HARARE, June 27 (Reuters) - The opposition MDC came within five seats of the ruling ZANU-PF in contested constituencies in Zimbabwe's election, officials said on Tuesday.
Election Directorate information officer Apinos Makoni told Reuters the final result was 62 seats for ZANU-PF, 57 for the Movement for Democratic Change and one for the small opposition ZANU-Ndonga party.
Registrar General Tobaiwa Mudede earlier announced slightly different figures at a news conference but Makoni said: "There was a mix-up in the figures. What I am giving you is the correct figure." The new numbers also conformed with unofficial counts.
There were 120 seats up for grabs in the weekend elections but President Robert Mugabe can personally nominate another 30 in the 150-member parliament.
The MDC's most significant success, apart from running almost neck and neck with ZANU-PF, was to rob Mugabe of the two thirds majority he needs for constitutional change.
He has used this power 16 times, most recently to enable him to seize white-owned farms. He also amended the constitution to give him the 30-seat voting block which has proved crucial in this election.
HARARE, June 27 (Reuters) - Opposition leader Morgan Tsvangirai said on Tuesday his party would have won Zimbabwe's elections if there had not been a state-sponsored terror campaign before the poll.
Tsvangirai told a news conference his Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) had identified 20 constituencies won by the ruling ZANU-PF where it would either ask for a recount or challenge the results in court.
"Without the subversion we would have easily won this election. There is no doubt in my mind," Tsvangirai said after the MDC won 57 of 120 contested seats. Around 30 people died in four months of violence before the poll.
President Robert Mugabe's ZANU-PF won 62 and a minor opposition party took the final seat. Mugabe personally appoints another 30 members of parliament, giving his party a majority in the 150-seat house.
The MDC denied ZANU-PF the two-thirds majority it needed to change the constitution. "The election results (show) ZANU-PF and Robert Mugabe can't go it alone. He can't change the constitution unilaterally," said Tsvangirai.
HARARE, June 27 (Reuters) - The ZANU-PF party of President Robert Mugabe retained control of Zimbabwe's parliament on Tuesday despite a stunning challenge from a new opposition party.
The Movement for Democratic Change (MDC), formed only nine-months ago, far eclipsed any previous challenge to ZANU-PF, which has totally dominated power since independence 20 years ago.
Latest results showed ZANU-PF with 51 of the contested 120 parliamentary seats and the MDC with 48.
The tiny ZANU-Ndonga party had one seat.
Mugabe personally nominates another 30 members of the 150-seat parliament, giving him well over the required 76-seat majority.
But the opposition needs only three more seats to deny Mugabe the two thirds majority needed for constitutional changes, like the one he used earlier this year to enable him to seize white-owned farms.
Mugabe has made 16 changes to the constitution including one that enabled him to move from prime minister to executive president.
The combined opposition had never previously held more than three seats.
SLAP IN THE FACE
The result was a huge slap in the face for Mugabe despite ZANU-PF retaining control of parliament.
The 76-year-old former guerrilla leader's power has never previously been challenged since he became prime minister at independence in 1980, following a bloody bush war against Rhodesia's white minority leaders.
Fears of violence following the poll turned out to be unfounded and the streets of Harare remained quiet.
Government officials, including police chief Augustine Chihuri, had repeatedly appealed for calm on Monday, warning against revenge attacks by one party against the other.
At least 30 people died in the four months up to the poll in political violence and a government-backed campaign of invasions of white-owned farms.
The violence was roundly condemned by foreign governments and the biggest group of foreign monitors, from the European Union, who said intimidation of opposition supporters prevented the election being free and fair.
MDC leader Morgan Tsvangirai ironically lost his own seat but so did no less than six government ministers including Emmerson Munangagwa, considered one of two heirs apparent to Mugabe. The other, Sidney Sekeremayi, held his seat by just 63 votes.
Tsvangirai told BBC radio: "The message to my supporters is ... not to feel despondent but to move forward because victory is certain anyway."
MDC officials said before the election that it would not overly concern them if Tsvangirai lost the tough contest for a seat in the southern town of Buhera because this would free him to challenge Mugabe for the presidency in 2002.
"HITLER" WINS
Chenjerai Hunzvi, leader of self-styled liberation war veterans who conducted the farm invasions, won a seat for the first time in a constituency south of Harare.
Hunzvi, who revels in his guerrilla name of "Hitler," won the seat in an area of central Zimbabwe heavily hit by the farm invasions.
ZANU-PF had predicted the MDC could win no more than 10 seats nationwide and said they would bar the opposition from government whatever the election result.
There was no immediate comment on the results from ZANU-PF but analysts said the government would find it difficult to ignore the MDC after its election performance.
Mugabe based his campaign on race and land, saying the MDC was a front for former Rhodesians to try to overturn his plans to seize vast tracts from white farmers and redistribute them to black peasants.
The MDC campaigned on a powerful campaign plank focused on the crisis in the economy, which has made Mugabe deeply unpopular in many areas.
Zimbabwe is in its deepest economic crisis since independence, with record inflation and unemployment and an acute shortage of hard currency.
Tsvangirai told a news conference his Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) had identified 20 constituencies won by the ruling ZANU-PF where it might ask for a recount or challenge the results in court.
"Without the subversion we would have easily won this election. There is no doubt in my mind," Tsvangirai told a news conference after his party gave ZANU-PF its biggest electoral scare in 20 years.
At least 30 people died in political violence and occupations of white-owned farms before the election. International monitors condemned the violence, which they said seriously curtailed the MDC's ability to campaign.
The MDC won 57 of the 120 contested parliamentary seats, against 62 for ZANU-PF and one for a minor party.
Mugabe personally appoints another 30 members of parliament, giving his party a majority in the 150-seat house.
Nevertheless, Tsvangirai's party won enough seats to deny ZANU-PF the two-thirds majority it needs to change the constitution.
"Zimbabwe will never be the same again," said the former trades union leader who formed the MDC nine months ago and waged a potent campaign against alleged mismanagement of the economy.
"This election result means that neither ZANU-PF nor President Mugabe will go it alone. He cannot amend the constitution unilaterally," Tsvangirai said.
CHALLENGE MUGABE IN PRESIDENTIAL RACE
He said the election also marked the beginning of the end for the 76-year-old former guerrilla leader, saying he would challenge him in presidential elections in 2002.
"Anyone who believes that the future destiny of this country lies with Robert Mugabe must have his head examined," he said.
"The sooner they start planning his retirement the better."
Tsvangirai shrugged off his own failed bid for a parliamentary seat in a poor rural constituency south of Harare.
Tsvangirai faced a tough battle against his cousin, a senior ZANU-PF party official, who outpolled the MDC leader by more than 2,000 votes.
"I have no doubt that the people of Buhera North support me and support the MDC," Tsvangirai said.
The MDC leader said his MPs would seek to work with those members of ZANU-PF who wanted change, but he added there would be no power-sharing agreement with Mugabe's government.
Tsvangirai said Mugabe's executive powers, which enabled him to send 10,000 troops to fight in the Democratic Republic of the Congo without consulting parliament, should be curtailed.
Mugabe's government has amended the constitution 16 times since a legal ban on changes expired in 1987.
The last major change in April gave the government powers to seize white-owned farms without paying compensation except for improvements made on the properties.
The MDC success comes too late to block the seizure of 804 farms for redistribution to landless black peasants, but Tsvangirai said he would stop plans for an upper house in parliament. Critics have accused Mugabe of wanting to fill the proposed senate with patronage appointments.
His sentiments were echoed around Bulawayo, Zimbabwe's second largest city and an opposition stronghold, after television and radio stations broadcast the final results of the polls, the mostly fiercely contested since independence in 1980.
The official result showed ZANU-PF taking 62 of the 120 contested seats with 57 for the MDC and one for a minority party.
MDC leaders said procedural irregularities and pre-election violence and intimidation in which 30 people died had robbed them of victory.
"There is no doubt that violence and intimidation have worked for ZANU-PF. We also have about 20 cases where we feel and know that our candidates were outright cheated out of their votes and we will be contesting these cases in courts of law," said David Coltart, the MDC's legal secretary and a new member of parliament.
The post poll disappointment contrasted with a carnival mood in Bulawayo, capital of the Ndebele people, on Monday when early results showed the MDC in the lead.
There was an eerie silence and sombre atmosphere at the MDC's regional offices.
In Bulawayo's townships the dancing and singing of Monday night had abruptly stopped.
Many people stayed at home to reflect on the result. Some shops, fearing post-election violence, remained closed.
But the huge police presence clearly visible when vote counting started on Monday had also vanished.
Many white farmers in the area said they were consoled by Mugabe's failure to retain the two-thirds parliamentary majority necessary to enact constitutional changes.
ZANU-PF supporters led by self-styled independence war veterans mounted a violent four-month campaign to occupy white farms before the election.
"We would have hoped for a better result. But we are happy with what we got. The government will no longer have the absolute impunity to change the constitution at will.
"We (MDC) will have a say in constitutional changes and that is a massive disaster for Mugabe and his party," a farmer who declined to be named told Reuters.
Another farmer said the MDC had actually emerged as the true winner of the elections: "People forget we are only nine months old and that we have actually driven Mugabe into the corner."
Hunzvi also sounded a new note of reconciliation, calling for an end to violence and urging cooperation with the opposition.
President Robert Mugabe's ZANU-PF won 62 of the 120 contested seats in the weekend election, against 57 for the opposition Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) and one for a minor opposition party.
There were only three opposition members of parliament before the poll.
"Clearly there is a revolution taking place. The party has to rejuvenate. To meet the challenge we need an overhaul from the grassroots to the top," said Hunzvi, who himself won a ZANU-PF seat south of Harare.
Hunzvi, leader of the national independence war veterans association, has led his men and ZANU-PF militants in the invasion of hundreds of white-owned farms since February.
The farm occupations were accompanied by a violent political campaign which killed around 30 people, mostly MDC supporters.
Hunzvi, who revels in his guerrilla name of "Hitler," said his men had already extended a hand of reconciliation to white farmers and opposition supporters.
"I say no more violence. No more violence," he said, before singing "ZANU-PF will move the country forward. All must work together. We are one people, black or white."
Hunzvi said he expected an appointment to Mugabe's government and urged his fellow ZANU-PF parliamentarians to work with the MDC.
"The government must be a government of Zimbabweans. We must be prepared to talk to the MDC or any other party to move the country forward," he added.
Hunzvi said these were the most difficult elections held in Zimbabwe since independence in 1980 and served as a reminder that ZANU-PF must not take its citizens for granted.
"These elections were something else, they were something to reckon with. We must work very hard," he said at a victory party in Chivu, south of Harare.
Hunzi, who wore a designer brown suit and tie with a Zimbabwean flag flung around his neck, at one point joined his supporters in a victory dance.
Men and women wearing ZANU-PF T-Shirts -- with Hunzvi or Mugabe protraits -- also joined in. Nearby, meat was being roasted and beer was flowing.
Hunzvi said some white-owned farmland had already been redistributed to landless black peasants and the Mugabe government's plan to seize 804 farms could be increased if necessary to provide more land.
He said any changes to the land acquisition programme would be done in consultation with Commercial Farmers Union, which represents 4,500 white farmers occupying 12 million hectares of Zimbabwe's most arable land.
Mugabe has set a target to seize nearly half the land owned by whites, paying compensation only for improvements made to the farms.
So decrepit is the regime of Zimbabwe's President Robert Mugabe that his party may lose a parliamentary election despite an energetic campaign to steal it. In spite of Sunday's warning by European Union observers that the two-day election had been anything but "free and fair" in light of a systematic campaign of violent intimidation by the ruling ZANU-PF, eight of the first 13 seats reporting on Monday went to the opposition Movement for Democratic Change. This for a parliament in which the ruling party had previously controlled all but three of the 150 seats.
Those early returns point to a stunning reversal for the party that led the liberation war against white minority rule and has ruled the country, with Mugabe at its head, ever since independence 20 years ago. ZANU campaigned on the basis of its liberation war record, attempting to demonize the opposition by casting them as stooges of the country's 70,000 remaining whites. The centerpiece of Mugabe's campaign has been the mass occupation by squatters of some 870 of the country's 4,000 white-owned farms, which occupy the best 70 percent of Zimbabwe's arable land while millions of black subsistence farmers scratch out a living on the remainder. All this was accompanied by at least 40 killings, incidences of kidnapping and torture of opposition candidates, confiscation of identity documents and fraudulent alteration of voter rolls. But for many Zimbabwe's 5 million voters, the government's sudden interest in "redistributing" white farms is seen as a cynical attempt at exploiting rural misery to deflect attention from its own legacy of corruption, catastrophic economic mismanagement, military misadventures and violent suppression of dissent. (The peasants know best of all that many of the farms previously acquired by the government in land-redistribution programs became the property of Mugabe cohorts rather than being parceled out among the rural poor.) Early returns suggest Zimbabweans are no longer buying Mugabe's rhetoric, as an untested opposition party that risked life and limb by contesting all 120 seats up for election rides a wave of voter protest against the poverty and stagnation over which Mugabe has presided.
Not that the result, whatever it is, will make a jot of difference to the immediate plans of the man who has ruled Zimbabwe as a personal fiefdom for the past 20 years. "ZANU-PF will form the government whatever the results," the party's national chairman, John Nkomo, vowed over the weekend. "Mugabe can have a cabinet of just five if he wants. Mugabe is an institution." Indeed, the fact that some 20 percent of the seats are reserved for his appointees and that a two-thirds majority is required for a move to unseat him before the next presidential election in 2002 gives him legal cover to hang onto power. But "cohabitation," as the French call a situation when the presidency and the legislature are in the hands of rival parties, would unlikely be a comfortable fit for a Zimbabwean strongman for whom it portends the final humiliation two years from now. And the danger is that the greater the challenge Mugabe perceives, the more desperate he becomes: The land invasions and accompanying violence began only after Mugabe lost a referendum in February that would have dramatically increased his constitutional powers. Then again, for the ZANU apparatchiks whose well-being depends on control over the state, a mauling at the polls and the consequent escalation of domestic protests and international pressure could be the cue to retire the 75-year-old strongman.
HARARE, Zimbabwe -- The ruling ZANU-PF party managed to maintain its control of Zimbabwe's government, but the opposition Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) made unprecedented gains in parliamentary elections held over the weekend.
Official final results released Tuesday show the ZANU-PF won 62 of the 120 seats in parliament that were up for election while the MDC won 57. The small independent ZANU-Ndonga party won a single seat, and President Robert Mugabe is allowed to appoint 30 seats himself to the 150-seat parliament.
Over the past 20 years, opposition parties have not held more than three seats in Zimbabwe's parliament.
Several high-level ruling party members lost their parliamentary seats, as did MDC leader Morgan Tsvangirai. But some observers believe this will give the opposition leader time to gear up for a challenge against Mugabe when the president's term expires two years from now, Hunter-Gault reprted.
Officials said the large turnout, estimated in excess of 3 million of the nation's 5.1 million registered voters, overwhelmed counting stations, leading to delays in confirming results.
CNN's Charlayne Hunter-Gault reports from Harare on the significnce of the Zimbabwe elections results
The turnout "was just too large ... more than twice as much as ever before," said Tobaiwa Mudede, the nation's registrar general.
As both sides waited for more results to come in, international observers from the European Union said the campaign was badly tainted by violence and could not be considered free and fair.
At least 30 people were killed ahead of the vote, and thousands were beaten and threatened, mainly by ruling party militants.
Leaders in Mugabe's party "seemed to sanction the use of violence and intimidation against political opponents and contributed significantly to the climate of fear so evident during the election campaign," the EU said. Meanwhile, police were being deployed throughout the country to prevent any possible outbreaks of trouble between the rival parties.
Riot police were sent to the southwestern Harare suburb of Budiriro, scene of repeated clashes in previous weeks between ruling party militants and opposition supporters. There were no reports of any clashes, and police appealed for calm.
"Those who win must be graceful and not target losers. Those who lose must accept losing with honor," Police Commissioner Augustine Chihuri said in a nationwide broadcast.
In the months leading up to the election, armed ruling party militants occupied hundreds of white-owned farms, demanding they be divided up and given to landless blacks.
The high turnout came despite what European observers said were intense levels of intimidation by ZANU-PF officials that made it virtually impossible for opposition candidates to campaign.
"The term 'free and fair elections' is not applicable in these elections," said Pierre Schori, head of the EU observers, the biggest group of foreign monitors.
"The level of violence and intimidation in the pre-election phase makes the term not applicable," the former Swedish government minister told a midnight news conference.
ZANU-PF secretary for administration, Didymus Mutasa, a close aide of Mugabe, told Reuters: "That is real garbage.
"They are biased and with this report they have confirmed that the EU's real mission is actually out to help those trying to overthrow President Mugabe and our party."
At least 30 people, mostly supporters of the MDC, have died in violence linked to the elections and invasions of hundreds of white-owned farms by pro-government militants since February.
Five MDC members were severely beaten by suspected ZANU-PF thugs on Saturday night in the Mataga area of central Zimbabwe.
"They were violently assaulted. People are really scared down there," human rights worker Val Ingham-Thorpe told Reuters after rushing three of the men to a Harare hospital on Monday.
Mudondo Timomenda was burned on the buttocks and beaten on his feet, while Simbai Murigwa had suffered a large, deep burn on his shoulder. Alphayo Shoko's face was badly swollen after he was battered on the head, she said.
The other two MDC members were still missing, Ingham-Thorpe said, adding that there had been 120 violent incidents in the Mataga area in the run-up to the elections.
Schori said that while weekend voting itself was "highly positive," the level of pre-poll violence and a "lack of transparency" by the government-appointed election body meant the process was seriously flawed.
"ZANU-PF leaders seemed to sanction the use of violence and intimidation against political opponents and contributed significantly to the climate of fear so evident during the election campaign," Schori said.
Observers from the Organization of African Unity (OAU) said they had noted scattered incidents of intimidation and problems with voters' lists, but the team judged the poll free and fair.
"In view of all that transpired during the campaign, including the violence and acrimonious debate, the major challenge now facing the Zimbabwean people has to do with creating a national strategy and forging forward with their development in an atmosphere of peace and harmony," the OAU monitoring team said in a statement.
HARARE (Reuters) - President Robert Mugabe's ZANU-PF party on Tuesday narrowly defeated a potent election challenge by a new opposition party but lost its power to alter the constitution despite a terror campaign before the poll.
Although the Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) failed to wrest control of parliament from ZANU-PF, it came within five seats of the government in contested constituencies.
The stunning political success was all the more remarkable because it followed a four-month campaign of state-sponsored violence and intimidation that international monitors said prevented the election from being free and fair.
Final official results showed ZANU-PF with 62 seats, the MDC with 57 and one for a small opposition party. ZANU-PF only retained a workable majority because of 30 members who are nominated personally by Mugabe.
At least 30 people died in political violence and a campaign to occupy white-owned farms since last February.
International monitors said this severely hindered the MDC's ability to campaign. MDC leader Morgan Tsvangirai said they would have won without the intimidation.
MDC control of more than one third of parliamentary seats was highly significant, robbing Mugabe of the two thirds majority needed to make constitutional change.
Mugabe has used his powers 16 times to amend the constitution and boost his powers, most recently to enable him to seize hundreds of white-owned farms.
He also used this power to create the 30-seat personal voting block which is so crucial after this election.
CHALLENGE TO RESULTS
Tsvangirai told a news conference he would formally challenge 20 seats won by ZANU-PF.
``Without the subversion we would have easily won this election. There is no doubt in my mind,'' Tsvangirai said.
The MDC was formed only nine-months ago but it far eclipsed any previous challenge to ZANU-PF, which had totally dominated power since independence 20 years ago.
The combined opposition had never previously held more than three seats.
The result was a huge slap in the face for Mugabe.
The 76-year-old former guerrilla leader's power had never previously been challenged since he became prime minister at independence in 1980, following a bloody bush war against Rhodesia's white minority leaders.
Fears of violence following the poll turned out to be unfounded and the streets of Harare remained quiet.
Government officials, including police chief Augustine Chihuri, had repeatedly appealed for calm on Monday, warning against revenge attacks by one party against the other.
Chihuri made the appeal again on Monday but the streets of Harare were unusually quiet, with the population apparently still absorbing the results.
Tsvangirai ironically failed to win a tough contest for a seat in southern Zimbabwe. But no less than seven government ministers lost their seats, including Emmerson Munangagwa, considered one of two heirs apparent to Mugabe. The other, Sidney Sekeremayi, held his seat by just 63 votes.
MDC officials said before the election that it would not overly concern them if Tsvangirai lost because this would free him to challenge Mugabe for the presidency in 2002.
``HITLER'' WINS
Chenjerai Hunzvi, leader of self-styled liberation war veterans who
conducted the farm invasions, won a seat for the first time in a constituency
south of Harare.
Hunzvi, who revels in his guerrilla name of ``Hitler,'' won
the seat in an area of central Zimbabwe heavily hit by the farm invasions.
ZANU-PF had predicted the MDC could win no more than 10 seats nationwide and said they would bar the opposition from government whatever the election outcome.
There was no immediate comment on the results from ZANU-PF but analysts said the government would find it difficult to ignore the MDC after its election performance.
Mugabe based his campaign on race and land, saying the MDC was a front for former Rhodesians to try to overturn his plans to seize vast tracts from white farmers and redistribute them to black peasants.
The MDC campaigned on a powerful campaign plank focused on the crisis in the economy, which has made Mugabe deeply unpopular in many areas.
Zimbabwe is in its deepest economic crisis since independence, with record inflation and unemployment and an acute shortage of hard currency.
The people of Zimbabwe have begun the process of reclaiming power and the institution of true democratic change.
Constituency |
Seats |
Tot votes cast |
MDC votes | MDC % | ZANU PF votes | ZANU PF % | ||
Total | MDC | Other | ||||||
HARARE | 19 | 19 | 389,968 | 296,052 | 75.9 | 85,286 | 21.9 | |
MASH CENTR | 10 | 10 | 240,477 | 47,587 | 19.8 | 188,967 | 78.6 | |
MASH EAST | 12 | 1 | 11 | 270,356 | 65,017 | 24.0 | 196,157 | 72.6 |
MASH WEST | 12 | 2 | 10 | 240,584 | 78,823 | 32.8 | 153,167 | 52.8 |
BULAWAYO | 8 | 8 | 170,396 | 142,379 | 83.6 | 22,350 | 13.1 | |
MAT NORTH | 7 | 7 | 143,425 | 105,492 | 73.6 | 30,062 | 21.0 | |
MAT SOUTH | 8 | 6 | 2 | 154,636 | 91,747 | 59.3 | 56,165 | 36.3 |
MANICALAND | 14 | 7 | 6 | 266,328 | 125,808 | 47.2 | 123,394 | 46.3 |
MASVINGO | 14 | 2 | 12 | 277,001 | 92,088 | 33.2 | 163,018 | 58.9 |
MIDLANDS | 16 | 5 | 11 | 340,754 | 126,058 | 37.0 | 193,736 | 56.9 |
120 | 57 | 63 | 2,493,925 | 1,171,051 | 47.0 | 1,212,302 | 48.6 |
Zimbabwe (Legislative)
COUNTRY | ELECTION TYPE | DATE |
Republic of Zimbabwe | Legislative | June 24-25, 2000 |
At stake in this election:
|
Description of government
structure:
|
Description of electoral system:
|
Main parties in the electoral race:
|
When was the last election? Number of seats in last election?
|
Population and number of registered voters:
|
Of interest:
|
SOURCE: INTERNATIONAL FOUNDATION FOR ELECTION SYSTEMS (IFES) |
For additional information: IFES ElectionGuide Online |