LIVE: Zim electoral body ‘bumped up Mnangagwa’s figures through double counts’, MDC claims

LIVE: Zim electoral body ‘bumped up Mnangagwa’s figures through double counts’, MDC claims

Source: LIVE: Zim electoral body ‘bumped up Mnangagwa’s figures through double counts’, MDC claims | News24

All eyes are on Zimbabwe as the country’s Constitutional Court hears the petition lodged by opposition leader Nelson Chamisa in his bid to overturn President Emmerson Mnangagwa’s victory in the July 30 elections. Get the live updates here



Chamisa’s lawyers in court said they had not been allowed to bring in electronic gadgets, either.

According to Veritas, a legal think tank based in Harare, the court can declare a winner or invalidate the election and call for a fresh election or make any other order it considers “just and appropriate.”

If the court upholds Mnangagwa’s win the inauguration would take place within 48 hours. This is not the first time the opposition has challenged election results in court.

Following the 2013 presidential election, then main opposition leader Morgan Tsvangirai filed a challenge but later withdrew it, claiming he would not get a fair hearing. The court declined his withdrawal and proceeded to rule on the case in favor of Mugabe. – AP


Mnangagwa and the electoral commission argue the opposition’s application should be dismissed on a technicality, saying it was filed too late and that papers were not properly served on respondents.

In his affidavit, Mnangagwa argues the court should not hear Chamisa’a application because he “scandalised” the court by claiming during political rallies that the judiciary was biased toward the ruling party, Zanu-PF.

Mnangagwa also accuses Chamisa of making “illusionary promises” to voters during campaign.

The case was being televised live by the state broadcaster, the Zimbabwe Broadcasting Corporation, but the courts ruled that the proceedings could not be livestreamed on social media.

Journalists and others accredited by the court were following proceedings from a giant television screen on the court premises, but they were not permitted to carry mobile phones or laptops. – AP


In Brief

Chamisa’s challenge claims the electoral commission bumped up Mnangagwa’s figures through double counts and the creation of “ghost” polling stations.

It also alleges that some polling stations recorded more voters than those registered to vote.

“It’s like a kid was playing with the figures,” a lawyer for the opposition, Thabani Mpofu, told the court. He alleged that 16 polling stations had identical results and that “massive doctoring” took place.

Chief Justice Luke Malaba, however, pressed the opposition for the original election results forms to back up their allegations: “We cannot act on generalities”. – AP


Court adjourns for lunch. Proceedings will resume in 40 minutes.


The sheriff had enough time to effect service on the first respondent but decided not to do anything and therefore the applicant cannot be penalised for someone’s dereliction of duty, says Mpofu


In brief

Zimbabwe’s opposition argued in the country’s top court Wednesday that the presidential election results must be thrown out, alleging that only “massive doctoring” of the vote had kept Emmerson Mnangagwa in office.

Lawyers for the Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) launched a blistering attack on the ruling Zanu-PF party and the election commission over the July 30 ballot – Zimbabwe’s first election since the ousting of Robert Mugabe last year.

“There is a massive cover-up. There has been a massive doctoring of evidence,” Thabani Mpofu, representing the MDC, told the court.

Mnangagwa, Mugabe’s former ally, won the election with 50.8% of the vote – just enough to meet the 50% threshold needed to avoid a run-off against MDC leader Nelson Chamisa, who scored 44.3%.

“There were at least 16 polling stations with identical results – identical result for Chamisa, identical results for Mnangagwa. It is like a kid who was playing with the figures,” said Mpofu.

He argued that irregularities wiped out the narrow margin by which Mnangagwa had avoided a second-round vote.

“A run-off is unavoidable. For now, the election must be set aside,” Mpofu said, adding that “we have a false ZEC (Zimbabwe Electoral Commission). We have a lying ZEC.” – AFP


“If we were to say the first respondent is the elected president, how many votes did he garner?,” Mpofu asks


Mpofu says Mnangagwa and ZEC connived to undermine the constitution by rigging elections


ZEC violated the constitution and the Electoral Act by denying some Zimbabweans their right to vote, that effectively means ZEC threw President Mnangagwa under the bus, says Mpofu


The applicant had no reason to cause the opening of ballot boxes for a recount and is not obliged to do so, says Mpofu, especially when there is evidence placed before the court that figures released by ZEC were not genuine and consequently Mnangagwa did not win the election.

In that case there is no need for primary evidence


Mpofu says they are sitting over 9000 votes that do not require the opening of the residue because those votes came from ghost polling stations


Mpofu says the fulcrum of the applicant’s case is not premised on the residue


Chief Justice asks why Chamisa has not applied for ballot boxes to be opened within 48hrs stipulated by law


Mpofu says they could not have gathered all the eveidence in seven days hence they chose to dwell on systematic manipulation by ZEC


Mpofu reads an affidavit by one of the polling agents who says she was chased away from the polling station by the presiding officer and was only allowed to return after counting had been done and was asked to sign the V11 forms and she refused.

Mpofu adds that the agent then went home and was followed by unnamed men who had covered their faces with ashes who sodomised the polling agent’s husband


Mpofu says one of the affidavits he has from one Madzudzo shows that some people came with unpopulated V11 forms for him to sign after polling had already closed and he refused


This is evidence of manipulation after the process by ZEC, says Mpofu


Mpofu says there had been a massive cover up


The Chief Justice asks why original documents were not produced and why the applicant did not seek to have the ballot boxes opened


V11 forms produced in court by Mpofu show that they are signed, stamped but they have not been populated – meaning that they have no figures. Mpofu says this demonstrates some of the irregularities


The key case of the applicant is based on ZEC’s own figures, says Mpofu


ZEC has now come up with a figure that has not been verified, says Mpofu


Mpofu replies that there is no need to defer to what has been defined as secondary evidence when ZEC has accepted that their figures are not genuine


Chief Justice Luke Malaba asks why the applicant filed his case on secondary evidence when there is first and original evidence


Hashiti says once the mathematics is gone then there is no valid election process. ZEC has admitted flaws in figures that it announced and that should settle the matter


Hashiti says there was no valid election


Another Chamisa lawyer Sylvester Hashiti takes the stage and says the validity of the July 30 is being tested


The case stands to be determined on the basis of numbers. Numbers do not lie and a run off is unavoidable, says Mpofu


Mnangagwa filed his notice of opposition out of time, says Mpofu


The people of Zimbabwe have a right to a free and fair election, says Mpofu


Once an application has been lodged, the court assumes jurisdiction to hear the matter


The sheriff initially agreed to serve our papers but was instructed to do otherwise, says Mpofu


ZEC has changed the results three times and that cannot be accepted, says Mpofu


Mpofu: A verification of the presidential results is a verification of V23 but ZEC was verifying results at ward level


There were instances Chamisa and Mnangagwa getting the same figures and the same spoilt papers at several polling stations and it looks as if a kid was playing with figures, says Mpofu


Mpofu: There is no dispute that 40 000 people were denied their right to vote

ZEC does not dispute that postal voting at Ross Camp police station was not secret


Zimbabwean following the Constitutional Court proceedings in and outside Harare.


Mpofu says many teachers were disenfranchised of their rights to vote when they were deployed to officiate during the polls but there are no affidavits places before the court by ZEC


Mpofu: In Masvingo ZEC does not explain how a 24.7% voter turnout was reached in the last hour


Mpofu says if a voter decides not to vote ZEC would have made an entry

Ghost polling account last for over 9000 votes

Ghost polling station account for over 9000 votes

9592 votes that came from ghost polling stations have not been disputed

Mpofu says there were more people who cast their votes than registered voters

Mpofu adds that some people who were not registered as voters were allowed to cast their ballots at a polling station in Belvedere in Harare


Nelson Chamisa’s lawyer says an expert report says the ZEC gave Mnangagwa 8944 votes undeservingly

He says the second set of figures is 7 730 that were given to Mnangagwa undeservedly

The difference between the presidential and parliamentary tally is not tallying, he says


Hundreds of people have gathered around screens outside Zimbabwe’s top court on Wednesday to watch a legal showdown between President Emmerson Mnangagwa and the opposition leader challenging his July 30 election victory. – Reuters 


Meanwhile, Chamisa’s lawyer, Advocate Thabani Mpofu says the results announced by the Zimbabwe Electoral Commission are invalid because they were not verified by anyone. – Frank Chikowore, News24 


Application by respondents to be party to the case have been dismissed and reasons to follow later



The African Editors Forum (TAEF) is deeply disappointed by the decision by the Zimbabwean Broadcast Corporation to impose fees on broadcast feeds of the ongoing Constitutional Court hearing on the recent elections.

The Zimbabwean Judicial Services Commission decided that the ZBC will have exclusive access to the court hearing.

The ZBC then decided to impose charges for distributing the broadcast feed.

TAEF learned with disappointment that the ZBC, a state broadcaster, charges USD 13500 per day for live TV feed and USD 5200 for radio feeds.

While TAEF appreciates the creative ways the ZBC has employed to raise much-needed revenue, their decision will limit access to the proceedings which are of acute national and international interest.

Therefore the decision by the ZBC will deny millions across Africa and the world – including Zimbabweans in the diaspora, access to information that they have a right to.

TAEF calls on the leadership of the Zimbabwean public broadcaster to adopt and implement universally accepted conduct where the host broadcaster provides TV and radio feeds free to others.

TAEF is in principle opposed to the imposition of the fees by ZBC. We appeal to the leadership of ZBC to rescind the decision to charge for broadcast fees.

We also urge the Government of Zimbabwe, who control the ZBC through the Ministry of Information, to demonstrate the dawn of a new era in Zimbabwe by instructing the leaders of the ZBC to do the right thing and open up the airwaves.

The imposition of prohibitively expensive feeds belongs to the old Zimbabwe and an epoch that the new Zimbabwe is supposedly walking away from.


Water cannons near the Constitutional Court building in Harare. (Picture: Frank Chikowore, News24)


  • comment-avatar
    Flick 5 years ago

    “claiming during political rallies that the judiciary was biased toward the ruling party, Zanu-PF”, which is a very well known fact and especially so when said judges are appointed by the president and, by association, zanupf. How can there possibly be impartiality ?