Disingenuous to start quantifying sanctions after all these years

The government has called for proposals into the research of the economic impact of sanctions, which on the surface may look like a good idea, but some may fear this is another elaborate waste of taxpayers’ money.

Source: Disingenuous to start quantifying sanctions after all these years – NewsDay Zimbabwe September 20, 2016

NewsDay Editor

On Sunday, the Higher and Tertiary Education ministry advertised the call for proposals and it is baffling why the government has taken so long to undertake studies on the effects of sanctions, almost a decade and a half after they were first imposed.

Firstly, this comes as the then Attorney-General Johannes Tomana wasted thousands of scarce dollars pursuing a useless lawsuit against sanctions. A question that needs to be asked is: What was the basis of the lawsuit if the government really had no idea of the effects of sanctions?

In a normal situation, the government should have first carried out the research it has now called for instead of putting the cart before the horse by starting with a lawsuit.

The government was literally groping in the dark with that ill-fated lawsuit and rightfully lost and this call for proposals should further serve as an indictment for Tomana for his abuse of public money.

The government has thrown about figures ranging up to $42 billion, saying this is the revenue lost due to sanctions and a key question is where were they getting these figures or these were just thumb-suck as usual.

This means the government is approaching sanctions like a headless chicken, with no clue on their impact and, therefore, with no idea how to get them overturned.

In that same breath, the Higher Education ministry should not worry about external realities it cannot change, but rather look at how it can change internal dynamics.

What Zimbabwe needs first is a study on how poor governance, nepotism and corruption have brought the country to its knees.

Examples of corruption in the public sector are abound and even if the country were to get sanctions overturned by the West, what is the impact of “internal sanctions” we have imposed on ourselves?

Government ministers cannot even agree on spending cuts, public debt is spiralling and, more than ever, there is policy discord and the country needs to know what effect this has on the economy before we even discuss sanctions.

No matter how evil sanctions are, what Zimbabwe needs is deep introspection and getting the internal fundamentals right, rather than worrying what our neighbours think about us.

Once we have cleaned up corruption, improved on our governance record, stuck to the rule of law and observed basic human rights and constitutionalism, sanctions will rightly fall away.

As it is, this looks like a waste of money and even if we were to get the results of how bad sanctions are, the reality is they will not be lifted until we improve on democratic fundamentals and that is where we need to start.


  • comment-avatar

    They will set up a Board of possibly 10 people, all from ZanuPF, to look into and investigate the economic impacts of the sanctions. All these people will be paid $30 000 each PER MONTH as Board members, with a free Merc or Range Rover Sports, free medical, free cellphones and calls, free house help, First Class travel and whatever other perks these thieves can think of. It will cost Treasury at least $1 million a month to have this Board. But, that’s what ZanuPF is all about. Bloody thieves, the whole lot of them.

  • comment-avatar

    What a joke. There are no sanctions other than those imposed by Zpf in the form of import restrictions, excessive duties/taxes, corruption, theft from the fiscus etc.

    The shortages are already beginning to show. 2008 here we come.

  • comment-avatar
    Barry 6 years ago

    We need this as much as we need a new parliament. Just another jobs for the boys scam.

  • comment-avatar
    Johann 6 years ago

    Just think what RGM has cost and continues to cost the country. He’s one hellova expensive individual.

  • comment-avatar
    Fallenz 6 years ago

    “No matter how evil sanctions are,…”

    Do I detect bias by the author? Evil was what caused the sanctions to be imposed. Who in their right mind would call for an end to the sanctions, when the farm invasions continue to be supported by the zanupf government.