http://www.theindependent.co.zw/
March 1, 2013 in Politics
CABINET ministers
fiercely clashed on Tuesday in a meeting chaired by
President Robert Mugabe
as tempers flared over the arson attack which led to
the death of a
12-year-old Headlands boy, Christpowers Maisiri, ahead of
do-or-die general
elections expected in July.
Owen Gagare/Wongai
Zhangazha
Christpowers’ father, Shepherd Maisiri, is the MDC-T’s deputy
organising
secretary in Headlands, Manicaland, and has been a victim of
life-threatening acts of political terror for over a decade.
While
cabinet meetings are usually kept secret, Tuesday’s explosive
gathering
spilled into the public domain after it was resolved the boy’s
death and the
resurgence of political violence must be openly condemned
through statements
from the President’s Office, principals and government,
ministers
said.
Presidential spokesperson George Charamba and Information minister
Webster
Shamu issued statements after the tension-filled cabinet meeting
condemning
violence, in line with resolutions of the meeting.
Some of the
resolutions passed by ministers after a bruising cabinet
engagement
include:
That co-Ministers of Home Affairs Kembo Mohadi and Theresa
Makone should
direct the Police Commissioner-General Augustine Chihuri to
investigate the
arson;
Police must hunt down, arrest and prosecute
perpetrators of the fatal
burning;
Police and Jomic (Joint Monitoring
and Implementation Committee) must give
regular security reports to cabinet,
particularly on issues to do with
political violence; and
All
government officials take a united stand on violence and denounce it
unreservedly.
Ministers told the Zimbabwe Independent debate on the
death of Christpowers
dominated cabinet proceedings with ministers of the
two MDC parties engaging
in a no-holds-barred confrontation with their Zanu
PF colleagues.
They said ministers from the MDC formations were united in
condemning the
incident which they viewed as a harbinger to a 2008-like
electoral bloodbath
and were anxious to tackle it head-on in front of
Mugabe.
MDC formations ministers presented a dossier of incidents of
violence
countrywide which have rocked the nation since January.
They
also condemned the crackdown on civil society as evidence of the
deteriorating security situation in the country.
A senior minister
said Minister of State in the Prime Minister’s Office
Jameson Timba ignited
the debate after tabling a motion, zeroing in on the
brutal death of
Christpowers.
Ministerial sources said Timba was supported by Finance
minister Tendai Biti
who directly confronted Minister of State for
Presidential Affairs Didymus
Mutasa over the boy’s death.
Mutasa,
also Zanu PF secretary for administration, is Makoni North MP under
which
Headlands falls. They said Biti tore into Mutasa, accusing him of
addressing
a rally recently where he allegedly said Zanu PF enemies must be
“roasted”.
Biti told Mutasa he was an elder in society and a senior
politician, likely
to be buried at the National Heroes Acre, and must be
responsible.
“He implored him to lead by example and even used a Shona
adage: Gudo guru
peta muswe kuti vapwere vagokuremekedza (literally meaning
an elder should
be humble and exemplary for him to earn respect from the
young),” a minister
said.
Sources said Education minister David
Coltart spoke strongly against
resurging political violence. He later went
on to condemn the brutality on
the social media yesterday.
“I did
speak in cabinet on Tuesday regarding this (Christpowers’ death) and
mentioned my own two friends Patrick Nabanyama (abducted on June 19 2000)
and Paul Chizuze (abducted on February 8 2012) who have never been seen
again due to political violence,” wrote Coltart while commenting on Women’s
Affairs deputy minister Jessie Majome’s Facebook post.
Several
ministers, including Priscilla Misihairabwi-Mushonga (Regional
Integration
and International Co-operation), Nelson Chamisa (Information,
Communications
Technology) and Elton Mangoma (Energy), also spoke out during
the tense
meeting.
Mutasa also spoke. He has several times vehemently denied
allegations that
he was behind the arson attack. Yesterday he repeated his
denials.
Sources said Mugabe remained calm, but was concerned throughout
the meeting,
although he also spoke about the situation repeating his recent
calls for an
end to political violence — Zanu PF’s key political weapon
since its
formation in 1963.
Zanu PF ministers were said to have been
defensive, refusing to take
responsibility. Mines minister Obert Mpofu,
accused of fanning violence in
Umguza near Bulawayo, called for
investigations into the incident, while
urging caution before pointing
fingers.
Shamu reportedly suggested the arson attack could have been
executed by
remnants of the Rhodesian Selous Scouts to divide the country,
an idea
scoffed at by MDC ministers.
The resurgence of violence has
jolted Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai out
of his comfort zone among the
principals and forced him to send Timba into
Sadc to raise alarm bells about
the deteriorating political and security
situation in Zimbabwe.
Part
of the dossier compiled by MDC-T on 2013 violations
January 4: Energy and
Power Development minister Elton Mangoma faces charges
of insulting
President Robert Mugabe.
January 7: University of Zimbabwe bars the MDC-T
Youth Assembly chairperson
Solomon Madzore from resuming his studies because
he has a pending criminal
case.
January 8: Four MDC-T officials in
Mashonaland West face charges of
insulting the president.
January 8:
MDC-T youths and supporters denied an opportunity to register as
voters in
Masvingo.
January 9: Soldiers harass villagers at Mataga Growth Point in
Mberengwa.
January 11: MDC-T branch chairperson for Cowdray Park, Bulawayo
Happison
Ncube’s house searched by police.
January 14: ZimRights
director Okay Machisa is arrested for allegedly
conspiring to commit voter
registration fraud and publishing or
communicating falsehoods.
January
29: ZRP Commissioner-General Augustine Chihuri addresses wives of
senior
police officers in Selous, Mashonaland West Province and tells them
to vote
for Zanu PF.
January 29: Fifteen people injured after soldiers attack people
in Tenda
village in Chiadzwa.
January 31: Zanu PF supporters naming
themselves Al-Shabab, stop a residents’
meeting to discuss the draft
constitution at Mbizo Youth Centre.
February 2: Flea market operators in
Chitungwiza forced to buy Zanu PF party
cards before they are allowed to
operate stalls.
February 4: Police in Lupane, Matabeleland North province
arrest 40 people
for trying to register as voters.
http://www.theindependent.co.zw/
March 1, 2013 in Politics
Prime
Minister Morgan Tsvangirai has threatened to pull out of the general
elections if politically motivated violence escalates in the country ahead
of the polls in July.
Staff Writer
The MDC-T leader made the
threats when he addressed mourners yesterday
during the burial of a
12-year-old boy, Christpowers Maisiri, killed in a
raging inferno after an
arson attack by suspected Zanu PF activists last
Saturday in
Headlands.
“I’m not going to be part and parcel to a process that
subverts the will of
the people,” he said.
Christpowers’ death is
widely seen as a harbinger to violent elections. His
gruesome death sent
shockwaves through the public and cabinet on Tuesday.
Mourners heard how
a stormy Tuesday cabinet session degenerated into a
naming and shaming
session, in which Zanu PF cabinet ministers, particularly
Didymus Mutasa was
singled out for allegedly instigating political violence
and causing
Christpowers’ death.
Tsvangirai said if Mugabe was sincere about his “no
to violence” refrain,
the perpetrators must be brought to book. “He (Mugabe)
told me that Mutasa
should pay” for the death of the boy. Tsvangirai said
Mugabe indicated he
had information Mutasa was involved.
MDC-T
secretary-general Tendai Biti disclosed how a tension-filled cabinet
session
on Tuesday condemned the boy’s traumatic death. “We told Didymus
Mutasa that
he is behind the murder of this boy. If he thought we were
hiding under the
cover of cabinet privilege, we are now saying it in public.
Mutasa you
killed this boy. If you think we are lying take us to court for
defamation,”
Biti charged.
Christpowers’ father, Shepherd Maisiri said his son was
born in the
mountains during 2000 winter. “I only saw my son after about a
month,” he
said. “Temperatures had dropped very low.
But my son
braved the winter, in the mountains, having fled terror,” he
said.
“The boy got his name Christpowers because I lived under the
grace of God.
If Mutasa is my friend as he claims, why isn’t he here at the
funeral,”
Maisiri asked.
Contacted for comment, Mutasa said yesterday
it was “sometimes stupid” to
engage MDC-T officials on matters like
this.
http://www.theindependent.co.zw/
March 1, 2013 in Politics
ZIMBABWE’S
constitution-making process continues spiralling into chaos as
the three
main political parties rush the draft through a shambolic
awareness campaign
ahead of a referendum penciled in for March 16.
Hazel Ndebele/Paidamoyo
Muzulu
The coalition government partners agreed to fast-track the draft
constitution last month without proper funding and logistical planning
resulting in the ongoing disorganised countrywide awareness campaigns where
copies of the draft are in short supply.
Copac launched a two-week
awareness blitz targeting 144 centres countrywide
to popularise the draft in
line with the government’s “Yes” vote in the
referendum.
The targeted
centres will share 92 000 copies of the draft constitution
published by
Copac with just two meetings being held in each of the country’s
59
districts.
About 70 000 copies are a full version of the draft and 22 000
a summarised
version, of which 10 000 are in English, 10 000 in Shona, 6 000
in Ndebele
and the remainder in minority languages such as Chewa, Kalanga
and Tonga.
Copac national co-ordinator Gift Marunda confirmed the
shortage of materials
and a disjointed national awareness campaign compared
to the outreach
programme in 2010 that solicited people’s input to the draft
during which 1
400 meetings were held.
Anyone above 18 years with a
national identity card can participate in the
referendum.
“We are
engaging in 144 meetings because of the constrained resources,”
Marunda
said. “It is impossible to have a full scale outreach like the data
gathering outreach that went into wards. We resolved that the awareness
should only be representative.”
This week’s meetings in Harare and
Bulawayo were poorly attended and some
had to be rescheduled.
For
example, only 25 people attended the Harare Central constituency meeting
held at Queen Elizabeth High School while another held at Kuwadzana High
School, had pupils comprising the majority of participants.
Even with
such low attendances, participants still failed to get individual
copies of
the draft constitution at the meetings.
“We underestimated the huge
response from the public since we had hoped that
at least copies would be
distributed to organisations rather than
individuals,” said
Marunda.
Civil society organisations like the National Constitutional
Assembly (NCA)
and International Socialist Organisation, as well as
political parties such
as Mavambo/Dawn/Kusile and MDC99 have complained
about the four weeks set
aside to study the draft before the
referendum.
NCA chairperson Lovemore Madhuku has petitioned the High
Court to direct
government to push back the referendum date by a month to
allow for thorough
debate of the draft.
http://www.theindependent.co.zw/
March 1, 2013 in Politics
DISGRUNTLED
aspiring parliamentarians have threatened to split their parties’
votes by
standing as independents in the imminent high-stakes elections in
protest
against primary polls criteria they believe unfairly ring-fence
party
heavyweights.
Report by Elias Mambo
Zanu PF and MDC-T have set primary
elections selection criteria being
resisted by aspiring candidates who say
the procedures are aimed at
sidelining new entrants while safeguarding the
incumbents.
To demonstrate its opposition to selection criteria adopted
by its party,
the MDC-T Supporters’ Forum said it would be mobilising
disqualified
candidates and campaigning for them to contest as
independents.
“The forum is already mobilising aspiring candidates who
have been barred by
these MPs to stand as independent candidates,” said the
forum in a
statement.
“We reiterate that the only democratic
criterion of selecting candidates is
to have an open membership meeting
where all contestants in the
constituencies will be nominated and seconded
by voters.”
In the 2008 harmonised elections, independent candidates
split the vote
resulting in Zanu PF, MDC-T and the MDC failing to secure
victory in
constituencies in which they would otherwise have
won.
This partly helped to create a hung parliament.
The most
significant splitting of votes was in the presidential poll where
current
Dawn/Mavambo/Kusile leader Simba Makoni claimed 8% of the vote,
denying
MDC-T leader Morgan Tsvangirai, who garnered 47%, an outright
victory to
wrest power from President Robert Mugabe.
Instead, Tsvangirai was forced
into a run-off with Mugabe, but pulled out
citing state-sponsored violence
unleashed on his supporters.
MDC-T also suffered significant losses,
especially in the Midlands, after
fielding more than one candidate in each
constituency due to factionalism.
MDC-T spokesperson Douglas Mwonzora
said his party would stick to the rules
and those who want to contest as
independent candidates could do so at their
own peril.
“MDC-T is a
party of rules and it has a constitution which must be
followed,” Mwonzora
said.
“The constitution stipulates a selection criterion and those who do
not
qualify should be patient and allow the ones who do to represent the
party
in the general elections. If they decide to run as independent
candidates
then they would have resigned from the MDC-T.”
Political
analyst Jabusile Shumba said the next elections would feature more
independent candidates than in previous ones.
“We are likely to see a
lot of independent candidates in the next elections
judging by the
disgruntlement in both Zanu PF and the MDC-T caused by the
stringent
candidate selection criteria which the parties are employing,” he
said.
Shumba also said the delay in finalising rules for primary
elections would
have a negative impact on the political parties because
those who would be
disqualified may opt to contest as independents as they
have already
invested time and resources in campaigning.
http://www.theindependent.co.zw/
March 1, 2013 in Politics
SHARP
differences have emerged among the three political parties that form
Zimbabwe’s transitional coalition government over the invitation of Western
poll observers as the referendum and crucial general elections
approach.
Report by Elias Mambo
Vice-President Joice Mujuru has
declared Zimbabwe would only allow regional
observers from southern Africa
to monitor elections to prevent Western
powers from meddling in the
country’s internal political processes.
“Why should we be monitored by
other countries outside Sadc when we are a
sovereign state?” asked
Mujuru.
Mujuru’s utterances have been trashed by the MDC formations who
say credible
elections can only take place under the monitoring of
international
observers.
Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai’s MDC wants
international referendum
observers to remain in the country until the
watershed elections around
mid-year.
MDC-T secretary-general and
Finance minister Tendai Biti said his party
would ensure international
election observers are invited and remain in the
country even after the
referendum.
“We want Sadc to make sure that referendum observers are
allowed to remain
in the country up to the time we hold our elections,” said
Biti.
“This election is critical and international observers will ensure
Zimbabwe
does not go back to the unforgettable 2008 political
crisis.”
The 2008 presidential run-off became a sham after MDC-T leader
Morgan
Tsvangirai pulled out citing violence against his supporters, which
led to
an inconclusive result and formation of the current inclusive
government.
MDC-T has previously called for international observers to be
deployed in
Zimbabwe six months before and six months after elections to
ensure
violence-free elections and peaceful aftermath.
MDC
spokesperson Nhlanhla Dube said his party would participate in elections
monitored by observers who share the same democratic interests with Zimbabwe
regardless of where they come from.
“As a country moving towards
democracy, we want those with the same
democratic interests as us to come
and scrutinise our elections,” Dube said.
However, European Union
ambassador to Zimbabwe Aldo Dell’Ariccia told the
Zimbabwe Independent on
Monday that EU election observers are still waiting
for Zimbabwe’s
invitation.
“We do not impose ourselves or force governments to invite us
to observe
their elections,” Dell’Ariccia said. “We wait for the government
to send an
invitation and this has to have a timeframe because we need time
for
observers to come and observe activities leading to the elections,” he
said.
http://www.theindependent.co.zw/
March 1, 2013 in Politics
THE preamble
to Article 6 of the Global Political Agreement (GPA) reads:
“Acknowledging
that it is the fundamental right and duty of the Zimbabwean
people to make a
constitution by themselves and for themselves.”
Report by Elias
Mambo
It also states that people should be “aware that the process of
making this
constitution must be owned and driven by the people and must be
inclusive
and democratic”.
However, it appears democracy is being
dealt a massive blow in the interests
of political expediency as the three
main political players, Zanu PF, MDC-T
and MDC, have ganged up to coerce
people to a short notice vote for a draft
constitution at a referendum in
March despite lack of debate and education
on the document.
Copac has
rolled out a chaotic awareness campaign countrywide running from
February 25
to March 8, which is just a week before the referendum. The
campaigns have
been hit by apathy, largely as a result of fatigue since the
process has
been going on for four years; announcement that all GPA parties
will
campaign for a “Yes” vote; and chaos which has characterised the
exercise.
Some of the apathy-hit awareness meetings have been
affected by logistical
problems such as transport, while in some places
confusion was widespread as
people could not get information on
time.
In Highfield, Harare, a Copac meeting held this week reportedly
ended
prematurely when Zanu PF activists in party regalia grabbed copies of
the
draft constitution and ran away with them.
This is in keeping
with the turmoil which has characterised the entire
constitution-making
process, starting with the fracas that marred the First
All-Stakeholders’
Conference in July 2009.
There were also disruptions during the outreach
programme as Zanu PF and the
MDC formations incessantly clashed as they
sought to advance parochial
partisan interests during the exercise which
gobbled up more than US$50
million.
A critical shortage of copies of
the draft constitution has been reported
after Copac printed 70 000 only for
its publicity campaigns nationwide
against a population of about 13 million
people due to lack of funds.
As a result, people have been advised to go
and queue at provincial and
district administrators’ offices to read the
draft constitution ahead of the
referendum.
Copac has also reneged on
its promise to translate the draft into the 16
indigenous languages, as well
as into Braille for the visually impaired and
blind.
Political
parties were given 3 500 copies to circulate among their
supporters, with a
limited number passed on to provinces.
National Constitution Assembly
(NCA) chairperson Lovemore Madhuku said due
to the lack of preparedness on
the part of Copac and Zimbabwe Electoral
Commission (Zec), the referendum
result would not reflect the wishes of the
people but a “predetermined
outcome in the interest of the political
players”.
“Zec is not even
ready to run the referendum and elections because they have
not started
training the 45 000 officials who will man the 9 000 polling
stations
because we expect to have about five officials per polling
station,”
Madhuku said. “Designation of polling stations also requires time
so that
the points are selected well in advance for logistical purposes.”
Madhuku
felt the 2000 Constitutional Commission referendum was better
organised
because President Robert Mugabe proclaimed the date when he
received the
draft constitution on November 29 1999, and the polls were
conducted end of
February 2000.
South Africa gave its people two years to familiarise
themselves with the
draft constitution before holding a
referendum.
“For Zimbabwe, we want at least three months so that we can
carry out
awareness campaigns,” Madhuku, who is challenging the proclamation
of the
referendum dates in court, said.
Madhuku has dismissed the
current awareness campaigns, claiming the
summarised version of the draft
constitution being used is different from
the original draft because it does
not include all the important points.
Mugabe has scoffed at the NCA’s
High Court application.
“Adequate public consultations, debates and civil
education have already
taken place,” said Mugabe.
“The one month will
give ample opportunity to the people to make up their
minds.
”
Zimbabwe Election Support Network (Zesn) director Rindai Vava also
called
for an extension saying Zec should be given more time to organise a
credible
plebiscite.
“The political decision to hold the referendum
undermines the ability of Zec
to enhance its capacity to conduct the
election or strengthen its
credibility with stakeholders and this might be a
missed opportunity,” said
Vava.
With 9 000 referendum polling
stations proposed countrywide, Zec has limited
time to take care of
logistical issues such as training personnel,
transport, ballot papers and
indelible ink.
Zimbabwe Democracy Institute director Pedzisai Ruhanya
said the fractious
coalition government partners are hoodwinking people into
believing the
country’s constitution-making exercise is a democratic process
when it’s
not.
“This whole process is a faÇade meant to hoodwink
people so that they do not
have enough time to interrogate the draft
constitution,” he said.
http://www.theindependent.co.zw/
March 1, 2013 in Politics
A
COUNTRY’S constitution is supposed to stand the test of time and be
inclusive in its making to serve future generations, but the current
constitution-making process in the country has been characterised by elitist
and partisan interests — a product of compromise among the three political
parties in the inclusive government.
Report by Faith Zaba
With
exactly two weeks to go before the country holds a referendum on the
new
draft constitution on March 16, it has emerged rural folks are clueless
about the contents of the document.
The current publicity campaigns
have not reached the rural populace, as was
done in 1999/2000, to explain
what the draft says.
The Zimbabwe Independent this week visited Uzumba
and Murehwa in Mashonaland
East in a bid to find out whether Copac and
Ministry of Constitutional and
Parliamentary Affairs campaigns were reaching
the people.
Interviews with people in Murehwa and Uzumba showed they are
unaware the
draft constitution was complete, while others said they are yet
to see the
document they are expected to vote for on March 16.
As
Copac rolls out its “Yes” campaign with limited reach and copies of the
English version of the draft without Shona and Ndebele translations, people
in Uzumba and Murehwa are concerned with fast-tracking the
process.
No meetings have been held in Murehwa and Uzumba as yet to brief
people on
the draft constitution, save for a Zanu PF ward 9 meeting
scheduled for
tomorrow, nor are translations of the draft available. The
villagers said
all they have been told is to vote “Yes” even without seeing
the draft.
Seventy-eight-year-old James Nyakabau of Charinda Village in
Murehwa said
government should have given them time to read or be
sufficiently briefed
before the referendum.
He said although he has
heard through rumours the draft was now complete, he
feels there is no
adequate time being given to people to learn about its
contents.
“We
have heard that the draft is out, but we have not seen it. We don’t even
know if we are ever going to see copies of it before the referendum,” he
said. “We have just been told that those that voted in the last elections
should tick ‘Yes’ and those that didn’t vote should tick ‘No’. We don’t
understand what this means.”
Nyakabau went further: “Obviously, I
want to know what is in the
constitution. I am very interested in what our
new constitution says, but
unfortunately, we are being taken for granted.
They think it is not
important for us to know so they have not bothered to
explain it to us.”
Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai recently defended the
short time given
people to study the draft before the referendum.
“It
doesn’t matter how many months you give people, they are the ones who
had
input in this constitution,” he said. “If you have not already made a
decision, I am sure that even if you are given 10 months, you will never
arrive at any decision.”
People in Uzumba and Murehwa, however,
disagree. They asked if what they
said during the outreach programme is in
the draft.
Gladys Matema, a widow from Mhondiwa village in Murehwa said
she is
interested in making an informed decision to vote “Yes” or
“No”.
“I want to know before I vote so I can decide how to vote. I might
not
understand most aspects of the constitution, but there are certain areas
I
am interested in like the rights of women and children,” she
said.
“We want to see the girl child and women enjoying the same rights
as men. We
can’t vote for a document that suppresses women — so, definitely
I want to
know. We don’t want a retrogressive document.”
Faith Zanga,
from the same area, said she hoped the meetings being organised
by Copac
would be informative.
“We need to know — it is our right to know what is
in the constitution. I
hope the meetings will deal with the important
clauses,” she said.
However, 22-year-old Clever Munengani said he was
clueless about what a
constitution is.
“I only went up to Grade 7, so
I know nothing about the constitution. So, I
don’t know what I should
expect. This is the problem when one is
insufficiently educated,” he
said.
Copac will be holding two meetings per district, which covers two
to three
constituencies, to publicise the draft while the Constitutional and
Parliamentary Affairs ministry will have two meetings per
province.
http://www.theindependent.co.zw/
March 1, 2013 in News
MDC-T
secretary-general and Finance minister Tendai Biti has been
short-listed for
the 2013 Chatham House Prize in recognition of his
contribution towards
political and economic stability and the re-engagement
of Zimbabwe with the
international community.
Staff Writer
According to a letter seen
by the Zimbabwe Independent, Biti is among three
nominees in line to land
the prize given by the London-based Royal Institute
of International Affairs
at Chatham House to the “statesperson judged to
have made the most
significant contribution to the improvement of
international relations in
the previous year”.
Your success during 2012 in stabilising and
de-politicising your country’s
economy and your instrumental role in
Zimbabwe’s re-engagement with the
international financial community have a
strong impression on our research
programmes and our three presidents,”
reads the letter to Biti.
The winner would be decided at the end of
March.
http://www.theindependent.co.zw/
March 1, 2013 in News
DESPITE having been
part of the national discourse since 2007 when Zanu PF
first formally mulled
the process, and more actively since 2010, the
controversial indigenisation
programme remains uncertain.
Report by Owen Gagare
Its architects
and implementers now publicly differ on its framework, thrust
and
implementation matrix.
Of late rival camps clustered around
Indigenisation minister Saviour
Kasukuwere and Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe
governor Gideon Gono have emerged,
quarrelling over a whole range of issues,
including the ideological
foundations of the programme, conceptual basis,
frameworks, implementation,
consultations, valuation of companies,
legislative issues, exchange rate
approvals, consultation fees, and
conditions precedent to agreements signed
so far.
Kasukuwere’s group
is basically campaigning for an equity-based model to
transfer ownership of
wealth to locals, while Gono argues a
“one-size-fits-all” approach would not
work.
He has suggested a supply-side model be applied in some sectors of
the
economy, enraging Kasukuwere’s allies.
Major indigenisation deals
signed up to date include Portland Holdings, Unki
Mine, Mimosa Mining
Company and Zimplats, mostly brokered by Brainworks
Capital Management,
raising the issue of how the consultancy firm was chosen
and amounts being
paid to it.
Brainworks has brokered deals worth at least US$1,7 billion
and stands to
reap about US$25,8 million in commission at an average rate of
1,5% of the
total transactions value.
A number of firms have been
engaged on consultancy works, although it is
unclear what criteria were
followed. This has raised suspicions of political
corruption, rent-seeking,
extortion, bribery, cronyism and patronage.
Against this backdrop, the
main question hovering over the indigenisation
process has been: Is this a
genuine empowerment programme or racketeering by
regulation?
Its
promoters say this is a genuine programme of empowerment premised on
resource nationalism to lift up previously underprivileged Zimbabweans out
of the depths of poverty to relative prosperity by leveraging mainly on the
abundance of the country’s mineral wealth. They say the primary objective of
the policy is to broaden Zimbabwe’s economic base by ensuring the majority
effectively participate in economic affairs of the country.
However,
critics argue that although indigenisation might be a good idea, it
has
degenerated into a racketeering. They say the way the programme is
financed
raises the spectre of a Ponzi scheme which will collapse with
disastrous
economic consequences.
Finance minister Tendai Biti, a lawyer by
profession, has said the community
share trusts aspect of the programme are
“illegal”.
The promulgation of the Indigenisation and Economic Act
(Chapter 14:33, as
read with the Indigenisation and Economic Empowerment
(General) Regulations
2010, Statutory Instrument 21/10 and supplemented by
the General Notice 114
of 2011, requires foreign-owned companies to dispose
51% of their shares to
locals at fair market value.
Many companies
have reportedly submitted indigenisation plans, although some
are resisting,
risking punitive measures or seizure.
Disposals of shares to indigenous
entities under empowerment transactions
are being treated as purely
commercial. The law does not allow expropriation
or
nationalisation.
Since indigenous people do not have capital to buy their
51% equities, a
notional vendor financing scheme was chosen as the
option.
Vendor financing is a loan finance method that facilitates
disposal of
equity interest in a business by existing shareholders to a new
investor
with the purchase price for the shares being settled by future
dividends
attributable to the buyer.
This method allows the purchaser
to secure shares without upfront capital
outlay or collateral and to settle
the share acquisition costs using future
dividends. However, it is very
risky as companies in this case are lending
money to people who are broke
and may never repay.
Although President Robert Mugabe has drawn parallels
between the land reform
and indigenisation programmes, it appears the lure
of unearned riches for a
selected few under the cover of majority
empowerment may be the biggest
motive for politicians and their cronies even
though this may well be the
only way out for besieged foreign-owned
companies.
http://www.theindependent.co.zw/
March 1, 2013 in News
ZIMBABWE Prison
Services (ZPS) deputy commissioner Agrey Machingauta said
there are no plans
to carry out any executions in the country and the ZPS
hopes all 77 death
row inmates get a reprieve.
Report by Wongai Zhangazha
Zimbabwe
recently hired a hangman raising speculation that the country could
be
resuming executions, but Machingauta assured a ZPS stakeholders
conference
at Harare Central Prison a fortnight ago that no executions would
be carried
out “anytime soon”.
Zimbabwe currently has 77 inmates on death row,
including two females.
“We have not carried executions for the past 12
years so we are in no
hurry,” said Machingauta. “We actually hope that the
77 inmates will get
their reprieve. We also stand guided by what Minister
(of Justice Patrick)
Chinamasa said that all death row cases will be decided
by cabinet.”
About 78 people have been executed in Zimbabwe since
independence in 1980.
The last executions were carried out on June 13
2003, when Stephen Chidhumo,
Elias Chauke, William Mukurugunye and John
Nyamazana were hanged.
The four had been convicted of murder without
extenuating circumstances and
their execution took place without any warning
to their families.
Chinamasa recently said the appointment of a new
hangman does not mean any
of the death row inmates would be executed and
government would instead push
for the sentences to be commuted to life in
prison.
The hangman’s job had been vacant and government had been
struggling to find
a replacement since the previous one retired in 2005
despite repeated
adverts in the local press.
The draft constitution
that would be tested in a referendum on March 16
retains the death penalty,
but prohibits executions of women and anyone
under the age of 21 years or
over the age of 70 years.
ZPS commissioner retired Major-General Paradzai
Zimondi said prisons were
holding 16 902 inmates.
He said only 587 of
these were women and 124 were juveniles.
http://www.theindependent.co.zw/
February 25, 2013 in
News
GOVERNMENT plans to seal off newly discovered diamond fields in
Masvingo
province’s Bikita district to halt illegal mining of the precious
stones,
Mines minister Obert Mpofu has said.
Report by Taurai
Mangudhla
In an interview with the Zimbabwe Independent, Mpofu said
government had
decided to control access to the area to avoid a repeat of
the Marange
diamond fields free-for-all where thousands of people descended
on Chiadzwa
to illegally mine diamonds before security forces brutally moved
in to stop
the chaos.
Mpofu insisted this would be achieved
peacefully and in an organised manner
to plug mineral leakages and allow the
nation to benefit from its resource
wealth.
“Yes we will seal off the
area, but it may not be exactly as Chiadzwa
because that was at a time we
were not sure of the availability of diamonds.
We have learnt our lesson and
will do things in a much more organised
manner,” said Mpofu.
Mpofu
confirmed there were Kimberlite diamonds in the Bikita area, saying he
had
received confirmation from his officials after getting police reports
about
illegal mining activities.
“According to the report, some villagers
reported that there were diamonds
in the Devure Ranch and the Chinese came
and started prospecting and found
diamonds, but said they were of no
commercial value. But I am told now they
have come with heavy equipment so I
have instructed the police and my
officials to stop them,” Mpofu
said.
“We are told equipment has been moved, which is very worrying
because we are
unaware of any special grant or any claim that was given to
any investor to
mine diamonds in that area.”
Two weeks ago, the
Independent reported a dispute had erupted over the
mining of recently
discovered diamonds in Bikita, with former freedom
fighters in the area
alleging corruption and contesting the “unclear
circumstances” surrounding
mining of the gems.
Kimberlite diamonds were discovered in Bikita’s
Village One and Two under
Chief Budzi last year, resulting in a number of
mining firms, including
Harare-based Bayrich Enterprises as well as senior
police and army officers,
jostling to acquire rights to mine the
gems.
Mpofu said the new diamond discoveries would go a long way towards
improving
the country’s meagre revenue collections.
http://www.theindependent.co.zw/
March 1, 2013 in Politics
JOSTLING for
parliamentary seats for the next elections is intensifying
throughout the
provinces amid revelations that some MDC-T bigwigs are likely
to lose to
relatively newcomers.
Report by Herbert Moyo
Although the jostling is
countrywide, the main focus is on the party’s
Bulawayo province where there
are looming massive changes likely to spell
the end of the road for some of
its stalwarts, including Dorcas Sibanda
(Bulawayo Central), Felix Magalela
Sibanda (Magwegwe) and Thabitha Khumalo
(Bulawayo East).
MDC-T deputy
president Thokozani Khupe is not contesting parliamentary
elections this
year as her party has resolved that as a “national leader she
should be
campaigning at a national level for the overall success of the
party”.
Provincial chairperson Gorden Moyo has been lined up to
contest Khupe’s
current seat.
“It’s not that Khupe is running away
from Makokoba due to past troubles in
the area,” said a source. “It has been
resolved that contesting in elections
undermines her stature as national
leader.”
New faces expected to be unveiled include academic Mandla Nyathi
(Bulawayo
East), lawyer Kucaca Phulu, clergyman Useni Sibanda and a son of
the late
Zanu PF Makokoba MP Sidney Malunga identified as Anele
(Magwegwe).
Sibanda confirmed being approached by MDC-T, but said he is
yet to make a
decision. Phulu is earmarked to take over from Bulawayo mayor
Thaba Moyo,
who sources said, has been undone by his lack of academic
qualifications.
Masvingo province has also been rocked by controversy
following claims by
aspiring candidates, including mayor Femias Chakabuda,
aspiring mayor David
Charirwe and deputy mayor Selina Maridza, who say that
their CVs had been
tempered with to undermine their
prospects.
Provincial secretary Tongai Matutu acknowledged receiving the
complaints but
said there are no problems in Masvingo and in any contest
“some people will
fall by the wayside due to the emergence of somebody more
popular”.
“There was that complaint but we opened all the applications in
the presence
of 38 provincial members and studied them in an open
transparent manner. The
complaint is without merit,” said
Matutu.
Although those rumoured to be facing the chop have remained mum,
the MDC-T
is desperate to avoid acrimonious battles that would divide the
party’s
potential votes. The disturbances have occasionally degenerated into
physical fights, especially in the run-up to the party congress held in the
city in 2011.
Factions aligned to Makokoba senator Matson Hlalo and
Moyo reportedly fought
pitched battles prompting party leader and Prime
Minister Morgan Tsvangirai
to appoint the Trust Mhanda-led Commission to
investigate the issue. The
commission’s findings have been
canned.
Crisis in Zimbabwe Coalition director Macdonald Lewanika said the
MDC-T
should realise that those who got them here might not be enough to
take them
to the next level, so reinvention and reinforcement is not a bad
thing.
http://www.theindependent.co.zw/
March 1, 2013 in Politics
AN
initiative by the three main political parties, Zanu PF, MDC-T, MDC, to
promote the Zimbabwe Code of Conduct for political parties has received a
major boost from their women structures which expected to meet today to
publicise the code.
Report by Wongai Zhangazha
In January
principals to the Global Political Agreement endorsed the Organ
on National
Healing, Truth and Reconciliation’s code of conduct which seeks
to hold
political parties accountable for any violence or intimidation
perpetrated
by their supporters.
Zanu PF Women’s League chairperson Oppah Muchinguri,
MDC-T Women’s Assembly
leader Theresa Makone and Thandiwe Mlilo of the MDC
have held meetings in
the past weeks at the Jomic offices to discuss ways of
promoting the code of
conduct at grassroots level.
The women’s
formations have agreed to hold a joint meeting today.
Makone said in an
interview this week the programme was a good initiative to
ensure protection
of women.
“This is something that was started by Jomic where three
chairpersons of the
women’s formations met and agreed on a number of
issues,” said Makone.
“As the MDC-T, we met on Tuesday to develop our own
code of conduct and
discuss what we see as important to us as women. To us
the most important
issue is say no to violence against women, especially in
constituencies
represented by women and an end to all sorts of violence
against women
during elections.”
Muchinguri confirmed the meeting,
saying they wanted issues of equality at
every level during
elections.
“As the women’s league we are looking at the participation of
women from
voting and monitoring to coming up with policies at every level,”
said
Muchinguri.
“We are saying how best can we work together looking
at the code of conduct
to reduce political violence? We seek to promote the
protection of women
contesting or monitoring and strongly condemn the
beating of (Zanu PF
Hurungwe East legislator Sarah) Mahoka by
youths.
If party activistsresort to beating contesting women or any form
of violence
we will not vote for them. All those perpetrators should be
brought to
book.”
The parties’ youth formations are also expected to
meet to map ways of
promoting the code of conduct. The code calls on
political parties to run
their election campaigns without infringing on the
activities of other
parties. It emphasises that political parties should be
able to campaign and
disseminate their political ideas without
fear.
The code also touches on the conduct of political parties during
polling,
accepting the outcome of a free and fair election and the use of
appropriate
language during campaigns.
It compels parties to desist
from bribery to garner votes.
http://www.theindependent.co.zw/
March 1, 2013 in Business
ZIMBABWE’S proposed
residence based tax system which comes into effect in
January 2014 will be
simpler and more user friendly and is intended to widen
the country’s tax
base, a local taxation expert has said.
Report by Clive
Mphambela
Presenting an analytical paper at the Zimbabwe Independent
Dialogue series
in Harare last week, Max Mangoro, a partner with Ernst &
Young Advisory
Services , said government had been motivated by several
positive reasons to
move to the residence based tax system.
One of
the reasons, he said, was to place Zimbabwe’s income tax system on a
sound
footing which would protect the tax base from exploitation.
He also said
the new measures were aimed at aligning the Zimbabwean tax
system with
international tax principles and best practices especially
following the
relaxation of exchange controls and the greater involvement of
Zimbabwean
companies offshore since dollarisation of the economy in 2009.
According
to Mangoro, the proposed new Income Tax Act will effectively cater
for the
taxation of e-commerce transactions.
“To facilitate the implementation of the
new proposals it has been necessary
to re-define one of the most important
building blocks on which the income
tax system is based, namely what income
is taxable?” Mangoro said.
“This is because income tax is levied on every
person who has taxable income
for the year of assessment.”
According
to expert opinion, gross income definition in the new Act will be
amended to
reflect the world-wide basis of taxation.
“In short, all residents will
be taxable on their Zimbabwean and foreign
income, non-residents will be
taxable on their Zimbabwean sourced income,
whilst expatriates will be
taxable on Zimbabwe sourced income and the
income, if any, which accrues
during that year from all sources outside
Zimbabwe and which is required to
be remitted to Zimbabwe in terms of
exchange control
regulations,”
Mangoro said.
He said currently, the Zimbabwean income
tax system is primarily based on
what is commonly referred to as the source
plus basis of taxation under
which all income which originates in Zimbabwe
and certain types of income
which are deemed to be from a source in Zimbabwe
such as foreign dividends
and foreign interest are taxable in terms of the
Income Tax Act.
Because the new world-wide tax system is based on
residency, it is crucial
that there is certainty of what the term
means.
Mangoro said two rules will apply to define what a resident is in
respect of
individual tax payers.
He said the first is a subjective
test based on one’s ordinary place of
abode under which a taxpayer is deemed
to be a resident of Zimbabwe if his
or her permanent home, to which he or
she will return , is in Zimbabwe and
he or she is present in Zimbabwe at any
time during the year of assessment.
“The second rule, based on physical
presence in Zimbabwe is time-based and
more objective. A person will become
a resident if he or she is present in
Zimbabwe for one or more periods
amounting in aggregate to at least one
hundred and eighty-three days in any
twelve-month period that ends during
the year of assessment,” he
said.
Mangoro said for corporate taxes, a company will be a resident if
it is
incorporated, effectively managed and controlled or undertakes the
majority
of its operations in Zimbabwe during the year of
assessment.
Control in this sense means where Zimbabwean residents hold
more than 50% of
the participation rights or votes in the entity or control
the entity.
http://www.theindependent.co.zw/
March 1, 2013 in Business
DESPITE concerted calls by banks
for Econet Wireless (Econet)’s mobile money
service, EcoCash, to be
regulated and ensure it does not eat into the
conventional banking market,
the giant mobile network provider has announced
huge expansion plans
including moving into new sectors like health.
Report by Taurai
Mangudhla
The banks, through the Bankers Association of Zimbabwe (Baz) ,
argued
EcoCash should be bound by the country’s banking laws to enable a
level
playing field after the country put a ceiling on bank charges
effective this
year.
Baz said there was no guarantee EcoCash would
not utilise the partnerships
with banks to steal customers from the
institutions, but Econet insists the
argument is invalid as it accounts for
more than eight million mobile phone
subscribers compared to the combined
one million plus registered depositors.
With attempts having been made to
put tight policy control around Safaricom
and Vodafone’s MPESA in Kenya and
Tanzania, the local financial
institutions, plight has also become a
regional concern which has seen
African policymakers and regulators from
Alliance for Financial Inclusion
member institutions gathering in Tanzania
last month to launch the first
African Mobile Phone Financial Services
Policy Initiative.
The meeting reflected on effective best practices to
support policy reforms
for mobile financial services in Africa within a
regional framework.
EcoCash is however unfazed with the concerns,
announcing ongoing plans to
integrate three major banks — CBZ Bank, TN Bank
and Stanbic Bank (Stanbic) —
onto its EcoCash platform within ten days and
the majority of financial
institutions by end of March.
Stanbic
became the third and first international bank to partner EcoCash,
meaning
anyone with a Stanbic account that is registered on EcoCash can now
use
their mobile phone to make banking transactions from anywhere.
The mobile
phone company recently got the support of Deputy Prime Minister
Authur
Mtambara who threw out banks’ argument, saying government had
declined to
promulgate a piece of legislation that penalises EcoCash for
straying into
banking activities.
He said banks should stop whining and develop mechanisms
that match mobile
money.
The DPM applauded the mobile money
innovation saying it gives 80% of
Zimbabwe’s population, currently unbanked,
access to banking facilities.
In its latest statement, Econet said it had
finally reached an agreement
with most of the banks on EcoCash integration,
adding the process is now
progressing smoothly.
The company sent a
message to all of its more than eight million customers
saying issues have
been resolved with virtually all the banks and
integration was progressing
well.
Econet said when a bank is integrated, a person can undertake
banking from
anywhere in the world at any time of day.
“You can move
money from your account, and send it to someone in Zimbabwe
even at midnight
from China; it is that flexible,” said the company
spokesperson.
The
company said banks that do not have integration have been concerned
about
losing customers to those banks that are already integrated with
EcoCash.
Last year EcoCash started partnering banks to ramp up mobile
money transfer
facilities.
With most of Zimbabwe’s estimated 14
million population currently in the
unbanked bracket and government failing
to solve a change crisis emanating
from adoption of a multiple currency
regime that was adopted in 2009,
experts say mobile money transfer is an
ideal solution.
The appetite for mobile money is huge in the country,
with most of the
population having access to mobile phone
services.
Latest figures show the country’s three mobile networks —
Econet, NetOne and
Telecel Zimbabwe — have a combined 11 million
subscribers.
Econet CE Douglas Mboweni said the move would see EcoCash
becoming a
financial service and not just a mobile money transfer as EcoCash
registered
banks account holders would be able to transfer money from their
bank
accounts to their EcoCash wallets and vice versa.
Econet says
transactions on its mobile money transfer facility, EcoCash, are
expected to
grow more than threefold and top US$1 billion by August 2013 as
compared to
US$300 million registered in its first year of operation.
Ecocash was
launched in August last year and has grown to register more than
two million
users.
http://www.theindependent.co.zw/
March 1, 2013 in Opinion
President
Robert Mugabe has promised to fully embrace football development
“as a
priority” only after winning elections.
Opinion by The
MuckRaker
Handing over the Bob 89 trophy to the winners Dynamos this
week, Mugabe
bemoaned the current policies “which do not embrace soccer”
saying he will
make sure football is adequately funded when he wins the next
elections.
This sudden concern is likely to provide cold comfort to
football lovers
considering it is Zanu PF policies that have destroyed local
football.
Sport has always taken a back seat under Zanu PF rule being
lumped together
with education and culture in one
ministry.
Government has idly watched as Zifa struggled to raise money to
attend
tournaments forcing the likes of Cuthbert Dube to bankroll the
association
from their own pockets.
Instead, they only want to take
credit in rare moments of success, such as
Kirsty Coventry’s Olympic
triumph, as if they had anything to do with it.
Sudden
concern
Thirty-three years on Mugabe has found it “worrisome” that
Zimbabwe fails to
qualify for the Africa Cup of Nations.
“The
government seems not to be doing much in supporting soccer,” Mugabe
said
without a hint of irony, since we are told ad nauseam he is head of
government.
It has apparently come to his attention that local soccer
has the potential
to become a force to reckon with at international level
“if we emulate other
countries who invest in the game”.
Zanu PF is
not fooling anyone in its attempt to latch on to popular football
clubs in
its bid to repackage its stale ideology. He should ask Webster
Shamu who
last December unsuccessfully tried to turn a musical gala into a
political
rally and instead got jeers for his troubles. He was forced to
change tack
by calling on the crowd to rally behind Dynamos football club.
“Pamberi
neDembare, neDembare yedu (forward with Dynamos),” yelped Shamu in
a bid to
pacify the restive crowd.
Singing from the same hymn sheet Mugabe made his
agenda all the more plain
stating: “The elections are coming and we want to
make sure that we will
support soccer with the much-needed funding, and a
Zanu PF government will
do that.”
Fat chance!
Strategic
mayhem
Meanwhile the ZRP has “assured” the nation that despite funding
and manpower
challenges, the referendum and elections will be held without
violence.
ZRP Elections Commander, Deputy commissioner-general Innocent
Matibiri said
the police has a “strategic” document in place and had already
started
training its members from district to national levels.
The
police, Matibiri said, will continue to clamp down on non-governmental
organisations and individuals “whose activities may pose a security risk to
the country during and after the electoral processes”.
“We will stop
at nothing to clamp down on those who carry out activities
that are not
noble to Zimbabwe’s cause,” Matibiri charged.
So it seems the “strategic”
document is there only to harass NGOs and to
determine what activities can
be deemed “noble”.
While they are at it, the Chipanganos and Jabulani
Sibandas of this world
are left to roam free and wreak havoc.
Freedom
my foot!
A statement last week by the Media Alliance of Zimbabwe (MAZ)
neatly
summarised the significance of the police’s confiscation of shortwave
receivers.
“MAZ believes that owning and distributing radio receivers is
not illegal,”
the organisation said. “Confiscating them was a gross
violation of citizens’
rights to receive and impart ideas and information
without interference as
enshrined in Section 20 of the constitution. People
have been deprived of an
important source of information.”
So here we are
at the outset of the “Vote Yes” campaign with an egregious
abridgement of
fundamental liberties without a squeak of protest by
political parties,
civil society groups, churches, the so-called public
papers and
government-owned radio and television stations.
So much for freedom of the
press and association as set out in the new
draft.
Clueless
accomplices
And at the same time we had the MDC-T accusing the
independent media of hate
speech.
Admittedly this was designed to
demonstrate an even-handed approach by the
MDC-T, but instead it simply gave
the impression that Morgan Tsvangirai and
his party did not uphold the
values that are fundamental to democracy.
The confiscation of SW radios, a
clumsy attack on democracy, should have
elicited the strongest of responses.
Instead we got a mealy-mouthed
response. It must be obvious to all including
the MDC that Zimbabweans rely
on external broadcasts to ascertain news and
views which they can’t get from
the Orwellian ZBC.
MDC-T spokesmen should
be challenged to tell us what hate speech they are
referring to. Instead
they are constantly finding ways to propitiate Mugabe.
The latest involves a
letter by Social Services minister Paurina Mpariwa,
which, according to
press reports, led to the raid on the Zimbabwe Peace
Project
offices.
Elections déjà vu
Now we hear the government won’t allow
foreign election observers other than
Sadc.
This is all very strange. The
government is desperate for money for election
funding. But for reasons of
dubious nationalism, it wants to assert its
sovereignty and bar those
countries which have been supporting Copac.
But there is no reason to be
dismayed. Studiously ignoring recent arrests
and other abuses ––most notably
the assault on Woza and the ZPP –– the
Scandinavians and others will come to
the rescue along with the UNDP.
So Zanu PF’s nationalist self-regard will be
spared. And the election will
go ahead as planned, flawed, bungled and
bashed.
Misplaced priorities
Harare City Council has suspended the
construction of a commuter omnibus
loading bay near Rotten Row because they
want to “prioritise” the
rehabilitation of roads, the Herald reports.
“It
is all about prioritising hence we have sought to concentrate on roads
and
water for the time being,” town clerk Tendai Mahachi said.
“We have
temporarily set aside the development of major projects like
holding bays so
that we can fully concentrate on the delapidating road
infrastructure.”
According to Mahachi, they had seen that “roads need
more work”.
We wonder how long before they also “see” that most of Harare’s
suburbs have
been without water for the past two weeks.
Hopefully sooner
rather than later!
Vote has final say
Finally, as we warned last week
state media delirium over President Mugabe’s
birthday reached ridiculous
proportions last week with ZBC claiming “youths”
in Matabeleland North
Province “have joined the rest of the country” in
conveying congratulatory
messages.
The youths, who ZBC miraculously found assembled in one place,
“said” the
president has been an exemplary leader who has shown his love for
young
people through the indigenisation and economic empowerment
policy.
The youths, we are told, also “expressed confidence” that the
president,
“who is among the most respected on the African continent”, will
win the
next presidential election.
Zanu PF’s electoral drubbing in that
part of the country since Independence
exposes such sentiments for the
hogwash that they are.
http://www.theindependent.co.zw/
February 22, 2013 in Opinion
PRESIDENT Robert
Mugabe turned 89 yesterday.
Editor’s Memo with Dumisani Muleya
It
would have been great to be among those who sent birthday greetings to
him
if one had a way of doing so, simply because it was an auspicious
occasion
for him, his family and many others.
Besides, longevity is a blessing,
not a curse as some would like us to
believe.
Even if there is a
stark reality of problems associated with old age, most
people would want to
age beautifully, take a rest and enjoy spending time
with family and friends
in the twilight years of their lives and careers,
while reminiscing on the
past and taking stock of achievements and failures
in life.
This is
probably what Mugabe should have been doing by now.
But his mantra is that he
is still active; as he said last year “at this age
I can still go some
distance, can’t I?”
Of course, Mugabe can still go some distance in
longevity. However, that is
entirely irrelevant.
What is important
for him as a leader is that after years of long service he
must appreciate
it is time to go. No matter how good a leader may be, there
is always time
to go. No one is indispensable.
Even those believed to have papal
infallibility are now realising this ––
which is why it is ridiculous in
this day and age for leaders, including
monarchs and those with
ecclesiastical responsibilities, to claim a divine
right to
rule.
Pope Benedict XVI (85) announced on Monday last week his
resignation with
effect from next Thursday after seven years in office,
citing “lack of
strength of mind and body” to continue his dual roles as
Sovereign of the
Vatican City State and leader of the Catholic Church ––
coincidentally
Mugabe’s church as well.
By so doing Benedict XVI, who
could claim a divine mandate and rule for
life, left a good legacy and
showed the way. He will become the first pope
to resign since Pope Gregory
XII in 1415, and the first to do so voluntarily
since Pope Celestine V in
1294.
But clinging on is not the only problem with Mugabe. There is
another,
perhaps more hidden, character flaw with him: his
self-righteousness.
It may well be that Mugabe is well-intentioned when
he talks about his life
and role as a leader but unfortunately his remarks
almost always come out
exhibiting sanctimoniousness, a veiled
holier-than-thou attitude perhaps
expressed succinctly and clearly in the
media yesterday when he was quoted
as saying:
“In my small way, this is
the task the Lord might have wanted me to fulfil
among my people and as I
carry the burden of fulfilling it, it being a
divine task, I read it as a
bidding of God. A commandment, that is how you
serve your nation,” Mugabe
said.
“The bidding says you move forward ever. Do not retrace when you
are right.
No backward movement when you are right. Your principles must be
well
defined. If they are those principles meant to enhance your people so
they
fit on the great neighbourhood, then there is no retreating. Principles
become sacred.”
Quite apart from insinuations of a divine right to
rule –– which is
preposterous –– this unmistakably shows Mugabe in
self-righteous mode. His
remarks betray some dubious moral superiority which
he wants to project,
derived from his view that his beliefs, philosophy and
actions are of
greater virtue than those of others.
Put differently,
he seems to believe he is infallible, has heroic endurance,
moral courage
and physical immortality. Moreover, Mugabe seems to believe he
is right, has
always been right and will continue to be right even though
there is
overwhelming evidence to the contrary.
In other words, he is consumed by
hubris and self-righteousness.
This delusional approach and denial of reality
has largely bred his vile
dictatorship and all the concomitant evils it has
wrought on this nation and
its people.
All the same, a belated happy
birthday Mr President!
BILL
WATCH
PARLIAMENTARY
COMMITTEES SERIES 6/2013
[1st March 2013]
Reminder:
Members of the public, including Zimbabweans in the Diaspora, can at any time
send written submissions to Parliamentary committees by email addressed to clerk@parlzim.gov.zw
Committee Meetings
Open to the Public 4th March to 8th March
The meetings listed below will be open
to members of the public, but as observers only, not as participants, i.e.
members of the public can listen but not speak.
They will be at Parliament in Harare.
If attending, please use the entrance on Kwame Nkrumah Ave between 2nd
and 3rd Streets and note that IDs must be produced.
This
bulletin is based on the latest information from Parliament. But, as there are
sometimes last-minute changes to the schedule, persons wishing to attend should
avoid disappointment by checking with the committee clerk that the meeting is
still on and open to the public. Parliament’s telephone numbers are Harare
700181 and 252941.
Monday
4th March at 10 am
Portfolio
Committee: Mines and Energy
Oral
evidence from the Ministry of Mines
and Mining Development
on diamond mining in Zimbabwe
Senate
Chamber
Chairperson:
Hon Chindori-Chininga Clerk: Mr
Manhivi
Portfolio
Committee: Higher Education, Science and Technology
Oral
evidence from the Ministry of Science and Technology on its 2013 programmes and
activities
Committee
Room No 3
Chairperson:
Hon S. Ncube Clerk: Mrs
Mataruka
Monday
4th March at 2 pm
Portfolio
Committee: Public Service, Labour and Social Welfare
Oral
evidence from PTUZ, ZIMTA
and Apex Council on the working conditions of civil
servants
Committee
Room No 1
Chairperson:
Hon Zinyemba Clerk: Ms
Mushunje
Portfolio
Committee: Public Works and National Housing
Oral
evidence from Ministry of National Housing and Social Amenities on various funds
administered by it
Committee
Room No 311
Chairperson:
Hon Mupukuta Clerk: Mr
Mazani
Tuesday
5th March at 10 am
Thematic
Committee: MDGs
Oral
evidence from NASCOH and Disability & HIV/AIDS on
legislation, policies and programmes for disabled persons
Government
Caucus Room
Chairperson:
Hon Chief Mtshane Clerk: Mrs
Nyawo
Portfolio
Committee: Health and Child Welfare
Oral
evidence from Standards Association of Zimbabwe
and Environmental Management Agency on the proess of
certification and monitoring of water bottling companies
Committee
Room No 1
Chairperson:
Hon Parirenyatwa Clerk: Mrs
Khumalo
Portfolio
Committee: State Enterprise and Parastatals
Oral
briefing from Air Zimbabwe on its current status
Committee
Room No 2
Chairperson:
Hon Mavima Clerk: Ms
Chikuvire
Portfolio
Committee: Industry and Commerce
Oral
briefing from Zimbabwe International Trade Fair Company’s board of directors on
the operations of ZITF and the benefits accruing to
local industry and the economy
Committee
Room No 311
Chairperson:
Hon Mutomba Clerk: Miss
Masara
Wednesday
6th March
Portfolio
Committee: Industry and Commerce
Oral
evidence from the Minister of Industry and Commerce on the progress made towards
resuscitation of operations at ZISCO Steel
Committee
Room No 311
Chairperson:
Hon Mutomba Clerk: Miss
Masara
Portfolio
Committee: Agriculture, Water, Lands and Resettlement
Oral
evidence from the
Minister of Agriculture, Mechanisation and Irrigation Development on the 2013
winter cropping season
Committee
Room No 4
Chairperson:
Hon Jiri
Clerk: Mrs Mataruka
Thursday
7th March at 10 am
Portfolio
Committee: Women, Youth, Gender and Community
Development
Oral
evidence from IDBZ and
Stanbic Bank on Women and Youth Empowerment
Funds
Committee
Room No 3
Chairperson:
Hon Matienga Clerk: Mr
Kunzwa
Portfolio
Committee: Education, Sport and Culture
Oral
evidence from the
Ministry of Education,
Sport, Arts and Culture and ZIMSEC on the
administration of national examinations
Committee
Room No 4
Chairperson:
Hon Mangami Clerk: Ms
Chikuvire
Thursday
7th March at 11 am
Thematic
Committee: Indigenisation and Empowerment
Oral
evidence from the Ministry of Youth Development, Indigenisation and Empowerment
on
the Empowerment Fund
Committee
Room No 311
Chairperson:
Hon Mtingwende Clerk: Mr
Ratsakatika
Friday
lst March
No
open meetings
Veritas
makes every effort to ensure reliable information, but cannot take legal
responsibility for information supplied