EDITORIAL COMMENT: Indigenisation: No one is above the law

EDITORIAL COMMENT: Indigenisation: No one is above the law | The Herald March 29, 2016

Youth, Indigenisation and Economic Empowerment minister Patrick Zhuwao told the nation disturbing news last week. He said Cabinet had endorsed a decision to stop the operations of all companies which had ignored the country’s indigenisation law. We hope that decision will not come to pass. We hold no brief for any of the companies likely to be affected by this Cabinet decision. We are largely looking at two key scenarios: first the implications and ramifications of that Cabinet decision being implemented and what it means for the economy and the workers.

Second, we want to believe the companies so affected have sense enough to weigh their options. They have a wide berth, to comply or to ignore the law.

Zimbabwe’s economy is in dire straits and Government has been trying to shore it up by promoting local initiatives like growing the informal sector and the Buy Zimbabwe campaign. Government is also trying to foster the consumption of local products to reduce the import bill on non-essential goods to save foreign currency.

There have also been efforts to attract meaningful foreign direct investment by improving the ease of doing business in the country. That explains why Government has remained engaged with the International Monetary Fund. This has also resulted in a number of business executives visiting the country to explore business opportunities. The latest was a South African delegation early this month which culminated in pledges to invest at least $500 million in Zimbabwe this year.

Locally, we believe there are companies which are doing their best to stay afloat under a difficult operating environment. Such efforts need to be commended and buttressed by Government incentives for them to save jobs.

Memories are still fresh and casualties aplenty of thousands of workers who lost their jobs following the Supreme Court ruling of July 17 last year that companies could terminate employment contracts on three months’ notice without giving a justification. Although the figures of people affected are contested, there is no denying the trauma that ruling caused.

Some people saw Government’s hidden hand in the Supreme Court ruling as it sought to meet the austerity requirements of the IMF’s Staff Monitored Programme to cut its payroll through “retrenchments”. It would therefore be risky to make light work of closing down companies and throwing more people on to the streets without any safety nets or alternative viable programmes of self-sustenance.

But Minister Zhuwao also pointed to something sinister: that there were people colluding with and influencing some companies not to comply with the country’s indigenisation laws. Such companies have been vocal about the need for policy consistency and clarification, albeit only through newspapers and social media instead of engaging Government directly to express their reservations.

Such companies, noted Minister Zhuwao, seemed to dare the President and his Government to a fistfight. If there is one thing which should be made clear, it is that no individual or company is above the law of the country. It is that simple. You may like or not like certain laws. There are ways of raising objections. Deliberately violating the law is not one of them.

Most of the big companies defying the law in Zimbabwe are very compliant in their own countries. They will not wilfully break the law in their own country simply because they don’t like it. Instead they will lobby, including bribing MPs if necessary, to have the law amended or repealed. They will succeed or fail depending on the reasonableness of their demands.

Indigenisation is one such very fundamental law to Zimbabwe’s economic well-being.

Now, when the same companies come to developing nations they want to arm-twist and manipulate the host country to maximise profits. They want to exploit the desperation of the host country to further plunder its resources for a penny in the name of employment creation. They are never interested in the prosperity of their host, but the size of their profit margin.

Such companies cannot try to hold the country to ransom in the name of jobs. They are simply not interested in doing business here except on their own terms.

We hope they will not call Government’s bluff, taking the April 1 ultimatum for a Fool’s Day joke.


  • comment-avatar
    Brian 7 years ago

    You conveniently leave out the small local businesses who are being discriminated on the basis of the “colour” of the owners, some of whom are born and bred in this country and others who have spent many years building up their businesses ( most post independence) and employing locals and creating business. I, for one, will refuse to comply with any law that discriminates in this way and which also so clearly violates our constitution…let alone flies in the face of all that I have justly worked for. I will give no more to a government that has committed wholesale theft and has used violence to maintain its own dubious status quo…my own a luta will continua….

  • comment-avatar
    C Frizell 7 years ago

    It is every thinking person’s duty to ignore unjust and stupid laws designed solely so that a small clique can “loot some more”

  • comment-avatar

    no one is above the law? really?

    please read the Chindori Chininga parliamentary portfolio committee report on diamond mining in Marange, and you will see that there are plenty of people who are above the law.

    joseph mwale, the cio operative, who killed Talent Mabika and David Chiminyi in full view of police officers – he still walks free and has never been charged let alone arrested.

    the truth is that anyone who blindly supports mugabe is allowed to get away with murder, and it is only the rest of us who have to obey the law.

    look at the people who surround mugabe?
    is there a single one left of any moral stature, or are they all bootlickers and gold diggers?

  • comment-avatar
    mrambiwa 7 years ago

    this law is so retrogressive and really lacks sense! On the other hand, the so-called powers-that-be are globe-trotting, in an “effort” to shore investment, yet on the other hand they’re busy chocking the economy with such stubborn moves. One really wonders, if education underlines any scope of these “hand-picked” ministers who do not have any clue with the repercussions of what they claim to “know”.That, the general person is suffering , is not a secret. This is a case of ..”cutting your nose to smite your face..”.Zimbabwe wake up!

  • comment-avatar

    Black lives don’t matter in Zimbabwe. ZANU Pf lives matter