http://www.swradioafrica.com/
By Tichaona Sibanda
SW Radio
Africa
6 June 2013
The SADC summit on Zimbabwe, which was due in
Maputo, Mozambique on Sunday,
will now be held in Pretoria, South Africa on
Monday, according to sources.
SW Radio Africa is reliably informed that
the summit was postponed by a day
to give all parties to the GPA enough time
to consult on a date for
elections.
President Jacob Zuma’s
facilitation team spent hours on Thursday in meetings
with GPA negotiators
in Harare. They were insisting that by the time all
parties attend the
summit, there should be an agreed date for an election.
This prompted the
ZANU PF negotiators to ask for a postponement to allow its
negotiators time
to consult President Robert Mugabe, who is currently
outside the
country.
The summit on Zimbabwe is due to be convened at a time when
there is
mounting disagreement between the political parties following the
Constitutional Court ruling that Mugabe should proclaim an election date
before July 31st.
The ruling last week suits Robert Mugabe better
than his political
opponents, who have however ganged up in a rare show of
unity to condemn the
court’s election ruling. The five parties – the MDC-T,
MDC-N, ZAPU, MKD and
ZANU Ndonga – have united to demand changes to laws
that inhibit freedom of
association, movement and expression and the
media.
They have agreed to speak with one voice at the SADC summit to
call for the
security sector to be reformed in line with the new
constitution, which
demands neutrality.
That court judgment,
described as an ‘election judgment fiasco’ by a leading
human rights lawyer,
dominated much of the discussion between Zuma’s team
and the GPA
negotiators.
While all parties, including Zuma’s team, were trying to
abide by the court
ruling and work out if it was feasible to hold elections
before 31st July,
legal experts say it will not be possible.
Senator
David Coltart, the Education Minister and MDC-N secretary for Legal
Affairs,
told SW Radio Africa that while it is the duty of everybody to
respect the
court ruling, it brings with it a big challenge for politicians
and
Mugabe.
‘The dilemma we find ourselves in is that it is impossible to
hold elections
in compliance with that court judgement without breaking
other provisions of
the new constitution.
‘In essence, the new
constitution says we must go through a 30 day process
to re-register voters.
And subsequent to that is a period specified by the
constitution that there
should be another 30 day period between nomination
day and the election
itself. Nomination day starts immediately after voter
registration. So you
are looking at 60 days from June 10th when voter
registration starts,’
Coltart said.
He continued: ‘These two processes cannot run concurrently.
They have to run
separately. There is no way round it and it is clear these
constitutional
requirements will go beyond July 31st.’
The Minister
suggested it would be wise for Mugabe and any other interested
party to
approach the constitutional court and ask the bench to revise the
order.
By Nomalanga
Moyo
SW Radio
Africa
6 June
2013
Civil society groups will be taking their push for electoral reforms to the SADC summit on Zimbabwe, now expected to be held in Pretoria on Monday.
The move by the civil society organisations (CSOs) follows the Constitutional Court ruling directing that the country should hold harmonised polls by July 31st.
A huge outcry greeted the directive with most major political parties, other than ZANU PF, saying the court’s decision fails to account for the democratic processes that the country’s new constitution outlines for the conduct of credible elections.
Now CSOs have weighed in with a petition which they say is a reminder to SADC, as guarantors of the Global Political Agreement, why the unity government was formed in the first place.
Nixon Nyikadzino of the Crisis in Zimbabwe Coalition, said the groups had been lobbying regional governments in preparation for the summit.
He explained: “Our petition is based on the understanding that when the GNU was formed, certain conditions had to be met by the unity government to facilitate a transition to a credible poll that would enable Zimbabweans to choose their leader.
“Therefore under the GPA both SADC, as guarantors, and the political parties have the responsibility to clear and level the ground so that Zimbabweans can exercise their right to vote in a credible election.
“We are trying to prevent a situation whereby there is another disputed election in Zimbabwe owing to a failure to ensure that key reforms outlined by the regional body itself, are implemented,” Nyikadzino said.
He added that the purpose of the petition was to bring SADC up to date regarding the outstanding issues, and also to ensure that regional leaders focused on what was agreed on under the GPA and not the recent court ruling which he said violated the rights of the majority of Zimbabweans.
There is also concern within CSOs that if SADC does not act to stop ZANU PF from announcing a date before end July, Zimbabweans may be forced to vote without necessary electoral reforms being implemented.
“This is why CSOs want SADC to set conditions for the elections, and also spell out the consequences of violating these conditions, including the possibility of alienating Zimbabwe if there is another stolen election,” Nyikadzino said.
With Zimbabwe having approached SADC for election funds, Nyikadzino said the regional body should use this as a bargaining chip to force Harare to carry out reforms in exchange for the money.
He told SW Radio Africa that civil society groups have been holding meetings with diplomats on the issues raised in the petition.
“They have been appreciating what we are saying because we are not saying anything new in the petition. We are simply restating what SADC, the AU and Zimbabweans said they wanted to be the roadmap towards a free and fair election in Zimbabwe,” Nyikadzino said.
For the full statement by CSOs, click here
http://www.voazimbabwe.com/
Nothando
Sibanda
06.06.2013
BULAWAYO — Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai told
civil society leaders in
Bulawayo today that the Constitutional Court erred
last week in giving a
judgement compelling Harare to hold elections by July
31 in the absence of
critical democratic reforms.
Mr. Tsvangirai, who
is on a two-day visit to the city, said his Movement for
Democratic Change
party is not concerned about the date the court wants the
elections to be
held but the lack of political will on the part of his
governing partner,
President Robert Mugabe and his Zanu-PF party to
implement necessary reforms
ahead of the poll.
Mr. Tsvangirai said Southern African Development
Community leaders should
push Harare for reforms ahead of the elections,
adding the region had a
right to question political and court decisions in
Zimbabwe as guarantors of
the Global Political Agreement that gave birth to
the unity government.
Commenting on yesterday’s statement where his party
united with other
political formations in the country in saying they won’t
participate in this
elections in the absence of reforms, Mr. Tsvangirai said
he hoped this was
the beginning of an alliance that will bring change to
Zimbabwe.
Chairperson of the National Association of Non-Governmental
Organisations,
Effie Ncube, said it is critical for civil society to
constantly engage
government, especially at when there’s a lot of debate and
uncertainty on
the electoral process.
Mr. Tsvangirayi also met with
representatives from various labour unions and
the local business community.
He was expected to visit the United Bulawayo
Hospitals this evening.
http://www.businessweek.com/
By Brian Latham
June
06, 2013
Zimbabwe can’t hold general elections by a July 31 deadline
set by the
Supreme Court without violating the constitution, according to
Senator David
Coltart.
There isn’t enough time for the registration
of voters that ends July 9 and
the nomination of candidates 30 days before a
vote as the constitution
stiplulates, Coltart, a lawyer and secretary for
legal affairs in a faction
of the Movement for Democratic Change party, said
today on his website.
“The election cannot under any circumstances be
held lawfully and in
compliance with the constitution before the 9th August
2013,” he said.
Coltart made his statement as the 15-nation Southern
African Development
Community prepares to discuss Zimbabwe’s elections at a
June 9 meeting in
the Mozambican capital, Maputo. President Robert Mugabe
has repeatedly
called for an early vote, while both factions of the MDC have
said the May
31 Supreme Court ruling was unconstitutional and
unfeasible.
The electoral commission yesterday described the voters’ roll
as a
“shambles,” Newsday, based in the capital, Harare, reported. The body
said
an election date must be at least 44 days after voter registration is
completed.
Mugabe, 89, has ruled the southern African nation since
its independence
from the U.K. more than three decades ago.
He shares
power with the Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai’s MDC and a
smaller faction
of the party led by Welshman Ncube, a law professor. The
five-year
power-sharing agreement was brokered by SADC after it declared
elections in
2008 void because of violence mainly against MDC supporters.
http://www.dailynews.co.zw/
By Chengetayi Zvauya, Parliamentary
Editor
Thursday, 06 June 2013 11:43
HARARE - The Zimbabwe Electoral
Commission (Zec) is in a race against time
as it battles to beat the July 31
deadline imposed by the Constitutional
Court last week, Zec admitted
yesterday.
Speaking to the Daily News after a consultative meeting with
the media, Zec
chairperson Justice Rita Makarau said although the body that
is in charge of
conducting electoral processes in the country is ready for
the watershed
elections if dates for elections are proclaimed, it has a
“tight schedule”
in terms of administration.
Zec has to clean up a
shambolic voters’ roll and supervise the 30-day mobile
voter registration
exercise.
The Constitutional Court ruled that President Robert Mugabe
calls for
elections immediately after the dissolution of Parliament whose
term expires
on June 29.
The Constitutional Court verdict has invoked
anger in some quarters, with
some legal experts saying the time-frame given
in the judgment is
impractical and quashes the rights of Zimbabweans to
partake in the
important national event.
Makarau said legally, there
was nothing that stands in the way of the July
31 polls, as the period
between the the proclamation of dates, the seating
of the Nomination Court
and the actual polling dates would fit in the
available time frame between
now and July 31.
The former Supreme Court judge said a minimum of 44 days
is all that Zec
needs to hold elections but stressed the fact that in terms
of
administration, it will be difficult.
“Once there is proclamation
if the President declares poll dates, then we
would be ready because we are
governed by the legal time frame. Although
this can be achieved, it will be
a tight schedule because we don’t know when
the president is going to
announce the dates,” she said.
A 30-day mandatory voter registration
blitz is yet to kick-start with Zec
yesterday vaguely saying the process
would start soon.
With the government still to secure funding for polls
in order to buy
materials like indelible ink, ballot boxes, ballots and put
in place
necessary logistics, analysts said elections if they are held
before July
31, would make it difficult for candidates to
campaign.
Makarau yesterday admitted that the cash-strapped body that has
received $20
million for a fresh mobile voter registration blitz, is
concerned with the
state of the voters’ roll, promising to ensure that every
Zimbabwean
eligible to vote will exercise his right.
“We want
everybody to participate in the elections and we don’t want to
attack the
system but we need to provide remedies. We want to give people
back their
rights to vote,” said Makarau.
“Give us evidence of the state of the
voters’ roll and we will clean it for
you. It is trite that a credible
electoral process begins with a credible
votes’ roll which is acceptable to
all stakeholders.”
Some civic rights organisations allege that the
voters’ roll is in shambles
and after a chaotic three week mobile voter
registration exercise, MDC
formations in the unity government were fuming
against the Registrar of
Voters, Tobaiwa Mudede, whom they say is
incompetent.
Mudede and Makarau are expected to meet Prime Minister
Morgan Tsvangirai to
give a heads-up on the state of
preparedness.
Makarau admitted that the voters’ roll is not in the best
shape.
“The commission is concerned that the voters’ roll may not be in
the shape
it ought to be in before the harmonised elections,” she
said.
“In particular, the commission is concerned that people who
lawfully
registered as voters in a particular ward may have found their
names removed
from the roll of that ward without their knowledge.
“It
is on the basis of this grave concern that Zec is calling upon each and
every one of the registered voters to inspect the voters’ roll during the 30
day voter registration exercise,” she said.
Apart from dealing with a
voter registration exercise, the commission, under
the Electoral Act which
is yet to be aligned with the new constitution, also
has to ensure that
postal voting for Zimbabweans in foreign countries on
government business
takes place as well as ensure that the disciplined
forces also exercise
their rights to vote two weeks before the actual
polling
date.
Tsvangirai, whose party has grudgingly accepted the Constitutional
Court
ruling, says he is going to take the issue of poll dates to the
impending
Sadc Extraordinary Conference in Maputo that will among other
things
deliberate on poll funding as well as the implementation of the
Global
Political Agreement (GPA), the basis of the coalition government.
http://www.dailynews.co.zw/
Thursday, 06 June 2013 14:55
HARARE - A grand
coalition of political parties in Zimbabwe has set
stringent conditions to
which the much anticipated elections will be held
under, stating that the
July 31 deadline set by the Constitutional Court is
impossible.
Prime
Minister Morgan Tsvangirai representing MDC, Mavambo Kusile Dawn
leader
Simba Makoni, Zanu Ndonga chairperson Reketai Semwayo, Zapu leader
Dumiso
Dabengwa and Edwin Mushoriwa presenting Welshman Ncube-led MDC
attended the
meeting.
They insisted that before elections are held, a mandatory 30-day
period of
voter registration should be held as well as amendments of other
laws that
have a bearing on the polls.
The political parties
yesterday told journalists in the capital after a
three hour closed-door
meeting that the forthcoming polls will only be held
if certain conditions
prescribed in the new constitution and those outlined
in the Sadc election
roadmap are fulfilled.
Indications are that the parties are planning to
boycott the next elections
if they are held without the necessary
reforms.
The five main political parties minus Zanu PF resolved to take
the matter up
with Sadc stating that they will not entertain an election
that is
disputable done in the “spirit of complying with the Constitutional
Court’s
ruling.”
“The political leaders expressed reservations about
the practicality of the
July 31 deadline set by the Constitutional Court and
resolved that they will
communicate their position to Sadc,” a statement
read MDC leader Morgan
Tsvangirai after the meeting said.
“They
(political leaders) noted that the court action, ironically supposedly
informed by the desire to safeguard the rights of the individual applicant,
has resulted in the infringement of rights of millions of Zimbabweans, in
particular the right of eligible voters to have adequate tome to register
and elect a government of their choice in a free and fair environment,” said
Tsvangirai, the group’s spokesperson said.
Last week, the
Constitutional Court ordered that elections should be held
before July 31
and told President Robert Mugabe to announce the preferred
date.
The
court led by Chief Justice Godfrey Chidyausiku and eight others ruled
that a
postponement of polls beyond July 31 would be a violation of people’s
rights.
Seven judges of the bench conquered in their individual
rulings that
elections should be held by July 31, while two others -Deputy
Chief Justice,
Luke Malaba and Justice Bharat Patel gave disserting
judgements stating that
the July 31 deadline is unconstitutional.
The
two judges stated that the executive-who are the president, prime
minister
and cabinet, can run the affairs of the country for four months
after the
collapse of the current parliament on June 29.
Mugabe, who will battle it
out with Tsvangirai, Ncube, Dabengwa and Makoni
among other political
leaders in the coming elections, has hinted that he
will abide by the
court’s ruling.
However Edwin Mushoriwa, deputy to Ncube said he doubted
whether the 89-year
old leader will do so considering his previous action on
court judgements
and the legacy he would want to leave after the
elections.
“The issue is not about holding of an election, it is about
having
undisputed results and a scenario where the winner is able to work
with the
loser for the purposes of developing this country.
“I
believe that the Constitutional Court has a mechanism of reviewing their
judgements, and if it is in the interest of the public, it would be
advisable for it to sit and have a re-look at the judgement,” Mushoriwa
stated.
According to the statement, the forthcoming extra-ordinary
Sadc summit
should make a final determination as to how Zimbabwe will have
elections as
well as ensure that all agreed reforms are
implemented.
The political leaders stated that security chiefs should
stop meddling in
the country’s political affairs as it a violation of the
new supreme law
which requires that the military should not be actively
involved in civilian
politics. - Xolisani Ncube
http://www.dailynews.co.zw/
By Maxwell Sibanda, Assistant
Editor
Thursday, 06 June 2013 11:55
HARARE - All eyes will be on Sadc
leaders as they meet this weekend in
Maputo, Mozambique, for an
extraordinary summit to deal with Zimbabwe’s
political and security
situation ahead of elections which the Constitutional
Court says have to be
held by next month.
Sadc is eager to restore political and economic
stability in Zimbabwe and
prepare the southern African nation for harmonised
free and fair elections.
Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai, who is also
MDC leader, and Industry and
Commerce minister and smaller MDC leader
Welshman Ncube are said to have
lobbied regional leaders for the special
summit.
The Maputo extraordinary meeting is set to make a comprehensive
review of
the situation in Zimbabwe in the context of the Global Political
Agreement
(GPA) and the roadmap for elections as set by Sadc.
It will
also look at the poll funding and how the country seeks to raise
more than
$100 million urgently needed for the elections.
But everything else under
discussion at the Maputo extraordinary meeting
will be dominated by the
Constitutional Court’s deadline for holding
elections and the electoral
environment.
Mugabe and his party have in recent years been fighting with
regional
leaders over implementation of the GPA, roadmap and reforms before
any
credible elections could be held.
Sadc facilitator, South African
President Jacob Zuma, and his team, have
resisted Mugabe’s moves to wriggle
out of the GPA set conditions and call
for polls unilaterally.
But
now armed with a Constitutional Court ruling compelling elections to be
held
by next month, a showdown looms in Maputo as Mugabe sees this as an
excuse
to ultimately hold the elections without adhering to all expected
reforms.
Will Sadc accept the date set by the Constitutional Court
given that all the
reforms it had been lobbying for have not been
met?
Media practitioner Rashweat Mukundu said this is a catch 22
situation for
Sadc as the body cannot be seen to be going against a court
ruling.
“Nevertheless this does not take away the demand by Sadc that
significant
reforms take place before the election, to make that process
credible.
The pressure might as well fall on Zanu PF and President Mugabe
to make this
election process acceptable to their peers before the date set
by the court.
“I doubt Sadc will accept anything less simply because
there is no time,”
said Mukundu.
Political activist Tabani Moyo said
we have two positions here; the first
one is that the court ordered the
holding of elections by July 31 and that
the political parties on the other
hand are not yet ready for that hyped
election which is being annexed to
institutional reforms.
“Sadc will stick to its roadmap compliance before
elections call and try as
much as is possible that the feuding parties
should reach an agreement. So
as far as the elections date is concerned, I
don’t see a radical change from
the previous resolutions.
“But you
must also realise that Sadc does not want to be seen to be
interfering where
court matters are involved so there is a catch 22
situation on the date. In
terms of implementation, the message will remain
that of insisting that
reforms must be completed for the outcome to be
respected across the
national divide,” said Moyo.
He added that it is therefore critical that
the political parties should
iron out their differences on the issue
internally before pinning their
hopes on Sadc which will also face its
limitations in terms of being
perceived to be calling for the non-compliance
with court orders.”
Theatre producer Daves Guzha was doubtful that Sadc
would have come this far
insisting on the reforms only to give in this last
minute.
“Assuming that the MDC formations and Zanu PF agree on a way
forward, I
think Sadc still has to convince the world that everything is
being done
above board.”
Social commentator Phillip Pasirayi said the
Supreme Court judgement is
ultra vires the GPA which gave birth to the
coalition government.
“The GPA is clear on the need for consensus among
the GPA principals on
setting the election date. President Mugabe cannot
unilaterally set the
election date, but should consult with PM Tsvangirai
and the other MDC
formation led by Ncube, as spelled out in the GPA. So
contrary to what some
lawyers are telling us the correct position is that in
this new dispensation
which was ushered in by the GPA election dates are set
by consensus by the
three principals and not by Zanu-PF alone or by Zanu-PF
through suspicious
court process,” said Pasirayi.
He said as civil
society they expected Sadc to stick to its original
position that parties in
the inclusive government in Zimbabwe should agree
on an election date which
is informed by progress in the implementation of
media and security sector
reforms.
“We also reiterate our calls for a more hands-on approach, a
kind of
interventionist strategy by the sub-regional body, Sadc, to save the
situation from imploding.
“The stakes are high- the forthcoming
election is going to be hotly
contested because Zanu PF wants to regain its
lost hegemony while the MDC
believes it is their time to govern,” said
Pasirayi.
He said as Zimbabweans there are questions we should ask as we
interrogate
the Supreme Court ruling on the forthcoming
elections.
“Is the law what the courts say it is as we are being told?
What if the
courts are not competent and are a mere extension of the Zanu-PF
party
patronage politics?
“Can the decisions by these court processes
still be considered as genuine
law or this is now politics?”
Commentator
Thomas Deve said the Sadc election roadmap was a mediation
instrument
designed to bring some semblance of normalcy in the country.
“And it now
becomes difficult for Sadc to ignore the existence of some form
of
constitutionalism as this is the bedrock of liberal democracy.
“The
judgement on elections opened a new chapter for Zimbabwean politics and
observers have no option except to follow what the Constitution puts before
us as guidelines and president Mugabe must oblige with the ruling or be
condemned by the same Sadc.”
Social commentator Precious Shumba said
Sadc has no option but to respect
the decisions of the Constitutional Court
of Zimbabwe, which is a creature
of the GPA-led constitution-making
exercise.
“The regional body’s reform path can only be revisited upon
satisfying
itself that the three parties are serious about going for
elections, which
Zanu PF is not ready for given that they have failed to
produce election
guidelines for its primary elections.
“Zimbabwe is
above all the three political parties concerned, and they
should give the
nation a break from its ransom politics.
The best Sadc is likely to do is
to acknowledge the steps taken by Zimbabwe’s
GNU partners in ensuring
democratic, free and fair elections are held in
Zimbabwe without further
delays.
“All the three parties have previously denounced the GNU as
dysfunctional
and only an election can settle this matter. All the three
governing
political parties have been in the inclusive government, and in
the past
four years, they should have prioritised reforms in the media and
electoral
conditions, but they wasted a lot of time testing each other’s
powers and
fighting useless power games,” said Shumba.
The video below shows Zanu-PF MP for Mudzi North, Newton Kachepa, who is reportedly infamous in the district for his brutal campaigns of intimidation and violence and party dominance in the area. He is allegedly responsible for the murders of various opposition members during the violent 2008 elections and the current spate of violence and sabotage of opposition party meetings in the Mudzi district leading up to the next election.
In his various speeches, his incendiary rhetoric is often focused around a sense of Zimbabwean patriotism and the stature that being a war veteran aligned with the ruling party.
The recent murder of Sekuru Cephas Magura, the MDC-T chairman for Ward One Mudzi North has been attributed to, in various testimonies (including that of his son), to Kachepa's Youth Militia who invaded a planned MDC meeting in the district (SWRADIO, May 30, 2012).
While the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights, Navi Pillay, has urged Western countries to lift sanctions on Zimbabwe to give the country a chance to implement reforms within the period of planned elections, there are still serious concerns of violence and human rights abuse in the country as seen with Kachepa and other hard-liners.
Ironically, this murder occurred less than 24 hours after the UN envoy had left Zimbabwe.
For now, Kachepa still remains on the EU's sanctions list for the undermining of human rights and democracy.
http://www.swradioafrica.com/
By Alex Bell
SW Radio
Africa
6 June 2013
The international diamond trade watchdog, the
Kimberley Process (KP), is
once again under pressure to reform, to remain a
relevant player in the
fight against diamond trade abuses.
KP members
are currently gathered in Kimberley, South Africa for an inter-
sessional
meeting, hosted by that country’s Mineral and Resources Minister
Susan
Shabangu. She used her opening speech at the start of the session on
Tuesday
to applaud the KP for being responsible for what she said was a “99%
conflict free” diamond trade.
Shabangu however also used the
opportunity to recognize the growing calls
for reforms and urged the body to
consider proposals that have been made on
the organisation’s policy reforms
and structural changes.
“The moment has finally arrived for the KP to
sharpen its efficacies. It is
against this background that the KP is
conducting a review of its processes
and functions. It is for this reason
that my government is fully behind the
KP proposed reform initiatives,” she
said.
These comments have been cautiously welcomed by civil society, who
have for
years been calling for the KP to urgently reform and refocus its
mandate.
Civil society groups, who gathered ahead of the KP meeting last
Saturday,
again reiterated that the group needs to expand its mandate to
remain
relevant.
The civil society meeting was co-hosted by the
Southern Africa Resource
Watch group (SARW), the International Crisis Group
and Partnership Africa
Canada (PAC). The SARW’s Director Claude Kabemba said
the KP has to be
reformed “or fade into insignificance.”
“Now that
most diamond-linked conflicts have ended, the KP will only remain
relevant
if it is given the mandate to monitor the entire diamond industry
chain –
from mining the rough stones to polishing the final jewels – and to
look at
diamonds that are fostering human rights abuses as well as armed
conflict,”
Kabemba said.
Kabemba told SW Radio Africa on Thursday that the KP’s
‘irrelevance’ has
been on display, particularly when dealing with the
Zimbabwe diamond
situation.
The KP cleared Zim diamonds for
international trade, despite warnings by
human rights groups that abuses are
being committed at diamond mines in the
Marange region. This clearance was
the result of the KP’s limited mandate
that it only deals with diamonds
fuelling conflict by illegitimate
governments and rebels. In Zimbabwe, the
situation did not fit this
description, because the technically legitimate
ZANU PF government was
involved.
This has seen the KP overlooking the
abuses as well as the deaths of more
than 200 diamond panners in 2008, who
were killed in a military led
operation to clear the Chiadzwa diamond
fields.
There has also been ongoing controversy about the diamond sector
in
Zimbabwe, fuelled by revelations by the country’s Finance Minister Tendai
Biti that almost no diamond remittances were reaching the national coffers.
This is despite the government being part of joint venture initiatives
actively mining the diamond fields.
Biti’s concerns have echoed those
voiced by groups like the PAC, which last
year reported that over US$2
billion had been stolen from the diamond mines.
The PAC blamed high level
members of the Robert Mugabe regime, amid
speculation that diamond profits
were being used to fund a ‘parallel
government’ aimed at keeping Mugabe in
power.
The SARW’s Kabemba said that this situation, and others around the
world, is
a key reason why the KP needs to reform.
“The protracted
conflicts in Africa fuelled by diamonds are over, and this
was the mandate
of the KP. But it doesn’t mean the problem has been
eradicated. The
situation in Zimbabwe is similar to situations elsewhere
where thousands of
diamond miners are working in appalling conditions, and
still diamonds are
reaching the international market. So the definition of a
conflict diamond
is not relevant anymore,” Kabemba said.
http://www.swradioafrica.com/
By Alex Bell
SW
Radio Africa
6 June 2013
Zimbabwe’s main gay, lesbian and transgender
rights group on Thursday came
under attack by a group of unknown, armed men,
who forced their way onto the
premises and ransacked the offices.
The
attack happened about 11am on Thursday morning, and saw five men, armed
with
hammers, forcing their way into the Harare offices of the Gays and
Lesbians
of Zimbabwe (GALZ) group.
According to a statement from GALZ, one of the
men “disguised as a mentally
challenged person,” threatened the security
personnel manning the gate with
a hammer while a visitor was driving onto
the premises.
The men rounded up all staff and board members and locked
them up in the
guard room whilst they ransacked the offices, collecting all
personal
property including cellphones, laptops and bags.
The attack
was short lived as the police arrived promptly on the scene and
arrested the
five men. They were taken to Harare Central Police station for
questioning.
“We commend the Police’s swift reaction that arrived at
the scene and
promptly arrested the men. All members present at the office
were unharmed
and one cellphone and some cash belonging to a board member is
allegedly
missing,” GALZ said.
The group went on to insist that they
do not believe the incident was a
random attack, but something that had been
orchestrated.
“We are not taking this incident as a random act of
attempted robbery but
that of youth militia acting on someone’s orders. The
men were constantly
making communication with an individual addressed as
‘Machacha’ of an
unknown ‘security wing’ over the phone,” GALZ said.
http://www.swradioafrica.com/
By
Nomalanga Moyo
SW Radio Africa
6 June 2013
The case of the 29 MDC-T
activists accused of murdering a police inspector
in Glen View two years ago
is set to resume next week after the High Court
set a date for the
hearing.
The matter had been postponed indefinitely in April to give the
defence team
time to prepare discharge applications for each of the accused,
five of whom
have been in custody since May 2011.
Gift Mtisi, one of
the defence lawyers, told SW Radio Africa Thursday that
his team had
submitted the discharge application for each of the activists
on May
12th.
Mtisi said the State, which had two weeks to submit its responses,
had
already indicated that they will be seeking a conviction for the 29
activists.
All 29 MDC-T activists have pleaded not guilty to
murdering police inspector
Petros Mutedza two years ago in Harare’s Glen
View suburb.
In the application, the defence will have to satisfy the
court that the
prosecution team failed to prove their clients’ guilt and
that they have no
case to answer.
Speaking to SW Radio Africa in
April, Mtisi said the defence team was
optimistic that their application for
discharge will be granted. He said all
the evidence given by state witnesses
had no substance and exonerated their
clients.
Justice Chinembiri
Bhunu is expected to hear the matter, while Edmore
Nyazamba will be
representing the State.
The 29 activists were arrested in May 2011 when a
police detail, responding
to reports of political disturbances in Harare’s
Glen View area, was
attacked, resulting in the death of Inspector
Mutedza.
Five of the activists Tungamirai Madzokere, Yvonne Musarurwa,
Rebecca
Mafukeni, Last Maengahama and Simon Mapanzure were deemed a flight
risk and
held in custody when their colleagues were bailed last
year.
Lawyers for the five detained activists say they have been tortured
and
ill-treated.
http://www.swradioafrica.com/
By Alex
Bell
SW Radio Africa
6 June 2013
Zimbabwe’s church and spiritual
leaders are becoming the latest nationals to
embrace social media tools, in
order to develop a peace monitoring
initiative ahead of and during
elections.
The Southern Africa Crisis Management Agency (SACMA) and
Christian Action
Trust Zimbabwe (CAT-Zim) have come together to launch a
grassroots anchored
peace initiative ahead of the polls expected this
year.
Their plan is to create a network of individuals who will monitor
electoral
processes and any incidents of political violence, so that the
incidents do
not pass by unchecked, unreported and forgotten.
The
first step in this programme has been the training of church pastors and
spiritual leaders in electoral processes and monitoring. A total of 200
church leaders, comprising Pastors, Reverends, Apostles and Bishops have so
far been trained, and the programme is expected to reach 5,000 church
leaders across Zimbabwe.
“We are part of a broader group of
organisations affiliated to the Zimbabwe
Council of churches who have
embarked on various strategies to minimise
violence and torture as part of
our normal pastoral work in Zimbabwe. This
program seeks to compliment the
efforts already underway…to address Zimbabwe’s
perennial legacy of violence
before, during and after elections” said
Reverend Kadenge, chairman of
CAT-Zim.
Speaking after the Pastors training in Mutare on Monday, SACMA
Zimbabwe
Coordinator Tichanzii Gandanga said: “SACMA in partnership with
CAT-Zim is
training pastors in electoral processes and monitoring of
political
violence, equipping them with various skills like terrain
scanning, event
diarising, incident recording as well as peace building. The
initiative aims
to finally set up a Zimbabwean version of Ushahidi, where
incidences of
violence are fed onto an online database in real time with
church leaders
as Community focal persons in scanning, detecting, verifying
and feeding our
call centre”
The Ushahidi initiative an online
mapping tool that started in Kenya in 2008
to track and map political
violence there. Meaning ‘witness’ or ‘testimony’
in Swahili, Ushahidi has
grown over the years to become a free to use,
online mapping system, used
around the world to report and track issues like
violence and
corruption.
The technology is already used in Zimbabwe to map and report
corruption
through the ‘I paid a bribe’ anonymous reporting website. A
political
violence map was also started using Ushahidi in 2011 by the blog
3rdLiberation.
It was a similar project that is believed to have been
the cause of the
police’s deliberate targeting of human rights defender
Jestina Mukoko’s
earlier this year. Mukoko was in March charged with
allegedly running a
non-registered organisation and for smuggling radios and
cell phones, which
had previously been seized during a police raid on her
offices.
But it later emerged that Mukoko was in the process of starting
a violence
monitoring initiative, using smart-phone and internet technology
to allow
people to report incidents of violence
Human rights activist
Phillip Pasirayi told SW Radio Africa said such social
media tools, if used
effectively, can make a difference during this year’s
election, because the
online community “is far more difficult to control.”
“You’re aware of the
political situation we have faced, with human rights
violations and so on.
People do not always feel safe having meetings to
discuss what is happening,
but social media means you feel safer from
potential targeting by the
police,” Pasirayi said.
He added that Zimbabwe’s still limited internet
coverage meant only a
minority had real access to social media tools. But he
said: “There is
progress and social media will definitely play a role in the
elections this
year.”
http://www.dailynews.co.zw/
By Chengetayi Zvauya, Parliamentary
Editor
Thursday, 06 June 2013 14:56
HARARE - Parliamentarians
yesterday castigated Local Government Urban and
Rural Development minister
Ignatius Chombo for political patronage and
nepotism in appointing special
interest councillors.
The legislators also blasted the minister’s
appalling meddling in local
authorities.
Lynette Karenyi, MDC MP for
Chimanimani West and chairperson of Local
Government and Urban Development
parliamentary portfolio committee
presented a special report to the august
house condemning Chombo’s
leadership qualities.
The committee
recommended that Chombo practise professionalism in the
administration of
council affairs by ensuring that the law is not applied
selectively and that
special interest councillors should truly represent the
interest of special
groups.
“The appointment of special interest councillors to serve in the
various
local authorities left a lot to be desired,” Karenyi said. “The
minister
alluded to the fact that different parties could present their
candidates to
be considered as special interest councillors in the various
councils.
However, Chombo did not inform the political parties which
special interests
their parties would present.
“The majority of the
special interest did not bring in any special interest
to the councils.
Instead the special interest councillors appointed by the
minister to
represent interest groups in different local authorities came
from one
party, Zanu PF.”
Some of the councillors mentioned were Esau Mupfumi,
Zanu PF Central
Committee member in Mutare, Monica Chinamasa, wife of
Justice minister
Patrick Chinamasa, Alfred Tome, Harare provincial
administrator, and Tapiwa
Matangaidze, a Zanu PF loyalist.
Karenyi
said there seemed to be selective application of the law when
dealing with
cases of misconduct by councillors.
“The committee could not comprehend
the logic of imposing different
disciplinary measures for similar offences
by councillors in the same
ministry. Some were dismissed, others were
pardoned, cautioned or suspended
for exactly the same offence,” said
Karenyi.
She said Chombo disregarded the laws of the country by
dismissing
councillors who had been acquitted by the courts.
Blessing
Chebundo, MDC MP for Mbizo, seconded the report, describing Chombo
as the
“worst minister” who had performed dismally.
He said the minister had to
be ashamed of the corruption by the councillors
he was protecting. Chombo
informed the committee that he suspended the
councillors for corruption and
said they were not following the laid down
procedures in conducting their
duties.
He blamed the mayors for allowing cases of impropriety to
flourish with the
local authorities. He said he had given the councillors
the chance to
explain extricate them but had failed to do so.
http://www.dailynews.co.zw/
By Fungai Kwaramba, Staff
Writer
Thursday, 06 June 2013 14:48
HARARE - The Zimbabwe Electoral
Commission (Zec) has warned political
parties to stop forcing people to
register as voters for the forthcoming
harmonised elections.
During
the abortive three-week mobile voter registration blitz, civic
society
groups claimed that President Robert Mugabe-led Zanu PF, was forcing
members
of the public to submit their names and national identification
numbers to
Zanu PF youths who were moving around in a door-to-door campaign.
In
volatile high density suburbs such as Mbare and the town of Chitungwiza,
for
instance, Zanu PF youths have allegedly been forcing people to buy the
party’s membership cards as well as provide voter registration slips for
those who would have registered at the Registrar General’s
office.
However, Zec yesterday told more than 20 political parties that
excluded
Zanu PF that such a practice is an infringement of human rights
which may
affect the holding of a free and fair election.
Zanu PF
snubbed the consultative meeting that was graced by the two MDC
formations
in the unity government and several smaller parties that
included, the
Zimbabwe Freedom Party, the National Development Party and a
new party Good
of the People.
Bessie Nhandara, Zec’s commissioner responsible for voter
education said the
parties should let people make a choice of whether they
want to participate
in polls or not.
“Let us not force people to go
and register as voters and political parties
should not help people even
with transport — that should be for the people
to decide.
“Political
parties should not ask for people’s ID numbers in order to have
them
registered. That is the responsibility of Zec.
“We now have our teams on
the ground and they will be educating people on
voter registration. We are
warning parties to stop such practices,” she
said.
http://www.voazimbabwe.com/
Irwin
Chifera
06.06.2013
HARARE — Finance Minister Tendai Biti today
launched three poverty survey
reports whose findings he says need to be
addressed urgently if the country
is to effectively deal with socio-economic
problems and poverty.
Mr. Biti said the surveys show that 63 percent of
Zimbabweans are poor with
16 percent living in extreme poverty.
The
three reports - the Poverty Income and Consumption and Expenditure
Survey,
the Poverty Datum Line Analysis, and the Demographic and Health
Survey -
were produced by the Zimbabwe National Statistics Agency.
Major findings
of the poverty reports are that 70 percent of rural
households are poor
compared to 38 percent in urban areas.
The reports show that Matabeleland
North has the highest percent of
households in poverty at 81.7
percent.
Mr. Biti said these and other findings are depressing.
He
said the reports dispel some statistics that unemployment in Zimbabwe
stands
at above 85 percent as they show that most Zimbabweans are
economically
active.
The minister said the reports show that government must come up
with
policies to counter the rapid growth of poverty in the country adding
this
must include equitable allocation of resources to every section of the
society.
With poverty remaining predominantly a rural problem, Mr.
Biti, said there
is need for viable drought mitigation programs to alleviate
poverty in rural
areas.
The finance minister said the reports provide
crucial data for evidence
based policy formulation and decision making.
http://www.voazimbabwe.com/
Gibbs
Dube
06.06.2013
WASHINGTON DC — The European Union today launched an
export helpdesk in
Harare expected to boost trade between Zimbabwe and the
27-member bloc of
developed nations.
According to the EU Ambassador
to Zimbabwe Aldo Dell'Ariccia, 100 exporters
of various commodities attended
the launch seminar in the capital, focusing
on the use of the free online
helpdesk.
Mr. Dell’Ariccia says the informative service, which was
launched worldwide
in 2004, is a one-stop shop to inform businesses in
developing countries
like Zimbabwe on how to export goods to the
EU.
He says in a few clicks, businesses can find the EU requirements,
taxes,
tariffs, preferential arrangements, rules of origin and the necessary
export
and import statistics.
“It is a free online service which
permits the business community to have
all relevant information needed for
the export of their products to the EU.
This will enable them to make an
informed decision about exports to the
27-member bloc,” says Mr.
Dell’Ariccia.
Zimbabwe last year ratified an economic partnership
agreement signed by the
EU and Eastern and Southern African (ESA) nations,
making the ESA region the
first of four African regions on the continent to
have a partnership
agreement with the European nations.
“This means
that all the products exported from Zimbabwe to the European
Union have
access to these markets with half a billion people. They will
have this
access free of quarters and free of duty which means they don’t
have to pay
taxes when the products are imported in the EU and people do not
have
restrictions in terms of quantity,” said Ambassador Dell’Ariccia.
He
says this helpdesk will therefore help exporters to make sure that they
take
full advantage of the opportunities that the EU offers as a market.
He
further says total trade between the European Union and Zimbabwe in 2012
amounted to $800 million. “There is a positive trade balance for Zimbabwe as
the country exported to the EU $170 million more than what it imported from
the EU.”
Mr. Dell’Ariccia says Zimbabwe’s total exports to the EU
amounted to $500
million and imports of EU goods to the country were pegged
at $300 million.
Zimbabwe exports to the EU various commodities including
copper, sugar,
flowers, cotton, fermented tea and leather. It imports
vehicles, chemicals
and other goods from the European nations.
http://www.thezimbabwemail.com/
Staff Reporter 20 hours
39 minutes ago
MEIKLES LIMITED will start mining operations next year
after its investment
vehicle, Meikles Resources, obtained a special mining
grant in the Midlands
province, the group said in a statement Meikles Hotel
in Harare’s
contribution to revenue was constrained due to renovations
yesterday.
Meikles owner business mogul John Moxon, widely regarded as
one of the
richest men in Zimbabwe, has nailed his political colours firmly
to the Zanu
PF mast by donating brand new vehicles to spearhead the party’s
campaign for
crucial general elections later this year, the local weekly
business
newspaper Zimbabwe Independent said in February this
year.
Moxon, Meikles Africa Ltd chairman, handed over the vehicles to
Zanu PF
secretary for administration Didymus Mutasa at the party
headquarters last
year to boost President Robert Mugabe and his party’s bid
to remain in
power.
The special grant allows the group to prospect
for various minerals,
including iron ore and chrome.
Meikles said it
also had opportunities relating to gold and tantalite. “We
plan to have at
least one mine in operation in 2014,” the statement said.
In a report by
the State media, Meikles said “We have signed a Memorandum of
Understanding,
which will shortly become a full shareholders’ agreement,
with a substantial
technical partner to pursue these opportunities,
including the provision of
necessary capital, skills and expertise in
mining.”
The Zimbabwe
Stock Exchange-listed firm could not say how much investment is
needed to
start the mine but indicated “the division will raise its own
capital and
will not be dependent on the group’s financial resources”.
During the
year end to March 31, 2013, the group reported a revenue increase
of 11
percent from US$354,1 million to US$391,3 million, boosted by
supermarket
sales. But the group managed to make an operating profit of
US$5,1 million
compared with a loss of US$8,3 million in the same period
last
year.
Supermarket division contributed US$335,9 million compared with
US$296,4
million last year, followed by the agriculture division which
contributed
US$24,2 million from US$20 million in the prior
year.
Hotel contribution to revenue was overall constrained due to
renovations at
the Meikles Hotel in Harare and Victoria Falls. The Victoria
Falls Hotel’s
revenue increased relative to the previous year due to
improved room rates.
A deliberate decision to curtail credit saw revenue
from Thomas Meikles
Stores declining from US$24 million to US$18,5
million.
Cash flow from operations increased by 243 percent from US$6,1
million to
US$21 million. About US$18,3 million was spent on refurbishments
at the
hotels and supermarkets. Net borrowings rose by US$14,3 million to
US$59
million, including a long-term debt of US$7,4 million.
Total
assets grew by 7 percent to US$275,5 million with current assets
declining
by 32 percent to US$69,6 million due to the disposal of US$38
million worth
of assets which were held for sale in the prior year.
Current liabilities
grew by 23 percent due to an increase in short-term
debt, trade and other
payables. Thus, the current ratio deteriorated from
1,2 to 0,66 as
short-term obligations increased.
Meikles highlighted the challenge the
company is facing in accessing its
Initial Public Offer funds deposited with
the Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe,
amounting to US$26 million and the impact it
is having on the gearing
position of the company.
The funds on
deposit with the central bank originated from the listing of
the group on
both the Zimbabwe and London stock exchanges and the raising of
funds from a
number of substantial international investors for the benefit
of the
group.
The funds were remitted to Zimbabwe and ultimately placed on the
deposit to
be used for balance of payments support.
“We have without
success engaged both the RBZ and the Ministry of Finance in
an attempt to
negotiate arrangement whereby access to these funds may be
facilitated,”
said the group. “In the circumstances, we deem it appropriate
to further
escalate our efforts to access these funds.”
The management said believed
if it had had an opportunity to utilise this
money, the interest burden on
the financial statement would be much less
than the current situation. Going
forward, the company said “the group’s
fortunes will be affected if the
funds held on deposits at the RBZ are not
made available”.
Moxon ––
once targeted by Zanu PF bigwigs during the controversial Kingdom
Meikles
Africa Ltd demerger saga — reportedly played an important role in
the
acquisition of an assortment of single and double-cab 4×4 vehicles,
including ranges of Toyota Hilux, Nissan NP300s, Ford Ranger and Mazda
BT50s.
Curiously, around the same time, Moxon’s flagship company
Meikles Africa
Ltd, formed a mining arm, Meikles Resources (Pvt) Ltd, and
applied for a
diamond mining licence with the Zimbabwe Mining Development
Corporation
(ZMDC) as a possible partner in a joint venture.
It was
not clear whether the vehicle donation was linked to the application
for the
diamond mining licence although sources said the two could not be
separated.
However, Moxon said Meikles had not supplied vehicles, but
said a company
“with whom we have a connection” donated some vehicles,
claiming he was not
sure of the beneficiary.
“A company with whom we
have a connection donated a small number of
vehicles, but I’m not sure
exactly whom they were donated to as we have not
seen any registration
certificates,” said Moxon.
He said 500 or more vehicles would cost over
US$15 million, adding no one
connected to him would have that kind of
money.
Zanu PF spokesperson Rugare Gumbo declined to comment, referring
questions
to Mutasa.
When approached for comment, Mutasa said: “Tell
me who is the source of your
story. If you can’t tell me then I won’t
comment.”
http://www.newzimbabwe.com/
05/06/2013 00:00:00
by
Staff Reporter
PRIME Minister Morgan Tsvangirai and
Professor Welshman Ncube’s MDC
formations and three other political parties
have rejected the election
deadline set by the country’s top court and
hinted at the possibility of
forming a grand coalition to fight the next
elections.
The Constitutional Court last week ordered President Robert
Mugabe to set a
date before the end of July for crucial elections in a case
filed by
Harare-based activist Jealousy Mawarire in which he argued that the
failure
to proclaim a poll date had violated his rights.
In a joint
statement soon after emerging from a lengthy crisis meeting at
Harare’s
Crown Plaza Hotel, the leaders of the five parties resolved to take
the push
for a later election date to SADC’s Extra-ordinary SADC summit in
Maputo,
Mozambique at the weekend.
“The leaders expressed reservations about the
practicality of the July 31st
deadline set by the Court and resolved that
they will communicate their
position to SADC,” read the statement which was
presented to the media by
Tsvangirai.
“The parties therefore look
forward to the Extra-ordinary SADC summit to
affirm previous SADC
resolutions and agreed roadmap to elections.”
Tsvangirai stood in his
MDC-T party while the Ncube-led MDC was represented
by deputy president
Edwin Mushoriwa. Mavambo Kusile Dawn was represented by
party leader Simba
Makoni while Dumiso Dabengwa stood in for Zapu and
Reketai Semwayo
represented Zanu Ndonga.
The parties said by upholding Mawarire's claim
that his rights had been
violated the top court may have infringed on the
rights of millions of other
Zimbabweans.
“The (leaders) note that the
court action, ironically supposedly informed by
the desire to safeguard the
rights of the individual applicant, has resulted
in the infringement of the
rights of millions of Zimbabweans, in particular
the right to eligible
voters to have adequate time to register to vote and
elect a government of
their choice in a free and fair environment,” read the
statement.
The
parties said they feared the country would slide back to the 2008
political
paralysis which resulted in the formation of the inclusive
government if
attempts to short-circuit the process were to succeed.
Responding to
questions by journalists, Tsvangirai accused President Mugabe
of double
standards after the veteran leader told the media in Japan this
week he was
would respect the Constitutional Court ruling.
“I doubt whether that
position is sincere. If the question of respecting the
rule of law and court
decisions is anything to go by, lam sure it’s a
dishonest position,” said
the MDC-T leader.
Tsvangirai cited his 2002 court challenge against his
defeat by Mugabe which
he said has still not been heard insisting the rule
of law was being applied
selectively in Zimbabwe.
“And lam sure that
if he is committed to the rule of law it must apply in
all cases and not to
change the law to suit yourself. So we can’t change
goalposts when it comes
to the law. The law cannot be applied selectively.
It has to be applied in
all cases,” he said.
The parties further mooted the possibility of a
loose pre-election coalition
against President Mugabe and his Zanu
PF.
“We and the organisations that we lead are committed to working together
both among ourselves and with others like minded in order to improve the
conditions of life of Zimbabweans,” said Makoni.
“We have cooperated
on this one matter today because we have judged it
important that we should
work together. When such similar other matters
present themselves, we will
not hesitate to work together again in order to
bring benefits to the people
of Zimbabwe,” he said.
MDC's Edwin Mushoriwa insisted it was still within
the capabilities of the
Constitutional Court to revise its unpopular
ruling.
He further accused President Mugabe of double standards after the
89 year
old leader opposed another Supreme Court ruling a few months ago
which
compelled him to call for by-elections in three Matabeleland
constituencies.
Dabengwa said the parties would take the matter up with
SADC if they fail to
reach an agreement with Mugabe.
“Well we intend
to take the matter further so that SADC also aware.”
Tsvangirai added: “I
want to remind you that SADC (and the) AU are committed
to resolving the
political crisis in Zimbabwe (and) that resolution can
only come when there
is a free and fair legitimate and uncontested outcome.”
http://www.dailynews.co.zw/
By Guthrie Munyuki, Senior
Assistant Editor
Thursday, 06 June 2013 14:56
HARARE - MDC youth
leader Solomon Madzore spent 405 days at Chikurubi
Maximum Prison as he was
jointly charged with 28 others for allegedly
murdering a
policeman.
Recently, he was charged for insulting or undermining the
president after
prosecutors said he called President Robert Mugabe a
“limping old donkey” at
a party rally in Mushumbi Pools, Mbire.
As
Zimbabwe prepares to hold crunch elections whose dates are expected to be
announced very soon following a Constitutional Court ruling ordering Mugabe
to proclaim dates and hold the plebiscite before July 31, Madzore told the
Daily News he has no hard feelings about his torment.
Instead, the
lanky MDC youth leader says Zimbabwe needs healing for it to
move
forward.
“I would never want to see Mugabe behind bars. I think there has
to be time
for healing and there has to be time for progress. There has to
be time for
development. I think we have to agree on that,” Madzore
said.
“It’s non-negotiable. For me forgiveness is all we need in this
country. I
know they (Mugabe and his allies) have done very heinous things
against our
people. But I believe strongly that where forgiveness is found,
progress is
also attendant to that.”
Madzore was arrested in May 2011
with 28 others for allegedly murdering
Inspector Petros Mutedza at Glen View
3 Shopping Centre according to the
State.
He spent close to
one-and-a-half years in remand prison in one of the high
profile cases to be
brought before the courts during the life of the
inclusive
government.
Rights groups claimed the arrests and the current trial are
an assault on
the pro-democracy movements.
However, the State maintains
emotions must be separated from the trial as it
has a strong case against
the suspects.
But Madzore does not see the reason to hold grudges,
whether justified or
not — choosing to take the root of peace and
forgiveness.
“In fact, I think I have already forgiven those guys who
imprisoned me for
close to one-and-a-half years. And I meet them, and we
laugh, we talk. Who
am I not to forgive?
“I think forgiveness is
Godly. And we would all want to go back to our
likeness. I am a Christian. I
believe in what the Bible says. God created us
in His own image,” said
Madzore.
“I think it’s about love. It’s about forgiveness. Zimbabwe needs
love. This
is the missing link in this country. The more we pray; the more
we believe
in forgiveness and the more we can move forward. I am not bitter
at all. I
have gone past that.”
Madzore believes the MDC’s quest to
bring change has been hazardous but
remains alive amongst the party’s
supporters and the general populace.
“I have travelled this journey and
it has been a very arduous trip towards
what we believe to be the real
transformation for this country. What drives
me is the quest to see a better
Zimbabwe where each and everyone of us as
Zimbabweans, is able to exercise
their rights.
“I have been in touch with so many people across many
provinces around the
country. People are not able to exercise their right to
free speech.”
The aspiring MP for Dzivaresekwa said the current
environment makes it
difficult to promote and recognise people’s rights,
such as freedoms of
expression, peaceful assembly and
association.
Zimbabwe has some of the harshest laws in the world that are
synonymous with
dictatorship.
Among them are the nefarious Access to
Information and Protection of Privacy
Act (Aippa), Public Order Security Act
(Posa) and the overly used Criminal
Law (Codification and Reform)
Act.
These directly and indirectly curtail free press, freedom of
expression and
peaceful assembly.
Critics say these have been used to
silence the media and opposition
political parties to the benefit of Zanu
PF.
But cases of harassment against the media and opposition parties
receded
with the consummation of the inclusive government.
Madzore,
however, expressed disappointment with the way the inclusive
government has
handled its business.
“It was our strong belief that through the GPA
(Global Political Agreement)
executive authority was going to be shared
equally between the winner of
March 29, 2008 elections, Morgan Tsvangirai
and Mugabe. That’s what we
believed,” Madzore told the Daily
News.
“But I want to say looking back now I think we were very wrong. I
am really
very disappointed in how the GPA was implemented. There are so
many things
that were left hanging. There was an issue of rotating
ministries that was
never done.
“And you have got Mugabe leading his
team in Zanu PF behaving like big
brother in the inclusive government. For
us this has been a very tiring
journey. I don’t think I would want to see it
going beyond its envisaged
lifespan.
“I am one of those people who
think the inclusive government did what it
could, it stabilised the economy,
violence has been going on but we are very
disappointed in the behaviour of
the president of this country. He treats
the prime minister as if he is a
political novice, as if he did not win the
election yet he (Mugabe) is the
beneficiary of the GPA.”
Madzore, while lauding the positives in the new
Constitution, remains
sceptical of Mugabe protecting the citizens’ rights,
at least between now
and the elections.
He believes the MDC will form
the next government.
“Sometimes I used to think that if you take the
American Constitution and
bring it to Zimbabwe; the million dollar question
that you would ask Mugabe
would be, will he implement it in the same manner
the Americans do?
“I think the answer will be very simple. The answer
will be no. We need a
new political culture to be inculcated into the minds
of the people. I think
you are talking of a system that has overstayed in
power. For me, Mugabe has
been institutionalised.
You are looking at
a situation where people have not been able to provide an
alternative.
“While I have hope that something positive is in the
making, and you would
also want to recognise that there are so many reforms
that have been
brought forward by the new charter, but I want to be
sceptical about Mugabe
and Zanu PF officials being able to safeguard
people’s rights.
“The past speaks of itself; they have failed dismally. I
would want to
believe this is the very same reason why we must ensure that
the forthcoming
elections are going to be free, fair peaceful and its
outcome must not be
contested by all the political parties contesting for
power,” said Madzore.
He said the MDC was ready for the elections and its
structures have been
activated to mobilise the youths to register to
vote.
“We are going to ensure that people get registered as voters. We
have a very
clear position as the youth assembly that there shall be no
election without
voter registration because that is a total disregard of the
people’s rights.
“As much as we want to respect as a party the decision
that was given out by
the Supreme Court (Constitutional Court) that
elections should be held by
the July 31st; we don’t have a problem with
that. But we have problems with
a scenario where such a pronouncement is not
met with reforms that we have
been clamouring for.”
Madzore said
their youth policy was clear on what needs to be done for young
Zimbabweans,
both in the political movements, church and civic groups.
“The party’s
youth policy is very clear; it begins and ends with the people.
We are
coming from a backdrop where the MDC youth assembly is not
necessarily an
autonomous body in the party.
“We are part of the bigger picture, which
is the party. We have a clear
vision where young people are actually part of
the main structure of the
economy. Our policy has various functions. We are
proponents of free
education for young people during their primary
education. We believe that
it is the State’s role to ensure that youngsters
go to school for free.
“There has been a lot of burden on the shoulders
of parents. You hear of
issues of incentives in schools and that is very
burdensome. So we are
saying free education as far as primary education is
concerned. We would
want to see grants coming back and we would want to see
students getting
what they deserve,” said Madzore.
The party has an
upliftment plan which takes a broader approach to include
all classes in
generating jobs and wealth for the people.
It also seeks to provide
optimal health for the nation and remove the
commercialisation of health
services which he says currently dominate the
health services sector.
http://www.dailynews.co.zw/
Thursday, 06 June 2013 11:29
HARARE - Daily
News' political editor Gift Phiri (GP) talks to opposition
Mavambo Kusile
Dawn leader Simba Makoni (SM) about the forthcoming election.
GP: How do
you define yourself as a leader, and why should Mai Rherhi in
Mahenye vote
for you?
SM: I am a team player, who works with others. I place
importance on
consensus rather than unilateral decisions.
I seek high
office to serve, rather than to wield power and control. I am
motivated to
enable and or facilitate others to do things for themselves
rather than I
doing things for them, or trap them into dependence.
I believe in honest,
clean, hardworking and exemplary leadership. I believe
in community and
sharing rather than greed and selfishness. I believe in
kindness and
compassion rather than cruelty and arrogance.
I believe in the equality
of all citizens, and in equity and fairness.
I believe in the oneness of
our country and all its people, and in the right
of all of us to justice,
security, peace, happiness and harmony.
GP: Is your party conducting
primary elections?
SM: Not yet, but we will shortly launch our candidate
selection.
That selection will entail the holding of primary elections,
in cases where
there are more than one candidate vying for the same
seat.
GP: Are you fielding candidates in all the forthcoming harmonised
elections,
I mean municipal, legislative and presidential polls?
SM:
Yes, we plan to participate fully at all levels of the elections.
GP:
Dumiso Dabengwa told a rally held in Gwamayaya communal lands in Nkayi
recently that “We used Makoni to stop the old man (Mugabe) and Tsvangirai
whose track record we did not feel would make him a good president.” He
actually said you were used as a “braai stick”, a Zanu PF project.
Is
this correct and what guarantee is there that your current campaign is
not
another regime project?
SM: I have no evidence that Dumiso said that. But
even if he did say that,
it is not true.
In the statement I issued on
February 5, 2008, I explained why I left Zanu
PF, and why I offered to stand
for the office of President of Zimbabwe as an
independent
candidate.
On July 1, 2009, we launched Mavambo Kusile Dawn as a fully
fledged
political party, under whose auspices many colleagues and I, as law
abiding,
patriotic citizens are contributing our best to get Zimbabwe
working again.
GP: What caused the fallout between MKD and
Dabengwa?
SM: The facts are that Dumiso Dabengwa supported independent
candidate Simba
Makoni in the 2008 presidential election.
In late
2008, he and other former PF Zapu members decided to revive that
party, for
reasons they have explained. On the other hand as stated above,
we launched
Mavambo Kusile Dawn as a party in July 2009.
He and I maintain cordial
relations, and our two organisations liaise with
each other
constantly.
GP: There is talk of talks about a grand coalition involving
yourself and
Tsvangirai. Is there any such dialogue underway, and what are
you
envisaging?
SM: On January 23, 2013, in a formal statement
presented to the media, I
proposed a ‘Grand Coalition for Change’ and called
on all like-minded
Zimbabweans committed to solving the problems of the
country to agree to
work together.
Such like-minded Zimbabweans may
be in politics, civil society, business,
faith organisations, and all other
walks of life.
They may be young or old, men or women, urban or rural, in
the country or
outside, in organisations or just individuals; they are
welcome to
participate in the grand coalition.
We are actively
canvassing this idea to all who care to listen to us.
GP: You are one of
more than 20 presidential candidates. What’s your take on
the number of
candidates, and what does your manifesto say?
SM: I am not aware there
are more than 20 presidential candidates. However,
if there are, that is
democracy.
We are finalising our manifesto. It focuses on healing,
uniting and
reconciling Zimbabweans, thereby eradicating the fear that
currently grips
the nation. It emphasises on empowering citizens, families
and communities
to fend for themselves, rather than waiting for ‘Dai
Hurumende …’
The manifesto exalts honesty, integrity and hard work. We
implore citizens
to patriotism, without turning them into mindless and
thoughtless zombies.
GP: Who funds MKD?
SM: It is funded by our
members, as well as many citizen sympathisers and
well-wishers.
GP:
Ex-ZNA soldier Rtd Major Kudzai Mbudzi, a founding member of MKD claims
you
failed to account for $3 million in cash donated to the party by
well-wishers for your 2008 campaign including cars, 300 000 litres of fuel,
and 100 000 rims of bond paper among other gifts.
These are serious
charges, how do you respond to that ?
SM: Rtd Major Mbudzi was in the
‘Movement of Volunteers’ who supported
independent presidential candidate
Simba Makoni in 2008. A not-for-profit
Trust was established to mobilise,
deploy, husband and account for resources
for the independent candidate’s
campaign.
As stated countless times before, MKD was launched on July 1st,
2009.
Rtd Maj Mbudzi was no longer working with us from October 2008, and
is,
therefore, not a founder of MKD party.
GP: How do you plan to
tackle corruption?
SM: First, through my own anti-corrupt behaviour, and
not tolerating
corruption among colleagues in leadership with
me.
Then, by growing a culture of honesty among citizens, through
national
anti-corruption programmes.
Further, by ensuring that State
agencies responsible for enforcing
anti-corruption laws do so without fear
or favour.
GP: Do you think we’ve lost the belief that we can succeed as
Zimbabwe?
SM: No, I have not seen any evidence of that anywhere. On the
contrary, I
see everywhere evidence of a burning desire to succeed, a
resilience to
overcome all impediments. Although notably less so than in
earlier years,
Zimbabweans are still hardworking, still honest and still
ambitious to
succeed.
That is why our motto is ‘Let’s get Zimbabwe
Working Again’.
Violet Gonda’s guest on Hot Seat is Zimbabwean business mogul Mutumwa Mawere, who was recently told by Registrar General Tobaiwa Mudede that he had to renounce his South African citizenship before he could apply for a Zim identification document. Mawere says under the new constitution, signed into law by President Mugabe last week, an individual cannot be denied dual citizenship if they were born in Zimbabwe. There are tens of thousands of Zimbabweans in the Diaspora who were born in the country, but have taken citizenship in foreign countries where they now live and work. The businessman has now written to the Registrar General, who is the authority that administers the Citizenship Act, and has given him a deadline to make an official response explaining the status of the dual citizenship provisions in the Constitution, or he will seek redress in the Constitutional Court.
Broadcast: 30 May 201 3
VIOLET GONDA: Zimbabwe’s citizenship law has come under the spotlight again after a well known businessman with foreign citizenship was told by the country’s Registrar General Tobaiwa Mudede that dual citizenship is not permissible in the country. Mutumwa Mawere gives us the details in the Hot Seat programme.
MUTUMWA MAWERE: What happened is I did go to the Registrar General to establish citizenship and I applied for the identity document and I was then referred to the Registrar General who then advised that the proper procedure and the only procedure, is for me to first come through immigration and then following that, then apply for Residence and then to be followed by an application for citizenship. As you know foreign born persons who wish to naturalize as Zimbabwe citizens are required to go through a roadmap that includes initially residency and then that is followed by citizenship as I think the same situation applies in the United Kingdom.
GONDA: So in your case, you were born in Zimbabwe but you also have South African citizenship.
MAWERE: I was born in Zimbabwe, naturalized as a South African citizen, which means first I was a resident of South Africa, then I applied for citizenship having completed the minimum period that is required to apply one to apply for citizenship; and by operation of the Zimbabwe Citizenship Act it meant that when I acquired South African citizenship I forfeited the right to Zimbabwean citizenship. I think some people have misconstrued that I did renounce Zimbabwean citizenship but there’s no provision in terms of Zimbabwean law for someone to renounce citizenship when you are naturalized in a foreign state and the same situation applies to South Africa. South Africa would not permit me to renounce South African citizenship unless I have the citizenship of another state and those facts were brought before the Registrar General and he simply dismissed that reality.
So what happens is, in the case of what the Registrar General is proposing, is that I will go to Zimbabwe – and for me to leave South Africa it is common cause that I must be a holder of a valid passport and that passport would have to be a South African travel document. If I renounce South African citizenship then it means I can’t travel to Zimbabwe anyway to establish residence in Zimbabwe. So what he is proposing is that I go to South Africa, I go to Zimbabwe holding South African citizenship and then apply and then have residence, have a minimum of five to ten years before I can even be considered as a Zimbabwean or a Zimbabwean citizen. That is the absurdity that the Registrar General is proposing that, not just for me but for all the people who were born in Zimbabwe and by birth are qualified to be Zimbabwean citizens.
GONDA: Doesn’t the new constitution allow you to have dual citizenship?
MAWERE: I did raise that issue that in light of the new constitution I thought dual citizenship was permissible and he says no that’s not the case. Even under the new constitution one still has the obligation to renounce foreign citizenship before you can apply for Zimbabwe citizenship – that’s the version of the Registrar General. So I said to him – then what was the point of amending the constitution? I am a Zimbabweans, as a Zimbabwean born person you automatically have a right to acquire citizenship when you can’t even exercise that right in terms of the law? He says that is the case. If I have any queries I must refer to Honourable Chinamasa the Minister of Justice – which I said how does the Minister of Justice come in? Either the constitution stipulates this and is applicable once it’s in force then one doesn’t have the obligation to renounce another citizenship because that gives you an automatic right to citizenship and the only way to exercise this is by you obtaining the document that pursuant to the operation of the Zimbabwean laws. And clearly the Zimbabwe constitution and the Zimbabwe Citizenship Act are not speaking to each other and therefore the extent of citizenship by birth – it will appear that the Zimbabwe Citizenship Act is unconstitutional and that’s the point I made to the Registrar General.
GONDA: So what are you going to do?
MAWERE: Like everyone else – is to make sure that this position is in writing because I find no legal authority supporting the version of the Registrar General. What I do know is that under the new constitution it’s very clear that any person who is Zimbabwean-born, whose parents, either the father of the mother is Zimbabwean, is automatically entitled to citizenship but obviously the Registrar General is not a registrar of citizenship. He may be a registrar of political citizenship because he seems to have powers from God which gives him the right to appropriate citizenship as he wishes not as the constitution says.
GONDA: So what would be the right forum to approach in a situation like this if the Registrar General is saying something that is totally different from what is in the new constitution?
MAWERE: Obviously the right forum would be the court to conclusively establish whether it was the intention of the drafters of this constitution and the people who voted that they would insert a provision which gives a right that cannot be exercised. So I’ll definitely have to take this issue for a review by the courts but up to now I’ve yet to receive a written statement from the Registrar General confirming that the position that he asserted is the legal position and a constitutional one.
GONDA: Why do you think this is happening and what are the implications, especially for the many Zimbabweans who are in a similar situation?
MAWERE: After 33 years of Independence there are a number of absurd occurrences in Zimbabwe. This is just one of many so anything is possible in Zimbabwe so one cannot put this as a special case but obviously the constitution supports the position that Zimbabwean citizenship is open and qualified for anyone who is born in Zimbabwe or outside Zimbabwe but of Zimbabwean parentage. That is the position but obviously the Registrar General for different reasons may wish this to be different but I would presume that the fact that this issue is being discussed and people are digesting what is happening in respect of, not just my case, there could very well be many people whose rights have been also affected, who don’t know what would happen.
Just imagine Violet if you were to die in the UK and your body is to be buried in Zimbabwe it may very well be the case that the Registrar General may refuse your body to be buried in Zimbabwe because you are now deemed to be foreign. This is how absurd it is. Also for instance somebody who left home and got married to a foreign born person and decides to come back home, they’ll now be subjected to an application for residence in their country of birth. What we do know is that in any other country, except the country of birth, one applies for citizenship but in the country of birth one doesn’t apply to be born and one doesn’t have a decision to make as to which place one is born and what the Registrar General is now proposing is that Zimbabwean born persons must also apply as if they were born in the air.
GONDA: How do you respond to your critics who are saying that this is a publicity stunt and that you are only doing this as you want to participate in the forthcoming elections?
MAWERE: Obviously history when it is being made, it looks like publicity but if underpinning that experience there is no issue then I can’t create an issue out of nothing but if people believe that they are secure, safe and with this kind of interpretation then one cannot help them. There’s no better time to test this case than when the constitution is coming into force. This could have been somebody else, it just so happens that it’s me and obviously because of the profile I was targeted. I went there as an ordinary person to seek, to establish citizenship. If I was just an ordinary person with citizenship elsewhere, I don’t think I would have been subjected to the treatment or even to the VIP treatment of meeting the Registrar General when I’m applying just for an identity document. That doesn’t call for the Registrar General to meet somebody. I consider myself privileged to have been invited to meet the Registrar General although I had no intention of meeting with him. But not many people would be given that honour and that privilege to meet with the Registrar General.
So to the extent that I did meet, if I kept it to myself having established this absurdity then it would be an injustice on other people who may be subjected to the same – because as you can imagine, it is very difficult for anyone to know what status you have because when you take foreign citizenship that occurs outside the borders of Zimbabwe and if it occurs outside the borders and knowledge of the Registrar General it means he has no personal knowledge of your status. It’s only relevant for me because my status was known; I never sought to publicize my status because it was irrelevant. But it only came to the fore when these guys tried to use dirty tricks in Zimbabwe and that’s how it came to be known.
That’s how you know I’m a holder of South African citizenship but even when I was elected by Zanu PF in the provincial structures of Zanu in Masvingo, I was already a South African citizen, but no one knew about it because it was not relevant. But now it is common cause what citizenship I hold and it’s common cause what is happening. That’s why it has become relevant. If we don’t test this ourselves who is going to test it for us?
GONDA: So you said you were actually personally invited to see the Registrar General himself? Tobaiwa Mudede?
MAWERE: Firstly I went to apply in the ordinary course of business for an ID. At no stage did I seek to meet with the Registrar General. In the course of processing my ordinary application I then became the guest of the most senior person in that office and how did I acquire that status and how did the Registrar General know of my application? What I was told is that in the computer system my name was already flagged – the fact that I have a South African passport was already in the system which means for anyone else who goes to apply, they will give their ID documents and they will not even know that you are a holder of a foreign citizenship but in my case that is not the way I am now treated. So I’m already treated as a special person anyway by the system so whatever I do it’s now no longer a private matter.
GONDA: Right, did you try to get hold of the other political actors in the GNU to find out what they think about these latest developments since they are the ones who wrote this new constitution which allows dual citizenship by birth.
MAWERE: Yes as you appreciate once the constitution has been put into place it ceases to be political football for parties, it now becomes a state matter so I can only meet the Registrar General who has the power and authority to administer the Citizenship Act so that’s what I did but obviously some of the political actors that you refer to are in the government and they will be aware of it. They maybe affected to the extent that the political parties that they represent may have members who fall into the same category and their silence can only be an issue that you investigate, not for me. I can only deal with the officer of the state in resolving this matter but I do hope that if my matter is resolved it will then open the door or clear the way for other people who may feel insecure or who may not know what is to become of them if they acquire the status that I now have – because ordinarily you will keep your foreign passport as a private matter, between you and the state concerned, it would not have any effect or impact on Zimbabwe but it would appear that my relationship with the South African government or the South African state is of such importance to Zimbabwe that the Registrar General feels that I’m not entitled to the right that is enshrined in the constitution.
GONDA: Are you planning to contest in the forthcoming elections?
MAWERE: No. I hear that in the media about a plan and I’ve not been privileged – first I am reputed to have formed a party and yet I don’t even, according to Mudede, qualify to be a Zimbabwean and this party, is a Zimbabwean party that is contesting the Zimbabwe elections and the unfortunate part is that my name becomes associated with a body corporate that should stand on its own. But it’s not unusual for Zimbabwe because it’s the only country where political parties have surnames where you have MDC-this, MDC-that, Zanu PF also has a surname but all the parties have surnames so it has become customary for people to expect parties to belong to somebody. So one person with two eyes, two hands, and two ears is now presumed to follow a party. That will be a most unusual party where I’m the follower and I’m the leader. I’ve not called anyone to say follow me because there’s nothing to follow.
What I do wish is that Zimbabwe deserves better; Zimbabwe actually has to rise above the thinking of people like Mudede the Registrar General and he should not be afraid of anyone having the right to vote. After all the liberation movement was fought to allow people to express themselves freely. So I don’t see that Zimbabwe can advance itself with small minds.
GONDA: Do you think he was serious? Perhaps he was just… (interrupted)
MAWERE: He was serious, he was serious! He actually wanted me to surrender the passport to him, hand over my South Africa passport to him. I said no. He said; ‘but Mawere how do I make sure you will renounce this SA citizenship I cannot take chances with you.’ That is when I said you are an idiot – under what laws do I surrender a South African property to you?
GONDA: What do you think it is really about?
MAWERE: Most people obviously when you leave home, they think you have deserted home, they think you have turned your back on home. Mudede when he was born, he only knew of one nationality so he has not known anything else except the government of Zimbabwe. After all do you know how old he is now? He is now 69 and the retirement age is 65. The man will only go when Mugabe goes. They have signed a contract that ‘we have no other life except to be in the government of Zimbabwe’. So the fight is going to be long.
GONDA: On Tuesday 4 June the Zimbabwean businessman filed an urgent application calling for the Constitutional Court to confirm the provisions regarding the issue of dual citizenship and to stop the voter registration exercise, which was supposed to restart on Monday, until his case is finalised.
http://nehandaradio.com/2013/06/06/zimbabwe-wall-of-shame-kembo-mohadi/
By Lance Guma
Co-Home Affairs Minister Kembo Mohadi was implicated in the 1999 murder of Lutheran World Federation employee Strover Mutonhori and has since then used his control of the police to kill off any investigations into the case.
It was reported that Mutonhori worked with Mohadi’s wife Tambudzani and the two allegedly had an affair. Mutonhori disappeared from the Omadu Hotel in Kezi, only for his remains to be found in Mzingwane outside Bulawayo.
Soon after the murder, family members were harassed by suspected state security agents.
In May 2001 a team of police officers from the Criminal Investigation Department (CID) travelled to South Africa and interviewed a number of people in connection with the murder.
The matter was transferred from Matabeleland South to the Special Investigating Branch at the Police General Headquarters in Harare. The officer investigating was identified as Chief Superintendent C. R. Gora.
Although police finally interviewed Mohadi, who was then Deputy Minister of Local Government, Public Works and National Housing, he was later promoted to Home Affairs Minister in 2002.
This effectively put a stop to any chance of a proper investigation, since the police fell under his Ministry.
“I did not appoint myself Minister. The Mutonhori family is free to contact me or my lawyers, instead of communicating with me through the Press,” Mohadi told journalists. Mutonhori’s family have kept up the fight for justice.
In January 2007 they sought the intervention of the Attorney General and the President’s Office to try and open up investigations into the murder case. But it was reported that the docket had disappeared and the evidence tampered with.
Mohadi remains co-Home Affairs Minister and is in charge of the same police force that is supposed to be investigating him. The Mutonhori family say their best chance for justice is either a cabinet reshuffle or a new government.
In March 2010, Jane Dongo, a family member, wrote an open letter to Mohadi saying; “It is now 10 years since my uncle Strover Mutonhori was murdered, but we are still waiting for the Minister of Home Affairs Kembo Mohadi, to prove that there is rule of law, justice and that he has not covered up his own tracks in this murder case.”
Dongo wrote several letters, one through the Zimbabwean embassy in London, and several directly at Mohadi in Harare – but no reply.
“I call upon Mr. Mohadi to come clean and be proven innocent in the courts so that we can put this case to rest” she said at the time. She even quoted remarks by then Home Affairs Minister Dumiso Dabengwa who in 1999 said;
“Zimbabwe will not tolerate a situation where people are kidnapped and murdered. The culprit will definitely be brought to book. It has been brought by a colleague in our weekly Cabinet meeting and there will not be any cover up”.
Dongo said that Mohadi, who was then Deputy Minister of Local Government, Public Works and National Housing, wrote a letter to Mutonhori asking to meet him at the Ambassador Hotel in Harare. Mohadi did not say why he wanted the meeting but offered to take him back home at the end of it.
“It was the last week of February, that is 1999 when Mutonhori had come to Harare when he was off-duty and I remember very well, according to that letter because the letter was written by Kembo Mohadi.
“He cannot deny it, he wrote it in his own handwriting. If it was going to be proved, his handwriting, the authenticity of the handwriting, I’m quite sure and he signed it “KB”; Kembo Mohadi signed that letter,” Dongo said.
Sensing something was wrong Mutonhori is said to have declined to meet the Deputy Minister. It’s suspected that Mohadi was following up on allegations that Mutonhori was having an affair with his wife, Tambudzani.
The two worked together in Mberengwa. Dongo said the family are in possession of a letter written by Tambudzani to Mutonhori, but in the letter she only discusses the degree program the two were doing at the time.
Because Mutonhori declined to meet Mohadi the family believe that a further plot was hatched to set him up for the kidnapping several days later.
Dongo said what puzzles them is that Mutonhori was not supposed to be at work on the day he was kidnapped, “he was off duty but was called and told – you have got to attend it, you have got to attend it.”
Eventually he went to the workshop at the Omadu Hotel in Kezi.
Mutonhori played soccer that night and around 9pm went to his room. Dongo said delegates to the workshop were booked into rooms in pairs but somebody tampered with the arrangement and gave Mutonhori his own room to ensure he was alone.
Mutonhori was told that the person booked in the room with him was no longer coming since they lived in Bulawayo and would come to workshop the following day.
Dongo said Mutonhori’s kidnapping was meticulously planned. She said the bed was never used on the night.
“Mutonhori was kidnapped with one shoe, one sock. The two hundred Zim dollars which was in his purse was there, the cell phone was there, the suitcase with his clothes was there. Only him and one trainer and one sock were missing.”
Mutonhori went missing on the 1st of March and his decomposing body was only found on the 17th August at the Whitewaters Range in Matopos, “just bones, sheer bones,” Dongo said.
Mutonhori’s wife was able to identify his remains by counting the number of teeth he had in the upper jaw. “She only identified those bones with one tooth which was missing and a belt which he was wearing on that particular day.”
When Mohadi was appointed Home Affairs Minister in 2002, investigations into the case were dropped and evidence went missing.
In May 2011, Mutonhori’s son Ian Tatenda Mutonhori (19) said ever since the murder of his father the family has been struggling to make ends meet. Mutonhori left behind a wife and three children, Ian and two girls (22 and 28).
“My mother is unemployed and can’t get work,’ Ian explained.
An added challenge to finding work is that they keep having to move house, because Mohadi allegedly keeps track of where they are staying and they are afraid of being in one place for too long.
“My dad used to earn a good salary working for an NGO, the Lutheran World Federation, but now things have changed and life is hard for us.”
Sadly, the Mutonhori family still wait for justice.
http://www.politicsweb.co.za/
Vince Musewe
06 June 2013
Vince Musewe says
fewer than ten men of average intelligence are holding 12
million
Zimbabweans to ransom
The evil that men do
The embellished role of
those that served in the liberation struggle for
Zimbabwe has become an
albatross upon our necks.
I cannot believe how our security sector has
become so pernicious in their
claim as our liberators and therefore our
infinite rulers. It is incredible
that 33 years after the effect, we
continue to be denied that very freedom
which they solely claim to have
attained for us. My question is always; what
freedom?
As I listen to
the arguments being presented by ZANU(PF) on why they need to
continue
govern us, it continues to show me how man has become so debased
and
inhuman in his aspiration to hold onto political power and acquire
personal wealth and comfort at the expense of the simple values of human
dignity.
We cannot watch and wait for the army generals masquerading
as politicians
to act and decide for us what is best. I have heard calls
for them to be
fired and for me that would be the right thing to do. Can
less than ten men
of average intelligence hold 12 million of us at such a
costly ransom? In my
opinion, our true freedom can only begin when we begin
to reject the idea
that they have a better plan for us.
The
revelations we now hear everyday from Baba Jukwa must surely make us
realize
how rotten our leadership has become. The evil that permeates our
political
leadership is just too deep to fathom and I can bet there is worse
to come.
In my books anyone who supports ZANU (PF) needs their head read.
Besides
denying Zimbabweans the freedom they deserve, ZANU (PF) has
practically
killed the work ethic that Zimbabweans were once so well known
for. They
have created a society that aspires for instant gratification. The
take over
of land assets by individuals with no clue on farming or any
willingness for
hard work is evident as one drives across the country.
The policies of
Gideon Gono around 2008 which led to the "burning" of money
further
exacerbated the situation where an honest day's work was no longer
necessary. The indigenization policy that seeks to take over for free that
which people have not worked for is the nail in the coffin of hard work,
honesty and integrity. We have become a nation of speculators, schemers and
traders and it will take some doing to change this culture.
My
message to all is that Zimbabwe if we wish the future to be significantly
different prom the past, we will have take the responsibility of creating
it. We must therefore take the leadership now to create new empowered
communities through behaving differently.
For far too long we have
just accepted mediocrity and apathy. We cannot give
the responsibility of
creating a better future for Zimbabwe to the army
generals, the police top
brass or the intelligence services; they are
incapable of thinking beyond
their stomachs.
Time and time again we have seen that liberation cannot
be given unto us,
but must be taken by us. We are our own
liberators.
We however must find joy from Hesiod, the Greek poet's words
that: "He
harms himself who does harm to another, and the evil plan is most
harmful to
the planner"
Vince Musewe is an economist based in Harare.
You may contact him on
vtmusewe@gmail.com
Zimbabwe Election Watch Issue 3 is written in the wake of a Constitutional Court ruling handed down on 31 May which compels the President to hold elections before 31 July 2013. This ZEW summary focuses primarily on the ensuing issues raised by the ruling. The case was brought before the courts by Jealously Mawarire, a private citizen, a registered voter and a member of the Centre for Election Democracy in Southern Africa. His complaint was that his constitutional rights to have elections before the 30th June had been violated by the failure to do so by the President. The court ruling follows endless disputes between the three main parties on when elections should be held. Robert Mugabe's Zanu PF party has been adamant that elections should be held earlier - 29 June 2013 was their preferred date - while the MDC parties have insisted on September/October as a more reasonable time. The later date, the MDCs and others have argued, allows time for necessary legislation to be passed following the acceptance of a new constitution, and also allows time for reforms to be implemented as agreed in the Global Political Agreement (GPA). Zanu PF is resisting implementing reforms, and their push for an early election date has been seen as one way for them to secure elections without reforms. The court ruling also comes one week before the Southern African Development Community (SADC) holds a special summit on 9 and 10 June 2013 in Mozambique to discuss and approve a roadmap for Zimbabwe's elections. How the various parties respond to the ruling will have consequences for clauses in the SADC electoral guidelines. Two of these are of particular concern to election weary and violence wary ordinary Zimbabweans: in particular, 4.1.1 compelling governments to protect the constitutional and legal guarantees of freedom and rights of the citizens, and 4.1.2 asking governments to provide a conducive environment for free, fair and peaceful elections. Zanu PF has responded with support for the date: Robert Mugabe has said he will comply with the ruling and hold elections before 31 July regardless of objections from his rivals (http://bit.ly/13wQMvg). And both MDCs have publically recognised the importance of the rule of law and their willingness to comply with it: Douglas Mwonzora, spokesperson for MDC-T, said “For the avoidance of any doubt, the MDC is ready for free and fair elections in Zimbabwe. That means for the MDC, the issue is not about the date of the elections, is about the conditions under which these elections are held" (http://bit.ly/17og5Fk). Welshman Ncube, MDC leader, has said "We all need to respect court judgments because not to do so invites anarchy" (http://ht.ly/lILYh). Despite stated support for the principle of the rule of law, the two MDC parties have also expressed serious reservations over the rightness of the ruling. Welshman Ncube, himself a constitutional lawyer, wrote:
The MDC-T said:
The MDC-T has also inferred that they believe the recent appointment of two new judges to the bench was Zanu PF's way of securing judicial advantage for their party in cases like this one. They argue that Robert Mugabe swore in the judges before he assented to the new constitution, and in so doing bypassed the more rigorous new conditions for judicial appointments enshrined in the new constitution. There is clear precedent for Zanu PF influencing judicial appointments that dates back through the last decade right up until the current time: in ZEW Issue 1, for example, we highlighted the current harassment of Justice Charles Hungwe following two judgements he made which did not support the political agenda of Zanu PF hardliners. Senator Coltart, MDC Secretary for Legal Affairs, has also identified a fundamental contradiction in the Constitutional Court ruling, and that is that if all parties are to comply with the ruling, then the only way they can do so is to break the law. He points out that the new constitution specifies a minimum 30 day period for voter registration and inspection exercise which is a fundamental precursor for nomination courts. He points out that the new constitution demands a further 30 days between nomination day and election day:
The confusion and discussion will make its way to the SADC summit this weekend and pressure will be on SADC to broker a way forward. Five of Zimbabwe's political leaders have come together (leaders representing MDC-T, ZAPU, MDC, MKD and ZANU Ndonga) to form a joint position demanding that political and electoral reforms are implemented before the next harmonized elections. In a statement released yesterday, the five said:
SADC, via the office of Jacob Zuma, the South African President and facilitator of Zimbabwe's GPA, has provided some indication for the focus of the meeting:
ZEW continues to log breaches of the SADC electoral principles and guidelines throughout, and eight examples of breaches since Issue 2 are outlined below. The new voter registration drive, as required under the new constitution, was due to start on Monday this week (3 June) but will now only start on 10 June 2013 and run-up until 9 July 2013. The previous registration drive was plagued by problems right up until it concluded. Examples of breaches affecting voter registration in this ZEW issue include funding shortages, an admission by the Zimbabwe Electoral Commission (ZEC) chairperson that the exercise was chaotic, and a serious concern raised by the Women’s Affairs, Gender and Community Development deputy minister Jessie Majome, who noted that the registration exercise disenfranchised women:
Majome's point is a violation of SADC electoral guideline 4.1.3 which compels signatory states to ensure non-discrimination in voters’ registration. And when the Parliamentary Portfolio Committee on Defence and Home Affairs attempted to visit voter registration centres to monitor and inspect the voters’ roll countrywide, their permission to travel was refused by the Clerk of Parliament. Silobela MP, Anadi Sululu, who is also a committee member, described the decision as 'political'. Police obstacles to meetings and voter education continued. Two examples: in Hwange, police falsely accused Zimbabwe Election Support Network (ZESN) officials of illegally carrying out voter education in the region. They confiscated hundreds of materials meant for distribution in the area to encourage people to register to vote. Simba Makoni, leader of the Mavambo / Kusile / Dawn (MKD) party, had police permission to hold a meeting with the Norton Community withdrawn only hours before the meeting was scheduled to start. Finally, in previous ZEW issues we have highlighted extreme partisanship on the part of security sector leaders. In this issue, three police officers found themselves charged with contravening the Police Act because they attended a political rally - an allegation they deny. The difference in this case is that the police officers apparently attended an MDC-T ralley. Noting the very different approaches to these men and the heads of the security sector, Zimbabweans will infer that political partisanship is acceptable within the security sector, provided it is supportive of the Zanu PF party. Broke ZEC urged to rope in NGOs for voter education
~ http://bit.ly/19IViLM The Zimbabwe Electoral Commission (ZEC) on Wednesday May 8 revealed that a serious shortage of funding is hampering the voter education exercise which is part of preparations for the forthcoming general elections. Briefing journalists in Harare, ZEC chairperson Rita Makarau said that the electoral body had deployed only two voter educators per district, raising fears that these will not be able to cover most areas by the time the exercise ends. On average, a district has about 25 wards. Makarau said out of a budget of $8 million submitted to treasury for the voter education exercise, the commission had so far only received $500,000.She raised concern that if the balance was not released soon the civic education programme, which started a week later than the registration exercise, will be seriously hampered. Elections expert Jack Zaba on Thursday said “ZEC can easily approach the many NGOs and stakeholde rs that work in the field of civic education to help raise awareness of the electoral process. So far ZEC has not done this, we haven’t seen space being given to civic society organisations to do their part."
Voter
outrage ~ http://bit.ly/14wjKMM The Zimbabwe Electoral Commission (Zec) has admitted that the on-going voter registration exercise is chaotic, and there is a growing in government that Registrar General Tobaiwa Mudede is doing a shoddy job and should be fired. Zec chairperson Rita Makarau told church leaders in Harare yesterday May 15: “We accept that there are gaps between what we are saying and what is happening on the ground.” Another Zec commissioner, Petty Makoni, said she witnessed “sad scenes” in Mashonaland Central Province. "when we went out yesterday, we were saddened ... but there was nothing we could do,” said Makoni. Zec says voter registration is in the hands of Mudede and Zec can do little to influence the process. Church leaders said their members are failing to register as voters because of stringent requirements by Mudede’s officers. This comes as government insiders said a meeting of top Cabinet ministers this week roundly condemned the on-going voter registration exercise. Zanu PF ministers who have previously defended Mudede are also outraged after finding irregularities on the voters’ rolls for their constituencies.
Voter
registration nightmare for women ~ http://bit.ly/17E9oP7 Requirements demanded by the Registrar General (RG)’s office for voter registration are leading to massive disenfranchisement of potential women voters, Women’s Affairs, Gender and Community Development deputy minister Jessie Majome said, speaking at a round table discussion hosted by the Media Centre on women participation in politics. Proof of residence disenfranchises women because of the nature of the society we live in. There are very few women who can claim to own a house, let alone a lease agreement in their name...,” said Majome. “Zimbabweans are notorious for not registering marriages and now that there is need for someone to prove where they live it makes it even more difficult. The new draft constitution provides for universal adult suffrage but women have to be on the voters’ roll in order for them to be able to claim the 60 seats reserved for them as well as take up their place among the other 210 legislators,” said Majome.
Zvoma
stirs hornet’s nest over voters’ roll inspections ~ http://bit.ly/ZP2EeU Clerk of Parliament, Austin Zvoma, stirred up a hornet’s nest after blocking the Parliamentary Portfolio Committee on Defence and Home Affairs from monitoring the shambolic mobile voter registration exercise and inspecting the voters’ roll. Zvoma’s move raised eyebrows as the House of Assembly Standing Orders makes it clear that it was the Speaker, Lovemore Moyo, who approves travelling by committees and not the Clerk of Parliament. The portfolio committee, which plays oversight role on the Defence and Home Affairs ministries, last week resolved to visit voter registration centres to monitor and inspect the voters’ roll countrywide as the chaotic scenes were disenfranchising a large number of Zimbabweans who were keen to cast their ballot in the forthcoming elections. Silobela MP Anadi Sululu, who is also a committee member, said Zvoma’s decision to deny them the opportunity to m onitor the exercise and inspect the voters’ roll was “political”.
Police
ban political parties from door-to-door campaigns ~ http://bit.ly/ZP93XF OFFICER Commanding Harare Suburban District, Chief Superintendent Reggies Chitekwe, this week of May 17 announced the ban of door-to-door campaigns to curb political violence which might increase as the country heads for general elections this year. Chitekwe told representatives from the main political parties Zanu PF, MDC-T, MDC and Mavambo/Dawn/Kusile, saying this was an official directive to curb political violence and protect citizens. National police spokesperson Chief Superintendent Paul Nyathi said the regulating authority is given powers to assess situations in their areas as far as security and the safety of citizens is concerned. However, MDC parties’ activists said the move was unfair as Zanu PF has been embarking on door-to-door campaigns since early this year without any arrests taking place. Lately Zanu PF supporters have been accused of carrying out door-to-door voter registration exercis es in high density residential areas checking whether names of citizens above 18 years of age appear on the voters’ roll. Those not found not on the roll were asked to go and register while the registered were given Zanu PF membership forms.
Police
in Hwange summon ZESN and confiscate civic education material ~ http://bit.ly/ZRfadT Yesterday May 28, Sergeant Dzvimbu of Hwange police summoned the ZESN Director and officials to answer charges of allegedly conducting voter education in the province. Later, two police details visited the Hwange offices of ZESN member organisation, Legal Resources Foundation (LRF) offices and confiscated hundreds of ZESN posters and flyers meant for distribution in the province. The materials were confiscated following unsubstantiated and false allegations that ZESN had conducted voter education from the 13th to the 17th of May 2013 without the approval from the Zimbabwe Electoral Commission (ZEC). The materials confiscated include posters and flyers meant to encourage Zimbabweans to register to vote in the impending harmonised elections. According to Mr Settie Ncube, the ZESN taskforce Chairperson for Matabeleland North, the two police officers who were in plain clothes demanded to know the persons responsi ble for distributing the materials before confiscating the posters and flyers. The police officers did not have a search warrant.
Police
thwart Simba Makoni’s meeting with business community ~ http://bit.ly/11YK1qt Efforts by Dr Simba Makoni’s political party to hold discussions with the Norton community a fortnight ago were thwarted, after police went back on their word and withdrew clearance.The Mavambo / Kusile / Dawn (MKD) party had received permission to hold its ‘Conversations with Simba Makoni’ in Norton on Saturday, May 11th. However, a few hours before party president Makoni was due to meet the town’s business community, police withdrew clearance citing missing documentation in the MKD application. MKD official Liberty Mukwakwami told SW Radio Africa Wednesday that when he telephoned Norton police for clarification, a Sergeant Demha could only say the party had not attached an authorisation letter from the owners of the venue. “We asked why the police had not informed us in advance but the officer refused to discuss the issue further, asking us to visit the station instead.” Mukwakwami said this was the first time the authorisation letter had been used to block his party’s meetings. Previous applications had been granted without one.
Detained police officers deny
‘crime’ of attending MDC rally ~ http://bit.ly/1a7jpRH Three police officers, who have been detained over their alleged attendance at an MDC-T rally last month, have denied they are guilty of this ‘crime’. Courage Manyengavana, Marshal Zindoga and Lovemore Mupedzapasi were tried and convicted for contravening the Police Act, after being accused of acting in a manner which brought ‘disrespect’ to the police force. The police claimed that the three officers attended an MDC-T rally held at Mushumbi Business Centre in Mashonaland Central Province on 27th April.The three police officers were reportedly spotted at the rally while in civilian clothing by members of the police’s Internal Security and Intelligence unit. Zindonga and Mupedzapasi were tried by a “trial officer” early this month, while Manyengavana’s trial was conducted in Harare. They were all sentenced to serve 14 days in detention at Chikurubi Support Unit C amp, and their sentence is set to come to an end by the end of this week.He explained that the three might appeal their conviction once their sentence is completed, but he could not confirm is this was the case.
We have a fundamental right to freedom of expression!
|