Mphoko pockets US$3 million to exit Choppies

Source: Mphoko pockets US$3 million to exit Choppies – NewsDay Zimbabwe June 6, 2019

Former Vice-President Phelekezela Mphoko and his son Siqokoqela have sold their shares in Choppies Supermarkets Zimbabwe for US$2,9 million, the company has announced.

In a notice to shareholders, Botswana-headquartered Choppies said before the transaction, it held “93% of the economic interest and 49% of the equity while the Mphokos held a 7% economic interest and 51% of the equity” in Nanavac Investments, trading as Choppies Zimbabwe.

“Following completion of the Nanavac transaction, Choppies now holds 100% of the economic interest and equity in Nanavac Investments,” Choppies said in the May 21 notice to shareholders, although the transaction is said to have been completed on January 11 this year.

Economic interest refers to one’s share of the company’s profits, losses and distributions.

Mphoko was locked in a bruising fight for the control of Choppies Zimbabwe after he was removed as Vice-President in November 2017 following a military coup.

The conclusion of the transaction finally confirms that Mphoko and his son may have helped circumvent Zimbabwe’s indigenisation laws which required big foreign investors (transactions of US$500 000 and upwards) to cede majority shareholding to locals.

Choppies’ suspended chief executive Ramachandran Ottapathu said last year that Mphoko and his son had not invested a cent in the operation, and were only given 7% shares for “facilitating” the retailer’s entry into Zimbabwe.

“As a matter of fact, Choppies operations in Zimbabwe are owned, in the main, by Choppies Enterprises Limited, a company registered in Botswana. The reference of the 51% being owned by the Mphokos was done so as to comply with legislation which was put in place by the government which precluded foreigners from owning big stakes in businesses in preference to locals,” Ottapathu was quoted as saying.

The new government of President Emmerson Mnangagwa has committed to do away with the indigenisation legislation except for diamond mining – a move which triggered Choppies to move against the Mphokos.

Siqokoqela and his wife, Nomagugu had been hit with fraud charges instigated by Ottapathu over claims they went to supermarkets and took cash from tills without authorisation. The charges were dropped after they agreed to the exit.

Meanwhile, Ottapathu is fighting his suspension by Choppies.

Choppies said in a notice to the Johannesburg Stock Exchange that the CEO’s suspension was “valid and proper” and related to “an aggregation of activities and conduct” by him which would be disclosed soon.

“This is simple character assassination, which does not give me a chance to defend myself. I was suspended without notice and without a hearing,” Ottapathu said. “I deny the insinuations and allegations that I have done anything wrong.

“I have said repeatedly that I have not been involved in material wrongdoing or that I benefited financially from any of the transactions, which have now been under investigation since our shares were suspended almost a year ago. I’m going to challenge my suspension in court at the soonest opportunity — as I do not believe it is justified or that it was done in a manner which was valid or proper.”


  • comment-avatar
    ace mukadota 4 years ago

    Mphoko was the indigenous investor of Choppies ZW – these shares came to him FREE comrades. When you are a big wig politically -ZANUPF_- you win for free – just like the BEE system in SA – get onto it as soon as you can.

    • comment-avatar
      Nintalan 4 years ago

      I realise you are probably being sarcastic Ace, but your point that I’d like to expand on is that when someone benefits in this way someone else loses. Corruption and patronage of this type is why the Zimbabwe economy is suffering. Every person benefitting, even in the smallest way, without contributing to the economy is taking from the many who actually contribute.

  • comment-avatar
    ace mukadota 4 years ago

    RTGS 30 million at present black market rate

  • comment-avatar
    Nintalan 4 years ago

    So “indigenization” was just a way for crooks like Mphoko to make money out of their patronage positions. Who would have thought!? Of course ED and his team are dedicated to the “new dispensation” and wouldn’t stoop to such behavior. Yeah right.

    • comment-avatar
      ace mukadota 4 years ago

      Correct – start a business in ZW and eventually it will get stolen by ZANUPF comrades & friends.
      ED has been in charge of ZANUPF accumulating assets since 1980 – in 1980 a company called M & S Sundicate was formed and all the assets that went in their came from foreigners who were strong armed out of their assets.
      THE RBOZ helped with its muscle as favouring M&S at all times with the discretion of who got USD & who didnt. This hidden hand came under Exchange control.
      For e.g. Tregers were forced to hand shares to ZANUPF or M&Syndicate for a few USD. Kingstons was another and Zimpapers all were forced sales.
      Pamberi ne business in ZW but be careful as ZANUPF and RBOZ can always move the goal posts.
      Multinationals BP – Shell – Caltex – Mobil were all forced out too. As were all the foreign insurance companies – the brainchild of who was Albert Nduna.
      Why would anybody come back ?