City bosses divert loan cash to cars | The Herald

via City bosses divert loan cash to cars…• 25 luxury vehicles bought • Funds meant for water, sewage | The Herald May 17, 2014 by Innocent Ruwende

Harare City management has used part of the US$144,4 million loan from China for water and sewerage reticulation to buy 25 luxury cars, which include Land Rovers and Range Rovers. Mayor Bernard Manyenyeni revealed this at a full council meeting on Thursday, where acting town clerk Engineer Christopher Zvobgo said he was aware of 13 vehicles — though he first said eight had been bought.
The value of the cars was still to be established.

Yesterday, deputy mayor Thomas Muzuva revealed further lack of clarity on the whole deal when he said: “I understand 25 vehicles were bought. When I asked the town clerk (Dr Tendai Mahachi) he said 21 were bought, but Engineer Zvobgo told full council that 13 vehicles were bought.
“We will need proof in the form of receipts to know the actual number of vehicles bought as well as the price,” he said

On Thursday, Clr Manyenyeni told the full council, “Every day we are waking up to surprises, the deal continues to be too cloudy to be ignored.
“There are reports that council bought vehicles using funds from the water project. We cannot continue to ignore these reports, we have to do something about them.”
In 2010, the city secured a US$144,4 million loan for China National Machinery and Equipment Import and Export Corporation to refurbish water and sewage treatment plants.

Government guaranteed the loan, which was signed for by Dr Mahachi and the then Mayor Mr Muchadeyi Masunda.
Councillors expressed outrage over the purchase of the vehicles, with former finance committee chairperson Clr Norman Markham saying there was too much opacity in how council spent money and that is why he had resigned from his brief earlier this year.

Deputy mayor Muzuva added: “Your Worship, the finance committee should have been involved because these officials are diverting funds from the Chinese loan facility. This is a loan, it is not a grant and residents will pay for it.

“We want a breakdown of how the money was used. We might wake up to be told that there is no money left.”
Cllr Muzuva said Dr Mahachi should have left officials responsible for water to run the programme “instead of imposing himself in the committee”.

“We are smelling a rat,” he said “We want to know how many cars were brought because we hear 26 vehicles were bought, including some Range Rovers.”
Mr Manyenyeni asked acting town clerk Eng Zvobgo to comment, and he responded: “Under the project, there is a provision of eight cars.”
Pressed further, Eng Zvobgo then said 13 vehicles were bought for the project team.

Cllr Febion Kufahakutizwi argued that the project team already had council vehicles.
Hatcliffe’s Cllr Naboth Munyengera alleged that Dr Mahachi knew the deal would be questioned, hence he absented himself from the meeting. Dr Mahachi sent apologies saying he was unwell.

Council resolved to establish a committee of two councillors and three experts to probe the entire deal after acting chamber secretary Mr Charles Kandemire said it was possible for council to set up such a special team.

A report by consultant engineer Mr Peter Morris shows that council could lose more than US$100 million in the deal because many project items are grossly overpriced.
The city has denied irregularities in the deal.



  • comment-avatar

    This is an example of how the entire government is run on a massive scale of corruption and grand larceny.

  • comment-avatar
    Taylor 9 years ago

    Mayor we support your efforts to clean up the City’s affairs. An arduous and dangerous task. We are with you.

  • comment-avatar

    Remember the Warship Dumba led council commission probe into corruption? Once they found evidence of corruption in the City management, they handed over the files to the police. The police arrested Warship Dumba. !

  • comment-avatar
    ndaizviziva 9 years ago

    somebody should be prosecuted for violation of human rights, how could some people divert funds meant for a water project while people are drinking raw sewage. The Chineese should also be wary of extendings loans to a corrupt government

  • comment-avatar
    Mixed Race 9 years ago

    They claim the cars are for the project when we know that after 5 years these cars become their private properties after paying almost nothing for them.
    The good thing is that these naive and misguided officials have very limited foresight because they forget that once they retire they won’t be able to maintain them with their limited pensions so they will be forced to get rid of them.The system of corruption has turned people to be worse than the animals with no personal conscience.How can a person drive a new expensive car bought with funds meant for water treatment plant when his countrymen are drinking dirty water or going for days without water?This shows what type of people are in leadership positions.I really hope that this story is not correct otherwise Harare is doomed.

  • comment-avatar
    Saddened 9 years ago

    If the residents of Harare who are directly affected by poor water delivery do not look into taking legal action against Dr Mahachi & whoever else is complicit then they only have themselves to blame. Our hands are not tied at every turn, so that all we do is complain.