Judicial capture a sad reality in Zim 

HIGH Court Judge, Justice Erica Ndewere was recently suspended for ‘misconduct’ after she granted bail to MDC Alliance Vice National Chairperson, Job Sikhala on September 22, 2020.

Source: Judicial capture a sad reality in Zim – The Zimbabwean

Erica Ndewere

Sikhala had spent a month detained at Chikurubi Maximum prison on charges of inciting public violence.

Investigations into the suspension of Justice Ndewere, however, revealed that the Head of the Judicial Services Commission, Chief Justice Luke Malaba was unhappy with the granting of bail to Sikhala hence the move to suspend Justice Ndewere.

Justice Ndewere received the letter of her alleged misconduct from Malaba despite the fact that Malaba is only empowered to supervise Supreme Court Judges while High Court judges are supervised by the Judge President.

Malaba’s interference in the case of Justice Ndewere reveals the coordinated capture of the judiciary and interference into the work of judges and magistrates in Zimbabwe.

In the case of Justice Ndewere, Chief Justice Malaba’s role in the capture of the judiciary has been laid bare.

Quite often, the state’s capture of the judiciary has allowed for persecution by the prosecution with opposition and civic society activists having to endure lengthy periods in detention on frivolous and trumped-up charges.

Crisis in Zimbabwe Coalition Spokesperson, Marvelous Khumalo said it is an open secret that Zimbabwe’s judiciary is captured.

“We would like to believe that in Zimbabwe, judicial capture is a reality. There is a lot of interference in how the judiciary is composed. The President plays a big role in the composition of the judiciary and that alone compromises the independence of the judiciary. Recently we had Justice Francis Bere being fired by the President and that is a clear sign of interference,” said Khumalo.


  • comment-avatar
    Kalulu 2 years ago

    That is the problem in having a corrupt or weak person as a Chief Justice. A good example of an independent Judiciary is just across the border in Malawi who resisted the interference from the then sitting President.

    Chief Justice Malala is a disgrace both to the Judiciary and the nation of Zimbabwe. In view of this and other sickening revelations, it would appear that there is no other option for him other than to resign and leave the post to principled custodians of Justice who are willing to serve the nation without fear or favour.  He should move to the Shake-Shake Building where he rightly belongs.

  • comment-avatar
    harper 2 years ago

    In 1986 the Judges from the old order and those on loan from Tanzania held back ZANU’s drive to control the Judiciary. Sadly lower down the order the rot had set in. Nemapare was not allowed to recuse himself from the Tekere trial and when I appeared before the Detainees Review Tribunal I was looking at two Lawyers under investigation by my unit for laundering stoled cars.