Electronic voting faces stiff resistance

Electronic voting faces stiff resistance

Source: Electronic voting faces stiff resistance – DailyNews Live

Gift Phiri      15 March 2017

HARARE – The process to compile a credible voter register ahead of the
2018 general elections has been thrown into disarray after authorities
argued biometric voter registration (BVR) and voting is a luxury
government cannot afford.

Zimbabwe is hoping thumbprint scans and voter cards with electronic bar
codes will enable it to accurately register an estimated six million
voters and eliminate the kind of fraud that has undermined previous

An electoral roll riddled with fictitious names and omitting legitimate
voters, combined with ballot-stuffing and intimidation, marred previous
elections so badly that observers deemed them not to have been credible.

A tender for electronic voter registration kits – laptop computers, finger
print scanners, cameras and printers – has been floated by the United
Nations Development Programme (UNDP) and bidders shortlisted. After
concluding the bidding process, government then announced three weeks ago
that it was joining the process after pumping in $17 million, with Vice
President Emmerson Mnangagwa telling Parliament that the biometric system
will be used during both registration and the actual voting process.

But Zimbabwe Electoral Commission (Zec) chairperson Justice Rita Makarau
said only voter registration would be biometric not actual voting, and
that the State Procurement Board would assist with adjudication in the
process of procuring BVR kits, and have set March 20 as the date for site
validation tests of the three top bidders being considered.

Now the official media – which reflects government thinking – is casting
aspersions on the BVR process, saying it can actually be “a danger to
democracy” because it is vulnerable to hacking and that advanced
democracies such as France were ditching electronic voting.

While Zanu PF administration secretary Ignatius Chombo was not taking
calls from the Daily News whether the ruling party was still keen on BVR,
political commissar Saviour Kasukuwere said: “It’s an area covered by

Zanu PF secretary for legal affairs Patrick Chinamasa’s mobile was

But authoritative sources said the issue was likely to be high on the
politburo agenda today.

MDC spokesperson Obert Gutu said: “We saw this coming. Zanu PF will do
everything within its power to scuttle the holding of free and fair
elections.  The crumbling and faction-infested Zanu PF regime has realised
that a transparent BVR process will not play into their grand plan of
stealing the 2018 elections.

“However, we will maintain pressure on this evil regime until Zimbabwe
becomes genuinely democratic.”

PDP spokesperson Jacob Mafume said the remonstrations could be a trick to
make the opposition think that the ruling party does not want BVR.

“As you know we have knee-jerk reaction to Zanu PF positions. But all
dictators don’t like anything that improves the electoral field.

“If done properly, it can remove ghost voters. It is best international
practice,” Mafume said.

An information officer at Heal Zimbabwe Trust, Rawlings Magede said it
might be a trap being created “where they appear to dismiss the BVR on the
pretext of costs which we know that it’s false.”

The Herald editorial comment said: “BVR is a luxury we cannot afford at
the moment. Those mandated to come up with a clean voters’ roll can have a
paradigm shift by thinking outside the box, because it is still possible
to do so, at a cost that Zimbabwe can afford.”

Solomon Bizmack, an elections expert, said those saying BVR is expensive
forget that democracy is expensive.

Finance minister Chinamasa appropriated a “meagre” $9,7m budget to Zec in
the 2017 National Budget, an amount that falls far short of the $59,2
million requested by Zec.

“I solely need it (BVR) because it places premium on transparency and
accountability in our electoral and democratic governance,” Bizmack said.

“Our elections are always contested on the basis of the voters’ roll, so
this is an opportunity for a new roll.”

Magede said: “The sudden change and shift from BVR raises a lot of

Election Resource Centre (ERC) executive director Tawanda Chimhini, said
the U-turn was disturbing given that State media has almost always
dictated policy.

“This is an opportunity for Zec to pronounce itself on the matter and in
so doing assert its independence in determining how elections are
administered in Zimbabwe,” he said, adding the decision on how voters will
be registered must be taken by Zec alone.

“Attempts by government and other actors such as the media to hijack what
is purely the mandate of Zec is a blatant disregard of the constitutional
independence of Zec and if Zec wants to be taken seriously, it must
pronounce itself on the matter once and for all.”

By remaining silent, Zec was being “reckless”, he said.

A senior researcher at Human Rights Watch, Dewa Mavhinga, said the State
media was doing a terrible job of trying to cover up the real reasons why
the government would be opposed to the BVR system.

“It is not about cost, because international donors are ready to support
that sort of thing, and when Zimbabwe was unable to fund its own
Constitution-making process, donors stepped in and funded the process,” he

“What we have here is a fear that the BVR could prove difficult to
manipulate in a context where the existing manual system has repeatedly
proven to be vulnerable to manipulation and control.

“The real fear among some quarters is that the BVR system could level the
electoral field and take away the rigging advantage that has existed for
decades benefiting the ruling Zanu PF party.”

Commentator Rejoice Ngwenya said Zanu PF wanted to take away BVR
procurement from Zec and opposition was mobilising popular resistance.

This comes after opposition political parties coalescing under the
National Electoral Reform Agenda (Nera) banner have said they will on
March 22 take to the streets in protest at government’s alleged hijacking
of the procurement of BVR kits from the UNDP.

“Zanu PF is afraid of a clean voters’ roll. Why are they worried about the
cost if UNDP is footing the bill?” Ngwenya said.