Stressed Zim cries for rands

Source: Stressed Zim cries for rands – DailyNews Live

Ndakaziva Majaka and Farayi Machamire      10 May 2017

HARARE – With the current acute cash crisis worsening by the day, experts
have made renewed calls for the country to adopt the South African rand as
Zimbabwe’s anchor currency, to stem an impending economic implosion.

This comes as Parliament has summoned under-pressure Reserve Bank of
Zimbabwe (RBZ) governor John Mangudya and Tobacco Industry Marketing Board
(TIMB) chief executiveW Andrew Matibiri to explain the payment chaos that
is being experienced by farmers at the Harare auction floors.

An economist with a local commercial bank, Joseph Mverecha, told the Daily
News yesterday that the country urgently needed to adopt the rand as its
anchor currency to save Zimbabwe from an economic disaster.

“Unless we count on miracles, the only logical step to take now is to
adopt the rand, while simultaneously addressing deep structural and macro
imbalances, to get back our industry production to full capacity and
increase exports and forex reserves … and thereafter introduce a
graduated return of the local currency.

“Going forward, and if dollars continue to flow out of the formal system
as is happening at present, we will have only two options left – either a
full scale return to the Zimbabwean dollar or the much maligned rand.

“An immediate return to the local currency is not sustainable. Significant
long-term damage can be done to this economy through a hurried and
injudicious return of the Zimbabwean dollar,” Mverecha said.

Economics professor Ashok Chakravarti also said adopting the rand would
help the dying local economy.

“There are no economic issues in adopting the rand tomorrow as I have
always said. All it needs is a simple law, a statutory instrument from
government with an exchange rate re-denomination of all US dollar
balances, salaries and prices.

“The obvious currency of choice is the rand because of the strong trade
link with South Africa. About 70 percent of our exports go to South Africa
and 40 percent of imports come from South Africa.

“The rand is an answer to many of our problems . . . The rand is also a
non-convertible currency that will remain in the region and, therefore,
cash will be maintained,” Chakravarti said.

Economic analyst Vince Musewe also said it made “sense” to adopt the rand.

“It has always made sense to have the currency of our biggest trading
partner as the main currency . . . this would also minimise
externalisation and also help with trade transactions between the two

“However, in my view, retailers and other service providers just need to
also price their items in rands. After all, the currency is already legal
tender in the country, so it is not like there are legality issues with
doing this,” Musewe said.

“Of course, the currency issues are indicators of deeper economic
challenges like fiscal and monetary discord.

“I also do not understand it when people keep stressing that the rand is
volatile. Yes, it is . . . show me a currency that is not volatile. What
is the point of having a stable currency that you do not have in the

“It is simply an issue of choosing between two devils here, and the rand
is the better devil. The RTGS system is already in Rands as well, so it is
simply an issue of ensuring that everything is also priced in rands.

“It will save Zimbabweans from United States dollar over-pricing. So, it
will have a positive impact on the pricing regime and get rid of all these
ridiculous mark-ups and margins we have seen in the economy,” Musewe

CZI president Busisa Moyo is also on record pleading for the adoption of
the rand.

“We have been talking about randisation and individual members of CZI have
come out strong on randisation, and I think we need to have some sort of
action towards this,” Moyo has said.

This comes as the National Assembly has summoned Mangudya and Matibiri to
explain the payment chaos being witnessed at the tobacco auction floors,
which were turned into a mini-war zone last week after police fought
running battles with angry farmers who had staged a demonstration
demanding their cash for their delivered crop.

“Obviously, I am not happy with what is happening at the auction floors,”
chairman of the parliamentary portfolio committee on land and agriculture,
Christopher Chitindi, said.

“After my investigations, I realised that there is still a shortage of
cash at the banks, which is why there was that noise. When I checked with
them (TSF) again, they assured me everything was now back to normal.

“But as a committee, we have resolved that we will call in Mangudya and
Matibiri so that we get the full information why we are still having this
problem yet they promised us that things will change,” he added.

Tobacco farmers were earlier this year advised they would be permitted to
withdraw cash of up to $1 000 from their first sale, and $50 for
subsequent sales in light of ongoing cash shortages.

However, many of them have not been able to withdraw those amounts, which
has seen them sleeping out in the open on empty stomachs, as they wait to
access their money.

Despite authorities injecting more bond notes into the market and
increasing their weekly importation of US dollars by 50 percent, the
government continues to battle to stem the country’s severe cash shortages
which have seen desperate Zimbabweans besieging overstretched banks as
they despairingly try to withdraw their money.

This comes as banks are reporting a rising demand for cash despite the
aggressive push by authorities to promote the use of plastic money and
mobile platforms as part of their measures to promote a cashless society.

At the same time, analysts have warned in interviews with the Daily News
that the snaking queues which have become a permanent feature at banks
around the country signalled the fact that “panic” had set in among both
ordinary Zimbabweans and businesses – amid understandable fears that the
dying local economy is hurtling towards the debilitating lows of 2008.

They also said that the accelerating disappearance of the country’s
surrogate currency – bond notes, which were meant to mitigate the
country’s acute cash crunch – was worsening the panic.

This comes as United States dollars have long vanished from the formal
market – with the coveted greenbacks now only easily available in the
country’s thriving black market.

Economist Godfrey Kanyenze also warned long-suffering Zimbabweans earlier
this week that all indications were that the current long cash queues
would worsen as the watershed 2018 elections approached.

“There is a real problem in the sense that what precipitated this problem
in the first place was the government’s fiscal indiscipline … you will
notice that it is because of this imbalance that Treasury is scrambling to
pay bonuses which were not budgeted for in the 2017 National Budget …
and therefore the immediate future is not looking good.

“Then of course, there is the fact that the country is headed for an
election and due to the state of things in the country and in Zanu PF,
with its factional fights, populist decisions cannot be ruled out, so this
situation can only be expected to worsen,” Kanyenze told the Daily News.

In the meantime, the disappearance of the country’s surrogate currency
from the market is also forcing banks to give desperate Zimbabweans their
cash in sackfuls of coins.

The RBZ introduced bond notes at the end of last year to ease the severe
cash shortages, but so far this has completely failed to satisfy the
market’s cash needs.

This has seen banks limiting the amount of money both individuals and
companies can withdraw to as low as $20.

Zimbabwe is deep in the throes of a debilitating economic crisis which has
led to horrendous company closures and the consequent loss of hundreds of
thousands of jobs.

At the same time, economists have said that poverty levels in the country
are skyrocketing, with average incomes now at their lowest levels in more
than 60 years – with more than 76 percent of the country’s families now
having to make do with pitiful incomes that are well below the poverty
datum line.

This comes as Zimbabwe has now been officially ranked as the poorest
country in Africa.


  • comment-avatar

    What REAL difference would the Rand Make. The article goes around the fundamental problem:-
    No money coming in.
    Elsewhere the argument for large demonetization notes in made, again not the route cause of the predicament. Will not work; been tried in Zim before, Argentina and the Germans know all about it as well, you cannot print wealth, the basic value is a Konstant so it just spreads out thinner.
    * The RAND is convertible its quoted worldwide.