in the hope of supplementing their income.
Zimbabwe's hard
times, in which annual inflation is officially estimated at 2.2 million percent,
is also seeing daughters being married for dowries at very young ages.
In a bid to avert hunger, the parents of Yevai Dongo, 15, in the
Muzarabani district of Mashonaland Province, consented to their daughter
becoming the third wife of a 50-year-old local shop owner. Yevai's 17-year-old
sister ran away to Mozambique to avoid a similar fate.
In search
of dowries
The Dongo family now boasts six head of cattle,
whereas they had none before, and are given a constant supply of maize-meal by
their new son-in-law, who also gave them a cash "windfall" of one trillion
dollars (about US$8) when he married their daughter two months ago.
"True, my family is poor and
there are times when we went without food," Yevai told IRIN. "But I was still
going to school, and for my parents to sell me off like a commodity is unfair to
me because they used an old fashioned practice to solve the problem that we were
facing, while I will be confined to a home that I don't enjoy."
True, my family is poor and
there are times when we went without food. But I was still going to school, and
for my parents to sell me off like a commodity is unfair
She is
concerned that joining a polygamous family might expose her to HIV/AIDS, and
"most of the time when I am alone in bed, I seriously consider following my
sister, who refused to be imprisoned."
Yevai told IRIN that girls of her
age in the community were being forced by their parents to enter into love
relationships with older men, and then faking pregnancy so the men would be
compelled to marry them.
"Even when the men insist that they used a
condom, no-one listens to them and, again, that is not fair, because young girls
unwillingly lose their virginity and expose themselves to sexually transmitted
diseases," Yevai said.
Erich Bloch, a Bulawayo-based economic
consultant, said unusual methods were being employed to beat hunger because of
the "sheer desperation and the widening poverty cycle set off by the current
economic meltdown."
"When people are starving, when children cry all
night long because of hunger and parents have nothing to give them, you see an
acute decrease in moral standards," Bloch told IRIN.
[ENDS]
[This report does not necessarily reflect the views of the United
Nations]
http://english.ohmynews.com/articleview/article_view.asp?menu=f10600&no=383286&rel_no=1
Good governance the bedrock
upon which the environment can be better
managed
Masimba
Biriwasha
Published 2008-07-31 02:39 (KST)
Zimbabwe, which
currently faces seemingly intractable social, political and
economic
problems, has some of the worst environmental indicators in the
world with
ecosystems either in decline or under severe threat.
The country did
institute some good environmental protection programs in the
decade
following the attainment of independence from British rule in 1980.
During
that period, the government even went as far as adopting a radical
policy of
shooting poachers on sight in order to protect endangered animal
species.
In recent years, however, Zimbabwe has experienced
desertification, soil and
water pollution, and slash and burn agriculture,
resulting in soil erosion
mainly caused by an unplanned land resettlement
program initiated by
incumbent President Robert Mugabe's government in
2000.
Yale University's 2008 environmental performance index (EPI), which
ranks
149 countries according to a weighting of carbon and sulfur emissions,
water
purity and conservation practices, positions Zimbabwe at number 95,
thus
highlighting the grim state of the environment in the
country.
"Zimbabwe's air is polluted by vehicle and industrial emissions,
while water
pollution results from mining and the use of fertilizers.
Zimbabwe's cities
produce half a million tons of solid waste per year. The
nation has been
estimated to have the highest DDT concentrations in the
world in its
agricultural produce," states the Encyclopedia of the
Nations.
In Zimbabwe, as in many countries in sub Saharan Africa,
environmental
management tends to play second fiddle to social, political
and economic
imperatives that ultimately result in environment degradation.
In that
sense, Zimbabwe is a microcosm of environmental conditions
unraveling across
much of the continent.
Today, Zimbabwe is
experiencing high levels of poverty, disease, political
mismanagement and
other significant obstacles to development that make
regard for the
environment the least of priorities at both government and
societal
levels.
High levels of poverty, particularly in the rural areas, where
approximately
70 percent of the population lives, make deforestation and
wildlife poaching
a huge environmental challenge due to increased demand for
household fuel
wood and food.
The rampant cutting down of trees
for both fuel and agricultural purposes is
perhaps the biggest problem
because it negatively impacts the weather,
rivers, rain and soil
quality.
To make matters worse, climate change, with its disruption of
rainfall
patterns, has negatively affected subsistence agriculture, which is
the main
source of livelihood and food for 80 percent of the
population.
According to analysts, among the most serious of Zimbabwe's
environmental
problems is erosion of its agricultural lands, wildlife
poaching and
deforestation.
By 1992, deforestation was progressing at
the rate of 70,000-100,000
hectares per year, chewing up 1.5 percent of the
nation's forestland.
It is estimated that between 1990 and 2005, Zimbabwe
lost 21 percent of its
forest cover. The country has no primary forests
left, and deforestation
rates have increased by 16 percent since the end of
the 1990s.
In 2001, nine of the nation's mammal species and nine bird
species were
endangered, as well as 73 types of plants. Zimbabwe has about
half of the
world's population of black rhinoceroses, an endangered
species.
Despite this degradation, Zimbabwe has some 1,747 species of
trees among its
4,500 species of higher plants. The country is also home to
a number of
safari animals like elephants, lions and hippos. In total, 270
species of
mammals are found in Zimbabwe along with 180 reptiles and 661
birds.
As Zimbabwe seeks a way out of its political and economic morass,
it is
clear that solving the basic needs of the poor -- particularly food
security
and energy needs -- will play a key part to reduce problems such as
deforestation and land degradation. In Zimbabwe, as in many parts of Africa,
eradicating poverty is an indispensable condition to better environmental
management.
But good governance is the bedrock upon which poverty is
reduced and the
environment better managed.
Zimbabwe 's President, Robert Mugabe is a very very bad man. This we all know
from reading the newspapers or hearing the pronouncements of George W. Bush,
earlier Britain 's Tony Blair and more recently Gordon Brown. In their eyes he
has sinned badly. They charge that he is a dictator; that he has expropriated,
often with violence, the farms of whites as part of land reform; they claim he
rigged his re-election by vote fraud and violence; that he has ruined the
economy of Zimbabwe . Whether Robert Mugabe deserves to be in Washington 's honor roll of villains
alongside Fidel Castro, Saddam Hussein, Milosevic, Ahmadinejad, and Adolf
Hitler, however, it is not the reason Washington and London have made Zimbabwe
regime change priority number one for their Africa policy. What his sin is seems to have more to do with his attempts to get out from
under Anglo-American neo-colonial serfdom dependency and to pursue a national
economic development independent of the International Monetary Fund and World
Bank. His real sin seems to be the fact that he has turned to the one nation
that offers his government credits and soft loans for economic development with
no strings attached—The Peoples' Republic of China. Western media accounts conveniently tend to omit the second major party to
what is a huge tug of war between Anglo-American interests and China to get
control of Zimbabwe 's vast mineral wealth. We should keep in mind that for
Washington there are always “good dictators” and “bad dictators.” The difference
is whether the given dictator serves US national interests or not. Mugabe
clearly is in the latter category. Cecil Rhodes' legacy Zimbabwe is the name of what under the era of British
Imperialism a century ago was named Rhodesia . The name Rhodesia came from the
British imperial strategist and miner, Cecil Rhodes, founder of the Rhodes
scholarships to Oxford , and author of a plan for a vast private African zone,
to be chartered from the Queen of England, from Egypt to South Africa . Cecil
Rhodes created the British South Africa Company, modeled on the East India
Company, along with his partner, L. Starr Jameson of Jameson Raid notoriety, to
exploit the mineral riches of Rhodesia . It controlled what was later named
Northern Rhodesia ( Zambia ) and Southern Rhodesia-Nyasaland. The model was that
the British Government would assume all risks to militarily defend Rhodes '
looting while Rhodes and his London bankers, above all Lord Rothschild, who was
a close associate, would assume all the gains of the business. Rhodes, a seasoned geologist, knew well that there was a remarkable
geological fault running from the mouth of the Nile at the Gulf of Suez south
through Sudan , Uganda , Tanzania , down through today's Zimbabwe on to South
Africa . Rhodes had already instigated several wars to gain control of the
diamonds of Kimberly and the gold of Witwatersrand in South Africa . This
geological phenomenon he, as well as enterprising German explorers, had
discovered in the 1880's. They named it the Great Rift Valley . Rhodesia , like South Africa after the bloody Boer wars, was settled by white
settlers to secure future minerals gains for allied interests of the City of
London , mainly those of the powerful Oppenheimer family and their gold and
diamond enterprises in the region. In 1962 when Africa was undergoing the wave of national liberation from
colonial rule, a wave calculatedly supported by “non-colonial power” Washington,
Rhodesia was one of the last bastions, along with former British colony South
Africa, of white Apartheid rule. Whites in Rhodesia constituted only 1-2% of the
total population so their methods of holding on to power were rather ruthless.
White supremacist Prime Minister, Ian Smith, declared Rhodesian independence
from Britain in 1965 rather than agree to the slightest compromise on race or
power sharing with black nationalists. Britain got UN trade sanctions imposed to
force Smith to buckle under. Despite sanctions, there was considerable support
from conservative business interests in London . Britain 's Tiny Rowland, head
of the Lonrho mining conglomerate, secured the bulk of his African profits from
Rhodesian copper mining and related ventures under the Smith regime. The City of
London knew very well what riches lay in Rhodesia . The question was how to
secure enduring control. Smith's Rhodesian backers had little interest in giving
it all to London . Following a long and bloody struggle, in 1980 the leader of the black African
Popular Front coalition, Robert Mugabe, overwhelmingly won election as the first
Prime Minister of a new Zimbabwe . Twenty eight years later, the same Robert
Mugabe is under escalating attack from the West, especially Zimbabwe's former
colonial master, England, including strong economic sanctions designed to bring
the country to the brink of collapse, to force him to open the economy to
foreign (read Anglo-American and allied) investment. Ironically, the issue seems
not all that different from the Ian Smith era: London and US control of the
resources of the rich land, and Zimbabwean efforts to resist that control. The Great Dyke Within Zimbabwe, a portion of the rich Great Rift is called the Great Dyke,
an intrusive geological treasure zone running over 530 kilometers from the
northeast to the southwest of the country, in places up to 12 kilometers wide. A
river runs along the fault and the region is volcanically active. Here also lie
vast deposits of chromium, of copper, platinum and other metals. The US State Department, as well as London , is aware of the vast minerals
and other riches of Zimbabwe . It states in a recent report on Zimbabwe , “
Zimbabwe is endowed with rich mineral resources. Exports of
gold, asbestos, chrome, coal, platinum, nickel, and copper could lead to an
economic recovery one day...The country is richly endowed with coal-bed methane
gas that has yet to be exploited.
With international attractions such as Victoria Falls ,
the Great Zimbabwe stone ruins, Lake
Kariba , and extensive wildlife, tourism historically
has been a significant segment of the economy and contributor of foreign
exchange. The sector has contracted sharply since 1999, however, due to the
country's declining international image.(sic). Energy Resources With considerable hydroelectric power potential and plentiful coal
deposits for thermal power station, Zimbabwe is less dependent on oil as an
energy source than most other comparably industrialized countries, but it still
imports 40% of its electric power needs from surrounding countries--primarily
Mozambique. Only about 15% of Zimbabwe 's total energy consumption is accounted
for by oil, all of which is imported. Zimbabwe imports about 1.2 billion liters
of oil per year. Zimbabwe also has substantial coal reserves that are utilized
for power generation, and coal-bed methane deposits recently discovered in
Matabeleland province are greater than any known natural gas field in Southern
or Eastern Africa. In recent years, poor economic management and low foreign
currency reserves have led to serious fuel shortages." In short, chrome, copper, gold, platinum, huge hydroelectric power potential
and vast coal reserves are what is at stake for Washington and London in
Zimbabwe . The country also has unverified reserves of uranium, something in big
demand today for nuclear power generation. It is clear of late that so long as the tenacious Mugabe is running things,
not the Anglo-Americans, but rather the Chinese, are Zimbabwe 's preferred
business partners. This seems to be Mugabe's greatest sin. He's not reading from
the right program as George W. Bush's friends see it. His real sin seems to be
turning East not West for economic and investment help. The Chinese connection During the Cold War China recognized and supported Robert
Mugabe. In recent years as China 's search for secure raw materials escalated
its foreign diplomacy, relations have become stronger. According to the Chinese
media, China has invested more in Zimbabwe than any other nation. Already back in July 2005 as Tony Blair turned the sanctions screws tighter
on Zimbabwe , Mugabe flew to Beijing to meet with the top Chinese leadership,
where he reportedly sought an emergency loan of US$1 billion and asked increased
Chinese involvement in the economy. It began to bear fruit. In June 2006 state--owned Zimbabwean businesses
signed a number of energy, mining and farming deals worth billions of dollars
with Chinese companies. The largest was with China Machine-Building
International Corporation, for a $1,3bn contract to mine coal and build
thermal-power generators in Zimbabwe , to reduce Zimbabwe 's electricity
shortage. The Chinese company had already built thermal-power stations in
Nigeria and Sudan , and had been involved in mining projects in Gabon . In 2007 the Chinese government donated farm machinery worth $25 million to
Zimbabwe , including 424 tractors and 50 trucks, as part of a $58 million loan
to the Zimbabwean government. The Mugabe administration had previously seized
white-owned farms and gave them to blacks, damaging machinery in the process. In
return for the equipment and the loan the Zimbabwean government will ship 30
million kilograms of tobacco to the People's Republic of China . Other Zimbabwe-China agreements included a deal between the Zimbabwe Mining
Development and China 's Star Communications, forming a joint venture to mine
chrome, with funding from the China Development Bank. Zimbabwe also agreed to
import road-building, irrigation and farming equipment from the China National
Construction and Agricultural Machinery Import and Export Corporation and China
Poly Group. Zimbabwe also relies on China for imports of telecommunications
equipment, military hardware and many other critical items it can no longer
import from the west because of the British-led sanctions. Relations have become so important that Zimbabwe 's police have a dedicated “
China desk” to protect Chinese interests in the country. In April 2007 the chairman of China 's top political advisory body, Jia
Qinglin, head of the National Committee of the Chinese Peoples' Political
Consultative Conference, flew to Harare to meet with Mugabe. It was a follow-up
to the 2006 Beijing China-Africa Cooperation Summit where the Chinese government
invited the heads of more than 40 African states to discuss relations. Africa
has become a diplomatic and economic priority for China and its economy. At that time, Beijing got an open invitation to help develop dormant mines in
the country. The deputy speaker of Zimbabwe 's parliament called for more
Chinese investment in the country's mining sector, according to China 's Xinhua
news agency. Zimbabwe 's mining laws were changed to allow the government to
reallocate mining claims that were not being exploited. Mining generates half of Zimbabwe 's export revenue. It is the only sector in
the country that still has foreign investors after the collapse of the main
agricultural sector. Western companies with mining claims in Zimbabwe were not
exploiting them. "We would appeal to the Chinese government to come in full
force to exploit these minerals," Zimbabwean Deputy Parliamentary Speaker,
Kumbirai Kangai said to the official Xinhua. Kangai assured potential Chinese investors that they would not expose
themselves to legal action if they took over claims held by Western companies.
A few months after, in December 2007, Chinese company, Sinosteel Corporation,
acquired 67 percent stake in Zimbabwe 's leading ferrochrome producer and
exporter Zimasco Holdings. Zimasco Holdings is the fifth largest high carbonated
ferrochrome producer in the world. It used to produce 210,000 tons of
high-carbon ferrochrome per year, nearly all of it along the mineral-rich Great
Dyke, accounting for 4 percent of global ferrochrome production. Zimasco has also the world's second largest reserves of chrome, after South
Africa . It was formerly owned by Union Carbide Corporation, now part of Dow
Chemicals Corp. Oh, oh! Alarm bells went ringing in London and in Washington at that news.
China clearly views Africa as a central part of its strategic plan, most
notably for its oil reserves and vital raw materials such as copper, chrome,
nickel. The continent is also at the same time becoming an important region for
Chinese manufactured exports. But the raw materials battle is at the heart, and
the real reason by all accounts, why Washington recently decided to form a
separate Africa Command in the Pentagon. Controlling China 's economic emergence is an un-stated strategic priority of
United States foreign and military policy and has been since before September
11, 2001 . The only delicate point in the business is the fact that China, with
well over $1.7 trillions of foreign exchange reserves, most believed in form of
US Treasury securities, could trigger a complete dollar panic and further
collapse of the US economy should she decide for political reasons it were too
risky to continue holding its hundreds of billions of US dollar debt. In effect,
by buying US Government debt with its trade surpluses, China has been indirectly
financing US policies counter to Chinese national interest such as the Iraq war,
or even the $100 million or so annually that Condi Rice's State Department
spends on Tibet . China is refusing to play by the rules of the Anglo-American neo-colonial
game. It does not seek IMF or World Bank approval before dealing with African
countries. It makes soft loans, regardless who might be running the country. In
this it does nothing different from Washington or London . The Chinese see
American influence in Africa less entrenched than in the rest of the world, thus
offering unique opportunities for China to pursue its economic interests. It may or may not be cynical. It may be Realpolitik. If it results in the
ability of certain African countries to use China as a political counterweight
to the one-sided Anglo-American domination of the Continent, that itself could
be a major benefit to Africans depending on how they use it. Clearly, it has been extremely positive for Chinese access to vital economic
minerals for its economy as well as oil from places such as Darfur and southern
Sudan , or Nigeria . Mineral wealth has once more put Africa on center stage of a battle for
mineral riches between East and West. This time, unlike during the Cold War era,
however, Beijing is playing with far more assets, and Washington with far less.
By F. William Engdahl COPYRIGHT © 2008 F. William Engdahl. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED * F.
William Engdahl is the author of
A Century of War: Anglo-American Oil Politics and the New World Order
(Pluto Press) and Seeds of Destruction: The Hidden Agenda of
Genetic Manipulation , www.globalresearch.ca . The present series is adapted from his
new book, now in writing, The Rise and Fall of the American Century:
Money and Empire in Our Era. He may be contacted through his website,
www.engdahl.oilgeopolitics.net .
www.engdahl.oilgeopolitics.net
http://www.thezimbabwetimes.com/?p=1686
July 30, 2008
Jupiter Punungwe
SO
MUCH hope seems to have been invested in the ongoing talks between the
MDCs
and ZANU-PF. At last a glimmer far down the tunnel is visible. Many
people
are excited that a solution to Zimbabwe's problems seems within
reach.
I hate to be a spoilsport but my view is completely different.
The glimmer
so many are excited about is not the end of the tunnel but just
another
dying candle in the long dark tunnel.
The first problem I
have with the talks is that issues of principle are not
featuring at all in
the talks. If they are they are coming a distant second
to the sharing of
political spoils among the participants. An indication of
the shallowness
and frivolity of the participants at the talks is that the
first issue that
had to be ironed out at the talks is that the hosts had not
provided equal
access to free beer. All had access to free beer, but some
had mini-bars in
their rooms and some didn't.
Secondly, it seems the major issue being
talked about is who gets what post
in the so called government of national
unity. It seems people are mortified
at the thought of ending up with
'junior' posts in the new arrangement.
Everybody wants 'senior' posts. Some
people are simply delighted that Mugabe
is being made to talk to Tsvangirai.
While I agree that it is awe-inspiring
to see the leopard and the hyena
holding a peaceful discussion in the same
cave, it would be extreme naivety
to believe that the resulting agreement
could be beneficial to the
goat.
Thirdly, I am not happy at all that the talks are being held in
total
secrecy. Those people sequestered in Pretoria are discussing matters
of life
and death for ordinary Zimbabwean people like you, me, the umdala in
Plumtree and the ambuya in Nyamaropa. If they were merely discussing
Priscilla Misihairabwi's bridal shower, I wouldn't care to know. The issues
being discussed affect every Zimbabwean's life thus in my view every
Zimbabwean has a right to know and pass judgement.
On matters of
principle, there are fundamental flaws in the way the
Zimbabwean legal and
governance system is structured. Any discussion that
does not recognise what
those flaws are and commit everyone to addressing
them is bound to be
inadequate in the long term. The dividing of cabinet
posts between Zanu-PF
and the MDCs is not one of the fundamental flaws. It
is merely a matter of
the hyena and the leopard deciding which pieces of the
goat's carcass each
should get.
Some of the issues of principle that need to be discussed
include the
property laws of the country. The property laws have been messed
up by such
laws as the Land Acquisition Act and the law forcing some
companies to
surrender shareholding to locals. In particular the Land
Acquisition Act has
virtually removed security of tenure on all agricultural
land in Zimbabwe.
Without security of tenure the collateral value of land is
zero. Given that
land forms the bulk of property in Zimbabwe, once you take
away its value
you render the whole credit guarantee system based on
property rights
useless. The collapse of the credit guarantee system does
not only affect
agriculture but industrial production as well, because
people can no longer
borrow money to start industrial ventures based on the
value of their land.
It seems Zanu-PF was subconsciously trying to model
the land tenure system
in Zimbabwe after that used in the former native
reserves, which largely
resembles the pre-colonial land tenure system. Under
that system the land is
communal property controlled by some central
authority. The authority rested
with chiefs in the pre-colonial days, and
nowadays it has been assumed by
the state. While that system was good for
the economic model of the time,
which was entirely subsistence agriculture
based, it simply cannot sustain a
modern economy which needs to have a
substantial industry portion to be
successful.
The other matter of
principle which needs to be addressed is devolving power
from central
government, and making all levels of governance more
accountable to the
people. Under the current heavily patched Lancaster House
constitution, too
much power lies with an executive authority. It doesn't
matter whether that
executive authority is a president or a prime minister,
the bottom line is
power needs to be taken away from the centre. I have
always maintained that
provincial governors need to be elected and given
control of provincial
budgets, possibly under the supervision of a
provincial parliamentary caucus
made up of parliamentarians from that
province.
Under the present
system it doesn't matter whether governors have to lick
Mugabe or
Tsvangirai's butt, so long as they have to please one man in
Harare to
guarantee their posts, it is likely they will neglect the
interests of the
people in their provinces in the long term.
The other fundamental issue
that needs to be tackled once and for all is
guaranteeing freedom of trade.
Citizens' right to exchange goods and value
among themselves on their own
free market based terms needs to be
guaranteed. The government's role should
be restricted to maintaining a fair
competitive environment. The current
economic crisis has been caused chiefly
by the government's interference
with the free exchange of value among
citizens through price controls,
prescribed rates of exchange and
restriction of the free trade of some
commodities such as the economically
critical maize.
Not only has the
government interfered with trade, in some cases it has
prevented citizens
from acquiring goods and services that could have
alleviated their plight.
An example of this is the banning of the
importation of maize by citizen's
organisations, as well as the banning of
the operations of some humanitarian
citizens' organisations.
The above should make it absolutely clear that
the critical issue at this
moment is not the sharing of power between
Zanu-PF and the MDC but, actually
the reduction of the power of central
government. In short, we should
restrict both leopards and hyenas from
accessing the grazing areas of our
goats. Letting them talk among themselves
is not going to achieve that.
Zanu-PF and the MDC are focused on sharing
the excessive power of central
government, not on reducing those powers to
enhance the rights and freedoms
of ordinary citizens. An indication of that
wrong focus is the endless
preoccupation with who gets what post. I hope I
am not alone in observing
that precious little has been said about what
needs to be done to get
Zimbabwe right. Besides arguing about free beer, the
only other thing
participants are arguing about is the sharing of
posts.
In light of the fact that leopards and hyenas cannot be trusted to
negotiate
the safety of goats honestly among themselves, it is therefore a
matter of
urgency that representatives of goats need to be let into the cave
where the
discussions are going on. Representatives of politically
unaffiliated civic
organisations such as the NCA need to be given observer
status to the talks
urgently.
I am not saying Dr. Lovemore Madhuku of
the National Constitutional Assembly
should be shipped all the way from
Harare at the expense of the South
Africans. I am sure he or representatives
of the NCA can make their own way
to the talks. What is important is to
incorporate a non-partisan input into
the talks. What is important is to
make sure there is someone who can remind
participants about matters of
principle.
One can argue that such matters of principle can be discussed
in the
transitional period after the power sharing has started. The people
of
Zimbabwe are starving now. To save them, principles such as free trade
need
to be implemented now, not after a transitional period. Therefore it is
important to get those who are going to be in charge of the governance
system to commit to such principles, to paraphrase Arthur Mutambara, as of
yesterday.