The expansion of towns into rural areas is a phenomenon being seen across the country. This is especially the case for ‘small towns’ that continue to grow massively thanks to land reform. Linkages from land reform areas to towns is driving a huge array of businesses from retail to services to transport and entertainment. Housing is growing too, with significant numbers of land reform farmers buying stands and building houses for rental.
This growth of towns is causing conflicts over land, and there are numerous court cases on-going contesting decisions around redesignating rural land as urban. Town Master Plans have been produced across the country, and these are supposed to provide a road map for the future, but these have not made conflicts disappear. As land values rise with redesignations or the prospects of them many engage in speculative activity creating new ‘urban’ plots in rural areas. Yet the differences in planning and building regulations between areas deemed to be rural or urban are huge, causing even more confusion. In communal areas where informal urban land expansion is happening, some speculative investors (often outsiders who illegally purchase land) are building houses akin to those in formalised urban areas in the hope that ‘when council comes’ one day, such structures will be formalised. Yet in other places where a formal process is in train, we see the issuance of receipts certificates and receipts for inspections by the Council. All this makes urban fringes the most dynamic and complicated areas to study.
We have been exploring these issues in two towns in our study areas – Mpandawana in Gutu and Mvurwi in Mazowe district. As our satellite analysis of changes in built up areas show, both these towns have grown massively since land reform in 2000. Now earlier town boundaries are being challenged as urban-style developments spill over into rural areas.
Mpandawana: changes in built up areas since land reform
Mvurwi: changes in built-up areas since land reform
The town of Mpandawana is surrounded by communal areas (notionally state land under ‘traditional’ authorities), old and new resettlement areas (again state land but with permits for use or offer letters in the case of post 2000 resettlements) and private farms purchased with freehold title. In Mvurwi, the town is surrounded by post 2000 resettlement areas, both A1 (smallholder) and A2 (medium scale farms). A2 farms may not have more than an offer letter (as 99-year leases largely have not been issued), although others have now managed to acquire title deeds the farmers may be influential people able to raise questions about town expansion through political lobbying. Each of these land use types presents different challenges for how future land use is negotiated as we highlight briefly below.
Communal areas
The state sees communal areas as simply state land requiring no involvement of local people if changes of use are required. Obligations for compensation are limited too. It simply means transferring land between councils – between the rural district council and the town council. These are still seen as ‘the reserves’, places that the colonial authority saw as dumping grounds for poor people and places that provided labour for the core economy. Officials see these as ‘reserves’ of land for ‘development’ ready to be annexed any time if required.
Local people of course think otherwise. They have different claims to the land through ‘traditional’, customary law, with local chiefs, headmen and village heads having control over land distribution. Individual households may have lived in these villages for generations of people buried on these farms. And within these areas are sacred sites – hills, pools, particular trees – that ancestral spirits occupy and protect. As such, people make use of these sacred places and graves to fend off the council or to stake claim on a portion of the land when it eventually becomes urban real estate. Bureaucratic redesignation of use meets all these layered rights over the land. The formal law of the state is only one part of the story.
Meanwhile, in the communal areas of Gutu, people are well aware that their ability to defend their land from urban expansion is limited. They know that ‘the council is coming’. They equally understand that their land is now much more valuable as town stands than for planting maize, sugar beans and vegetables. By demarcating stands for relatives and for others who want to purchase (illegally), some individuals (and the village leaders who oversee the process) are looking to make a quick buck. At the same time, some who were looking at this land as their inheritance are becoming disenfranchised, creating tensions within families and particularly across generations. Yet in where formal urban expansion has happened, others have successfully negotiated for a share of urban stands with the council, but this required good negotiation skills.
Resettlement areas
Since land was allocated to individuals as part of the resettlement programme in the 1980s or as part of the fast-track programme after 2000, the holders of such land have slightly more rights over it compared to their communal area neighbours. But not much. Offer letters may be registered with the Ministry of Lands, but land registries are notoriously chaotic and inaccurate. In Gutu, the town council has already put a dump site and a cemetery on old resettlement land, after objections from a private land holder. Just as with communal area residents, smallholder resettlement farmers are seeing the speculative benefits of conversion to town areas, and are seeking ways of capitalising on this by establishing stands.
But it is with the more influential owners of A2 areas where the biggest contests arise. In Gutu, long-running legal disputes between A2 landowners and the town council are on-going, confused by the fact that the original title (pre-land reform) is held by a bank because of outstanding debts from the earlier white farmer, and the bank is now also staking a claim. In Mvurwi, where influential landowners have been affected by attempts to expand the town, various moves are afoot. These range from attempts to get title through the new scheme being offered by the state to secure rights to the land, with changes in designation sought by the landowner rather ceding land to the town council. In other cases, landowners have proposed a research institute and a school on the land, which change the land’s status, allowing the owner to contest expropriation in court. In another case, land with a recent title overlaps with an area being developed by the town council together with a contractor, where stands, roads and other infrastructure are being built, now seemingly on someone’s private land.
Private land
Land with established title deeds offers the most clear-cut case where contestations over redesignation are fought based on formal ownership rights. However even this is not completely straightforward. A case in Gutu involves an intensifying contest with the council where the landowner is speculatively trying to develop his land for urban use, while the town council wants to claim it. Title deeds needed political backing in this case, as the owner sought help from a number of influential people in asserting his claim.
Contested land, layers of claims
Whether the land is ‘communal’, held under a use ‘permit’/’offer letter’ or is formally freehold title, contests over future use are growing on the urban periphery. Many see the value of urban land and wish to cash in; others want to retain agricultural use and a rural setting; others are hedging not knowing which way things will go but are speculatively engaged in developing the land. There are layers and layers of different claims and rights, some formal, other informal; a pattern that we see with land markets exploding across Zimbabwe’s rural areas.
Political connections become important as rights are asserted, and the tussles between ‘traditional’ leaders and the bureaucratic state are often intense. Meanwhile lawyers get involved offering complex legal arguments in court around ambiguous claims. Planners, building inspectors and land officers issue certificates and provide receipts for changes that may or not be legal. Many in the bureaucracy as well as local land holders are able to make money from these transactions capitalising on the uncertainties that exist.
Compared to the very direct patterns of patronage and party control through land barons and brokers that exist in Harare for example, the situation in Mpandawana and Mvurwi is more subtle. Politics, corrupt practice and the influence of key people certainly come into play but the on-going negotiations on the ground, in the offices and in the courts is much more complex.
The next two blogs in this short series will explore two themes that emerge strongly from our research. Next week, we look at the way competing claims are negotiated and the role of paperwork in land adjudication, as colonial era planning and building legislation meets the realities on the ground. In the final blog in the series, we look at the ways the ‘rural’ is reshaped by expanding towns, and how different generations of men and women see the potentials and dangers of expanding towns.
This blog was written by Tapiwa Chatikobo and Ian Scoones with input from Felix Murimbarimba, Nyarai Mhiripiri and Betina Muzambigwa. The satellite maps were prepared by Keen Marozva.
The blog first appeared on Zimbabweland
Source: Contesting land use on the urban periphery in Zimbabwe | zimbabweland
COMMENTS